Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / Michelle Hadley | Framed, Arrested & Exonerated After 88 Days in Jail
Transcript
- Zalle: Imagine sitting inside a jail cell knowing that everyone outside believes you're dangerous. You're accused of stalking a woman you've never even met. You're accused of sending her threatening emails and of creating disturbing Craigslist advertisements. Eventually, you're accused of trying to have her attacked. But there's something you know that nobody else seems to understand. You didn't do any of it. You gave police your phone, your computer, your tablet. You told them to look. And then another threatening message appears. Except your devices are sitting in police evidence. So who is sending the messages? and why does that person behind them know so much about you? Nicholle: Welcome back Zalle: back. Nicholle: to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicholle Mom. Zalle: And I'm Zaylee. Nicholle: Today's case is about a woman who went from being engaged and planning a future to leaving what she described as an increasingly abusive relationship to become the suspect in an elaborate stalking investigation. Zalle: And eventually she would spend eighty eight days in jail for crimes she didn't commit. Nicholle: But we're not going to start with the arrest. We're going back to the beginning because before the fake emails, before Angela, before Lilith's truth, there was Michelle and Ian. And understanding that relationship is essential to understanding everything that comes afterwards. Before we begin, a quick content warning. Today's episode discusses domestic abuse, stalking, harassment, coercive control, sexual courage, coercion, fabricated sexual assault allegations, and wrongful incarceration. Some of the allegations involve disturbing and emotionally difficult subject matter. We will discuss these events without graphic descriptions. Zalle: Coerce of control, sexual purge, coercion, fabricated sexual assault allegations, and wrongful frustration. Some of the allegations involved are certainly an emotionally difficult subject. We will discuss these events without graphic research. these topics are difficult to, please take care of yourself out of this. And with Nicholle: If any of these topics are difficult for you, please take care of yourself while listening. Zalle: that, let's go back to your career. Nicholle: And with that, let's go back to the beginning. Zalle: In October of 2013, Michelle Hatley met Ian Diaz online. Ian was a U.S. Marshal. Michelle was in her late twenties, and at first, according to Michelle's later recollections, the relationship felt like a fairy tale. Ian was attentive, they spent time together, they fell in love, and eventually they became engaged. Nicholle: And that's important because when we tell stories about abusive relationships, it's easy to look backward and think, how could she not have known? But that's not necessarily how these relationships begin. Michelle wasn't knowingly walking into an abusive relationship. She believed she was building a future with someone she loved. Zalle: But that's not necessarily how these relationships began. Michelle wasn't knowingly walking into an abusive relationship. She believed she was building with someone she loved. According to Michelle's account, Ian proposed in New York City. the engagement represented a future they were planning together. And rough in roughly a year after they met, they were engaged. And sometime during this period, Michelle said something began to change. The relationship became more controlling. The changes weren't limited to one part of her life. Ian began expressing opinions about how Michelle should look, how she should dress, how she should present herself. Michelle has described Ian becoming increasingly interested in controlling her appearance. He wanted her to dress differently. He encouraged her to wear more revealing clothing, including crop tops. He wanted her to wear acrylic nails and more makeup. He wanted her to get a belly button piercing. He even suggested that she get a boob augmentation, a breast augmentation. I don't know why that sentence ate my ass up like that. Did not. And he even suggested that she get a breast augmentation. And to be clear, there's nothing inherently wrong with proxy. There's nothing inherently wrong with film. There's nothing inherently wrong with makeup, here's significant car positive surgery. The issue here is who's making the decision. Michelle has described herself as someone who wasn't particularly interested in. So these weren't simply suggestions about fashion. Nicholle: And to be clear, there's nothing inherently wrong with crop tops. There's nothing inherently wrong with acrylic nails. There's nothing inherently wrong with makeup, piercings, or cosmetic surgery. The issue here is who's making the decisions. Michelle has described herself as someone who wasn't particularly interested in those things. So these weren't simply suggestions about fashion. Zalle: She experienced him as pressure to be. Nicholle: She experienced them as pressure to become the woman Ian wanted her to be. Zalle: And that's an important distinction. He wasn't simply saying, Here's something I think looks good. According to Michelle's account, these expectations became part of a larger pattern in which Ian increasingly dictated how she should look and behave. Current reporting based on Michelle's account describes the same pattern, Including pressure around clothing, acrylic nails, a belly piercing, and even breast augmentation. then came something much more invasive. When Michelle and Ian moved into their Anaheim condominium, Ian installed surveillance cameras inside the home, not just outside, inside. The cameras allowed him to monitor Michelle's movements. And according to Michelle's account, he could watch the camera feed remotely. And it's important for you guys to know that they had been together, like around six or seven months when Ian decided that he wanted to get a place together. she went along with it and they were supposed to be splitting, putting like the down payment down. And it was once they decided to Nicholle: You went along with me and they were supposed to be exploited putting like the down payment app in these pieces. Zalle: get the house and everything had went through that Ian was like, Well, I don't have the money for it. And so Michelle put all that money down, which was like Nicholle: So Zalle: Fourteen thousand dollars. Right. So Nicholle: Right. Zalle: to push for all of this, then I pay for us to get this condo and then you're controlling me and you have cameras in here watching me. Nicholle: Right. No. Think about that. Think about what that means. Home is supposed to be the one place where you don't have to perform for anyone. You close the door and you're alone. Zalle: Think about that. Think about what that means. Home is supposed to be the one place where you don't have to perform things. You close the door and you're alone. You change you relax, But Michelle said that she would be moving. Nicholle: You change clothes, you relax, you sleep. But Michelle says that even inside her own home, she was being watched. Zalle: Yeah, and the surveillance wasn't an isolated behavior. Michelle described Ian monitoring her movements and communications. He would question where she had been. He would notice when she was late. He monitored her phone and computer. And according to later reporting, he downloaded information from her computer onto a portable storage device. Definitely stalker. Definitely control. So the pattern becomes clear. He was influencing what she wore, how she looked, who she spent time with, where she went, and what happened inside the home. That is much bigger than an argument about clothing. That's control. Nicholle: Definitely controlling. So the pattern becomes clear. He was influencing what she wore, how she looked, who she spent time with, where she went, and what happened inside the home. That is much bigger than an argument about clothing. That's control. Zalle: Yeah, and Michelle all had blah blah. Yes, and Michelle has also described Ian monitoring her schedule. If she was late getting home, he wanted to know why. He would send repeated messages. He showed up at her workplace unexpectedly, and according to her, he pressured her about her career as well. Michelle was pursuing an MBA at Chapman, at Chapman University. Ian encouraged her to quit her job and work at Disneyland instead. He had previously worked there. Michelle believed that his connections at Disneyland would make it easier for him to keep tabs on her. I mean and then okay. So let's just put this out there. Michelle was like twenty one when they Nicholle: Right. Zalle: first got together, okay? And she said she hadn't really had too many like serious relationships. And so she was very, Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: what is it, impressionable. So it wasn't hard Nicholle: Right. Zalle: for her to just get into the flow of kind of just letting him control whatever she had going on. So very young mindset, Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right, definitely. Zalle: okay. Before we get to being like, you know, judging her or whatever. But she even describes herself as bitch that's what she was. Yeah. And that's what she was kinda looking for. Yeah. And again, one behavior by itself can be dismissed. You're worried because she's late. You want your girlfriend to dress her Nicholle: Right. And she even describes herself as like a goody two shoes. That's what she was. And that's what she was kind of looking for. And again, one behavior by itself can be dismissed. You're worried because she's late. You want your girlfriend to dress differently. You want her to work somewhere else. But when you put them together, you're seeing someone else's independence slowly being squeezed. Zalle: You want her else. But when you put them together, you're seeing someone else's independent, slowly getting sweet. Yeah. And then there was another part of Ian's behavior. Ian wanted Michelle to have sex with other men. He wanted to watch and he wanted it recorded. According to Michelle, this wasn't something she wanted. She resisted. She told him she wasn't comfortable with it. And she almost was like, This is a deal breaker, we're not compatible because that's not who she was at all. But in But she also said that she was like, Well, maybe this is what you do in adult relationships. Right. She hasn't had that many relationships. And she was very young. Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. but she also said that she was like, Well, maybe this is what you do in adult relationships because she hadn't had that many relationships and she was very young. Zalle: Yeah. She just thought that this is what you do and you know, you want your man to be happy. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. So unprofessional. Zalle: But Ian repeatedly repeatedly pressured her. When Michelle traveled for work, he would continue bringing it up. He would text her and he would ask her to have sex with strangers. And according to later accounts of the relationship, Michelle eventually threatened to leave if he wouldn't stop. But the pressure continued. The federal court later described Ian as persistently badgering Michelle to indulge his sexual fantasies and begging her to have sex with strangers. Right, and she was standing with like it was her body. Like felt like it how however he wanted. Nicholle: Right. And she was saying it was like it was her body, but he felt like he could use it however he wanted to. Zalle: Yeah. Poor Michelle. Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: Eventually Michelle gave in and the circumstances matter, okay? She was sick and she was taking cold medicine. Nyquil, to be precise precise. She was taking NyQuil. Ian had arranged for a stranger he found through Craigslist to come to their home. I need you guys to keep in mind how often I am bringing up Craigslist. Hated. he found somebody through Craigslist to come to their home. Okay. According to the federal court record, Ian gave Michelle three shots of whiskey. He set up cameras in their bedroom and he watched and filmed from another room while the stranger had sex with Michelle. I don't Nicholle: That is I Zalle: know what to say about that. We're not going to describe the sexual encounter itself, but we do need to understand what Michelle said about it afterwards. She was traumatized. She wanted the reporting destroyed. But she later told Ian that the encounter felt like breaking her. According to the court record, Ian became angry when she described that brain. Nicholle: don't know what to say about that. We're not going to describe the sexual encounter itself, but we do need to understand what Michelle said about it afterward. She was traumatized, she wanted the recording destroyed, and she later told Ian that the encounter had felt like rape to her. According to the court record, Ian became angry when she described it that way. Zalle: She said that Ian told her while she was sitting there bawling afterwards that nobody put a gun to her head. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: So basically it's no reason for you to be sitting here crying 'cause you willingly let me do that. And also Nicholle: Yeah, you you went along with it. Right. Zalle: told her that she needed to go to the doctor and get tested because the stranger's condom had came off. The stranger's condom the strangers condom came off while Nicholle: The stranger's condom came off. Zalle: they were having sex. Yeah. Yeah. And When I say disgusting earlier, I don't mean disgusting as far as like somebody wanting to have maybe the strangers part, that's a little weird, but to wanting to watch other people sleep with your partner, if Nicholle: Right. Zalle: that's what you do and you want to record it, that's you, you know what I'm saying? To each their own. That's your house. But forcing somebody you know who does not Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: want to participate into doing that and then dismissing her afterwards is what's disgusting. It's very disgusting. You do what you want to do. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. It's very disgusting. You do what you want to do, that your sexual Zalle: As long as everybody's consenting I don't I don't want to know about it. But it's not only did he kind of push her into that, then he treated her like, you know, it was nothing. Yeah. She should calm down. Nicholle: choices are yours. As long as everybody's consenting, I don't I don't want to know about it. But not only did he f kind of push her into that, then he treated her like, you know, it was nothing and she should calm down. Zalle: Yeah. And that reaction matters because Michelle wasn't saying I changed my mind about something I had freely wanted. She was describing the experience as something that had deeply disturbed and traumatized her. And remember those cameras we talked about earlier, the cameras inside their home. Now they have another context. Ian had already installed surveillance cameras in the condo. And then during this sexual encounter, he deliberately set up cameras to record what happened. So recording and surveillance weren't simply technical details. They were part of the control dynamic Michelle described. Yeah, then that's something that's hanging over my head because I know you have it. Whatever I'm doing. It doesn't matter. You've got Nicholle: You can never fully relax because somebody is watching. so the home was being monitored. Her appearance was being managed. Her movements were being questioned. And now her sexuality was being controlled and Zalle: it. Yeah. And the home so the home was being watched. Her appearance Her weakness was being touchy. And now her sexuality was taking reported. Nicholle: recorded. Zalle: Hmm. According to Michelle's account, the controlling behavior continued and controlled aspects of her daily routine. He dictated how much she drank. He disrupted her sleep. He would wake her during the night, and the resulting exhaustion affected her work. He also kept firearms in the home. Michelle found his possession of those weapons intimidating. Nicholle: I'm sure. Again, we're not saying every allegation in a civil complaint was independently proven in a criminal trial, but there are allegations Michelle made and they're important because they explain the relationship that she says she was trying to escape. Zalle: But there are allegations Michelle made and they're important because they explain the relationship she said she was trying to attack. Eventually Michelle reached a point where she couldn't continue. In August twenty fifteen she left Ian. She moved out. She did this while his friend, his US Marshall coworker, Leslie Carlson was at the house. And she said while she was there, she just packed up everything she could fit in her car and she left because she knew Ian wouldn't do too much while his coworker was there. And that's how they broke up. It's important to keep that in mind. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: So she left and she went back to her parents. And according to the federal court record, she later experienced experienced a trauma related episode and was diagnosed with complex PTSD. Nicholle: Good. my goodness. But she had gotten out, at least physically. But there was one thing she couldn't simply leave behind that Zalle: But she had gotten out, at least physically. But there was one thing she couldn't simply leave behind that Nicholle: condo. Zalle: In June 2015, Michelle and Ian had purchased an Anaheim condominium together. Michelle paid the down payment. The couple financed the rest with a mortgage of approximately four hundred fifty nine thousand seven hundred and forty five dollars. After Michelle left, Ian remained and the property became a major point of contention. in November twenty fifteen, They entered into an agreement involving Michelle's interest in the condo and Ian's assumption of the mortgage. But Ian didn't complete the required mortgage assumption, So by June twenty sixteen, Michelle learned that his application had been denied, meaning he hadn't paid the mortgage through and it wasn't s you know, everything wasn't switched over to where it just belonged to him. So she then told him that she intended to enforce Nicholle: So she then Zalle: their agreement, which was putting the house on the market. So Michelle was she still has the financial and legal connection. Nicholle: So Michelle is trying to move forward, but she still has the financial and legal connection to Ian, and that's when the next woman enters the picture. Zalle: And as he said before. Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: In j in January 2016, Ian met Angela Connell. They connected online again. He met Michelle online. And the relationship moved very quickly. He said that she was everything he ever asked for, which is the same thing he said about Michelle. Are we seeing a pattern? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: By February, they were married. Less than a month. Angela moved into the Anaheim condo, the same condo Michelle had helped purchase. And that creates an incredibly situation to say the least. Michelle has just escaped relationship she described as a her former fiance has remarried the wife is now living Michelle left high. And Michelle is still fighting over the property. Nicholle: And that creates an incredibly complicated situation, to say the least. Michelle has just escaped a relationship she described as abusive. Her former fiance has remarried. His new wife is now living in the home Michelle helped by, and Michelle is still fighting over the property. Zalle: Eventually, then Angela announced she was pregnant. Then these messages started happening, and she said she had a miscarriage. Shortly after that, she was pregnant again, and she claimed she was carrying twins. But investigators would later determine that the pregnancies were fabricated. That discovery wouldn't happen until much later. At this point though, Angela was presenting herself as Ian's new wife and expected mother. The messages appeared to come from Michelle. They were personal. They referenced Ian they contained religious language, and they became increasingly threatening. One identity connected to the communications was Lilith is truth. According to the federal case, Ian and Angela created and used falsely registered accounts as part of the scheme. And here's what makes the impersonation believe. Michelle really had written emotional messages to Ian. She had really been able to there was a real relationship. There was a real breakup. And there was still that conduct. So the person creating messages had something to work with. Nicholle: And here's what makes the impersonation believable. Michelle really had written emotional messages to Ian. She had really been angry. There was a real relationship. There was a real breakup. And there was still that condo dispute. So the person creating these messages had something to work with. Zalle: Yes. Angela went to the police. She reported the threatening communications and she said Michelle was behind them, but Ian was the one who pushed the Michelle was behind the message. As soon Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: as she got the messages, immediately his response was, It has to be Michelle. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: And the messages kept coming. He kept, you know, making police reports, and every time the police came, Ian did most of the talking or tried to do what you know they would necessarily call coaching where he was like speaking in the background trying to lead Angela in the direction Nicholle: Even the bank kind of leaves. And Zalle: of what was happening in the story. He was very emotional. Very Nicholle: And he was very emotional. Zalle: emotional. He called Michelle out of her name. He tried to get her arrested Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: several times. And at one point at one point during one of these incidences where they had the police come to the condo to report These emails and told the police that Michelle was crazy. She was bitter behind all of this stuff. And that the reason why they broke up was because he found out that Michelle had cheated on him with six or seven guys from Tinder. And he had his best friend over at the apartment for safety reasons. When he told her, either you need to figure it out and tell me the truth about all these guys you were sleeping with, or you need to leave. And he said that she just packed up her stuff and left. I told you guys Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: how they broke up earlier. So this tells you this is just setting a stage of where the lies are. Yes. Nicholle: You setting it up, yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: So after that, Michelle was served with a temporary restraining order. Suddenly, the woman who'd had the woman who had left Ian was being but was being portrayed as the woman who wouldn't leave him alone. Excuse me. Michelle denied sending the messages and she didn't simply deny them. She asked investigators to examine the technology. She asked them to trace the IP addresses. She contacted Microsoft and law enforcement. She contacted Craigslist after learning that advertisements were being associated with her identity. She left Detective Michael Lee detailed voicemails, three detailed voicemails. She was essentially take my word for it. Check the evidence. Nicholle: She was essentially saying, Don't take my word for it, check the evidence. Zalle: Yes, she was very worried. Like, I know I didn't do this. Somebody is framing me. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Then the scheme moved beyond email. Craigslist advertisements began appearing. Some were sexual in nature, and they were designed to create situations that could later be blamed on Michelle. according to the federal case, a Craigslist advertisement linked to Ian's email account was part of the investigation. Investigators also discovered communications and advertisements connected to the Anaheim condo, including And this is where the story takes a a disturbing turn. Because Ian had already used Craigslist in 2014 to arrange a sexual encounter involved in the chef. And they figured this out because it was linked to an email that was Ian's email. Now in 2016, Craigslist is being used again, but this time it was being used as a part of an alleged intense of brain chef. Nicholle: And this is where the story takes a a disturbing turn because Ian had already used Craigslist in 2014 to arrange a sexual encounter involving Michelle. And they figured this out because it was linked to an email that was Ian's email. Now in 2016, Craigslist was being used again, but this time it was being used as a part of an alleged attempt to frame Michelle. Zalle: Men responded to the advertisements. Some were directed toward the Diaz condo. One responder was a seventeen year old boy. The purpose, according to prosecutors, was to create the appearance that Michelle was orchestrating increasingly dangerous sexual encounters like rape fantasies involving Angela. Nicholle: And that's important because the alleged scheme wasn't just creating messages. It was manufacturing events. Someone was trying to turn a digital lie into physical evidence. And they were willing to set up a rape fantasy and have this woman raped if this story is true. Zalle: And they were to set up a rape candidate open rape if the story is true. Yes. And on June 24th, Angela reported that she had been attacked. She told police a stranger had come to the condo. The allegations were serious. Police responded, and Michelle became the suspect. But investigators would eventually uncover surveillance. surveillance footage that contradicted important parts of Angela's account. Nicholle: On June 24th, Michelle was arrested. police took her electronic devices, her phone, her laptop, iPad, and she cooperated. she showed investigators the communication she believed had been spoofed. Zalle: Police took took her electronic devices, her her laptop, iPad, and she cooperated. And she investigators the communication she believed had been spoofed. She thought the devices might finally prove what she'd been saying, but instead, she became the person sitting in jail. She had no idea that Angela had been attacked. She had no idea that the messages were still going through. She had no idea about Angela until she was served the restraining order. Which happened not long before the attack. So Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: she had no idea when the police came to her door, she thought that they were coming because she had left the voicemails and they were coming to investigate that it wasn't her. So Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: imagine being just completely left fielded like that. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Michelle's bail was set at one million dollars. She was facing serious felony charges and the investigation continued. If she was prosecuted, she was facing life. But then something happened that should have immediately raised questions. The messages didn't stop. So I don't know about you, but that raises immediate flags for me about the police because Nicholle: Immediate for me. Zalle: it's like, what what were y'all doing? What were you doing? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. What was your point? Zalle: Because wasn't your job. It wasn't your job. That's not what you were doing. Michelle's devices were in police custody. Yet threatening communications continued. One particularly important email was sent while Michelle was outside the police station after her release on bail. She did not have her devices. They were still in police possession. Yet a n Yet another threatening email was sent to Angela. That should change the question. That's just crazy. If it is saying could Michelle have sent it, it's how. How? Nicholle: That should change the question. That's just crazy. It isn't could Michelle have sent it. It's how could Michelle have sent it? Zalle: And I mean I'm not a police officer. I don't have any kind of degree or not in that area or a badge. So I could probably buy one on Nicholle: Right. Zalle: Amazon because my detective skills are detecting that that's in BS. Something isn't isn't right. Nicholle: Right. Right. I'm gonna need for you to show me how that's done. If you're saying that's done. Zalle: Right. I'm gonna need you to show me how that's done. Yeah. Right. But the case continued to escalate. Michelle was arrested again. This time she remained incarcerated and ultimately she spent eighty eight days in jail. And that was that she was saying in the IT once we were watching that her dad was like, We can use that money to get you a great lawyer and get you out of there. Nicholle: And that was sad when she was saying in the ID one we were watching that her dad was like, We can use that money to get you a great lawyer and get you out of there, but you're gonna have to sit in there for a while and she's like Zalle: You're gonna have to sit in there for a while. Yeah, we could pay Bell or we could get you a lawyer. Yeah, which one do you want? She's like, okay, I can handle it. But she of course breaks down before the Yeah, I felt Nicholle: Yeah, which one do you want? And she's like, Okay, I can handle it. But she of course breaks down this poor lady. I feel so bad. Zalle: bad for her. Crazy part is when we were watching here's the thing. Here's the thing I've learned about Netflix. They are some messy bitches. Because let me tell you something. They're gonna Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: set up the scene to make whoever look guilty as shit until the very last minute. Because she's not the first woman that I've watched in a Netflix documentary and I was like, That hoe is guilty. Nicholle: No day. Zalle: Ain't no way she didn't do it. And now I'm like, Ugh, she's a horrible person. L and then you flip it, now I'm like, Now I feel bad 'cause I done talked about this woman. Throw her under the jail. Whoever is writing Nicholle: man. they set you up for Netflix. They set you up away. Zalle: the scripts, great job, but how dare you? Do you know that's an emotion? Nicholle: How dare you do that to us? That was an emotional. I felt bad. I was I was feeling so guilty. If I had just shut up for ten more minutes. Zalle: I feel bad. I'm so bad. So bad. Like how can we do this to this woman? Yeah, it's not I'm part of the problem. I don't want to be part of the problem. Don't write your script so well Nicholle: I don't wanna be. Zalle: where I think she did it. Don't make her look guilty because she made herself look guilty. Like don't do that. Okay. Michelle was watching her life disappear. She had gone from engaged to trying to escape an abusive relationship to fighting over a condo to being portrayed as a dangerous stalker. And now she was behind bars. But while Michelle was in jail, the evidence was beginning to move. And the crazy part is when she got arrested, the whatever state they were in, I can't remember off the top my head, that year she got the the craziest person award or something like that. They really Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: she was one of the hate the most hated people and all of this was going on. They like literally called her the crazy ex girlfriend all over the news. Like it was so bad. And then you heard dad talk about it on the IT show. I love Net documentaries, but this IT one that we watched obviously it was it was good because you got to like Nicholle: Mm-hmm. And that you heard the dad talk about it on the ID show. I love Netflix documentaries, but this ID one that we watched, Toxic, it was it was good because you got to like listen to the dad talk. You got to hear more about that side of the story. It's more focused on Michelle's experience. Zalle: Listen to the dad talk. We got to hear more about that topic story, more focused on Michelle's experience. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Rather than just trying to fit her in so the story is good. Right. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: Investigators began finding inconsistencies in Angela's story. The pregnancy was one of them. Evidence surfaced showing that Angela had manipulated pregnancy tests. And the stories she had presented to believe to police began to unravel. Now investigators had a different problem. If Angela was capable if Angela was capable of fabricating one story, what else did she then fabricate? And that's she just kept lying and lying and lying. Angela has her own set of problems. Nicholle: Now investigators had a different problem. If Angela was capable if Angela was capable of fabricating one part of the story, what else has she been fabricating? And she just kept lying and lying and lying. Angela has her own set of problems. Zalle: Her own set of problems, because not only did she lie about the pregnancies, Then she told Ian she was sick and she had cancer. Never had cancer. Never had Nicholle: Never had cancer. Zalle: cancer. She told him that she was a lawyer or did some kind of something in the law. Law failed. She never been to law school. She didn't even have a job. She didn't have she wasn't even going to work. Wasn't even going to work. Nicholle: She didn't even ha she wasn't even going to work. She was lying about going to work. Zalle: Lied about going to work. Ian's best friend. I cannot remember that woman's name. But her Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: Yeah, she wanted to she wanted Ian. She wanted his draws. She would have put them on her forehead and sniffed Nicholle: Look shh. Zalle: the booty section. here's the thing. Here's thing. She was annoying me, not because she wants me. But she obviously doesn't. That should be. But she kept trying to set it up like a friend. And I'm sure maybe they are. No, definitely not because she doesn't. Nicholle: She here's the thing. Here's the thing. She was annoying me, not because she wants Ian, which she obviously does. That's your business. But she kept trying to set it up like we're just friends. And I'm sure maybe they are because, you know, definitely not because she doesn't want to be a part of it. But Zalle: Well he she clearly was not everything that he was looking for. Clearly. She was the one woman in town that was not everything that he was the only one. But every time she would talk about she was telling her story, it was in Ian or Kenna and I and it was always them. I guess it's because they were actually doing the things at the same time. But it's just the way that she said it. It's so clear this woman wants that. Nicholle: Clearly. She was the one woman in town that was not everything he was looking for. But every time she would talk about she was telling her story, it was me and Ian or Ian and I. And it was always them. I guess it's because they were actually doing the things at the same time. But it's just the way that she said it. It's so clear this woman wants that man. Zalle: Yeah, you'll see if you watch the Netflix Toxic Love Story or Toxic Love, Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: you'll see it. It's good, it's juicy. I recommend it. I also recommend Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: the I D Toxic series. It was episode two, season one. It was great. It's called Three's a Crow. Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: Anywho, investigators obtained warrants for the relevant email accounts and Craigslist activity. And the digital evidence began pointing somewhere unexpected. Some of the threatening emails had originated from the IP address associated with the Anaheim condo. The home where Ian and Angela lived. Why are you trying not to laugh? You know the words are right over your face, so I can see. No, laughing at these people. Like Nicholle: No, I'm just laughing at these people. Like Zalle: Yeah, they he was stupid. To be a US Marshal, he's dumb as hell. Nicholle: A US Marshal. Zalle: The home where Ian and Angela lived, others were connected to Angela's phone. Another device was located at Angela's father's home in Phoenix. The evidence wasn't pointing towards Michelle. It was pointing towards the people accusing her. And if they said it in the ID was that something came from the department that is IT or the So one of the Nicholle: And they said in the ID one that something came from the Department of Defense IP or the the right Zalle: emails came from his phone. It was his D.O.J. issued work Nicholle: DOJ. Zalle: phone. That he had sent one of these emails from. Nicholle: right. Zalle: From the beginning, Michelle had been asking investigators to trace the digital evidence. Eventually, after at least eighty eight days, they did. Nicholle: At least Zalle: Yeah. And the technology began telling a completely different story. Nicholle: This is one of the most important moments in the case, really, because Michelle didn't know exactly who was framing her. She couldn't tell police it's Ian's computer or it's Angela's phone. She didn't have that information. She simply knew it wasn't me. And she kept asking them Zalle: Really? Because Michelle didn't know exactly who was framing her. She couldn't tell police it's Ian's computer his Angela's phone. She didn't have that information. She simply knew it wasn't me. And she kept asking them to look. Nicholle: to look. Zalle: I mean, obviously Michelle had an inkling of who the hell it was. Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: So by October twenty sixteen, Michelle was released, thankfully. She had spent Nicholle: Thankfully. Zalle: eighty eight days in custody. And on January 9th, 2017, the Orange County District Attorney announced that the charges against Michelle had been dismissed and that she had been fully exonerated. Thank you, you arrested me, kept me in jail for eighty eight days, but you exonerated me. Boy, get out of here. Get out of my face. Get out of my face on TV anyway on TV. Yeah. In front of the courthouse. In front of the course. Bumpy you and your mama. Nicholle: Get out of my face. Get out of my face on TV at your news conference. In front of the courthouse. Zalle: So at Nicholle: So at least she was free. But the investigation wasn't finished. because now the question was, who had done this? Can I just say something right here? I just want to say this. I really no, I wait till the end because we're going to discuss it. Zalle: least she was but the investigation wasn't finished. now the question was that. And I just say something right here because I just want to say this. I really no, I wait till the end because it's gonna be seven. Okay. Angela became the focus of the investigation. The pregnancy had been fabricated, the Craigslist evidence was pointing towards the condo. The digital communications weren't coming from Michelle. And investigators found evidence that Angela had staged aspects of the story. And here's one of the aspects. Where they stay at the condominium. There are at least twenty-four cameras. Twenty four. They're very well protected over there. None of the cameras picked up the anybody Nicholle: No, no. Zalle: coming when the night she reported that she was attacked. They captured nobody coming or leaving. And I think that's amazing that those Nicholle: And I think that's amazing that those cameras that Ian was so hot to put up around this condo helped, at least in part, to prove that nobody came to that condo. Zalle: cameras that Ian so have to put up around this contact. At least the part. To prove that nobody came that contact. Well the crazy part it wasn't even the cameras that Ian put up. These are the cameras for the property. He that Nicholle: okay. Zalle: and the attacks supposedly happened in the garage. Which if it had happened they would have seen it because one of the cameras pointed towards like the little drive part where their garage was. So Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: that's a lie. Angela ultimately pleaded guilty to charges connected to the scheme, as she should have, but she was only sentenced to five years in prison. And this is where Michelle's story and this is where Michelle's story doesn't. Because Michelle has spent years telling people that Ian was involved. And now investigators have to answer a much harder question. Was Angela acting alone, or was he getting involved Nicholle: And this is where Michelle's story and this is where Michelle's story doesn't end. Because Michelle has spent years telling people that Ian was involved. And now investigators had to answer a much harder question. Was Angela acting alone or was Ian involved too? Zalle: too? And let me tell you for the majority for almost all of this, the fucking Anaheim excuse me, the freaking Anaheim Police Department and the US Marshals refused to believe that Ian was involved in this, police covering their ass. Police will stick up for they were they arrested Angela which they should have. But nobody was talking about nobody even discussed it. Nobody. Nicholle: Yeah, and like Michelle said, they were tr they arrested Angela, which they should have, but nobody was talking about Ian. Even when she's saying, Look at him, nobody wants to look at him. They're show the dad is going through looking at Zalle: All this stuff and he's like everything comes back it has its footprint moment. Everything has nobody focused on Ian until an outside Nicholle: all this stuff and he's like, Everything comes back to it has his footprint on it. Everything has Ian's footprint on it. Nobody. Zalle: D. O. J. investigator stepped in and looked at him. I think his name was Mike something. I don't wanna lie. but he was the officer that came in and he was like, What she's saying makes sense. None of this evidence is matching up. Yes, Angela's crazy and she was guilty of her own stuff, but she's Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: not the one That could have done this because, first of all, what they were saying in the emails, one email, it ended with saying, like it was signed her nickname, Missy. Mishi. Nicholle: Mushy mushy or so. Mushy. Zalle: Her nickname. Nobody knew about that nickname but Ian. So Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Angela could not have known that unless he was helping her write it, right? The DOJ phone, the fact that it was act actively connected. Angela wouldn't have had access to that. So Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: the fact that they ignored this man for so long pisses me off. And it pisses me off. Because in things like that little nickname at the bottom of the email doing sending things or whatever he's doing from your POJ phones, either it's almost like he's wagging it in Nicholle: And it pisses me off because in things like that little nickname at the bottom of the email doing sending things or whatever he was doing from his DOJ phone, either it's almost like he's wagging it in Zalle: her face that he can away with it because he knows that they don't they're not gonna look at him. Yeah in the unless they're forced to. Nicholle: her face that he can get away with it because he knows that they don't they're not gonna look at him unless they're forced to. Zalle: So the crazy part was for these the rape fantasy posts he put on Craigslist, they make you verify that like this is a consenting thing. You're actively wanting to do this. So they had to send him a verification phone to a verification code to his phone. And went to his Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: cell phone, his personal cell phone, he responded to it obviously giving it access because the fa the rape fantasy post was on Craigslist. Clearly you approved Nicholle: Was on the front. Mm-hmm. Zalle: it, but he said he didn't do it. He he got the message, but he never opened it. That doesn't make any sense to me. You're just not being smart. And as soon as he did it, the next day he went and got a new phone. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Like they but like that's gonna erase it. I don't even understand why he went to do that. If it's your phone, they're gonna know that's your phone, even if you don't have that phone anymore. Zalle: Like that, but like that's gonna erase. I don't even understand why he went to do that. If it's your phone, they're gonna know that your phone, even if you don't have that phone anymore. That's what I'm saying. But it's all of these trying to cover it up. You can see all Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: of this. And the dad, while Michelle was in jail, had all of this evidence and he was like, I'm telling you, like, l the here you go. This is where it's not making sense. Nicholle: I've done all the work. Zalle: And the they requested To have what was it? Whatever information is they send where you can see all the backlogs on Craigslist where it shows you what where the IP Nicholle: yeah. Zalle: address and stuff is coming from. The police requested Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: all this information during the investigation for Michelle, but they never actually opened it and reviewed it to see where the messages were coming from. It wasn't until Nicholle: Right. Zalle: after this and after Angela was arrested that they actually opened this information to even see that Ian was involved. And like I said, it wasn't until the other DOJ The DOJ investigator got involved. This wasn't even Trash ass law enforcement. Not all of you. But this situation was trash ass. I'm pol like you gotta take the L of The federal investigation eventually focused on Ian. Investigators reconstructed the communications finally. They examined email accounts, digital devices, and followed IP addresses. They examined Craigslist's activity and they looked at the evidence surrounding the impersonation of Michelle. According to the prosecutors, Ian and Angela used falsely registered email accounts. They used VPNs to conceal internet activity and they commuted through encrypted messaging services. Ian deleted email accounts associated with the scheme. And that matters because wasn't just a spontaneous lie. The evidence presented by prosecutors deliberate efforts to deal with factors behind the communication. Nicholle: And that matters because this wasn't just a spontaneous lie. The evidence presented by prosecutors showed deliberate efforts to conceal who was actually behind the communications. These he just trash. He's just trash. Zalle: And she's trashed Nicholle: Ew. Zalle: for going along with this and for all of her own lies. Right. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: In twenty twenty one, Ian Diaz was federally indicted. The charges included conspiracy to commit cyber stalking, cyberstalking, perjury, Obstruction of a federal proceeding. In March twenty twenty three, a federal jury convicted Ian. The evidence presented at trial connected him to the conspiracy, and the jury found him guilty of the federal charges. On June 30th, 2023, Ian Diaz was sentenced to 121 months in federal prison. That is 10 years and one month. He also received three years of supervised release. Nicholle: So the man who had once portrayed Michelle as the dangerous ex fiance was now a convicted federal criminal. Zalle: Yep. Eighty-eight days is a number. But to Michelle, it was a portion of her life that couldn't be returned. She went into jail accused of crimes she hadn't committed. She came out knowing that someone had deliberately built a false version of her and then she had to rebuild it all. Michelle later pursued civil litigation civil litigation related to her arrest and the investigation. As she should. Good job, Michelle. Go get your bag. Nicholle: Yes. Zalle: The litigation raised questions about how police handled the evidence and the investigation. They didn't handle it. They didn't handle it. Nicholle: They didn't handle it. Zalle: The white man said, My girlfriend did it. And they said, Bet. Bet. Nicholle: But Zalle: That's what happened. Yeah, Nicholle: We believe you. Zalle: as you should. Some claims survived while others were dismissed, and the city of Anaheim eventually settled with Michelle. Michelle continued her education, she built a career, she became a mother, and eventually began speaking publicly about what happened. And that brings us to what we did. Because Michelle's story has now been in that in Netflix documentary, a toxic love story. Nicholle: And that brings us to twenty twenty six because Michelle's story has now been revisited in Netflix documentary, A Toxic Love Story. Zalle: Revisits Michelle's relationship with Ian, the abuse, the breakup, the condo, Angela, the fake digital identity, the Craigslist scheme, the investigation, and the years Michelle spent trying to rebuild her life. But what makes the story especially concerned is the connection between the beginning and Nicholle: But what makes this story especially disturbing is the connection between the beginning and the end. Think about what Ian allegedly did during that relationship. He monitored Michelle, he controlled her appearance, he installed cameras Zalle: the end. Think about what Ian allegedly did during that relationship. He monitored Michelle, he controlled her appearance, he installed cameras. in their home. He pressured her sexually. He used Craigslist find a stranger for a sexual encounter involving her. And then he filmed it. After Michelle left, Craigslist became part of the alleged team that used Nicholle: in their home, he pressured her sexually. He used Craigslist to find a stranger for a sexual encounter involving her. And then he filmed it. After Michelle left, Craigslist became thoroughly. Part of the alleged scheme used to make Michelle look like the aggressor. Zalle: to make Michelle reflect the rest. And the whole time they were doing this investigation, Ian kept claiming that he had no idea how to use Craigslist. He said he used it maybe one time to like sell a T V. So Yeah, okay. Nicholle: Celly TV, yeah. Zalle: And I think that that's the part that's easiest to miss. The story isn't just Michelle was frame. The larger story is about control. It started as Ian trying to control Michelle during their relationship, her movements, communication, and so forth. And eventually led to him trying to control the story about what was happening, who police believed, what evidence they saw, and what identity appeared up behind the emails. And also who was portrayed as the victim. At first, investigators had a story that seemed to make sense. Michelle was Ian's angry ex fiance. There was a condo dispute. She had written two angry messages. Angela was now receiving threatening emails, so then the strangers were showing up at the condo. She had written angry messages. Michelle became the obvious suspect. Nicholle: But pipe. Zalle: A person can look suspicious, a story can sound believable, a victim can appear convincing, and yet none of those things replace evidence. Michelle didn't have all the evidence, but she kept asking questions to find. And eventually they did Nicholle: Michelle didn't have all the answers, but she kept asking questions to find them, and eventually they did. So do you think the abuse Michelle described changed the way she was perceived later? Because the angry messages she had sent in, they were real, Zalle: You think the abuse Michelle described changed the way she was perceived later? Because the angry messages she had sent in, they were real. I definitely think that once Michelle was able to get her story out and tell what it was actually like to be in a relationship with Ian, that the perspective of her was changed. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think because like for Zalle: Yeah. Yeah, go ahead. Because like for speaking even about us. What we were just saying. Just watching at least when she first came on in the Netflix documentary. I was like, okay, yeah, she is Nicholle: speaking even about what we were just saying, how just watching at least when she first came on in the Netflix documentary, I was like, Okay, yeah, she did this. Zalle: Yeah, me too. I definitely was like, she's guilty. She's guilty. But as we were watching the ID about her, all I could think was how much not the story itself, but the way that it's working out Nicholle: Sh she's guilty. But as we were watching the ID show about her, all I could think was how much this not the story itself, but the way that it's working out seems very much like the Lindsay Clancy case with her husband. Zalle: Seems very much like the Lindsay Way. I was just thinking the same thing. I was thinking the same damn thing. Doesn't it? The Nicholle: Doesn't it? Zalle: same thing. And the fact that nobody's looking at that nigga neither. Nobody's Nicholle: Nobody's looking at him. Zalle: looking at that nigga neither. And guess what? Ian motherfucking ass was guilty. So let me tell you something else. Nicholle: When I was listening, I was like, why does this sound familiar? Zalle: When I was listening, I was like, hm Why this sound familiar? Yeah. Yeah. Okay, so at what point do you think that investigators at what point Nicholle: think they should have Zalle: do you think that the investigators should have started questioning the original theory? Because I feel like it You know, maybe it should have been when Michelle asked them to trace the IP addresses since she was the one that was being, accused, or maybe after sh her messages were taken and then the messages still kept coming. I mean that that would have been a good point for me, but what do you think? Because those are both very good points to do it. I think you should start when the person makes the complaint that all of these things are happening. Nicholle: Those are both very good points to do it. I think you should start when the person makes the complaint that all of these things are happening. At the very least, you should be looking at the complaint's devices so that you can see where they're coming from, so you can find the person who's sending them. So I think we wouldn't have we wouldn't have even gotten to the rest of it if the police had done their job at that point. But they were too busy trying to protect Ian. I don't even know that they knew he was Zalle: Mm-hmm. At the very least you should be looking at the complaint's devices so that you can see where they're coming from. Right. So you can find the person who's sitting. Yeah. That's sound like I think we wouldn't have we wouldn't have even gotten to the rest of it if the police had done their job at that point. Yeah. But they were too busy trying to protect Ian. I don't even know that they knew he was doing Nicholle: doing anything necessarily, but they were just taking what he said and going with it. And then as the story went Zalle: anything necessarily. But they were just taking what he said and going with it and then as the story went on. Nicholle: on, that's when they started covering his ass. Zalle: That's when they started covering the thing. Yeah, they took his word as a law instead of just like they normally would. Another police job and investigating. Right. And here's the hardest question. Nicholle: Doing the police job and investigating it. And here's the hardest question. How much easier is it to frame someone when you already know their private history, their relationship, their writing style, the things they fear, the things that you tell people when you're in a relationship? Zalle: Much easier is it to train someone when you already know their private history, their relationship, their writing style, the things they fear, the things that you tell people when you're in a relationship. Clearly, it's very easy. Once again, Lindsay Clancy. I rest my case. I mean, even this, because Ian framed two women. Two women. Nicholle: Two women. Zalle: Angela was a little she was involved at some points, like towards the end. But at the beginning, what even once Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: like when she first started calling, making all the police reports, she had no idea Ian was Ian was involved in any of this. She just took his word Nicholle: Right. Zalle: when he said, It's my crazy ex-girlfriend. So she was being a good wife to him or whatever. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: He framed Michelle first and then set it up, got Angela involved, and then when he figured out that things were crumbling, set Angela up to take the fall so he wouldn't go to jail. And he turned her in. Yes. He Nicholle: When it said, right. Hurt in. Yes. Zalle: turned her in. He told the police yeah, look at Angela. Check her out. Check her out. Check Nicholle: Check her out. I think she's doing all of this. Zalle: her out. That blew my damn mind. He was like, I'm a liar. And when he was bamboozled by Angela's ass, he was like, Well, she done manipulated me. She's manipulated me. Yeah. a whole intervention. Show me your board. Show me your board. And they were mad. Mad, okay. They should have been. They should have been the b Nicholle: He had a intervention set up and everything. Interventions. So and the people were there and they were mad. As they should have been. But they were there with Ian, who was the biggest liar in the world. Zalle: Lying. And then in the and then had the audio talk about you lied to all these people here, nigga. I mean, sir. Good day. Nicholle: Okay, now we want to hear from you. What part of this case shocked you the most? Was it the abuse that Michelle described? The cameras inside the condo? Zalle: Now we want to hear from you. What part of this case shocked you the most? Was it the abuse that Michelle described? The cameras inside the condo? mean any of these are great questions. Nicholle: Mean any of these are great questions. Zalle: Let us know in the comments. If you liked it, definitely make sure that you subscribe to our channel. Follow us on all the socials so you don't miss any updates or any of our future episodes. Other than just telling us about this episode, if there is another episode you would like us to cover, leave it in the comments. We do need the reviews and the shares and all of the extra click all the buttons you see on the screen except report or delete. Yes. Nicholle: Right as Zalle: Because we need all of the encounters so other people can find us and we can get out there. We love talking to you guys. We've been seeing all of the views come in, which have been insane. Yes. Nicholle: We're finding our community. We're finding our community. Zalle: All of the c the conversations happening in our comments. We go through and we read it and we are loving it. So please come in. Come in. Yes. And please Nicholle: Yes, definitely come subscribe on YouTube. That's where all of our videos are posted. Zalle: subscribe on That's where all of our videos are. I'm Zaylie. And I'm the home. And we'll see you next time. Nicholle: And I'm Nicole and we'll see you next time. Zalle: We cannot do that together. Did it go at the same time? your coffee hot. And your dairy stuff. See ya later, co-conspirators. Nicholle: And your theory's coming. Bye.