Latest / Ego and Other Things / The Moral Pursuit and It's Costs
Transcript
- William: I'm out for a walk this morning. And I've got the the embryo of a question brewing in my mind that definitely isn't fully developed even the question, never mind the answer. But I wanted to give it a shot today. I wanted to give it a shot at trying to figure out even what the question is, and then maybe a shot at answering it as well. It's question that's come up again and again. in my life as a Christian, but even I would say before I became a Christian, it has to do with morality. It has to do with the notion of once you understand what is right and what is wrong, once you have come to the conviction of what you ought to do, To live a good life, what the good life looks like. To what extremes do you go? To live that kind of life. What do you give up for the sake of that life? And this question has come up again just out of re listening to this novel by Leo Tolstoy called Resurrection. Now Tolstoy is is great for this kind of for probing this kind of question. because I don't know how much people know outside of his his more famous novels like War and Peace and Anna Karenia, but Leo Tolstoy was well he would consider well, people have considered him a a Christian anarchist, though whether he was a Christian or not is debatable because He didn't actually believe in the divinity of Christ, nor is it necessarily clear whether he believed in God. But he took the moral teachings at the very least of Christ very seriously. Though I don't think he took the Bible to be the infallible perfect word of God. oftentimes in his works like my religion and the kingdom of god is within you, he would reference Paul, for instance, as somebody who had perverted the the teachings of Christ and brought the church in a direction that Christ didn't intend it to be. So he wouldn't take the writings of Paul, for example, as as the inspired word of God. And I'm not even entirely sure if he would take every every statement that Christ had made as as At least every statement that Christ had made in the Word of God to be True, he would probably if something that Christ said came against his own understanding of morality, he would say perhaps that that had been manipulated by by the people who wrote the gospels. I think this would be his kind of attitude towards it. I think what he saw in Christ's moral teaching was perhaps the most morally perfect teaching that the world had ever seen. And he would take, you know, commands like Commands like do not resist evil, and he would take that to its logical conclusion and apply that something to like the state or government, and rejected the state because the state was an entity, still is an entity, that violates not only the commit the the teachings of Christ, but the Ten Commandments. And he would take something like Paul's insistence to respect authority in Romans 13 as, well, basically a perversion of Christ's teachings. Now, to be perfectly clear, I also consider myself to be a Christian anarchist, but I don't take Tolstoy's line. I believe in the infallible perfect word of God. I believe that every every word written in the in the scripture is is perfectly true, but at the same time, I recognize the fact that human beings are limited, sinful, fallen, broken, and that our interpretation of the of the word is limited, broken, sinful. We are imperfect people trying to understand a perfect word. And insofar as we arrive at the truth. of that word that is by the grace of God and it is by the grace of God that we get faith, that we get assurance of that which is necessary for salvation. But many of the things within the word that are not related to necessarily salvation, are are misinterpreted. And this is why this is actually what you would expect, you would expect sinful people to break into a thousand different denominations based on different interpretations of the word. And this has nothing to do with the perfection of the word. It says everything to do with the imperfection of man. But the basics of salvation are are are universally accepted by the faithful. But you know I would look at something like Romans 13 as a misinterpretation of what Paul is what Paul is talking about there as sort of a blanket approval of state force and violence. Whereas I think if you you look at the surrounding chapters, you compare it to other other instances where we're we're taught to taught to obey authority like in I believe John, second John maybe. there's other books that talk about obeying masters, obeying slaves obeying their masters, wives obeying their husbands, other situations in which people are talking about obeying the state. But I think all this can be all this can be related to The trials that God gives us in order to perfect us, as James talks about. So God, a as Paul talked about in Romans thirteen, God gives rulers to us in our lives, for our own good. But not because the rulers themselves are good, not because they're necessarily appointed by God or morally approved by God, but they they represent opportunities to embody Christ's love. And I think that makes more sense, even just in the historical context of what we're talking about there, because of course, I don't think God would morally approve of the Roman state slaughtering Christians or of the German state slaughtering Jews. Or any of these s kinds of things. Nor do I think God would approve of masters owning slaves and or husbands ruling over their their wives. Because of course this wasn't this was not the case in the garden. this is not reflected in every image that we get about heaven, and we're not supposed to have any other master but Christ. But the fact is that human beings corrupt one another. The the The fact is that human beings lord over each other, they be they place themselves as masters over people. And Christians, the question is as a Christian, how should you respond to being enslaved, right? How how should you respond to being under the power or dominion of a violent and evil state? How as a woman should you respond to the violence With the domination of your husband. And Christ says, do not resist evil. Christ says, Love your neighbor as yourself. And that's actually radical. That's closer to the kind of radical message of universal love that Christ was talking about. And we can get in more detail about that whole idea a different time. The point is to say that and get really getting back to the spirit of what I was talking about here. Tolstoy took a very hard line when it came to the moral commands that were given to us by Jesus and by by God. And he wrestled most of his life with how to live those things out. And how to live those things out, even though it was very difficult and practical to do so. So Tolstoy was. a count. He had land, he had serfs, I believe, or peasants or something like that. And according to what he read in the word, this was immoral. And so he spent much of his later life trying to live a a sort of more simple Christian life. He renounced the state, he renounced the Orthodox Church, he tried to renounce his lands and his possessions and his wealth, which he believed he had gotten he had gotten through immoral or evil ways, sinful ways, he had tried to morally perfect himself in his life by going to the extreme. out of his understanding of what was right and what was wrong based on on Christian teachings. And I think many of the many of the people that I admire, at least in my reading, including Jesus himself, but also people like Jonas Kortruck, Benjamin Leigh, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, many of these kinds of people are people who took a stand on a moral a moral issue. Soltsenitschen as well, Victor Frankel. These were people who took a stance on a moral issue. And they were willing to follow the consequence in the costs of that of that moral standing, moral issue to the extreme. So I could take Benjamin Lay as an example here. Benjamin Lay was a Quaker, hunchback Quaker. And he was one of the first, if not the first, Quaker abolitionists in the United States to take a stand against slavery. And he faced tremendous opposition from the other Quakers of his time. But not only did he go to the extent of I mean he would go to Quaker meetings at the at the threat of ostracism and hatred and abuse. And he would go to these meetings and he would rail against the evils of slavery. He went so far as to live in a cave, sew his own, make his own clothes, and grow his own food, so that he could be entirely detached from the evil institute of slavery. He didn't want to have any he didn't want to have any products that had anything to do with slave labor. and he spent his entire life doing that. He wasn't educated necessarily. All he had was the word of God. He wrote a book condemning slavery. And he spent most of his life doing this with no little to no visible traction coming out of his efforts. Little to no evidence that what he was doing was actually changing the minds of the people around him. It was only near the end of his life that A new generation of Quakers, sort of younger generation of Quakers, came up and read his book and were familiar with him and began the the abolitionist movement that would later come out of the Quakers, that the Quakers are often are often known for. But I mean it's it's little known that at the at the time in the beginning, that these Quakers were as much for the institution of slavery as any other religious institution. And so it wasn't necessarily even the Quaker belief or practice or whatnot that that would that helped to create the abolitionist movement through Quakerism. It was in many ways Benjamin Leigh, the single individual who took a moral stance on this Went out of his way in in an extreme way, to live his life in opposition to the institution of slavery. And it was by that demonstration, and then by the Methodist movement, the Methodist abolitionist movement that was coming out of England, that you really had that you had the ultimately you had abolition come to the United States. Which is fascinating to me. I mean it's you know, I mean, talk about a person who gave up all comfort to gave all yeah, gave up all comfort, gave up all social standing, gave up all necessarily relationships, for the sake of what he knew was wrong, and persisted in this his his entire life with no no assurance except from God Himself that this is gonna matter. this was gonna change anything. I mean, it could have j very well have just turned out that he died in obscurity and the slavery and the institution of slavery continue on. I mean, at the very least it looked like that was going to happen, through his lifetime. but it was only because of that he him him pushing through that that he was able to stand up against this and and and really again begin that abolitionist movement really on almost on his own. Anything about Jesus. I mean talk you know, talk about a person who of course this is God here, but talk about a person who comes comes earth, lives a the morally perfect life, and you know, he doesn't even have the luxury of being opposed his entire ministry, right? He has to experience the well, the wellspring of support for him and his ministry and what he's doing. Living and teaching in this incredibly incredibly radical way for his time, a way that is so radical that today We still marvel at his kinds of teachings, right? You know, give to everyone who asks. You know, don't even even hating somebody in your heart is a sin. Lusting after somebody in your heart is a sin. you know, do not resist evil. When you d when you take many of Christ's commands and you you follow them to their logical conclusions, it feels like an impossible mountain to climb. And yet Christ not only lived this way, he taught this way, he he had the the groundswell of support from the people for a time. And then everybody turned on him, right? Not just the people, but even his own friends. Even his closest friend Peter denied him, turned away from him. And he was entirely isolated and mocked and whipped and hated, spat at. And hung on a cross to suffer and die for all of humanity. For all of humanity. And he suffered this like a man would, like a man would. Though he was God, he was also a man. And suffered this like a man would. And none of us, I mean, none of I I certainly couldn't do this kind of I I certainly couldn't do that kind of live that kind of life. And he took it to the extreme. He took it to the extreme of Of crucifixion and death. Not just isolation, not just the hard life of trying to live a morally or living a morally perfect life. He took the the extreme of living that life and all the hardships that endured because they'd have to beg and and they'd have to you know, procure their own food. They were traveling all the time, they had very little money or support. they're out there caring For all these people, Jesus was out there every day trying to help people, praying for them, casting out demons, healing the sick, feeding the poor. So not only living the difficult life, but then dying for those principles. Dying for that. And just another I mean it's a supreme example. That's where every other example really points to is what Jesus did for us. But it's that same thing of sacrifice for the sake of of a moral principle, sacrifice for the sake of what is right. So many of the people I admire the most, including Tolstoy, because Tolstoy did this himself to a degree, though he struggled, as any individual would. all the people that I admire so much. are exactly the kinds of people that did this. The exactly the kind of people that took a stand for a moral principle that cost them. That cost them. And I think often times. I'm nowhere near doing that. And I want and I struggle internally over what what should I do? You know, I I I understand the state as being fundamentally evil. And yet I do not do everything I can to resist the violence of the state. I think that wealth is a corrupting factor, but I still live pretty comfortably in in my home. I mean I spend money on things I really don't need. That could be going to somebody who actually needs it. You know, on on my own luxuries, on coffee or diet soda or you know, some sort of snack or a new book, even though I have books to read, or you know, so many kinds of things. So much I waste so much even though I think that one should do everything that they can. use every resource that that they have to help the people around them. I reject force and violence on principle, but I still willingly participate in a force and in a force-based violence society. Ostracism is something that that frightens me. I think I've gotten better and braver at voicing what I really think and speaking up when I see something that is wrong. But there have been so many moments in my life where I have, you know, tuck-tail and run, where I've kept silent, where I haven't voiced what I thought, where I've been scared, I've been a I've been a coward when it comes to standing up to my own for my own moral principles. So often I turned away from them because I mean quite literally because it's frightening. Quite literally because it is so inconvenient. Quite literally because in some corner of my life I've been I've been captured by the seduction of the world. Right? I I like my little luxuries. I like my free time. I like my leisure. I like The things that this world provides for me. And it's hard to let them go. Even if I know it's r not right to to hold on to them. Even though I know I could be doing more. But then the question comes back. I don't know. I don't even know if this is the devil. This is the thing. The question comes back, wouldn't this I mean, wouldn't you get burnt out, right? Wouldn't you collapse under the weight of trying to be morally perfect? Isn't it isn't it pride to be to try to be morally perfect? Isn't it pride to try to you know live the the morally perfect life? Can you even know what that is? Even with the word, can you even know what that is? Would you not fail at that? I mean that's the words that get spoken to my head. And again, you look at examples like Tolstoy, right? He he well, he he didn't he he sort of inflicted harm on his family in a lot of ways, distressed his wife, certainly, for what he was doing. died, I think, on a train trying to go live with the peasants or something like that. out of the sense of simplicity, and just died doing that. You know, it caused a lot of turmoil for the people around him. But there's a question like Is it right to cause turmoil for the people around you for the sake of a moral principle? For the sake of what you know to be right? And I don't know necessarily what the answer is. What I know is that I'm afraid of the answer being yes because of how much it would cost. I'm afraid of the answer being yes because of how it might distress the people around me. I'm afraid of the answer yes because I worry that people are gonna look at me and think of me as some sort of a freak, as deranged, as crazy, as misguided as unintelligent and ignorant as impractical as someone to be ignored and pushed aside and those all those things frighten me because i actually you know i actually like people right and i want to be accepted by people and i want to have close friendships and i want to have you know people around around me I want my my my family and my wife to respect and love me. I mean these are all not that I would lose their love for really anything, but these are all things which which I think everybody wants. And everybody craves. Everybody craves and there's especially when you know trying to be morally perfect distresses the people around you. That's that's when the tension becomes the most acute. You go back in your s forth in yourself and go, What what is more important? What is more important? The moral principle or Or I don't know, keeping the peace in one sense. And then you also have to worry about, okay, well, how do I know this is the right moral principle? I mean, I think about something like the Westboro Baptist Church, how they they are for one reason or another convinced that that going out and spewing hate towards homosexuals or people of other faiths or other churches. just spewing vitrail at them is the way is the is the moral the moral way, right? That that's the that's the way that God has commanded them to go. And they are so convinced of that that they are willing to to pay the costs. Right? I mean they're willing to go out there and be hated. They're willing to to have things thrown at them, to have you know bomb threats sent against them, to be hated by the whole world. be sued time and time again, they welcome they welcome it proudly, because they they are trying to be morally consistent or morally perfect. Now I don't know if that's truly what they're trying to do or whether there's just a tremendous amount of of How do put it? A tremendous amount of trauma, generational trauma, abuse, and the cult like enclosure. And perhaps one of the ways that you actually balance this moral this attempt to be morally perfect with with or I I don't even like the idea of trying to be morally perfect, because none of the heroes that I've that I was describing, none of them were morally perfect people. It's not so much that they were trying to be morally perfect. And in fact, with Tolstoy, the most perverse thing was that he was trying to morally perfect himself, and there's this kind of like self-obsession with it. That and that part I I resist because that does seem to be prideful. That does seem to be, you know, well, the goodness is about is about me. It's for me, not for other people. And I think the real The real thrust of morality or taking a stand for a moral principle is something which doesn't have to do with you, really. you take a stand because you know that a world the world would be a better place for other people because you because of this moral stand that you're taking. people of the Westboro Baptist Church, I think they're thoroughly convinced that they have to do what they're doing in order to be saved. that if they don't go out there and hurl abuses at people, that this means like I don't know, God will accuse them of of I don't know, impiety or something like that and cast them into hell. So you a lot of time of course the what they're not they're they're motivated by fear. They're not motivated by love of other people, they're motivated by fear. Whereas I think if you're going to make a moral stand, it better be about the people, right? In some fashion. And I think the the other thing that that traps them is this enclosure. They try to cut themselves off from the people around them, the different thoughts and perspectives and ideas and whatnot. They refuse to learn, right? They think they have the one understanding of the word, and so they fail to recognize that they are broken people who are susceptible to error or susceptible to arrogance and pride. And so they refuse to do any sort of real self-examination on that part. In fact, I think they train themselves not to self-examine. And I think if you're gonna take up a moral principle, you have to be willing to self examine, you have to be willing to see to work it out for yourself. You have to be able to see, okay, is this is this moral principle I guess worth the cost? You know, ask yourself in a world where this moral principle was was true, would that be something I'd be willing to to live for and to die for? I think Benjamin Nalay does this with slavery. He he understands that God's kingdom is not a kingdom of slavery. God's kingdom is not a kingdom of oppression. It's a kingdom of free, freely loving God, freely obeying his commands. Clearly knowing him. And that's what that's what heaven is about, right? And he knows that slavery is not a part of God's kingdom. with a real conviction. And regardless of how the people around him how the people around him react, he knows that he is willing to he knows that he is willing to put up with the hatred of the world. For the sake of those people who are being oppressed, for the sake of a world in which they are free, for the sake of a world that is actually akin to God's kingdom and our real display of his love. But he's not hiding himself. I mean I I I guarantee you that he would be willing and open to have every kind of conversation about what he was doing. Morning. as As people would be willing to to speak with him about that. Whereas you look at somebody like Fred Phelps, for example, the patriarch of the the Westboro Baptist Church, he is famous for refusing to speak to people about his church, about what he actually believes, about actually getting into biblical I don't know, what the Bible actually says, because he knows that it would expose him. So It's all driven by fear. It's all driven by hiding. It's all driven by hatred. And if you're going to take a stand for a moral principle, it has to be about other people. It has to be about love. It has to be about Bringing in God's kingdom kingdom meaning you know, knowing knowing that this that who we are and what this world is right now is not what God has intended it to be. By any stretch. By any stretch. Still the cost is scary. Still the costs can be intimidating. And I in my life I've been kind of trying to edge myself into it. I mean, as an atheist again, I trying to edge myself into it. But now, even as a Christian, the the the pressure seems almost stronger. I think about Jesus' command to give to everyone who asks. And I think, well, what if you actually followed that? I mean, if I gave If I gave to everybody who asked, you know, I think, what would I have for myself? What would I have for my wife? What would I have for my family? And it's it's scary. You know, do I even have the right to give to everyone who asks when for instance I share resources with my wife? It seems like such an extreme such an extreme Thing because it is. Anything about the command, do not resist evil. I mean, what does that mean? What does that mean? In one sense, I'd be willing to, if someone attacked me, I'd be willing to you know take the beating or whatever and not resist, not resist the violence. But if someone attacked my child or my wife or my friend, I mean, do I have am I supposed to sit there and just throw my hands up? And say I'm not going to resist evil, right? And does that command extend to something like speaking out against the evil of the state or the evil of the people? Am I supposed to just remain silent with that? Do I not have a responsibility to my family, right? Someone's going to kill me. Do I not have a responsibility to fight back to save my own life for the sake of my wife or my family? Or do I do what's written in the word and not resist evil? And then all ties into the question of like, well, am I trying to be am I trying by my own efforts to be morally perfect, or am I allowing the spirit to to perfect me? But then I wonder, is that just a thought from the enemy, right? And an enemy who does not want me to pursue righteousness, that does not want me to be a disciple of Jesus, is not so it fills me with these fears and doubts about the consequences of falling God's moral law. And wouldn't it be a greater act of faith to follow these commands as consistently as I could and depend on God completely to To provide me with the things that I needed or to rescue me in those moments of attack. And the answer is I don't know. The answer is I don't know. Every every figure in the Bible seems to have been to have been a person who followed God's commands and was obedient to his word, regardless of the cost to himself. Sometimes regardless of the cost to the to his immediate family and the people around him, which is what really is. And one sense frightening or overwhelming about that. The word itself seems to say take the risk. And it's those stories that again speak the most to me. Benjamin Lay sacrifices the comfort of his life, sacrifices the comfort of social acceptance for the sake of living out God's law. Dietrich Bonhoeffer refuses to go along with the Church of Germany and opposes Hitler and the Nazis and dies for. Jesus lives the perfect, righteous life, despite the fact that he could have been the most powerful man in all of the earth. Rather, he goes to the cross, he takes the crown of thorns, he suffers, he dies, he's betrayed by everybody he knows, mocked, humiliated, hated. Because he was obedient to God's commands. Jonas Korchuk. The king of children, right? The the one who stood against culture of his time that disrespected children, one and all that that treated them like objects, like less than human beings. This man not only spends his entire life helping these people at tremendous cost to himself, running himself ragged, And order to give these children what they need, learning how to write children's stories for them. When he could have you know, he could have gone off and been a doctor, made a bunch of money, lived an easy life. No, he starts an orphanage for these children. And he takes the risk to help to teach them autonomy and gets creative with the children's court and all these all these things. And then at the end, when when the Nazis send these children off to a concentration camp, and Janis Korchuk has a choice whether to flee, he had a real chance to flee and to live, to save his own life, what does he choose instead? He chooses to go die with the children. He goes and chooses to die with these children for the sake of comforting them. Just for not to say not to rescue them, but to comfort them. And says, you do not abandon children in their greatest hour of need. I I look at these people and I go, Am I capable of that? I want to be I want to be capable of something like that. Even Tolstoy even Tolstoy as imperfect as he was, as perhaps separated from from the true gospel message as he was, he tried to live The good life as he saw it. And he took on real costs and real ostracism because of it. Was willing to struggle his own his whole life over the over the question. And I I feel myself struggling with that. And I wonder. Well, I wonder what it is what what the answer is. But I fear that the answer is is hard, right? I feel like there is not an easy answer. I feel as though the I fear as though the answer actually is yes, it's difficult, it's costly, it's gonna hurt, people are going to reject you, you're going to lose things that you think are important to you. Yes, the moral life, at least trying to live a moral life, is costly. Dangerous, risky. Because you see it in the in the lives of all these people. Do it anyway. Right? I I experienced a little of this when I do the street preaching where you you go out there, you share the gospel with people and a lot of people are not happy about it. The other day I think I got a cup of soda thrown at me. Thankfully I missed, but there are plenty of people I tell them, Yes, I'm I do street evangelism and they look at me like I'm crazy. that's before I mean that that's other Christians, right, doing that. or I mentioned that I'm doing it and they you know, they find an excuse to go somewhere else, which is fine, you know, I can kinda handle that. But that's just the beginning of the cost of trying to live a moral life. So I don't know, I I still wrangle with this, I still struggle with this on a day-to-day basis. And all I can do right now really is is ask God to give me the wisdom, ask Jesus to give me the the wisdom and the ability. To embrace that risk, embrace that cost. Give me the strength and I don't know. Well I do know, and one thing I do know is that God is with me, regardless. Jesus is is with me regardless. I know that he's in control. And my life will go as he's ordained it for me. And that way, maybe I should just step out in confidence. Step out in confidence that Jesus is guiding me the whole way. And even if something feels risky to me or difficult to me. If I just follow him, regardless of my own imperfections, regardless of my own sin, regardless of my own weakness. He will see me through. And at the end of the day, this life is short, it's temporary, it it's nothing. And if I if what I do Can be an inspiration to other people. If what I do through the power of Jesus can be an inspiration to other people in the same way that these people have been an inspiration to me. I mean, these people led me to Jesus even before I was a Christian and have continued to strengthen me. And so if I can do that then Again, if I can do that by the power of God, by the power of Jesus, 'cause I I certainly don't feel as though I have it within myself. But if I could do that by the power of Jesus. And well I pray that he would enable me. Because all the struggle and the strife of this life is nothing compared to the eternity of heaven. But what I do through Jesus' power may guide somebody to Christ. And maybe that's enough. Maybe that's enough to do it anyway. Maybe that's enough to take the risk. But anyway. You made it this far, I I appreciate you you listening as I try to formulate and answer that that question. if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think this video would help somebody else, maybe, and please share it with them. If you want more videos like this, then please subscribe. And as always, thank you guys for listening.