Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How the 10-Year Term Premium Is Quietly Boosting Debt Costs
Transcript
- Lucas: So we're finally at episode 150, and I wanted to dig into something that's been nagging at me for a while. You see these headlines about the 10-year Treasury yield sitting around 4.69 percent, and everyone focuses on the Fed's rate cuts or the jobs data. But there's this quieter force underneath that's been pushing long-term yields up over the past year, and it has a direct line to the national debt. Luna: You're talking about the term premium, right? That extra compensation investors demand for holding a longer-dated bond instead of rolling over short-term bills. Lucas: Exactly. And it's been creeping higher, even as the Fed has cut rates. The 10-year yield is 4.69, but if you strip out where markets expect short-term rates to go over the next decade, you get this residual piece — the term premium — and that's been climbing. Some estimates put it near zero or slightly positive, which is a big shift from the deeply negative territory we saw for years after the financial crisis. Luna: Why does that matter for the debt? I mean, the Fed controls short rates, but the Treasury has to borrow long term to fund the deficit. Lucas: Right. And the Treasury has been issuing a lot of long-dated debt — 20-year and 30-year bonds — to lock in low rates. But if the term premium is rising, the cost of that new issuance goes up. And with the debt at 39 trillion dollars, even a few basis points on the average maturity can add tens of billions to annual interest costs. The Congressional Budget Office actually projected that net interest costs will exceed a trillion dollars this fiscal year, and a rising term premium is part of that story. Luna: So it's not just the level of rates, but the premium on top of expected short rates. And that premium has been negative for a long time, so now it's normalizing. What's driving it back up? Lucas: A few things. First, the Fed's balance sheet runoff — it's shrinking its holdings of Treasuries, which means the private sector has to absorb more supply. That requires a higher premium. Second, the fiscal outlook itself. With deficits still around 1.8 trillion and debt to gdp at 122.6 percent, investors are demanding more compensation for the risk of holding long-dated paper. And third, there's just more uncertainty about inflation and the path of monetary policy. Luna: The July jobs report probably didn't help. We saw that unexpected loss of 23,000 jobs. That kind of data can make investors question the Fed's ability to manage a soft landing, which feeds into that uncertainty. Lucas: Absolutely. And the yield curve is telling a similar story. The 10-year minus 2-year spread has widened to about 46 basis points, up from 44 a day earlier. That's still positively sloped, but the fact that long yields are staying elevated even as short-term yields have fallen to 3.63 on the fed funds rate suggests the market is pricing in more term premium, not just expectations of future hikes. Luna: So if the Fed is cutting rates later this year, why aren't 10-year yields coming down more? It's because the term premium is offsetting the drop in expected short rates. Lucas: Precisely. And here's the thing — a rising term premium has a direct impact on the government's interest bill. When the Treasury refinances maturing debt, it has to pay that higher premium. And with the average maturity of the debt around six years, a 50-basis-point increase in the term premium translates into roughly 150 billion dollars in extra interest costs over the next decade. That's real money. Luna: And that's on top of the fact that we're already paying more interest on reserves. The Fed is paying 3.65 percent on reserves, which is another cost that flows back to the Treasury as remittances — but those remittances have basically dried up. Lucas: Right, the Fed's reverse repo and interest on reserves have become a significant part of the federal government's cash outflows. It's all interconnected. And as the term premium rises, it also affects corporate borrowing costs, mortgage rates, and so on. So it's not just a fiscal issue — it's a broader economic headwind. Luna: Before we keep going, I want to say — if this conversation about the economy is something you find useful, and if it's worth the price of a coffee to you, there's a link for that. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's the easiest way to support the show and keep it ad-free. Lucas: Yeah, we've been doing this for 150 episodes, and it's only possible because of listeners who chip in when they can. No pressure, but if it's helped you understand a slice of the economy, that's the link. Now back to the term premium. Lucas: So where does this leave us? The term premium is still below its historical average of about 1.5 percent, but it's moving in the right direction — or wrong direction, depending on your perspective. And the question is whether it's going to keep climbing. Luna: What would push it higher from here? Lucas: The biggest risk is supply. The Treasury is going to have to issue a lot more debt to fund the deficit, and if foreign buyers continue to step back — we saw in the last episode that foreign demand for Treasuries is cooling — then the domestic market has to absorb that. That requires a higher term premium. We also have the Fed's quantitative tightening continuing, though they might slow it down if the jobs market weakens further. But even if they pause, the term premium could stay elevated because of the sheer scale of issuance. Luna: And there's also the risk of a term premium shock — like a sudden repricing if investors lose faith in the fiscal trajectory. That's what some economists worry about. Lucas: Exactly. The term premium is the market's way of pricing that faith. It's been remarkably stable over the past few decades, but the fiscal situation is different now. debt to gdp is over 120 percent, and the deficit is running at about 6 percent of GDP. That's a level that historically has been associated with higher term premia. We just haven't tested it in the modern era with this much debt. Luna: So what should the Treasury do about it? Are there options to manage the term premium? Lucas: There's always the option of issuing more short-term debt, but that creates rollover risk — you're exposed to changes in short rates. The Treasury's been trying to extend duration to lock in low long-term yields, but that's exactly what's pushing up the term premium. It's a tradeoff. The other thing is that the Fed could help by committing to keep rates low for longer, but that's a monetary policy decision, not a fiscal one. Luna: And at the end of the day, the only real fix is to get the deficit under control. But that's politically hard. Lucas: Right, and that's the underlying tension. The term premium is a barometer for how the market views the long-term trajectory. If it keeps rising, it's a signal that investors are losing patience. And that has real consequences for the cost of government debt, and for the broader economy. Luna: So as we go into the fall, what should we be watching for? Lucas: Look at the Treasury's quarterly refunding announcement in early August — that's already out, but it set the pace for issuance. Beyond that, keep an eye on the 30-year yield. It's at 5.22 percent right now, which is close to a multi-year high. If that pushes higher, the term premium is definitely climbing. Also watch the 10-year break-even inflation rate, which tells you how much of the yield is inflation compensation. If that stays stable, then the rise in yields is mostly term premium. Luna: And that's a bad sign for the debt, because it's not going to come back down quickly. Lucas: No, it won't. Term premium tends to be sticky. Once investors get burned, they demand a permanent premium. That's why the 1970s and early 1980s had such high term premia — it took a decade of credibility to bring them down. We're not there yet, but the direction is concerning. Luna: So bottom line: the term premium is a quiet but powerful force that's making the national debt more expensive. And it's not something the Fed can easily fix. Lucas: Exactly. It's a market-driven cost, and the only real lever is fiscal policy. But that's a conversation for another episode. For now, we've covered a lot of ground — thanks for joining us on episode 150.