Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Electric Car Paradox: High Prices Despite Falling Battery Costs
Transcript
- 0:09Have you noticed the buzz around electric vehicles lately?
- 0:12I mean, they seem to be everywhere, right?
- 0:13Oh, absolutely Sleek new models gliding past headlines shouting
- 0:18about the future of transport. Yeah, exactly.
- 0:21But have you ever, like, stopped to think about what really makes
- 0:25someone choose an EV, or why they still feel so expensive for
- 0:31a lot of us, even with all this talk about battery costs
- 0:33dropping? That's the $1,000,000 question,
- 0:35isn't it? It really is.
- 0:37So today we're going to peel back the layers in a deep dive
- 0:39into electric vehicles, EVs. We'll look at, you know, the
- 0:42surprising history, what drives people to buy them, the
- 0:45economics and the crucial role of innovation.
- 0:48And to help us get a clear picture, we've lined up some
- 0:52really insightful sources. We've got a recent study looking
- 0:55at EV marketing and analysis of R&D spending in the industry,
- 0:58which is fascinating, and several economic reviews,
- 1:01looking at pricing, business models, all that stuff.
- 1:04Great. So our mission here is basically
- 1:06to cut through all the noise. We want to give you a kind of
- 1:09shortcut to understanding the whole EV landscape.
- 1:12You know, consumer psychology, industry investment policy, the
- 1:16works. Yeah, get ready for some maybe
- 1:19surprising facts and hopefully a much clearer idea of where this
- 1:23is all heading. OK, let's start with a bit of
- 1:25history, because this actually blew my mind a little.
- 1:27Ev's aren't new. Not at all.
- 1:29They were some of the very first cars Think about President
- 1:32Woodrow Wilson driving his Millburn Electric getting 6070
- 1:36miles range over a century ago. It's.
- 1:39Amazing, right? Back in the early 1900s,
- 1:41companies like Baker Electric, Detroit Electric, right?
- 1:44They actually outsold gas cars for a time, made-up something
- 1:47like 28% of cars on US roads. Wow, what would Wilson think of
- 1:52a Tesla today? Good question.
- 1:54But yeah, that early lead, it didn't last.
- 1:56By the 1920s, things shifted. Why was that?
- 1:58Well, gas cars just got more powerful.
- 2:00They could go much further, and critically, you could refuel
- 2:03them in minutes. Electric tech back then just
- 2:05couldn't compete on those points.
- 2:06Right. Makes sense.
- 2:07But Fast forward to now and we're seeing this huge comeback.
- 2:11A modern Renaissance, you could say.
- 2:12Definitely driven by, well, better motors, way more charging
- 2:17stations popping up and obviously big concerns about
- 2:20climate change and air quality. And the benefits today are
- 2:22pretty compelling. There really are.
- 2:24Environmentally it's it's pretty clear cut E VS mean.
- 2:29Fewer greenhouse gases, less air pollution.
- 2:32They contribute to cutting CO2. It's a big plus for
- 2:35sustainability. And efficiency wise here they're
- 2:38much better. Oh significantly.
- 2:40E VS convert electricity straight to motion so they're
- 2:43over 70% efficient. Your typical gas or diesel car,
- 2:47even a good diesel, struggles to hit 40%.
- 2:49That's a huge difference. It is.
- 2:51Plus they capture braking energy, You know, regenerative
- 2:53breaking. They're often two or three times
- 2:55better at using that energy. Very clever stuff.
- 2:57And then there's the driving experience, right?
- 2:59Less maintenance, quieter. Yeah, quieter ride, smoother
- 3:02acceleration, that instant torque is quite something, and
- 3:05generally lower running costs per mile for energy.
- 3:08No more oil changes, for instance.
- 3:10OK. So lots of positives, but
- 3:12historically there were drawbacks.
- 3:14You mentioned range and refueling times earlier.
- 3:17Exactly. And while the tech's improving
- 3:19fast on those fronts, the big hurdle that still remains for
- 3:21many people is that initial purchase price.
- 3:23It's still quite high. Right.
- 3:25So we got the overview benefits hurdles, but let's let's get
- 3:30granular. What actually goes on in
- 3:32someone's head when they're deciding whether to buy an EV?
- 3:34Well, there was a really interesting recent study
- 3:37surveyed about 100 people in Malaysia, Indonesia and India.
- 3:40It tried to pin down exactly that.
- 3:43And what did it find? What are the key drivers?
- 3:44It identified 3 core things directly affecting behavior, how
- 3:49happy people are with EV efficiency, how happy they are
- 3:52with the environmental side, and public perception, how others
- 3:56see EV. OK, efficiency, environment
- 3:59perception. Which one mattered most?
- 4:01Get this satisfaction with being environmentally friendly.
- 4:04That had the strongest impact by quite a margin.
- 4:07Actually the beta value was .594, which statistically that's
- 4:12a very strong link. Wow, so people really buy into
- 4:14the green aspect, Yeah. It seems so.
- 4:17Most respondents felt EVs help reduce global warming, and the
- 4:20research back set up fewer emissions over the car's life,
- 4:23even counting production and electricity generation.
- 4:25That's a key marketing angle. Makes sense?
- 4:27What about efficiency? Did that matter?
- 4:29Yes, definitely played a role. Beta value of 0.186.
- 4:33Around 38% were happy with performance, mentioning the
- 4:37quick acceleration and better range these days.
- 4:39Plus, you know, 0 tailpipe emissions, reliability, lower
- 4:42running cost. Those attract people too.
- 4:44And public perception. How you look driving 1.
- 4:47Also significant beta value .192 people felt buying an EV would
- 4:52boost their image and interestingly, 60% strongly
- 4:56agreed that EVs are just more comfortable to drive.
- 4:59Attitudes are definitely shifting.
- 5:01Awareness of EV advantages in the US hit 75% by 2022.
- 5:05OK. But here's a twist, right The
- 5:07study found something surprising about just knowing about EVs.
- 5:10Yeah, this was fascinating. Just general public awareness
- 5:12about EVs. It turned out not to have a
- 5:14significant impact on actual buying behavior during this
- 5:16study. The beta value was tiny .003.
- 5:20So just knowing EVs exist isn't enough.
- 5:22Apparently not. It suggests changing habits,
- 5:25especially big purchases like cars, needs more than just
- 5:29awareness. It needs to connect to like
- 5:32deeper values or real tangible benefits.
- 5:35Which brings us neatly to that big barrier we mentioned the
- 5:38price paradox. Batteries are getting cheaper,
- 5:41but EVs still cost more upfront. Right.
- 5:45Look at the US figures from June 2021.
- 5:48Average EV even after tax credits was over $61,000.
- 5:52Average gas car around $42,000. That's a big gap A.
- 5:56Huge gap. No wonder EVs were only about 2%
- 5:59of new US car sales back then. Exactly.
- 6:02So why? Why this paradox if battery
- 6:05costs are falling? Professor Peter Wells has some
- 6:07really good points on this. OK, let's hear them.
- 6:09Well, first perspective. Gas cars have had like over 100
- 6:12years of development, constant tweaking, perfecting
- 6:15commercially viable EV battery chemistry.
- 6:17We've only really been intensely focused on that for maybe 10-15
- 6:20years. There's still a lot of
- 6:22innovation to come. OK.
- 6:23So they're still on a steeper part of the development curve.
- 6:25Precisely. Second, battery size.
- 6:28Yes, the cost per kWh has plummeted maybe 90% in a decade,
- 6:31which is incredible. But the batteries themselves
- 6:34have gotten much bigger, much more powerful.
- 6:37So even if the unit cost is down, we're buying more units
- 6:40per car. Exactly.
- 6:42Think about the first Nissan Leaf in 2011.
- 6:44It had a 24 kilowatter battery, today 70 kilowaters.
- 6:48Almost standard. Bigger battery means more raw
- 6:51materials, more complexity, more cost.
- 6:53Got it. Yes. 3rd upfront engineering,
- 6:56designing totally new EV platforms like Tesla skateboard
- 7:00or T tray chassis where the battery is the floor, That super
- 7:02expensive initial even if it pays off later.
- 7:05Yeah, huge R&D investment. OK. 4th the business model.
- 7:09Traditional car makers often use the razor blade model, sell the
- 7:11car relatively cheap, make money on servicing parts, financing
- 7:15over years. Right, sell the razor.
- 7:16Cheap profit on the blades. You got it.
- 7:18But EVs need much less servicing, often have longer
- 7:21warranties, so manufacturers feel they need to make more
- 7:24profit from the initial sale that pushes the sticker price
- 7:27up. Interesting point. 5th Professor
- 7:29Wells calls it SUV addiction. We just love big, big heavy
- 7:34vehicles. Even electric ones.
- 7:35Huh. Guilty as charge, maybe.
- 7:37Right, so the market's full of these large EVSUVS.
- 7:40Think Hyundai Ionic 5. Great car but big, heavy uses
- 7:44lots of materials, Cost maybe £50,000.
- 7:47There just aren't enough smaller truly affordable options yet.
- 7:50Like, you know, a basic electric City car.
- 7:52Yeah, where the simple, cheaper electric runabouts.
- 7:55Exactly. And finally, material supply.
- 7:59Getting enough cobalt, lithium, nickel, it's a bottleneck.
- 8:03Tight supply holds back production volume, and high
- 8:05volume is what really helps drive costs down.
- 8:07This pressure is why some companies like Daimler Trucks
- 8:10are exploring alternatives like LFT batteries, lithium ion
- 8:13phosphate, even if they have slightly lower performance,
- 8:16because the materials are cheaper and more available.
- 8:19OK. So that explains the high cost.
- 8:21Given all that, what's the path to actually making Ev's
- 8:23affordable? How do we get to price parity
- 8:25with gas cars? Well, the biggest factor is
- 8:27still continued drops in battery costs.
- 8:29That powertrain, battery, motor, electronics, it's over half the
- 8:32cars cost. Right now over 51%.
- 8:34Yeah, and prices have plummeted 97% since 1991.
- 8:38The forecasts are still strong. Ford thinks 40% less by 2025.
- 8:42GM says 60%. Tesla predicts 50% with new
- 8:46battery designs may be enabling a $25,000 car.
- 8:49A $25,000 EV that would be a game changer.
- 8:53Absolutely. The magic number everyone talks
- 8:55about is getting battery cost below $100 per kWh.
- 8:59Bloomberg NEF thought that might even happen by 2023.
- 9:02Maybe we're already there are very close.
- 9:04OK, so battery costs are key. What else helps?
- 9:06Reducing range anxiety is another big one as fast charging
- 9:09networks get better and more widespread.
- 9:11Look at China installing over 112,000 chargers in just one
- 9:15month, December 2020. Manufacturers won't feel forced
- 9:18to pack in massive, expensive batteries just to calm consumer
- 9:21nerves. So better infrastructure means
- 9:24potentially smaller, cheaper batteries are viable.
- 9:26Exactly. Smaller, efficient batteries
- 9:27that still offer perfectly adequate range for most People's
- 9:30Daily needs? That lowers the car's cost.
- 9:32Makes sense. Production volume.
- 9:34Earlier economies of scale. Definitely look at Norway again.
- 9:3775% of new cars sold are electric.
- 9:40When you hit those kinds of volumes, the cost per car
- 9:42naturally falls. The EV industry is still young
- 9:45enough to really benefit from what's called Wright's Law.
- 9:47Basically efficiency rockets up as you produce more units,
- 9:51optimized designs, high volumes. It could be over a third cheaper
- 9:55by 2025. And more competition should help
- 9:57too, right? For sure, the market's growing
- 9:59incredibly fast. North America's projected
- 10:01growth, the THR is over 37% by 2028.
- 10:05Worldwide, it's over 22% by 2027.
- 10:09As more players jump in traditional automakers, new
- 10:11startups and offer more models beyond the high end Tesla's that
- 10:14dominated early on, that competition will push prices
- 10:17down. OK.
- 10:18And the final piece seems to be government support policies,
- 10:21subsidies. Crucial, especially in the
- 10:23medium term, subsidies help people overcome that initial
- 10:26price hurdle, stimulate demand, which then leads to higher
- 10:28volumes and lower costs in the long run.
- 10:30They also help correct, you know, existing market issues
- 10:33like gas prices not reflecting the true environmental cost or
- 10:36heavy taxes on fuel. You mentioned policies are about
- 10:39making the economics work. It's not just about handing out
- 10:41money. Right.
- 10:42It's about balancing the wider social benefits like cleaner air
- 10:46with the commercial reality, trying to make prices reflect
- 10:49true costs. And electricity pricing is part
- 10:52of that too. Charging at home off peak can be
- 10:54super cheap, maybe 5 euro cents per kilowatt.
- 10:58But using a public fast charger at peak time, that could be much
- 11:01more, up to $0.45. OK.
- 11:03So pricing, batteries, scale, it's complex.
- 11:07Now let's talk R&D. You mentioned it's a critical
- 11:09indicator for companies in this space.
- 11:11Hugely important R&D intensity. How much a company spends on
- 11:15research relative to its income shows its ability to innovate
- 11:18fast and grab market share in this super competitive EV
- 11:22market. And the advantages of high R&D
- 11:24are pretty clear, I guess better tech Guler products.
- 11:26Exactly. High R&D leads to cutting edge
- 11:29tech, advanced products and that attracts those early adopters,
- 11:32people wanting the latest thing. That helps companies seize
- 11:35market share, quickly build a brand and and ideally, turn a
- 11:38profit. You see that with companies like
- 11:39Tesla, right? Leading on autonomous driving
- 11:41software over the air updates. Absolutely.
- 11:44Or look at BYD and China. Big breakthroughs in battery
- 11:47tech and even making their own crucial components like Igbts,
- 11:51the power control chips, and R&D leads to patents protecting
- 11:55those innovations. Tesla filed way more patents
- 11:58than BYD or X paying in 2019-2020.
- 12:01Although interestingly, X, paying even with less total
- 12:04spending than Tesla, had a high number of patent applications
- 12:08for its R&D level. OK.
- 12:09But there's a flip side, isn't there?
- 12:11Too much R&D can be risky? Oh, definitely.
- 12:14If a company plows too much of its income into R&D, especially
- 12:17as a percentage, it can leave them with virtually no cash
- 12:20reserves. That's a huge financial risk if
- 12:22they hit any kind of trouble. Can you give an example?
- 12:25Xping Motor is a good case study.
- 12:26Back in 2019 they apparently invested almost all their
- 12:29revenue into R&D. Wow really?
- 12:31Yeah, and it led to massive losses early on.
- 12:33Something like CN¥5.9 billion lost in just 2 1/2 years.
- 12:37Spending that intensely means you risk literally running out
- 12:40of money for day-to-day operations, paying suppliers.
- 12:43It could even lead to bankruptcy if things go wrong.
- 12:45So it's a high wire act, and companies face other risks too,
- 12:49beyond just R&D spending. For sure, Teslas had product
- 12:52issues like a battery cooling problem on the early Model S,
- 12:56and now they face huge marketing risks from all the competition
- 12:59flooding in from legacy automakers and new EV players
- 13:02that's expected to eat into their global market share.
- 13:05What are BYT? You said they're technologically
- 13:07strong. They are, but they've had
- 13:09production headaches like 3.5 month waits for some cars in
- 13:122021, and profitability has been squeezed.
- 13:16Their net profit rates reportedly dropped from around
- 13:1820% down to just 3% / 2 decades as their costs went up.
- 13:23So the bottom line on R&D is? Pretty much find the right level
- 13:27of investment relative to revenue.
- 13:29Manage the risks carefully. It's about sustainable
- 13:32innovation, not just throwing money at problems.
- 13:35OK. Let's shift gears slightly.
- 13:37Beyond the cars and the R&D, the whole ecosystem matters,
- 13:40charging infrastructure, business models.
- 13:42Absolutely essential. You can't have mass EV adoption
- 13:44without robust ways to charge them.
- 13:46Even back around 2012, European cities were trying all sorts of
- 13:49things. Special EV parking spots,
- 13:51roaming payment systems, monthly subscriptions.
- 13:54Battery swapping, right? Yeah, battery swapping stations
- 13:57were being piloted, and even things like intelligent sockets
- 14:00to manage charging times, automatically save money on
- 14:03electricity and avoid overloading the local grid.
- 14:07And that company, better Place, they had a model where they
- 14:10owned the battery. That's right, partnered with
- 14:12Renault, they owned the batteries and you'd pull into a
- 14:15station and swap your depleted battery for a full 1 in just a
- 14:18few minutes, like filling up with gas.
- 14:21It didn't quite take off globally, did it?
- 14:23No, it faced challenges, but the idea of separating battery
- 14:27ownership from car ownership is still around.
- 14:29Some experts think manufacturers might eventually keep ownership
- 14:32of the battery pack for its whole life, maybe across several
- 14:36leases. Why would they do that?
- 14:38Mainly for recycling and managing the valuable materials,
- 14:41but it could also give them more control over pricing,
- 14:44warranties, maybe even insurance and financing tied to the
- 14:47batteries condition. It could really change the
- 14:50ownership model. Interesting.
- 14:51And all this happens against the backdrop of policy and
- 14:54economics. We touched on subsidies.
- 14:56Yeah, subsidies are key in the medium term to get things
- 14:59moving, overcome those barriers, boost volumes, lower costs and
- 15:03as we said, to offset existing distortions like fuel taxes or
- 15:07lack of carbon pricing. It helps level the playing
- 15:10field. But it's a constantly moving
- 15:11target, isn't it? Because gas cars are getting
- 15:13cleaner, too. Exactly, internal combustion
- 15:16engines aren't standing still. They're improving under stricter
- 15:20emissions rules and eventually as more E VS hit the road,
- 15:23governments will have to figure out Rd. funding.
- 15:26Right now fuel taxes pay for a lot of Rd. maintenance and EVs
- 15:30don't pay that directly. That will need to change.
- 15:32So wrapping this all up, what's the big picture take away for
- 15:36someone listening? I think it's that the EV
- 15:39revolution is this really dynamic mix of things.
- 15:41You've got the tech advancing super fast.
- 15:43You've got consumer priorities shifting especially towards the
- 15:46environment. You've got huge strategic bets
- 15:48on R&D and these evolving economic models and policies
- 15:52trying to keep pace. And while that upfront cost is
- 15:55still a hurdle. It is, but the trend towards
- 15:58price parity and wider adoption seems, well, pretty much
- 16:02inevitable, driven by better, cheaper batteries, more places
- 16:05to charge and just the sheer scale of production kicking in.
- 16:09It really feels like more than just changing how cars are
- 16:12powered. Oh, absolutely.
- 16:13It's a case study in how values, innovation and policy can
- 16:18totally reshape a massive industry.
- 16:20And like we discussed, it might fundamentally change how we even
- 16:23think about owning a car. Maybe it becomes more of a
- 16:26service, especially the battery part.
- 16:28That's a fascinating thought to end on.
- 16:30Will we own the car but lease or subscribe to the battery?
- 16:34Lots to think about. Definitely the next decade is
- 16:37going to be transformative. Well, this has been incredibly
- 16:39insightful. If you enjoyed this deep dive
- 16:42and found these insights valuable, please do consider
- 16:44liking this episode and subscribing to our channel.
- 16:47We aim to bring you more shortcuts to being well
- 16:48informed.