Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 301: Stop Wasting Money on Bad Communication – Celeste Headlee
Transcript
- 0:00Bad communication costs businesses $37 billion per year and chances are it's costing you too.
- 0:07My guest is Alistair Hadley. She's one of the most watched tech speakers of all time
- 0:12and a global authority on conversation and she's going to show you how you can save money with great
- 0:18communication. Celeste, billions upon billions of dollars could be saved with good, clear communications.
- 0:27How? Yeah, I mean, as of 2022, which was the most recent data I could find, the cost of
- 0:35poor communication in the United States alone hit about $37 billion. I mean, break that down just
- 0:41a little bit. Poor communication wastes about seven or eight hours a week per worker,
- 0:48which is about 18% of what anybody is paying in salary. So you're paying nearly 20% of your
- 0:54salaries just to bad communication. And it's such an unforced error. You know, we're talking
- 1:01about billions of dollars that could be saved. You know, I could save people billions right now
- 1:07just by getting to stop using email for everything. Just that change alone could save billions of
- 1:14dollars. And that's what I mean when I say it's an unforced error. It's such a silly way to waste
- 1:18money. What is it wasted on emails, you said, but how? Well, I mean, emails a time suck. I mean,
- 1:26it was a massive amount of time. It's such an inefficient method of communication. We think
- 1:32it's efficient. We think it's saving us time. But emails been around for a long time, which means
- 1:37we have reams and reams of research in this. And so we can say definitively it takes much more time
- 1:44to communicate through email than it does over the phone. Over the phone. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:49Yeah. Makes a lot of sense. And conversations, I mean, you wrote a book about communications.
- 1:54We need to talk how to have conversations that matter, which is fantastic, highly recommended.
- 2:00What's weird is that conversations is something, you know, we're born with almost, right? We
- 2:04pick it up when we're a few years old. We practice it. We have conversations all the time. And yet,
- 2:08even you and I as communications experts, at least in my case, I find sometimes I really suck at this.
- 2:13I could be better at it for sure. Yeah, I'm always a work in progress. You know, I like to think
- 2:19of it this way, you know, because our species, homo sapiens, survived through communication,
- 2:24not through advanced intelligence or skills, skill, certainly not speed or resilience, right? Like,
- 2:30you change the temperature by 5 or 10 degrees and we get uncomfortable. But it was our ability to
- 2:36communicate a collaborate that has allowed us to survive on the planet. So I like to think of it like
- 2:42the very first movie in a superhero series, right? When they first get their superpowers,
- 2:48but they don't know how to use them yet. So they're like running into walls and falling and stuff.
- 2:52That's sort of where we all start. Like, we have this superhuman skill, this incredible power,
- 2:57which is our extremely sophisticated communication skills. That's part of
- 3:02homo sapiens skill set. But you do have to learn how to use it, right? And that we don't focus on that.
- 3:09Think of all the public speaking courses that are offered in schools and not a single one in
- 3:15how to listen. And yes, listening is the more difficult half of that equation, right? We don't
- 3:20teach each other how to communicate properly. We have that one of the biggest parts of our daily
- 3:26work life is meetings and yet we almost never train people in how to hold a meeting.
- 3:31So it's really silly that we just don't focus on the one thing which is the most important part
- 3:40of what we do. Yes. And it's pretty much all we do at work these days. I mean, if you acknowledge
- 3:45work, if you're leader, then communication is what you do. The data says 88% of your time. You
- 3:49know, could say communication is work for most people these days, whether it's emails, meetings,
- 3:54conversations, speaking, chords, etc. It's pretty much what we do. Yet so little attention is
- 4:00paid to it. And from your perspective, I mean, let's, I would love to hear a little bit about
- 4:04your backstory. You've been working in communications and with communications for a long time,
- 4:09but how did you get into it? Well, I'm a professional opera singer by trade, which is a kind of
- 4:15communication. But my day job for since 1999 has been journalism, which is another form of
- 4:25communications. And I did not study journalism. So I had to once I was on the job, I had to learn
- 4:32my job. So I focused a lot of my attention on interviewing skills, how to interview. And,
- 4:39you know, you've been doing this podcast for seven years or so, you know, an interview is just a
- 4:43formalized time limited conversation. Right. So I was reading a lot of books and research on
- 4:55communication, only to find that the communication advice we've been getting is bad. It's not only
- 5:03not effective. It's counterproductive. You know, that advice we've all gotten, and I talk about
- 5:08this in my TED Talk, you know, nod your head to show you agree yours. Three times. Right. Exactly.
- 5:14Four times is bad. Two times is not quite the exact. Exactly. Based on what? Yeah. Did you test
- 5:20this at all? You know, and one of the things I like to like to give you an example all the time is
- 5:25one of the piece of advice they gave you is to hold eye contact. You know, I tested that out.
- 5:32If you hold eye contact with someone, it's uncomfortable. It's very uncomfortable. So that's
- 5:40sort of where all of this started for me. The true, you know, in-depth research was because we'd
- 5:45been getting such bad advice for so long that I was like, okay, I'm going to have to start from scratch
- 5:51and that's sort of where it all started. You mentioned listening noises as well in the TED Talk,
- 5:55and I had to chuckle, to be honest, because when I started this podcast seven years ago, I made
- 6:01a love listening, was it? Yeah. Because I thought that's how you do it, right? And you need to listen
- 6:06to the recordings. That's not right. It's terrible. It's terrible. And I stopped doing it. I hope I
- 6:09stopped doing it. And you make this great point in the book as well that if you really listening,
- 6:13you don't have to pretend to listen. You don't even have to think about nodding and making noises
- 6:18et cetera. It will be obvious to the other person that you're listening because, you know,
- 6:23we assume it's actually pretty good at picking up the signal. We're natural. We're naturally gifted
- 6:28at it. And, you know, the other thing is that when you are naturally listening, a lot of your
- 6:35conversation will be questions and especially follow-up questions. And there's been a ton of research
- 6:40this, especially featured in the Harvard Business Review on the power of the follow-up question,
- 6:45right? How powerful that is, how it has this, you know, unique ability to make people feel heard,
- 6:50to make them feel as though you're friendly. Exactly. And I'm like, of course it does. Because how do
- 6:54you ask a follow-up question unless you're listening, right? The power of the follow-up question is
- 7:01just the power of listening. Yes. And terrible conversation means you're jumping from subject to
- 7:05subject. You're talking about, you know, Harvard Business Review Studies and what it shows,
- 7:10and I go somewhere else. I mean, not really being a conversation. So, in a way, you're
- 7:14totally right. Follow-up questions are natural result of listening and going deeper into something,
- 7:19which is when conversations get interesting, right? Yeah, exactly. I mean, you're going to have
- 7:23questions. People are going to say stuff. And, you know, you've probably heard these interviews
- 7:27also where it's clear that interviewer isn't listening. You know, the person will say, they'll
- 7:32say, well, how did, you know, how did you become a rock star, whatever? They say, well, you know,
- 7:36I'm growing up in Oakland or whatever that I experienced a lot of abuse. And then I went on to
- 7:41did it and the person will say, so how are you feeling about the upcoming content? You're like,
- 7:46wait a second. Go back. You know, it's so clear when someone isn't listening, especially in an
- 7:53interview. It's painful when someone is not listening. It feels like disrespect, not just
- 7:59to listener, but to the person who's being interviewed. Yeah. You must have interviewed thousands of
- 8:04people as an NPR host and you kindly pass on what you've learned in terms of conversation skills.
- 8:11How can we have better conversations? What are your top tips? The number one thing is to stop
- 8:18entering conversations worried about what you're going to say and just focus on what it is you might
- 8:23hear from the other person. You know, so often we see conversations as a as a means of showing how
- 8:30much we know or educating the other person. And I can just relieve you of that stress right now
- 8:38in terms of I'm going to change their opinion or educate them. You're not like we have zero
- 8:42scientific evidence that over a course of a conversation, you can educate anybody or change
- 8:48their minds on anything. In fact, the human brain hates getting advice, hates it. There's only
- 8:56two situations in which a conversation is not good for you physically and emotionally and that's
- 9:01if it's hostile and if you're getting advice. And we are who are big brained social animals, we
- 9:08react to getting advice someone even if we've asked for the advice in the same way our brain
- 9:16launches the exact same sequence as though we've just been punched in the face. So that's the number
- 9:21one thing is stop telling people what to do. If they say, oh my god, I loved this book so much,
- 9:26do not respond with, oh, you'd love this other book also. That's a form of advice, right? So stop
- 9:34telling other people what to do. You hate it also. Like I'm not sure where the disconnect comes
- 9:40from. We hate it when people do that to us and then we turn around and respond to other people
- 9:47by giving them advice for kids. Yeah, exactly. I know something. I want to share that with you.
- 9:52Yeah, it's not appropriate. So what's the goal of the conversation then? If it's not to give
- 9:57advice and it's not to persuade the other person, which I agree is super, super hard.
- 10:02Yeah, I mean, if you've walked away from a conversation, you haven't learned anything,
- 10:07then it wasn't a productive conversation. So yeah, I mean, and you talked, you know, you also,
- 10:15you and I both have the benefit of talking to people who are smarter than we are, right?
- 10:18Who have done more than we have done. And the beauty of that is it keeps you humble. But
- 10:25B, you learn so many interesting things, right? And when you start getting into that habit
- 10:33of looking forward to conversations, because you're going to learn something cool or interesting,
- 10:38it's addictive. It's so enjoyable to learn new stuff from other people. And you know,
- 10:45what is it? Bill and I says, everybody you will ever meet knows something you don't, right?
- 10:50We don't go into conversations trying to figure out what that is. And that's crazy to me.
- 10:55People know cool stuff. Yeah. You said another objective that the other person learned something
- 11:01as well so that we learn from each other. Was that secondary? Yeah, I mean, they will learn it
- 11:07from you. I mean, I never worry about other people talking enough. And I get this question
- 11:11all the time when I'm doing like workshops and keynotes, people say, well, if I follow your rules,
- 11:16I'll never get to speak. I'm not worried about that. You know, research that began at Harvard
- 11:22shows that talking about yourself and what you like and what you know activates the same
- 11:26pleasure center in your brain is sex and heroin. Okay. Okay. Yeah. And in that experiment,
- 11:33they offered participants more money to talk about anything else. And they turned down
- 11:41the extra money, right? That's how much we love to talk about ourselves and our likes and our
- 11:48dislikes and our opinions. So I'm not worried that you're not going to talk enough. You will.
- 11:52And the other person will learn from you. It's true. I mean, it's really also for me as a host
- 11:57and you as well. I guess it's not hard to get people to talk about themselves and what they're
- 12:01passionate about. It's actually one of the easier things to do. How to make it as accessible and
- 12:06easy to everyone's listening, I think that is that is slightly more tricky because people can
- 12:10go down rabbit holes and obviously they know so much that sometimes it's our job then to channel it.
- 12:17Yeah, they data dump on you. But there's a host of a public radio program here in the US
- 12:23the show is called fresh air and Terry grossed the host always says that the only conversation
- 12:29opener you'll ever need is tell me about yourself. And it's it's very true. That is true. That is
- 12:36true. What else can we do to become better conversationalists? Another thing is that
- 12:43A, acknowledge that it's not easy to listen, right? You're not going to listen to a keynote or
- 12:49this episode and be like, I'm going to be a better listener from now on. That's not how it works.
- 12:54You know, we got this great set of data from the school systems in Australia, New Zealand,
- 13:00where they were trying to figure out how to teach listening. And the takeaway was you have to
- 13:05actually teach listening, right? You have to practice it specifically. You don't learn how to
- 13:10listen while you're studying history or anything else. You have to focus on listening itself.
- 13:15So that's number one, acknowledge that it's difficult. And sometimes you won't have the energy
- 13:20to do so. Listening is the mode, you know, having a conversation is the most cognitively demanded
- 13:28demanding and significant and sophisticated thing that our brains do. In fact, there's evidence
- 13:34that the only reason our brains or eight brains got bigger was in order to be in relationships with
- 13:39other people. So it's going to be hard. And it's going to, you're always going to be a work
- 13:45in progress. And it's going to require your attention. You know, so go into each conversation
- 13:51saying, okay, this is going to be difficult. And my brain is going to go off on tangents. And
- 13:56each time I'm going to pull it back, right? That's going to help you a lot. Yeah. So be humble and
- 14:02also be kind to yourself, right? Not beating ourselves up afterwards. Oh, why did I say this? And
- 14:07didn't properly listen. It's natural. Speaking comes a little more naturally to us. But listening
- 14:11is a skill can develop. Yeah, absolutely. And you can become a better listener. You know,
- 14:18that you don't born either a good listener or a bad listener, just like you're not born either
- 14:22an empathetic person or an unempathetic person, unless you're a sociopath, right? These are
- 14:28skills that you can develop and improve and or you can lose them. Also, if you're not losing,
- 14:35if you're not using them, but you can strengthen them. Yeah. 100%. What about emotion versus logic?
- 14:41How important is it that we inject emotions and or logic into conversations?
- 14:46Very glad you asked this question because
- 14:51conversations aren't logical. You know, we have this. It makes me laugh when I hear people say,
- 14:57let's not bring emotion into this. That's so ridiculous. For our species, you're not going to
- 15:03have a conversation that doesn't involve emotions. That's, you know, we're not an IBM computer.
- 15:10We are homo sapiens. We are big brain social atoms. And emotion is important data for us.
- 15:17So a, every conversation is going to have emotion in it. But also, it's important.
- 15:23Like you need to pay attention to emotions. That's that's information that you are either
- 15:29for, you know, relaying or receiving. And we're not particularly logical.
- 15:37You know, that's, that's not the way our minds work. If you look at like they have a wheel of
- 15:41cognitive biases, all the ways in which our brains lie to us. And it's massive, right? It is
- 15:48very, very easy to fool, dilute, trick, distract the human brain. Yeah. And so you cannot rely
- 15:59on your logic. You can't. You can't yet in business. And with business leaders, I often find that
- 16:06logic comes naturally, right? He's the logical. He's the plan. This is what we're going to do.
- 16:11And then you almost have to go back and say, okay, but there are these two gatekeepers in the
- 16:15brain, which are instinct and emotion. We have to think about those as well and ideally start with
- 16:19them and take people on this journey from the instinctive to the emotional to the logical. So
- 16:23you're not even allowed to talk about logic before you address the emotional side of the brain.
- 16:27And that seems to be something that maybe people used to understand, but through education,
- 16:33university, being on the job for a long time gets lost. So almost you have to unlearn what they,
- 16:39what they learned over the years in order to come to more human to human level of communication.
- 16:45Yeah, it's real. It's complicated, right? What you're talking about is organizational
- 16:48psychologists refer to as the expertise trap. And we know that the more one thinks of oneself as an
- 16:54expert in inverse ratio, almost, your learning curve declines. So the more likely you are to think
- 17:01of yourself as an expert, the less you're learning means, you know, some new employee that you hired
- 17:08because they're bright and have lots of great ideas. And they come into your meeting with an idea
- 17:13and you who have been doing it this particular way for, you know, two decades are like,
- 17:18that sounds crazy to me, right? You're not even these new ideas don't seem right because you're
- 17:24relying on the information you already have instead of widening your depth of knowledge.
- 17:31And it becomes a trap, absolutely becomes a trap. So here's the problem. A, you're not making logical
- 17:40decisions. There's no such thing as a purely logical human decision. It does not exist.
- 17:46Also, the other end of that spectrum, though, which is equally dangerous is those who rely on
- 17:52gut instinct because there is no more part of your brain that is susceptible to bias and discrimination
- 18:00than gut instinct. But the great part of this is accepting this with no shame. This is just how
- 18:09our brains work can also lead you to realize that the, the safety for this is always other people.
- 18:17You know, over and over again, we have found that if you just pull people, if you pull a large group
- 18:23of people, you will arrive at a more accurate and effective answer than if you rely on the five or
- 18:29six people around you that are part of your team, right? And this has been shown in terms of
- 18:34mergers and acquisitions, some of the most consequential decisions that a boss makes.
- 18:40If you pulled everybody in your company, including the janitorial staff, research shows
- 18:45that answer will be better than the one you come up with in your C-suite meeting.
- 18:50But we don't, we never do that. You know, we never, and we've known this for literally hundreds
- 18:57of years. I'll give you an example and it concerns a great book called The Wisdom of Crowds.
- 19:03At one point, the US Navy lost a submarine in the Atlantic Ocean. Could not find it. They brought
- 19:08in the best experts they could absolutely find on ocean currents and, you know, oceanography, etc.
- 19:15Could not find the submarine. So one of the guys on the team was like, you know what, I'm going to
- 19:19run a poll. And he literally asked everybody, his grocery store clerk, his grandma, and he would
- 19:24show him a map and he'd say, this is where we last had contact with the submarine. This is where
- 19:28it was headed. Take a guess. And he, he averaged their answers and they found the submarine.
- 19:35Okay, wow. This is how human brains are designed to work. Yeah. We work as groups. We are a hive
- 19:43mind, right? None of us think that an individual bee is particularly genius, but working together
- 19:50bees accomplish incredible things. This is exactly how human beings work. So when we're talking about,
- 19:56you know, business people trying to rely on either their logic or their gut instinct, rely on
- 20:01neither understand that both of those things are inherently flawed and rely on your team. And by
- 20:06team, I mean team writ large team writ large. Absolutely. And how do you, how do you train that
- 20:14in an organization? We can obviously develop our skills based on the information we share and
- 20:18you can get elsewhere. But as an organization, I say that I want my team, my, my employees, my staff
- 20:25to become better communicators, better listeners. How do you go about this?
- 20:30So the biggest stumbling block to better communication on your team is your own communication,
- 20:38right? If you are, if you seek communication from management as, as being heavily gatekeeping,
- 20:44right? Like you do not have transparency. You don't bring employees in until a decision has
- 20:49been made and is already in progress, right? If you have closed doors meetings, if you don't,
- 20:57of only communicate with your team members when something is going wrong, if that's the kind
- 21:02of poor communication skills that you have, that's the kind of poor communication skills.
- 21:09We'll be on your latest, right? We'll have. Absolutely. They're going to model that because
- 21:12that's what they think you want. And also they think that's the culture of they will adapt to
- 21:18the culture of the business. And I see this all the time. I get called in and paid a good
- 21:24amount of money to give keynotes and workshops of communication and the C-suite executives are
- 21:30never there. That's shame. That's a sign of it. Yeah. It's a waste of money in a way. You know, why,
- 21:38why are you spending all this money to improve your employees communications in which I'm going to
- 21:44tell them don't send emails after hours. And then their boss is sending them emails at 9 p.m.
- 21:50on a Thursday night, right? It's just not helpful. Makes sense. It's also my experience. It's really,
- 21:57you know, the tone is set and the communications culture is set by the senior leadership team.
- 22:02They are modeled, they are related and the better they communicate, which is why I love to talk to
- 22:08and work with leaders because I know if they improve the way they communicate, it will have a
- 22:13cascading effect on everyone around them. And that is beautiful. That's how you can actually
- 22:17uplift the whole organization. And that is something that some leaders open to, but unfortunately,
- 22:22is that not not all of them are. You know, we all tend to vastly overestimate our communication skills
- 22:29and I say we, including myself, you know, research shows that more than four out of five people say
- 22:35a relationship has been damaged by poor communication. But fewer than one in five say it was their fault.
- 22:43We can all do that math, right? It doesn't it up. It doesn't. And also, we tend to think we're,
- 22:50we have equal skills of communication in whatever platform, right? If we're good at giving speeches,
- 22:56we think that makes us also good in conversation. It makes us think we're good at writing emails
- 23:01and newsletters and typing on Slack. But they don't translate, right? I keep, you know, and also
- 23:11leaders often to make the mistake of thinking that a paycheck is the number one motivator for
- 23:17workers. It is very much not a focus on wages in terms of motivation for your employees results in
- 23:24higher turnover rates. The number, either the number one or number two motivations, things that
- 23:31employees say is the things that they want the most. It's always either in the number one or number
- 23:36two slot is an is empathic leadership. Empathic leadership? Yeah. Yes. And that sends up belonging,
- 23:43right? To feel that, you know, I belong here, we and this together, I've clarity about the
- 23:49direction we're heading. So I'm not using. I have value here. I'm heard. I'm supported. I have
- 23:55psychological safety, meaning I can, I can feel safe bringing up an idea in a meeting and I won't
- 24:02be humiliated about it. I can make a mistake and it's I'm not going to be treated like a leper.
- 24:10Yeah. All of these things are part of empathic leadership, but a big part of it is clear
- 24:15communication. Yes. That's not condescending and is not critical. Yes. Where do I start as a leader?
- 24:21So I hear you useless. What's one thing I can change today?
- 24:26Send a note out to your team members or go and see them in person and say, hey, I'm working
- 24:30on my communication skills. And here's the number thing I'm working on. I'm bad at
- 24:34interrupting people. So I want you, if I interrupt you, I want you to, you know,
- 24:38tug on my shirt or whatever and help me get better. Right? That's great. I never heard this.
- 24:45I never heard this advice that you should come clean and say, I'm working on it because I think
- 24:51I should improve. I want to improve on working on it, but tell me if, you know, where I go wrong.
- 24:56Yeah. And it also makes it safe for other people to say, okay, what do I need to work on?
- 25:01What do I do badly? And you can say, okay, we're going to have a workshop or whatever in terms
- 25:10of communication because communication training that focuses on clarity, that focuses on honesty,
- 25:21are incredibly effective. We have seen this in a lot of medical settings where there's a massive
- 25:31amount. I think it's over half of medical errors, preventable medical errors are caused by poor
- 25:37communication. And when after they have done communication workshops, some of them as short as
- 25:44three hours, they've seen a massive reduction in medical errors, but also it took no more time.
- 25:52It didn't add to the time it took, but it actually reduced the number of errors. So, you know,
- 25:58leaders with good communication skills add well over 40% of shareholder value to the company.
- 26:04There's just no downside. And so if you model that kind of behavior, the kind of humility that says,
- 26:10okay, I'm working on this. I realize I'm not getting it right. And we're going to do this together.
- 26:16It can change your entire culture. And I think it actually signals confidence and status.
- 26:23Oh, absolutely. Because if I'm saying that, it just shows I'm super confident person. Yeah.
- 26:28I'm just thinking how to persuade leaders to apply this advice. It increases trust among your
- 26:35employees. And trust is one of those things you can't, you know, the principles you cannot have
- 26:40growth without trust. And trust requires honesty, requires transparency. It requires honesty, right?
- 26:47So, you know, another great thing is that it will actually help you see your blind spots.
- 26:53You know, you are the most biased person on the subject of you.
- 26:57So, you can't see your own blind spots. You know, maybe you think that interrupting is your
- 27:04biggest flaw. But other people see a very different side of you. And so if you open it up, you might
- 27:11actually get this incredibly valuable information. You could pay a consultant, you know, $100,000
- 27:16to give you this information. Or you could get it for free from your own co-workers. Adam Grant has
- 27:21done some great work on this. And he, you know, some of the research that he has participated in and
- 27:26pointed to and highlighted has shown that the people who are the most accurate in terms of judging
- 27:32how your personality traits affect your work are your co-workers. They're more accurate. Obviously,
- 27:37than yourself, the most biased, but they're also more accurate than your friends and your loved ones.
- 27:43It's your co-workers. So ask them. Ask them. Yeah, that has brilliant advice. What is
- 27:48conversation on narcissism? So sociologists came up with this term to talk about the very human
- 27:57tendency to turn conversations to the subject that we know the most about and that we're most
- 28:02confident talking about, which is ourselves. Right? So this is especially true in conversations
- 28:10where we might feel like we don't know what to say. So it comes up a lot when someone's talking
- 28:15about a painful experience they've had or they come into work maybe and say my dog died over
- 28:20the weekend, right? And you don't know what to say. And so you'll say, oh, I know how you feel my
- 28:24dog died like five years ago. And it was really, really tough. Right? Yeah. I was delighted the
- 28:32airport for three hours. Oh, that's nothing. I was delighted for five hours last night. Yeah,
- 28:36exactly. Let me tell you about the time we were stuck on the runway for, you know, not to mention
- 28:41the fact that we have scientific evidence that we didn't need to tell us that travel delay stories
- 28:46make everybody miserable. Right? Like it's this, it's this, but it comes up innocuously as well,
- 28:52you know, someone will say, oh, I got to go to the grocery store and they're like, oh, I do too.
- 28:55And I also need to go to the bubble. So he talks, he talks about it in terms of a switch response
- 29:01versus a support response. So someone comes in and says, um, I, my dog died over the weekend,
- 29:06you can switch and say, oh, I remember what that feels like. Or you can support and say, I'm so
- 29:11sorry, what was your dog's name? They want to talk to you about their dog. Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 29:16Yeah, they want to tell you what they lost. Yeah. So let them talk about their dog, right?
- 29:23As opposed to switching it. So they need to spend some of their emotional energy that they need
- 29:29to worry about you and your dog that died five years ago. Yeah. Yeah. Um, your tattoo came out
- 29:35nine or 10 years ago, the book on conversations, I think, um, 2018. So also some time ago,
- 29:41since then, communication technology has clearly improved. I'm not sure that our conversation
- 29:46of skills have become better or worse. So how do, how do you, how do you judge our conversation
- 29:51of skills holistically as societies these days? So our communication technology has quote
- 29:57improved. Um, I really don't get, okay, so again, I don't mean to beat a dead horse, but
- 30:05communication is the thing homo sapiens do the best period. That's the only way that we have
- 30:12survived as a species, right? So why we keep coming up with new ways to do the thing we already do
- 30:20better than any other technology as opposed to coming up with ways to do the stuff to, to be better
- 30:26at the things we don't do well like taxes or, you know, any of the things we don't do well, right?
- 30:33Um, let's come up with new tech for that because nothing absolutely no technology
- 30:39is better than your voice and your ears. Yes. Period. I asked one scientist to, at some point,
- 30:46written technology, even just writing would equal the voice in terms of effectiveness and she
- 30:54said it's possible in five to 10,000 years. We'll take some time to that. Yeah, we, I think we
- 31:01forget that, um, you know, written communications only a few thousand years old,
- 31:06where it spoke for communications a few hundred thousand years, right? Yeah, I mean,
- 31:13we know from the histories of your country and the Nordic countries that people have been
- 31:18preserving history for a very long time through songs and super, super boring poems. Um,
- 31:24that's how we, you know, we're boring. Yeah. Oh, my God. That was not meant to take it around.
- 31:30You make me read bay wolf one more time. Um, so like that's how for most of 300,000 years,
- 31:38we've preserved knowledge. We passed knowledge along. We have evolved specifically in order to do
- 31:43that, right? We are evolved in order to learn through stories, uh, relay information through stories,
- 31:49preserve knowledge early. Now, I'm leaving out ASL and, um, the whole deaf community, but there's
- 31:55equal effectiveness in terms of, um, ASL and other, uh, languages for the, what's the ASL? I'm sorry,
- 32:04American Sign Language. Okay. Okay. Yeah. It's very similar in terms of effectiveness. But that's
- 32:10what we evolved to do. Writing is super recent. Yeah. Yeah. And there's also great research
- 32:18showing that if you read someone's opinion in any written form, a book, an op ed, a social media post,
- 32:25you are much more likely to dehumanize them, to not recognize them as a fellow human being,
- 32:32than if you hear that opinion, uh, exact same opinion from their own voice. Yes. We, our voices allow
- 32:39us to recognize what another is human beings. Yeah. I think we all know that, you know, texting each
- 32:44other leads to a lot of miscommunication that could be avoided, but just talking to each other.
- 32:49Oh, absolutely. So when we say improved conversation technology, it's going the wrong direction.
- 32:55It's our conversations are getting worse because we're trying to avoid doing the one thing we do
- 33:01best. It's like Whitney Houston going, you know, I'm going to choose not to sing, um, like the one
- 33:07thing you do really well and you're like, I'm going to do this other thing instead. Yeah,
- 33:11that's a terrible idea. It's pretty well. Thumbs and tried to, you know,
- 33:15tie on a small screen. Yeah. Great. Exactly. Or Cheetah's being like, you know, I'm going to,
- 33:19I'm going to, you know, not try to outrun other animals. Like, what are you talking about?
- 33:25You know, exactly. Play to your strengths, which is, which is further communication. What impact
- 33:30do you think will AI have on our communication in next couple of years? It can only degrade it
- 33:36further. You know, years ago, I was brought in by Amazon to try to make Alexa
- 33:42converse more like a human being. Um, and that's not, she's not a human being. She's not a she.
- 33:50Right? She has all the flaws and thinking of a human being because they programmed her,
- 33:56but she cannot respond emotionally, you know, she doesn't have a prefrontal cortex. She doesn't have
- 34:02a temple parietal junction, you know. Um, so it's not going to happen. AI is, I mean, I'm,
- 34:11it's going to be a disaster. And again, if we were using AI, if we were trying to develop AI
- 34:17to do the things that human beings weren't good at, I would, if it weren't a climate disaster,
- 34:23I would probably be all for it. But we're not. We are yet again trying to use technology to
- 34:30replace the thing that humans do better than any other species. It is the dumbest, most short-sighted
- 34:36stupid waste of trillions of dollars. You know, since email, no, email has its place.
- 34:43Email has its place and its usefulness. It's just that almost 90% of workers would rather
- 34:48communicate through email than any other way. And it's, oh god, it's such a, such a disaster.
- 34:54Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you're taking AI is really interesting and take it very seriously. And I think
- 35:00the, the risk is that our communication skills will atrophy because we, you know, hey, can you
- 35:06write this in a more empathetic language, etc, etc. So, you know, it kind of suggests that we don't
- 35:12have to think about our communication anymore because AI does the thinking for it, which of course
- 35:16is an illusion. It is an illusion. It's, it's just, it's so backward. Let me, so let me take this
- 35:22back and explain how important this is, just how much of an existential threat AI is.
- 35:29You know, for a very long time, evolutionary psychologists and biologists didn't know how
- 35:34homo sapiens survived. Like we are, I think one biologist described us as eminently killable.
- 35:42We are slow. We are thin skinned. We don't have, you know, a thick hide or armor or spikes or
- 35:49venom. You know, we are very fragile. And Neanderthal was strong and fast and agile. They had bigger
- 35:59brains than we do. They practiced a rudimentary form of dentistry, right? There's no reason why
- 36:06homo sapiens would outlast Neanderthal except that human beings have the most sophisticated
- 36:13collaboration skills on the planet, which means if you're dealing with one human being
- 36:17homo sapiens, you are almost always dealing with more. It means a tiger can't come to your village
- 36:22night after night and drag another person out. Eventually people will get together and they will
- 36:27be able to as a group overwhelm a stronger force. Yeah. Yeah. But you need very sophisticated
- 36:35communication skills for that, right? Like the only two species that can regularly take down a
- 36:39bison, they probably don't have bison in Germany. No, we don't have bison. Bison are, you know, we're
- 36:46talking about a ton. They can jump six feet straight into the air. They can go on 40, 50, 60 miles
- 36:51an hour. Like they are, you know, yeah, the only two species that can regularly take them down are
- 36:57homo sapiens and wolves pack animals. Yes. So when you start degrading our communication skills,
- 37:05you are literally threatening the existence of our species. That's how we have survived. It is
- 37:12not through advanced intelligence because the more we know about animals, the more we realize we
- 37:18probably are not the smartest species on the planet. It is not through our strength. Come on,
- 37:24we're not stronger than a gorilla. We're not faster than most animals. Mosquitoes take us down. If
- 37:31you look at the actual, you know, pecking order, we're pretty far down in terms of prey. Yes. But
- 37:39as we lose and degrade these communication skills, our ability to talk to another human being
- 37:45using our voice, this beautiful, advanced technology in our, in our throats, we are threatening the
- 37:53survival of the species. So what should we do? Should we not use AI for communication purposes?
- 37:58Yes. Or should we use it in a smarter way? Don't use AI for communication purposes. Okay. Period.
- 38:05And also start using your phone as a phone. Yeah. Just pick up the phone. It's, yeah, that phone call
- 38:11is going to be faster. We know it's going to give you, it's going to lower your heart rate,
- 38:14it'll lower your cortisol levels. It'll relax your muscles probably. It's going to lift your mood.
- 38:22That phone call you're avoiding is super good for you. So, yes, especially if you walk in talk,
- 38:28right? I love to go on the wall and then just call friends or family and have a conversation and
- 38:33you get these two things which are, you know, as I said, would your stress get things cleared out?
- 38:37Yeah, three things actually because most likely you're seeing some form of nature while you're
- 38:43walking. So not only are you getting the endorphins of the exercise and that great physiological and
- 38:50psychological boost of the phone call, but we know that seeing trees is in some cases better for
- 38:57you than an antidepressant. Don't stop taking your antidepressants. It's not medical advice.
- 39:01Right. This is not going to go into experts. But it's just really good for you. So,
- 39:06yeah, your walking talks are great for you. Like a huge boost. Yes, I love them and I can only
- 39:14recommend it because otherwise you just have more video calls, you have more emails, you more hours
- 39:19in front of a screen. So it's great for your eyesight. You know, lots of, lots of advantages.
- 39:24Yeah, get a dog. Take a walk with your dog a couple times a day and call people on the phone.
- 39:29Well, cats, but they don't come a walk. That's the problem. Yeah. That's the that's the
- 39:34snag in the system of cats. I wanted to ask you on a more serious note about diversity, equity
- 39:40and inclusion, which is a big part of what you do these days. And I wanted to ask you about,
- 39:44you know, having sensible conversations about something that's been so politicized and also means
- 39:49different things to different people in different areas of the world. So what's your what's your
- 39:53what's your take on DI at the moment and how should we approach it in organizations? So
- 40:00it's always bring it down to the most micro level you can. Don't talk about people. Talk about
- 40:06you, right? Because when you talk about inclusion, we just mean not making people feel excluded
- 40:12because of who they are. That's all that means it means if you're uncomfortable at work, it shouldn't
- 40:17be because of the person you are. And frankly, that includes in the United States includes a
- 40:22conservative. If you're going to work and you're being, you know, picked on because of your political
- 40:28views, I don't want that for you. That's what inclusion means. And we all know what exclusion feels
- 40:33like, right? We all went to high school. We all, you know, maybe have gone to a party where we didn't
- 40:41know anybody. We've all gone started a new job and felt like, you know, very excluded. It goes
- 40:48to yeah, you know, it's one of the worst experiences as a human being because we're absolutely evolved
- 40:53to be, you know, and our tribe and our group. So, yes, be long. Yeah. And so we know what that
- 40:59feels like. And so all DEI is saying is like, hey, let's try to not make anybody feel that way
- 41:06because of who they are. Now, if their behavior is reprehensible, if they do awful things,
- 41:11okay, but it shouldn't be because they grew up in a small town or they came from some other
- 41:17country or they went to a public university instead of an ivy league, it should be because they're
- 41:23awful. You know, and it's the same thing with equity. It's like in the United States, they like
- 41:30to talk about meritocracy a lot, which is bogus. Obviously, we're not a meritocracy. But everyone
- 41:36can understand that people should have an equal opportunity to get ahead. That if you're a brilliant
- 41:41kid, you should have a chance to get educated and succeed in life. Everyone can understand that.
- 41:48Politicians like to say, oh, this is about some people wanting a free ride. Nope. So if you just
- 41:54bring it down to this basic like think about, think about going to your holiday dinner. Tell me
- 41:59about the diversity at that table. Very different people with very different views. That's also
- 42:06what diversity is. Diversity also means people's weight, people's height, you know, where they grew up.
- 42:14It means all the beautiful differences in our species, all the ways in which we are different.
- 42:22That's all that that means and not punishing people because of those differences. So yeah,
- 42:28it has become a political football, but it shouldn't be. Most people, most Americans believe in
- 42:34the principles of DEI, even though they've been fooled, some of them have been fooled in the
- 42:40thinking they don't. They do. Do you ever think that it needs to be rebranded almost because the
- 42:46terms become this political hot potato in order to establish these principles of justice and
- 42:52fairness further that it needs a different term? Yeah, and I don't care about changing terms.
- 42:57You know, I run a nonprofit headway which does training science-based training in this field,
- 43:04right? Like everything that we teach has been rigorously tested and it works because so much of
- 43:10DEI training globally is incredibly expensive and doesn't do a damn thing to fix the problem.
- 43:17So what makes it work? It can give us principles that you have to do this way or that way for it to
- 43:21resonate. Yeah, sure. There's a lot of specific techniques that actually are shown to work.
- 43:28One of them, for example, is a structured mentoring programs that go throughout the entire
- 43:33organization. Another one, of course, is sort of blind hiring techniques. There's very specific
- 43:42things, but one of the main ones is that a lot of inherent bias trainings, which is the most
- 43:51common type of training people get in a workplace, focus on changing your values, right?
- 43:57We're going to show you all these horrible, we're going to tell you all these horrible stories
- 44:00about discrimination and bias and tell you what happened to so-and-so when they got sexual
- 44:05harassed and that's going to show you how bad this is and then you're going to not do discriminate
- 44:10anymore. Not going to do discrimination anymore, but we have no idea how to change someone's values.
- 44:17What we do know a lot about is how to change someone's behavior.
- 44:21Yes, and it's easier to change behavior than strongly held beliefs. Also, it seems to be an
- 44:28attack on people's identity because whatever identity we have, it probably includes the notion
- 44:31that we are good people. So in a way, if you suggest to people that they are bad people,
- 44:36oh, I'm not aware of it. You're so bad you don't even know you're bad. I just failed to see how
- 44:41that is constructive and we'll change anyone's behavior.
- 44:44Well, and most of these programs absolutely start exactly where they end exactly where they
- 44:49should start. When we're training people, we say, look, you are biased. Let's spoil an alert.
- 44:55I'm biased, you're biased. Maybe I'm not biased against African Americans because I am African
- 45:00American, but I probably have a bias against short people or people who didn't get a college
- 45:11education. Almost everybody is biased against older people. That's a super common bias.
- 45:17So let's start there. We're all biased. You're not going to be able to get rid of all your bias.
- 45:21It's not going to happen. So let's figure out how to move forward and be fair to everybody.
- 45:25In spite of that, let's figure out how we can design a system that's fair.
- 45:31And that's where you go from because changing behavior is really quite simple.
- 45:37Marketers know all about how to get us to buy this thing and not that thing at the grocery store.
- 45:43So we can use that to our advantage to make our workplaces more equitable. And everybody likes
- 45:49it better once those changes are made. Even the people who say they hate DEI training actually
- 45:54enjoy the equitable, fair, inclusive workplace more than they do the former.
- 46:00And it's good for business to have that internal culture and also most businesses sell to
- 46:07diverse audiences. It makes perfect sense in that way. It's just become sort of politically
- 46:12hot potato. I also wanted to ask you about your latest book called Do Nothing and I have to say,
- 46:18I read it a few weeks ago on vacation. Obviously perfect time to read it.
- 46:27It's interesting because you're obviously very busy person. You're very accomplished. You've
- 46:30done a lot and I'm sure you do a lot still. Yet you wrote a book called Do Nothing. How do
- 46:35how do I square the circle? Yeah, it's funny. I always get sometimes I get asked this question like
- 46:40it's a got your question. You're telling me to do nothing. Yeah, no, I know yours isn't.
- 46:46But it's what I've discovered since I wrote that book because up to writing that book I tell the
- 46:50story of how driven I was and just unsustainably. But since I did all that research and wrote that
- 46:57book and suggest ways to break away from the hustle culture. I get just the same amount if not
- 47:06actually more done in much less time. I have a ton of time to just screw off and do
- 47:15absolutely nothing valuable at all. I have the time to work out and I have hobbies and take my
- 47:23dog for walks between two and four miles every day. There's a number of ways that I lay out. I'll
- 47:30give you one example and this is when I've been working on lately is I stay as far away from
- 47:35my cell phone as possible. Angela Duckworth talks about this quite a bit that the function of your
- 47:41brain increases with every foot away your phone is from you. So like at home I have regular phones.
- 47:53I have like an actual phone. Okay, so if you're only missing this is an old school
- 48:00not just an online but one I haven't seen since my childhood. Yeah and it's not an actual
- 48:05landline. What I have is a device that connects to my smartphone through Bluetooth. So I switch it
- 48:11over and if a call comes in on my smartphone I answer it on a landline which means I can just
- 48:16leave my cell phone in the other room all day because text notifications will show up on my watch
- 48:22and I can decide whether I want to pay attention to them or not usually not and I answer on the
- 48:28landline and I got to tell you I just turned in my latest book to the publisher a book that's over 90
- 48:37thousand words long and I implemented all of the edits the first round of edits in that book
- 48:43in two days time because that's the kind of deep focus I was able to click into simply by not
- 48:50staring at f-ing screens and having my phone next to me interrupting me all the time.
- 48:56So that's one thing I did. I also went through and did an an audit on my own schedule right like
- 49:04ask yourself how much time you want to spend on social media every day right like well you take
- 49:09it's one step before that how much of conscious time do you have every day right this is how much
- 49:15I sleep this is how much I commute to work if you do this is how much time I spend on on lunch
- 49:21blah blah blah blah and it's going to leave you this is how much time I'm spending at work it's
- 49:24going to leave you with this is my amount of free time every day right for most people at somewhere
- 49:31around five hours somewhere between three and six of hours of free time how much of that five
- 49:38hours do you want to spend on social media because for most people they're spending much more time
- 49:44on social media than they think and when you start to do an audit and actually track your time
- 49:48I found out I was spending like over two hours a day on social media so there's like 40% or
- 49:55or 50 or more percent of the actually available free time we have just you know rinsing through our
- 50:01fingers because we're being at a screen but not really getting much out of it probably yeah so
- 50:06of course I didn't have time to go to the gym yeah you know and we don't realize it right it's
- 50:12like we're sitting in front of it a movie and with a bag of Doritos and just mindlessly eating
- 50:17until the whole bag is gone that's the way we're squandering our time so those are just two
- 50:21ways right there step away from your phone get it out of your peripheral vision and also audit
- 50:26your time perfect so do nothing doesn't mean don't do anything ever it just means that create a
- 50:32beat me so focused and efficient and mindful about how you spend your time that there's enough
- 50:37time left a few hours every day that you can do nothing which by the way also leads to better
- 50:41conversations and in my experience do nothing means you know spend time doing nothing productive
- 50:50you don't need to be contributing to capitalism every moment of your day yeah you don't
- 50:56you know and doing nothing doesn't mean inactive idleness doesn't mean you're not active a fisherman
- 51:03it is active while idle right so it has nothing to do with your activity level it means you're not
- 51:11trying to make money or improve your brand yes and often that's often the best ideas
- 51:19not just for work but for play for everything relationships come when we are idle and not let's
- 51:23forget that so that's we kind of need that creative space so that can actually actually you know
- 51:29germinate those ideas yes what's your what's your new book about so I had the what I
- 51:37I published a book just after the pandemic that was called speaking of race um which is it's it's
- 51:43it's supposed to be how to talk about racism but it's really how to have difficult conversations
- 51:47and then this one is actually entirely different from those other three books right this one's
- 51:52actually about my own family it tells a story of my great grandmother um who was uh uh
- 51:58it born enslaved on a plantation in Georgia um the state of Georgia and uh went on to do
- 52:05incredible things be one of the founders of the NAACP and opened the very first library for African
- 52:11Americans in the state of Arkansas and all these other wonderful things and you know black women
- 52:16especially in the United States their history has been very much buried um and intentionally
- 52:20forgotten so I'm just trying to pull that history back out so we don't lose it completely amazing
- 52:27yeah I'm looking forward to reading and Celeste unfortunately our time is almost coming to an end so
- 52:32what's your best piece of communications advice uh my best piece of communications advice is uh put
- 52:39away the screens put away the screens the screens are so distracting to your mind and we think that
- 52:45when we sit down at a table to have lunch with a friend and we turn you know we mute our phone
- 52:51we think that does it but it's not the way our brain works right just the presence of the phone
- 52:55is really distracting your brain so get it out of your eye line get it off your eye line
- 53:00feeds away to increase the potency of our brains where can people keep up with everything you do
- 53:06what's the best place to check out i mean i have a website like everyone else does celestelee.com
- 53:12i uh social media is difficult because i keep having to leave platforms
- 53:16go there so um i'm on blue sky um i'm on instagram but for a very short period of time i'm
- 53:22just getting ready to leave instagram and i'm on linkedin uh but yeah it's it's it's tough these
- 53:28days the social media situation is not gonna ask you about email anyways thank you so much
- 53:32it's great from the beginning celeste i appreciate you appreciate everything you you've done
- 53:36you contributed the field and and all the brilliant ideas you put out so thank you thank you a lot
- 53:40for taking time to talk us through your latest ideas and and everything you've done so far thank you
- 53:46my pleasure you're welcome have a good one