Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / The Quiet Grief of Outgrowing a College Roommate | Friendship Project
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that settles into a room when you realize you no longer fit in the same story. It doesn’t happen with a bang, or a fight, or even a clear goodbye—it happens in the slow, quiet drift of two people who used to share everything, and now share nothing at all. I was cleaning out my closet last week, digging for a sweater I haven’t worn in three years, when I found it. A polaroid photo, slightly curled at the edges, stuck to the inside of my mirror with a piece of blue painter’s tape. It’s me and Sarah, sitting on the floor of our first apartment together, legs crossed, eating cold pizza out of cardboard boxes. We are laughing so hard our eyes are squinted shut, hair messy, wearing oversized t-shirts that probably belong to each other. In that moment, we were inseparable. We were a single unit. Two halves of a whole. But here’s the thing about polaroids: they capture a moment, but they don’t capture the passage of time. And time, my friends, has a way of changing the chemistry between people without asking permission. I looked at that photo today, and instead of feeling warmth, I felt this sharp, hollow ache in my chest. It wasn’t sadness exactly. It was grief. But not the loud, wailing grief of losing someone to death. This was quieter. It was the grief of realizing that the person who knew your deepest secrets, who saw you cry over bad breakups and failed exams and cheap wine, is no longer the person you run to when life gets heavy. Let’s sit with that for a second. That ache. Because I think many of us have felt it, even if we haven’t named it. We tell ourselves we’re lucky to have grown up, to have evolved, to have moved on. And we are. But there is a mourning process attached to every version of ourselves we leave behind, and often, that means mourning the friend who was the witness to that old self. When friendships end due to betrayal or conflict, it’s easy to understand why they ended. There’s a villain, or a mistake, or a line that was crossed. You can point to the exact Tuesday afternoon when things went south. But outgrowing someone? That has no villain. That has no moment. It’s just… erosion. It’s like watching paint dry, except the paint is your shared history, and you’re standing there holding a brush, wondering when it started to change color. I remember the first time I noticed it with Sarah. We were supposed to meet for coffee after work. I had just gotten promoted—a huge deal for me, something I’d been working toward for years. I called her, buzzing with excitement, ready to hear her voice, ready for that shared joy. She answered, but her voice was distant, distracted. She was talking about her new boyfriend, or her dog, or something else entirely. When I tried to bring up my promotion, she gave a polite, perfunctory response. “That’s nice,” she said. Not “I’m so proud of you.” Not “Tell me more.” Just… polite distance. In that moment, I realized I was speaking a language she had stopped understanding. My joys didn’t resonate with her anymore because they weren’t part of her world. Her struggles didn’t interest me because I was too busy navigating my own new terrain. We hadn’t fought. We hadn’t drifted apart out of malice. We had simply outgrown the container that held us together. And that realization hit me harder than any argument ever could. So what do you do when you feel that gap opening up? Do you force it? Do you try to recreate the magic of the past by reaching out with old memes, referencing inside jokes that only make sense if you were both in the room in 2018? I’ve done that. God, I’ve done that. I’ll send a text saying, “Remember when we got lost in that subway station?” hoping it will spark that old connection, that quickening of the pulse that says we are still us. And sometimes, it works. Sometimes, the nostalgia bridges the gap, just for a little while. But mostly, it feels like performance. It feels like I’m trying to pull her back into a costume that no longer fits. And maybe she’s doing the same thing, trying to hold onto a version of me that doesn’t exist anymore. We become curators of our past selves, presenting highlight reels of friendship to avoid the awkwardness of the present reality. It’s exhausting, isn’t it? To constantly translate yourself for someone who used to speak your native tongue fluently. You start to wonder if you’re being selfish for wanting them to keep up, or if they’re being dismissive for letting go. But the truth is, neither of you is wrong. You’re just moving at different speeds, toward different horizons. And trying to walk together anymore feels less like companionship and more like a tug-of-war. One of the hardest parts of this grief is the internal narrative it triggers. You start to question your own worth. You think, If she doesn’t want to talk to me anymore, does that mean I’m boring? Does it mean I’m difficult? Does it mean I’m too much? We live in a culture that tells us friendship is a choice, but it also implicitly tells us that if you lose a friend, it must be because you failed. That if you’re not interesting enough, loyal enough, or available enough, people will leave. So when a college roommate pulls away, it’s easy to internalize it as a reflection of your flaws rather than a natural evolution of life stages. But let me tell you something important: their distance is not your deficiency. Their change in capacity is not a verdict on your value. People have limited emotional bandwidth. As we move through our twenties and thirties, we get jobs, partners, children, health crises, career pivots. Our bandwidth shrinks or shifts direction. It’s not personal. It’s logistical. It’s human. We are all just figuring it out as we go, carrying heavier loads, needing lighter connections sometimes. Or deeper ones, with fewer people. The structure of our lives changes, and so does the architecture of our friendships. So how do we navigate this? How do we honor the sacredness of what we had without clinging to it until it suffocates? I think it starts with allowing ourselves to grieve. Really grieve. Acknowledge that it hurts. Say out loud, “I miss who we were.” Admit that it’s sad. Don’t rush to fix it with positivity or distraction. Let the sadness sit there. It’s proof that the love was real. Then, we have to make a choice. Do we try to rebuild the bridge? Or do we build a new one, smaller, simpler, connecting only where we currently overlap? For me, with Sarah, it became the latter. We stopped trying to recreate the intensity of our college days. We stopped forcing the deep conversations that no longer felt natural. Instead, we started celebrating the small stuff. A funny meme. A quick check-in before a big event. A brief hug when we see each other. It’s less frequent, yes. But it’s honest. It’s grounded in who we are now, not who we were then. It’s okay to be happy for the person you used to be close to, even if you aren’t part of their daily life anymore. It’s okay to love them from a distance. It’s okay to say, “You were my person for a season, and that season was beautiful, and now I’m ready for the next one.” Outgrowing someone doesn’t mean they were a waste of time. It means they served their purpose. They witnessed your beginning. They helped you form the foundation of who you are. And now, that foundation is strong enough that you don’t need them to hold it up anymore. You’re building new walls, new windows, new doors. And you might find that you have room for new witnesses. People who are walking the path you’re on right now. People who understand your current struggles, your current joys, your current language. This isn’t a replacement. It’s an expansion. Your heart is not a pie with a fixed number of slices. It’s a garden. Some plants bloom and fade. Others take root and grow tall. And some, like the wildflowers of college, remain beautiful memories in the soil, nourishing the ground for whatever grows next. So if you’re holding onto a friendship that no longer fits, ask yourself: Am I holding on because I love who they are today, or because I’m afraid of who I was yesterday? Are you willing to let the past rest, so the present can breathe? Tell me more about why that matters to you. Because sometimes, the act of naming it is the first step toward releasing it. Thank you for sitting with me in this quiet space today. Be gentle with your heart. The changes you’re feeling are not losses; they are transitions. And you are allowed to mourn, to celebrate, and to let go, all at once. I’ll be here whenever you need to talk. Until then, take care of yourself, and take care of each other. Bye for now.