Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #2 - Election Timing and Why it Matters When We Hold Elections
Transcript
- 0:00Oops.
- 0:01Welcome back to the show.
- 0:03It's episode 2 of the pian6 with Paul podcast with your host.
- 0:06That's me, Paul Raider,
- 0:08non partisan political analyst, and thank you so much for listening and or watching.
- 0:13So is that time of the year?
- 0:17Election.
- 0:17Another election is just around the corner.
- 0:20In a few months, as of this recording, we will be voting for the next president of the United
- 0:25States and lots of other elections going on at the federal, state, and local levels.
- 0:30But have you ever wondered why it's in November or why the timing of elections matters at all.
- 0:39I mean, who cares, really?
- 0:41Oh, are a due in luck because that's what we're gonna talk about today, and it matters a great
- 0:47deal when we have these elections.
- 0:49And so gonna get into that today.
- 0:51We're talking about the timing of elections and its effect on turnout and how election timing
- 0:57and term lengths have changed over time.
- 1:00And I wanna open that up with, chatting out this book right here.
- 1:05It's called see.
- 1:06Can you hit it right there?
- 1:08Timing and turn out how off cycle elections favor organized groups by Sarah Anzia.
- 1:13She's a professor at the University of California, Berkeley.
- 1:17I highlight this book because when I was at ballopedia, one of the, later things I did
- 1:23before I left was I led a book club that was open to the public about this very book.
- 1:30And, actually, the, I believe, is the 2nd to last week.
- 1:34Got to actually interview, Professor Anzia.
- 1:38And very nice lady, very, obviously, very well versed and well read, very smart lady, and also
- 1:48just very interesting and general to talk to.
- 1:51So I don't wanna obviously give away the whole book, to to great read.
- 1:55It's a little bit more, We're not a little bit more.
- 1:59It's much more of an academic tone.
- 2:01So I don't know if that's your cup of
- 2:03tea, but it's a great book.
- 2:05But the basic idea behind the book was talked about why timing of elections is so so
- 2:10important.
- 2:11Now it got to be where it is, what kind of groups care about whether the election is held
- 2:18at a certain time versus another time and why some groups want off cycle elections.
- 2:25And I will explain a little bit, about more about that in a minute, but also what kind of
- 2:30influence those groups have and case studies about how much changing of election timing has
- 2:36impacted voter turnout across different kinds of offices.
- 2:39And What kinds of office holders have a vested interest in having elections be at the normal
- 2:46time of November, love an even numbered year versus even another month or an odd
- 2:52numbered year.
- 2:55So before we go into, anything else we have to talk about?
- 2:59How exactly we classify election timing?
- 3:02Now you've heard me say this term several times already.
- 3:05What is off cycle elections?
- 3:07Well, there's not an agreed upon definition.
- 3:11But the cycle typically refers to we're talking about presidential and midterm elections, so
- 3:17even numbered years.
- 3:18Although I have heard people even refer to midterm elections as off cycle, which to me is
- 3:25kinda weird, but do we consider I'll cycle elections as elections that are outside of even
- 3:32numbered years, or is it if it's just outside of November?
- 3:36Is there another way we do it?
- 3:38Personally for me and for this video, we're going to consider it as it has to fit these 2
- 3:44criteria, both of them.
- 3:47One, it has to be an odd numbered year, so not even number, not so something like 2023, 2021,
- 3:542025, and also not the 1st Tuesday after the 1st Monday of November, which is when elections
- 4:03are typically held.
- 4:04And I'm also talking specifically about general elections.
- 4:07Primary elections are a whole other can of worms who would go into them just a little bit,
- 4:11but unless otherwise specified, I am talking about
- 4:17general elections and their timing.
- 4:20So oh, and also another term you also hear is off year
- 4:25and off date off year meeting might just be on numbered years or it might be midterms.
- 4:32And off date just means it's not at particular day in November.
- 4:36Again, we're just gonna consider for, I've I've made, a somewhat arbitrary decision, although
- 4:44one, I think, makes sense.
- 4:46Is when I say off cycle, I'm talking about odd numbered years and not 1st Tuesday after the
- 4:521st Monday of November.
- 4:55So Where do we usually find these off cycle elections?
- 4:59Again, just general elections.
- 5:02And
- 5:02we bend that partly depend on your finish it.
- 5:06But, in the case of, well,
- 5:10actually, it does not entirely fit my criteria because While it's in an odd numbered year,
- 5:16it's act it's that same date in November, like Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, New Jersey
- 5:22and Virginia all have their governor's elections and a lot of other state executive
- 5:27elections like attorney general an odd numbered years, but it's in November.
- 5:32So, again, is that off cycle?
- 5:34I'm not considering it off cycle, but you can, obviously, if you so choose.
- 5:40And then all of those except Kentucky have, their state legislative elections in
- 5:46outnumbered years as well.
- 5:48So 2021, 2023, 2025, 2027, etcetera, etcetera.
- 5:53But the vast majority of elections at the state level and then all the ones at the federal
- 6:00level are going to be an even numbered years.
- 6:05But the ones that are held or
- 6:08the vast majority of those that are held in odd numbered years and or months other than
- 6:13November, those are almost all for local level offices.
- 6:18There is one state executive, believe it's Wisconsin's superintendent of education, If I
- 6:28remember correctly, that's in April of odd numbered years every 4 years.
- 6:32And I think they just had that in 2021.
- 6:36I had to go back and read it to him.
- 6:37So don't quote me on that entirely, but I believe it's it's that specific state
- 6:42executive, but That's otherwise, that's that's the odd one out.
- 6:45But that's majority of odd numbered elections that are also when months like April or May or
- 6:53March or June, those are you're gonna find those at the local level.
- 6:58So things like sportal boards and city councils, maybe even county commissioners.
- 7:05But there is somewhat of a trend of moving toward even numbered years in those elections.
- 7:11Like, for example, Los Angeles just back in I wanna say it's 2018.
- 7:16Their their voters decided to move elections to odd numbered years.
- 7:21And so or excuse me, moving on to even numbered years.
- 7:25So now Los Angeles says mayor gets elected in even numbered years.
- 7:29Leave, yeah, 4 year terms.
- 7:32And you see that in some other, places too.
- 7:35There are some some towns though that do actually move him to odd numbered years, and
- 7:40we'll go into the debate over that, later on in this video.
- 7:46And also, we gotta keep in mind when we're talking about timing of elections.
- 7:51Special elections are a completely different topic because special elections are inherently
- 7:57regular.
- 7:57They happen at rather in opportune times because somebody either resigns or they pass or
- 8:07they're otherwise incompass incapacitated and can't perform their duties or they're just
- 8:13removed from office.
- 8:15So we're we're not talking about special elections and Each office has their ends within
- 8:22each state.
- 8:23They all have their own criteria of when those special elections are supposed to happen.
- 8:31So we're not gonna worry about those because that's just too much to cover.
- 8:37But a little bit about the brief history of the changing of election time.
- 8:40And again, we don't wanna go too much into it because, well, a, we only have so much time in
- 8:45this episode.
- 8:46And, b, I don't wanna steal Mister Anzia's thunder.
- 8:50That's great book.
- 8:51Very informative.
- 8:52Talks a lot about that.
- 8:54But some of the small or the the overarching overview of hiring.
- 9:01And back in the early days of the US, we really didn't actually have a thorough lot of
- 9:06uniformity as to when, federal elections were held in the earliest days of when we became an
- 9:15independent country from those solid red coats, and actually, we're spread out much more and
- 9:21fleets holding them tended to have them within a a certain 4 day window before the 1st
- 9:27Wednesday of December.
- 9:30Yeah.
- 9:30December.
- 9:32But in 1845, Congress passed a law that set the 1st Tuesday after the 1st Monday in November as
- 9:38election day.
- 9:39It was the most convenient day of the week and time of year for farmers.
- 9:44They could take the time to travel to a polling place and was during harvest season instead of
- 9:49when they had to plant their crops.
- 9:52But there is still a lot of, the states still retain a lot of authority over when they can
- 9:59set their elections for state and local level offices.
- 10:03And there's still some, There's some leeway they have with, elections for, like, US House
- 10:10and US Senate when it comes to special elections.
- 10:12But, again, don't wanna go too much into that.
- 10:16There was, for a while, a few states had congressional elections and odd numbered years
- 10:21even after that 18 45 date.
- 10:24I was doing some research, for a ultimately, I wanna do a a book on the political history of
- 10:31the United States or of each state.
- 10:34And I found that there were a few states like New Hampshire that in the 1850s and 18 sixties,
- 10:43had There are congressional elections even in including it out a number of years.
- 10:48I'm not entirely sure why that's the case.
- 10:50I have to do some more digging into it.
- 10:51We're only speaking.
- 10:531845 is when they set that date as 1st Tuesday after 1st Monday of November of even numbered
- 11:01years.
- 11:03So now we talked a little bit about how we got to off or to elect the timing of elections that
- 11:11we have car.
- 11:13Excuse me.
- 11:13The way that we have election timing set up now, and how or where exactly you find some of
- 11:21these off cycle elections, what off cycle elections are.
- 11:25But now Why does this matter so much?
- 11:29Why not just who cares what time that these are held?
- 11:34I'm glad you asked.
- 11:35Well, I guess I understand.
- 11:37But the elect when the election is held greatly influences when voter turnout rates or, excuse
- 11:43me, They greatly influence what turnout rates, how high and how low the turnout rates are
- 11:53simply by having it at a normal or unusable time.
- 11:59And also affects which voters show up just because a lot of people, for 1, are often
- 12:06unaware that elections can happen at times other than November, or they just don't dare
- 12:12enough to show up at times.
- 12:14Other than November of even numbered years.
- 12:18And which voters show up to vote are
- 12:21often different
- 12:24than what they would be for if
- 12:26they weren't on cycle elections.
- 12:29They are often older, more affluent, wider.
- 12:34And, obviously, that's not that's not always the case, but generally speaking, that that's
- 12:37the hides of voters that show up for the off cycle elections.
- 12:41And there also tend to be very more, In tune, I guess, with, for lack of a better term, a lot
- 12:51more ingrained, I should say, with call it and a lot of times they are very strongly
- 12:56Republican or Democrat.
- 12:59Again, not always the case, but also the concurrence with other elections especially
- 13:04bigger name ones like if there's a mayoral election or if there's a presidential election,
- 13:10they reciprocally They have a reciprocal effect on each other's turnout rates.
- 13:17And when you have a a longer ballot, you tend to see what's called ballot drop off, meaning
- 13:22the elections that are lower on a ballot tend to have, lower turnout rates.
- 13:30So president and governor and, other big name elections Those would tend to have the highest,
- 13:38levels of turnout when you start getting to things like county commission and city council.
- 13:45Those tend to have a lot less choices made by voters.
- 13:49Some people just fill out president or just fill out governor.
- 13:53And they sent the ballot in to be counted, but they don't actually fill out the whole thing
- 13:59necessarily.
- 14:01Now I will go into primary election timing just a little bit just just for the, sake of At
- 14:11least having a little bit more well rounded.
- 14:12So in this particular case,
- 14:14I am talking about primary Alexis now.
- 14:16Those are all over the place.
- 14:17They're often around over 9 months out from a general election depending on what the office
- 14:23is and what the state is.
- 14:25I can tell you, for example, Florida.
- 14:27The presidential preference primary is in March, the year of a presidential election.
- 14:35But you go to some states and and it's a lot sooner than that.
- 14:40I wanna say it's Rhode Island, I think, has one of the latest ones that's in September.
- 14:46Off the top of my head, I'm not entirely sure about that, but I believe it's Rhode Island has
- 14:50one of the latest ones.
- 14:52And even even with that, there could be
- 14:56other offices you see like governor and and or even local level offices like mayor, those can
- 15:03be at even another time.
- 15:05So March is typically presidential preference primary in Florida, but August is when you see
- 15:12the, primaries for other offices.
- 15:18So now we'll move away from that.
- 15:21Now let's talk about the arguments for and against having off year elections now when I'm,
- 15:30again, talking purely about general, elections here.
- 15:37So there are several major
- 15:41arguments you'll hear from people who support having more off cycle elections versus people
- 15:48who don't support having more off cycle elections.
- 15:51So, again, obviously, this is not I'm not go arguing one way or
- 15:55the other.
- 15:55I'm just telling you what people say about it.
- 15:59So we'll start with the support for off cycle elections.
- 16:04So One of the arguments you often hear is that it decreases and that you usually since you see
- 16:12it usually with local level elections, it decreases the nationalization of local politics
- 16:17and state state politics too.
- 16:19Like, how we talked about, like, Kentucky, for example, has governor elections in odd numbered
- 16:25years and Mississippi, Louisiana, New Jersey, and Virginia, have state legislative elections
- 16:33in odd numbered gears.
- 16:34The argument is that it decreases nationalization of local politics because it
- 16:39keeps the focus on local issues.
- 16:41You don't have them running at the same time as, presidential election or and, congressional
- 16:48elections, US Senate, US House.
- 16:53Because we've seen a lot of a there's been trend of increasing national nationalization of
- 16:59local politics.
- 17:00More and more people care about Do these county commissioner support Donald Trump, or do they
- 17:05support well, now Pamela Harris, but when Joe Biden was in the race, did they support her or
- 17:11or him or act when it was Donald Trump versus Hillary Clinton, did they support Hillary
- 17:15Clinton?
- 17:17That's become more and more.
- 17:19That's been that's become more important to to many voters.
- 17:23And more recent, years.
- 17:26So the argument is that there's a lot less of that being or there's a lot less of that
- 17:33happening if we have these elections on an off cycle format as opposed to on cycle because
- 17:39they're not happening at the same time.
- 17:41As these on cycle elections.
- 17:44Also, they people who support off cycle elections argued that people are more invested
- 17:50and more knowledgeable voters than the ones who typically show up to the on cycle elections, on
- 17:56cycle elections, especially presidential elections see the highest rates of turnout.
- 18:01You see them about, you know, depending on how exactly you're calculating them, around, like,
- 18:0560 to 70% give or take and, obviously, varies by state.
- 18:11Whereas in off cycle elections, you might see them at if you're using my definition, you
- 18:18might see them at, like, 35, 30, 20, It can get as low as, like, 10 to 15% depending on what
- 18:26office is being talked about.
- 18:30So the idea is that there's more invested and more knowledgeable voters because they care
- 18:35enough to come out for those elections, I'm actually researched those, candidates that are
- 18:42running in those elections.
- 18:44Again, I'm not saying that I agree or disagree.
- 18:47That's just what a lot of people argue.
- 18:51Another argument we'll go with 4 for for both supporting off cycle elections and closing off
- 18:58cycle elections, but One of the the 3rd big argument you often hear is that, voting
- 19:04officials stay up to date on election protocols because There these elections are happening
- 19:10more often.
- 19:11There's a lot of behind the scenes stuff that voters just
- 19:14aren't privy to.
- 19:15And especially because even though states have a lot of,
- 19:24power and and say in when how these elections are set up and when to have them and all that.
- 19:30Local elections are the ones that bear the brunt of the administration costs.
- 19:34It's more local officials that are having to actually administer these elections and finance
- 19:42them.
- 19:43So the idea is that these local voting officials stay up to date on these election
- 19:48protocols because they're having to set them up more often, keeping up to date more often with
- 19:53what's going on instead of having to come out every 2 years or 4 years.
- 19:59And then A 4th major argument you hear is that it's less overwhelming because there are fewer
- 20:06elections, depending on a time.
- 20:07So instead of having a giant ballot of, like, I don't know, 2025 races.
- 20:16Again, depends on on where you are and the and the year because you might have more things to
- 20:22vote on in 1 year versus another.
- 20:25The idea is that you have to research maybe 15 elections as opposed to 20 to 25.
- 20:35Partly because you see that drop off of a lot of people don't even,
- 20:40participate in those lower elections that are much more local, much more obscure, and they
- 20:50don't They're they're they don't really wanna put, make
- 20:53a choice in there because they haven't had the time of research or they just don't know or
- 20:57they just don't care about that election.
- 20:59So the idea is that there'll be fewer elections happening
- 21:03at the same time, and you won't have that ballot drop off.
- 21:07So those are 4 of
- 21:08the big arguments that are sub planning off cycle elections.
- 21:11Now let's move over to the opposition to off cycle elections.
- 21:17So number 1 is that voters have to go to the polls more often meaning more time spent having
- 21:26to travel to the polls.
- 21:27You might have to wait in line.
- 21:30You have to do more research.
- 21:33I'll get actually, I'll get to that point, in a little bit, but you have to spend more time
- 21:37going out to those polls.
- 21:40And for some people, that's a lot easier to do than others.
- 21:43Some people have a lot less access to these polls.
- 21:48I remember back in I wanna say it was 2020.
- 21:52There was a Georgia precinct that or maybe it was the county, set a, polling place or 2 out
- 22:03and a significant number of voters were impacted, and they didn't really have a means
- 22:09of transportation to get to a further a a polling place that was much further away from
- 22:15where they live.
- 22:16So there's a a lot of those little things you also have to consider too.
- 22:21And which leads into point 2.
- 22:24A lot of people that propose off cycle election argue that they are West representative because
- 22:29fewer people are participating in them.
- 22:33And they will argue that the idea of it being more knowledgeable and invested voters is not
- 22:41necessarily the case.
- 22:43Again, that's up to you to decide But, the idea is because you're having even less people like
- 22:49you're dropping from maybe 65% of voters turning out to 30%, for example.
- 22:56And then whatever the numbers are, it's you're going to have a drop off for off cycle
- 23:02elections.
- 23:03Compared to if they were on cycle, elections.
- 23:07And then point 3, they argue they argue how it's more costly to hold more elections.
- 23:12Like I said earlier, local elect or local government officials are the ones that bear the
- 23:19brunt of the cost and administration of these elections.
- 23:22Not that the state governments don't have a little bit of say, but local governments handle
- 23:27the vast majority of the actual administration of these elections.
- 23:32And because you're having more of them, you're having to spend more money getting everything
- 23:36set up so that these other elections can be held at more unusual times of the year.
- 23:45And then 4th, I just, touched on it
- 23:49a little bit earlier, but there is more they must spread out the time for research instead
- 23:54of researching everything at the same time.
- 23:57And now you have to spread it out and you have to take that extra time to, at another point in
- 24:02the year, research these offices and candidates.
- 24:08So you see how a lot of these arguments see see things one way.
- 24:14Others see it another way is it's one on the support side.
- 24:18They, for example, they say that more invested, more knowledgeable voters.
- 24:23Up opposition to off cycle elections, they say it's less representative So, which one of those
- 24:29matters more to you.
- 24:31Again, that's for you to decide.
- 24:33So it's not a very It's, again, like many policy debates in politics, and it's not cut
- 24:44and dry, but When there has been, one one of the points that Professor Anzia touched on is
- 24:52that There's a lot of support when people are asked about it and when they're made aware of
- 25:00the existence of off cycle elections a lot of them say, well, I'd rather have it on cycle.
- 25:07I think there was about 70% of people that responded when they were made aware of the
- 25:13existence of off cycle elections, they wanted them to be on cycle instead.
- 25:17Let's when she followed up on that about, basically, how much did they care about it?
- 25:24Didn't really matter all that much to them.
- 25:28Whether candidates wanted more on cycle elections or, yeah, or more off cycle
- 25:34elections, It's it's one thing to want something to change or want something to
- 25:40happen, but whether you're actually gonna take the steps to try to change it, people didn't
- 25:45necessarily care all that much about there being off cycle election sayers.
- 25:49It was just like, well, I'd rather not have those but
- 25:53it didn't really impact how they voted or who they voted for.
- 25:59Though.
- 26:00It's one
- 26:01of those things where you gotta keep in mind what people want and how much they want those
- 26:07things
- 26:08are 2 very different things.
- 26:11So just to keep that in mind,
- 26:12but that does that for or that does it for this episode, like like always, though, I want to
- 26:19end on, a random question of the day.
- 26:24So last week, I asked about what Olympic sport you would wanna be good at that you don't
- 26:29already play.
- 26:30So random question.
- 26:31We're gonna put the sports topic, but move on to football because NFL season is right around
- 26:39the corner.
- 26:39And, boy, am I excited NFL and college football, USF, University, South Florida,
- 26:45Durham Bulls, looking forward to big things from them.
- 26:49But stick to the NFL for that question.
- 26:52So with NFL season around the corner, team has
- 26:55your favorite uniforms.
- 26:58Now do
- 26:58a little bit of a homer, but I'm a big buccaneers.
- 27:01I have the best uniforms in the NFL, perfect shade of red.
- 27:05Red's my favorite color.
- 27:07Has nothing to do with projects.
- 27:09I just like red, and just a unique color combination of red and pewter and and and all
- 27:16that It's just shifts kiss.
- 27:19My other, silver team, New York Giants, honestly, kind of land.
- 27:25And then there's that 100th end of, season, special uniforms they've got that Boy, I don't
- 27:34I don't know who whose bright idea it was to design those, but those don't look good.
- 27:40Also shout out to the Cincinnati Bengals who I have a little bit of a soft spot for.
- 27:43They've got great uniforms too with those Bengals stripes, on their uniforms.
- 27:48And it's a really good combination of of, orange and black.
- 27:53So but, anyways, that will actually do it for this episode now.
- 27:58As always, Thank you so much for listening and or viewing.
- 28:01And, please like, comment, subscribe, share, this podcast and help it help it grill.
- 28:09And until next time
- 28:12take care.