Latest / Braver New Worlds / Rebuilding a Shared Reality: Media, Trust, and the End of Institutions with Jackie Bryant
Transcript
- Nathan Young: New Worlds, the podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host. And today I'm talking with Jackie Bryant. She is a journalist, a writer, an editor, and a media professor. And she spent her career working in media, primarily as a reporter and a journalist, both like within a media organization and as a freelancer. And she's been on the ride that the like the that our whole media landscape has been on for the last twenty years or so. Definitely like always oscillating between this like cycle of reinventing and dismantling itself every few years. Whether that's from like newspapers and journalism to the evolution of video and podcasts and independent media, the whole thing. She's been involved with all of it. So I was really excited to get a chance to talk to her about The state of media in our world today. I originally came to this conversation thinking we would talk about media literacy because that's definitely something I've observed as in decline for the last decade, although maybe it's not so much that it's been in decline mibe it's more that the tools for manipulation have gotten stronger. But underneath it all is like another important question too that came out from her point of view What happens to us when we stop sharing the same view of reality as informed by media institutions? And as you're gonna hear in our conversation, you know, there are very good reasons why the old media institutions lost our trust and deserved every bit of skepticism that they got in the first place. And also like independent media and so these social platforms that we're all using now, they've opened the door to so many different voices and perspectives that were not given an opportunity to really reach the audiences that they can reach now. But on the flip side, like let's not, you know, delude ourselves. There's there's challenges with that too. And for every person that has their own algorithm, their own creators, and increasingly their own set of facts, that that that wraps a little tear in the shared fabric of reality that we all have and creates a lot of opportunities for more nefarious characters to sneak their voices in and Let's be real, we are not any more free from corporate media than we have been in the past. Jackie and I both have backgrounds in media and are basically just nerds on this topic. So we just start riffing on all kinds of different topics. We actually like have some debates in here, which is which is cool. Like I don't really get to debate much on this podcast, so it's fun to have a little bit of a debate. and we also get into the collapse of traditional media and the promise and limitations of independent creators and what she's seeing amongst the journalism students that she's teaching, and why the future of trustworthy media might require us to rethink what authority looks like altogether. So if all this interests you, you're kind of curious to hear what two media geeks would talk about when we just start geeking out on it, this is gonna be a great conversation to listen to. And if you just want to get a better understanding of what's going on in the world of media, especially as it comes down to like news and local news that you consume, I think this could be helpful too. So here is my conversation with Jackie Bryant. Jackie Bryant, welcome to the podcast. jackie: Hi, happy to be here. Nathan Young: before we get into it, l how about just give your introduce yourself real quick to the audience here so they know who you are. jackie: Yeah, my name is Jackie Bryant. I'm a journalist, a journalism professor, an editor, a writer, whatever polyglot media person. At add in I guess now I do video, now I do audio. Is there anything we don't do? Nathan Young: You gotta do all the things. You can't just like do yeah. Yeah. jackie: that I I think that encompasses who I am, at least professionally. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And yeah, and like we've actually I don't know that we've ever met in person, but we've been like in overlapping worlds for a long time. So jackie: Yeah. Nathan Young: it's good to like doing this pod together. jackie: It is, thank you. Nathan Young: and so I nominally reached out because I saw that you did a talk about media literacy, and that's like one of my soapbox topics. And then there's like all kinds of other things related to that we can get into just this sort of state of media and all the stuff going on. So Yes. jackie: Did you know the history of the soapbox? Nathan Young: No. Okay, let's go there. jackie: my goodness. No, this is actually Nathan Young: Okay. jackie: Let me look it up really quickly. This is an incredible place to start, and I promise Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. jackie: this all ties together. So actually in the early 1900s, there were the like basically like radical leftist politics that were coming about because of the Industrial Revolution. labor unions were forming, they were growing, etc. etc. So in the late 19th century through like the early 1920s. Soapboxing became a really popular way of like spreading news and information. It started in nineteen twelve at the free speech fight in San Diego, which saw Nathan Young: wow. jackie: activists flood like downtown to deliberately get arrested while they were soapboxing to overwhelm the court and the jail system. So that actually Nathan Young: Wow. jackie: came about here in San Diego that term. Nathan Young: Okay. jackie: And obviously the history of free speech in the United States is heavily rooted here in San Diego and the term soapbox comes from here. Right. yeah, Nathan Young: Wow, wouldn't have thunk it. That's interesting. Yeah. jackie: yeah. I mean we can get into it. I mean definitely would not have thought it because we have a a somewhat anemic media market here in San Diego. Free speech is Nathan Young: Yes, yes. jackie: not exactly something we cherish in this town, but yeah. It did start here. I I love that. That's like one of my favorite San Diego facts. Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay. Well that now there's like you've sparked like two digressions that I'm curious about. I always assumed that like it referenced people standing on a soap box and yeah, yeah, jackie: A literal soapbox, yes. Nathan Young: yeah. But why a soap box? what is so like unique about boxes for soap back in the nineteen jackie: that's a good question. I think so basically before the invention of like corrugated cardboard, these like discarded wooden crates were kinda like everywhere. They were like the de facto styrofoam or like cardboard packaging or whatever. So you would find these soap crates everywhere. So they were very easy to grab. And Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: formally just throw up in a town square or like a city street or whatever and then you stand on it and ba ba ba ba. So it was very rooted in like literal grassroots, use Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: what you have, use what's around you to get the word out. Nathan Young: Not all. jackie: So it's because it was like the ubiquitous packaging of the deck. but yeah, it was definitely not considered a positive practice. It was considered rabble rousing, disturbing the peace, like et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Yeah. Nathan Young: Perfect. Yeah. Okay. do you have a theory on why San Diego is such an anemic media market? I have my theories, but jackie: even a theory. I think it's actually pretty well laid out. I think the scholars and authors, Mike Davis, Kelly Mayhew, and Jim Miller did a really good job laying this out and under the perfect sun. San Diego historically is a town where there were native tribes, the Kumeyaay and Luis Señor in particular. And then you had missions and colonizers come in. And then of course, you had like a little bit of a bustling port and waves of immigrants coming in from China building the railroad, Portuguese building the fishing industry, et cetera, et cetera. But this was always an extractive place. it was also always a destination. so this was never part of like the Industrial Revolution, San Diego. There was never a sizable working class here. that was organic to the city from its origins. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: the working class was imported to build the housing for Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: for example, Niki de Saint Phalle, she was a famous artist who came to live out her final years here in La Jolla, Nathan Young: yeah. jackie: because of how much the paints she used, the oil paints, damaged her lungs, for example. So the reason the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: famous would come and convalesce here, or it like this was always like a nice place to end up. But there was never like any critical mass of work. this was not an agricultural or industrial hub where there were tons of workers. It was always Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: a nice place to end up or a way station. so basically after World War Two, you had such an influx of people. This that's really when San Diego exploded in population for the first time. And those were mostly people from elsewhere. They weren't from here. The people building the places and the facilities that house this population and service the population also came from elsewhere, whether that was overseas marginalized immigrant like work groups or you had different immigrant work groups already in the United States, whatever that was. And then Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. jackie: time goes on, like obviously it's a beautiful place. It's been Republican in its history. It's been always been an expensive place to live. So you have this tandem of this city Sort of rising up out of the desert, but it's only ever serving a certain class. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. jackie: So media that grows up around it is Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: also only ever gonna serve a certain class and a certain perfect purpose, Nathan Young: Okay. jackie: right? Like there was no, there's of course like a labor union history and labor history here. And of course, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: there are working class people, et cetera, but it just wasn't like other American cities where most of the people were working class. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. jackie: And you had class consciousness. You had unions. You Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: had a strong union market affecting Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: politics and also in the hearts and minds of like everyday people in the city. Like there's Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: just always kind of been more wealthy people here and the working class populations have been transient. Media flows Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: down from that. It reflects the values of a society. Historically booster media has done well here. It's a sunny place, it's a happy place. city and regional magazines, one of which I used to be the managing editor, San Diego magazine. I still co-host a podcast there, write for it occasionally, and I wrote for it for years before that. But those magazines were started back in the forties, fifties, sixties in various cities and regions around the state. the Baffler did an incredible wonderful article about it in nineteen ninety two. To s signpost that for you. We've always Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: been wondering, like, what do city magazines even do? They're intended to be boosters. They were never intended to like do real deal journalism and and Nathan Young: Boosters as in like boosting the lifestyle, boost boosting the city, boosting yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: Exactly. They tell you about local businesses and then people Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: know that they exist and go shopping them and vice versa and then they buy ads Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. jackie: and that is supposed to be like a healthy local media system and boosterism is actually like a stated part of that. So Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: obviously I believe in like truth and reporting and all of that, but I do think we have to be honest about like the function of some of this media. And so Nathan Young: Try. jackie: in a town that is sunny with a lot of palm trees where tourism Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: is a huge part of the economy and other transient industries like bring transient populations here, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: like education, like the military, like us just being a border town in general. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: it does mean that sometimes the institutions at Anchor a City, media especially being Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: one of them, they tend to be weaker because Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: you just don't have the culture behind it supporting it. So we Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: Being the eighth biggest city in the country, obvious and like being a border city, being a military city, you name it, you add it, Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: obviously we deserve, I think, a stronger and more robust media market than we have. But Nathan Young: Totally. jackie: we have one. and it's not that robust. Nathan Young: Not that robust. jackie: it's getting worse every day. It's definitely getting kneecapped. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: but at the same time, it it kicks on, and that just sort of proves that there will always be this. You have to fight to keep it honest in a certain way. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: You may not always win, but it does come in going waves and there will always like it is important to this like functioning city, even if it is not I don't think it's like the appropriate media market for a city of our size and importance. But it goes Nathan Young: No, no. jackie: all the way back, I think, to the fact that like there was never a strong political working class movement here, period, in any way, shape Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Well, 'cause we're like jackie: or form. Nathan Young: Yeah. Cause we're like, I mean, on some level, like we're like a transplant town too, right? Like people come here and so they Yeah. And so like Yeah. Yeah. And jackie: Yeah. We have always been. Yeah. Since it's since our inception, literally. So you know. Nathan Young: so yeah, the people come here, they still have like an affinity for wherever they came from. there's like when you go to a a baseball game, there's like more fans for the other team than there are for like the Padres, usually. No. jackie: like LA has that, so why does it have a stronger idea? There's so many reasons, right? And again, Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. jackie: like LA does have a strong working class Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: population, that makes up the majority of the population of the city. it's less politically segregated in so many ways. And that's because as a city it kind of came up more organically. Basically, San Diego is like a planned mall for developers. And that's how it was built. That's how it was conceived. And that's how it is now. So if you feel disconnected from your neighbor and the car situation and the walking s situation feels awkward, that's actually like literally by design. Half intentional, half like they don't care. So it just wasn't planned out, right? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: all of these things, all of these weird feelings that people have about San Diego, like why doesn't the media here mostly kind of suck and like not do a great job? Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: And why is it does it feel weird to walk down the street? Why I why can't I walk a mile from my house and not have it feel weird? Like why doesn't it Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: feel right? Those things are all connected. Nathan Young: Interesting. jackie: They all go back to a very specific origin and and I think it just goes back to this is a city built by rich people for rich people. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. did you corrupt here then, or are you from here or are you a transplant? Okay. jackie: No, I'm from New York. I've been here for twelve years, but I've been here I've been here for yeah, I but I grew up in New York. I'm from New Nathan Young: Okay, like New York, New York or like Rochester or like jackie: No, ew. no, I was born in Queens. I grew up on Long Island. I lived in Manhattan Nathan Young: wow, okay. jackie: for ten years before moving out here. So yeah, yeah, yeah. My whole family is valid that he's still there. Nathan Young: always been in San Diego and so everything here seems normal to me. And like I mean I moved away for a while, but like I grew up here and lived most of my adult life here, except for like six years. So it so everything jackie: It's not normal here. Like, it's it's really not. we should not have destroyed this natural landscape like we did. But that's not a just a CD Yeah. Nathan Young: Well, that's good to be said about every city, right? jackie: but we really paved over the American Southwest. we really did a great job with that. And that's because the American Southwest and Southern California in particular was literally the apple of the car lobbies eye. And Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: all of these things they can be traced back to a specific time period, a specific political and social ideology. And it it all kind of ties together. But in it in a certain way, like San Diego was always designed to be a high-end retirement community. And so that's why Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: Some of these things are sticky. That's why NIMBYism is sticky in a certain way here. That's you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: know what I mean? Like certain things kinda are just that way. And it's that way. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, a retirement community and like a military town. jackie: Like redlining is is is a huge thing here and so responsible for just so much of what's going on here politically and with schools here, et cetera, et cetera. So it's it's an interesting town from its inception as a modern day American city. I'm like not going all the way back into like native history but and like colonial history but present Nathan Young: Yeah. What jackie: day. Nathan Young: so when you moved here, like what inspired you to move here then or what was what was going on? jackie: I did not want to move here. I moved here for my ex husband's job and just through inertia and life and, you know, getting myself set up, I'm here, but no, I did not want to move here. Truthfully, I was very happy in New York. Sure, yeah. I mean, Nathan Young: Now you now you're here. Okay. What do you okay. Yeah, look then have you settled into it here? Do you like it here or are you yeah? jackie: I teach at San Diego State University. I was the managing editor of San Diego magazine for many years. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: I have settled into my community, I think, really well. have a a big full life here. So it wasn't where I set out to end up, but yeah, definitely. It's been twelve years now. So yeah, for sure. Yeah. Absolutely. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well so nominally I wanna talk about media literacy. But you know, San Diego rants are great too though. jackie: I love San Diego, but I think it reflects a lot about modern American values and how we conceive of like living spaces in society. And I think there are some specific problems here with the way we built this city that we are trying to figure out in real time now. I think the sewage crisis is a big part of that. For examp just to give one example. And Nathan Young: do you wanna? Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: so I think we're seeing that like come out and it it provides a roadmap for what to fix, of course. I love San Diego, but I do think and again, this is not my original point. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: Mike Davis, Jim Miller and Kelly Mayhew made this point eloquently and with the recent release of this book, Under the Perfect Sun now actually it's it's a Nathan Young: yeah yeah. jackie: lot easier to get that book. We don't lose anything by admitting some of the less savory conditions and dreams under which San Diego was built and and conceived, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: right? We lose nothing by acknowledging that we are in a nice place and maybe it's been steered by some kind of nasty people over history for for Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: purposes that didn't serve the people who lived here. And that's okay. and I actually think that that's like really common in beautiful, like touristy places. You Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: look at the economies of the Caribbean, et cetera. And so I think we're having a really interesting moment in San Diego history right now where a lot of these things are coming out. Social media, media literacy, a Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: lack of a strong media, but a growth in independent media, that's helping some of that. I think with the recent mosque shooting, you have so many discussions and rhetoric that even just a few years ago people wouldn't have been comfortable saying out loud or wouldn't have attributed to this city, because it's a marginalized community that even though it's very Muslims are obviously very numerous here, they don't get the shine. And so I I just think Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Good. jackie: like so many things have changed. It's a result of how San Diego is conceived and where it comes from. and I think that Yeah, again, it's like a very modern Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: conception of an American city. And so we're living through just like very predictable social and economic changes for a city that really has only been like cooking as a major city since like the middle of the last century, right? it just isn't Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, for sure. jackie: old or or as industrialized as like even LA, even other cities. You know what I mean? So I think everybody says that everything happens here a little bit later. I think that that's true, but it's not because we're like slower or dumber or worse. Got Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: a little bit of a later start and maybe maybe, yeah, the sun makes it a little bit slower. So I I love San Diego, but I actually think that we're living in such a pivotal time in its history, different from other cities, because we're not on that like post-industrial revolution timeline in quite the same way, if that makes sense. I think us being a military Like hub also really. It just gives Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. jackie: us a different polar look out than the rest of the country has because like we're the seat of everything happening geopolitically right now. Nathan Young: Well yeah, and then to the degree that there is a sort of like industrial base, it's in Tijuana. jackie: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: Right? Like that's like they got the Maquiladoras down there. jackie: Well, that's because we offloaded our industrial production to that. Yeah. It like Nathan Young: Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. jackie: so there is there is, but the traditional industrial revolution like the American industrial revolution didn't happen here. You know what I mean? And and if it did, it Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Just military and tourists. jackie: was in service of like military tech and building and Nathan Young: Yeah. Well yeah, 'cause it there was a big shipbuilding industry here until the nineties and that got closed s like kind of suddenly. And jackie: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: I don't know if you yeah, you weren't here in the nineties or whatever, it's sort of strange to say 'cause I don't want to like overemphasize it, but it w was actually like kind of a rough town. Like even jackie: Yeah, for sure. Nathan Young: even in Encinitas where I grew up, I saw there was gangs and I saw gang brawls and stuff and yeah. jackie: Totally. Oceanside, you know, as a military town, is d is is rough. We don't we don't Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: pay infantry members a lot of money. there's a lot of social problems that come with mil yeah, like abs a hundred percent. Yeah, it makes sense, truthfully. Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I'm curious to make here is about the sort of media landscape because whether San Diego or in general, you mentioned something interesting there about like just sort of like the growth of independent media and I hear a lot of people talking about hopefully this sort of feels like in your wheelhouse because like jackie: No, it is. I have so many thoughts about it and I I just think it's it is interesting hearing everybody like I mean like again people are still saying like Substack like it's a new thing. I started mine in twenty twenty and that was already because of COVID and things blowing up budgets blowing up because of COVID. But at that point we had already lived through several like digital media disruptions. We'd already lived through one Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: major pivot to video in media, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: which I think like everyone is forgetting. this already happened pre-COVID. Yeah, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, we're here doing videos. Yeah, yeah. jackie: we already had mass layoffs due to video and that didn't happen and then COVID happened and then TikTok happened and now it's happening again. And so I it it's like I I it's it's it's like We've been flirting around this independent media thing for so long. I came up as a freelancer, so I obviously embody that and I understand it. I espouse it. I believe in it, but I also kind of knew and I still believe along the way Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: that I am scabbing in a sense. I have an independent media career because I can and I've been able to do it and I prefer to work Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: that way. And it it works out for me and people trust me and they give me work and you know what I mean? Like I built this Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: but I don't do I really think that that's the way media should be? No. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: I think it's good that we have challenged our major media institutions. They were kind of getting rotten from the inside out. I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: think any institution anywhere is worthy of a look in Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: and a hollowing out, and that's not just media. so I think it's good that some of the big media institutions, especially the New York Times, CNN, I think that they're getting a little bit ripped apart ideologically and the quality of the reporting. Great, we needed that. truthfully. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. jackie: Two enthusiastic thumbs up. But I don't think the answer is everybody turn the camera on you and learn how to fact check and just do Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: it. Like again I loved being a freelance journalist. I think that that's part of a healthy media ecosystem. I just don't think that that can be all media. There are is value in institutions because they do create communities, bodies of information, like legacy, institutional knowledge, which is so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: important to this kind of work. mechanisms for fact checking, editing. I mean, if you've anyone out there who works for media, if you've ever worked at a somewhat healthy media company and you know how many people touch that product before it gets published, you know, my God. So it's why I think a lot of journalists like watch what's happening out there and they're like, my God. Like w there's no editors, there's no fact checking. And I agree with that. even as a freelancer, I It's weird. I've had a successful Substack, but anyone who's followed me knows that like I really I just don't put that much effort into it anymore. Even though I could, I have an audience for it. But I I just I believe in being edited. I believe in in an Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: editorial structure. I believe in that vetting of information and that process and the checks I even at my big age and with my experience. And so I'm always really hesitant to put all of my eggs in the independent media basket because while I think it is a vital, vibrant, democratizing part of media and should always be part of it, I do not think it can be the standard for information Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: dissemination going forward. And so kind of stuck between those two things. I think society is stuck between those two things. but I do think ultimately that relying on information being atomized among individual creators. It's just not gonna work long term for a variety of like actual mechanical reasons. But I also don't think that it's like healthy for society. And so Nathan Young: Mm-mm. jackie: I don't know how it's gonna all shake out, but Nathan Young: Well jackie: you will see new institutions forming, I think. But that's the thing. Like Nathan Young: Well, that's my theory. jackie: I'm yeah, like I'm already hearing people being like, Why can't we just bucket Substack subscriptions and then we can get all the articles in one place? Whoa, fucking brilliant. You just invented magazines and newspapers. Like, you know what I mean? Like we're Nathan Young: I know. Yeah, yeah. jackie: just kind of going around this and so I know this will all congeal Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: and come I just don't know what that looks like. So I'm critical of this. I'm also a product of the boom of independent Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: media. But also literally for the last ten years, I've been out here being like, You should freelance. Freelancing is great. You know what I mean? I Nathan Young: I wanna sort of contextualize and yeah, frame kind of what what we're talking about there too. Because yeah, there is this transition that's been happening and that's been going on since like the seventies or eighties or whatever, where there was lots of local regional newspapers and magazines and that but also there was like these very like established publishing houses and TV networks, like the big three ABC, NBC and CBS and the New York Times and the sort of big and the big the LA Times, Chicago Tribune, Washington Post, like very institutional focused ways of doing media. And then over time that sort of spread out to where you've got cable news and then internet. And then now we're at this point where a lot of those institutions back that existed most of our lifetime are all starting to crumble or lose ground or everything. And so it has created the situation where like, yeah, there's a bajillion different creators that could just show up there and do just turn the phone on themselves on TikTok and just start doing the news. Yeah. jackie: Right. I mean and they do. And they do. And n some of them are doing well, some of them are not, right? it's created a Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: problem for news people, but in this decline that's been happening since the seventies, eighties, really, of traditional news media, the industry has been loath to catch up. And like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: low key, I genuinely believe that that's because They're not in business for readers. They are in business to harness advertising money and information. Right? So, we know this. We don't need to Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, too. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. jackie: pretend. And so it's almost like this came of cat and mouse where we're like talking about one thing, but I don't think we're even like on really speaking honestly about what's actually is happening and what Folks are holding on to with these big institutions. Nathan Young: what do you mean by that? Like the the h the holding on to? jackie: Like I just I think people think these institutions exist because they are being talked to by who whomever is on the other end. But I do Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: think people believe that it's all a little bit freer than it is. I don't think that people realize the everyday news consumer I think they suspect, but I don't think they honestly realize how tailored their information is by Nathan Young: yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: so many people on the other end. And like even Nathan Young: like these institutional news channels, like jackie: Absolutely, yeah. Nathan Young: it tailored as far as like the message that's being given to them and like the edit the way things are editorial. Yeah, yeah, of course. Well jackie: Like like all of it? Yeah. Nathan Young: and that's well that's sort of like on some level that's that's both the case for and the case against institutional news, right? That like jackie: Right. Yep. Nathan Young: the news is filtered and established and fact checked and tacked yeah. jackie: But by whom, right? Nathan Young: Tacked yeah, exactly. But also like tacked jackie: That's where it Nathan Young: to like a shared reality that shared reality is probably like in tied to the reality that a larger set of systemic power structures want us all to be beholden to and agree with. And when the news was talking from that reality to that reality and creating that reality, on one level, yeah, it was good because you could sort of trust it that way, but it did keep us stuck in sort of like one reality. And now we have The inverse, like for all the frustrations that created. And now we have this sort of inverse where like there's just so many realities out there and you don't even know what reality people jackie: Yeah, it's extremely dangerous. Nathan Young: are talking about or to. And it's so easy to go down some weird rabbit hole in the news media you pick up that could like jackie: Well, it's not even a rabbit hole. It's it's it has created such a state of a alienation and atomization. I know people are aware of this, but I don't know if they really truly understand what's actually happening. But nobody has an identical reality as anybody else anymore. No one Whoever did, yeah. I I believe objectivity is a myth. Like, I get it. You know what I mean? Like Yeah, yeah. But we used to have a monoculture. We used to Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, of course. But there was like some there was a little bit more agreement prior to mm-hmm mm-hmm. jackie: at least be able to tap into the same type of mass media. and that's why subcultures were so valuable, because that's where you exercised your weird true Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: personal self and found other weirdos like you. But we were tapped into this monoculture, which Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. jackie: results in this mono-reality. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: And obviously organized religion plays a part in that. Schools play a part of that. the media obviously helps move all of that along. But now we have no monoculture and we have all Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: individual algorithms and feeds that are Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: 100% personalized. We are not even drawing from the same reality, the same point Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: of view, the same set of facts. There is no one truth anymore. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: And so this is dangerous. if you think if you're a government, from a population control standpoint and just a societal standpoint, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: that's dangerous, but and I am anti-authoritarian in so many ways, but it's so it's weird. It both hurts and benefits authority to have this. But at the end of the day, I think it's ultimately more dangerous For us and it benefits authority because it just alienates one of us from each other and it erodes Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: our village. And so I guess that's why I'm so passionate about media and information, because it is more than entertainment. It's more than just like being informed. It Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: actually is a reflection of how we just communicate and relate to each other on a very microcosmic level, like as humans. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. jackie: so with that so broken and so atomized, it absolutely reflects. Every other way that we are living our lives. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. So I want to sort of make a case for this fractured media thing and then like kind of get into maybe how we could be thinking about this going forward. Because I think this is like so important and valuable. And the case I would make for this fractured media is just we are both white and waspy, you know. And back in the Okay. jackie: I'm not wasping, I'm Italian. I'm a Catholic. Nathan Young: Okay. All right. Well, but jackie: Not waspi. Nathan Young: okay, European of European descent. we have very similar skin tones as far as I can tell via the camera here. and the news media, like that very like monoculture sort of represented us on some level, right? And we are getting a lot more voices from people of color, people of different like marginalized groups now. jackie: Nice. But why can't we do that in institutions? I don't and I think like to say that the only Nathan Young: Well that's the case jackie: way that marginalized folks is to go around Nathan Young: Well, I mean I'm not saying that's the only way, but I'm just saying that's what happened. Yeah. jackie: That's nice, but then what do we have? We don't it hasn't made anything better, truthfully. Like our news media is actually worse Nathan Young: Mm, maybe. jackie: off than ever. So even though we have so many quote unquote diverse voices, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: we also have so many more uninformed voices. And I'm not saying that those Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: are the same communities. Democratization in media is a good thing and it's good that we're not gatekeeping, but I don't think that media institutions are the reason that there was any gatekeeping happening. What was happening is that There are certain interests that advertise and pay for these publications and prop Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: them up. Those are aligned with power. All of those kids went to the same ten Ivy League schools. They went to the same prep schools in Boston, New Nathan Young: Mm, mm. Yeah. jackie: York, LA, Minneapolis, what Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: have you, like name a city and name a prep school. They fed you know what I mean? it's like really good to have this democratization. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: But now a lot of those voices are gone. a lot of those independent creators, for instance, black American creators who came up during the George Floyd era or got hired at news publications, they've already been fired, their positions have been eliminated, or maybe there's no focus, or they just got hired for DEI and got pigeonholed there. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: it's good to bring these creators in, but what we are seeing here is just the fallout of identity politics in general and the fact that is baldly centrist Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: to just democratize based on identity alone because Those things are not what are causing the strife Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: in our society. Like what's actually causing the strife in our society are baseline wealth hoarding and class tensions. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: And like racism and sexism and all these other isms are all a part of that and a part of white supremacy Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: and all help to hold that up, right? So all of those things are a good thing, but when you just deploy them without the proper support, the proper Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: structure. If you don't rebuild an institution that can house these diverse voices, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: you're really just letting them out like Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: to the sharks. And that's kind of what's happened. And that's why news media quality has not increased on a whole, even though you have arguably more Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: and in many cases better voices out there than ever. I will fully a thousand percent agree with that. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: you've also left like a lot of people adrift and readers also adrift, without be or listeners or what have you Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: not being able. So I like a million percent hear you and I'm with you. And democratization is always a good thing. But also Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: like how many voices do we need? I think Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: like menus, restaurant menus. do you need one that has every type of food, or do you want one that sort of delivers you a very tailored experience and you know what to expect? Could make the case for either. So Yeah, I hear you. Those are all the things that that kicks off for me. Like democratization a good thing, but when it's rudderless and there's no ideology behind it like we can't do democratization just for the sake of it. And that goes obviously with legacy Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, sure. jackie: creators and and news Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: people as well, like evaluate everybody, right? I guess what I'm trying to say is that these concepts on their own without some kind of class intersectionality and how we got here and some examination of that, it's always gonna result in something flat. And then it creates an environment where it's able to be co opted by other forces. I think right. why you would Nathan Young: What yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: That is now a punchline, even though what it just means is you've done your homework and you respect inter intersectional politics and class relations and stuff like that. Nathan Young: Yeah. Nathan: As much as I love doing this podcast, sad truth of it all is that doesn't pay the bills. It actually cost me money to make this podcast. That's okay, I love doing it, so we're doing it. So what does pay the bills for me is I help individuals and organizations leverage the power of storytelling for leadership and persuasion. This is the work I do and I want to tell you about it real quick here. For organizations, a lot of times the work is very much focused on fundraising for nonprofits or developing a narrative strategy for the important messages that they want to get out in their campaigns. It can also be about developing leadership and communication skills amongst a team that you've already got working within your organization. For individuals, a lot of my work revolves around helping develop a narrative-based communication approach for those high-leverage career moments that come up from time to time, like giving a public talk, interviewing for a new position, integrating into a new role at a new company, or making the leap for yourself to jump into entrepreneurship and how you talk about the work that you do with external audiences there too. These are very much the moments that can have a huge impact on your career. And by utilizing storytelling and narrative, you can not only communicate a more resonant message about what it is you're doing, but also what is going to stick. So if this is intriguing to you and you wanna know more, you can check out my website, storycultureconsulting.com. I'll have a free tool on there that's available for download, or you can check out the show notes too. I'll have the same tool down there that you can grab too. Once again, that's story culture consulting.com and now back to the show. Nathan Young: and I guess that's sort of the bigger point I was trying to make there too. I was just sort of bringing up people of different racial minorities having a chance to get their voice out there as sort of an example. But like the democratization has just put a lot more voices out there. And on jackie: Yeah. Nathan Young: one level that's great, but it also depends on a certain level of literacy and being willing to seek out voices that they cover a range of affirming the things you want to know and believe and understand. But yeah, jackie: It's hard, right? Yeah. Nathan Young: challenging those beliefs from like different levels of the spectrum too. Like challenging those beliefs jackie: Right. Nathan Young: from I hate left, right, conservative, liberal, progressive that like way of speaking about it. But like Yeah. jackie: Yeah. Like breaking out of those binaries in general. Nathan Young: But also like to kind of all ends too. I always want to sort of challenge myself with more kind of conservative ideas and more progressive ideas than I get. But you and me are the people that are gonna be doing that. Like, 'cause we have yeah, that sort of baseline. And yeah, you're right. the great majority of people out there, they're gonna kinda get funneled into a media machine. jackie: Well and also who decided that you have the ability to do that or I do. You know what I mean? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: I was always very cognizant in my freelance reporting career that like there was a certain arrogance Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: in striking out on your own because I do think that most good and healthy environments include some level of consensus. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: And so I think that's why in the end I have shied away from building my own platform and I still stick towards not like blindly chasing institutions, but trying trying to reimagine how institutions could be because ultimately I believe in some kind of consensus for leadership. And I think I there's no ideal structure that has come across my desk yet. And so it's like Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: Keep fumbling around and forming these new groups and different ideas to see how it might best work out. and so yes, like to all of your points, I think it's it's no surprise legacy media and institutional media has fallen out. it was not serving its readership for a long time. It still doesn't. and it's a diversity of voices is truly a huge, huge, huge, huge, huge part of that. I think there are just so many ideas out there because of real culture and a lot of the social problems that we've had in this country since COVID, since George Floyd. I'll put those as like two specifics. I think I think Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. I mean that that was a sort of moment. Yeah. jackie: yeah, and on social so much has changed since those moments. I mean that we're even talking out loud in the United States about racial and class consciousness the way that we are these days. And even talking about Palestine As a concrete political issue, not just a specter of something. That's all very new. And I I really credit Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: social media and like independent media really with doing that because institutional media ignores it. So yes, there is so much value here, Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: but I feel like we are stuck at this critical mass level and and how to do that and then how to empower Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: These and and capitalized. Let's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: just empower. Like fuck that fluffy language. how do we get money to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: these newer more representative, diverse, categorize it however it makes sense for whatever you're talking about, voices, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: and incentivize, capitalize, and also legitimize and also Nathan Young: And legitimize. jackie: right, like, yeah, legitimize, have that be the social standard we aspire to rather than the traditional markers of institutional Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: like institutional hegemony where we used to confer authority because you were part of this institution Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: or other social like tells like you were white or made. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. What this is an interesting point too, because I think about what happened in Gaza or what's happening in Gaza, could you imagine how ABC, NBC and CBS would have reported that like like they would have been Yeah. Yeah, they didn't No. Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: We saw it. We saw it. And I don't think it was very objective. I will throw the New York Times on that as well. Absolutely. And so yeah, the one good thing you will always hear me say about this era of independent media, social media, independent media, whatever whatever you're calling it, is part of this democratization of ideas and perspective. And it's sort of like in the way that third parties in the United States Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: well, historically, that's not happening anymore. But historically and what we were taught is that they keep the big two in check and they allow ideas that the big two don't already espouse to come into the public discourse. I do feel like independent media is serving the Green Party. Yeah. Nathan Young: Third parties is in like independent versus Republican, Democratic. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Total yeah. jackie: I feel like independent media is kind of like doing that check on institutional media right now, being like, Well, why aren't you reporting this? Okay, if you're not, I'm going to because I have a Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: platform too now. There just wasn't that ability before. And now there is. And so it Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: is that's a good check. I think then new institutions can form with that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: in mind and learning what we can learn from independent media, or we can have some kind of structure where we are incentivizing, independent media makers to go out there, but they have kind of like an ideological an institutional Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: home to come back to that confers authority, offers support, that kind of thing. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well yeah, that's kinda like the the question I was gonna ask you too is how do we keep the good and minimize the bad in this sort of model this this clusterfuck that's emerged. jackie: don't know. I really don't know. I'm gonna admit like this is where I run out of steam. Like I don't know. Especially because like I teach journalism as in a college journalism program. I can't stand up there and say go be an influencer. The fuck are they paying for a degree for? You know what I mean? they would probably but a lot of them want to do that. So a lot of my students are going into TV careers because TV news is the only segment of news that's really hiring right now. They're Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: like the only ones that still have jobs because it's the only one that still has advertisers because boomers watch TV, right? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: they think if I go into TV and I learn how to be a TV news reporter, at least I can back into social media because I will have learned an on-camera skill. This is really very smart thinking. I just Nathan Young: Mm mm. And develop an audience that way too. Yeah. jackie: don't but you're banking on that even being an option and you being able to pop and you even being decent on camera and making it on your own and I just don't think everyone also realizes what happens when you make your own media. You're admin, your legal, your HR, you're the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: CEO, you're the producer, you're the editor. I've done it a lot. I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yep. Yep. jackie: I personally I don't want to do that anymore. I Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: I want a team behind me helping me with that. And I also think that it's safer. obviously I make so much independent media. I'm so in favor Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: for it. I just don't think we can look at it to be the savior of media because I think we lose so much in the middle. And it's always corrosive. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well I guess I'm curious, you're talking to young people. how are they understanding the news? how are they able to parse what they're getting from like yeah. jackie: They're not. They're not. They get their news on social media. Even my students who are literally in a journalism program. I mean, I Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: teach the class for the daily Aztec, which is the newspaper. They literally are in a newspaper reporting class with me. Writing and reporting Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: in the newspaper. They don't follow the news. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. I mean they follow the news and like what gets sort of fed to them, I'm assuming, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: algorithm they don't follow the news stations they don't they don't they get news but they don't get it at all through traditional channels i ask this every semester show of hands and then i make them take out their phones and i sit there and i go follow CBS eight follow mbc seven follow and listen i got criticisms with all of this i know how media is being made at every Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Mm. Mm. Yeah, yeah. jackie: Institution in San Diego right now, and it's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: not a pretty picture anyway. Let me tell you. they're not my NDEs, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: so I'm not breaking any information here, but it's not good. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: but this track, so we were talking off you know, off camera about Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: this Reuters institute digital news report that I love. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: one of the classes I teach at San Diego State is authenticity, influencing and community leadership, and it's a social media class about all of those topics and algorithms and AI and also like how to be an authentic communicator, a leader on social media, and also examine Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: how institutions and people do this or they don't. And that comes from a news perspective, but also the brand and marketing universe as well. I have a lot of PR Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: students and journalism students in that class. So one of the reports I use ad nauseum, but I really do think it's the best and most current out there because there's not a there's social media analysis done out there, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: but it's it's new, right? It's all new. So like the ways that we're Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Mm-hmm. jackie: looking at this are constantly changing and there's not like a ton out there. So a lot of this is just like vibes or compiling your own. Always changing. It's the one class Nathan Young: It it'd be hard to study it, I think, too, 'cause it would like by the time you finish the study it's changed. Yeah, yeah. jackie: where I'm constantly making new material and always doing it even through the semester. Like I have to do a new prep. even though I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: do that class every semester because I could get away with not, but I wanted to be current for them, right? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. That's what I jackie: anyway, this Reuters Institute digital news report, the twenty twenty six one just came out on June sixteenth. they survey a hundred thousand people in forty eight markets. It's funded by YouGov one of the lead authors there kind of leads the study and it's also done in conjunction with the University of Oxford. I love it. I think it's really authoritative. It's got a whole bunch of really good inputs. but very interesting. 54% from this report, 54% of people globally use social media or video networks for news in the past weeks. So over half of the world right now, regardless Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: of age, is using video video to get their news. that's the first time in the report's fifteen year history that it beats anything else. So that's TV, which is fifty-two percent, news websites and apps, which is fifty-one percent, radio, which is twenty-one, and AI chatbots and third-party consumption together. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: that is fifty-six percent. So it's a huge shift, this is the first time in history. Nathan Young: Wow. Interesting. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. jackie: thirty percent of people acr globally now call social and video their main news source. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: That is up 22% from five years ago. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: TV news is down like consumption of it 13 points. Publisher Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: websites and apps are down twelve percentage points since 2020. And the collapse Nathan Young: Well. jackie: isn't just in TV. It's like the publishers own digital front doors. They're falling down just as fast. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: And news sites and apps are no longer the number one source of news for any age group. TV Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: holds only a among forty-five and up. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: And over half of 18 to 24 year olds say social video or AI is their main news source. Reuters has found that they won't age into old habits. They were basically just socialized into new ones. So Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah. jackie: under four and ten, trust the news that they see. News Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: interest fell, this is just general news interest, fell from fifty-nine percent to under forty six percent since twenty twenty one. Forty-two percent say that they have news avoidance. They just avoid it outright, which is up twenty nine percent since twenty seventeen. And twelve percent of people get news again only from social, which is doubled in five years, and only seventeen percent pay for online news anywhere. Nathan Young: I hear that. I'm I'm reading that, but like for maybe somebody listening that doesn't, you know, like what what does that all mean? That maybe isn't like in the media world, like what does that mean? jackie: It means we're all getting our information from unverified individual sources. And I certainly know what I think that that means, but Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. so jackie: I don't think it's good. it means that there's opportunity, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: But here's the thing. Opportunity in media doesn't always correlate with morality. And so Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: I think personally, if you work in media, you have a moral obligation to your readership. Obviously, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: and you've worked on the advertising side of media, so have I. That is so not how most of media operates. Most people are not sitting around being a lot of people earnestly really are. what happened in like Spotlight? That's real. Some people Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: are sitting around earnestly being like the readers are, you know, we owe this to the public. That is true. Most Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: people are just trying to figure out how to make a book and get home to their families at the end of the day and come back and do it again, right? So Nathan Young: Yeah. Well Yeah. I mean my experience when I worked at alt weeklies, it seemed the editorial side was very much like you had that division of the editorial and the advertising. There's actually different wings of the building or the office. And the editorial side, they were very much focused on the reader and the stories jackie: Sure. Nathan Young: and what they're but then yeah, on the advertising side, you were focused on making money. And there was an editor on the editorial side, there's a publisher on the advertising side. And like those two things kinda did their own it was jackie: They took it out and Yeah. Nathan Young: almost like two separate businesses that symbiotic. jackie: Then when you think about it, I think about a video feed where none of that exists, and you just have one person boop. I just feel like we Nathan Young: Yeah. totally, totally. jackie: have lost something crucial. Nathan Young: yeah, for sure, for sure. jackie: But like I guess, like, yeah. So so I guess to me, like this provides opportunities. These Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: sobering stats that I just there's obviously opportunities for independent creators and media makers. People want to make money off of them, obviously. But does is that a good just 'cause it's an opportunity, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: financially, economically, is that a good thing? is it Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: good for society? I don't know. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well, I mean, if I were to ask you, what do you think the closest thing to not necessarily a solution, but just sort of like if we were to choose like one place to really focus a good amount of our energy towards a better jackie: to me the answer is an economic one and it has to be baked into the process somewhere that quality is part of the end product and is something that is valued. And I don't feel like that's where we are anywhere in society with consumer packaged goods or media and I think where this next phase of the internet is hopefully going to mature and the information economy with it is that like As we see more pay-gated things and more AI, obviously, I think you're gonna see like a good internet and a bad internet, like a quality internet and a slop internet. This is not an original thought, but I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: think that that quality internet, what is gonna denote quality is authenticity, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: effort, work, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: and not just not just bellowing that, because I have a lot of followers or I came from the New York Times. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: can be the same thing and also can be diametrically closed, right? Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yes. jackie: where that used to confer authority. Now I think the process of being able to show your authenticity and show your work as a communicator is where the new authority will be conferred from. And I think Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: that that is going to be the big tell for people about whether or not they can trust you or you're worth following or signing up with. And so Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. jackie: I think like the showing your work, which means you have to do the work. So I think that there will be Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: some natural slowing down in this rapid, fast posting Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: information economy because I think audiences on some level, especially especially mature and educated audience like I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: like the type of people who I am sure listening to this podcast, they know that what they're getting is shit. They know that they're being lied to. They know that this is all just like bottom of the barrel entertainment that's subsisting some CEO and its advertisers. Like we know that. And so it's like, what Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: comes next? And I I do think creators, institutions, whatever, whoever, if you are putting information out there on a platform, you will be called on to actually do it well in the future, or you will Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: die and be relegated to slop. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: That may be like a very obvious and baseline prediction, but I actually think it's gonna be harder to achieve than it than it sounds because we have gotten used to just producing and the whole thing of AI Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: is like it look, it just exists. It doesn't need to be good. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. jackie: It's gonna require some slowing down and I don't know that we even have remotely that skill, as a societal whole anymore. Nathan Young: Yeah. yes, and then there's no like perfect answer, right too. It also does sort of put the onus on people that sort of like have the ability or bandwidth and time to like sort of slow down, which I think one of the challenges that's come up, we haven't even talked about this, is just the way that companies like Meta have just sort of siphoned all the money out of the media industry and are getting their reporters for free. As as they're sort of near Yeah, yeah. totally. Mm-hmm. jackie: Did that intentionally. I mean, when you read the internal reports and the things that leak, like they say, we want to change your behavior. We're trying to change your behavior. This is all a Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. jackie: test. Nathan Young: Yeah. so before it news media definitely required somebody that had the ability to work for less or work for free for a couple of years to sort of like work their way up the ladder as a reporter or something like that. So they come from some means. And now that's even more so because they're not even gonna get a sort of minimal salary necessarily starting out unless they can build an audience. And it's it's sort of like jackie: And the and the institution used to they were supposed to provide that audience to you. You were supposed Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: to just go to work, show up, submit your copy, and then go home and they took care of the rest. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. jackie: that's what I say, it seems like this independent creating can be a panacea, but it actually just puts working class medium workers in more chains. Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, it does. But it's also like, well, like this we're here. This is it. Like jackie: And that's why I'm doing I have my my hands in so many pots. and part of that is because I've been forced to try out so many different things and I like a lot of them and I am Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. jackie: good at them, but I also don't know which one's gonna stick. I also Nathan Young: Toilet. jackie: don't know which one is gonna fulfil me long term. I don't know which Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: one offers the best compromise to what I really just wanna be doing, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: which is like honestly writing, reporting and editing. Like sorry, everyone. I'm sorry, Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: I just like kinda wanna do journalism and write some fucking stories. Like I d Sorry. Damn it. Jesus Christ. Nathan Young: Totally. And like and just like you've got a byline and that's it. Like you you turned it in and you get to leave. Yeah. jackie: Now you go to boo boo boo and then you got the comments and the I mean, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: I can't even tell you like real PT, like it just and it makes even people without a huge following, it turns them into punching bags in public and so and that's like a niche problem, that parasociality. I actually I don't think that that's I don't know. It is kind Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: of a big thing. Because then I actually that flows into authenticity and relatability too. So it's like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. That's all there. jackie: you do have to Like you used to just be able to be a grumpy writer and like listen, if you were pretty impersonable, okay, go on. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And you could be you could be grumpy and like you could show up and be grumpy and people would love you for it. And like yeah, yeah. jackie: Yeah, or like whatever. We always knew the TV people were different. And that was okay. That's why there's like a dis like TV people go be happy on camera and then like let Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: the rest of the cigarette smoking ro you know what I mean? and now Nathan Young: Yes. Yeah, yeah. jackie: it's like we all gotta like and I gotta be relatable and this and and it's like Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Yeah. I have just even for myself I have sort of like conflicting things about it too because I doing this podcast, it's fun, but also it's weird that I'm basically doing this to promote other things that I do, and having these conversations. Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: my God, yeah, story of my life. And there's no real ROI ever. And I'm like, but I have to do this and it's part of a larger whole. But like, how also? And Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. jackie: and listen, like my students, again, I teach mostly upper level journalism courses in the undergrad journalism program at state. I just had a whole bunch of students graduate. I taught the multimedia news reporting capstone. So, like, literally, they're off in the world. It's rough. It's rough. And they are super disillusioned and Listen, like state is a Hispanic serving institution. Most of my students are working class and not white. And and most of them are the first in the in their families to go to college, which I was as well. And so I think there is still this myth of like, it's starting to fall out and people know it, but college, the American dream, if you do this, there will be something waiting for you on the other side. And I I think some of those kids were Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: too late on the track to really subvert it, but like they are ending up in careers that don't really exist anymore. And it's an ethical question for me too. how do I make peace with teaching this, knowing that there's not a lot on the other end for them right now? And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: the way that I make peace with it is I say, Well, you you are taught valuable skills that you can use in another arena. Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: And also like critical thinking is a valuable skill. So that's ultimately how I make peace with it. But I have to admit, I'm partially teaching because I'm dissatisfied with Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: the lack of media jobs out there and the type of media jobs out there. And so it's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. jackie: it's partially an off ramp for me. And so It feels like a hamster wheel to nowhere. Like I'm teaching this Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: thing that I know they can't get jobs and they're doing and then what if just to end up a teacher like me to teach more kids who can't get jobs. And so it's a real conundrum Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: and and they are really feeling it. But it's interesting they also obviously feel called to journalism and to this work more strongly than ever, probably perhaps because they are mostly non-white, mostly first generation college students, mostly working class, they do Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: want to report on their communities and the people around them. And they still believe that that's not happening. And so Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: it's a real earnest moral and social imperative that my students have Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: versus like a real inability to find a path to get started on. And so Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: like that's kind of what I'm dealing with now with this young cohort. Nathan Young: No. jackie: And yeah, some of the only advice I have for them is okay, when you graduate and you continue your barista job, yeah, maybe you should start a sub stack, maybe you can freelance, maybe you should Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: start a podcast or do video reels. and it's kind of how I did it. these kids can't be paying for a degree and then that's ultimately the ad advice that they get, right? So that's really where I get stuck. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well, yeah, yeah. Well, at some level too, 'cause this is the challenge of institutions that are always gonna be a little bit behind changes and part of what we're dealing with is jackie: yes. Nathan Young: the a disruption has happened. All these media companies have disrupted everything. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: Academia too, struggling for relevancy, struggling to justify, because we told everybody, you need a degree to get a job, and now we don't have enough jobs, so everybody's Nathan Young: Yeah, exactly. But so it does sound like you are like updating your curriculum though to really sort of like try to prepare them as best you can and like keeping yourself informed. Yeah, yeah. jackie: Yeah, always. I love it. And I try to I'm very honest with them and I tell them what's out there, how I did it. My husband had he's a journalist as well, had a very traditional path. He went to Columbia Journalism School and he's always been at publications, whereas I was intentionally a freelancer. So between Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: us we have a good view of the world. Obviously, like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: we always caveat we are white. we can afford our student loans, this, that, whatever. we sort of give all of we let them know how we came up, the privileges that we had that we didn't have, the opportunities we had. I never really had formal mentorship, for example. and so I think between our two careers, we represent a wide swath of media experiences, just because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: we both had so many. And so that's really valuable for them. But we are honest. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: I think it's off putting For some students. I do especially maybe some of the higher achievers who will get whatever job is out there and they're kinda like the valedictorian type. it's just really hard to talk about this stuff, honestly, right now. You're gonna you're gonna Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: offend somebody. because everybody will have a different experience. To me, that just shows how broken it all is. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I was gonna say we're kinda got a good got a good spot to like things up. we get that a positive note in here. Yeah, yeah. jackie: Yeah, I can talk about so much. There's so much I feel like I only half touch on and I promise I have so many more deeper and nuanced thoughts, but Nathan Young: totally. Well, let me ask you this. I always like to ask the magic wand question. And I think it's like it's kind of a tough question with media because there's just so many factors coming in of who's making it, who's controlling the distribution, who's reading what, and how are people reading it? But to the degree that like you had a magic wand over this, what would you do with it? You could cast one spell, what would be that spell? jackie: God, I really just don't know, but I'm tempted, and I don't know if this is just nostalgia. So if this is not an ideologically perfect answer, nobody get mad at me. But like Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. jackie: 90s magazine culture. I think I think that's where I want to live. There was Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: a fucking magazine for everything, dude. And like everything, Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: like every little niche subculture this, there was no mass internet yet. There was no social. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: I do think the internet is a bad thing. I actually do think it's a bad Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: thing. The internet was started by the D O J. it was not. I don't Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. jackie: even get me started on that rabbit hole. That's like a whole other conspiracy Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: theory podcast we could talk about. But like I actually don't think the internet's a great thing. But back then it was very limited. There was no social media. So Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: you had more exposure, more ideas. one could argue in the United States was the peak of kinda neo liberal Clintonian globalization, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: prosperity before it all kind of got would inevitably be kneecapped if you ask me. I think it was inevitable, but so Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: there was this largesse that when there is cultural largesse and there is money, media gets funded. Magazines Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: pop up. we have things we need to do. When you have excess, there are things there like a gas, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: it f it will expand to fill the shape, right? and so we had such a healthy media environment. The economy was healthier. so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: i I mean, there's so many other things that were wrong w with that time. I'm Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: not lionizing the nineties in any way, like socially Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. jackie: or anything, please believe. But the magazine Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: culture was healthy, but it also represented a healthy liberal democracy, I think, behind Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: it that was well capitalized, but that was also espousing. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. jackie: certain views that were just palatable. Like it's the nineties, we're having fun, we're out there, we're kicking ass. the communists are down. it really was Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. jackie: of this, if not actual abundance in American society, then the perception Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: of it. And that flows right through to media. I mean, like the vibes, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: they are the same, one Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: of the same. So if I had a magic wand, because I like physical media. Again, I I am a fan of slowing down. I do Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. jackie: think we have too much at our fingertips, too many inputs, too much stimulus. So I am inclined to think that analog is just like healthier for our brains. So Nathan Young: Mm. jackie: that's why it's that abundance, I guess. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: the fact that you could only make media in certain ways produce so much of one kind that happens to be slow, I guess to me, those are Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: like some ideal conditions. Nathan Young: Yeah. That is interesting. I think about like 'cause yeah, magazines back then too, I was in my early twenties. So the magazines were late teens, early twenties, like late nineties. So I was maxim and those kind of magazines were like every every dude had a subscription to those. But it was interesting jackie: Yeah, totally. I mean totally. Nathan Young: because they would it'd be a mix of like goofy funny things and then there'd be a feature article that was usually pretty serious. There'd be a celebrity interview. There'd be recipes. There'd be clothing tips. And it was all kind of like all in like one thing. So 'cause now that yeah, my social media is like Gaza, Gaza. Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. jackie: But this is where you got that from. There's nowhere Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: else to get that from unless you were like in the mall or in a city and you like saw it or in a st you know what I mean? this is where you had those conversations and where you got Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah, yeah. jackie: that from. And so I am such a simp for magazines because they were this and more so the newspapers cause they had the visual component. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. jackie: this is where culture coalesced or was digested. it wasn't where culture Nathan Young: mm-hmm. jackie: happened in its initial Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: form, but it's where we talked about it. And so, Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: God, that's a soapbox. I mean, that's a soapbox. It's so pivotal, right? I got you there. I I'm sorry you were like, Whoa, how are we gonna do this? But I got you. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, it's a soapbox. Soapbox. Full circle. Full circle. You did it. We did it. We did it. Okay, cool. We're calling it then. This is it. This is the end. We're doing it. all right. Well, Jackie, thank you so much for coming on. And then so people that want to hear more from you, where can they go? What can they do? jackie: Bless you, first of all. I am on Instagram, totally fineable, J A C Q B R Y. I I've been like kinda not I've been kinda like just having a hermit summer. I'm having an analog hermit summer. Nathan Young: That's fine. jackie: I co-host the Happy Half Hour podcast with Troy Johnson at San Diego magazine's restaurant podcast. Nathan Young: cool. jackie: been doing that for many years now. I teach at San Diego State. I am well known on the the cannabis reporting beats. So if you pop into cannabis Nathan Young: Yeah, okay. Is that jackie: media, you will certainly find me there. and then I pop up in travel media, local media here and Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: there. and I have some cannabis client work. So I I'm in sort of like a again, a hermit state of my career, but I pop out now and then. Nathan Young: That's fine. Like does yeah, yeah. Yeah. Well I'll put links in the show notes and God, we didn't even talk about the whole cannabis thing 'cause that's like whole there's a ton going on there, but all right, whatever. All right, fine. Fuck it. Okay, interesting. jackie: Yeah. Honestly, I'm sick of talking about it. It it was supposed to be legal now. It's not. We're all still sitting here saying legal and and then our heads are falling off. That's the TL. I think the two worst industries Nathan Young: Okay. it's yeah, that jackie: to work in, like like genuinely weedy and weed Nathan Young: I know. Media is like jackie: I is I mean one of them's not even legal. So and the other's probably Nathan Young: Yeah. jackie: about to not become legal anymore. So you know. Nathan Young: All right. Yeah, here we are. all right, well, Jackie, thanks for coming on and really appreciate it. And yeah, we'll jackie: Thank you for having me. Nathan Young: talk again soon. All right, thanks so much to Jackie Bryant for joining us on the podcast here today. I've been thinking a lot about the this conversation in the in the week since we've had it, and especially about like the value and limitations of institutions, especially institutions in media. And I still don't have any good answers. It really does seem to me that media institutions that's sort of like the center of our conflicts where a lot of folks are really going to have some extreme trusts and believe one thing while completely distrusting and disbelieving in another thing. It's sort of like tend to tend to like really overvalue the institutions or completely disavow them. Whereas the reality I think is we just have to have a more of a middle ground approach towards them with all media. Like there's gotta be some trust and skepticism and and understanding a little bit of where they come from because these mis media institutions, they are businesses, right? And the same way so many other things in our world are, they have motivations that align with maintaining a institutional status quo that benefits them. And that's gonna color the news that they're reporting. And maybe not necessarily specific wording or ways they'll they'll go for a story, but like it'll cover like which kind of stories they do go after. And it'll cover where they put reporters and it will inform like which reporters are hired and the base point of view that these reporters bring into their job and that's gonna trickle down into the media that we receive too. But even within all that These media institutions do often add a lot of valuable news and information to our ecosystem. We just have to learn how to better parse it. And I know for some that's a tough line to toe, and I get why media literacy can be just something that a lot of people don't really think about and don't really worry about and don't really acknowledge in their life. But at the same time, I really wish there was just like something that more of us understood about our world. So I'd love to hear your thoughts about this episode. What stood out to you? What do you think about media literacy? And if you want to follow Jackie, you can read her work or check out the podcast and newsletter that she's mentioned. We'll have links to all that in the show notes. And if this conversation made you think differently about where your information comes from and what your information is informed by, send this to somebody you think would also want to have this conversation. You can also subscribe to Braver New Worlds wherever you're listening to your podcast. And just Stay tuned for the next episode. All right. Thanks so much, y'all. Have a good night. And we'll see you on the next episode of Braver New Worlds.