Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / Why Your Job Title Is a Trap
Transcript
- Lucas: If we've helped you think through a career move or decision, know that this show runs entirely on listener support, not ads. Luna: Yeah, it's wild how many people have become regulars here just by showing up consistently with real questions. Lucas: A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these. Luna: Exactly, so if you get value, consider joining them because it keeps the lights on without us having to sell out. Lucas: Let's talk about something that feels like a trap but isn't, unless you let it be: job title inflation. We are seeing a massive shift in how companies use titles as currency, often decoupling them from actual responsibility or pay grade. Luna: Right, and it's not just tech anymore; I'm seeing this in traditional sectors like manufacturing and healthcare too, where 'Director' means something totally different than it did five years ago. Lucas: The specific case I want to drill into is the rise of the 'Chief Of Staff' and 'Head Of' titles at junior levels. In September 2026, our data shows that nearly forty percent of new hires are entering with titles that sound executive but come with individual contributor responsibilities. Luna: That sounds dangerous for someone trying to build a resume because later on, they might struggle to prove they can actually manage people. Lucas: It is dangerous, but only if you don't understand the mechanics. Companies are doing this to attract talent without raising salary bands. If they hire a 'Senior Vice President' who reports to a manager, they save money on equity and base pay, but the employee gets a shiny card for their LinkedIn profile. Luna: So it's basically a marketing expense disguised as compensation, which works until that person tries to leverage the title for a higher-paying role elsewhere. Lucas: Exactly. And here is the concrete thing you need to know: hiring managers are getting better at filtering this out. When we look at hiring patterns across mid-sized firms, there is a distinct preference for 'substantive titles'—like Senior Engineer or Account Manager—over 'status titles' like Strategic Partner or Brand Evangelist. Luna: I remember reading a report last quarter where recruiters said they ignore any title that doesn't map directly to a standard industry framework. Lucas: That report was spot on. The key is understanding the difference between a title that signals authority and one that signals function. Authority titles imply budget control and headcount management. Function titles describe what you actually do day-to-day. Luna: So if someone comes in with a fancy title but no direct reports, how do they protect themselves during their next job search? Lucas: They have to reframe their resume around outcomes, not labels. Instead of leading with 'Vice President of Growth,' they should lead with 'Scaled user base by thirty percent using paid acquisition channels.' The title becomes secondary to the metric. Luna: That makes sense because metrics are universal, whereas a title like 'Growth Ninja' means nothing to a recruiter in a different industry. Lucas: Precisely. And this ties back to the broader market environment in September 2026. With interest rates stabilizing and capital becoming more efficient, companies are less willing to pay premium salaries for inflated titles. They want ROI, not prestige. Luna: It seems like the era of buying loyalty with titles is over, replaced by a more transactional approach to career advancement. Lucas: I would argue it was always transactional, but now the terms are clearer. You trade your output for cash and experience, not for a corner office nameplate. The smartest candidates are negotiating for clear scope and budget authority, even if the title stays modest. Luna: But how do you negotiate for scope when the company wants to keep things vague to maintain flexibility? Lucas: You push for a written charter. Not a contract, but a document that outlines your key performance indicators and decision-making boundaries. If they refuse to define what you own, you have to assume you will own everything and nothing at the same time. Luna: That is a great red flag indicator. If they won't put it in writing, it probably doesn't exist. Lucas: And it creates a nightmare for performance reviews later. Without defined scope, your success becomes subjective, which makes asking for a raise impossible because you can't point to objective achievements. Luna: So the real cost of a vague title isn't just confusion, it's lost income over time because you lack the evidence to justify an increase. Lucas: Yes. Let's look at a specific example. A software engineer accepts a role titled 'Technical Lead' but has no authority to hire or fire. Two years later, they try to move to a larger firm and are offered a lower salary than a peer who had a standard 'Senior Engineer' title but managed a small team. Luna: Because the second candidate can demonstrate leadership impact, which is usually worth more than technical expertise alone in today's market. Lucas: Correct. Leadership impact scales. Technical execution is linear. The market pays a premium for people who can multiply the output of others, regardless of whether their current title says 'Lead' or 'Manager'. Luna: This feels like a lesson for early-career professionals especially, who might be seduced by the first impressive sounding title they see. Lucas: Absolutely. My advice is to treat every job offer as a data point. Ask yourself: does this role give me assets I can take with me? Assets are skills, networks, and verifiable results. Liabilities are ego bruises and empty titles. Luna: I love that framing. Assets versus liabilities. It turns the emotional decision of accepting a title into a financial calculation. Lucas: It does. And finally, remember that you can always correct the record in your bio. If your title is weird, add a parenthetical clarification. But it is much easier to avoid the trap upfront than to clean it up later. Luna: Smart. So check the org chart, ask about reporting lines, and prioritize substance over style when evaluating offers. Lucas: Exactly. Because in the end, your reputation is built on what you deliver, not what you call yourself. Luna: Well said. I wonder how many people will realize this once the next wave of corporate restructuring hits. Lucas: Probably not enough, which is why we keep talking about it. Next time you see a title that sounds too good to be true, assume it is.