Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Always Says I Need More Time
Transcript
- Lucas: You assign something to an employee on a Tuesday. They say, 'Sure, I can get to that.' By Thursday you ask how it's going and they say, 'I need a little more time.' By the following Tuesday it's still not done. Sound familiar? Luna: Very. And it's not always about laziness. Sometimes it's about perfectionism, or they genuinely underestimate the work. Lucas: Right. That pattern — 'I need more time' — is one of the most common complaints I hear from first-time managers. So today we're going to dig into why it happens and what you can actually do about it. Luna: Let's start with a specific case. I was talking to a marketing manager at a mid-size agency. She had a senior designer who was excellent — creative, great eye — but every project came in late. And the designer's default line was always 'I just needed a little more time.' Lucas: That's a perfect example. So what did she do? Luna: She started by asking the designer to estimate how long each phase would take. Not just the final deadline. And she made it clear the estimate wasn't a trap — it was a planning tool. Lucas: That's smart. Because when you're vague about timing, the employee can always claim they needed more. But when they commit to a phase-by-phase estimate, they own each piece. And if they're consistently off, you have data to discuss. Luna: Exactly. And the data showed that the designer was spending too much time on early-stage polish — making mockups look presentation-ready before the client had even signed off on direction. Lucas: Which is a classic perfectionist trap. So the manager didn't just solve the 'more time' problem — she solved the root cause. But let's talk about three concrete strategies that work in general. Luna: Lay them out. Lucas: Strategy one: tighten the initial deadline. If you normally give someone a week, try four days. Make it clear that this is a pilot — you're testing whether a shorter cycle improves focus. And be explicit that if they need to reprioritize other work to meet it, they should come to you. Luna: I like that. It forces a conversation up front instead of an extension request later. Lucas: Right. Strategy two: structured check-ins. Not micromanaging, but a 10-minute mid-point check-in where they show you what they have so far. That way you can course-correct before they've spent three extra days on the wrong thing. Luna: And if they say they don't have anything to show yet? Lucas: That's a red flag. But honestly, if they genuinely have zero output at the halfway point, you have a bigger problem. Usually they have something — even if it's rough. The check-in gives you a chance to say, 'That's enough, move to the next step.' Luna: Strategy three? Lucas: Reframe the request for more time as a trade-off. When an employee says 'I need two more days,' you say, 'Okay, I can give you two more days. But then we have to push back the launch review. Are you comfortable with that?' That puts the cost of the delay on them. Luna: Yeah, that's powerful. A lot of employees don't realize that time is a zero-sum resource in a team. If your task slips, something else slips. Lucas: Exactly. And when they feel the weight of that trade-off, they often find a way to finish on time. There's actually research from the Journal of Applied Psychology that shows people are more accurate at estimating task duration when they are asked to consider the consequences of missing the deadline. Luna: Wait — so just asking 'what happens if you're late?' can improve their estimate? Lucas: That's what the study found. When people were prompted to think about downstream impacts, their estimates got 20 to 30 percent more accurate. The human brain naturally optimises for optimism unless you force it to consider the external costs. Luna: That's a really easy thing to start doing tomorrow. Just add one question to your next assignment. Lucas: Right. And if today was actually useful to you, the way these episodes stay ad-free is listener support. We keep this show independent so we can talk about specific cases without any sponsor influence. If you've gotten value from Manager Mondays, you can throw a few dollars into the tip jar at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple way to keep this going. And it genuinely makes a difference. So thank you to anyone who does. Lucas: Alright, back to the tactics. Let's talk about what to do when the 'more time' request keeps happening even after you've tried these strategies. Luna: I think at that point it becomes a performance issue, not a behavior issue. You need a firmer conversation. Lucas: Agreed. I'd frame it around consistency and trust. Say something like: 'Over the last three projects, you've requested extensions each time. I need to be able to rely on your deadlines. What needs to change so that I can count on your estimates?' Luna: That puts the ball in their court. And if they don't have a credible answer, you may need to document it and move toward a formal improvement plan. Lucas: But before you get there, try one more thing: offer to reduce scope. Sometimes the employee is saying 'more time' because they think you want the full deliverable — but you might be okay with a simpler version on time. Luna: That's a great point. I've seen managers who never clarify what 'done' looks like. So the employee adds bells and whistles that weren't asked for. Lucas: Yes. And then they need more time to polish those extras. So part of your job as a manager is to define the minimum viable output — what must be true for the task to be considered complete. If they finish early, they can always add more. But the deadline is for the minimum. Luna: Clear definition of done. That's a powerful tool. So to recap: tighten initial deadlines, use structured check-ins, reframe requests as trade-offs, and clarify the minimum viable output. Lucas: And don't forget to ask the question about downstream consequences. That one question can shift the whole conversation from 'I need more time' to 'How can I make this work with the time I have.' Luna: Alright, I think we've given managers a solid playbook. Next time someone says 'I need more time,' you'll have something to say. Lucas: That's the goal. Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll see you next Monday.