Latest / Her Chapter: Real stories of women, courage & change / Leaving the Church That Raised Me Behind Forever | Her Chapter
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that follows you out of a church door for the last time. It’s not peaceful. It’s heavy. You know that feeling when you’re standing in the parking lot, engine running, but you don’t turn the key? The one where your hands are on the steering wheel, knuckles white, and you’re waiting for permission to leave. Permission from God, maybe. Or permission from your mother. Or permission from the version of yourself that used to believe if you just sang loud enough, prayed hard enough, and kept your head down, everything would be okay. I want you to take a breath right now. In through the nose, out through the mouth. Let’s sit with that for a second. Because leaving the church that raised you isn’t like quitting a job. You can’t just send an email. You don’t get a final paycheck. You lose your Sunday best, your Wednesday night study group, your mentorship circle, and sometimes, you lose the people who held your baby when it wouldn’t stop crying. I remember the first time I walked out. It was a Tuesday. Small group was meeting at six. I had my notebook open on my lap, pen hovering over the page, ready to write down what the speaker said about submission and sacrifice. But my hand just stopped. The air in that living room felt suddenly thin, like oxygen had been sucked out by a vacuum cleaner. I looked around at these women—these good, kind, loving women—and I didn’t see sisters anymore. I saw jailers. Not because they were mean. They weren’t. That’s the hardest part. They loved me. They baked me casseroles when I was sick. They cried with me when I lost my job. But their love came with a condition. And that condition was that I had to shrink myself to fit into a box that was always too small. I stood up. My knees popped. I said, "I’m going home." And I walked out. No one stopped me. No one even looked up. That indifference hurt more than any shout ever could. We talk a lot about grief here, don’t we? But there is a very specific type of grief that happens when you leave a religious community. It’s complicated because society doesn’t give you a script for it. If your marriage ends, people bring soup. If you lose a parent, people send flowers. But if you leave the faith that shaped your entire moral compass, your social calendar, and your understanding of who you are… people tell you to be careful. They say, "Are you sure? Maybe you’re just angry." They imply that your doubt is a phase, a temporary spiritual malaise that will pass if you just try harder. But it doesn’t pass. It solidifies. I spent months trying to explain this to my aunt. She’s a sweet woman, devout, the kind of person who prays over every meal and believes that suffering is always a lesson. I told her, "Aunt Martha, I don’t feel like I’m learning. I feel like I’m disappearing." And she looked at me with those sad, pitying eyes and said, "Oh, honey. The devil is working overtime on you right now." Can you imagine? To be told that your awakening is actually an attack. That your search for truth is actually a trap. I had to grieve the loss of certainty. That’s what hurts the most. Not the rules. Not the politics. The certainty. For thirty years, I knew exactly why I was here. I knew what happened after death. I knew what constituted good and evil. It was a binary world. Black and white. Clean lines. Leaving that meant stepping into a fog. A gray, messy, uncomfortable fog where I had to decide for myself what mattered. Was kindness more important than purity? Was justice more important than tradition? Who gets to define those words? I didn’t have answers. I only had questions. And for a long time, I was terrified of the silence that followed those questions. I missed the hymns. I missed the structure. I missed knowing that someone else had the map, even if I hated the destination. Let’s talk about fear. Real fear. Not the kind that makes you jump at a loud noise, but the kind that lives in your chest, a low hum that never quite turns off. When you leave the church, you carry with you a lifetime of warnings. You’ve heard them since you were five years old. You’ve been told that outside those walls, there is only chaos. That without God’s protection, you are vulnerable to every bad idea, every temptation, every disaster life can throw at you. I remember driving past the local strip club after I left, and I felt a physical flinch. My body reacted before my brain did. I thought, "This is what I’m becoming." This is what happens when you internalize shame. You start to believe that your natural instincts are dangerous. That your desire for autonomy is sinful. I had to unlearn that. I had to learn that enjoying a drink with friends wasn’t a slide toward hell. That questioning authority wasn’t a sign of weakness. That having doubts wasn’t a crack in the foundation, but the light getting in. Rumi said that, you know? The light getting in. It sounds cliché until it’s your life. Until you realize that the cracks were letting in enough light to finally see the dust motes dancing in the air. See how beautiful the mess is. It took me two years to stop expecting the sky to fall. Two years of waiting for the lightning bolt. The sudden financial ruin. The tragic accident. The divine punishment. And nothing happened. I got a promotion. I fell in love with a man who asked me what I believed, not what I should believe. I learned to cook meals that didn’t involve three hours of prep time because fasting was considered holy. I lived. And slowly, the fear lost its teeth. It became manageable. It became background noise. But it didn’t disappear overnight. If you are in that space right now, if you are sitting in your car in the parking lot, or lying in bed staring at the ceiling, wondering if you’re making a terrible mistake… I want you to know that the sky has not fallen. It hasn’t. The earth is still holding you up. Gravity works whether you’re praying or not. Physics doesn’t care about your denomination. And neither should you. One of the hardest parts of leaving is rewriting your own history. You look back at your childhood memories, and they’re stained with theology. Every birthday party feels like a celebration of God’s provision. Every triumph feels like a reward for obedience. How do you separate the joy from the doctrine? How do you keep the love while discarding the lie? I struggled with this for a long time. I felt like I was erasing myself. Like if I stopped saying "bless you" every time I sneezed, I was disrespecting the people who raised me. But then I realized something. Keeping the language didn’t keep the love. It just kept the performance. I started to reclaim my narrative. I began to notice the moments that weren’t about God. The time my dad taught me to ride a bike. That was just him. He was tired. He was scared I’d fall. He wasn’t thinking about scripture; he was thinking about my safety. The time I found peace in nature. That wasn’t a sermon; that was trees and wind and quiet. I started to collect those moments. I put them in my worn notebook, the one I carry everywhere. I wrote them down as mine. Just mine. Not gifts from heaven. Just human experiences. Beautiful, fleeting, precious human experiences. It felt radical. It felt dangerous. Like I was stealing something back. And maybe I was. I was stealing back my agency. My ability to say, "This made me happy," without adding a footnote about gratitude to a higher power. It’s a slow process. You stumble. You slip back into old habits. You’ll catch yourself apologizing to God when you trip over a rug. You’ll feel guilty for enjoying art that isn’t explicitly religious. But you keep going. You keep writing your own story. And eventually, the ink dries. And you realize that you are the author. Not Him. Not her. You. Now, I won’t lie to you. Leaving the church creates a void. A huge, echoing void. You need connection. We are wired for it. And when you walk away from the largest social network you’ve ever known, it’s lonely. Terrifyingly lonely. I moved to a new city, and I had no one. No one to call at 2 AM. No one to ask for advice on raising kids. No one to watch my dog while I went on vacation. So I had to build something new. And it was messy. I joined a book club. I volunteered at a food bank. I sat in coffee shops and pretended to read while watching people. I was looking for signals. Looking for other people who seemed slightly out of place. Slightly unsure. And I found them. They weren’t wearing matching t-shirts. They didn’t have a structured curriculum. They didn’t promise me eternal life. They promised me presence. They listened. They validated my pain. They didn’t try to fix me with a verse. They just sat with me in the dark. Take your time there. That’s a heavy one. Building a community from scratch is exhausting work. You have to be vulnerable with strangers. You have to risk rejection. What if they don’t like the real you? What if they find out you’re full of questions? But the beauty of chosen family is that it’s chosen. It’s not based on geography or obligation. It’s based on resonance. On shared values that you’ve defined for yourself. Kindness. Curiosity. Honesty. These are the pillars of my new community. And they are stronger than any creed I ever memorized. I’m learning that belonging isn’t something you’re given. It’s something you create. Together. With people who see you, all of you, and stay anyway. Thank you for listening. Thank you for trusting me with your time and your heart. You are not alone in this journey. However you’re defining your next chapter, may it be written with courage, clarity, and deep, abiding love for yourself. I’ll be right here, listening, whenever you need to speak. Until next time, take care of each other.