Latest / Newcomer Pod / 100 Percent Ethereum (w/ Daniel Liss)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome Tom is here at my apartment in Brooklyn because I
- 0:17think he's doing sort of Insider stuff and taking tourist
- 0:20meetings and he needed the real Mike set up.
- 0:23So my girlfriend who's a video producer has him with all her
- 0:27camera mics set up, but he's in the same room.
- 0:30Is me, and I feel like he's, he's dealing with a sort of
- 0:33dystopian sound overlay. So, we're gonna see how that
- 0:38comes out. And then we're here with Daniel
- 0:41list who is the CEO of dispo but we are equally excited that he's
- 0:47been deep in nft World in this last week for NYC and ft and so
- 0:53we want to talk about that sort of building on the metaverse
- 0:57conversation from last week and yeah.
- 1:00I'm excited for Daniel to play a little bit of tour.
- 1:03Guide in nft World. Daniel like what?
- 1:07How deep how deep into the world of nft.
- 1:11Sorry, right. Would you consider yourself a
- 1:13Believer or where? Give us the sort of where you
- 1:17stand right now? I'm a I'm, you know, as the
- 1:20people I don't have see. NYC would say, I've taken the
- 1:22red pill. I'm absolutely a Believer but I
- 1:26think the caveat and we'll walk through it.
- 1:29I'm sure but You have to believe as an operator and someone
- 1:32leading a company that this is what you're in.
- 1:34I'm building a social media company.
- 1:36With my team, we have to believe that this is what our community
- 1:40wants, if our community doesn't want it, right?
- 1:41And we're trying to skate to where the puck is going and
- 1:44build a once-in-a-generation company.
- 1:45Then we shouldn't be using this technology.
- 1:48There's a lot about this promising.
- 1:49There's a lot about it. That's really frightening.
- 1:52So I think we'll get into that Tom, you.
- 1:54Good, tell me about the most red pill person you met at the
- 1:57convention so far like you're somewhere in the It all you're
- 2:00buying it but you still need to be convinced like, how who's the
- 2:04most fucked up person you met in this in this conference?
- 2:10I wouldn't put it that way but the person who the biggest
- 2:12believer. So I was at the fun part of this
- 2:15week is he was just dinners parties activities coffees.
- 2:19It was an incredible social week and you know, for me who, you
- 2:23know, we started this company a year and a half ago, we have not
- 2:26been doing these social networking events and no pun.
- 2:29Intended. And so it was just a rush of
- 2:33human interaction activity, you know, with vaccination cards and
- 2:35mass and safety protocols. But I was at one of these
- 2:38dinners and an investor throughout a question, to all
- 2:43the founders and CEOs in attendance and the question was
- 2:47your portfolio, your personal Investment Portfolio right now?
- 2:51What is the allocation? And I said, okay, I think it
- 2:57would be, you know, I'm 33. I'm risk on A lot of my net
- 3:00worth is tied up in the equity of our company but for of my
- 3:04liquid assets, I would put 75 percent in the Vanguard S&P 500
- 3:10ETF. I would do ten percent in bonds,
- 3:13maybe if I'm being aggressive, you know, of the remaining 15%
- 3:17seven and a half in cash, seven and a half across.
- 3:21Bitcoin is here, IAM in Solana, right?
- 3:24And the guy sitting next to me goes, 100% etherium.
- 3:32Deadpan. Look in his eyes like I did not
- 3:38know what I was talking about that.
- 3:39I was an alien of some sort right.
- 3:41And maybe I am and I understand looking at that man's net worth
- 3:47that it has quintuple. You know, gone up 50 acts.
- 3:51I don't know when he bought right.
- 3:53If he bought in 27 at the bottom of the last cycle, you know, if
- 3:58you know I was at a meeting with buying Is, you know, one of the
- 4:01most senior people there and 12% of their Volume last week was in
- 4:05Shiba Inu, right? So the world in which were
- 4:08living the volatility of the assets, I'm even in a world
- 4:12where in the public markets Peloton can go down two thirds
- 4:15in less than a year, right? But in, you know, the Bitcoin
- 4:19world or just the cryptocurrency world, the volatility of the
- 4:22world in which we are living is shocking amazing.
- 4:26Incomprehensible to the average average.
- 4:29Joe Oh, but it's still exciting and I think, you know, we
- 4:32haven't gone into it, but there is real utility to the
- 4:35technology that was not necessarily there in 2017.
- 4:37So if you're serious about building a company, particularly
- 4:41in the gaming and social world, you have to be looking at this
- 4:44incredibly intensely but it's so it won't get to sort of the use
- 4:48cases and with this phone when you're thinking about, but just
- 4:51like the people part of this story first like so how did you
- 4:54even? I feel like the nft NYC
- 4:57conference sort of came on to my Twitter.
- 4:59Feed all of a sudden or like I was clearly not ready to flee.
- 5:03Like right, did you? Are you where are you based?
- 5:06When did you realize this was coming in?
- 5:08Like why did you decide to go? And then you said, it's like, is
- 5:12it mostly like going to panels? Or is it mostly going to dinners
- 5:15around it or like what is the conference as sort of a start-up
- 5:19CEO going to this thing? Great question.
- 5:21So I first of all just interest in cryptocurrency, I would call
- 5:26myself a web to lot of. I assume that's most of Of our
- 5:30listeners who we can be run through this.
- 5:32For those of you me, who are not quite sure about the specifics
- 5:35of web to, and web three. What is web to versus web 3
- 5:39because I'm assuming web one is eBay, right?
- 5:42Well, web to is the cloud, right?
- 5:45It's how I would Define it, right?
- 5:46You're in a previously. I mean, in, I'll talk about it
- 5:50in terms of our business, right? 04 to 0-6 when the Myspace
- 5:54friends stirs, Facebook wars were on Mark Zuckerberg, dad.
- 5:57Famously put a hundred thousand dollars of server costs on
- 5:59Personal credit card, right? Because you can.
- 6:02Now we talk about the network Dynamics, and soccer Bridge
- 6:04genius, and the news feed and f/8 and all the amazing
- 6:07technological developments. He really is the greatest
- 6:10operator in software of our time, but at that time, you
- 6:14know, Friendster don't forget had every advantage.
- 6:17And a lot of the closed Network just magic that propelled
- 6:21Facebook ahead of the dangers of the stranger danger of Myspace,
- 6:26but friends are couldn't keep their back end up.
- 6:28And so technical a Excellence in a pre Cloud world was a huge
- 6:33part of the game and now of course, with AWS has your, and
- 6:36Google Cloud, I'm able to have a much smaller back-end team and
- 6:40worry about a lot less. Of course, our team is Best in
- 6:43Class. I'm really proud of them but we
- 6:45worry about that. A lot less in the web to world
- 6:47than the prior generation did. And you know now of course, web
- 6:523 is about the blockchain. So it's about smart contracts in
- 6:56the uniqueness and provenance of, and of teas.
- 6:59And Jurors and I mean, it's like a distributed internet powered
- 7:03by the economics of cryptocurrencies.
- 7:06The let us drive away from sort of centralized Gatekeepers.
- 7:09The even the cloud itself is too centralized in the web.
- 7:12Three definition. There has been a history of
- 7:14across the centralized the database.
- 7:15Yeah, absolutely. Decentralization.
- 7:18I think is the core premise. The court magic.
- 7:21Anyway, that's web to web three. Your web to going into this sort
- 7:26of web, three World, figuring out what you think, and then,
- 7:29The conference itself, how it came on your radar and sort of
- 7:33talk talk me through that sure. So Ryan Hoover, you know, the
- 7:38founder of product on and we can fund is an adventure of ours.
- 7:43I put in a very little money to be an LP in weekend fund.
- 7:48He's also an investor and dispo and he sends out the best LP
- 7:52letter I've ever read better than Howard marks just he not
- 7:55go. What they do is incredibly
- 7:57ornate, really thoughtful and So I read it religiously and the
- 8:02last one he sent I mean, was he the last quarter?
- 8:04The quarter prior there was this company called Eternal .g G
- 8:08which is an N of T Marketplace for twitch streamers.
- 8:16My eyes are like, nosing over laughing, but right, but if you
- 8:20think about it, right? If you actually do the work, you
- 8:23realize that the gaming Market is bigger than the MBA market.
- 8:27So if the volume that Dapper Labs did with Top Shot is, you
- 8:32know, billions, why wouldn't gaming highlights and gaming
- 8:36moments and collectibles be a multi-billion dollar market.
- 8:39And then you start to think, wow, these guys are really on to
- 8:42something. And so I asked Ryan to introduce
- 8:45me to the co-founders of Eternal who just raised again,
- 8:49incredibly incredibly sharp guys who you know Jeff and Derek or
- 8:54the name of the co-founders who have been in the crypto world
- 8:57forever. So five plus years and they you
- 9:02know, Jeff has a tokenized community called Jeff's buddies.
- 9:06I hope I'm not saying anything. I'm not allowed that not doxxing
- 9:10the Jeff's buddies communities, but shout out to them and he Did
- 9:13me but, you know, you had he had ascended to Discord or what's
- 9:17the commits a Discord? Can he said he sent you, the
- 9:20tokens, you had to use collab land to prove that you have the
- 9:24tokens. Then you're included in the
- 9:25Discord server and then they're in this random Discord Community
- 9:28for four people speculating on criminal nothing you speculate.
- 9:33It's just an Enthusiast Community for people and the
- 9:36people in this chat. I'm not going to tell you who
- 9:38are in it, but our real crypto investors builders Credible
- 9:43group relatively small group of people and I was I felt the
- 9:47least intelligent on the subject matter but also they were
- 9:50interested in my experience, right?
- 9:52And our experience, it just bow. We have more downloads and a
- 9:55bigger Community than most of the people involved.
- 9:58So it wasn't just people still like web to people want to make
- 10:02money off by 3. But yeah, it's all right.
- 10:03Keep Goin sure. So you know they're interested
- 10:06in scale we're facing a lot of the same problems and are
- 10:10interesting. A lot of the same subjects
- 10:11fundamentally right? How do you Something that really
- 10:15changes the world and has an impact and, you know, has scale.
- 10:19So I was a part of this and then there was a channel in it.
- 10:23That said, well first the first one was main that.
- 10:26So then I went to Maine that and then the next channel was nft
- 10:28NYC. And when I went to Maine that
- 10:30all people could talk about it, may not was, bro.
- 10:32What's going on? And it's a lot of bros not
- 10:34nearly enough women, which was shocking to me, because I'll get
- 10:37there. My team is majority women.
- 10:39Our team is majority women at dispo and our community is 30
- 10:43women. You know, if you're building a
- 10:44social product in any generation teen girls run the world.
- 10:48So the most interesting part and also, the scariest part for the
- 10:51dispo team is when we're our audience is primarily teen girls
- 10:55college kids, and the primary. Crypto audience is the 20,000
- 11:00open sea whale Bros. There is a huge disconnect and
- 11:03gap between what our community is interested in, right?
- 11:06And when we say the world, say the word Madam asked or wallet,
- 11:10or seed, phrase, or a pin or Wagner.
- 11:13You know, all the lingo that's now begun to dominate our
- 11:16Twitter feeds. Our community don't care, and
- 11:18haven't noticed. And so thinking about what the
- 11:21future is and what they will tolerate, I think the gaming
- 11:24world is going to break down a lot of barriers and not actually
- 11:28Infinity but when the real AAA Publishers when you know, this
- 11:31past quarter, the CEOs of EA and today to both had questions
- 11:35about and FTS like the gaming world is going to break down the
- 11:39barriers, but basically you're in this like sort of like all
- 11:41male Community, obviously you're right.
- 11:43Representing sort of a super female Community predominately
- 11:45male, but a couple of, Yeah, couple rain.
- 11:47And the, but the hope is that still, the technology is like
- 11:50relevant to your company. Correct.
- 11:53So now you're in the nft NYC disc or group, and that's where
- 11:57they're chattering about it. Well, there was a channel in
- 11:59Jeff's buddies about it and then, if, you know, there were
- 12:04spreadsheets of all the events that were happening and then
- 12:07that was, you know, months ago. And then I started meeting
- 12:10everybody's gotta by Southwest when people would like sir.
- 12:13Try and get the good events and you send around spreadsheets
- 12:16with that kind of or Sundance or any of these content industry
- 12:20contract versus you've been do or there's just everybody's
- 12:23there, right? And that became obvious to me
- 12:25and then I started meeting as we really did a deep dive and did
- 12:28some out of T. Testing a couple of months ago
- 12:30I'm just bow and we started getting a lot of inbound calls
- 12:33from investors and potential employees interested in building
- 12:37that out. Then the first question within
- 12:39the first five minutes is oh what's your schedule?
- 12:41And of tem I see we got To get together, you know, oh, are you
- 12:44going to the board Apes party or what's going on with FWB or oh
- 12:49this, you know, CAA is throwing something with their new?
- 12:51And I thought, wow, this is not all, you know, there's a lot of
- 12:54really interesting cross-current, you know, we're
- 12:57in La based company. I've been in La for five years.
- 12:59There's a lot of interesting cross current between The
- 13:02Chainsmokers. I heard they were out there.
- 13:05Unbelievable, unbelievable. They will be the next great,
- 13:08their investors and dispo. No, my good next great.
- 13:10Yeah, I was waiting for that anytime.
- 13:13Seems to the audience. If you are not co-investing with
- 13:15The Chainsmokers and mantis, there's something wrong with
- 13:18your portfolio. The amount of work that they do,
- 13:21they're incredibly incredibly bright switched on guys who's
- 13:25there? Like who's the who's the man
- 13:27behind them? The team.
- 13:29There is no man behind them. There on all the calls from Alex
- 13:31are sending out the emails. I'm so impressed by them.
- 13:35There, you should have them on. I think they're incredibly
- 13:37thoughtful and I mean when you see their name in the deal,
- 13:41announcements now it means Thing right there, not just investing
- 13:44in random companies. They're investing in a lot of
- 13:46categories, potential category. Yes, Chainsmokers also have 100%
- 13:49exposure to etherium, so that's also very concerning the future
- 13:53of don't don't, don't let me down sequel is not going to be a
- 13:56promised, should the crypto Market tanked, but otherwise,
- 14:00enjoy. Well, I'm going to the salon.
- 14:02A conference in Lisbon this week.
- 14:04Oh my God. Yeah, I introduced them to a me.
- 14:07Woo-hoo just announced her fun with ft x and Solana, so I
- 14:11assume The Chainsmokers will Soon have plenty of Salon
- 14:14exposure. That's actually super smart just
- 14:16for gigs, right? I mean, if you just appear as
- 14:18the house band at every crypto conference, over the next
- 14:21several weeks, like your solid booked, do they play a?
- 14:25Did they play or they got. I'm sure they did.
- 14:28But, you know, little baby performed board.
- 14:30Apes after buying one or maybe they gave it to him.
- 14:33It's hard to say there's not a lot of trees.
- 14:35There may be no little baby, not debating.
- 14:38Yeah, sorry. Okay.
- 14:39I was about to say we come, we had a much bigger story on our
- 14:41hands. But you see you did good.
- 14:45There were jumping now. I mean, you went to the board
- 14:47Apes thing. Our yeah.
- 14:49Well was this I didn't I didn't make it but I have a lot of
- 14:52friends he did and it's interesting, right?
- 14:55You start to realize as a social media company and now we're kind
- 14:59of heading into people call this social 3 as well.
- 15:03Social media is a cultural artifact in many ways, right?
- 15:07You've seen the Cycles. Now first it was Facebook
- 15:09friends to her. Myspace, there's Instagram
- 15:12hipstamatic. Please that was Snapchat and
- 15:14then Tick Tock, triller whatever else.
- 15:17And here we are with this bow and a bunch of other companies
- 15:21emerging that are trying to reinvent the photo sharing
- 15:24memory making category and really get to the point where we
- 15:28can Embrace some of these new values that you know, have come
- 15:32out in the discords and clubhouses the world.
- 15:34So that they're about Community about intimacy about
- 15:37authenticity and figure out how to bring that into the future.
- 15:40And I think how do you do that? And do that on a scale that
- 15:44takes on the titans of social media.
- 15:46The, you know, one of those answers, one of the hypotheses
- 15:49has to be that it's built on the blockchain and taking advantage
- 15:53of whether it's etherium or or Solana what we choose to build
- 15:57on. But secondly, I think what acts
- 16:01he's done with the progressive decentralization model.
- 16:03So you know, functionally inverting your cap table, and
- 16:06having the community participate in a real substantial, you know,
- 16:10almost a b Corp on steroids manner.
- 16:13Is interesting, no one's done that before.
- 16:15And in many ways, it would be as if Kickstarter gave equity in
- 16:20their company to the community that shows and equity in the
- 16:23products, to the people who chose to build them.
- 16:26But obviously, like Kickstarter mini over those products never
- 16:30materialized in the form that people expect them to.
- 16:34Well that's the danger, right? You have to figure out as an
- 16:36operator and what we're trying to determine the dispos.
- 16:39All of our testing is how do you layer in the blockchain?
- 16:42To your product in a way that is not fundamentally changing the
- 16:46nature of the game. You know the game play, right?
- 16:49So in social media, what we're building will be closest to read
- 16:54it in that you your contributions to the community
- 16:57are valued and denoted in some way that, you know, we haven't
- 17:01settled on quite yet and whether you're contributing to roles or
- 17:06otherwise, you know, which are the group albums on our on our
- 17:09Network or other contributions to the community people.
- 17:13Value your contribution. And this is a long history in
- 17:15the internet from Wikipedia moderators to Foursquare,
- 17:18mayor's to whatever else you might want to keep hearing about
- 17:21the conference. But let's talk about this book
- 17:23because obviously, okay, that's what you do and we're getting
- 17:26we're touching on it. So like, I guess in my very
- 17:29Layman sense, my understanding of dispo and you can disillusion
- 17:34a, but like super hot with, you know, obviously David dobrik
- 17:39co-founding and the sort of Disappearing messaging thing He
- 17:43gets like cancel delayed. Not am delayed, right?
- 17:46Always the court can delay. Sorry, you take a photo and you
- 17:49can delay till 9 a.m. right opposite of disappear.
- 17:52Yeah. Okay, I'm sorry.
- 17:53Okay, good very web to we're so then he's gone.
- 17:58That's Insider cancels him, right?
- 18:00Yeah. And then you guys like your
- 18:03investors have different Stakes, but like, we're spark sort of
- 18:07like, says, oh, we're like giving him back or something,
- 18:10but then whatever. So there's that whole thing.
- 18:13And you've been able to, like, I've watched the gross stuff
- 18:16obviously in covered a little bit and like in some of these
- 18:18other countries, particularly you've sort of held on to growth
- 18:21and are trying to sort of, despite sort of like a media
- 18:25sort of like losing your sort of like favored status in the
- 18:28media. Keep growing is that the journey
- 18:31is that a reasonably Fair version of the journey and now
- 18:34you're like trying to figure out sort of how to capture the
- 18:38growth you've built in. Like so part of it is exploring
- 18:41web 3 and like, Nerve or where is that?
- 18:45How is that a fair Journey or where would you say you're at
- 18:48now in that and that path? Absolutely.
- 18:50I think you know, I wouldn't exactly put it that way if you
- 18:53know but we're that 18 months into this code base.
- 18:57The team went from six and March to now 22 on four continents, I
- 19:03think it's incredibly exciting. If you were to ask me or anyone
- 19:08were working with any of the co-founders that this is where
- 19:12the Pretty would be. And obviously, there were some
- 19:14incredible ups and some incredible Downs along the way.
- 19:18We have a company we're really proud of.
- 19:21We have a product that is resonating with you know
- 19:24millions of teens and college kids around the globe and I
- 19:27think yes, we where we're at now, is we need to figure out as
- 19:32any social media company would at this stage.
- 19:34How do you really? You know, you can get downloads,
- 19:37you can pay for downloads, you can partner with an influencer
- 19:39celebrity for downloads. You know, acquisition is only
- 19:42only one part of the game and in social media, you know, when
- 19:46investors mute us and whether it's tiger, or SoftBank or GST,
- 19:50or you know, whoever would hypothetically call they will
- 19:53never ask about our download numbers.
- 19:56They're going to ask about retention, right?
- 19:58Because if I were to pay, is it working?
- 20:01Is it working right? And particularly D30?
- 20:03So, on the discrete day, 30 days later, or, you know, it camera
- 20:07apps are often weekly. So weak for, you know.
- 20:10How are you building? What are the features?
- 20:12You're Developing to capture more of the users time in a way,
- 20:16you know, especially for us, the very Mission driven almost
- 20:20political company and what we're trying to accomplish.
- 20:22How are you doing in a way? That's different from the
- 20:24companies of the past and how are you going to set yourself?
- 20:27What do you mean all political? I think you know the choice of
- 20:31non am development or delayed development.
- 20:33In any sense is a choice to untether you know the community
- 20:37from their phones. And when we asked the girls in
- 20:40particular why do they like this is is I feel so much pressure,
- 20:46use it, you know, taking photos, sharing photos online.
- 20:49And this isn't just an Instagram problem.
- 20:51This is, you know, everyone's seen what came out in the
- 20:54hearings. This is really a problem that
- 20:57the, you know, the phone has created, right?
- 21:00And what are these social media platforms, make them feel.
- 21:03They feel alone. They feel not good enough.
- 21:05They feel issues about their body.
- 21:07They feel like they have the wrong lifestyle.
- 21:10They don't have the right clothes.
- 21:11It's this incredibly Sad and negative impact.
- 21:15And so for us and I spent my 20s primarily in politics.
- 21:19How do you genuinely create a social media Network that you
- 21:23know, delivers joy and connection?
- 21:26Even if that was the intent of these original platforms?
- 21:2915 years ago? That's the the question.
- 21:31And so for us not in development means when you take the photos
- 21:34you can't access them immediately and that powerful,
- 21:37right? Because you don't, you know,
- 21:39next time you go out into the wild and you watch someone no
- 21:41matter what age or gender. Either they are they take a
- 21:44photograph or a video the immediately are clutching and
- 21:47you can see the veins and their neck pop out as they look at and
- 21:50they say off my arm is fat or whatever it is, right?
- 21:53It's an incredibly stressful experience.
- 21:55And so the magic of, you know what, we call the digital
- 21:58disposable camera is you can wait a little bit, and when you
- 22:02get the photos back, the next morning, something we hear quite
- 22:05often, you use your user interviews, is that it feels
- 22:07like Christmas morning again, right?
- 22:09It feels like going to the one-hour photo with my mom or my
- 22:11dad and Up back my role of 24 36, and, you know, almost 20
- 22:17percent of our users are sharing photos.
- 22:20The next day, or no, to almost 20% of the photos are being
- 22:23shared the next day, so that core Loop of taking and sharing
- 22:28is defensible and magical and inherently viral.
- 22:31And I think that's what's so exciting thus far.
- 22:33When we don't think it's important for you to put Eric.
- 22:35I mean, maybe you're going to same question, but explain to me
- 22:37the crossover between the instant - of photos and social
- 22:42media. Leah and the delayed reaction of
- 22:44it of the nine, a m-- development, that you think
- 22:47ameliorates the problem of self-image and negativity that,
- 22:52you know, something happens between the photo being taken
- 22:54and 9 a.m. the next day that allows people to feel better
- 22:56about themselves. I don't get that, I think it's a
- 23:00first of all, you know, on the scale of Purity, you know, I'm
- 23:05not going to stand here and say we have the solution, right?
- 23:09That's a very dangerous proposition.
- 23:12It's incredibly Are to fix the way that people look at
- 23:16themselves in the mirror, right? That's an example, existed and
- 23:18predated Instagram, and all of this, so sure.
- 23:20Even before mirrors, let's go back to the Garden of Eden.
- 23:23I'm sure we, you know, we all look at ourselves and we wish
- 23:26something, we're different whatever, the societal standards
- 23:28were at the time, right? And that's something that's
- 23:30baggage that all of us have from birth.
- 23:32And it's not a function, just of cell phones, right?
- 23:35You know, go back to the Renaissance or the Roaring 20s
- 23:38or, you know, pick your historical Epoch.
- 23:40There were Trends, there were he's that were, you know,
- 23:43certain body images that were more popular.
- 23:46We're not, we're never going to fix the Francis Hogan of the of
- 23:49the Medici era was a very different person, but we all
- 23:51know that the portraits were extremely defeating to the
- 23:54Arctic rubenesque this story. Yeah, sure.
- 24:02Go ahead, sure. But I think what we're aiming to
- 24:05do is create something that it's not perfect, but it's
- 24:08fundamentally better, right? And so the act of getting back
- 24:12specifically to the Question. The act of taking the photo
- 24:15right now on your iPhone when you can see so much and you're
- 24:19obsessing over it and you're immediately clenching and you
- 24:23feel this intensity and in turn because of some feelings.
- 24:26And maybe you're bringing negativity about what you see
- 24:28that ruins the moment. And so creating that distance
- 24:33for you from that or even you know will test a gentle reminder
- 24:37to you to wait a little bit and allow yourself to enjoy Joy at
- 24:43the next day, we found users. Tell us that they enjoy that a
- 24:47lot more than the way. They've been taking photographs
- 24:49in the past and if you can compare it, everyone on this
- 24:51Zoom, I think is old enough to remember the way that we would
- 24:55get photos back. When we were kids, it was a very
- 24:58different feeling from the feeling that we have.
- 25:00Now when we see them on our phone and our pie apophysis is
- 25:04one, part of that is the just the time, the distance, you have
- 25:08between taking it and experiencing it, and that
- 25:11reveal, and then, Web three, right?
- 25:13I get I if you lose like on the one hand, you know, if you're a
- 25:17new up-and-coming consumer company, makes sense to like get
- 25:21on and see what sort of the new trends are happening, maybe
- 25:24you'll get adoption some way doing that.
- 25:27On the other hand there's an argument.
- 25:28You know that focus is good. You guys have sort of a cool
- 25:32idea with the disposable camera thing.
- 25:34Like why why do something else like complicated or Innovative
- 25:39with like web three? Or I mean, it seems like you're
- 25:41going through that Journey now or What sort of what got you to
- 25:44say? Oh, we should think about
- 25:46crypto. Is it the money side?
- 25:48The enthusiasm? Or like, if you had to distill,
- 25:50like, what appealed to you about it and then like, yeah, where
- 25:53are you in sort of in that journey I think, first and
- 25:57foremost is just a healthy sense of the history of Technology
- 26:00knowing that at some point, the switch was made from the
- 26:03Mainframe to the cloud and the people, the incumbents, you
- 26:06know, it's hard to think of a company that is almost 18 months
- 26:11old as an incumbent. But I'm coming from the prior
- 26:13mindset was slow and, you know wasn't necessarily building.
- 26:17You know, I met Devin from Open Sea, they were building from
- 26:192018, that's a lot longer than we've been building.
- 26:22So, in Tech a big part of the job is reacting and reacting
- 26:28because you're smaller with a speed and precision that a major
- 26:32incumbent. So the metas the Snapchats, the
- 26:37Pinterest, right? The, you know, 50 100 billion
- 26:39plus market cap companies will never be able to A because of
- 26:43the size of the company and, you know, the speed at which the
- 26:46ship turns, but then also the regulatory concerns that they
- 26:49have, and I think that was a really interesting part of all
- 26:52of this is uoft, acts moving to the Bahamas, the Dow laws and
- 26:56Wyoming. What is actually, what is
- 26:59actually going? I love what you have to do is a
- 27:00start-up founder these days like track.
- 27:03All these like really, it's like what what the most ambitious
- 27:07part about injuries and Horowitz?
- 27:09This is an Assad, but related, the most interesting part.
- 27:12Of injuries in Horowitz to me right now is not how they've
- 27:17doubled the size investing staff, and that they're probably
- 27:20going public. It is that they're
- 27:22single-handedly becoming a regulatory, they don't call a
- 27:26lobbying, so, whatever, whatever it is, a regulatory shaping
- 27:30process. And, you know, that front-page
- 27:32article in the New York Times last week is really breathtaking
- 27:35when you think about it, right? It's as if we were, you know, if
- 27:39you think about the analogy of the cloud again, right?
- 27:42It's Amazon, Microsoft and Google are now the three big
- 27:47players but imagine a world where those are the only three
- 27:50players. So Bitcoin salon and aetherium.
- 27:53And the same person owned a huge chunk of all of them and was
- 27:57investing in all three of the platform's themselves.
- 28:02And in all the companies building on them and had such a
- 28:05head start in funding and access that they then went to
- 28:08Washington and shape, the rules of the gray.
- 28:11And the other major lobbyists is Many called coinbase, which they
- 28:14happen to be a major shareholder in, right?
- 28:17You know, and one of the partners and I'm sure she didn't
- 28:20mean anything by it, but happens to be on the board of both
- 28:22coinbase and Open Sea, which are now going, you know, right?
- 28:26I think coinbase will destroy open, see your?
- 28:28Or has a really good shot of just placing it in the popular
- 28:32imagination, right? The just the breadth of coinbase
- 28:35is wild compared to open sea, even if opens he continues on
- 28:39this crazy growth path. So, to answer the original
- 28:42Question, which is why are we looking at this so hard?
- 28:45I think it's a belief, you know, it's to your first question.
- 28:48Do I believe in deleted in the company?
- 28:50Believe that the blockchain is real?
- 28:52And it is the future. And, yes, unequivocally.
- 28:54I think that it is really interesting.
- 28:57You can talk about the promise of the chains themselves, but
- 29:00when you think about the Dow model and what axi Infiniti has
- 29:04done as an example, right? Which is you are giving your
- 29:08users a percentage of the profits of the company.
- 29:12By virtue of their participation.
- 29:14So in the same way, you know, Abraham Lincoln with the
- 29:17Homestead Act gave in the 1860s people I think was up to 140
- 29:22acres of land, if they went out and they developed it and they
- 29:27paid a registration fee, right? If you as a company, and this is
- 29:30why I read it seems to be going so hard their collaboration with
- 29:34Arbitron. And I was, I met up with Stephen
- 29:36and their team this week to learn about what exactly?
- 29:39They're planning, but it is really interesting.
- 29:41He's Huffman or You're saying no, Steven?
- 29:44Who runs our Bertram, okay? Who's a brilliant guy?
- 29:47He came out of, they actually launched this company before
- 29:50etherium launched out of a pH. A group of phds at Princeton
- 29:54brilliant, brilliant movie. You guys, the idea is that for
- 29:58all the pictures or some subset, the people could easily turn
- 30:01them into n FTS or I don't want to specifically get into that
- 30:05right now, but trying to get ahead of whatever you're
- 30:07announcing but what's the intuition that's one hypothesis,
- 30:11right? But if you can also If you open
- 30:13the app and you look at what we're doing, we have cameras and
- 30:18you have to open dispo to understand it.
- 30:20But they're, they're almost digital objects in the way that
- 30:24a skin on for tonight is or certain objects on Roblox and so
- 30:28we just did our first big collaboration with YSL, the
- 30:31fashion house, a couple weeks ago, and the user response to.
- 30:34That was remarkable. It, shocked everyone internally.
- 30:39And so that opened our eyes. Well, what if the cameras You
- 30:42know, the images is one way to look at it.
- 30:44But what if the cameras themselves were mft?
- 30:47He's right are there are filter and ft's today or other.
- 30:51I've heard of this idea, right? Or this exists.
- 30:53It's an idea, right? But I think what's interesting
- 30:56to the community, you know, the eith community Solana Community
- 31:00is our scale already. And also the fact that we, you
- 31:03know, if you compare it to the play, Turn gaming world, we have
- 31:06a game of our social network, which is you contribute posts
- 31:10and you contribute to Rolls images.
- 31:12Rolls and your video will launch sometime soon and you are
- 31:17rewarded, you know, whether through likes and up votes and
- 31:21you know, whatever or equivalent of karma is the red of karma but
- 31:25also emotionally rewarded, right?
- 31:28So much of what we project on social media is a bid for
- 31:31affirmation or connection or attention or flirting or
- 31:34whatever it is that you're looking for in the world and so
- 31:38layering in and of teas to that right where people can trade
- 31:41them. You know, so there and we you
- 31:44create a Marketplace. There's also a resale value to
- 31:46the person who generated the asset a lot of the behavior.
- 31:50When you look at what more tapes or crypto Punk's or
- 31:53fundamentally enabling, right. It's peacocking by putting the a
- 31:56poor, the crypto punk as your Twitter profile and then it's
- 31:59access to a community. And so for us to do that on a
- 32:03social media Network would not be a huge leap and then the
- 32:06second part of the equation which is actually a very
- 32:08separate discussion is do you issue a token as the company.
- 32:12And I think that's the one that's very out there for two
- 32:16reasons. One is the regulatory issues and
- 32:18secondly, what is the App Store going to do?
- 32:21And, you know, I think that it's because for now, they're really
- 32:24not allowing from what I understand.
- 32:27At least any company that issues a token to do that in app and
- 32:31the biggest challenge, you know, and I keep asking this in every
- 32:35single meeting and every single person I meet is the ux, the
- 32:40user experience of the The web three native people is not even
- 32:44close to what we do in the web to it sucks, right?
- 32:47It's um, it's it's not even close.
- 32:50And and so every time we say the word wallet or seed, freeze and
- 32:56I said this earlier, but any of the lingo, right?
- 32:58And I'm only getting to one or two of the words but in order to
- 33:01now open a while at on metal mask or right?
- 33:05Even know the names of all the companies you have to do.
- 33:07Yeah. The process, the companies like
- 33:10it requires charts to lay it all out.
- 33:12It requires charge to lay it all out but you know, the
- 33:15Counterpoint to all that and I think the really exciting part
- 33:18is you look at axi and you have to open the Ronin wallet and
- 33:22then you have to transfer the funds and then you have to wait
- 33:25sometimes and they're still doing their taxes and they're
- 33:28still doing it and they're still doing it and so maybe you maybe
- 33:33you would say well the issue here is, this is a job and it's
- 33:37not a game but they're all these stories back from 06.
- 33:42Right, 07, when Facebook was rolling out internationally and
- 33:45traditionally in Mobile, you know, in our team.
- 33:48Well, it was mostly desktop then, but traditionally in the
- 33:51internet, people are not willing to wait for things to load
- 33:53right, but, you know, latency right?
- 33:55Our back-end team were constantly reviewing how quickly
- 33:59are people getting it to load because they will abandon people
- 34:01have incredibly short time, you know, attention spans.
- 34:06But with Facebook in the beginning, it was such a magical
- 34:09product and people felt that it was the internet, right?
- 34:12They were unable to understand that there was a difference
- 34:14between the internet and Facebook that they were willing
- 34:16to load. Wait 30 seconds, 90 seconds per
- 34:19page load to use it. And so if axi really is, you
- 34:25know, and most of the times, the first Market mover, when it
- 34:28comes to the internet is not the winner, right?
- 34:29Google is not the first search engine started Facebook, not the
- 34:32first social network. So I think that's what's so
- 34:34exciting to everyone in the gaming world.
- 34:36And now, you know, I've met in AA.
- 34:38Everyone at every, you meet every product manager or game
- 34:41developer. A game designer at Zynga
- 34:44supercell Riot, you know, and and and and Dan they're all
- 34:49thinking about this. This is obsessing them, right?
- 34:52Because they've existed in a world where people were willing
- 34:55to buy spend real money on Virtual Goods which adults and
- 35:00the media still don't really even though it's not a own
- 35:03skins, I have a great you exactly.
- 35:06But for my money, I think it made money in OverWatch.
- 35:10People are people are still very He's skeptical of the digital
- 35:15Goods economy even with Fiat right even if we don't talk
- 35:18about blocks, right? And so why couldn't you Eric
- 35:21trade your skin and have it then live?
- 35:25Not just in for tonight but also in Roblox and the owner lots of
- 35:30already met. Why would a centralized company
- 35:32want to? I mean, we could that is so fun
- 35:34to be no. But yeah, right?
- 35:36But the big centralized companies, the incumbents are
- 35:38not going to necessarily want that, right?
- 35:41But all the Challengers will, right?
- 35:44It'll help us scale much faster. So the fluidity it's the same
- 35:48way that in social media social graphs, right?
- 35:51It would behoove all of the Challenger companies to create
- 35:55an interoperable social graph, but of course, the Legacy
- 35:58companies will never allow it. So, what I think is interesting
- 36:01about your company approaching crypto and then FTS
- 36:06specifically, is that to me it could represent this jump from
- 36:09gaming, towards mainstream usage, right?
- 36:11Because at the Level, I understand it.
- 36:13People are very accustomed to Virtual Goods.
- 36:16The trading of that there is a there is a market, there is a
- 36:18currency, there is a value for non tangible objects but what
- 36:21you guys have existed on what your success has come on.
- 36:24So far, has been through straight-up social media, right?
- 36:27It's people taking photos things in the real world and gaining
- 36:30social currency through the success in whatever.
- 36:33Attention those photos get, where do you see on the your
- 36:37users interest, the involvement of this kind of web 30 Approach
- 36:43to social currency towards I guess financialization, when it
- 36:46comes to like, potentially issuing a token.
- 36:49I don't think our users understand this, but I don't
- 36:52think we had Mark Zuckerberg when they announced the news
- 36:56feed. And, you know, his product
- 36:58manager was famously, threatened by the community, but the
- 37:00numbers on the back, end told them, it was working, you know,
- 37:04there's a part of, and, of course, Steve Jobs was the king
- 37:08of this. There's a part of creating
- 37:09consumer products, which is data driven.
- 37:12And talking to users, of course, right?
- 37:14Ultimately we are serving them, but there's also a part of it
- 37:17that's intuition and trying to create something that's
- 37:20different and enabling enabled by the technologies that you see
- 37:24adult way, the whole Henry, Ford thing, they would have said I
- 37:27want Faster Horses or more horses or whatever.
- 37:29Right, right. Right, right.
- 37:30I think that's that has to be an obsession of yours if you're,
- 37:34this is the hardest category in the world.
- 37:36I think to build in, right is, how do you create something
- 37:40that's taking advantage? So much has been Built already,
- 37:43right? I mean you talk to investors
- 37:45who've investing in Social for the last 15 to 20 years and
- 37:49there was a consensus, maybe five years ago that social was
- 37:52over, right? And even Snapchat had to
- 37:55overcome that in their road to the market.
- 37:59And of course when Instagram copied stories, a lot of people
- 38:03thought and the snap share price reflected.
- 38:05A lot of people thought snap was dead and it's the essential
- 38:08thesis, the bear case. At that moment was social has
- 38:10been built already, no one's ever.
- 38:12Going to touch it again and the emergence of tick-tock, which I
- 38:16think will be bigger than any of these companies has really
- 38:19corrected. The market.
- 38:20It is extremely addictive. It is, it's amazing, it's
- 38:24amazing. And then, you know, Discord is
- 38:26surging Jason, and that team are amazing.
- 38:28Are going to build a behemoth company and hopefully with not
- 38:31an a driven model. It's really exciting to see what
- 38:34they're doing seems with subscriptions and I think now
- 38:37there's this energy out there that social is about to change
- 38:41and you know my belief is that why is it changing?
- 38:43Its really because social media is a cultural artifact enabled
- 38:47by technology, right? Fashion goes through Cycles.
- 38:50Why were skinny jeans in in last week and now mom jeans are in
- 38:53this week. Music goes through psycho,
- 38:55right? I was managing an R&B group for
- 38:57a while and the the whole premise was.
- 39:00It's the Boys to Men of this time which was inspired by the
- 39:02new edition of that time. And then the Four Tops and the
- 39:05Jackson 5 and The Temptations of that time, right?
- 39:08And so when you look at social media, you Really, if you're
- 39:13building it, you really have to believe that it comes in cycles.
- 39:16And so you have to think about what are the product values.
- 39:19And for us, that's the authenticity, the community, the
- 39:21intimacy that gen Z seems to really care about.
- 39:24But also, what are the unique? Technological changes of this
- 39:28time, right? No one talks about it, but
- 39:30Facebook, Surviving the shift from desktop to mobile was
- 39:33triumphant. Right meeting ever thought it
- 39:35was gonna happen media. Never never thought it was going
- 39:37to happen. It's a testament again to why
- 39:39Zuckerberg is just the best. But also That is why they
- 39:43hundred here for. He said that earlier and I was
- 39:45surprised, you didn't react, I was like, I'm not as far as
- 40:00the antitrust issues facing Facebook and the fact that I do
- 40:03believe if he's as smart as I think and everyone else thinks
- 40:06he is, he should break up the company, but as a technical
- 40:10innovator, he really is preeminent.
- 40:12But that's all I have to say on that one.
- 40:14Well, I mean, what's interesting to me, let's see if I can make
- 40:17this analogy through media here because that because I covered
- 40:19that for a long time. And to me the most impressive
- 40:21transformation that happened on that side of things was Netflix,
- 40:24right? You know, moving from DVDs,
- 40:26through the qwikster debacle to streaming, right was incredible
- 40:30and has left them far out ahead, at least for the time being when
- 40:32it comes to subscribers. But it would also like reads
- 40:36Reed Hastings, thesis from the beginning was that eventually we
- 40:39will get to this point where content is going to be streamed.
- 40:42Directly into people's homes, like DVD was the intermediary
- 40:46between where the president was and his vision.
- 40:49And maybe that was the case with shock to, you know, he always
- 40:51knew that social media was something that needed to exist.
- 40:54You know as an extremely personal level and on people's
- 40:56phones is like crypto and N FTS the end result of something that
- 41:02has been. You know when it comes to social
- 41:05media something that is needed to exist.
- 41:06For some time great question. That is exactly why we're
- 41:09looking so hard and do it and I would actually separate Two
- 41:13different parts of the web. Three worlds, right?
- 41:16So first, there's n of T. So the product itself, what are
- 41:19you? You know, the equivalent in
- 41:21gaming on a Roblox or a fortnight is the skins or the,
- 41:26you know, in-game assets. But then the more exciting part
- 41:31in some ways or the equally, exciting part is Progressive
- 41:34decentralization model and issuing a token, which enables
- 41:40people and it's obviously in extract.
- 41:42Lee link to the issuance of entities.
- 41:44But if you look at axi right, just the nft of the back sees
- 41:51themselves as not as interesting as tying them to a token that's
- 41:54publicly traded and is tied to the primary sales of the axes
- 42:00and then the resale fees generated by the platform that
- 42:03go into the community Treasury and are then given to the
- 42:07participants in the ecosystem. That's really interesting.
- 42:10It's never been done before, right?
- 42:12And Back to Zuckerberg because I know you like talking about him
- 42:15as do. I the fundamental problem that
- 42:19Facebook is facing if we ignore section 230 and First Amendment
- 42:24issues. If we ignore privacy and data
- 42:26collection issues, the fundamental problem they're
- 42:28facing is one that's driven by the business model which is we
- 42:33need to create an algorithm that drives engagement because
- 42:37engagement creates Adam to Tori and Adam inventory creates
- 42:41Revenue growth. And so, what's really, what's
- 42:44really compelling to our company is if you were genuinely trying
- 42:48to create the once-in-a-generation social
- 42:50media company that will change that, right?
- 42:54Because Evan and Snapchat tried to build Hardware, you know, had
- 42:59a bunch of false starts went into the ad model Pinterest has
- 43:04to be an ad model. Reddit has tried all these other
- 43:06things, it's going to be an ad model.
- 43:08So if you're going to try to Jet, if you have teen girls in
- 43:11college kids, Drive Social Network adoptions excluding the
- 43:15Pinterest case, which is amazing for other reasons.
- 43:19If you have that audience, which is really, really hard to do.
- 43:22And you can see from all that's leaked in the hearings that
- 43:25Facebook and Instagram have lost that audience.
- 43:28So, if you're our company and you're trying to create
- 43:30something that has a business model, that is not a driven
- 43:33because there's something wrong with that ethically and
- 43:36politically, then looking very hard at what a token issuance
- 43:40and what changing the business model fundamentally because
- 43:42Jason and the Discord team are choosing subscriptions which is
- 43:46one of the other models, but end of TS and a token issuance are
- 43:49really, really interesting from an ethical standpoint.
- 43:54And I think that's why we're so inspired and energized to spend
- 43:58all this time exploring it because that could be a
- 44:01game-changer. That's the numbers I've
- 44:02understood. Why you're looking into using
- 44:05the most, I believed it the point that it's like, oh, it's
- 44:07an escape hatch from the ad model.
- 44:10That is condemned, which is it. Has such strong gravitational
- 44:13pull because I covered Snapchat during that period, where Evan
- 44:17actually embarrassingly one of the Scoops that I had early on
- 44:20covering the company was like, Snap doesn't want to do ads
- 44:23because they were talking to the all the Chinese companies of the
- 44:25time. Evan didn't?
- 44:26I mean it's true that it's one of the journalists, like Escape
- 44:29hatches of true at the time? Because yeah, you know, they
- 44:31were looking at, you know, micro payments and people spending
- 44:35money on individual filters and I mean I guess you could call it
- 44:38early and have tea or whatever Shirley.
- 44:40Why didn't they have? They should have had An mou they
- 44:43should have had cash app, right? The snapcash I want to go back
- 44:46to the conference where we all got were this guy started.
- 44:48And there's like, financialization is part of what
- 44:51excites web three. I mean I was joking online.
- 44:54Somebody was showing a chart of like interest in web three
- 44:56verses like the Creator economy and it's way bigger for web
- 44:59three. And I do think part of it is
- 45:00like there are others Financial speculation to go with web three
- 45:03like web, three justifies people, who just want to like
- 45:07bedding currencies, and on the flip side, you know, there are
- 45:10founders, like, yourself who are like, oh, I To build a company
- 45:14like some actual things in this new technology could be useful
- 45:17and make it possible. So you're interested in more
- 45:20like a product lens, but then you go to this world.
- 45:23That's so Financial eyes. And, I mean, that sort of the
- 45:25etherium joke, you sort of started off with that story and
- 45:29even some of the founders, who are hardcore, how what's the
- 45:33Speculator percentage? I guess at this conference, or
- 45:36like, if you had to say they're just like, betting on currency
- 45:38goes up, I make a lot of money. That's what I care about, how
- 45:42How prevalent was that? It's very large, it's very
- 45:45large, and I think it's fascinating to think, as well.
- 45:48So, on the individual basis there, right?
- 45:51All of the open sea, whales the 20,000 of them, the board Apes
- 45:54holders, the crypto Punk's holders, not all of them, but a
- 45:57large number of them are very much interested in this, it's
- 46:01part Community Driven, its part Financial speculation driven,
- 46:05right? It's very hard to, as an
- 46:07outsider who's, you know, a Believer now, but still an
- 46:10outsider because I haven't Been with them, for any real period
- 46:14of time, it's very hard to see what the difference is.
- 46:18And you know, to untangle the links.
- 46:22I think what's really interesting, people will be
- 46:24giving you some Spiel and is like empty and you're like, you
- 46:27just want to make money. I mean, like, you have to say
- 46:30like, I mean, maybe you disagree, but certainly, some of
- 46:32the things people say around crypto.
- 46:34It's like what's the there there?
- 46:37Right. Sure.
- 46:38But in any emerging in any emerging technology in that,
- 46:42Doubly. There will be a bit of a wild
- 46:44west feel right. Just think about all some of the
- 46:47news that's been made in the last couple weeks, right?
- 46:50The head of product to the top and of Team Marketplace is
- 46:55front-running the transactions and they then have to throw out
- 46:59the squid games token. Right?
- 47:02Goes up through the roof and built into the smart contract.
- 47:04You can't sell and then the developers Cash Out 12 million
- 47:08dollars. It was a fake squid game token,
- 47:10they cashed out 12 million dollars.
- 47:11So Definitely their security issues.
- 47:15There's a big, alleged alleged everywhere.
- 47:17Anybody just said, alleged? Yeah.
- 47:19Right. Right.
- 47:20So we'll run the disclaimer at the end of the episode.
- 47:23Sure. But I think the majority of the
- 47:25people I met and interacted with do seem to be good and are much
- 47:29more interested in the community elements.
- 47:32The decentralization elements. But of course, there's a little
- 47:34bit of a manager. It's also knew I was just yeah,
- 47:37somebody just had a like a bunch of their crypto like stolen at
- 47:40gunpoint a I mean it's constant. All of that, all of that.
- 47:43When you say like the wild west, I mean, so what were you going
- 47:47to a lot of panels or give us a couple more scenes?
- 47:50There what was another, like striking striking event?
- 47:54I would say, one of the interesting observations I had
- 47:57was there were a lot more investors there than there were
- 48:01people building. So it was a commentary and
- 48:04reflection on the amount of dry powder and investor dollars
- 48:11chasing deals and They're not being that many people with
- 48:15experience in the space. And also, you know, we to dinner
- 48:18Monday, where we're trying to recruit people out of the social
- 48:21media, Behemoth for art, you know, different parts of our
- 48:24company. And there just seemed to be this
- 48:27energy. They're searching for a cause
- 48:29write, like this is the future. I'm, I'm not quite sure for what
- 48:33it is, but we do. I want the money is feels like
- 48:36when you know, for people who build consumer products when we
- 48:39went up when an iPhone was first put into your hands.
- 48:42Ends and you realize what the Apple team had accomplished and
- 48:45what this would mean. It feels like another
- 48:48generational seminal moment, even if you can't, you know, you
- 48:53couldn't have predicted the first time you and I phone in
- 48:55your hand, all the use cases and all the magic that would happen
- 48:58just feel like Uber or covering Uber, you know, a lot of people
- 49:02went there because it was such a hot company.
- 49:04I mean, coinbase people ask me. Oh, like, what's the Uber now?
- 49:08And coinbase is already public and so valuable.
- 49:12But they're doing so well, but it doesn't feel as exciting.
- 49:14I mean, you were sort of saying, you think coinbase is going to
- 49:17beat Open Sea which would presumably mean, they have a lot
- 49:20of room to grow here. I mean, but yeah, it just seemed
- 49:24like people are in search of like the company.
- 49:26That's clearly owning the trend to go for the greatest product
- 49:30there. I mean, like I want to go back
- 49:31to your iPhone reference for a second there because one of my
- 49:34favorite moments in, you know, whatever I periodically re-watch
- 49:39the video, Steve Jobs introducing the iPhone in The
- 49:42seven. It's a great hook and reporters
- 49:44are cynical. You're like, every morning when
- 49:46I wake up, I didn't get excited. I watch a Steve Jobs.
- 49:49Yeah, I mean I think it's like you can talk about the world
- 49:51that was created after that all you want.
- 49:53But in terms of just like a great product reveal, it's
- 49:56fucking incredible because it you know, before there was the
- 49:58knowledge before the iPhone, there was a time afterwards and
- 50:01you see him, everyone knew that it was coming.
- 50:02We had a vague idea of what the iPhone was.
- 50:05He takes it out, everyone kind of gets it and then at some
- 50:08point in the movie, sorry in the video, he takes that he He shows
- 50:12the feature where you can pinch to zoom.
- 50:14So he's like you just take a photo and you take your finger
- 50:16like this you should end the audience has this moment of like
- 50:19fuck, that's so good that makes so much sense.
- 50:22This is the perfect user interaction.
- 50:24It's a it's a most I've never made in my life before and yet
- 50:27now I knew exactly what to do with it and that to me is why
- 50:30the iPhone works because they had like that feature in there
- 50:33in which people intuitively knew what to do with it and it worked
- 50:35and instantly this became the best product in a field of
- 50:39people all trying to make this product.
- 50:40And so that's sort of Do you see anything close to that with, you
- 50:44know, at this conference that somebody has a product there in
- 50:46which any, you know, lay person once they see, it does
- 50:50demonstrate in front of them, it will click in some sort of like
- 50:53visceral Atomic away, that they will get it and all the sudden,
- 50:57all this bullshit that's been going on around, it will fall
- 50:59into place and the good ideas will fall in and the bad ideas
- 51:02will go away. And like this world is web three
- 51:05world will actually exist in the tangible aspect.
- 51:08Now I feel it coming right? That's fundamentally.
- 51:11What we would hope to build, right?
- 51:13Because the web three Community is building the technological
- 51:17backbone. But on the ux side, all the
- 51:20nomenclature we talked about earlier is not there, right?
- 51:23So, even using for us, the word and have tea, or the word token,
- 51:28is going to be a huge decision, right?
- 51:31Maybe that's the underlying technology were using or the
- 51:35architecture, but we may use other words, you know, my
- 51:38friends, Eternal, the video game and of Company.
- 51:42They called their nfc's moments. And right now they're built on
- 51:46floats as the Dapper Labs chain, and so you can buy their moments
- 51:50for nine dollars. You use.
- 51:51There's a Fiat on-ramp. And, of course, you can also buy
- 51:54them in flow, but they're incredibly sharp.
- 51:57And, you know, the Dapper Labs Top Shot, you acts is probably
- 52:01the best in class right now, when it comes to serving up,
- 52:04users can consumers the your community, something that the
- 52:08average Layman can understand. And I think, In the wallet
- 52:12worlds, you know what, the team at Rainbow or building, which is
- 52:16the best etherium wallet, or just crypto wallet by, you know,
- 52:22Leaps and Bounds that wallet I think is going to do amazing
- 52:26things for the adoption of cryptocurrency.
- 52:29But even then, you know that team is coming from the crypto
- 52:32world. So I think it'll be really
- 52:33interesting when the two really Collide and you can find,
- 52:37hopefully a product with web to design, you know, Qualities that
- 52:42can be understood and really lead to mass adoption.
- 52:46Did you pick up any new cryptocurrencies while you were
- 52:50there? How much was there, sort of,
- 52:52like, get on this one? It's about to go up or I heard
- 52:57Whispers And rumbling of that but that's not what I was there
- 53:00for seven. But does it come up like at
- 53:02these dinners? But people are like, oh, like
- 53:04what's the hot? Small currency or buying or
- 53:07absolutely. Absolutely.
- 53:09And I think, what's also interesting is You know, back to
- 53:12the Open Sea. Ethical lapse that, you know,
- 53:16they had to depart Reserve in there, keep their product guy
- 53:20was before they would list it. You know, buying some of the
- 53:24collection of nft is known on their homepage so he then knew
- 53:28where the volume would then go, right.
- 53:29He was bomb but then these kryptos lose found it and as a
- 53:34result and that part of the promise of this technology is
- 53:37how quickly someone was able to find it because it's all public
- 53:39on The Ledger. And so, They founded.
- 53:42And then he they had to fire him.
- 53:44But, you know, you've got to believe there are employees at
- 53:49coinbase and a bunch of these companies who are seeing flows
- 53:53happen and acting on them, right because there's no regular
- 53:56regulation about all of it. So to me it seemed and back to
- 54:00the question earlier about the amount of financial speculation
- 54:04it definitely was coming up and a lot of the you know, hushed
- 54:07Whispers that I wasn't necessarily participating in
- 54:10that. There is a lot of Of and even
- 54:12it's interesting when you talk about the VCS themselves, right?
- 54:16The multi coins, the Alameda research, the jump capitals, the
- 54:20finance, a lot of them have both Venture arms and hedge funds and
- 54:25that's new to the Venture Capital World, Andreessen
- 54:27Horowitz. I'm sure we'll introduce it in
- 54:292023 but and you know and the changes that Sequoia just made
- 54:33are preparing but they're going to think of it more as a mutual
- 54:36fund approach less than a hedge fund.
- 54:39But what's interesting in to me, You're going to this crypto
- 54:42world, and I grew up in New York and her friends.
- 54:44A lot of the hedge funds is hedge funds, entering the space.
- 54:48You have to understand, you know, you have to approach it
- 54:51with a sense of caution. And with real due diligence,
- 54:55because their incentives in, you know, creating the ecosystem
- 54:59around a currency, they were very early in which they're
- 55:02incredibly deep holders. M are not aligned necessarily
- 55:05with those of your company. And I think really getting, you
- 55:10know, in terms of what you're building on Whose money or
- 55:13taking thinking hard about that and who's, you know, when you
- 55:16give access to the information, the private information of your
- 55:19company who are you giving it to?
- 55:20And why you have to be really, really careful about that, hmm.
- 55:24He's yeah, these firms want visibility into how things are
- 55:27going so they want access to companies, you might see it,
- 55:30right? And I think they're all from my
- 55:33interactions, ethical genuine, thoughtful people.
- 55:36But still, you know, you know, this is an incredibly
- 55:40capitalists. Machine.
- 55:43Like if you had a an ape or whatever Krypto Punk like was it
- 55:48obvious that you own like we're people wearing them on there
- 55:51like t-shirts or was there a way to like in the real world signal
- 55:54to people? Like I sunk a bazillion dollars
- 55:57and do a hot and ft at this thing.
- 55:59Yes! People wearing them on t-shirts.
- 56:02Alexis Ohanian. Whom I love is our lead seed
- 56:05investor. He wore his crypto Punk of his
- 56:08wife Serena Williams to the Met Gala.
- 56:11That's so absolutely there's a huge element of Pride taken and
- 56:16being a part of this community is the nice side of it for sure
- 56:20but it's also a status symbol. You know.
- 56:22You see on Twitter people refer to their nft collections as the
- 56:25equivalent of their Rolex, right?
- 56:27So it's like having a really fancy watch.
- 56:29I like seeing a huge crossover between like sneaker heads and
- 56:32people that are in 2nf. TS, right, right.
- 56:35Do you have a fancy nft? No, no.
- 56:38I see nothing wrong with it though.
- 56:39But I also don't have a fancy watch or a fancy.
- 56:41The car right? Well, that's the next move.
- 56:44I mean, if that's the end of, that's the culture, that
- 56:46society, that decision not to wear those things is like, I do
- 56:50think it's weird, and I think somebody else was maybe it was
- 56:53like Sam, Lester's. I I mean, our culture,
- 56:56especially Silicon Valley culture, moved away from like
- 57:00the showy wealth of Wall Street and like Rolex type behavior.
- 57:03And I think in like San Francisco that was always sort
- 57:06of tacky, you know, you just like we're all birds and a
- 57:10hoodie or whatever. It's Strange to me, that sort of
- 57:14the yeah that's super consumerist showy.
- 57:16And if tea culture has sort of become acceptable and I wonder
- 57:22how long I think it's part of it is related to the rise of
- 57:26injuries and Horowitz, right? Which is as much a media Empire
- 57:29as an investing Empire and heard was so inspired by what Michael
- 57:32Ovitz did was CIA, right? Why did it?
- 57:35Why did Chris lines win the clubhouse deal?
- 57:37It was because he was able to get Kevin Hart and a bunch of
- 57:40celebrities even though You know, the clubhouse team had
- 57:43been Benchmark, entrepreneurs and residents, right?
- 57:46Brutal, right. So, they saw, they saw a real
- 57:49strategic and again, to my point earlier, social media consumer,
- 57:54Tech social companies are cultural artifacts, and
- 57:57therefore, are inextricably linked to celebrity in this
- 58:00country. Are you an and recent company?
- 58:03No, we're not. I am an admirer, you know, I met
- 58:05them. I think what?
- 58:07And have met a number of the partners, over the years.
- 58:10I think, what they do isn't Incredibly impressive for a
- 58:13number of reasons. Yeah.
- 58:14And the people working there very small, right.
- 58:16But the truth is, when you look at the rise of Instagram, right?
- 58:20Scooter Braun was calling, Kevin trying to get Bieber to be an
- 58:23investor. When it because Bieber drove a
- 58:25huge part of the adoption Snapchat, a little less.
- 58:28So because it's based on intimacy but Clubhouse their
- 58:30rise very driven by celebrities Twitter.
- 58:33Of course, huge moment when Ashton Kutcher was using it and
- 58:36that inspired Ashton becoming a VC and then Oprah, you know,
- 58:40there's great. Beans in that Nick Bilton book
- 58:43about their servers melting when Oprah.
- 58:46First, you know, talked about Twitter on her show which was,
- 58:49you know, the preeminent couch at that time.
- 58:51So I think Silicon Valley has long wanted to believe that.
- 58:56It's all about product and engineering and you acts but
- 59:00celebrities have always driven adoption.
- 59:02And so, there's been this uncomfortable relationship with
- 59:06Hollywood, of course, because who's who's your most helpful?
- 59:11Bertie investor, we got a number, you know, of course, in
- 59:14the beginning, it was David, but can't pick among your children,
- 59:17right? Yeah.
- 59:18All that happened. But you know, now we've brought
- 59:20Annie Leibovitz and her team Karen and Jason are unbelievably
- 59:23help. We're going to hopefully do
- 59:25something big with them soon. The Chainsmokers have been
- 59:28amazing, you know I've course of a long relationship with Sofia
- 59:31Vergara and her manager Luiz. It's like my brother.
- 59:33They've been very very helpful to us.
- 59:36We have a number card Delevingne got involved.
- 59:38Kevin Durand Rich climb in. I just saw her.
- 59:41Every dollar and Rudi with Mastery.
- 59:44So I mean and and in right are coming wasn't going to mention
- 59:47the name, you underestimate La tech companies.
- 59:49Like name-dropping is the currency down there like he'd go
- 59:52on for more. Well you can you can't leave
- 59:55anybody out. They all want to help it is
- 59:56amazing. I mean, it's yeah, it's cool.
- 59:59It's a cool moment right now. I mean cool.
- 1:00:03Well I don't know any final, thoughts from anybody?
- 1:00:05I got one last question here. You know we're recording this
- 1:00:07episode both Eric and I are in New York City momentous day
- 1:00:10earlier this week when Eric Adams was not only elected
- 1:00:13mayor, but made the announcement that he was going to be
- 1:00:16accepting his first three paychecks in Bitcoin.
- 1:00:19Can you pledge or sign a pledge on our show that the next couple
- 1:00:23of paychecks that you get will be in some sort of
- 1:00:25cryptocurrency to our accountants?
- 1:00:27But I'm incredibly interested in that.
- 1:00:30Thank you for. All right, thank you so much for
- 1:00:34coming on. Covered a lot of ground, you
- 1:00:36know, kind of Realtek, shit. You know, web three.
- 1:00:39We use that phrase which I don't think we've said before on the
- 1:00:43show, I'm not sure. Thanks a lot.
- 1:00:45This is fun. So if I'm Valerie, goodbye,
- 1:01:07goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:01:08Goodbye goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.