Latest / Columbus' Morning News / 11 year old girl mauled by 2 Pitbulls! What should the punishment be?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: The lawn.
- 0:00Speaker 2: I may have to drag the sprinkler out just to
- 0:03kind of green it up a little bit.
- 0:04Speaker 1: This afternoon. It's a little crispy, little crispy.
- 0:08Speaker 2: They're starting to use the d word drought because we
- 0:12really have not had any rain since.
- 0:14Speaker 1: Pretty dry August July.
- 0:15Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, nothing of really any measurability there.
- 0:20Speaker 1: So we'll see what happens next.
- 0:22Speaker 2: Best chance of showers, by the way, gotta be Sunday morning,
- 0:24but that's a very slight chance.
- 0:26Speaker 1: So kind of feels like Texas is what it does.
- 0:29Speaker 2: Let's go there down to Dallas our attorney legal defense
- 0:32firm dot com.
- 0:33Speaker 1: It's Jeremy Rosenthal j R. How are you, man?
- 0:36Speaker 3: Man? Good Texas is We're the land of winners because
- 0:39we win that everything we do. We just like to
- 0:42win here at football and whatever, everything, powerball. I think
- 0:46they were from here.
- 0:47Speaker 1: Yeah, they were one of them. Was anyway.
- 0:49Speaker 2: I mean there are some there are some Ohio State
- 0:52fans that would beg to differ with you that Texas
- 0:55doesn't win everything.
- 0:57Speaker 4: Oh I was referring to the two and zero Texas
- 1:00tech Red Raiders.
- 1:02Speaker 1: You were, Hey, I want to pick your brain.
- 1:06Speaker 2: We got a couple of kind of a lighter fun
- 1:08stories that are actually pretty interesting.
- 1:10Speaker 1: I want to get to you. But a local story here.
- 1:12And I don't know if you have.
- 1:13Speaker 2: Any any experience with you know, dog attacks or dog
- 1:17bites as a defense attorney, Jeremy. But story here and
- 1:21I'll give you that just a quick nutshell. Eleven year
- 1:23old girl was attacked last summer, brutally mauled by two
- 1:28American bulldogs. She was in a coma for a week.
- 1:33She's had to learn how to walk, eat and talk again.
- 1:36She's undergone at least six surgeries. She was brutally mauled.
- 1:41And this is only a misdemeanor in Ohio. So the
- 1:44dog owner the max sentence is thirty days in jail.
- 1:48She's only going to serve four days in jail and
- 1:50pay about five hundred bucks in fines and court costs.
- 1:54Speaker 1: The question is how do you how do you handle this?
- 1:59Speaker 2: Because she was found guilty of failing to confine and
- 2:02control the dogs, right so, and I get that, But
- 2:07you don't know what's in the mind of an animal though, right,
- 2:10I mean, so, how do you handle something like this?
- 2:13Speaker 3: That's the challenge. The challenge is is that you are.
- 2:17It's really hard from a due process standpoint to be
- 2:21criminally responsible for the action of somebody else or an
- 2:27animal that is a domestic animal right you can have
- 2:32if you have a tiger, that's a different story. And
- 2:36a pit bull kind of falls on the line, right,
- 2:40I mean, you've got people who love pit bulls. You've got,
- 2:44I know, plenty of pit bull owners. Sure, you just
- 2:47don't you know, and they'll they'll they will, they'll argue
- 2:50with you all day about how docile and peaceful they are,
- 2:53and I'm sure they're right. Then again, you have stories
- 2:56like this. So from a due process standpoint, it's really
- 3:00really hard to prosecute somebody for something like this, which
- 3:03is why the sentence range is so low. So it's
- 3:08really and it's really hard. It would be hard to
- 3:10afford to pass constitutional muster if the punishment range was
- 3:15really a lot higher than this.
- 3:16Speaker 2: Yeah, I would imagine it comes down to as a
- 3:19pet owner, you as the human owner, are ultimately responsible
- 3:23for the actions of that animal no matter what happens
- 3:26under any situation. You should not have your animal in
- 3:29a in.
- 3:31Speaker 1: A scenario where it could do this.
- 3:33Speaker 2: I mean, you don't know if you know maybe the
- 3:35the the in any case, if the animal was provoked
- 3:38by a child, or maybe the child had just pet
- 3:41another dog or a cat and they got us a
- 3:43whiff of something it didn't like it took.
- 3:46Speaker 1: I mean that it's really hard.
- 3:47Speaker 2: I mean your heart goes out to the family and
- 3:49this little girl in this situation. And there are people
- 3:53that say that this should be a felony. I don't
- 3:55know that that's the answer, but it's just a it's
- 3:57a heartbreaking story. And you know, four days in jail
- 4:01in exchange for being in a coma for a week,
- 4:04and and you know, six or seven surgeries.
- 4:06Speaker 1: It doesn't seem fair. But I don't know what else
- 4:08you do.
- 4:10Speaker 3: No, you can pass new legislation require uh people that
- 4:15with certain breeds of dogs carry you insurance. Yes, you
- 4:19could do something like that. You could, uh. And and
- 4:22really civil liability here is a little easier when you're
- 4:25when you're in law school, they teach you that it's
- 4:27actually called the one bite rule, which means that the
- 4:30first bite from your dog is free.
- 4:32Speaker 1: Right.
- 4:33Speaker 3: But then once you're on notice that your dog likes
- 4:35to do this, you're you're strictly liable. You're liable when you're.
- 4:39Speaker 1: When your dog. Yeah, I like that. That makes sense
- 4:43to me.
- 4:44Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, uh and and uh and this I understand,
- 4:49this is the dog. This was this dog's first attack.
- 4:53So yeah, it's it's it's it's horrifying for the for
- 4:56the poor kid, and for the for the family. And uh,
- 5:00probably the dog owner doesn't feel great about it either, probably,
- 5:03so yeah, and yeah, and it's like I said, I've
- 5:08known plenty of pit ball owners that that they just
- 5:12I mean, you start talking about how dangerous they are
- 5:15and they will shut you down. And and so it
- 5:19could be a hard topic.
- 5:20Speaker 1: Yeah, very emotional, no doubt.
- 5:22Speaker 2: I appreciate your perspective on that and pivoting and talking
- 5:24about that with us. Jeremy Rosenthal, our defense attorney in Dallas,
- 5:28Texas legal defense firm dot com. I'm sorry, Texas Defensefirm
- 5:31dot com. Jeremy, let's switch it up and go a
- 5:35little bit lighter. This guy from Indiana, his name just
- 5:39so happens to be Mark Zuckerberg.
- 5:42Speaker 1: He's suing Facebook.
- 5:43Speaker 2: He's suing Meta because his accounts were disabled at least
- 5:47five times in the last eight years. He's trying to
- 5:50advertise on Facebook and his business and personal pages, and
- 5:54they are shutting him down because they're accusing him of
- 5:58impersonating a celebrity.
- 6:01Speaker 3: Right, right, Yeah, So there's a lot of different reasons
- 6:03for a lawsuit, right. There's when you are aggrieved and
- 6:06you are the victim of something and you need to
- 6:09see justice, right, That's that's a good reason for a lawsuit.
- 6:12When you're hurt or injured, you know, that's a good reason.
- 6:15When you're angry at somebody, that's a good reason. When
- 6:17you have voices in your head, that's a reason. Or
- 6:22you want to advertise to the world for free because
- 6:25your name is Mark s Zuckerberg and you handle bankruptcyes
- 6:28in Indianapolis, Indiana, and you want the whole world to
- 6:31know about your practice, and you get people talking on
- 6:34the radio everywhere about it. That's another reason to sue somebody. So, yes,
- 6:39Mark s Zuckerberg is suing Meta. And he's had some headaches, right,
- 6:45he's had a headbanging experience with with Facebook. They've they've
- 6:49kind of yeah, they put him in Facebook jail a
- 6:52whole bunch of times. Actually, this poor guy he gets
- 6:56he like he gets hate mail, you know, just not
- 6:59not because they think he's the real Mark Zuckerberg, or
- 7:02or he is the real Mark Zuckerberg. You know what
- 7:04I mean. Right here, they think he's the other Mark,
- 7:06the famous Mark Zuckerberg, right, the famous Mark. He gets
- 7:09hate mail. He actually got sued once on accident by
- 7:12Washington State. By the State of Washington was suing Facebook
- 7:16over something and they actually served this poor guy, uh
- 7:20and and and so like. Can you imagine how bad
- 7:24it would be like if like some famous Jeremy Rosenthal
- 7:29went and decided to hit sixty home runs for the Yankees, right,
- 7:33and then you're the for the rest of your life.
- 7:36You know, God, that's got it that that that can't
- 7:39be any fun.
- 7:40Speaker 2: I mean, I think it's safe to say you are
- 7:42the most famous Jeremy Rosenthal out there.
- 7:44Speaker 1: There's no doubt, There's no doubt in my mind.
- 7:47Speaker 3: With with my luck, there's another Jeremy Rosenthal running around
- 7:51out there who's going to be the president who I'm
- 7:53gonna hate, right, and I'm gonna I'm gonna hate him
- 7:56and then every day of my life, oh, just like
- 7:58the count and you gotta you know that just that
- 8:03can't be fun.
- 8:03Speaker 4: I'm just I'm just saying, Jeremy Rosenthal Texas defense firm
- 8:06dot com Yes or no question, I'll let you fly.
- 8:09And I wish we wish we had more time for this,
- 8:11the hard hitting story of the morning. Should Taylor Swift
- 8:14and Travis Kelsey have a prenup?
- 8:17Speaker 3: Absolutely absolutely, there you go, yeah, no, it's it's it's
- 8:21gonna cost him eighty times more to to to to
- 8:25triage it after they break up, and let's be honest,
- 8:28we all want this to fail.