Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Emergencies Act Ruling and Construction Liability
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for Legally Speaking, joined as always by Michael Mulligan, barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Morning, michael.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: A couple of very interesting stories on the agenda for this week, of course, the one everybody is talking about with a federal court decision.
- 0:17Adam Stirling: Shall we start with the Emergencies Act.
- 0:20Michael Mulligan: Sure, it's a very interesting decision, which I'm not sure the government read before it started responding to us and saying it was wanting to appeal, but it's a very interesting 190-page read, at least for me.
- 0:36Michael Mulligan: The challenge was, of course, a challenge to the declaration of a public order emergency in February of 2022, as a result of the trucker protest around the Parliament buildings and elsewhere.
- 0:48Michael Mulligan: The judge concluded that that use of the Emergencies Act was both unreasonable and unconstitutional.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: The analysis was an interesting one.
- 1:01Michael Mulligan: First of all, it's important to know that the Act doesn't just allow anyone at any point to come out and yell I declare an emergency, as you would hope.
- 1:10Michael Mulligan: It defines what is meant by, for the purpose of this Act, a public order emergency.
- 1:18Michael Mulligan: The essence of it is it has to be a national emergency, it's got to be urgent, a critical situation that's temporary.
- 1:25Michael Mulligan: It has to seriously endanger life, health, safety of Canadians.
- 1:29Michael Mulligan: It has to exceed the capacity or authority of provinces to deal with and this is important and that it cannot be effectively dealt with under any other law of Canada.
- 1:41Michael Mulligan: And so, the important thing and the judge finds this halfway through the decision he says look, the Emergencies Act is a tool of last resort.
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: The government can't invoke the Emergencies Act because it's convenient, it might work better than other tools at its disposal or disposal of the provinces.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: It doesn't mean that every other thing that you could possibly do has to have been tried right, the judge says that, but he said in this instance the evidence is clear.
- 2:11Michael Mulligan: The majority of the provinces were able to deal with the situation using other federal laws, such as the criminal code and their own legislation, and so that's really what's at the heart of the finding that the decision to use the Emergencies Act was unreasonable right, because, remember, we have really broad authority to do all kinds of things without having to declare an emergency right.
- 2:34Michael Mulligan: The criminal code can be enforced.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: It's unlawful to, for example, block people from going down the road, as we've talked about.
- 2:40Michael Mulligan: You can get an injunction in court in order people to be removed.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: You can enforce injunctions.
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: You can arrest people.
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: There are all these.
- 2:48Michael Mulligan: There's really quite broad authority that we have, without resorting to this act, that allows for the control of all sorts of situations, including things like you're blocking a road or you're blocking a bridge.
- 3:02Michael Mulligan: We don't have to resort to the Emergency Act to do that, and so the judge found that in virtually all the provinces, that was dealt with under those laws.
- 3:11Michael Mulligan: And even in the circumstance, like in Ottawa, where there's horn honking and people all around the Parliament buildings and blocking the road and so on, that it just wasn't on the evidence such that those things could not have been dealt with by operation of the laws that currently exist, and so there wasn't an evidentiary basis to declare this emergency and the extraordinary powers that it provides.
- 3:38Michael Mulligan: And then the judge moved on to a constitutional analysis and found that, on that basis as well, the regulations that were brought into place pursuant to this Emergency Act, which allow for really broad and draconian things, what was brought in and it's important to remember what was being challenged was not the act itself, like it wasn't a constitutional challenge saying, well, you can't have an emergencies act or in no circumstance could you have an emergency.
- 4:06Michael Mulligan: What was being challenged was the use of it in this case, and in that regard the judge found that the regulations the government did impose, which were quite sweeping right.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: They were doing things like requiring financial institutions to freeze bank accounts and credit cards of people they thought were associated, banning people from coming to the Parliament buildings, and so on.
- 4:27Michael Mulligan: He found that those were overbroad and were in breach of sections including 2B, the freedom of expression and opinion, and so on under the Charter freedom from search and seizure, section 8.
- 4:43Michael Mulligan: What they were doing involved things like freezing the bank accounts and credit cards of things like family members and joint account holders the people that were protesting such that they couldn't pay bills.
- 4:54Michael Mulligan: The judges found that was just way too broad and didn't meet the sort of minimal impairment that's required when you are going to be breaching somebody's constitutional rights, and so the judge found, on both those grounds, it was unreasonable and unconstitutional.
- 5:11Michael Mulligan: One of the interesting things that was argued that the judge found that he did not need to consider I think is worth noting is one of the other things that the litigants claimed was that the judge should be applying the Canadian Bill of Rights, which is a different thing from the Charter.
- 5:27Adam Stirling: The.
- 5:28Michael Mulligan: Bill of Rights is a piece of legislation that came in in 1960.
- 5:32Michael Mulligan: And it was sort of a predecessor to the Charter.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: But it's still in force and the way the Bill of Rights works is it's just an ordinary piece of federal legislation.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: But what it says is that unless another piece of, of course, you can't bind future parliaments right.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: Is it just a piece of legislation?
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: the government could in theory, the Parliament could repeal it right.
- 5:53Michael Mulligan: But it says that unless the parliament, unless other legislation expressly says that it's operating not withstanding the Bill of Rights, any other legislation should be interpreted in a way that doesn't abridge, abrogate or infringe the various things, the rights that are set out in the Bill of Rights.
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: That's how it's designed to operate, and one of the things the Bill of Rights has, which the Charter does not have, is a protection for property rights.
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: One of the protections of the Bill of Rights is, it says, the right of the individual to life, liberty, security of the person and enjoyment of property, and the right not to be deprived thereof except by due process of law.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: And so one of the I thought really creative arguments was hey look, this may not be.
- 6:39Michael Mulligan: You've frozen people's bank accounts without any process or allowing them to make any submissions.
- 6:44Michael Mulligan: You're freezing bank accounts of family members.
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: All of this without any process at all.
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: Those people didn't get to say anything about it.
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: There wasn't any hearing.
- 6:52Michael Mulligan: That they argued was in violation of the Canadian Bill of Rights.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: That's him, I think, a really good argument by the judge found.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: He didn't even need to get to that, he didn't even need to interpret it because of his principal findings that what the government did was both unreasonable and unconstitutional.
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: He didn't even need to use the interpretive powers or the Canadian bill of rights to find that what went on there may have also interfered with the enjoyment of property.
- 7:21Michael Mulligan: But that's an interesting thing people should know about.
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: That's the difference between Canada and the US.
- 7:26Michael Mulligan: Property rights are protected in their constitution.
- 7:28Michael Mulligan: They are not in Canada.
- 7:30Michael Mulligan: Now we still do have the Bill of Rights, but the Bill of Rights of course, or of course.
- 7:35Michael Mulligan: But the Bill of Rights applies only to federal legislation.
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: So you could not rely on the Bill of Rights to argue about, for example, what the government might be doing to landlords or condo owners or various people in BC, because those aren't federal laws, they're provincial.
- 7:50Michael Mulligan: And so that's the Bill of Rights.
- 7:52Michael Mulligan: That's how it was argued and that was the outcome of that I thought quite remarkable decision that the government announced it was going to appeal faster than anyone could possibly have read the thing.
- 8:02Michael Mulligan: But I guess we'll see what comes of it if you are interested in, say, an interesting 190-page careful analysis of what went on.
- 8:12Michael Mulligan: And boy are we fortunate to live in a country where we have an independent judiciary to review things like this and tell us whether what went on was lawful or not?
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: The answer here was no.
- 8:27Adam Stirling: Did the court make a finding as to whether the protest was legal?
- 8:32Michael Mulligan: Well, that's interesting.
- 8:33Michael Mulligan: The court was not declaring the protest to be legal and, in fact, what the court was saying is there may be things that were going on.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: Of course, protesting is legal.
- 8:40Michael Mulligan: Yes, but this one but the point the court's making is there are things going on that clearly would be, at least in my view, not legal.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: Like you can't legally block the bridge running to the United States to get your point across, any more than you can crazy glue yourself to the road on Blanchard or something to try to make your point that you don't like trees getting cut down, neither are legal right.
- 9:01Michael Mulligan: The point is that you don't need to invoke the Emergencies Act to unlaw the person from the road.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: You can go there and enforce the criminal law.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: You can get an injunction, you can do all sorts of things.
- 9:13Michael Mulligan: We don't need to go to the Emergencies Act.
- 9:15Michael Mulligan: It's just hey, you can't crazy, glue yourself to the road and you can't block a bridge in order to make your political point.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: The point is that we have authority to deal with that.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: You don't need to go here.
- 9:25Adam Stirling: Yeah, so in other words, we could have seen an outcome where they sent in the police horses and shot a bunch of people.
- 9:30Adam Stirling: That would be legal, but freezing bank accounts was illegal.
- 9:33Adam Stirling: Well, I don't know about the shooting people.
- 9:36Adam Stirling: Well, if they fought back, if they had weapons, look if it came to that.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: Fair enough.
- 9:40Michael Mulligan: But I mean, I'm saying, for example, if you've got trucks blocking a bridge, there's no question the police could show up and tow the trucks away, right, or arrest the people for doing it.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: Hey, you're committing a crime, you're under arrest, you don't need to get special emergency powers to do that.
- 9:54Michael Mulligan: It's already illegal.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: And whether the police force is doing what you think they should be doing, that's kind of a separate matter from do you have laws that allow them to do things?
- 10:03Michael Mulligan: Well, yes, of course we do.
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: We don't wait around until somebody decides to block the bridge or glue themselves to the road and then say, oh, my goodness, we have to set our hair on fire and declare an emergency.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: We've kind of thought of that in advance, and then so, unless you can show that, there isn't a way that it can be dealt with under the laws that exist you can't use this to sort of short circuit it.
- 10:24Adam Stirling: Interesting I'm just sort of thinking through this because it was the bank account freezing was the power that didn't exist anywhere else and they did apply that.
- 10:32Adam Stirling: So, absent the Emergencies Act, they would have had to disband the protests using other means.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: But even that, for example, right.
- 10:40Michael Mulligan: I mean we have laws on the books already dealing with things like proceeds of crime.
- 10:45Michael Mulligan: We've got laws on the books dealing with all kinds of sweeping things right.
- 10:48Michael Mulligan: And so the point is you can't go here because you think it might be easier or faster, or you know more efficient or whatever, or you don't like how the police are dealing with it.
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: That may have been part of what went on, if you recall the dynamic at the time.
- 11:03Michael Mulligan: You had this protest on the Parliament buildings and trucks blocking things and horns honking and the police didn't seem to be too engaged in moving some of that stuff along.
- 11:14Michael Mulligan: And so there is no doubt political pressure to do something.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: And the judge, I must say, is pretty restrained.
- 11:20Michael Mulligan: He's even sort of acknowledged the look.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: Yeah, he might have made the same wrong decision himself if he was called to at the time.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: But with the basis, with the benefit of hindsight and knowing what in fact was going on and looking carefully at the evidence, it just didn't meet the meet the requirements.
- 11:36Michael Mulligan: So it was unlawful, all right.
- 11:39Adam Stirling: Let's take our first break Legally speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 11:42Adam Stirling: Right after this, back to legally speaking here on CFAQ 1070 with Michael Mulligan, barrister, and Slycer with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 11:48Adam Stirling: Up next the latest on the Ridgeview Place saga, michael.
- 11:51Adam Stirling: But first I got a text and I just wanted to ask you how long might the appeal process take in the issue at the Emergencies Act before we have a final court ruling?
- 12:01Adam Stirling: That cannot be challenged.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: Perhaps years, because of course there could be an appeal from the federal court trial division to the federal court of appeal and then you could have, of course, one of the other parties seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 12:17Adam Stirling: Okay.
- 12:18Adam Stirling: So, we'll watch that with great interest.
- 12:20Adam Stirling: What's next?
- 12:20Adam Stirling: This is a complicated case.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: There's absolutely no doubt about that.
- 12:25Michael Mulligan: So this is a court of appeal decision dealing with the litigation that's arisen out of the Ridgeview Place debacle, and it is extremely complicated for a variety of reasons, but one of the central.
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: The background is this you had an original builder developer who wanted to construct that building, the.
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: The builder who wanted to build it hired a company to do that.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: That company then hired some engineers to do the engineering of the building.
- 12:56Michael Mulligan: It's now clear that the engineers had no experience doing that and were not competent to do the engineering on an 11 story building.
- 13:03Michael Mulligan: They nonetheless did so, knowing that they didn't know how to do that.
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: That's the origin of the problem.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: Now, the further complicating factors in the litigation included the fact that the original builders who built the thing sold the building, and they sold the building before that, before anyone was aware of that problem with the engineering, other than perhaps the engineers, of course, who knew they were incompetent to do it.
- 13:30Michael Mulligan: And so the company that owns the building now, or they group of people that's a limited partnership that owns the building is suing all in sundry trying to recover for the fact that they've got this building that's now completely defective right.
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: And things are made more complicated because the original builder developer has gone bankrupt, and so now you've got the entity that owns the building.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: Now who are they going to sue, and on what basis?
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: They can't really sue the well.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: They can't sue the people, the company they purchased it from, they're bankrupt, and the bankruptcy act provides that claims are stayed when you go into bankruptcy.
- 14:15Michael Mulligan: That's sort of the nature of the somebody going bankrupt.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: And so the owners of the building are trying to sue people, including the municipality Langford.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: They're also trying to sue the engineers saying, hey, you incompetent engineers, this is your fault, right, and it may be their fault, but the legal issues are these when you're suing somebody civilly, you need to have a basis to do that, and so one of the ways you could sue somebody would be for a breach of a contract, right?
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: So you say, hey, we had an agreement to do this, you didn't hold up your end of it.
- 14:51Michael Mulligan: I'm suing you for compensation.
- 14:52Michael Mulligan: That's pretty obvious, right?
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: The problem is the current owners of the building have no contract with the engineers.
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: The entity that had a contract with them was the original builder developer, and they're bankrupt.
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: Okay, so there's no contract with the engineers, and so the alternative approach is to sue them for what's referred to civilly as a tort, alleging that, hey, you were negligent in what you did, right, you were careless, you caused harm.
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: Now, the wrinkle here is that you, there has to be that concept of suing somebody for negligence or carelessness.
- 15:27Michael Mulligan: The law surrounding that requires there to be a sufficient proximity between the parties for there to be a duty of care.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: It's a bit of a mouthful, but the idea is that, let's say, you know, you see me flip and fall and get hurt on somebody else's yard.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: You can't.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: Well, that's not the best example.
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: The point is there has to be a connection between the person you're alleging was careless and the person who's suing, trying to get compensated for it.
- 15:54Michael Mulligan: Right, that's the basis of that.
- 15:57Michael Mulligan: And at the trial stage, the owners of the company tried suing the engineers, amongst various other people, right, like the bankrupt company and the municipality, and so on.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: Yes, and the judge found that there wasn't a sufficiently close proximate relationship between the engineers who worked for the original owner developer, right, and the new owners just say, well, hey, these people aren't closely connected enough, you can't sue them in negligence because they didn't know you a duty of care and, moreover, you have no contract with them.
- 16:30Michael Mulligan: They had a contract with the original builder developer.
- 16:33Michael Mulligan: So who are you to sue them?
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: You're out of luck.
- 16:36Michael Mulligan: And so the judge at the trial stage found that the current owners were basically out of luck because you bought it from somebody who's bankrupt, and it was the bankrupt entity that had the agreement with these engineers that weren't competent to do the work, and so you don't have a claim.
- 16:55Michael Mulligan: And so that's the meat of what got appealed to the court of appeal, and the court of appeal decision that just came out yesterday concluded that the judge who heard that was mistaken.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: And they did a careful analysis of the nature of the relationship between the engineering company and the company that went bankrupt and the new purchasers and how the sale transaction worked, and they relied upon a Supreme Court of Canada decision that dealt with condominium owners suing for defects in their condos and ultimately came to the opposite decision of the judge who originally heard the case and found that there was, at least on the face of it, enough proximity between the engineers, who didn't have the necessary authority and necessary skills to engineer this thing properly, and the company that purchased it and so found that the claim can go ahead.
- 17:55Michael Mulligan: It shouldn't have been stopped against the engineers.
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: But there are other interesting things that to come out of the decision, including pointing out that the engineering company which took on this task, despite having no employees or members with the necessary experience to do it, they found that one of the issues there is that the contract between that engineering company and the original builder developer had a provision that said their liability, the engineer's liability, was capped at the amount of fees they charged.
- 18:31Adam Stirling: So a refund, a refund.
- 18:34Michael Mulligan: Sorry, we blew it, we didn't know what we were doing, so you can get your money back.
- 18:38Michael Mulligan: You paid us.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: That's an interesting clause.
- 18:41Michael Mulligan: If you've ever had a house inspection, you'll find that if you carefully review the contract from the house inspector, one of the common clauses is exactly that.
- 18:50Michael Mulligan: It says that if I'm negligent, my liability is limited to the $500 you paid to have the house inspector.
- 19:00Michael Mulligan: And so the court of appeal found that that's going to be an issue and that, unlike what the original judge thought should happen, which was to try to deal with the matter by way of what's called a summary trial, sort of an abbreviated trial process, the court of appeal said no, there's going to have to be a full trial to deal with issues, including that issue, which would be like is there I think it was some $80,000 or something Is that the full limit of the liability for the engineers who did this work?
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: And so this will mean that the thing can go back and that there be a trial.
- 19:37Michael Mulligan: I must say, reading the court of appeal decision as well, it is quite concerning in terms of the risk that people were living in that building, one of the things which was concluded by the engineers and geoscientists of British Columbia, like the regulatory body that regulates the people was that the investigation into it, their investigation into it, concluded that quote elements of the gravity system design which could fail suddenly and with little warning, and so the conclusion was, at least from that entity, that the building was subject to.
- 20:18Michael Mulligan: it Sounds like the little warning falling down is what I take from that language.
- 20:23Michael Mulligan: It's also notable the court of appeal noted that one of the engineers who worked on the thing had been cited by that regulatory body for what the body concluded was unprofessional conduct and incompetence, and so all of this is clearly a giant legal mess.
- 20:47Michael Mulligan: But it is now of course.
- 20:49Michael Mulligan: Of course, but it is clear reading is where the fault lies.
- 20:52Michael Mulligan: It's really at the matter.
- 20:54Michael Mulligan: At the end of the day, the issue is going to be who's going to pay, if anyone?
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: Or are the current owners who bought the thing just left holding the bag?
- 21:04Michael Mulligan: Because the people they bought it from are bankrupt and the engineer or engineering company has this clause limiting their liability, and so at the end of the day, it will be a matter of are they left holding the bag, and or is there some liability for the municipality?
- 21:22Michael Mulligan: Because of course, with these things not of course, but I think with construction litigation.
- 21:28Michael Mulligan: when you have things like companies going bankrupt, or companies that are created for the purpose of one project and they're then gone, the only entity at the end of the day that still exists may be things like the municipality right Going anywhere, and so if you're the last man standing, you can wind up with holding the bag for a whole lot of things, even if your liability for it was only a small portion of what went on, and even where it's clear, at least on the court of appeals decision, that the fundamental problem was the issue of the engineering company taking on a project that they knew full well they didn't have the experience to do and providing a design that, according to the engineers and geoscientists in British Columbia, could have led to a sudden failure with little warning.
- 22:22Michael Mulligan: Obviously a completely unsatisfactory circumstance.
- 22:25Michael Mulligan: But there'll now be a trial and there could be a determination made about whether the engineers are liable to the new entity and, if so, is that new owners and if so, is that liability limited to the fees that they received?
- 22:42Adam Stirling: There's some interesting information here.
- 22:44Adam Stirling: I might have actually solved the mystery as to why the second evacuation happened, but that'll be coming up, michael.
- 22:48Adam Stirling: Thank you, as always, appreciate the thoughts.
- 22:50Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:51Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 22:51Adam Stirling: All right, we'll be speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday on CFAGS.