Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / What’s Next for Credit Unions - with Mike Macchiarola of Olden Lane
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:04I'm here today with the return guest of the show of Old
- 0:07and Lame, Mike Macchiarola.
- 0:08Mike, how are you doing today?
- 0:10Doing great.
- 0:11Glad to hear it.
- 0:12Interesting times.
- 0:13We had a little pre chat maybe we'll talk about some of the
- 0:16pre chat here on the call.
- 0:17But, I get your newsletter.
- 0:19I follow you guys on LinkedIn.
- 0:21And you had an interesting article, your newsletter for January that caught my eye
- 0:29called the 10 themes for the new year.
- 0:32And I reached out and thought, hey, let's walk through these on a podcast.
- 0:36You hadn't been on for a few months.
- 0:38Wanted to get you back on the show and Mike for people who might not
- 0:43have listened to some of your other shows that I've had you on or are
- 0:46not familiar with Old and Lane.
- 0:48Could you give your background and a little description of what Old and
- 0:51Lane does for the credit union world?
- 0:54Thanks for having me on Mark.
- 0:56Really appreciate it.
- 0:57Olden Lane is a broker dealer and a registered investment advisor.
- 1:01But really what we are is a boutique investment bank that meets the
- 1:05needs of credit unions exclusively.
- 1:08We're unique in that sense To our knowledge, we're the
- 1:11only one who has that charge.
- 1:13We've really cut our teeth or made our name to the extent that we have
- 1:16in the subordinated debt market.
- 1:19We've been in that game since about 2018 or so and have now brought more than 50
- 1:24clients through that process successfully.
- 1:27We've raised more than a billion dollars of approvals and is that
- 1:31almost that much in, in In actual dollars all for low income credit
- 1:37unions, although that rules expanded.
- 1:39We're yet to see anyone in the industry other than a like, who raised money.
- 1:43That's a curious thing.
- 1:45And increasingly in the most recent period, we've been in the M and a game.
- 1:50Our biggest deal to date has been the Kiesler Jefferson merger that
- 1:54was announced end of last year.
- 1:56That's just about finishing up its regulatory approval process.
- 2:00And we just announced the beginning of this year the first full bank purchase.
- 2:05By a credit union in the state of California.
- 2:08That's the front wave transaction buying Community Valley Bank's assets.
- 2:13So we're excited about that.
- 2:14It's taken us some time to get our team totally aligned with both of those
- 2:19verticals but we are now full steam ahead in both business lines and excited to
- 2:24be servicing the credit union community.
- 2:26Yeah, just in time because I think mergers, I think actually
- 2:29we have that on the list here.
- 2:30Mergers.
- 2:31I'm hearing a lot of chatter from my credit union conversations, both
- 2:35with clients and non clients and the stats, I think, show that we'll
- 2:39get to that here in a few minutes.
- 2:41Most likely.
- 2:42You the article newsletter is laid out greatly.
- 2:45I'm just going to walk through.
- 2:46through the specific topics and let me know what your thoughts are on what the
- 2:50newsletter said or anything else related to that because, things change quick.
- 2:54That was the January newsletter.
- 2:56Here we are early February and there's a lot going on in the world in so many ways.
- 3:01All right.
- 3:01So the first topic on the newsletter is hire for longer.
- 3:05Let's talk about hire for longer and without going back and reading it.
- 3:09I'm sure rates have something to do with this.
- 3:11Mike, let's chat.
- 3:12Yes, sir.
- 3:13So let's paint the historical picture 1st, right?
- 3:16So we had a benign interest rate era for a good decade.
- 3:21Where we didn't have to concern ourselves too much with the traditional metrics
- 3:25that a banker cares the most about which is what's going in my front door
- 3:29and what's going out my back door.
- 3:31With interest rates benign or basically at zero, close there too the effects
- 3:37were not felt as broadly as they might otherwise be when they were around.
- 3:42What happened is we ended up in a two and a half year period.
- 3:46Ending in October of last year, where the twos and tens were inverted an
- 3:50inverted yield curve is not a friend of financial institution because essentially
- 3:55we typically borrow short and lend long and an inverted yield curve makes
- 4:00that not so profitable of an exercise.
- 4:03That inversion unwound the end of last year as the.
- 4:07Rate cutting set in at the Fed.
- 4:10What's interesting here is that everybody was optimistic that the rate cutting would
- 4:14take a lot of the pressure off of the 500 points of rate increases that have
- 4:20been going on for the last two years.
- 4:23But what's happened here is since September of 24, Fed funds rate at
- 4:27that point was a five and a half.
- 4:29They cut a hundred basis points and brought Fed funds to four and a half.
- 4:33But during that time, the 10 year rate.
- 4:36Rose in the face of that 3 65 to basically 4 45 where it is today.
- 4:43So we've had 100 basis points of cutting and 100 basis points of interest rate
- 4:48effects on the 10 year going higher.
- 4:50That is.
- 4:52Made it difficult for those who thought that those cuts would be
- 4:56beneficial and would take some of the pain off of the cost of funds.
- 5:01The average cost of funds in light of all those moves has continued to rise
- 5:05in the industry, settling at around 218 in Q4, and just to give you a
- 5:11ballpark, that's up from a 58 basis point level industry wide in, in,
- 5:17The 2 year ago period of Q4 of 2022.
- 5:20So absorbing more than 150 basis points of increase on your cost of funds has
- 5:26obviously put pressure on credit unions.
- 5:30The fact that the rates have stayed high here is also going
- 5:35to have an acute creative, an acute problem for some, because.
- 5:42By the estimates of Callahan, about 80 percent of the CDs that are out
- 5:46in the industry are expected to roll over by September of this year.
- 5:51If they roll over and you don't get a benefit of the repricing because rates
- 5:56have not moved back in, it's going to hurt more than many had expected.
- 6:02So that's why you're seeing pressure that comes from this interest rate environment.
- 6:08And it's, it's stressing many credit unions Very acutely at this point.
- 6:13Yeah, a lot of variables here, but when you walk through that, and I put my
- 6:16old examiner hat on, and I'm thinking of a credit union that might have some
- 6:19pressures already on profitability, and they're having to, having to pay 150 basis
- 6:26points more, maybe they're making up.
- 6:28A hundred of that on the loan side.
- 6:30Maybe not.
- 6:31And then they're going, okay where can I cut on my operating expenses?
- 6:35And the operating expenses, they've got their data processing contract
- 6:40locked up for X number of years visas locked up for X number of years.
- 6:45They just lost their CFO to the bigger credit union down the street.
- 6:49They're looking out at the market.
- 6:51You've got inflation, which is impacting salaries.
- 6:54And you find yourself in this Robin from Peter to pay Paul to figure out what that
- 6:59budget is going to be to show that you can break even or make half of what you
- 7:03made two years ago, et cetera, et cetera.
- 7:06So that's that I think that's probably a challenge.
- 7:09That a lot of credit unions are dealing with out there because of what's going
- 7:14on with the hire for longer potentially.
- 7:16Any thoughts on that?
- 7:18Yeah, you've hit it, you've hit the nail on the head.
- 7:20It's the, none of these can be seen in isolation, right?
- 7:25So all of them mix together and you're right.
- 7:29We're an industry of gentlemen and gentle ladies.
- 7:31So we tread lightly on head count.
- 7:34And so that lever is pulled reluctantly if it's pulled.
- 7:38And we saw a big announcement today of a headcount reduction at a big credit union.
- 7:42We're going to continue to see those.
- 7:44Those are done reluctantly.
- 7:46I will tell you when we start and I don't want to jump the gun to the MNA discussion
- 7:50that I'm sure we'll have, but Yeah, I already jumped at the profitability.
- 7:53Sorry about that, but yeah.
- 7:54That's okay.
- 7:55But when we start to screen for those MNA client potential Merging
- 8:00credit unions, if you will.
- 8:02One of the things we look for is if they're, if their
- 8:06liabilities have not yet repriced.
- 8:08That is, they're inside that 218 and they're struggling to gain profitability.
- 8:14It's only going to get worse when those CDs and share certificates or
- 8:19their members ask for more rent rate.
- 8:22And if you can't make it work, When you're inside the 218 industry
- 8:26level, it's going to be really hard when you catch up to peer group.
- 8:30The other thing is, if your OPEX is already inside peer group,
- 8:36and there's not anything left.
- 8:38You're cutting now into bone, right?
- 8:40So there are plenty of credit unions that are suffering.
- 8:43And honestly, the levers are not there to pull.
- 8:46The other thing is there are some one time levers, right?
- 8:49We've seen, we've gone through a couple episodes where we've
- 8:51seen the sale lease back.
- 8:53We've seen the sale of Visa B shares.
- 8:56Those trades are only available once we've seen the sale of a headquarters
- 9:01but when you start to pull on those, you've pulled on your rainy day
- 9:05fund and, you're now stuck with some choices that are not great.
- 9:08And as you and I talked about in a couple episodes ago.
- 9:12When you're in that position, your menu your option set as a
- 9:16potential target in M& A shrinks.
- 9:19And so you don't want to get yourself to the M& A discussion
- 9:23when you don't have the full panoply of options in front of you.
- 9:26You got that right.
- 9:27Yeah.
- 9:27And in those one time profit saving events, NCUA heavily discounts
- 9:32those and says, that's great.
- 9:33Now, what have you done for me lately and what's your core profitability?
- 9:36So you're spot on on that.
- 9:38And one of the other levers.
- 9:39Historically has been tweaking your fee income, whether, in the old days, you
- 9:43could say let's, you'd have a credit union that had a little bit of had to put
- 9:47together a net worth restoration plan.
- 9:49They'd say, yeah, let's raise our NSF fees.
- 9:515.
- 9:52Let's raise our overdraft fees.
- 9:545.
- 9:55We'll put a fee on this.
- 9:56We'll start charging fees to, to get out inactive accounts and
- 10:00that'll help us restore capital.
- 10:03And so that gets us to topic two, regulatory pressure on fees.
- 10:07Yes.
- 10:08Some good news here.
- 10:10Couple things.
- 10:10Number one is you just hit capital.
- 10:12So capital's at great levels.
- 10:15The industry strong the net worth ratio across the industry strong, but we always
- 10:19caution folks that median net worth and mean net worth industry wide is of
- 10:25little relevance to a particular credit union at a particular moment in time.
- 10:29So, my father used to always say there's only one unemployment rate.
- 10:33It's either zero or a hundred you either have a job or you don't
- 10:37it's the same essentially for the capital level of a credit union.
- 10:40You really don't care so much about everyone else You
- 10:43care about yourself, right?
- 10:44But the fee pressure this is good news, right?
- 10:47So the fee pressure has been coming for a while it's been coming largely
- 10:51from the CFPB and it's been, pretty significant now the NCUA got in on
- 10:56the act a couple of different ways.
- 10:59The 1st was that the 5300 reporting since the beginning of last year for
- 11:04those above a billion dollar level has included a breakout of NSF and OD fees.
- 11:10And then the second way that the NCOA got involved was their letter to credit
- 11:14unions, 24 03, which was about unfair and abusive and deceptive practices and fees.
- 11:22So it looked as if they were getting harmonized with the CFPB, which
- 11:26is, terrific from a regulatory standpoint, and all of that.
- 11:31Probably slow thanks to the Trump administration's approach to CFPB, right?
- 11:37Last week they appointed Treasury Secretary Besant
- 11:41as the acting CFPB director.
- 11:44Seems to indicate that they are going to treat it much like they did last time with
- 11:48Mick Mulvaney essentially put it to sleep.
- 11:51That should mean that the regulatory pressure coming
- 11:53on the fee side should ease.
- 11:56The other thing that's happened, obviously, is that we've changed
- 11:59the chairman at the NCUA.
- 12:01And my bet is that fees in light of the political structure and
- 12:05the change of guard there are not going to be top of the list.
- 12:10Now, I don't think it's going to Way, I think more than ever we've
- 12:14seen sort of constructive work.
- 12:16I think credit unions own approach and own appetite for NSF and OD fees
- 12:22has changed a little bit here, right?
- 12:24Yeah.
- 12:25So I think it will have a it will have a persistence.
- 12:28It will be sticky, which is probably good.
- 12:30But here is where I take a little bit of.
- 12:34Exception to the NCA.
- 12:35They did it.
- 12:35They did a research note that they released a couple weeks ago, and I
- 12:40appreciate what they're trying to do.
- 12:42They're trying to really measure the sensitivity of fees and
- 12:44what's going on, but they make.
- 12:45Vast, sweeping conclusions based on a very small data set for a very
- 12:51small universe of credit unions.
- 12:54And they try to extrapolate from three quarters of data
- 12:58what's going on under the hood.
- 13:00There's no allowance for the fact that many of those institutions cater to very
- 13:05different regions, very different Groups.
- 13:08Some face the underserved in a big way, some not so much, just based on
- 13:12geography and historical presence.
- 13:14And so I think we've gotta hesitate before we draw massive conclusions
- 13:19from a very small sa sample of data.
- 13:22You said that very nicely.
- 13:23I, I need to go back and look at that data.
- 13:25'cause I was chatting with one of my, one of my team members who
- 13:29said, Hey, have you looked at that?
- 13:31I said, I saw the headlines.
- 13:33And and he had already read it, and he said what you said, but then went on to
- 13:38say the economist at NCOA said we can't draw conclusions of X, Y, and Z on this.
- 13:43And then the former chairman Harper went on and drew some
- 13:47conclusions from some limited data.
- 13:50Yeah, and he's very passionate about that topic.
- 13:52So he highlighted what he could highlight to help make his point.
- 13:56The pivot point to the new chairman.
- 13:59We're recording this on Wednesday, 1st, Wednesday of February.
- 14:05The priority letter to NCA also refers to overdrafts and consumer
- 14:10compliance and things like that.
- 14:11That was issued by Harper.
- 14:13Tomorrow, NCA is doing a webinar on the the priority letter.
- 14:18Typically, those are kicked off by the chairman.
- 14:20So I had a, I'll put a link in the show notes.
- 14:22I did a, here's what the, what the helpmann administration might mean to
- 14:26credit unions, but one of the things I posed was, what is he gonna do?
- 14:30Is he going to skip that meeting?
- 14:31Is he going to cancel the meeting?
- 14:33Is he going to go into it and say, and we're canceling the letter, which
- 14:36he has the authority to do because he's the spokesperson for the agency.
- 14:39So he could cancel those if he wants to, or is he going to say, we're looking at
- 14:43it and we're going to have a softer touch on overdrafts than we implicated there.
- 14:47And this is where, when I was at NCOA, if I was there right now I would get calls
- 14:51from the regional directors saying, Hey, Mark, the priority letter says we're
- 14:56supposed to do this and we haven't pulled the letter and the Trump administration is
- 15:02saying this and the CFPB is saying this.
- 15:05My examiners need to know how to deal with overdrafts on the exam.
- 15:09And until I could get a commitment from the board you'd have to, you'd
- 15:14have to tell them it's in flux.
- 15:15It's not a good answer while you're in sending examiners out there because they.
- 15:19They like clarity and the credit unions need clarity.
- 15:21So that stickiness is there because that's one of the things that leads to
- 15:24that stickiness too, is they're going to get unclear guidance from NCOA until NCOA
- 15:29either says, okay, that's off the table.
- 15:32Our letter that we wrote last year is off the table, which again, Hauptmann
- 15:36can do, or he can put his own, he put his own priorities out, which
- 15:39were a big picture priority, but that letter is still out there saying
- 15:42they're going to do A, B, and C.
- 15:44And then they've got.
- 15:46I'm going down a rabbit hole.
- 15:47They have an internal internal instruction that issues what
- 15:50their scope is for their exams.
- 15:52Nobody knows what it is, but internally, and some chairmen's look at that.
- 15:57Some chairmen's don't Kyle Hoffman.
- 15:59If you're listening, you should look at that and see if it's consistent
- 16:01with what you want the scope to be.
- 16:03All right.
- 16:05Yep.
- 16:06No it's in flux and we'll get to that.
- 16:08I have a lot.
- 16:09I keep you, you're going to say, I will get to that when we get later.
- 16:12I keep, I have a hard time keeping these things.
- 16:15It's like I said, it's a soup.
- 16:17It all mixes together.
- 16:18The other thing on, on, on the fees is we cannot, as an industry, get to
- 16:23a place where the words non sufficient funds are overdraft or we just can't.
- 16:28We have to make allowance for the fact that this industry reaches different
- 16:33demographics and different folks at different parts of the ladder.
- 16:37And so there are particular credit unions where we work with the people and I can
- 16:41assure you, I have the greatest heart and the greatest tolerance, but they
- 16:47are in a place where their riskiness dictates a certain the expectation
- 16:53that if they just took it away.
- 16:56They would threaten their business, their franchise, and then you'd be in
- 16:59a place where people who need those financial services and the delivery of
- 17:03those products and services would be just, out of luck, and I can't do that.
- 17:08And a guy who needs to get a replacement tire.
- 17:11It could be a used tire, right?
- 17:13He has to get a used tire for his truck so he can go out to work so he
- 17:16can put, food on the family table is better off getting an NSF fee than going
- 17:23to the predatory lenders that are out there and that is a service that we
- 17:27can't let credit unions get away from.
- 17:29And the hyper focus in my opinion, the hyper focus on fees of the
- 17:33Biden administration Was getting dangerously close to actually harming
- 17:39people when it was trying to do good.
- 17:41I think it could be intellectually lazy to paint every credit union and every
- 17:46style in every region with the same brush, again The data will tell you
- 17:51some things and you've got to be careful and you can't Read them too broadly,
- 17:54but at the same time, you have to have a heart here somewhere underneath and
- 17:58make allowance for, customization.
- 18:01Another non sequitur you reminded me of a former NCOA Attorney who
- 18:05retired and at his retirement party.
- 18:07He said he was a lazy genius I'll take it.
- 18:11And you know what?
- 18:12He was right.
- 18:13I never free.
- 18:14He's a great guy.
- 18:15A smart guy.
- 18:16I enjoyed chatting with him, but but he nailed it.
- 18:19He knew it.
- 18:20If you don't, by the time you're at the end of your career, hopefully you
- 18:22can know yourself and he knew himself.
- 18:24Self assessment.
- 18:24That's a good self assessment.
- 18:26All right.
- 18:27So that's a good pivot to the.
- 18:29The strained consumer, which is up next.
- 18:32Let's chat about the strained consumer and the the impact that's happening on
- 18:37our soup that we're building here today.
- 18:39Look, you could stop at any moment in time and, throw the towel in on the U.
- 18:43S.
- 18:43consumer but you'd be wrong most of the time.
- 18:46So there always just seems to be a tolerance for more, right?
- 18:49I opened the household credit report from the Federal Reserve and my eyes
- 18:53bulge out of my head when I see 17.
- 18:5794 trillion dollars of household debt.
- 18:59When I look at the California line and I look at debt encumbrance at 90, 000 per
- 19:04person and I say what does that mean?
- 19:06We had a big discussion in the office the other day about that.
- 19:10All I know is California is a good 15, 000 higher than the next.
- 19:15Illinois.
- 19:15So congratulations.
- 19:17But again, at what point do you truly throw the towel in?
- 19:20I will caution that when it comes to credit you go up in an elevator
- 19:24and you go down in an escalator.
- 19:26Here we are 11 percent of credit card balances in the U S or
- 19:3090 days or more delinquent.
- 19:32That makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up, but you know what, here we are.
- 19:36There's been a significant drop in a continued drop quarter over
- 19:39quarter in personal savings rate where it really expresses itself
- 19:42for credit unions, the delinquency lines getting to be a little ugly.
- 19:48It has been running now, all the way since quarter 1 of 2022 where it bottomed
- 19:54out at 42 basis points at the time.
- 19:57We were ringing the bell here that there may be a spring effect
- 20:01in those numbers because all the moratoria that had been building.
- 20:04And I think we're seeing it.
- 20:06I think the chickens are coming home to roost.
- 20:08We're at 97 basis points in the most recent quarter here and it's causing acute
- 20:13stresses in pockets You're seeing some of the bigger credit unions that tend
- 20:19to have commercial real estate exposure there's some serious issues in a couple
- 20:24places some of the credit unions who were Addicted to growth in a certain
- 20:29sense in the last few periods have gone out on a binge on the consumer unsecured
- 20:38where you've seen a lot of stress.
- 20:40And I think in the auto patch in certain pockets you're seeing some softness.
- 20:44And the word here is just be careful.
- 20:46I would, like I said, I'm not going to call the end of the day or ring the bell.
- 20:50But the consumer is under stress and just know that lurks in the
- 20:53background of everything you're trying to do as a credit union.
- 20:56Which is going to segue us right into the next one which is loan growth.
- 21:00Yeah, so the challenging environment for loan growth.
- 21:02Let's speak to that.
- 21:03Yeah, here it looks like in the, the last credit unions are still reporting,
- 21:09but it looks like we're going to be right around 5 percent growth of loans
- 21:11in Q4 which reverses a quarter over quarter decline that's been in the
- 21:15market for a while, for about two years.
- 21:18So I don't know whether that's an anomalous piece of data.
- 21:21I don't know if it's yet bottomed out and we're going to see growth.
- 21:24I do think we want to look for loan growth coming off an environment that
- 21:29was tight on the liquidity side, and that should be easing where interest
- 21:33rates have probably bottomed, topped so that, that effect should be seen.
- 21:38Bearing off and you're certainly going to get pro growth posture and less
- 21:43regulatory posture across a large swath of industries, which should
- 21:48encourage typical lending activity and growth in the broader economy.
- 21:52I do think, you're going to see some long growth here.
- 21:56I think it will take a little bit time to lag in.
- 21:59But I definitely am more bullish on loan growth and that
- 22:03has knock on effects as well.
- 22:04I think that will more than anything else.
- 22:07I think that will wake back up the sub debt market.
- 22:10Because as much as people will complain about interest rate the
- 22:13absolute level of interest rates is irrelevant when you've priced in both
- 22:16sides of the balance sheet and we've found a new level of normalization.
- 22:20What's more important in my mind is do you have true visibility and belief
- 22:24in your loan growth because if you can see that and you understand that
- 22:28you have pricing room then you can.
- 22:31Project out that you can grow into a levered balance sheet and an
- 22:35appropriate amount of sub debt is probably an order for many institutions
- 22:39that have been waiting it out.
- 22:41Yeah.
- 22:41When I think of that too I'm wondering, you can't paint
- 22:45with the broad brush, right?
- 22:46That's the average.
- 22:47Where is it happening?
- 22:48Are there states where it's 2%?
- 22:50Are there states where it's 10%?
- 22:52Where are the winners and losers individually?
- 22:55But to see the number.
- 22:56Going in the right direction.
- 22:58Hopefully that trend will continue.
- 23:00So the next step we've got, we talked about profitability, but
- 23:05profitability has been getting squeezed general thoughts in addition
- 23:09to what we might have already said.
- 23:11Yeah, here it's all of the stresses we've identified.
- 23:13It's a little bit of credit deterioration.
- 23:16It's probably we're feeling the effects of some lax underwriting standards
- 23:21some reaching for growth and or yield some tighter liquidity some underwater
- 23:26investments that continue to mature or roll off, but are doing it slowly and
- 23:31the underwater ness, if you will, is as high as it's ever been because the
- 23:36interest rate rip was as fast and as aggressive as it's ever been We're chewing
- 23:42through it and we're being constructive.
- 23:43I'm just worried that, not everyone's going to get to the other side.
- 23:47If you look at the absolute level of return on assets 64 basis points.
- 23:52But again, there's a pretty significant variance.
- 23:54We're doing some work here.
- 23:56We're not through it yet to understand both geography where that cuts.
- 24:01And I think also size matters here and not as much as you think in the positive way.
- 24:08Being bigger here can be more dangerous because they can wear bigger risks and
- 24:14some of those bigger deteriorations on credit are being felt at the
- 24:18more sophisticated, larger shops that are into more sophisticated
- 24:21asset classes that are suffering.
- 24:23So we're doing some work on that.
- 24:25But overall, yeah.
- 24:27We need to be more profitable than 64 basis points.
- 24:29I know that for some, they say, wait a minute, it's a non for profit industry.
- 24:34What are you talking about?
- 24:35That level doesn't matter, we have a saying over here.
- 24:37If it don't make sense, it don't make dollars.
- 24:40And you have to make dollars because you have to continue to squirrel
- 24:44money away and retain earnings because that is your war chest.
- 24:48That's what allows you to fight for a rainy day.
- 24:50That's what allows you to build capital.
- 24:52And if you're not growing that.
- 24:55Capital and that retained earnings line fast enough.
- 24:58You're out running that rainy day fund, that cushion, that risk absorbing capital.
- 25:03And it's not good again, though.
- 25:05Capital levels are pretty significantly high, historically high for the industry.
- 25:10Good as an overall measure but not quite there for every credit union, if you will.
- 25:15Now, a great point.
- 25:16I don't think I have it based on what you just said there.
- 25:19What we said previously, nothing for me to add on that.
- 25:22I guess maybe other than 1 thing I always used to like to do is and something I want
- 25:26to do when I see the December data is how many losers and winners were there, right?
- 25:30So the average is 64 basis points.
- 25:32You're saying the smaller ones might have some flexibility.
- 25:36That normally would be normally you'd see the better profit at the bigger
- 25:39ones as opposed to the smaller one.
- 25:41I always like to have the context of the 4400 credit unions.
- 25:46What's the number that lost money?
- 25:48Because they're definitely on into his radar.
- 25:51That is 1 of their risk reports.
- 25:53The lose the loser report.
- 25:54So it's big this quarter.
- 25:56It's we were parsing through that the other day.
- 25:58It's significant.
- 25:59It's a significant list.
- 26:00It's not a short list this quarter.
- 26:02Yeah, there was some pretty big impairments.
- 26:04Some big numbers, some big write downs from some prominent folks.
- 26:08Yeah.
- 26:08Yeah.
- 26:09And that if you're going to have a loss, you might as
- 26:11well have a little bit bigger.
- 26:13I, my advice always with credit unions, when I was at the
- 26:18supervisory level or lower was, make rip the bandaid off, right?
- 26:22Don't cherry pick and go, gosh, we're only losing 20 basis
- 26:25points this year and then lose.
- 26:2730 basis points the next year and then 30 basis points the next year, right?
- 26:31If you got, if you've got allowance to deal with, if you've got some
- 26:34other bad decision to write off, reposition yourself get to the bottom,
- 26:38the first go round and NCOA will.
- 26:42We'll view that better than you being on a one time loser, two time
- 26:45loser, three time loser report.
- 26:47So it's a little late for that advice because everybody's filed their December.
- 26:50But next year, keep that in mind, listeners, if you
- 26:53find yourself in that boat.
- 26:56So consolidation, increased consolidation we touched on a little bit.
- 26:59I know you're seeing it.
- 27:00I know I'm seeing it.
- 27:01You talked about it in, in the newsletter general thoughts on consolidation as
- 27:06we sit here today, early February.
- 27:08Yeah, I'm in 2024.
- 27:11Big year.
- 27:11The credit union for bank style transaction is out there in spades.
- 27:18Last year was a record setting year.
- 27:2022 of those.
- 27:20I think again, like I said, we started, we kicked off the year
- 27:24with one big one in California.
- 27:26There are more that are in play.
- 27:27Certainly.
- 27:28And we're seeing a lot of those banks quietly shop credit unions are good
- 27:32buyers certain jurisdictions they're not because the legislatures have seen fit
- 27:39through a lot of twisting of arms from the bank lobby to, to make a rule or to
- 27:45have folklore that basically says credit unions buying banks is no, no good.
- 27:49But that's a small select few states for the most part.
- 27:53This is still open for business.
- 27:55The N.
- 27:55C.
- 27:55U.
- 27:55A.
- 27:55Has been supportive.
- 27:57Those bank transactions are fairly dilutive to capital.
- 28:00And so you have to keep your capital level in, in the in the screen when
- 28:05you're on the radar, when you're doing those not only your PCA net worth,
- 28:08but also your risk based capital understanding the effects of those
- 28:12transactions on intangible assets and goodwill and what you can carry.
- 28:17But we're going to see more of them.
- 28:18I think what we haven't yet seen as much of that I think we're going to see a
- 28:23lot of is bank deals is branch deals.
- 28:25Here we've got a few at Olden Lane.
- 28:28We've got a few more on the table here.
- 28:30I like the branch deal as a solution at the margin for some
- 28:34credit unions that want to validate or optimize their geography.
- 28:39Sometimes you end up with a stray branch, a distance away, and it honestly is
- 28:43better parked in some other credit union.
- 28:45And so you may want to swap out of those members and into it can
- 28:49also enhance your financial ratios.
- 28:52It can be seen as a way to go back to core and protect the hub as
- 28:57opposed to a hub plus satellites.
- 29:00So we're seeing a lot of folks rationalize what they've got, and if
- 29:04it makes sense, they will part with a branch to another credit union.
- 29:07Two reasons why I see consolidation continuing one is anecdotally the
- 29:13amount of time in my day that's spent to that issue is just off the charts.
- 29:17So when my phone rings chances are it's going to be on that subject.
- 29:20And the 2nd thing is when you look at this industry.
- 29:24And, I started down this road about a year ago on this particular statistic
- 29:30and chairman Harper picked it up.
- 29:33So I was either flattered or annoyed.
- 29:35I think I was probably more flattered.
- 29:37But if you break out the industry.
- 29:40Very crudely, and these levels are arbitrary, but in the 10 billion
- 29:45Q3 numbers because everybody's not report, but in Q3 in the 10 billion
- 29:52or more club for assets, 21 credit units in the billion to 10 billion
- 29:59asset club, 425 credit units.
- 30:03Below a billion, 4200 credit unions, so 90 percent of this
- 30:09industry is below a billion.
- 30:10Now, I don't, a billion is not a magic number, we can do it down to 250, down
- 30:14to 100, wherever you want to slice it.
- 30:16But we've got a lot of credit unions that are below a level where many folks would
- 30:21think it's optimal to run systems that are accountable to members in terms of,
- 30:27What they want best in class on, mobile platform and solutions and payments
- 30:32and cyber security and compliance.
- 30:35There is a lot to do.
- 30:37It has a lot of costs.
- 30:38That cost is in what you pay your vendors and your solution providers.
- 30:42It's also in what you pay your employees.
- 30:44It's also in the strength, quality, and frequency of your footprint.
- 30:49And those are just big costs that honestly, it favors bigger players.
- 30:54So I just think the consolidation is going to continue.
- 30:56The other thing that's there is age.
- 30:58We have an aging population of C suites.
- 31:02We have an aging population of board members.
- 31:04I don't know if this is a secret or not, but the 25 to 35 year old set,
- 31:09they're not big into volunteering on the boards of financial institutions.
- 31:13They want, they like their free time and they want to be paid.
- 31:17So I don't know how long we're going to push that model.
- 31:19It's going to continue to be strained.
- 31:22No, you're right the boards are getting older.
- 31:24The staffs are getting older.
- 31:25On consolidation, the branch at the branch.
- 31:29Spin off, I think is good to from the perspective of if you're.
- 31:34You're having exam challenges and your net worth is you're in a situation
- 31:39where you might have to put a net worth restoration plan together.
- 31:41And the only solution is shrinking by reducing your rates or shrinking
- 31:46by cutting staff that you might need is 1 way to do it for a year or 2.
- 31:51But you get so lean that it can cause it can buy you time.
- 31:57But the spinoff where you're purging off a whole area that might be break
- 32:01even and maybe making a profit on the sale of it and quickly getting a little
- 32:07bit smaller footprint, I can see where that might make more sense long term
- 32:11for some credit unions, I'm glad to hear that you're seeing some of that.
- 32:14And I think you're right.
- 32:15That will be seeing more of that you touched on.
- 32:19Cyber and the general regulatory burden that I think it makes it small,
- 32:24the harder and harder it's going to get for the smaller institutions.
- 32:27And again, pick a number on what you want to define a small technology.
- 32:30So technology having to deal with the technology side of it, and then.
- 32:35The buzzword last year in this work year is artificial intelligence.
- 32:40What's your take on the technology and artificial intelligence game and how
- 32:44that impacts credit unions these days?
- 32:47A couple things here.
- 32:49First thing I would say is the cost of admissions going up every day
- 32:53the technology that you have to have the expectation that your member
- 32:57has about the level of service you can provide is just getting higher.
- 33:01You need a best in class platform for online banking.
- 33:06You need, payments that are, very quick very reliable very easy to use.
- 33:10So you need convenience.
- 33:12You need reduction and frictions.
- 33:15Then you want to play offense.
- 33:16The best credit unions are playing offense.
- 33:18They're taking AI or solutions like it, and they're using it
- 33:21for predictive results, right?
- 33:23They're trying to predict or improve Certain processes, whether it be
- 33:27underwriting or account opening and understand what their customers are doing.
- 33:31They're also using it to target marketing campaigns to cross sell if
- 33:36you're not doing any and all of that.
- 33:38You're not in the top quartile of credit union.
- 33:41You also need it.
- 33:43For defense we need cyber.
- 33:46That's perfect.
- 33:47We can't have an attack or have, any data breached and we need data
- 33:52to have integrity and to be as robust as we can because we want
- 33:55to refine that data and understand it and use it in a predictive way.
- 33:59We also want to take processes and optimize them and
- 34:03make them more efficient.
- 34:04And that's typically some of that repetitive work is going to robotics.
- 34:09Yeah.
- 34:09And here again, we have some tensions, right?
- 34:12We have the gentleman, gentle ladiness of our industry.
- 34:18We have folks that we respect to do jobs, but we also have a cycle
- 34:22of technology or innovation that can replace some of those jobs.
- 34:26So we've got to do it smartly for the good of the institution, and we've got
- 34:30to do it with a heart, but we've got to be moving to a posture that allows
- 34:35us to do the things we do better.
- 34:38quicker, faster, more reliable, perfect, and then figure out what's next.
- 34:43So it's a tall order.
- 34:45And again, one of the things I worry about.
- 34:47I do the board meetings.
- 34:48I go around the circuit and I, talk to our board about X,
- 34:51Y, or Z or strategic planning.
- 34:53And I probably shouldn't do this.
- 34:55I'm probably get myself in trouble, but I go to some of these credit unions
- 34:59and I say, okay I just looked at your last presentation and it's all about
- 35:02what we're going to do in technology.
- 35:04I said, who on the board has a technology background?
- 35:06Raise your hand.
- 35:08And.
- 35:08Okay.
- 35:08It's it's invariably zero.
- 35:11And the other thing is we will pound the table and talk about
- 35:15how the lifetime value of a 25 year old is significant to us.
- 35:19And we've got to turn over our member set.
- 35:21We've got as much as we respect the people who are with us at 75.
- 35:25They're not taking out loans anymore.
- 35:27And, they are very predictable and very stable.
- 35:29We've got to find 25 year old customers who can come with us for a lifetime.
- 35:33But we don't have any rep.
- 35:35Presentation of 2530 year olds on the board and I would argue they
- 35:39know as much whether they know it formally or have as much experience.
- 35:42They know things that, your average folks by age don't know.
- 35:47And I would encourage all of these boards to at least have
- 35:491 member who's in that set.
- 35:51Because I work with them all day over a year, and I'm amazed at what these
- 35:55guys can do the folks we work with on our team what they can do with data,
- 36:00what they can understand, what they understand about social media and the
- 36:03way it interfaces it's staggering.
- 36:06And you're drinking from a fire hose to try to keep up with them.
- 36:09Yeah, you know that reminds me of a book title.
- 36:12I quote a lot the wisdom of crowds.
- 36:14And if your crowd is a bunch of, it's nothing but 75 year olds or, 775 year
- 36:19olds and 260 year olds, you're going to reach different decisions that
- 36:23might be optimal for the future and the members that are going to make
- 36:28need, need loans et cetera, et cetera.
- 36:31So that's great advice.
- 36:32I think it's probably the biggest challenge facing the industry
- 36:35right now is capturing the youth market and being relevant for those
- 36:38folks, five, 10, 15 years from now.
- 36:43So we've talked a little bit about, the election and the got a couple
- 36:49more here before we wrap this up.
- 36:51But the Trump effect and we were talking a little bit before we got on that.
- 36:57Maybe even the Trump effect that you wrote the article on 10 days
- 37:00ago might be a little bit different than the Trump effect today.
- 37:04But the Trump effect.
- 37:06Let's talk about the impact of that on credit unions as you see it.
- 37:11I would say very crudely at 20, 000 feet, two things to emphasize number one is
- 37:17philosophically politically, whether you agree with it or not, we should pivot to a
- 37:24pro growth, lower regulatory environment.
- 37:27I think it's going to take a little time to get there practically, but it's
- 37:31clear that's where he wants to be right.
- 37:33So he is going to encourage growth.
- 37:36He's going to encourage less regulation.
- 37:39Okay, getting there.
- 37:42I think is more interesting to look at.
- 37:45So if you look at what we've already seen out of the new administration,
- 37:49we've seen a hiring freeze and we've seen a return to work order.
- 37:54Those are the 2 that I'm focused on for a 2nd here.
- 37:57The hiring freeze.
- 37:59I get what you're trying to do.
- 38:00You're trying to, shrink the size of government or stop it from growing.
- 38:03The return to work.
- 38:04I get what you're trying to do too.
- 38:05You're saying how long can we run this covert thing out?
- 38:08And this has been a luxury that honestly, we don't need from
- 38:10a medical standpoint anymore.
- 38:12I get it too philosophically.
- 38:14The issue is and this as well as I do the folks at these
- 38:17regulatory agencies don't yeah.
- 38:19Exactly live there anymore.
- 38:21And so a return to work order is not as simple as I just turn back on
- 38:26my monthly card and get back on the transit system and go back to work.
- 38:32A lot of folks have moved out of the area and I believe some of the more senior
- 38:37folks are going to take this plus the offer of a buyout and say, I'll take it.
- 38:43I'm just not going to return to work.
- 38:44It's not You know, the lifestyle, the expectation I want at this
- 38:47point, and therefore you're going to see a brain drain at the top.
- 38:51We can argue about how big that's going to be, but I think it's going to be
- 38:53significant enough that it matters.
- 38:56Bring behind that the hiring freeze.
- 38:58You're not going to be able to replace those people from a body count standpoint.
- 39:02Either way, you're not able to replace it from a knowledge standpoint.
- 39:04So you're going to have a vacuum.
- 39:07And what worries me about the vacuum is some of the things
- 39:11that we're trying to do.
- 39:12At an Alden Lane, for example, are they're not the everyday thing, right?
- 39:17So when a when an institution regulatory institution like the NCUA shrinks like
- 39:21that, they're going to play defense.
- 39:24They're going to do the things that are absolutely necessary.
- 39:26They're going to do the things that they have to do for their day job.
- 39:29So exams will continue.
- 39:30They're not going to let people off the hook on that.
- 39:33And so a lot of the time that is spent on the things at the margin that, that we try
- 39:38to do here whether it be an application to issue subordinated debt or a merger
- 39:43application those can go to the back of the line the back of the queue at the
- 39:47agency and tend to get less attention.
- 39:50Now, maybe.
- 39:52We just enter a regulatory environment and a change of guard that says,
- 39:55all right, just wave them through.
- 39:57I wouldn't suggest that because I think the agency does a good job of being
- 40:01gatekeeper on a lot of these things.
- 40:03And frankly, we try to keep up with what their expectations are.
- 40:06But I do think you'll see a backlog.
- 40:08We already saw it.
- 40:10Some of the bank deals we've been working on have just been slowed.
- 40:12The FDIC has not gotten to visit on their normal pace.
- 40:17And so I worry about operational tempo at the agency and how that's
- 40:21going to affect credit unions, especially in a dynamic environment
- 40:25where you've got to be more nimble and quicker with your decision making.
- 40:28So that is 1 thing.
- 40:30We have a pro growth posture.
- 40:31We may have a frustrating implementation.
- 40:34The other thing in the soup at the N.
- 40:36C.
- 40:36U.
- 40:36A.
- 40:36is the changing of the guard.
- 40:37We spoke of earlier Harper out, help men in as chairman help men in his
- 40:42chairman with 2 Dems on the board.
- 40:45You tend to get a deadline.
- 40:46Situation, you also have help in taking orders probably, more than usual from the
- 40:53main house down the road in Pennsylvania Avenue and trying to implement those
- 40:57into a difficult political slash personnel environment it's going to
- 41:01be, I think it's going to be tough.
- 41:02It's gonna be choppy here for a little bit.
- 41:04No, it's very astute.
- 41:05I agree with everything you said.
- 41:07And when the hiring freeze first came out, I chatted with somebody
- 41:12at NCUA through the grapevine who said, yeah, we just met on this.
- 41:18Exams come first.
- 41:19So the thing you said is exactly what they communicated to their executives.
- 41:24Right out of the gate and they communicated that to their
- 41:26examiners when they offer buyouts.
- 41:28Historically, the only thing that happens is people either feel like
- 41:33they won the lottery or they ignore it.
- 41:35Because they are about to retire and they go, wow, look at, I get
- 41:39X amount of dollars and I was going to retire in six months.
- 41:42Those folks, it's heck yeah.
- 41:43Where do I sign up for it?
- 41:45Nobody else leaves other than the people who are going, gosh, those are
- 41:50some good people that are leaving.
- 41:51We have the fi hiring freeze on.
- 41:54I'm already the go-to guy in this division or go-to GAL in this division.
- 41:59And guess what?
- 42:00The top performers, the pressure on them goes up and the top performers
- 42:06are the ones who have options to leave and might be able to call, might be
- 42:10able to pivot to another industry.
- 42:11They can't really pivot to another government agency right now.
- 42:14But I think you'll see opportunities where some folks will be going out
- 42:20into the credit union land, perhaps, or going out and consulting et
- 42:24cetera because they have options.
- 42:25And so then you get, and you layer on top of that.
- 42:29There hadn't been a real economic issue.
- 42:31We talk about rates having been low.
- 42:33It was easy to make money.
- 42:35Everybody was doing things and the exams got easy.
- 42:38The jobs got easy and then rates went up 500 basis points and you've
- 42:41got examiners dealing with things that they hadn't seen before, right?
- 42:46And they've maybe seen it now for six months, but you, that corporate
- 42:50knowledge you lose by chasing away.
- 42:52Some of these people is going to have ramifications on every federal agency.
- 42:57It'll have ramifications on into and again, step stepping aside of whether
- 43:02or not government's too big and this needs to happen or not, there will be
- 43:05these ramifications on the hiring freeze.
- 43:08Just out of curiosity the other morning, I, I went to USA jobs.
- 43:12gov because that's where agencies.
- 43:14Put their their jobs.
- 43:16And I thought I'm going to go see if anybody was dumb enough
- 43:19to leave up job announcements.
- 43:20And I checked seven or eight agencies, including NCOA and no,
- 43:25none of the, in the big agencies, none, no job vacancies came up.
- 43:30So that's where you'd probably get called over by Pennsylvania Avenue
- 43:34saying, Hey, there's a hiring freeze on.
- 43:35Why do you have these announcements up, when they turn that spigot on, it's
- 43:40I'll have clients where NCUA, they do commercial loans wrong and NCUA will say,
- 43:46you need to cease commercial lending.
- 43:47It's you're increasing the risk of the insurance fund saying I need to cease.
- 43:51We need to come up with some sort of pocket of things that you think
- 43:53I'm doing okay for whatever reason.
- 43:55So that don't make me say we don't make these loans anymore because I'll
- 43:59never be able to turn the spigot on.
- 44:00When you turn that spigot off and say you're doing no hiring, gearing
- 44:04it back up, let's say it's three months before the freeze comes off.
- 44:08Who knows?
- 44:09It might be four years.
- 44:10Let's say it's one year.
- 44:11Whatever it is, whatever carve outs they make, turning those spigots back on,
- 44:16getting those announcements back out.
- 44:19So that you can full, you have to have it out for a certain number of
- 44:21days and you have to get it in and you have to review it and you got
- 44:24you have less people to review it.
- 44:26Oh, by the way, on top of the fact that are people gonna want to come and
- 44:29apply with all the angst that's there.
- 44:32So it's creating some serious angst and mayhem At all of the agency, some
- 44:37more without naming names that are in the press, but some more than others.
- 44:41But yes, it's a good time to be a consultant thinking
- 44:46about how this is impacting N.
- 44:47C.
- 44:47U.
- 44:48A.
- 44:48as opposed to being over there.
- 44:49Because I know there's a lot of.
- 44:50Anxiety as they're trying to do what the administration wants, they're trying to
- 44:55meet their mission and they're trying to carefully, take care of the employees
- 45:01that help them achieve that mission and some of these, just like it's hard
- 45:04to be profitable in this soup that we're talking about, all those things
- 45:07and these challenges are the agencies, including NCOA are facing right now.
- 45:12Of clicks and mortars.
- 45:13I love that headline of clicks and mortars.
- 45:16So let's talk about about what that that topic and what
- 45:19that means for credit unions.
- 45:22I think it's trying to find the optimal balance between high tech and high touch.
- 45:28So it's what is the right presence from a branch standpoint versus
- 45:35from a digital standpoint.
- 45:37And this is going to vary by credit union.
- 45:39It's going to vary by your history, your culture your, the makeup of your members.
- 45:44It's going to vary by geography and how people bank but banking has changed.
- 45:49And if you don't see it or understand it all you have to do
- 45:52is take my mother as an example.
- 45:55She used to not.
- 45:57Dust the computer because she was afraid it would do something.
- 46:00And when COVID came, she had no choice but to access her account on the computer
- 46:07or the iPod and she figured it out.
- 46:11And she's now a deft mobile banker.
- 46:14And it's funny at the very first quarterly report of JP Morgan when
- 46:19COVID set in, Jamie Diamond said, when we look back on this, it will have
- 46:25done what I couldn't do with a team of technicians over a 10 year period.
- 46:30It will have forced people in a certain age group to change their
- 46:36habit and access accounts online.
- 46:39And that's a blessing in many ways because it allows us to do things without
- 46:46the physical presence and the cost of that physical presence, but we have
- 46:49to be careful because that physical presence still matters to some and
- 46:54again, it's going to vary by what style of business you have and who you serve.
- 46:57It also has a billboard effect.
- 46:59It also has some knock on community effects.
- 47:03If you think of your branches more than just a place where people
- 47:07deposit checks and wait in line.
- 47:09A lot of branch.
- 47:10A lot of the credit unions that are progressive are turning their branches
- 47:14into financial education centers.
- 47:16I can think of certain clients we have who are very deep into that into that
- 47:21mission and understand it as both a community center and a financial resource.
- 47:27I will say there's a couple of things from a socioeconomic standpoint.
- 47:32Some of the surveys talk about how the interaction of people is at an
- 47:35all time low across all cohorts, all swaths, all socioeconomic statuses.
- 47:42And I think credit unions, particularly community credit unions, can play
- 47:46a role here that's more broad than what they sometimes see their vision
- 47:49as I, before I got on this podcast I was gonna, I was gonna joke with you.
- 47:54I just saw that the average American speaks 3, 000 fewer words today
- 48:00in a day than two decades ago.
- 48:03And that is because, they blame social media and they blame
- 48:07texting as a communications medium.
- 48:10Now I'm solving that problem by going on a podcast binge with you.
- 48:14I just want to remain as, as loquacious as ever.
- 48:17But credit unions can fill that gap.
- 48:19In communities, and there are credit unions who are doing
- 48:22some interesting things.
- 48:23Rick Weber out on the West Coast at at Oceanair, which is the old CBC.
- 48:28He's put his branches into the Department of Motor Vehicles,
- 48:32or he's got Department of Motor Vehicles services in his branches.
- 48:35He's also put branches in Dunkin Donuts, or Dunkin Donuts in his branches.
- 48:40I know that Matt McCombs at Vibrant out in Moline in the Quad Cities area,
- 48:44he's turned a lot of his branches essentially into coffeehouses.
- 48:49They're fully functioning restaurants and he's building a sense of
- 48:52community and he's going about deposit gathering in a very different way.
- 48:57He's created an affinity card and folks get rewarded for carrying
- 49:00balances and that reward is affected in the price of their lunch.
- 49:04Those are different approaches.
- 49:06They may not all win.
- 49:07They may not all make total sense to every credit union, but it's great
- 49:10to see folks that are innovating and understanding that the branch and the
- 49:15digital and that optimal mix across their membership is really what it's about.
- 49:20Yeah, boy, that's a lot of powerful things you said there, but that 3000
- 49:23words less a day that has ramifications.
- 49:26And if you can help people create a sense of community, like those examples
- 49:30that you grave, gabe, that's fabulous.
- 49:32And you talk about your mom, I have the same thing.
- 49:34I help her with her taxes.
- 49:36I help her with her investment account.
- 49:38And she very proud that she's never, put her credit card into the
- 49:43ethosphere out there anyway, anywhere.
- 49:47And when I help her with their taxes every year I'll tell her I need her
- 49:51social security number and she'll forget that I did it the last year and she'll
- 49:55say, okay, I'm going to give you the first three numbers and I'll call you and
- 49:58hang up and I'll give you the next two.
- 49:59And then I'll give you the next four.
- 50:01And then at the end of the third call at Mike, I always say to
- 50:04her, I said, okay, just to make sure I got that let me repeat it.
- 50:07And she goes, no, my mom, the same way.
- 50:11Interesting, she's had some issues with things in the mail checks.
- 50:14And so she's, we're learning together.
- 50:17The threshold for wiring money is a lower number now when she does things
- 50:21because, avoiding checks, avoiding, just changing kind of the way you bank.
- 50:26For a whole host of reasons and it's unique to each person, credit unions
- 50:29provide an incredible service in that they're able to tailor the, their
- 50:33solution to the needs of the customer.
- 50:36Whether it's a small business or a person or, a sophisticated person or
- 50:40less sophisticated person, and honestly that's what at the end of the day is
- 50:43so rewarding about what, I do an awful lot of visiting the credit unions, I
- 50:47go to see, Folks all over the country.
- 50:49I love spending time in the lobby, just observing, just watching what's going
- 50:54on, seeing how people bank, understanding what they're doing differently and
- 50:57what solutions work and don't work.
- 51:00It's fascinating.
- 51:00Yeah.
- 51:00Yeah.
- 51:01And my mom still has her account.
- 51:02My dad worked for the telephone company.
- 51:04He's since passed, but she has her account there and she had to go do business there.
- 51:08And she's talked to the same teller for 25 years.
- 51:11And that's the credit, that's the credit union way which is really cool.
- 51:15Lastly, we've talked about aging leadership.
- 51:17We've talked about aging at a couple different top, a couple
- 51:22of the other nine points.
- 51:23First, anything else to add on aging leadership that we haven't hit here yet?
- 51:28No, one of the themes we, we talk about.
- 51:30Here, because it's not said enough honestly, is NCUA was on this, right?
- 51:35They did a succession rule last year.
- 51:38We can argue again at the margin.
- 51:39I, we did a comment letter here that's accessible on our website.
- 51:42I thought they didn't go far enough.
- 51:44I would have loved that they pressured it a little harder.
- 51:47I also think sometimes regulatory agencies are immune to how much things cost.
- 51:53They did it in sub debt when they forced people to go get a lawyer.
- 51:56And didn't have a de minimis exception.
- 51:58So you've got small credit unions raising small amounts of money and paying
- 52:02fees to lawyers that are unnecessary.
- 52:04And, they did it in succession planning when they insisted on a certain format
- 52:08and a certain, certain credit unions.
- 52:11Can't hire people to do that.
- 52:12And if they do, it's more cost and or you're going to get
- 52:15something that's boilerplate and it doesn't really answer the needs.
- 52:18But for the most part, it's an issue that has to be confronted.
- 52:22We have to be straight up about it because, C suites plus boards are getting
- 52:27older and we've got to figure out how to capture younger folks into this market.
- 52:32I will say, We work with an incredible number of.
- 52:38Newer C suite people who are extraordinarily talented, who come from
- 52:45less traditional background, different, they didn't grow up credit union, right?
- 52:49Some have now come from the banking space.
- 52:52Some have come from the consulting space.
- 52:54Some of the CFOs that we see are very adept at reading balance
- 52:58sheets and understanding the levers at a credit union very quickly.
- 53:02And are progressive in their thinking.
- 53:03And that is very welcome development.
- 53:06Because we're, we're going to get there with experimentation, smartly
- 53:10done and with, pushing the envelope where it makes sense because doing
- 53:14things the same way tomorrow that we did them yesterday, because we did them
- 53:17that way, it just doesn't fly anymore.
- 53:21It's the most exciting time to do things.
- 53:23We talked about AI.
- 53:24What some of the guys in my office are doing with AI is unbelievable.
- 53:27You gotta be careful and ultimately you need a person that's responsible, but this
- 53:31is the most exciting time to do business.
- 53:33It's the most exciting time to have clients and customers.
- 53:37And it's extraordinarily rewarding if you come to work and you
- 53:40work hard at it every day.
- 53:42And, for Olden Lane and its clients, it's a gift to have what we have here and to
- 53:46continue to be able to do this every day.
- 53:49Perfect.
- 53:49Said.
- 53:49That's a good wrap.
- 53:50If someone has listened to this and they want to reach out and chat with
- 53:54you and your team about this podcast, any topic we've talked about, or the
- 53:58things that Olden Lane is offering for credit unions that you summarize
- 54:02on the front end, what's the best way for someone to reach you, Mike?
- 54:05I'm on LinkedIn.
- 54:05Pretty active.
- 54:06Olden Lane has a has a page as well.
- 54:08We have a website.
- 54:09It's www.oldenlane.com.
- 54:13And we've got a box on there that says, contact, or, we'll send an info
- 54:17to a whole group of us over here.
- 54:19And we'd love to speak to any credit union, large or small,
- 54:22about any of these issues.
- 54:23We just think we're part of the mission trying to help and we'll do
- 54:26anything we can to help credit unions do the right thing by their members.
- 54:29You got it.
- 54:29I've seen it in action.
- 54:30That's a fact.
- 54:31Thanks so much for your time today, Mike.
- 54:33Really appreciate it, Mark.
- 54:34Thanks a lot.
- 54:35Got it.
- 54:36And listeners, I want to thank you as always for listening.
- 54:38Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.