Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #5: Previewing the 2026 Big 12 Season
Transcript
- 0:14Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:18As we've done in the last couple episodes, we will continue to preview the twenty twenty-six college football season, going conference by conference.
- 0:25And today, we'll be talking about the Big 12 Conference.
- 0:28The twenty twenty-six season will be the thirty-first for the Big 12, and they'll be in their third season at 16 teams.
- 0:34Big 12 has played a huge part in recent conference realignment.
- 0:38In twenty twenty-three, they added BYU, Central Florida, Cincinnati, and Houston.
- 0:42Then, once Oklahoma and Texas left the following year, they added Colorado, Arizona, Arizona State, and Utah, all joining the Big 12 from the Pac-12.
- 0:52So, the Big 12 has swelled from just 10 teams in twenty twenty-two to 16 teams by twenty twenty-four, where it will remain for the twenty twenty-six season.
- 1:01The Big 12 competed well head-to-head ag- with the other conferences in the country, matching the Big Ten with winning records against five of the other conferences, including an even two and two record against the Big Ten.
- 1:12They trailed only the SEC in the CSR conference rankings, while ranking ahead of the final Power Four conference, the ACC.
- 1:20At the end of the twenty twenty-five regular season, Texas Tech and BYU were tied atop the Big 12 at an equal eight and one record, sending both teams to the Big 12 championship game where Texas Tech took down BYU for the second time last season and claimed the number four seed in the twenty twenty-five college football playoff.
- 1:37While the Big 12 only got their champion, and the committee really fell short in their ranking of BYU, BYU should have been in the playoff over the Miami Hurricanes.
- 1:45Not only were their direct wins more impressive statistically, but the quality of their opponents' wins outshined Miami's as well.
- 1:52Last year's CSR, this was the only qualm that we had with the college football playoff, was the omission of BYU.
- 2:00Ranked Big 12 teams by the CSR at the end of the season included number four, Texas Tech, number seven, BYU, sixteen, Utah, and twenty-one, Arizona.
- 2:08Houston fell just outside the top twenty-five of the CSR, but they did fall inside the college football playoff committee's top twenty-five at number twenty-one.
- 2:17At the bottom of the conference, we saw Oklahoma State finishing at one and eleven, and then one- moving up the standings, we saw Colorado, West Virginia, UCF, and Kansas.
- 2:27With all Power conferences now playing nine conference games, the Big 12 can label themselves trendsetters, as they were the first to start a nine-game slate in two thousand eleven, five years before the Big Ten followed suit.
- 2:38And now, in twenty twenty-six, both the SEC and ACC have moved to nine-game conference schedules too.
- 2:44In the twenty twenty-six season, the Big 12 will face every other Power conference at least three times, but there are a few group of six conferences they'll play only twice.
- 2:52The American, Conference USA, MAC, and Mountain West matchups with Big 12 teams will loom large in the upcoming season for the Common Sense ranking.
- 3:00Okay, just like with the ACC and the American, we're gonna tackle the Big 12 alphabetically First up will be the Arizona Wildcats, who finished nine and three last season and ranked number twenty-one in the Common Sense rankings at the end of the season, number seventeen in the College Football Playoff Committee rankings.
- 3:17Brent Brennan will return for his third season with the Wildcats, and he'll have the benefit of retaining both his offensive and defensive coordinators from last season.
- 3:25Arizona scored the third most points per game in the Big Twelve in twenty twenty-five at thirty-one and a half points, in large part due to their passing offense.
- 3:33Defensively, the Wildcats allowed less than twenty points a game, ranking first in the Big Twelve in opponent pass yards per game at just a hundred and sixty-five per contest.
- 3:41Arizona didn't have the best incoming transfer portal class, but they also didn't need to, as they were able to retain much of the twenty twenty-five roster in the offseason.
- 3:49That includes Noah Fifita, the preseason All-Big Twelve quarterback, who returns to lead the offense.
- 3:54Key additions will be new starters at each safety on defense, with a couple new linebackers coming in to start as well.
- 3:59Arizona will, unfortunately, have the second hardest schedule among Big Twelve teams in twenty twenty-six.
- 4:04That's based on the final CSR points from twenty twenty-five.
- 4:07Their non-conference slate includes one of two Big Twelve matchups with the Mountain West and a week three date with Northern Illinois.
- 4:13Their other FBS opponent out of conference is Washington State in week four.
- 4:17In conference, they'll have games against the majority of the teams in the top half of the twenty twenty-five standings.
- 4:22Texas Tech, BYU, and Utah, the top three teams from the Big Twelve last year, all appear on the Wildcats schedule.
- 4:29If Arizona didn't have to play such a hard schedule, they'd be poised for a great season.
- 4:33They've got a potential award-winning QB leading the offense and quality added on defense, but there are just too many good teams on their schedule.
- 4:40So unfortunately, I'd predict another nine and three-ish finish for the Wildcats this season.
- 4:46Kenny Dillingham will return to lead the Arizona State Sun Devils in twenty twenty-six, being rejoined by Marcus Arroyo at offensive coordinator and Brian Ward as the defensive coordinator.
- 4:55The Sun Devils finished eight and four in twenty twenty-five, finishing sixth in the conference in the final common sense rankings.
- 5:01Their season ended last year with a loss to in-state rival Arizona.
- 5:05Arizona State had a prolific rushing offense in twenty twenty-five, gaining nearly two hundred yards on the ground per contest, but they couldn't translate that into points, scoring only twenty-five points per game.
- 5:15Defensively, their rush defense ranked third in the conference, allowing just one hundred and twenty-four yards a game.
- 5:21The Sun Devils ranked near the top of the conference in incoming transfer talent, but lost talent to the portal as well.
- 5:26They'll need to replace one of the most sought-after QBs of the off-season in Sam Levitt, you'll see him at LSU next season.
- 5:31But they did manage to find talent at several game-changing positions, with key additions coming at wide receiver, linebacker, and edge rusher.
- 5:38That includes wide receiver Omarion Miller, who was the only ASU player in the preseason All-Big Twelve.
- 5:44Arizona State's schedule in twenty twenty-six comes right in the middle of the conference.
- 5:48There will be extra pressure on their out-of-conference game against Hawaii, as that is one of just two games the Big Twelve plays against the Mountain West.
- 5:54They'll also have a match up with Texas A&M in week two, which boosts their strength of schedule considerably.
- 5:59ASU gets the benefit of playing several teams in the Big Twelve that were near the bottom of the conference last season.
- 6:04Oklahoma State, Colorado, UCF, and Kansas are all on their schedule, while Texas Tech and BYU will be games everyone is going to be watching.
- 6:12It won't be easy to improve on their eight and four season from a year ago, especially after losing your star QB, but I think they could log nine wins given the relative ease of their Big Twelve schedule.
- 6:22The Baylor Bears finished last season five and seven with a three and six conference record.
- 6:27Dave Aranda will enter his seventh season with the program, also returning his offensive coordinator, Jake Spavital, for season number three, while his defensive coordinator will be new.
- 6:35Baylor hired Joe Klanderman away from Kansas State in the off-season.
- 6:39It was the pass attack that was Baylor's bread and butter in twenty twenty-five, ranking first in pass yards per game and second in pass touchdowns.
- 6:45But for all the yardage they picked up, they allowed just as much to opposing offenses, allowing thirty-two points per game on defense and nearly two hundred rushing yards per contest.
- 6:54Baylor hit the portal hard, landing thirty recruits in one of the better transfer classes in the Big Twelve.
- 6:59That includes likely QB one DJ Lagway, previously of the Florida Gators.
- 7:03Past Lagway, Baylor shored up both the offensive and defensive lines where there will be plenty of new faces in twenty twenty-six.
- 7:10Baylor plays the third hardest schedule among Big Twelve teams with a date with Auburn in week one getting them started quickly.
- 7:16In week two, they'll play an FCS team and then Louisiana Tech in week three.
- 7:20They'll only face two of the four CSR ranked Big Twelve teams in twenty twenty-five in both BYU and Texas Tech, while also getting dealt games with Colorado, UCF, and Kansas from the bottom half of the conference.
- 7:32My prediction is a bowl-eligible season for the Baylor Bears.
- 7:35They're likely to be favored in over half their games.
- 7:37And if we give them one upset, I'd say a seven or maybe even an eight-win season is possible, while bowl eligibility is a must for the twenty twenty-six Baylor Bears.
- 7:46The Cougars of BYU deserved a spot in the college football playoff last season.
- 7:51They finished at CSR number seven, well higher than the Miami Hurricanes team based on resume through the regular season.
- 7:57Kalani Sitake is entering his 11th season for the Cougars, while OC Aaron Roderick will commandeer the offense for the sixth time.
- 8:04Defensive coordinator Kelly Poppinga is new, as their previous DC got lured to go to Michigan.
- 8:10BYU's offense was above average but not stellar statistically in twenty twenty-five, but their defense held opposing offenses to the second fewest rush yards per game in the Big Twelve and also picked off the most passes in the conference.
- 8:22It was quality, not quantity, for BYU in the portal.
- 8:25They didn't pick up a lot of recruits, but the players they did import are going to be impact players.
- 8:30Cade Uluave is going to be a force at linebacker in twenty twenty-six, and three of the top incoming players are new pass catchers for returning quarterback Bear Bachmeier.
- 8:39They have two offensive and four defensive players on the preseason All-Big Twelve team too, so they're expecting big things from those key players in twenty twenty-six.
- 8:48BYU plays the fifth hardest schedule in the Big Twelve this coming season.
- 8:52They'll begin the season with an FCS school, then play Colorado State in week three and Notre Dame in week seven.
- 8:58In conference, they'll avoid Texas Tech, but they will have to face the numbers three and four teams from the Big Twelve in the common sense ranking last year, Utah and Arizona.
- 9:07BYU has set itself up for another run at the Big Twelve title, which now gets an auto bid to the CFP.
- 9:12If they can avoid slip-ups against teams they should beat, they'll be right back in the CFP conversation come December.
- 9:19The Cincinnati Bearcats found themselves mired in the middle of the twenty twenty-five Big 12, finishing seven and five with a five and four conference record.
- 9:27Head coach Scott Satterfield did enough to retain his job going into his fourth season, but he was required to replace both offensive and defensive coordinators at the end of twenty twenty-five.
- 9:37While Cincinnati's stats were mostly middle-of-the-road compared to the Big 12 Conference, where they really struggled was maintaining possession of the ball.
- 9:43They averaged just twenty-four minutes of possession in the twenty twenty-five season, worst in college football by a full two minutes.
- 9:50Cincinnati's transfer success was highlighted by its pass catchers as, count them, one, two, three, four of their top incoming talents are wide receivers.
- 9:57They'll likely also have a handful of new starters on defense, mostly at linebackers and in the secondary.
- 10:03Cincinnati plays the fourth toughest schedule among Big 12 teams in twenty twenty-six.
- 10:07After opening the season with a matchup with Boston College, their week three tilt with Miami, Ohio is the one of the two Big 12-MAC matchups alongside Iowa State-Bowling Green.
- 10:17Those two games will determine which conference has more head-to-head success versus the other.
- 10:22Cincinnati also has a horrendous in-conference slate, playing each of the top five teams from last season's Common Sense rankings in the Big 12.
- 10:29Based on the immensity of their conference games, I'm guessing Cincinnati is right around bowl eligibility again, finishing somewhere between five and seven wins.
- 10:38Coach Prime, Deion Sanders, is back for season number four in Boulder, Colorado, leading the Buffaloes into twenty twenty-six.
- 10:44He's had to replace both coordinators, but he hired Brennan Marion with his go-go offense from Sacramento State, then Chris Marve was hired internally to oversee the D.
- 10:53In twenty twenty-five, Deion Sanders led the Buffaloes to the bottom of the Big Twelve, only finishing ahead of Oklahoma State in the year-end CSR rankings.
- 11:02Colorado struggled in all facets of the game in twenty twenty-five, but were particularly porous when it came to stopping the run.
- 11:08They allowed two hundred and twenty-two rushing yards per game, second worst in the FBS last season behind only Eastern Michigan.
- 11:15Coach Prime's biggest asset, without much argument, is his ability to bring in talent.
- 11:19Colorado brought in forty-three new players for the twenty twenty-six season with, get this, every single starter on defense likely to be an incoming transfer.
- 11:28The offense is only slightly more stable, but only just as they break in new starting quarterback Julian Lewis.
- 11:33Colorado's schedule isn't overly tough in twenty twenty-six, ranking in the middle of the conference.
- 11:38They'll start their season against Georgia Tech and also have a game against Northwestern for eleven total Power Four matchups.
- 11:44In conference, they'll get the benefit of playing Baylor, UCF, and Oklahoma State, but they'll also need to play Texas Tech and Utah throughout the season.
- 11:52Colorado's goal for the upcoming season will be to get to bowl eligibility, no matter what their famous head coach is telling the press.
- 12:00The Houston Cougars will have all three of its top coaches returning in twenty twenty-six.
- 12:04Head coach Willie Fritz will enter his third season on the sideline after a huge bounce back year in twenty twenty-five.
- 12:09Houston finished inside the top twenty-five of the final college football playoff rankings, but just outside the CSR top twenty-five at the end of last season.
- 12:17A nine and three record and a bowl win are giving the Cougars some high expectations coming into twenty twenty-six.
- 12:22Houston's defense performed better than its offense in twenty twenty-five, allowing fewer than twenty-three points per game.
- 12:28Where Houston's offense excelled, however, was maintaining possession.
- 12:31They lost the fewest fumbles in the league and had possession for over thirty-two minutes per game.
- 12:37Houston had a higher inflow of talent than outflow through the portal in the off-season.
- 12:40While they didn't set the world on fire with a number of newcomers, they made them count with new skill position starters on offense and a key signing in Ashton Porter on the defensive front.
- 12:50Fortunately for Houston, they'll face an easier schedule in twenty twenty-six compared to their peers.
- 12:54Oregon State and Georgia Southern make out of conference wins look likely.
- 12:58In the Big Twelve, they'll have to deal with Texas Tech and Utah, but the rest of their schedule is against the bottom half of the conference based on finishing CSR in twenty twenty-five.
- 13:07Based on their easy schedule and a good inflow of talent, the Houston Cougars have a better chance than most to lock up a Big Twelve Championship game spot in twenty twenty-six, and a spot in the playoff is definitely within reach.
- 13:19The Iowa State Cyclones finished the 2025 season at eight and four, finishing conference play at five and four, which was good for eighth in the Big 12 in the Common Sense rankings.
- 13:29The Cyclones will be breaking in a new set of coaches as most of their previous staff is now at Penn State.
- 13:34Jimmy Rogers is the man taking over the top position, having joined ISU after one successful season at Washington State.
- 13:41It was incredible how average Iowa State's stats were in 2025.
- 13:44I really had to squint to find anything worth mentioning.
- 13:47What I did find, their pass rush was less than stellar.
- 13:50Averaging just one sack per game is not going to get the job done in the Big 12.
- 13:54Unfortunately for Cyclone fans, the off-season transfer portal was more about quantity than quality.
- 13:59They did sign 48 players from the portal but are still at or near the bottom of the transfer rankings going into 2026.
- 14:06The outflow of talent following their coach to Penn State was specifically enormous.
- 14:11One bright spot for the upcoming season though, Iowa State plays an easier schedule amongst the Big 12 teams.
- 14:16They'll have their yearly meeting with Iowa and their game against Bowling Green is crucial because it's one of just two the Big 12 will play against the MAC.
- 14:22So Iowa State needs a dub over Bowling Green to keep the Big 12 near the top of the CSR conference rankings.
- 14:29Iowa State will play more teams from the bottom half of the Big 12, giving some outside hope to a decent season.
- 14:35But with as much talent as they had leave the program, Iowa State will be lucky to be bowl eligible at the end of 2026 The Kansas Jayhawks finished in the bottom half of the CSR in 2025, going five and seven with just a three and six Big 12 record.
- 14:50Lance Leipold has done enough to maintain his job as head coach.
- 14:54He'll head into his sixth season with the returning offensive coordinator and co-defensive coordinators.
- 14:59What held Kansas back in 2025 was their inability to get opposing offenses off the field.
- 15:04They ranked near the bottom of the Big 12 in both third and fourth down defense and didn't force enough turnovers to get their offense chances.
- 15:10When their offense did take the field, they were efficient, ranking near the top of the league in yards per pass attempt and yards per rush.
- 15:17Kansas will be breaking in a handful of new starters that have joined from the transfer portal, including a couple new running backs in Dillon Edwards and Yasen Willis, while also getting help on the defensive line in Kevin Otis, who came over from Arkansas.
- 15:29Kansas has the benefit of an easier schedule for a Big 12 team.
- 15:32They'll have a date with SEC rival Missouri in week two, and they'll play Middle Tennessee in week five, a surprisingly crucial game in the season as it's one of just two featuring a Big 12 Conference USA matchup.
- 15:43They'll need to endure Big 12 matchups with Utah and BYU, but the rest of their schedule features teams no higher than sixth in the Big 12 last season, according to the common sense rankings.
- 15:52So after consecutive five and seven seasons, the Kansas Jayhawks are likely a favorite to go bowling in 2026.
- 16:00Kansas State has brought in a recognizable alumni to coach in twenty twenty-six, hiring former QB Collin Klein to lead the Wildcats.
- 16:07Klein is joined by new OC Sean Gleason from Missouri and new defensive coordinator Jordan Peterson, who joins them from Texas A&M.
- 16:14Kansas State finished the twenty twenty-five season with a balanced six-and-six record and a five-and-four record in conference.
- 16:21Kansas State's rush game carried the offense in their wins as their pass game garnered less than two hundred yards per game in twenty twenty-five.
- 16:28On defense, they averaged both one fumble recovery and one interception a game, forcing turnovers better than most Big Twelve teams.
- 16:35Quarterback Avery Johnson will return to lead the offense, and he'll have the benefit of new receivers coming from the portal in Josh Manning and Isaiah Williams.
- 16:42Defensively, nearly half the defensive starters are incoming transfers, while the biggest addition being Wendell Gregory as an edge rusher.
- 16:49He also makes the All-Big Twelve preseason team.
- 16:52The Wildcats have an average Big Twelve schedule this year.
- 16:55In their non-conference games, their mar- matchup with Tulane will prove important in week three since the Big Twelve only plays the American twice this season.
- 17:02And then their other non-conference game is Washington State.
- 17:05They'll play half their in-conference games against teams from the top half of the Big Twelve last year.
- 17:09But fortunately for the Wildcats, no Texas Tech, no BYU, and no Utah, each of the top three teams from twenty twenty-five.
- 17:17Given their schedule doesn't include the Big Twelve favorites, the Kansas State Wildcats are set up for relative success in twenty twenty-six.
- 17:23I'd be looking for at least seven, but potentially even eight or nine wins for Kansas State.
- 17:29The Oklahoma State Cowboys made a smart move after finishing one and 11 last season.
- 17:34They hired one of the more successful group of six coaches, and he brought a lot of talent with him.
- 17:38Oklahoma State hired Eric Morris away from North Texas, and he brought his offensive and defensive coordinators, as well as his top quarterback, running back, and wide receiver with him.
- 17:48OSU needs to improve in all facets of the game.
- 17:50They scored the fewest points in the Big 12 last season, and they had the fewest rush yards and passing yards in the league, generating less than 300 yards total per game on offense.
- 18:00Defense proved no better.
- 18:01They allowed over 33 points per game on defense while allowing the second most passing yards.
- 18:06The Cowboys will have an entirely new look in 2026, likely starting 20 incoming transfers among the 22 starters on offense and defense, led by Drew Mestemaker, the QB for the Mean Green last season that threw for over 4,300 yards.
- 18:20Oklahoma State's schedule in 2026 includes a date with Tulsa in week one that is a must-win for the Big 12.
- 18:25In order to prove the Big 12 is head-to-head better than the American, the Cowboys will need to start one and O.
- 18:30Then they'll play Oregon in week two before a team from the FCS in week three.
- 18:34Conference games include the four worst teams in the Big 12 from last season not named Oklahoma State, so the upcoming season is ripe for improvement from Stillwater.
- 18:42Bowl eligibility is almost an afterthought going into this season.
- 18:47Sonny Dykes is back for his fifth season at the helm of the TCU Horned Frogs as he looks to recreate the success of his first season, where he led them all the way to the College Football Playoff National Championship.
- 18:57He'll have a new offensive coordinator in Gordon Sams, while defensive coordinator Andy Avalos is back for season number three.
- 19:04Last year, TCU finished at eight and four, scraping a winning record in the Big 12 at five and four.
- 19:10TCU's offense was led by its air attack last year, ranking second in the conference in pass yards per game while ranking near the bottom in rush yards per game.
- 19:17Success was flipped on defense, where their rush defense was significantly better than pass defense when compared to the rest of the Big 12.
- 19:25TCU only picked up 12 incoming transfers through the portal in the off-season, but they did a good job retaining talent as most starters are likely to be homegrown.
- 19:32They did pick up Jaden Craig, their likely QB one from Harvard, as well as improvements at wide receiver, corner, and linebacker for the twenty twenty-six season.
- 19:41TCU's schedule is manageable for twenty twenty-six with non-conference games versus North Carolina in week zero and Arkansas State in week three.
- 19:49Games against UCF, West Virginia, and Kansas will be circled as hopeful dubs in the Big 12, but they'll have a hill to climb in games with BYU, Arizona, Utah, and Texas Tech.
- 19:58TCU looks destined for a similar result in twenty twenty-five.
- 20:02Bowl eligibility is almost assured, but progressing to the top of the Big 12 is unlikely given who stands in their way.
- 20:08The defending Big 12 champions are back and looking to repeat.
- 20:12The Texas Tech Red Raiders have retained their head coach, Joey McGuire, as well as both their coordinators.
- 20:17The most important retention, though, is likely the money from their biggest boosters, and the Red Raiders can pay their players more than most other teams in the country.
- 20:25Texas Tech wrapped up the regular season last year at eleven and one.
- 20:28They then won the Big 12 championship to lock up a bye as the fourth seed in the college football playoff, only to fail to score a single point against Oregon when they played them in the Orange Bowl.
- 20:38Texas Tech blitzed the Big 12 in twenty twenty-five, both literally and figuratively.
- 20:42They ranked first in total sacks but also top three in offensive points, passing yards, and rushing yards, while simultaneously allowing the third fewest points in the country and the fewest rush yards per game in the country on defense.
- 20:53Texas Tech's off-season was marred by the Brendan Sorsby saga, which resolved itself by his leaving school.
- 20:58But TTU is filled to the brim with talent.
- 21:01Putting seven players on the preseason All-Big 12 team, Texas Tech's portal additions were highlighted by the defense, where they added both starters and depth at all three levels.
- 21:09Texas Tech will also face the easiest schedule in the Big 12 this season.
- 21:13They'll play Oregon State in week two and have a date with Sam Houston in week four, one of just two Big 12-CUSA matchups this season.
- 21:19So even though it's a likely win, they need to win it for the Big 12's sake.
- 21:24In conference, they'll avoid BYU and Utah while also getting games against Colorado, West Virginia, and Baylor, three of the bottom teams in the conference last season.
- 21:32Texas Tech is the heavy favorite to win the Big 12 again, and there's no reason they shouldn't.
- 21:36They're reloaded at key positions through the portal and have the easiest schedule, and I'd be surprised if their name wasn't called on selection Sunday in December.
- 21:44The UCF Knights finished near the bottom of the Big 12, ranking thirteenth of the sixteen teams in twenty twenty-five in the CSR at five and seven, but managing just two wins in conference.
- 21:54They will have the benefit of returning coaches as Scott Frost enters his fourth season at head coach, and both coordinators are entering season number two.
- 22:02The bright spot statistically last season for the Knights was their pass defense, which allowed just a hundred and eighty-five yards per game, good for third in the Big 12.
- 22:09Offensively, it was mediocrity all the way around, ranking in the bottom half in points scored, as well as pass yards per game and rush yards per game.
- 22:17UCF will have the benefit of an easier schedule for a Big 12 team in twenty twenty-six.
- 22:21They'll start FCS, Pittsburgh, Georgia State, then launch into a Big 12 schedule that includes BYU and Houston from near the top of last season's standings, but also games against Oklahoma State, Colorado, and Kansas from near the bottom.
- 22:34UCF will likely be favored in a handful of games this season, but I don't see them overcoming last season.
- 22:39No bowl for the Knights in twenty twenty-six.
- 22:42The Utah Utes finished the 2025 season ranked number 16 in the CSR, good for third among Big 12 teams after earning a 10-2 record.
- 22:50Morgan Scally was promoted from defensive coordinator to head coach following a regular season which saw longtime Utah coach Kyle Whittingham leave for the Michigan Wolverines.
- 22:59Scally will be joined by first-year coordinators Kevin McGiven on offense, formerly of Utah State, and Colton Swann on defense, who was another promotion from within.
- 23:07Utah led the Big 12 in points per game in 2025, averaging 41 per contest, thanks in large part to their ground game, which ranked second in yards per game in the country.
- 23:16While they couldn't stop the run on defense, both their defensive passing yards per game and points allowed per game were second in the Big 12.
- 23:24Utah saw a lot of star players follow their coach to Michigan, so while many of their starters in 2026 were on the roster last year, it may still take a few games to get familiar with those starters.
- 23:33They added 17 players from the portal, including two of their likely starting wide receivers in Braden Piegan from Utah State and Kyrie Shulz from San Jose State.
- 23:41Utah's 2026 schedule is on the easier end of the conference, coming in as the 11th hardest among Big 12 teams.
- 23:47A yearly showdown with Utah State finishes a non-conference slate that includes Arkansas.
- 23:52In conference, their hardest test will be in-state rival BYU, as well as games versus Houston and Arizona.
- 23:58On the easier end of their schedule, they get games against Kansas, Colorado, and West Virginia, teams in the bottom five of the conference last season.
- 24:05Utah lost talent, no doubt, but hiring from within is crucial to continuity.
- 24:09I predict the Ute players will rally behind their first-year coach, but they'll have trouble reaching the 10 wins they had in 2025.
- 24:17We'll wrap with the West Virginia Mountaineers, who finished fourteenth of the sixteen Big 12 teams in the Common Sense rankings in twenty twenty-five, stumbling to a four and eight finishing record.
- 24:26Rich Rodriguez is entering his second year of his second stint with the Mountaineers, and he'll be overseeing offensive play-calling duties in twenty twenty-six, while Zach Alley will return for his second season calling the defense.
- 24:38West Virginia had a hard time scoring points in twenty twenty-five, ranking near the bottom of the conference with an average of just twenty-one points per game.
- 24:45Defensively, they allowed the most pass yards per game of any team in the conference, making it glaringly obvious where they need to improve.
- 24:52West Virginia is projected to start mostly transfers on both sides of the ball, with a key newcomer being running back Cam Cook, who did make the preseason All-Big 12 team.
- 25:01They also shored up their defensive secondary, securing new starters at both safeties as well as pass rushers on the edge.
- 25:07Unfortunately for West Virginia, the Mountaineers face the hardest schedule of any Big 12 team.
- 25:12They'll have games against Coastal Carolina and Virginia, as well as the seemingly required FCS team in the first three weeks of the season.
- 25:19They'll have a gauntlet of Big 12 teams on their schedule, facing six of the top eight teams from the Big 12 in the final CSR of twenty twenty-five.
- 25:26I don't know if they'll be favored against any of their in-conference opponents in twenty twenty-six.
- 25:31Considering their tough in-conference schedule, I'm not sure West Virginia can expect more than the two Big 12 wins they managed in twenty twenty-five, and I would be betting the under on three and a half wins if given the opportunity.
- 25:43At the end of the season, it's hard to see Texas Tech not making the Big 12 championship, while their opponent is likely to come from a group containing Houston, BYU, or Arizona.
- 25:53A team to keep an eye on is Oklahoma State, as it may have one of the most impressive bounce-back seasons of any team in college football.
- 26:00The Common Sense Rankings will be keeping a close watch on the Big 12's Week 3 schedule.
- 26:05As a reminder, conference head-to-heads against all the other conferences are what contribute to the value of wins and losses, so how they perform against each individual conference will prove valuable.
- 26:14Most of the games they play in Week 3 are against conferences that they will only play twice this season, so they will be must-wins if the Big 12 wants to be high in the college football hierarchy.
- 26:24The Big 12 will likely be light on ranked teams early in the season, as nine of the 16 teams play an FCS team Week 1, and six of the remaining seven play one in Week 2.
- 26:34FCS wins mean nothing in the CSR, meaning the Big 12 will have to catch up teams from behind.
- 26:40And that will be it for Episode Number 5 of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 26:44If you want to follow the CSR on the socials, you can find us@comsenseranking.
- 26:49You can also check out commonsenserankings.com throughout the season to see the actual Top 25 each week.
- 26:54We'll be back next time with the Big 10 preview for 2026.
- 26:58Until then, as you go about your day-to-day, please use some common sense.