Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 81: Justice for all? The state of things in France with Yasser Louati
Transcript
- 0:08You're listening to the New Paris, I'm your host Lindsay
- 0:11trim, you do. It's been a while since I've
- 0:14done a France news update but there are so many pressing
- 0:17issues facing the country. Now besides covid that it was
- 0:19really time to jump back in and this time I'm joined by Yasser
- 0:23Luigi, human rights and civil liberties activists a community
- 0:26organizer and political analyst, he also co-founded the Geo cjl a
- 0:31transnational human rights and civil liberties organization as
- 0:35a fellow podcaster, a true break down and easy De Lima.
- 0:38I couldn't think of anyone better to join me to discuss the
- 0:41status of Francis, controversial security, Bill ongoing racism,
- 0:44islamophobia and historic sources of many of the country's
- 0:48troubles. Yes, sir, welcome to the show,
- 0:53glad to be here. Thank you for having me.
- 0:55You know, I have been a guest now on your show twice once in
- 1:00French, and once in English, and it's, it's been basically a
- 1:04question of which major topic do I bring you on the show to
- 1:08discuss, because there are so many and it just so happens
- 1:13that, you know, you've been more vocal obviously, in recent
- 1:17weeks, as we have new information, Shane about certain
- 1:21bills and certain topics of discussion that have become
- 1:26prominent yet again in France. And so I wanted to actually
- 1:29begin by asking you to explain something that you tweet it and
- 1:35it shouldn't come as a surprise. You wrote.
- 1:38The more France becomes impotent on the international scene.
- 1:41The more it is racist at home. This country has both
- 1:44intellectually and morally collapsed.
- 1:46And no institution is safe from this downward spiral.
- 1:50Spiral toward neo-fascism. That's quite an opinion, sir.
- 1:55Can you explain what prompted that sentiment?
- 1:59I mean if this sentiment grew throughout the years, I kept
- 2:03seeing these governments from the left and the right.
- 2:07And now the so-called Center which is actually the hard,
- 2:10right? If not the far, right under
- 2:12Emmanuel macron. And the more the more I saw
- 2:15these one-upmanship and these are bravado Around identity
- 2:22security and how they are going to be tough on minorities.
- 2:26The more they reminded me of the abusive husband who comes home
- 2:29from work to beat his wife because he's becoming, he feels
- 2:33like his irrelevant at work and for him to feel like a man.
- 2:39Again he needs to kind of show his strength against who is
- 2:42weaker and against a person who couldn't answer.
- 2:45And that's exactly what I what I thought when I kept seeing
- 2:48these, you know, discourses and How tough they were going to be
- 2:51especially against Muslims and at the same time, I had a chance
- 2:56of living in seven different countries, including in the US
- 2:59in the middle. Even I don't think I realized
- 3:01that. Where have you lived besides?
- 3:04No, I know you were. I know about your pilot your
- 3:07airplane flying days. Only recently actually.
- 3:11But so, you know, you have that whole side of you and you lived
- 3:13in the US. But where else have you lived in
- 3:16Saudi Arabia? The Emirates Bahrain Jordan
- 3:19Tunisia. What did I miss number two that
- 3:23yeah, Jordan are Saudi Arabia, Bahrain UAE Tunisia, the US, the
- 3:30US and of course fronts, so that's seven total.
- 3:33Okay, so sorry to have cut you off there.
- 3:35You were on a you are on a little problem and I realized
- 3:42how France had missed, you know, the turn of a new world during
- 3:48the Arab revolutions. It's was in Saudi Arabia when
- 3:52the Tunisian Revolution happened and being a parent myself.
- 3:56We work me a map and my comrades.
- 3:59We were following Ben Ali's airplane, before it landed in
- 4:02gender at the VIP at the Royal terminal.
- 4:06And I realized that France instead of seizing the
- 4:08opportunity to establish a new relationship with the Arab world
- 4:12and position itself as a country.
- 4:15That would uphold the so-called, you know, liberal values.
- 4:18It keeps lecturing the rest of the world.
- 4:20Out. No, it started with all the
- 4:22dictators, it supported benally it, supported Hosni, Mubarak,
- 4:25it's imported. Who else are forget?
- 4:30Among these rulers. And when we intervened in those
- 4:33countries, it overthrew the dictator, we not know, Qaddafi
- 4:38in Libya and created the mess. We are facing today with what's
- 4:42happening in Libya and I couldn't help but think when was
- 4:47the last time France I had a really relevant Position on the
- 4:50international scene, the only memory I had was Dominic develop
- 4:54a famous speech at the UN calling for a refusal of the
- 5:00invasion of Iraq, under George W.
- 5:01Bush. And then of course, in the in
- 5:04the course of my work as an, of course, head of an NGO found
- 5:08that we know you have all these statistics, we are lagging
- 5:10behind in international trade, lagging behind in in Africa.
- 5:15Now French is no longer the favorite language in Africa.
- 5:18People are turning. Now, of course to But also to
- 5:20China does not mean it's better, but front is lagging behind.
- 5:25We are the, our schooling system is among the most in egalitarian
- 5:30in the oecd region. And now the most obvious, you
- 5:35know, sign is that France? Despite it's a prestigious
- 5:38Pasteur Institute that is known as, in other words as a global,
- 5:43as a world-famous in our laboratory, couldn't even come
- 5:47up with a vaccine against the covid-19.
- 5:50And I'd leave and the country's been taking away.
- 5:54Research funding in the pharmaceutical industry.
- 5:57There was go to years. Exactly.
- 5:58I was, I was coming to it and now and actually that revealed
- 6:02how much, or how France was as you said that taken away
- 6:05research and money from research and on top of it, to make things
- 6:10even worse in the midst of this, you know, controversies around
- 6:14identity Politics, the even thought about conditioning
- 6:17research grants to UNI to Provided their research behold
- 6:23Republican values. So to me, I'm like, oh no
- 6:26soccer, here we are lagging behind on all fronts at the
- 6:30global scale and the only thing politicians have a to a hammer
- 6:33and show their their relevance to the rest of the country is.
- 6:37We are going to Crackdown against these minorities when
- 6:39they March against police brutality as they did in the
- 6:43aftermath of the George, Floyd racist, killing, they became
- 6:46separatists. If not, you know, yeah while be
- 6:49slacking The famous on sauvage not term used by Domina and
- 6:54following that in mind went back home came up with the anti
- 6:58separatism bill with all the consequences that we know on
- 7:01opening the floodgates of hatred that, you know, in mainstream
- 7:04media today alone like five individuals from the far, right
- 7:07are being interviewed in preparation for the presidential
- 7:10campaign. And we have a France continuing
- 7:14to position itself as a liberal democracy and I'm watching my
- 7:17country sinking horror. And the only thing I It was that
- 7:20is that, yes, that's what I thought about my country and I
- 7:24think I would do it again. I know people were unhappy about
- 7:27it but I would do it again. Well, I thought it was very
- 7:31powerfully articulated and certainly you know, goes in line
- 7:35with all of your other viewpoints and and the critical
- 7:39eye you take to the country. And you know it reminds me of
- 7:42something that okay had zero has told me before which is that,
- 7:45you know, it's not because she hates France that she comments
- 7:49and Antiques, it's because she knows, it can be better.
- 7:53And so I get the sense that that's sort of where you're
- 7:55coming from. It's not that you're, you know,
- 7:57you expect more from this country that, you know, where
- 8:00you've grown up. I mean a sign of it is that I
- 8:03came back to France after I left France, I was 19 years old.
- 8:07I came back, I was 30 and wow, that is all that is a chunk o
- 8:12your. I left after high school to
- 8:15become a pilot and all my teachers and the council were
- 8:19like, no I just thought maybe You is your daddy a pilot know.
- 8:22So you cannot do it except Aurora and I was like, you know,
- 8:24what to hell with it. I'm gonna, you know, across the
- 8:26Atlantic and see what happens over there and I did and I got
- 8:29my license, I became a party. Took me a long time to become
- 8:32because it's very competitive market, but I did.
- 8:35But at the end of it, I got homesick.
- 8:37I thought I was done to be honest.
- 8:39Was not even like I'm going to discover the world.
- 8:41Yeah, but you know, at some point you're like, where is
- 8:44home? Yeah, my home is myself side
- 8:47down. You know, I love when you, I
- 8:49love when you talk Talk about that but you said you were born
- 8:53in on the Left Bank of Paris, right?
- 8:56But yeah, I was born in the 60s, this morning, no stunts, you
- 8:59know, conservative District but I think that's what that also
- 9:02contributed to my political education because I knew what it
- 9:07was. I knew what it was to be a
- 9:10minority and to be looked at with a very condescending, I
- 9:14from the white Catholic bourgeoisie and that I had a
- 9:18specific space But to be at, I couldn't be anything.
- 9:22For example, my mom always wanted me to have, you know, a
- 9:25to go to college Etc. And other people should work
- 9:28with. But why, why do I?
- 9:29Why? Why?
- 9:30Why he could be a plumber. He would make as much money as a
- 9:33doctor. Why would he need to go to
- 9:35college? You know, and growing up.
- 9:37It turned out, all of my friends, you know, had their
- 9:40parents, you know, hear it from either the employer or they are,
- 9:42you know, the people, for example, in this cooling system.
- 9:46So but I still came back regardless, we still you still
- 9:49came back and So the work that you're doing at the NGO which is
- 9:53an NGO, you created, correct. I go created you.
- 9:56You co-created, and it's all around civil liberties, and
- 9:59protecting human rights. And, and, and so, what's always
- 10:04shocking to me? And I think I've had quite an
- 10:05education in the last three years.
- 10:07Following you, and a number of, you know, other very vocal
- 10:11activists. It's just how much France does
- 10:15indeed like to Pat itself on the back for four historical.
- 10:20Compliments. And and sort of the labels that
- 10:22it attributes to itself as the rupee.
- 10:26They don't learn. I know you're smiling.
- 10:29I know that's that's one of the classic ones, right?
- 10:32Like oh yes the country of Human Rights and you know what, in a
- 10:35way and maybe you tell me if you you see the parallel, the United
- 10:38States does a similar thing, this sort of the myth of the
- 10:43exceptional country, the exceptional Homeland.
- 10:46Do you see both countries operating and sort of A similar
- 10:51position of declining power with the risk of kind of, you know,
- 10:57making my friends in the u.s. frown.
- 10:59I think in the u.s. people have a lot more space to be to be
- 11:03activists and to criticize and to express their criticism of
- 11:06the government. You don't have a tradition of a
- 11:09highly centralized government. Unlike France, which has been a
- 11:11monarchy for centuries. You have a tradition of whenua
- 11:15federal system checks, and balances strong protection of,
- 11:19you know, civil. Liberties at least on paper that
- 11:21you can still uphold regardless. But at the same time, what
- 11:27brought what my education about America was accomplished through
- 11:31hip-hop, which means Public Enemy.
- 11:34And all those critical voices at the same time when I went to the
- 11:38u.s., even though I had a very critical eye on race relations
- 11:42class relations, Etc, was in Fort Worth Texas.
- 11:44So, I could see really, what how things were like in a Stark in
- 11:48contrast to France. You still have a lot more, you
- 11:51know, space to operate in France.
- 11:54Not only, we have a tradition of a strong central government.
- 11:58The current so-called Republic is not really very public, it's
- 12:01a compromise between a monarchy in a republic, the fifth
- 12:04Republic, born in 1958 through a coup d'etat.
- 12:09That's important to mention in the favor of a Charles de Gaulle
- 12:14came with a constitution, that gives so much power to the
- 12:17president that he is above So he can for his, he nominates, the
- 12:24prime minister with the numbness, the government, the
- 12:26president can dissolve the National Assembly.
- 12:29He's the head of the army. He is legally Untouchable and on
- 12:33top of it we have this tradition of not having a strong
- 12:36Parliament that can stand against the president especially
- 12:40since the, the re-election of Jacques Chirac.
- 12:43I think it was afterward 2002 when the Electoral you know,
- 12:48calendar was changed. So we Like the president first
- 12:51and then the National Assembly two weeks later, which means
- 12:53when you elect the president logically, the majority of the
- 12:56parliament of the National Assembly would be at the colors
- 13:01of the president of the president-elect.
- 13:03So he comes in power and he has like almost a guaranteed
- 13:06majority in Parliament. So where are the checks and
- 13:08balances on top of it? There is because have a strong
- 13:13government. The government does not like
- 13:15strong cities, strong citizenry or citizens that are capable of
- 13:20You know, conflict in the government and standing against
- 13:23it. You know what, we know what
- 13:23happened with the commune De Paris in 1871 and the massacres
- 13:27in the heart of Paris, but even if you don't go to the full
- 13:29extent of proclaiming, and an autonomous region, the, the
- 13:34simple fact that you stand and say, listen government, racism
- 13:39exists and is not a series of isolated events.
- 13:42It is a system. It is properly set up to
- 13:45benefit. The majority population.
- 13:47Police brutality is real and racism is the police is real.
- 13:51That's unacceptable. So, the government has so much
- 13:55organized a monopoly over the the political discourse over the
- 14:00legislative process over, even the dominant discourse in the
- 14:03media. And on top of it, if the
- 14:06government we know is liable for something wrong about something
- 14:10only, it can create can provide you with self-criticism.
- 14:15So there is not really much room.
- 14:16And the last thing if I can is Because we have a strong central
- 14:20government in France. It has accustomed people to just
- 14:25shout a little bit and wait for the government to help you.
- 14:28You know, that's why the in the American context.
- 14:32No we see, no luck, no day, the various rebellions that happened
- 14:35in even after the proclamation of the Republic cetera, you
- 14:38still have a long tradition of activism, a long tradition of
- 14:42solidarity networks and a long tradition, even off, you know,
- 14:45subversive media. We don't have that here.
- 14:47In fact, I will agree with you is for 100% on the media, not
- 14:52really doing much to challenge the government almost ever
- 14:55really. So for you, the, the
- 14:59demonstrations we've seen in the last year, especially after the
- 15:03separatist bill was first announced, and we'll talk about
- 15:06that Buddha level one security. The security Global for you.
- 15:11Those demonstrations are not an example of I guess the
- 15:17government's willingness to let the people make its feelings
- 15:21known. I mean, look, let's see how the
- 15:24government welcomed the demonstrations of the past 2
- 15:26years. That's true.
- 15:28Let's take a look at the yellow vest movement how it was
- 15:30brutally crushed. Now, of course, this did not
- 15:33come out of nowhere, you know the ball, you know, where have
- 15:36the have been the laboratory of repression for four decades.
- 15:40But now this state violence is being or put on display in the
- 15:43heart of Paris and against white people.
- 15:46That's why we now we have a national debate on police
- 15:48brutality, but when blacks and Arabs were falling victims of
- 15:51it. Yes, something must be wrong
- 15:52with them. Even as I know as late as 2016
- 15:552015, with the state of emergency, Well, the government
- 15:58right now call for those 4,000 raids 99 percent against the
- 16:02Muslim homes businesses and places of worship.
- 16:05Even the left was like he had a must be something wrong.
- 16:07They weren't very vocal about it, but the day that violence
- 16:10was applied against the opponents to the, the Paris
- 16:14climate Summit, even mu Goodman. Did you know that I had met that
- 16:18day? Your she smelled like tear gas
- 16:20and I could even close to her that day.
- 16:23They realize, oh, the state of emergency is going to be a
- 16:26long-term problem. So today when we see those
- 16:30marches being repressed with the with the way they are and have
- 16:34been for know so many years, it shows that the government is
- 16:38showing the is making this demonstration of force to scare
- 16:42you. They were not me, no tell you
- 16:44you cannot you know, demonstrate, it would be
- 16:46complicated to implement but there will be down so many
- 16:49people and maim. So many people that you be like,
- 16:52reconsidering should I go or not?
- 16:54And sometimes I used to go to rallies with my son.
- 16:57I Any more I'm like and if I could probably take my son to a
- 17:00demonstration with the cops around and you know I'm not sure
- 17:03if they're going to start throwing tear gas in the crowd
- 17:05Etc. So not a message is sent that
- 17:08there will be no place for Dissent and the low and a bit on
- 17:12the the comprehensive security law today is about making it
- 17:16even more complicated or difficult, if not outright
- 17:19impossible to challenge the government and where does that
- 17:24lost? And currently, where has it
- 17:26passed? And where does it?
- 17:27Still need to pass before it becomes enacted into law.
- 17:31What is so far that it has passed at the National Assembly
- 17:33the last week or so we have so far is maybe apart, maybe
- 17:38elected official, would, you know, calling the Constitutional
- 17:40Council and have it, you know, for example, censored in
- 17:44multiple articles, but I'm not going to, you know, hold my
- 17:48breath on that because there are so many problematic articles.
- 17:52And this law also comes after so many laws that have already
- 17:56enshrined these securities. A tour.
- 17:57They did the police state in France.
- 17:59Remember after this total Revelations, we pass know the
- 18:03government passed in 2015, the bill on mass surveillance, then
- 18:08pass the silk law, the silk law of October 2017, and this one
- 18:15made a set of emergency permanent, which means, if the
- 18:18government wants to call for a raid, they no longer have to go
- 18:21before the before the judge. And that's exactly what happened
- 18:24in the aftermath of the Macomb speech.
- 18:27A kamijo or the, so-called the separatism general Domina, the
- 18:31minister of interior with, by the way, being investigated for
- 18:33multiple allegations on sexual violence against women, the
- 18:38minister of interior called for like something.
- 18:40I forgot how many dozens of raids against Muslim and the
- 18:44next day, he is in giving an interview afterwards saying, we
- 18:47have legally speaking, we have nothing against those people, we
- 18:50are just sending a message. So, here we are.
- 18:52We have a government using the governors of states of the, the
- 18:56course of means of the state. I guess people and outward
- 18:59saying well, you know what, it's about sending a political
- 19:02message. How can we how can we still
- 19:04speak for the mark of a functioning democracy in France,
- 19:07in this situation, right? So so that's that's the big Bill
- 19:11that we've been now talking about for.
- 19:13I mean almost a year at this point more recently there have
- 19:18been developments with specific legislation around the hijab so
- 19:24it feels like we're yet again. I mean France has like it's like
- 19:27a Broken record country, right? Like we just we keep talking
- 19:29about the same issues in various ways all the time and and and
- 19:34and what I hope listeners understand and certainly I was
- 19:38very clear about talking about Li City in my book because it's
- 19:42super complicated. It's not just separation of
- 19:44church and state, right? The way that France intended it
- 19:47is and you are perhaps the best expert on this is, you know,
- 19:50keeping the Affairs of the state out of sorry of the church out
- 19:53of the state. But people are supposed to be
- 19:55free to practice their beliefs. As they wish.
- 19:59But why is it that somehow not only have the sort of the laws
- 20:05and rules around? Lacet, a seem to have shifted to
- 20:08become very anti Muslim. And how does the new rule on the
- 20:15wearing the hijab? If you're a think it's a young
- 20:17girl under 18 and in active in sports or School, tell me about
- 20:22what what is going on here and why is this A continuing?
- 20:27Why is this still going? Why is this still going on?
- 20:29Yes, sir, please. Well, it's what if there are two
- 20:31things there is, of course, the national obsession with the
- 20:36Muslim headscarf, the tradition that the white man is to save
- 20:39those Muslim girls. The problem is that those Muslim
- 20:41girls became Muslim women saying, I don't need you to save
- 20:44me. I'm wearing this on my own and I
- 20:46want to go to school with it. I want to work with it.
- 20:48I want to go to sports with it. I want to travel with it.
- 20:50Etc. The government is incapable of
- 20:53accepting a, because like you have a cognitive dissonance
- 20:56these people are raised. Aged in a way that they feel
- 20:59Superior because of their class and they go to schools over
- 21:02there are told, you are look, like handle Le creme.
- 21:05You are the Elite. You're going to make the day and
- 21:07now that they are in power, they do believe that, whatever the
- 21:10thing and Emmanuel macron is truly a personification of that
- 21:14that he's never wrong. He is and enlightened
- 21:17individual, and that he knows everything, and he even
- 21:20understand the covid-19 better than specialist themselves.
- 21:23So, today was happening with the Muslim head scarf.
- 21:26Is that this Became a problem. The day Muslims were no longer
- 21:30statistics or invisible beings in France.
- 21:33Because before they were what they were just workers and they
- 21:36were out of the public space. They were in their ghettos.
- 21:39They were in their slums. For example, in Ontario, on the
- 21:41west side of Paris, but in the early 1980s, Following over to
- 21:45know, two decades of openly racist crimes and and terrorist
- 21:49attacks. I say terrorist attacks which
- 21:51means the car bombs cocktail molotovs.
- 21:55The Aegean Embassy being bombed are Algeria being Bombed people
- 21:58getting killed in the in broad daylight by the police, by four
- 22:02white activists, in total impunity.
- 22:04And after dozens of people got killed and 1983 is the historic
- 22:08March Against Racism for equality.
- 22:11And that sent a shockwave through the political spectrum
- 22:14because they are like, hold on a second.
- 22:16There are no longer guest workers.
- 22:18They have children who dare to ask for equality?
- 22:22What did we miss here? So after 1983 comes a DEA,
- 22:28Muscle commission to reconfigure the game on citizenship 1987
- 22:33they set up the muscle Commission on citizenship in
- 22:36order to deny the right of soil to foreigners which means they
- 22:39have kids here but they can their kids are not automatically
- 22:42French. The last time that was
- 22:44questioned, it was during the anti-semitic policies of Vichy.
- 22:48That's when the right of solve, these are long-term tradition in
- 22:51France that's when it in, it was you know put into question fast
- 22:55forward to this day. We see.
- 22:58See that after, you know, 1987 we saw multiple events that led
- 23:01to so called the national debate on what it means to be French.
- 23:06But what it means to be French in terms of who we really are.
- 23:10It's, we are going to look at what those Muslims are and
- 23:12defined ourselves in opposition to it.
- 23:16You don't die from French fries. Do not Define France.
- 23:19So, according to its note Heritage, but only in opposition
- 23:23to its post-colonial immigration and the Muslim have a headscarf
- 23:28Is the symbol of the rejection of an affront.
- 23:31His obsession with Islam today. They banned the headscarf in
- 23:35public schools, which is against lie City, because Li city is
- 23:41about neutrality of the State and State services.
- 23:45Not users of State Services. Hmm.
- 23:49And this is where the it's and the 2004 law was passed after a
- 23:55rigged campaign and When you ask, for example, what are these
- 23:59laws about? It's, again, about rigging the
- 24:03game. Once more in order for sin, a
- 24:05Frances laws and Liberties and pretend protections of human
- 24:09rights, do not benefit these minorities.
- 24:12So, when these women say, hold on a second, I'm Muslim artists
- 24:15had to wear a headscarf often times.
- 24:17I guess my parents will know. They are told you know what?
- 24:20You are. No longer a victim who needs to
- 24:22be saved. Now, you are the culprit sir
- 24:24that we need to, to, to limit. Whose Freedom must be very
- 24:30limited and this is exactly what's happening.
- 24:33So being a Muslim woman in France, if you wear a headscarf,
- 24:36believe me, it's a social death sentence, why you can go to
- 24:39school, you can't work. If you work, have you stand.
- 24:42According to the European Network Against Racism.
- 24:44I want percent chance of getting a job.
- 24:47Now they are prohibit prohibiting it to four girls
- 24:50under 18. Even though the age of consent
- 24:53is 15, go figure. They wanted a birthday.
- 24:57Remember The bikini, a controversy in 2016 is so yes,
- 25:01we keep talking about it but that's what I call Islam or
- 25:04diversion with all the problems going on in France.
- 25:07There is a focus on a piece of cloth over up, you know, some
- 25:10woman's head. And if she'd is, of course, if
- 25:14he decides to wear it the letter, where it, if a person
- 25:17makes her wear it then yes, there is a problem.
- 25:20But for that, there are police stations and there are chords
- 25:23where they were the people doing that.
- 25:25It can be hard to be prosecuted. But, and just to finish on that,
- 25:30I see no difference between the taliban's app or whatever,
- 25:34religious extremists imposing, you know, wearing a head scarf
- 25:37or a full-face veal on women and those here.
- 25:40The lake of islamophobes we know imposing on Muslim woman to take
- 25:44care of because at the end of the day, women are not free with
- 25:47our bodies, then exactly what they couldn't decide what to
- 25:51wear. And of coming myself, for
- 25:53example, from AV know, from from business Aviation.
- 25:56I'm like, I was a captain on some The Jets, I've had my
- 26:00father attendance, they were in suffering because of the short
- 26:03skirts and because of their high heels and they were causing a
- 26:05complete American, what you want to work on the cabin, if you
- 26:08want to repent some paint, go ahead.
- 26:10You want to wear ballerinas? I don't care.
- 26:13I mean, like you're here to resolve to do to, you know, make
- 26:15sure that the passengers are safe, you're not there to be,
- 26:18there are some colors and some kind of eye candy, but in
- 26:22France. No saying that women are free in
- 26:25France. Muslim women tell you how free
- 26:28Fresh fruit where women are. It's so interesting because at
- 26:32what you said Echoes, what he Masala sahal one recently
- 26:37expressed. Yeah, what she expressed in an
- 26:42interview and she said it's all about visibility.
- 26:45Nobody cares about the hijab. When it's your maid who was
- 26:48wearing it because when Layla is going to clean a senator's
- 26:51office, she is invisible. But when we Layla's kid, Sue,
- 26:54Myra is highly educated went to college wears.
- 26:56Hijab wants to have More visible position and is fighting for her
- 26:59rights and is doing things that are very empowering her
- 27:02visibility becomes a problem. So that's just a to excerpt her
- 27:08comment in this in this online interview.
- 27:10But, you know, to me, it sounds like the recurring theme,
- 27:14whether it's, you know, Frances former problem with the Jewish
- 27:20Community with the Muslim Community, with the Spanish, the
- 27:24polls right fill in the fill in the blank.
- 27:26It's that it's about Entity and how the French view themselves
- 27:30and who is French, who gets to be French and how that
- 27:34conflicts, with migratory patterns and all of the other
- 27:37and the colonial history, it's like they refuse to accept that
- 27:40they've opened the doors and who is French is now a much more
- 27:45diverse answer than it ever used to be?
- 27:48What do you know what? One day I was I was at a meeting
- 27:50with an American organization that of that was bringing in
- 27:55some soon-to-be politicians and Leaders in the US, and they were
- 27:59touring France in various administrations and I was called
- 28:01in for a meeting at were to speak of Ron's Etc.
- 28:04And one of the, one of them, I remember our have from Detroit.
- 28:10She said, when I take the subway, I see a kind of run that
- 28:15is really diverse when I go to my meetings in those newsrooms
- 28:19and political parties and institutions it becomes all
- 28:23white and to me France is really the people are seeing this in
- 28:27the The Metro the Subway or in the street, not in those
- 28:31institutions overlap. Well you got it, you know you
- 28:33someday things pretty well. Because again if the day you
- 28:38become visible the dare you say I exist there.
- 28:40You dare to say, you know what, I'm equally to you.
- 28:43And on top of it I'm going to push it even further.
- 28:46The try to make it, to make it to me, to make you believe or
- 28:50feel guilty. Anytime you express criticism,
- 28:53as if you were supposed to be somehow grateful for being here.
- 28:57Well, first, I didn't invade this country, your grandparents
- 29:02second, when the elite of this country was collaborating with
- 29:07the Nazis under Vichy and departing, it's their own Jewish
- 29:12neighbors. And calling the, the one of the
- 29:15French police, by the way, born under the, she had its first
- 29:19major so-called accomplishments in the deportation of Jews.
- 29:23A big starting in Marseille in in southwest.
- 29:26The indigenous were fighting those Nazis.
- 29:29So, which means that lets hear yourself.
- 29:31They are from Senegal and The Gambia from Morocco and and all
- 29:36the the colonial our troops, they were fighting the occupying
- 29:39forces so that's number one France owes, its freedom to its
- 29:45blacks and whites and Muslims. The second point when France was
- 29:49devastated. After the second world war, who
- 29:51rebuilt it, my parents, their parents, their It's excetera.
- 29:56So how am I supposed to feel grateful?
- 30:01When this country owes, my parents, their health and all
- 30:04the generations. Before me all the sacrifices
- 30:07they made for in order for friends to be free and
- 30:09economically prosperous once more.
- 30:11So where do we go from here though?
- 30:13Because everything you're saying is super pertinent and and
- 30:19exactly you know it it highlights precisely the issue
- 30:24but how do we resolve this? How do we, what has to happen?
- 30:28Well, all of us, regardless of your skin color or religion.
- 30:32Our, you know, Elizabeth our beliefs Etc.
- 30:36We are all now victims of the same, you know, corrupt and
- 30:40unjust system called the fifth Republic.
- 30:43Some people still feel safe because the is there are not
- 30:47targeted as much as the others, but I tell them, don't worry,
- 30:50you're going to be next. So now it's about French people.
- 30:54Realizing that their Destiny is sealed.
- 30:58They are going to live and die together.
- 30:59There is no second, no, plan. B people Muslims are here to
- 31:04stay. And unless the bring back the
- 31:05trains and the boats, they're going to be here for a long time
- 31:09as much as they have been here for a long time as well.
- 31:11So it's about us being capable of holding a different narrative
- 31:18for us to accept the idea that our children are bound to grow
- 31:22together in a more hostile environment.
- 31:25Not only Politically economically.
- 31:27But also in what, when we speak of climate change and the
- 31:30destruction of the environment is about us, promoting a
- 31:33different Republic. The fifth Republic is more
- 31:36rebound. It is bound to collapse.
- 31:38Will it collapse through a coup d'etat will collapse through
- 31:41civil unrest? I don't know.
- 31:42Only time will tell, but it is unsustainable.
- 31:45Now what kind of political regime do we want to live under?
- 31:48That's our call the Pedro today active and we in and and looking
- 31:53at the ones who are 10 15 years old, Who will one day look back
- 31:57and judges, you know, ruthlessly and, and look out and tell us
- 32:01that we failed them. So there is that, but in the
- 32:05short term is about struggling, every day to have a, you know, a
- 32:08voice in the media of was in political institutions and to
- 32:12hold the government in check, even though it means sacrificing
- 32:15a sacrificing a lot, but hey, if people want to Define being
- 32:19French at a five, being French with the French Revolution of
- 32:221789 1848 and the Paris commune and The struggles of the people
- 32:26have been dominated and still many difference after the
- 32:30sacrifice everything. So you see there's still an
- 32:33element of Hope. Well there's no hope then let's
- 32:36just like, no stop doing anything, you know, and stop
- 32:38now, of course. But you know what I like, I like
- 32:41this quote of Marcus Aurelius, he says, the object of life is
- 32:45not to stand of the son of the majority, but to escape and find
- 32:49oneself in the ranks of the insane.
- 32:51Well yes, sir, it is such a pleasure to get to talk to you.
- 32:57We clearly only scratched the surface but this is, this is
- 33:01this is the good. Lesson number one and then we'll
- 33:04have you on and we'll talk about, you know, we'll go a
- 33:06little bit deeper and in until then, you've got two shows that
- 33:10people can listen to rubric down, which is an English and
- 33:14Lizzie daily bomb, which is in French.
- 33:16And you are the co-founder of the justice and Liberties for
- 33:19all committee. Yes, sir, thank you so much for
- 33:22being here. Thank you.
- 33:23Thank you. That's the show for today.
- 33:27As always. Thank you for listening
- 33:28subscribing and sharing with Friends, you can find all
- 33:32previous episodes of the new Paris podcast wherever you
- 33:34stream your podcasts and on world radio Paris.
- 33:37If you're enjoying these conversations, please consider
- 33:40picking up a copy of the New Paris book or my recent release
- 33:43their new proposition from your local book sellers.
- 33:46Until next time, I'd be in tow