Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 15)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with the alex Acosta interview with
- 0:09the OIG Inspectors. Question, all right, let's turn to the NPA.
- 0:14What is it Exhibit twenty two? Did you read it?
- 0:17We know that you made some final tweaks to it. Answer,
- 0:20and so I would. Again, I don't have an independent
- 0:23recollection of reading it. I would not have made tweaks
- 0:26to it without reading it. Question okay, answer, and so
- 0:30I think you can infer that I read it. Question
- 0:32all right, And let me say you were a clerk
- 0:35to an appellate, a very eminent appellate judge, and you
- 0:39did appellate work yourself. So you were somebody who's an
- 0:42appellate lawyer who has the experience at a high level.
- 0:46It's often more sensitive to words and phrasings and the
- 0:49documents contents than might be again to characterize a little
- 0:54bit but more of a shoot from the hit trial
- 0:57attorney who spends his days, you know, in a row
- 1:00in tumble court room. And it's fair to say that
- 1:02you were more of the former. Here. They get cut
- 1:05off here by Acosta. So I would push back. I
- 1:08think that's not respecting the talent of the trial lawyer,
- 1:11and particularly on these types of agreements or documents. These
- 1:15are folks that sort of have expertise, because even if
- 1:18this was Suiy Generis, they have seen a lot of
- 1:22this question. I'm not suggesting that redacted and redacted Lori
- 1:28were not up to this answer right question, because certainly
- 1:32she also had a lot of appellate experience. I'm simply
- 1:36noting that this seems to be sort of in your
- 1:38wheelhouse answer. Look, I apologize whether I'm not sure what
- 1:44is in my wheelhouse means, you know, I appear to
- 1:47have read this. I suggested some medits. As I would
- 1:50have approached this document, my assumption would have been, I'm
- 1:53looking at it from my earlier concerns that the policy
- 1:56level concerns. Does it capture what we're deferring to this state,
- 2:00going back to put this in the petit policy versus not,
- 2:03does it capture the policy concerns of appropriately understanding that
- 2:08we can force the state to do something, and does
- 2:11it capture the essential elements of the terms that we
- 2:14had looked for, you know, the imprisonment registration and restitution question.
- 2:20All right. So one of the things that is a
- 2:23little striking that's different from the original draft NPA, even
- 2:27as amended by you. So let's pull out sixteen B.
- 2:31Is that what I would call the non admission of guilty.
- 2:34So the first page of sixteen B, the first paragraph,
- 2:38that's the first clause after the one through five statutes
- 2:41listing in sixteen B reads it appearing that Epstein has
- 2:45accepted a responsibility for his behavior by his signature on
- 2:49this agreement. Answer I'm sorry you're on sixteen B. Question
- 2:54sixteen B answer okay. It appearing yes question okay. So
- 3:00this is not, I mean, this is not to be
- 3:02fairly typical sort of plea agreement language right answer, right question.
- 3:06And if you look at the top of the final
- 3:08NPA twenty two to third it appearing clause sixteen B,
- 3:14it appearing he has that down at the bottom it
- 3:17says it refers to at the second up answer yes
- 3:22question exactly, he'd accepted a responsibility answer right question, and
- 3:27then above in the fourth it appearing it references the
- 3:31fact that it appearing Epstein has committed offenses against the
- 3:34United States. Answer yes question, okay. So there's a sense
- 3:39of acceptance of responsibility in the final NPA, which is
- 3:43twenty two in your right hand. Third, it appearing clause
- 3:47says nothing about Epstein committing offenses. It simply references the
- 3:51US Attorney's Office and the FBI having conducted their own
- 3:55investigation into Epstein's background and any offenses that may have
- 3:59been admitted by Epstein, including the enumerated statutes, and then
- 4:04following the enumerated federal statutes, there's no reference at all
- 4:07to Epstein accepting responsibility. Do you view that the removal
- 4:12of that acceptance or responsibility to be something that was appropriate? Answer? So,
- 4:18trying to reconstruct the focus was and I know I'm
- 4:22repeating myself, but jail time, registration, restitution, whether he accepted
- 4:28responsibility for a federal or a state, I think my
- 4:31focus would have been on these were the terms? Does
- 4:34this encompass those terms? Question? So as the concession is
- 4:38not something material as far as I don't want to
- 4:41use the legal term material, but it wasn't important to
- 4:44your objectives? Is that right? Answer? First, I'm not sure.
- 4:48So it wasn't a concession from that those four bullets, right,
- 4:52It was a concession from an earlier draft question right
- 4:55answer and to say it's not important to us. Again,
- 4:58there was an early draft changed. The focus was in
- 5:02any give and take draft change, the focus was did
- 5:05he go to jail? Did he have to register? Did
- 5:07he have restitution? Question? All right? Do you remember noticing
- 5:12that change and thinking it doesn't matter? Answer? I don't
- 5:16in all candor, until right now, I was not aware
- 5:19of that change. I doubt I would have taken two
- 5:22documents and sort of put them side by side, as
- 5:25opposed to does this capture what we're trying to get to? Question?
- 5:28And you're aware of the twenty four to eighteen because
- 5:31you noticed it in the NPA or because somebody told
- 5:34you separately? Or do you know? Answer? I can't say
- 5:38other than I was aware. Question in the final MPa
- 5:42on page five. There's a series of things that are
- 5:45included at the bottom of that page, in that long paragraph,
- 5:49and the one that I want to focus on is
- 5:51the immunity portion that was certainly not in the original
- 5:55draft proposed by the US Attorney's Office. In this paragraph,
- 5:58the US agrees that it will not institute any criminal
- 6:01charges against any potential co conspirators of Epstein, including but
- 6:06not limited to or redacted. Did you notice that provision? Answer?
- 6:10I don't recall focusing on the co conspirator provision. To
- 6:13the extent that I reviewed this co conspirator provision, I
- 6:16can speculate that my thinking would have been the focus
- 6:20is on Epstein. Epstein's going to jail. Whether some of
- 6:23the employees go to jail or other lesser involved is
- 6:26not the focus of this question. All right, This particular provision,
- 6:30as you know, has been enormously criticized. Answer enormous yes,
- 6:35question for a number of reasons, one of which is
- 6:38that it is a blanket transactional immunity. It gives blanket
- 6:42immunity to unnamed, unidentified potential co conspirators, people who, even
- 6:48in the future, if evidence is developed against them, as
- 6:50long as they could be considered co conspirators of Epstein
- 6:54in this conduct, they'd have a get out of jail
- 6:56free card. Do you have any idea where that came from?
- 7:00I don't, and I don't want to characterize it as
- 7:02giving I understand how it could be read that way
- 7:05in the record. I don't want to characterize it, but
- 7:08I don't know where this could have come from. I
- 7:11would have reviewed this for the policy concerns? Did it
- 7:14do the sort of bullet point? And my assumption, rightly
- 7:17or wrongly, would have been that redacted and redacted would
- 7:20have looked at this and that this was appropriate. I
- 7:24understand your point question, all right, And I believe the
- 7:27point you were referring to is that when I use
- 7:30the term jail get out of a jail free card,
- 7:32that you recognize this is limited to your district. Answer,
- 7:37and that's an important point, question of course, answer or recognize,
- 7:41and right here and there that kills Glenn Maxwell's argument. Folks,
- 7:45Remember she said that this covered her everywhere. No, it doesn't,
- 7:48just in the southern district of Florida, and that's already
- 7:52been determined by the appellate courts as well, question of course.
- 7:57But nonetheless, this does give blanket immunity of people. You
- 8:00have no idea who they might be. Correct if you
- 8:03had focused on it, would that have raised some questions
- 8:07in your mind? Answer? If there was a discussion like
- 8:10that we're having here, then it very possibly could have
- 8:13been raised. It's difficult to say it would have. But
- 8:16I understand your concern question, all right, And the named
- 8:20individuals redacted are all individuals who were described in the
- 8:24prosecution memo and so on, And the prosecution memo does
- 8:28identify that at least one of these women herself engage
- 8:31in sexual activity with a minor with minor girls. Answer yeah,
- 8:36question so that she has liability in and of her own. Answer, So,
- 8:41I don't have an independent recollection of that. But when
- 8:44I reviewed the prosecution memo, I did notice that. Question
- 8:47All right, now, you have told us this morning that
- 8:50you have no recollection of that actually having read the
- 8:53prosecution memo back at the time. Answer, I think I said,
- 8:57I don't have a recollection of whether I did or
- 8:59did not read the prosecution memo. I have since when
- 9:02you provided it, read it, and I note that it
- 9:05does reference her. Question having read it now, does that
- 9:09change your view of anything that we've talked about so
- 9:12far today? Answer? So reading it twelve years later, knowing
- 9:15all of this possibly, and part of it is, I
- 9:18do think we approach these cases differently, and I think
- 9:21these cases would play out very differently in court today.
- 9:25I think it's very difficult to sort of go back
- 9:27and recreate a thought process from twelve years ago. Question,
- 9:32And if you are relying back then on the characterization
- 9:34in summary, and are accounting of this case to you
- 9:37by your people, your senior people redacted and in particular redacted,
- 9:42Would you do you, do you have or did anyone
- 9:44in that ground, including redacted LORI, in any way to
- 9:48your recollection, characterize the case as not serious, or as trivial,
- 9:53or involving non important, unimportant victims in any way to
- 9:57try to diminish either the conduct or the victims. Answer
- 10:01not to my recollection. I do think there was a
- 10:04concern as how the victims would present in court given
- 10:07impeachment and given contradictory statements, But that's different than trivializing
- 10:12the case. Question all right back to the immunity provision.
- 10:16Were you aware that none of the four name co
- 10:18conspirators had cooperated? Answer? I was not. Question And do
- 10:22you recall any other case in which blanket immunity in
- 10:26the US Attorney's office, in which blanket immunity really without
- 10:30virtually without limitation was granted. Answer I don't recall discussion
- 10:35around this provision and in general matter, I did not
- 10:38discuss this In typical cases that came that bubbled up
- 10:41to my level. The focus was on who the prime,
- 10:45you know, target is and not on what we could
- 10:48do with the co conspirators, and so I don't recall,
- 10:51But that doesn't mean it didn't happen. That's just not
- 10:53typically something that I got involved with. Question And likewise,
- 10:57non immunity being given to non cooperate co conspirators or
- 11:01code defendants, is that something that was done in your office? Answer? Again,
- 11:07as a typical matter, I did not get involved with these.
- 11:10But let me also say that this wasn't a federal
- 11:13prosecution in the first place, and so this whole thing
- 11:17in suiy generous to some extent. Question it is, but
- 11:22the grant of immunity is real, right answer. I understand
- 11:25where you're coming from. Question all right, if you had
- 11:28focused on that provision, would you have insisted it come out? Answer?
- 11:33One question I would have had is if we're naming
- 11:36as I sit here in sort of focus as we
- 11:38are now, But this is with the benefit of hindsight
- 11:41and criticism. If there are specific folks, why do we
- 11:44have any potential language because that seems quite broad. Question.
- 11:49It's without limitation as to people as long as they
- 11:52are co conspirators, right answer. But so what is the
- 11:57need for that question, okay, and I would so if
- 12:01we had this kind of discussion, I would be sending
- 12:03an email saying, what's the need for this? What's up? Question?
- 12:08But to be clear, as we sit here today, you
- 12:10have no recollection of having noticed that answer. I don't
- 12:13have recollection of if I read over it, my assumption
- 12:17would have been that redacted and redacted thought this through
- 12:20and sort of addressed it for that reason. Question all right,
- 12:24and if and by did you have any anyone ever
- 12:28come to you with the evidentiary issues and say we
- 12:31need to track this down before we give such blanket
- 12:33immunity answer, I don't recall any conversations around co conspirators.
- 12:39All right, folks, we're going to wrap this episode up
- 12:41right here, and then the next episode dealing with the topic,
- 12:44we're going to pick up where we left off. All
- 12:47of the information that goes with this episode can be
- 12:49found in the description box.