Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the IKEA Effect Shapes Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: So you walk into a meeting. Emma from marketing presents a campaign idea she's been working on for three weeks. It's got a massive hole in it — the target demographic doesn't match the channel. Everyone sees it. But Emma defends it like it's her child. Luna: Right. And the more she talks, the more entrenched she gets. It's painful to watch. Lucas: Classic IKEA effect. We value things more when we've put effort into creating them. The name comes from the furniture — you assemble a Billy bookcase yourself, and suddenly you're convinced it's better than a pre-built one from a proper carpenter. Luna: It sounds like the same reason I won't throw away that casserole I burned last week. I spent two hours on it. Lucas: Exactly. In the workplace, this bias is everywhere. A 2011 study by Norton, Mochon, and Ariely showed that people who built IKEA boxes — and actually assembled them — valued them as much as expert-built boxes. Their effort inflated their subjective worth. Luna: Okay, so what does that look like in a real office? Not just a box. Lucas: Let's take a product team I know of — a mid-sized SaaS company, about 200 people. They spent six months building a feature for enterprise clients. The engineering lead was deeply invested. But after launch, adoption was below five percent. The data was clear: kill it. Luna: Let me guess — they kept it alive for another year. Lucas: Fourteen months. They poured another three hundred thousand dollars into it. Every quarterly review, the same debate. 'We just need to tweak the onboarding.' 'We haven't marketed it properly.' All rationalizations driven by the IKEA effect — they loved what they'd built. Luna: And nobody wanted to be the one who killed the team's baby. That's a political minefield. Lucas: That's the double challenge. The bias is internal — you genuinely overvalue your work — but it's also social. Attacking someone's idea feels like attacking them. So the bad idea survives on politeness. Luna: So how do you use this for good, not just avoid the trap? Can you harness the IKEA effect to get buy-in? Lucas: Absolutely. If you want someone to support your initiative, let them contribute. Let them shape a detail, write a paragraph, choose a color. Their ownership goes up, and they'll defend your project as if it were theirs. Luna: That's the old saying: 'People support what they help create.' I've seen that work in my own teams. When we let the sales team tweak the pricing slide, they sold it harder. Lucas: Right. But you have to be subtle. If it's obvious you're just trying to manipulate them, it backfires. Authentic co-creation — you genuinely want their input — that's where the magic lives. Luna: What about when you need to kill someone's pet project? How do you disarm the IKEA effect without making an enemy? Lucas: You have to separate the identity from the idea. Start by acknowledging the effort. 'I know you've put a lot of heart into this, and I see the thinking behind it.' Then frame the decision around external constraints, not the idea's worth. 'The market has shifted, and our data shows this path has a lower probability of success.' Luna: So you're not saying it's a bad idea. You're saying the situation changed. Lucas: Exactly. You also give them a graceful exit. 'What part of this approach could we salvage for the next project?' That way they don't lose everything they built. Luna: That's the opposite of what happened in that SaaS company. They doubled down. Lucas: Because nobody gave them an off-ramp. The CEO eventually stepped in, but by then the resentment was high. A middle-ground approach — let the team 'retire' the feature with a ceremony, celebrate what they learned — that would have preserved relationships. Luna: You know, this reminds me of something I read about Pixar. They have a 'plussing' technique — instead of saying 'this doesn't work,' they say 'I like the part where... and what if we added...' It builds on the effort already invested. Lucas: That's brilliant. You're leveraging the IKEA effect to improve the idea rather than scrap it. The person stays invested, and the output gets better. Luna: And we should mention — if you're the one with the pet project, you have to watch for this bias in yourself. Ask yourself: 'Would I still love this idea if someone else had proposed it?' Lucas: Hard question to answer honestly. I try to get an outside perspective early. Show the work to someone who wasn't involved in the creation. Their reaction is a gut check. Luna: If we've helped you think through a career move or a sticky office situation like this one, there's a small way you can keep these conversations going. Lucas: Yeah, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these episodes ad-free and independent. If you've gotten something out of them, you can head to buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: It really does make a difference. We've had listeners say they listened to an episode right before a tough conversation and it changed the outcome. Lucas: So back to the IKEA effect — one more practical take. When you're proposing a change, involve the people who will be affected early. Let them design the new process. Their effort creates buy-in, and you avoid the resistance that comes from 'this was imposed on us.' Luna: That's a huge political win. The change lands softer because people feel it's partly theirs. Lucas: I saw this at a manufacturing plant. They needed to switch to a new inventory system. Instead of rolling it out top-down, the plant manager formed a committee of floor workers to configure the dashboard. The workers loved it — they'd built it. Adoption rate was over ninety percent in the first month. Luna: Compare that to the typical rollout where people complain for six months. Lucas: Exactly. The IKEA effect is a force multiplier when used right. It's not just a bias to avoid — it's a tool for alignment. Luna: What about situations where you can't involve everyone? Say you're in a big company and a decision is already made by leadership. How do you handle the resentment? Lucas: Then you create ownership in the implementation. 'We can't change the what, but we can decide the how.' Give them a choice in the rollout order, the communication plan, the training. Even a small area of control triggers the IKEA effect. Luna: So it's about finding any sliver of co-creation. Lucas: Yes. And it's honest. You're not pretending they have more influence than they do. You're giving them real autonomy within the constraints. Luna: One last question — does the IKEA effect apply to work that's purely mental? Like, I wrote a report, I designed a strategy — there's no physical assembly. Lucas: It applies even more. Mental effort is deeply personal. Your ideas feel like extensions of you. That's why feedback on a strategy document can sting more than feedback on a chair you assembled. Luna: So when you give feedback on that report, you need to handle the IKEA effect too. Lucas: Absolutely. Start with what you value. 'Section three has a really sharp analysis.' Then ask a question: 'Have we considered the counterargument on page five?' That invites them to adjust without making them defensive. Luna: And if you do that consistently, people will trust you with their work. They'll know you're not attacking their baby — you're helping them build a better one. Lucas: That's the real office politics win. Not manipulating people, but respecting the effort they've put in while steering toward a better outcome. Luna: Alright, so next time I'm in a meeting and someone is over-defending their idea, I'll think: that's the IKEA effect, and I'll handle it with care. Lucas: And next time you're the one defending, take a breath and ask yourself if you'd still love it if someone else built it. Luna: Tough test. But worth it. Lucas: Alright, that's our episode on the IKEA effect in office politics. Until next time, pay attention to what you've built — and what you're about to build.