Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 8)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:05where we left off with Alex LaCosta and his interview
- 0:09with the OIG inspectors. Question, Okay, the proposed indictment included
- 0:15one conspiracy, a conspiracy that has a five year statutory maximum,
- 0:20and this notion is that Epstein be charged with a
- 0:22five year conspiracy count and take it from there. Do
- 0:26you know what he was referring to when he noted
- 0:28that a court could give you a hard time in
- 0:30dismissing indicted counts in the case answer, So, as a
- 0:34typical matter, once there's an indictment, the pre indictment, well,
- 0:38by definition, a pre indictment resolution comes off the table.
- 0:42But in cases of this nature, the resolutions tend to
- 0:45happen before indictment because once the indictment is done, at
- 0:49least in South Florida, dismissal of charges, for example, you know,
- 0:53if saying, let's think about a three seventy one with
- 0:56a five year cap at rule eleven, that's something that
- 0:59South Florida judge they tend not to, you know, dismissing
- 1:02a number of accounts and then doing a rule eleven
- 1:05is not something that judges tend to do. Question all right,
- 1:08Two pieces to that. One is the issue of dismissing
- 1:12substantiative accounts substantative counts. Was that a particular concern in
- 1:17the case because of the nature of the conduct represented
- 1:20in the substantative accounts? Answer? So your question you asked
- 1:24a general question and then you're moving to a specific
- 1:29but as a general matter, not just in this case,
- 1:31but in other cases. It was rare that the office
- 1:34after in cases like this, after a full charge was done,
- 1:38that the substantative counts were dismissed. So, for example, in
- 1:41the public corruption cases that I referenced earlier at upon Beach,
- 1:45those were all negotiated pre indictment and agreed to, and
- 1:49then by the time the case was indicted, it was
- 1:52all sort of set on autopilot questions. So typically, in
- 1:56my experience, a disposition like that results in a criminal information,
- 2:01not an indictment. Question. Are you saying that you would
- 2:04go ahead and indict then answer? No. What I'm saying
- 2:08is that there were it was all negotiated in advance,
- 2:11and then there was information and the information would go forward,
- 2:15not an indictment. Question All right, answer, And so that
- 2:19is how a member of a high profile case typically
- 2:21proceeded as opposed to indict and dismiss. Question And that's
- 2:26the experience of the Southern District of Florida in general. Answer.
- 2:30It was in particularly in the Palm Beach office, with
- 2:33other high profile cases that were there at the time.
- 2:37Question do you recall in any case in which a
- 2:39judge in an indicted case refused to dismisscounts when the
- 2:42government in an indictment under those circumstances. Answer? I don't
- 2:47recall specific cases, but I can say that typically in
- 2:50the higher profile cases, you'd negotiated with opposing council presenting information,
- 2:56the information would have agreed to an agreed guideline, and
- 3:00it would proceed in that way. Question understood. But in
- 3:03this case, I'm focusing on the assertion by redacted that
- 3:07the court could give us a hard time, and that's
- 3:09a little different from you know, exercising discretion to negotiate
- 3:13and proceed by information. So is there any judge that
- 3:17was particularly concerning with regard to an unwillingness to dismiss? Answer? So, first,
- 3:24this is twelve years ago, and I don't recall any
- 3:26specific judge, but I can sort of say that was
- 3:29not the practice of the office. The practice of the
- 3:32office was to proceed by information rather than indictment with
- 3:36dismissal because there is more, you can lay out more
- 3:41what you negotiated. I think later there's a letter from
- 3:44redacted that sort of presents the same perspective. Question you said,
- 3:49in a case of this nature, the resolution happens before indicting.
- 3:53What is a case of this nature? Answer higher profile,
- 3:57higher profile cases. Questions not necessarily a sex offense case?
- 4:02Answer not necessarily sex offenses. No, no higher profile cases.
- 4:07This was just a So I would say it's a
- 4:10combination of all of the above. And to my mind,
- 4:13one of the parts of this case is the legal
- 4:15theories were, if not novel, there were novel within the
- 4:18Southern District of Florida, at least some of the legal theories.
- 4:22And well, we'll probably get into that question. Did his
- 4:26wealth make it a high profile case? Answer? Well, it
- 4:29was clearly in the paper, and so that made it
- 4:31a high profile case. I don't think. I don't think
- 4:34it was his wealth. I think it was all of
- 4:36the above. This was a matter that the state attorney
- 4:39had been ready to charge that the federal government is
- 4:42now jumping into and saying by its presence that the
- 4:45state did not do enough. That in and of itself
- 4:50makes it a very high profile case. I can't remember
- 4:53any other instance, certainly during my time, when we jumped
- 4:56in and said, you know, the state dropped charges, and
- 4:58so we're going to do more. Question as opposed to,
- 5:03or as distinguished from, when you described a few moments
- 5:05ago a situation in which the federal authorities and the
- 5:08state authorities kind of work together to sort out what
- 5:11would be charged where, and do it cooperatively? Answer? And
- 5:17that was more cooperative. I would you know, I do
- 5:20recollect that, and I think the record bears this out
- 5:23that this was not a particularly cooperative relationship between us
- 5:26and the state attorney. If I could, if I could
- 5:29return I think your question the way you posed your question,
- 5:32you set a recommendation from redacted and let me let
- 5:36me push back a little bit on that, saying what
- 5:38are your thoughts? Have you read it? What are your thoughts?
- 5:41And he says, yes, we can talk next week. My
- 5:44current thoughts are it's very different. Then we've sat down,
- 5:47we've discussed this. This is my now informed position. Question understood,
- 5:53And I should have been clearer. I was referring to
- 5:56his recommendation that if you were going to proceed, you
- 5:58should start with a complain. Just to be clear. Answer
- 6:03and I'm just saying initial thoughts gets cut off. Question
- 6:07all right? So were you aware that redacted bootleg the
- 6:10copy of the pro's memo to redact it? At CEO's
- 6:13answer I was not. Question he did at the time?
- 6:16Answer okay. Question and did you know redacted? Answer a
- 6:20little bit. I certainly knew of them. Had you encounter
- 6:24him when he was chief of the Child Exploitation and
- 6:27Obscenity Section? Answer right? Question in the criminal division here? Correct?
- 6:33Had you encountered them while you were in this building?
- 6:35Also answer most likely? I knew of him enough that
- 6:39I correspond and shose and I recall asking to involve
- 6:42him pretty early on question. So it does read as
- 6:46if you were acquainted with him. Answer yeah, Question all right?
- 6:50And did you have any did his opinion his views
- 6:52as chief of CEOs and as redacted who had been
- 6:56in AUSA in Miami, did his views influence on your
- 7:01thinking about the case? Answer? I don't think at this
- 7:04time I was aware that redacted had been consulted. Answer,
- 7:07all right, and in July, just so you know, and
- 7:11I have this as not something you saw, he provided
- 7:14a fairly strong statement by emailt or redacted and redacted,
- 7:17which he advises that he reviewed the prosecution memo closely.
- 7:22It's terrific, He says. Redacted did a terrific job. And
- 7:26he says we agree with her legal analysis. Her charging
- 7:29decisions are legally sound. And then redacted goes through the
- 7:32different statutes and concludes that they are all properly charged
- 7:36and that although there are some issues legally, that in
- 7:39his view, we should prevail, our position should prevail, and
- 7:44that he also reviewed the arguments contained in the letters
- 7:47from defense counsel and he found none of their arguments persuasive. So,
- 7:51at least as of July eighteenth, your three levels of
- 7:54supervisors down were unnoticed that CEOs was on board and
- 7:58wanted to see the case move on. But is it,
- 8:02am I correct an understanding that at the time you
- 8:04were unaware of that answer? I do not recall being
- 8:08aware of that question. All right, Okay, if you had
- 8:12been aware of it, if they had sent this, I
- 8:14don't want to overstate it, but it's pretty strong endorsement
- 8:17for the proposed prosecution. Would you have been influenced by that? Answer? Sure,
- 8:22I would have. I mean I respected or redacted and
- 8:25clearly wanted him to be part of the team and
- 8:27later invited him down and so on. So yes. Question okay,
- 8:31all right. Do you know why they wouldn't have shared
- 8:33your people wouldn't have shared this with you? Answer? I
- 8:36don't know. Question all right. So, as far as based
- 8:40on the briefings that you got in this time period
- 8:44when there was an effort to try to figure out
- 8:46what you were going to do, were there any issues
- 8:49of concern of fact or evidence or the charges that
- 8:52were left unaddressed? In other words, if there were issues
- 8:55about victim credibility, were steps being taken to address those? Answer?
- 9:00Unaddressed is again it's a very binary. It's not about
- 9:05addressed versus unaddressed, And so let me sort of come
- 9:08at it if I can try to get there. There
- 9:11were concerns around some legal issues. There were concerns about
- 9:14how the victims would do when put on the stand.
- 9:17Question right answer. As a general matter, we thought there
- 9:21was enough if we had to go forward, we could
- 9:23as an ethical matter go forward. That doesn't mean that
- 9:26there was not value in a pre indictment resolution. And
- 9:30so here you have redacted based on this exhibit saying
- 9:33we need to get on the same page as to
- 9:35what the charge pre indictment resolution cap them with conspiracy
- 9:39count to make up the attractive so a five year cap,
- 9:43something less than five years. You have redacted in Raffid
- 9:46David that was submitted to the court saying she favored
- 9:49a pre indictment resolution. And so it's not a have
- 9:52you addressed everything yes or no? As opposed to putting
- 9:55all of this how do we move forward? Question? Right?
- 9:59But there is a b binary point here, and that
- 10:01is you either indict or you don't indict. You either
- 10:04present an indictment to the grand jury or you don't. Right,
- 10:07that's a decision, right answer, So I would actually push
- 10:11back in that many cases it's not quite that binary.
- 10:15In many cases, you sit down with the opposing counsel
- 10:17and say, look, we can go to a grand jury
- 10:20and we can present this indictment and indict, or we
- 10:22can resolve this now. If we resolve this now, this
- 10:26is the path that we can go forward. Alternatively, we
- 10:29can go here, and so it's not an a versus
- 10:32B question. I understand that nuance. But the decision to indict,
- 10:37I mean, you either indict or you don't. If you
- 10:39don't indict, it's for any number of reasons. If under
- 10:43the circumstances, the choices that are available are you have
- 10:47a case that's been brought, taking it from the state,
- 10:50You can decline it, send it back to the state,
- 10:52make it go away, whatever answer right question, We're not interested.
- 10:57You can indict, You can indict and go to trial.
- 11:00These are the subcategories. Or you can indict and have
- 11:03the defendant plead to the indictment. Or you can indict
- 11:06and work a post indictment pleed deal which raises the
- 11:09issue you talked about. Or you can negotiate, or you
- 11:12can charge proceed by complaint and do as redactive with
- 11:16suggesting work a pre indictment but post charge disposition. Or
- 11:20you can work a precharge disposition. Right, I mean that's
- 11:23really that's the parade of possibilities. Answer sure, that's more
- 11:29than indictment or don't indict. That's six or seven options. Question.
- 11:33I understand that that's how it'll play out. But the
- 11:36decision as to whether to indict is binary. You're either
- 11:39indicting or you're not indicting. The act of indicting is
- 11:43something that either happens or doesn't happen. That's all I'm saying.
- 11:47Answer sure question. Okay, So that's what I'm getting at
- 11:51with respect to the indictment. So as you're looking at
- 11:54this case, it sounds as if you're doing sort of
- 11:57one analytical track, which is what do we do with
- 12:00the case. The other piece of that and a track
- 12:03that could have been followed exclusively is what do we
- 12:06need to do to get an indictment that is legally
- 12:09sound and evident, evidentiary solid. I'd like to focus on
- 12:13that track because they're not unrelated. Answer sure question. If
- 12:19you never get down, do we have a viable indictment
- 12:22road and you're not going to be able to do
- 12:24anything in the other road. So at this point, you
- 12:27have identified and you have collectively you and your people
- 12:31had identified some witnesses, victim witnesses issues, and some legal issues.
- 12:36My question is where steps being taken I use the
- 12:39term address. Let me let me clarify with respect to
- 12:42the witness as the FBI and the line attorney with
- 12:45the assistants, perhaps of the grand jury, taking steps to
- 12:48corroborate Shore Up victim witness testimony, find new victims, find
- 12:52additional evidence, and so on. Answer so taken that in
- 12:57part is helpful. So with respect to the witness issues,
- 13:00I recall and Redacted goes into much more detail in
- 13:03heraffid David, but I recall concerns that were communicated to
- 13:06me in essence, in sort of a summary my impression
- 13:10of recollection. If these girls are young, they're impressionable, they're scared,
- 13:14will they stand up in court? There are any number
- 13:17of there's any number of things that could be used
- 13:19against them. Some of them are and this is uncomfortable,
- 13:22but some of them thought he actually cared for them,
- 13:26and that's not a typical in these cases. They were
- 13:28sort of to develop those thoughts and they're wrong, but
- 13:32they are what they are and were actually saying he
- 13:34did nothing wrong. And because many of them knew one another,
- 13:37how would that all play out? And so it would
- 13:40have been my assumption, particularly given you know how much
- 13:43work redacted was doing on this case. Misredacted was doing
- 13:47on the case, and she, in combination with the FBI,
- 13:50would be pursuing those matters and looking to develop the
- 13:53evidence and corroborate and throughout the process, it would have
- 13:56been my assumption and hope that she was continuing to
- 13:59develop the thing, because that can only help. Question and so,
- 14:03as us attorney, would it indeed have been your expectation answer, yes, question,
- 14:09and the expectation that her that all those interim supervisors
- 14:12would have been supporting her and encouraging her and guiding her. Answer,
- 14:16it would have been that's what happens in typical cases.
- 14:19Question right, answer. Just because we're having a legal discussion
- 14:23doesn't mean you stop pursuing leads. All right, folks, We're
- 14:25gonna wrap up right here, and in the next episode,
- 14:28we're gonna pick up where we left off. All of
- 14:30the information that goes with this episode can be found
- 14:33in the description box.