Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 114
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two one one. Welcome
- 0:28back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are all ready
- 0:31to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started. On
- 0:37today's episode, we are going to delve into the top five cold cases finally
- 0:43solved in twenty twenty three. Bear with me as some of these are quite
- 0:49disturbing. With that in mind, let's get into the top five cases solved
- 0:56in twenty twenty three, Humming Bird. In twenty fifteen, the Countess of
- 1:03Chester Hospital in Cheshire, England faced a disturbing mystery. A series of unexpected
- 1:10infant fatalities and life threatening incidents began to occur, raising concerns among the staff.
- 1:15Lucy let Be, a nurse in her mid twenties working in the neonatal
- 1:21ward, became a figure of intense scrutiny. Let be known for her love
- 1:26of cats, salsa dancing and cocktails, harbored a dark secret that defied understanding.
- 1:34The first alarming incident occurred on August fourth, twenty fifteen, when the
- 1:40mother of a five day old baby child E returned to find her son with
- 1:45blood around his mouth and let be near by the new born, born seven
- 1:51weeks premature, did not survive, with his death attributed to a bowel condition.
- 1:57However, this was not an isolated event. The neonatal unit, which
- 2:05typically witnessed only two to three deaths annually, saw an unprecedented rise in infant
- 2:10fatalities and near fatal incidents. By August twenty fifteen, five infants had lost
- 2:19their lives and five others had narrowly escaped death, many developing long term health
- 2:27complications. Suspicion grew as all these incidents had one common element, Lucy Letbe's
- 2:36presence during the shifts. Considering Letbe's reputation as a caring and diligent nurse,
- 2:43colleagues initially dismissed this as a coincidence. However, with each incident the pattern
- 2:50became hard to ignore. Doctor Stephen Briery, a concerned colleague, escalated the
- 2:58matter to the unit manager, suspecting let Be's involvement. Despite these suspicions,
- 3:07the hospital's response was initially one of denial, citing the lack of concrete evidence
- 3:15against let Be. The situation escalated in twenty sixteen when another episode involving let
- 3:23Be occurred intensifying the suspicions among the staff. This time, a consultant found
- 3:30let Be watching a baby who had stopped breathing and not taking immediate action.
- 3:38Although the baby survived, the incident prompted further scrutiny. By June twenty sixteen,
- 3:46three more newborns had nearly lost their lives under Letby's care, culminating in
- 3:53an emergency meeting after the death of another infant. Finally, after another near
- 4:01fatal incident, let Be was removed from her position in the neonatal unit and
- 4:08reassigned to administrative duties. This decision marked a turning point, as the unexplained
- 4:15deaths and critical incidents abruptly ceased. However, the hospital's reluctance to involve law
- 4:24enforcement and its protective stance towards let Be initially hindered a formal inquiry. It
- 4:31was only in May twenty seventeen, after persistent efforts by doctor Briary and other
- 4:36concerned colleagues, that Cheshire Police launched Operation Hummingbird, initiating a full scale investigation
- 4:46into the deaths. The subsequent year long investigation revealed chilling findings. Lab results
- 4:54indicated unnatural levels of insulin and air injections in at least two of the victvictoms,
- 5:00pointing toward deliberate harm. In twenty eighteen, let Be was arrested in
- 5:06connection with the deaths and attempted murders, bringing the case into the public eye.
- 5:14Investigators discovered a diary at her home with contradictory statements suggesting a troubled mind.
- 5:21Her Internet search history further implicated her showing searches about the parents of the
- 5:28deceased infants. Despite the mounting evidence, let Be wasn't formally charged until November
- 5:33twenty twenty. The trial of Lucy let Be, which began in October twenty
- 5:41twenty two, concluded in August twenty twenty three. The verdict was a significant
- 5:46moment for the families of the victims and the community. Let Be was found
- 5:53guilty of seven counts of murder and six counts of attempted murder between June twenty
- 5:59one, fifteen and June twenty sixteen. The jury's decision was based on overwhelming
- 6:06evidence of her presence during each incident and the incriminating details found in her diary
- 6:13and Internet activities. The sentencing of Lucy Letby on August twenty first twenty twenty
- 6:20three, brought closure to a case that had haunted the city of Chester.
- 6:28The judge, citing the gravity of the offenses, sentenced her to life imprisonment
- 6:34without the possibility of parole. In the trial's aftermath, questions linger about the
- 6:42hospital's initial response and the systemic failures that allowed these tragedies to occur. The
- 6:49Countess of Chester Hospital, now under new management, faces the task of rebuilding
- 6:56trust and ensuring such a catastrophe never happens again. Melissa's long lost return.
- 7:06The resolution of Melissa's kidnapping case marked the end of a heart wrenching story that
- 7:14spanned over five decades. In nineteen seventy one, a young mother named Alta
- 7:21Apentenko living in Fort Worth, Texas, faced every parent's worst nightmare. Her
- 7:30daughter, Melissa, just twenty one months old, was abducted by a woman
- 7:35posing as a childminder named Ruth Johnson. Despite desperate efforts to locate her daughter,
- 7:44including a widespread search and extensive media coverage, Alta's hopes dwindled as days
- 7:50turned into years without any trace of Melissa. In a bizarre twist of fate,
- 7:58the breakthrough in Melissa's case came through the advancements in DNA technology, which
- 8:03had been a distant dream back in nineteen seventy one. In late twenty twenty
- 8:09two, Jeffrey Highsmith, Melissa's biological father, unknowingly set the stage for the
- 8:18reunion. He submitted his DNA sample to the genealogy website twenty three and Me,
- 8:26hoping to explore his family tree. The results, however, were unexpected.
- 8:33Jeffrey discovered matches for three individuals who, according to genetic similarities, could
- 8:39only be his grandchildren. This revelation was perplexing as his only child, Melissa,
- 8:46had been missing for over fifty years. Intrigued and hopeful, Jeffrey delved
- 8:54deeper and identified the mother of these grandchildren as Melanie Walden, a woman in
- 9:01her fifties living near Fort Worth. After convincing Melanie to undergo a DNA test,
- 9:07the results confirmed the unimaginable Melanie Walden was indeed Melissa Highsmith. The discovery
- 9:16sent shock waves throughout the local community and rekindled memories of the decade's old kidnapping
- 9:22case. Melissa, who had spent the majority of her life believing her adoptive
- 9:28parents were her biological family, was confronted with a life altering truth. Her
- 9:35adoptive mother revealed that she had acquired Melissa for five hundred dollars from a woman
- 9:43in nineteen seventy two. The accuracy of this claim remains uncertain, but due
- 9:50to the statute of limitations, no legal actions were pursued. The emotional reunion
- 9:58of Melissa with her biological parents, Alta and Geoffrey in twenty twenty three was
- 10:05filled with joy and tears. Alta's reunion brought vindication from years of accusations and
- 10:13suspicions regarding her daughter's disappearance. For Jeoffrey, it was a bittersweet moment of
- 10:20reconnection with a daughter who had no memories of him. Melissa, now with
- 10:26a new identity and a complex past, faced the challenge of integrating this revelation
- 10:33into her life. She expressed a desire to reclaim her birth name and planned
- 10:39to renew her wedding vows, allowing her birth parents to witness her marriage.
- 10:48A mystery beneath the waves, the disappearance of sixty one year old Dale Nicholson
- 10:56in twenty sixteen from New Norfolk, Tasmania initially seemed like an unsolvable mystery.
- 11:03A well known local figure, Dale was last seen by his neighbor carrying fishing
- 11:09rods and heading towards his car. His sudden vanishing act left his family and
- 11:16the community in despair and confusion. Despite extensive search operations, there were no
- 11:24clues to his whereabouts, leaving the case cold until a crucial development in twenty
- 11:31twenty three. In January twenty twenty three, the case took an unexpected turn
- 11:39thanks to the efforts of two dedicated divers known on YouTube as down Under Dan
- 11:45Diving and as American colleague Bill McIntosh. The duo, driven by a mission
- 11:52to help families of missing persons, traveled to Tasmania to investigate another case.
- 11:58However, their focus shifted when they stumbled upon a clue linked to Dale Nicholson's
- 12:05disappearance. Using sonar equipment, they detected an object resembling a car in the
- 12:13River Derwent. The location, near the New Norfolk swimming Pool, was mere
- 12:20minutes from Dale's residence. On their first dive, the team confirmed their suspicion
- 12:26it was indeed Dale Nicholson's car, a blue Ford Faremont, hidden beneath the
- 12:33water's surface. Inside the vehicle, they discovered human remains. This discovery was
- 12:43immediately reported to the local authorities, marking a breakthrough in the case. The
- 12:50Tasmanian police, respecting the diver's contribution, acted swiftly to recover the vehicle and
- 12:58the remains. The diver's discovery provided tangible evidence and brought the Nicholson family closer
- 13:07to understanding Dale's fate. Forensic analysis confirmed that the remains belonged to Dale Nicholson,
- 13:16bringing an end to years of uncertainty. However, the question of whether
- 13:22Dale's entry into the water was accidental or intentional remained unanswered. The discovery elicited
- 13:31mixed emotions among his family members, who had clung to a faint hope that
- 13:37he might still be alive. A decade's old murder case revisited. Viola,
- 13:46a forty eight year old mother of three, was found dead in her home
- 13:48in Dubuque, Iowa, in nineteen seventy seven. The gruesome crime shook the
- 13:54community. Despite extensive investigations, no one was ever charged with her murder.
- 14:01In twenty twenty three, with advancements in forensic technology, investigators decided to re
- 14:07examine the evidence collected from the crime scene and revisit the Viola Hugencourt case.
- 14:13The key to progress lay in DNA analysis, a technique unavailable in the nineteen
- 14:22seventies. Samples taken from the crime scene were sent to a forensic laboratory for
- 14:28DNA testing. The hope was that any trace of the perpetrator could be identified,
- 14:35no matter how faint. The results were astonishing. DNA evidence from the
- 14:39crime scene matched a profile in the national DNA database. The DNA belonged to
- 14:46an individual with a criminal record, and further investigation revealed that this person had
- 14:52been in the Dubuque area at the time of Viola's murder. The suspect,
- 14:58now in his seventies, had evaded the law for decades. The man was
- 15:03arrested and charged with the murder of Viola Hagencourt, a crime that had remained
- 15:09unsolved for forty six years. Viola's surviving family members were informed of the breakthrough.
- 15:18While they had resigned themselves to the idea that her killer might never be
- 15:22found, the news of an arrest brought both relief and grief. The Okalusa
- 15:28Jane Doe identified in twenty twenty three. The mystery of the Okalusa Jane Doe,
- 15:35who was posthumously identified as Suzanne Kellenberg, finally reached its conclusion, providing
- 15:45much needed closure to a family that had long awaited answers. The case began
- 15:52in nineteen ninety four when the remains of an unidentified woman were discovered near the
- 15:58Holt Exit outside of Crestview. At the time, the available forensic technology was
- 16:06insufficient to establish her identity or the details surrounding her death. In a startling
- 16:14development, Keith Jessperson, infamously known as the Happy Face Killer, confessed in
- 16:21nineteen ninety six to killing a woman he believed was named Susan or Susette and
- 16:27dumping her body at the location where the Jane Doe was found. Despite this
- 16:33confession, the lack of a victim's identity hindered the progress of the investigation.
- 16:41Okaloosa County Sheriff Eric Aden reflected on the challenges faced acknowledging Jesperson as a suspect,
- 16:49but emphasizing the absence of the victim's identity as a critical missing piece.
- 16:56The turning point came with genetic genealogy, a revolutionary approach combining DNA analysis with
- 17:04traditional genealogical research. Investigators extracted DNA from the remains and compared it to genetic
- 17:12profiles in public databases. This process involved constructing family trees and identifying potential relatives.
- 17:22The match in the DNA database provided a critical lead that would eventually reveal
- 17:27the identity of the Okaloosa Jane Doe as Suzanne. This revelation brought a complex
- 17:36mix of relief and sorrow to her family. Suzanne Kellenberg's case, now closed,
- 17:44serves as a reminder of the countless mysteries that still exist and the families
- 17:49waiting for closure. As we reflect on the successful resolution of this case,
- 17:56we are reminded of the relentless pursuit of justice and the ever evolving tools at
- 18:02our disposal.