Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 3: RESP's for Doctors, Smart strategy or emotional trap?
Transcript
- Vishal Gill: How's it going everyone? Welcome to episode three of portfolio talks. Today we're going to be talking about RESPs for doctors. So you've probably had a kid and you had that guilt right when you had a kid you thought, should I be doing RESPs? Should I not be doing RESPs? You know, is it urgent for me to do right away? Is it a smart strategy or is it an emotional trap that everyone just guilts me into doing? So follow along episode three portfolio talks. We'll dive into RESPs for doctors. All right, we are diving into our ESPs. As always, you have myself, Vishal, you have Tyson Nagasaki from Portfolio Planning, and we're going to teach you everything you need to know about our ESPs because a lot of our clients and ourselves included, both have kids. It's that initial thing of you look at this baby and you're like, holy cow, your entire future is in my hands. And I guess I got to do an R.E.S.P. and I don't even know what that is, how to do it. It's just another acronym that's in Canada, which is a lot of them. So the good, the bad, the ugly, all the details. And of course, if you could like, share, and subscribe, it really helps us out on that front to keep on giving you the information that you need to make your career as successful as possible. So let's jump into it. know the pain point really for you guys is ⁓ want to build for your kids future which respectful and admirable But you're really sure Sorry, ⁓ but you're really sure how to do it or how much you should prioritize that in relation to your other goals And you can't want to balance family life. You want to bounce your retirement you want to balance? Everything which is always hard to do so You know RSPs are one of those things that we're gonna chip away at today and by the end of the episode you should have a good understanding of Do you want to do RISPs? How it works? the next steps are to get that started for you and some traps to look out for. before we jump into it, Tais, anything add on? Tyson Nagasaka: really. The majority of the work that we do right now, we're working with, incorporated professionals, medical professionals, doctors, dentists, optometrists. So their, their cashflow and their means is a lot different than like my legacy client base where I used to work with like middle-class middle income Canadians. And we to have a serious conversation because sometimes it is more important to prioritize your retirement. over your children's education because kids can get a loan for school, you can't get a loan for retirement. In the current client base that we work with, it's the same prioritization. So I think just be aware of your circumstances, what level of income you are and what you want to do because you can fund your children's education. We just want to also make sure if you're ⁓ more in middle, you're the average Canadian. is you have a serious look at your long-term savings picture as well and then prioritize. Vishal Gill: Yeah, I couldn't agree more. think that's a conversation that we have when we talk to our clients. One of the first things that we do, well, I guess the second thing, the first thing we do is help you get out of debt. And that's like your only priority, which is totally fair and it should be. that is when the debt starts ramping down, you start building your full actual real financial plan as a practicing practitioner is readiness. what is that number that you need to hit in order to get to your retirement? And it's really reverse engineering time value money calculation of based on your ideal life, this is what it's gonna cost you in retirement, so now we can calculate how much you need then, what your government benefits are gonna do, and then how much you need to fund yourself, and you can work backwards. The reason why that's so important is as your income comes in, you know automatically the non-negotiable is this money that should be going to retirement, because unlike your children, who could fund their retirement many different ways, they could go to school, or sorry, they're gonna go to school, they could work while they're going to school is what I meant to say, they could get a scholarship. Tyson Nagasaka: That's correct. Vishal Gill: They could take a student loan and a of credit. They could take a sabbatical for a year, get back into it. There's so many different ways for them to fund their education. But as Tyson and I mentioned over and over again, and you'll realize this as you listen to our last episode and our further episodes, is you have no one else to retire you. And even if you're spending an inheritance, you don't know what that looks like. So you need to plan for your own retirement. Otherwise, you may be in a situation where you're stuck doing clinicals forever. And that may sound great for you as an early career. physician for example, I love my profession, I'm finally working in it, I don't think I ever retire in a week or that often. I'll never retire, I love my job. That can change after you're doing clinic for 20 years straight. I can't wait to retire. So the reason why I mentioned that is it's important to know all the buckets that your money should go to and retirement is the most important one. After that, you'll have subsequent goals like RESP. So one of the things that we always go to on other episodes, which is becoming increasingly... popular topic is the Mythbusters. And I wanna just also say thank you everyone for the feedback on the last episode. were just on an event actually, Tyson, if you wanna mention this a little bit here too as well, but we just had an event on the weekend at the Happy Gilmore Lounge in Burnaby, Coquitlam. Coquitlam? Burnaby. Maybe both, Burquitlam. So we had an event there and it was fantastic. So shout out to Happy Gilmore Lounge. We watched the Masters, Rory won. made it tough on myself, but he won, that's all that matters. through that event, it was fantastic because we had a bunch of guests that came and they listened to our podcast and one of them was just laughing. He was like, man, I will just listen to your podcast on the way here. And we chuckled. I was like, I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing. You might have an overdose of the shawl in your ear, but ⁓ know, we really appreciate the feedback on this. So as always, we're going to go through Mythbusters. We're going to go through our learning, teach you guys about the topic, and then we're going to wrap up with our prescription pan. And if you want to get your questions into the prescription pad, make sure you join our closed Facebook group for doctors across Canada. It's a place where we'll let you know what we're chatting about. You can put your questions in there and we'll answer them here. So Tyson, I'll pass it off to you. Let's bust the first myth, which is you should fund your kids' RESPs immediately. Tyson Nagasaka: Right. The funny part about this is, is we've talked about this offline is as soon as you have the child in the hospital, there seems to be somebody that either shows up at your bedside or they call you right away and be like, Hey, I heard you had a kid. Congratulations. By the way, you should sign up for an RESP. for the initiative and whatnot. That of like, it's almost like door to door sales, but for children's education, that's hard to do. So you got to respect the hustle for that. However, the program is not always the most flexible. It's not the best program. You don't get a choice of how you invest the money. There's a myriad of things that I would say, hold on. Like, let's look at some options before you lock in this person. so what we want to do? Like, and so with clients have means, we have a couple of choices. We have some scenarios and I put together a little like walkthrough. Let me see if I can share this. All right, you can see this. Okay, RESPs for doctors. You're a doctor, you're an incorporated medical professional, you have had children, do you fund their RESP and what does that look like? So we had some assumptions built into this example to take out all of these what ifs and then just focus on a couple of different scenarios. We're gonna assume you're gonna get a 9 % compound annual growth rate on your RESP investments. Vishal Gill: Yep, we're good to go. Tyson Nagasaka: The time horizon is 18 years, so you're starting this at zero years old as soon as your child gets a social insurance number. The Canadian Education Savings Grant is 20 % match up to $2,500 a year. The Lifetime Canadian Education Savings Grant, the CESG, is $7,200 per child. And if you're investing corporately, we're assuming it's 6 % passive rate after tax. And redemption is going to last four years because your child is going to go to school for four years. Although if they're going to follow in your footsteps and they're going to be a doctor, it's going to be 10 years in school. So let's look at these scenarios. Scenario A, you have $50,000. You're going to fully fund the child's RESP at birth and leave it invested in your tax deferred growth vehicle, the RESP. Scenario B. You're going to contribute $2,500 a year every year for 17 years to max out the grants and have it grow. And scenario C, you're going to do the $2,500 every year into the RESP and you're going to do $2,500 into a corporate investment account every year. What does that look like? Scenario A, lump sum upfront, $50,000. It has the longest time horizon to grow and compound. It's going to grow to $235,000. Scenario B, where you're contributing every year, $2,500. It's going to grow to $121,000. So you are getting all the grants in scenario B, but the growth trajectory, because the money's not in on day one, the compounding is wildly different. Scenario C is you're doing $2,500 into the RESP and $2,500 into your corporate investment account. It's going to wind up being about $199,000. The reason scenario C is thrown into the mix here is because it's highly flexible. You can drain the RESP account and then you still have corporate investment dollars should the child decide to specialize. to continue to pursue education, to do something else. So maybe you've just finished your degree in biomechanics and now you wanna go into surgery, you wanna go into something else, you wanna specialize, do internal medicine. It's another layer of schooling, it's another layer of cost. So you wanna know, you wanna have some flexibility available there. So these are three scenarios that really just show you the difference. If you had the means and you wanted to fully take advantage of the RESP, loading it up from has the longest unmolested compounding time and as we've talked about before and we do in our presentations of the rule of 72 is your rate of return divided by 72 it shows you the number of years it's gonna take for that money to double and if you have 18 years of it being in there you might have two or three doubling periods Vishal Gill: Yeah, I think that's a great illustration for those of you that are watching our podcast. those of you listening, hopefully you can visualize it and watch it back later. But important things there is there's three different ways to get to the same finish line. And it is just dependent on your own situation. So to answer that question, you should fully fund your RESP immediately. I'm always hesitant with definitive statements like that. You don't need But if are going open up your RESP, the numbers kind of point you towards just really fully into the compounding effects. So if you listen to this podcast, you're probably in the bucket where you have the accessible funds. Often times we tell our clients like you have the money, it's just about a reallocation of that money. So what accounts do you have it in? And you know, we do that every single year. So not an income problem. It's just a pending of your plan for your taxes and where you want to hold that money for specific goals throughout your life. So if you are going to fully fund it, option C obviously makes the most sense because you have two different accounts going for you. I would always say that dropping money in on an annual basis, like having a automation on whatever platform you're using, have that automated so the first week of January, that money goes in there and you let it compound. Or just say that 50k and drop it in the beginning and yes, you're giving up those grants, but the compounding effects are going to absolutely smash it out of the park. The other thing I would say on that is option C. If you want the most money, that is obviously a great tool of having that money inside your corporation. sometimes there's going be other goals you can do. really Tyson alluded to this about your time horizon. depending what your time horizon is, are you going to be wanting to be mortgage free prior to your kid going to school? Are you going closer to retirement before your kid goes to school? One of those things you could do instead of having that 50K just sitting earning interest inside your corporate structure, depending on the rest of your plan, you may have some passive problems. You could also have that same money that would otherwise be inside your corporation. You could pull it over onto the personal side and pay down a non-deductible debt like your primary residence and then tap into that via home equity line of credit or refinance later on if and when your child does need the extra money. at least that money is doing something for you, improving your cash flow over the years. And say that to say this, everyone's situation is a bit different. So a definitive statement like you should fully fund your kids' RISB. ⁓ doesn't make that much sense to me, it really just depends on your situation, but as Tyson illustrated, there's three different ways to get to the same finish line, and there's probably another 40. That can get you there as well. Tyson Nagasaka: There's probably a few more. Yeah, there's probably some nuance in there. But yeah, I mean, we want to throw show big categories and then work with the family to say like, you know, this is what this is what your options are. And then on top of that, there's many different streams that we can look at. Some people huge proponents of family R.E.S.P.s. So if you're going to have lots of kids or you already have lots of kids, they want to have one unit and sometimes for the parents or the subscribers is they have one thing to think about even though you have four or five children. I have a family that has eight children, my family, I have a client family that has eight children and know like you got to keep things organized, dates of birth and who's going to school when and when do they graduate and where are going to go to university. So sometimes family RESP simplifies the picture. The challenge is ⁓ Vishal Gill: Hahaha Tyson Nagasaka: What if your second oldest child is Doogie Howser and they're going to go to Stanford or they're going to go somewhere and you want to all of the R.E.S.P. ⁓ to fund their like education. They could potentially drain the entire family R.E.S.P. So there's always pros and cons to every situation. Then there's the individual R.E.S.P.s. The individual R.E.S.P.s is per child per child social insurance number. It's very ⁓ Nice to be organized. So if you have two, three, four, five children, you can have five RRESPs and you can see who you funded, who's behind, who's getting all their grants. It's much cleaner in terms of like an audit process for the family and for the financial advisor to see who's getting what and what's happening. It's very clean that way. So you get a couple of different options. Vishal Gill: Yeah, and I think it goes down to the quantitative versus qualitative sometimes is the numbers can point towards, oh, family RRSP, you know, let that compound and make sense, pull the money. But when it comes to administrative burden, you're busy. It's a bandwidth problem that is keeping things organized and clean and simple sometimes will outweigh the quantitative side of it. So that's a great point about family versus individual RRSP. So switching gears into our learning center, CESG. So we talked about that before. those know, let's call it. You're not gonna get the bond So don't worry about the bonds, but when it to the grants the CESG grants I know there's a couple different ways that you can use them and how you get them and you know Do you manually apply for does automatically happen when you put your money in? So let's jump into that CESG grants and limits. How does that work for our ESPs? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, so you get a limit of matching on $2,500 of contributions per year. It's a 20 % grant. So if you're doing year to year, it's very simple. It's very linear, right? As long as you're putting in $2,500, you're getting the full 20 % grant on that $2,500 contribution. However, we do have some families that they come to us and they're like, I have a seven year old, I have an eight or a 10 year old. We haven't started RESPs yet. Did we lose the grant money? And the answer is no. You can actually do catch-ups, but you have to do them two years at a time. So you would be doing $5,000 contributions. You're getting double the amount of grant. You can't go above that threshold. And then next year, you would do another $5,000 catch-up until you've caught up on all of the years that you've missed. And then you can kind of do whatever you want. you get a lifetime grant maximum of $7,200 and you can't get any more out of this program, which means that maybe you want, once you've hit that limit, if you want to continue saving, you think this child's going to go to an expensive medical school or pursue some higher education, get their PhD, and you want to fund that, then maybe you want to utilize, you know, your, as the parent, your tax free savings account or even your corporate investment account so that that retained earnings, the money that's sitting somewhere. is sitting and growing at the same time. you are going to redeem from your... Am I jumping ahead? Talking about redemption. Vishal Gill: No, no, you're good. That actually goes right to our next one, which is the redemption rule. So the only thing I would quickly pause and talk about the CSG, I guess we just kind of skip past it. We both said that you won't qualify for any extra or the bonds. Reason being is based off your net income. So if you're high income earner, you don't get any bonuses. So that's why when we kind of brush past it, like you're not getting any extra money, you can expect the grants like the 7200 that Tyson talked to talked about, but you won't get any more because Tyson Nagasaka: awesome. Vishal Gill: your net income is too much. sorry, guess to spin on that, I guess if you're an early career physician, like if you're resident or if you're like a local optometrist who's just kind of starting out and you're starting working in like August and you're going to have a low income year and you have a child already, so perhaps in that first year, you'll get the extra money and you can qualify for the bond. So again, I shouldn't say definitive statement, but once you are in the main income earning years and you're a full-fledged doctor, then yeah, you're not going to get that because your income is too much. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, there could be some scenarios where you just have a low income year, maybe you have a million dollars of student tuition credits, and it wipes out your income for two years. You know, we've seen some pretty numbers. And then when they start earning income, that's a huge offset to your taxable income, you might qualify for the Canadian learning bond in your first few years, if you have a child already. So those could happen. Vishal Gill: Yeah, again, it was one of those things that I'm like, as I said, I'm like, wait a minute, there's nuance to here as well. yeah, of course, but that's a perfect segue. So going into the redemption rule. So we talked about grant. So you can put your money in, you'll get some grants money as well. All that can be compounded and invested. Let's say you do it ⁓ one lump sum at the start of each year. So you're doing here maximum annual deposits to get your grant and lend that compound. If you're doing the 50,000. Tyson Nagasaka: There's gonna be some one-offs, yeah, definitely. Vishal Gill: Off the bat, I don't know if we talked about this, but if you're doing option one that you talked about, if you do 50K right in the beginning, do you get grants for every single year? Like how does that work? Tyson Nagasaka: So if you do the 50K right at the beginning, you don't qualify for the grants. Like you'll get the first grant, but you won't get the additional subsequent grants because the contributions already made. You've made it above the limit in which the Canadian government will release grants. So you're only getting tax deferred compound growth, which based on the numbers that we showed in the long run, it's more than doing the small amount and getting the free money every year. So it's kind of like, priority are we going to go with? So, so, you yeah, you can, you can go that route and get all the grant money, or you can make the lump sum deposit and have it grow. But like what happens down the road, if we're going to talk about redemptions and getting the money out, the RESP can actually be in existence for 35 years. So if your child is going to become a young adult and go travel or figure their life out or do a myriad of different things, they can go back to school later you keep the RESP in existence for 35 years before you have to collapse it. Which if you had all that money invested, it can stay invested. It's going to compound. It might double one or two more times. So that could be a really good thing. And then what do do? you could always transfer it to another sibling that also has an RESP open. So in the event where we have families that have two, three, four, five children child number one doesn't go to university, you can cascade that money down to child number two. The CESG, grant, also rolls over. It stays sheltered. I think the rule used to be that you had to give the grant money back, but it looks like you can keep that grant money inside. It continues to grow and then you deal with it later on. Another option that you have is as the subscriber or the parent that sets up the plan. If the child doesn't go to school or if there's lots of leftover funds that are in there, you can always roll the RESP into your RRSP, your retirement account, which is really nice. And so that as long as you have a available contribution room, you can roll that over into your RRSP for your retirement, because that's your money. You don't get a tax. ⁓ deduction when you deposit it into the RESP. And I don't know if you get a tax deduction when you do the tax free rollover into your RRSP. It would make sense that you don't, then you also don't pay tax of taking it out and then putting it somewhere else. So it's a tax free rollover. Vishal Gill: Thank Tyson Nagasaka: Next one, there's a few of these. Next one, if your child doesn't go to post-secondary education because something happened and they've developed a disability, they get the disability tax credit, which I think we're gonna do a whole episode on that. They've really expanded the program in the last few years. If your child gets the disability tax credit, they qualify for an RDSP program, a Registered Disability Savings Plan. You can roll the RESP into the RDSP, the Registered Disability Savings Plan. What is that? That is designed to be the pension for the child that's gonna become an adult that has a disability and it's going to fund some of their future financial needs. it's there and invested long enough, it can be a fully funded, self-funded so that it can give them an income when they need it in their adult life. Very cool. And then all you can, you could fully collapse the R.E.S.P. This is kind of like the last option. If none of these other ones work, you can collapse the option. You have to repay the grant money and then you'll have to pay tax on the growth that happens in the investment account, the R.E.S.P. You'll pay tax on the growth, you can just collapse the whole thing, take the money out if the child never goes to school. That's options. That was a lot of talking. Vishal Gill: But by the all great options really the general rule of thumb is if you have a registered account they are Registered with the series so I always tell clients like it don't complicate if you have registered money you may think that like oh it's a different specialized account how do I invest this whatever more or less money's money like your Investment holder your custodian if you're an inquest rate well simple project wealth, whatever they don't care if it's registered or or not It's just a wrapper of treatment for the series So if you don't use certain types of registered account, general with them is there's some other kind of registered account that you can also go to or benefit from. So just jumping backwards to the option of RESP to RRSP, and I know there's a lot of acronyms and letters we kicked around, but your kid doesn't use all the money in the education. Let's say they have a scholarship, so you'll need some of that money and don't have another kid in the hierarchy of who's going next. So, okay, well, can either withdraw this money or just transfer to my RRSP. You can transfer to your RRSP as long as you have the room. So you gotta double check that you have the room and that you're not your numbers wrong because you're doing monthly deposits and then you think you have the room so you transfer the solver so you double check you have the room. But if you do have the room, yes, you can move from RESP to RRSP and you're not gonna get another tax deduction. Reason being is you were just to take the money out of your RESP, you have to have that income added to your marginal tax rate, which is already gonna be high. plus you're gonna give back the bond, the CESG bond. So you got the 20 % and you're gonna give the 20 % back. So if you're in like a 40 % tax bracket, you're gonna have more income in the 40 % tax bracket, plus you gotta give back 20%. So 60 % loss or hit on that is quite significant. So instead you can just add your tax deferral strategy, which is just moving that money to your RSV. And then it goes as per your retirement plan that you can do that. The other thing I would add is sometimes people are... frustrated that if they give the money to the kid and they use it effectively, so you put the money in the RESP and the kid goes to school and they withdraw it and it's taxed under the kid's name, some people are frustrated about the fact that it's like, man, there's just tax everywhere. Yes, but don't be scared of tax. Sometimes tax does suck, yes, but it has other benefit that it can open up. For example, when your child is getting taxed, taxable income in their hands, for the most part, unless they're doing... some fantastic worker have their own business while they're going to school, which I doubt they're to for the education. They'll usually have a part-time job or not that much income that's being earned. So even though they're having the RESB withdrawals added to their taxable income on top of whatever else they have, they'll probably be under the basic exemption or not that much over. So they're not going to have a lot of tax bill owed to them. I would argue that you probably don't even want to your tuition tax credits. So they'll be in a low tax bracket regardless. So they're not going to pay that much tax. but there are the benefits of them having taxable income, such as they get to open up our RRSP room for themselves. So while they're going to school, they can be opening up some RRSP room. Obviously it's not that much, but it's still something. Let's fast forward when they graduate. Because they were having RRSP opened up throughout those years, they can graduate, they can stay as a sole proprietor, earn as much income as they can individually, they can use their tuition credits, wipe that tax bill out. go into year two and rinse and repeat more or less, but now they'll also have money their RRSP that they can move this over to. So they'll have their RRSP room from the first year, and then they'll have the RRSP room carried over from when they were going to school. In addition to that, if you want to help your child start their asset growing early on, you can give them some money to put into their RRSP in addition to the FHSA, and now you use that as a first time home, and now you're creating generational wealth and them build an asset. So there are advantages of doing that. Plus, earned income will have CPP, a that's opened up as well, or contributing to CPP. So there's a bunch of different benefits. So don't get so frustrated about the fact that, well, it's a RESP, why are they being taxed in their hands? The socks I should pay for it in a different way. There's always a cost to everything that you do, but I would always argue that the RESP really benefits, especially for doctors that are gonna be earning good income, it really benefits you in a number of different ways. So don't be scared of... the taxation of RESPs in your kids' names. Next thing we want to talk about is the opportunity cost. So we kind of talked about this already, about the opportunity cost of investing money early, but let's talk about the opportunity cost of how you invest it. So let's say in this example, ⁓ you having kid that's one or two years old and now you're opening the RESP for the first time. In relation to investment profile, risk profile, time horizons, Let's talk about the opportunity cost of an RDSP JSON. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I mean, some people look at this and say, like, in the example, you do $50,000, assuming you earn 9%, it's $235,000 by the the child is 18 years old. Some people will say, if I kept that money in my business account, I can make more money. That might be true. That, you know, if they're a developer or they manufacture something, they might be able to do that. But it's good to have the conversations to show them what could happen being good steward of money and having right programs and having things in the right places because we've also seen people who are very confident in themselves and use that money for something. And then when the need arises, finances are tied up. The money's not available. The business has gone belly up. Now with our current client base with mostly physicians and doctors and dentists, mean, the business is not going to really go away. It might transition, it might change over the years, but the business itself is not going to go away. But we will have those conversations where people say, ⁓ know, I can, ⁓ can make more money in real estate. Maybe, but it's not tax deferred. It's compounding in certain way that, you know, you can just take the money out. for education, for post-secondary education. So there's conversations to be had that we have to look at the nuance of that. Vishal Gill: Yeah, and the only thing I would add on to that is when you look at the opportunity costs is for the most part, when you look at investing into your child's RESP for the first couple of years, so they're one or two years old and you're opening up the account, they're gonna have a long time horizon. They're not really be accessing that money until they're 15, 16, 17, 18, somewhere around there, depending, obviously, go ahead of the class and things like that. So there's that anomaly. But let's just say 17, 18, for the most part. You have... a very long time, or as an over a decade. So for the opportunity costs to take advantage of the tax deferred growth, get the best returns projected, which would be a more equity focused portfolio because you can get higher returns, but you're also going to be in line with inflation, cost of living, whatever that may be. So as there's an exponential growth in cost of living and how that would manifest itself in 17 years when they start going to school. at least for the most part, you can ride that growth as well. So if you want to take advantage of opportunity costs, if your child is young and you're opening up your RESPs for the first couple of times, definitely invest in heavier equities and just really realize that your time horizon is quite long. And then, you know, when your kid's 10, 11, 12 years old, you can start tapering that down and getting more into like a balance, more conservative as you get closer to graduation because you want to preserve that wealth, but you really have the opportunity to take some big shots early on. in their RESP career. So when they're young, go equity focused and then start to taper that down as they get a little bit younger. you don't have to worry so much about the grants, that stuff will be automatically applied for the most part, depending who your custodian or who your account is with. But for the most part, they'll automatically have that in your account. So see it in your activity. So if you open up your RESP account, you can look at your transactions or activity inside that account and you'll see like they're buying and trading and rebalancing, whatever. And part of that, you'll see the grant money that comes in. if you're curious if that has happened to your account, you can just log in and take a look at that. And if you missed it for whatever reason, you can always make it back for a year missed. So let's say your kid's two years old and you made your RESP for the first time, they're two years old, go heavy equities, get the grant for this year, and you can make it one year of missed grants as well. So you can get all that money, compound it, throw it into the stock market, and it ride because you don't need the money, or your kids don't need the money for a very, very, very long time. So switching gears, we're jumping into our prescription pad segment. So again, as a reminder, these questions come to us from our closed Facebook group for doctors across Canada. So if you want to get your questions in, the Facebook group. We'll let you know prior to our episode what we're chatting about. You can ask your questions and we'll answer them in longer format here. And if you don't get a chance to, we'll answer them when we go live in our Facebook group as well. So get your questions in, we'll answer them ⁓ as come in. So. ⁓ Prescription pad, let's jump into the first one here. So funding your RESP to maximize your grants. We kind of chatted about that as well. I think that question was more in relation to, you know, should I do the annual contributions or should I do a lump sum contribution? Again, it really just depends on your situation. So to answer that one quickly, we chatted about it already. If you have the money and your goal is to have the most amount of money set aside for your child. then it doesn't make sense to fund it annually to maximize the grant money. you can outperform those numbers by just compounding effects. Again, what I just talked about is you have a long time horizon, put that lump sum in, invest it for the future, get the one year of grant, but don't worry so much about the small grants year in year in. So get the most money that way. Next question prescription pad, Tyson, this is for you ⁓ is how I open an RESP? Going really to the grassroots of the question, I Sometimes these questions are good because we get so in the weeds about the particulars about it, we forget about the basics. So how do I even open up an RASP? Like someone just had a kid, what does that look like? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So you wherever you are saving and investing money is you can open a registered account with them. So in this case, we're talking about a education savings plan or R.E.S.P. So if you're doing by yourself and you're on Wealthsimple, you can open an R.E.S.P. there. If you are at the bank or you're dealing with an investment firm, you can open an R.E.S.P. there. They want your money, they want your business, they will open the account for you. But what do you need? You need the child to have a social insurance number. And Vishal, we talked about this before is like, just, you're the most recent baby in the group. And so you had a child last year, she's real cute. And when you were at the hospital, they give you a little package, right? And they had an application for a social insurance number in there. They had all the forms and the walkthroughs and the guides that an exhausted parent Vishal Gill: You Tyson Nagasaka: would want in one place. And I think that hospitals that do that are It's fantastic. So ⁓ need a social number for the child before you can apply for the RESP. So sometimes that creates a delay, especially because as a brand new, exhausted parent, you might not have the capacity to put the child to sleep, clean up, and then fill out some forms, some government forms, which are always awesome. So your advisor can't do that part for you. They might help you, but they can't do it all for you. Once you have the social insurance number, any platform where you can save and invest money will open an RRESP for you. And then you're just going to go through the regular account opening process. You're going to have to provide ID, void check, that kind of stuff, and then talk about your time horizon and your risk. This is kind of where what Vashal is talking about, what I've talked about, the nuance and having a professional to have a conversation with can make a lot of sense to help you prioritize and then execute the proper things in the right order of operations. So just because you have 50 grand doesn't mean you should invest all 50 grand right away, because what if that's your only 50 grand? Then it might not make sense. You might have to do some other things first, because the last thing you want to do is have to dip into the RESP, ⁓ the grants, and you're never going to get that back. Vishal Gill: Yeah, as perfectly said, and really when it comes to opening the RISP, you know, it really just depends on, ⁓ mentioned what hospital you're at. if don't have that booklet, I think it was like the counselors that at the hospital. So Fraser Health did a great job. They're the ones came by and gave that package. But if not, you can find everything online. So I think it's just on Canada, Government Canada website of how to open up ⁓ a SIN number for kid and things of that type. So Yes, you could do it. There's a long list of things to do. So you don't need to open it first things first. Like right before you get home, before you learn how to use the car seat, you got to open up the RESP. That's not the case. But you can get to it when you get to it. Next one. So this is always a funny one. Tyson kind of shared a story early on about these private RESP companies. And I was going to say a funny story, but I don't know if it's funny or sad or crazy. Tyson Nagasaka: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill: but we had a client who had a child last year and she called me, said, yeah, I'm to open up the RESP. And she goes, it's kind of weird. Like someone from company blank has been calling me and just blowing up my phone about opening this RESP. And she was like, I was so shocked of like who this person is, they got my number. And so she asked the person, like, how'd you get my information? I don't even know you. Like, how'd you get my information? And they were like, you signed up for a baby registry at like, I don't even know what store it was or platform. But wherever she signed up for a baby registry, guess there's some kind of like partnership or maybe data mining. Like they bought the data from these companies. So they knew when her baby's due date was. And that's where they got the information, the content information to email her, call her, like non-stop trying to open up this RESP. And we were just both shocked. was like, that's crazy. I didn't realize like it was to that extent. But Tyson mentioned before, back in the day, I don't know if this happens anymore, but there used to be some of them roaming around the hospitals and... Tyson Nagasaka: That was wild. Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill: door knocking while you're doing postpartum like, hey man, can I help you with an RESP? crazy, crazy times. But there's a difference of companies of RESP specific companies versus just doing it whatever institution or financial institution you're at. ⁓ So what the difference between doing it through a bank versus like a specialized company? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I mean, if you're to deal through a bank or a ⁓ financial institution that invests money, I think you have the most flexibility. You can start and stop, which, you know, some people have to do. Sometimes your cashflow needs are not the same year after year. The roof blows off your house, the car breaks down, whatever. And it all happens at once. Right. And your appliances all go. So sometimes cashflow needs dictate that you have to start and stop the program. When you're dealing with a bank or a professional investment firm, they're very flexible. They'll work with you. When we're dealing with some of these specialized ones, they used to always have the word scholarship attached to the name. The way that their programs work is if you stop funding, you could forfeit all the previous deposit that you've done. And part of the challenge too is We've seen contracts as aggressive as the first three annual deposits all go to commissions. And so if you're maxing out, you're doing $2,500 a year, that's a lot of money, right? That's 7,500 bucks that's going to commissions for the salesperson. And then the fourth year deposit starts growing and whatnot. strings attached programs have many gotchas ⁓ and ⁓ brand parent never reads fine print. I've read them from a few different companies. I don't like them. I'm not sure how they're allowed to exist. But if you have a platform like Wealthsimple or you have a financial professional or even if you're at a bank, it's preferred that you there and do that because of the flexibility, because of the low fees. there's no strings attached. If you're at bank A and you decide to pull all your business and go to bank B, you're allowed to do that. It's just a, it's a lateral transfer. It stays registered. You can move your money anywhere you want. It's your money. And that's a big piece of the conversation that I like to have with clients about this and all of your other accounts. It's your life savings. It's your earnings. should have control over it. And so you should ask lots of questions. And you have questions for us, we're happy to answer them. Vishal Gill: Absolutely, and the other thing about, you you're talking about the fee structure, so your first two to three years are often gone to the fees and then you start in year three or four. The tough thing about that, if you remember my earlier conversation about the opportunity costs, is the first couple of years are so important to get started because you're going to be all growth-focused and just let that compound. So if you're missing the first three years when your child has the highest risk tolerance because they have the highest long-term time horizon, that's a lot of missed opportunity as well. It's kind like a double whammy, which sucks. And then, you know, there's a lot of inside the literature of these plans. If you don't use your money, you don't get it back, ⁓ on the company and the rules over to, you know, other kids. And it's just, it's not ideal. So definitely if you are opening up your RASP, open it up at your own institution, you have control, you have ownership, you can see it, you can make definitive decisions with it because you're money. And seems simple, but oftentimes people get duped into other programs that don't make the most sense for them. So that's it for us today on episode three of Portfolio Talks. Of course, if this gave you value, really, really appreciate subscriptions and likes and shares. just really allows us to keep on doubling down on this platform. thing about having your own firm as a boutique firm, time valuable. you know, it's a good thing when we take the time out to build this up that we get the feedback from you guys. It just really inspires us to keep on going to give us, ⁓ you give you guys more and more content and just doubling down on. I'm doing this on a more in-depth and higher level. appreciate all the feedback we've gotten so far. Love we'll keep it up and stay tuned for the next episodes of Portfolio Talks. We'll be breaking down more financial topics and prescribing you your financial plan so you can run your finances, not having your finances run you. Thanks and tune in next time.