Latest / The Goats of Growth / Bigger and Better Than LinkedIn — Ben Keighran on the Relationship Intelligence Layer
Transcript
- Jay Webb: What's good everybody? Thanks for tuning in to another episode of the Goats of Growth, sponsored by no company yet. But if you'd like to get in out of spam folders and out of crowded inboxes to get the attention of the go-to-market leaders and founders who aren't answering the phone anymore, please reach out to me, Jay, at thegoatsofgrowth.ai, to find out how you can sponsor this podcast. And I'll also, if you sponsor, I'll make personal introductions. when they are available for into people such as my next guest, who happens to be Ben Karen, a four-time founder and CEO who's built technology that's reached over a billion people, an Australian-born entrepreneur. He started coding at 13 and moved to Silicon Valley in 2006, where he eventually founded Chomp, which we'll get into in a minute, an app search engine that was acquired by Apple and built into the App Store and iTunes. He then founded Caffeine, a live streaming platform for niche sports and gaming that grew to 61 million users. perfect guest to have on the goats of growth, just given that alone. Today he's the founder of my favorite new tool, probably my first favorite new tool in, I don't even know, maybe 10, 15, 20 years, called Supercall, which is an AI super connector that I've personally used. You may have seen me post about it on LinkedIn to build my own AI recruiting agent. You can go to my website to l learn all about that, particularly for my business and my customers. and I believe that SuperCarl is well positioned to take over LinkedIn as head to head in a head to head battle as the new leader in BW connections. Ben, welcome to the Goats of Growth. Ben Keighran: Thank you for having me, Jay. I'm stoked to be here. Jay Webb: Yeah, man. This is a long, long overdue for sure. Because I've ever since we met for the first time, I've had a thousand questions that I wanted to ask you. And now Ben Keighran: Mm-hmm. Jay Webb: here you are in the hot tea where I can actually ask you some of those questions that we'll get to. so thanks for for joining me. so before I get into Supercrawl, as I just alluded to, obviously you had great success at at Chomp and and then Caffeine, but what I want to know is Just like how what's your creative process, right? Like what how do you how did you come about that chomp as as a as a as a problem to solve or an app to build? and and then caffeine. And then obviously Supercall as well. Is that something that you seek intentionally? Is it something where you're just looking for problems to solve? Is it something where people have come to you and you've had many conversations about certain things? It's like, you what, there's gotta be a way to solve that. Tell tell me about how. Ben Karen thinks about these things. Ben Keighran: Yeah, thanks for asking. So, you know, since since I was a kid, I've just loved building things on computers, trying to add as much value to other people as I possibly can with whatever I'm building. And so, with all of the different sort of companies and products that I've worked on, they generally start with just me obsessing over some new technology change that has happened and then starting to kind of see problems that lots of people are experiencing and trying to to solve that problem. So with Chomp specifically, you know, that happened around the time that we started to get like iPhone and people starting to adopt smartphones. And the thing I was noticing was that you know, looking back at the history of consumption across like media and consumer products, like the print media people sort of were not necessarily successful in like broadcast television and broadcast television people weren't necessarily successful in the web. And and I was thinking about apps and media and thinking like, well, who's going to be successful as we go into apps and media? Like it may not be like all of the big web companies. And so as I was kind of looking at the you know, like I guess looking back now, you can kinda kind of connect the dots like, We had like major photo sharing services before Instagram came along. We had things like PayPal before like Square came along, now called Block, I guess, right? So like it wasn't always like the person that owned the space with the previous medium that was successful in the new medium. And so specifically with Chomp, like that that's kind of a little bit of insight as to what I think about, right? And so with Chomp specifically, I was like, hey, like discovery was really hard on the web. Companies like Google, et cetera, emerged around discovery and search. And so, you know, how's discovery going to work for apps and media and content? And and that was ultimately the the the thing that we started to dive into, became very, very good at it. And then Apple ended up acquiring the company from us, and it became the search engine in the App Store and iTunes and a lot of Apple's media services. And so, yeah, that's a little insight as to how I think. Jay Webb: That's so fascinating. Let me just ask a follow-up question there, which is that to me, what I'm hearing in in the lesson and the practical lesson is that you you you found a problem in another an existing problem, frankly, in a previously mature medium, let's just say, right? Like search, right? Or web the web. And you said, what problem was solved for the web? And you looked at the largest company's office in the world, well, one of the largest companies in the world, Google, and you say, hmm. They solved that problem there, there's gotta be a similar problem in this new media, medium, called, you know, apps, right? And all the the the the the smartphones. And how can I take the lesson from that big success there and say, Okay, this problem's going to need to be solved. I'm gonna be the one to solve that problem. least I'm gonna start exploring, experimenting and see where it goes. Is that is that fair to say? Ben Keighran: Yeah, yeah, that's it. That's it. And and to really like explain it a little bit, little bit more, like there was there was really new technology, completely new approaches that were needed in order to solve that problem. And that's what got Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: gets me really excited is as you start in the early stages, you kind of look at what you know, you look at history, think about a new medium, think about a big technology shift. Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Ben Keighran: But then like as you start to scratch and like look into it, you're like, is there a real technology problem here? And the technology problem was that apps and music and movies, they don't have the same metadata that that websites have. And websites have like anchor text and metadata and all this stuff that a Google search engine can use to search. This Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Ben Keighran: is a different, this is a different type of search. This is a different type of discovery problem. It's happening on a phone, it's happening with apps, it's it's totally different. And so until we came along with Chomp, you all we really have is exact same matches on you'd have to literally type in Facebook to find Facebook. You couldn't Jay Webb: Yeah. Right. Ben Keighran: type in social network to find Facebook. So it's crazy as that sounds, but like that's Jay Webb: Right, right. Right. Ben Keighran: that's what was going on like ten or fifteen years ago, fifty more fifteen years ago at this point. But yeah. Jay Webb: man, we I feel like we need to do a whole nother episode about Chomp. But let me just ask you this this this question, which is the there's it's one thing to to identify that a problem, right? And there's another thing, frankly, to to solve that problem. I think it's an entirely different and maybe a biggest challenge, especially now anybody like myself can just vibe code an app, is how did you start to, you know, get attention? if you will, right? And to to build a a customer base or or or user base from there. Just walk me through those those early stages so to speak. Ben Keighran: Yeah, I I can't, I mean, each company I've built has it's happened in sort of different different ways. And and now with like SuperCal, it's really different, actually. Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: I think the I think the common thread probably is in the early days, you're just sort of trying to find Friends, people within your network, you're trying to find ways for people to try, you know, what it is that you're building. That's kind of the common thread. The approach for doing that has definitely changed over the 20 years I've been building in Silicon Valley for. Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: But I think that's probably the early days. Then you're sort of trying to, at least in the consumer world, trying to identify like a behavior, something that no one else is seeing that you're seeing, make sure people are are very retentive, activations working really well. Things are, you know, people are getting into the product that. getting to magic, so to speak, within the product quickly. Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: And then usually with each of my products, I've also looked for opportunities for people to want to share the product with other people and for the product to be better when that happens for both people. Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: and that's what can enable these like network effects and and huge user numbers that people talk about and get excited about really helps with distribution and getting things going. Yep. Jay Webb: Let's fast forward then to a l over the last twenty years. And what has changed? You mentioned that's changed a bit, right? Like tell me a little bit about your approach now to growing the supercarl audience versus growing, you know, caffeine Ben Keighran: Yeah. Jay Webb: and and and chomp. And this one, you know, obviously this one, supercarl is more of a B2B play, right? It's almost like a B2B to C kind of a play as opposed to the other ones, which were more B2C. Is that fair to categorize it like that? Ben Keighran: Yeah, I mean I think of SuperCal as being, I call it pro sumo because people can just jump on and start using it and self-serve, but we're also talking directly to companies about it as well. It's a little bit like Slack in the sense that like people start using it within an organization, and the organization's like, What like who's using this? We need to we need an enterprise arrangement. And so you can kind of provide the product in in both ways. It is a business, it is a business tool. Jay Webb: Yep. Ben Keighran: but like To like really kind of expand the the th the the the the thinking on this, like You know, I was close, not super close, but I was but I but I was aware and and and speaking with the guys that built Instagram, right? And like if you go back to what like the time where they were getting that out there, there was a really and maybe they would say it differently than what I'm about to say, but I'll I'll give you an example. There was a really interesting moment where if you were on the app store and you were in the top charts on the app store. You would get lots of downloads, especially when when Apple would release a new iPhone every year, everyone would get a new iPhone. The first thing they would do is open up the App Store and see what was on the top on the charts. And it was actually easy to like game the charts back then. You just needed to get like high velocity downloads and you would be like high on the charts. And so in that window of time, what the Instagram guys had found was if they could get high, you know, profile influencer people to post photos on Twitter. The only way to see the photo was to download Instagram. That pushed them up the charts. And then lots of people were downloading it because it was just on the top of the charts. And then as they got to critical mass, then you can start to build a network and a flywheel in a way that the thing goes. And so, like, like people use, depending on the moment in time, like different techniques for getting these different products to scale. I actually think the Slack guys were some of the first ones to figure out what I just said as well, which is. If you could get people in an organization using a product, then that would speed up like the enterprise deals that you could do with people because people are using it and then you're getting calls. so like the way SuperCarl started was to me, let's come back to like the the problem space and then how you go get users and growth. like the way it started was, you know, I as someone that has had a history with like natural language processing, machine learning, but also search, chat, you know, apps, social apps, things like that. and as a serial entrepreneur, you know, I've become frustrated with the fact that, you know, Claude couldn't search LinkedIn and like Claude couldn't search all of my data. And I was like, why why is that? And it's because there's bit like LinkedIn and others have have businesses that are about Protecting their data and getting you to come into their sort of walled garden and buy their products. But I could tell like it wasn't just me as a networking professional, it was lots of people I knew that were having the same question, like, hey, like with AI and these big, beautiful graphs and address books were built over the last 10 or 20 years, like why can't I access it all with AI and just reach the right person? and so you could say to me, there's like this sort of growing problem in that area. And so my co-founder Michael and I started exploring what could be done there. And basically while exploring what could be done, as much as we would have ideas on solutions for making it much easier to get high signal and actually access all the data that's out there and use AI and make it work for you and streamline the process, you know, from a recruiting standpoint with sourcing, streamline the process from a sales standpoint, like. Building a prospect list, streamline the process for a founder, like trying to find an investor, streamline it, make it like almost instantaneous, something that used to take hours or a week. How do you do that in minutes? The first thing we do is we start building ideas, but then we start hitting up everybody we know, all of our friends and all of our networks and saying, try the product. And it's through those conversations, including my own conversations with you, Jay, that you're like, this is actually what. the power user of this is is really looking for. And that that's us to guide the idea. The other thing I would say in terms of sh guiding and shaping the idea is I always think about like, what can you do for the smallest number of people right now that makes them feel like this is a hundred times better than what they're currently doing and and hopefully significantly less expensive. But then how can that ratchet up into an idea that could serve you know, in our case, every every person that spends on LinkedIn, which I think they make like 10 or 20 billion a year in revenue, like how could you service everybody, every networking professional on the planet better? Like Jay Webb: Yeah. Ben Keighran: what's the vision? And and so how do you start with the smallest number of people and like totally hit it out of the park for them? But then how can that grow into a bigger thing? And so I like to to be building very iter iter iterative iteratively you know, talking to people, talking to customers, but have a vision on how that how I could see that sort of growing and then I also need that to sort of line up with, you know, the big problem I see, the big opportunity I see, which is, you know, why hasn't LinkedIn done this? And why can't AI do that? And everybody wants this and and sort of somewhere in the middle of all that is the is the is the plan and the execution and the idea. Yeah. Jay Webb: Obviously, like I said, I'm a I certainly am. I would call myself a power user of of of Ben Keighran: Definitely. Jay Webb: SuperCarl. and I remember when we first met and and and and spoke, it was essentially a search interface where I would go on and and and I told you, like I I I fell in love with it immediately because I'm a LinkedIn recruiter power user, or at least I was. I'm a formal I'm a recovering LinkedIn recruiter power user because of because of Supercarl. And you know, I've seen how the product has evolved. And one of the things that I would love for you to talk about, which I think to me is definitely gonna be the most powerful and most impactful area that you're tackling right now, which is the intelligen relationship intelligence layer, right? Because Ben Keighran: Yeah, yeah. Jay Webb: it does I and I posted about this, you guys can go look at it, like the precision with which in the speed And the accuracy that my agent has because of Supercarl is just absolutely amazing. I mean, we're w it was taking us weeks to find really niche, hard to find candidates. And the agent found them within Supercarl within a matter of moments. Like literally, it was like 20 minutes. It's getting to the point now, it's been where I'm like, hurry up. It's been like 18 minutes. What's happening? You know what I mean? But but I'm actually asking it to do so much, like build company lists and target people and do all stuff where now it's it's a two hour It's really up to two hours. And after two hours, I it sources, depending on the search, could be like hundreds of people. And then it just starts sending me people based on a whole bunch of criteria. But the thing that I that that the reason I I say that as the foundation is because the search is so powerful. And then the only hole in the whole concept, right, and everything that I'm building right now is the connection, right? 'Cause I've like I said, I've had people testing it, and it's like, but nobody's getting back to me and you I'm still reaching out, but people aren't answering me and stuff like that. And it's like Can it do that? I'm like, well, it can do that, but it's not really like it's really just a f top of the funnel kind of a thing, right? And now with this relationship intelligence layer that you're that you're building, I think that is fantastic. So talk a little bit about the genesis of that and and sort of where you are with with with with with with things there. Ben Keighran: Yeah, so I would say like the way I would break down the problem is that there's kind of two or three areas that I think are quite problematic right now. Like number one is that our agents, you know, ChatGPT, Claude agents, like they're they're sort of quote unquote walled out from large professional networks like LinkedIn. So that's like one huge issue. The second is that you know, it's kind of difficult to go and connect up all of these big, you know, beautiful graphs that have been built over the last 20 years, like your Instagram and your Twitter and your LinkedIn contacts and all there's so much information out there within our current networks, and none of that is all connected up. Cold outreach is becoming really painful, and I think becomes even worse with with AI, because now you've got all these j AI generated things. there's no system that is like learning what's the best way to kind of reach someone and the right etiquette and the way to to to to connect with someone. So so there's a bunch of problems. I said two, but I kind of went on to even more problems there. But anyway, there's a bunch of problems in in in there and that's why I think it's not as easy as it as it sounds like it should be, which is just why can't AI find me the right people? Like for who I'm recruiting, to who I needed as an investor, to s for sales reasons, for product feedback, for Why can't I just find me the right person? That that's c some of the reasons why. So we've tried lots of approaches, but the approach that appears to have worked is the first thing we we did is we built a proprietary data set that is now larger than LinkedIn. And the advantage that LinkedIn has had for 20 years is their data set. They basically are very protective of it. You're not allowed to scrape them. You can't do automation they'll They'll they'll block you if you do any of those kinds of things. And they're very insistent on you put the data in, you can't take the data out, you come to LinkedIn, you use it there, and you use it as a human and use it the way they want you to use it, and you pay them the way they want you to use it. Very, very very controlled, basically. And so one of the things we found, Michael and I, was that we could we could now build due to a bunch of changes in technology and even laws. A LinkedIn size data set that's larger than theirs. And then we can allow you to use that data through places like Claude and your own agents, make it really easy. And that that's like the first huge unlock. And the way we did it was we crawl the web like Google does, looking for public profiles. We have data partnerships with a range of like 50 different like data partners that are getting data from a bunch of different ways. We enrich the data using inference tokens from OpenAI and Anthropic. So have a bunch of techniques like that that we've used to build this proprietary set. It's now more than like a billion people. It does 75 million updates a day. It has over 50 million company posts in there, company information. Like in total, it's about 10 billion records. It's a massive data set. and it's proprietary, it's not scraped, and people are able to use it as say in Claude and it's You know, we we give away free credits to use it, but you can buy credits for like eight dollars or ninety-nine dollars. It's extremely affordable to get in and use that data set. But then the second thing we do is is we allow you to download, we don't allow you, every site has to allow you to download your contacts. LinkedIn allows you to download your contacts. Everybody allows you to download the contacts. Cause under GDPR, you're have to be able to download your contacts. So what happens is the AI can now search a billion profiles and say, hey, Jay, here's the 25 best matches for for what you're looking for, whichever hire you're looking for. But within those matches, if you upload your your address books from these different places, we can tell you within those matches if you know anyone. So that's the beginning of the reachability question that you just asked for. Another part of it is you can actually connect with other people on SuperCarl. And if they've done the same thing, it'll say, it turns out Ben through his connection on Instagram knows that particular person. And then using AI, what we can do is we can then start to build a learning loop around, like Jay is connected to this person on LinkedIn, but also has calendar meetings, but also has had communication through email. We don't read emails, do any of that stuff. All the data remains your data. You can pull it out, you can export it, you can delete it. It's like metadata that we're kind of looking at to make these connections. But and you can read our privacy policy and all that stuff to see how we're doing it. But we're trying to make sure it's your data as a user. We're never using it for advertising purposes. You're in control the whole way. But basically, when you put that information in, we can be like, Jay has a real relationship with that person. And so if I'm looking for a connection to that particular person, the AI can be like, You should hit up Jay and I hit up you. And then you're like, yeah, I know that guy well. Well, and I'm like, yeah, the AI said that that, you know, like you would be a good person for an intro there. And then, you know, then there's social capital, right? Like you made an intro for me, I'm gonna make an intro for you. And so using AI to basically build that learning loop around relationships and reachability, but in a way that respects people's privacy, builds trust with them, they're in control of the data, they're in control of the information. They can use this information that was once trapped inside these walled gardens to their own benefit. And they're basically layering it over the top of all this public data that we've aggregated and made available, you know, through MCP to places like Claude and your agents. And that's that's kind of the what's going on under the hood and why it's so powerful. I actually think that searching vast amounts of public profile data is not like like I think lots of people will eventually be able to do that. And and probably within I don't know, like I don't think that's Like that's our hu that's a big advantage today, but it's a diminishing advantage. The real advantage is really understanding b building a system that a allows AI to navigate human relationships in a way that the that the data remains the each in our control, basically, in every individual's control. I think that's really unique and that's that's what's gonna be, I think, ultimately very special about SuperCal, the superconnector. Jay Webb: So many follow-up questions there. But one thing that I want to make sure people know as well is that you know, Supercarl will decide. If you're if you're if I'm using my agent and I send a campaign to SuperCarl, it will decide based on a number of things. If okay, should I reach this person on SuperCarl? Should I reach them directly on LinkedIn? Should I reach who should I reach out to to connect me to this person as you were just alluding to, or should I send them to the should I send it to The email, right? Is that gonna be the the the best way, right? Because of all that data that you just had and all the information that you that you have, you're able to to to tell and my own human brain doesn't have to figure that out anymore, right? Ben Keighran: Exactly. Exactly. And so you you know, the way I think about like Steve Jobs once said a computer's like a bicycle for your mind, meaning it can s speed up your thought process. And in so many ways, like that's how I think about how the best AI is for us today, is it really should just speed up things that we're currently doing. And so rather than you trying to recruit someone, source somebody and then do outreach, rather than you spending hours or days or even weeks sourcing on LinkedIn and then going through your contacts and and then your contact contacts manually trying to figure out what the best way to reach out to them is or just sending them a a cold email and hoping for the best. What if like you were in control of your your data? It's your data, you're in control of the whole thing, but you could use it with AI to just make all of that stuff happen in, you know, 10 minutes, basically. super useful, I think. Jay Webb: Yeah, yeah. So let me ask you this, because this is something I didn't know and I I wanna I guess ask this follow-up question so that I'm clear. Cause I actually just did this. I downloaded my first connections, I don't know, about two weeks ago, I guess, right? And the reason I did that, I actually asked my agent to essentially segment them by go to market role, right? So VPs of sales, accounts executives and so forth. And just put them into a a CSV file so that I can use them f strategically for the things that I want to use them for, right? are you saying that if I took that same I I can upload that same CSV file to to Supercrawl? 'Cause maybe and and then and then Ben Keighran: You can. Jay Webb: that okay. We wanna you think you've mentioned this to me before, but this is the first time I'm actually hearing you. Ben Keighran: Well well, no no, it's okay. It's okay. I mean, honestly, like our focus has been really getting the huge data set up and running. And and now that that is up and running and people have been using it for months now and it's going gangbusters, like people are giving like it's awesome. Feels like a superpower, which is exactly how it should feel. Now we're building features like what you and I just discussed into the product. and You know, up up up until late, that's been like very, very like bleeding edge that stuff, like how I've built it in. But we're really streamlined basically you'll be able to go in as of next week and just go contact sources and upload a CSV from any of these places and and it can do exactly what we just talked about. You've actually been able to do it previously, but it's been a little bit rougher and a bit more difficult. But it's gonna be super easy for people to do that. Yeah. Jay Webb: By the way, by the time this publishes, you will already be able to do that. All right. This is this is yeah. This is the this Ben Keighran: Yeah, yeah, that is correct. That is correct. Jay Webb: is we're doing this at the towards the end of July twenty twenty six. this will be out easily by say the end of August twenty twenty six, early September. So yeah, that's that's that's fantastic. All right. That is that is great. Okay. let's see, where do I wanna go from just just I guess One other question before we get into the rapid fire five, if you don't mind. Which which which is Ben Keighran: Yeah, of course. Jay Webb: what's next? In other words, this is obviously called the goats of growth and you've obviously shown an inclination, a na a knack, so to speak, for growing large user bases and so forth. And obviously you've got a really large database right now. Where when do you and you know, before we hit record, you know, you talked about a large account that you're that you're onboarding and getting on. Tell me, when do you let it go, so to speak? Like in other words where you say, All right, boom, like it's time for you know, let's let's let's add fuel to this fire and really scale it up or or yeah, what is what what does that look like, I guess, for you? Ben Keighran: Yeah, so for us like trying to find and I think like just about any entrepreneur would would probably this isn't like a very special answer, but basically in the in the early days of of building, I think you should be just in absolute maniacal focus of trying to find what they call product market fit. Meaning Jay Webb: Uh-huh. Ben Keighran: like there's people that, you know, have once they start using your product, they can't stop using it. It it solves a massive problem. And it's probably cheaper and wildly better, but definitely wildly better than how they were doing it previously. And they're obsessed. Like they're they're, you know, and and I think that like in the early days, what you're really doing is you build You get customer feedback, you build, you get customer feedback. Like that's really like you're just doing that over and over again until you kind of get get clear on like what what it is that you're you're building. And that's Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: what I mean. It's just like super iterative process. And so I think in like phase one, you're kind of figuring out the product. And then once you've sort of figured out the product, which I believe like what we released about six to eight weeks ago now, when you look at How much revenue that's generating, how successful it's been, not just with recruiting teams, but which is where I started, but now with like sales teams and founders and beyond, which is awesome because that's what I was dreaming about, but I was really focused on recruiters, but and I still still am, but it's people are pulling it, the using it, and all these other use cases are flying. That that that that's making me go, okay, okay, like I think we've got the early beginnings of product fit here, like we've got it. So when I think about the next phase. I think you like build the product in first first phase, and it's really gotta, you know, be strong. Like people are hyper engaged, it's solving a problem for them in a huge way. But then the second thing that you do once you hit that product fit, which is the answer to your question, is now it's time to build the business. Right. And so you can't, it's hard to build a business if if you don't have a product. But I think about you build the product and then you build the business. And Jay Webb: Right. Yep. Ben Keighran: so when I think about building the Business, that means I gotta, you know, in my business, like you're gonna have to hire people, you're gonna have to have go-to-market people, you're gonna have to have teams that are talking to enterprises and and customers, you're gonna you're gonna be truly in this, like, okay, it's time to build the business, build the revenue, Jay Webb: Mm. Ben Keighran: scale, scale, scale, like basically what's there. And so when you go into Jay Webb: Mm-hmm. Ben Keighran: that phase, yes, you're still working on the product, you're always working on the product, but you're now like refining it, perfecting it, getting in our case, more data, more learning, more, you know, depth to to what is there. But now you're like building the team that's actually going to build, you know, the revenue and the growth and and and go pursue those things. Yeah. And and and I think and Jay Webb: Yeah, you know, one of the mm. Ben Keighran: I think that by the time this comes out, we will be transitioned into that, into that mode. that is what Supercar will be doing. That's where the polish will, you know, more and more polish will be coming into the product and we'll be like really ramping things up. Yeah. Jay Webb: I mean, from a selfish perspective, one of the reasons I like doing this podcast is exactly that. I feel like I get a master class from the minds of people like you every time every in a public setting. I'm like, guys, just thank you for thank you for turning into my master class, my private master class with with Ben Karen, because I feel like every time I talk to you I I learn something new and that certainly resonates, frankly, as I I build what I'm trying to build on on my side of So to speak. And don't please don't forget about recruiters. I hear you say, you know, you talk about the sales and the investors, but don't forget about the little recruiters over here because we're we're needed. That is fantastic. Ben Keighran: We will not. I will not. Jay Webb: I love it. I love it. All right. Are you ready for what I'm calling the Rapid Fire Five? And again, let me just pause here and say that a sponsor of this episode or a sponsor of this podcast would actually be able to sponsor the Rapid Fire Five. But there is no sponsor, so I'm gonna sponsor right at the Ghost of Growth. go to go to Growth dot AI to learn more about what I do. But For now. Ben, are you ready for the Rapid Fire five? All right. Fant Ben Keighran: Let's let's do it. Sounds great. Jay Webb: fantastic. first question. what motivates you? Ben Keighran: I love trying to add value to other people through building new technology. Like I just, for some reason, I have found passion in that since I was a little kid. Like my Canvas, my art, my way of contributing to things, and I get a lot of satisfaction from that. And that's where the main motivation comes from, is just that feeling of wow, we built something. I was on a team that built something that added a lot of value to other people and they're really excited about it. I just Find that super motivating. Jay Webb: Yeah, well we all want you to continue to stay motivated 'cause if you keep building things like this, we're gonna all be happy. So it's fantastic. I know I am. number two, name Ben Keighran: Awesome. Jay Webb: a big goal you have right now and when Ben Keighran: I would say like the biggest goal that I have is to make that that transition from like product fit into like the building the building the business of of SuperCal. And I, you know, believe that will happen imminently. I've been working on it for about a year now. the product's been in market for as say six to eight weeks and is like in the in the version that's out there right now, the one that I think has product fit and and that's a a a big goal. I I I love the idea of getting to that next step of of of building and growing this thing. Yeah. Jay Webb: What's your most preferred way to learn new information and to stay sharp? Ben Keighran: I I definitely am a play based learner. Like I I I I f I I fail like constantly to learn, basically, whether it's with technology and building products and putting them in front of people like all you know, a lot. to even the sports that I do, like I I definitely fail a lot at things in order to learn and Much prefer that than sort of having someone try and teach me or reading a book or s some other way. Yeah. Jay Webb: smiling because you say play bass and I never I never put it that way. I heard it put that way because I always say I'm an experiential learner. I have to experience for better or for worse, frankly, failure, success, whatever the whole nine yards, because that's how I learn, which probably made for I was just I'm not a very good classroom traditional student because of that. And I didn't know until I was an adult. I'm like, yeah, no wonder why so bad. Like I can't sit there and listen to people like you know, I need to be act I need to be in the action. So I love that. That Ben Keighran: Well Jay Webb: resonance. Ben Keighran: we have we are the same, my friend. Jay Webb: Yeah, that resonates with me for sure. who's your favorite character of all time? I actually got this from a past guest who asked that question and I decided to keep it in the rapid fire five because it's such a fantastic question. Could be could be real, it could be fictional, whatever. Could be the neighbor down the street. Ben Keighran: Okay. And it could be like just any person, any any anything. I mean, look, I I I know that so many people would probably an answer the same way. but like Steve Jobs, I mean, had like such a huge impact on me. I was I feel very fortunate that they bought my business a long time ago and I you know he you know, I know that he There's people that love him and don't like him and all the stories and all the things. But I I I was always just really inspired by his obsession with trying to build great products. and you know, I th I just and I and I just loved the attention, you know, to detail on the care and the passion, you know. yeah. Jay Webb: Amazing. I and several people have have mentioned him, but you're gonna be you are and maybe the only person who can actually say they got a quarry by the company that he started. So that's that's rarefied air in and of itself, and I love it. last last question. I should get a sponsor for the last question too, but what's your favorite thing to do when you aren't when you aren't working? Ben Keighran: well, look, I mean I love my family, my kids, my wife, like for sure. But you know, outside of spending time with them, I I love the mountains. I'm a big snowboarder. In the in the summer I'm a s I'm a mountain biker and I even even skateboard and I have a lot of injuries from the skateboarding at this age to prove it. But but yeah, f f family and the mountains and s snowboarding is probably the the main thing, my main answer to that. Yeah. Jay Webb: I have to con I have to confess I do have a fondness for your wife as well because she introduced us and she introduced me to some great company. So I have to I'm gonna have to double click on that one. Ben Keighran: Yes, yes, no, she's she's the best. She was definitely the best decision I ever made in my life. So yeah. Jay Webb: Yeah, she's a she's a force, a force of force of nature. Actually, one last this is actually a bonus question. So we're done with the rapid fire five, but the bonus question sponsored by thegots of growth.ai, could be also sponsored by whatever company wants to do the sponsor. what question would you like for me to ask my next guest? It could be anything. Any question at all, like if you were a baseball player, what would your walk-up music be? Like the question, the four number four question came from another guest. Like, what would Ben Keighran: Yeah. Jay Webb: you say? you'd like for me to ask the next guest. Ben Keighran: You know, I think asking them, and you might want to give them a heads up before asking them so they can really think about it, but asking Jay Webb: Sure. Ben Keighran: like what their biggest learn has been, right? Because Jay Webb: Yes. Ben Keighran: the thing is like when we think about growth, like everybody l loves the the hey, we got like this many users or this much revenue, and like they love those stories. But what's behind those stories is like Jay Webb: Yes. Ben Keighran: so much. So much hard stuff basically. And I Jay Webb: Yeah. Ben Keighran: think it's real I get inspired like going like all even though I have over 20 years in Silica Valley built four venture back companies, like and just been through like lots of stuff. I think we need to as entrepreneurs and people thinking about growth open up a bit more about like the the the learns basically. And and I call them learns because I think there's either succeeding or learning. Right. Jay Webb: I loved I love to hear you say that because to me those are my favorite kinds of conversations to have. I'm a very big fan of the hero's journey, you know, which is basically this this whole journey of you start off in a certain direction, you you know, with this big vision, you hit a wall, you have to overcome that wall. You know, it's basically every superhero story you've ever seen, right? you have to come through that wall, you've you've you've think you're going somewhere you battle some demons again and then you come out the other side as this transformed person with all of the learnings, right? and in this conversation that we're having here today is is is Ben Karen the the transformed person, so to speak. Although you probably laugh and be like, Jay, you don't know what the heck is going on. Trust me, there's storms that I'm fighting every day. But the point Ben Keighran: Ha ha ha. Jay Webb: is, is that like you are inspiring in and of itself. And then also it's it's I guess the way to say it like, I would love for you to come back to actually talk about that. Maybe even like in a I don't know, six months a year or something like that, to talk about that part of it and obviously we can talk about the success of and on the journey o of supercrawl, but I love conversations like Ben Keighran: Absolutely, I'd love to. That'd be awesome. Jay Webb: Fantastic. What's the best way for people to reach out to you? to maybe ask a question I didn't ask, to learn more about Supercarl and how they can build their agents like I did on top of Supercarl? Like what's the best way to to find out more about Supercarl and about you? Ben Keighran: Well, as it's as it stands, there's a there's a book a meeting link with me on the homepage of supercarl.ai. so quite literally, they can if they can go to supercarl.ai, that's the website, that's the the web address. and it's so superc-ar-l dotai. And then they can create a free account in less than like 10 seconds and try the product out. But if they want to speak with me, they can just hit book a meeting on the homepage. Mm-hmm. Jay Webb: I love that. I'm sorry. Do you have like just three more minutes? All Ben Keighran: Yeah, sure. No problem. Jay Webb: right, I'm I know I'm getting ready, but I d I have to ask this question 'cause I don't think I ever did. How d where'd the name Supercarl come from? Ben Keighran: So we we fell in love with the idea of super connecting, right? Like we because the super connector, like we've all been to a conference or an event or a party and had someone make an amazing introduction for us. And that was the kind of genesis, the vision of what this was going to be, which is like high signal, just connect me with the right people, whoever I need. And we love that idea of the superconnector for that. and in some ways we were gonna call it super connector. but that was like too literal, and then we came up with other other names like forests, like see the forest through the trees, and then we came up with like path, it'll find your path, like all sorts of things, and nothing nothing was sticking, like people were just again, just socializing it with friend friends and family. And then at some point, my co-founder said, you know. Everybody knows a knows a c a person called Carl, like why we just call it Car Carl? Like we can't come up with a better name. He just randomly said it. and then I jokingly said back to him, Well, why don't we call it Super Carl? Like your super connector. and I thought it was like I mean, I was just joking. He liked it. And my wife liked that name. And then multiple other people liked that name. And then it and I was like, fine, well, we'll just leave it as the placeholder for now and we'll come up with something better. And We've never come up with anything better. A and and and people have just, you know, found it to be catchy and I don't know, it's worked. So that's it. Yeah. Jay Webb: That's well, I will say I have an uncle named Carl and a late grandfather named Carl. So there you so so there you go. That's Ben Keighran: There you go. Jay Webb: that's that's quite amazing. That's quite amazing. Ben Keighran: Mm-hmm. Jay Webb: Well I'll well and it's no wonder why I connect with it so well. so thank you very Ben Keighran: Ha ha ha. Jay Webb: much, Ben for for joining. thank you for everybody for for tuning in. Don't forget to subscribe, rate, listen to the other episodes and tell a friend. And again looking for sponsors. So yeah, tell people that they if they want to get in front of co to market leaders and and founders of tech companies, this is the place to be. Thank you. Goodbye everybody. Talk to you later.