Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 20)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:07where we left off with alex Acosta and his interview
- 0:10with the OIG inspectors. Question. Okay, let's get back on track.
- 0:16The question that I asked earlier about allowing the defense
- 0:19the courtesy to look at these letters. Can you just
- 0:21remind us again, what was the reasoning that you're allowed
- 0:26to look at the victim notification letter. Answer? I can't
- 0:29speak to that. That's something that redacted and redacted would
- 0:33have handled. I think that you know, I'm responsible for
- 0:36the office. I'm not shirking. I'm just saying that this
- 0:39that this for the most part, is within their willhouse
- 0:42and not something that I was involved in. I can
- 0:45speculate question, sure, answer, the agreement was notifying them. The
- 0:50letter was notifying them of certain rights in the agreement,
- 0:53and therefore this is the time we weren't sure what
- 0:57was happening with the agreement, and so perhaps this is
- 1:00a way to address some of the concerns around the
- 1:02twenty two to fifty five I don't know, I'm just speculating. Question. Okay,
- 1:07let's move on to Exhibit thirty six. This is a
- 1:10letter that goes out to left Kowitz under a redacted signature.
- 1:14You are c seed on the letter. Answer all right, question,
- 1:18And what he's doing is sending a draft victim notification
- 1:20letter which is attached as the attachment there dated December sixth,
- 1:24two thousand and seven. And I wanted to get your impression.
- 1:27If you go to page three of the letter, please
- 1:30the first little paragraph there when it refers to the
- 1:34Victims' Rights and Restitution Act and the ultimate for the CBRA.
- 1:38If you could just read the paragraph to yourself, please
- 1:41answer are you referring to paragraph ten? Question? I'm sorry,
- 1:45I'm on the letter left the letter left Kuwitz, not
- 1:49the draft letter, this one right here? Answer the additionally
- 1:53question yes, additionally pursuing too the Victims' Rights and Restitution
- 1:58Act of nineteen ninety Our office is obligated, etc. Answer Okay.
- 2:03Question do you agree with the language that interpretation of
- 2:07the victims' rights as far as the notification? Answer, So
- 2:11let's sort of take this this one sentence out of time.
- 2:14With respect to the notification of other information that we
- 2:17were supposed to disclose. The statute requires that we provide
- 2:20victims with the earliest possible notice. I will assume that
- 2:24this is a restatement of the statute. I don't have
- 2:28it in front of me, but let's assume that that's
- 2:31a restatement of the statute. Just as in eighteen, these
- 2:33sections are not limited to the victim through the Federal
- 2:37should be appropriately informed that a non pros does not
- 2:41require to forego its legal obligation on a sentence by
- 2:44sentence basis. I mean, do I agree sitting here, sure,
- 2:48but I would want to sort of sit down before
- 2:50I gave a legal opinion and spend more time with it.
- 2:53He gets cut off. Question Okay, because coming out of
- 2:56your office sort of this. Well, let's go to the
- 2:59next page, page four. There's a citation to the right
- 3:02to confer in the first paragraph there, citing the cvra's
- 3:06reasonable right to confer with the attorneys of the government
- 3:09in the case. Answer, okay, question, so you know it
- 3:12looks like to me, I mean, well, it appears that
- 3:16there is two references to the CVRA obligation that the
- 3:19government has that ultimately the government argues that it did
- 3:23not have. Can you explain why that is a correct interpretation? Answer? So,
- 3:28what I can say, is I recall, so it looks
- 3:30like at least some of the victims were notified. I
- 3:34recall a discussion and a view that the CVRA did
- 3:37not require it and it was discretionary because it wasn't
- 3:40the case had not indicted, so it did not attach
- 3:43to its terms. Now that doesn't mean that it's not
- 3:46something to aspire to. That just means it wasn't legally binding. Question.
- 3:51And in the same manner though, while the CVRA isn't
- 3:54legally binding, it's also doesn't prevent you from notifying the victims.
- 3:58Does it answer? It does not know question? And you
- 4:02have the discretion to notify should you choose to answer
- 4:06correct question? Okay? And so if you look at the
- 4:09letter that's attached to this, this is a draft that
- 4:12goes out. We're on page one, page three of the letter,
- 4:16and the second to last paragraph the letter is giving
- 4:18notice of mister Epstein's change of plea and sentencing that
- 4:22will occur well at this time it was December fourteenth
- 4:26of two thousand and seven, and it gives the address
- 4:28and it says underneath there you are entitled to be
- 4:30present and make a statement under oath if you choose.
- 4:34You can submit a written statement under oath et cetera,
- 4:37et cetera. So this is a letter that's actively inviting
- 4:40victims to come to the state. Would you agree that
- 4:44that's inviting victims to come to the state? Plea? Answer?
- 4:47I think that's fair question. And with the letter is
- 4:51reasoning that the government is sending, would like to send
- 4:54this letter because it believes it's obligated to because it
- 4:57resolves a federal case. Answer, So I don't want to
- 5:00speak to the reasoning, but it's clearly a draft that
- 5:04the government is saying it intends to send. Question. Okay, Now, ultimately,
- 5:09just this is not a question some information that will
- 5:12help to move us along. Obviously this letter is never
- 5:16sent misredacted drafts. We have them, and I'm not going
- 5:20to show them to you. Thirty letters, copies of the
- 5:22letters to different victims, addresses them, puts them in envelopes,
- 5:26and is then told not to send the letters. Answer
- 5:30all right, well, the plea. It's scheduled for December fourteenth,
- 5:33So yeah, question yes, But one of the issues that's
- 5:37still percolating until the end of December is who is
- 5:40going to make this notification? Because, as you can expect
- 5:43the defense pushes back on the letter, and so now
- 5:46we go to the number thirty nine please, And this
- 5:49is a December eleventh, two thousand and seven letter from
- 5:51Ken Star to you. And if you look on page
- 5:54two at the front at the top, at the top
- 5:56of the page, there this letter is complaining about an
- 5:59oral noteif that misreadacted gave to one of the defense,
- 6:03one of the victim's attorneys, that a letter would be coming,
- 6:06and so mister Starr is writing you to complain about it.
- 6:10And he mentions in later paragraphs that we have thought
- 6:13that the notification process had been an abeyance until completion
- 6:17of our ongoing discussions with respect to that process. So
- 6:22were you having discussions with mister Starr about the process
- 6:25at this time? Answer? I don't recall discussions. I think
- 6:29there were at least correspondents. I'm sorry, Where are you?
- 6:32I was reading the letter. I'm sorry, where are you?
- 6:35What paragraph? Question? Let's take a look. I know it's
- 6:38been a long day. Let's slow down here. We're on
- 6:40the second page of the Star letter. Answer yes, question,
- 6:45and it would be this the language in there in
- 6:48the second sentence, which goes towards the bottom answer, this notification,
- 6:53but quite apart from our substantive concerns, which we had
- 6:56thought the notification process had been an abeyance until completion,
- 7:01that appears not to be so, this is respectably, So,
- 7:05where does it imply that I was having I don't
- 7:07recall communication with mister Starr. That's why I'm curious, at
- 7:11least verbal communications. I'm curious where you're reading that from question.
- 7:17He's saying we had thought that the notification process had
- 7:20been held in abeyance until completion of our ongoing discussions.
- 7:24Are you saying that he gets cut off there by
- 7:26a star answer? So, I don't know where that may
- 7:29have come from. And I don't recall I recall at
- 7:32one point I think I sent a letter saying we'll
- 7:34hold off for a week. I don't recall the date
- 7:36of the letter. While your review some matters where the
- 7:39abeyance came from, I can't speak to question. Okay, let's
- 7:42go to Exhibit forty one B. This is your December
- 7:45nineteenth letter, and what I'd like you to draw your
- 7:48attention to is page two, the second to last paragraph
- 7:52there answer, yes, question, so could you tell us how
- 7:55your decision making around this paragraph. How you got to
- 7:59this decision? Answer, so you're asking me to recreate at
- 8:03some point the issues clearly move from reacted interacting with
- 8:06defense counsel to my desk and my recollection twelve years
- 8:10after the fact. Is so you're saying we shouldn't notify
- 8:13them about the state proceeding. And sure, the state this
- 8:16was negotiated between Epstein and the state attorney. We did
- 8:21not direct the state proceeding. So whatever state process is
- 8:24appropriate for the state process will be given. But with
- 8:27respect to the federal resolution, we intend to provide victims
- 8:30with notice of the federal resolution as required by law.
- 8:34And your question is if we thought it was discretionary.
- 8:38I recall our believing it was discretionary, but you could
- 8:41also it doesn't hurt to when a letter say we're
- 8:44kind of required to do this, and I think it
- 8:46was the right thing to do, and to provide them
- 8:48with notice of federal resolution. And once that resolution was reached,
- 8:53and part of the key word is what the resolution is,
- 8:56my understanding is that Redacted made efforts to notify victims
- 9:00of that resolution and let them know that there would
- 9:03be a hearing the following Monday, and that they should
- 9:06attend because it would bring an end to the case. Question, Well,
- 9:11let's just back up real quick as far as the
- 9:14state attorney notifying people victims of the state resolution, did
- 9:18you have any concern with any particular part of it? Answer? So,
- 9:22it's difficult to recreate the thought process twelve years later,
- 9:25but ultimately you've got federal and you've got state, and
- 9:29the state attorney will do what the state attorney thinks
- 9:31is appropriate. It's not for me to direct the state attorney.
- 9:35I'm inferring based on this language, it's not for me
- 9:37to direct the state attorney or for our office to
- 9:41direct the State Attorney's office on its obligation with respect
- 9:44to the state outcome. Question Okay, I'm just asking because
- 9:48you know, the whole case came to the office because
- 9:52of some issue with the state attorney's resolution of the case.
- 9:55So now it's going back and they're going to be
- 9:57in charge of the notification. Did that raise any red
- 10:00flags with you or did you have any concern about
- 10:02whether it would be done correctly or done at all? Answer? So, again,
- 10:07this has come up in different contexts, and I think
- 10:10there was obviously a concern about how he was being charged.
- 10:13But that doesn't mean that they will not fulfill whatever
- 10:15obligations they have. Let's not assume that the state attorney's
- 10:20office is full of bad actors. Question. Okay, but even
- 10:24if I'm not assuming that they're full of bad actors,
- 10:28it's going to be difficult for them to notify the victims.
- 10:30Wasn't it that they didn't even necessarily know the same
- 10:33list as the federal victims because you had found more
- 10:36victims answers, so we could certainly have shared the list
- 10:40with them. I mean, there are ways that this could
- 10:42have happened. I don't know how what the communications were,
- 10:46but as a conceptual matter, having the state notify them
- 10:49of the state hearing and having the federal government say
- 10:52that this is the federal resolution is consistent with the law. Question,
- 10:57But since the federal resolution is tied to this date plea,
- 11:00why not just combine the two of them in the notification.
- 11:04Here's the federal resolution, we're tying it to the state plea,
- 11:08and here's the date of the state plea. Answer. I
- 11:11can't speak to why or why not? I can you know,
- 11:13I can speak to my belief that this would be
- 11:15consistent with the law that could also be one approach.
- 11:19I can't speak as to why a versus b question.
- 11:24Did somebody instruct you that or did you have a
- 11:26conversation consulting with somebody about whether this was a better approach?
- 11:30Answer I would have said, you know, based on practice,
- 11:33not recollection, but based on practice. I would have sat
- 11:36down with redacted, most likely since he was handling this matter,
- 11:40and we would have talked about it. I would not
- 11:42have sent this without running it by at least redacted,
- 11:45if not other individuals in the office. I don't know
- 11:48if based on your record there are emails with drafts,
- 11:51but you know, every document that I'm aware of was
- 11:53sort of shared within the management team, and this would
- 11:56have been one of those. Question with respect to the
- 11:59one specif decision about this should be at the discretion
- 12:03of the state's attorney, did you consult with anybody in
- 12:05DC about the issue? Answer? I don't recall consulting with
- 12:09someone in DC about the issue. I recall general perspective
- 12:13that the CVRA as a technical matter did not attach
- 12:16because ultimately this was not an indictment. Question. Oh, can
- 12:22we before we leave? This letter gets cut off again
- 12:25by a costa if I could. I understand your questions,
- 12:29but I feel some obligation to erase the tension between
- 12:32did you consult in DC versus should you allow DC
- 12:35to review? And so, just so you know, we certainly
- 12:39were allowing review, but US Attorney's Office don't consult on
- 12:42every matter, especially offices that have the kind of experience
- 12:47that Miami does. Question. Before we finish with the letter
- 12:51from the nineteenth, can we look at page three please?
- 12:55If you could read the first paragraph on page three
- 12:57to yourself, please answer, okay? Could you in that section
- 13:02you mentioned that prosecutors that ask you to declare a
- 13:05breach and you resisted. Can you discuss that answer? Sure,
- 13:09that's referencing I think increasing frustration by the prosecutors, and
- 13:13I think that's reflected in contemporaneous emails saying why don't
- 13:17we just rip this up? And I recall conversations with redacted,
- 13:21And that goes a little bit to what we talked
- 13:23about earlier, which is concerned that a unilateral breach would
- 13:27overlay not just the initial issues that we had, and
- 13:30not just the fact that the victims are getting older
- 13:32and the case isn't getting better. But then we have
- 13:36was the unilateral breach a valid breach or was it
- 13:39not a valid breach? And is the delay justified or
- 13:43not justified? And ultimately that additional liability, well not liability,
- 13:48that additional legal uncertainty would have made the case even
- 13:51harder because they were very careful to always say there
- 13:55is no breach. Let me address because I went on
- 13:59to read the next paragraph as well, and so let
- 14:01me circle back to an earlier issue, because I at
- 14:04least want to address it, because the next paragraph then says,
- 14:07and it's clearer that I'm increasingly frustrated that my frustration
- 14:12with it appears to be an eleventh hour appeal weeks
- 14:15before then, now schedule July eleventh flea date. That said,
- 14:19the issues raised are important and must be fully vetted,
- 14:22irrespective of timeline concerns. We hope to preserve the July
- 14:26fourth date. I understand Defense counsel with this in mind,
- 14:30and in the event the Defense counsel may wish to
- 14:32seek review of our determination in Washington. I spoke this
- 14:36past Monday with Attorney General redacted, confirming if it's possible,
- 14:40appearing to ask her to grant the potential request for
- 14:43review and to the fact review this case in an
- 14:47expedited manner, in an attempt to preserve the July fourth date.
- 14:51He gets corrected January fourth. The address that address January Acosta,
- 14:57I'm sorry the January fourth plea date question, and that
- 15:02addressed the question I was asking answer, and that goes
- 15:05to the question you're asking, and again I'm recreating and
- 15:08I'm speculating having that following another eleventh hour appeal here
- 15:13I would say, I wouldn't say, let's appeal to this again.
- 15:17I think I'm saying pretty clearly it's against my frustration
- 15:20with what appears to be an eleventh hour appeal weeks
- 15:23before the now scheduled January fourth plea date. And this
- 15:27is not an invitation to do another appeal, because the
- 15:30appeal is already in DC. But my if we're going
- 15:35to do this appeal, let's get it over and done with.
- 15:37Then I'm sort of speculating based on the language, so
- 15:40that we can get this played on January fourth, and
- 15:43let's not put it off until after the holidays. Question.
- 15:47But you did say to ask her to grant the
- 15:49potential request for review. Answer, which is why I wanted
- 15:52to on my own raise it, because is that saying
- 15:55please appeal me, or is that saying this is an
- 15:58eleventh hour appeal that you have now taken to DC.
- 16:02It's December nineteenth, we're about to go into the holidays.
- 16:05There's a January fourth plea date. This should not be
- 16:08another way to put it off. And so if you're
- 16:10going to do this, I'm going to try to expedite
- 16:12it so we can get this done. Question. In fact,
- 16:16it took until May answer. Yeah, answer it did And apologies,
- 16:21I just realized my voice question all right rising. So
- 16:24I don't know if that's my frustration at reading this
- 16:27again or it's getting late, but it was a frustrating matter. Apologies.
- 16:32All right, folks. We're going to wrap up right here,
- 16:34and in the next episode dealing with the topic, we're
- 16:36going to pick up where we left off. All of
- 16:39the information that goes with this episode can be found
- 16:42in the description box.