Latest / Film And Whiskey / Vertigo (1958) / Larceny Small Batch Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1958, director Alfred Hitchcock and star Jimmy Stewart
- 0:04gave the world a dizzying thriller that enslaves a man to
- 0:07a dissipating dream. In 2023, we take a second look
- 0:12at Heaven Hill's most famous weeded bourbon.
- 0:15The film is Vertigo. The whiskey is Larceny small
- 0:18Batch. And we'll review them both.
- 0:20This is. The Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:43Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 0:46review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:48I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 0:51And today we are looking at what was once dubbed the greatest
- 0:55film ever made, Alfred Hitchcock's 1958 masterpiece
- 1:00Vertigo and. We're here to tell you that it
- 1:02is hot garbage. What a terrible film.
- 1:07Brad, let me let me just immediately dive in for some
- 1:10context as to why we're recording this at the time we're
- 1:13recording because we've been trying to work through in order
- 1:17our re watches of Season 1. But a local theater was doing a
- 1:22Hitchcock double bill a couple weeks ago.
- 1:24They showed North by Northwest followed by Vertigo and I had
- 1:28never seen Yeah, right. What a pairing.
- 1:31I had never seen either of those movies on the big screen.
- 1:33And so I was like, well, I know what I'm doing with my Friday.
- 1:37And it was interesting, man. Like, North by Northwest plays
- 1:41perfectly to an audience, even in 2023.
- 1:44It was like people were laughing, people were gasping,
- 1:47and, you know, there was applause at the end of the
- 1:49movie. I forgot how quickly that thing
- 1:51moves and just what an incredible job of editing that
- 1:55movie does. And then we took 1/2 hour break
- 1:58and we watched Vertigo. And Vertigo is a movie that I
- 2:01love, but I think even the first time we watched it, you and I
- 2:05were like, you got to push through the 1st 45 minutes and
- 2:08then it's like the most rewarding thing ever.
- 2:10But do not put Vertigo on a double bill after North by
- 2:15Northwest. People like that.
- 2:17It was just lost on this audience and you could feel the
- 2:21boredom creeping in. And it really sucked because I'm
- 2:24still very high on this movie, but it's like, why would you put
- 2:28it after North by Northwest? Yeah, totally.
- 2:32The the films have such a different, at the very least,
- 2:36outcome. But even when you look at the
- 2:39humor in North by Northwest, any amount of humor in Vertigo at
- 2:44the time that it happens can be somewhat funny at the start of
- 2:48the film. But by the end of the film, you
- 2:49realize you're like, oh, all of the humor in this movie does not
- 2:54land well on your soul when you consider the outcome of the
- 2:59film. So I feel like if you're going
- 3:01to watch those two movies back-to-back, you you need to
- 3:04watch Vertigo first. 100%, yeah. And it's easy to see why he
- 3:09pivoted to North by Northwest as his first film after this,
- 3:13Vertigo was a big flop and was not really critically well
- 3:16received either. And so he's like, all right, I'm
- 3:18going to go back to what I do best.
- 3:20I'm going to make entertaining, you know, suspense movies.
- 3:23And this one's going to be a a spy chase thriller.
- 3:26And it is like to your point, tonally, these things are like
- 3:30night and day. Well, there's our our quick
- 3:34review of North by Northwest. I guess we should probably
- 3:37probably talk a little bit about Vertigo.
- 3:40This is our second watch through for the podcast.
- 3:42Brad, had you watched Vertigo in the interim between season 1 and
- 3:46now? I don't think that I did.
- 3:49I, I think it has been 5-4 years, five years since I
- 3:52watched it. So it has been a minute.
- 3:55And let me tell you, Bob, this is an incredible film.
- 3:59Good movie, good hot take, Vertigo, Good movie, real good.
- 4:05So it's been marinating in your brain for the last five years.
- 4:08And I guess one of my questions, you know, if I can be honest
- 4:12with you, man, I did not expect you to like Vertigo as much as
- 4:14you did. Like it's a it's a much slower
- 4:18paced, kind of mournful, really dark, kind of disturbing movie.
- 4:24Not not like a North by Northwest, not like a rear
- 4:26window even. And so I was really shocked when
- 4:30you came into the recording studio back in Season 1 and gave
- 4:33this movie a 10 out of 10. So when you think back like what
- 4:37about it worked for you on that first watch and does it still?
- 4:41Are those still the things you latch onto now on a second
- 4:44watch? I'm sure I mentioned it back
- 4:46then, but it was not actually my first watch.
- 4:48I had seen Vertigo before I watched it for the podcast.
- 4:53And I think that for me, the things that have stuck with me
- 4:57each and every time I watch it is the depth of the, the fall to
- 5:04which Jimmy Stewart endures and had, I don't know, man, the the
- 5:09way that Hitchcock captures psychological trauma and he
- 5:14captures the dangers of a twisted desire, a perverted
- 5:19desire. I I don't think anybody has ever
- 5:23done it better than what Hitchcock does here.
- 5:27All right, well, if you have not seen Vertigo, it's time for us
- 5:29to talk a little bit about what the movie is actually about.
- 5:32And in order to do that, we're going to throw over to America's
- 5:35favorite segment, which we call, Brad Explains.
- 5:38Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 5:41ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 5:45this little segment that we call, Brad explains.
- 5:48Brad explains. Is the part of the show where I
- 5:52spoil everything, Bob? You certainly do, man.
- 5:56We're going to give you 60 seconds to break down the plot
- 5:59of this movie, which you have not watched for at least the
- 6:02third time. You're this is old hat to you at
- 6:05this point, right? It sure is, Bob.
- 6:08So you've got 60 seconds on the clock and you've used the
- 6:11keyword here, spoil Brad. You are going to give away
- 6:14everything about this movie that you can fit into a minute.
- 6:17So if you have not seen Vertigo, first of all, what, what are you
- 6:20doing? Yeah.
- 6:21Yeah. I mean, just stop here, go watch
- 6:24it and then come back. Because I don't, I mean, I don't
- 6:27know, I, I feel like this is one of those movies where you could
- 6:29probably know the spoilers and it would still work because it's
- 6:32not about the spoilers. Yeah, but also don't do that to
- 6:35yourself. Yeah, I mean, Hitchcock even
- 6:38said to to Kim Novak at one point in the filming of this.
- 6:41It's, it's not about like what's happening on screen.
- 6:45It's about what people see on screen, the visuals of the
- 6:48movie, the feel of the movie. And so I, I think that to a
- 6:51certain point, the plot of this film kind of falls to the side
- 6:55of the feelings that it invokes in you.
- 6:57Well. Let's see what feelings it
- 7:00invoked in you, Brad. You have one minute on the clock
- 7:03and go. Vertigo's a film about a police
- 7:07detective in San Francisco who is tasked by an old college
- 7:11friend with following his wife around.
- 7:14He's not suspicious that she is cheating on him, he is worried
- 7:18that she is possessed by the ghost of a woman who committed
- 7:21suicide. Jimmy Stewart's character Scotty
- 7:24continues to follow her around the wife played by Kim Novak and
- 7:29eventually comes to believe that she truly is indeed possessed by
- 7:32this ghost. He follows her until she goes up
- 7:37into this bell tower and he is unable to follow her because he
- 7:40has Vertigo and is unable to make the ascent fully.
- 7:44He watches her jump off the tower and he falls into a state
- 7:48of depression which is on again off again girlfriend is unable
- 7:52to bring him out of. Upon recovering, he is in the
- 7:55streets, sees his old girlfriend look alike, and tries to turn
- 8:01her into this woman that he once loved.
- 8:04When he realizes that she was a actor playing the role of the
- 8:09wife, he calls her out on it and they fall in love, kind of, and
- 8:14he's angry. And then she falls off of a bell
- 8:16tower because the specter of death looks at her.
- 8:20The end. I like how you could sense that
- 8:23the minute was almost up and so you just started giving bullet
- 8:25points. But they're like, they don't
- 8:28seem to logically flow like Oh yeah, she they fall in love,
- 8:30Everything's good. And then also she falls off a
- 8:32bell tower. She.
- 8:33Sure does. Man, go.
- 8:34Wow. I mean, I will say there's like
- 8:37a few famous shots from this movie.
- 8:39I don't know if this is considered one of them, but when
- 8:42when the nun walks up into the bell tower, she looks like death
- 8:46itself. Yeah, it's like she has her
- 8:48shadowed perfectly. The lighting is Immaculate.
- 8:53Man, that'll give you chills. I've been trying to think about
- 8:56what the best entry point into talking about this movie is,
- 8:58because this is trying to do a lot on a really high level, and
- 9:05it takes a long time for this movie's pieces to fall into
- 9:08place like you it. It opens with this chase across
- 9:12rooftops where Jimmy Stewart's character, a police detective,
- 9:15is chasing a perp, and him and this other cop don't quite make
- 9:20the jump over to this other building.
- 9:22And then the cop tries to. Say it's basically the matrix.
- 9:24Right, the cop falls to his death and that induces Jimmy
- 9:28Stewart's as agoraphobia. Agoraphobia.
- 9:31No acrophobia. That's right, fear of heights,
- 9:34which gives him Vertigo. Now this comes up a couple times
- 9:38in the beginning parts of the movie, and then that plot thread
- 9:40is pretty much dropped. And it seems like it's only
- 9:44there to establish that he is now kind of forced into early
- 9:47retirement from the police force.
- 9:49His old college buddy that he hasn't seen in a long time is
- 9:52then like, hey, how about a ghost story?
- 9:55And for a really long time, it seems like this movie is truly
- 10:00toying with the supernatural, that this person might actually
- 10:04be being possessed by a dead person.
- 10:07This is something we've never really seen from Hitchcock.
- 10:10You know, there's always some sort of elaborate scheme a la
- 10:13Dial M for murder, right? And so you, you don't really
- 10:17think that it's going to go the supernatural route.
- 10:19But everything that's happening on screen suggests, oh, yeah,
- 10:22this this lady might actually be getting toyed with from the
- 10:26beyond. She falls to her death.
- 10:29And then you're like, where is this movie going now?
- 10:32And it's not really until the last, I don't know, 30 minutes
- 10:35of the movie, Brad, that all of these sort of disparate threads
- 10:39fall together. And I guess that's, that's where
- 10:43I want to start, is there's not a lot of movies that require
- 10:48this much patience before it all makes sense.
- 10:51It's a really, really big gamble.
- 10:54And I guess I'm wondering for you, Brad, like, does the gamble
- 10:57pay off or are there stretches of the movie where it feels a
- 11:01little bit stretched thin and your patience has tried?
- 11:05Man, that that is interesting. I think that they're the reason
- 11:10the long stretches of Jimmy Stewart following Kim Novak work
- 11:15is because of the soundtrack. Like, like the score for this
- 11:19film is so haunting and elegant and beautiful that you find
- 11:27yourself drawn into the world of Jimmy Stewart and the mystery
- 11:32that he's trying to unravel. Right?
- 11:34Like the there's, there's a reason he's chosen as a
- 11:37detective. Like the the whole purpose of
- 11:40this film is if you're in the the shoes of Jimmy Stewart, you
- 11:43also are playing the role of detective trying to figure out
- 11:45what's actually going on here. And as you follow her around, as
- 11:50you go to the Bay and she jumps in the water, and as you go to
- 11:54the sequoias in the the National Forest, like you, you get this,
- 11:59this strange sense of a dreamlike quality that this
- 12:04chase is taking on, that it moves so slowly and yet
- 12:07everything feels so important and like anything might be a
- 12:11clue to unraveling the entire mystery.
- 12:15And I for me, that kept me at the edge of my seat.
- 12:17Yeah, I mean, like I said, it's really high risk, high reward
- 12:20because Hitchcock is kind of counting on you, the audience
- 12:23member, being like, what the hell is going on?
- 12:27And as a result of me not knowing what's going on, I want
- 12:30to know more. I want to figure this out as
- 12:32opposed to I can't tell what's going on.
- 12:34And therefore I'm going to turn this movie off after 1/2 hour.
- 12:37And I think that, to be fair, the people that this movie does
- 12:41not work for fall into that latter camp.
- 12:43And I can't necessarily say that I blame them like the movie
- 12:47works for me. But you there really is a sort
- 12:50of active participation in the detective part of things that if
- 12:56you want to be given the information, this movie is not
- 13:00going to reward you with that until the very end of the movie.
- 13:02You have to be wanting to go down the rabbit hole with Jimmy
- 13:06Stewart. Yeah, this is easily not second
- 13:09screen material, no. Not at all.
- 13:12I mean, I guess like some of those long drives through the
- 13:14sequoias. You could probably check your
- 13:16e-mail if you really need to, yeah.
- 13:17Maybe. Maybe.
- 13:19All right, let's talk performances here because
- 13:22they're man, they're really interesting performances.
- 13:24Like you've got one, one person is playing multiple characters.
- 13:28Technically, you've got Jimmy Stewart with perhaps the
- 13:31weirdest character arc in movie history like these at the end of
- 13:35the movie. These people are just not the
- 13:37same people they were at the beginning.
- 13:38And let's start with Jimmy Stewart.
- 13:41This is the opposite of a Jimmy Stewart role in terms of what
- 13:45we're used to seeing. And part of what I love about
- 13:48him and, and Henry Fonda would do this once in a while too, is
- 13:52he would not just play against type, but he would use his
- 13:56trustworthy persona to then play against type and like, really
- 14:02Plumb the depths of like the darkness of the human soul.
- 14:06And I feel like it's, it's so much more disturbing to see it
- 14:11happen to Jimmy Stewart than it would have been a Cary Grant or
- 14:14whoever it might have been that Hitchcock would have worked
- 14:16with. Like when you see it happen to
- 14:19the most likable guy in the world, it gets under your skin
- 14:22because you start to feel like, oh, that could be me having this
- 14:26sort of mental collapse and obsession.
- 14:29Yeah, Humphrey Bogart would not have been good in this role.
- 14:32You know what I mean? Like, you would believe him as a
- 14:34grizzled, angry ex retired cop who's, like, kind of falling
- 14:39into Vadnais. Jimmy Stewart, though, you're
- 14:41like, oh, this is Jimmy Stewart. He's like flirting with Midge
- 14:45and and down to earth and like, oh, man, he had to.
- 14:47He had to quit the force. That's too bad.
- 14:50And like the The Descent feels that much greater.
- 14:53Like if this was remade, the only person who could play that
- 14:57role is like, Tom Hanks, right? Like to see Tom Hanks?
- 15:01There's something. About like, there's something
- 15:03about Hanks though, too, that he's tried this kind of thing
- 15:05before. Like he did Road to Perdition
- 15:07where he played a hitman. And like, I love that movie.
- 15:11And I will still say like, Nah, he's probably miscast.
- 15:13Like he just, he can't get there.
- 15:16And it's nothing against him, but I I think that makes it all
- 15:19the more miraculous that Hitchcock could go there with
- 15:22Jimmy Stewart and that Stewart allowed himself to be taken
- 15:25there. Oh, do you think it's that's
- 15:28Hank's fault, or do you think that he just doesn't have a
- 15:30Hitchcock on the other side of the camera?
- 15:33I don't know man. I think it's at some point it's.
- 15:35Like, what do you think a David Fincher could pull that out of
- 15:38out of Hank's The Descent Into Darkness?
- 15:40I don't know. That's a great question.
- 15:42You know, I'm thinking about you said Bogart couldn't have played
- 15:45this role, though. I think Bogart probably could
- 15:46have. I see a lot of Casablanca Bogart
- 15:49here, like where where he is like absolutely tortured at the
- 15:53sight of seeing her again. And I'm like, I think Bogey
- 15:56could play it, but it would be a much more like physical and
- 16:02dangerous kind of role. Where is like when you see Jimmy
- 16:05Stewart start to like, throw her around the bell tower at the end
- 16:08of the movie, you're like, oh, like this guy has absolutely
- 16:11snapped. Jimmy Stewart doesn't treat
- 16:13women like that. Not even there like when they're
- 16:16in her hotel room and he has his hands like tremblingly grasping
- 16:22at her neck and like cheek and face.
- 16:24You're like, he's either about to like passionately neck her or
- 16:29he's a going to wring her neck. I'm not really sure which one's
- 16:32going to happen. That was a fun sequence to watch
- 16:34in the theater. Not because it's fun, it's super
- 16:36disturbing. Like talk about Fincher level.
- 16:38Bob's a big, big fan, but from the moment he meets, it's Kim
- 16:43Novak's second character right on the street and then in Judy
- 16:47and then immediately starts trying to make her over.
- 16:50And it it's a great. We'll talk about the way the
- 16:52script is set up, because if they didn't have a very crucial
- 16:56scene showing Judy's past, then you'd be like, why is she going
- 16:59along with this plot? This man is a creep, but every.
- 17:03Like, there's nothing she can do that will make Jimmy Stewart
- 17:07fall in love with her until she looks exactly like.
- 17:12Not Carlotta. What's that, Madeline?
- 17:14Yeah. And, you know, she finally gets
- 17:17her hair done and she buys the suit, and then she comes out of
- 17:20the elevator and her hair's down.
- 17:22And like, the ladies behind me at at the disappoint.
- 17:26The immediate rejection and disapproval from Jimmy Stewart
- 17:29are just like, like, it was so funny to hear how disgusted they
- 17:35had become with him. And it's really, it's really
- 17:37cool because the way this movie is set up, like Jimmy Stewart's
- 17:40the hero and then all of a sudden he is the villain and you
- 17:43were actively rooting for the other person.
- 17:45And then in the last scene, the wires get crossed so much that
- 17:49you don't really know who you're rooting for or if you're rooting
- 17:52for both of them. It's it's just a really, really
- 17:55messed up movie. I love it so much.
- 17:58Yeah, well, I mean, that's the dark element of it, right?
- 18:00That I, I believe his name is Gavin is the the old college
- 18:04friend who we haven't said this yet, is trying to murder his own
- 18:09wife. Yes.
- 18:10And so he he hires Kim Novak to play his wife to convince Jimmy
- 18:15Stewart that she commits suicide so that he has a reliable
- 18:18witness. It is the very It is very
- 18:20convoluted. You could have murdered your
- 18:22wife, much like you know, we've already established that the San
- 18:25Francisco Bay is a great place for someone to die.
- 18:28Like just throw her off the Golden Gate Bridge and be done
- 18:30with it. Man, yeah.
- 18:32Here's the thing though. Having watched Rope and having
- 18:36watched ILM for Murder, this movie makes so much more sense.
- 18:42Like this is, I think that this is the ultimate version of those
- 18:46two movies 'cause the movie is about a perfect murder, but the
- 18:51movie never talks about it being about a perfect murder.
- 18:54And I I think that that makes it work so much better than in
- 18:57those two films, which are both great films.
- 19:00So the source material for this book, it's from a book called
- 19:03From Among the Dead. It's a French book.
- 19:06And the authors of that book also wrote a novel prior to that
- 19:09that Hitchcock had tried to adapt.
- 19:11He was unable to secure the rights.
- 19:13The rights went to this French filmmaker, Enrizores Clouseau,
- 19:16who made a movie called Diabolique.
- 19:18And Brad, if we ever, if we ever get to watching more foreign
- 19:22films on this podcast, Diabolique is a freaking banger.
- 19:26It is so good, but there's a, there's an element of, you know,
- 19:31people using the idea of dead people to psychologically
- 19:35manipulate someone into going mad in that book too.
- 19:37So like, there's, there's a common thread here.
- 19:39It's a, it's very European. I don't know what it is about,
- 19:42like, you know, gaslighting through ghosts, but that's
- 19:46what's going on here. And I guess, Brad, this is a
- 19:49good place to talk about Kim Novak because you don't really
- 19:52hear. Her speak a resident ghost.
- 19:54Yes, you don't hear her really speak a word until I don't know,
- 19:5740 ish minutes into the movie and she starts doing this very
- 20:01fake sounding, you know, affected like quasi British
- 20:05accent. And then you realize that it's
- 20:08because she's, I mean, she's a very mannered, wealthy woman,
- 20:11but also is being possessed by this old timey ghost.
- 20:15And the the more you watch the performance, the more you let it
- 20:18settle in. And then when you see her as
- 20:21Judy, a completely different person later in the movie, this
- 20:25is a pretty revelatory performance, man.
- 20:27Like, I was really blown away by Kim Novak.
- 20:29The the only part was when, as Judy, she tells him that she's
- 20:34from Salina, KS in the most Brooklyn, NY accent I've ever
- 20:40heard in my life. I've always hated how she does
- 20:44that line reading because, you know, she's like, oh, you know,
- 20:47it's issued On this date and she knows half the date off the top
- 20:50of her head and then has to look at the thing for the other half.
- 20:53And I'm like, oh, Hitchcock, just take a dip.
- 20:55Use a different take for the movie, man, Come on.
- 20:57Yeah, one, one more take is all all it, all it needed.
- 21:02Yeah, I think that Kim Novak is incredible in this film.
- 21:06I think that the movement between 2 characters from the
- 21:10first half to the second-half is great.
- 21:12I think that she comes across as a little bit wooden at the end
- 21:16of the film until everything breaks down and they're back at
- 21:20the mission where, you know, the wife was murdered.
- 21:24She she just completely breaks down and has these great bouts
- 21:29of of like almost a gasping emotionality.
- 21:33And and that's where I think everything comes together for me
- 21:36like the the woodenness works because you can tell that it was
- 21:40a dam holding back the depth of her emotion at the end of the
- 21:44film. And her performance just evokes
- 21:50a sense of, of crazed wonder of of why?
- 21:55Like how could you do the things that she did if not she actually
- 22:00fell in love with Scotty? All right, real quick, let's
- 22:03kind of round out the major players in the movie.
- 22:05And I guess the only other person we really need to talk
- 22:08about is Barbara Belghetti's as Midge, who is, you know, has an
- 22:13unrequited love for Jimmy Stewart.
- 22:16And it's a really funny, it's not a funny character, but it's,
- 22:19it's an interesting character in terms of like figuring out how
- 22:22she fits into the plot of the movie.
- 22:25Because if you take a reading of the movie that this is just
- 22:27about obsession and someone looking in the wrong place for
- 22:31love and all that, then then I think the character makes sense,
- 22:34right? Like she's right there and Jimmy
- 22:36Stewart's not noticing her. But I was listening to a podcast
- 22:40the other day and and the hosts were talking about how it's
- 22:43really hard to adapt like high literature to movies because
- 22:49there's just, there's usually so many like threads that go
- 22:52unresolved and just like extra context and characters that
- 22:55aren't central to the plot. And they always feel like extra.
- 22:59And I kind of feel that way about Midge with this movie.
- 23:01Like I I'm not entirely sure how she fits into the overall plot
- 23:07of the film other than just being like the supportive,
- 23:11broken hearted, not quite girlfriend.
- 23:14And I'm kind of wondering Brad, like what, where do you land?
- 23:17I think the performance is great but like what is her function in
- 23:20this story? Yeah, I think you already
- 23:22pointed it out. Like her, her function is to
- 23:26show that Jimmy Stewart could have what he wanted to that and
- 23:32and and that's such an important concept in the in the theory of
- 23:37this film, because for me, the entire film is about what
- 23:41happens when human desire is twisted and when human desire
- 23:48goes to a dark place and how how willing we are to go to the
- 23:53depths of darkness in our soul based on a a twisted desire.
- 23:58And I think that if you don't have Midge in this film, then
- 24:01you might understand why he goes after her.
- 24:05But at the end of the day, if he's looking for love, if he's
- 24:08looking for a beautiful woman to spend the rest of his life with,
- 24:12if those were the things that he wanted, then he can have them.
- 24:15She's right there. Yeah, that's a good point.
- 24:17She's right there and I I think that that makes her kind of the
- 24:20linchpin for the story. Yeah, I mean, you know, I, I
- 24:25think about, I hate to be a Nolan bro, but one of my
- 24:29favorite Nolan films is Oppenheimer.
- 24:31And I've seen Oppenheimer, I don't know, 5-6 times at this
- 24:34point. And it's like it is to me.
- 24:37It's like simultaneously his greatest accomplishment and also
- 24:40like the the most 9 out of 10 movie I've ever seen.
- 24:45It's kind of like it's like his Apocalypse Now.
- 24:47Like there's so many ideas and it's a little bit messy
- 24:50sometimes. But because it's a little bit
- 24:52messy, I feel like you can take 5 different readings of the
- 24:56movie and all of them are there. And I kind of feel like that
- 24:59with Midge. Like I love this movie so much,
- 25:02Brad, because it's not as tight as Rear Window, it's not as
- 25:05tight as North by Northwest. There's some messiness here.
- 25:09There's some threads that are unresolved.
- 25:11There's some questions I have at the end of the movie that I'm
- 25:13like, how did she get into that hotel unseen again?
- 25:16Like I I still don't understand how she did that and and I feel
- 25:20like it adds to the totality of the movie instead of taking away
- 25:24from it. Yeah, I, I think that especially
- 25:29with her final scene where she goes to the doctor and basically
- 25:32says, like, Mozart's never going to bring him out of this.
- 25:36He's still in love with her. And there's nothing I can do
- 25:38about that. I think that there, you know,
- 25:41and then she walks off, closes the door and disappears from the
- 25:45rest of the film as if she never existed.
- 25:48And I think that the importance of that is that she represents
- 25:52desire properly construed, that she has a desire for these
- 25:57healthy good things, marriage, kids, you know, a person to love
- 26:02for the rest of your life. Those are all great things.
- 26:05And when, when it when it becomes clear, and maybe it
- 26:09takes a little more than the average woman would need to push
- 26:13her away, but when it becomes wholeheartedly clear that the
- 26:17object of her desire is not going to lead to anything good,
- 26:22she walks away. And that's exactly what Jimmy
- 26:25Stewart should have done months and months and months
- 26:28beforehand. But because he continued to, you
- 26:31know, indulge his dark desires, he is now in a mental hospital.
- 26:36Right. Well, one thing I want to talk
- 26:38about before we go to break here is the visual look of the movie.
- 26:42It is, first of all, gorgeously photographed.
- 26:44There's a lot of there's a lot of like diffused light, a lot of
- 26:47fog filters going on in this movie, soft focus, but
- 26:51particularly the use of the colors red and green.
- 26:54And I really wish that I'd gotten a chance to talk to my
- 26:57wife about this. My wife is an art history major
- 27:01and an art therapist and she works with color theory all the
- 27:03time. I'm interested to hear because I
- 27:07was trying to parse it out as I watched Brad.
- 27:09Like, they both represent desire in some ways, like the red and
- 27:12the green. And there's key moments where
- 27:15Kim Novak's character is wearing a green dress or a green
- 27:18sweater. But then there's also times
- 27:20where Jimmy Stewart's wearing a green sweater.
- 27:22And when the the illusion of Madeline is finally fully
- 27:28consummated and and Judy walks out of the bathroom bathed in
- 27:32this eerie, like from beyond the grave green light, I'm like, OK,
- 27:38I know this is supposed to mean something.
- 27:41I'm not entirely sure if the red and the green mean the same
- 27:45thing, if they're completely different, but it's definitely
- 27:49something I noticed and it's something that piques my
- 27:52interest. I'm curious to hear what your
- 27:54thoughts were on the color in the movie.
- 27:56I think that the red in the movie represents desire, passion
- 28:03and movement. So the first time that he meets
- 28:06her, where is she? She is in this restaurant that
- 28:10is the most red. It's like a Paisley wallpaper,
- 28:14bright Christmas red walls. And her necklace is this, you
- 28:20know, giant square cut Ruby. And this, this red represents a
- 28:25movement towards madness, a movement towards something that
- 28:29he shouldn't have. Green represents the descent
- 28:32right when he's wearing his green sweater, it's after he
- 28:36saves her from from drowning and he is falling in love with her
- 28:41even though he shouldn't be. When she is at the hotel room
- 28:45and the the green light is bathing her, that happens
- 28:49multiple times. First where she's sitting in the
- 28:51chair and she kind of asks him like if I turn into Madeline,
- 28:55will you love me? And then finally she turns into
- 28:58Madeline and she's fully engulfed in this green light.
- 29:00For me, green can represent and like sickness and death and
- 29:05plague and and it evokes these images of like going to the
- 29:09grave and you see that as soon as she is bathed in that green.
- 29:14That's it, man. That's like what seals the deal.
- 29:18Man, we are. This is like the best analysis
- 29:20we've done on a movie in a long time.
- 29:22I'm very proud of us and I think that we deserve a reward.
- 29:25So this might be a good place to press pause and to drink some
- 29:29whiskey. Let's try this larceny.
- 29:31What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 29:39All right, so today we are checking out larceny small
- 29:42batch. This is a very popular whiskey
- 29:44from Heaven Hill. It is their kind of, you know,
- 29:47baseline level wheated bourbon. I I always feel the need to add
- 29:52a hard tea Brad, because whenever we do transcriptions of
- 29:55our audio, it doesn't know what the word weeded sounds like.
- 29:59And so I always get WEEDED. I think if you pronounced it, it
- 30:05would come across even of course.
- 30:06Yeah. So this is kind of their
- 30:08competitor with Weller Special Reserve.
- 30:11Heaven Hill a long time ago bought all the rights to the
- 30:14brand that was called Old Fitzgerald, and it kind of
- 30:17didn't do anything with it for a while.
- 30:18And then it released Larceny basically as like this is our
- 30:22homage to Old Fitzgerald. And then they started producing
- 30:25Old Fitz again, and now it costs hundreds of dollars.
- 30:27So there you go. But Larceny is the people's
- 30:30wheated bourbon. The mash bill is undisclosed but
- 30:34the proof on this is 92 proof. It is non age stated so we know
- 30:38that the youngest in here is at least four years old.
- 30:41Brad, I am very excited to try this again because I remember
- 30:45not being a huge fan of this and I know that the Larceny barrel
- 30:49proofs now are like all the rage, but I've never pulled the
- 30:52trigger on one because I remember not liking the 92 proof
- 30:55version. Which is wild because you are a
- 30:57noted hoited fanatic. Big fan of wheat.
- 31:01All right, dude, I don't have much more to say.
- 31:03Let's go ahead and dive in. What are you picking up on the
- 31:06nose of this larceny small batch?
- 31:09This nose is really pleasant. There's some caramel, there's
- 31:13some simple syrup. There's it's definitely a little
- 31:16more corny, but it's got a little bit of a raw corn feel.
- 31:20And the, the note that I really enjoyed the most was it.
- 31:23It really smells like a little bit of melted, salted butter.
- 31:27And I and I liked that it was pretty good.
- 31:29I'll give it a 7 out of 10 here. Yeah, I like this a lot,
- 31:32actually. This is much less astringent
- 31:34than I thought it would be. Like, it's not harsh at all.
- 31:37There's some good peppery notes to it.
- 31:39There's just a hint of oak. You get that, that wisp of like
- 31:42the cherry cola thing that we like on our wheated bourbons.
- 31:46I get a lot of citrus and particularly orange on this.
- 31:50Like it's kind of like if we could make an Old Fashioned out
- 31:53of our favorite wheated bourbon. This isn't a good spot, you
- 31:57know? Again, I know in the back of my
- 31:59head this is like a $30 bourbon, so I'm not expecting anything
- 32:01mind blowing, but this is significantly better than I was
- 32:05expecting. I'm going to give it an 8 out of
- 32:0710 on the nose. Yeah, and the palate has a
- 32:10really nice that that corniness and butter continued for me.
- 32:14So I, I just called it buttered corn or like corn on the cob.
- 32:18There's some cream of wheat flavor going on here.
- 32:21And I, I got a little bit of vanilla extract, like a little
- 32:24bit artificial, but but a nice flavor.
- 32:28And I think I, I would come up just a little bit from the nose
- 32:32here. I I think it's a solid tasting
- 32:34whiskey that I'll give a 7 1/2 to all.
- 32:37Right, so I just had my first sip and I can see why I didn't
- 32:40like it the first time, but I am going to come up on it this
- 32:43time. It tastes like a really good
- 32:47wheated bourbon. Was then mixed with a batch of
- 32:53stuff they needed to get rid of, and they tried to blend some of
- 32:57the harsher edges off of it by introducing good stuff.
- 33:00The master distiller at Larceny is like, oh, he found me out
- 33:03you. Bastard.
- 33:04The very tip of my tongue. It's just sugar water.
- 33:07Like it. There's not much there.
- 33:08And then it almost immediately gets this note of like heavily,
- 33:11heavily charred oak that's like, oh gosh, we over oaked this
- 33:15batch. And all through the taste in the
- 33:18experience, underlying it is this almost bitter burnt note.
- 33:23But then you get the really pleasant, again, like old
- 33:26fashioned notes. I get bitters on this, I get
- 33:27orange on this, I get cherry on this.
- 33:30It's really, really nice. But then it's just like, hey, we
- 33:34got to get rid of this bad batch too.
- 33:37So I don't really know. Like there's a part of me that
- 33:39wants to give it like a 6 1/2, but the pleasant notes are
- 33:43really pleasant. And I think Brad, this being
- 33:45what it is, it would blend really well in a cocktail.
- 33:48I think it'd be really good on the rocks.
- 33:50Like it's not bad for the price point, but if I take that out of
- 33:54it and try to be objective, I'm just going to give it a 7 out of
- 33:5810. Yeah, and that and that's where
- 34:01I'm at on the finish. Seven out of 10 the the caramel
- 34:04kind of comes around on the back end of this for me.
- 34:07It gets almost like a unflavored cream cheese.
- 34:11There's some honey flavor. But you are right, the oakiness
- 34:15came around for me on the back end.
- 34:17And I I think, I think that this is just a solid, decent whiskey.
- 34:23I'll go ahead and get my balance score here too.
- 34:25And and then you can get both ears.
- 34:26I think this is a 7 out of 10 on balance.
- 34:28Like there's nothing crazy here. It's it's just kind of pretty
- 34:32good solid whiskey from start to finish.
- 34:34Yeah. I'm going to give it a 6 1/2 on
- 34:36the finish it it does remind me you said honey.
- 34:40It kind of reminds me of like a honey liqueur or like a, you
- 34:43know, what's that crappy? Germany.
- 34:45Bar the Baron Jaeger, like the just like, you know, very kind
- 34:50of pleasantly honeyed but a little bit artificial.
- 34:53It still has those notes of like being too over oaked.
- 34:57So it's just a 6 1/2 for me on the finish.
- 35:00On balance, I'm with you. I'm going to give it a 7 and
- 35:02that takes us to value now currently Brad in the state of
- 35:06Ohio. What will a 750 mil bottle of
- 35:10this cost you? It it says on our website that
- 35:13it is on sale for 2799 but I I did score it on the MSRP 2999.
- 35:21All right. So it's a $30 whiskey.
- 35:23That's kind of what I expected. I think when we first started
- 35:26doing this podcast, this was closer to like 24 or $25.
- 35:31It's not a bad $30 whiskey. I'll give it a 6 1/2 again.
- 35:36Yeah, I give it a 7 1/2. I think for me, I didn't get
- 35:39quite the bitterness that you are experiencing.
- 35:42And so I think at $30, this is about what you should expect.
- 35:46Like I think this is a solid benchmark for what you're
- 35:50drinking at the $30 range. Bob, I came to a 36 out of 50.
- 35:56I'm at a 35 out of 50, so we're averaging a 35.5 or a 71 out of
- 36:02100. I think that's a good place for
- 36:04this. You know, 35 is where we
- 36:06normally start recommending that you try it or buy it.
- 36:09I absolutely would give it my stamp of approval to just go
- 36:12ahead and buy a bottle. Like, it's a really good mixer,
- 36:14especially for people that, you know, that are willing to try a
- 36:18whiskey cocktail but don't want anything that's too high proof.
- 36:22I actually think that some of these, like darker, bitter Chari
- 36:25notes would hold up really well in an Old Fashioned or, you
- 36:28know, a Manhattan or something like that.
- 36:30So yeah, I'm going to go ahead and say buy a bottle of it.
- 36:33Yeah, I, I would say that too. I I think that this is a bottle
- 36:37that anybody would be happy to have on their shelf.
- 36:40All right, man. Well, going from that to a movie
- 36:43that I am happy to have on the shelf behind me here, let's get
- 36:46back into talking about Vertigo. What do you say?
- 36:49Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 36:55That was Larceny Small Batch weeded bourbon, a whiskey that I
- 37:00I don't know if I would feel comfortable stealing Bob, but I
- 37:03will drink it. No, I am not committing larceny
- 37:05to acquire this, but yeah, offer it to me for free and I'll down
- 37:10a shot of it anytime. Easily Next up on the docket,
- 37:15though, we have Canada's favorite segment 2 facts and a
- 37:18falsehood. It is going to try to stump your
- 37:22ball. 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 37:282 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 37:32the podcast where Brad presents three items to me as fact about
- 37:36the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie that he
- 37:39has invented and it's my job to guess which one that is.
- 37:43Brad, you, you keep thinking you got me this season, but I keep
- 37:47clawing my way back. Yeah, as with most seasons, it
- 37:51seems like we're we both have each other's numbers pretty
- 37:54evenly. Yes, it's it's a nice rat, a tat
- 37:57that we have going back and forth here.
- 37:59So. Are you?
- 37:59Are you rat or are you tat? Oh, I got to be tat.
- 38:03OK, Yeah. Even though I'm the one with
- 38:05tattoos and you do not. I mean, you know, I just, I
- 38:08think I just give up a tat vibe, you know what a.
- 38:11Tatty kind of guy. All right man, hit me with your
- 38:15two facts and a falsehood. So wait, are you saying that I'm
- 38:18a rat then? I mean that would be.
- 38:20Implication. Yes.
- 38:21If the movie of my life ended, there'd be a rat sitting on the
- 38:24balcony. You could just think of it as
- 38:27like you are ratatouille, and then you're destined for
- 38:31greatness. Can I be raccoonie?
- 38:36All right, man. Give me your two facts #1 fact
- 38:40#1 during During one take of the final scene of the movie, Jimmy
- 38:46Stewart accidentally tripped and fell off the bell tower after
- 38:50Kim Novak. She was pulled out of the way by
- 38:52an alert crew member and filming was stopped for the day as
- 38:54Stewart was quite shook up. Also like 60 years old he
- 38:59probably dislocated a hip. Yes, fact #2 Sir Alfred
- 39:05Hitchcock had originally wanted to use his now famous Vertigo
- 39:08zoom shot as far back as Rebecca in 1940, but due to the lack of
- 39:12technology at the time, he could not do it.
- 39:15The technique was inspired by a time when Hitchcock had fainted
- 39:18during a party. Fact #3 Kim Novak already had a
- 39:23reputation for being difficult, so perhaps it was not a surprise
- 39:27when she refused to show up for work one day.
- 39:29She was on strike for more money from her home studio, Columbia
- 39:32Pictures, who was paying her $1250 a week.
- 39:36Even though they were receiving a $250,000.
- 39:40Even though they were receiving $250,000 for her loan out for
- 39:44this and one more movie. The ploy worked, and Novak got a
- 39:47raise. Good for her.
- 39:49I hope that's a truth. Stick it to the man, Kim Novak.
- 39:58I don't remember hearing anything about Jimmy Stewart
- 40:00falling out of the bell tower, but let's just assume that that
- 40:02could be true for now #2 is interesting to me.
- 40:06It sounds very plausible. It also sounds like something
- 40:09that Brad would invent. I just, I just feel like I know
- 40:14you, Brad. I'm willing to stake my
- 40:17reputation on #2 I think I'm going to say #2 is the
- 40:20falsehood, but I am also 78% certain I'm wrong.
- 40:25So what you're saying is you're 78% certain that you don't
- 40:29actually know me? Correct.
- 40:31OK, just making sure the The thing is Bob, you 100% do not
- 40:37know me because number 2 is not the falsehood.
- 40:41Man, which one was false? Number one.
- 40:44Oh, nice. OK, yeah, yeah, I guess they
- 40:48probably had Jimmy Stewart strapped into a harness or
- 40:50something. They had him on a strap on
- 40:54harness Bob. Yikes.
- 40:58All right, well, let's good luck.
- 40:59Let's steer out of that, because I really don't want to start
- 41:01talking about that on this episode.
- 41:03You know, I, I think Brad, when I try to put this movie in
- 41:06context, I see a lot of people that are just talking about
- 41:10like, oh, this is a movie about obsession.
- 41:12This is a movie about blah, blah, blah.
- 41:14And like, yes, it is. But I think there's, there's so
- 41:17many more complex things going on in the way the story of this
- 41:20movie is told. And I think honestly, I've kind
- 41:24of come out the other end of it like I was going to have this
- 41:26really complex thing that I was going to Oh, it's, it's this and
- 41:28this combined. This is a ghost story.
- 41:32This movie is a ghost story. And like, I, I really think
- 41:36that's the best way to think about it because for the first
- 41:38half of the movie, you're truly trying to piece together whether
- 41:43there is something supernatural going on here.
- 41:46And you know, this, this woman commits suicide and you really
- 41:49don't have any easy answers. And Jimmy Stewart is now like in
- 41:52a mental hospital and is just a, a shell of himself when he
- 41:56emerges. And then you get this scene
- 41:58where he finds Judy just walking down the street, goes and and
- 42:03kind of almost forces himself into her home to demand a date
- 42:06with her. And you're like, well, this
- 42:08doesn't seem like it's going to go well.
- 42:09And then he leaves and the camera stays with her and you
- 42:14get the reveal that she is Madeline, that she is this woman
- 42:19who was hired as an actress to convince Jimmy Stewart she was
- 42:23this guy's wife. He never actually saw the real
- 42:26wife. And they knew that when he ran
- 42:28up this this tower, he wouldn't get all the way up.
- 42:30And the guy dumped his wife's dead body off the top of the
- 42:33tower. And Madeline slash Judy hid up
- 42:37there. And then you're like, oh, you be
- 42:40like, you really hate Judy for a minute.
- 42:43And over the course of the next 40 minutes, she kind of becomes
- 42:47the protagonist of the movie as she is the victim of this plot
- 42:50by Jimmy Stewart to recreate someone from the dead and, and
- 42:55she's. And she's been a victim of of
- 42:57Gavin Elston. Of everyone.
- 42:59Yeah, like, truly. But.
- 43:00But that's why I keep coming back to this idea of this being
- 43:03a ghost story. Because Jimmy Stewart becomes
- 43:05exactly what Gavin told him that his wife was, that he was, that,
- 43:10that she was haunted by this figure from the past, that she
- 43:13had to recreate herself in the image of that figure from the
- 43:16past. And then you start to see that
- 43:17actually happened to Jimmy Stewart, that he becomes, he
- 43:21looks dead when he comes out of this mental hospital.
- 43:23He looks like a ghost, and the only way that he can find
- 43:27meaning in life is to essentially do exactly what
- 43:30Gavin was saying, to turn Judy into this dead person from the
- 43:35past, to go the places that she went, to live the way that she
- 43:38did to to eat and to walk and to dress like her.
- 43:42And then you finally get that image of her emerging out of
- 43:46that bathroom in that green light, like visiting him from
- 43:50the dead. And he is a man possessed at
- 43:52that point. And it's a really cool inversion
- 43:56of, like, you think it's going to be one kind of a ghost story.
- 43:59And it is a ghost story, but it's not the kind you were
- 44:01expecting. Yeah, yeah.
- 44:03I mean, Jimmy Stewart becomes the ghost by the end of the
- 44:05film. Exactly.
- 44:06And as he as he stands on the tower with, you know, Judy now
- 44:11having fallen to death, just like Madeline fell to death in
- 44:14his, you know, dream world, he is left completely bereft of
- 44:19anything that he ever wanted. And I think that I was reading
- 44:24Roger Ebert's review of this and he describes it perfectly when
- 44:29he's talking about when Kim Novak finally fully transforms
- 44:35herself it back into Madeline. And they kiss and the the music
- 44:40swells and the camera circles around them and it's just as
- 44:43beautiful shot where halfway half of the circle is them back
- 44:48in the stable kissing, and then the other half is them still in
- 44:51the hotel. And Ebert says this and the
- 44:55camera circles them hopelessly, like the pinwheel images in
- 44:58Scotty's nightmares, until the shot is about the dizzying
- 45:02futility of our human desires, the impossibility of forcing
- 45:07life to make us happy. I'm like, that is brilliant
- 45:13because the the whole point of a of a ghost film is in my mind to
- 45:19try and deal with like the guilt of the past so that you can be
- 45:24happy and content and in the present.
- 45:28And throughout the entire film, you realize that these desires
- 45:32that Stewart has have been so twisted and become so darkened
- 45:37that there is no way he will be happy in the present.
- 45:41And the only way he can feel any sort of happiness is if she is
- 45:46representation of something that he's lost.
- 45:48I mean, he's an addict at that point, right?
- 45:50Like he's just, he's chasing this high.
- 45:52The thing is though, like I, I, I hear what Ebert's saying and I
- 45:55actually think that's the overall point of the movie.
- 45:57But in that shot in particular, why it worked so well for me is
- 46:00I think Jimmy Stewart actually achieves what he wants.
- 46:05Like it works. It does transport him back to
- 46:07where he wants to go. And there's this great moment
- 46:09where he kind of pulls away from the kiss and he's like looking
- 46:12around, like I'm disoriented. I'm confused, you know, and he
- 46:16doesn't know in the moment that the reason it works so well is
- 46:19because this is the same woman, right?
- 46:21But it's this, it's this really brilliant image of like, I have
- 46:25achieved exactly what I wanted to achieve.
- 46:27I have created this scenario where I am now back living in
- 46:31the past and there's still something unsettling about it.
- 46:34There's still something that makes me like look around, like
- 46:36this doesn't feel right. It's this weird facsimile.
- 46:40And I, I just, I love that shot so much because like, everything
- 46:45the movie wants to achieve is in that one shot.
- 46:47Well, let's let's talk about the the camera used throughout the
- 46:50film. From the very start of the film,
- 46:54you you can tell that Hitchcock is very is very careful about
- 46:59which the height and the angle of which his camera shots.
- 47:04Like if you take the entire scene of Gavin explaining the
- 47:07ghost story to to Scotty, the the, the height at which the
- 47:11camera is AT and it angles in such a way that it places
- 47:15Stewart either below or above Gavin throughout the entire
- 47:20scene. And you see that again later in
- 47:22the film when Judy is trying to explain to him, like, can't you
- 47:27love me for me? They're they're sitting in the
- 47:29hotel room and the shot starts with Judy below Stewart, Stewart
- 47:34in power. And then as she explains, hey,
- 47:37like, like, can't you be in love with me?
- 47:38Can't. Can't I be enough for you?
- 47:41She stands up and the camera rises just a little bit so that
- 47:44they are, they're even, they're equal.
- 47:47And then Stewart stands up. The camera raises back up.
- 47:51She is now below him again in perspective, and the camera gets
- 47:55shaky. And it's in that moment that he
- 47:58says to her, we need to get you new clothes.
- 48:01We need to do your hair. Sorry.
- 48:03It's not the new clothes, it's the hair.
- 48:05That's when he says, we need to dye your hair, the final piece
- 48:08needed for this transformation. And the camera is still shaky
- 48:11and it, and it's representing that no matter what stability
- 48:15she offers him, the things still aren't right.
- 48:19And it isn't until that moment, when the camera very steadily
- 48:22circles him and represents his imagination of the kiss in the
- 48:26stable with the last time things were perfect, that the use of
- 48:30camera work here is just perfect.
- 48:33Bob. I have a couple more things I
- 48:36want to talk about before we get out of here, and I guess we'll
- 48:38start with the good That last scene where they go up the bell
- 48:43tower together and he is manhandling her and just he'd go
- 48:47up the stairs. Go up the stairs, Judy.
- 48:50And you fear for her safety because you're kind of on her
- 48:53side now, like she is a victim here.
- 48:55Even if she did the most unspeakably horrible thing.
- 48:58You're on her side. And then you get to the top of
- 49:01the bell tower. And it's not necessarily that
- 49:03your allegiance flips back again.
- 49:06But it's like you get reminded that, yes, you actually do have
- 49:10empathy and sympathy for for Scotty because he has that that
- 49:13moment where he tells her how he figured it out.
- 49:16And he says you shouldn't have been that sentimental.
- 49:19And it's like, oh, man, like, this dude is broken, you know?
- 49:24And then you don't know what he's going to do.
- 49:26You don't know if he's going to fly off the handle.
- 49:28But in that moment, this movie has gone from you're totally on
- 49:32his side to you're totally on her side.
- 49:34And then as they go up the stairs, you're going back and
- 49:36forth and back and forth, and you're finally arrive in this
- 49:38place where you just want things to be OK.
- 49:42And you know that they're not going to.
- 49:44Like, this is hurtling towards disaster.
- 49:46There's a moment at the beginning of the movie, it's
- 49:49like a throwaway line where Midge just kind of mentions to
- 49:52Scotty like, oh, well, you remember the doctor told you?
- 49:54Or maybe he says it to her like it's going to take another one
- 49:57of these incidents for me to kick this thing for good, you
- 50:00know? And then you have that moment
- 50:02where after she falls, he just walks right out onto the ledge.
- 50:04You can tell he's not scared anymore and and his Vertigo is
- 50:07cured. But like, at what cost here?
- 50:10Yeah, well, and once again you talk about desire.
- 50:13He proclaims his desire to be free of Vertigo and here he is
- 50:18at the end of the film film free from his it.
- 50:21Only took It only took at least three people falling off
- 50:24buildings for that to happen. Well, and and to get back to
- 50:27that final scene, though, there is just one slight moment where
- 50:33they kiss and it seems like they have reconciled and the haunted
- 50:39specter of his past has been dissipated and maybe they could
- 50:42fall in love with each other. Oh, no way.
- 50:44They can't shoot off the building.
- 50:48Oh man, the so I will, I will put this in the episode, but the
- 50:51ladies behind me at the end of the movie, you know, the nun
- 50:56comes up and scares her and she falls off and then the movie's
- 50:59over. Like it's immediately over.
- 51:00Yep. And this lady behind me was
- 51:02like, that's right. That goddamn nun, that goddamn
- 51:05nun. It was really funny.
- 51:09I just like. I can't not think of that now.
- 51:11I don't even know what that means.
- 51:12I don't. Either I think she was a little
- 51:14bit drunk by the end of the movie, but it was great.
- 51:17That's incredible. All right, man, let's talk one
- 51:21more scene. The dream sequence, the very
- 51:24famous dream sequence from this movie does not play well with a
- 51:30theater audience in 2023. What?
- 51:32Are you talking about Bob? When?
- 51:34When Jimmy Stewart's disembodied head started floating around,
- 51:38there were audible laughs. Yeah.
- 51:40And I think in the context of the movie, like, it still really
- 51:42works. Like the, the function of it
- 51:45works, but it's, it's getting kind of hard to defend like
- 51:49almost 70 years on, you know? Yeah, I mean, I'll say this,
- 51:52when I watch this film is like, I don't know, probably like a 15
- 51:56year old. It terrified me.
- 51:58I was not a fan of the dream sequence.
- 52:01I mean the the silhouette of him falling is incredible.
- 52:04It's mostly just like the the disembodied head with the fake
- 52:08hairpiece flapping in the winds, you know?
- 52:11Yeah, it kind of feels similar to me to a Willy Wonka and the
- 52:16as they're taking the the the boats down the river and the
- 52:20tunnel. Like it.
- 52:21It felt somewhat similar to that for me, but it it definitely had
- 52:25the feel of like a James Bond title sequence more than like
- 52:30this suspense thriller. But once again, I think that the
- 52:34the score kind of saves its bacon.
- 52:40Right. Yeah.
- 52:41I mean, you've mentioned the score twice now by Bernard
- 52:43Herrmann. It is just quite simply one of
- 52:45the best scores ever put to a film.
- 52:47It is. Yep, man.
- 52:49And, and in person in the theater, that thing was booming.
- 52:52It is lush and suspenseful and dark and, you know, like
- 52:58everything you could possibly want out of a movie score.
- 53:00And I feel like it's pretty much like wall to wall music for
- 53:04almost the whole movie until that final.
- 53:07They get up to the top of the bell tower at the end of the
- 53:09movie and the soundtrack cuts out like he's he's dragging her
- 53:13up the stairs. And it's really suspenseful.
- 53:15And then all of a sudden it's just silent again.
- 53:18And I think that once again, this is where Hitchcock and his
- 53:21genius comes in, because he knows exactly when the music is
- 53:24beneficial, and then he knows when the music is going to take
- 53:27away from something. Yeah, and, and it's just
- 53:30haunting. Like, like it, it, it sticks in
- 53:33your brain and it, it keeps everything moving when the
- 53:37things on screen are not moving quickly.
- 53:41And, and I think that's what makes it so important to this
- 53:44film. All right, man.
- 53:45Well, I think it's time for us to get into our final segment of
- 53:48the day, which we call let's make it a double.
- 53:51We're near the end of the episodes of Things, listening to
- 53:54the film and Whiskey Show. Let's have another film with
- 53:57this one, even if it's struggling.
- 53:59It's the final segment of the day.
- 54:00Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 54:03part of the podcast where we pick a movie to pair up with
- 54:06this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 54:09Brad, I'll go first since I think I already mentioned mine.
- 54:11I'm going to pair this up with the 1955 French film Diabolique.
- 54:17It. Is so good and it's like the
- 54:20perfect bridge between Rear Window and this movie.
- 54:24Like it's a little bit more conventionally suspenseful than
- 54:27this movie is, but you still got the themes of like dead people,
- 54:31folks going crazy. It's a it's a good time at the
- 54:33movies. So I'm pairing it up with
- 54:35Diabolique. All right, so for the average
- 54:37American moviegoer, give me your one minute pitch on why they
- 54:42should see old French film Diabolique.
- 54:46It doesn't feel like an old French film, all right, you
- 54:50know? What I mean, that's a that's a
- 54:51great. Pitch feels like a Hitchcock
- 54:53movie where they just happened to be speaking a different
- 54:55language, but you forget about it 10 minutes in and then you're
- 54:58just all the way bought into the movie.
- 55:00How much French do you need to learn and study before watching
- 55:04Diabolique? Well, if you are Bob Book then
- 55:06the answer is 0 because your boy does not know French.
- 55:10You hear that, everybody? It's like Hitchcock, but not.
- 55:14And you don't need to know French, so go watch it.
- 55:16Boom. All right, Brad, how about you?
- 55:18What's your Let's make it a double.
- 55:20Bob, I am going to pair this up with Shutter Island.
- 55:25Oh, that's a good one. I think that Shutter Island is a
- 55:28it would make for just a really fun, who is our main character
- 55:34evening. Like, you don't quite know
- 55:37exactly what's going on. You're thrown in five different
- 55:39directions and you don't feel great at the end of it.
- 55:43I'm in for that kind of a movie night.
- 55:45Yeah. Man good.
- 55:46I love Shutter Island, what an underrated movie.
- 55:49It's such a good movie. Man, it's like a masterpiece
- 55:52that no one recognizes it as such.
- 55:55All right, man, let's give this movie some scores.
- 55:57I think unsurprisingly, I am going to give this movie a 10
- 56:00out of 10 with the caveat this is not a perfect movie.
- 56:05Like I know Brad, you like to say there is no such thing as a
- 56:08perfect movie. I think that there are films
- 56:10that approach like quote, UN quote, perfection in terms of
- 56:13like, it is cut perfectly, it moves perfectly.
- 56:17It is a technically perfect movie.
- 56:19And I am much closer to thinking that about North by Northwest
- 56:22than I ever have been after watching it in a theater.
- 56:25Like that movie just works. There's not an ounce of fat on
- 56:28that thing. That is not this movie.
- 56:30This one's much more messy and kind of boring at parts and kind
- 56:34of like confusing and I don't know what's going on.
- 56:37But the, the overwhelming totality of the movie, The sum
- 56:41of it is A10 plus. It's a movie that sticks in your
- 56:45brain that you can never fully get your arms around.
- 56:48And it just, it gets under your skin and, and disturbs you.
- 56:53And yeah, yeah, man, I, I, I watched it weeks ago and I can't
- 56:56stop thinking about it. Still.
- 56:58It's a 10 out of 10. Yeah.
- 57:00And and when you allow yourself to question what level of action
- 57:06am I willing to take to consummate my desires?
- 57:11And you watch what happens to Jimmy Stewart throughout the
- 57:14film versus, you know, Midge and how she just walks away from
- 57:18things. And even as you watch Kim Novak,
- 57:22like, she also gives in to her desires.
- 57:25She has a moment where she almost walks away and she
- 57:27literally writes, I don't know if I can stay away from you, dot
- 57:31dot, dot. And then she tears the note up.
- 57:33Like everything about this movie is about the dangers of
- 57:38indulging in desire, unfettered desire.
- 57:41And I, if you're willing to wrestle with that in your own
- 57:46heart and your own soul, this is one of the best movies ever
- 57:50made. Bob, 10 out of 10.
- 57:51All right, so it's a pair of 10s from us, but we want to know
- 57:54what you think. You can reach out to us on
- 57:57Facebook X question mark, Twitter, whatever you want to
- 58:00call it, Instagram. What else are we on?
- 58:04Brad TikTok, YouTube at Film. Whiskey.
- 58:09We're also on Discord. We have a channel over on
- 58:11Discord where we are talking all the time about movies, whiskey,
- 58:15and any other sort of topics that you might want to enjoy and
- 58:18indulge in. So you can find a link to our
- 58:20Discord at the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 58:23All right, Brad, one final question.
- 58:25Is this the greatest movie ever made?
- 58:27Slash Can you see why it was ranked the greatest film ever
- 58:31made? No and yes.
- 58:36I think I'm in the same. Like, yeah, I, I think that this
- 58:40film is so beautifully, you know, I've used the word
- 58:45multiple times, so beautifully haunting that I can 100%
- 58:50understand why this would get ranked as as the greatest film
- 58:53of all time. All right, folks, next week we
- 58:56will be back talking about, in my opinion, maybe the best
- 59:00sports film of the 21st century. We're talking about Ron Howard's
- 59:04boxing masterpiece Cinderella Man.
- 59:07So. I thought you were going to say
- 59:09trouble with the curve. Yes, that's it.
- 59:14All right. So join us for both of those
- 59:15movies next week. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 59:19I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.
- 59:45Music.