Latest / What Would We Know: Pop Culture, Internet and Giggling / Who Owns "Hot Girls Read", Molly Mae's baby name, & Ai vs creativity
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to What Would We Know? Our group chat on branding, pop
- 0:03culture and whatever the Internet is doing.
- 0:04Something is always happening and we always have thoughts.
- 0:07I'm Brooke and I work as a creator and in the marketing
- 0:09space, so I spend a lot of time online trying to figure out what
- 0:12is actually worth paying attention.
- 0:13To and I'm Georgia, a graphic designer, and Brandon Girly,
- 0:15which means I'm always noticing details and trying to understand
- 0:18why something works. Between the two of us, we have a
- 0:20lot of opinions. Just not always a clear answer
- 0:23because honestly, what would we know?
- 0:25Hello young Georgia, how is your week my.
- 0:27Week was good because we had the long weekend.
- 0:30We're back to rain, which we know is not good for me.
- 0:34But yeah, I feel like my week so far has been quite uneventful.
- 0:38Nothing exciting, just catching up on work.
- 0:42What about you? I think you've had a better
- 0:44start to this week than me. Yes, so I have been on a
- 0:49journey. My partner's wanted to get a
- 0:51second dog for about a year and I have avoided getting a second
- 0:55dog because I've been worried about it's ruining my first
- 0:58dog's mental health because that's the kind of things kind
- 1:02of things I worry about. But we finally, we wanted to get
- 1:06a rescue dog, obviously because our first dog Luna is a rescue
- 1:10as well. So we're on the hunt for a
- 1:11rescue dog and we found one and my partner applied for it and
- 1:16they called us and said yeah, you can come get her today.
- 1:18And I was like, OK, that's fine. He goes here, we go to Albany,
- 1:20which is like 5 hours from where I live.
- 1:22So on Sunday we did like a 10 hour car ride with a new dog.
- 1:27So that was all a journey. Now we have a little lab across
- 1:31something, something, something. She's just a rescue mix of them
- 1:34all. She's really cute and I'm Betty
- 1:36and she's a little, she is really cute, but she's a bit of
- 1:40a terror like definite puppy vibes at the moment.
- 1:44So sharp, not getting. Yeah, sharp take love to bite
- 1:48things, not getting a full night's sleep, but it is it is a
- 1:52little bit of a joy. So it is what he.
- 1:55Brooke hasn't really had a puppy before, and on the first night
- 1:59she said, oh, Betty was a dream. She slept through the night.
- 2:02I basically have an Angel dog. Oh, that's.
- 2:05Manifesting the times have changed but it's OK because I
- 2:11don't do the get up in the middle of the night to pee.
- 2:13That's not my job, so. That's very nice.
- 2:17It is very nice, but because I do, I get up everyone, you can
- 2:20just enjoy these fun facts. I get up a lot earlier than my
- 2:23partner, so I do the getting up early part like 6:00 AM.
- 2:28Which is fine, except I mean, he's actually can't do anything
- 2:31because I've got to entertain this little dog for the hour
- 2:35that I'm up before my partner. They're like movement.
- 2:38Let me follow you everywhere, yeah?
- 2:40And I'm like, I'm you're my productive window now, like I'm
- 2:43trying to do work, but alas. So productivity down, mental
- 2:49health slightly down, happiness up.
- 2:52No one knows. Yeah, she's not destroyed
- 2:56anything yet too, so that's lovely.
- 2:58But the good thing is where she's allowed and where she is,
- 3:01only my partner's belongings are out there.
- 3:03And notoriously, if you know me in real life, you know that I am
- 3:07a declutterer. I like getting rid of everything
- 3:10and I think he has too many belongings so I'm OK if we lose
- 3:13a few. It's like a lesson.
- 3:16I buy him directly stuff out. She's already tried to eat one
- 3:20of his gnomes and I was like oh God forbid, goodbye gnome.
- 3:24So that's. Funny.
- 3:27We can put one of his 37 hats on the floor and hope she gets one
- 3:30of them too. Not the Bass Pro.
- 3:35It's an Internet thing. You obviously know nothing about
- 3:36the Internet gossip. I hate gossip.
- 3:39Help me. More Where on the Internet in
- 3:41the Instagram interview shall we look at what the Internet has
- 3:43been doing this week? Let's do it.
- 3:47Well, one of my what actually, I think the one we should start
- 3:51off with is the whole hot Girls raid saga.
- 3:55It's. Amazing, yes.
- 3:59So Georgia sends me a message the other week, last week and
- 4:03says Oh my God, someone just tried to trademark or someone
- 4:06trademarked Hot Girls Raid. And I read her message and I
- 4:08thought, that's crazy. I'd not seen a single post.
- 4:11I had no idea what was going on. And I was like, that is crazy.
- 4:14And I went about my day and it was fine, fine, fine, fine.
- 4:18And then my entire feed was flooded with videos of people
- 4:20talking about this. And I was like, what is what is
- 4:23going on? Like how is how is this all
- 4:24happening? And I thankfully people love to
- 4:28explain to the Internet. So I didn't have to search too
- 4:30long to figure out what had happened, which is perfect.
- 4:34So if you don't know or you haven't seen, strap in.
- 4:38This is exciting. Even my partner was excited.
- 4:41So a girl named Kyla. Crazy, it's.
- 4:44Juicy. This is like property for the
- 4:46Internet. It's prickly pear level.
- 4:48So this girl named Ali Rose, she has a small business where she
- 4:52makes cutesy, artsy, crafty things.
- 4:55She makes like a coffee sleeves, like a stubby holder for coffee
- 4:59cups, That kind of vibe. Some of the stuff is really
- 5:01cute. So three years ago she got into
- 5:04her reading era, which is a very common thing on TikTok.
- 5:07People love to read. There's a whole book talk
- 5:09community and there's so many cute small businesses that do
- 5:14product. Common phrase is hot girls read.
- 5:16So that is on a lot of people's merch and it is everywhere.
- 5:20It's kind of giving the millennial live laugh love.
- 5:22It is a common phrase to use. No one owns it, everyone uses
- 5:26it. And this girl Ali started
- 5:28releasing clothes and merch with the phrase Hot Girls Read and
- 5:34lots of them took off and she sold a bunch of them and she
- 5:37posted the Internet this week. After two years, she can finally
- 5:41officially say that the Hot Girls Read trademark is hers or
- 5:45as she says, is ours. So she trademarked the phrase
- 5:49Hot Girls Read and then post on her Instagram story and asks
- 5:53people to remove their listings because she knows that people
- 5:55that follow her have with that phrase please remove them as I
- 5:59own that with love and thankfully the Internet had a
- 6:05field day. From now on I'm going to start
- 6:07all my book review videos by saying welcome back to Hot Girls
- 6:10Read just out of pure spite. Send me that cease and desist,
- 6:15baby. And absolute coronary has gone
- 6:20down in the Internet. I've seen hundreds if not
- 6:24thousands of people making videos about how dare you do
- 6:28such a thing. You don't own that phrase.
- 6:30You didn't make that phrase. If anyone owns that phrase, it's
- 6:33Megan Thee Stallion. I've also seen girls with T
- 6:36shirts from 2004 come out with a T-shirt from Target that says
- 6:40Hot Girls Read. And I have never seen the
- 6:43Internet unite so much over one topic.
- 6:47Agree. What are your initial thoughts
- 6:48before we get into the updates? Well, when I first saw it, I
- 6:53thought, wow, this is crazy because hot girls is like a
- 6:57little bit of a movement like hot girl walk, hot girl summer.
- 6:59It's just like a kind of just. A thing you.
- 7:02Can use, yeah, like hot girl stuff is there's so many things
- 7:06that you'll be able to find that that's on.
- 7:08And when she said she trademarked it, first of all, I
- 7:11thought I didn't even know that. Thought I'll be too common like
- 7:14that. I didn't think that she would be
- 7:15able to own that as a trademark in the first place.
- 7:19And then I all I mainly saw was so many people because I'm a
- 7:23little bit on the big book top. Book.
- 7:25Talk community on TikTok video after video of people saying how
- 7:33and just hating it really. And I think that I really think
- 7:36this killed her business because I think she's got.
- 7:38So we almost every week now we've talked about some kind of
- 7:41like influencer or business apology that's got more traction
- 7:46than the drama itself and it ends up worse off the person
- 7:50that initiated it. And I think that's the exact.
- 7:53Same thing. Yeah.
- 7:55And one, one thing that shocked me was how quickly people were
- 7:59willing to sell out businesses that had anything else.
- 8:03Hot Girl read like a couple of small businesses were like, oh,
- 8:06I make bookmarks with this phrase and I have a bunch in
- 8:08stock and I won't be able to sell them anymore.
- 8:10People sold her out within the day.
- 8:12I watched a PR lady talk about how like, how do you come back
- 8:15from this as a business owner? And she's like, I don't really
- 8:17think you can. I think it's like you've sunk a
- 8:20ship. Serious question.
- 8:21I'm still on Hot Girls Read and Ally fucking whatever her name
- 8:25is is. There any redemption for her?
- 8:28Like, let's be honest, because as a human being, right, there
- 8:31are times that so many times we've done the thing that we
- 8:33thought. Was the correct move in the
- 8:35moment or said something that we thought was right just for
- 8:38someone to come by and be like hey so fuck you.
- 8:42The damage is done and no one's buying hot girls read jumper
- 8:45from her anymore. No, and I just think if.
- 8:50Your business lever that you have to pull is oh, I'm going to
- 8:54trademark that so you can't use it and then they'll only buy
- 8:57from me. Your product must not have been
- 8:59that good. Then if you have to do that like
- 9:02rising tides lift all ships. That's I've always been a
- 9:05believer of that. There is only healthy
- 9:07competition. Like if you started doing a
- 9:10special interest cleaning series tomorrow, then people going to
- 9:13start searching the phrase special interest cleaning.
- 9:14They're probably going to see my videos too, and they're probably
- 9:16going to enjoy my videos as well because it's the same topic.
- 9:19Like if anyone else is a cleaning video, it is not a
- 9:22competition. To me.
- 9:23It's actually kind of exciting to have someone else to talk
- 9:25about the topic with. So I don't know why why we're
- 9:28like, Oh well, I'm going to trademark this.
- 9:30You could never use this again. Like it's just weird behaviour.
- 9:32It is, and then you will. She's obviously received so much
- 9:37backlash that she's now tried to revoke her trademark
- 9:41application. I want to talk about my
- 9:44trademark. First and foremost, the
- 9:45trademark is being surrendered. It is in the process of being
- 9:48filed right now to be abandoned. I want to say that it does take
- 9:51time for that to go through, so it's not going to show up
- 9:53automatically, but the paperwork has already been filed.
- 9:56But more importantly, I want to say I'm so sorry to every small
- 9:59business that I harmed in doing this.
- 10:01The decision was made more as like a business strategy
- 10:04decision than a human being decision, and I take full
- 10:08accountability for that. That was entirely wrong on my
- 10:10end. But did she surrendered the
- 10:12trademark? She did a video yesterday.
- 10:14It's happened when like I think I sent this to you maybe last
- 10:18Thursday or something, I can't remember.
- 10:19It's been less. Than a week.
- 10:21That it gone from I own these two.
- 10:24Oh my God, I'm so sorry. Then she starts this is about I
- 10:28really don't like about it is she said that she wasn't the one
- 10:32that was sending because people were getting cease and desist.
- 10:34I think mainly on Etsy that it wasn't her that was sending
- 10:38them. It was.
- 10:41It was a people in our community were sending these messages
- 10:43saying, take down your listing, Ali Roseko owns this trademark.
- 10:47And she's like, what? That wasn't me, but we have no
- 10:49idea. What she wanted, though, that's
- 10:51the point of doing a trademark, is that she doesn't want other
- 10:54people to be trading with the term.
- 10:55So to say, oh, that wasn't me, but you've applied for the
- 10:58trademark, so that is. And you posted a story telling
- 11:00people to take down their listings.
- 11:02With love, yeah. So maybe you didn't directly do
- 11:04it, but because of you it happened.
- 11:06And that is essentially the point of the trademark my.
- 11:09Next one because that was also my my first one, so we're just
- 11:11going to count that together. I saw I post on TikTok and it
- 11:16screenshotters and parts of us for us to talk about it's from a
- 11:19girl who username. I need to zoom in because I
- 11:22can't read it Alessandra Mercedes is so I've got really
- 11:26bad eyes set and I got to zoom back here so we're back This is
- 11:30everything you got when you bought the first iPhone in 2007,
- 11:33and this is what you get nowadays I love that the box
- 11:35just says iPhone. There was no other iPhone.
- 11:37So you obviously got the phone used to get the little SIM
- 11:39remover. This is a little iPhone cleaning
- 11:41cloth of course you got stickers full guide and brief fingertips
- 11:46shout out to Jack Black. You obviously got the charger
- 11:48and the charging brick and a pair of headphones.
- 11:51I'm missing the little charging stand that you got in the
- 11:52original box as well for comparison.
- 11:54This is how thin the iPhone 16 Pro box is.
- 11:57You obviously get the phone and then you get a lovely USBC
- 12:00charging cable and there's no pictures, there's a few
- 12:03different languages. That's kind of it.
- 12:06You're paying more for less is what it was, what it was quite.
- 12:09And I was like what is this? And she showing a screenshot.
- 12:12She's got like a flat lay. All of her little bits and bobs
- 12:15are laid out and it is every item you got with the first
- 12:19iPhone. So 9 things for the first
- 12:21iPhone. I think if I'm really good at
- 12:22maths, then the second lot of stuff she shows is the current
- 12:25iPhone and that comes in the box is the charger and the phone and
- 12:30that's it. So just the two items and I
- 12:33think that's so true. When did we stop?
- 12:36Like when it should not be allowed if you were to buy a
- 12:40phone that you were not given the charging base, like you're
- 12:43just given the charging cord. I had to go buy a charging base
- 12:47because the charging cord is now not a USB to USBC or lightning
- 12:52cable. It's now a USB C to USBC.
- 12:55So I didn't have a base that charged to USBC.
- 12:58So I then had to go out and buy a USB C charging base.
- 13:00So it's like you actually can't buy the iPhone and then use it
- 13:04because you need to go then buy the charger.
- 13:05It's like why are things not included?
- 13:08Yes, I had to do the same thing. And you know what doesn't make
- 13:11sense is I bought an iPad like I got upgraded my iPad at the end
- 13:18of last year. Which is.
- 13:20Cheaper than if you're buying a brand new phone and that did
- 13:23come with the charging block. So make it makes sense.
- 13:29The only place I could charge my iPhone when I got it with a
- 13:32USBCDUSBC was in my car because that's the only place or my
- 13:37computer I guess. But you're paying so much money
- 13:40and I understand why they made it the USBC bit so every it was
- 13:45like a type of cord that you would use more universal but the
- 13:50fact that let nothing I don't know if nothing else, but not
- 13:53many other things have USBC to USBC.
- 13:57So agree IA 100% agree. It's a joke Apple, what are you
- 14:02doing? And I wonder if Android does
- 14:03this too. I.
- 14:04Don't think they would. Android gives Android lets you
- 14:06swap out your batteries that I think I saw another video, same
- 14:09sort of topic. I think I'm on the Apple
- 14:10algorithm at the moment. I'm happy to be there.
- 14:12But I saw another video of a girl with an original MacBook
- 14:16like an older Macbooks Pro. I don't know which model it was,
- 14:18but it had batteries that were removable, so you could go
- 14:21charge the battery separate and you can swap them in.
- 14:22And I thought, bring that back, bring it back.
- 14:26Like I want a removable battery. I would pay more to have an
- 14:28iPhone that had a removable battery that rather than
- 14:30bringing a stupid battery pack, I could just swap out the
- 14:33battery. A. 100% agree.
- 14:35There's something Apple does really know.
- 14:36Like couldn't live without AirDrop, but things like an
- 14:40Apple mouse that has the silly like.
- 14:43Charging. That's intentional.
- 14:45That's annoying. So now I have.
- 14:47Do it so that you can't use a quartet.
- 14:48It's crazy. Yes, I get your ergonomic mouse.
- 14:51It is silly. Logitech, you didn't have my
- 14:53money for a mouse. Mike's Logitech too.
- 14:56Oh my God. But Mike's a little thin.
- 14:59Look at the difference in our mouses.
- 15:02Compare the I have no mouse. Too.
- 15:04That one has a real battery that I love that.
- 15:07Yes, it's so good. OK, well what else do you have
- 15:11for the Internet this week? The other thing I have is that
- 15:15you may not care about this because you've not read it, but
- 15:17last year I read, I was in a reading train and I read
- 15:21Magnolia Parks and got somewhat exited.
- 15:23Right. It is a silly book but addictive
- 15:25at the same time. Is going to be a TV show and
- 15:29it's been bought, I think by independent.
- 15:31Like it's not through Prime or a BIG4 Netflix.
- 15:35Yeah, it's independent. So I don't think that's good or
- 15:37bad. Hopefully good.
- 15:38Yeah, that's exciting for the book talk community if you're in
- 15:41true Magnolia Parks and you need something to consume other than
- 15:45hot girls raid drama. Made into a TV show by a 24.
- 15:49And it said to be a Gossip Girl but set in high society London.
- 15:53I'm really excited about that because I feel like we've all
- 15:55been trying to find the Gossip Girl vibe since we first watched
- 15:58Gossip Girl. I think maybe I because I
- 16:00actually bought the book after you said it was good so I have
- 16:02it on my kindle for when times get tough.
- 16:04Like I literally put it the same way you told.
- 16:06Me, I said it's addictive. Oh no, because I recall you
- 16:10saying to me, I don't think you'll like it.
- 16:12And I was like, okay, so I'm confused.
- 16:14So I have it, never opened it. But the audio book of the
- 16:17Magnolia Magnolia Park series is quite good.
- 16:21The people that read it are British and Magnolia Parks is
- 16:26based in London, so that is if you were to listen to an
- 16:30audiobook. I feel like that would be a good
- 16:31one. It's the only one I found that's
- 16:33the least annoying, but they talk too slow for me so I have
- 16:35to go back to book. There is something about
- 16:37audiobooks that I love and I don't know if everyone knows
- 16:40this. When I found it out, it changed
- 16:41my life. I'd never use the feature, but
- 16:43if I was to use it, I'd love it that if you have a Kindle and
- 16:47then you listen to the audiobook on Audible, wherever you're up
- 16:50to on the audiobook, it will then flick to that page on your
- 16:53kindle. So if you pause the audiobook at
- 16:5633 minutes on page 400, when you open up your Kindle, it'll go
- 16:59back, it'll go to that spot so you can read and listen at the
- 17:02same time, and it'll keep your place across platform.
- 17:07That is interesting when I I like borrowed it the audio book
- 17:12from the library, so I couldn't do that but.
- 17:15Borrow the audio book from the library.
- 17:17Yeah, on Libby. But what else?
- 17:20You were more. What's more, what's more do you
- 17:23have? Molly mate had a baby.
- 17:26Oh, do you have baby name guesses?
- 17:29Oh, I actually thought it was going to.
- 17:30Be a girl so. I don't.
- 17:34I actually. Have no clue what the name could
- 17:39be like. I feel like I'm making some like
- 17:41random little like animal name like wool for fox.
- 17:45I've I sent them sent my baby name guesses so I can read them
- 17:49to you just so I can cement them in history before she announces
- 17:52it because I think I'm not correct.
- 17:54But if I was correct, this will be iconic.
- 17:56So if you're hearing this in the future and we already know her
- 17:58baby name and I guess it correctly, be really proud of
- 18:00me. OK.
- 18:00But I'd like for the record to show that I'm guessing this
- 18:03prior to the baby name coming out.
- 18:04I guess these are Monday. So my guesses are row like, row,
- 18:09row, row your boat, night as in like night and Princess forest
- 18:15as in the the forest. Rogue.
- 18:20I like rogue. Like like Rogue Traders but
- 18:22rogue? Oh rogue.
- 18:25So you're saying? Rogue no no iconic though and
- 18:29Fiat 500 I just. Realised my guess is a stupid
- 18:35because rather kids name is Bambi and she's also not going
- 18:37to have a wolf that's going to go on ETA Bambi.
- 18:41I saw the Remy by Riley girls, was it them or was it girls with
- 18:45gems? One of the two said told the
- 18:47other person that they she named the baby Bambino and I think
- 18:50that's so funny. I think that's hilarious and I
- 18:55love that music. Rumours surrounding Molly May
- 18:58and Tommy Fury's baby boy's name Wild.
- 19:01But two names keep being given to me by various different
- 19:04sources, and both begin with the letter M One of these names is
- 19:09Madius and the other name is Midas.
- 19:13And both of these names are quite unusual, but they keep
- 19:16coming to me, so I don't know if the rumour mill is just going
- 19:19wild or if there's any truth to them whatsoever.
- 19:24So we find out when what the baby's name is at Tommy's fight
- 19:29on his boxing pants. So.
- 19:31It's a journey. Wow, that's actually an amazing
- 19:33segue to the marketing group chat.
- 19:35OK, group chat, ladies. Bad news.
- 19:37Bad news. I know Rana has her own
- 19:39receipts. Are you out of your I would chat
- 19:42give us life. Shall we discuss some things
- 19:45Let's the I've already told you these these stats.
- 19:49So you already know these stats with the audience doesn't so we
- 19:51can begin the stats again. The best season of Love Island
- 19:54ever was the Molly Mae and Tommy Fury season season 5 and that
- 19:59brang brang. What word is that?
- 20:01That brought in 6 million people to the first episode and across
- 20:05the season. That was their average watch of
- 20:07episodes this season, which I have not started watching yet
- 20:11because the clips haven't been very good.
- 20:12Usually that's how I begin. This season has only brought in
- 20:15600,000 people which is a huge difference.
- 20:20Yeah. Like 5.4 million people less.
- 20:23I think it's just done to me like those.
- 20:26Times. I think for me, like I know that
- 20:30your big into reality shows. I am very into it, specifically
- 20:35based on the people like was very into that say I also
- 20:38watched it after the fact. Someone told me it was good.
- 20:40And then I was like, I think I wouldn't like it, but I decided
- 20:44to persist and I actually did like it.
- 20:48But then I don't think I tried to watch the next season.
- 20:50Like I just don't care about these people.
- 20:52The same with Dancing with the Stars. the US last year, or was
- 20:55it this year? Can't remember.
- 20:57The one that I think was last year that had like Rob.
- 20:59Oh, and Alex. Oh, Yep.
- 21:01Whitney Levitt. I don't think I care about the
- 21:04next season of Dancing the Stars.
- 21:06Like I won't be as invested as I was with this one because I
- 21:08think it's the people. Like, there's so much Yeah on
- 21:12the casting team to make a group of people really interesting
- 21:17that people want to watch. It's hard.
- 21:18What? Do you think it's a reality TV
- 21:21enthusiast? I think it is the people, which
- 21:23is why like. Usually I will start Love Island
- 21:25because of the clips. I've noticed I've not even seen
- 21:27a single clip for the USA season.
- 21:29Like I don't even know if the USA has actually started.
- 21:31I've not seen anything about Love Island at all so.
- 21:35Yeah, really off the radar. So maybe we won't be tuning in
- 21:38this season, but we spoke about Calabasas Confidential a couple
- 21:41of weeks ago on the podcast and they commented on our Instagram
- 21:46after you have a chance pointed to.
- 21:48Was on the approach. I was disappointed and I'm not
- 21:52going to sugarcoat it. Then I've seen some clips from
- 21:55the show and the clips are who's Daddy paid for this show.
- 21:58And so I don't think it's for me.
- 22:02I want to. I want reality TV back.
- 22:05That's good. So last night we started
- 22:06watching the Caravan of Courage and Hamish Andy's Gap here just
- 22:09to, you know, spark joy back in our lives.
- 22:12Yeah. Love we're currently watching
- 22:16This is not part of No one cares but Dutton Ranch on Paramount.
- 22:22Last week's episode I actually couldn't even watch all of it.
- 22:26Like I think that's so many TV shows they lack emotion or it's
- 22:29just a bit meh. It was like Last Egg was so
- 22:33intense that I couldn't watch it all because I wanted to cry
- 22:36about the poor cows. That's not for me then.
- 22:41No. Well, the show was good that
- 22:43particular episode. Yeah, they did well with making
- 22:46the audience feel the emotions because, God, I felt like my
- 22:49cattle was also no more. Do you have anything else for
- 22:54the marketing group chat this week?
- 22:56Yes, my other one is that Cash app.
- 22:59This is an American thing, I think have introduced a new way
- 23:04of paying with a fairy wand link the whimsy of the world.
- 23:09Let's unbox the brand new limited edition Cash App wand
- 23:13now. Yes, if you did not see Cash App
- 23:15did come out with a limited edition wand that you can pay
- 23:18with like your cash App card, except it's a wand.
- 23:20It looks like, just like iPhones, they have that little
- 23:22thing right there that you have to peel so you can open it.
- 23:26I. I don't really know who started
- 23:27this because I think it was kind of a thing on TikTok that people
- 23:30were like making little fairy ones and sticking their credit
- 23:33card to it and just like shopping and tapping their card
- 23:38like, and he's never loved it. And then Cash App is really
- 23:42leaned in. I think you can buy it.
- 23:45It's $25. I imagine This Is Us.
- 23:48USD. So it's they've said it's like a
- 23:52new way of paying. So it's waving a fairy like wand
- 23:55so you can like pay pass is the point of it perfect And $25.00.
- 24:00It features a light green faux gemstone at the centre of the
- 24:05star shaped tip and it's small enough to clip to a key chain.
- 24:10And do you know what I would be someone that would pay $25 for
- 24:14that because it's. Quite fun.
- 24:16I do think it's quite fun and I probably would get one too.
- 24:18It's all very practical, but who needs practicality when you do
- 24:20the little whimsy in your life? Yes, like I'm a fairy.
- 24:26Ding, Ding, Ding. Yeah, love.
- 24:28The sad thing is you're using your own money.
- 24:30It's not magical fairy money, but.
- 24:32If I link it to your card, then I'm using your money and that
- 24:35feels way better. Yeah, well, you would be very.
- 24:37Limited on what you could buy. Well, have you seen that there
- 24:44is a New Zealand brand coming under fire for alleged AI use of
- 24:48models? I was.
- 24:49About to say I have seen this but I think that you're the one.
- 24:52That's I sent it to you last night because I wanted you to
- 24:54watch the full video. I will insert the full audio so
- 24:57everyone else can enjoy it. Bye, but it begins by saying I
- 25:00just got blocked by an ex client for commenting.
- 25:03Yo, that AI model actually goes kind of hard.
- 25:06Hi, my name's Elijah and for those that don't know me, I'm a
- 25:07model in New Zealand, from New Zealand.
- 25:10And this all started when I was scrolling past an ad and I
- 25:13noticed an image that looked very similar to me, but as I
- 25:16zoomed in, it wasn't me. And then I thought it was my
- 25:18brother because my brother also has modelled for this client.
- 25:22But then it was neither of us. It was almost like both of us
- 25:24combined. And that's when I realised it
- 25:25was AI. Now although I wasn't 100% on
- 25:28this, I started bumming into other models, photographers etc.
- 25:31And they were talking about how this brand are using AI and how
- 25:34it was actually affecting them. Now the whole premise of this
- 25:37video isn't the Shamer brand for using AI models like it is what
- 25:40it is from a business perspective and like where the
- 25:42economy is going, you kind of see it happening sooner rather
- 25:45than later. This guy and his brother have
- 25:47both modelled for this brand, and then they've seen an image
- 25:51come up that looks a hell of a lot like them and thought, OK,
- 25:54this is not a real model. This could possibly be AI.
- 25:56And then when the brand was asked about this on the news,
- 25:59they were asked on the news. The woman says, yeah, I know.
- 26:03I've got the audio of this too. Don't you worry.
- 26:05And then she goes on to basically say that it's assisted
- 26:08computer, assisted technology. Did you see the TV in Z?
- 26:11So you're not using AI to, you know, create different pictures
- 26:15of them? No, I tell it all.
- 26:18So I don't think I'm so excited that I can go download audios.
- 26:21I'm like, Oh my God, Investigative.
- 26:23Journalists report to do a podcast is to have audio
- 26:26inserts. Potentially anyway, it was great
- 26:32they were going through it and she basically says that they
- 26:36used like computer assisted images.
- 26:39So she wouldn't say it was AI, but she would like allegedly she
- 26:42would say that it was like computer assisted technology.
- 26:44No idea what it is, but the guy that did the original video has
- 26:48done subsequently other videos going through looking at some of
- 26:51the other models that have been used recently and what he
- 26:54believes to be the AI counterparts of those exact
- 26:56models. And it is really interesting.
- 26:59He said that other photographers and models that they've have
- 27:01worked for this brand, we're talking about how that they
- 27:04think the brand also is using AI for a number of different
- 27:06things. So I wonder what's going to
- 27:08happen because I don't think the issue is the AI.
- 27:11I think the issue is the deceit of the AI of saying, oh, we
- 27:16didn't use it, but they might have.
- 27:19I think the trust part goes, it's really hard to build trust
- 27:22with consumers and this is a quick way to lose it.
- 27:25They also said that maybe there's a quote he says it in
- 27:28the video at something along the lines of they told him that
- 27:31maybe he should think about why he's not getting work.
- 27:33One of the comments she made was maybe he should think about why
- 27:36he's not getting any work or why he's not getting booked along
- 27:41those lines and. Not worry about this.
- 27:44Wait, the company said that to him?
- 27:46Yes. The audacity.
- 27:51I know I was like, OK, well, this is this is a journey.
- 27:54I'm not. Made for the model.
- 27:56So it's like what? Literally I, I'm shocked.
- 28:00I don't know what's going to happen.
- 28:01TikTok that I saw recently or maybe it was a real whatever our
- 28:04same thing store in America and I can't I'm not exactly sure the
- 28:08exact brand, but it was that the campaign shoot was AI.
- 28:14They did have it on there saying that the campaign was shot in
- 28:17AI. Kind of sad that that's the new
- 28:20creative path for photoshoot. Like they've got the money to
- 28:24have a photo shoot that they can have real models in.
- 28:30Like there's just so many options, especially for someone
- 28:34or like, I'm not sure the exact brand, but it was a.
- 28:36Huge of a big calibre. They had budget.
- 28:39They've got budget and they're just going with the AI photo
- 28:43shoots and I hate that. Also, how are you to really know
- 28:48how it fits on a body when the? Clothing.
- 28:51It's not real. It's not real like and you could
- 28:54say that for a regular photo shoot because brands have.
- 28:58Altered it in the back. Yeah, the altering thing so it
- 29:00looks the best for the photo, but yeah, I, I don't love that.
- 29:06Bring back the creativity in the real world, I say.
- 29:09Oh, couldn't agree more. I just, I think we're going to
- 29:12like reach a pitch of there's so much overuse of AI that's like
- 29:16it's kind of frustrating that AI is not the answer to everything.
- 29:19Sure, if you really want to use AI to help you organise some of
- 29:22your life, go for it, live your truth, that's your journey.
- 29:25But it should be taking away the admin tasks for you, not taking
- 29:29away the creativity part. Like it's, I think I see it all
- 29:33the time now. It's probably really frustrating
- 29:35when I'm watching someone's video and I realise that they've
- 29:37scripted their voice over by AI because you could tell and it's
- 29:41like, just talk to me. I'm a person.
- 29:43I want to watch a person. I don't want to watch what a
- 29:45robot has told you to say. Like it frustrates the hell out
- 29:48of me because it's just shit. It's just shit.
- 29:51Danny know what they're talking about.
- 29:53It's like you would be way more interesting if you just said it.
- 29:57How? You said it.
- 29:58How you think it? Yeah, I will say guess that the
- 30:03photo shoot with the Bing company at least it says on the.
- 30:07On the team, what it is? On the thing that it is, it's
- 30:09just the amount of people that are claiming AI work as their
- 30:12own is kind of annoying. And the fact that they think
- 30:16that, well, I think if you've used AI, you can really tell
- 30:19what is and what is an AI. And I think some people just
- 30:23assume that everyone has no idea and they're acting like they're
- 30:27making up all this and it's like, we, we know.
- 30:31It's really easy to tell guys. I can like I can tell that that
- 30:34whole post that you've just done is AI like.
- 30:37It's not just, it's the sentence.
- 30:40It's there's a lot of things and people can also tell if if one
- 30:45of your videos is you organically being yourself or
- 30:48one of your carousels is you organically being you, and then
- 30:50the next one is made by a robot. Even if you told them what your
- 30:53tone of voice is, it is never going to have the human tone of
- 30:56voice that you have because it doesn't know what you actually
- 30:59think. So just letting it put words
- 31:01into your mouth, quote unquote, it doesn't, it doesn't hit the
- 31:04same and you're going to forget what you've got AI to say about
- 31:08you. Like if you're getting AI to
- 31:09give you your 10 best tips on how to cook a chicken, and then
- 31:14you do a video about that two years later, you're not going to
- 31:16remember what AI told you to say.
- 31:17Like it's not what you actually thought.
- 31:21It kind of makes you think, what is the world going to be like in
- 31:2320 years? I'll be like self driving cars.
- 31:25I've known it as a real thought. And I'll still be entering this
- 31:29damn podcast using very wand. Yeah.
- 31:33Do you have anything more from the Marketing group chat this
- 31:35week? The only other thing I have is
- 31:38that I saw Instagram has brought out that you can rearrange your
- 31:42carousels now, which I don't. I think I I thought you could
- 31:47already. No, you could rearrange.
- 31:48The full feed, like the order of the actual feed, is what's
- 31:50changed. I didn't want.
- 31:53To burst your bubble, last night when you messaged me about this,
- 31:55I was like no, you're actually going to be excited about this
- 31:57because we've run into this issue all the time where we
- 32:00accidentally do 2 posts that look similar near each other.
- 32:02But you could now move a post from today to last February and
- 32:06move a post from last February to today.
- 32:07Like different order. Yes, I didn't research.
- 32:11That's life changing to you. Oh, this is all news, all
- 32:13they're talking. About It's not all news, baby.
- 32:16It's new and you're going to love that.
- 32:18Feature for work Yeah for my personal I post once a year so.
- 32:22I'm pretty you don't miss out the two Christmases that you
- 32:24post or the old meat and potatoes on your feed.
- 32:27You know that's fun. I'm going.
- 32:28To try it out today because it does annoy me when we have, Yep,
- 32:312 canolas too close. Yeah, that's great news.
- 32:35Oh. There you go.
- 32:37It's a good news here because I told you a message and I was
- 32:39like, because George said to me, because I swear they already
- 32:41have this feature. I thought, oh, she thinks it's
- 32:43this one. I thought, yeah, they do, don't
- 32:45they? And I thought, she's going to be
- 32:46so excited when she is. I am.
- 32:48Excited sometimes, like if something doesn't capture my
- 32:51attention straight away I probably won't watch the whole
- 32:53video. Makes perfect sense is that?
- 32:56Common sense, common sense common sense.
- 32:59Yeah, that, that makes sense. Shall we move on to the sense
- 33:03check of the week, which I have kept hidden from you?
- 33:05Yes. So I saw a tick tock.
- 33:07I'll insert some of the audio. The girl that made it brilliant,
- 33:10love her. She talked about how the
- 33:12invention of ChatGPT has affected How has the invention
- 33:15of ChatGPT affected the creativity of college admissions
- 33:18essays? My friend Kibu Moon did this six
- 33:21study that the New York Times just covered.
- 33:24It is so. Cool and I'm going to talk about
- 33:26it. Hi, I'm Mira, I study the
- 33:27psychology of technology. If you find this stuff
- 33:29interesting please join me. So to measure creativity, they
- 33:33use something called semantic distance.
- 33:35So basically how far apart the meanings of the words are from
- 33:37each other in a piece of writing.
- 33:39The idea being that genuine creativity pulls the other
- 33:42concepts that don't often appear side by side.
- 33:45To apply to get into a school, you have to write about
- 33:47something. It could be anything.
- 33:49People often write about their lives, but there was a time
- 33:52where there was no AI. There's a time that there is AI,
- 33:54and there's a time where AI exists but you didn't use it for
- 33:58your essay. So we're talking through all of
- 33:59these things. So the researchers compiled
- 34:02compared to 2000 human written college essays with the same
- 34:06amount of essays written by ChatGPT for.
- 34:09And here are the findings. So at the word level, the post
- 34:11ChatGPT essays were actually more creative than the pre
- 34:14ChatGPT essays. So the conceptual distance
- 34:16between words on average was greater.
- 34:18But then the team used a similar distancing technique to capture
- 34:21the idea variation from sentence to sentence, and that's where
- 34:25they saw it drop. So there was less idea variation
- 34:28from sentence to sentence in the post GBT essays.
- 34:31And then they decided to do a third analysis at the document
- 34:34level. So they took each essay in full
- 34:36and essentially found its nearest conceptual neighbour.
- 34:39So the most similar essay in the application cohort to kind of
- 34:43see, OK, how thematically unique are these essays relative to
- 34:47other applicants. And they found that the post
- 34:50ChatGPT essays were less distinct than the pre 2022
- 34:54essays. So the pre GPT essays across all
- 34:57the universities, the researcher's.
- 34:59Explanation was that most students are probably not using
- 35:01AI to write their essays entirely, but instead they're
- 35:03likely using it to edit, Polish, and refine their writing.
- 35:06AI can make writing sound more impressive by adding the richer
- 35:09vocabulary, but it also may smooth out the students original
- 35:12ideas and push the essays towards a more common and
- 35:16predictable theme. So Chachi BT is making college
- 35:19essays sound more polished, but it also is making them less
- 35:21original, less distinct, and less personal.
- 35:24And like, less distance. Semantically, that's.
- 35:27Crazy isn't it went I've done 2 uni degrees and have to print it
- 35:33out. We'd have to take it to the
- 35:34library and I think it was mostly hand marked.
- 35:37And then within that time of my life, this was when I'd first
- 35:41finished high school. We had to start submitting it to
- 35:43an online like it was turn it in I think.
- 35:46And then it would come up with how much was similar to what was
- 35:51on the Internet. Like, I don't even think it was
- 35:52just people doing your paper like the whole minute.
- 35:57Yeah. And then when I did my second
- 36:00one, they got rid of the paper 1 and it was all like you would
- 36:02submit online and you would find out straight away what your
- 36:05percentage of similarity was. And sometimes this was also
- 36:10before AI, so it was written by me.
- 36:13Obviously people are using the same sources or the same quotes
- 36:17from a recent paper. You do have so much doubt.
- 36:20You think, how do I make this better?
- 36:22Because people are wanting their papers to be the best they can
- 36:25be and putting I understand that that is probably you think, oh,
- 36:29what have I missed? But it really does remove any of
- 36:33the uniqueness and everything does sound the same, which is
- 36:36just like you scroll social media, everything sounds the
- 36:38same. So imagine it's.
- 36:40Frustrating. Yeah.
- 36:44Like you're also not going to learn if you put in your like
- 36:47your paper and then go, Oh well, what have I missed?
- 36:49Oh, it's going to tell you what you've missed, but you haven't
- 36:50come to the finding yourself. You haven't looked at it and
- 36:53gone, OK, there's a gap here. Where do I find that gap?
- 36:56People are going to AI 1st and they're not having the
- 36:58learnings. They're they're skipping apart.
- 37:01And I think it is going to be a really weird error.
- 37:05I know. I feel like we're in our prompt
- 37:06era, like everyone's a prompt for everything.
- 37:08Oh. If you stop being creative,
- 37:11you're good like and you start using AI for all your creative
- 37:13stuff, you're going to find it a lot harder to be creative.
- 37:15When I see on socials they'll be like this is how I batch create
- 37:19all my month's worth of content in one hour.
- 37:21This is the prompt I get clawed to make all my characters.
- 37:25It writes all the copy and I get this to spammy.
- 37:28I am uninterested in anything you have to post because you
- 37:31have no thought in that. No, it's, is it so much to what?
- 37:36Like it's like when you're doing the phone calls like Telstra to
- 37:38get your phone fixed and it's like press 1, press 2, press
- 37:41this. And it's like, let me speak to a
- 37:43human. That's how I feel on social
- 37:44media right now. Let me see a human.
- 37:46Very true. I think we should move on.
- 37:48Yeah, we should for. The special interest groups, I
- 37:51like that. Clubs for special interests.
- 37:53All right, I'll put the Prezis here taking a special interest,
- 37:55a special interest in this. Do you have a special interest
- 37:58this week? You go first.
- 37:59You're just going to enjoy. This is thinking time.
- 38:02No worries. So my special interest this
- 38:04week, maybe you've seen this too, but Clarkson spam season 5
- 38:09came out and oh what yes Oh my God, I've tried to not talk
- 38:14about this. Get excited because the new
- 38:16episodes is dropping in two parts.
- 38:18The first part drops last week and then the second part last
- 38:20Wednesday and then the second part is dropping today.
- 38:23We've recorded a Wednesday for Thursday.
- 38:25Edit everyone please enjoy behind the paywall.
- 38:28But the first 3 or 4 episodes came out and they're all really
- 38:31fun, so that's really good. That is exciting.
- 38:36I do love a bit of Clarkson's Farm.
- 38:38I this is the last season too, isn't?
- 38:40It yeah, I think they're then going on a little bit of a break
- 38:42and maybe they probably won't return, but it's been a really
- 38:46fun show. Clarkson's farm, it's about
- 38:48farming. Yeah, it is Jeremy Clarkson
- 38:51who's from Top Gear. He basically bought a farm in
- 38:54the Cotswolds. And then he has enlisted the
- 38:57help of a local farmer named Caleb.
- 38:59And they're just learning. Well, Caleb obviously knows how
- 39:02to farm, but Jeremy Clarkson does not.
- 39:04And they try every type of farming.
- 39:06And it is not practical in the way that they've planned it out.
- 39:09And it is really fun because I think Caleb does not care that
- 39:12Jeremy Clarkson is super famous. And lots of famous celebrities
- 39:16go on the farm, including in this season.
- 39:18There is Oscar Piastre on the farm and Jeremy Clarkson,
- 39:20sister. Caleb, do you know who this is?
- 39:21And he goes, Nah. And he says to Oscar Gastry,
- 39:24what do you do? And Oscar Gastry says, I drive
- 39:27cars. And Caleb's like, OK, well, can
- 39:28you reverse this tractor? I love that.
- 39:31One of the other things about Clarkson's Farm that I find
- 39:34quite interesting is that, like, Jeremy Clarkson is obviously
- 39:38loaded. He's got money, but he's going
- 39:40through all the hardships of farming of the people in the
- 39:44same area who also don't have the same amount of money or
- 39:49resources as him. And he does try to fight for
- 39:52certain things to make it like to help these people who's tell
- 39:56me it's like, farming's obviously a hard life, living
- 39:59off the land. You go through times with being
- 40:01really good and then you go through years and years of just.
- 40:05Crap. Destruction and just like
- 40:08everything is just destroyed. So I think it's an interesting,
- 40:13like little way to watch it because, well, I guess my
- 40:17special interest of the week is because there's a long weekend.
- 40:20We went away, we went down South a little bit and I was hardly on
- 40:24my phone at all. So I think my.
- 40:27Special interest is just a little bit.
- 40:29Of AD Connect and just enjoying people's company.
- 40:32We caught up with people we hadn't seen for ages and just
- 40:35chatting and people of different like live different lives to me
- 40:40and just yeah, I think my special interest is deconnecting
- 40:44from my phone technology. The long weekend was good for
- 40:48you. It was work wife to work wife.
- 40:52Or do you have any advice? But you know that makes you also
- 40:55the wife. You make the call, they call me.
- 40:57Work wife, I wasn't agree, so the work wife wisdom for the
- 41:00week. This is a phrase.
- 41:03A Brook term. This is a Brooke term.
- 41:05I don't remember when I go into this term.
- 41:07I definitely probably borrowed it from someone in my life, but
- 41:10it was you betrayed. Marking.
- 41:12I'll trademark this. Sorry I don't.
- 41:13Maybe it was something my mum said.
- 41:15It was back in 2016. I was going through some
- 41:17hardships of high school, but if you know me from high school you
- 41:21shouldn't be listening to this podcast.
- 41:22I'm pretty sure I got you all blocked.
- 41:24It was a horrible time. Don't worry about it, it's all
- 41:27good now guys, I'm off the SSRIs, we're good.
- 41:30Mum used to say to me good things happen to good people and
- 41:32like I have always carried that through life.
- 41:35It doesn't matter if people around you're being shit, if
- 41:38life is going tough, the good things always happen to you if
- 41:40you're a good person. Like you can only control
- 41:42yourself and 50% of conflict is your conflict, you know.
- 41:45So if you're just doing good in the world, good things will
- 41:48happen to you. And I argue this phrase has rung
- 41:52through my life in so many aspects.
- 41:54I feel like I might be one of the luckiest people for so many
- 41:58random shit that has happened to me.
- 41:59I just think how is that actually possible?
- 42:01Like, the stars have really aligned.
- 42:03Like, let's think about my Iceland trip.
- 42:05I went to Iceland with my partner for his birthday.
- 42:07We broke up at the airport. We've been kicked off the
- 42:09flight. OK, They've overbooked the
- 42:10flight. We've been kicked off.
- 42:11I'm about to have a little breakdown because my partner's
- 42:1430th and this is meant to be a spectacular extravaganza.
- 42:16And also going to Iceland, very expensive.
- 42:18He kicked off the flight. We still have to pay for
- 42:20everything else. And that night we had a $1700
- 42:22dinner. OK, don't ask.
- 42:24And there's just by magic happenstance.
- 42:27Nobody else gets on the flight. We get on the flight and we get
- 42:30upgraded to business. And that's not my first time
- 42:32accidentally getting upgraded to business when I'm 19.
- 42:35I'm in Spain, I'm incredibly hungover.
- 42:37I'm wearing a five times extra large champion yellow hoodie
- 42:41that's probably stained with my vomit.
- 42:42I'm at the airport and the lady goes, so sorry your ticket
- 42:44doesn't work. And it's just like, here you go,
- 42:47here's your new ticket, you've been upgraded to 1st class.
- 42:50I got to fucking have a shower on a plane like that.
- 42:53Doesn't happen to normal people. No, this stuff does happen to
- 42:58there's a lot of things that Brooke, obviously she puts in
- 43:00the hard work and everything she gets she's worked hard for, but
- 43:04there's just not really things that happen anything.
- 43:06How? How did you manage that?
- 43:09Even games go to fucking the Formula One.
- 43:11Everyone knows I love Formula One, OK, lover Formula One my
- 43:15whole life and it's my dream to go paddock pass.
- 43:18It's not possible to go paddock pass with a team unless you're
- 43:20invited by the team. Like you can't pay for that
- 43:22experience, like it's not actually possible.
- 43:25And that's always been a dream. And I know that's a pie dream,
- 43:26OK, And I never thought that dream was going to come true.
- 43:28It's like a night. It's a nice little like thing to
- 43:30think about. I need to go this year.
- 43:32Let me tell you, you're fucking better than I've expected.
- 43:36But how did I get there? Like awesome.
- 43:39The news, like we started the year.
- 43:40Got an email from Good Morning America.
- 43:41Do you want to come on Good Morning America?
- 43:43I didn't go because I got anxiety, but what?
- 43:47That's crazy. Good things happen to good
- 43:50people. So I'm trying to be good and
- 43:52hope that the good things get you to happen.
- 43:54Yeah. And I feel like from witnessing
- 43:57it, it makes me think, well, maybe one day I'll get upgraded
- 43:59to business if I keep being a good person.
- 44:03I think many good things are coming for your life.
- 44:05Don't worry. So what up?
- 44:08Yeah, Just just be good. Be.
- 44:11Good. Just be.
- 44:13Good be good, do good feel good. Yeah, I think that's all we have
- 44:18time for today because we've spoken for like 55 minutes.
- 44:21So it's going to be a joy for me to edit this.
- 44:24So I'll be not going to bed on time today, but hopefully you'll
- 44:26all enjoy listening to the podcast.
- 44:28And thank God for the additional audio inserts that Brooke can do
- 44:32later that will bring her some joy.
- 44:34And if none of this was helpful, well, what would we know?
- 44:39OK, goodbye Divas, Goodbye.