Latest / Interfaiths / Beyond Exclusivity: Rethinking Jewish Continuity in Interfaith Relationships
Transcript
- 0:01All right. Hello. Welcome to the Interfaith Podcast.
- 0:04I'm your host, Iqbal Akhtar. I'm here with Rabbi
- 0:07Ari Sachs, who is the host of the Interfaithing
- 0:13Podcast. Major advocate, of course, of interfaith
- 0:17dialogue, but particularly he has done quite
- 0:20a bit of work on interfaith relationships. And
- 0:22so that's one of the core things we'll be talking
- 0:25about today. But I guess we want to start, Rabbi,
- 0:29with a little bit about who you are and what
- 0:32brought you into interfaith engagement. Absolutely.
- 0:36Well, Iqbal, first off, it's a pleasure to make
- 0:38your acquaintance again. We recorded a previous
- 0:43episode on interfaithing. for with you, as long
- 0:46as with my interfaithing colleague and friend,
- 0:50Reverend Anna Deweese. It was a lot of fun. I
- 0:52learned a lot, especially about Jewish -Muslim
- 0:55or Christian -Muslim relations. And it's a pleasure
- 0:59to come onto your show, and thank you for the
- 1:00invitation. So my story is sort of twofold. One
- 1:04is my upbringing as a Jew in America and my path
- 1:11to becoming a rabbi. I was, I'm the son and grandson
- 1:15and nephew of conservative rabbis. So I affiliate
- 1:20as a conservative, as part of the conservative
- 1:23movement, conservative Judaism, which has a lot
- 1:27of different kinds of definitions. But I'd say
- 1:28two of the main ones are the ideas of tradition
- 1:31and change, the idea that we keep our tradition
- 1:33from one generation to the next, but we also
- 1:35create space for changes from one generation
- 1:38to the next. as well as what's called positive
- 1:40historical Judaism that looks at the past in
- 1:43a positive light or positivist legal light, meaning
- 1:46that we take all the decisions from the past
- 1:48and say that they are just as valid now as they
- 1:52were back then. And so then the change that we
- 1:54do through what's known as the halakhic process
- 1:57or the Jewish legal process must take into account
- 2:00what the past has said on specific issues. So
- 2:03it's not just change for the sake of change.
- 2:05In addition, the notion of scholarship, of being
- 2:09able to really go deep into the meanings of texts
- 2:12and trying to re -understand them, especially
- 2:14in the light of new information. I went to undergraduate
- 2:21at the Jewish Theological Seminary of America,
- 2:23both as an undergraduate and also rabbinical
- 2:26school. And when it was first formed, they considered
- 2:29themselves to be the Jewish Harvard in the sense
- 2:32of a place focused on scholarship, on rigorous
- 2:37academic... study, but to do so of Jewish texts
- 2:41and of biblical texts and all of the different
- 2:44sort of forms that Judaism has taken over the
- 2:46course of history to really understand sort of
- 2:49what is underneath the text, but also how we
- 2:51can be able to view the text in our day. So that's
- 2:54my kind of academic, intellectual, and also philosophical
- 2:59kind of underpinning that has stuck with me and
- 3:02really infused my learning throughout my own
- 3:05life. My grandfather, Rabbi Alexander Shapiro,
- 3:10was the president of the rabbinical assembly
- 3:14for many years, helped to introduce women being
- 3:18accepted as rabbis in the 1980s, which was a
- 3:20big deal. And he was also very involved in interfaith
- 3:23dialogue, one of the first leaders of the Jewish
- 3:27community to really engage deeply with Jewish
- 3:29Catholic dialogue, which was a big deal after
- 3:32the Holocaust, especially in America. And so
- 3:37I've always had an interest in interfaith work.
- 3:40I remember when I was working as a canvasser
- 3:43on the street in Philadelphia for a number of
- 3:47different kind of organizations that loved working
- 3:50in diverse communities and a diverse group of
- 3:52people, sharing Judaism, but also learning about
- 3:55other faith traditions, including Islam and Christianity.
- 3:57So I've always really enjoyed that. But more
- 4:00specifically to the question of my involvement
- 4:03in interfaith work. now and especially with interfaith
- 4:05families the other part of my own story is my
- 4:08connection to israel i self -identify as a zionist
- 4:12and i was i've been into israel many different
- 4:17times over the course of my life and at one point
- 4:19wanted to make aliyah i wanted to move to israel
- 4:22partially to be able to help solve the issue
- 4:25of the israeli palestinian conflict the israeli
- 4:28arab conflict um and I felt like sort of a deep
- 4:33connection there. And then a certain point in
- 4:35my life, I had to sort of figure out what I wanted
- 4:37to do. And one of the choices, again, was to
- 4:40make Aliyah. But due to other factors, I was
- 4:43also considering to stay in America. And because
- 4:46I like doing the Jewish thing, I've gone to synagogue.
- 4:49I like learning all different kinds of Jewish
- 4:54subjects. I probably felt I was going to be a
- 4:56rabbi, especially given my family lineage. But
- 4:58I didn't want to choose it just because. So I
- 5:01had to really think about it. And then I had
- 5:04an experience where I felt that call from God
- 5:06saying, go be a rabbi. And after that, I decided
- 5:10to be a rabbi here in America. And then ironically,
- 5:14as I was figuring out what that call was all
- 5:16about, I went back to Israel for my third year
- 5:18rabbinical school when I was at JTS. And I remember
- 5:22sitting in a yeshiva in a Jewish house of learning
- 5:25in the middle of the Nachlaot neighborhood in
- 5:28Jerusalem, which is a wonderful little neighborhood,
- 5:31a very religious neighborhood in Jerusalem. And
- 5:34I was sitting there studying and our teacher
- 5:35started to hear rainfall. And he made a blessing
- 5:40over the rain falling in Israel because it was
- 5:42the first time that it rained. And that rainfall
- 5:44in Israel is something that's really meaningful
- 5:47and special to the Jewish people, that it's a
- 5:49sign of God's blessing in that place. I recognized
- 5:54at that moment just how special it was to be
- 5:56a Jew in Israel, that it's a very unique experience,
- 5:59especially having lived my whole life in America,
- 6:02in the diaspora. And so I asked myself, I was
- 6:04like, well, if I feel this connection to Israel,
- 6:06why did I decide to stay in America? And I will
- 6:10say that for many, I've had many conversations
- 6:13with American Jews who feel very connected to
- 6:16their Judaism. who've gone through similar kinds
- 6:18of questions where they feel a connection to
- 6:21Israel. They don't necessarily feel that they're
- 6:23as religiously or connected to Judaism as much
- 6:27in America because of a number of issues. And
- 6:30so they kind of debate where they want to be
- 6:32able to end up and where they want to live. And
- 6:34I said, well, what was the reason that God called
- 6:35me to be a rabbi in America? And what I realized
- 6:38at that time, and hopefully we can talk about
- 6:41this in a certain way, is that In Israel, it's
- 6:46a very unique kind of role that the Jews can
- 6:49play, especially having political control of
- 6:53the land. My favorite Zionist thinker, Martin
- 6:58Buber, talked about that in Israel, by being
- 7:01surrounded by the life of the Bible, by being
- 7:03in a place that kind of oozes that sense of Jewish
- 7:06history and connection, that's where a Jew can
- 7:11be the most Jewish they can be. That's where
- 7:13they can really be able to fully express themselves
- 7:15in every way as a Jew. And there's something
- 7:18really special about that. And therefore, outside
- 7:23of Israel is a different job. And what I realized
- 7:26is that in America, especially, that we are living
- 7:31in perhaps the most diverse country. We live
- 7:41in the most diverse country in the history of
- 7:44the world. where people, for all the challenges
- 7:48that we face as a nation here in America, we
- 7:51can live in relative peace and harmony. We can
- 7:53be able to work together. We can be able to express
- 7:56our connections to our faith traditions, to our
- 7:59ethnic traditions in ways that we've never been
- 8:01able to in the past. And that presents an amazing
- 8:07opportunity as a Jew in which... much of our
- 8:10history has been living in the diaspora, living
- 8:13outside of Israel and trying to make it work
- 8:15among all the nations of the world, to be able
- 8:17to demonstrate that we can find a way to live
- 8:21together. We don't have to always be at odds
- 8:24with each other. We can find a way to build bridges,
- 8:27to make peace, to live together in the great
- 8:30diversity that is this world. So that's what
- 8:35I felt was my call. And then thinking about,
- 8:39well, where does that actually work or where
- 8:41is that most necessary? And this, I was thinking
- 8:44a little more practically speaking, because most
- 8:47of my interfaith engagement was sitting around
- 8:49a table with other academics or other religious
- 8:52leaders talking about different issues, talking
- 8:55about different ideas or kind of peace building
- 8:57in sort of a global sense. I was like, where
- 9:00does it really need to see, like, how is it possible
- 9:02for faith traditions to make it work? And that's
- 9:05when I came to the notion that. It's with couples
- 9:09who come from different traditions trying to
- 9:11make life work in their own family life and trying
- 9:15to see how they can be able to make peace among
- 9:18the different faith traditions. And so interfaith
- 9:21couples, especially those who want to engage
- 9:23with their faith traditions, who don't want to
- 9:26leave their histories behind, proved to be the
- 9:29place that I felt the greatest call to. And that
- 9:32was in, I'd say, 2010, 2011. And ever since then,
- 9:37I've been very involved with working with interfaith
- 9:41families, including working at an interfaith
- 9:44community in New York where I met Reverend Anna
- 9:47DeWeese, who is my interfaith and colleague.
- 9:49We were co -teachers in a school which talked
- 9:52about Judaism and Christianity together, to thinking
- 9:57through the Halakhic Foundation for Permitting
- 10:00Intermarriage, which, again, comes from my conservative
- 10:04Jewish upbringing to figure out. what is the
- 10:06Jewish legal basis for allowing this to happen,
- 10:08to working with couples and now working with
- 10:13them on ceremonies for their marriages, baby
- 10:15namings, working together with other officiants,
- 10:19with other family members to kind of craft ceremonies
- 10:22that work with them, and then to also build community
- 10:24among interfaith families to feel like they're
- 10:27not alone in that regard. And I will tell you
- 10:31that ever since starting this work, every single
- 10:34step along my journey, has reinforced my belief
- 10:37that helping interfaith couples find how to make
- 10:42it work is the key to being able to demonstrate
- 10:45how our faith traditions can be able to live
- 10:48harmoniously in this world. That's extremely
- 10:54powerful. And I completely second that. I think
- 10:57that that's absolutely, the lived reality is
- 10:59very, very important. And especially... I think
- 11:03in both of our faith traditions, there's nothing
- 11:05more important than the family. And so that's
- 11:07the building block of society. And if you're
- 11:10able to create strong relationships around faith,
- 11:14I think that's an amazing thing. And for those
- 11:18of our listeners who are not aware of the Jewish
- 11:22position on interfaith marriage, can you talk
- 11:25to us a little bit about what are the different
- 11:28groups within Judaism here in the United States?
- 11:31And how do they see the issue of interfaith marriage?
- 11:34Sure. Thank you for the question there. Okay.
- 11:37So I think that in order to really answer that
- 11:41question, I need to back up and to start with
- 11:42the Bible. Because if you look at biblical texts,
- 11:46and many folks will actually point to it today,
- 11:48there's an incredible amount of what we might
- 11:51call anachronistically interfaith marriage. You
- 11:54have Joseph, who is the... One of the sons of
- 12:01Jacob married Asenat, who is the daughter of
- 12:05an Egyptian priest. You have Moses, who leads
- 12:10the Jewish people outside of Israel, out of Egypt,
- 12:13who marries Zipporah, who is a Midianite. And
- 12:17so we have intermarriages sprinkled throughout
- 12:23the biblical text. And especially with those
- 12:27two examples. they're not viewed in a negative
- 12:30light. They're viewed either in a positive light
- 12:33or just stomp, like the Hebrew word for just
- 12:37like it is. So it doesn't necessarily seem to
- 12:39be as much of an issue. That being said, when
- 12:42you get to the rabbinic period, which really
- 12:44starts around the time of the death of Jesus,
- 12:47but even a little beforehand, and they're looking
- 12:49at those texts, they argue that what we think
- 12:53of as intermarriage is actually not. That in
- 12:55fact, Tzipora or Asenat, that they were either
- 13:00converted or that they left their previous Jewish,
- 13:04their previous life and faith in order to be
- 13:09able to marry Joseph and Moses respectively.
- 13:13So that is to say that what the Bible says in
- 13:18terms of the example of intermarriage is always
- 13:21interpreted by those in a certain generation.
- 13:25of what it actually means. And so you have a
- 13:27case here where what seems like intermarriage
- 13:29is actually not. Now one of the reasons for that
- 13:32is actually also comes from the Bible, and this
- 13:34is where the texts become much more significant
- 13:38in thinking about Jewish perspectives on intermarriage.
- 13:42According to Deuteronomy chapter 7, especially
- 13:46the beginning of chapter 7, you have two particular
- 13:50commands. One command is that you should not
- 13:53give You should not give quarter to nations who
- 13:59live in your territory. And they're talking particularly
- 14:02when the Israelites were going to be entering
- 14:04into the land of Israel, which at that time was
- 14:07called the land of Canaan, also known as the
- 14:09land of Palestine today. And that we should,
- 14:13and the reason for that is to be concerned about
- 14:15their negative influence on our faith, on our
- 14:18connection to God, that they would take us away.
- 14:20And then it says specifically after that particular
- 14:23command, that you shall not intermarry with them.
- 14:27And it listed specific nations with whom the
- 14:30Israelites were not supposed to intermarry. There's
- 14:32one other selection in Deuteronomy chapter 23
- 14:36that has a similar idea that there are certain
- 14:39nations, a little bit different than the one
- 14:41in Deuteronomy 7, with whom are not allowed to
- 14:45enter the community. It doesn't say specifically
- 14:47to intermarry, but it's often interpreted meaning
- 14:49to intermarry. And there's even a verse in Leviticus
- 14:51chapter 18, which speaks of a lot of sexual morality.
- 14:57And there's one particular command there that
- 15:00says that you shall not give over your child
- 15:03to Molech, who's considered to be a god of an
- 15:06immoral nation. And that was interpreted rabbinically
- 15:10to say that what does it mean to not give children
- 15:13over to Molech? It is not to intermarry with.
- 15:17a follower of Molech because they'll take your
- 15:19children away from you. And in particular, the
- 15:22reason why is because these nations are immoral.
- 15:26So one of the main things to think about in regards
- 15:29to the notion of intermarriage is that while
- 15:32we have, as I showed before, evidence of biblical
- 15:37intermarriage, and I would say that once Jews
- 15:40left or Israelites left the land of Israel, for
- 15:44instance, We're exiled to Babylonia. We actually
- 15:47have some evidence of Jews in Babylonia who intermarried.
- 15:51Pretty much everywhere in Jewish history, there
- 15:53is evidence of Jewish intermarriage. However,
- 15:56there has never been Jewish acceptance of intermarriage,
- 15:59especially from the rabbinic perspective. And
- 16:03much of that has to do with a sense that other
- 16:06nations are immoral, that they do not have the
- 16:09same values as we do. They take us away from.
- 16:13not following God, and that their traditions,
- 16:17their rituals are considered to be idolatrous.
- 16:21So it's morality, it's values, it's belief, and
- 16:26it's also traditions, idolatrous traditions.
- 16:30And that I would say has been the primary rabbinic
- 16:33perspective up until the modern era. Once you
- 16:38get to the modern era, and we're talking here
- 16:41about the late 18th, to early 19th century, there
- 16:45was a major shift. And that major shift, intellectually
- 16:49speaking, philosophically, as well as spiritually,
- 16:53was the notion that every person is created equally
- 16:58by God. And by virtue of the fact that we are
- 17:00all equal, it allowed for the possibility that
- 17:04peoples did not have to belong to specific nations.
- 17:08That is, Jews were always considered to be their
- 17:12own nation, no matter if they lived in France
- 17:14or Spain or Germany or wherever it might be.
- 17:18And they can never become equal with the other
- 17:20residents of the land. However, once it became
- 17:23clear that Jews could theoretically become citizens
- 17:27of, let's say, France or Germany, that, okay,
- 17:31you can become a full citizen. But doesn't that
- 17:35mean that now that you are part of this nation
- 17:37of a diverse group, that part of being in that
- 17:43nation is that you could marry somebody from
- 17:46that nation. And in fact, that was a question
- 17:48that Napoleon Bonaparte asked of a Jewish sect
- 17:52of nobles known as the Parisian Sanhedrin in
- 17:58the early part in the 19th century, where the
- 18:02question was, can a Jew or a Jewish marry a French
- 18:07citizen who is not Jewish? And the answer given
- 18:10by them, given by the rabbis at that time, or
- 18:12given by the Jewish community who was being asked
- 18:14at that time was fascinating. Because on one
- 18:16hand, they answered, well, if we take a look
- 18:20at the biblical perspective, putting aside for
- 18:22a second the examples of intermarriage, but that
- 18:24the laws of with whom you are not allowed to
- 18:28marry, those nations no longer exist. Those nations
- 18:32no longer exist. We're not talking about Amorites.
- 18:34We're not talking about Canaanites or Perizzites,
- 18:36all the nations mentioned in the Bible specifically.
- 18:38Because those nations don't exist, there is no
- 18:42element of intermarriage that is forbidden by
- 18:48Judaism. And because of that, we are now allowed
- 18:53to marry other nations. However, Judaism has
- 18:57never had a methodology for... being able to
- 19:02marry people from other religions. There's no
- 19:05ritual assigned with it. What I know from part
- 19:08of my work with interfaith couples is that there
- 19:11is a Muslim way for intermarriage to occur in
- 19:15a particular manner. There's a way for intermarriage
- 19:18to occur in the Roman Catholic Church, within
- 19:21Protestantism. So there are methods in which
- 19:25Intermarriage can occur by other nations, but
- 19:28there's no Jewish way to do it. There's no Jewish
- 19:30formula specifically set aside for intermarriage
- 19:33because it has been fought over. It has been
- 19:37one that has been, it's a prohibition. The prohibition
- 19:45against intermarriage has a very long history
- 19:47in Judaism, and there's never been a time in
- 19:49which it's been permitted. That group of the
- 19:52Parisian Sanhedrin, they were not able. It's
- 19:55not possible to look at them from a Jewish legal
- 19:58perspective and say we can base decisions now
- 20:01of intermarriage on them. That's part of my positive
- 20:04historical critique, that it gives us an understanding
- 20:07of what the Jewish community was like, but because
- 20:09the formation of that group was not just of rabbis
- 20:13and they were forced to by virtue of Napoleon
- 20:16asking them that question, which he kind of wanted
- 20:19a certain answer, probably, that you can't rely
- 20:22upon them to make. halakhic ruling for the future.
- 20:26However, the point being made in that text in
- 20:31the, with the Parisian Sanhedrin's answer, led
- 20:33in many ways to a movement that followed both
- 20:38in Germany, but then more specifically in America,
- 20:40in which looking at the biblical text, there
- 20:44was a sense that that prohibition no longer applies.
- 20:47And in the reform movement, The Reform Movement's
- 20:51vision was to reform Judaism to correspond to
- 20:54the values of the enlightenment of equality among
- 20:59all people. In the 1970s, they came out and said
- 21:02that intermarriage is allowed. And then in the
- 21:04early 1980s, another piece to this story is that
- 21:08they also recognized Jews of patrilineal descent
- 21:13as being full Jews. Because up until this time,
- 21:18Only Jews of matrilineal descent, people whose
- 21:20mothers are Jewish, would be considered to be
- 21:22Jewish. And by adding patrilineal descent, it
- 21:26allowed for all different kinds of intermarriage
- 21:28in which the child of that intermarriage would
- 21:31absolutely be a Jew. So that started in the 1970s
- 21:34and the early 1980s. The conservative movement
- 21:37at that time in the early 1980s did not. want
- 21:43to go down that road. And in fact, though there
- 21:45were some who wanted to consider the question,
- 21:49both the patrilineal descent and perhaps of intermarriage,
- 21:52it was very much put down. It was stopped almost
- 21:59in its tracks. And I would say that from the
- 22:02middle of 1980s and early 1990s up until really
- 22:06the past few years, that the official stance
- 22:09of conservative Judaism is that intermarriage
- 22:15is not allowed. It should not be supported or
- 22:19it should not be promoted. There definitely is
- 22:23no way to do a Jewish interfaith marriage and
- 22:27that the children of a Jewish father is not considered
- 22:32to be Jewish. So keeping that matrilineal descent
- 22:34piece. When it comes to orthodoxy, they have
- 22:38not engaged in this issue, I'd say as much. Part
- 22:43of the question of intermarriage is also just
- 22:44about the people with whom you affiliate and
- 22:46with whom you are interacting with. So I can't
- 22:50speak really authentically about the Orthodox
- 22:52experience, but I do believe that the Orthodox
- 22:56experience with intermarriage in some manner
- 22:59has to do more so about their engagement with
- 23:02folks from the outside world. How much is that
- 23:05engagement kept at arm's length versus intimate
- 23:08and really partnering together with people who
- 23:11are not Jewish? And I think that the more that
- 23:14Jews interact with people of different nations,
- 23:16of people of different backgrounds, the more
- 23:18that this becomes something that will affect
- 23:22all Jews. I mean, yeah, I know. I mean, there's
- 23:27a lot of interesting threads I want to, I mean,
- 23:31of course, you know, as an academic, I'm interested
- 23:33in kind of the history. I mean, the Persian Sanhedrin,
- 23:39I think was interesting. I was just, I mean,
- 23:41this is like a total random question. Do you
- 23:44know anything about the Jewish community, the
- 23:49Elephantine community in ancient Egypt? I mean,
- 23:53what was there? Right. Yeah. So I think that
- 23:58the thing that we have to keep in mind here is
- 24:00that, again, there's always been intermarriage
- 24:04in some sort. We have it in the Bible, right?
- 24:05Yeah, exactly. And in fact, we also have, by
- 24:07the way, at the same time that we have those
- 24:08marriages of intermarriage in the Bible, we also
- 24:10have two very strong critiques against it. One
- 24:13is that it is Rebecca who says to Isaac that
- 24:20I want our son Jacob to be able to marry somebody
- 24:25from our clan, not to go out into finding somebody
- 24:29of a different clan like their older son Esau.
- 24:32So there's a sense of wanting to keep it in the
- 24:34family. You have the story of Dina, who is, let's
- 24:41just say. taken by a non -Israelite individual
- 24:49by the name of Shchem. And while ostensibly there
- 24:53is acceptance of their marriage, the brothers
- 24:57of Dina turn it into an opportunity to wipe out
- 25:00Shchem. And they say, how dare we let one of
- 25:03our clan become engaged, become... be taken advantage
- 25:10of, and the language there is very strong, by
- 25:14this other nation. So there's also that critique
- 25:17about it. And what it also means is that from
- 25:20a perspective of tribal behavior, of living within
- 25:23the tribe, that you can only be within the tribe
- 25:27if you are able to marry or to be together or
- 25:31to live with others from that same tribe or who
- 25:34ally with that same tribe. So when you talk about
- 25:38the Jews of Elephantine, one of the, or Elephantine,
- 25:40I don't know exactly how to pronounce it. In
- 25:44that ancient world, the Jews were still their
- 25:47own nation. The difference between interfaith
- 25:51marriage now versus back then, and why I would
- 25:54say that the issue is a little bit more anachronistic,
- 25:56both in the sense of the Bible, but even early
- 25:58times, is that there was no sense that a Jew
- 26:00could be an Egyptian too. There was no sense
- 26:03that a Jew could be able to live. among the rest
- 26:06of the nation, and that their concerns were much
- 26:08more about how do we still, how do we continue
- 26:13to survive within the world in which we live?
- 26:17There's some evidence, especially in the Babylonian,
- 26:20from some Babylonian texts of intermarriage,
- 26:23in which the goal was to help a family raise
- 26:26its class, so that they would marry somebody
- 26:30of a higher class in order to be able to raise
- 26:33themselves up in that society. but they'd still
- 26:35probably consider themselves fully as Jews and
- 26:38not as perhaps intermarried or part of that other
- 26:41world. It's more of being able to raise their
- 26:44own sort of level. So I don't think that we can
- 26:48necessarily learn the value or the opportunities
- 26:55of intermarriage inherently from ancient times,
- 26:58more so because the ways in which, especially
- 27:02for the Jews, that... they were politically and
- 27:06socially organized was never as equal citizens
- 27:10to others, or that all of the different members
- 27:14of a local society were kind of subgrouped into
- 27:17these unequal groups that certain ones had more
- 27:22prior, had more rights than the other. Interestingly,
- 27:25along these lines, the rules around matrilineal
- 27:29descent It's a fascinating issue. We don't have
- 27:33the time to do it right now. But it seems clear
- 27:37that there was a change from the biblical times
- 27:40in which there's much more patrilineal. You're
- 27:43talking about the Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
- 27:48They pass it down to their fathers. It's not
- 27:50as much about the mothers. There was a change
- 27:53from biblical times to rabbinic times. One of
- 28:00the ways in which it seems like that change was
- 28:02made was through the prism of Roman law that
- 28:05was passed around the time that the rabbinic
- 28:08period was really starting up, in which Roman
- 28:11soldiers would have children with non -Roman
- 28:17wives, and the Roman government did not want
- 28:22those children of Roman soldiers and non -Roman
- 28:25wives to be considered Romans. And therefore,
- 28:29children would follow the, quote, parentage of
- 28:34lesser descent. The parentage of lesser descent.
- 28:38And that's actually the language that is used
- 28:41in the Mishnah, in one of the earliest texts
- 28:45from the rabbinic period, in which... It says
- 28:50of a marriage between a Jewish man and a non
- 28:54-Jewish woman that the child follows the one
- 28:56of lesser status. So it's also a question of
- 29:01who do children belong to? Because there was
- 29:05no way for it to work together. It was always
- 29:07separate. You had to kind of try to choose one
- 29:09or the other. And because of patriarchal societies,
- 29:13that would lead to it being much more the man
- 29:15or in. or in a case like this, where they would
- 29:20not want it to follow the man, it would, say,
- 29:22follow the woman. Yeah, no, I mean, so I think,
- 29:28I mean, and so you're, I mean, part of it, I
- 29:32think, of course, the difference also from the
- 29:36ancient times also is that the, I'm assuming
- 29:38that many of the communities that the Jews were
- 29:41not supposed to marry into were not, were probably
- 29:43not monotheistic also, right? So, I mean, there's
- 29:48a... That would be part of the issue is kind
- 29:51of the belief in God, but also the it's interesting.
- 29:54I think this is the larger challenge, I think,
- 29:56that we have also in thinking about Jews and
- 30:01Judaism kind of in the American context. Is it
- 30:05a tribal identity? Is it an ethnic group? Is
- 30:08it a religion? It seems to be, you know, many
- 30:10different things all at the same time. you know,
- 30:13within kind of this, whatever, you know, English
- 30:15law classifications that we have. What about,
- 30:23and so you're part of why you argue that it is
- 30:26acceptable, not just sort of on the historical
- 30:29perspective, but I'm assuming part of the way
- 30:33that you also see that it's okay is that people
- 30:36are able to keep the way that you're interpreting
- 30:39and the way that you're trying to do it is that
- 30:41Jewish interfaith marriage. people can still
- 30:45keep their Judaism. And ideally, also, the children
- 30:49can have Judaism as well, right? So that it's
- 30:52not kind of the end of the tradition. The difference,
- 30:55though, I would say, right, so I, actually, I'll
- 30:59back up for a second. I've actually had a little
- 31:02bit of shift in my own thinking over the course
- 31:05of this work, and particularly over the past
- 31:10three years or so. The very first episode of
- 31:14our podcast, we were talking about what our different
- 31:17perspectives were. And Anna asked me a question
- 31:21about whether or not I saw the work of interfaithing,
- 31:25of embracing multiple faith traditions as part
- 31:29of the job of Jewish continuity. And I answered,
- 31:33it was more nuanced than this, but the short
- 31:36answer was I said no, that it wasn't about Jewish
- 31:38continuity. It was a different idea of... How
- 31:42understanding that we are all shaped by one creator,
- 31:46that we're all equal, leads us inexorably to
- 31:50the point that not one tradition has priority
- 31:53over another. And that the idea to bring both
- 31:57together is to really embrace that idea of God,
- 32:00that one God. And that doesn't necessarily mean
- 32:04that Jews are going to be, or interfaith couples
- 32:06are going to be raising future Jews. I've kind
- 32:10of changed. my thinking on this, not because
- 32:15I inherently had a change of heart, so to speak,
- 32:18but what I realized is that I had internalized
- 32:22the sense of what Jewish continuity means within
- 32:26the Jewish world. And that is Jewish exclusivity.
- 32:32Jewish exclusivity. That if you want to have
- 32:36continuity from one generation to the next, then
- 32:39the only religion the only tradition that a person
- 32:44can be exposed to is Judaism. Any exposure to
- 32:48another fake tradition in the home would potentially
- 32:53lead them astray. And even when it came to intermarriage,
- 32:58from what I saw from my vantage point getting
- 33:01into this work, is that many what we might call
- 33:06Jewish intermarriages or Jewish interfaith marriages
- 33:09were really Jewish marriages with people who
- 33:13did not have much faith. So that the ideal non
- 33:19-Jew for a Jewish person to intermarry with is
- 33:23somebody who did not have much of a religious
- 33:25upbringing, did not have any connection to any
- 33:28particular faith tradition really, and was willing
- 33:31to embrace Judaism in the home regardless of
- 33:36their you know, not because of anything from
- 33:43their perspective, but that they're willing to
- 33:45go along with the Jewish angle. And I felt that
- 33:48that was counterintuitive to really what the
- 33:51biblical prohibition was all about, because,
- 33:54and this is something I think is important from
- 33:57my perspective as a conservative Jew and a conservative
- 34:00rabbi, that even though the ancient world is
- 34:04different than our world today, that from a positive
- 34:08historical standpoint, in which the decisions
- 34:12made in the past are still relevant for us today,
- 34:15still have to take those ideas very seriously,
- 34:18and that there's still wisdom that's applicable
- 34:21today. And the wisdom that I believe is applicable
- 34:23today is that there are people and there are
- 34:27nations with whom you might intermarry who would
- 34:31take you away from your connection to Judaism.
- 34:36The only way I believe And this comes back to
- 34:39my point of embracing multiple faith traditions.
- 34:42The only way I believe to ensure that another
- 34:46faith tradition or another person's traditions
- 34:49are not going to be a negative influence is by
- 34:53actually embracing as opposed to pushing away.
- 34:56And the reason for that is because pushing away,
- 34:59even if it is having to do with, let's say, certain
- 35:03traditions, like we're not going to have a Christmas
- 35:05tree because we're a Jewish household. and somebody
- 35:08not necessarily that religious, we're like, okay,
- 35:10fine. I guess we'll do a Christmas tree. I guess
- 35:12we wanted a Christmas tree. It can build resentment.
- 35:15And resentment leads to less engagement. Perhaps
- 35:20the most difficult issue when it comes to intermarriage
- 35:24that I believe is something that needs to be
- 35:27worked on, because I've seen examples where this
- 35:31is the case, and I've seen examples where it's
- 35:32not the case, is that a person who intermarries
- 35:37recognizes that their intermarriage is partially
- 35:40because they're not really that engaged with
- 35:42their faith tradition. They might do a few things,
- 35:45but they're really not going to engage that deeply.
- 35:47I even had one person who came up to me when
- 35:49I said, I want to talk more about, you know,
- 35:51you and your partner embracing your faith traditions
- 35:54or coming to synagogue. And the Jewish partner
- 35:58said, you know, Rabbi, I'm not really involved.
- 36:02I don't really do that much Jewish because you
- 36:04see who I married, right? It's almost as if looking
- 36:07at the person with whom a person you married
- 36:11is a sign of your lack of engagement. And one
- 36:15of the reasons why that lack of engagement occurs,
- 36:17I think, is because there's also fear on both
- 36:20sides of engaging a lot. And it makes it feel
- 36:24as if, well, are you trying to convert me? Are
- 36:26you trying to make us more like you than of me?
- 36:30And so the, and that's where the fear of. the
- 36:35negative influence of the other comes in. Because
- 36:37if you're worried about doing Jewish things,
- 36:40because you're worried how your partner is going
- 36:41to feel about it, that's something that we have
- 36:44to be aware of. And that's something to be concerned
- 36:46about. And the best way to show that it's not
- 36:50going to be a concern is by saying, you know
- 36:51what? I want to go all in. I want to embrace
- 36:54yours. And I want you to embrace mine. Doesn't
- 36:57mean that we are changing our affiliation. Like
- 36:59you are still identify as a Muslim, as a Christian,
- 37:01identify as Jewish, but. Um, I, I think that
- 37:06that's, I want our, I want myself to learn more.
- 37:10I want to see like how this works, especially
- 37:12if we have kids, I want them to be able to know
- 37:15both sides of the family and to do so with a
- 37:18sense of desire and not a fear. Because if we
- 37:21push people away, we create that fear and it's
- 37:24fear that leads to disengagement and it's fear
- 37:27that leads to that resentment that makes it difficult
- 37:31and impossible. I think. for people to really
- 37:34engage deeply with their tradition. And it's
- 37:37actually that piece, the sense that if you intermarry,
- 37:41you are going to not embrace your own Jewish
- 37:44faith, that I think is the reason why we need
- 37:48to embrace both. I think it's good. And I think
- 37:53the other thing, I think that there's also, which
- 37:56people don't realize that there's so much, like
- 38:02people think that they're not religious, but
- 38:04they think of religion in a very limited way.
- 38:07And I think that there are aspects of our lives
- 38:13that are shaped by, in very subtle ways, not
- 38:17just by religion, but the culture that we have,
- 38:19right? The language that we use, there are so
- 38:21many things that are being transmitted, especially
- 38:24as you're raising children that you don't even
- 38:25realize. And so, yeah, so I think that there
- 38:28is like the, so now you've come to this idea
- 38:31that it's important to have that sort of continuity
- 38:33as well, Jewish continuity. Because the Jewish
- 38:37continuity piece is to say, are you going to
- 38:40be able to educate your children of the significance
- 38:45and importance of Judaism in the next generation?
- 38:48And the more that we embrace and the more that
- 38:52we engage with each other, the more that it leads
- 38:56to Jewish continuity. The question of what that
- 38:59looks like, does that person self -identify as
- 39:01a Jew or as both or as? something else, that's
- 39:08less of my concern in terms of continuity and
- 39:10more so that they feel a Jewish connection as
- 39:15part of their upbringing. And that's something
- 39:17that's significant to them. Yeah, that makes
- 39:20sense. Okay. Yeah, I know. It's super fascinating.
- 39:26All right. I'm so sorry. I have to go. I have
- 39:27to teach a class in a few minutes, but let's
- 39:31continue the conversation then. Why don't you
- 39:33do this? You send me a time that works for you.
- 39:35Like just send me a calendar invite and then
- 39:37we can continue. Be happy to have another hour.
- 39:39Yeah, sure. Is this the only time of day that
- 39:42works for you? No, no, no. Any just figure out
- 39:45a time and just send it to me. Yeah, you got
- 39:47it. All right. Sounds good. Thanks a lot, Rabbi.
- 39:49And I have some notes. There's some things that
- 39:52I also want to double -click on, especially on
- 39:55the historical part. But I think also the relevance
- 39:58is really cool. And then, of course, getting
- 40:00into the Jewish -Muslim would be interesting,
- 40:02because especially with the politics of what's
- 40:04going on right now, it's been very, very difficult.
- 40:07So I'd love to talk about that. Thank you so
- 40:09much, Rabbi. I appreciate it. No problem. Take
- 40:10care. All right. Take care. Bye. All right. Come
- 40:15on, baby.