Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court May Limit SEC's Power
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: The case before the Supreme Court is about a challenge
- 0:13Speaker 1: to the powers of the SEC to bring legal actions
- 0:16Speaker 1: in house, and it's another example of the conservative justices
- 0:21Speaker 1: targeting the administrative state. During the oral arguments, Chief Justice
- 0:25Speaker 1: John Roberts expressed concerns over the power of federal regulators.
- 0:30Speaker 2: The extent of impact of government agencies on daily life
- 0:36Speaker 2: today is enormously more significant than it was fifty years ago.
- 0:43Speaker 1: The Jocracy case could strip the SEC of a key
- 0:47Speaker 1: enforcement tool, and Conservative justices like Brett Cavanaugh suggested that
- 0:52Speaker 1: people accused of fraud by the SEC have a constitutional
- 0:56Speaker 1: right to have their cases decided by a jury in
- 0:59Speaker 1: federal courts instead of by the SEC's in house administrative
- 1:03Speaker 1: law judges.
- 1:04Speaker 3: That seems problematic to say the government can deprive you
- 1:10Speaker 3: of your property, your money, substantial sums in a tribunal
- 1:15Speaker 3: that is at least perceived as not being impartial.
- 1:20Speaker 1: A change in the law by the Court here could
- 1:22Speaker 1: have effects far beyond the SEC, because roughly two dozen agencies,
- 1:28Speaker 1: including the EPA, the CFTC, and the Federal Trade Commission,
- 1:32Speaker 1: have similar enforcement schemes, as Liberal Justice Sonya Sotomayor pointed
- 1:37Speaker 1: out to Jocasy's attorney Michael McCulloch.
- 1:40Speaker 4: All of those agencies we'll have to go to court. Correct, Well,
- 1:48Speaker 4: you are, all of their proceedings are now nullified unto
- 1:53Speaker 4: your theory.
- 1:54Speaker 1: And Liberal Justice Elena Kagan pointed to a nineteen seventy
- 1:57Speaker 1: seven Supreme Court ruling at La Roofing, telling McCulloch it
- 2:02Speaker 1: settled the issue and there was no right to a
- 2:04Speaker 1: jury trial here.
- 2:05Speaker 4: In a case where Congress has given an agency the
- 2:09Speaker 4: power to enforce something and the agency is bringing the charge,
- 2:14Speaker 4: if you will that you know that that's just not
- 2:19Speaker 4: it's that's settled.
- 2:21Speaker 1: Well, it's settled only to the extent no one's brought
- 2:23Speaker 1: it up and forced this issue since Atlas Roofing in his.
- 2:27Speaker 4: Chorea is contact. Nobody has had the you know, kutzpa
- 2:35Speaker 4: to quote my people to bring it up since Atlas Roofing.
- 2:39Speaker 1: My guest is Harold Krent, a professor at the Chicago
- 2:42Speaker 1: Kent College of Law. How this involves George Jarcasy, a
- 2:46Speaker 1: former hedge fund manager and conservative radio host, and the
- 2:50Speaker 1: SEC found that he had committed securities fraud in twenty
- 2:54Speaker 1: thirteen for misleading investors. Hell tell us about the case
- 2:59Speaker 1: and what's at stake here.
- 3:01Speaker 5: This started ten years ago and the variety of challenges
- 3:06Speaker 5: against the SEC proceedings, and finally, after first losing in
- 3:12Speaker 5: the DC Circuit, he tried and found more success in
- 3:15Speaker 5: the Fifth Circuit, and the Fifth Circuit decided on three
- 3:19Speaker 5: distinct constitutional violations. First that there was a non delegation
- 3:24Speaker 5: violation in the fact that Congress had not given sufficient
- 3:28Speaker 5: guidance to the Security Change Commission about whether to bring
- 3:31Speaker 5: a security fraud action before an alj as opposed to
- 3:35Speaker 5: in front of a court. And second, that the SEC
- 3:39Speaker 5: proceedings weren't constitutionally constructed because the administer of law judges
- 3:44Speaker 5: in the Security is a Change Commission are protected from
- 3:47Speaker 5: that will removal and thus violate Article two. And the
- 3:52Speaker 5: third problem was that the fraud charges that the SEC
- 3:56Speaker 5: successfully brought against Charc echoed those of fraud cases at
- 4:02Speaker 5: common law and that therefore that duct should have been
- 4:05Speaker 5: granted a jury trial. If the Supreme Court decides all
- 4:09Speaker 5: three issues against the SEC, they would have enormous ramifications
- 4:13Speaker 5: on the administrative state. That's not likely after listening to
- 4:16Speaker 5: the oral argument, but nonetheless, the consequence of dramatic and
- 4:20Speaker 5: briefly they are that almost every particular individual or firm
- 4:25Speaker 5: performed agency, many at least, would have the right to
- 4:27Speaker 5: a jury trial and not have to go before an
- 4:29Speaker 5: administrative tribunalism is currently the case. That would be one
- 4:33Speaker 5: fundamental change. The second would be that all administrative law
- 4:36Speaker 5: judges would have to be subject there outwill removal, which
- 4:39Speaker 5: would undermine the independence, ironically of these administrative determinations. And third,
- 4:46Speaker 5: there would be some kind reinvigoration of the non delegation doctrine,
- 4:50Speaker 5: which was mimit Congress's ability to delegate issues for administry
- 4:55Speaker 5: of agencies to resolve. So very consequential case, very usual
- 5:00Speaker 5: what happened at oral arguments or the stakes couldn't be higher.
- 5:03Speaker 1: So, now, before we go into the oral arguments, explain
- 5:06Speaker 1: the difference between an administrative law judge and a federal
- 5:10Speaker 1: district court judge known as an Article three judge, and
- 5:13Speaker 1: the difference in the proceedings in the different forums.
- 5:17Speaker 5: So the two different tracks of litigation when the government
- 5:20Speaker 5: is involved. The first would be before an Article three
- 5:24Speaker 5: judge in a federal trial court, and those proceedings are
- 5:28Speaker 5: very similar to anything one would see on TV in
- 5:31Speaker 5: terms of having rules of evidence. You'd have a judge
- 5:35Speaker 5: who is protected from any kind of diminution and salary
- 5:39Speaker 5: or removal. You'd have attorneys for both sides arguing subject
- 5:45Speaker 5: to delineated rules, and at times you'd have a jury
- 5:49Speaker 5: trial as well if there were money damages at stake.
- 5:53Speaker 5: In contrast, in a typical administrative proceeding, of which there
- 5:57Speaker 5: are hundreds of thousands a year, you would have an
- 6:01Speaker 5: Administry of Law judge who is appointed by the agency
- 6:06Speaker 5: and is subject to remove by the agency, but at
- 6:09Speaker 5: least currently only for some kind of misconduct. The proceeding
- 6:13Speaker 5: would go before this Administry of Law judge. The rules
- 6:16Speaker 5: of evidence would be much more flexible, in other words,
- 6:19Speaker 5: more information could be submitted. In addition, there would be
- 6:23Speaker 5: no jury, and so the case would first go before
- 6:25Speaker 5: the Ministry of Law judge, but then can be appealed
- 6:28Speaker 5: to the administrative agency itself in this case the Securities
- 6:32Speaker 5: and Exchange Commission, and of course those are political actors.
- 6:36Speaker 5: But then only after these Securities and Exchange Commission would
- 6:39Speaker 5: make a decision, then judicial review would be opened up
- 6:43Speaker 5: and a court would determine whether the agency reasonably acted
- 6:48Speaker 5: in terms of deciding upon a fine or discouragement, as
- 6:52Speaker 5: indeed both happened in this case. So they're very different tracks.
- 6:57Speaker 5: There's judicial involvement in both of them. One the judiciary
- 7:02Speaker 5: has a review function over the agency and cancy agency
- 7:05Speaker 5: some difference in how it conducts the proceedings, and the
- 7:08Speaker 5: other it's much more protective of individual rights and the
- 7:13Speaker 5: individual would have the ability to have a jury check
- 7:16Speaker 5: upon any kind of zeal or overreaching by the government
- 7:20Speaker 5: and bringing these charges.
- 7:22Speaker 4: Now.
- 7:23Speaker 1: Jocasy contends that defendants in SEC cases have a constitutional
- 7:27Speaker 1: right to make their case to a federal jury, and
- 7:30Speaker 1: the oral arguments focused almost entirely on that one issue
- 7:35Speaker 1: on the Seventh Amendment, which provides that in suits at
- 7:39Speaker 1: common law, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved.
- 7:43Speaker 1: So tell us about the argument over the Seventh Amendment.
- 7:46Speaker 5: Well before the argument of the amendment. What I think
- 7:49Speaker 5: is extraordinary about this case is the two other very
- 7:52Speaker 5: significant constitutional arguments that we discussed were hardly mentioned it
- 7:57Speaker 5: all during oral argument and or argumently in almost two hours.
- 8:01Speaker 5: And so the question is why, And I don't know
- 8:03Speaker 5: the answer. You only speculate that either the justices were
- 8:07Speaker 5: convinced that the other two arguments were not very weighty
- 8:11Speaker 5: and therefore they knew what the result would be, or
- 8:15Speaker 5: they might have decided that they were going to throw
- 8:18Speaker 5: this case out on the Seventh Amendment grounds anyway, and
- 8:21Speaker 5: so they didn't have to decide either the non delegation
- 8:24Speaker 5: argument or the alga removability issue. But it is extremely
- 8:29Speaker 5: unusual for the Court to ignore two very important constitutional
- 8:34Speaker 5: challenges in a case of this nature, So that to
- 8:37Speaker 5: me is the biggest mystery of this case. But turning
- 8:40Speaker 5: to the difficult question about the Seventh Amendment, the question
- 8:44Speaker 5: is how broad the Seventh Amendment should be construed to extend.
- 8:50Speaker 5: On the one hand, an individual has a right to
- 8:53Speaker 5: a jury trial, but the courts for one hundred and
- 8:56Speaker 5: fifty years, if not more, have said that the very
- 9:00Speaker 5: trial right does not exist if there is a public
- 9:03Speaker 5: right involved, And so much of the argument discussed from
- 9:06Speaker 5: different perspectives what is a public right? And the Supreme
- 9:10Speaker 5: Court held fifty years ago in a case called Atlas Roofings,
- 9:14Speaker 5: that a public right would include not only issues between
- 9:17Speaker 5: individuals and the government directly, such as taxes and claims
- 9:22Speaker 5: like social security benefits, but also would include anything under
- 9:26Speaker 5: a comprehensive congressional scheme that was devised in order to
- 9:32Speaker 5: protect the public. So in that case, Congress had created
- 9:36Speaker 5: a mechanism to allow a federal agency OOSHA, to inspect
- 9:42Speaker 5: workplaces and find individual companies for failure to maintain a
- 9:47Speaker 5: healthy workplace. And then the court said, yes, these kinds
- 9:52Speaker 5: of finds are a little bit like negligence claims or
- 9:56Speaker 5: wantful death claims that could be launched against employers. But
- 9:59Speaker 5: when the government brings such an action, it does so
- 10:03Speaker 5: for a different purpose. It brings the action to protect
- 10:06Speaker 5: the public and to try to prevent these kind of
- 10:10Speaker 5: workplace accidents. And therefore, in light of this unique public nature,
- 10:14Speaker 5: there is no right to a jury trial, and that
- 10:16Speaker 5: therefore the government can recover fines even outside of the
- 10:20Speaker 5: jury context. So this is the precedent that the government
- 10:24Speaker 5: relied upon, and it has been cited in lots of
- 10:28Speaker 5: cases since involving finding immigration proceedings, in customs proceedings and
- 10:34Speaker 5: so forth. So the stakes are very high in this case,
- 10:37Speaker 5: and indeed, much of the argument was talking about line drawing.
- 10:41Speaker 5: What is to distinguish the fraud claim under the Securities
- 10:46Speaker 5: Act in the Jerxi case from a case involving taxes,
- 10:53Speaker 5: involving customs duties and so forth.
- 10:55Speaker 1: Coming up next, we'll talk about what the decision might
- 10:58Speaker 1: look like. I'm June gram So when you're listening to Bloomberg,
- 11:01Speaker 1: I've been talking to Professor Harold Krant to the Chicago
- 11:04Speaker 1: Kent College of Law about Supreme Court oral arguments this
- 11:08Speaker 1: week over a challenge to the power of the sec
- 11:11Speaker 1: to bring legal actions in house. The Conservative Justice is
- 11:16Speaker 1: seem to be very concerned about the right to a
- 11:18Speaker 1: jury in this case, and it struck me as a
- 11:22Speaker 1: bit odd because jury trial isn't something they've historically cared
- 11:26Speaker 1: about very much, right, They've always pushed forced arbitration they have.
- 11:30Speaker 5: I mean, certainly, it's true. And what is clear out
- 11:34Speaker 5: of this discussion is that they have circled back to
- 11:38Speaker 5: the importance in seventeen ninety one of the ratification of
- 11:43Speaker 5: the Seventh Amendment to think that this is a hallmark
- 11:47Speaker 5: right that should be preserved by any individual, not only
- 11:52Speaker 5: if they're litigating against another company or another individual, but
- 11:55Speaker 5: also when they're litigating against the government itself. And that's
- 12:00Speaker 5: not how we've recognized that right in the last seventy
- 12:04Speaker 5: five years. So the Court is I think using this
- 12:07Speaker 5: now is a lever to try to either cut down
- 12:12Speaker 5: or diminish the power of these administrative agencies that operate
- 12:16Speaker 5: in so many sectors of our lives, from transportation into immigration,
- 12:21Speaker 5: to workplace safety, to environmental safety, and so much more.
- 12:26Speaker 5: And so by focusing on the Seventh Amendment in a
- 12:29Speaker 5: way that they haven't before, they will effectively force agencies
- 12:34Speaker 5: to go to court to collect penalties, and that will
- 12:38Speaker 5: slow down the administrative process.
- 12:41Speaker 1: Justice is Elena Kagan and Katanji Brown Jackson said that
- 12:45Speaker 1: the at Liss ruling settled the issue here, So would
- 12:49Speaker 1: the Court have to overrule that nineteen seventy seven precedent
- 12:54Speaker 1: in order to rule for jocracy here.
- 12:57Speaker 5: Likely they would do so, at least in substance, if
- 13:00Speaker 5: not inform I mean. Chief Justice Roberts himself said, well,
- 13:04Speaker 5: you know that pathless was fifty years ago, and we've
- 13:07Speaker 5: seen a lot of that's happened in the last fifty years,
- 13:09Speaker 5: including the increasing power of administrative agencies. So it's time
- 13:13Speaker 5: for us to take a good look back at it
- 13:16Speaker 5: to see if it makes sense today. And to be fair,
- 13:19Speaker 5: some of the more conservative justices, particularly Justice Barrett, was
- 13:23Speaker 5: struggling to figure out a limiting principle about how you
- 13:27Speaker 5: could make the determination of when the Seventh Amendment right
- 13:31Speaker 5: would be triggered. For instance, is it just because there's
- 13:33Speaker 5: a civil penalty that would be at least one easily
- 13:37Speaker 5: administrable remedy to say, as opposed to say a discooragement
- 13:41Speaker 5: penalty or something else, or a cease and desist order.
- 13:44Speaker 5: So is that line important? So there was at least
- 13:47Speaker 5: some kind of wrangling amongst some of the conservative justices,
- 13:51Speaker 5: not Justice Alito, not Justice Thomas, but the others about
- 13:55Speaker 5: this kind of line drawing. Is if they extend the
- 13:59Speaker 5: Seventh Amend, how far will the extension be? And at
- 14:03Speaker 5: least they were concerned that a literal interpretation of what
- 14:08Speaker 5: Darshi was arguing might extend very far.
- 14:11Speaker 1: Indeed, the Assistants Elicitor General said the government was protecting
- 14:17Speaker 1: the rights of the public generally, and when the public's
- 14:20Speaker 1: rights are at issue, the right to a jury trial
- 14:23Speaker 1: guaranteed by the Seventh Amendment in suits that common law
- 14:26Speaker 1: did not apply. Do you agree or disagree that the
- 14:30Speaker 1: Seventh Amendment applies to this situation.
- 14:33Speaker 5: I think that the President is extremely strong that the
- 14:35Speaker 5: Seventh Amendment does not apply when Congress allows individuals to
- 14:40Speaker 5: sue each other before a federal form. That's where the
- 14:44Speaker 5: interest and concern of the Seventh Amendment should be at
- 14:47Speaker 5: its strongest. And those are the examples I think the
- 14:49Speaker 5: Court should be focusing on. But I don't think the
- 14:52Speaker 5: Court is correct to be concerned about is when the
- 14:56Speaker 5: actual challenges not between two private entities, but the between
- 15:00Speaker 5: a private entity and the federal government itself. That's really
- 15:04Speaker 5: the essence of what a public right is. That's what
- 15:07Speaker 5: Justice Scotias said years ago, and that should be the
- 15:10Speaker 5: focus here. And so in this case, when we have
- 15:13Speaker 5: the government saying that we're not suing on behalf of
- 15:18Speaker 5: a private party. We're suing because you have rattled confidence
- 15:22Speaker 5: in the securities markets, that's absolutely permissible, and the jury
- 15:26Speaker 5: trial right and the serf of Amendment should not be triggered.
- 15:29Speaker 1: How do you think they're going to rule? Is it
- 15:30Speaker 1: going to be a six ' to three ruling, whatever
- 15:32Speaker 1: it is.
- 15:33Speaker 5: You know, again, it's so difficult to judge from in
- 15:36Speaker 5: our a argument. How of course finally going to come
- 15:39Speaker 5: out but I would guess that they will try to
- 15:42Speaker 5: articulate a fuzzy line, but a line that is more
- 15:47Speaker 5: restrictive of Congress's ability really to determine what kind of
- 15:52Speaker 5: suits can be presented before administrative agencies. I doubt they
- 15:55Speaker 5: will go as far as to say that Congress can't
- 16:00Speaker 5: allow such suits to go before, but they'll probably talk
- 16:02Speaker 5: about Congress is limited when the suit is either in
- 16:08Speaker 5: all respects similar or echoes or derivative of a common
- 16:12Speaker 5: law right. So what the court we'll want to do
- 16:14Speaker 5: is say, use the touchstone of a common law right
- 16:18Speaker 5: and say, if you have the right to have a
- 16:19Speaker 5: jury trial in a similar case in seventeen ninety one
- 16:24Speaker 5: and a court to Westminster, then Congress cannot effectively deprive
- 16:28Speaker 5: you of that right by calling it something else, by
- 16:32Speaker 5: changing it slightly and vesting it before an administrative agency.
- 16:35Speaker 5: That'd be my educated guess.
- 16:37Speaker 1: Let's talk about the ramifications of a decision against the SEC. Here.
- 16:42Speaker 1: For example, will the decision affect the Federal Trade Commission,
- 16:47Speaker 1: which uses in house judges as well.
- 16:50Speaker 5: The decision is likely to affect Federal Trade Commission. It
- 16:55Speaker 5: may affect OSHA, It may affect the customs duties ends
- 17:00Speaker 5: on the exact test for how to determine whether this
- 17:03Speaker 5: particular right of action brought by the government is similar
- 17:08Speaker 5: to the suited common law in seventeen ninety one. I mean,
- 17:12Speaker 5: that is a very archaic way of understanding what Congress
- 17:16Speaker 5: can do and can't do in terms of deciding where
- 17:18Speaker 5: these particular claims can be brought. But I think that's
- 17:22Speaker 5: where the court is headed. And that was the concern
- 17:26Speaker 5: that was recognized by counsel for Darsi that depending upon
- 17:30Speaker 5: the line drawing, the case may either have a modest
- 17:35Speaker 5: impact or a tremendous impact. And so even if the court,
- 17:41Speaker 5: as it seems, will lean towards DARKSI, the real question
- 17:45Speaker 5: is how broad the decision and that's something they wrestled
- 17:50Speaker 5: at it. And indeed, just as Sodhamoyor said, look, this
- 17:53Speaker 5: is a big issue. Neither side has litigated how broad
- 17:57Speaker 5: the impact will be of a decision if we strike
- 18:00Speaker 5: down the claim in this case. Shouldn't we have more
- 18:04Speaker 5: briefing on the issue in recognition of how important it was,
- 18:07Speaker 5: And I doubt they we'll do that, But I mean
- 18:09Speaker 5: her point was, you know, we're just reaching in a
- 18:13Speaker 5: darker we don't know exactly how broad of an impact
- 18:17Speaker 5: a room for darcy would have.
- 18:19Speaker 1: This is part of a Supreme Court term that could
- 18:22Speaker 1: have broad implications for federal regulators. The justices heard arguments
- 18:26Speaker 1: in October over whether the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's funding
- 18:30Speaker 1: system is constitutional, and in January it will consider whether
- 18:34Speaker 1: to overturn the Chevron doctrine, which is a precedent that
- 18:38Speaker 1: gives agencies leeway when they interpret ambiguous congressional commands. Why
- 18:45Speaker 1: this focus and do you think federal regulators should be
- 18:49Speaker 1: afraid of what's going to happen this term?
- 18:52Speaker 5: Well, it's plain that the focus has arisen from a
- 18:55Speaker 5: deep distrust of the administrative state, and the Court has
- 18:58Speaker 5: signaled in a variety of cases is that it wants
- 19:01Speaker 5: to pair down the size of government, and it thinks
- 19:04Speaker 5: Congress has gone too far in an empowering administrative agencies
- 19:08Speaker 5: with the ability to investigate and to proceed against mostly
- 19:14Speaker 5: companies who violate the regulations that these agencies have promulgated
- 19:18Speaker 5: in order to enforce a congressional mission. And so these cases,
- 19:23Speaker 5: together with the appointments cases and removal cases that the
- 19:28Speaker 5: Court previously has articulated, is trying to take another look
- 19:33Speaker 5: at how broadly administrative agencies have influence over our lives.
- 19:37Speaker 5: But that being said, I think that the Court is
- 19:41Speaker 5: proceeding probably a little more slowly now than it thought
- 19:44Speaker 5: it might two years ago. My guess is that they
- 19:47Speaker 5: will take some steps to curve the power of administrative agencies.
- 19:52Speaker 5: But by ignoring the non delegation argument today, for instance,
- 19:55Speaker 5: they have bypassed an opportunity that would really stick a
- 19:59Speaker 5: stake in the most administrative agencies directly, because that could
- 20:04Speaker 5: have had an incredibly dramatic impact upon administer of agencies
- 20:08Speaker 5: had they held that Congress has to be incredibly clear
- 20:12Speaker 5: before an agency can't exercise any power whatsoever. Indeed, because
- 20:16Speaker 5: the question in this case was so minor, they had
- 20:19Speaker 5: to do with whether the agency could use the judgment
- 20:22Speaker 5: to decide whether to bring a fraud case before an
- 20:26Speaker 5: Article three judge or before an agency. And the argument
- 20:30Speaker 5: that the Fifth Circuit bought was because Congress didn't give
- 20:33Speaker 5: any guidance as to inform the agency's choices to which
- 20:37Speaker 5: route to take, that itself violated the Constitution. A decision
- 20:42Speaker 5: to uphold that understanding of the non delegation doctrine we
- 20:45Speaker 5: have done far more to dismantle this administrative state than
- 20:49Speaker 5: with the self of the amendment issue that the court
- 20:52Speaker 5: spent two hours on that oral argument. So yes, they
- 20:56Speaker 5: are thinking about curving the power of the administrative state,
- 21:00Speaker 5: but they're doing so not in a as aggressive manner
- 21:05Speaker 5: as they might have if they had just seized upon
- 21:07Speaker 5: the non delegation doctrine as a lever in which to
- 21:11Speaker 5: accomplish that result.
- 21:12Speaker 1: We'll see how these decisions come out. Thanks so much, Hal.
- 21:15Speaker 1: That's Professor Harold Krant of the Chicago Kent College of
- 21:18Speaker 1: Law coming up the racketeering trial of a famous rapper.
- 21:23Speaker 1: I'm June Grasso. When you're listening to Bloomberg, who is
- 21:26Speaker 1: Grammy winning rapper Young Thug. Is he the ruthless leader
- 21:29Speaker 1: of a violent street gang that terrorized Atlanta neighborhoods. Or
- 21:33Speaker 1: is he an inspiring success who pulled himself out of
- 21:37Speaker 1: poverty to stardom. Those are the competing narratives presented by
- 21:41Speaker 1: the prosecution of the defense as the rapper's trial got
- 21:44Speaker 1: underway this week. Young Thug, whose given name is Jeffrey Williams,
- 21:49Speaker 1: is charged in a sprawling indictment that accuses him in
- 21:52Speaker 1: more than two dozen others of conspiring to violate Georgia's
- 21:56Speaker 1: anti racketeering law. He's also charged with gang, drug and
- 22:00Speaker 1: gun crimes and a standing trial with five of the
- 22:03Speaker 1: others and dotted with him. Joining me is former US
- 22:06Speaker 1: Attorney for the Middle District of Georgia, M Michael Moore
- 22:10Speaker 1: Apartment Moore Hall. Even before the opening statements, there have
- 22:14Speaker 1: been almost ten months of jury selection in courtroom drama.
- 22:18Speaker 1: It started with twenty eight alleged street gang members as defendants.
- 22:22Speaker 1: The trial is down to six. Do all these months
- 22:26Speaker 1: of problems have any impact on the trial?
- 22:30Speaker 6: Well, I think it could, And I mean we started
- 22:32Speaker 6: with an extraordinarily long jury selection, and you know, trying
- 22:37Speaker 6: not only to find people who may not have some
- 22:39Speaker 6: familiarity with the case, but some famility with witnesses and otherwise,
- 22:43Speaker 6: but also folks who may just have the time to
- 22:46Speaker 6: sit for this long in a trial like this, it
- 22:49Speaker 6: can be difficult. And so I think that started the
- 22:51Speaker 6: case off with some problems. And then you've seen other
- 22:54Speaker 6: issues that have come up, with some issues with some
- 22:56Speaker 6: of the lawyers and things that have happened in the
- 22:58Speaker 6: court room and whether or out there have been rents,
- 23:00Speaker 6: and you know, it's been a little bit of a circus,
- 23:03Speaker 6: I think at this point and may continue through the
- 23:06Speaker 6: duration of presentation.
- 23:07Speaker 1: Tell us about the Rico indictment, about the case, what
- 23:11Speaker 1: the prosecution is charging.
- 23:13Speaker 6: RICO really deals with racketeer influenced corrupt organizations, and if
- 23:18Speaker 6: you think about it, maybe in Layman's term, that's really
- 23:21Speaker 6: talking about things like organized crime. And so you saw
- 23:24Speaker 6: some RICO cases that is going after these organizations the
- 23:27Speaker 6: mob basically where they would try to take down the
- 23:30Speaker 6: mob leader by essentially attributing the bad conduct of his
- 23:35Speaker 6: underlings to him. In other words, they didn't have to
- 23:38Speaker 6: find the mafia don pulled the trigger. They could actually
- 23:42Speaker 6: have a murder committed by somebody else, but they could
- 23:44Speaker 6: talk about this was a goal and an effort of
- 23:47Speaker 6: this criminal enterprise to either obtain money or property, and
- 23:51Speaker 6: that's how they went after the organization. Recently, you've seen
- 23:53Speaker 6: RICO cases used not only in drug cases and drug
- 23:57Speaker 6: conspiracy type cases, but also there was one relatively well
- 24:00Speaker 6: known case in Atlanta where a RICO case was used
- 24:03Speaker 6: involving public schools and the cheating scandal that went on
- 24:07Speaker 6: some of those people. I think indications may've got some
- 24:09Speaker 6: of them reversed that some certainly were convicted, And probably
- 24:12Speaker 6: the most famous one right now that we're hearing about
- 24:14Speaker 6: is a Trump campaign. But it's a prosecutor's dream really
- 24:17Speaker 6: because it allows them to basically paint everybody with the
- 24:21Speaker 6: negative brush, and so they can bring in a lot
- 24:25Speaker 6: of evidence. They get to attribute all the bad conduct
- 24:28Speaker 6: of your Code defendment to you if you're a defendant,
- 24:31Speaker 6: and it's more of a I guess the case involving
- 24:34Speaker 6: either directions to do wrong or involvement to do wrong,
- 24:37Speaker 6: or sometimes just knowledge of people who are doing wrong.
- 24:40Speaker 6: All that evidence gets to come in, and at the
- 24:41Speaker 6: end of the day, the prosecution has the jury to
- 24:43Speaker 6: convict you because you were part of this organization. So
- 24:48Speaker 6: it's not an uncontroversial statute. Many people think that it
- 24:52Speaker 6: allows prosecutors too much leeway in bringing cases that they
- 24:56Speaker 6: tend most of the time to be complex and involved
- 24:59Speaker 6: in sometimes unruly. As you're saying, in this case, this sort.
- 25:04Speaker 1: Of sounds like a movie script because Georgia is accusing
- 25:08Speaker 1: this Grammy winning rapper of leading a street gang that's
- 25:11Speaker 1: fronted by his record label, and the crimes include killings,
- 25:17Speaker 1: and shootings and carjackings, right.
- 25:20Speaker 6: And it's easy, remember, to charge people with a crime
- 25:23Speaker 6: and sometimes harder to prove that. And so the state
- 25:27Speaker 6: as they do in every criminal case, but certainly here
- 25:29Speaker 6: they'll have to come forward and put on some evidence
- 25:32Speaker 6: that the main defendant was really in control of what
- 25:37Speaker 6: was going on by other people on the street. I
- 25:39Speaker 6: think that gets harder to do if we are just
- 25:42Speaker 6: have realistic conversations about what actually happens in the real
- 25:46Speaker 6: world in certain neighborhoods and areas of town and that
- 25:49Speaker 6: type of thing, and the prosecutors will have to explain
- 25:52Speaker 6: how that's not just what i'll call street level crime,
- 25:56Speaker 6: but was actually part of this larger umbrella they've charged
- 26:01Speaker 6: as part of this Rico case.
- 26:02Speaker 1: They do. You have some people who pled right who
- 26:06Speaker 1: are going to testify?
- 26:07Speaker 6: They do?
- 26:07Speaker 1: They do?
- 26:07Speaker 6: I mean, And that's another reason that prosecutors like the
- 26:10Speaker 6: Rico case is it allows them to sort of pick
- 26:12Speaker 6: off defendants through plea agreements, and then they begin to
- 26:16Speaker 6: develop evidence in the case. It's always interesting to me
- 26:19Speaker 6: to see how Rico cases can be charged by a
- 26:22Speaker 6: grand jury, but then the prosecutor still needs the evidence
- 26:26Speaker 6: from code defendants. Who later plead to try to pull
- 26:29Speaker 6: the puzzle pieces together to really give a better picture
- 26:33Speaker 6: of what these cases or the organization's charged as part
- 26:37Speaker 6: of these cases, what it looks like.
- 26:38Speaker 1: What really interests me in this case is that the
- 26:41Speaker 1: judge has ruled that prosecutors can use his lyrics as
- 26:45Speaker 1: evidence of his involvement in the crimes. So they can
- 26:48Speaker 1: present seventeen sets of lyrics as evidence, provided they can
- 26:53Speaker 1: link their content to real world crimes. That's been done before.
- 26:57Speaker 1: Is it controversial?
- 26:58Speaker 6: Though it is controversial, and I don't know, frankly how
- 27:01Speaker 6: I feel about it. I think it's probably pushing the
- 27:03Speaker 6: envelope a little bit. And while it's not the first time,
- 27:07Speaker 6: so it's not really pressing a set in there other
- 27:09Speaker 6: cases where this has happened, I do think it'll raises
- 27:11Speaker 6: some pretty unique questions about the First Amendment about you know,
- 27:16Speaker 6: artist creativity and then whether or not later that can
- 27:19Speaker 6: be used in a case. You can think about cases,
- 27:21Speaker 6: you know, woe be it for any country music star
- 27:24Speaker 6: to either be charged with drug driving or get a
- 27:28Speaker 6: divorce because that's going to come up. Does that mean
- 27:30Speaker 6: now that that's going to be effence in their case?
- 27:32Speaker 6: That they talked about, you know, drinking too many drinks
- 27:36Speaker 6: or chasing too many paramoms or whatever the case may be,
- 27:39Speaker 6: or you know, smoking too much weed or you know whatever,
- 27:42Speaker 6: is that now going to be the norm. And I
- 27:44Speaker 6: think those are the kind of lines where this type
- 27:47Speaker 6: of admission of evidence, of this specific type of evidence,
- 27:51Speaker 6: that it gets blurry fright then you know, I was thinking,
- 27:54Speaker 6: is I thought some about the case that if you're
- 27:55Speaker 6: defending a case like this, or you're just representing an
- 27:59Speaker 6: artist of music artists, are you well advised to suggest
- 28:02Speaker 6: to them but just write a couple of songs with
- 28:05Speaker 6: really acceptable lyrics, things like I love the police, I've
- 28:09Speaker 6: never commit a crime, I don't do drugs, and say
- 28:11Speaker 6: well here's evidence. Now, by good care, you don't want
- 28:13Speaker 6: to if anything ever happen. I want you to put
- 28:15Speaker 6: this in. You know, that's something that I'll go into.
- 28:17Speaker 6: I assure you that the people who are prosecuting case
- 28:20Speaker 6: would say no. But somehow here this evident is coming in.
- 28:23Speaker 6: It limiting instructions too to a jury. And that may
- 28:27Speaker 6: be what the judge has in nine when he talks
- 28:28Speaker 6: about you have to link it up in office and
- 28:31Speaker 6: if he may limit the jury or tell them what
- 28:33Speaker 6: you can only consider this and it looks like it
- 28:34Speaker 6: went to an actual crime. That those are often a
- 28:37Speaker 6: little propylactic enough about it, because juries pay great attention
- 28:41Speaker 6: to what prosecutors put into evidence, and a prosecution like
- 28:46Speaker 6: it or not. The reality is that a prosecution team
- 28:48Speaker 6: goes in I think oftentimes with an advantage in a case,
- 28:51Speaker 6: and that is a jury want to believe them. It's
- 28:54Speaker 6: sort of like you want to trust your doctor, you know,
- 28:57Speaker 6: you want to trust the prosecutor, you want to trust preachery.
- 29:00Speaker 6: It's just something that's sort of ingrained in US, I
- 29:03Speaker 6: think to have this trust. Not everybody, but by and large,
- 29:07Speaker 6: I think they look for somebody to explain to them
- 29:10Speaker 6: what the case is about, what the evidence is going
- 29:12Speaker 6: to show, what it has shown at the end of
- 29:14Speaker 6: the case, and they often expect the prosecutor to do that.
- 29:17Speaker 6: And so the fact that the evidence comes in under
- 29:20Speaker 6: the guise of a prosecution presentation I don't think is
- 29:24Speaker 6: cured by some of the limiting efforts that may have
- 29:27Speaker 6: to happen in this case, because we don't know until
- 29:30Speaker 6: they get further along that they're going to be able
- 29:32Speaker 6: to connect the dots to these specific lyrics, you know,
- 29:35Speaker 6: and I think that can pose a problem later.
- 29:37Speaker 1: Some of the references that looked that I've seen are
- 29:40Speaker 1: you know, a little ambiguous, and the defense said that
- 29:43Speaker 1: not only it's a violation of free speech, but that
- 29:46Speaker 1: it would be unfairly prejudicial. So do you think that
- 29:49Speaker 1: will be an appellate issue.
- 29:51Speaker 6: I think there's no question. I mean, there have been
- 29:52Speaker 6: cases where it's been allowed, but I think this will
- 29:55Speaker 6: be right for an appeal, especially when they think about
- 29:57Speaker 6: how broad things have gotten. And I think that's one
- 29:59Speaker 6: of the concern and we're seeing in other cases, I mean, right,
- 30:03Speaker 6: we're seeing it in political cases too, right now, in
- 30:06Speaker 6: those types of things where some of what I would
- 30:09Speaker 6: call the protective norms that we've kind of held sacrisine,
- 30:13Speaker 6: we're willing to bend those a little bit because we
- 30:16Speaker 6: think that the end is going to justify the means
- 30:18Speaker 6: to get there. So, Presidents, here are we getting our
- 30:22Speaker 6: hands a little too tightly around the neck of the
- 30:24Speaker 6: First Amendment and the free speech of people off for
- 30:27Speaker 6: the sake of getting some small piece of evidence in
- 30:30Speaker 6: and the hopes that that might be what pushes the
- 30:32Speaker 6: jury over the edge to a conviction. As opposed to
- 30:35Speaker 6: looking for that evidence through witness testimony, codefindite testimony, physical evidence, videotapes,
- 30:41Speaker 6: whatever it is. We're saying, we're going to sacrifice a
- 30:43Speaker 6: little bit of what we've known traditionally as protection as
- 30:46Speaker 6: the First Amendment in order to get to this other place.
- 30:49Speaker 6: And I do think that's going to raise interesting issues.
- 30:51Speaker 6: And even though the evidence has been used in other cases,
- 30:54Speaker 6: appellate courts are known as time passes, and things change
- 30:58Speaker 6: and the technology evolves and all of that, they're no
- 31:02Speaker 6: for shifting or revisiting some of those issues later on.
- 31:06Speaker 6: And so I think this will be ripe if he
- 31:09Speaker 6: is convicted, or if anyone is convicted in this trial
- 31:12Speaker 6: and the evidence has been used for that, I think
- 31:14Speaker 6: this is the kind of thing that will be ripe
- 31:16Speaker 6: for an appeal.
- 31:18Speaker 1: In the opening statements, the long opening statements of the defense,
- 31:22Speaker 1: the defense attorney told his rags to riches story incidents
- 31:26Speaker 1: where the rapper's twenty year old brother was shot near
- 31:30Speaker 1: their building, and he sort of changed the narrative. He said,
- 31:33Speaker 1: THUG stands for truly humbled under God, and hy s
- 31:38Speaker 1: l the alleged gang doesn't stand for young slime. Life.
- 31:41Speaker 1: It stands for the luxury clothing brand Eves and Lauran.
- 31:45Speaker 1: I mean, he's trying to change the entire narrative of
- 31:50Speaker 1: who this rapper is. Is the jury going to pick
- 31:53Speaker 1: between this version of him and the totally opposite version
- 31:56Speaker 1: that the prosecution's presenting.
- 32:00Speaker 6: You know, And sometimes lawyers have to sort of dance
- 32:04Speaker 6: with what brung them, if you will, and or play
- 32:06Speaker 6: the cars they've been dealt. So this case, the lawyer
- 32:10Speaker 6: may have been looking for some way to make a distinction.
- 32:14Speaker 6: I do think though, that the Ragged the Riches story
- 32:17Speaker 6: is the type of thing that plays in what we
- 32:19Speaker 6: talk about him Indigo, and that is the lyrics. And
- 32:22Speaker 6: is this artist writing about what he saw as his
- 32:25Speaker 6: life experience or an experience of his friends, or something
- 32:28Speaker 6: that he believed might be relatable in his music genre
- 32:33Speaker 6: to his audience. And it's just something there as opposed
- 32:36Speaker 6: to some type of cryptic message about crimes that had
- 32:41Speaker 6: taken place or that he had been a part of.
- 32:43Speaker 6: And so those will be things they, you know, they
- 32:46Speaker 6: have to ferret out, you know. I'm mindful though, as
- 32:49Speaker 6: we think about how a lawyer might you know, change
- 32:54Speaker 6: the narrative. I mean, Remember that we've seen in famous
- 32:58Speaker 6: cases a narrative change. We've gone from a bloody crime
- 33:03Speaker 6: scene photo to scenes of somebody trying to pull on
- 33:07Speaker 6: a leather glove and an argument about it. If it
- 33:09Speaker 6: doesn't fit, you must have quit, you know, And so
- 33:12Speaker 6: the lawyer may try to change that narrative here in
- 33:14Speaker 6: this case to get the jury's attention on. This is
- 33:20Speaker 6: who he was, this is how he's come up, This
- 33:22Speaker 6: is why he writes these lyrics, This is why he
- 33:26Speaker 6: has this circle of friends.
- 33:30Speaker 3: You know.
- 33:30Speaker 6: This is him as a person, but he's now a
- 33:33Speaker 6: place where he's so successful that this idea of sort
- 33:35Speaker 6: of street crime at the level that's a legend of
- 33:38Speaker 6: the indictment is outside of what he does. And that's
- 33:42Speaker 6: why he may be talking about things like, you know,
- 33:45Speaker 6: designer clues as opposed to the gang name and such
- 33:49Speaker 6: as that.
- 33:50Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Michael. That's Michael Moore of Moore Hall.
- 33:53Speaker 1: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Launch Show.
- 33:56Speaker 1: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 33:59Speaker 1: listening to Ourloomberg Law podcasts. You can find them on
- 34:02Speaker 1: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot Bloomberg dot com.
- 34:07Speaker 1: Slash podcasts, Slash Law and attorneys looking for legal research.
- 34:12Speaker 1: Whether you're an in house counsel or in private practice,
- 34:16Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law gives you the edge with the latest in
- 34:19Speaker 1: AI powered legal analytics, business insights, and workflow tools. With
- 34:24Speaker 1: guidance from our experts, you'll grasp the latest trends in
- 34:27Speaker 1: the legal industry, helping you achieve better results for the
- 34:30Speaker 1: practice of law, the business of law, the future of law.
- 34:34Speaker 1: Visit Bloomberg Law dot com. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 34:37Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg