Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Goodbye FCC. Hello SEC.
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. This is David Bennett, and this is Bitcoin and, a podcast where I try to find the edge effect between the worlds of Bitcoin, gaming, permaculture,
- 0:08podcasting, and education to gain a better understanding of all. Edge effect is a concept from ecology describing a greater diversity of life where the edges of 2 systems overlap. While species from either system can be found at the edge, it is important to note there are species in the overlap that exist in neither system, and that is what I seek to uncover. So join me in discovering the variety of things being created as Bitcoin rubs up against other systems.
- 0:44It is 9:36
- 0:45AM
- 0:46Pacific Daylight Time. It's the 27th day of September
- 0:512024
- 0:52and this is episode 962
- 0:54of Bitcoin. And we're gonna just jump right in with both feet, dude. The water is cold,
- 1:00but, you know, it's just the best way to get this shit done. Alright. So, tornado cash
- 1:07is the first bad news that we've got for this morning. And I I honestly think this is pretty much the only if not the only bad news, the worst bad news. Okay? So we're gonna get it we're gonna do this shit get it over with quick. So you can just go on about your day.
- 1:22Tornado Cash has lost their motion
- 1:25to dismiss.
- 1:27Bitcoin Magazine Colin Crossman is gonna get us all squared away on this one.
- 1:32The judge in the Tornado Cash case
- 1:34delivered an oral ruling today rejecting both the defense's motion to compel discovery,
- 1:40as well as their motion to dismiss all charges.
- 1:44This represents a massive setback for the defense.
- 1:48And the judge's reasoning
- 1:50may not bode well for developers and projects going forward.
- 1:54So
- 1:55the motion to compel.
- 1:57Alright. This is what this is about. The defense's motion to compel discovery
- 2:02sought to access a broad range of government communications,
- 2:06including exchanges with foreign authorities under the Mutual Legal Assistance
- 2:11Treaty.
- 2:12And with domestic agencies like the Office of Foreign Asset Control and the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
- 2:19Citing federal rule of criminal procedure number 16, the defense argued that these materials were essential to the understanding of the government's case
- 2:28and could potentially include exculpatory
- 2:30evidence.
- 2:32The judge, however, made it clear that rule 16
- 2:35imposes a stringent requirement.
- 2:38The defense must show that the requested information is material to their case,
- 2:44not merely speculate on its potential
- 2:46usefulness.
- 2:48The court
- 2:49dismissed the defense's arguments as speculative,
- 2:53noting that the reference to what the information might or could reveal
- 2:57do does not meet the necessary standard for materiality.
- 3:02Material
- 3:04materiality.
- 3:06Wow. That is one hell of a word. It's material and I t y. You pronounce it for yourself. For example,
- 3:13the defense argued that the MLAT communications
- 3:16with the Dutch government might shed light on the evidence against tornado cash or reveal
- 3:21the government's investigative
- 3:22theories. The judge found this reasoning unpersuasive.
- 3:26It emphasizing that materiality
- 3:28or whatever the hell it's called cannot be established through conjecture
- 3:33or vague assertions.
- 3:34The court similarly rejected the defense's request for all communications between the government and OFAC as well as FinCEN.
- 3:41Although the defense claimed these documents were necessary to understand the government's theories and potential witnesses,
- 3:47the judge concluded that the defense failed
- 3:50to demonstrate how these communications were directly relevant to the charges at hand.
- 3:55The court
- 3:56reiterated that the burden is on the defense to show a specific link between the requested documents and their defense strategy,
- 4:04a burden they did not meet.
- 4:06When the defense suggested an in camera review to determine their
- 4:11their materiality,
- 4:13God, what a word. The court refused.
- 4:16The judge argued that granting such a request based on speculative
- 4:20assertions
- 4:21would set a dangerous precedent,
- 4:23effectively forcing in camera reviews in all criminal cases when a defendant speculates about the relevance of certain documents. This, the judge stressed, would undermine the purpose of rule 16 and transform
- 4:35the
- 4:36pretrial
- 4:37discovery process
- 4:39into
- 4:40an unrestrained
- 4:41search for potentially helpful evidence.
- 4:44The the defense also raised concerns under Brady versus Maryland
- 4:49arguing that the government might be withholding exculpatory and impeachable evidence. While the court acknowledged the government's obligations under Brady, it found no indication that these duties had been neglected.
- 5:00Without concrete evidence suggesting
- 5:02government was withholding information,
- 5:04the court saw no reason to compel additional disclosures.
- 5:09The judge cautioned that while the defense's arguments were theoretically possible, they lacked the factual support needed to warrant the court's
- 5:17intervention.
- 5:18Alright. So coming to the motion to dismiss all charges,
- 5:22well, that was presented
- 5:23or did present a much more significant set of issues.
- 5:27Central to the defense's argument was the definition of a money transmitter under the Bank Secrecy Act.
- 5:33The defense contends that Tornado Cash does not qualify as a money transmitter because it did
- 5:40not exercise control over any user funds. It merely facilitated
- 5:44the movement of cryptocurrencies.
- 5:47The court, however, rejected this narrow interpretation.
- 5:50The judge clarified that the BSA, Bank Secrecy Act, the scope does not require the control of the funds.
- 5:58Tornado Cash's role in
- 6:02facilitating,
- 6:03anonymizing,
- 6:04and transferring cryptocurrency was sufficient to bring it within the statute's ambit.
- 6:08The judge likened Tornado Cash to custodial mixers, which have been deemed money transmitting businesses.
- 6:15Further complicating the defense's argument was their reliance on the 2019 FinCEN
- 6:21guidance,
- 6:22which uses a 4 factor test to determine whether a wallet provider is a money transmitter.
- 6:27The defense claimed
- 6:29this guidance, which includes a total independent control standard,
- 6:33should apply to Tornado Cash. But the court disagreed,
- 6:36stating that this standard is specific to wallet providers
- 6:40and does not extend to mixers like Tornado Cash. Consequently,
- 6:45Tornado Cash's lack of total independent control over funds
- 6:48was irrelevant
- 6:50to its classification as a money transmitter.
- 6:53Another key point in the court's analysis was the distinction between expressive
- 6:58and functional code
- 7:00under the First Amendment.
- 7:02This is probably the most pivotal sentence in this entire
- 7:07article, so I'm going to read it again.
- 7:10Perk your ears up right now. Do it now. If you're if you're dazing off,
- 7:15come on man. Wake it on up. Another key point
- 7:18in the court's analysis
- 7:20was that there is
- 7:24a distinction between
- 7:25expressive code
- 7:27and functional code
- 7:29under the First Amendment.
- 7:31The defense argued that prosecuting Storm for his involvement with Tornado Cash was tantamount
- 7:38for punishing him for writing code, which they claimed was protected free speech.
- 7:43The judge acknowledged that while code can be considered expressive,
- 7:49the specific use of code to facilitate
- 7:52illegal activities such as money laundering or sanctions evasion falls outside of the bounds of the First Amendment protections.
- 8:03The judge emphasized that the court must focus on the conduct enabled by the code,
- 8:08not merely the code itself.
- 8:10Even under immediate scrutiny, which applies to content neutral restrictions on speech, The judge found that the government's interest in preventing money laundering and regulating
- 8:20unlicensed money transmission
- 8:22justified
- 8:23the restrictions imposed by the relative statutes.
- 8:27I'm pausing
- 8:28because later on we're gonna read a story about Gary Gensler
- 8:32and it's going to relate directly back to this entire paragraph I guarantee it continuing the court
- 8:41also addressed concerns about the immutability of Tornado Cash's smart contracts
- 8:45an issue raised by both parties the judge acknowledged
- 8:49the existence of a factual dispute but noted that it was not a decisive factor in the current motion
- 8:55However,
- 8:56the issue of immutability
- 8:58may play a role at trial in determining the extent of Storm's control over the service and its responsibility for its operations. In concluding remarks, the judge underscored that while the use of code
- 9:09to communicate
- 9:10ideas
- 9:11may be protected under the first amendment,
- 9:14using that code to facilitate illegal activities is not.
- 9:19This distinction is critical in the context
- 9:22of emerging technologies like blockchain where the line between speech and conduct can be blurred.
- 9:27The court's ruling serves as a reminder that the legal system is prepared to hold participants
- 9:32in the digital economy accountable
- 9:35even as it grapples with the complexities of applying traditional legal principles to new and evolving technologies.
- 9:43Okay. Let's let's I wanna read this one again.
- 9:46In the concluding remarks, the judge underscored that while the use of code to communicate
- 9:52ideas may be protected under the First Amendment,
- 9:55using that code to facilitate illegal
- 9:58activities
- 9:59is not. And again,
- 10:01we're gonna be reading something about Gary Gensler
- 10:07and his thoughts
- 10:08and potential impact
- 10:10on communication
- 10:12protocols.
- 10:14Do you see where this is going? If you don't see where this is going yet,
- 10:18then keep this story in mind as we when we're when we get to the Gary Gensler story. Okay? Because that's next. I I put that up next.
- 10:27But first,
- 10:29this is
- 10:31a terrifying
- 10:32prospect
- 10:34that code is free speech. We keep saying that. You know, the code behind Bitcoin is free speech.
- 10:40SHA256
- 10:41and the algorithm for very many, you know, cryptographic
- 10:45functions
- 10:46is free speech.
- 10:47Right? It's no longer munitions.
- 10:49It's protected free speech.
- 10:51But yet, here we have a court that's trying to make a distinction.
- 10:56Saying, yeah, well, code is free speech, but what you use it for
- 11:01if the code is used for something that we deem unacceptable,
- 11:05no longer does the protection of the First Amendment apply.
- 11:12Do you see the what
- 11:14ugly ass precedent this set sets?
- 11:18Right?
- 11:19Especially when we get to this next one. Keep all this in mind because Gary Gensler
- 11:24is going to rule
- 11:26on SEC
- 11:27licensing requirement
- 11:29for communications
- 11:31protocols.
- 11:32Gonna read it again.
- 11:34Gensler to rule on SEC licensing requirements for communication
- 11:39protocols.
- 11:40This is Lola Leitz from her,
- 11:44publication named The Rage.
- 11:46That's Lola Leitz
- 11:48from The Rage.
- 11:49In remarks before the 10th annual US Treasury Market Conference,
- 11:54SEC chair Gary Gensler has expressed intent to rule on amendments to rule 3 b dash 16 of the Exchange Act by November.
- 12:05The amendments expand the definition of the term exchange
- 12:09to include, quote,
- 12:11systems that bring together buyers and sellers of securities
- 12:15that offer the use of non firm trading interest
- 12:18and provide
- 12:20another type of non discretionary method,
- 12:23I. E. Communication
- 12:25protocols.
- 12:27The proposed amendments would require that these systems register as National Securities Exchanges
- 12:32or as broker dealers and comply with regulation.
- 12:36End
- 12:39quote.
- 12:41Okay.
- 12:42I'm just pausing a little bit because the impact of this is kind of bowling me over a little bit, especially coming off of what we just read.
- 12:50Alright.
- 12:52Is it to be
- 12:55that when I zap somebody through the Nostra communication protocol
- 12:59that this the code the expressive code
- 13:04of the Noster protocol is protected free speech in the United States under the First Amendment.
- 13:09But the fact that I zapped somebody using that protocol
- 13:13now causes me to be using that code in an illegal manner.
- 13:18See where this goes. You see how bad this is? Now, let's not take it as a zap. Let's say, ah, David, you're tinfoil hatting again. Please stop. Stop doing that. Okay. Okay. I'll stop. I promise. I'll stop. But what if we're using the Nostra communication protocol
- 13:34to set up,
- 13:37me opening a channel with your lightning node or vice versa?
- 13:40Are we getting closer to what Gary Gensler wants to rule on?
- 13:44Are we getting closer
- 13:45to the judge and the tornado cache and their interpretation of what is and is not protected free speech?
- 13:51See how these are working in tandem. The tornado cache and Gary Gensler
- 13:57ruling on what a communication protocol
- 14:01is and whether or not it should be required to be registered as a fucking exchange
- 14:05is starting to really concern me.
- 14:08Which is one of the reasons why I will reiterate it again. If you are working on Freedom Tech, please, for the love of God, do not use your name.
- 14:17Use a pseudonym.
- 14:19Never tell anybody that you're working on it, not even your friends, if at all possible.
- 14:24I know that that sounds extreme,
- 14:26but I'm starting to wonder how extreme the other side of this equation is getting. I'm more I'm more worried about them being extreme
- 14:33than us being extreme.
- 14:36So let's continue. The proposed amendment
- 14:38has received 180 comments since 2022,
- 14:42many of which appear to be critical of the the overly broad language
- 14:48applied. As the advocacy and research center coin center submitted, quote,
- 14:52the proposed rule as drafted would not withstand constitutional scrutiny as the proposed definition directly describes the publication of speech as a necessary and sufficient condition
- 15:03for the registration requirement.
- 15:05Merely making available a communications
- 15:08protocol can, by the SEC's own admission,
- 15:12trigger an obligation to register.
- 15:14A communications protocol is commonly understood as a set of rules.
- 15:18Making available
- 15:20a set of rules is an awkward linguistic
- 15:23construction that must,
- 15:24at the very least, include publishing
- 15:28and speaking,
- 15:29which are core First Amendment activities.
- 15:32By way of example, Corning Center argues,
- 15:35is Twitter's general communications protocol a negotiation protocol when users take advantage of the dollar sign to create a cash tag
- 15:44making stock names and ticker symbols accompanied by the price quote a trading interest?
- 15:50End quote.
- 15:51Criticizing the SEC's consideration of rewording the category of communications protocols
- 15:56to negotiation
- 15:58protocols,
- 15:59Coin Center argues that a dictionary contains a protocol for appropriate use of the English language,
- 16:04a communications protocol.
- 16:06But a subset of terms in that dictionary
- 16:09can be used by buyers and sellers of securities to interact and negotiate the terms of a trade,
- 16:15a negotiations
- 16:16protocol.
- 16:18One might be able to publish a dictionary that includes
- 16:22only these terms and successfully
- 16:24queue narrowly to a definition of making available a negotiation protocol,
- 16:29Coin Center adds. But
- 16:32one would have great difficulty publishing a useful English dictionary
- 16:36that contained every term
- 16:38except the terms that buyers and sellers might use to negotiate said trade.
- 16:43The SEC could easily use the proposed vague standard to target certain publishers
- 16:49of open source software who advocate for the use of that software for certain political ends.
- 16:55Arguably,
- 16:56the commission has already displayed a pattern of behavior of using its flexible regulatory power for viewpoint discrimination
- 17:04against developers of cryptocurrency
- 17:07or currencies
- 17:08and privacy protecting tools,
- 17:11CoinCenter concluded.
- 17:13Quote, as an investor,
- 17:15I understand the need to modernize regulations to address gaps in oversize
- 17:19in oversight of electronic trading systems, one anonymous commenter writes.
- 17:25Quote, defining an exchange as any system with non firm trading interest is excessively broad and vague. This could unintentionally
- 17:35encompass a wide range of communication platform
- 17:38sorry, platforms
- 17:39and online forums that enable discussion about said transactions
- 17:44but do not themselves execute trades or constitute regulated exchanges.
- 17:49Regulatory
- 17:51uncertainty surrounding licensing requirements for software publishers have dominated questions on compliance among developers since
- 17:59of Tornado Cash developers Roman Storm and Roman Seminar in August of 2023. See how this winds back?
- 18:06Storm and Seminar, who developed a non custodial privacy protocol for the cryptocurrency
- 18:11Ethereum,
- 18:12are charged with conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money transmitting business,
- 18:17conspiracy to commit money laundering,
- 18:20and conspiracy
- 18:21to violate sanctions.
- 18:23The pair are awaiting a jury trial in December.
- 18:26During the hearings on the case in July, appointed judge
- 18:30Filia
- 18:31or Fila, whatever,
- 18:33asked whether the charges were comparable to criminal criminally charging the creators of WhatsApp
- 18:38because criminals used it.
- 18:40If quote, if tornado cache has 1,000 customers and one is a bad actor, are they criminally liable? End quote.
- 18:48Much of the prosecutors'
- 18:50argumentation
- 18:51in the tornado cache case leans on control
- 18:54of the user interface as equivalent
- 18:57to control of Tornado Cash an argument which appears to stem directly from
- 19:02FATF,
- 19:03or the FATF, recommendations
- 19:05equating control over user interfaces as control over assets
- 19:10in apparent attempts to qualify UI developers as crypto asset service providers
- 19:16to impose licensing
- 19:18requirements.
- 19:19Are you fucking kidding me?
- 19:22I can't design a user experience or a user interface
- 19:26that has something to do with bitcoin
- 19:29and not be considered
- 19:31providing control of the asset?
- 19:34And have to be licensed to do so?
- 19:39Interesting.
- 19:41Similar charges have been brought against
- 19:44developers of the non custodial Bitcoin privacy wallet, SamuraI Wallet
- 19:48These charges arise
- 19:50from the defendant's development,
- 19:52marketing, and operation of cryptocurrency mixer that executed over $2,000,000,000
- 19:57in unlawful transactions and facilitated
- 20:00more than
- 20:01$100,000,000 in money laundering transactions
- 20:03from illegal dark web markets. The DOJ stated in a press release surrounding the arrest probably in my and I'm saying this for myself, probably without a shred of fucking evidence, but whatever.
- 20:15Goddamn whole thing's Kafkaesque. If you've ever read the trial from,
- 20:19Franz Kafka
- 20:21or I think it's Franz Kafka Kafka.
- 20:24K
- 20:24a f k a. Okay. Kafka.
- 20:27Go read the trial.
- 20:29Just go read the trial and then
- 20:32relisten to this episode and then go listen to my episode on Ranch Wars.
- 20:37We're talking about the King Ranch and what they're undergoing. They were under they were under full investigation for over a year and they never even knew it.
- 20:45Go read the trial from Kafka. Just go do that. Now, let's finish this off.
- 20:51In an in the EU,
- 20:53Telegram founder Pavel Durov was recently been charged with laundering of the proceeds derived from organized groups offenses and crimes.
- 21:02While not much is known about the charges, industry experts who wish to remain anonymous have told The Rage that the charges may be less related to Telegram's issuing of the cryptocurrency
- 21:11TON, t o n, and rather related to the fact that criminals may have utilized
- 21:17Telegram messenger to plan,
- 21:19coordinate,
- 21:20and possibly execute
- 21:22transactions
- 21:22violating
- 21:23AML and CTF
- 21:25and sanctions
- 21:26laws.
- 21:28Alex Pertsev,
- 21:29the 3rd developer of the Tornado Cash Protocol, was convicted of laundering 1
- 21:35$200,000,000 by a Dutch court in May of 2024 and sentenced to over 5 years in prison.
- 21:41In written remarks, Gensler stated that
- 21:44a lot has changed in the capital market since the initial introduction of alternative trading systems
- 21:49regulations in
- 21:511998 quote the challenge
- 21:53in our times is to bring reforms to ensure that they are as efficient
- 21:57and resilient
- 21:59as they can be it's critical to taxpayers yes to the taxpayers oh somebody think of the taxpayers for fuck's sake. To the capital markets, to monetary policy, and the role of the dollar around the globe.
- 22:13Given the evidentiary
- 22:15hostile environment
- 22:16for software developers
- 22:18and communication
- 22:19service pry providers today,
- 22:21it seems unlikely that the proposed amendments to the Exchange Act would not be abused
- 22:26to further crackdown on dissenting developers
- 22:29if the applied language remains as broad as drafted.
- 22:34Okay. That that that's it. That's the thing.
- 22:38Gensler
- 22:39getting to choose who and who is not a communications protocol
- 22:44which completely circumvents the Federal Communications Commission, the FCC.
- 22:49How is it that Gensler has anything at all to do
- 22:53with labeling
- 22:55electronic communications
- 22:56protocols
- 22:58as anything?
- 23:01This
- 23:03this is scope creep
- 23:05that's what this is this is the SEC
- 23:09allowing scope creep to occur
- 23:12and now they're starting to envelop the Federal Communications Commission's
- 23:16mandate.
- 23:17This is FCC,
- 23:19100%.
- 23:21Do you like, at one point or another, is Gary Gensler gonna be able to
- 23:25give me a license to as a as a radio network operator?
- 23:30Like, I get, hey man, it's Dave in the morning on 98.1
- 23:34FM.
- 23:35But I gotta go get a license for that shit. Do I go to the FCC or do I go to fucking Gary Gensler?
- 23:41Who? Who do I go to?
- 23:43If I want to be a ham radio operator, who do I talk to now?
- 23:48Do I go to the FCC to get a ham radio operators license or do I go call Gary Gensler's office at the Securities Exchange Commission?
- 23:57This,
- 23:58what's happening here,
- 24:00is the way you lose entire countries,
- 24:03republics,
- 24:04federations,
- 24:05states,
- 24:07populations.
- 24:08This is how it occurs.
- 24:10But one of the ways, it's not the only way, but it certainly is
- 24:13endemic
- 24:14of a failing empire
- 24:16that at this point
- 24:18is gasping for air,
- 24:21grasping for the last
- 24:23thread that they can hang on to before they go under the water.
- 24:27All we have to do is stand back and
- 24:30let them die.
- 24:32Just let them die.
- 24:35But the communication
- 24:37stuff doesn't really get we're not over the communication stuff, but we are gonna shift gears
- 24:43just a little bit. We're gonna talk a little bit about DNS.
- 24:46Now I had a discussion with with a guy on, like, you know, we had a Zoom call together. I'm not gonna tell you who it is, but I'm pretty sure that that my fellow brother
- 24:56is listening. So I enjoyed our discussion the other day. We will have it again. You will get on the show. We are going to figure this out. But I want to raise the flag
- 25:05about
- 25:07domain name servers
- 25:08DNS.
- 25:09Right? Just just the whole
- 25:11just think of everything that is DNS. Now
- 25:14I think I'm safe in saying that what for those that don't know, I think I'm safe in saying or giving
- 25:23a a a describing what a DNS is for those that don't know. When you go to a website
- 25:28and you type in, I don't know, axis of easy.com,
- 25:33That that's not how you get to the domain.
- 25:36That goes to a domain name server, and the domain name server kinda looks at it and says, I'm pretty sure I gotta I I it looks it looks through its own phone book. And then it looks up the name that you gave it axisofeasy.com
- 25:50and it says, oh there's the phone number, the IP address. It's like looking at a phone book. It's like you got the name of somebody but you don't know exactly how to get them on the communications
- 26:00protocol
- 26:01that we call
- 26:03the AT and T telephone network. So I go to my phone book. That's the DNS.
- 26:08And I look up the name of the guy that I wanna call. And his name is axis of easy. So I go to the a's, and then I go all the way down to the bottom of the a's where it's ax and then I look for axis of easy and I find it. I go to the right hand side and there's a telephone number
- 26:22in the format of an IP address.
- 26:25That is what gets returned to your browser and that's how your browser connects with the actual website
- 26:31that's providing the information
- 26:33from axisofeasy.com.
- 26:36That's how this works.
- 26:38So keep that in mind as we read
- 26:41this one entitled Malaysia Blocks Global DNS Resolvers,
- 26:46another salvo in the censorship battle.
- 26:49The Malaysian government has recently ordered all internet service providers
- 26:54within the country
- 26:56to block access to global
- 26:59DNS
- 27:00resolvers
- 27:01and they have
- 27:02until
- 27:04Monday,
- 27:04September 30th
- 27:06to fully comply.
- 27:08That's this September.
- 27:10Let me make sure about the date.
- 27:12This story was written September 8th this year by Mark e Jeftvich,
- 27:18September 8, 2024,
- 27:20this month. And they have until the end of the month, September 30th, to fully comply with blocking
- 27:26global DNS resolvers.
- 27:28All the ISPs in Malaysia have to do this.
- 27:32This act of digital gatekeeping,
- 27:35also known as censorship,
- 27:37is being justified under the guise of protecting the public from online harms.
- 27:42But like all overreaching government initiatives, it feels more like an exercise in censorship disguised to safety.
- 27:49So what's going on in Malaysia anyway? Well, briefly,
- 27:52the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission has decreed
- 27:56that the solution to controlling quote harmful content online
- 28:00is to enforce
- 28:01strict control
- 28:03over how internet users resolve domain names.
- 28:07Now, let's for anybody who's confused, because I gave you the the definition of DNS.
- 28:13When I look at a phone book and I look up Joe Smith's name to get his phone number, I'm resolving his name to the phone number.
- 28:21When I go to accessofeasy.com,
- 28:24my browser goes to DNS and says, I need you to resolve accessofeasy.com
- 28:29and return to me an IP address that I can that I know what to do with. That's what they mean by resolve continuing.
- 28:37They're essentially blocking people
- 28:40from using global DNS services like Google Public DNS,
- 28:46Quad9
- 28:47Cloudflare and others by redirecting
- 28:49all DNS traffic to local services or servers that are under their control.
- 28:56Why does this matter?
- 28:58Because controlling DNS
- 29:00is controlling access to the entirety of the internet at least for your people.
- 29:04You can't visit a website, send an email, watch a video, or have a chat session without translating
- 29:09the underlying host names like access.com
- 29:14into an IP address
- 29:16by resolving it with a DNS.
- 29:19When your government controls that process, it gives them the ability to decide what you can
- 29:26and cannot access.
- 29:28This is basically Orwellian,
- 29:29like, for reals. Here in Canada,
- 29:32we're watching this unfold closely.
- 29:35The looming C-sixty
- 29:36three quote online harms legislation
- 29:39is cooking up a similar brew, and it's something that the Internet Society of Canada has been flagging for a while now. I sit on their board. And this is exactly the kind of mission creep. We also know that as scope creep, and we just talked about it with Gensler and the FCC SEC.
- 29:55We've been warning about or warning against,
- 29:59also former CEO of the Global Internet Society, Andrew Sullivan, who is Canadian, wrote this post about the Canadian bill earlier this year, and that is at internetsociety.org.
- 30:10What what was it?
- 30:12What governments
- 30:13can learn from Canada when regulating online harms is the name of that particular one. Okay. So make no mistake. Protecting from online harms is censorship. Pure and simple.
- 30:23The phrase, protecting the public from online harms, is thrown around as a catch all rationale for governments that want tighter control over what their citizens see
- 30:32and hear online.
- 30:34Malaysia is saying they want to curb the spread of misinformation,
- 30:38extremism, and illegal content by clamping down on DNS services. And in their minds, if they control the DNS,
- 30:45they control the flow of information.
- 30:48DNS is a fundamental
- 30:51primary choke point for the Internet.
- 30:54Unfortunately, it's been designed in a
- 30:57comparatively decentralized
- 30:58manner, so controlling it isn't easy.
- 31:03Malaysia's
- 31:04MCMC
- 31:05has come out swinging in defense of their DNS redirection and website blocking.
- 31:11The government is focusing on platforms that allegedly spread disinformation and undesirable content. However,
- 31:17what seems undesirable
- 31:19is a gray area that expands to include political critique, oppositional voices, and even satire.
- 31:25Fortunately, it's relatively simple to set up a DNS resolver.
- 31:29And it didn't take long for people to begin sharing the details on how to do it across social media.
- 31:35Threads have popped up all over Reddit such as this one where Malaysian
- 31:40netizens
- 31:41are discussing workarounds.
- 31:42If you're reasonably tech savvy,
- 31:45defined as knowing your way around a UNIX shell, then running your own DNS server isn't exactly rocket science.
- 31:51The main challenge is sidestepping the ISP's block on port number 53,
- 31:57which is the standard port for DNS traffic.
- 32:01But even that has solutions.
- 32:03The trick is to use DNS over HTTPS
- 32:07or DNS over TLS,
- 32:11respectively known as DOH and DOT. Both of these protocols encrypt your DNS queries, making it harder for ISPs and governments to detect and block them. Even better, you can run these over alternative ports, making it practically impossible for sensors to lock down your DNS traffic. Setting up a DOH client to resolve queries via a cloud provider or a self hosted server can provide a quick escape from the government's filtering. You can also use a VPN service with integrated DNS support that can sidestep such blocks entirely.
- 32:44On a technical level, it's not trivial to do this, but with tools like AI and LLMs now,
- 32:50if you're capable of typing, reading, and copy pasting,
- 32:53you probably can. To give you an idea of just how far things are going, I whipped out these detailed instructions via chat gpt
- 33:01on how to set up a doh or d0tdns
- 33:04resolver on an alternate port
- 33:06and configure a macbook pro to use it for its dns queries and it took all of
- 33:1215 seconds.
- 33:13Even if Malaysia tightened its grips on these protocols
- 33:17open source tools like DNScrypt
- 33:20and local proxy resolvers still offer ways to thwart centralized control.
- 33:26I wasn't aware
- 33:27of the Malaysia DNS blocking until EasyDNS
- 33:31was mentioned in one of those Reddit threads as a potential alternative
- 33:34DNS provider. And to be clear,
- 33:37EasyDNS
- 33:38is not a DNS resolver.
- 33:40We provide authoritative
- 33:42DNS which means we help websites and domains stay online
- 33:46by ensuring their DNS records resolve correctly. We don't resolve queries
- 33:51for individual internet users.
- 33:55Malaysia is not the 1st country to attempt something like this. And they certainly will not be the last.
- 34:03We're seeing a disturbing trend where governments feel entitled to dictate how their citizens can access the web.
- 34:10Whether it's DNS censorship, blocking VPNs, or passing sweeping laws that criminalize
- 34:15online speech,
- 34:16the overarching
- 34:17theme is the same.
- 34:19Clamp down on digital freedom under the guise of public safety.
- 34:24As with any battle for control, there will always be those who fight back. The fact that people in Malaysia are already figuring out how to circumvent these blocks shows that you can't fully suppress the human desire for free expression.
- 34:35Tools like encrypted DNS and VPNs are just the start. The harder governments try to tighten their grip, the more creative people will become in finding ways around it.
- 34:46All right, so
- 34:48that's pretty much the article.
- 34:51That pretty much goes hand in hand with everything
- 34:56else.
- 34:57Alright?
- 34:58Gensler
- 34:59overstepping his boundaries to encroach on the FCC or the Federal Communications
- 35:04Commission territory
- 35:05is
- 35:06eye watering. And the fact that
- 35:09I could go out and I could probably strike up a conversation with some unknown gentleman at a bar over a beer and say, hey, did you know that this is occurring? And describe it to him in just a few sentences. I mean, not even getting on a soapbox. And he probably just his eyes would probably just glaze over and just doesn't give a shit.
- 35:24SEC, FCC, it rhymes.
- 35:26They must be the same. I'm serious, man. It's probably it probably goes off like that in most people's heads nowadays because they're worried about whether or not they can afford food at McDonald's.
- 35:37That's what all this shit does. That's what the the outside of this FCC,
- 35:42SEC, the tornado cash thing,
- 35:44this DNS attack in Malaysia.
- 35:47Is it like, it'll glaze people's eyes over because they're being distracted
- 35:51by all this other shit.
- 35:54Iran,
- 35:55Hezbollah,
- 35:57Israel,
- 35:58Ukraine,
- 35:59Putin,
- 36:00Russia.
- 36:01The elections are coming up. They can't afford Safeway, so now they're going to Walmart. They can't afford Walmart. So now they're begging that the dollar menu from fucking McDonald's comes back. They're just on their knees begging for any relief whatsoever. And when you tell them
- 36:15that it's already happening in Malaysia, that the DNS is being blocked and that goes hand in hand with Gary Gensler's overstepping the FCC
- 36:23and the tornado cash stuff on they're not gonna care. They're just not gonna care and they have no idea what it means for their future.
- 36:31It's up to us to figure out a way to get them to understand in a way that does not make their not only does not make their eyes glaze over, but where they actually understand it.
- 36:40So the gentleman that turned me on to this Malaysian DNS attack
- 36:45is saying that we should probably be raising flags to the developers of Nostr.
- 36:50I know they know.
- 36:52I know Fiat Joff knows about this. I know that j b that Will Kessarin or jb 55 from Thomas knows about it. I know hazard 183
- 37:02knows about it. I know all the developers of all the nostril clients know
- 37:07this. And there's a lot of nostril people that are not nostril developers and they know about this shit too. But in case you're wondering,
- 37:15if your only communication protocol is to pick up the phone and dial, what is it,
- 37:208 numbers.
- 37:21Like, 1 what was it? No. Well, they no. Seven numbers. Yeah. Seven numbers without the area code and country code. Just like 7 numbers in the United States and that's how you get to talk to somebody else on the other end of city, but you don't have a phone book and you don't have any other way to look up the friend's name you know
- 37:39to resolve it to the phone number of your friends so that you can call them on that protocol, what is that gonna do?
- 37:46What if you don't know let's let's take it one step further
- 37:51there's no phone book there's no 911
- 37:54there's not all you have is a phone and you need to figure out the 7 digits to call the hospital because your loved one needs an ambulance and they need it right now
- 38:04just pretend there's no such thing as 911
- 38:07alright
- 38:08you got to figure out how to get a hold of the hospital or the ambulance company to send an ambulance and there's no phone book. That's what this is.
- 38:19Now extend that to the entirety of the Internet.
- 38:22Paying your bill, DNS.
- 38:25Gonna send an email, DNS is involved.
- 38:28Do you need to go to your friend's website and work on it because your friend is paying you $50 to make sure that it's up and running? Need DNS.
- 38:38If there's no phone book,
- 38:40the phone on the wall is worthless.
- 38:43If there's no DNS,
- 38:45the internet is worthless.
- 38:47We've allowed this to occur. Like
- 38:49this said,
- 38:50this article said, and my friend said, it's lucky that there is at least
- 38:56a slightly decentralized
- 38:58nature to DNS,
- 39:01but that that's not enough.
- 39:04I posit
- 39:05that baby,
- 39:06like, I'd said look I know I'm being naive but let's say that we're just using Nostr and every time that we like, you know, like I just hook up like Nostr or rather I I like let's say I've got Albie, which I do. I've got Albie extension. It's got my private key my public key. Let's say that
- 39:23through Nostr WalletConnect,
- 39:26I'm able to somehow tell Albie and the Nostra Wallet Connect that, hey,
- 39:33use my Nsec and NPUB
- 39:36to read
- 39:37every single website that I go to
- 39:40send it as an event
- 39:42to a relay where that website is stored
- 39:46along with the returned,
- 39:48resolved
- 39:48IP address.
- 39:50And make and, in what I didn't say is like, yes, if you go to bad websites
- 39:56and it's attached to your your insect
- 39:58this could be a problem.
- 40:00We have a technology
- 40:02that is able to de identify
- 40:04subjects
- 40:05and
- 40:06get them away from their data that they provide to, like, medical studies. Nobody knows that Alice Smith is 87 years old and has type 2 diabetes.
- 40:16After the study, all they know is that
- 40:20patient number 124
- 40:23is 87 years old, is a female,
- 40:25and has type 2 diabetes.
- 40:28We can
- 40:29we're not stupid. We can figure out a way to de anonymize a SEND
- 40:33that I authorize with my insect
- 40:36to a relay,
- 40:37but somehow or another be able to pull my insect back so that the only thing that's left
- 40:42is
- 40:43the name of the person I'm looking up and their fucking telephone number. And if everybody's doing that, then we're continuously
- 40:50refreshing and rebuilding
- 40:52a completely
- 40:53ancillary DNS system.
- 40:55That's as far as I can take it. I don't know how to do this shit.
- 40:59All that I know is that this is a very dangerous situation.
- 41:02And with Gensler overstepping FCC boundaries,
- 41:06with tornado cash guys and the the judge in that case starting to try to make distinctions between
- 41:12essential code
- 41:13and executable code and your intent of use of code,
- 41:18This is not going to end well unless we start fighting back. And no. The answer is not. Well, we should have a protest.
- 41:25Let's go put on our coats and go walk around in a circle in a blinding blizzard so that then they'll feel sorry for us. And then they'll do everything that we want them to do. No. It doesn't work that way. Anybody listening to my voice that hasn't heard the last couple of shows where I basically take a great big giant shit all over your fucking protest has not been listening to the show. Or if you have been listening to that, you're not getting the point.
- 41:47Protest is a waste of time.
- 41:51It is a waste of your time it's a waste of my time to read about I don't care about your protest it's never going to work it never has worked nobody
- 41:58cares
- 42:00what do you do?
- 42:02Freedom tech.
- 42:05Be the mud that squishes out between the fingers of Moff Tarkin in Star Wars when all homegirl Princess Leia is going the more you tighten your grip, Tarkin,
- 42:16the more star systems will slip through your fingers.
- 42:19That's the water
- 42:21that Bruce Lee was talking about when he said be be like water.
- 42:26Be like water. Be like mud. Be that which cannot be contained.
- 42:31Be able to split yourself off in a 1000000 pieces and then regroup on the other side like the mud coming out between the fingers of somebody who thinks that they're gonna crush something. Fuck them. Fuck them to death. Let's run the numbers.
- 42:54CNBC Futures and Commodities Oil, West Texas Intermediate is up today after getting just
- 42:59basted
- 43:01on the,
- 43:02roast on the spit roasting it got yesterday.
- 43:0590 0.99 percent to the upside, 6834.
- 43:08Brittnortheast up
- 43:093 quarters of point to 7214.
- 43:12Natural gas doing what it always does, 5 and a half percent to the upside, $2.90
- 43:18per 1,000 cubic feet. Gasoline rose slightly to a buck 96 a gallon.
- 43:23Shiny metal rocks are having a bad day.
- 43:26Gold is down almost a point, but it's still above 26100 to 2671.
- 43:31Silver is down 1 and a half, but it's at $31.80.
- 43:36Platinum is down. Scant copper is down over a point. Palladium is over 2 points.
- 43:41Just damn near 3 points. Ag, biggest winner today is
- 43:46soybean.
- 43:482.5%
- 43:49to the upside.
- 43:50Biggest loser is sugar, 2.63
- 43:52to the downside. Live cattle,
- 43:54everything's moving sideways. No. Not everything. Live cattle's moving sideways, but it is in the green.
- 43:59Lean hogs is down a third, but feeder cattle are up a third. The Dow is up a third, but the S and P is down 0.13%.
- 44:07NASDAQ down damn near a half, and the S and P Mini moving sideways but in the green.
- 44:12Oh, and Bitcoin.
- 44:14Oh, god. We passed back down through 65,000?
- 44:18Assholes. We had a clear shot of 66,300
- 44:22earlier today, but now I've gotta give you 65,950.
- 44:26That is a $1,300,000,000,000
- 44:28market cap. We can buy 24.8
- 44:30ounces of shiny metal rocks with our 1 Bitcoin, of which there are 19,000,000
- 44:35759,458.62
- 44:38of, and average fees per block have risen
- 44:41precipitously
- 44:42today.
- 44:43We're at almost
- 44:44a tenth of a BTC.
- 44:470.09 BTC
- 44:48in fees on average on a per block basis, of which there are 100 blocks
- 44:54carrying almost 200,000
- 44:56unconfirmed transactions
- 44:57waiting to clear it double digits.
- 45:00Wow. 16 satoshis
- 45:02per vbyte for high priority, low priority, gonna get you in
- 45:06at 12 satoshis per vbyte.
- 45:08Hash rate, what's it doing? Oh,
- 45:11554
- 45:13exahashes per second. We are way down. We are 200 exahashes
- 45:18per second down off of our highs. Wow. I wonder what happened.
- 45:23Oh, well, I don't really care. We're gonna be fine. Heckles for shekels, which was Bitcoin and episode
- 45:30961.
- 45:31I got mister sat stacker with 5,000 sat says great great episode. Thank you. No. Thank you.
- 45:38Bitcoin Sandy with a 1,000 says love the chats. Fire emoji.
- 45:43Saints and sat666.
- 45:45Oh. Number of the beast boost for cashless Israel, he says. God's death 537.
- 45:50Thank you, sir. No. Thank you. Pies to pleb, 420. Thank you, sir. No. Thank you.
- 45:55And then ending it with Annabelle
- 45:57Handoek
- 45:58with a 100 sats says, thank you for the episode. No. I appreciate you listening to the episode. That's the weather report.
- 46:14Welcome to part 2 of the news you can use.
- 46:17Swan Bitcoin claims that former employees
- 46:20and Tether
- 46:22conspired to steal its mining
- 46:25business.
- 46:26Liz Napoletano
- 46:27is writing this one for decrypt.
- 46:31Bitcoin company Swan. Swan Bitcoin alleged in a lawsuit filed on Wednesday that ex employees of the company, including former executives,
- 46:40usurp
- 46:42the firm's Bitcoin mining
- 46:43business. The company further alleges that the scheme was aided by Tether, the cryptocurrency giant responsible for issuing the
- 46:55industry's largest stablecoin by market capitalization
- 46:58USDT.
- 47:00Pausing to put the meme in your head
- 47:03of the 3 people from Harry Potter standing before the teacher, and she looks at them and says, why is it that when trouble occurs, it's always you
- 47:123? Swan Bitcoin,
- 47:13Tether, and I'm just waiting on the third one. Okay. The complaint
- 47:18filed in the district court for the central district of California, oh, at least it's not in New York, alleges that the former employee stole highly proprietary
- 47:27code from Swan's Bitcoin Mining Monitoring Software
- 47:31in addition to stealing its vendors and business partners.
- 47:34The employees conspired to resign en masse
- 47:38and create a competing company called Proton Management, Swan Bitcoin alleges.
- 47:43Quote, the evidence of
- 47:45sorry. Excuse me. The defendants
- 47:47ah, my god. I'm having a having an attack here. An attack of stupid.
- 47:51The evidence
- 47:52of the defendant's
- 47:54brazen theft is overwhelming, Swan's lawyer said in the complaint. The former employees were stealing the crown jewels from Swan's Bitcoin mining business.
- 48:04Representatives for Tether and Proton,
- 48:07well, they didn't respond to decrypt's request for comments. I don't blame them. Swan's lawyers alleged that one of the Bitcoin firm's
- 48:14former executive, Swan vice president of institutional
- 48:18operations and research Brett Hilly
- 48:21downloaded more than 300 confidential
- 48:24documents
- 48:25from Swan's Google Drive, including mining inventory and performance data sheets, as well as a log of analyses of all the firm's mining sites and operations.
- 48:34Proton's
- 48:35employees were also allegedly solicited,
- 48:39or said to be allegedly solicited Swan's mining personnel in addition to appropriating Swan's financing partner, Tether, for its own operations in an attempt
- 48:44to
- 48:45partner, Tether, for its own operations in an
- 48:48attempt to irreparably harm Swan's ability to compete in the market, the complaint states. The scheme, in part, hinged on Tether delivering
- 48:54Swan with a default notice
- 49:00that would provide the legal cover for the hostile takeover,
- 49:03Swan alleges.
- 49:05Proton CEO
- 49:07Rafael
- 49:07Zaghuri,
- 49:08which was then chief investment officer at Swan,
- 49:12made a concerted effort to sow dissent and chaos at Swan in an attempt
- 49:17to galvanize Swan employees to defect from the company according to the lawsuit.
- 49:22From there, Zaguri and his alleged coconspirators
- 49:25attempted to force Swan CEO, Klipston,
- 49:28to resign
- 49:29and plotted to ensure that Swan would accept
- 49:32wind down capital from Tether,
- 49:35the Bitcoin
- 49:36firm's lawyer said. Oh, man. This is bad. Just 4 days after the employees resigned from Swan,
- 49:42including Zagury,
- 49:43who also served as their head of mining,
- 49:46quote, Tether, Swan's funding partner in its mining operation, notified Swan that the defendant, Proton,
- 49:53would be taking over day to day Bitcoin Mining Management in their joint venture.
- 49:59Oh, god.
- 50:01This
- 50:03this is bad.
- 50:05This is really bad.
- 50:07SWAN is still investigating its former executives and employees'
- 50:11alleged collection of its proprietary data and trade secrets in addition
- 50:16to the circumstances of the resignations the complaint shows, and a representative for Swan declined Decrypt's request for comment. Yeah. Of course. It's ongoing. It's too new. The Bitcoin firm is seeking a permanent injunction
- 50:28against Proton
- 50:30that would prevent the company from further disrupting Swan's mining business and is asking the court to compel the former employees
- 50:36to return stolen equipment and confidential material.
- 50:40Swan has asked the court for a jury trial and for damages to be determined at the trial. And you might be asking me what my gut feeling is. Swann's gonna win.
- 50:49That's gonna be that's my gut feeling. And
- 50:52why would I say that? Well, Swann has had a hell of a hell of a year.
- 50:58Actually, they've had a hell of a last 2 years
- 51:00for like like beginning
- 51:03I I can't even remember exactly when Texas told Swan to piss off,
- 51:07but they did. The state of Texas told Swan, uh-uh, uh-uh, you ain't servicing any customers
- 51:13because your 3rd party,
- 51:16whoever's holding the Bitcoin
- 51:18for you in your customer's name,
- 51:21we don't like them. We don't think they're above board. You're gonna stop doing business in the state of Texas. And then a few other states went along for the ride and it really hurts Swan Bitcoin's business.
- 51:32And they roll on. They kept going. They kept going. They kept going.
- 51:36And then
- 51:37they finally got Texas they finally got another custodian.
- 51:41And it wasn't my favorite choice but they did make a choice that they switched custodians, it made Texas happy, made a whole bunch of other states happy. So then we could resume, like, you know, buying Bitcoin,
- 51:52like, once a week, every week, like I set up our family companies to do.
- 51:56And we've now resumed,
- 51:58buying bitcoin pretty much on the weekly. But right after that,
- 52:02Swan announced this major mining venture.
- 52:05I was like,
- 52:06damn. They're really going whole hog. And they were, like, basically, like, bankrolling all the podcasters in the space, except for me, of course, because, you know, nobody wants to sponsor me. But that that that's me feeling sorry for myself. I'm just saying that they were basically bankrolling like all the podcasters.
- 52:22And a lot of them got hurt when Swan said, we can't
- 52:26advertise anymore on anybody's podcast.
- 52:29This was a major
- 52:31major advertiser
- 52:32for a lot of my favorite podcast, and I could tell that it hurt. It hurt these guys,
- 52:38you know, and it's like, god dang it.
- 52:40Now
- 52:41now this.
- 52:43Now this.
- 52:45And I'm wondering, it's got to be connected.
- 52:48When when Swan said, hey, we're laying off a bunch of people.
- 52:51It's like, you know, this downturn is kinda hurting us and it's like, you know, we've had some you know, we've had a couple of bad years and all that kind of stuff and we all understood.
- 52:59But so, you know, I I still like Corey.
- 53:02But this is just
- 53:06it really got to them to the point that they gotta lay off a bunch of people and then all of a sudden they basically told all they pulled all their advertising from anywhere they were advertising to save money.
- 53:17And then all of a sudden we get this shit.
- 53:20It's got to be related.
- 53:22Alright. So do I know that for a fact? No, I don't. Have I ever spoken to Corey Clipston himself? No, I haven't. I'm just letting you know I'm not anywhere close to this. You're getting what I'm getting. Okay?
- 53:36But this thing?
- 53:37What we're I mean the fact that Tether called Corey
- 53:41and said: Oh, by the way, that mining deal that we had that we made a big old fanfare about a few months ago, yeah, that's over. We're gonna let Proton do it.
- 53:51This is bad.
- 53:52But somehow,
- 53:54my gut feeling suggests that that Swan's gonna win. Is it wishful thinking? Maybe.
- 54:00Swan's been around a long time, the good bitcoiners.
- 54:03Sure, they've they've
- 54:05they've fucked up a couple of times, but honestly in this space, it's surprising that not that everybody hasn't fucked up to the point of damn near disaster.
- 54:13So I'm just gonna let that one go. I'm just I'm I'm over it. I'm done. I'm not gonna hate on Corey and and Swan Bitcoin for any reason whatsoever. They've always been pretty good Joes.
- 54:24So my but my gut feeling really is is that somehow this is so terrible
- 54:30that what what has what has occurred here is so awful. It is probably so blatant and and
- 54:36it sounds to me like a bunch of mistakes were made by the people that started this proton thing
- 54:41that in court it's gonna be easy to prove that they were in in possession of stolen
- 54:47trade secrets.
- 54:48They were probably in possession of stolen code that was proprietary.
- 54:52They're probably in possession of, like, business materials and intelligence that they should not have unless they are an employee
- 55:00of Swan. And when they left Swan and took the materials with them, they were no longer employees.
- 55:05And by all rights should have given all that information back. I get the feeling all this shit's gonna be found in discovery and it's gonna be an open and shut case.
- 55:13And who's on the hook?
- 55:16Tether is now exposed.
- 55:19USDT
- 55:21and the company behind it, Tether, that everybody makes fun of well, not they don't make fun of it because it's like too damn big
- 55:28but like,
- 55:29Bitfinex.
- 55:32That that account kept saying that the whole reason that Bitcoin's price was was what it was, and he's been saying this for the last 5 years, and he's clearly wrong, but he kept saying that there's something wrong with Tether.
- 55:43And now we're, you know, we now understand that Tether is, like, one of the leading purchasers of United States debt in the form of Treasury.
- 55:53And then all of a sudden they're hanging around with a crew of people
- 55:57that clearly stole a bunch of shit from Swan?
- 56:01I don't know, man.
- 56:03Something don't something about this doesn't sit right with me at all, and I think it's gonna be bad. I'm just gonna say it now. It's gonna be bad, but I do think Swan's gonna come out on top.
- 56:15Okay.
- 56:16Let's see. Do we wanna do this one?
- 56:20We're not gonna do that one. We're not gonna do that one, but we are gonna talk about b n y Mellon.
- 56:27BNY Mellon
- 56:28has been approved by your friends at the SEC
- 56:32for crypto custody beyond
- 56:34ETFs,
- 56:35Gensler said.
- 56:37The structure
- 56:38Bank of New York Mellon Corporation
- 56:41is using to offer custody services for digital assets could be used beyond the Bitcoin and ether exchange traded funds that the bank is considering
- 56:50according to SEC
- 56:53commission chair or SEC chair Gary Gensler.
- 56:56Earlier this week, the bank acknowledged that it had presented a plan to the SEC's office of chief accountant to custody those two assets in a way that would protect
- 57:05customer funds in the event of an insolvency.
- 57:09The agency provided BNY with a non objection to the plan, a regulatory term that gives comfort to the bank that its structure
- 57:17will not fall afoul of the agency's requirement that banks reflect the value
- 57:21of the digital assets that they custody on their balance sheet.
- 57:25BNY previously told Bloomberg News that the SEC's non objection was specific
- 57:30to the ETF use case. Quote,
- 57:33though the actual
- 57:35consultation
- 57:35related to 2 crypto assets,
- 57:38the structure itself was not dependent on what the crypto was. Gensler told Bloomberg News on Thursday
- 57:45after he delivered a speech at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York's annual Treasury Market Conference.
- 57:51Quote, it didn't matter what the cryptocurrency
- 57:54was,
- 57:55end quote.
- 57:57The Bitcoin and Ether investment products are the only crypto related ETFs approved
- 58:02so far by the U. S. Regulators.
- 58:04A BNY spokesperson did not immediately respond for a request for comment.
- 58:08BNY's proposed structure includes the use of individual crypto wallets,
- 58:13each of which would have a separate bank account and would be prohibited
- 58:17from being commingled with bank assets.
- 58:20It's up to the bank to decide whether to expand the pool of digital asset use cases it's comfortable custodying,
- 58:26Gensler said. Gensler credited BNY for doing all of the legwork
- 58:31on how to make sure customer assets would remain theirs and that they wouldn't be shunted to the back of the line in case of a bankruptcy.
- 58:401000 of crypto traders have found themselves
- 58:42in that position as a result of the blow up blow ups
- 58:46sorry. Sorry. Blow ups in recent years of the Celsius network, FTX, Voyager Digital, and BlockFi, and all the rest the assholes that are out there that need to be in prison for the rest of their lives and buried in the prison
- 58:58school yard. Whatever. I'm sorry. Ginsler noted that several banks and brokers have been in discussions about potential digital asset custody structures
- 59:05that would segregate customer assets
- 59:08from the banks and thus could also avoid the requirements of staff accounting bulletin 121
- 59:13or that SAB 121 that I was talking about yesterday,
- 59:17the measure laying out the agency's balance sheet requirements for crypto. You know, the industry has vocally complained about SAB 121,
- 59:25one of its litany of complaints regarding the Gensler's administration
- 59:28aggressive posture towards the digital asset industry, president Joe Biden
- 59:33vetoed congress' efforts to overturn
- 59:36the SAB 121
- 59:38earlier this year. Safeguarding digital assets for clients is a lucrative business,
- 59:43with many non bank providers charging 10 times more than the service compared
- 59:48to cost for more traditional assets. And by one estimate,
- 59:51the crypto custody market is now worth approximately
- 59:55$300,000,000
- 59:57and growing by 30%
- 59:59annually.
- 1:00:01300,000,000
- 1:00:02now.
- 1:00:03It'll be 300,000,000
- 1:00:05times 30%,
- 1:00:07added back to 300,000,000
- 1:00:09next year, and then take that multiply it by 30%,
- 1:00:12and then add those together and that's next. See, that that's this thing is just is going off the rails.
- 1:00:18What what is this?
- 1:00:20BNY basically got a blank check to custody
- 1:00:24whatever digital funds their customers want to custody.
- 1:00:28Now it doesn't mean that they're going to do it immediately. It's just that Gensler is saying it's up to them.
- 1:00:32Do they do they want to, like, allow people to custody their ton?
- 1:00:36Do they want people to, you know, well, I I guess tons out of the question now because Telegram's all screwed up a doge.
- 1:00:43Am I gonna get a Doge wallet with BNY Mellon? Well, BNY Mellon can say yes if they want to. It's got to be them that say yes. I can't force them to custody it, but they could.
- 1:00:54This is
- 1:00:56this doesn't help
- 1:00:57this doesn't help for Bitcoin
- 1:00:59against all the shit coins that are out there,
- 1:01:02but
- 1:01:03it's it it does add to the ablative armor aspect
- 1:01:08that is there to protect Bitcoin
- 1:01:10by having these multiple layers of shielding
- 1:01:14that is the shitcoin market. So now that BNY Mellon has this mandate to custody whatever the fuck they wanna custody for whoever the hell they wanna custody it for,
- 1:01:25well, that just adds to the strength of the blade of armor.
- 1:01:29However,
- 1:01:30it kind of cuts both ways, doesn't it? It also means that shit coins are gonna be just all that much harder to get rid of.
- 1:01:41However, if you've listened to the show before, you know that my stance is the following.
- 1:01:46The shitcoiners
- 1:01:47will always be with you.
- 1:01:49And then Jesus walked on down the path.
- 1:01:52And if you don't understand the reference from the Bible, is that Jesus told us that the poor will always be with us.
- 1:01:59They were like his disciples were like, what are we gonna do about the poor? And he's like, dude the poor is always gonna be with you. You don't have to worry about the poor. They're always gonna be here. There's always going this work will always be here. We will always have to love these people because they're fucking broke.
- 1:02:14Well,
- 1:02:15the shitcoiners
- 1:02:17will also always be with you. They'll probably also always be poor, but by God Almighty they will always be with you.
- 1:02:25Speaking of, you go out, you have a great weekend. That is the officially the end of the show. I will not be back until Monday,
- 1:02:32and I hope that you find it within yourself to go out
- 1:02:37and think about some of the shows that I talked about this week.
- 1:02:40Like today, we're talking about the overstepping of the bounds and scope creep of Gary Gensler
- 1:02:46as being able to tell us what is and what is not a communications protocol and whether or not should be it should be licensed.
- 1:02:52We've got a US federal judge that's trying to make a distinction between expressive code and other kinds of code. And one is protected free speech, but the other is not even though it's the same base code. It depends on what your intent
- 1:03:05is.
- 1:03:06We got DNS attacks in Malaysia. That can be performed anywhere.
- 1:03:10Right? I talked about what is wealth earlier this week.
- 1:03:14Now, I really want you guys to think about that. I had a discussion with a cattle woman last night at a cattlemen's association meeting. We were talking about her 2 sons and her husband and the ranch that they that they own and they operate.
- 1:03:26And I was talking about secession issues. And she's like, yes. Because and when when when I brought up a show that I did about what is wealth,
- 1:03:35I told her I basically gave her the gist of that show as like a 32nd, you know, elevator pitch,
- 1:03:41and she understood immediately what I was talking about. She's like even, you know, my 2 boys, they have every opportunity to go out and get all the things that you talk about, but they want the ranch. They want to do ranching.
- 1:03:54They don't need the money. And I'm like, that's because they understand what real wealth is.
- 1:03:59So if you didn't listen to that show, go listen to that show. There was a lot of stuff I covered this week, and I hope you got a lot out of it. And if you did,
- 1:04:07use podcasting 2.0
- 1:04:09to throw me some sats, send me some boostograms,
- 1:04:12zap my ass on Noster,
- 1:04:14and I will see you on the other side.
- 1:04:16This has been Bitcoin and
- 1:04:18and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 1:04:25Have a great day.