Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #59 🎙️ | Public Inquiry -Emergency Timetabling Week Beginning 12th May 2026 | Day 3
Transcript
- 0:05The day began with Beatty, counsel for the applicant,
- 0:08advising the court that his expert witness would be
- 0:11unavailable for the dates 26th to the 28th of May He further
- 0:16explained that the witness may remain unavailable for some
- 0:19time, as one of the experts parents is currently receiving
- 0:23hospice care.
- 0:25Connor Fagan, counsel for fodc, said his witness was also
- 0:29unavailable for the same period.
- 0:32He went on to point out that we are where we are as we are
- 0:36trying to fix a timetable for days which are scheduled for
- 0:41just over a week's time, and that was not possible with so
- 0:44many competing concerns in the room, that was simply not going
- 0:48to work out.
- 0:50Speaking for save our spurns third party, Mary brolly was
- 0:54proudly able to announce that our expert witnesses were
- 0:56available. Unfortunately, it's beginning to look like there may
- 1:00not be many others in the room to inquire with on the 26th to
- 1:05the 28th of may.
- 1:07I don't know if I mentioned in an earlier podcast that third
- 1:10party Pat haughty had created a spreadsheet of his own economic
- 1:14model and had asked the commission to accept it as
- 1:17supplementary evidence. The Commission turned that down.
- 1:35From here, we moved on to the development plan questions, and
- 1:39for some reasons, we revisited the exact same questions as last
- 1:43year. I do not understand why we're going over and rehashing
- 1:48all of this, which was more than adequately covered and agreed on
- 1:52in 2025
- 1:54and particularly as we are so far behind on our timetable when
- 1:59the DFI were asked by the Commission to the department,
- 2:03have any thoughts about the waste mine 01 designation, and
- 2:09if it is applicable to the mine waste tailing facility,
- 2:14to us the great unwashed, this waste policy sets out the
- 2:18requirements for developers to consider potential environmental
- 2:21impacts of a waste management facility.
- 2:26The department Council Elvin came quickly back with the
- 2:29somewhat startling assertion that it wasn't applicable.
- 2:33The commissioner seemed quite surprised at the answer and
- 2:36repeated the question again,
- 2:39a convoluted and extended conversation then followed about
- 2:43the interpretation of policy, in which it transpired that the
- 2:46applicant's barrister, Mr. Beatty, seemed to be trying to
- 2:49use an avenue to circumvent the local development plan.
- 2:54This hinged all in one word, that the waste mine facility was
- 2:58an ancillary operation to the mine, this one word ancillary
- 3:03was being used to obfuscate, create uncertainty and ensure
- 3:06that the designation was obstructed.
- 3:10So while the Department led by Mr. Elvin was outright rejecting
- 3:14the suggestion that the so called dry stack facility was in
- 3:18fine, was in fact a mine waste tailings facility. This is
- 3:23precisely what the department was enabling del radian to
- 3:26develop through its ancillary works application, but without
- 3:30any of the environmental safeguards that would come with
- 3:33a waste management designation.
- 3:37And just for academic interest, dalradians proposed mine waste
- 3:41tailing facility would permanently store millions of
- 3:45cubic metres of mining waste, including tailings waste, rock
- 3:49and ore rejects. This waste would contain water along with
- 3:53toxic chemicals, heavy metals, creating long term environment,
- 3:58environmental risks for rivers, ecosystems and surrounding
- 4:02communities for generations to come.
- 4:06Mr. Fagan came back in at this point to the discussion with the
- 4:09remark about the department's unequivocal and very firm
- 4:12decision about the mine waste designation without having heard
- 4:18all the depositions. Emmett McAleer said the department's
- 4:22mask of neutrality is beginning to slip. All week, they have sat
- 4:27there and deferred answers to other questions, saying it will
- 4:31be up to the PAC to decide, or that that or that they would
- 4:36have to take instruction on this issue and so on, to quote
- 4:40Emmett, and
- 4:42when the topic of mine waste comes along and the possible
- 4:45designation of
- 4:47Wm 01 you suddenly have a very strong opinion about it.
- 4:53Mary Brawley quickly followed up, saying, This response does
- 4:56not smack of neutrality, but could be attributed.