Latest / Politics with Paul / Does the Supreme Court Need to Rein in Presidential Power? w/ Peter Cohen | Politics with Paul #68
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08Another guest episode is on the way today, as you can see.
- 0:12For anyone who is new to the show, I always start off with a disclaimer that I do not take
- 0:16a stance for or against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:22But regardless of your political persuasion, the power of the presidency has has undoubtedly
- 0:29expanded over the course of US history, both with Democrats and Republicans, and even with
- 0:34the now defunct Federalists and Whigs.
- 0:37But has it gone too far, especially in recent decades?
- 0:40Does it break the separation of powers doctrine that is intrinsic to The US constitution and
- 0:46the system of checks and balances that goes with it?
- 0:49And if it has gone too far, how do we rein in the presidency and the overall executive
- 0:55branch?
- 0:56Well, that's what my guest, Peter Cohen, is here to talk about today.
- 0:59Peter just retired from active legal practice this year, but he has over forty years of legal
- 1:04experience, including civil litigation, legal writing, editing, and appellate advocacy.
- 1:10He also used to be an adjunct professor of law teaching landmark US Supreme Court decisions,
- 1:16constitutional foundations, due process, judicial review, and especially relevant for
- 1:21today, cases addressing presidential authority.
- 1:25Now Peter brings that experience to his book he just released this year titled, In the Supreme
- 1:30Court's Own Words, First Principles for Checking Presidential Power and Preserving the
- 1:35Republic.
- 1:36So let's talk about his book and its insights into presidential power and whether that power
- 1:41is going too far.
- 1:43Please welcome Peter Cohen to the show.
- 1:45Peter, thanks for coming on.
- 1:46How are you?
- 1:47Very well, and thanks so much for having me.
- 1:49Yeah.
- 1:50Absolutely.
- 1:50A couple of previous episodes I had done had been sort of along this path of the expansion
- 1:58of the presidency over time, but it's nice to get somebody who's much more ingrained in that
- 2:03field that has a lot more insights to provide to sort of build on that conversation.
- 2:09So let's go sort of back to the beginning with you.
- 2:13I like to do that for the first question.
- 2:15So before even writing this book, of course, we'll get to that shortly, but I mentioned you
- 2:19just retired from being an attorney, so can you give us some more details on your experience
- 2:24with legal cases concerning presidential power, whether it's trying a case, writing opinions
- 2:29and commentary, or teaching cases as a professor?
- 2:32Sure.
- 2:33So, my focus on presidential power didn't begin with presidents at all.
- 2:40It began with abuses of governmental power, and particularly at a very human level.
- 2:49My first job out of law school was with a public interest organization representing
- 2:55indigent criminal defendants, including in capital in death penalty cases, which is the
- 3:01ultimate life and death power that the government could ever exercise.
- 3:05We were oftentimes the last line of defense for people who had no power at all.
- 3:12And in those cases, everything turned on the constitutional limits on governmental powers.
- 3:20What can government do?
- 3:21What can it do?
- 3:23Who makes that decision and the like?
- 3:25So, I was exposed early on in my career to questions of governmental power, the wielding
- 3:32of governmental power and the constitutional limits on governmental power.
- 3:39And that experience shaped me for the past thirty five years as a trial and appellate
- 3:45lawyer, I handled hundreds of cases that involved confronting institutions such as
- 3:51employers, corporations, and many times government actors within the executive branch
- 3:57headed up by the president who exceeded their lawful authority.
- 4:02It was also during that time that I developed a strong interest in research and writing.
- 4:08And in fact, that was always the aspect of law practice that I always enjoyed the most and
- 4:14particularly Supreme Court decisions, hundreds of which I had to analyze down to their essence
- 4:22and explain in an understandable fashion at all levels of the judiciary.
- 4:28The focus more specifically on the limits of presidential power emerged years ago when I
- 4:35began teaching constitutional law to both US and international law students, and
- 4:41particularly international students who were most interested in learning what kinds of
- 4:49constitutional limits do we place on the highest executive officers in the land, because
- 4:54many of them came from countries where they had no such limits on their executive officers.
- 5:01So, in the course of teaching, we delved into the constitution, the origins of the
- 5:08constitution, the separation of powers, checks and balances among the various branches of
- 5:13government, and in particular, and more specifically, the constitutional limits on the
- 5:19presidency, formed the foundation of the book.
- 5:22So for me, studying not so much the abuse of power, but the excesses of power, and in
- 5:30particular presidential power and its limits, has very much been an evolving process over
- 5:36time.
- 5:38I think that's a good distinction to make there, actually, those abuses versus excesses.
- 5:43Because sometimes it's not necessarily something that a president or a governor or a
- 5:48mayor or whoever, they don't necessarily do something illegal, but it is something that you
- 5:53say, well, that might be unethical.
- 5:55Is this something that we should outlaw?
- 5:58That sort of thing.
- 5:58And, of course, you know, make a great point where for all our grievances about our
- 6:05governments, whether it's a chief executive or anything like that, a lot of people, a lot of
- 6:11international students are coming from a place where they don't have those same kinds of
- 6:15constitutional principles necessarily.
- 6:17So that's that's definitely a a good thing to shed light on.
- 6:21But I said, I I think that's that's fascinating that it didn't actually start with the
- 6:26presidency for you.
- 6:27It actually started with other cases.
- 6:29And Correct.
- 6:30I'm sure there's countless examples throughout American history, federal, state and local
- 6:36level that you can point to and give you a couple of couple of them come to come to mind.
- 6:41But let's move to the main reason for this discussion, and that's your book.
- 6:46So why write your book in the Supreme Court's own words?
- 6:50And what do you want people to get out of it?
- 6:52So, I wrote the book for three main reasons.
- 6:57One is because issues of executive power is very much in the news today.
- 7:07We have a president who is engaging in certain kinds of actions where people have strong
- 7:13feelings on both sides of it.
- 7:16And many issues regarding presidential power are now coming before the Supreme Court.
- 7:22So I wanted to not necessarily look at sort of the contemporary surroundings of presidential
- 7:31power, but it motivated me to do sort of a deep dive into the history of Supreme Court
- 7:37decisions, landmark Supreme Court decisions, where the Supreme Court, had to address issues
- 7:44of whether the president was acting within his Article two powers or was acting, in excess of
- 7:51it.
- 7:51And that's exactly what the book does.
- 7:53It starts from 1803 and works its way up to 2024 and curates landmark decisions where the
- 8:02Supreme Court has challenged the president of The United States, sometimes agreed with the
- 8:09president of The United States that the president was acting within his constitutional
- 8:12powers, but in many instances has not.
- 8:15So one reason for the book was I wanted to use sort of the present day circumstances to
- 8:21collect up all of the or the landmark decisions of the Supreme Court from the founding of the
- 8:28nation to the present time because it reflects upon an issue that is very much in the news
- 8:33today.
- 8:34Another reason why I wrote the book is that I wanted to make Supreme Court decisions more
- 8:39accessible to people.
- 8:42There's no question that most people do not read Supreme Court decisions.
- 8:46And indeed, it can be daunting.
- 8:50Sometimes they can be complex.
- 8:52Sometimes they can be dense.
- 8:54Sometimes some cases produce more than one opinion.
- 8:57You could have a majority opinion, a concurring opinion, and dissenting opinions.
- 9:01And as a result, I think many people sometimes shy away from delving into Supreme Court
- 9:09decisions and sometimes rely instead upon newspaper headlines or Internet headlines to
- 9:16inform them about Supreme Court decisions.
- 9:19Well, I wanted to write a book where I would quote many of the passages from Supreme Court
- 9:25decisions to show people that reading Supreme Court decisions is not as daunting as some
- 9:32people may make it out to be, but rather to get past the newspaper headlines, past the Internet
- 9:38headlines, and to actually show people what the Supreme Court has said on this particular
- 9:43issue, presidential power from the founding to to the present day.
- 9:49So one reason for the book was to make Supreme Court decisions more accessible.
- 9:54The third reason why I wrote it was for the current members of the Supreme Court.
- 9:58In fact, I dedicate the book to the current members of the Supreme Court as a reminder to
- 10:05them of what the Supreme Court as an institution has said from 1803 to 2024 on the
- 10:14subject of the excesses of presidential power to remind the court of what kind of cases it
- 10:22dealt with in the past, of many of its eloquent passages in its opinions where it has reigned
- 10:29in the president.
- 10:31Indeed, I sent the book to each of the members of the Supreme Court and got responses back
- 10:37from three of them.
- 10:38So another reason the book was written was to, as sort of a historic reminder to the current
- 10:45members of the court, here are examples in the past where you have confronted and dealt with
- 10:52presidential excesses, which is again an issue that's very much in the news today.
- 10:57So those are the three main reasons why I wrote the book.
- 11:01In terms of what I would like people to take away from it, which was the second part of your
- 11:05question, there would be a couple of things, just three things, real three quick things.
- 11:08One is, I would like people to develop a deeper appreciation for the separation of powers.
- 11:17The constitution was built on one constitutional edifice, one idea, and that was
- 11:24the separation of powers because the founders of this country came from countries and also
- 11:30experienced it in colonial America where they came to the conclusion that if power
- 11:35concentrates in any one particular branch of government, that that is the beginnings of
- 11:41tyranny.
- 11:43And the Supreme Court has spoken eloquently on the subject of separation of powers throughout
- 11:49the decades and centuries, and I collect up those cases so people can read them.
- 11:54So one takeaway is a deep appreciation for the founders' embrace of the notion of separation
- 12:01of powers.
- 12:02Another takeaway would be to, is for people to have a better understanding of how truly unique
- 12:10the judicial branch of government is.
- 12:13It's really different than the other two branches.
- 12:15The other two branches, the legislative Congress, the executive, the president deal
- 12:20with policy making matters.
- 12:22The Supreme Court and the judicial branch do not.
- 12:25And one takeaway is for people to have a real good appreciation for the role that the
- 12:32judicial branch and the Supreme Court plays in our system.
- 12:35The last takeaway, and this is at the heart of the book, is that the Supreme Court has spoken
- 12:40eloquently over the last several centuries on how the president is not above the law.
- 12:47And there, the book collects up various instances where the Supreme Court has
- 12:53illustrated that point.
- 12:56And we can get into several of them during the podcast today.
- 12:59So those are the three main takeaways that I would like people to have upon reading the
- 13:03book.
- 13:05Gotcha.
- 13:05Yeah, the thing about the accessibility, I'm definitely going to ask you a little bit more
- 13:09about that.
- 13:09But now as part of the problem with politics in general, it's just this information is so it's
- 13:15hard to access it.
- 13:16It's either hard to access or people know where it is, but they don't have the time to research
- 13:21it, or they they have some semblance of research skills, but they don't really know how
- 13:29to actually get takeaways from that information.
- 13:33So I can always really appreciate the accessibility part.
- 13:37And something that just occurred to me, and it may have occurred to me before, but when you
- 13:42talk about the separation of powers, and sometimes I feel some people don't really
- 13:46appreciate the whole concentrating power in one branch because especially with today with how
- 13:50much people their their perceptions are colored by their parties is it's also just not
- 13:58efficient to have one branch do everything anyways.
- 14:02It's more efficient to have the judicial branch interpret laws, legislative branch, write laws,
- 14:09the executive branch, execute laws.
- 14:11But I guess that's a that might be a little bit out of the the purview of this discussion.
- 14:16So let's let's get a little bit more into the accessibility part that you were talking about
- 14:21because, like you said, this legalese and the discussion about law can be very opaque and
- 14:26hard to understand for the general public.
- 14:28So give us a little bit more detail about how exactly you try to make it more accessible for
- 14:35regular citizens to read, especially when it comes to these cases about presidential power.
- 14:40So as I say in the introduction to the book, I have no problem doing the heavy lifting in
- 14:47terms of reading Supreme Court decisions.
- 14:49I've been doing it for forty years now.
- 14:51And I and I enjoy it because I like to see what the court's reasoning is and why it reached the
- 14:57decision It did either the majority or the dissenting opinions.
- 15:02So one purpose of the book, again, was for me to do the heavy lifting and to sort of sort of
- 15:09write the book in a in a in a way that that people, the general readership, could
- 15:15understand without getting into the technicalities and all of that.
- 15:19I try to strip the book of all the technicalities and because some of these
- 15:25opinions can be dense.
- 15:26There's no question about it.
- 15:27Hey, it's tough for lawyers to even get through some of these decisions and the like.
- 15:33What I would really impress upon the viewers is that if you're interested in sort of bypassing
- 15:43the newspaper headlines and the Internet headlines and look at what the Supreme Court
- 15:48has actually said, which is why I called the book that it did, in the Supreme Court's own
- 15:52words, to look at the Supreme Court's own words, All the decisions by the Supreme Court,
- 15:58as well as other divisions of the judicial branch, are public.
- 16:03They're public.
- 16:04They're accessible on the Internet.
- 16:07There's a service that summarizes the opinions at the very beginning, so that before you even
- 16:14get to the opinions, majority concurring dissenting opinions, there is a summary of the
- 16:22court's decisions right at the beginning, and they're excellent.
- 16:29And so I would highly recommend that people, it's okay to read media accounts, but just keep
- 16:37in mind that sometimes media accounts, depending on what the source of the information
- 16:42is, sometimes sees decisions, Supreme Court decisions, judicial decisions generally through
- 16:49a certain lens, through a certain ideological lens.
- 16:53And sometimes when they condense it down into a headline, I have found that many times they're
- 16:59not accurate or they're not inclusive.
- 17:01They're not providing sort of a full throated explanation of what the Supreme Court's actual
- 17:08decision was.
- 17:09So I would highly recommend that if people are interested, not in addition to reading my book,
- 17:14which tries to do some of the heavy lifting on the reading of Supreme Court decisions, is that
- 17:19if a major decision comes up, for example, the Supreme Court's going to be deciding the
- 17:25constitutionality of President Trump's tariffs.
- 17:28That decision, they just had the oral argument.
- 17:30The decision will probably be out in a couple of months, and there'll be headlines about it.
- 17:35My suggestion to people is don't rely on the headlines.
- 17:39Go to the opinion.
- 17:40They're public.
- 17:41And before the opinion, there is a summary.
- 17:44And you can actually read what the court in a very condensed summary fashion can read what
- 17:51the issue was, because sometimes there's confusion about that, what the issue was, what
- 17:56the Supreme Court decided, what its reasoning was, and can do it in a more condensed fashion,
- 18:02and that could substitute.
- 18:04I always think that people should read the opinions themselves, but at a bare minute to
- 18:08read those opinions.
- 18:09So in terms of accessibility, it's all public.
- 18:12And I would bring up the opinion on the Internet and read the summary beforehand.
- 18:17And then as an exercise, compare it to the media accounts that you're being given and
- 18:22seeing whether or not the media accounts are accurately portraying.
- 18:26So if I had one big suggestion on accessibility in addition to my book, it would be that.
- 18:31Gotcha.
- 18:32And that was something I meant to bring up earlier too, so I appreciate you talking about
- 18:35it.
- 18:36When you talk about this accessibility, a lot of times, people, whether they're deliberately
- 18:40trying to obfuscate rulings, or they just can't get past their own biases, they paint these
- 18:48rulings in a certain way.
- 18:49And and it doesn't really necessarily inform people.
- 18:53Just just gets their side mad or happy or the other side mad, depending on on what the issue
- 19:02at hand is.
- 19:03And you talk about the the summaries.
- 19:05That's that's really nice to hear because there you have some of these other places like Oyez,
- 19:12for example.
- 19:12For those of you at home, Oyez is is actually spelled o y e z, but it's it's a website that
- 19:18has a lot of summarized information about some of the some of the most important supreme court
- 19:24cases we've ever had.
- 19:25And there's also places like Cornell Law too.
- 19:27But
- 19:27I was gonna I was gonna mention Corlet Cornell Law is excellent.
- 19:31Yeah.
- 19:32And they've been doing this for a long time.
- 19:35So the Cornell site is an excellent place to go to.
- 19:38Yeah, exactly.
- 19:39I was actually going to ask if you had any in particular to recommend.
- 19:43So I guess Cornell would be
- 19:44the top for you then?
- 19:45It would be.
- 19:47But even if you just go on the internet, because sometimes news organizations will give
- 19:51you the link to the actual opinion.
- 19:55And many times the link will go right to the opinion.
- 19:58Other times it will bring you to that that summary that I talked about.
- 20:02And the summary is really, really excellent.
- 20:04But I would go to Cornell.
- 20:05Excellent resource.
- 20:07Okay, perfect.
- 20:08Yeah.
- 20:08And as great as a lot of those other sites can be, it is hard to beat the original source
- 20:16because that's where all the information is coming from.
- 20:20So moving on to some more specific instances that you feel that the boundaries of
- 20:31presidential authority have been challenged.
- 20:32So what do you think are two to three particular constitutional restraints that
- 20:39presidents from both parties have been guilty of overstepping?
- 20:42And what are some examples from both parties, whether more recently or historical, that
- 20:46you've seen?
- 20:47So historically, it is true that presidents from both parties have been reigned in by the
- 20:57Supreme Court of the United States.
- 20:59It's not just one party over another party when you look at it.
- 21:02And this is one of the reasons why I wanted to do sort of a deep dive to get out of our
- 21:06contemporary circumstances and look at it historically.
- 21:10There have been many instances where Republican presidents, the Democratic presidents have been
- 21:16reigned in by the Supreme Court.
- 21:20So let me give just a couple of examples.
- 21:22Historically, my introduction talks about the famous Youngstown case in the 1950s involving
- 21:30democratic president, or he was a member of the democratic party, president Truman.
- 21:35President Truman during the Korean war nationalized The US steel mills.
- 21:41Why?
- 21:42Because there was a war going on, the Korean War.
- 21:46And in the 1950s, you couldn't run a war without steel.
- 21:50And the labor unions were threatening to go on strike.
- 21:55Truman tried to get the matter resolved.
- 21:57It didn't work.
- 21:58So what did he do?
- 21:59He ordered his secretary of commerce to nationalize The United States steel mills.
- 22:06That issue went up to the Supreme Court.
- 22:08Supreme Court said in no uncertain terms that President Truman was acting outside any
- 22:15authorization from Congress.
- 22:17Congress never authorized the president to do such a thing And that there was no provision in
- 22:23article two, which is the article of the constitution creating the executive branch,
- 22:27including the president.
- 22:28There was nothing in article two, which gave president Truman the authority to nationalize
- 22:34an industry, a private industry.
- 22:36And as a result, the Supreme Court invalidated President Truman's decision.
- 22:42So that would be an example, one of the historic examples where the Supreme Court stood
- 22:47up to the president and said, Nope, you can't do that.
- 22:51Other instances involving a Republican president would be George Bush.
- 22:56Second George Bush after nineeleven, the Congress issued a rather broad authorization
- 23:06for President Bush to take whatever actions he believed was necessary in order to respond to
- 23:13the nineeleven terrorist attacks.
- 23:16The President Bush used that authorization to invade Iraq.
- 23:22And so there was large issues of whether the Supreme Court, of whether the President was
- 23:29using an authorization from Congress well beyond the bounds of what was permitted.
- 23:37And one case did go up to the Supreme Court where President Bush used that authorization to
- 23:43try to justify military tribunals of enemy combatants in the Supreme Court.
- 23:50That issue went up to the Supreme Court.
- 23:52Supreme Court said no to President Bush saying that this is a country of due process.
- 23:59Even enemy combatants who are particularly American citizens who are detained abroad are
- 24:06still entitled to the due process rights under the constitution and held that military
- 24:13tribunals or holding enemy combatants without any due process rights violated the
- 24:18constitution.
- 24:19A democratic example would be president Obama, although this issue never went up to the
- 24:24Supreme Court, I don't believe.
- 24:26But in 2011, he authorized military attacks against Libya, citing his powers as commander
- 24:36in chief.
- 24:37There was large constitutional issues as to whether or not President Obama was exceeding
- 24:45his constitutional powers.
- 24:47So, there's been many examples.
- 24:49Other historic examples would be President Lincoln during the civil war.
- 24:55President Lincoln suspended what is called habeas corpus rights under the constitution.
- 25:00One person, Mr.
- 25:01Milligan, was imprisoned pursuant to that.
- 25:05He had no allegiance to either side on the civil war.
- 25:09He was not politically active.
- 25:12The president ordered his imprisonment for eighteen months.
- 25:18And the case went up to the Supreme Court.
- 25:20The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Mr.
- 25:23Milligan that President Lincoln had gone beyond his Article II powers in terms of imprisoning
- 25:32someone for eighteen months without charge, without due process rights.
- 25:37So that would be sort of another famous historical example.
- 25:42So these would be a couple of examples.
- 25:44Other examples have come up in the context of executive orders.
- 25:48President Biden used an executive order to try to put in place student loan forgiveness
- 25:56program.
- 25:57Supreme Court did weigh in on that question and ruled that President Biden's executive order is
- 26:04is a violation of the constitution and the like.
- 26:07So, there has been many examples on both sides where the Supreme Court has been called upon to
- 26:14determine the constitutionality of either a Democratic president's actions or a Republican
- 26:19president's actions.
- 26:20And these are just a couple of examples.
- 26:23War powers and the executive orders seem to be in particular to cases of constant controversy
- 26:32in that regard, and especially when, you know, one side complains about the other,
- 26:36overstepping their war powers, and then the other one does the same thing to the other
- 26:40side.
- 26:40And same thing with executive orders.
- 26:42I'll actually get a little bit more on that track later on during this interview.
- 26:49But but, yeah, I think the what is just made me think the war powers and executive orders that
- 26:55tends to be particularly common sources of complaints and has only become more so over
- 27:00time.
- 27:01Correct.
- 27:01And the the source of the tension on war powers is Article one says of the constitution says
- 27:11that only Congress can declare war.
- 27:15Only Congress can create an army or a navy.
- 27:21Article two establishes the president as the commander in chief.
- 27:26And so there's always been tension between those between that part of Article one and that
- 27:32part of Article two, where presidents who generally do like to push out, they like to
- 27:38push out to see how far their powers can go, have used the rationale that they are the
- 27:45commander in chief and therefore they can order military actions without necessarily
- 27:50authorization from Congress and the like.
- 27:54And the Supreme Court, quite frankly, has struggled with that issue.
- 27:59And you're right.
- 28:00Democratic Republican presidents have ordered military strikes, not necessarily with any
- 28:06authorization from Congress.
- 28:08I gave a couple of examples.
- 28:10That is a tension that the Supreme Court will continue to grapple with as time goes on.
- 28:18Right.
- 28:19And actually speaking of this schism, if you will, sometimes between Congress and president,
- 28:26a lot of the discussion about presidents and whether they've expanded their powers too much
- 28:31isn't just about whether presidents have seized that power for themselves.
- 28:35Sometimes it's been criticism that the US Supreme Court and Congress have willingly ceded
- 28:40power to the president.
- 28:42Do you think that criticism is warranted?
- 28:44And if so, what are some examples?
- 28:47So there's some historical examples of that.
- 28:51And it has come up at least constitutionally in the context of what's called the delegation
- 28:57doctrine or what's sometimes referred to as the non delegation doctrine.
- 29:03There have been instances in American history where Congress, for example, has delegated some
- 29:09of its Article One powers to the president because it's felt that the president and the
- 29:17executive branch would be a more efficient branch to implement something.
- 29:21We just recently saw that with the pandemic where Congress passed several laws which
- 29:29empowered the executive branch to take quick action on what was clearly a national
- 29:34emergency, international emergency, and the like.
- 29:39The Supreme Court has dealt with that issue historically, and they've dealt with it.
- 29:44And it just came up in the recent tariff case on nondelegation doctrine.
- 29:52Just to provide you with sort of a historical example of kind of at least some of the genesis
- 29:57of this.
- 29:57In the 1930s, during the depression, this country was involved in a severe economic
- 30:05downturn, the great depression, which began in 1929.
- 30:10Congress was passing all sorts of laws to give President Franklin D.
- 30:16Roosevelt and the executive branch lots of powers in order to deal with the depression and
- 30:22then later on World War II.
- 30:25Well, one of those areas, you know, believe it or not, came up in the area of a monopoly of
- 30:33the chicken business in New York City.
- 30:35Believe it or not, this is an issue that came up to the Supreme Court where New York City had
- 30:41kind of a monopoly the sale of chicken to consumers.
- 30:49It was becoming a monopoly.
- 30:50Well, the Congress, as part of Great Depression measures, gave President Roosevelt carte
- 30:56blanche authority to basically regulate the chicken consumer industry.
- 31:02No standards.
- 31:03Just here you go.
- 31:05You know, we're delegating our authority to you to regulate this industry because generally,
- 31:09congress is the one that has the power to regulate interstate commerce.
- 31:13Well, that issue went up to the Supreme Court.
- 31:14And the question is, could congress do that?
- 31:16Came up in a silly kind of context, chickens and the consumer the consuming of chickens.
- 31:21But if that's the posture that the case went up to the Supreme Court, could the Congress
- 31:26delegate basically carte blanche legislative authority to the president?
- 31:31Supreme Court said no.
- 31:33Not this way at least, that the the the Congress cannot just delegate its authority
- 31:39without any intelligible principles is what the supreme court said to the executive, in order
- 31:45to carry a to carry out what is arguably a legislative function.
- 31:48So that would be an example where the supreme court stepped in and said delegation under some
- 31:53circumstances is okay, but not this way.
- 31:58We just saw this with respect to the tariff case, just to use another current example,
- 32:05where there is a federal law where members of Congress as well as President Trump is arguing
- 32:11that Congress, when it passed this law, it's called IEPA, we don't need to know the name of
- 32:16it, but it passed this law, which delegate to the president tariff making authority, even
- 32:24though that power is with congress in article one.
- 32:28And that is one of the issues that is currently before the court today.
- 32:32The oral argument in that case was last week, and the nondelegation doctrine came up in that
- 32:37context.
- 32:37And several several of the justices expressed concern that if this is what Congress wanted to
- 32:43do, it wanted to delegate that kind of large authority to do worldwide tariffs, that that
- 32:52raises issues of the nondelegation doctrine, and it raises issues about whether or not
- 32:58that's really what Congress intended.
- 33:01So there have been many examples where at least the Congress, their actions have been called
- 33:08into question as to whether when they delegate to the president certain responsibilities that
- 33:14arguably are Article one responsibilities, legislative responsibilities, but delegating
- 33:19that to the president.
- 33:21Is that a constitutional transfer of authorized power?
- 33:27And we're seeing that being played out today in the tariff case.
- 33:30On the Supreme Court side, because you raised not just the Congress but Supreme Court as
- 33:34well, the answer is yes.
- 33:36And just one recent example would be the presidential immunity case from last year,
- 33:422024.
- 33:42In fact, my book ends with that decision.
- 33:45From eighteen oh three to twenty twenty four, it ended with the presidential immunity
- 33:49decision.
- 33:50Some would argue that that the Supreme Court in that case ceded too much authority to the
- 33:56president to engage in unlawful action.
- 33:59Supreme Court in that case was called upon to determine whether or not President Trump could
- 34:06be criminally prosecuted for certain actions that he took while being being present.
- 34:14And the Supreme Court, even though Supreme Court's been around for over two thirty years,
- 34:18never dealt with that issue.
- 34:20Never came up, except now.
- 34:23When are the circumstances when a president can be criminally prosecuted for actions taken
- 34:28while in office?
- 34:29And the Supreme Court struggled with that and did provide the president with some immunity
- 34:35with respect to powers that are expressly given the president under the constitution and in
- 34:42other circumstances.
- 34:43There were heated dissenting opinions by several of the justices who believed that this
- 34:49was ceding too much power to the president, that it's going to allow the president to get
- 34:55away with too much criminality.
- 34:58That issue is going to continue depending on what type of factual circumstances come to the
- 35:04court in the future.
- 35:05So this would be a couple of historical and present examples of where it's been argued that
- 35:11Congress has ceded too much of its power to the presidency, thereby expanding the powers of the
- 35:16presidency, and arguably a situation, although there's debate on the subject, where the
- 35:21Supreme Court recently may have done the same.
- 35:25I think something that you really highlighted there, and I I've talked about it in a previous
- 35:30episode of the podcast.
- 35:31It was actually just me that time, and it's something I've been wanting to work with more
- 35:36in some way.
- 35:37I haven't really figured it out yet.
- 35:39But it's this dichotomy between efficient versus deliberative government and really
- 35:45trying to get this idea in people's heads of, do you want the government to be quick acting
- 35:50in x y z situations, or do you want them to ponder things more?
- 35:55And you're talking about congress ceding authority to the president in the name of
- 36:00efficiency.
- 36:01I think that's a perfect example of the, well, do you want to do that?
- 36:04Efficiency?
- 36:05Yeah.
- 36:06You might get a quicker solution, but it might lead to more of an abuse of power.
- 36:10Right.
- 36:10If you do a more deliberative process, a lot less likely to be an abuse of power, but also
- 36:16you can really bog things down and make it inefficient.
- 36:19A lot of people complain about congress being gridlocked all the time.
- 36:22So I just thought that was a nice way to really think about government in general, and yours
- 36:30was a really good example of
- 36:32Can to it?
- 36:33Yeah, I go ahead.
- 36:34Go ahead.
- 36:34Really put your finger on something that the founders discussed in the Philadelphia
- 36:42Convention, the Constitutional Convention in 1787.
- 36:45Do we want an efficient government, or would you want a deliberative non tyrannical
- 36:50government?
- 36:51And the founders unequivocally decided in favor of creating a government that wasn't
- 36:59necessarily efficient, but was trying to create a government that would not collapse back into
- 37:07tyranny and realize that the best way to do that was to spread out the various political
- 37:17and lawmaking authorities among three branches of government, some overlapping powers between
- 37:24each of the three, but each jealously independent, jealously guarding their powers,
- 37:31that that is the best way to distribute, to divide up government so that it doesn't
- 37:37collapse back into tyranny.
- 37:40So the founders and then the founders Supreme Court acknowledged from the founding of this
- 37:45country that this can lead to inefficiencies.
- 37:48But efficiency was not the goal of this government.
- 37:51It was endurance.
- 37:53The founders wanted endurance because they looked at the course of human history, James
- 37:59Madison in particular.
- 38:02He spent about eight to ten months before the constitutional convention in Philadelphia by
- 38:09his farm in Montpelier, Virginia, which is not I point him because it's not far from me.
- 38:15And he spent about eight or ten months before the Philadelphia convention reading every book
- 38:21he could find, including Thomas Jefferson sending him books and manuscripts from France
- 38:27because Thomas Jefferson at that time was our ambassador to France.
- 38:31James Madison read every book he could find on when do democracies and republics succeed and
- 38:38when do they fail.
- 38:39One of the lessons that he concluded was that it's the concentration of power, lawmaking
- 38:48power, in one branch that leads to dictatorship, it leads to anarchy, it leads to
- 38:55anti democracy.
- 38:57And so James Madison, as well as the other founders, went into the convention realizing
- 39:02that the best way to create this government was to distribute the powers amongst the three
- 39:08branches, legislative in one, executive in one, judicial in one, have some overlap between,
- 39:14have some cooperation between the three of them.
- 39:17And there's many examples of that in the constitution, but to keep them separate so that
- 39:21power doesn't get concentrated in one particular branch.
- 39:26And so the founders opted in favor of endurance over efficiency.
- 39:30And there's no question that many times it can lead to inefficiencies and slowness.
- 39:38But here we are well over two thirty years through all sorts of ups and downs, a civil
- 39:47war, slavery, post slavery, a great depression, two world wars, scandal after scandal, recently
- 40:00a pandemic.
- 40:02And here we are still standing.
- 40:05And it really is a testimony, and this is one of the themes that I'd like people.
- 40:08You talked earlier about some of the takeaways.
- 40:10Another great takeaway would be sort of a deep appreciation for the founders of this country.
- 40:16They had their flaws.
- 40:17There's no question about it.
- 40:19They punted on the issue of slavery during the Philadelphia Convention of seventeen eighty
- 40:24seven, which arguably contributed later on to the Civil War.
- 40:29They had their flaws, but they crafted a government, a democratic government for a
- 40:36republic that has lasted all these years.
- 40:40And so it may be inefficient, but it has endured, which was their goal.
- 40:46Yeah.
- 40:46And unfortunately, you're never gonna have a flawless document or system of government when
- 40:51human beings are involved.
- 40:52But you you saw you saw some of those concerns also borne out with the articles of
- 40:57confederation too where too much power concentrated in the legislative branch.
- 41:02And then Right.
- 41:02Funny enough, though, the constitution both made it more deliberative and more efficient
- 41:07compared to what we have with the Articles of Confederation.
- 41:09And also not just legislative.
- 41:12One of the lessons that James Madison and some of the other founders learned in their study of
- 41:16human history on democracy and republics is that majority rule can be dictatorial.
- 41:24Majority rule can be too much democracy can lead to tyranny.
- 41:31And that is why the constitution was crafted and is crafted as it was, basically limiting
- 41:40the participation of the citizenry.
- 41:42I mean originally citizens, their main way of participating was directly voting for members
- 41:50of the House of Representatives, which was one half of the legislative branch.
- 41:55At that time, the original constitution did not allow citizens to vote directly for senators.
- 42:02That was decided by state legislatures.
- 42:04It was decided by the people's elected representatives in the state legislators
- 42:08because it was felt that the people could not be trusted to to vote for their senators.
- 42:14Same with the president.
- 42:15The president is not directly voted on by the citizenry.
- 42:19It is filtrated through this electoral college that the the founders put into the constitution
- 42:28to limit the citizens' involvement in the selection of the president.
- 42:33The idea would be that it would be more of the elite who would be able to select the
- 42:40president.
- 42:40And then, of course, in the judicial branch, at least at the federal level, the citizens don't
- 42:45participate at all directly.
- 42:47They vote for the president who nominates people for the federal bench, by the
- 42:53legislative branch, and of course they serve for life.
- 42:56They're not up for elections.
- 42:59So one of the lessons that James Madison drew was that we want the citizens to participate,
- 43:05but not too much, because history has shown that if you allow citizens too much democracy,
- 43:11that can lead every bit as much to tyranny as concentrating power in one particular branch of
- 43:18government.
- 43:20Yeah.
- 43:20That also made me think one last thing before we move on to the next question, because you
- 43:24were talking about how US Senate used to not be popularly elected, and obviously, the president
- 43:30is a more well, I mean, people he is directly elected, but technically indirectly elected
- 43:36because of the the electoral college.
- 43:38But, in my research on state partisanship history, which I'm hoping to release in the
- 43:44near future, some really because state legislatures and state state politics in
- 43:50general can be has a very quirky history in a lot of ways, and there were actually even a few
- 43:55states that governors were not directly elected either.
- 43:58They were actually chosen by state legislators.
- 44:02So kind of in that similar vein to the US senate.
- 44:06But I I do wanna keep more on this
- 44:08Sure.
- 44:09The interbranch relationships.
- 44:13So we sometimes hear about this political questions doctrine.
- 44:17And for those of you at home who don't know what that is, it's basically the supreme court
- 44:21declines to step into certain conflicts between the president and congress by just letting the
- 44:26executive and legislative branches sort things out.
- 44:29They try not to favor the idea is that they're trying not to favor one branch over the other.
- 44:34What for you, Peter, though, what is your take on the political questions doctrine?
- 44:38And do you think that this has also contributed to an increase in presidential power?
- 44:44So the political questions doctrine developed a long time ago by the Supreme Court, and it was
- 44:52created as a doctrine basically to reign the Supreme Court in, to reign the judicial branch
- 44:59in, because under the Constitution,
- 45:05you know, the creation of laws, policy decisions on, you know, what's good health care
- 45:10policy, what's not.
- 45:12Should we go to war?
- 45:13Should we not go to war?
- 45:15The constitution in Articles one and Articles two, creating the legislative and the
- 45:19executives, leaves those kinds of questions to those two particular branches and not to the
- 45:27judicial branch of government.
- 45:30So the political question doctrine was developed by the Supreme Court as sort of a
- 45:36self monitoring to make sure that the court and the judicial branch as a whole does not delve
- 45:43into questions of law or policy that are at least expressly given to either Congress under
- 45:52Article I or the executive branch under Article two.
- 45:57And so if a case comes before the Supreme Court where the Supreme Court believes, you know,
- 46:02that really deals with inter branch conflict between the legislative and executive branch.
- 46:10It's really not we're not being called upon here to determine the constitutionality of
- 46:16anything.
- 46:17We're not being called upon to determine whether or not the president is acting within
- 46:21the confines of a statute, a law passed by Congress.
- 46:25It's really inter branch fighting on policy and law creating matters between Congress and the
- 46:32president.
- 46:33So we, the judicial branch are going to stay out because we're really not being called upon
- 46:38to decide anything here.
- 46:41Indeed, the Supreme Court from the beginning, from the founding of the nation, been very
- 46:48careful, and the book talks about this as well, has been very careful to make clear that there
- 46:55are some things the Supreme Court does not do.
- 46:58The Supreme Court and it's interesting to say this because sometimes people may have sort of
- 47:03a misconception about what is the role of the Supreme Court and the judicial branch
- 47:07generally.
- 47:08Supreme Court doesn't decide policy.
- 47:11The Supreme Court doesn't veto legislation.
- 47:14The Supreme Court doesn't weigh in on what's good policy or bad policy.
- 47:20That is not the role of the judicial branch government.
- 47:23That's the role of the other two political branches.
- 47:27The Supreme Court is being called upon to determine, well, if that's what you want to do,
- 47:33we will decide whether the constitution gives you the power to do it.
- 47:37Or if you, the president, want to engage in this kind of action, in addition to seeing
- 47:43whether the constitution gives you that power to do it, has congress authorized you to do
- 47:48this?
- 47:48These are legitimate judicial related questions.
- 47:53Political question is when the Supreme Court I wouldn't say the Supreme Court when they invoke
- 47:58political questions is necessarily giving either the legislative or the executive branch
- 48:04additional powers.
- 48:06At least the Supreme Court wouldn't say that.
- 48:08They would say that's their power, and we're not being called upon.
- 48:13We cannot be called upon to weigh in on that kind of political or lawmaking kinds of
- 48:21decisions.
- 48:22So the way I see the political questions doctrine is it's a self regulating mechanism
- 48:29that the judicial branch uses to remind itself that our role is limited.
- 48:35All role is limited to whether the Congress or the president is acting within the confines of
- 48:41the constitution.
- 48:42That is squarely a judicial question.
- 48:44And with respect to the president in particular, whether the president is acting
- 48:49within his powers under Article II of the constitution and or is acting under a valid
- 48:55law, valid statutory authorization by the president.
- 48:59So I wouldn't see it as an expansion one way or the other.
- 49:02I think it's mainly a way for the judicial branch to mind its own business when there are
- 49:08issues that the other two political branches need to resolve on their own.
- 49:13Interesting.
- 49:14I don't think I ever realized that it was actually more of a self regulatory measure for
- 49:20the the supreme court.
- 49:21I mean, obviously, they were the ones that came up with it, but I I guess I never really
- 49:24thought about it like like that where they I I think that's also one of those things where I
- 49:32mean, obviously, lots of things in politics are about your perception and perspective.
- 49:37But I think a lot of times people see political questions doctrine as almost like a cop out
- 49:44from the Supreme Court, and they'll say, well, you're you're letting one one branch or the
- 49:49other is just gonna overstep the other, and and you're not gonna do anything about it.
- 49:53But then at the same time, somebody could turn around and say, well, the Supreme Court does
- 49:56step in on these things, then maybe the Supreme Court is actually taking more power for itself.
- 50:02I guess it is you gotta you gotta find out the right balance to strike in that regard.
- 50:08And That's true.
- 50:08You you actually just kinda touched on this a a little bit In your answer, you're talking about
- 50:16how judges or the Supreme Court does not rule on policy.
- 50:21And I think that's a really good segue into this question where you sometimes hear
- 50:27situations where members of congress, activists, and, quote, unquote, influencers,
- 50:33they chastise the US Supreme Court or other federal courts, but especially the US Supreme
- 50:38Court for being, quote, unquote, activist judges when they push back on a president or a
- 50:43president's policies and saying, oh, there's a lot of times they'll say, oh, they're trying to
- 50:48legislate and trying to write laws.
- 50:50What is your take on the activist judge argument?
- 50:54And do you think that is a particularly problematic argument for holding presidents
- 50:59accountable?
- 51:01So I do think it's partly problematic.
- 51:06My experience with the judicial activism argument sentiment is that it's typically the
- 51:16loser in a case that raises judicial activism.
- 51:22It You rule against can't be me, so you're
- 51:23wrong.
- 51:24Yes.
- 51:25And so typically it's the loser in a case that says that the court did something wrong.
- 51:33It's too active.
- 51:35It's making law instead of construing laws and the like.
- 51:39But then again, it depends upon what your political stripe is.
- 51:43So for example, there was a string of decisions in the 1960s by the Supreme Court where it
- 51:52started liberalizing the constitutional rights of criminal defendants.
- 51:58That's where we got the Miranda warnings, the Miranda decision that before the police can
- 52:04engage in custodial interrogation, you first have to advise someone of their rights, the
- 52:10rights of indigent criminal defendants to a lawyer, even if they can't afford a lawyer.
- 52:18There was some loosening up, or I'm sorry, there was some more stringent requirements put
- 52:24on law enforcement under the Fourth Amendment for searches and seizures.
- 52:28Criminal law was a big issue in the 1960s, and the Supreme Court weighed in on many of those
- 52:35decisions.
- 52:36And if you're a person who's a political conservative, you would probably be arguing
- 52:45that this was activism by the court.
- 52:48Of course, the other side of it, including the justices themselves, and there were some
- 52:52dissenting opinions in these cases.
- 52:55These were not unanimous.
- 52:57On the other side of it would be, no, the court is doing what it should be doing, which is to
- 53:02recognize the constitutional rights of criminal defendants, reining in law enforcement so that
- 53:09they don't contravene the constitution.
- 53:11It depends on what side of the aisle that you're on, but it applies today as well.
- 53:18Many if you know, many people who are who would consider themselves to be progressives or
- 53:23politically liberals would see the court more in a conservative bent on many of these
- 53:30decisions.
- 53:31But people on the political conservative ideological side would say, No, the court is
- 53:38construing the constitution according to its original terms.
- 53:41It's engaging in original meaning of the constitution.
- 53:44That's always the way constitutional interpretation should be done.
- 53:48So my view on sizing all of this up after several decades of hearing these references to
- 53:54judicial activism is that it depends whose ox is being gored.
- 54:00If you believe that the court is issuing decisions that you don't agree with, it tends
- 54:07to raise these concerns about activism.
- 54:10Activism, on the other hand, if you believe the Supreme Court's getting it just right, you
- 54:14believe that they're not being activists, they're doing their job.
- 54:18So it kind of depends upon political ideologies and whose ox is being gored.
- 54:29I think that the way to look at judicial activism is that it's never meant in a positive
- 54:37way.
- 54:38It's always meant in a disparaging way.
- 54:41That concerns me.
- 54:42And this gets back to why I said I think it's problematic is that, you know, the confidence,
- 54:50the stature of the judicial branch of government, you know, judicial branch of
- 54:54government, as Alexander Hamilton said, doesn't have an army.
- 54:58It can't command the respect of the people through force, through coercion, through a tax
- 55:05code, through policy making.
- 55:08The Supreme Court and the judicial branch generally depend upon, their credibility
- 55:13depends upon to the extent that the American people believe that they are making decisions
- 55:19on the basis of law, on the basis of the facts before them, that they are coming up with
- 55:24reasoned judgments and the like.
- 55:27If people start not to believe that, which is prevalent, I would say in today's society, well
- 55:35then the credibility of the institution starts to diminish.
- 55:38And so when I hear accusations of judicial activism, not only do I conclude that you were
- 55:46on the losing side of that case, but also I think that it's a disparagement that whittles
- 55:52away at the institutional strength of the judicial branch of government.
- 55:59So it does concern me, in that regard, and I tend not to pay too much attention to it.
- 56:06What I would suggest to people, this goes back to piercing through newspaper headlines,
- 56:12getting past newspaper headlines, getting past, you know, the the the Internet displays one
- 56:22side or another on Supreme Court decisions.
- 56:24Same here.
- 56:25Get past the labels.
- 56:27Get past people's accusations depending upon what their political ideologies are.
- 56:33Get to the decisions.
- 56:35Get to the decisions.
- 56:36Read the decisions.
- 56:38Make decisions for yourself.
- 56:41Use the summaries at Cornell or elsewhere to actually read the opinions.
- 56:45It's a big point in my book so that And maybe you'll conclude that the court is activism.
- 56:51Great.
- 56:51But at least it'll be on the basis of what you're actually reading.
- 56:56The Supreme Court decisions themselves or a really intelligent summary, accurate summary of
- 57:01that.
- 57:01Get past the headlines.
- 57:02So I would say the same here.
- 57:04People getting past sort of the labels that sometimes people append to Supreme Court
- 57:09decisions and get to the decisions themselves.
- 57:11What was the facts?
- 57:12What was the holding?
- 57:14What was the reasoning behind it?
- 57:15Do you agree or not?
- 57:16That's what I would say with respect to judicial activism.
- 57:20I think you see a lot of that whole, we have to apply a specific disparaging word, so that we
- 57:25can't just disagree with it or say it's wrong.
- 57:27You know?
- 57:28Maybe they're not activists.
- 57:29Maybe they just have what you think is a bad interpretation of the law.
- 57:33I mean, it's not like they haven't had that in the past, especially when it comes to, well,
- 57:38the lack of civil rights initially, like with Dred Scott versus Sanford or Plessy versus
- 57:42Ferguson.
- 57:43But it kind it kind of is a similar case to when people can't just disagree on policy.
- 57:49They have to call each other traitors or evil or stupid.
- 57:52It's it kinda makes me think of that.
- 57:55And I think that is a problem that you you pointed out there.
- 57:58The The legitimacy of the branch has been called into question.
- 58:02I'm not saying that they've been ruled well, I'm not saying I agree with their rulings
- 58:07recently on various cases.
- 58:09That's for other people to decide, but I think it is very concerning trend here where we see a
- 58:17plummeting trust in the judicial branch in particular.
- 58:21I mean, Congress has has had that kind of thing for a long time, which is also still a problem,
- 58:27but it's a little bit out of the purview of this discussion.
- 58:29But it is you know, there's there's nothing necessarily wrong with disagreeing with how a
- 58:37branch of government is.
- 58:37And a lot of times, they do need to be criticized and and held accountable.
- 58:40No no nobody no entity is above accountability, but when it gets to a point where you're
- 58:46starting to doubt the legitimacy of it purely because they are doing things that you don't
- 58:51like, I think is a very serious problem.
- 58:54And Right.
- 58:54Speaking of which, do you see a lot of hypocrisy where these members of congress,
- 59:01activists, influencers, that to bring it more back to the presidency specifically, that
- 59:07they'll be more supportive of an expansion of presidential power when it is a president they
- 59:13like?
- 59:13And if so, how much of an issue do you think this poses for our political discourse and
- 59:18democratic norms?
- 59:20It's a big issue, And you put your finger on it.
- 59:25And I mentioned this in the introduction to the book.
- 59:29I think that far too many people look at the question of whether what a president has done
- 59:35is lawful or not.
- 59:38They confuse that with partisan loyalty, that they see that issue through partisan lens.
- 59:46And one effort I've tried to get across in the book is that the question of whether what a
- 59:52president does is lawful or not is shouldn't be seen, should be determined on the basis of
- 1:00:00constitutional law.
- 1:00:01It should not be on the basis of whether on the basis of personalities or on the basis of you
- 1:00:09like him or her, you like their policies or not.
- 1:00:14And I think far too often people today see Supreme Court decisions, with respect to the
- 1:00:22president, as sort of a sum total gain.
- 1:00:26They see it as, well, I don't like this president who's sitting in the Oval Office now,
- 1:00:32and therefore I'm going to see Supreme Court decisions through that lens.
- 1:00:37Does it help him or her or does it hurt him or her?
- 1:00:41And if I don't like this president, well, then I'll agree with the Supreme Court decision.
- 1:00:45If it hurts this current president or goes against this president, that may be the
- 1:00:50opposite kind of thing.
- 1:00:53That is not the way, at least I would suggest to people, that the lawfulness of a president's
- 1:01:00action should be seen.
- 1:01:01You know, Chief Justice John Marshall, who was not this nation's first chief justice, but I
- 1:01:08think he was the third, but he was the first preeminent chief justice from the early
- 1:01:16eighteen hundreds, I think, the into the eighteen thirties.
- 1:01:19And he wrote a lot of landmark decisions, including Marbury versus Madison, which
- 1:01:23established judicial review and many other decisions.
- 1:01:27He always said, famously so, this is a constitution that we are expounding here, not
- 1:01:35policy preferences, not presidential preferences, not whether you like the president
- 1:01:41or don't like the president, that the question of whether a president is acting within Article
- 1:01:47two powers, whether he's exceeding those powers, should not be seen through the lens of
- 1:01:51partisan loyalties, but rather should be seen in the context of constitutional law as it is
- 1:01:57developed from the founding of the nation.
- 1:02:01And this would be, I think one antidote to that would be to actually Supreme Court decisions
- 1:02:08themselves or a really good summary of them so that you can see that as an institution, the
- 1:02:15Supreme Court justices, at least in my view, are not sitting around the table saying, how
- 1:02:20can I help this president?
- 1:02:22How can I not help this president?
- 1:02:24I don't think they see it that way at all.
- 1:02:26I think that they do see it in terms of their precedent on the matter, which sometimes goes
- 1:02:31back decades, if not a couple of centuries, and trying to decide issues that come up to the
- 1:02:39court in a manner that is consistent with its prior precedent, in a manner that they believe
- 1:02:44is consistent with the constitution of The United States, not whether it helps one
- 1:02:49particular president or another.
- 1:02:52So so I think that that we do see far too much of people seeing the Supreme Court.
- 1:02:59Now, let me say this.
- 1:03:00That's not to say that the Supreme Court is not a political body.
- 1:03:03It is.
- 1:03:04There's nine individuals.
- 1:03:08Whenever you get more than one person in the room, there's always going to be politics.
- 1:03:15That's just the nature of the human condition.
- 1:03:17But I do get the sense that the Supreme Court doesn't sit around saying, how can I help this
- 1:03:22particular president or not help this particular president?
- 1:03:25They're looking at it more historically.
- 1:03:28And that's one reason why I sent them my book, what and why I dedicated my book to them, which
- 1:03:32is that you are going to have issues of executive power before you.
- 1:03:39And and I wanted to use this book.
- 1:03:42One of its purposes, as I said at the outset, was to remind the current justices, this is
- 1:03:46what you all have said historically on the subject of reigning in presidents or not
- 1:03:53reigning them in.
- 1:03:54And and I wanted write a book that would remind you of what you said historically.
- 1:04:01So, look, I think that we live in a very partisan age.
- 1:04:05We live in a very polarizing age where people see things.
- 1:04:10You know, people are in their information bubbles and they tend to consult the same news
- 1:04:16sources and the same news opinions.
- 1:04:19And there's not a whole lot of venturing out between the bubbles.
- 1:04:23And that affects the Supreme Court.
- 1:04:25That affects the views of the Supreme Court because I think much too much of it is seen
- 1:04:29through, you know, whether it's going to help my guy or not.
- 1:04:34And institutionally, the inquiry by the Supreme Court and the judicial branch generally is much
- 1:04:40broader than that.
- 1:04:41It really is.
- 1:04:43That's one of the reasons why I wrote the book to try to convey that to people.
- 1:04:48It just made me think of when I went back up to Gainesville to see my undergraduate alma mater
- 1:04:56play my graduate alma mater, USF versus UF from football earlier this year.
- 1:05:01I I went to go visit a somebody a friend of mine who was an adjunct professor at the time
- 1:05:07and or when when I was in grad school, and he's he still does some adjunct teaching, but he was
- 1:05:13just talking to me about how when he has his students, he tries to teach them, especially
- 1:05:19when they have that issue of they're thinking of things through a parson lens and really
- 1:05:23trying to instill them.
- 1:05:24They're not necessarily purposely trying to do that.
- 1:05:26It's just they haven't really thought about the the idea of, okay.
- 1:05:30You you like what this president is doing, but now what if the shoe's on the other foot?
- 1:05:34What if the a president that you don't like is doing this thing that you support?
- 1:05:40And then it you start to get the gears, Hogan, their heads, and they're thinking, oh, yeah.
- 1:05:43That's a good point.
- 1:05:44We had to have rules for everybody.
- 1:05:46So I think there is some of that, at least for regular citizens, they do sometimes not take
- 1:05:53that to its logical conclusion.
- 1:05:55Although, unfortunately, I think with a lot of members of Congress and activists and
- 1:06:00influencers, they know that they're hypocrites and they don't care, or they just refuse to
- 1:06:06acknowledge it, and and, obviously, those are issues too.
- 1:06:09And and something you you pointed out too is the supreme court, they aren't impartial.
- 1:06:16I forget the exact wording that Alexander Hamilton used in whichever Federalist paper it
- 1:06:22was, but he basically was saying, like, that they need to be completely insulated from
- 1:06:27politics.
- 1:06:27And
- 1:06:27yet, think that's why when he was arguing about having lifetime terms for them, which Right.
- 1:06:34I mean, that that's that's another argument that I've I've talked about in the past.
- 1:06:38But to some extent, you certainly insulate them for politics.
- 1:06:42And I would agree that I don't think that they're sitting in a room thinking how they can
- 1:06:47help this president or help this congress.
- 1:06:50But just like any other human, they do have their biases and sometimes they don't
- 1:06:55necessarily acknowledge it, but now they do have a lot of information to back them up.
- 1:07:02Like, I I remember not to I if I don't want it to make it sound like I'm trying to to rag on
- 1:07:11him.
- 1:07:11I would say this for anybody who thinks they could or any regular person that thinks they
- 1:07:15could take on a supreme court in terms of legal minds.
- 1:07:19But I remember Stephen Colbert was trying to have an argument with Antonin Scalia when he
- 1:07:24was still alive, and it's just like, Steven, you you're you're not gonna win an argument
- 1:07:28against Antonin Scalia.
- 1:07:30And but but it's it's the same other way if it was somebody who was a conservative trying to
- 1:07:34argue against Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
- 1:07:36You are not going to beat her in an argument.
- 1:07:38Doesn't that does not mean that they don't have their own biases that they're contending with,
- 1:07:43and it doesn't mean that they're not it it doesn't mean that they're impartial, but at the
- 1:07:48same time, these are still very brilliant people that are I think at at least the vast
- 1:07:54majority of them are trying to do what they think is right.
- 1:07:57And, obviously, there are many cases in the past where they have objectively gotten things
- 1:08:03wrong.
- 1:08:03Like, we talked about some of the old civil rights cases where where they certainly took
- 1:08:10way too long to affirm civil rights.
- 1:08:14But but, yeah, at the same time, you know, we we do have to have a very specific not not not
- 1:08:20litmus test, but it's like a set of principles that we apply to every single president.
- 1:08:26If if if if this president if it's a democratic president and they're overstepping their bounds
- 1:08:31with x action, it's also overstepping their bounds if it's a republican president or if
- 1:08:35it's an independent president.
- 1:08:37And Right.
- 1:08:37Like you said, I think we unfortunately stray too far from that because we're too concerned
- 1:08:43about winning as opposed to actually keeping the system running the way it's supposed to.
- 1:08:50So we are coming up on the homestretch here, but before we get to those final few questions,
- 1:08:58near the end of interviews, and I know you talked about already how you try to keep things
- 1:09:02as practical as possible, which I really appreciate.
- 1:09:05So for I wanna hone in on those practical applications for anybody who's listening or
- 1:09:12watching.
- 1:09:13What are two to three practical ways that listeners for this episode can hold presidents
- 1:09:18accountable for overstepping boundaries, especially for those citizens who are the same
- 1:09:23party as the president, whichever president it is.
- 1:09:26So, I mean, one thing comes at least one thing comes to mind, and that is many people, many
- 1:09:33constituents do speak with their with their elected member in Congress.
- 1:09:38And what I would advise people to do, including people of the same party as the president,
- 1:09:44whether the president happens to be Democrat or Republican, is to put aside as best you can
- 1:09:52partisan loyalties and tell your elected representative to defend the constitution and
- 1:09:59not necessarily defend the president.
- 1:10:02Huge distinction between the two.
- 1:10:06And I think far too often on both sides of the aisle, people place their allegiance with the
- 1:10:12person instead of the founding fundamental document of the country.
- 1:10:18So one practical thing I would suggest to people when they meet with their congresspeople
- 1:10:22or they meet with their senators is to make the point to them that they expect them to defend
- 1:10:28the constitution and not necessarily the president, whatever party the president happens
- 1:10:33to be in.
- 1:10:34That would be one practical application.
- 1:10:36A second app practical application I've mentioned, I'll mention it again, read Supreme
- 1:10:41Court decisions.
- 1:10:42There are sources out there including Cornell or the opinions themselves where you can dive
- 1:10:49through media presentations of on one side of the of the other and read the decisions
- 1:10:55themselves and come to your own conclusions about whether you agree or disagree.
- 1:11:01The other major thing, that I would suggest is voting.
- 1:11:05You know, people vote.
- 1:11:07Voting is one of the most practical things that, that we can do in this country.
- 1:11:11And I would suggest to people, maybe this is asking too much, is to not necessarily vote on
- 1:11:17the basis of party affiliation, but vote on the basis of defending the constitution and in
- 1:11:23particular the separation of powers.
- 1:11:26It is always a dangerous thing, I believe, for American democracy, for the Congress of the
- 1:11:34United States to be both chambers, to be of the same party as the sitting president.
- 1:11:39We've had that.
- 1:11:40We have that today on the Republican side.
- 1:11:42We've had that before on the Democratic side.
- 1:11:46I do believe strongly in checks and balances, and I believe that should primarily come, and I
- 1:11:51know the Supreme Court would say this, it should come, the checks and balances mainly
- 1:11:56should come between the two political branches themselves.
- 1:11:58Yes, it leads to less efficiency, more gridlock, no question, but each acts as a check
- 1:12:06upon themselves when the Congress of the United States is controlled primarily by one party and
- 1:12:15the president is of the other party.
- 1:12:17It does lead to inefficiency, but it also reduces the chances of there being a
- 1:12:23concentration of power in one branch or another.
- 1:12:27So I would ask people to vote not as much on party affiliation, but rather on the basis of
- 1:12:34separation of powers.
- 1:12:35That's a tall order because much research has been done in this country about partisan
- 1:12:40affiliation is probably the predominant factor upon affecting voting.
- 1:12:46It's a problem.
- 1:12:47It's a problem.
- 1:12:48But I would invite people to think about whether to vote on a different basis, in a more
- 1:12:54constitutional basis to make sure that the checks and balances, particularly between the
- 1:12:59Congress and the president, can take hold and take effect in terms of preserving our
- 1:13:06government.
- 1:13:08And it is it is good to also note with this efficiency versus deliberation debate.
- 1:13:14Even if a government is taking swift action, doesn't mean that action's good.
- 1:13:18And it's also the same way if if it deliberate if it's a deliberative government, doesn't mean
- 1:13:21they're coming to the right conclusion either.
- 1:13:23But Right.
- 1:13:24You do need to make sure that it is the process we want, and we have good reasons for why we
- 1:13:31choose the process we want.
- 1:13:33And as an addendum to what you were saying at the beginning, I I I would agree with obviously
- 1:13:38defending the constitution, but I also want to encourage people to also make sure that when
- 1:13:44they call their member of congress to defend the constitution, make sure that that is not
- 1:13:49just a euphemism for defending your party because a lot of times Right.
- 1:13:54People's opinions of what the constitution says are still unfortunately colored by their party
- 1:14:00and which party is in power.
- 1:14:01So I would also encourage people to think about that as well.
- 1:14:06So we are just about just about out of time.
- 1:14:09So we are gonna go ahead and move on to the random question of the day.
- 1:14:13If you are new to this podcast, I like to pose a random, fun, nonpolitical question to my
- 1:14:20guests just to round things out and make things a little bit varied and get get a get another
- 1:14:26side of of the guest.
- 1:14:29So, Peter, for you, today's random question of the day is, what is the silliest, dumbest,
- 1:14:37whatever legal case you have ever seen or tried, and what exactly happened?
- 1:14:45Oh my goodness.
- 1:14:48Where to begin?
- 1:14:49Where to begin?
- 1:14:52Well, so I was working on a sexual harassment case because I did a lot of employment
- 1:15:03discrimination law under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and a host of other federal
- 1:15:10anti discrimination statutes.
- 1:15:12This wasn't in court, although we have some there.
- 1:15:16This was before we went to court and we were at a mediation.
- 1:15:20Certainly, I'm not going to mention any names.
- 1:15:23Mediation is sometimes a former judge will come in to see whether or not they can mediate the
- 1:15:29dispute so that there is no trial and to save everyone the time and expense.
- 1:15:34It was a sexual harassment case where the client was alleging that she was the victim of
- 1:15:39all different kinds of sexual harassment by a certain male individual in the workplace.
- 1:15:48And as I was going to to when I was driving to the mediation, I noticed driving there that
- 1:15:57there was this new Chinese restaurant on the side of the street, and I'll come back to that.
- 1:16:01But I noticed the new Chinese restaurant.
- 1:16:03So I go to the mediation, and before we actually do sort of the plenary session where
- 1:16:09we're all together in the same room, the judge the judge, you know, former judge, but we
- 1:16:13always called him judge.
- 1:16:14He would, you know, came over to, you know, he said, Peter, come over here.
- 1:16:17And and we went to a separate room where the employer's lawyer was.
- 1:16:23And and she and the judge said, you know, Peter, you may want to take a look this.
- 1:16:33Keep in mind, I had a client that was seem very honest and straightforward.
- 1:16:38And the other lawyer just kind of opened up this folder and saw Sorry.
- 1:16:43Real quick.
- 1:16:44Was your clients the the woman or was it the male?
- 1:16:46No.
- 1:16:46It was the woman.
- 1:16:47It was a woman.
- 1:16:48Okay.
- 1:16:48And she was alleging that the sexual harassment.
- 1:16:51So the other lawyer kind of opens up the folder and and says, you know, Peter, take a look at
- 1:16:57this.
- 1:16:58And it was my client in how shall I put this in various states of undress, engaged in certain
- 1:17:07kinds of activities that, you know, you know, one wouldn't think would occur at the at the
- 1:17:11site of employment, let alone be on camera and on film.
- 1:17:15And at that point, you know, the judge kind of looked at me and said, well, so Peter, what do
- 1:17:20you want to do here?
- 1:17:23And so I went back to the client and she, you know, ranted and raved that that this isn't
- 1:17:32true and that was her boyfriend and this kind of thing.
- 1:17:35Of course, it blew the case up.
- 1:17:37And it's kind of hard to argue sexual harassment when you've engaged in in these
- 1:17:43activities and it's caught on film and caught on in photographs and the like.
- 1:17:47So long story short, we the case was settled for for dirt cheap.
- 1:17:53And and on the way back, I because it ended after like two hours or so, I was able to have
- 1:17:59a really nice lunch at that Chinese restaurant on the way back.
- 1:18:03So that's one that kind of stands out in That was kind of an embarrassing case, but you know
- 1:18:12what happens?
- 1:18:13I've had hundreds, if not thousands of cases, and there's bound to be a couple that stand
- 1:18:18out, but that one surely did.
- 1:18:20Yeah.
- 1:18:21Yeah.
- 1:18:21I can understand.
- 1:18:22So obviously, I have never tried a case.
- 1:18:25I am not a lawyer.
- 1:18:26I've never A lot of people I knew back from undergrad days at University of South Florida,
- 1:18:31they were all mean, obviously, a lot of political science people want to go on to law
- 1:18:35school.
- 1:18:36I knew that was never what I wanted to do, but obviously, I still find law fascinating, and
- 1:18:42that's part of the reason I have you on here.
- 1:18:46But I remember back in high school, I guess it was called Intro to Law, and I just remember
- 1:18:51several cases from there just being just so not only that the case itself was stupid, but that
- 1:18:58the the plaintiff actually won the case.
- 1:19:02That that was what really boggled my mind.
- 1:19:04I remember the one time, you know, the one where a lady, she put on her cruise control for
- 1:19:12Winnebago to go make a sandwich.
- 1:19:14And, of course, cruise control does not actually go with the twists and turns.
- 1:19:19And so but but she I think she sued Winnebago for basically not describing what cruise
- 1:19:27control actually does, and she won.
- 1:19:29So Winnebago has that in their in their user manual.
- 1:19:33And then there was another one I remember reading about somebody.
- 1:19:39He broke into this couple's house when I guess they were on vacation.
- 1:19:46And for some reason, he could not get out of the house.
- 1:19:49And they just had cans of Pepsi, I think, and he basically had to subside on those.
- 1:19:54And then when he got home, he actually sued them for mental distress or something like
- 1:20:01that.
- 1:20:01And I think he actually won that case.
- 1:20:03Had to go back and find that.
- 1:20:04But it's just like, we're kidding, right?
- 1:20:07This is not like, even if it's like, technically, I guess even if there's
- 1:20:12technically a legal justification for it, like the stupidity of some people's like, we
- 1:20:17shouldn't be rewarding that.
- 1:20:19But
- 1:20:20So talking about stupidity, have one quick example, another case that just came to mind.
- 1:20:26So I represented someone who was sued.
- 1:20:30He was actually the defendant in this employment case, and he was sued by a
- 1:20:35colleague.
- 1:20:38And he and others played a practical joke on their colleague in the workplace, and their
- 1:20:45practical joke is that they got what looked like to be dynamite, real dynamite.
- 1:20:52It looked like it from a glance.
- 1:20:55It certainly looked like it.
- 1:20:56Of course, wasn't.
- 1:20:58And they put a timer on it and they put it in her credenza in her office.
- 1:21:06After a while, they detonated it, which means that the clock started ticking down.
- 1:21:13She wanted to know where the ticking was coming from.
- 1:21:16She opened up the credenza and she thought she saw what was dynamite.
- 1:21:20And she went flying out of there and she ultimately did sue the employer and she sued my
- 1:21:28client for all sorts of claims.
- 1:21:30The case ultimately got resolved.
- 1:21:32But in the scheme of stupidness, things that you should never do, would rank on the list as
- 1:21:40well.
- 1:21:42It was well meaning, believe it or not, but maybe you ought to think these things through
- 1:21:47before you carry them out.
- 1:21:49Yeah.
- 1:21:51Some people just really don't think through.
- 1:21:55And I'm I mean, I know there are ties where I don't either, but that that is not something I
- 1:21:59I would do.
- 1:22:01Certainly, that's not my idea of a practical joke.
- 1:22:03But Right.
- 1:22:04But, yeah, it it is just amazing how even in these cases that you think are just so dumb,
- 1:22:11some sometimes they work out in a way that you don't expect.
- 1:22:15Like, the judge is really gonna rule for them or the jury's gonna really rule for them.
- 1:22:18But Right.
- 1:22:19Sometimes it's it's just it's just how it goes.
- 1:22:22But, anyways, that is gonna wrap things up for today's episode.
- 1:22:26Peter, thank you so much for coming on.
- 1:22:29Real quick, any links that you wanna share?
- 1:22:32Obviously, I'll put your book in the show notes, but anything else?
- 1:22:35My book is on Amazon.
- 1:22:37All you have to do is put in the words in the Supreme Court's own words, and my book will pop
- 1:22:42up.
- 1:22:43Nope.
- 1:22:43There you go.
- 1:22:44Then for my show notes or my my links, my Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my
- 1:22:51LinkedIn profile, my medium.com profile where I write on from time to time, my email,
- 1:22:58PaulRaiderWritesgmail dot com, my five day educational email course about how we can all
- 1:23:04more effectively mitigate polarization because some of the ways that we try to mitigate
- 1:23:09polarization is not effective and sometimes actually makes it worse.
- 1:23:13And my website, paulrayder.org.
- 1:23:15So that should be all those links.
- 1:23:18So as always, thank you so much for listening and tuning in.
- 1:23:22Thanks, see you next time.
- 1:23:24Thank you, Peter.