Latest / Newcomer Pod / Is the Tech IPO Window Open?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Eric Newcomer. And I am Madeline Rinbarger.
- 0:04And this is the newcomer podcast.
- 0:10Each week, Eric and I discuss the VC deals and the drama that
- 0:14went down. Let's do it.
- 0:16Here we go. Let's dive in.
- 0:19Welcome back to the Newcomer Podcast.
- 0:21It's our last show of the year, Eric.
- 0:23I mean, it's flown by. I know.
- 0:25Yeah, it's crazy. It's a very busy December for
- 0:29me. We've survived our events, but
- 0:32have a very ambitious plan for Newcomer next year.
- 0:35And I think as we're going to get to on this show, it seems
- 0:38like tech itself might be positioned for a better year
- 0:43next year than we expected. So we'll definitely be a busy
- 0:46year for us and big slate of stuff to talk about in this
- 0:50episode. So excited to get into it.
- 0:52Yes, let's jump in. I'd say bullish on 2025 if it's
- 0:55anything like this, the last couple of weeks of December that
- 0:57we've had. First.
- 0:59First up off, of course, is Servicetitan saw its stock price
- 1:03pop during its IPO this week. Huge.
- 1:07I feel like we are tech is desperate to make a mountain of
- 1:11out of a molehill out of this one.
- 1:12I mean, Servicetitan, good company, not like a
- 1:16transformational iconic company that everybody's heard of, but
- 1:19positive IPO. Uh, Servicetitan helped avoid
- 1:23some of a brutal ratchet, though.
- 1:25I think the late stage investors still got a little extra money,
- 1:29but they had a lot of pressure to go public, uh, thanks to
- 1:32their deals with late stage investors.
- 1:35And thank God they got that extra push because they had a
- 1:39successful IPO. We saw a pop.
- 1:42I don't know what. What's the mood?
- 1:44The mood seems really positive. I mean, the shares opened at
- 1:47101. They had continually raised the
- 1:50share price ahead of the IPO, which was, you know, priced at
- 1:5371, which was a big jump up from what we first thought it was
- 1:56going to be. And, you know, there's been some
- 1:58investors in the deal that it's just a really big win for them.
- 2:01I think a lot of people were really hoping for something like
- 2:04this at the end of the year as a positive signal.
- 2:06Part of what motivated Certos Titan to go public at the end of
- 2:09the year and not wait a year was, you know, this ratchet
- 2:11mechanism. What are your thoughts on this?
- 2:14Is this like a good bet going forward?
- 2:16Does this work well for companies or how do investors,
- 2:18you know, take it? I mean ratchets, you know, like
- 2:21a four letter word among VCs partially because early stage
- 2:25VCs are the ones getting diluted potentially by ratchets.
- 2:30I mean I I have two views. On the one hand, it's like
- 2:35ratchets are bad when founders use them to prop up a high
- 2:39valuation for vanity, right? And they would argue that it's,
- 2:45you know, employee recruiting or that they really believe in the
- 2:48valuation and they don't want to sacrifice it.
- 2:50But it's dangerous when a founder is delusional about what
- 2:54their company is worth. So they cut a deal that works
- 2:56out well in the upside but underestimates the risk and the
- 2:59downside. So Servicetitan getting out and
- 3:02doing OK, I guess they they correctly calculated.
- 3:06On the other hand, you know, I think it's easy to be like, oh,
- 3:11ratchets, you're just chasing a high valuation that's not
- 3:14defensible. On the other hand, you know,
- 3:16these founders certainly understand hopefully the terms.
- 3:21And, you know, often they're raising a ratchet when they
- 3:24can't get sort of equity at terms they prefer.
- 3:27And so, you know, these are sophisticated investors doing
- 3:32deals. So I don't have any real moral
- 3:33problem. The the big problem I have is
- 3:36just the valuation itself. You know, the world, founders,
- 3:40reporters, media, we all love valuations.
- 3:43And of course, the more complicated math and terms that
- 3:46go into evaluation, the more bullshitty they are.
- 3:50So often ratchets are just a reminder that we all place too
- 3:54much stock in private valuations, and they're flawed
- 3:58measures of how good a company is.
- 4:01And that's why ultimately we often want these companies to go
- 4:04public where there's an ongoing market for a company stock and
- 4:09their market cap is more more serious than the idea that you
- 4:13can get one person or a couple, a small number of firms to
- 4:17invest with complicated terms that inflate your valuation.
- 4:21I wanted to highlight my favorite tech meme account tweet
- 4:25on this whole thing. It's from Buku.
- 4:28Is it Buku Capital? It's one of my favorite accounts
- 4:31like. Buku Capital bloke or yeah yeah
- 4:33yeah yeah. Long time follower.
- 4:37He has a picture of Stringer Bell from The Wire and it says,
- 4:42I want you to put the word out there that we back up and he's
- 4:47quote, tweeting Bill Gurley, who's, uh, whining about IPOs,
- 4:51leave money on the table and everybody should do a direct
- 4:54listing, which is obviously, you know, Bill Gurley's, uh, hobby
- 4:59horse, you know, his obsession. And yeah, I do think there's a
- 5:03truth to it. It's like, man, we're really
- 5:05back to normal if Gurley's out there making the case for direct
- 5:08listings because you only, you know are will it you, you don't,
- 5:11you don't quibble about the small stuff if you're worried
- 5:14about big existential questions around whether tech companies
- 5:17can go public at all. You're only sort of making the
- 5:20case for direct listings. Once IPOs are so good that
- 5:24you're like, Oh well the balance is is money that you're giving
- 5:27to bankers to give away to their friends instead of making sure
- 5:30us VCs and founders get get as much money.
- 5:35Get a fair share. Shares, yeah.
- 5:37Right. It seems like it's very much,
- 5:39you know, just if we're, if we're in this debate like that's
- 5:43the bull signal, right? Good, good.
- 5:45Madeline, you you've been sort of eyeing the IPO market with
- 5:49Servicetitan doing well. What companies does that sort of
- 5:52give a potential nudge out the door that might have been
- 5:55considering it next year? So the big talk of the town is
- 5:58obviously data bricks. I've heard kind of mixed signals
- 6:00actually on that one. Some sources are saying that's a
- 6:02lock for 2025. Some are saying no, no, no, it's
- 6:052026 because they just had this really big capital raise.
- 6:08So that one I think will be soon.
- 6:10But they did acquire some capital pretty recently that
- 6:13could hold them off for a bit if they want to.
- 6:15So that may not be one. Obviously, people have their
- 6:18eyes on Stripe. I think some more interesting
- 6:20ones that I've been hearing about, you know, are Chime of
- 6:24Figma maybe again Chime I. Believe next year.
- 6:27Yeah, Chime, that seems likely. Some people told me canvas.
- 6:31So quite a quite a slate there. There's a lot of deca corns kind
- 6:35of waiting in the wings. So there's a lot to choose from,
- 6:37but. The problem with data bricks and
- 6:39Stripe is what you're touching on.
- 6:41Their ability to raise these insane private rounds just takes
- 6:45off so much pressure. I mean, Stripe is doing so well
- 6:48that they can, you know, you know, buy shares from their own
- 6:51employees. So it's sort of there is a
- 6:53continued sort of perpetual private company anyway.
- 6:56We can talk about the psychology of these big companies staying
- 7:00private all day. But I think the point here is
- 7:02clearly there's a lot of hope right now that a positive
- 7:05Servicetitan IPO will mean that everybody's a little more
- 7:10enthusiastic going into next year, which certainly the
- 7:13software world, you know, it's, it's been brutal.
- 7:16You know, it's been a good time for AI, but the classic sort of
- 7:20software company? Much harder.
- 7:22In private markets news, we had a massive capital raise this
- 7:26week with Crusoe, friend of the pod Chase Lochner, but.
- 7:33Chase, he's run staple at Cerebral Valley.
- 7:36Some of our dinners, the character, I think one time,
- 7:38yeah, we had somebody bail and we had like Chase, I just met
- 7:43Chase and put him on stage in Cerebral Valley.
- 7:45I mean, he's a great, very charismatic guy.
- 7:48Sort of fun story of like they, you know, they got into AI cloud
- 7:52compute business from working crypto and you know, they're all
- 7:56about using sort of captured energy.
- 7:59So both the creative business. Yeah, the most successful crypto
- 8:02to AI pivot of all time maybe. But yeah, they they're, they're
- 8:07doing quite well. They raised a 600 million series
- 8:11round led by Founders Fund, notably a fund who really likes
- 8:14to take a big chunk of the round, so they delivered on
- 8:17that. Fascinating founders fund bet
- 8:20you know, we've said it before, but you know a lot of their
- 8:24successful investments have been these growth stage deals.
- 8:27High conviction with with this one at a time when many people
- 8:31think if AI continues to accelerate we'll have sky high
- 8:35energy costs and really need to build up infrastructure.
- 8:37Yeah, absolutely. It seems like also, you know,
- 8:39Founders Fund has a pretty prominent position in open AI.
- 8:41So I feel like they're here with this high conviction bet where
- 8:44they're taking a big chunk of this.
- 8:46They're going all in on every part of the the stack needed to
- 8:50power the AI future. Moving on to our main story,
- 8:53Alphabet had a bunch of wins last week.
- 8:56I just am shocked. Insane.
- 8:58I mean quantum chips announcement was great, so
- 9:01they've made big progress there. They have the best public
- 9:04company offering in generative AI, which they just updated
- 9:09their models. And then a sort of unforced
- 9:12error from General Motors abandoning Cruise means that
- 9:17Waymo, which already, you know, is in the lead, is now sort of
- 9:21uncontested again, except Tesla, which of course, is, you know,
- 9:25an automaker building their own autonomous technology.
- 9:28So if you're an automaker without self driving
- 9:32capabilities, it seems like Waymo is your only potential
- 9:36partner. So yeah, what did I miss?
- 9:38Any Google wins or I mean the stock price is up too.
- 9:41Yeah, the price is surging. I mean, it's just been an all
- 9:44around great period for them in a time when I think a lot of
- 9:47people were really writing them off.
- 9:48They had, you know, a lot in the AI race specifically, and this
- 9:51Gemini News is just really promising for them too, I think.
- 9:55And I, you know, I thought you and Jonathan had the right take
- 9:58in the newsletter, which was this has been a company that
- 10:02people are like, oh, they're their lunches are too good, you
- 10:05know, they're too soft. And and certainly, you know,
- 10:07I've known Google people who didn't seem like they were in
- 10:09the office super long hours, but.
- 10:11I think about that part in Silicon Valley where they're
- 10:13unassigned, you know, at huli, right?
- 10:16Like that's the classic Google negative stereotype.
- 10:20But, you know, the counter to that is that sort of, you know,
- 10:23researchers require a little bit, you know, of Slack and time
- 10:27to think. And, you know, in some ways
- 10:30Google was setting itself up as a very researcher friendly
- 10:32company. Of course we knew that, you
- 10:34know, the Transformer paper came out of Google and all those
- 10:37people left. And so maybe it's like, OK,
- 10:39they're going to discovering things, but then everybody else
- 10:41is going to eat their lunch and execute.
- 10:44But now we're starting to see some signs that no, with this
- 10:48advanced technology, they're still very capable of producing
- 10:51results. And so that's made the market
- 10:54and I think Silicon Valley more bullish on Sundar, even as what
- 10:58the government's trying to break them up.
- 11:00So we'll see if you know Google as we know it, Alphabet as we
- 11:03know it. Still exists, right?
- 11:05Totally. I think, I think it's really a
- 11:08story of not counting them out at this point.
- 11:11They're bets that they've made that are these sort of wonky
- 11:14research bets that seemed like long time horizons since we've
- 11:17hit those time horizons that it seems like they're paying off
- 11:19and it seems like despite all of the criticism, they are turning
- 11:23them into products, which is pretty impressive.
- 11:24So obviously they have a lot of competition, but not really on
- 11:27self driving. So I mean.
- 11:29I mean, a super macro theme. You know, we talk a lot about
- 11:31venture, but the big public tech companies keep dominating, you
- 11:36know it. I mean, people counted out
- 11:38Facebook Meta for a while and that company was a great sort of
- 11:43public investment. People then counted out
- 11:45Alphabet. Now.
- 11:46It's been great public investment.
- 11:48Microsoft is obviously crushing it.
- 11:51So, man, the tech giants just continue to win.
- 11:55And, you know, if in a Trump world, it feels like, oh, they
- 11:58can do deals again, Yeah, I remain pretty bullish on those
- 12:03companies. And lots, lots of excitement
- 12:05that they can just gobble up the startup winners going forward.
- 12:09For sure, definitely. You mentioned that Alphabet's
- 12:12work on Quantum was getting the startup world excited.
- 12:15How much is the Quantum world delivering?
- 12:17You know, I wrote about Righetti many years ago.
- 12:20It seems like that's a now public company that has
- 12:23struggled. Or what's your sense of the
- 12:25startup world's answer to what Alphabet has produced here?
- 12:30Yeah, I think it's pretty early. From my understanding, startup
- 12:33funding to Quantum companies, it spiked this year to 1.7 billion.
- 12:38According to Pitchbook, there were across 73 deals.
- 12:41Last year there were 93 deals, but there weren't, they weren't
- 12:44as capital intensive. So the overall funding total was
- 12:46lower, but it's the highest total for funding in a year for
- 12:50quantum computing yet in the venture market.
- 12:52So obviously there's some excitement around that.
- 12:54I think people are exploring different ways we can develop
- 12:57compute as we get, you know, further into the future.
- 13:00That seems really promising. But the main thing I get from
- 13:03talking to quantum founders, even obviously who are very
- 13:05bullish on this technology is that it's early days.
- 13:09The use cases are still kind of far.
- 13:11So for these sort of moon shot bets, as exciting as Alphabet's
- 13:14breakthrough is with these chips, and it does have, you
- 13:16know, a lot of founders equally excited and jealous that this
- 13:20has happened. It's it's still we're still in
- 13:22early innings. It's not necessarily like we're
- 13:24going to see the killer quantum use case or product yet, but
- 13:28it's very promising right now. Very Silicon Valley, always
- 13:32early. We talk fantasize about the
- 13:35technology when it's in early innings.
- 13:36It'll take take a while, but. You got to have the video.
- 13:39AI Open AI was once sort of in this it's a research project
- 13:44period with some exciting ideas. And now you know, I'm talking to
- 13:48ChatGPT. I'm talking to ChatGPT more and
- 13:50more every day. What do you talk to ChatGPT
- 13:52about Eric? I mean, I do too, but yeah.
- 13:55I'm trying to use it as like my To Do List where it's sort of a
- 13:58dynamic To Do List where I updated on what I've done.
- 14:02And then it's like come back to me with what I need to do and
- 14:05like cross off things. It's, you know, if anything,
- 14:08it's smart formatting. But it's also nice in that
- 14:11ideally it keeps sort of a running track record of what I
- 14:16need to do. And, you know, in some ways I
- 14:19think what it delivers honestly, is it's like very affirming
- 14:22relative to, to to list. It's it's like, yeah, OK, you
- 14:26know, this is you've gotten a lot of stuff done today.
- 14:29You know, it's good job. It's good of being sort of a
- 14:30little supportive while keeping track of things, doing the
- 14:33formatting. So it brings a lot of little
- 14:35things that a traditional word processor doesn't on ChatGPT.
- 14:39I actually, like had a long conversation with ChatGPT about
- 14:43Google's Quantum announcement because they claimed that their
- 14:47discovery pointed to like multiple universes.
- 14:51And I, I found that somewhat hard to believe or like, at
- 14:55first I was enticed, but then I was like, really.
- 14:59And, and so it honest, honestly, it was a good way to sort of dig
- 15:02into quantum mechanics and the current research.
- 15:05And basically, you know, there are people real, you know,
- 15:09scientists who think that quantum is evidence that there
- 15:13are multiple universes and perhaps.
- 15:16Some people think it really does prove the multiverse theory,
- 15:18yeah. Right.
- 15:19That it's that the processing is actually happening in other
- 15:22universes. Where is there other people who
- 15:24think the the the waveforms sort of contain embedded information
- 15:30and just the ability to access basically their probability
- 15:34computing power is in our time just able to get a lot of
- 15:38information very efficiently. And, and so I came away from my
- 15:42discussion with chat GP not convinced that anything about
- 15:45Google's finding uniquely pushed us towards multiple universes
- 15:50versus just the wave functions having embedded information.
- 15:55But I'm I'm not the most knowledgeable about it.
- 15:58I was. Going to say beyond GPT, you did
- 16:00write about quantum back in the day a little bit So but yeah,
- 16:04your prospect is, you know, we're still early days.
- 16:06Where? Where do you land?
- 16:08On the actual business, putting aside the deep philosophical
- 16:11questions about the. Universe.
- 16:12Yes, exactly. Let's get to the facts.
- 16:15It takes too long. You know, a lot of things often,
- 16:20you know, even though Silicon Valley doesn't like to say it,
- 16:22you'd, you'd like to be like the second company, you know, once
- 16:26it's a sure thing and somebody's making some money on it.
- 16:29Can you fast copy a lot of these things?
- 16:31I mean, like we're, we've sort of referenced open AI did not
- 16:34come up with the transformer paper.
- 16:36They were in a good position to sort of seize on it.
- 16:39And so to some degree, you know, I, I think if I were building a
- 16:43quantum company, I might wait another five years and then copy
- 16:47all the good work that everybody's done.
- 16:48But, you know, so much of it is, do I have the right
- 16:52sophisticated team at the exact moment where the breakthroughs
- 16:57are finally becoming commercially, commercially
- 17:00viable? And yeah, I, I guess I don't
- 17:03think we're at that moment yet. So if I were starting the
- 17:06quantum computing startup, I'd wait a couple of years and then
- 17:09try again once we feel a little closer.
- 17:11But as I said on the last podcast, happy for people to
- 17:14burn money trying to build it because we want it.
- 17:18But yeah. You want your investments.
- 17:21Shares as an investment. Moving on.
- 17:23I did want to shout out a couple honorable mentions this week.
- 17:26They weren't our top stories. We love we.
- 17:28Love upstart venture capital firms, so we do not.
- 17:31Leave them off. The roster we have.
- 17:32To mention them two that really came out were Laud Ventures
- 17:36raised a debut $150 million fund to back precede and seed stage
- 17:41technical startups founded by Pete Sonsini, Andy Kowinski,
- 17:46who's the Co founder of Data Bricks, and Andrew Kriyakov.
- 17:49It's a great team. Again, an example of emerging
- 17:52managers work when you have like a powerhouse team behind you.
- 17:55So clearly this is one of those cases.
- 17:57But yeah, I'm bullish. I feel like one of, you know, a
- 18:01premise of newcomer has been data bricks is underrated and I,
- 18:04you know, early on did a bunch of scoops and their valuations
- 18:07and you know, Ollie Goatsy, the CEO has been prominent cerebral
- 18:12Valley Cincini, you know, did the data bricks investment for
- 18:16NEA and was a star over there and is now off with his own
- 18:19firm. So I guess if my data bricks
- 18:22bullishness holds, then I'm bullish on law adventures.
- 18:25So we'll be interesting to see what they do the other emerging.
- 18:28Fund this week that announced a dimension big fund.
- 18:31Dimension raised an upward oversubscribed fund to $500
- 18:36million to invest across the stages.
- 18:39So not just, you know, early stage or late stage, they'll do
- 18:41it all in tech, bio and AI. It's Zavin Dar, Adam Gilburn and
- 18:46Non Lee also came out of, you know, prominent firms were Eric,
- 18:52you know, you broke dimension one on your news on the
- 18:54newsletter back in the day and they're back at it again with
- 18:58even more capital. Love those.
- 18:59Guys, exciting firm don't claim to understand what every company
- 19:04they invest in does, but godspeed, you know interesting.
- 19:10You know, ZOV broke off of Lux, so did Adam.
- 19:14Adam. Was at Lux too.
- 19:15Oh yeah. Adam and Bilal just left.
- 19:18So I mean, we're in this moment where and I think we're
- 19:22agonizing about in our own sort of how we're writing about this
- 19:25stuff at once. It's like the big firms are
- 19:28getting more dominant and then interesting partners are, you
- 19:33know, shaking off. And obviously some of those
- 19:35interesting partners maybe don't have the performance, so they're
- 19:38not surviving the big funds. And then other ones are
- 19:40superstars and think, well, why are my bosses getting the
- 19:42management fees I should? And so as you know, observers,
- 19:47it can be hard sometimes to separate one from the other.
- 19:50But we're would love you feel glad to e-mail us and tell us
- 19:53who's who. But yeah, but clearly the
- 19:55dimension team has one over their LP's.
- 19:58I think Zav, you know, is in runway.
- 20:01I know he has another successful Lux investment under his there
- 20:05is in beta. Biosciences, yeah, on the
- 20:07biotech side as well. So they'll they'll cross that
- 20:10while there is this sort of flight to quality with the mega
- 20:13firms and LP capital. If you are a star player at one
- 20:16of those mega firms and you decide to break off the the
- 20:18tough market for emerging managers does not apply to you.
- 20:20If you're in that case, there are I'm going to call.
- 20:22Bullshit on your term flight to quality.
- 20:25I feel like we should start calling it like flight to
- 20:28consensus or flight to cab flight.
- 20:31To existing capital, yeah, quality.
- 20:33You know, it's like it's a flight to a safe bet that's not
- 20:37going to get you fired as an LP with you know, but but yeah, the
- 20:41mega funds, however they're doing a flight to.
- 20:45Consensus. That's a better term for it.
- 20:47Yeah. Flight to consensus.
- 20:48There, that's it. I take that one.
- 20:49That's good, really exciting for.
- 20:51Both of these teams and can't wait to see what they do in the
- 20:54new year. Wow covered a lot of.
- 20:55Ground we went from. I know some ChatGPT IPOs.
- 21:00Yeah so new finds. This was a lot happening.
- 21:03As reporters, you know, we cheer for news.
- 21:05And so it's a, it's a good sign that in December, I don't know,
- 21:09positive IPOs, Google doing well, Yeah, makes me a little
- 21:14more optimistic about next year than maybe I was a month ago.
- 21:18Oh, yeah. I put in AI.
- 21:19There's an annual discount to newcomer right now.
- 21:21It's 30% off. So maybe, you know, wait.
- 21:24Oh. My gosh, what a fantastic
- 21:26holiday gift. Wow, what a loyal employee.
- 21:29Yeah, better than what? Better than.
- 21:32Could you do then? Pay, make, you know, make our
- 21:37business possible, you know, but seriously, you know, we, we
- 21:40appreciate everyone who subscribes.
- 21:42It's a good moment to jump on board.
- 21:45And then also, I'd say, you know, you can always e-mail, uh,
- 21:48Madeline and I, you know, our first names at newcomer.co.
- 21:53Always open to topics and thoughts.
- 21:56Just reminder that we do our best when you all weigh in.
- 21:59And so I don't want this podcast to be 1 directional.
- 22:03And so feel free definitely. And I need to do a post, maybe
- 22:07the podcast. I can always preview the posts I
- 22:09should be writing like default off the record.
- 22:12Or it's like, I think people get worried that if they send us our
- 22:14thoughts, we're going to like trick them and put it on the
- 22:17record. Definitely not.
- 22:19You know, I when we're publishing people, they they
- 22:22know about it and we want information more than we want
- 22:25you to be nervous that we're going to trick you to put your
- 22:28emails to us on the record. So definitely reach out with the
- 22:31comfort that we won't spill the beans and on that.
- 22:35Note send us your scoops in the new year.
- 22:38Thanks so much. All right, Thank you.
- 22:40Have a happy holidays.