Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Understanding Knowledge
Transcript
- 0:13It is 09:57AM
- 0:15Pacific Daylight Time. It is the April
- 0:192025.
- 0:21This
- 0:22is episode
- 0:23ten eighty two of Bitcoin End.
- 0:26It's not a news day.
- 0:28It's a think day.
- 0:30Today, I'm reading a piece called Understanding Knowledge
- 0:34from my friend, Liminal.
- 0:35And before you skip ahead,
- 0:37let me tell you,
- 0:39this ain't just academic naval gazing. This one's got roots. It ties straight into how we handle knowledge
- 0:46in a decentralized
- 0:47world.
- 0:48Nostra,
- 0:50zettelkasten,
- 0:51mycelial structures, the whole nine.
- 0:54We're talking about what it means to know something in a world where knowledge doesn't live on university shelves anymore. It moves.
- 1:02It forks. It dies. It spawns. It's organic. And sometimes,
- 1:06it changes form.
- 1:08The network matters more than the node. So if you're into stuff like how information spreads across Nostr,
- 1:15how your zettelkasten node system mimics forest fungi,
- 1:19or how the collapse of centralized
- 1:21institutions
- 1:23might not be a bug, but a feature,
- 1:25buckle
- 1:27up. It's Bitcoin and knowledge.
- 1:29Let's go.
- 1:31Introduction.
- 1:33Knowledge
- 1:34as a living ecosystem.
- 1:37Why Investigate
- 1:38the Nature of Knowledge?
- 1:41Understanding the nature of knowledge itself is fundamental,
- 1:44distinct
- 1:45from simply studying how we learn or communicate.
- 1:49Knowledge exists
- 1:50first as representations
- 1:52within individuals,
- 1:54separate from how we interact with it.
- 1:57Consider a physicist's
- 1:58understanding of quantum mechanics, the complete
- 2:02interconnected web of concepts in their mind,
- 2:05exists
- 2:06differently
- 2:07from how they might explain it in a lecture,
- 2:09write it in a textbook, or summarize it in a tweet.
- 2:13When knowledge must be shared, it undergoes
- 2:17transformative process,
- 2:18moving from its represented form within a dynamically changing individual
- 2:23to something that could be transmitted.
- 2:26This transmission demands
- 2:27not just translation into words,
- 2:30but adaptation
- 2:31to specific mediums,
- 2:33each shaping how that knowledge is ultimately conveyed.
- 2:37As technology advances,
- 2:39developing systems that more closely mirror knowledge's true form becomes crucial.
- 2:44Not just to improve the retention and navigation,
- 2:47but to enable more effective critical examination
- 2:51and connection of ideas across existing bodies of knowledge.
- 2:55Traditional approaches that ignore this fundamental nature of knowledge inevitably
- 3:00create
- 3:01artificial constraints
- 3:03on how we understand,
- 3:05share, and build upon
- 3:07human understanding.
- 3:10Challenging
- 3:11the static perception of knowledge.
- 3:14Traditionally,
- 3:15knowledge has been perceived as a static repository,
- 3:19a meticulously
- 3:20cataloged library,
- 3:22or a readily queryable
- 3:24database.
- 3:25This conventional viewpoint treats knowledge as a collection of discrete facts and information that can be stored,
- 3:32retrieved, and utilized
- 3:34in a linear fashion.
- 3:37However, this perspective may oversimplify
- 3:39the complexity and fluidity
- 3:41inherent in how knowledge is generated,
- 3:44shared, and evolved.
- 3:47Viewing knowledge through this static lens risks neglecting the intricate interactions
- 3:52and continuous evolution that characterize
- 3:55our collective understanding.
- 3:58Reimagining
- 3:59knowledge as a living ecosystem.
- 4:04Contrary to the static model,
- 4:06this essay proposes
- 4:08a reimagining of knowledge as a living process.
- 4:12In this framework, knowledge is seen as dynamic
- 4:15and ever evolving, much like a natural ecosystem that adapts,
- 4:20grows, and thrives
- 4:22through complex interactions and relationships.
- 4:25This biological perspective
- 4:27highlights several key characteristics.
- 4:31Resilience,
- 4:32the ability to maintain integrity
- 4:35while adapting to new information.
- 4:38Interconnectedness,
- 4:40the organic formation of relationships between ideas.
- 4:44Higher order interactions,
- 4:47the capacity to be built with other sets of ideas.
- 4:51Adaptability,
- 4:53the capacity to evolve in response to new contexts and needs.
- 4:59In conceptualizing
- 5:00knowledge in this manner, we acknowledge
- 5:03its capacity for growth and transformation,
- 5:06mirroring the resilience and adaptability
- 5:09found in living systems.
- 5:11This approach
- 5:12not only provides a more accurate representation
- 5:15of how knowledge functions, but also offers practical insights for designing more effective and responsive
- 5:22knowledge systems.
- 5:25The four perspectives.
- 5:27One, the building blocks.
- 5:30Material cause.
- 5:32Just as living organisms are made up of cells,
- 5:35knowledge systems are built from fundamental units of understanding.
- 5:39These range from simple concepts to complex theories,
- 5:43each capable of standing alone while contributing
- 5:47to larger structures.
- 5:49Think of them as knowledge cells,
- 5:51Self contained, but ready to connect and combine
- 5:55in meaningful ways.
- 5:58Two.
- 5:59The pattern of organization.
- 6:02Formal cause.
- 6:03If you've ever seen how mushrooms connect through underground networks, you'll have a good picture of how knowledge
- 6:10naturally organizes itself.
- 6:13Rather than fitting into neat hierarchical boxes,
- 6:16knowledge forms web like connections in all directions.
- 6:20Modern digital systems are finally catching up to this natural way of organizing information,
- 6:25moving beyond rigid folder structures to more fluid,
- 6:30interconnected
- 6:30approaches.
- 6:33Three.
- 6:34The forces of change.
- 6:36Efficient cause.
- 6:38Knowledge
- 6:39grows and changes through a complex dance of individual insights, community discussions, technological
- 6:45tools, and cultural developments.
- 6:48Like an ecosystem,
- 6:49it evolves through the interaction of many forces. New tools, like Nostr,
- 6:55are making these natural processes
- 6:57more visible
- 6:58and more powerful, allowing knowledge to evolve
- 7:01more organically
- 7:03than ever before.
- 7:05Four,
- 7:06the purpose and direction.
- 7:08Final cause.
- 7:10Why does knowledge exist?
- 7:13Not just to sit there looking impressive, but to help us understand our world and make better decisions.
- 7:20This purpose shapes how knowledge systems develop and organize themselves.
- 7:24When we design knowledge tools and platforms,
- 7:27we need to keep this ultimate purpose in mind.
- 7:32Why this matters.
- 7:34Understanding knowledge as a living system isn't just a nice metaphor. It has practical implications for how we
- 7:41create and share information,
- 7:43build knowledge management tools,
- 7:46design
- 7:47educational systems,
- 7:49approach research and discovery.
- 7:52When we work with knowledge's living nature rather than against it, we can create more effective ways to learn, share, and grow
- 8:01our collective understanding.
- 8:04Looking
- 8:05forward.
- 8:06Continuing to explore this perspective,
- 8:08we'll dive deeper into each of these aspects, examining
- 8:11how they play out in practical situations
- 8:14and how we can better align our knowledge tools and practices with the natural dynamics
- 8:20of living systems.
- 8:21This journey will help us see knowledge not as a static resource to be stored,
- 8:26but as a living ecosystem to be nurtured and grown.
- 8:30Whether you're a student,
- 8:32researcher, teacher, or knowledge worker,
- 8:35this perspective
- 8:36can change how you interact with and contribute to
- 8:41our collective understanding.
- 8:44Section one,
- 8:46material cause,
- 8:47the substance
- 8:48of knowledge.
- 8:51Knowledge itself as an entity
- 8:53is composed of fundamental building blocks that form the basis of our understanding of the world.
- 9:00These knowledge cells
- 9:02combine and interact to create complex structures of meaning and insight in response to new stimuli and insights born from observations
- 9:10and existing knowledge.
- 9:12To truly comprehend the material cause of knowledge, we must dive into the interplay between these basic components
- 9:19and the systems they engender.
- 9:22The modular nature of these knowledge units
- 9:25becomes evident
- 9:27when we consider how complex ideas could be broken down into smaller,
- 9:31more manageable components.
- 9:33Each of these components is capable of being studied, modified, or combined with others
- 9:39much like the modular organization
- 9:41of biological
- 9:42systems.
- 9:43This modularity is crucial for the growth and evolution of our understanding,
- 9:48allowing us to adapt to new insights
- 9:51and challenges with efficiency
- 9:54and resilience.
- 9:55To better grasp the nature of these fundamental units, we can turn to the concept of semantic closure.
- 10:02This principle,
- 10:03particularly
- 10:04visible online,
- 10:05refers to the ability of a piece of content
- 10:09to generate meaning within itself
- 10:11without requiring extensive external context.
- 10:15Nowhere is this more apparent than in the realm of microblogging
- 10:20where platforms like X and Noster's Kind One Notes
- 10:25exemplifies
- 10:26semantic closure in action.
- 10:28Each note, limited in length, encapsulates
- 10:31a complete thought or idea
- 10:34capable of standing alone while contributing to broader conversations and narratives.
- 10:40Additionally,
- 10:41each note is temporally
- 10:43and contextually
- 10:44bound
- 10:45even though much is not explicitly noted. And when recovered out of context at some point in the future,
- 10:52the note may bring a new interpretation
- 10:55or understanding.
- 10:57When we think about notes and other stuff transmitted by relays,
- 11:02what is a note?
- 11:04A short form piece of text conveying the idea.
- 11:08The limits imposed by the format of a short note forces the user to distill their thoughts into concise,
- 11:16self contained units of information.
- 11:19Each note becomes a semantically closed unit
- 11:23capable of conveying
- 11:24meaning independently
- 11:26of the broader conversation.
- 11:28This microcosm of ideas demonstrates
- 11:31key aspects of knowledge units.
- 11:34Conciseness,
- 11:35context compression,
- 11:37stand alone value,
- 11:39recombinatory
- 11:40potential,
- 11:41and the ability to contribute to larger narratives
- 11:45through network effects.
- 11:47The principle of semantic closure extends beyond microblogging to larger knowledge structures such as videos,
- 11:55books,
- 11:56chapters, and academic papers.
- 11:58These structures create a hierarchy of semantically closed units that can be understood independently
- 12:04while also contributing to a comprehensive
- 12:07whole.
- 12:08The organization embodies
- 12:10Herbert Simon's concept of near
- 12:13decomposability,
- 12:15where knowledge is arranged in hierarchical levels that are relatively independent in the short term,
- 12:21but interconnected
- 12:22over the long term.
- 12:24Delving deeper into near decomposability,
- 12:28we find that it provides a powerful framework for understanding the multilayered nature of knowledge systems.
- 12:35Just as biological organisms can be analyzed at multiple levels, from somatotic
- 12:39particles to cells, tissues, organs, and whole organisms,
- 12:44knowledge systems, too, can be decomposed
- 12:47into various levels of granularity.
- 12:50These levels might range from individual words or concepts to sentences,
- 12:55paragraphs, chapters, entire books, or even whole fields of study.
- 13:01Simultaneously,
- 13:02these knowledge structures exhibit characteristics of what Deleuze
- 13:07and Guitari
- 13:08themed rhizomatic
- 13:10organization.
- 13:12Unlike rigid hierarchies,
- 13:14rhizomatic structures allow for non hierarchical interconnections
- 13:18between knowledge units,
- 13:20providing multiple entry and exit points for exploration.
- 13:25This facilitates creative associations and nonlinear learning,
- 13:29mirroring the complex,
- 13:31interconnected
- 13:32nature of living systems.
- 13:35The near decomposable and rhizomatic
- 13:37nature of knowledge systems has
- 13:40profound implications
- 13:41for how we manage and interact with information.
- 13:44It enables efficient information retrieval with search systems
- 13:48optimized to return results at the most appropriate level of granularity for a given query.
- 13:54It encourages adaptive knowledge creation
- 13:57where authors and researchers can structure their work with multiple levels of decomposability
- 14:02in mind,
- 14:03making it more accessible and useful to a wider range of audiences.
- 14:08Furthermore,
- 14:09it facilitates
- 14:10interdisciplinary
- 14:11connections,
- 14:12allowing us to more easily identify links between seemingly disparate fields at various levels of abstraction.
- 14:22Crucially,
- 14:23the way we choose to decompose these systems
- 14:26depends
- 14:27entirely on our specific goals and interests.
- 14:30There is no single, formally correct way to decompose knowledge.
- 14:35Instead,
- 14:36we select the level of analysis that is most meaningful and useful for our current purposes.
- 14:41A student might study a textbook at the chapter level to understand broad themes, while a data scientist might process the same text at the sentence or word level for natural language processing tasks.
- 14:55This flexibility
- 14:57in decomposition
- 14:58allows us to adapt our approach to different contexts and requirements,
- 15:03much like how biologists might study an organism at the cellular level for some purpose and
- 15:08at the organ level for others.
- 15:11It enables modular learning where learners can engage with knowledge at various levels of granularity
- 15:18depending on their needs and expertise.
- 15:20It also facilitates the creation of flexible knowledge representation systems that allow users to zoom in and out between different levels of details,
- 15:30supporting both broad
- 15:32overviews
- 15:33and deep dives.
- 15:35Zooming out from these individual units, we observe how they interconnect to form
- 15:42networks of information.
- 15:44These knowledge networks bear a striking resemblance to mycelial structures in nature,
- 15:49allowing for the dynamic exchange and evolution of ideas.
- 15:53Like mycelia networks in forests,
- 15:57knowledge in the digital age flows through decentralized,
- 16:00highly interconnected pathways.
- 16:02The parallels between mycelial networks in nature and digital knowledge networks are indeed striking.
- 16:09Both exhibit a decentralized
- 16:11interconnected structure where information and resources
- 16:14flow
- 16:15through multiple pathways
- 16:17rather than a centralized
- 16:19hub and spoke model.
- 16:21This architecture ensures robustness and adaptability,
- 16:24allowing both networks to evolve and thrive
- 16:27in dynamic environments.
- 16:30Moreover,
- 16:31the living nature of knowledge demands a shift in our relationship with information.
- 16:36Rather than passive consumers, we must become active participants in the growth and evolution of our collective understanding.
- 16:43This participatory
- 16:45approach to knowledge creation and curation
- 16:48aligns with the decentralized nature of systems like Nostr,
- 16:52where each contributor plays a role in shaping the overall knowledge landscape.
- 16:58Recognizing knowledge as a system of interconnected,
- 17:02semantically closed units that can be decomposed
- 17:05and analyzed at multiple levels,
- 17:08we gain a powerful framework for navigating our information rich world.
- 17:12From the micro scale of individual tweets
- 17:16to the macro scale of entire books or wikis,
- 17:19this perspective reveals the living, adaptive nature of knowledge.
- 17:23The fundamental building blocks of information when viewed through the lens of near decomposability
- 17:29and rhizomatic
- 17:30structure
- 17:31reveal a living system that is at once robust
- 17:35and flexible,
- 17:37capable of adapting to new insights while maintaining
- 17:40its essential coherence.
- 17:45Section two,
- 17:46formal cause,
- 17:48the structure and organization
- 17:50of knowledge.
- 17:52The rhizomatic
- 17:54essence of knowledge.
- 17:56To understand the formal cause of knowledge, we must first grapple with the concept of form itself.
- 18:01In Aristotelian
- 18:03philosophy, the form of a thing is its essential nature,
- 18:07the pattern or structure that makes it what it is.
- 18:10When we apply this concept to knowledge, we encounter trouble. While we often interact with knowledge through structured interfaces like books, databases, or educational curricula,
- 18:21the underlying essence of knowledge itself
- 18:24resists
- 18:24such rigid organization.
- 18:27Instead,
- 18:28knowledge in its purest form exhibits a rhizomatic
- 18:31structure,
- 18:32a concept borrowed from botany and popularized in philosophy by Deleuze
- 18:37and Guattari.
- 18:39In nature, rhizomes are horizontal,
- 18:42underground stems that sprout roots and shoots from their nodes.
- 18:46Examples include potatoes,
- 18:48crabgrass, and turmeric.
- 18:50These plants grow not from a central point, but laterally,
- 18:54forming networks without a clear hierarchy or central organizing principle.
- 18:59A secondary metaphor can be drawn from patches of grass or mycelial networks,
- 19:05systems that seem to fill space without a clear center, but fruits are born from an interconnected mesh.
- 19:12In the case of patches of grass, flowers bloom. And in the case of mycelial networks,
- 19:18mushrooms sprout.
- 19:20In the case of knowledge, these fruits are the objects, the books, the articles, the notes
- 19:26that we interact with and are born from a surrounding context
- 19:31of observations.
- 19:33From the analogies described above, we can draw several key characteristics of rhizomatic structures. One,
- 19:40no single idea serves as the root from which all others stem,
- 19:44non hierarchy.
- 19:46Two,
- 19:47diverse concepts coexist
- 19:49and can blend with one another,
- 19:51multiplicity.
- 19:53Three,
- 19:54ideas can be fragmented and grow from any point.
- 19:58A signifying rupture.
- 20:00Four,
- 20:01knowledge serves as a map of the world.
- 20:04Cartographic
- 20:05nature.
- 20:07Just as a bamboo grove can spread in unexpected directions, ideas from disparate fields can unexpectedly connect, leading to novel insights and innovations.
- 20:15However,
- 20:17our challenge lies in how we navigate
- 20:20and harness this intrinsically
- 20:22rhizomatic structure
- 20:24through more linear or hierarchical interfaces.
- 20:28A tension we'll explore further in this chapter.
- 20:31The rhizome analogy holds strong. What may look like a hierarchical
- 20:35tree like structure is only a snapshot of an ongoing,
- 20:39ever changing exploratory
- 20:41process.
- 20:43Practical
- 20:44interfaces,
- 20:46navigating
- 20:46the knowledge rhizome.
- 20:49While the underlying structure of knowledge may be rhizomatic,
- 20:53a structure without a clear hierarchy,
- 20:55our practical interactions with it often occur through more rigid interfaces.
- 21:01These interfaces serve as partial captures or representations
- 21:06of the rhizomatic whole,
- 21:07allowing us to navigate and access information in manageable ways.
- 21:13Textual representations,
- 21:16the linear pathway.
- 21:18Books and articles have long been our primary means of transmitting and accessing knowledge.
- 21:24They provide a linear pathway through information, guiding readers from beginning to end in a predetermined
- 21:30sequence.
- 21:31This linearity
- 21:32offers several advantages.
- 21:35Coherent
- 21:35narrative.
- 21:37Authors can craft a logical flow of ideas.
- 21:40Structured learning.
- 21:42Readers can progress through information in a controlled manner.
- 21:46Ease of reference.
- 21:48Page numbers and chapters allow for quick location of specific content.
- 21:53However,
- 21:54even within this linear format, elements emerge that hint
- 21:58at nonlinearities.
- 22:00Footnotes and endnotes,
- 22:02these offer tangential information and connections to other sources.
- 22:06Cross references,
- 22:08directing readers to related sections within the text.
- 22:12Indices,
- 22:13providing multiple entry points into the text based on key terms or concepts.
- 22:19Bibliographies,
- 22:20linking the text to a broader network of knowledge.
- 22:24Digital Knowledge Structures,
- 22:27embracing
- 22:27nonlinearity.
- 22:29The digital age has given rise to new forms of knowledge representation
- 22:35that more closely mirror the rhizomatic structure.
- 22:38Wikis and hyperlinked
- 22:40documents,
- 22:41these formats explicitly embrace non linear navigation.
- 22:45Multiple entry points,
- 22:47Users can begin their exploration from various pages or articles.
- 22:51Interconnected content.
- 22:53Hyperlinks create a web of relationships between concepts.
- 22:58Collaborative editing.
- 22:59The knowledge base can grow and evolve organically.
- 23:03Search engines and recommendation systems.
- 23:06These tools create dynamic pathways
- 23:09through information.
- 23:11Personalized
- 23:12exploration.
- 23:13Results are tailored to individual users and contexts.
- 23:17Serendipitous
- 23:18discovery,
- 23:20related content suggestions can lead to unexpected connections.
- 23:24Adaptive learning,
- 23:26Algorithms
- 23:27refine results based on user behavior and feedback.
- 23:32Academic disciplines and curricula.
- 23:34Structured
- 23:35yet connected.
- 23:38Academic fields and educational curricula attempt to organize knowledge into distinct categories.
- 23:45Specialized focus
- 23:46allows for deep exploration
- 23:48of specific topics.
- 23:51Structured learning paths
- 23:53Curricula guides students through foundational
- 23:56to advanced concepts.
- 23:58Methodological
- 23:59Consistency
- 24:00Disciplines develop specialized tools and approaches.
- 24:04However, the boundaries between disciplines
- 24:06are increasingly recognized as permeable.
- 24:10Interdisciplinary
- 24:11concepts.
- 24:12The same ideas or lessons can be taught in a class from a different discipline.
- 24:18Cross disciplinary
- 24:19collaborations
- 24:21lead to innovative insights and methodologies
- 24:24creation of new fields
- 24:27connecting theories
- 24:28and methodology
- 24:29across domains,
- 24:31new fields emerge as a result of combining a consistent set
- 24:35of theoretical principles
- 24:37with another consistent set of methodologies.
- 24:41Libraries and databases,
- 24:43balancing structure, and flexibility.
- 24:47These repositories of knowledge
- 24:49must strike a balance between organization
- 24:52and interconnectedness.
- 24:55Traditional classification
- 24:56systems,
- 24:58Dewey Decimal System and Library of Congress classifications
- 25:01provide hierarchical
- 25:03organization.
- 25:05Subject headings and catalogs
- 25:07offer standardized
- 25:08access points.
- 25:10Digital libraries and modern databases
- 25:14Tagging systems allow for multiple,
- 25:16non hierarchical
- 25:18categorizations.
- 25:20Full text search enables exploration beyond predefined
- 25:24categories.
- 25:25User generated metadata
- 25:27adds diverse perspectives
- 25:29to classification.
- 25:31Recommendation
- 25:32algorithms suggest related resources based on usage patterns.
- 25:37The interfaces
- 25:38through which we engage with knowledge
- 25:41serve crucial roles in making information navigable and accessible.
- 25:45They act as lenses through which specific aspects of the knowledge rhizome can be examined and understood.
- 25:52As understanding of knowledge structures evolves,
- 25:55these interfaces gradually move towards more flexible
- 25:59interconnected systems that better reflect the true nature
- 26:03of human knowledge.
- 26:05Nostr's protocol architecture
- 26:07exemplifies
- 26:08this evolution
- 26:09toward more dynamic
- 26:11knowledge interfaces.
- 26:12Its fundamental structure incorporates multiplicities
- 26:15of functionality,
- 26:17unique
- 26:18identifiers, authorship attribution,
- 26:20tagging systems,
- 26:21labeling capabilities,
- 26:23cross referencing, and nested discussions.
- 26:26These elements,
- 26:28originally conceived for social interaction,
- 26:31serves as building blocks for more complex knowledge structures.
- 26:34Early implementations like Wikifredia
- 26:36and Wikinoster
- 26:38demonstrate
- 26:39how these components
- 26:40can be leveraged to create collaborative
- 26:43knowledge bases
- 26:44that more closely mirror the interconnected nature of ideas.
- 26:49The protocol's distinctive approach to community structure differentiates
- 26:53it from traditional platforms.
- 26:55Rather than enforcing rigid boundaries,
- 26:58Nostra enables a spectrum of closed and open communities that can intersect and interact
- 27:04in novel ways.
- 27:06This architecture reflects the real world dynamics of knowledge creation and sharing
- 27:11where different disciplines and schools of thought exhibit varying degrees of overlap
- 27:16and collaboration.
- 27:19The relay system within Noster provides
- 27:22an instructive model for understanding the organization and dissemination of knowledge,
- 27:27The ability to curate information sources and collaboration
- 27:31channels,
- 27:32particularly through the outbox model enables interactions beyond immediate shared networks
- 27:38analogous to how ideas propagate across traditional
- 27:42disciplinary
- 27:42boundaries.
- 27:44Furthermore,
- 27:46Nostra's protocol level design, rather than platform specific implementation,
- 27:51creates opportunities for experimentation and specialization.
- 27:55The ability of different relays and clients to implement varying specifications
- 28:00enables the emergence
- 28:02of specialized knowledge communities,
- 28:04much as academic disciplines develop distinct methodologies
- 28:08and vocabularies.
- 28:10The interaction of these specialized communities may facilitate the evolution of new interdisciplinary
- 28:16languages
- 28:17and knowledge sharing structures.
- 28:20This examination
- 28:21of formal structure transitions
- 28:23naturally
- 28:24to an analysis of the efficient cause of knowledge,
- 28:28the processes
- 28:29driving its creation and evolution.
- 28:31The protocol's
- 28:32decentralized
- 28:33and flexible architecture
- 28:35enables rapid iteration and adaptation
- 28:39in information organization
- 28:41and dissemination.
- 28:42It creates an environment where the traditional boundaries between knowledge consumers
- 28:47and producers
- 28:49become increasingly
- 28:50permeable,
- 28:51fostering
- 28:53participatory
- 28:53modes of learning and discovery.
- 28:56The following chapter will examine these processes in detail, exploring how the interplay between rhizomatic structures and diverse interfaces drives knowledge creation
- 29:07and transformation.
- 29:09Understanding these mechanisms
- 29:11enables more effective cultivation
- 29:14and collective intelligence,
- 29:16expanding
- 29:17the possibilities for collaborative knowledge generation
- 29:21and curation.
- 29:23Chapter three,
- 29:24efficient cause,
- 29:26the process of knowledge and evolution.
- 29:30Knowledge itself
- 29:31demonstrates properties remarkably similar to biological organisms.
- 29:36Just as living systems engage in metabolism,
- 29:40growth, and adaptation,
- 29:42knowledge undergoes continuous processes
- 29:44of creation, integration, and evolution. This conception of knowledge
- 29:49as a living process provides a framework for understanding
- 29:53how ideas emerge,
- 29:55stabilize,
- 29:56and transform over time,
- 29:58revealing patterns that mirror those found in biological systems.
- 30:03The metabolic process
- 30:05of knowledge creation.
- 30:08The creation and evolution of knowledge can be understood through the metaphor of metabolism,
- 30:14where new information is digested and integrated into existing knowledge structures.
- 30:19This process,
- 30:21like biological metabolism,
- 30:23involves both the breaking down of complex ideas into manageable components and the building up of new understanding.
- 30:31Through this lens, we can better understand how knowledge systems maintain themselves
- 30:36while growing and adapting to new conditions.
- 30:40New knowledge often begins as someone perceives a pattern,
- 30:45anomaly, or possibility
- 30:47that others have not yet recognized.
- 30:49These early ideas tend to be fragile.
- 30:52They may be incomplete,
- 30:54poorly articulated, or challenge existing assumptions.
- 30:58When shared with others, these nascent ideas often face
- 31:02skepticism,
- 31:04dismissal,
- 31:04or active pushback
- 31:06based on others' established understanding and beliefs.
- 31:10This initial resistance
- 31:12is an important part of the knowledge validation process.
- 31:15Some ideas will fail this scrutiny,
- 31:18while others will be refined and strengthened through critical examination
- 31:23and evidence gathering
- 31:24until they become more widely accepted
- 31:27as valid contributions to our collective knowledge.
- 31:31This initial fragility serves an essential function in the knowledge ecosystem.
- 31:36Just as biological systems require variability
- 31:40for evolution,
- 31:41the malleability
- 31:42of new ideas allows for rapid adaptation and refinement before
- 31:47they become firmly established.
- 31:50Through this process, knowledge systems can explore new possibilities
- 31:54while maintaining their essential structure and function.
- 31:57As knowledge matures,
- 31:59it undergoes a process of stabilization
- 32:02and integration
- 32:03just as nutrients are used to build the scaffolding of an organism.
- 32:09This occurs
- 32:10through the interplay of verification,
- 32:12validation, and community
- 32:14adoption.
- 32:16Ideas are tested
- 32:17through peer review and empirical investigation,
- 32:20refined through academic discourse, and gradually integrated into existing theoretical frameworks.
- 32:26This process of stabilization
- 32:29doesn't occur in isolation, but rather through the complex interactions
- 32:33of academic
- 32:34and professional networks,
- 32:36educational systems, and practical
- 32:39applications.
- 32:41The translation problem in knowledge evolution.
- 32:45A fundamental tension exists between knowledge's rhizomatic form and our attempts to capture and transmit it through formal structures.
- 32:54This tension, which we might call a translation problem,
- 32:58lies at the heart of knowledge evolution.
- 33:01Knowledge itself
- 33:02exists
- 33:03as resistant
- 33:04to complete formal representation. It possesses no clear boundaries between concepts,
- 33:10maintains multiple overlapping relationships,
- 33:13and constantly
- 33:15evolves in response to new inputs and contexts.
- 33:19Our need to communicate and preserve knowledge demands that we attempt to capture it in more formal structures.
- 33:26We create discrete units of knowledge,
- 33:29bounded definitions, and hierarchical
- 33:31organizations.
- 33:33This process of formal encapsulation,
- 33:35while necessary for transmission and preservation,
- 33:39inevitably simplifies and constrains the living complexity of knowledge.
- 33:44The relationship between these two forms, the living rhizome and its formal representation,
- 33:49creates what might
- 33:51be called a modeling relation from Robert Rosen,
- 33:56an attempt to capture the complexity of living knowledge in simpler, more manageable forms.
- 34:03The very process of turning ideas contained in our minds to words,
- 34:08spoken or otherwise,
- 34:09is necessarily a transformative
- 34:12process,
- 34:13a process that is not reversible.
- 34:16The transmission of knowledge
- 34:18involves multiple layers of translation
- 34:20and interpretation,
- 34:22each adding complexity to the evolution of ideas.
- 34:26Individual understanding
- 34:27is shaped by personal experience,
- 34:30cultural context, and domain expertise.
- 34:33When knowledge is transmitted,
- 34:35it must be translated
- 34:37from its rhizomatic
- 34:38form
- 34:39into linear communication,
- 34:41then
- 34:42reconstructed
- 34:43by the receiver through their own conceptual framework.
- 34:47This process of translation and reconstruction
- 34:50continually
- 34:51reshapes the knowledge itself
- 34:53contributing
- 34:54to its evolution.
- 34:57Dynamics of Knowledge Change
- 35:01The evolution of knowledge follows patterns that mirror those found in biological systems,
- 35:07exhibiting both gradual change and sudden transitions.
- 35:10Most commonly,
- 35:12knowledge evolves through gradual accumulation,
- 35:15the slow refinement of existing theories,
- 35:17the addition of supporting evidence, and the progressive specialization
- 35:22of fields.
- 35:23This process resembles the gradual adaptation of organisms
- 35:27through natural selection.
- 35:30However,
- 35:31knowledge systems also experience periods of rapid change analogous to punctuated equilibrium
- 35:37in biological evolution.
- 35:39These episodes
- 35:40often coincide with paradigm shifts,
- 35:43revolutionary
- 35:44discoveries, or technological breakthroughs
- 35:47that fundamentally
- 35:48alter how we understand
- 35:50and interact with knowledge.
- 35:52The emergence of new fields or disciplines
- 35:55often occurs during these periods of rapid change as existing knowledge structures reorganize
- 36:02themselves around new insights
- 36:04or methodologies.
- 36:06The evolution of knowledge is shaped by fundamental tensions between stability and innovation,
- 36:11between the need for reliable, verified knowledge and the importance of novel insights and perspectives.
- 36:18Similarly,
- 36:19knowledge systems must balance the benefits of deep specialization
- 36:23with the need for cross disciplinary
- 36:25integration and synthesis.
- 36:28These tensions create dynamic patterns of change
- 36:31that contribute to the overall resilience and adaptability
- 36:35of knowledge ecosystems.
- 36:38Further Directions
- 36:40and Duplications
- 36:42As we improve our understandings
- 36:44of knowledge and how we interact with it, we will need to develop tools and systems that can better support the natural dynamics of knowledge evolution.
- 36:53Tools that can capture patterns,
- 36:55track the development of ideas, and facilitate
- 36:58processes
- 36:59of knowledge creation that is capable of maintaining
- 37:02semantic meaning
- 37:04aligned and approximated
- 37:06to the representation contained within the author's mind.
- 37:10More fundamentally,
- 37:11we need to re conceptualize
- 37:13our relationship with knowledge itself.
- 37:16This means creating environments that support both the stability needed for reliable knowledge
- 37:22and the flexibility
- 37:23required for innovation and adaptation.
- 37:28Chapter four,
- 37:30final cause,
- 37:31the purpose of knowledge and knowledge ecosystems.
- 37:37Knowledge
- 37:38serves as our guiding star,
- 37:40illuminating the path forward and enabling us to navigate the complexities of our world.
- 37:46At its core,
- 37:47knowledge fulfills a fundamental purpose. It acts as a catalyst for adaptive behavior,
- 37:53drawing organisms, including humans, towards information
- 37:56that is meaningful and beneficial for their survival and thriving.
- 38:01However,
- 38:02the abstract nature of knowledge presents a significant challenge.
- 38:06We cannot directly manipulate or interact with knowledge in its pure, conceptual
- 38:12form.
- 38:13Instead,
- 38:14we engage with knowledge that has been captured and formalized in language or other representational
- 38:20systems.
- 38:21This limitation
- 38:22necessitates
- 38:23the development
- 38:24of interfaces and methods for knowledge interaction,
- 38:27leading to the creation of knowledge bases
- 38:30and other knowledge management systems.
- 38:34The purpose
- 38:35of knowledge bases then extends beyond mere storage and retrieval of information.
- 38:39They serve as bridges between the abstract subjective knowledge and the concrete decision making.
- 38:46Effective knowledge bases facilitate the efficient transmission of knowledge, enabling users to navigate
- 38:52the information landscape,
- 38:54synthesize
- 38:54ideas to generate new insights,
- 38:57update and refine existing knowledge, and collaborate in the collective development of understanding.
- 39:04To fulfill its purpose,
- 39:05a knowledge base must strive to mirror the inherent structure of knowledge itself.
- 39:10This is where the concept
- 39:13of rhizomatic
- 39:14knowledge structures becomes crucial.
- 39:17Knowledge, in its natural state, resembles a rhizome,
- 39:20a non hierarchical,
- 39:22multiply connected network of ideas and concepts.
- 39:26Unlike the rigid tree like structures often imposed on information,
- 39:30rhizomatic
- 39:31structures
- 39:32allow for dynamic growth,
- 39:34multiple entry points, and unexpected connections between disparate elements.
- 39:40The most effective knowledge bases, therefore,
- 39:43are those that conform to this rhizomatic
- 39:45structure.
- 39:46They should offer
- 39:47non hierarchical
- 39:49organization that allows for multiple pathways through information,
- 39:53dynamic linking capabilities that reveal
- 39:56unexpected
- 39:57connections between ideas,
- 40:00flexibility
- 40:01to accommodate
- 40:02new information without disrupting existing structures,
- 40:06and support for collaborative knowledge creation
- 40:09and curation.
- 40:11Interestingly,
- 40:13the affordances
- 40:14provided by Nostr
- 40:16align remarkably
- 40:17well with these requirements for rhizome like knowledge bases.
- 40:21Nostra's
- 40:22decentralized
- 40:23open protocol offers several features that make it highly amenable
- 40:27to creating rhizomatic
- 40:28knowledge structures.
- 40:30Decentralized
- 40:31nature,
- 40:33mirroring the distributed nature of knowledge itself, Nostra's decentralized structure allows for multiple entry points and perspectives.
- 40:41Once a structure has been defined,
- 40:43anyone can take the existing structure,
- 40:46modify it, and build their own garden of knowledge
- 40:49with their own rules for contribution.
- 40:52The decentralized and permissionless
- 40:54nature
- 40:55of Nostr
- 40:56allows for anyone to continue the conversation,
- 40:59build upon, and modify the existing structure while still maintaining the integrity
- 41:04of the original content
- 41:06and being interoperable
- 41:07with other knowledge bases.
- 41:10The two data specifications
- 41:12for a Nostr knowledge base,
- 41:14Nostr knowledge base implementation
- 41:17possibilities,
- 41:18n k b I p o one
- 41:21and n k b I p o two.
- 41:24Provide a foundation for creating structured knowledge bases that, when coupled with the decentralized nature of Nostr,
- 41:32can enable the creation of knowledge that aligns
- 41:35with the intrinsic
- 41:37rhizomatic structure of knowledge.
- 41:40N k b I p o one
- 41:42enables for the creation of knowledge as a rhizomatic
- 41:45structure.
- 41:47Taking influence from zettelkasten,
- 41:49a popular note taking method, users can link ideas in a variety of ways, of which a linear assembly is one such possibility.
- 41:59Paired with other affordances such as tags,
- 42:02labels, external ID, forking of notes,
- 42:05knowledge can be navigated in a nonlinear way that where every note
- 42:11can be a starting point for new explorations.
- 42:15N k b I p zero two
- 42:18defines
- 42:19a specification
- 42:20for AI
- 42:21embeddings,
- 42:23which can be used for context free navigation.
- 42:26The creation of numerical representations
- 42:29of text allow for distance
- 42:31calculations
- 42:32between the semantic relationships of notes.
- 42:36What this means is that even if the authors have not explicitly
- 42:40linked ideas together,
- 42:42embedding distances
- 42:44allow for a formal process of grouping
- 42:47disconnected ideas.
- 42:49What this implies
- 42:50is that a user who is interested in learning about a topic can be recommended notes that are semantically
- 42:57similar
- 42:58even if they are not directly linked.
- 43:01Additionally,
- 43:02just like GitHub Copilot,
- 43:04the AI system can take the context
- 43:07of already existing text and notes and synthesize
- 43:12new knowledge.
- 43:13It is important to note that these tools must be used in conjunction with human curation
- 43:18as the AI system must be guided
- 43:21in such a way that is meaningful to the writer and potential readers.
- 43:26By leveraging these affordances,
- 43:28we can create knowledge bases that not only store information but actively support the expansion
- 43:35of human understanding
- 43:36and capability.
- 43:38Such systems would go beyond traditional static repositories
- 43:41to become dynamic environments of exploration,
- 43:44discovery,
- 43:45and the generation of new insights.
- 43:48Continuing to develop and refine knowledge bases,
- 43:52our goal should be to create interfaces that emulate the dynamic,
- 43:57adaptive nature of knowledge itself.
- 44:00These systems
- 44:01should support prediction,
- 44:03enable action, and facilitate
- 44:06learning in ways that mirror our cognitive processes.
- 44:10They should be accessible,
- 44:12comprehensible,
- 44:13interconnected,
- 44:14and adaptable allowing users to navigate
- 44:18written knowledge with unprecedented
- 44:20ease and insight regardless of background.
- 44:24In conclusion,
- 44:26the purpose of knowledge is to guide
- 44:28adaptive behavior
- 44:30and enable effective interaction with our environment.
- 44:34This is fundamentally
- 44:35intertwined
- 44:36with the purpose of knowledge bases.
- 44:39Through the strive to create knowledge bases that mirror the rhizomatic structure of knowledge itself, we can develop tools
- 44:46that not only store and organize information,
- 44:50but actively support the growth and evolution of human understanding.
- 44:55Nostr and its rhizome friendly affordances
- 44:59offer exciting possibilities for realizing this vision,
- 45:02potentially revolutionizing
- 45:04how we interact with
- 45:07and build upon
- 45:08our collective knowledge.
- 45:12So that was Liminal's
- 45:14article
- 45:15titled Understanding Knowledge and whoop de doo, man.
- 45:19Yeah. And I know it was it's a lot to take in. You know? We don't normally on this show talk about,
- 45:26you know, subjects as deep as what knowledge itself
- 45:30actually is and what
- 45:32structure it takes and the fact that you kinda can't
- 45:36directly interact with knowledge until after it's been
- 45:40represented
- 45:41in some symbolic form like letters or, you know, having a discussion with your buddy or listening to a podcast.
- 45:48Those are all symbolically
- 45:51or symbologic
- 45:53instantiations
- 45:55of particular
- 45:56points of knowledge that particular people have.
- 46:00So why am I even bringing this to you today? Well, it's because I'm a big Nostra user, and this was essentially
- 46:07all about how Liminal was telling you
- 46:10that the very
- 46:12structure
- 46:13of Nostr, the way it exists right now,
- 46:16without
- 46:17with with almost no iterate you know, with no not even having to iterate on its structure at all
- 46:24is already able to be a receptacle
- 46:27of this ability to store,
- 46:30categorize,
- 46:32mix and match different pieces of knowledge from
- 46:36different authors. Some may be collaborating together.
- 46:39Other authors may actually be on to the same you know, be looking at the same idea,
- 46:45but they don't even know each other. They don't know that they're looking at at the same idea.
- 46:51And then we get into where Liminal brings up
- 46:54the notion of bringing in artificial intelligence.
- 46:58What he's really talking about, and me and him have talked about this on the show before,
- 47:04and that was, in fact, episode nine thirty seven of Bitcoin and
- 47:09I'll if I remember, I'll try to put the link directly to that episode in the show notes.
- 47:14The ability for AI to start looking at different notes.
- 47:19And sure, I know what you're saying.
- 47:21Nobody wants nobody really is gonna care about the shit posting.
- 47:26There are other notes that are out there.
- 47:29Right? And and and we're also,
- 47:31you know, not we're we're also not thinking of the capability of saying, well, me making a shitpost probably is so semantically
- 47:39divergent
- 47:41from the idea of, I don't know, solar processes
- 47:44that maybe some other Nostra user decided to write a small essay on. How does Stellar Dynamics work? Right? My ship posting is gonna be so distant away from that that the that if we do crawl this entire network of knowledge with an AI, it's probably just gonna throw it out. It's gonna throw out memes. It's gonna it's just gonna be going through. It's like like, think of it like some kid looking for something that they lost in a big old trunk upstairs in the attic, and they're just chucking crap out of the you looking for what
- 48:11chucking
- 48:12crap out of the
- 48:14looking for what it is that they
- 48:16want. I mean, that's what that's sort of where Liminal's getting. And I'm I know that I'm not touching as deep down as what what Liminal is thinking in his mind, but that
- 48:26is
- 48:27exactly the essence of what he's talking about. I'm not Liminal.
- 48:31I do not see
- 48:33exactly how he's thinking about using AI to connect
- 48:37possibly different threads
- 48:39or context,
- 48:41the semanticism
- 48:43of notes.
- 48:45I I'm not in his mind. I cannot touch his knowledge. The only thing that I can touch is what he wrote here and what he's writing about AI. So I have to interpolate.
- 48:56I have to, like, expand what I think he's talking about, which causes me to do what?
- 49:03Make a whole bunch of assumptions.
- 49:06And in many cases, you kinda have to. And that way, when Liminal hopefully, he'll listen to this because he I haven't told him that I'm gonna be reading this on the show today, so I I will let him know that I've done so. But Liminal, if you're listening to this,
- 49:20I kinda get what you're talking about here.
- 49:23You have to symbolically reflect what it is you're thinking
- 49:27in the form of the written word, and I've got to ingest that. And then I make assumptions about it, which can make an ass out of you and me. But when you hear this and you say, that's not at all what I was thinking. Let me explain it further to you. Or maybe I did get part of it, but I know I'm not getting all of it. I'm not in your head.
- 49:46But I do I think that I feel
- 49:49at a fundamental level what you're talking about when it comes to knowledge.
- 49:53What's in my head
- 49:55about
- 49:56things like like the Forest Walker idea that I have?
- 50:00Man, I like I like, Guy Swan read it on his podcast, and he picked apart a couple of good problems.
- 50:07But he didn't even he didn't even touch the surface
- 50:11of just how many problems there is with that system.
- 50:16But I had to actually formalize it into words.
- 50:20And once I formalize it into words and I heard Guy Swan read it back to me, I was like,
- 50:26I now I've gotta go through it. I gotta go do that one, and I've got to address this. And, oh, by the way, he didn't think about what happens in the wintertime,
- 50:33is what happens if the wood is too wet because that can that can actually be a thing. You know, there's all manner of issues about the Forest Walker, but it's all in my head.
- 50:43And if I don't formalize it in a symbol logical way, like writing it out in in symbols
- 50:49in the form of letters of the alphabet,
- 50:52right, then there's no hope of having any of that knowledge restructured
- 50:57by somebody else. Or the fact of me writing it down
- 51:02does something
- 51:03magical to what's in my head. It causes it to exist outside of me.
- 51:10If I die tomorrow, the Forest Walker article is out there. At least one other person has heard that article because Guy Swan read it on his podcast.
- 51:19You guys have heard me talk about it before. But the idea is out there. It's it's a baby. It's walking around.
- 51:27But when we take it back to Noster,
- 51:30that article,
- 51:31I can get to that article on Noster, and I can't remember which NIP it uses, but it was I I published it
- 51:40I published Forest Walker in a couple places, and one of them I did on highlighter,
- 51:46Pablo f seven z. Right?
- 51:48Now
- 51:49that nip is a long form nip. It's like if if your relay isn't reading, like,
- 51:55kind one is only reading kind one notes, then you're not seeing that article because it is not a kind one note.
- 52:03But that note is out there, and it is available by somebody who's reading that particular kind of NIP
- 52:10on their relay.
- 52:12Right? So it exists,
- 52:13and I can die tomorrow, and it will still exist.
- 52:17I pulled something out of my head.
- 52:19Now other people can attach to it. And like like what Liminal's saying, what if we have a AI crawl it?
- 52:27The Noster network.
- 52:28Just start crawling
- 52:30and say, okay.
- 52:32Given what you've said here in this Forest War Walker article, you know, there was a guy over here that wrote this other article about biochar,
- 52:39and y'all both use the word biochar.
- 52:41Maybe that is semantically
- 52:43close enough
- 52:45that I should start looking deeper. And I when I say I, I mean, I as an AI that's crawling the system. Maybe I should look deeper and see if there's any other connections.
- 52:54And maybe the guy uses the word forest.
- 52:57And maybe the guy, you know, ends up using the words,
- 53:02oh, God,
- 53:03wood vinegar.
- 53:04Maybe the guy uses
- 53:06something like data collection.
- 53:09Well, shit. At that point,
- 53:11we start getting very, very semantically close. Even though I have no idea what this theoretical article said, I don't know the author that wrote it.
- 53:20The fact that we are becoming very, very, you know, very much closer because we're using a lot of the same words,
- 53:26then maybe we get a semantic distance,
- 53:29a value that's assigned to those two notes
- 53:32as a connect as a bridging connection
- 53:35that says,
- 53:36I don't know, something like a short distance, which means these are very similar and some other author may pick that up and say,
- 53:44you know, scan the Nostra network and look for all semantic differences with a distance of no more than, I don't know, x.
- 53:51Right? And then a filter is enacted, and then every they can see all these things and say, okay. Well, here's all these connected notes. Let's go through them and see what I can dig up. Let's go gardening.
- 54:04Let's go harvesting.
- 54:06Maybe they start looking at these notes in an interconnected ways and then start looking at it from a completely different lens and comes up with something of their own,
- 54:16either completely
- 54:17novel
- 54:18or
- 54:20helping me and this other author get our shit together because we were wrong about whatever.
- 54:26Right? This is what Liminal's talking about.
- 54:29And I saw this a long time ago. I saw this he calls it affordances.
- 54:34And he's that's a great word to use.
- 54:37Nostra affords the ability for us to look
- 54:40at notes and their interconnectedness
- 54:44in this very,
- 54:45not only fundamental way,
- 54:48but a highly
- 54:49utilitarian
- 54:51way. And I don't mean utilitarianism
- 54:53in the old
- 54:54you know, if somebody's thinking, oh, yours sounds like Soviet Russia. No. No. No. I'm actually talking about utility,
- 55:01something I can use, something that brings,
- 55:03you know, a better, you know, a better way of thinking for me or
- 55:08something. Like, teaches me, like, four notes that if I take them all together, teaches me exactly how to go garden, I don't know, golden beets.
- 55:17That you know, maybe I like golden beets. Maybe I've never been able to grow golden beets. But some somehow or another, by asking AI to filter out all the Nostra network except everything
- 55:27that is about beets and and and gardening beets and and make sure that semantic differences are no more than this x amount of distance away so that I can collect up very close notes. Maybe it teaches me how to grow golden beets, and I start growing them and it's completely successful.
- 55:45It actually, from that standpoint, changes my life.
- 55:49I mean, in this particular example, it's kinda dumb because it's just golden beets. Shit. You can go get that at the store, but you get my point. We're playing with Nostra like it's a toy right now. It's not a toy. It's Nostra is so far from being a toy, it's not even funny. And this is why I get really, really miffed
- 56:10when people shit all over Nostra because they're like, it's not as good as Twitter.
- 56:14Twitter has no freaking hope
- 56:18to scale
- 56:20knowledge
- 56:21at all.
- 56:23It'll scale Grok's knowledge,
- 56:25and that knowledge will make a shit ton of money for the people over at at x or whatever,
- 56:31but it's not going to expand human knowledge.
- 56:34It doesn't have the capacity, and neither does Facebook, and neither does Instagram, and neither does TikTok.
- 56:40None of these things.
- 56:42Because they are all so centralized.
- 56:45The only other thing that I could think of is possibly
- 56:48the Feddy verse, but that is so filled with trite bullshit that it's not even funny. And it's a real pain in the ass to jump from
- 56:58one of their
- 56:59servers to another. And and from that standpoint,
- 57:02it's not a walled garden. It's like a million walled gardens all contained in a something that they would call an open garden, but it's not really all that easy. Nostr is the only thing that has, as Liminal says,
- 57:16the affordances
- 57:18to be able to mimic a structure
- 57:22that would provide us a pathway to discover new knowledge.
- 57:27Yeah. It's okay. Post memes. I think memes are hilarious.
- 57:31I think it's funny when people shitpost.
- 57:34It doesn't mean that I don't find value in it. I actually do.
- 57:38There's nothing better than having somebody make you laugh when you've had a shitty day.
- 57:43That's of real value.
- 57:45Maybe there's some semanticism
- 57:47that can be discovered there by somebody who wants to be a stand up comic.
- 57:52Hey. Go show me all the shitposts.
- 57:54How are how are all these shitposts connected? How's Korn DeLorean shitpost,
- 57:59you know, semantically
- 58:00close to this this other author's shitposting?
- 58:04That's not without value.
- 58:08This all exists
- 58:10inside this structure
- 58:12that Fiat Joff gave us.
- 58:15And even fiat Joff sometimes, I think, doesn't like Noster.
- 58:18But who knows what fiat Joff is actually kinda crazy. It's okay. I love that I he it's it's like
- 58:25Shia Labeouf. They're both batshit crazy, and I don't care. I love them both. I don't care what anybody thinks about me liking Shia Shia Labouf because he's, like, just hated Trump. I don't care. I don't care. I don't care.
- 58:39Fiat Joffe has said on several occasions some bad shit about his own creation, and people got got mad at him. I don't
- 58:46care. He's batshit crazy, and I love him to death for it.
- 58:50Only a batshit crazy person could come up with something like Nostr.
- 58:55Only liminal
- 58:56could come up with something that I just revved you.
- 59:01So with that said, I really, really am desperate for people to stop looking at Nostril like it's simply a social media platform.
- 59:10It's not.
- 59:11It is probably going to become one of the most extensive knowledge bases that humankind has ever come to know, and Fiat Joff can't even stop it.
- 59:21Oh, nobody's gonna use it. Yeah. We're I use it every day.
- 59:25I know hundreds of people that use Nostra
- 59:28every day.
- 59:31And every single day, more and more knowledge gets poured into this thing.
- 59:36And people
- 59:37like
- 59:38Liminal
- 59:39and Lissarian, if I'm pronouncing her name right. She's one of the other developers on this project Alexandria.
- 59:45If they could just get some freaking grant funding
- 59:50and I really mean that. They've been rejected by a couple of different places,
- 59:54and I don't understand why. It is one of the most
- 59:58pivotal
- 1:00:00things in the human spirit
- 1:00:03to create
- 1:00:04knowledge,
- 1:00:06to organize
- 1:00:07knowledge.
- 1:00:08Remember all the way even if you're a Christian or not, remember all the way back to the story of Adam and Eve.
- 1:00:15What was Adam's job?
- 1:00:18Adam had a couple of jobs. Basically, he had one real huge job.
- 1:00:24Him and Eve were supposed to name all of the creatures and plants and animals and trees and blades of grass. He was supposed to give everything in the Garden of Eden
- 1:00:33Eden a name.
- 1:00:35Honey, that's categorization
- 1:00:37of knowledge.
- 1:00:39That that's that is that is turning
- 1:00:41a thing that is amorphous into a static structure.
- 1:00:46By giving
- 1:00:47a tree a name, like it's a tree,
- 1:00:51I've turned this thing that I would have to normally describe
- 1:00:56by sight to somebody who is blind,
- 1:00:59instead of doing it that way, I could just say, ah, we both agree, we both look at this thing, and we both say, that's going to now be a tree.
- 1:01:08Now when I go and tell somebody that I saw a tree,
- 1:01:12the idea forms in their mind through that one symbol.
- 1:01:18Nostra's way more important than people think it is, and it's kind of embarrassing that we're missing it. It's right here, right in front of us.
- 1:01:27It's going to be
- 1:01:29everything that Wikipedia
- 1:01:31thought it was going to be and could never be.
- 1:01:35It's going to be everything that Twitter thought it could be and is never going to be because it never could be. It never
- 1:01:43had the structure for it.
- 1:01:45Only Nostr
- 1:01:47has the structure
- 1:01:50to usher in what comes next. And you'll go, I I know. You'll say, David, I think you've just
- 1:01:56damn near lost your mind on this one. No. No. I really haven't.
- 1:02:01We've been forced into thinking that
- 1:02:05McDonald's
- 1:02:06and Taco Bell is real food.
- 1:02:09It's not. It's bullshit. It's crap. It's garbage. It's poison.
- 1:02:14But if I go to a party and I say that, people are gonna look at me funny,
- 1:02:18aren't they? But I guarantee the people listening to my voice, most of you are nodding your head going, yes. It's poison.
- 1:02:25We've all we we're we're breaking out of this knowledge structure that we've been given
- 1:02:31through media
- 1:02:33since we were children.
- 1:02:36Probably even before we were children, we were probably hearing the bullshit from the news in our mother's wombs.
- 1:02:43We were probably already
- 1:02:45well on our way to being programmed to be in good little dogs and cats so that we could function in society and not cause problems.
- 1:02:54You know, like that Gutenberg dude that
- 1:02:56invented the printing press
- 1:02:59and started printing
- 1:03:00of all things. The first thing that he printed was Bibles.
- 1:03:04He didn't he didn't print
- 1:03:06Odyssey and Iliad. He didn't print the tomes of Plato and Socrates and all that shit. No. He's like the Bible.
- 1:03:14The most
- 1:03:15disruptive thing that you could have done at the time that Gutenberg was doing his shit was to print the freaking Bible. Why? Because it was always,
- 1:03:25always
- 1:03:26only ever held
- 1:03:28by the people
- 1:03:31who owned the church.
- 1:03:34And if you wanted to know what God was actually saying in the book, you couldn't have one yourself,
- 1:03:39you had to go to church, which meant that knowledge
- 1:03:44was gatekept.
- 1:03:45And it always has been. It's never changed until people like Gutenberg come along.
- 1:03:51And I always used to think that the World Wide Web was gonna be the printing press two point o, and I was so wrong
- 1:03:58because everything was gated, and it's become more so.
- 1:04:03And now we have Nostr, and yet we treat it like social media.
- 1:04:07Nobody sees
- 1:04:09any potential at all, apparently.
- 1:04:11All I hear about is people bitching that, you know, direct messages don't work. So what?
- 1:04:18The other shit works.
- 1:04:20Well, nobody's gonna read these these long ass notes. I do.
- 1:04:24I read this one. This one is in the form of a note on Nostra through project Alexandria.
- 1:04:33If you have not gone
- 1:04:36and looked at what
- 1:04:38Liminal
- 1:04:39and LeSaren and a couple of other people are doing,
- 1:04:43you're really missing out on what the potential of all this actually is.
- 1:04:48Because like I said, right now,
- 1:04:50we're just like little kids playing with a a toy Ferrari on the floor.
- 1:04:56But what we're really playing with is a real Ferrari.
- 1:05:00We just haven't turned the key in the ignition yet.
- 1:05:03In fact, we can't even climb into the driver's seat yet because the door's closed and we're too small to reach the handle.
- 1:05:11But once that son of a bitch handle gets reached for
- 1:05:15and we open the door, and we sit our happy asses down, and we plug that freaking key into the ignition and fire that son of a bitch up, watch out.
- 1:05:27A 80
- 1:05:28miles an hour plus.
- 1:05:32Okay.
- 1:05:34Y'all,
- 1:05:35reach out to Liminal,
- 1:05:36Lycerin. I'm gonna put both of their, their Noster in pubs
- 1:05:41into the show notes. Let them know what you thought, if you have any ideas about what they're doing.
- 1:05:47And honestly,
- 1:05:49if you don't wanna do any of that,
- 1:05:51reach out to,
- 1:05:54OpenSats
- 1:05:56and ask them to fund
- 1:05:58Project Alexandria.
- 1:06:00I love Matt O'Dell. I really do.
- 1:06:04But they're one of the people that have denied a grant to Project Alexandria.
- 1:06:08And I for the life of me, I'm going to I'm not even gonna make any assumptions about the grant proposal and what its format was versus how Gigi and all the guys over at OpenSats read it. I'm not gonna make any assumptions at all as to why
- 1:06:23that the this granting opportunity
- 1:06:25has not come to Project Alexandria.
- 1:06:28But I get the feeling that if done right,
- 1:06:31politely,
- 1:06:32respectfully,
- 1:06:33with kind words,
- 1:06:35and
- 1:06:36an appreciation for the project that maybe,
- 1:06:39just maybe, if they're Gigi,
- 1:06:41Matt,
- 1:06:43some of the other guys at at OpenSats,
- 1:06:45hears it enough
- 1:06:47in a again, in a positive light, not, hey. Screw you. David said you did you you didn't give no money. No. Don't do that shit. Just tell him what if you agree with me and you think that Noster is as important as it is
- 1:07:01and that Project Alexandria,
- 1:07:03which is part of what Liminal's discussing here in this piece,
- 1:07:08if you think it has the potential to unlock it and to crack an egg the likes of which we have never seen before,
- 1:07:16to get a hold of those guys and say, take a look at their grant proposal one more time, please.
- 1:07:21Please.
- 1:07:23You do that,
- 1:07:24and I will see you on the other side.
- 1:07:26This has been Bitcoin, and
- 1:07:29and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 1:07:35Have a great day.