Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-Episode 6-Are there subjects that are just too offensive
Transcript
- 0:00Wow, Wow, wow wow. This is Hashtag Channel, a podcast about
- 0:05discord with Ben and Steve. Well, actually a hashtag means it's a channel,
- 0:18all right, Steve. So we had a a eminent drama critic come
- 0:25on the Discord and give some incredible drama criticism to the Hashtag Channel show.
- 0:32And as we all know, you are always looking for and accept ill feedback.
- 0:36Yeah, don't find it. Resent for it all. And he said
- 0:38that the opening banter bit is too long, So what are we gonna do
- 0:42about it? After altogether too much consultation with the greatest minds in the world
- 0:48topics, we present this screw you Giles, back to getting screw through you.
- 1:00Do we have any banter that we can engage in for the next forty
- 1:03five minutes? I I'm thinking the twenty six days of Bouncer. So first
- 1:08of all, what's today? It is Sunday, Sunday, like lovely winter
- 1:14Sunday. The sun is shining, lovely cup of tea. I was hoping
- 1:17that after this recording, sometime much later than this, I might be able
- 1:21to persuade you to finally visit the historical Christmas market down at an Era Venu.
- 1:25Yeah, well, we tried it the other day. Wouldn't let you
- 1:27in? Why not because like no cucks allowed. Yeah, that's cucks a
- 1:32loud Yeah, and so I've got to I've got to decock myself. I'm
- 1:34thinking of watching Andrew take videos. They beckoned me to come inside. But
- 1:38you know, if I spoil loyal friend, if I smoke a big cigar
- 1:42and act like a twat, do you think I'll be less cocky? There's
- 1:45probably like a separate entrance just for people like you, if you know that.
- 1:48Yeah, yeah, but you were carrying your your new foldable bike.
- 1:52I'm looking at it right now, your foldable bike on which you look like
- 1:55a very cool young person. Cool cool hips to do despite your grizzled appearance.
- 1:59Yeah, I gotta do some. So I was reading in the Guardian
- 2:00a few months ago that this company are trying to They've got this pill that
- 2:06they say, if you take the pill, your hair just goes back to
- 2:08its normal natural color. Yeah, they've got another pill that will like reduce
- 2:14your cravings and cause you to lose weight and drink less alcohol. Then bloody
- 2:19hell you could take what if they fucking did a combo pill? Wah.
- 2:22Fountain of youth, sober with big, bushy black beards. Yeah, just
- 2:27think about it. You don't have to be the the fucking, the old,
- 2:30cynical, jaded, drunk crank that you are. You could be a
- 2:32younger, better, cleaner, living version of yourself, equally a cynical,
- 2:38still frustrated. So there's probably no pill for that part anyway. I just
- 2:42wanted to say to the listeners, if you've got some, you know,
- 2:45constructive criticism and I to structure the show, get on the discord. How
- 2:49would they join the discords day even if they got all that wonderful constructive criticism
- 2:53www dot five games for Doomsday dot com. The entire thing spelled out like
- 2:59five. It's because we're bloody sophisticated, none of this. Oh well,
- 3:01you've an in bullshit? So what is your username on x at five games
- 3:09four doomsdays with the numbers? Right? Yeah, but they had a character
- 3:13limits, they had a character Okay, what about mastered on fucking email address?
- 3:22What's the email address? Five games to Doomsday gmail dot com or written
- 3:24out some classic Okay, so these two are consistent. Yeah, what about
- 3:28blue Sky it's a good five G for DAL I think are you're on Blue
- 3:32Sky. I am on Blue well, I mean I'm on Blue Sky in
- 3:35the sense that the thing is the thing is I've mentioned this on the podcast
- 3:38I did with Uli, which was a far better experience. And what anyway,
- 3:43So like everyone on X is going, oh, I think I'm going
- 3:47over to Blue Sky. Like the atmosphere is like, looks so more friendly
- 3:53people, and it just seems like a it seems like a sort of bourgeois
- 3:58circle jerk where everyone is just pretending to be friendly, and so it seems
- 4:01like an absolute bloody nightmare. I'm staying I'm staying on X. You like
- 4:04you like keeping it edgy, don't you? Yeah? Feels like the wild
- 4:08West? Still, you know what I mean? What do you suppose he
- 4:10paid for X dot com loads of money? I see X dot com and
- 4:14I think of the board game which you have x coom. Yeah yeah,
- 4:16and like someone must have had it, and he just like he fucking reached
- 4:20into his bottomless pitt, bottomless pit of wealth and pulled out a check for
- 4:24a fucking on hundred million. What doesn't he buying me five g f D
- 4:26dot com? Yeah? I don't know why anybody's squad. I'm gonna tonight.
- 4:30How much do you think five G for D dot com cost? I
- 4:31would actually be curious to know from Giles how much he thinks five G for
- 4:34D dot com might be worth? Why is here? Is that what he
- 4:39does? No, I'm just trying to involve Giles in the banter. I
- 4:41mean, I actually think his critique is not so much about the format of
- 4:44the show, is that we don't mention him. Yeah, he feels a
- 4:46bit left, is a bit cry cry. I think he's a bit cry
- 4:48cry Giles. I think he's got a very fragile sensibility. Like at any
- 4:51moment when I was speaking to him, I thought he was about to lose
- 4:54it. Do you think do you think people like that you have to like
- 4:56walk on eggshell Do you think he's crying into his diet coke. I think
- 4:59he's probably like shaking with frustration right now. So again again, I'm gonna
- 5:04keep I'm gonna keep vampaing the thing about the Christmas markets. The thing about
- 5:08Berlin is everyone has this attitudes like, oh it's fucking Berlin. There are
- 5:11no rules here. Everyone just like lives the way they want to. Like
- 5:14the one part of Germany where you think that that's not true. But it's
- 5:18still Germany and they still have these fucking rules, and like, if you're
- 5:21not following the rules, like there's no negotiating and I honestly, I just
- 5:28there's no contingency for these things. I can see why they don't want you
- 5:30to bring a bike into the Christmas market. But like, what domain is
- 5:33available on go Daddy. It says five g fd dot com twelve euro sixteen
- 5:40for the first year, but then it says estimated value three hundred and twenty
- 5:44nine euros. Now, go to Hover dot com. Don't buy it from
- 5:46go Daddy. Wells hoaver dot com. It's just better Hover hyder dot com.
- 5:51I don't spell that h O V e R. It's not Hoover.
- 5:55It's Hover dot com. Not like that that fucking Frank Zappa musical about fucking
- 5:59vacuum cleaner you made me listen to last night. Yeah, it's very good.
- 6:01That's Joe's garage anyway. So anyway, it was supposedly be doing a
- 6:03bloody podcasting Steve. I'm just saying, like there was nobody in the Christmas
- 6:08market. It's a fucking weak night. It was raining, Yeah, and
- 6:10I couldn't into like it's like nothing when you're carrying it, what's the big
- 6:14deal? No, we have rules, we have to follow them. So
- 6:16so why is hova dot com so god daddy just has a bad reputation among
- 6:24geeks for like overcharging and oh it says, so could you help me do
- 6:29a redirect if I bought the domain because it's only seventeen dollars and ninety nine
- 6:32cents. Yeah, absolutely, you can probably just configure it right there and
- 6:35it's like nothing. We'll do that after the podcast. Anyway, My god,
- 6:39this is fucking break Giles, Giles, you made this happen five gfd
- 6:42dot com. Giles made this happen. This is very exciting. It wasn't
- 6:45for his fucking obnoxious, unwelcome feedback, we wouldn't have bothered to go through
- 6:50the trouble of extending this already onerous band terrific prelude to the podcast and look
- 6:58for the fucking website in real time anyway, So, uh, this this
- 7:02is something This Today's show is something of a mash up. Steve, Yeah,
- 7:05new show, let's do it because the news show is not going to
- 7:09happen this month. Because this was the new show. No, no,
- 7:12this is the hashtag Channel show, Steve. What's the difference again, Well,
- 7:15one is where we read out Discord comments on a chosen topic, yep.
- 7:19And the other one is where I interview luminarias from the industry about their
- 7:23upcoming projects. I'm involved in that part, but I know that I'm on
- 7:26some of it. Yeah, So banter at the beginning, yep. Then
- 7:30your favorite bit, the Q and A. Right, yeah, that's the
- 7:32news show. Yeah, and then the Channel show is banter at the beginning,
- 7:38and then like a different kind of Q and A. No, this
- 7:41is what the what the people? What the people write? It's the democratic
- 7:45show on the Discord. But you you, you pose the question, you
- 7:47give the cue. Well not this month, but we'll get to that,
- 7:50and they give the a's. Yeah. So also, I just want to
- 7:54say to the listeners, you understand my confusion here, So Giles, you
- 7:57understand my confusion. I just want to say to the listeners, if you're
- 7:59not a member of the disc there's a good reason to become a member of
- 8:01the Discord. And that's because soon we're going to put up the categories for
- 8:05the annual, first ever inaugural five g for the awards. Who's listening to
- 8:09this right now, who's not a member of the Discord, Well, I
- 8:11get it. Boggles the mind. I get a lot more downloads than I
- 8:15have Discord members, so lots of people would be my assumption. Unless people
- 8:18are downloading the show, we need to keep reinforcing this message. This is
- 8:22Can I get this? Can I get this messagize? This is not a
- 8:24bit? Can I get this messagiz? I need the people to understand this
- 8:28Discord is a real thing. I get this message. Ben. I think
- 8:33everyone I'm trying to do some Everyone thinks that all we do is bits.
- 8:35Yeah, this is not a bit. You gotta get on the Discard.
- 8:39I'm getting progressively angry and angry, and I just want to say the bits
- 8:41so people can listen to it without you interrupting. Five Games for Doomsday dot
- 8:45com. We didn't finished this from before, right, there's a pinned post
- 8:48at the end of the page right that will that that's a redirect that will
- 8:52redirect you to Discord with the maybe maybe after the show five g fd dot
- 8:56com, but anyway carry out. Possibly you'll be able to go to five
- 8:58g for d dot com, which is better it'll it'll redirect five games from
- 9:01doomsday dot com. There'll be a pinned post the top of the page with
- 9:05a link the invite link to the discord. You click that, you get
- 9:07redirected again. Then you're in the discord. And when you join the discord,
- 9:11everyone says alotio when you come in, because the discord announces it,
- 9:13and then people say, e lootio to fucking jump in and start making obnoxious
- 9:16remarks like the other dickheads. Right, can I do one minute now,
- 9:20just while I explain something to the listeners, Yes, without you interrupting.
- 9:24One minute? God anyway, so we have some tea. So we're gonna
- 9:28do the first ever annual five G for the Awards, and we're gonna put
- 9:35up categories for you to vote. Not all the categories are going to have
- 9:39you voting on it, but there's gonna be categories that you're gonna be able
- 9:43to vote on. I'm not sure if I can do polls in discord or
- 9:46find it out. And so if you join the Discord, you'll be able
- 9:48to contribute to the five G for the Awards, the most prestigious awards in
- 9:54the board gaming world. Are there other Awards. I mean, this is
- 9:58Schmielders Yrus, but no one gets shit about that? Is that about this
- 10:00podcast? Dice Tower Awards. I'm on the committee, but you know they're
- 10:03not as important as the five g f D Awards. I not think so
- 10:05the Golden Geeks, but we I I've never heard of that awards. Frankly
- 10:11anyway, So what was saying, There's gonna be no new show this week
- 10:15due to scheduling issues. So we're gonna mash the new show in here and
- 10:18we're gonna thank the new patrons this month. Scheduling issues means that, like
- 10:24you weren't on top of shit or something. No, I was on top
- 10:26of shit. But you know people, you know, people are busy.
- 10:28Yeah, but you and I we will have news go on? Then what
- 10:33you news? Well, we just had a visit from Ves opponent, the
- 10:37designer of All Bridges Burning. He came down. We played All Bridges Burning
- 10:41with some rules tweaks. I consider him my my paduan Steve. Why well,
- 10:48because I'm oh, yeah, that's right, your quest. I'm I'm
- 10:50coaching him in podcasts. So you introduced me to the Coin series of games,
- 10:54and I think this is a fucking cracking series of games like The Sister.
- 10:58I love the card You're and model, and I love this implementation of
- 11:01it. And what a treat to be able to play one of these games
- 11:05with its designer. Absolutely, and I was gonna kick your ass. The
- 11:09communists or and I guess they're not technically communists, right, the Reds.
- 11:11Yeah, the Reds were fucking mopping all over Finland. Yeah, mapping up
- 11:16the whites and the Bluize. It is amazing. So I did a review
- 11:18of Vezzi's game or Bridges Burnie a couple of years ago, and we had
- 11:24got it down to quite a fine arts a three player coin game. It's
- 11:28really great, and we've got it down to about three hours at one point,
- 11:31right, which for a game? Did you play it four or five
- 11:33times? I think I was only involved in one of those. So who
- 11:37are these other people? You're playing coin games with the best of people anyway,
- 11:41So, so, and it is amazing. I hadn't played it for
- 11:45two years and I just completely forgot everything. I did not know how to
- 11:48play it. It's absolutely astonishing the way the human mind works. But anyway,
- 11:52but you can get back into it quickly because the coin games all share
- 11:56like like some you know, genetic similarities. Yeah, like the eligibility system,
- 12:01like it's an event or a command or a limited command or or whatever
- 12:05the fuck. And even I, even I only who only played it once
- 12:09I got back into it, and there's just something like really compelling about it.
- 12:13I mean, the theme is like maybe dry as dust for some people,
- 12:16the early twentieth century finished Revolution, but it's just it's just such an
- 12:22engaging game, such an engaging model for games. So that's some news.
- 12:24Yeah, what let's get to Let's get to these patron backers, Steve,
- 12:30I'm going to give you their names and then you're going to give them a
- 12:33nickname. Oh god, I want to progress, to get procrastinate this some
- 12:35more. There's only two this month, okay, so it's better than the
- 12:39previous month, though the previous month wasn't very good. How many of the
- 12:41previous month that was zero the previous month, well actually minus three that previous
- 12:46month. At least they didn't have to come up with nicknames. How many
- 12:48patrons are there in total? In total active members one hundred and ten,
- 12:54one hundred and ten. That's perfect because next year I want to hit one
- 12:56thousand. How are you suggesting we we are increase this magnitude. We're gonna
- 13:01grow. Yes, we're gonna grow the audience for this podcast exactly by an
- 13:05order of magnitude. Ben, thank you for citing a very important term in
- 13:09my field, computers. Yeah. Anyway, so how are we gonna do
- 13:13it? Fucking dogged, relentless pursuit of audience, of of of notoriety,
- 13:20getting the word out, messaging, forcing engagement, all of the things that
- 13:24you need to be doing every single day. I'm gonna fucking start doing it
- 13:26amazing, all right, So we'll get so the first one, Steve is
- 13:31Paul, Right, do I know this person? I don't think so.
- 13:33I don't know. Maybe I know him, I don't know Paul. He's
- 13:37always right, very very good and then flattering too, I might say.
- 13:43And then secondly, they just joined the discord, this person, and I
- 13:46am absolutely definitely not gonna butcher their name, Steve. Okay, they are
- 13:52called askus fair and dule christiaden saying I didn't even understand why. I'll do
- 13:58it again. And uh, if you're I think you're severin on the discord,
- 14:03get on the discord. Tell me how I did with the pronunciation escasverin
- 14:07ule Christian and sin esther ascar ascar severin escare severin ule, youll Christian and
- 14:16sin ascar severin you'll love it Christian. Amazing. Anyway, So that's been
- 14:26fourteen minutes about to Steve, that's short enough for you, Giles. That's
- 14:30short enough for you, Giles. After altogether too much consultation with the greatest
- 14:35minds in the world topics, we present this is all right, Steve,
- 14:45here we go. So this this topic this week in the hash channel show.
- 14:50It's Uli. I choose Uli. No, are we doing post three
- 14:52of the month. No, we're doing the topic verse. We gotta do
- 14:54the topic verse. You've got to know the posters before you can just reflexively
- 14:58fucking talk about Uli. Okay, there is a poster of the month part
- 15:01to this bit though, right well, another section later later, did Ulli
- 15:05weigh in on this one? No? What if I text him right now
- 15:09and he manages to weigh in, Like while we're recording this, when the
- 15:13quote go into the document, that's it. They're all right, they're locked
- 15:18in a right, all right, let's do it. Let's do it.
- 15:20Giles is waiting after all. Anyway, So I can't remember who because I
- 15:24couldn't find the original post, So I apologize for whoever made the original comment.
- 15:30But go into the discord and announce yourself and we'll all give you those
- 15:33likey like things on your comment. But they had a comment that was I
- 15:37thought it was a great topic because I like these sort of topics, and
- 15:41that is, you know, is there a subject for a game that we
- 15:43shouldn't make? Are there things that are that are sort of out of bounds
- 15:50for the art form of board games? And so I guess my first question
- 15:54to you, Steve is what is your reaction to that question? Do you
- 15:58recall some years ago there was a controversy about a statue of Jesus that was
- 16:03put on display at I think the Brooklyn Museum of Arts in New York that
- 16:07was made out of shit, very controversial. So I would ask you,
- 16:11if we believe board games or art bent, is there even by definition a
- 16:15subject that a board game should not go into. If we think of them
- 16:18merely as commercial products that are meant to, you know, flatter the sensibilities
- 16:26of mainstream play society and are ephemeral fund yeah, that is basically kid stuff,
- 16:32then then I agree I suppose, like you shouldn't go into certain topics.
- 16:37Why because I suppose it'll offend some people, It'll be bad for business,
- 16:42uh, some other bullshit reasons. If you really do think that there
- 16:47art, then the same thing like should should should movies not go into certain
- 16:48topics? There's a play that also controversial that came out last year in New
- 16:53York City, I think called Slave Play. You can guess what it's about,
- 16:56very controversial. Should plays not touch certain subjects? Should paintings not depict
- 17:03certain things? Right? Should music? I mean, obviously any of these
- 17:07things. You would say that that's patently ridiculous, because art is the way,
- 17:10the means by which we reflect on our on our reality, and the
- 17:14way we we more or less communicate ideas to one another and and extend the
- 17:18conversation and actually, you know, somehow evolve and progress our sensibility toward better
- 17:22ideas and in a better world. Sometimes, I mean, I would say
- 17:26that we can't always depend on art to be like politically progressive. I would
- 17:32say that generally speaking, well, no, and by its very nature,
- 17:33I mean, if our art art reflects politics, and politics is progressive and
- 17:37conservative, right, and and art can be ideological, but it doesn't necessarily
- 17:42like to be. It doesn't have to be, and it certainly is not
- 17:45on one side or another. In fact, I would say the best art
- 17:48probably isn't it's it's complex and nuanced, and it makes you think, and
- 17:51it's interesting, and there are well. I mean, Shakespeare is a great
- 17:53example. So maybe in his day, and I think almost certainly in his
- 17:57day, Shakespeare's plays were expressly ideological, basically in favor of the current regime,
- 18:04right. I mean, I don't think you had much choice in the
- 18:07matter. Right. But the point is, at five hundred years distance,
- 18:11they've been decoupled from that politics. And now what we get from Shakespeare is
- 18:17eternal truths about who we are as humans, right, which is great.
- 18:21I think stuff that is expressly political in that way dates very quickly, and
- 18:26are they are labile enough that you can do things with them that the author
- 18:33never intended? And who cares what the author? First of all, we'll
- 18:36never know what the author intended. Firstly, don't even know the author themselves
- 18:38will know what they intended. In the case of Shakespeare in particular, it's
- 18:42not like he kept a diary and he's like fucking oh, that's named after
- 18:48my son who just died. And I am a closet Catholic, and therefore
- 18:51I'm going to make some like you know, sub subterranean claims about June exactly
- 18:56fifteenth June nine to fucking hope some dickhead called Steve doesn't end up studying these
- 19:04works later down the line that would make me flip in my grove recently discovered
- 19:11in the old and old book binding in the British Library. So do you
- 19:15see the point I'm trying to meet? I do, I do, And
- 19:18I think what's interesting about this question is I think this question reflects a term
- 19:25you don't like, but it reflects the gaming community. So I think I
- 19:29think gaming is two things. Incredibly bourgeois, very conservative, and I think
- 19:38there is this idea that the worst thing you can do is rock the boat.
- 19:42And then couple that with Twitter. The kind of people who cause issues
- 19:49for games on Twitter are American leftists, right social justice American people who have
- 19:56very little knowledge of topics but like to angry. And you couple those two
- 20:00things and what you have is a real conservatism. You see a profusion of
- 20:07games about cats because they're unthreatening. Firstly, because people are essentially conservative.
- 20:11Secondly, people think, well, these are actually even you know, died
- 20:15in the wool. Gamers think well, these are just you know, it's
- 20:19actually just a thing I do to chill out. I don't want to think
- 20:22when I play games. And then thirdly, you have an army of people
- 20:26from Twitter. If you try to make what oh sorry x, you you
- 20:30have an army of these people who will try and crash your project the establishment.
- 20:38So, for instance, there was that game the what was that?
- 20:42What was it? What was it called the Vanze Conference where governments from around
- 20:48the world cut up Africa in the eighteen hundreds. Is it the Scramble for
- 20:52Africa? Yeah, and that got canceled because people on Twitter are angry about
- 20:56that was also in Vansee. I think the Vansee Conference was the one that
- 20:59did it. Van is usually associated with with the other a different thing.
- 21:03Yeah, but no, I think I think that's what it was. It
- 21:06was Bismarck, who do who brought the comfortation. I remember the story of
- 21:08the Scramble for Africa and it's just like it's just like it makes you feel
- 21:14uncomfortable, so it shouldn't be produced. I mean, it's that kind of
- 21:17mob like censorship, that there are people on Twitter who claim to be against
- 21:23and yet because what it is is essentially conservative. It is, as someone
- 21:29said to me the other day, diversity in everything except opinions, right,
- 21:33and so so someone someone when I'm going to ask you a question, and
- 21:37you may not be able to answer it or unwilling to answer it. But
- 21:40there was there was a person whose name I'm not going to mention, made
- 21:42a post on Facebook saying, I am leaving the board game industry because it
- 21:48is completely ideologically captured by the radical left and any kind of dissension from a
- 21:56radical social justice left position will result in your cancelation. And I am not
- 22:00prepared to be in an industry that is like this. Do you see that?
- 22:07Not really? I guess you're not as online as me, so so
- 22:10I think it's because, like, because I'm probably like most people like online
- 22:14quite a lot, but not so much that this would make a difference to
- 22:18me. So I think it hit its like you see, people are like
- 22:21canceled to the point where their game, their games have no potential commercial viability.
- 22:25So it hit its acme during COVID, I would say, but it
- 22:30had been bubbling there were certain people on Twitter from a certain political standpoint who
- 22:36basically had this is this sounds like massively hyperbolic, but to some degree had
- 22:42ideological pressure over the American side of the industry. I think this is a
- 22:48problem with people spending way too much time on exactly, And so there was
- 22:52a reluctance, especially in America and especially at a febrile time, for people
- 22:59to unless it was sort of morally sanctioned by that particular cadre of people.
- 23:06So there are serious topics that you could go into, but unless you did
- 23:08it from that perspective, and of course that idea, that sort of modern
- 23:12American idea that if you study a sociological group of people, it is better
- 23:21and more worthy that a person be part of that group and not really know
- 23:26much than be an expert from outside of that group. Right. And so
- 23:30there was a time where it felt like, and this just might be you
- 23:33know, COVID times, but it felt like there was an enforced adherence to
- 23:42a certain political ideology and to step outside of it even slightly would result in
- 23:48your cancelation. I think it feels like this only for people who spend which
- 23:52too much fucking time on X and Facebook and like. But it feels these
- 23:55other all these other platforms that by the way, that people using them who
- 23:57think that they're advancing some progres of cause these platforms are are run by some
- 24:03of the most like capitalistically rapacious corporations in the history of humanity, and almost
- 24:08I do by creating content as well. By the way, I don't use
- 24:12any of this shit anymore. And it's not like I'm not trying to take
- 24:15an ideological stand either. I find like it's, uh, it makes my
- 24:18life worse and like my fucking mental health worst to use them. But I
- 24:22also think all you're doing is like creating content for free for these platforms to
- 24:26become even more powerful, to capture more attention and more information and sell your
- 24:30data. I mean, anyone who like takes an ideological position on anything and
- 24:34claims to be progressive, that's using as a platform Facebook and X, I
- 24:37mean, go fuck yourself. You are already compromised from an ideological position.
- 24:41As far as I'm concerned. Posting is not activism anyway. So we're going
- 24:45on to also, by the way, this idea that this is a reflection
- 24:48of the boarding community, I think it's probably which it's deeply I think it's
- 24:52a reflection of the broader sort of cultural zeitgeist. This is true a certain
- 24:55population. There is no types. There is no mind that the people in
- 25:02charge of producing the games that we love to play, yeah, are very
- 25:07very wary of a very small card ray of people. I've got two more
- 25:11things to say quick, because I want to get to the other one.
- 25:15You've primed me for Fox's sake. I've got things the other people I didn't
- 25:18think I would have anything to say about because I'm annoyed by the topic.
- 25:21Come on, two things. The first thing is what is the problem with
- 25:23playing games like this or that there are games like this because it forces you
- 25:27to play acts, to play a role of a group or a person or
- 25:33whatever, from from from history or from some scenario, which is like somehow
- 25:37unsavory, right, Very much like I would say like theater and film,
- 25:41we would not say the same thing. So the second thing, all of
- 25:44these arguments that you shouldn't address certain themes and games are predicated on the assumption,
- 25:48I would guess that games are ultimately silly, right, They're toys,
- 25:52and by having a game with such and such a theme, you are trivializing
- 25:56the original topic, which I think is unfair and could not be further from
- 26:00the tree, because there is an assumption that the medium itself is trivial.
- 26:07Therefore, no matter how you address it, you are trivializing the subject because
- 26:11the medium in it and of itself is trivial. And I disagree with I
- 26:15reject this basic premise. And unless there's like a counter argument that does not
- 26:19derive from that premise, I don't think we're gonna get anywhere with this line
- 26:22of thought. Ben So Scott Hill fucking amped now, it's probably it's probably
- 26:26the tea. Thank you for the tea, by the way, Yeah,
- 26:29got honey in it like a fucking five year old. Listeners love that,
- 26:33Steve. Listeners love the sound of people slurping and eating. Will you stop
- 26:37that? Fuck sa Hello Giles, So Scott Hill, I think this is
- 26:41a hard thing to find. I will play games about most subjects. I
- 26:45love Nemo's War. But then just the other day I was listening to a
- 26:48podcast about a solo game which you play a German U boat captain going out
- 26:52and sinking Allied shipping, and I was like, Nope, why is that?
- 26:56I don't know, does that make me a hypocrite? Probably? Okay,
- 27:00I do have a reaction to this one. Yep. I think that's
- 27:03totally fine. So if you don't want to play a game, that's great.
- 27:06If you want to argue that a certain game should not exist, or
- 27:08that games shouldn't tackle certain subjects, that's where we would differ. We you
- 27:14and I are both aware and maybe many of our listeners will be aware of
- 27:17certain extremely unsavory games from the early twentieth century that that were like, ye,
- 27:22like we would find them pretty disgusting, like horribly anti semitic. I
- 27:26don't want to play games like that, I mean so so, so it's
- 27:30that classic thing, right, It's interesting that they exist as like cult yeah,
- 27:34historical curiosities, and like they they give us another form of insight into
- 27:40the mentality of the time exactly we need to know about so we don't repeat
- 27:44it, and we like the fact that they would make games out of these
- 27:47kinds of subjects is interesting, like horrifying, but interesting. So so the
- 27:52thing is, I think what we see and this is this is a this
- 27:56is a facet of sort of politics in general. I think is I think
- 28:00it's absolutely fascinating, And I think it's absolutely permissible to go by your own
- 28:08principles and not do things that you consider to be against your principles. Right.
- 28:14Where we have a problem is when you assert that other people shouldn't.
- 28:21And the big problem with the big problem with the way people discuss these things
- 28:26online is they make moral judgments about people. If you see this movie,
- 28:30you are a blank. If you play this game, you are a blank.
- 28:34And this sort of really pernicious thing. So recently, Rodney Smith did
- 28:40a video on X about some guy who has been going around saying things about
- 28:47him and who is blocked so Rodney can't see them. But someone told him
- 28:52and he's saying some really silly stuff about Rodney right, clearly not true.
- 28:55So Rodney went out and made this video saying this guy is lying about me.
- 29:00And someone responded to his tweet with and this is this has been happening
- 29:06a lot, but I find it. I find it deeply sinister. I
- 29:11can't believe I've got so many mutuals who also follow this guy. This has
- 29:15got to change. So this is this idea, because you know, with
- 29:19X right, you don't really get to choose who follows you. If someone
- 29:22wants to follow you, they do. And this idea that if I see
- 29:26that person in your follower list then you are now persona non grata all feels
- 29:32a bit stazy to me, you know what I mean? I think people
- 29:34need something better to do than this kind of shit. They certainly do.
- 29:37But anyway, I mean, Scott is Scott is right. I mean,
- 29:40the point is if something doesn't appeal to you, and that's whether it's squeamish
- 29:45or boredom or you know, all of this sort of stuff. If it
- 29:52doesn't appeal to you, then that's perfectly fine. It's just when you extend
- 29:56that to say it doesn't appeal to me, I don't find it morally defensible,
- 30:02and if you engage in it, you are now morally tainted. That
- 30:06I think, is it? Yeah? I mean it's sort of like the
- 30:07moralism of like trying to police people's behavior and the sort of like litigation in
- 30:14the public square about what is and is not acceptable. I mean, people
- 30:15are gonna do it anyway, sure, Like what would be like a good
- 30:19Internet style counter argument here, Well, I don't like it that some people
- 30:22are homosexual and engage in homosexual activities. Therefore, I don't think anyone should
- 30:27do it. In fact, we should have laws about it. And if
- 30:30anyone does it, I'm gonna like make sure they feel uncomfortable in public situations.
- 30:33And if you would be right to say that this is a ridiculous argument,
- 30:37it's a ridiculous analogy. But all I see on the internet are ridiculous
- 30:41analogies. Reductio is ad absurdum and just like public pillaring of things that you
- 30:45just don't like, you know what, other people do enjoy it, and
- 30:48huge amounts of cultural imperiod but with no basis and really like genuine engaged thought.
- 30:53And it's okay to have the conversation and huge amounts of cultural imperialism by
- 30:57the way Americans are so that American moral code should be followed by everyone in
- 31:03every country around the world, regardless of context. It is absolutely fucking upset.
- 31:07I'm okay with the strong opinions, but when we stop having the conversation
- 31:11and we simply start to condemn and like destroying people's careers and just like trolling
- 31:18and flaming, Like what is the purpose of all of this kind of activity?
- 31:21All it does is insight and encourage exactly the same behavior by the people
- 31:25you disagree with, who you probably would consider your enemies. So what good
- 31:27are you doing by engage? And all it does is increased division anyway.
- 31:30Isaac Shalev famed board game designer Isaac Shalev. So, personally, I don't
- 31:37play Secret Hitler. I'm not interested in pretending to be Hitler unless a game
- 31:41has more gravity. On the other hand, even though my grandparents survived concentration
- 31:45coms with Auschwitz and Treblinka, I do tell and laugh at jokes about the
- 31:49Holocaust. The right audience, the right context, the right moment can make
- 31:53that okay, at least for me. I love endeavor, but I don't
- 31:56suggest playing it with my black friends, who probably don't need to unexpectedly encounter
- 32:00slavery at game night. Right. So, so the second part of this,
- 32:07people talk within their own private sphere in ways they wouldn't talk publicly,
- 32:15right mm hmm. That's definitely true for you and I, and this has
- 32:23always been the way, except we are we don't deal with social media particularly
- 32:30well, and we don't realize. I think people don't realize sometimes that if
- 32:34you say things on social media, that this is a public forum. And
- 32:39if you say something silly, even if so so Isaac's example that he may
- 32:45joke about the Holocaust within a very specific context of people who survived the Holocaust
- 32:50and the generations, and you say that in a living room, in a
- 32:53context where it doesn't hurt people. Because this is this is my biggest issue,
- 32:58right, so I think it's perfect entitled to say that. I find
- 33:02it odd that he would go on the Discord, which is a public forum,
- 33:06and talk about that. But still, this is a fundamental problem with
- 33:13what the Internet has become, and I think this is a this is a
- 33:19core issue. Words are completely contextual. Words do not have an intrinsic meaning,
- 33:30power or context. Used in different context words mean different things. There
- 33:36are terrible words that you don't use, and that is completely insane to me,
- 33:42because the context in which the word is used denotes whether the word is
- 33:49abusive or funny. And this idea that words have an intrinsic value and certain
- 33:54words have an intrinsic damage. Words are violence is religious? No, that
- 34:01is that is a religious way of thinking. I mean this is where some
- 34:05people might say that in intent matters, but I don't know, like black
- 34:09humor and like you know, like get Gallows humor or black comedy, whatever
- 34:13these I mean, this is this is like ingrained into like human culture that
- 34:16people make jokes about dark things. Yeah, and if you hear one and
- 34:22it's a joke, I mean, I guess you have to be there and
- 34:24know the person and understand the situation at the time before you want to make
- 34:29some remark about how what they're saying is offensive or inappropriate or so you know,
- 34:34it's not some variety of hate speech. I don't know. Daniellisisheney got
- 34:37in trouble because he talks about the way he would speak to a certain group
- 34:40of friends. And he said something and it was translated from Italian, and
- 34:45I think people were trying to say, oh, but an Italian is different.
- 34:47I mean, it's clearly not. What he said was what he said,
- 34:51and he got in trouble. And the reason he got in trouble is
- 34:52because, regardless of the context in which he operates in his private sphere,
- 34:58you don't talk about that in a public spe because it's the different thing we
- 35:02you don't go into you act differently at work than you do in your own
- 35:07home, right. I mean, it's just a fact. And social media
- 35:10was first, of course you need to. Well you need to because this
- 35:14is how society's work. And what's fascinating is that people haven't learned that with
- 35:20social media yet. And I think in the same way that I mean,
- 35:23social media is not the venue where they're going to learn that. It's probably
- 35:27like the single most destructive force in human history. Well, it's funny,
- 35:34it's funny though. I was listening. I was listening to a content of
- 35:36our polarization, which is probably why we have this problem that we're talking about.
- 35:38I was listening to a podcast the other day and they were talking about
- 35:42how when the printing press was invented, for like a decade, there was
- 35:45an epidemic of like real sort of it seemed like society was breaking down and
- 35:52people were printing these crazy divisive pamphlets and they were and it felt like,
- 35:57you know, the foundations of society were crumbling. I see this in social
- 36:00media, right, I think, well, this is my hope the social
- 36:04media will become less impact. Martin Luther would have been all over X right,
- 36:07absolutely absolutely calling the pope the Antichrist. Yeah, exactly, get away
- 36:12with that today hashtag antichrist. And so this is the point right. I
- 36:15think that my hope is that social media the people learn that distinction between the
- 36:22private sphere and the public sphere, and they'll learn that social media is the
- 36:25public sphere and ameliorate their behavior accordingly. Right, Probably not, Probably not.
- 36:31Well, this is because these tools don't encourage it, because it's not
- 36:35a public square like it is. You know, this whole idea of the
- 36:37medium being the message. The medium is not simply the platform that is provided
- 36:43for you to broadcast some message. There is a lot of like heavy lifting
- 36:49behind the scenes that chooses which messages to broadcast to which people actually times.
- 36:53Absolutely, and we ignore that at our peril. I mean, these platforms
- 36:57are algorithmically designed to courage incitement. And this idea that the previous owners of
- 37:04X were any better for the Elon mask is absurd. No, I don't
- 37:08think so at all. He's just more visible. He's just more visible and
- 37:12more a public troll. Yeah, you'll see Jack Doors. He didn't tweet
- 37:15stupid fucking shit. But the way Twitter was engendered is to just use division
- 37:23as a tool for engagement to sell you adverts. Yeah, and he's arguably
- 37:28done a lot to like both damage the company as well as make the platform
- 37:32less inviting and appealing to a lot of people and more open you might say,
- 37:37you might say freer to people who have divergent opinions or whatever. But
- 37:40at the same time, these are these are corporations that want to sell your
- 37:47attention and your information to advertisers. They are not the public square, and
- 37:52there's no freedom of speech there either, by the way, and you want
- 37:54who talks about it, Jack Doors, and there isn't under el mask anyway,
- 37:59Cebrin, so Severn said kind of what I was talking, you mean
- 38:02as Gear. This is my assumption. He's called Severn on the as Gear
- 38:07severin you'll love it Christiano and Christiansen. So the balance I think is finding
- 38:14out when to say that's not for me and when to say nobody should want
- 38:17that. But I guess the latter is sometimes just the aggregate effect of the
- 38:21former. So I take a little exception to what he says, because he's
- 38:27saying when to say that's not for me, and when to say nobody should
- 38:30want that. I don't ever see myself being in a position to be able
- 38:36to say nobody should want that. So there is who do you need to
- 38:40be to be able to say that nobody should want that. I mean,
- 38:45there's lots of there are lots of behaviors engaged in by humans in different cultures
- 38:50throughout history that you know, I don't find them particularly tasteful for myself.
- 38:54Have you heard a vegetarian day in Thailand? This is where people like they
- 39:00heer'ce their bodies and engage in extreme mortification of the flesh. Right future,
- 39:02google vegetarian day right now. I'm not gonna vegetarian Day Bangkok or something,
- 39:07and you'll see that people like they put like spikes through their bodies, through
- 39:10like their their faces, and they're like carrying heavy objects around with And this
- 39:15is some kind of like I think it's like a Buddhist purification thing. So
- 39:19I don't look at that and think that I want to do it. Do
- 39:22I need to go so far as to say that nobody should do it?
- 39:24I mean, well, I think, I mean, this is not even
- 39:27a matter of like, you know, cultural relativism. You know, it's
- 39:30like I don't I don't really get it. But I'm also not them,
- 39:34and I'm sure that there are lots of things that I do that they would
- 39:36think are abhorrent. For example, tie. People don't put forks in their
- 39:39mouths, right so so, so it's that classic sort of free speech distinction.
- 39:44Right. So I'm not a free speech absolutist. I believe there should
- 39:50be laws in place to limit free speech to an extent, like yelling fire
- 39:53in a crowded theater, for instance. I think. And the distinction that
- 39:58people draw that I tend to agree with is there is a difference between free
- 40:02speech and incitement to violence, because I am one of these people who believes
- 40:07that the state should have a monopoly on violence, right and so and so
- 40:12incitement to violence, and the classic thing is should people should people be prosecuted
- 40:17for saying racist stuff on X for instance? Now, I don't think you
- 40:22can legislate ignorance and stupidity people who are allowed to be stupid, right,
- 40:29and so I think it depends, right. So the difference is there is
- 40:32ignorance is not an excuse for Britain the law. So there is a well
- 40:36exactly, but there is a difference I think between saying I think X race
- 40:40is inferior to me, and I think X race is inferior to me.
- 40:46Therefore we should go out and kill them, right, I think there's a
- 40:52there's a distinction to be made there, and I think that's a fair distinction
- 40:57to be made, right. I think the state should legislate on what is
- 41:00incitement to violence and what isn't. But I would never take it upon myself
- 41:04to say no, you shouldn't do that, because that strikes me as I
- 41:09mean what I see. And I was gonna write an essay about this because
- 41:14I'd be able to say it much better in an essay. But I don't
- 41:16see a huge amount of difference in conduct policing now than the Victorian times in
- 41:27the eighteen sixties to eighties. There is that kind of social uniformity, that
- 41:34is that is pushed by a greater society and essentially a bourgeois society. The
- 41:42one thing you could argue is that it's coming from a different place politically,
- 41:45But that kind of social coercion is just as prevalent now as I think it
- 41:51was in the Victorian age. Or am I or am I speaking bulshit is
- 41:54a popular topic with you? I don't know. I mean, there's a
- 41:59difference between cult norms, I would say, and then what is legislated on
- 42:02the other hand, So and I don't know, I don't know which country
- 42:07we could say gets it right, Like your country has like much stronger libel
- 42:09laws than my country, and they always like blow my mind. Like you
- 42:13could actually sue somebody for like what is considered lible right because it seems to
- 42:17be antithetical to freedom of speech. And freedom of speech is an important value
- 42:21in the United States, probably because of like the onerous restrictions at the British
- 42:25Empire at the time. But surely if you're saying something that negatively impacts on
- 42:30someone's life in print, you should be held accountable if you're not telling the
- 42:34truth. It depends, right, I mean, this is where the law
- 42:36has to decide has there been like material harm. You might say we went
- 42:40to an extreme whereby like we reject this principle of like what is it lesisse
- 42:45marges say like you can't say anything at all against the monarch or against the
- 42:50government, like you are not you are you are forbidden to commit acts of
- 42:52sedition. But actually it is the right of citizens to make certain statements in
- 42:59defiance of of their leaders and defiance of the government if you want to have
- 43:01a free society. It's not the same thing as like slandering somebody in public
- 43:07or in print, and then you know, we have to decide as a
- 43:09society, like how strong we want to make these kinds of laws against that
- 43:14kind of behavior, because it's a very it's a very fine line between impinging
- 43:17on someone's right to say what they want and allowing speech that would cause harm
- 43:21to others. Right, Germany is another interesting case. You are not allowed
- 43:24to I don't know the exact laws are here, but I'm pretty sure like
- 43:29Nazi stuff is forbidden completely illegally. Yeah, there cannot be a Nazi party,
- 43:32you can't display Nazi symbols, you can't engage in like hate speech along
- 43:37the way, if I were to do a Nazi salute on a street in
- 43:43Germany, I can be arrested for that. Yeah. And I think they
- 43:46have like more generic laws here about like like even like swearing at people and
- 43:52like fighting. I mean, they're very sensitive about this stuff, and you
- 43:54know, perhaps for a good reason they have decided. Well, I hope
- 43:58there isn't a law agains swearing against people, because when I'm on my bicycle
- 44:00cycling through the fucking town, I swear all the time. Nobody's brought up
- 44:04charges yet, but I mean they maybe they've decided to like overshoot the mark,
- 44:07and they have more onerous laws against free speech in this country than they
- 44:12would in yours or mine, especially for certain topics. But I wouldn't say
- 44:15that they're wrong to do it. So anyway, moving on, Matt Green,
- 44:20Oh two your friend and mine? Yes, hello, Matt. So
- 44:23this one I have things to say about this. So this is more of
- 44:27a sort of cultural literary critique on what he So, we are really being
- 44:30given the opportunity to talk out of our asses to really amazing. So He's
- 44:34and Giles, you better be listening to this. This is the this is
- 44:37the cream of the cookie that you want exactly. Let Us from Whitechapel is
- 44:40the one I find too close to the bone. Will the prostitute murderer win
- 44:44this one? Injurygue and hydrins, I think that's ironic, and I read
- 44:47it in an ironic manner. So I've had this discussion about let Us from
- 44:52Whitechapel a few times with people, actually, because you are you familiar with
- 44:55Letters from whitechap Vaguely, it's like Jack the Ripper. It's the hidden movement
- 44:59where one one person plays Jack the Ripper. And then the rest play the
- 45:01police trying to is it Is it like qualitatively different from the Halloween board game
- 45:06we played. No, it's the same. It's hidden move but I mean,
- 45:09like but sort of in a grisly genre. Like, so this is
- 45:15interesting, right, real crime? I think true crime? Yeah, I
- 45:20think rhyme. I think there is a qualitative difference. Now, people,
- 45:23it was not horror though, right, Well, it's a hidden movement game
- 45:28again, so I'm going to get to this. I'm going to get to
- 45:30this, right, So there is a difference. I think people would feel
- 45:36more squeamish about letters from Whitechapel if it was Jeffrey Dahmer or uh optimize getting
- 45:47like the body parts into the freezer for something like this, right, Jeffrey
- 45:52Dahma. I'm trying to think of other serial killers now, usually an expert.
- 45:54Yeah, and all the names are gonna one from Gloucestershire, Fred West,
- 46:00something like this, right? And why right? Why because son of
- 46:05Sam, son of Sam, for instance. Yeah, we don't need to
- 46:07list serial killers, but the point is historical Zodiac killer. Yeah. Yeah.
- 46:14If you're gonna interrupt me again, I'm going to fucking pour my cup
- 46:16of tear of your face. So historical figures, I can see that smile
- 46:23on your face. Yeah, So historical figures after a time stop being real
- 46:32people and become folk tales. Right. So there's a lot of controversy over
- 46:40the Napoleon movie at the moment because of his historical inaccuracy, but not one
- 46:45of us think about Napoleon as a real historical figure. He has become a
- 46:51narrative. He is a folk hero in many ways. What is historical accuracy.
- 46:55It's not like any of us are there. Well and Jack the Ripper
- 46:59like it or not, and some people find it squeamish. But Jack the
- 47:01Ripper, especially the conditions around Jack the Ripper, that it was in Victorian
- 47:05times, that there are only news clippings, that it's a completely different technological
- 47:09era, and the fact that he was never caught. Jack the Ripper,
- 47:14the actual murderer, is not who we think of when we think about Jack
- 47:16the Ripper. Now we think about Jack the Ripper as the folk creation,
- 47:21the boogieman, the the monster under the bed. It is no longer connected
- 47:29to the real person. Therefore, you can do a game like Letters for
- 47:32Whitechapel and actually what you're doing is manipulating a creation of fiction rather than a
- 47:39human being. Do you think I'm talking Bolocks the Boston Strangler? Great anyway,
- 47:46so a question for me, there was a question for me directed directly
- 47:52at you. It's a bit cheeky. Ooh faga. My question for at
- 47:55Benny's Ace. The reason my by the way, listeners, the reason Benny's
- 48:00Ace is my handle on all social media. I thought I was pronounced to
- 48:05Benny Sache. It's not Benny's Ace is because I came up with that when
- 48:07I was about nine years old for like a computer game, and it's been
- 48:14my computer game name forever, so it's about like sixty years old. Now
- 48:17at this point, did he ask the origin of your No? He didn't,
- 48:21so did Why did you just explain? I thought i'd go a bit
- 48:23for the listeners. Okay. My question for having is that how do you
- 48:28feel about Lewis and Clark. It's a game I own and have never played.
- 48:30I was hoping that we would come to Lewis almost entirely because when I
- 48:34opened the box, I realized the me pull were little red Indians and it
- 48:37made me feel queasy. Okay, So again, Puerto Rico as well I
- 48:39think with the little brown Yeah, so before before I go, before I
- 48:44go any further into this, firstly, if it makes you queasy and you
- 48:47don't want to play it, cool, no side from me. If there's
- 48:52stuff I don't like and I won't engage with it, so that's absolutely fine.
- 48:55So just get that out of the way. It's clear that I don't
- 48:59consider you to be you know, stupid or reductive because you know you're entitled
- 49:04to do what you want to do. Right. But so it wasn't like
- 49:07a bigger like problem with the game, just the fact these meeples were read
- 49:12well and they've got little feathers, they're little Indian shaped meeples, right.
- 49:15And so the point is if you, now, I don't know, you
- 49:21probably know much more about this than me. But if you play the game,
- 49:28the Native Americans are helpers that you can get to help you progress through
- 49:35the game. Sakajuwa for instance, in my view, the art from the
- 49:43art from Vincent Detroit is not stereotypical. It doesn't caricature. It's not caricature.
- 49:51Everyone looks like real people. There is historical context for this, and
- 49:55again it's this thing. Right. People may argue well, a Native American
- 50:00board game designer should have done this, not a French board game designer.
- 50:04But frankly, we can go down that path if we want. So what
- 50:08I would say to Ufaga and I think there is a new addition that comes
- 50:12out whether meeples aren't Indian shaped, and I think in my view, and
- 50:17so the point is, I'm going to put a view across here, and
- 50:20I don't think it makes a statement about who I am morally, and presented
- 50:28with an argument that it would debunk mine, I'd be willing to go,
- 50:30Okay, fair enough, right, But I don't think Lewis and Clark portrays
- 50:37the Native Americans as lesser people. It doesn't portray them as as like forties
- 50:45fifties cowboy movies do as savage beasts or anything like this. I think the
- 50:49game is fairly respectful and as far as I know, cleaves to the history.
- 50:54And also the game is fucking brilliant. And if the me pulls bother
- 51:01you that much, swap am I yeah. I mean, I don't know
- 51:07to what extent it represents them at all. They're a component of a of
- 51:13a game mechanism, and even even historically speaking, it is it is thematic
- 51:20to some extent. I mean, I suppose you could reskin the game and
- 51:23like relabel everything something else and it would still be the same game. I
- 51:27don't know. I was actually get ready to get ready for this bombshell remark.
- 51:30I was actually chatting with Cedric about this very topic, Oh wow wow,
- 51:36because I was curious if he'd ever gotten any flak for the game.
- 51:38And of course the answer is yes. And you know, I don't want
- 51:42to like repeat the entire conversation that we had, but the feeling I get
- 51:47is that whatever people the negative comments people have made, it's not like it's
- 51:52not like it was his intention. To go back to intention, I think
- 51:55he regrets that it was taken in this way, and if it means too
- 52:00if it means updating the production in order to retain what is essential to the
- 52:05game, then like he's fine with that. I don't even know if it
- 52:09was a conscious choice to make the Indian meeples read. I'm just not sure.
- 52:14Well, it had to be. They were read, and I've got
- 52:15little feathers. I mean, that's got to be a I guess probably at
- 52:19the time someone did that, they weren't even thinking about it and and I
- 52:22don't know if people have a problem with that, that's and then they decided
- 52:27to change it in response to the concern. This is different from saying the
- 52:30game shouldn't exist at all. And again and again, it's that thing that
- 52:35the internet does, right. And I think this whole topic is so exacerbated
- 52:37by the internet. Is the I think there's a difference between saying that's not
- 52:44my bag really and saying you are a moral monster for it being your bag,
- 52:49right, And that's where people leap to in their discussion on the internet.
- 52:53And I think that is I think it's tragic. Any question, the
- 52:57question though, is it is it disrespectful? Like I don't know how to
- 53:00answer it. I mean, some of these debates and conversations I probably will
- 53:04end by saying, I'm just not sure. Is it disrespectful because you've reduced
- 53:09an entire population or cultural group to merely being like serving a function in a
- 53:15game. Like it's not like they there's no there's no agency to them,
- 53:17and you're not you're not playing as them in the game. They're they're simply
- 53:22part of a of a of a bigger picture that you are manipulating as like
- 53:25I don't know. European Colgon narratives have focus, right, narratives have focus,
- 53:30And this idea that so so Lewis and Clark focuses on Lewis and Clark.
- 53:36No, there is a wider argument to be had about whether the American
- 53:42focus on Lewis and Clark is not telling a tenth of the story that should
- 53:47be told. That's that's a decent debate to have. But the fact is
- 53:52the game is a narrative and it focuses on two main characters, and there
- 53:57are secondary and two should we characters around that? Which is just the way
- 54:02narrative one? Yeah, right, I'm not complaining about it. It's just
- 54:05like every game does this. Every game goes some way toward instrumentalizing. Well
- 54:10not every game, but there are loads of games instrumentalized you know, groups
- 54:14of people, populations, classes, I mean, how many how many worker
- 54:16replacement games are there in which the workers are workers? I mean, right,
- 54:20No one is complaining about, you know, the degree to which board
- 54:23games are are trivializing the class struggle in right, human history since the Industrial
- 54:30Revolution? Right, no one complains about Lancaster, right, which is nights
- 54:35on a board anyway, So mister special pleading all the way down. I
- 54:37suppose indeed, mister Bonzo, this is the last one, And I just
- 54:42want a one minute exegesis on this because our friend Cock Bonzo, No is
- 54:45it? I don't know. Maybe anyway, me thinks a picture of mister
- 54:51Pista. Methinks that's how he started it. Yeah, classic, Me thinks
- 54:55a picture of mister Pista. Oh no, it's cock Bungo, isn't it.
- 54:59Yeah, okay, so it's probably not. Me thinks a picture of
- 55:01mister Pista could easily be used as an illustration in the lazy Racism entry in
- 55:07any encyclopedia. One minute, Stephen Cyrek, I don't think I have a
- 55:14minute. I mean, this is like a cat, a cat casually flung
- 55:20upon the discord. Hot take right, lazy love them? This is about
- 55:23Mombasa. I suppose Mombasa. Great Western Trail Western Trail also has the first
- 55:29edition of Great Western Trail? Is you had to where is their bandits now
- 55:32in Great Western Trail? Originally they were Native Americans? Yeah, I don't
- 55:36know. I mean maybe the product of this discussion in general is that we've
- 55:39raised our consciousness about these topics. To some extent, the best possible outcome
- 55:45of these debates has been more games treating a wider variety of topics, Like,
- 55:50for example, I'm just looking across at your bookshelf and I see votes
- 55:52for women. Maybe somebody thought it was a good idea to have this kind
- 55:55of a game because they felt that these topics were like underrepresented among the themes
- 56:00that games typically treat. And I think that's fine. I don't know that
- 56:05when Alexander Pistor was coming up with great great Western trailer Mombasa, he like
- 56:10put loads of thought into the sort of the consequences of choosing these themes.
- 56:16I mean, I just don't know. I also think that games are designed
- 56:20by large groups of people that involve the designer and editors and and artists and
- 56:27you know, companies that make various choices about how to get their product to
- 56:31market. So I wouldn't I wouldn't put it all on him. But I
- 56:35also think it's a bit glib to dismiss his work as the product of lazy
- 56:40racism. So we're going to move on to post or the month it was
- 56:44kind of like a minute, it wasn't good. We're going to move on
- 56:45to post for the month, and I swear to God if you say OUI
- 56:50I'm gonna I just want them to participate more. In an act of willful
- 56:53competition, we present our Alright, Stephen, it's our poster of the month.
- 57:04Who is it? You always get to choose because you're the academic.
- 57:07I think this time I'm probably gonna go with themed board game designer Isaac Shallez.
- 57:13Wow. Wow, I think he made a somewhat brave and cogented point.
- 57:19He did, and I happen to agree with it as far as I
- 57:22can remember it. Excellent, Well, famed board game designer Isaac Shalev,
- 57:27you are this month's poster of the month. That was our All right,
- 57:38let's do this wrap up because we've been going for fifty seven minutes and Giles
- 57:43is going to be losing it. Do you think he's started listening? Oh
- 57:45defo, he's listening now. He's like trump listening. Do you think they're
- 57:50gonna mention my name again? I'm gonna mention my name again. So do
- 57:52you think that the sort of like large like wooden analog box on which he
- 57:55listens to podcasts lacks buttons for like being ahead? Oh? Yeah, definitely,
- 58:00definitely in case he does, I'm sure. Yeah, Like, I
- 58:04mean, he wants to like skip ahead to the content, like the meat
- 58:07of the show, but he doesn't have like, you know, a knob
- 58:08or a diary. Difficult, very difficult on an old wireless to do.
- 58:12Yeah, so I understand, like your country really needs to like level up?
- 58:15Is that the phrase that you use. I've squatt Michael Gove tried to
- 58:17do bless him. Do you know how you level up? How's that been?
- 58:22You persecute the poor and have more food banks in the country than McDonald's.
- 58:28I was gonna say, if you'd like to level up, dear listener,
- 58:30you can go to five games for doomsday dot com and join the Patreon.
- 58:36Yeah, patreon dot com forward slash five g D. I meant go
- 58:38to patreon dot com slash five G for D. That's the number five G,
- 58:42the number four D. I think we'll discuss this before, but I'm
- 58:44in am I an incredible boomer that I say forward slash. I think forward
- 58:47slash is fine, it's just how I learned it. I think I think
- 58:51it's precise. But like we're so used to rattling off internet addresses that we
- 58:54just know it's a slash. Do you know the thing that made me feel
- 58:58the most old, Like I stumbled on YouTube one day, like a young
- 59:04lady called you, sir. No, no, no, I mean women
- 59:07have always found me disgusting, so just just because I'm old now it is
- 59:10just another string to that bow. No. I was watching this video and
- 59:14it was like amazing tips to help you search on Google. And you know,
- 59:19one of the tips was, what's that to surround your search term in
- 59:22inverted commas? Yeah? So it only specifically quotes. Yeah, it only
- 59:29specifically searches for that. Oh, come on, they're far better like Google
- 59:31had times. And I learned that that was like the first thing I learned
- 59:36about searching. And you know, I'm so old that that piece of information
- 59:40is just like the zoomers don't know it anymore. What's the second tip that
- 59:46you learned? Oh? Remember ago? Anyway? Anyway, level up.
- 59:50You've got a Patreon on dot com slash five g for d and become a
- 59:53patron because our goal next year is to have a thousand patrons. I mean
- 59:58one one euro is it now? One yuro a month is fine if you
- 1:00:02want to join the thousand, but for five yuros a month. You get
- 1:00:06to listen to this shit all the time, time, all the time.
- 1:00:07Also, how do I join the discord? Tell them again once again?
- 1:00:12Www dot five games through doomsday dot com, dB FIGVD dot com. Yeah,
- 1:00:16I mean, you know, if you google some combination, you're going
- 1:00:20to get Steve to help me after we start recording. Yeah, if you
- 1:00:22like type in five games for Doomsday and Google, you're eventually going to get
- 1:00:25routed to one of many to wonder who spends many media properties. Yeah,
- 1:00:30that's right. That will eventually direct you to the discord, where you can
- 1:00:35tell us directly, live in person on the internet in real time, what
- 1:00:40twats we are? Also, what should they do on the iTunes? You
- 1:00:45should first of all give us a five star rating and then you know,
- 1:00:50maybe like write a nice review rate and review And so I just want to
- 1:00:53wrap up by saying thank you to everyone who has contributed to this show.
- 1:01:00We're and contributed. I'm seriously Giles, we're just having lols. Thank you
- 1:01:07for your contribution, and thank you for approaching me at the convention we were
- 1:01:10at and having a go at me because I didn't write back to your criticism
- 1:01:15and everyone on the Discord. Everyone who's not a member of the Discord listening
- 1:01:19to this, and you should become a member of the Discord because it's a
- 1:01:22really great resource where you get to have clever, rational, decent conversations with
- 1:01:28people. And that's it. So it was one of our New York's resolutions
- 1:01:31last year. It's really worked out to like, you know, do more
- 1:01:34Discord, and I think we did thanks to you. So say goodbye Steve.
- 1:01:38Goodbye Steve love that joke. Without you, this show wouldn't exist.
- 1:01:51So really you're to blame, So thank you for listening and oil up your
- 1:01:55ears for the next ASTEC Channel. Instant Friends and Frandstand fust In France and
- 1:02:05Deference and Fanist to Understand the Frank stands the Franston of Fidstone. Frandstone Stand