Latest / ThisWeekInGeek / Botched Roll - Conflict Resolution And You
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, it's time for another special feature. Hey guys, what's going on?
- 0:16You are listening to boxed roll only on this weekend geek dot Net.
- 0:22I'm your host, Mike the Birdman, your dungeon master, your storyteller,
- 0:26you're idiot who probably will fire it in the combat. That's right, guys,
- 0:31So we are back here on the show. I've been recording a couple
- 0:33of these over the past couple of days, and this is actually take number
- 0:37like four on this particular topic, only because I wanted to protect the identities
- 0:43of people, but I've also had a chance to reflect upon it and get
- 0:46some feedback from some people who heard the early drafts of those previous episodes.
- 0:52But before we start today, I just want to mention I'm going to be
- 0:55launching my new dungeon Master for hire service in just a couple of weeks as
- 1:00of this recording. On June twenty second, or whenever, Free RPG Day
- 1:03is, so to be sure to be checking out your local game stores and
- 1:07get some really cool shit from people like Wizards, Piezo, Renegade Games Studios,
- 1:15Free League Publishing Like seriously, go to freearpgday dot com. I'll make
- 1:19sure Alex puts an episode or I'll put some link in the episode description,
- 1:25and yeah, we can do that. And like I said, I'm looking
- 1:29forward to hanging out with you and just playing some fantastic games like I did
- 1:34on Terrible Warriors. So if you've ever wanted to have the Power Rangers fight
- 1:38Megatron, or if you want to explore the depths of the Enterprise NX,
- 1:44and maybe there's a xeno morph on board, who knows, maybe we can
- 1:48do that while flying the flag of House Kreta against the clans. So let
- 1:55us talk about this evening's topic. And I don't know how long this one's
- 1:59gonna go simply because like I said, I'm not going to describe the situation
- 2:02that prompted this, and I'm gonna talk a lot in vagities, but it's
- 2:07gonna come down to this is conflict resolution. And I'm basing this upon a
- 2:15couple of different things. So in my professional life, I am an activist,
- 2:21I'm an advocate, and I deal a lot with conflict resolution in very
- 2:27tense and hot circumstances, be it from an indigenous point of view, a
- 2:31disability point of view, or just plain yelling with people who are jerks.
- 2:38So recently, I had a situation happen in one aspect of my personal life
- 2:46where it involved some people not getting along. And that's all I'm really gonna
- 2:51say about that. And it got me thinking about how do you resolve problem
- 2:58conflict when it comes to dealing with toxic players and toxic game masters because both
- 3:04do exist. You can be a fantastic player but be in a really toxic
- 3:08game, and you can be a really fantastic DM and have toxic players that
- 3:13are affecting your enjoyment of wanting to prepare this adventure for them because it might
- 3:20be mentally draining. And it basically comes down to how do you deal with
- 3:25this? Right? Because I'm going to presume most of you that are listening
- 3:31out there are adults or you know, reasonably well behaved, I'll say,
- 3:37and a lot of this just comes down to communication. And I know that
- 3:43is the dumbest and most broad answer I could possibly give you, but stay
- 3:47with me. So if you I'm gonna address this as a player first and
- 3:54then as a DM. So as a player, let's say you're in a
- 3:59situation in a game and you're not having a good time, be it with
- 4:03someone else, at the table, maybe it's your DM, whatever the situation
- 4:10might be. I think the most important thing is to acknowledge your feelings,
- 4:15like, Okay, I don't like this, this sucks. What can I
- 4:19do? But the most important thing I think is to not lash out emotionally,
- 4:27like you can't literally go to war on said person or persons, because
- 4:32then everybody's feelings get hurt, and then nothing gets resolved, and you've literally
- 4:38accomplished nothing by you know, giving into your Goku super sayan rage. But
- 4:45your feelings are valid and you should pay attention to those. So if you're
- 4:49able to remove yourself from the situation and approach it from a place of calm,
- 4:57I think a lot of it just is being comfortable in that space of
- 5:00vulnerability to approach someone. And I know this is a big ask of people
- 5:05because I know some people have social anxiety. So you could even do this
- 5:10via email. You could even do this via letter. But I think the
- 5:14important thing is to remain as poised as possible, remain composed. So you
- 5:21might say to I don't know, let's call the dungeon master Terry. You
- 5:28are the player in this case, so you could be like dear Terry,
- 5:31Hi, I'm not having a good time right now with what's happening in the
- 5:39story. I feel like it might be bringing up some stuff that I'm not
- 5:44prepared to deal with, or I think maybe in what I'm perceiving is I
- 5:51feel like I'm being picked on, for example. And one big piece of
- 5:56advice I can always give is, if you're a game master, don't you
- 6:00ever let this get fucking personal, because you're not there to punish your friends.
- 6:04You're there to have a good time. But again, I'll talk about
- 6:09that a little bit later. So it's more or less just being able to
- 6:13calmly communicate what is like, what's going on. You might say, hey,
- 6:16I don't like the themes you're dealing with. I don't like the encounters,
- 6:21feel like they're may be a little too lopsided. Maybe you're favoring one
- 6:27player over another. And that's a thing that could happen with group dynamics,
- 6:30Like it could be a boyfriend, girlfriend, partner, whatever, best friend.
- 6:34It could be kind of clicky, and honestly, you're just gonna have
- 6:40to use a lot of best judgment how to kind of deal with that.
- 6:42It's going to be a lot of learning how to read people, and you
- 6:46would be surprised how much this whole thing has actually helped me in my professional
- 6:54life. Like, for example, I was dealing with a meeting. I
- 6:58guess this would have been and over a year ago and change. We had
- 7:00a very tense moment at a service meeting I was at and someone was quoting
- 7:06directly from a police report and they said something very racially insensitive and that room
- 7:14lit up real fast, and fortunately I was able to talk to everybody,
- 7:21all the parties of all say all right, guys, like, look,
- 7:25let's take a breath, let's take a heartbeat here, and you didn't mean
- 7:30anything harmful by it. Your feelings are valid. Let's work through this and
- 7:35let's talk this out because we're all here together to get the good work done.
- 7:40And you can kind of apply the same thing for your role playing gamings.
- 7:45It's like, hey, we're all here to have fun, we're all
- 7:46here to make memories. Because conversation doesn't need to lead the confrontation, but
- 7:53it sometimes does. And confrontation is not always a bad thing. It's just
- 7:58how aggressive you take that confrontation. Like I say, if you go in
- 8:01with pitchforks and knives and that's your go too. Again, maybe it's valid,
- 8:05but at the same time, if you stab the guy, you're not
- 8:09gonna get the resolution that you want because now they're dead. So I know
- 8:13that's a very extreme example, but what I'm saying is if you go in
- 8:18guns blazing, you're probably not gonna get what you want. But if you're
- 8:20willing to take that step back to remove yourself from the emotional part of that,
- 8:28even if your feelings have been hurt, you might be able to find
- 8:31a common ground with the DM or the other players. And like I said,
- 8:37like if these are people that you're hanging out with, you're choosing to
- 8:39spend time with, If they're your friends, they'll understand, and if you're
- 8:45any sort of of a game master, you'll listen to them. Because you
- 8:48want to engage your players. You want to help create these wonderful worlds of
- 8:50fantasy, be it Shatter Run, Transformers, Star Trek, Battle Tech,
- 8:54whatever. You want people to have fun in these worlds. You don't want
- 8:58to expose them to something terrible, and maybe you are. And as a
- 9:05player, you also don't want to be a disruptive person to others around you,
- 9:09because one thing that could happen is you could end up being the problem.
- 9:16And you know, it's basically I would like to think most people,
- 9:22for the most part, are not there to make each other feel bad.
- 9:26Nobody wants to feel grumpy, Nobody wants to feel terrible when they go out
- 9:31to go out and play their games together. Like, nobody wants to be
- 9:35upset. So if you can approach the affected party and like, hey,
- 9:41let's talk this out. Because I find, at least in the personal stuff
- 9:48that I've observed being a player talking player to pather player two player, that
- 9:54tends in my opinion, to work out a little bit better just because you
- 9:58can easily talk to them saying, hey, man, we're not having the
- 10:01group cohesion we want right now. Can we work this out? Can we
- 10:05figure something to do? Like you know, it's it's just talking, right,
- 10:09like just be a friend, oh, be a friend O to this
- 10:13person, or if you've got a personal problem with them, say hey,
- 10:16can we do anything to move past this? Is there anything that can be
- 10:20done? And I'm not saying you have to throw yourself on the sword like
- 10:26they have to meet you halfway too. So it's all about learning to get
- 10:30the best compromise that works for everybody and understanding you may always get what you
- 10:35want. Hopefully you'll get what you need if I think that's how the old
- 10:41song goes. But there is a flip side to this. Now, if
- 10:46you are the dungeon master or the storyteller, who or whoever, you can
- 10:50have toxic players and you may observe people picking on another player or doing things
- 10:58that are disrupting group harmy, like for example, maybe somebody hogs a scene,
- 11:05and maybe somebody throws a hand grenade or a thermal detonator into the middle
- 11:09of a crowd, or they're making inappropriate or racist jokes or something right like,
- 11:13I'm just kind of spitballing ideas here. If you're the storyteller, gay
- 11:22master, whatever, it is up to you to control that situation. It's
- 11:24up for you to figure out ways to wrangle that in while not disrupting player
- 11:30agency. But it's also being able to take so and so aside and say,
- 11:33hey, Okay, something's happening here and I think it could potentially cause
- 11:43a problem. Now what can we do to work through this? And that's
- 11:46where you, as a storyteller really hold a lot of power because you can
- 11:50be like, Okay, maybe we can turn what's bothering you into something positive.
- 11:56Maybe there's a way to fix this. And that's very much the important
- 12:00of Sessions zero is setting tone and parameters and really kind of getting a vibe.
- 12:07And I really feel after about like three or four sessions, you kind
- 12:09of get an idea on where everybody's coming from. Like, Okay, that
- 12:16is Jill and she likes to do X. That is Terry. They like
- 12:20to do X. This is Frankie and Michelle. They tend to gel this
- 12:24together, and you'll get an idea on how that table functions and what works.
- 12:30But sometimes, uh, Samantha Cause comes in and fucks up the whole
- 12:37thing. And maybe Samantha's very new, maybe they're over eager. But sometimes
- 12:45people are just trolls, right, Sometimes people are just there to fuck up
- 12:48your fun and you'll recognize those guys pretty quickly. It doesn't always happen,
- 12:54not always. I've seen it happen in like three games, and I've actually
- 13:01been that guy. So true story. I was playing a game on a
- 13:05podcast. This would have been about ten years ago. I was not having
- 13:09a good time. So me and another player said, hey, man,
- 13:13let's throw a wrench into the works. We're still gonna have fun. We're
- 13:16not gonna totally you know, call in the proverbial swat team here, but
- 13:24let's be a little bit goofy. Now. The game itself was very goofy
- 13:28and over the top and very much depended on you doing things that would get
- 13:31you in the trouble and get you killed. Right, But we were those
- 13:37players not exactly being cognizant of our GM's feelings. But the other time,
- 13:41when we've bucked tradition as a player to a DM, it made the game
- 13:46really, really, really funny, and it made for a really entertaining piece
- 13:50of content. But not everybody rolls like that. I think it's very much
- 13:56that you can be funny haha, but don't be funny, you know what
- 14:01I mean, Like, don't grit your teeth to cause someone a headache,
- 14:05because, like when you're a dungeon master, when you're any type of storyteller,
- 14:11you want to engage your audiences and that being your friends or in my
- 14:16case, if you've ever been a podcast producer, you have to be willing
- 14:22to have those tough conversations like hey, listen here, Johnny could you not
- 14:28do fifteen minute soliloquies or can you not split the party? Because then I
- 14:33have to run all these things. But it's what my characters do. Yeah,
- 14:37I get that, But can we figure a way to can we work
- 14:43together to make this happen? And again that's you as the DM, working
- 14:46cooperatively with your players to hopefully make this happen. However, not every story
- 14:54has a happy ending. Sometimes players are just disruptive. Sometimes players don't want
- 15:01to play well with others. And I've even seen people feel like they're taking
- 15:07things to personally and that is a thing that does happen. And at that
- 15:13point, that's where I really feel empathy and you really have to talk to
- 15:20these individuals as people be like hey man, who hey, whoever? What's
- 15:26going on? What can we do to work this out? And how those
- 15:31conversations go can be fifty, can be fifty to fifty. Sometimes people will
- 15:37be like, okay, cool, let's let's kind of do this, and
- 15:41other times those results, those conflicts do not get resolved. So what do
- 15:46you do as a storyteller? What do you do when you're maybe engaging a
- 15:50friend or you're engaging a stranger. And this is where conversation does lead to
- 15:58confrontation, but again, you don't have to be a jerk about it.
- 16:03And this is something I've seen them do in the corporate world when it comes
- 16:07to human resources. I'm sure the bane of everybody. But it's called the
- 16:11exit conversation, and it's very much saying, hey, look, there are
- 16:18differences here that may not be overcome, and you, as the storyteller,
- 16:26can ask them to leave. And it's not a fun position to be in.
- 16:30I do not envy anybody who's ever done this, because feelings inevitably get
- 16:37hurt, and usually justifiably so. But I find with the exit conversation it's
- 16:47always important to stress the point and if it's something that you want, like
- 16:51if you want to be friends, say like, hey, man, I
- 16:52need you to step away from this. This is not personal. I want
- 16:56to still be friends, but for right now, I need you to take
- 17:00a time out or I need you to not engage with me in this space.
- 17:04And you, as a storyteller, have an absolute right to You are
- 17:07supposed to enjoy what you're doing. I mean, if they're paying you,
- 17:12I guess there's a conversation there too, right, But see, I'm on
- 17:22about three hours of sleep. I'm tired. But it boils down to like,
- 17:27don't make people feel bad, but let them know what they're doing is
- 17:32not cool. Like you, as a storyteller, are just as entitled to
- 17:37having a good time as anybody else to. And you, as a player,
- 17:41your job is to be there, to have fun, to be present,
- 17:47but don't be a disruption. Like the idea of storytelling and playing these
- 17:52role playing games, whatever system they are, is we're all there to tell
- 17:56a story, but at the same time, we're also there to have fun,
- 18:00and you're there to make memories, you're there to bond. Like I
- 18:04kind of see role playing games as the ultimate icebreaker. It's a really good
- 18:12way to get to know somebody. It's a really good way to build friendships.
- 18:15And I am very fortunate that I've had a chance to play in a
- 18:22really long running weekly game for quite some time with some really really cool people.
- 18:27And there was a time where I thought it was gonna implode, but
- 18:30it didn't, thankfully. And yeah, there's been some growing pains here and
- 18:37there, but the group has stuck together because we all just talked, and
- 18:41I'm glad that happens. But have also been on the other side of the
- 18:48coin, where I've seen groups just stop talking to each other. I've seen
- 18:52I've seen complete friendships just dissolve over fucking dice, and that sucks. It
- 19:00sucks to see it happen like it feels like playground politics. And again,
- 19:06there could be some very very real factors at play, and those do need
- 19:11to be considered. But at the end of the day, I guess my
- 19:17best advice for conflict resolution be mindful, be in the moment, be willing
- 19:26to communicate in a non hostile manner, Listen to what everybody says. You
- 19:32have to put on the active listening thing. Like one of the things we
- 19:34do in the indigenous teachings that I've been given is you're given the talking feather,
- 19:41and when you hold the talking feather, you can talk. When someone
- 19:44else holds it, you are in the moment listening and that's actively engaging.
- 19:49And you may like, don't just sit there and think about what you're gonna
- 19:52say next. Sure, listen to them and see how you can respond,
- 20:00because you may think of something new if they say something like, oh,
- 20:03I never thought of it like that, and while you're sitting there kind of
- 20:04stewing about something that was where we've had prep for like twenty minutes. Like
- 20:11just ultimately, there is no easy way to solve conflicts, and if there
- 20:15was, well I'm sure we'd have a lot less people shooting at each other.
- 20:19Let's be real about it. But I think there is a way forward.
- 20:23I do, but it's hard. I'm not gonna lie to you about
- 20:29that. And feelings can and probably will get hurt. But I think the
- 20:33important thing is don't go out there causing them. Don't be the reason someone
- 20:38is upset. Don't be the reason someone feels betrayed or feels upset by something
- 20:44you did. But also don't be the reason that someone feels like that either,
- 20:48Like, don't be that disruptive player. Talk with your friends. If
- 20:51your friends say, hey, hey, that was really funny, but could
- 20:53you dial it back? You know what? Do that? And if it's
- 20:56gonna affect your enjoyment of the game, maybe you need to take a step
- 21:00back and say, hey, maybe I'm the problem, and you know what,
- 21:03That's a good moment for personal growth too, is recognizing we are not
- 21:10perfect beings. We are not we're not all the cast of critical role.
- 21:15We are unique individuals given life to this wonderful tapestry that is the role playing
- 21:23game experience. I said. Be it sci fi, be it space fantasy,
- 21:29be it dungeons and dragons or whatever. You know, just create a
- 21:32fun experience for you and your friends. Create something memorable. Don't create headaches
- 21:37for people. So, like I said, be willing to be teachable,
- 21:41be open to valid criticism, but listen to what's being said to you.
- 21:49But also don't take any shit out there. Someone's being aggressive towards you and
- 21:52they're being mean about it. You'll know pretty quickly if you have that conversation
- 21:57and it's not RECIPI precadd but I am the eternal optimist. I like to
- 22:04believe in the best in people. I really do. And does that make
- 22:08me not even stupid? Yeah? Probably, But that's okay. I like
- 22:14to be that positive influence in a room. Have I been wrong? Yeah?
- 22:18And it sucks. It sucks to see when people can't just see past
- 22:25their differences to cooperate. But nobody should feel like they're a burden on another
- 22:33and no one should feel traumatized when they play what should be a fun experience
- 22:37for them. So it's a lot of learning to be emotionally present, to
- 22:42be emotionally aware of yourself. And I know it sounds so dumb. We're
- 22:48talking about a game where we can stab a floating eyeball on the head with
- 22:52the knife of many stabs or whatever, or or flying water moccasins or whatever.
- 22:59That's a pretty extreme example, granted, But you learned a lot about
- 23:04yourself playing these games. And I like to think through D and D I
- 23:10have become a better conflict resolution person. I've become a better negotiator in many
- 23:15instances. I remember I had one person from a police service approached me last
- 23:22year. I was walking, I was driving down the street. I was
- 23:27playing Pokemon. But the person brought up the incident that happened in that room
- 23:33and they said, hey, Mike, question for you. Have you ever
- 23:37taken any conflict resolution training? I fought a dragon once? What like?
- 23:48Yeah, I haven't done anything other than just you know, I play a
- 23:51lot of D and D in mass effect. I don't know, I punched
- 23:53a reporter in the face, and then you should really consider taking conflict resolute.
- 24:00You knew exactly how to take that room down. And I'm kind of
- 24:03hoping maybe you guys can apply some of that video game logic, right,
- 24:07like be Commander Shepherd, right, Like, you know, not everything has
- 24:12to be the renegade option. Be pair gone when you can, right,
- 24:17but also realize that that's not always the option. I'm not saying you can
- 24:22always be optimist prime. Sometimes Megatron was right and have the right idea.
- 24:27Sometimes you want to be Professor X. But Magneto is making a pretty compelling
- 24:32argument here today. So yeah, Ultimately, I guess final piece of advice
- 24:38be teachable. Listen, don't be a jerk, don't be the reason someone
- 24:44feels like crap. Just try to be a good person as best you can.
- 24:49Hopefully we'll still be rolling Dice together for many years to come, and
- 24:53you will have that epic twenty year campaign that people only dream of, that
- 24:59people reach levels and it feels legit and earned. I hope you get that.
- 25:04I know I'm experiencing my longest running game ever, and I hope it
- 25:10continues to survive and thrive on to a long time. I really want to
- 25:15know what's past level six. I've never seen it. It would be cool.
- 25:19So anyway, guys, I'm not quite sure what's going to be coming
- 25:22up on boss roll. Like I said, if you want to keep an
- 25:23eye to my socials over the next little bit, you'll be able to find
- 25:26out what's going on with my role playing game service. And then I'll probably
- 25:30be doing some stuff on Patreon that's a little bit more exclusive, like maybe
- 25:36some writing prompts, some NPCs for different games, maybe just kind of hang
- 25:40out. Maybe we'll do something on Twitter, like kind of discord or something
- 25:44like that, and then I'll start offering services via that way as well.
- 25:48So hopefully you got something valuable out of this. I would be really curious
- 25:52to hear from you, So Mike at this weekend, geek dot net,
- 25:56or you can try getting a hold of me through my various other platforms.
- 26:02I'm always at Birdman dot everywhere. I do well have one set up for
- 26:07my DM service at some point, but I'm not quite ready to reveal that
- 26:11yet. So yeah, we're gonna keep work shopping that, keep rolling craft
- 26:17checks until I eventually get that critical success that I'm currently looking for. So
- 26:21away, guys, this has been Mike the Birdman saying, may all your
- 26:25roles be with advantage and may you always get that critical success you're looking for.
- 26:30At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to
- 26:36anything that could be considered a rational thought. Thanks for listening to this episode
- 26:41of This Week in Geek. Hungry for more, check out our website at
- 26:45this Week in Geek dot Net. You can subscribe to the podcast, browse
- 26:49our Twitter and Instagram, and leave your thoughts on today's topics. If you'd
- 26:53like to give us some feedback, send us an email at Feedback at this
- 26:56Week in Geek dot Net. Tune in next time, and remember, lower
- 27:00your shields and surrender your listenership. We would be honored if you would join
- 27:04us. Thank you for your cooperation. Good night,