Latest / Spank The Mic / Circumstantial Spank: The Idaho 4
Transcript
- 0:01Hit it. It's raining.
- 0:02It's pouring. The old man is snoring.
- 0:06I Really I. Started to help me out.
- 0:08No, I, I, well, I started to be mean and I didn't want to do
- 0:11that because it's your birthday. Saw it, Your wheels were turning
- 0:14and you. I'm like, he's going to say
- 0:15something about old men. And I was, that's what he's
- 0:17going to do. No, it was, it was more along
- 0:20the lines of Granny Shanny. That's what it was.
- 0:22Granny Shanny vibes. Yeah, it was going to be Granny
- 0:25Shanny snoring something along that line.
- 0:27Shame on you. Yeah, not it wasn't going to be
- 0:29real mean. It is the day we're recording.
- 0:31This is in fact, my birthday. So happy birthday.
- 0:35And in honor of my birthday, I want to tell you right now that
- 0:38I am sick and tired of this swamp ass weather. 32 years
- 0:45young. I'm done.
- 0:46Can we say that? We can say that, right?
- 0:48You're not one of those people. No, I don't care.
- 0:50Not yet. When you get my age, you're
- 0:52going to be like, man, we'll have to talk about how old I am.
- 0:56I really thought you'd agree with me.
- 0:58Swamp ass weather, yeah, I mean, but you're over it.
- 1:01I got to be honest with you. If it's raining real bad, it's
- 1:06not 9000° outside so I don't have a problem with that.
- 1:10But I am not Shrek. I do not know the gingerbread
- 1:13man. But we do have some nice
- 1:16boulders. Nice boulders in West Virginia.
- 1:20Oh, in West Virginia, I thought you were talking about you.
- 1:22I was like. No, you.
- 1:24Don't. What?
- 1:24No, you don't. What are you talking about?
- 1:27Let's even. Get through this episode of
- 1:29Spank the Mic without me no hitting Wade.
- 1:33What were you going to say? Whacking?
- 1:35Were you going to say whacking? Wade I.
- 1:37Was going to go with a different term.
- 1:39Oh OK, I'm trying to think of all the verbs.
- 1:41That doesn't. Sound like actually words?
- 1:46OK, All right. Welcome to spank the mic.
- 2:19another fun episode. I can't believe we're already on
- 2:22episode 9. That is wild.
- 2:24Which means next week we're getting into double digits.
- 2:27And I was thinking about this. So what do people normally do?
- 2:30Like is this season? So I kind of pictured 10
- 2:34episodes. Would be our first season.
- 2:36OK, I feel like a lot of podcasts don't do seasons.
- 2:39They're just like we're on episode 452.
- 2:41I was going to say I'm down with either and maybe we should have
- 2:44talked about this and workshopped it off.
- 2:47Probably the. Pod, but you know, it's kind of
- 2:50on brand. We likely should have decided
- 2:52that at the beginning. Yeah, but maybe we say this is
- 2:56our first season, and then we never do another season ever
- 2:59again. We just continue with episodes.
- 3:00Well, you know, here's the crazy thing too, is like, we didn't
- 3:04just all of a sudden decide to do this on a whim.
- 3:08No, like we talked about this for a good year and a half
- 3:11before it actually came to fruition.
- 3:15Yeah, we just kept doing the morning show for the radio
- 3:18station and talking about doing this on the side.
- 3:20We're like, we're going to do it.
- 3:21We're going to do it, Yeah. And then finally we did it.
- 3:24You'd think that'd been one of the things we talked about early
- 3:26on, but it was not. No, we were just so excited to
- 3:29finally start the podcast. We were like, yeah, we get to
- 3:31talk about like, true crime and fun stuff and yeah, drop bad
- 3:36words every now and then. Would still it feels odd.
- 3:40Oh yeah, like when we said swamp booty earlier, I was like, we're
- 3:46going to get in trouble. Swamp booty almost sounds worse.
- 3:49That does sound worse in swamp ass.
- 3:50Yeah, you should. You should just.
- 3:52You should just drop the a. Word.
- 3:53I don't know why but it yeah it does sound way worse.
- 3:56Speaking of things that sound terrible.
- 3:58So last week we talked about right?
- 4:00Like how cousin Cody was like, oh, fall watermelon.
- 4:03Fall. Yeah.
- 4:03Fall watermelon. I was like, yeah, you a pumpkin.
- 4:06Well, when we posted that video on our Facebook, one of my
- 4:11friends from this was a few years ago.
- 4:14I was doing my student teaching at a middle school for 7th
- 4:17graders, right? That's been a minute.
- 4:19And so that's been a minute ago. And she said, do you remember?
- 4:22And I went Oh no, Oh no, I had forgot that in front of class
- 4:29full of 30 7th graders. And that's the worst age group.
- 4:35Oh yeah, they're sometimes I feel like we.
- 4:38Have their minds though, like. Of a 12 year old and we are
- 4:42reading this book, the novels. Everybody was falling along and
- 4:47instead of saying the annuls of history.
- 4:54That's not how you say it. That's not how you say it either
- 4:56though. I'm trying really hard not to
- 4:57say the word that I said. It's Annals.
- 5:00Annals. Yeah, yeah, the annals of.
- 5:02History, you said the. Annals of History.
- 5:07I'm done, I'm done. So one season and we're out
- 5:12then, right? Yeah, that's like, that's not
- 5:14right. If that didn't bail me out of my
- 5:16teaching career, then I think we're safe.
- 5:18I think we're safe. So that the next class period
- 5:21she was like hey, make sure you don't say annals of history.
- 5:29So her and I could. We were up in front of the
- 5:32classroom and we could not stop laughing.
- 5:35Who was your student teacher? Like who was your mentor in that
- 5:38situation? Do I know her?
- 5:40Her name's Elise. Elise.
- 5:42Yeah, she teaches 7th grade where your son went to school,
- 5:45so I don't know if you know her or.
- 5:47Not no, I, I don't think I'd not unless you give me a last name
- 5:50because I don't know any teachers for you're the only
- 5:52teacher that I know the first name.
- 5:54Otherwise it's miss so and so or misses so and so.
- 5:57I I guess that's fair. You don't typically know the
- 5:59first day, but we like those kids were so the next last
- 6:01period didn't know what was going on.
- 6:02They were so confused because her and I were laughing.
- 6:05We were crying like I could not read, like I could not continue
- 6:10because I was so afraid like that, like I was trying to over.
- 6:13Pronunciate it. That I was like, I'm going to
- 6:15say it again. It's.
- 6:17Annuls of history. Annuls yeah, I didn't not say it
- 6:21like that. And I was like, we are in fact
- 6:22not going to talk about the annals of history.
- 6:26That would be inappropriate for 7th graders.
- 6:31That would be wildly inappropriate for 7th graders.
- 6:34So my question So what? Have you ever had a bunch of
- 6:37kids like some of your students no matter what grade?
- 6:40Have they played any pranks on you?
- 6:43Like I can remember in 10th grade, Mr. Burgess's class, I
- 6:48can remember this kid named Brian, we had to, we had to sign
- 6:51the attendance sheet every, and he would sign it and then he
- 6:55would call roll right, based on the attendance sheet just to
- 6:58make sure you weren't making up names for people who weren't in
- 7:01class. Yeah, a a Ron.
- 7:03Yeah, so Ryan put Jack and then me off as the last name.
- 7:13Kids actually did this. As a for real thing, yeah, this
- 7:15is a for real thing. Ryan.
- 7:16I can give you his last name, but I'd rather not.
- 7:20And he actually did it. And Mr. Burgess, he did it, but
- 7:23it was tongue in cheek. Like he knew.
- 7:26And he knew immediately who did it.
- 7:28I think he never said anything but I I feel like he he dead
- 7:34spotted on Ryan and went like. OK, see, thankfully by the time
- 7:39I started teaching, it was all like technology based.
- 7:41Yeah. So all of our class lists were
- 7:45on the laptop. To be fair, we were still using
- 7:48chalk. Yeah, like.
- 7:49At that time, it was a little. It's a little more difficult for
- 7:52kids nowadays. And we still have the projector.
- 7:55If you wanted something to go up on the board, they had to pull
- 7:57the screen down and the projector and.
- 8:00It would get super hot and then don't touch the.
- 8:02Projector 9000° in that classroom.
- 8:05No, the kids, and I'm not saying this as like a pad on my own
- 8:11back, like kids liked me. Yeah.
- 8:13So they would say stuff that they done to other teachers, but
- 8:17like they didn't do it to me. Do you have any?
- 8:20OK, what did they do to other teachers?
- 8:22So wank a couple kids that I had and I believe this was like
- 8:27first block 1 semester and they said to a previous English
- 8:31teacher they had snuck a Turkey call into the classroom so they
- 8:36would just randomly. Right in the middle of class,
- 8:39just like, yeah, that's a terrible Turkey call, as you can
- 8:42tell. That was.
- 8:44I'm not a Turkey hunter. Is that what a Turkey sounds
- 8:46like? I.
- 8:46Mean in my brain. Sometimes it sounds like a
- 8:49combination of a duck quacking and Charlie Brown's teacher.
- 8:54They exactly reminded me of Charlie Brown when you did that.
- 8:57I was like, OK, Charlie the duck.
- 9:00No. And he said it went on for a
- 9:02while, like before she actually caught.
- 9:03Him. That would be awesome though.
- 9:05And I was like, oh, that's funny.
- 9:07How would you not know where that sounds coming from?
- 9:10I still. I get the weeds on these things.
- 9:13I don't know, but I like a part of me misses high school because
- 9:17they're, you know, they're old enough that you can kind of joke
- 9:21around. Like, you know, elementary
- 9:23school kids would just cry if you were sarcastic to them.
- 9:27But they are also old enough to listen and know when to listen
- 9:29and everything. But it's like, I remember one
- 9:32time we were about to do our, I think it was our finals review
- 9:36or a midterms review or something.
- 9:38And I can't remember what I said, but one of the kids raised
- 9:44his hand. I was like, what?
- 9:44He was like, did you just say, damn?
- 9:47I was like, no, why would I say that?
- 9:49He was like, I'm pretty sure you said damn and.
- 9:51Another kid, he was trying to and.
- 9:53Another kid went why would we care if she said damn?
- 9:55And I was like, can we all please stop saying damn?
- 10:01That's like a Seinfeld Seinfeld bit or something it.
- 10:04Was I was like, I think you all just wanted to say the word.
- 10:07I was like no, and what reason would I be teaching and say
- 10:10that? Word.
- 10:10Clearly you did, unless you were doing some kind of literature or
- 10:13something. Like this is Hoover Dam.
- 10:15Like in that sense, yes. But one time they got me.
- 10:20I don't even know if I should tell this story, but I'm going
- 10:24to because it was. So we've had 10 minutes of
- 10:27nobody got me, they liked me, and now all of a sudden you're
- 10:31going to open. Have we not been in the tree
- 10:32address this whole time? No, when I say they got me, I
- 10:35don't mean with a prank. I mean, I think they thought I
- 10:40was on the same page, but I wasn't because sometimes I'm
- 10:43just a little little behind, you know, my brain's moving a little
- 10:47slow on occasion. That's fair.
- 10:51We were, this was also maybe, maybe I should just stop doing
- 10:54reviews. This was also for some review.
- 10:56We were coming up with teams, one side of the classroom and
- 10:59the other side of the classroom and it was like a baseball
- 11:01review. So if like you got it right, you
- 11:02have to go to first base, blah, blah, blah, that kind of thing.
- 11:06So we actually had bases put up in the classroom.
- 11:08It was fun, it was cool. So they were trying to come up
- 11:10with their team names and one of these kids was like, hey, I want
- 11:17ours to be cool kids club. And they were like.
- 11:23But I think I know where this is going.
- 11:25Let's go. I'm Buckle.
- 11:27Can I continue? Yeah.
- 11:27Let's go. Are you sure it's OK?
- 11:30Yeah. So they were like, but we don't
- 11:31know what like our abbreviation should be or whatever.
- 11:34Like cool because not like using, we don't want to see like
- 11:38CC said like that's no fun cool kids club like that's what it
- 11:41is. And I was like, why don't you
- 11:43just use K? And the whole class got silent
- 11:48and looked at me and they looked at me for like 5 seconds before
- 11:51they just burst out laughing. And as soon as I said it, I
- 11:54knew. I was like.
- 11:57Oh, Oh my, good there was. But now, did you actually say it
- 12:04though? Or did you just say 1?
- 12:07No, I just said one I. Said, why don't you go OK, OK,
- 12:09well, at least you didn't go all three.
- 12:12And then in my head I went, Oh, no, oh, I've really messed.
- 12:19Up. Oh no.
- 12:19And this was at the high school. This was at the high school, but
- 12:22like and then there were a couple kids that went Miss
- 12:25Foster you did not just set. My girl, you did not just say
- 12:30that. And I was just like had my head
- 12:33in my hand and I was like, I. That's when you immediately get
- 12:36like the cold sweats and you've got that pit feeling in your
- 12:39stomach and you're like last dismissed.
- 12:42I'm so nervous but thankful like I had a good relationship.
- 12:44It's time for 7th period. And like, we would joke around
- 12:48and stuff. And they also knew this did not
- 12:50come from a place of like, you know, there was no nefarious
- 12:55intention. I will say there's never a
- 12:58nefarious intention with Shannon.
- 13:00People who listen to our morning show, you know they're.
- 13:03Yeah, no, I mean, there's no malice whatsoever.
- 13:06It's just sometimes, you know, sometimes we don't think before
- 13:10we speak and that was one of those occasions and.
- 13:14That was a good one. Yeah, that was that was one that
- 13:17I was like you. I wanted to be like, you know,
- 13:19jam. Well, what you just.
- 13:21Did I? Was going to say they set you up
- 13:22good on that one. Yeah, 'cause it just, it flew.
- 13:26Do you remember the kid who who set you up like that?
- 13:29I do remember. Did he get a bad grade in the
- 13:31class? No, I liked.
- 13:32I like that kid. I'm not going to say anymore.
- 13:36Yeah, yeah, I like. I love how you can get Shanny.
- 13:40You can get her off and she'll just start talking and then all
- 13:44of a sudden it's like it'll kick in.
- 13:46I'm not going to say anymore. I'm I'm going to cut it off.
- 13:48It's not HIPAA, but I it's. I was going to say, you're not
- 13:51going to get in trouble. Some privacy issues there
- 13:54because, you know that kid knows who that kid is.
- 13:56And I also still remember the kid that was like Miss.
- 13:58Paul Was he over 18 now or did he get held back?
- 14:01No, no, he's, is he? Still in 11th grade, no.
- 14:04He's he has graduated. He is on with his life at this
- 14:09point. But you know, you know, Speaking
- 14:11of like mispronunciations, misspeakings, you have a story
- 14:16for us, don't you? Oh.
- 14:18Oh, oh, oh, I know what you're talking about.
- 14:21You're talking. So she is.
- 14:23She has gone nationwide. She's made it on TMZ.
- 14:25She's made it on The Tonight Show.
- 14:27She's all over the place. I think her name is Tammy and
- 14:30she's from QVC. And she was talking about, she
- 14:35was talking about a wig, right? Getting your hair.
- 14:38She's talking about getting hair done.
- 14:39And and she was like, you can, she started to say.
- 14:44You can say it. She said blow job.
- 14:48But she meant. Blow.
- 14:49But she meant blow out. And my favorite part about that
- 14:53is she never turned around the rest of the interview.
- 14:56Like she had the back of her hair, she was showing the back
- 14:58of her hair, and she never turned around the rest of the
- 15:01interview. And you could tell she was
- 15:03laughing. And at one point, yeah.
- 15:05And at one point you just see her duck down and she's in the
- 15:07floor crying and laughing. You can hear everybody behind
- 15:11the camera. Laughing.
- 15:12Everybody's snickering. Everybody had a fun time with
- 15:14because you could tell genuinely it was an accident.
- 15:16Yeah, those are the best kind. She was like, you know, you know
- 15:20this place, you can get a really nice blowjob blowout, you can
- 15:22get a really nice blowout. And at this point, it was our.
- 15:26She's like, the layers don't look good.
- 15:27So. So Shannon and I were talking
- 15:30about that last night, oddly enough.
- 15:32And I've, you know, shared her the clip.
- 15:34And do you remember the news guy, Shepard Smith back in the
- 15:38day? He was on Fox News.
- 15:41He was a very yeah, yeah, yeah. He was a very handsome
- 15:43gentleman. Yeah, he.
- 15:44Was very dapper handsome fella. Very dapper.
- 15:47Well, he was doing a party. He was doing a news story about
- 15:51a block party that Jlo was having back in the Bronx, and he
- 15:56meant to say block party. He's like, it looks more like a
- 16:00blowjob party than a block party.
- 16:03And he's like, oh, because I don't know where that came from.
- 16:08I'm sorry, I know one thing, it'll never happen again.
- 16:12What was he trying to? Say, I don't know what he was
- 16:14saying. I guess he was trying to say
- 16:15block party, but he's like, it looks more like a blowjob party
- 16:19than a block party. And I was like.
- 16:23I wonder if BJ has ever been mentioned so many times within
- 16:2630 seconds in a podcast before. Or did we just set a record?
- 16:30Well, I mean, there is that one podcast where that dude
- 16:34interviews adult film stars, so I feel like he's probably got
- 16:37the record. They probably have us beat,
- 16:39yeah. OK, big breath and you're going
- 16:53to need a huge cup of coffee. I mean, you might have to
- 16:56Gilmore girls that Gilmore girls this with.
- 17:00What does that mean? And an IV.
- 17:02Oh, did they do that on Gilmore Girls?
- 17:05Lorelai Gilmore. She's always like coffee,
- 17:08coffee, coffee. Is that the one played by Lauren
- 17:10Graham? Yes, I think.
- 17:12She's attractive, I like her. She is, she is a fantastic
- 17:15Lorelai. Her and Rory, I don't know how
- 17:16they did it. They were just so bump up, up,
- 17:18up, up, back and forth. But it is a Gilmore Girls cup of
- 17:22coffee kind of day. I've never been more excited to
- 17:25talk about coffee cup crime episode in my entire life.
- 17:28Man, like this case has Wade and I's brains jumbled like a
- 17:35freaking overflowing trash heap. I don't even know how to explain
- 17:40it. What we're talking about is the
- 17:41Idaho 4. It's I was pretty.
- 17:45And I will say from my point of view, before Koeberger filed
- 17:51this, he's wanting to appeal or whatever.
- 17:54He's changing his plea. I was on the side of most people
- 17:59where I was like, this SOB has to stay in jail.
- 18:01Like, he doesn't deserve to get out.
- 18:05But then Wade was like, hey, have you heard of this book?
- 18:10OK, so to be fair, I got it based on an interview from
- 18:15another podcast. I love Dax Shepard.
- 18:17Armchair expert. Yeah.
- 18:19And on Wednesdays they do an expert.
- 18:21So they had a former FBI guy, Christopher Whitcomb.
- 18:25He was on there talking about his new book called Broken Plea,
- 18:29which is all about the Idaho 4 and Koburger's, you know, mess
- 18:36that he's in, right? And I'm just going to say, wow,
- 18:44I don't know any all the way around.
- 18:45Wow. Because everything you think you
- 18:49know about the case is wrong. Right, like.
- 18:55Right. Like.
- 18:56It's all incorrect. And he in the book like so we
- 19:01listened, we did Audible and he is actually the one who reads
- 19:05it. I'm so proud of you.
- 19:06And. We listened.
- 19:08I know I'm trying not to. Start.
- 19:10We go back and forth all the time if you listen to a book on
- 19:14Audible or whatever. Can you say you read?
- 19:16It can you say you read that book?
- 19:18And I say no. And she says yes, but we'll not
- 19:21do that now. Maybe we'll do that for spank it
- 19:24or. Yeah, I was going to say that'd
- 19:25be a perfect opportunity to take it.
- 19:27But we listen to it and it's just like he really does break
- 19:33it down and he actually reads a lot of the case filings like the
- 19:37police reports and the interviews and all of this
- 19:41stuff. And I don't even know where to
- 19:45begin with this because I went from 100% convinced to Koburger
- 19:50did it to. Don't think he did.
- 19:54I. Think I was going.
- 19:55To say I at this point I think he did something, but what his
- 20:03involvement was I'm not sure. But there's no way like just the
- 20:09the physical evidence alone, I don't think there's any way one
- 20:15person did it just in the timeline of when they were
- 20:18supposed to be like within 4 minutes.
- 20:21There's no way you can. You know what I mean?
- 20:24That's just, it's just not possible.
- 20:26Physically possible. Physically possible.
- 20:28And the way he broke down what happened in that house that
- 20:31night about how there was like, well, there was some Ethan's
- 20:35undiluted blood was on the wall going down to the first floor,
- 20:39right? And if the killer quote, UN
- 20:41quote Coburger was never down there, how in the world did it
- 20:44get there? But then they said there was
- 20:47also diluted blood all throughout the living room mixed
- 20:50with some other substance which you never heard.
- 20:52About until that interview and the book, yeah.
- 20:57So it's like I in my brain when they say, oh, this blood was
- 21:00mixed with some substance, you assume cleaning solution.
- 21:04That's exactly what. You.
- 21:05Yeah, so. Who cleaned up the living room
- 21:09and put that O and the whole the beer pong table, The beer pong
- 21:13table? That was a.
- 21:14Huge thing like they said it was because so the night it happened
- 21:20what was about 2:00 AM, they said Kaylee and one of her
- 21:24friends and was Bethany there at that point watching Vampire
- 21:27Diaries maybe she. Was there at that point as well
- 21:30not. Kaylee sorry, Dylan.
- 21:31Dylan was there. And Dylan, I posted to her
- 21:34Snapchat story a picture of her sitting on the couch watching
- 21:38Vampire Diaries, and you can see the beer palm table in the
- 21:41background and it's not in the same spot as it is when
- 21:45Detective. Muniz went in the house and you
- 21:48catch it on his Cam for the first time.
- 21:50His body Cam, Yep, for the first time it's in a different.
- 21:53Spot so here's. And that is one of the other
- 21:57issues that I have with this and I don't think.
- 22:04Organizing. I'm trying.
- 22:06I'm trying to say this in a way that's not going to come off
- 22:12wrong. I think Bethany and Dylan know
- 22:18more than what they've let on, especially Dylan.
- 22:22I agree. Maybe not.
- 22:24Bethany, but especially Dylan. I think she knows more than what
- 22:28she's letting on. Yeah, because.
- 22:30As far as those 2GO when they said this part, when it comes to
- 22:34this part in his book, my jaw hit the floor.
- 22:38So apparently that first floor bathroom, which is where Dylan
- 22:42ran down to to go to Bethany's room, supposedly after she saw
- 22:45the masked man or whatever, that the first floor bathroom they
- 22:51said was like Immaculate. It was extensively cleaned.
- 22:56There were no towels, no toilet paper, no makeup, no typical
- 22:59bathroom. Which you don't.
- 23:01I mean, that's just not realistic for anybody's house.
- 23:04No, let. Alone.
- 23:05A college student's house? Yeah.
- 23:07They're typically gross then, if that.
- 23:09Wasn't crazy enough. Literally in my I had to put
- 23:12notes down so I didn't forget all of this stuff that I was
- 23:15like listening to the book totally parked while also typing
- 23:19on my phone writing down notes. That Dylan's blood soaked green
- 23:25jacket was found on the 1st floor, but it was given back to
- 23:28her as her personal property. And the only DNA like what the.
- 23:35Only. Blood that they could make out
- 23:37DNA wise was hers. Everything else was mixed up so
- 23:41much you couldn't tell what was what.
- 23:43Yeah. So it's like.
- 23:44Wait, what? Why are we giving back?
- 23:46And why did we never the knife that Hunter, Emily's boyfriend,
- 23:52when he was the first one, they called Emily to say, hey, can
- 23:56you come over and check? We haven't heard from any of the
- 23:59other four. And they called her because they
- 24:02knew Hunter would come with her, right?
- 24:06That's what they that's what they said in one of the
- 24:07interviews. According to Wickham, he comes
- 24:12in and grabs a big butcher knife or whatever from the kitchen.
- 24:17From the kitchen. And nobody like Munez or none of
- 24:23the detectives are like, hey, you have a knife.
- 24:27All these people were stabbed with multiple knives.
- 24:32Let's grab that knife and check it.
- 24:34Yeah, like let's. See there's there might be
- 24:35something on it, I just don't. I, I mean, yeah.
- 24:39And I mean, I get so like, one of the things, I don't want to
- 24:41try to make the police in Idaho look terrible or the ISP or
- 24:45whatever, you know, whether it's a county or the Sheriff's Office
- 24:50or whatever. But I feel like they botched so
- 24:54many things. And to be fair, it had been
- 24:57like, what, six or seven years since a murder happened in this
- 25:01town. Yeah, they went.
- 25:02From So they don't have no murders, just four.
- 25:05Yeah, they don't have. A lot of experience on that, but
- 25:07I feel like just going down the list from A-Z, there's a certain
- 25:14way you do things. They didn't.
- 25:17I do, I think. They were so overwhelmed with
- 25:20what was happening that stuff was just missed.
- 25:24Which I mean, can't happen, but the least you can do is go back
- 25:28and look at this and be like, oh, this isn't adding up because
- 25:33especially when it comes to the roommates.
- 25:34Like one. Besides the green jacket, there
- 25:36was also a broken woman's bracelet that have blood on.
- 25:39It floor. As well, I didn't have one.
- 25:43Of one of their, one of the blood.
- 25:46I, I don't know which one it was.
- 25:47At this point, it's tough to keep unless you're reading it
- 25:51verbatim. Yeah.
- 25:53And I went through and I actually listened to 'cause
- 25:56they're saying that from that Ring camera, from that one
- 25:59house, you can hear screams, right?
- 26:01So you were telling me that four of your friends that live, I
- 26:07mean, in the same house. Well, that's one of the things.
- 26:09So Dylan, in one of the early interviews, she's like, you
- 26:12know, you can hear everything in this house, but you didn't hear
- 26:15that. But yet it's going to pick it up
- 26:17on a Ring camera across the street in another house, and you
- 26:21didn't hear it. Yeah, you had.
- 26:22No clue what was going on then she.
- 26:24Says, you know, one of the things that she's like, I was so
- 26:28drunk, she didn't test drunk. And somebody testified that when
- 26:34she was out wherever, doing whatever that evening, she said
- 26:38she didn't want to drink or take part in any of the other
- 26:41substances that they were doing, which I think it was just
- 26:44Adderall. Yeah, that's.
- 26:45From what I've heard, that seems to be what it was, so that's.
- 26:48Inconsistent right there. She sounds like she's covering
- 26:51some up and like she refutes this was AI Finished up the book
- 26:56this morning on my way into work and then she did 4 different
- 27:00interviews and she said but I don't know.
- 27:04I'm not sure about every fact that she gave like 52 or 62
- 27:10times, including the assailant. 'S height, yeah, she's like, oh,
- 27:13maybe my height. Couple inches.
- 27:15Shorter couple inches more. Like yeah, there.
- 27:18Was no and the. Bushy eyebrows weren't mentioned
- 27:21until the second interview. I think it was the.
- 27:23Second or third interview that she mentioned the bushy
- 27:25eyebrows. But here's the other weird
- 27:27thing. Did you pick up?
- 27:30It was one of the early chapters where they were doing like,
- 27:32victimology or whatever in her room.
- 27:37She had a bunch of drawings of eyes and eyebrows all over her
- 27:41walls. Oh my gosh, yeah.
- 27:44So I saw. That and I was like, what this
- 27:48is weird something there's something weird there and I
- 27:53just, I can't figure it out like what the connection is 'cause
- 27:58you know, they say they haven't really found any connection
- 28:00between Co Burger and those girls, right Well, and Kaylee.
- 28:03Unfortunately, Kaylee can call this she, you know, was appeared
- 28:09to be the intended victim. She was beaten.
- 28:12The worst and I think. Everybody else, and I think even
- 28:15Christopher says this toward the end of Chapter 15, everybody
- 28:20else is just a victim of circumstance so that they were
- 28:24trying to hide the killer's identities at that point.
- 28:28But then. Again, why would he?
- 28:30So Dylan was also on the 2nd floor.
- 28:32Why would he let Dylan live? I I know everybody's like, oh,
- 28:35he was tired. He.
- 28:37Just killed four people. That's why I think.
- 28:40Somehow I don't, I I'm not saying they were involved, but
- 28:47you know what I mean? And like, the only reason Kaylee
- 28:49was in town because she had effectively moved out and moved
- 28:52back home because she was getting ready to move to Texas,
- 28:53right? Yeah.
- 28:54So the only reason she was back in town that particular weekend?
- 28:59Because of Dylan. Dylan had invited her to the
- 29:02sorority homecoming her right the day.
- 29:05Yeah, she came for the homecoming football game and
- 29:07then so. I mean, what are the odds?
- 29:12Yeah. Whoever it was.
- 29:13Knew she was going to be there. Knew she was going.
- 29:15To be in that house at that time, that weekend, so.
- 29:19I There is so much to get into this and another huge part that
- 29:23the book revealed that I had not heard anything about was the
- 29:27morning of the murders. So 4 minutes after the murders
- 29:32were committed, apparently there was this like dark SUV that
- 29:37can't again ring camera. Well, there's a couple.
- 29:39Of different vehicles he talks about that again in chapter 15
- 29:44that had a tan SUV and a black truck because the.
- 29:49Dylan mentioned she saw a black truck.
- 29:51Well, the. Mcmichaels girl who was doing
- 29:54the DoorDash at that time, she testified about both of those
- 29:58vehicles as well, and that was never explored.
- 30:01And why? Because that SUV, so that the
- 30:03SUV pulls up, shows up 4 minutes after the murder.
- 30:06Somebody, some man with a black or a backpack.
- 30:10Dark backpack. Throws it.
- 30:11In the SUV and gets in, it leaves and then it comes back a
- 30:17few minutes later, right, But to a different spot.
- 30:20Nobody gets out, it leaves, and then two hours later at like 628
- 30:25or something, it comes back to its original spot and I believe
- 30:30that person with the backpack got back out.
- 30:33I mean, nothing makes sense. Nothing makes sense.
- 30:36But we didn't. And.
- 30:38There was no more about that. There was no more investigation
- 30:41about that. Like that was it?
- 30:42I don't know how. And even if you're going to
- 30:44clear that, that's got to be in the report somewhere, right?
- 30:48That you cleared those people, yeah.
- 30:50To be. Thorough, but it's not and so.
- 30:53My thought process was, did they come back two hours later for a
- 30:56cleanup? Well, so toward the end of
- 31:01chapter 15, Christopher posits one theory about one person
- 31:10stayed in the house cleaning up while another person left and
- 31:17like disposed of the murder weapons and did the other stuff
- 31:20and then got picked back up around the time you're saying
- 31:24OK. With that.
- 31:25SUV and see that make. That makes so much more sense,
- 31:29yeah. Then the Koburger theory, Yeah.
- 31:33And well, I mean. Even if you just look at even if
- 31:36you just look at the murders themselves.
- 31:38OK, so let's take and he walks you through this is I'm telling
- 31:44you, it's the book is called Broken Plea and it's it's an
- 31:48amazing book. And he walks you through every
- 31:52bit of the evidence. I mean, to the point where
- 31:55you're like, this is a lot Christopher, I'm having a hard
- 31:57time picking up. I will say that.
- 31:58Like I got overwhelmed in a couple points because certain
- 32:01points are repetitive. Like it'll be like November 13th
- 32:04event. With the victim solution
- 32:06November 13th. Event it's.
- 32:08A lot. But so you've got, you know,
- 32:11Kaylee is the intended victim, right?
- 32:14And it's not just murder for murder's sake, OK?
- 32:17Because at that point you would have stopped on the 1st floor
- 32:21and you would have gone downstairs to see who's there.
- 32:25You are looking. For somebody specific, they
- 32:28immediately. Came in and went up to the third
- 32:30floor directly to Kaylee's room. So, and this is, and this is the
- 32:35theory that he talks about where he mentions multiple killers,
- 32:39OK, a couple of at least two, if not three doing this crime
- 32:44together because he says you go upstairs to the third room, he
- 32:49said. And there's so much damage
- 32:52inflicted on Kaylee's body with so much force that there's no
- 32:57way somebody can remain asleep beside them.
- 33:02So somebody had to they. Woke up hurt, Megan.
- 33:06And kill Megan at the same time while one was going on Kaylee
- 33:12more. Or Maddie.
- 33:14Maddie. Maddie.
- 33:15Did I say Megan? Yeah, Maddie Mogan.
- 33:17Mogan. And then they go downstairs and
- 33:23he says that he believes that Zanna met the killer in the
- 33:32kitchen area. 'Cause she had just ordered
- 33:34DoorDash and. That's where they heard the
- 33:38noise with the the table, because Dylan said that she
- 33:41thought she heard the table flip over and the cups spill.
- 33:46Yeah, it was like. I think it was Bethany when
- 33:48because she said sound of like a firecracker and she saw like a
- 33:51light going off under her door. So so I just.
- 33:54Wonder if that's, you know, and that's the thing that
- 33:57Christopher talks about. He's like, so he met Dylan and
- 34:00Chase Dylan around the ping pong table.
- 34:02When he hits the ping pong table, Xana, XANA and that
- 34:05there's too many names. There's too many names to keep
- 34:07up with everything. So he meets Xana in the kitchen
- 34:11area, chases her around and downstairs and he I guess gets
- 34:19to her. The thought is it gets to her
- 34:22and knocks her out or does something while somebody else is
- 34:27attacking Ethan. Because Ethan, he, you know, he
- 34:30had the socks on right in bed. There was no blood on any of the
- 34:35bottom of the socks. So and the other wounds that he
- 34:39had, he never raised up out of bed, right?
- 34:43So he. Was killed in a prone position
- 34:45in bed. You're 6 foot four, 228 LB
- 34:52football player and the love of your life is being stabbed and
- 34:57attacked 4 feet from you. You're going to put up a fight,
- 35:02right? You're going to do something
- 35:04about it. And that's one of the other
- 35:05things that never got tested either, is when they were doing
- 35:08the evidential discovery and stuff, they find a clump of hair
- 35:13in Dylan's fist and they label it as debris and they never test
- 35:19it for any DNA or anything. And they found a few.
- 35:23Hairs in Maddie's bed. So that's the thing I had to
- 35:26double check. It was so it was Maddie's
- 35:27bedroom that Maddie and Kaylee were both in.
- 35:31So that's why at first they were kind of like, OK, maybe Maddie
- 35:34was the intended target, but when they realized the extent of
- 35:38Kaylee's injuries. So my theory was that maybe
- 35:42Maddie was the intended target and they were so angry that
- 35:46Kaylee was there that they took it out on her.
- 35:50Maybe, I don't know. So I.
- 35:53Haven't, I haven't said that I was saving all of this for today
- 35:56and I haven't said this. I haven't told, told Shannon,
- 35:59you know, my wife or anybody in all of our discussions about
- 36:03this. So she had just, Kaylee had just
- 36:07broken up with Jack. Yeah, maybe 2-3 months before
- 36:13the murder happened. And she had already started
- 36:17seeing a Mason Barstow, I think was his name.
- 36:20He was in one of the Greek fraternities.
- 36:24And they described it as she would occasionally hook up with
- 36:27him. Yeah.
- 36:28Something casual, so I think it. Was one of the things that
- 36:35somebody didn't get to spend enough time with her because of
- 36:41her relationship with Maddie? Because they've been best
- 36:45friends since what, 6th grade and never did anything apart?
- 36:48I mean, obviously if they went to school together and room
- 36:50together and everything, I think that that's one of the things
- 36:55that they were bothered by and that's why they were in that
- 36:57specific position, because it wasn't a sexual position they
- 37:01were placed in. It was like a.
- 37:03Cuddle. It was a.
- 37:04Cuddle it's like oh you 2 want to be together?
- 37:07Here you go. Yeah, because that that was a
- 37:10big part of it too, was like, why were their bodies positioned
- 37:13right? Why were they?
- 37:14Positioned in the in the way they work because nothing about
- 37:16any of the murders were appeared to be sexual in nature.
- 37:21So. And.
- 37:22Then even even Ethan was covered up waist up, right is what they
- 37:27said. He had a he had a blanket.
- 37:28On him, tucked in, Put it like. So I mean.
- 37:32It's just the whole thing's weird.
- 37:33Zana doesn't make any sense because she was in the floor.
- 37:38So that's why we assume she was running.
- 37:40That's why trying to get back to Ethan Exactly she was.
- 37:43Trying to go to Ethan for protection and you know, that's
- 37:48just where it happened to take place.
- 37:53I don't know, I just like my I've been my brain has just been
- 37:59like rumbling around trying to figure out and I'm I'm not a
- 38:03detective. I don't know, like this is just
- 38:06trying to put these facts together as in amateur over
- 38:10here. Well, and.
- 38:11I mean, there's a couple other things real fast that bothered
- 38:13me. So you say you see your roommate
- 38:22and she's passed out on the floor, right?
- 38:26And she said she could see the top of her head.
- 38:30You're going to see your roommate passed out on the floor
- 38:33and the top of the head, and you're not going to see that
- 38:37she's laying in a pool of blood. Yeah.
- 38:39How'd you? See that but not you got that
- 38:41much. Detail, but not blood.
- 38:42OK, that's for that was for Dylan, right?
- 38:46Because Dylan's the one that ran downstairs to Bethany.
- 38:48Another thing that really bothers me, and he talks about
- 38:51this as well. You know, she said she ran
- 38:55straight downstairs and Bethany and went to sleep, right?
- 39:01They were so out of it, they just passed out.
- 39:05But her Apple Watch shows all kinds of movements between the
- 39:12hours of four to six, 4:00 AM to 6:00 AM, or like 630, something
- 39:17like that. In the book he.
- 39:19Gives the specific numbers that she travelled, and I'm pretty
- 39:21sure at one point he said that she travelled 2 steps or two
- 39:26flights of stairs. Two flights of stairs.
- 39:28And it's like. But you never left the room.
- 39:30But you never left. The room.
- 39:31And then also there was evidence that she was on social media, on
- 39:34her phone. So I mean, she was awake.
- 39:40She was awake. What were you doing?
- 39:41What were you doing? It's already been proven that
- 39:45you weren't drunk based on your toxicology.
- 39:47You know, your blood alcohol report and eyewitnesses from
- 39:50earlier that evening. You hadn't had anything to
- 39:54drink. You hadn't taken any drugs.
- 39:56It was. Apparent that the living area
- 39:58had been attempted to be cleaned up right you've.
- 40:01Got all this diluted blood? You've got the replacement of
- 40:05the beer pong table and all the cups set back up in order.
- 40:11So I've been trying to think of it from the perspective of how
- 40:15could Koeburger be involved in this?
- 40:19And he went there 'cause it was noted that he had an obsession
- 40:23with serial killers. Like he was invested in it.
- 40:27I mean, he was at Reddit, he did Reddit surveys.
- 40:30Like how did you feel when you committed this crime?
- 40:32Weird dude gives off weird vibes. 110% and motionless.
- 40:37This is just like. Me brainstorming completely my
- 40:40opinion or thought process of what maybe could have happened.
- 40:43What if he went to like the dark web or something and like wanted
- 40:48a hire to kill thing or he wanted to be involved in a crime
- 40:53in some way as almost like an experiment for him right?
- 40:57And that's how he got tied to this again, he wasn't alone.
- 41:01There was other people in it, but somehow he got.
- 41:06Or if he's like I want to help, I want to put my knowledge to
- 41:10the test. But you would think too, when
- 41:12he's going to prison to serve 4 consecutive life sentences, that
- 41:17you would give somebody up well. See, here's the other thing that
- 41:21that's really crazy is, you know, they interviewed a couple
- 41:25of the of the guys that he was in prison with early on and they
- 41:30said every time the news will come on.
- 41:33He was glued to the news about it like he liked.
- 41:36Hearing him he loved. Seeing himself and hearing his
- 41:40name on the news and like to the point where he's like every
- 41:44channel nice or something to that effect, but he didn't.
- 41:49Like it when his family I was going to say but every.
- 41:51Time his family came up, he turned it off immediately.
- 41:54So it's clear he didn't want to put them in harm's way or or
- 41:58whatever. And at one point he told his
- 42:00sister, you need a lawyer. I remember that from the book as
- 42:04well. But I, yeah, I mean, I, I
- 42:08because that's a crime of passion to do that to Kaylee.
- 42:13That's, I mean, that's broken teeth.
- 42:15Broken skull strangled her to. The point where she had
- 42:18Petechia, is that how you say it?
- 42:20I believe so. And.
- 42:22That takes a while, you know, And there was no ligature mark,
- 42:26so that was hands, hands on the amount of stab.
- 42:28Wounds she had to again. He was in a detail in the book.
- 42:32Yeah, was unreal. It tells you.
- 42:34Like he legit the part I actually just listened, I'm
- 42:36almost done with it. I have like 40 minutes left.
- 42:39The part he went got into right before I got out of the car was
- 42:42talking about how many stab wounds each of the victims had
- 42:46and it was just an insane amount.
- 42:47And again, you were like, this didn't happen in under 5
- 42:49minutes, right? There's no.
- 42:51Way. There's no way that.
- 42:52Happened, but more more parts. We we could literally talk about
- 42:56this for hours. I feel like the knife sheath,
- 43:00yeah. Should we get into?
- 43:04That rabbit hole because, well, one.
- 43:07So when they first went up to Maddie's room on the 3rd floor,
- 43:11they didn't even note the knife sheath, right?
- 43:14Right. And then somebody said it was on
- 43:16the floor, but then picture evidence shows it was tucked
- 43:19under Maddie's thigh. Yeah, but it didn't have blood.
- 43:25So like you would think, was it they were saying like where it
- 43:28was sitting and all that blood on the bed that the blood should
- 43:30have soaked into it, but it didn't, which means it was
- 43:33placed there after the blood had dried.
- 43:36Yeah. Who put it there?
- 43:40Who put it there? My guess is Dylan or Bethany.
- 43:44I. Don't know that Bethany doesn't
- 43:46come off as guilty to me. No, as as Dylan does.
- 43:51Dylan comes off as knowing more. And Bethany, I think she was
- 43:54like, drunk out of her mind. Yeah.
- 43:57Like you're very intoxicated. Well, and Bethany?
- 43:59Isn't the one who saw anything that night, right?
- 44:01Like she was just going by what Dylan was saying, right.
- 44:04And so it's like you're being ridiculous.
- 44:07Well, but if you're the one that physically sees it and then you
- 44:10get. Into the DNA of the knife
- 44:12sheath. And you talk about the ISP, the
- 44:19Idaho State Police, I think they were the ones that were in
- 44:21charge of that at that point. They were going to have it
- 44:25tested by one person or one particular company.
- 44:30And that company said it wasn't Koburger.
- 44:35Yeah, that was. The private lab they.
- 44:37Cancelled the contract with them and went with another company
- 44:41who said yeah, this DNA is the father of your killer.
- 44:50And I'm like. But then you had you were
- 44:52talking about the one FBI agent, wasn't it, who said that it
- 45:00showed the DNA evidence of four brothers who were not named
- 45:04Koburger. Yeah, so the.
- 45:06Private lab in Texas said that the genealogy led to four
- 45:09brothers. Yeah.
- 45:11And in the book, he goes over the lead detective being
- 45:15questioned. And the lead detective of this
- 45:18case couldn't remember the last name of those four brothers.
- 45:22And so she said, well, you do remember the last name of the
- 45:25guy who's been in prison for two years, Copper?
- 45:27Was it that name? And he went, no, it was not that
- 45:29name. Who were these?
- 45:31Four brothers, I guess they did I it mentioned in the book that
- 45:37they contacted one of the brothers and the brothers said
- 45:39they wanted nothing to do with the case.
- 45:41And it's like, and then you just dropped it.
- 45:44You're just like, OK, you don't want anything to do with it.
- 45:46All right? Four brothers makes a whole lot
- 45:49more sense killing four people than one person.
- 45:54Well. And then at some point, one of
- 45:57the interviews I saw said something about maybe looking at
- 46:02some of the Greek fraternities, like the fraternity brothers.
- 46:10So I mean, there's just so many. So a couple of couple of things.
- 46:16I think Koeberger was involved somehow, someway.
- 46:20Yeah, He didn't act alone. I know that for sure.
- 46:24And I think even though I've never practiced law at all, I
- 46:30could probably get him off just based on the evidence alone.
- 46:34And I don't know, Blank from Shinola.
- 46:38That's what they were. Saying was like if he would have
- 46:40gone to trial, right? Yeah, it probably would have.
- 46:44Had a pretty good chance and number.
- 46:45Two, Dylan knows more than she's letting on.
- 46:50She knows what happened that night, but is covering up
- 46:54something. Those are the only two things
- 46:58I'm 100% concrete about. In this case I think it.
- 47:04Needs reviewed again. I understand that like when
- 47:08Koeberger went to do his appeal, like part of his plea deal was
- 47:11he gave up the right to appeal. In the future.
- 47:16And now all of a sudden he's like, wait, wait, wait, but
- 47:20like, look at this, look at that.
- 47:22And so I'm curious. Is it?
- 47:25Possible to overturn a conviction like that if you
- 47:28agree to a plea deal where says where it says you give up the
- 47:31right to that. I mean, that's I've got a
- 47:35feeling that it's going to go all the way up, like it's going
- 47:38to hit the Supreme Court and we could.
- 47:41Possibly get a trial out of this.
- 47:43Yeah. And honestly, I feel like that's
- 47:45what needs to happen because like these four young college
- 47:49students, they need justice. And I don't know that they got
- 47:53it. Kaylee and Maddie and Ethan and
- 47:56Zana. Yeah, they definitely.
- 47:58They need some justice like. And unless he.
- 48:01Goes on trial or somebody goes on trial, I don't think we'll
- 48:05ever find out because until you start putting the pressure on
- 48:10some of these other people and they face some serious
- 48:13consequences or, or the threat of some serious consequences, I
- 48:18don't think you're going to find out anything.
- 48:20No. And we?
- 48:20Haven't even touched upon Murphy the dog.
- 48:23Yeah. Well, whoever it was did.
- 48:26Not hurt so. Supposedly, one of the theories
- 48:32that Christopher Whitcomb, the author of A Broken Plea he talks
- 48:35about in Chapter 15, is the theory based on evidence and
- 48:41Ring cameras and dogs barking and neighbors hearing dogs bark,
- 48:44dogs barking. Somebody even called the cops
- 48:47because the dog was barking. They said that the dog was put
- 48:53outside and not let back in until after the murders were
- 48:58over. And that would explain how the
- 49:01dog didn't have any blood or wasn't tracking blood or
- 49:05whatever. And then you talk about whoever
- 49:07committed these murders, how are they getting around the house
- 49:12without tracking blood, that blood getting all over
- 49:15everything. Yeah, one person's.
- 49:17Theory was he just ran around naked.
- 49:18That's the dumbest. Thing I've ever heard like.
- 49:21I told them, yeah, I mean, that's just, that's just silly.
- 49:25But then still if that's it. You would still have feet print,
- 49:28like there would be a footprint somewhere, somewhere there'd.
- 49:30Be a toe that hit a wall that has blood on it.
- 49:33I mean not to. Be graphic, but there was so
- 49:34much blood that you could see it from the outside of the house.
- 49:38Well, and the crazy thing about it is, is I forget which bedroom
- 49:43it was, whether it was Maddie's or whether it was the one where
- 49:46Zayna and Ethan were, but there was still a pool of liquid blood
- 49:53in that room. Whether it was, I think it was
- 49:55on the bed. And I'm like, and still we don't
- 50:00have a fingerprint, A footprint, a paw print, nothing.
- 50:05Nowhere, because wasn't. Murphy locked in a bedroom when
- 50:08they got there? I think so.
- 50:09I think he was upstairs either locked in a in a crate or a
- 50:12bedroom or something, but like he was clean.
- 50:15Yes, he. Was clean, nothing and.
- 50:17That that before that was another thing that kind of
- 50:20pushed me toward Coburger was because Coburger had a love for
- 50:22dogs. Like everybody talked about how
- 50:24much he loved his dog, his family dog and stuff.
- 50:26So it's like, oh, I'm not going to hurt him.
- 50:29I'm not going to touch him, put him in a separate room.
- 50:31But also if it's somebody who knows.
- 50:35Murphy. Who cares for?
- 50:37Murphy. Of course they're not going to
- 50:40hurt him. They're going to put him Haley's
- 50:42ex-boyfriend. Somewhere else.
- 50:44And but then also I There's so many.
- 50:48But then also. But then also.
- 50:50What about Ethan? Received a text message Friday
- 50:54night and Saturday night, the exact same text message that
- 50:57said you're being cheated on. Yeah, Zaina.
- 50:59Was cheating on him is that? Just a coincidence.
- 51:04Well, it certainly made it seem like in the latter chapters,
- 51:09when they were doing the victimology and stuff, that
- 51:14XANA, for lack of a better word, was a fun time girl and Kaylee
- 51:23was a fun time girl. At least that's the way it it.
- 51:27It made it seem that they were having the typical college
- 51:31experience, hooking up and partying.
- 51:33And, well, that was the one of the other things in the early in
- 51:37the chapters, they were like, somebody testified that that
- 51:40particular house on King Rd. 1122 King Rd. that sorority
- 51:44house hosted a party every week where there were 50 to 60
- 51:49guests. Yeah.
- 51:51Dude, that's a. Lot.
- 51:52It's a lot of random. People in your house, that's a
- 51:54lot of. Random people.
- 51:56That's the only thing that would perhaps start to let Zana off
- 52:02the hook, is it? There was so much activity in
- 52:05that house, how could you keep it straight?
- 52:08But then you go back to hearing the screams and all the, you
- 52:11know, crying. She's covering something, Dylan.
- 52:17Dylan is, yeah. Yeah, it's.
- 52:19A It's a bit suspicious because Dylan also said in one of her
- 52:22interviews that she's usually the one who locks the door.
- 52:25And she was like, oh, maybe I forgot that night.
- 52:29Well, somebody testified early on in one of the chapters of the
- 52:32book that they usually leave the door open, like the sliding
- 52:38glass door. It's usually open, like, not
- 52:40locked. I don't mean like wide open but
- 52:42not locked. Yeah, I.
- 52:44Don't like so? I mean, and you know how the
- 52:47security is that these if you're, if it's a frat house
- 52:49like that or or a sorority house, security is probably not
- 52:55top of the list as far as priorities, no.
- 52:58And, and sorry, we kind of went into this assuming that each of
- 53:03you have already heard of this case and know what happened.
- 53:07Really, I don't know how. You haven't if you haven't,
- 53:10yeah, at. This point you would have to
- 53:11live under a rock. You probably have bigger.
- 53:13Problems than than what we're talking about, but.
- 53:16Right, you had you had the four students, right?
- 53:19Go to University of Idaho. On the 3rd floor we had Maddie
- 53:24and Kaylee's room. 2nd floor we had Zanna's and Dylan's room.
- 53:28First floor is where we had Bethany's room.
- 53:31So Dylan is the only one that escaped the second floor and got
- 53:34down to the first floor apparently.
- 53:36And then Brian Koburger was a student at Washington
- 53:40University. Which was what?
- 53:4230 minutes away. 2030 minutes. Something like that Might not.
- 53:45Yeah, might. Not even been that far.
- 53:47It's, it's pretty close, but he was getting his PhD in
- 53:49criminology and that was something else about the knife
- 53:53sheet that they say he ordered from Amazon.
- 53:55Apparently he had ordered that and it was sent to his house in
- 53:58Pennsylvania before he ever even left Pennsylvania, before he was
- 54:02even accepted into the program at Washington.
- 54:06So, you know, he didn't. It wasn't that premeditated.
- 54:10That part of it wasn't premeditated, right?
- 54:12It's just. I guess.
- 54:13Could it be coincidental? Yeah.
- 54:16Maybe. I don't know, but I'm, I'm very
- 54:19curious to see how his appeal plays out.
- 54:23If if they kind of, I got to be honest.
- 54:26With you, I mean, from a selfish standpoint, I hope they give him
- 54:30an appeal so we can take this to trial, so that we can take this
- 54:33to trial and hopefully get some answers for not only these,
- 54:37these four young lives that were taken so early, but their
- 54:41friends, family, parents. I can't imagine as a parent.
- 54:45Oh my Lord, no. And.
- 54:47The parents, the parents were kind of split, like some were
- 54:52very against. I would be.
- 54:54Angry if we didn't go to trial. It was actually.
- 54:57Kaylee's Kaylee's parents that were that stated they have
- 55:00remained vocal about wanting answers for the motive because
- 55:04again, their daughter was beating the worst.
- 55:06So it's like, what hat? Why?
- 55:10Why was he targeted? Apparently, I guess.
- 55:12They weren't told about the plea deal before.
- 55:14It was already like out there and in.
- 55:16The open, so it's. Not like they got to review it
- 55:19and approve it and then be like, OK, that's fine.
- 55:22Which I think's out. It's their, it's their family.
- 55:25It's their children. I was going to say yeah.
- 55:26That's just another one of the things that was not handled
- 55:29correctly in this case. No, they have a.
- 55:31Right to it. But I do think it's important
- 55:33that we discussed just a little bit about each of these 4
- 55:38victims, you know, like a little bit about them, who they were
- 55:41'cause I don't think they should just be remembered by their
- 55:44deaths. You know, they very much had
- 55:46lives before this. So Kaylee, she was 21, she was
- 55:49from Rathdrum, ID. I could be saying these names.
- 55:53I was going to say that's easy for you to say.
- 55:56She was a senior at the University of Idaho and
- 55:59apparently she wanted to become a school teacher.
- 56:01And she only came, like we said, she only came back that weekend
- 56:04to attend the homecoming football game, go to the dance
- 56:06with Dylan. And she had recently was
- 56:09preparing to graduate. She was, of course, extremely
- 56:12close with Madison. They were best friends.
- 56:15They had been for a long time. And she was preparing to move to
- 56:18Texas to take a job down there. I guess she'd already prepared
- 56:20roommates to move in with as well.
- 56:23Already bought a car. Ready to go and.
- 56:25Then Maddie, same age. She was 21.
- 56:29From Coeur d'Alene, Idaho Coeur d'Alene.
- 56:33Coeur d'Alene. She's senior, University of
- 56:36Idaho. She was majoring in marketing.
- 56:39Kaylee's best friend as well. And of course, they did end up
- 56:43spending that final evening together.
- 56:46And we have Zana, who she was a little bit younger.
- 56:48She was 20 from Post Falls, ID, a junior at the University of
- 56:52Idaho, and she was in marketing too.
- 56:54So it seems like a lot of these, they had a lot in common, all
- 56:56these girls. Yeah, two of them, I believe,
- 56:59were in the same. For sorority, yeah.
- 57:03Sorority, yeah. And then another.
- 57:04One wasn't a different sorority she was dating Ethan Chapin, who
- 57:09was 20, from Conway, WA and he was a student at the university,
- 57:14member of Sigma Chai Chai Is it Kai Simon Kai you can tell I was
- 57:20not a sorority girl, nor was. I I was not a sorority girl
- 57:24either. So he was dating Zana and unlike
- 57:27the other three he didn't live there.
- 57:29He was visiting Zana that night but apparently from what a lot
- 57:31of people say he was there most night like 6 nights out of.
- 57:34Seven, they said, I think, yeah. So it's.
- 57:36Not unusual that he was there and of course they their lives
- 57:43were taken close to 4:00 AM that morning, but then police weren't
- 57:46called until around noon, which is another.
- 57:49Problem. That's plenty of time to clean
- 57:51up just. And dilute some.
- 57:53Blood just saying that's. Where all that, yeah, diluted
- 57:56blood. But we we love, we're going to
- 58:00of course, we always post some of this about about our coffee
- 58:03cup crime on social media. So we would love to hear your
- 58:06opinion. Get in on this case.
- 58:08Let us know what you think because our minds are blown.
- 58:11We want to hear what's on yours. All right, shake it off, Shake
- 58:23it off, Shake it off. That was a lot.
- 58:25Shake it off. That was a lot.
- 58:26But it was so much fun though. Like I just, I love to dive in
- 58:30deep on some of those cases that are just so enthralling.
- 58:37Yeah. Unexplainable.
- 58:38Yeah, unexplainable. And like, by the time you get
- 58:42done, there's more questions and answers and then you're like,
- 58:45oh, what about this? What about this?
- 58:47What about this? Like you would think.
- 58:48More details would help you put the pieces together.
- 58:51It just makes. It more confusing a lot of the
- 58:52time. Nope it does not.
- 58:53So I think we should spank it or take it please.
- 58:57Please let us. I'm tired.
- 58:59Of being an extra and a lot of other people's FaceTime videos
- 59:04and calls. In.
- 59:06Public I'm tired of people putting everybody on speaker I'm
- 59:11tired of just walking around holding the phone out like this
- 59:16I'm tired of it and I just want it to stop and I'd like to maybe
- 59:22be credited if we are going to do that they're going to be
- 59:26like, hey, we'd like to give way to special shout out for
- 59:29appearing in today's episode or our.
- 59:32Extras are brought to you by or we could just.
- 59:34Stop all together and you could make it a private conversation
- 59:37like the good Lord intended. I hate when people are in
- 59:41restaurants and they're either it's on speakerphone or it's so
- 59:45loud up to their ear that you can still hear it and they're
- 59:48like screaming in the restaurant and it's like, can't you step
- 59:51outside? Just it's like, what are we?
- 59:53Doing Yeah, just like step over. There and so.
- 59:56You know, a lot of the comments I've seen online is 2026.
- 59:58That's the new life. That's the way it is now.
- 1:00:01Just get over it, move on. Doesn't have to be.
- 1:00:03I don't. Let's keep some things between
- 1:00:07me and you, You know what I mean?
- 1:00:08Yeah. We don't have to.
- 1:00:10Involve Pete down the street, I was going to say or.
- 1:00:13If you are going to involve me, give me the all the details.
- 1:00:16Yeah, be like, all right, girl, hold on.
- 1:00:17Let me catch you up real quick. This is where we're at.
- 1:00:19This. Is how we got here.
- 1:00:21OK, all right, I'm back. Like, yes, you got it.
- 1:00:25That's yeah, that's kind of how when people post like,
- 1:00:28mysterious stuff on Facebook. And I'm.
- 1:00:31Like tell me. The details?
- 1:00:34Oh no. What's?
- 1:00:34Going on well and then. Two, I'm guilty of keeping some
- 1:00:38people around just for the drama on Facebook.
- 1:00:41Yeah, it's like. Oh, I'm like, I don't want to.
- 1:00:42Delete you just yet or hide your hide your, you know, updates
- 1:00:46just yet. You're like, what tea?
- 1:00:48You got I'd like to get all. The scoop and then let's go.
- 1:00:52And then you got some people around that just make you feel
- 1:00:54better about yourself. I feel like a better parent
- 1:00:57seeing you and your activities. I love when I.
- 1:01:00Read something and just immediately go to the comments
- 1:01:03and I'm like, oh, 'cause you know.
- 1:01:05Somebody is going to say something and they're going to
- 1:01:08be like, what's going on? Oh man, there's some.
- 1:01:11Funny people out there. That don't give.
- 1:01:12Enough get enough credit. Yeah, I 100.
- 1:01:15Percent agree. So I'm going to say yes, I think
- 1:01:17we should tank it. I don't want to be an extra in
- 1:01:21your FaceTime call, your telephone call.
- 1:01:23I, I don't unless you're going to, unless I get to be an active
- 1:01:28participant. I don't want to be passive and
- 1:01:31just like along for the ride and I want.
- 1:01:33To say this applies to people watching videos as well, yeah,
- 1:01:36you know, some people put some. Ear pods in man.
- 1:01:39They they make cheap ones. I mean they make cheap ones.
- 1:01:42You don't have to get air pods like you can get a lot of times.
- 1:01:44You can get some free ones somewhere, right?
- 1:01:47So don't. I don't want to hear about your
- 1:01:49fishing experience, you know, although.
- 1:01:52That was a good looking largemouth bass.
- 1:01:54I'm proud of you for landing a non pounder.
- 1:01:56I don't know if that's big or not, although that was a.
- 1:01:58Big end. That was a big end.
- 1:02:00I don't give it to yourself. Even though you would spank that
- 1:02:02fish. I don't want to.
- 1:02:06I prefer tank it. So so so you're tanking.
- 1:02:10I'm tanking this week, I'm tanking.
- 1:02:11I don't want to be on. I don't want to be on your call
- 1:02:14so. Since you're tanking this week,
- 1:02:16I am going to spank. You're going to spank.
- 1:02:19I want to spank away. I mean, I'm going to tell you
- 1:02:23right now, what do you spank? It's kind of a part.
- 1:02:25Spank oh part oh all day long. I'd spank some cereal.
- 1:02:31I love cereal. Captain Crunch more so.
- 1:02:34I had it for dinner. More so than breakfast.
- 1:02:35I never had breakfast. Yeah, I was going to say I'm
- 1:02:37really bad about that, but a lot of times around 10/30, 11:00
- 1:02:41I'll be like, I'm going to get some cereal.
- 1:02:43Yeah, the other. Day we talked about like 9:00 PM
- 1:02:45snack when we're going for it. Yeah, cereal.
- 1:02:47Every time I love it. And it depends on the day.
- 1:02:49Sometimes I like want that Cinnamon Life cereal or Honey
- 1:02:51Nut Cheerios, and other days you don't.
- 1:02:55Have to be an adult at that point, at that time of the that
- 1:02:58time of the day, you can be a kid.
- 1:03:00That's what cousin. Cody, one time he was like, he
- 1:03:02was, he was texting me. He was like, man, I really want
- 1:03:05to have just like some fruity pebbles, a huge bowl for dinner.
- 1:03:08And I'm like, you're an adult. You can.
- 1:03:10And he went, Oh yeah, I love. Fruity Pebbles so much was my
- 1:03:13favorite cereal when I was a kid, along with Froot Loops,
- 1:03:16but. Fruity.
- 1:03:17Pebbles get soggy way too fast. You got to be like a speed
- 1:03:21eater. It does.
- 1:03:22You got to be like Nathan from the hot dog eating contest to
- 1:03:24get that down before it gets soggy.
- 1:03:27Yeah. And I like a lot of milk, but
- 1:03:29with those you can't put too much milk, too much milk.
- 1:03:31And I don't. I'm very, I'm very organized
- 1:03:35when it comes to this. I'm very.
- 1:03:37Organized. I have my bowl.
- 1:03:38Right. And like, I don't pour the milk
- 1:03:40like this all over the place in a swirl.
- 1:03:42You pour it in one spot so that only that one little spot of
- 1:03:45cereal gets soggy while the other lifts.
- 1:03:48So you get some ounce of. Milk in your cereal?
- 1:03:50How much are you? I mean I.
- 1:03:52Like quite a bit of milk. I want the.
- 1:03:54Cereal to come up out of the bowl and greet me.
- 1:03:56That's what I like. I want it to.
- 1:03:57I want it to float right up. So yeah, I'm putting.
- 1:04:02Like 1/2 a gallon of milk in each bowl grow to me.
- 1:04:05Baby, because I love. That's one of the other things I
- 1:04:07love to drink the milk when I'm done with the cereal because
- 1:04:10it's got such good flavor, especially if you have.
- 1:04:11Cocoa Puffs, and it's like Cocoa Puffs.
- 1:04:14Cinnamon toast crunch, peanut butter captain crunch.
- 1:04:18Fun fact, those are all good. I couldn't eat.
- 1:04:20Cocoa Puffs for a long time because I thought they look like
- 1:04:22rabbit turds. I had rabbits when I was a kid
- 1:04:26and when I saw them like poop for the first time, I'm going to
- 1:04:32tank. That that's what I'm thinking
- 1:04:33right there. I've got 2 tanks this week.
- 1:04:36Rabbit, turd, cereal. And you know what so much of
- 1:04:40your life experience revolves around Creek stuff and like farm
- 1:04:46stuff and wood woodland creatures and stuff like that.
- 1:04:51You'd be a very you'd. Be a very.
- 1:04:53Different adult now if you weren't raised in such a country
- 1:04:59Crock environment, you act. Like I grew up with Keebler
- 1:05:02elves in the Oaks Outback. No, I don't.
- 1:05:05Think no, but it's like they were.
- 1:05:08Bringing Lucky Charms to my door at 1:00.
- 1:05:10Point. If you told a story about how
- 1:05:12for the first seven years of your life you all had an
- 1:05:14outhouse, I would be like, that's on brand.
- 1:05:17It wouldn't surprise anybody. It wouldn't surprise.
- 1:05:19Anybody. I had an Uncle Phennis who lived
- 1:05:22way up Harts Creek, and he had an outhouse.
- 1:05:25He had an outhouse until the day he passed away, knowing good and
- 1:05:30well that he could afford plumbing, and he had an
- 1:05:33outhouse. Yeah, I draw the line.
- 1:05:34There, I enjoy plumbing. I don't, I don't want to use an
- 1:05:38outhouse anyway. How in the world did we get
- 1:05:40here? I was talking about because
- 1:05:41you're talking. About rabbit turds.
- 1:05:43Thank you, rabbit turd girl. You're welcome.
- 1:05:46Next. Time you have Cocoa Puffs.
- 1:05:48I don't eat. Cocoa Puffs anymore and I'm
- 1:05:50especially not going to eat them now that you said they were
- 1:05:52rabbit turds. That's what they look like
- 1:05:53they're. Obviously not, but it's what
- 1:05:55they look like. But anyway, so yeah, spank
- 1:05:57cereal all the way. Spank cereal for dinner.
- 1:06:00But one thing that y'all could do, Kellogg's, if you're
- 1:06:05listening, team up with Ziploc, please, and make this happen.
- 1:06:13Come on. Can I tell you a?
- 1:06:14Story I. Don't know the.
- 1:06:19The generic cereal off brand. It comes in a Ziploc bag.
- 1:06:25I know, but. That's off brand.
- 1:06:28She's like, I'm not. Eating fruity rings.
- 1:06:31I want my loops. That's not what.
- 1:06:34I signed up for. I'm not.
- 1:06:37Doing that Kellogg's post I don't want.
- 1:06:39Like nunny butt eerios I don't want you don't get a name.
- 1:06:45Anything anymore? Nunny butt eerios?
- 1:06:48OK, well, I don't even know what that is.
- 1:06:53That sounds terrible. I wouldn't want to eat that
- 1:06:55either. Whether it was in a Ziploc bag
- 1:06:57for freshness or not, I was. Trying to think what the generic
- 1:07:01of Honey Nut Cheerios would be, and that's the first thing that
- 1:07:04popped into my head. I'm sorry, sweet.
- 1:07:09Cashew circles. You could have gone with that.
- 1:07:11That would have better than Nutty butt Beerios or whatever
- 1:07:14you said it was. The hell.
- 1:07:16Yeah, you can name stuff from now on, so there's some.
- 1:07:19Spanking or tank action? Jenny's tanked the whole thing.
- 1:07:32Hands up if you love Appalachia. Nope.
- 1:07:39I don't know. I mean, I was waiting on Miley
- 1:07:43Cyrus, and then it's like all of a sudden you turn into
- 1:07:47Appalachia and I was like, huh, I don't know.
- 1:07:50I don't know how I feel about that.
- 1:07:51Yeah, I was going for the. Molly Bobs.
- 1:07:53I mean, that's. Cool, but then I wanted.
- 1:07:55To tie in Appalachia because we're going to do our
- 1:07:57Appalachian air freshener, yes, because we need a little little
- 1:08:02good news especially. After the Idaho Four thing,
- 1:08:07well, the good news this week, America has finally discovered
- 1:08:11what we've all been trying to tell them forever.
- 1:08:13The Mountain. Fresh Air, West Virginia.
- 1:08:15Is ridiculously beautiful. It is.
- 1:08:19Like it took us how long to get an actual National Park, but
- 1:08:22finally we. Do it took forever.
- 1:08:23New River Gorge National Park was recently recognized by
- 1:08:27Architectural Digest as one of America's most beautiful places.
- 1:08:31Oh, really? Yeah, Louisburg.
- 1:08:36We love Louisburg. It's been getting some national
- 1:08:38love, too, including recognition for being one of Appalachia's
- 1:08:42most charming small towns and having one of America's best
- 1:08:47small town food scenes. Dude, that's what I.
- 1:08:49Was about to say they were voted like America's coolest city and
- 1:08:53it is like we were just there last weekend for the literary
- 1:08:57festival which just like a little sneak peek into next
- 1:09:01week. I was thinking I bought this.
- 1:09:03I actually have it with me. The Big Book of West Virginia
- 1:09:06ghost stories. I thought we could dive into
- 1:09:10this next week. I think that would be.
- 1:09:11Fun. I think that would be fun.
- 1:09:12Spooky stories. Well, people aren't just talking
- 1:09:17about almost heaven, they're coming here as well.
- 1:09:19West Virginia welcomed more than 77 million visitors last year.
- 1:09:23Oh, creating a record 9.1 billion economic impact, man.
- 1:09:30I'm telling you, Fayetteville right there is New River Gorge.
- 1:09:34Like they have white water rafting, we have zip lining, so
- 1:09:38much hiking, delicious food. Like not to make this an ad for
- 1:09:44Fayetteville WV, but it is. You need to go there.
- 1:09:47So you got mountains. You got small towns, good food,
- 1:09:49people who are probably going to give you directions using a
- 1:09:52Dollar General and a hill that hasn't had a name in a long
- 1:09:55time. Right.
- 1:09:58But it's not just a catchy line. Turns out almost heaven is real,
- 1:10:04and it just takes the rest of the world a little longer to
- 1:10:07catch up. Yeah, I'm glad.
- 1:10:08That we had it to ourselves for so long.
- 1:10:10Now I guess we can share the love a little bit.
- 1:10:12I was going to say, there's nothing wrong.
- 1:10:13With Sharon Sharon's Karen, I was going to say Sharon.
- 1:10:16Is Karen. I'm mixing it up this week with
- 1:10:28our rapid fire spanking. Oh no.
- 1:10:30OK. You've got one sentence to
- 1:10:35either spank or tank or rebut I should say OK instead of just
- 1:10:41like tank it or spank either. Agree.
- 1:10:42Or don't agree with it or you. Can or you can rebut and say
- 1:10:45here's why. Oh, OK.
- 1:10:47OK, OK. Are you ready for number?
- 1:10:49One, yeah, it goes to real tank it or spank it if they're
- 1:10:55watching you shower. I think ghosts, I believe ghosts
- 1:11:02have some decency and they have a little bit of privacy.
- 1:11:04They're like, you know what? I'll haunt you in your living
- 1:11:06room. You think they're OK?
- 1:11:07But the bathroom? You're already haunting
- 1:11:08yourself. You get out of the.
- 1:11:14Shower and catch a side glimpse. Oh God.
- 1:11:17So they're just like, I'll leave that to you, buddy.
- 1:11:19I think that's happened. To everybody OK, is it rude to
- 1:11:22recline your seat on an airplane?
- 1:11:25You're getting ready to fly pretty soon going to be headed
- 1:11:28out to a What? He he OK?
- 1:11:30No. I think we all want to relax and
- 1:11:33recline a little bit, but don't go so far.
- 1:11:36You're in the other person's lap.
- 1:11:37Like I kind of look back, like, is there a tall person behind me
- 1:11:40whose knees are already up? I'd be conscious of what's
- 1:11:42around. Definitely spank.
- 1:11:43It we're not. We're not lowering that seat.
- 1:11:46All right? You discover your neighbor is a
- 1:11:48Bigfoot. Spank it or tank it.
- 1:11:51Are you telling? I'm so excited.
- 1:11:54Oh, no, no, girl, that's our secret.
- 1:11:56That's your you're. Not going to tell.
- 1:11:58Like if you're a. Bigfoot let me know the.
- 1:12:00World wants to know that. Like, I'm cool with it.
- 1:12:02I'll tell you, I'll come to work and be like guys and I promise
- 1:12:07you. I won't tell anybody, but like
- 1:12:10I'm. Not, you know, I'm.
- 1:12:11I won't put you up on my mantle or anything.
- 1:12:12I just want to be friends, OK? I just want to be buddies.
- 1:12:15All right? Finally.
- 1:12:15Would you rather have a rewind button or a mute button for real
- 1:12:20life? Spank it or tank it.
- 1:12:23Yeah, not for yourself. Oh, OK.
- 1:12:27I'd rather have rewind. You'd rather have a rewind so
- 1:12:30you could relive some stuff. Yeah, so you could relive.
- 1:12:32Some moments What if you? Have and this is a just, I'm
- 1:12:35going off off track here. If you had one of those buttons
- 1:12:41on you and somebody could come up and press it, which would you
- 1:12:45rather have on you? Would you rather have a rewind
- 1:12:47button or a mute button? Would I know?
- 1:12:50I was being rewinded, yeah. You know either way if you hit
- 1:12:53that damn button. One more time we're going to
- 1:12:55lose it. I'm tired of this grandpa.
- 1:13:01So mute. Button obviously, right?
- 1:13:03You go with the mute button. Yeah, I'd go with the mute.
- 1:13:05Button. But would you want?
- 1:13:06Would you want a? Mute button.
- 1:13:08Every time you and pH get into it he goes bumps you right on
- 1:13:14the forehead. I can still, I can still throw
- 1:13:17some punches, but all right, you don't want to talk, you want to
- 1:13:20fight. Let's go.
- 1:13:22It's time to. Throw hands.
- 1:13:27All right. I think that's I think that's
- 1:13:29enough. We'll we'll mute ourselves.
- 1:13:33Is that acceptable? Can you say that?
- 1:13:34Yeah, we're going to. We're going to mute ourselves
- 1:13:37and let Scott take over until next week.
- 1:13:39Where we here I can if you're on Oh, if you're on TikTok, I'll OK
- 1:13:44show this to you. The big book of West Virginia
- 1:13:45ghost stories. I'm excited and.
- 1:13:47You know, here's something. We actually talked.
- 1:13:50About this. So I'm from Logan originally.
- 1:13:52OK, we've got our own ghost story down there.
- 1:13:56Have you ever heard of Mamie Thurman?
- 1:13:58No. Save that for next week.
- 1:14:01Save it for next week. There you go.
- 1:14:02All right. Scott, take us to the house.
- 1:14:03I cannot seem