Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #54: Do We Really Want Political Compromise?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan, nonideological
- 0:05discussion of politics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about compromise in politics.
- 0:12Is this something we really want?
- 0:14In 2023, Georgetown University's battleground civility poll results showed 83% of respondents
- 0:22agreed that compromise and common ground should be the goal for political leaders, But 82% of
- 0:29respondents also agreed that they are tired of leaders compromising their values and want
- 0:34leaders who will stand up to the other side.
- 0:37And that was just one of the seeming contradictions in people's beliefs on the need
- 0:42for compromise.
- 0:44And that's just one of the inspirations for today's topic.
- 0:48Do we really want compromise in politics?
- 0:53On the one hand, it is important to have convictions that you really strongly believe
- 0:57in, that you really stand up for.
- 1:00There is some truth to the common phrase, if you don't stand for something, you'll fall for
- 1:04anything.
- 1:05You have to have a belief in something so that you can effectively advocate for it.
- 1:10But on the other hand, there is a considerable stubbornness that is rampant in today's
- 1:16politics.
- 1:17The very idea of even considering compromise is considered weak and even traitorous by many of
- 1:24the loudest voices in politics.
- 1:26It's an all or nothing approach.
- 1:30So where is this fine line between being strong in your convictions and being willing to
- 1:36compromise?
- 1:37What does public opinion polling say further about citizens' desire for compromise?
- 1:43What are some major historical compromises?
- 1:46What makes compromise more likely or more unlikely?
- 1:52What are some groups that are working on compromise?
- 1:55And how do we move forward as a country regarding compromise?
- 2:00Let's talk about it.
- 2:01So first of all, what exactly is compromise?
- 2:04That seems very obvious, but we need to be clear about what we actually mean.
- 2:09I've talked about it before on the podcast, how it's important to define the words that we're
- 2:13actually trying to figure out how to address them.
- 2:18So basic definition is simply a situation like a public policy through passage of a bill where
- 2:25two or more sides with conflicting views agree to some concessions in order to achieve a
- 2:32solution.
- 2:33So need to think about questions like who is making the compromise?
- 2:38A lot of people think of compromise as between democrat and republican, which obviously, yes,
- 2:43that those are compromises that need to be had and are had, but it can also be within a party
- 2:49as well.
- 2:50Sometimes republicans compromise with each other or democrats compromise with each other.
- 2:55You have more ideological to the left democrats and a more moderate democrats.
- 3:01You have more ideological to the right Republicans and a more moderate Republicans.
- 3:07And even in state governments where one party is dominant, different factions have to make
- 3:12concessions on what they want.
- 3:14So we'll talk a little bit more about some of those specific situations or more general
- 3:20situations.
- 3:22Another question to think about, how much does the magnitude of the compromise matter?
- 3:27So in other words, how far reaching is the compromise?
- 3:30Is it on one tiny facet of a policy or on a broad overall policy?
- 3:36What if we're talking about an entire budget for the government or just one project having
- 3:42money being spent on it.
- 3:46Is compromise only about the end results of a policy, or can the very act of opening dialogue
- 3:53also be considered as part of a compromise?
- 3:55Now, obviously, just having dialogue does not lead to any tangible results.
- 4:02But at the very least, can there be say, okay.
- 4:05We're at least listening to what other people have to say and genuinely doing so, not just
- 4:10taking any sort of feedback and saying, okay, yeah, we'll do something about it.
- 4:16And then they never actually do anything about it.
- 4:19Just how much does that matter for when we're talking about compromise?
- 4:24Is someone compromising more than another person?
- 4:28How do you even quantify that?
- 4:30Oh, this person's giving up two concessions, but this other person's giving up three or this
- 4:37person's giving up two small concessions, and then this other person's making up one big
- 4:42concession.
- 4:43How do you define that?
- 4:45How do you quantify that?
- 4:47Our answers to all these questions can influence what we see as a compromise or how
- 4:52much compromising there is.
- 4:54So what about some famous historical compromises that we've seen, at least for US
- 5:00history?
- 5:01Because American history is littered with compromises, many that we don't even realize
- 5:06were compromises or that have been lost to history.
- 5:09But we'll just focus on a few of the most well known examples, and some of them are good
- 5:14compromises.
- 5:15Some of them are not so good compromises.
- 5:18Some are in between.
- 5:19Biggest one that you can look at is the US constitution.
- 5:22Really, the US constitution is a giant compromise containing several smaller
- 5:27compromises, but we'll highlight several of the biggest ones here.
- 5:30The very structure of congress was a compromise.
- 5:35You had two competing plans generally speaking for the structure of congress.
- 5:41You had the Virginia plan, which would have been two chambers representation proportional
- 5:45to state size.
- 5:46So that benefited large population states like Virginia or New York.
- 5:52Obviously, smaller states didn't like that because it would have severely diminished their
- 5:57power, especially when you come from the articles of confederation where each state had
- 6:01one vote on policies pertaining to the nation.
- 6:05You also had the New Jersey plan, which was one chamber, and each state receives one vote.
- 6:11So that benefited smaller population states and bigger population states would have gone, hey,
- 6:17we have bigger populations, we have bigger, we have more people to represent why should they
- 6:22have the same?
- 6:23These smaller states have the same power that we do.
- 6:27And so after a lot of discussion, the plans merged into what became known as the
- 6:33Connecticut plan or sometimes called the great compromise, which was the two chambers, US
- 6:39house, proportional representation, and the US senate, equal representation, two senators to
- 6:45each state.
- 6:46Another compromise was the selection of the president.
- 6:51That was one of the most contentious problems that really threatened to sink the
- 6:55constitutional convention, which multiple times almost fell apart.
- 7:00And a bunch of ideas were proposed at the constitutional convention by the delegates,
- 7:05including a direct election by popular vote, which a lot of people want today.
- 7:11There was also the idea that it would be by members of congress, which many framers
- 7:15supported.
- 7:17There is even the idea of having its having the president be selected by electors that were
- 7:22selected by a lottery system, and then also an option of doing it by state governors voting.
- 7:32So, obviously, very different ideas there, and a lot of the debate was how much influence
- 7:42should the people have.
- 7:43You want to have the people have a voice, but then some framers were considered or considered
- 7:51the populace to be too given to a mob mentality.
- 7:55So there was a lot of those discussions there to be had about how we should select the
- 8:01president.
- 8:01Eventually, they compromised with the electoral college, which was an indirect election by the
- 8:06people.
- 8:06The people do choose the president, but it's through the states that have electoral votes
- 8:11equal to their congressional representation.
- 8:13And if a president won wins the popular vote in a state, he wins that state's electoral votes
- 8:19or she wins that state's electoral votes.
- 8:21And then if you get win a majority of the electoral votes that are available, you become
- 8:26president, generally speaking.
- 8:28Obviously, it's a little bit more complicated than that.
- 8:30We've talked about that in the past with how the presidency is or how the president is
- 8:35selected.
- 8:37And then there was also the issue of slavery.
- 8:41For all the great ingenious things that the US constitution did, it had and still has flaws
- 8:49like any other document or system of government created by human beings.
- 8:55And in this case, the most glaring and troubling flaw was that it didn't outlaw
- 9:00slavery.
- 9:01Whether The US constitution or the new nation could have ever happened with the banning of
- 9:07slavery is outside the purview of this discussion.
- 9:09Some people argue that America could never have happened if we ban slavery outright.
- 9:15That's for you to decide.
- 9:17Maybe we'll do another podcast episode or I'll write about that at some point, but that's out
- 9:22outside the scope of this discussion.
- 9:25But one of the major components to this issue was how to count slaves for purposes of
- 9:31representation at the US house.
- 9:34So pro Southern slaves or pro slave Southerners argued slaves should be counted as full person
- 9:41for apportionment.
- 9:41Of course, they did because that would have given them more power as slaveholders.
- 9:45But then anti slavery Northerners called that hypocrisy.
- 9:49If you're to treat slaves as less than human beings because you're considering them
- 9:53property, how can you count them fully for representation in government, which makes
- 10:01sense.
- 10:01It's pretty you wanna have your cake and eat it too there.
- 10:05You don't want them to be considered people, but you want them to be people.
- 10:09You only want them to be people when it's comes to apportionment in congress.
- 10:14So ultimately, they settled on the three fifths compromise where slaves were counted as three
- 10:19fifths of a person, and the term slave was not used in the three fifths clause.
- 10:25I think it was forget the exact term, but they did not use slaves.
- 10:30This would be eventually repealed by the fourteenth amendment, thankfully, but that
- 10:35would take some time before that would come into effect.
- 10:39But they also did secure an eventual end of the Transatlantic slave trade, which allowed
- 10:46congress to prohibit importation of slaves by eighteen o eight, though attacks could be laid
- 10:53on those imports.
- 10:55Even some slaveholders were against the Atlantic slave trade because of how absolutely
- 11:00barbaric it was where you put these eventual slaves into really tight quarters on ships.
- 11:08Many of them died on the way because they were inadequately fed.
- 11:13They were too close to each other, so there's really no room for them to sleep.
- 11:17Disease was prevalent as a as even as horrific as slavery is and was.
- 11:26The slave trade was a particularly horrific part of it.
- 11:30But they did secure an end to the slave trade by the by eighteen o eight, or it allowed
- 11:37congress to prohibit the importation of slaves.
- 11:40Now moving on from the US constitution, another prominent compromise that also dealt with
- 11:47slavery much more directly was the Missouri Compromise.
- 11:52As tensions between free states in the North and slave states in the South were heating up,
- 11:58a truce of sorts was created in 1820 called the Missouri Compromise.
- 12:03So Missouri was admitted to the union as a slave state, but it also created Maine as a
- 12:11free state to keep the balance between north and south.
- 12:14Maine was originally part of Massachusetts, but then it just became its own separate state.
- 12:20And it also banned slavery North of The 30 Sixth Parallel, which was approximately the
- 12:27southern border of Missouri.
- 12:30And this stood for over thirty years until being repealed by the Kansas Nebraska Act of
- 12:351854, which let those two states decide by popular vote whether to be slave or free, even
- 12:43though both states were north of that 30 Sixth Parallel.
- 12:48Next up, the compromise of 1877.
- 12:51So Reconstruction era policies in the wake of the civil war were meant to, among other
- 12:57things, implement racial equality policies across the South, but those policies had been
- 13:05losing steam.
- 13:06And in the eighteen seventy six presidential election, there was a lot of contention about
- 13:11who really won that election with both democrats who backed Samuel Tilden and
- 13:17Republicans backing Rutherford b Hayes, accusing each other of electoral fraud.
- 13:24And eventually, they came to an agreement where Democrats would agree to declare Hayes the
- 13:31winner of the presidential election, but Republicans agreed to end Reconstruction in the
- 13:37South.
- 13:38And then just a handful of other compromises to run through here since I wanna get to the rest
- 13:44of the content here.
- 13:46Other compromises include the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
- 13:50Yeah.
- 13:50Compromises relating to slavery.
- 13:52Now, fortunately, we had compromises that led to more racial equality.
- 13:57So the Civil Rights Act of 1964 outlawed segregation in businesses and public places, as
- 14:04well as banning discriminatory practices in employment.
- 14:08And if you look at the roll call votes for the bill or for the final bill, the US house, 157
- 14:15democrats and 139 republicans voted yes on it.
- 14:19And in the US senate, 47 democrats and 27 republicans voted yes on it because they were
- 14:25able to come to a compromise to actually push it through.
- 14:29Medicare and Medicaid implemented in 1965.
- 14:33That also had both democratic and republican support.
- 14:37In the US house, 237 democrats and 70 republicans voted yes.
- 14:42And in the US senate, 57 democrats and 13 republicans voted yes.
- 14:47So once again, a situation where both parties supported the bill, and that was through a lot
- 14:56of wrangling and wheeling and dealing behind the scenes.
- 14:59Food stamp reform in 1977 was engineered primarily by two US senators, Republican Bob
- 15:07Dole and Democrat George McGovern.
- 15:10They sought to control costs more tightly or buy more tightly, focusing eligibility
- 15:16requirements to the truly needy while also streamlining the program's purchase
- 15:21requirements.
- 15:22You also had Social Security reform and tax reform in the nineteen eighties with Republican
- 15:27president Ronald Reagan and Democratic US house speaker Tip O'Neill.
- 15:32And then welfare slash government aid reform.
- 15:36Gotta be careful how you describe that.
- 15:38Welfare, usually people have a negative connotation on.
- 15:41Government aid, people usually have a more positive connotation on it.
- 15:45But welfare slash government aid reform and tax reform in the mid to late nineteen nineties
- 15:51under Democrat president Bill Clinton and Republican US House Speaker, Newt Gingrich,
- 15:57another case of compromise.
- 16:01So now that we've gotten some examples of compromise out of the way, let's talk more
- 16:08about that public opinion on compromise that we mentioned at the beginning of the podcast.
- 16:14So diving more into that Georgetown poll and the, at least ostensibly, contradictory
- 16:21opinions on compromise.
- 16:23Now most of these data points I'm gonna bring up are from the 2023 poll, but Georgetown
- 16:29University also had a 2024 poll that didn't ask all the same questions, but some similarities
- 16:35between the two because overall, they were about civility, these polls.
- 16:41And so whenever I mention one from the 2024 poll, I'll make that clear when I do.
- 16:48And you also have to be careful comparing two different sets of respondents by using two
- 16:54different polls, because these are going to be two different groups of respondents that are
- 17:00polled.
- 17:00You can't necessarily assume that they would be have the same exact views on everything.
- 17:06But this is just to illustrate the general point about contradictory beliefs.
- 17:11So some of the positives, some of the things that are more amenable to compromise.
- 17:1883% of respondents in the 2023 poll agreed that compromise and common ground should be the goal
- 17:26for political leaders, and 54% said they agreed with that strongly.
- 17:3171 of respondents agreed with the statement that I think it is okay for my side to
- 17:38compromise a little more if it means getting something done.
- 17:41Getting something done is better than getting nothing done.
- 17:44And then in the 2024 battleground poll, 8282% of respondents agreed it will be good for the
- 17:52country if president Trump and congress compromise to find solutions even if this means
- 17:58I will not always get everything I want.
- 18:00And then 95% of respondents stated they want president Trump and both parties in congress to
- 18:06work together.
- 18:08Now for the negative side where it sounds like people are less given to compromise.
- 18:16Back to the 2023 poll, 82% of respondents agreed with a statement, I'm tired of leaders
- 18:23compromising my values and ideals.
- 18:26I want leaders who will stand up to the other side, and 54% of the respondents strongly
- 18:32agreed with that statement.
- 18:33And then 77% of the respondents agreed that on the issues most important to me, I think my
- 18:40side has already compromised enough.
- 18:43The other side now needs to give a little.
- 18:46So how do we reconcile these ambivalent views?
- 18:50Do people really want compromise or don't they?
- 18:53It seems a lot of people really do want compromise, but they conveniently want it from
- 18:58the other side.
- 18:59But if you prod people enough about it, it seems that many will still say, okay.
- 19:04I can give up just a little bit more if it will get results.
- 19:09But this this poll also doesn't go into specific issues to see which ones people might
- 19:18be more less willing to compromise on.
- 19:21Would they be more amenable to compromise on gun policy versus abortion or versus health
- 19:29care?
- 19:30It's hard to say for sure, but if you get more into the details of specific issues, there
- 19:37might be less willingness to compromise.
- 19:40They they might they might think they really want compromise, but then you actually try to
- 19:46get tell them what they have to compromise on.
- 19:48Now they're really thinking, oh, do I really want to compromise on that?
- 19:52Because now the views on compromise are becoming more concrete instead of a nebulous
- 19:57general philosophy.
- 19:59I want us to come together to solve problems.
- 20:02Now, I'm not saying that I think that people are really full of it that they don't want
- 20:06compromise, but it does partially depend on how you frame compromise.
- 20:13And I'll talk a little bit more about some of the ways I think we can reframe compromise to
- 20:19see if more people would be more agreeable to it.
- 20:25But there does seem to be some conflicting views people have about wanting compromise.
- 20:31And if they realize that, oh, yeah, I guess if I'm saying I want them to compromise, but I
- 20:38don't wanna do anything, I could see how that's not agreeable to compromise.
- 20:42At least I would hope some people could come to that decision.
- 20:46So there is that's I don't I can't say for sure, but I think some people don't realize
- 20:56they're at least seemingly contradictory views on compromise.
- 21:01Really, it's easy for any of us to say, Oh, yeah, I think we need to come together and we
- 21:06need to come up with solutions.
- 21:07I think most people are going to actually in the poll, most people do say that.
- 21:13But when you actually really get them to think about that, now it becomes a little bit more
- 21:18difficult to figure out where exactly we can have that compromise.
- 21:22But that's, that's the importance of talking about it to figure things out to see why people
- 21:27think the way they do.
- 21:28More on that soon.
- 21:30But what makes compromise so difficult to achieve?
- 21:34There's more reasons than the ones I'm going to talk about here, but I do wanna highlight some
- 21:40of them specifically.
- 21:42Moralized attitudes.
- 21:44So when you believe your views have a moral superiority, you don't wanna budge because then
- 21:50you're being immoral.
- 21:51You it means you are not standing for what you believe in.
- 21:54It means you're letting people who believe in something horrible that they're getting
- 21:59something they want.
- 22:00And it's very easy to fall into this trap.
- 22:03Of course, when we believe something, when when our views are a certain way, we're gonna think
- 22:10that this is the correct view because if we didn't think it was correct, then we wouldn't
- 22:14believe that we would believe something different.
- 22:17But when people have more of that self awareness of realizing, okay, this is my
- 22:23opinion, but maybe this is not the correct one.
- 22:27I should hear what other people have to say, then it becomes a little bit they're they're
- 22:32the possibility of compromise becomes much more likely, but moralized attitudes are a huge
- 22:41impediment to our ability to be able to compromise and to make progress.
- 22:48And I'll highlight something specifically from Timothy j Ryan in the American Journal of
- 22:54Political Science in 2017, in a 2017 article.
- 22:58He talked about how moralized attitudes shift behavior from maximizing gains to adhering to
- 23:04rules.
- 23:05So instead of like, okay, I'm gonna get whatever wins I can.
- 23:10These little bits of changes in policy here is basically you're standing on prince principle.
- 23:15You're standing on business.
- 23:17I'm not budging.
- 23:18Other people gotta figure this thing out.
- 23:21And so these mortalized attitudes lead to citizens, not just politicians, but citizens
- 23:27opposing compromise, punishing compromising politicians, and forsaking material gains.
- 23:33It's that all or nothing approach.
- 23:36Might as well just lose outright if we're only gonna get small wins.
- 23:40Another contributor to making compromise difficult to achieve is perceptions that
- 23:46personal values are under attack in that 2023 Georgetown poll.
- 23:5272% of respondents felt this way, 59% strongly, and republicans felt that way more than
- 24:00democrats and independents did, but still sizable majorities of all three of those
- 24:05groups, democrats, republicans, and independents felt their values were under
- 24:09attack.
- 24:09And if you feel your values are under attack, you're you're not gonna wanna hear other people
- 24:14because you're just gonna lash out at them and you're gonna stand your grounds.
- 24:18I know your values are what's wrong, and it just becomes this reciprocal vicious cycle.
- 24:25We just start attacking each other's values and we think they don't share the same values that
- 24:29we do.
- 24:30Even if that's complete crap.
- 24:33It's something that we start to believe in.
- 24:36Another reason that can make compromise more difficult to to achieve is a lopsided
- 24:44electorate or government representation.
- 24:47When you have a an electorate that skews very heavily toward one party or government
- 24:54representation that skews heavily toward one party, whether that's through gerrymandering or
- 24:59simply because the electorate is just that heavy towards the Democrat or Republican Party,
- 25:05it's you run the risk of completely shutting out the smaller party.
- 25:09Now there may be compromise within the Democratic Party if they're dominant or the
- 25:13within the Republican Party if they're dominant, but you're not having any of that
- 25:18cross party compromise.
- 25:21Another thing that really makes compromise difficult to achieve, and it's one of the
- 25:26biggest ones I think, is it's really disincentivized by the realities of
- 25:32campaigning.
- 25:33When you're campaigning, compromise is considered a dirty word.
- 25:38Compromising means that you're not having a spine.
- 25:42It means you're a coward.
- 25:44And you see that in these negative targeted ads all the time that trash candidates and
- 25:49officials for being compromising, but saying basically that they're being cowards.
- 25:55They're not standing for things.
- 25:57And meanwhile, these candidates that are against compromise, they're really it's just
- 26:01them being warriors.
- 26:03They're conservative warriors.
- 26:04They're liberal warriors.
- 26:05They're they're just fighting for common sense, and that's a whole other can of worms.
- 26:10I hate the phrase common sense just because of how overused it is in politics to really
- 26:15describe.
- 26:16Oh, this is what I think.
- 26:17That's not common sense.
- 26:18That's just your opinion.
- 26:20But I digress on that point.
- 26:22Especially when you have closed primaries, those are more insular minded.
- 26:27Most voters in these want you to stand your ground because there are more they tend to be
- 26:32more polarized.
- 26:33Because they're more polarized, they tend to be more invested, so they're more likely to come
- 26:37and vote.
- 26:39And oftentimes, this is where you hear these accusations of people being rhinos and dinos,
- 26:46which is Republican in name only or Democratic name only.
- 26:51And I will highlight another academic article by Amy Gutman.
- 26:57I hope I'm saying that correctly.
- 26:59And Dennis Thompson in perspectives on politics in a 2010 article where they talked about how
- 27:05the permanent campaign encourages attitudes and arguments against compromise.
- 27:11Because if you feel like campaigns never end even right after an election is just had, well,
- 27:19it's kinda true because there's no real there's an incentive for them to keep campaigning.
- 27:28We ultimate as tired as we get about this constant campaigning, we don't ultimately
- 27:34actually react in a way that disincentivizes them from campaigning.
- 27:40I think there's some I believe there's some countries where the campaign season is set
- 27:46specifically for a specific time of the year and a certain year.
- 27:50I'm I remember hearing that a long time ago.
- 27:53I'm not entirely sure if that's the case, but at least in America, we don't have anything
- 27:57like that where, like, no, you need to campaign in this specific time.
- 28:01Technically, there's no end to the campaigning cycle, unfortunately.
- 28:08But this permanent campaign philosophy, it incentivizes politicians to stand on principle
- 28:15to mistrust opponents to say that they're the bad guy.
- 28:19They're stupid.
- 28:20They're evil.
- 28:20Do not listen to them.
- 28:22We cannot concede any ground to them.
- 28:25And so this is conducive to campaigning, but not to governing.
- 28:29When you're governing, you inherently have to be more compromising even if you don't want to
- 28:33be, because that's the only way you can get stuff done.
- 28:37Even if you have a one party government or a government that is heavily dominated by one
- 28:43party, there is still some sort of handshake deals that have to go on to say, okay.
- 28:51I'll do this, but you do this, and then we make progress.
- 28:54But, obviously, it's a lot harder to get compromise across the parties that way or
- 29:01across party lines that way.
- 29:03Another contributor to why compromise is so difficult to achieve.
- 29:08Obvious one is polarization, partisan polarization, ideological polarization.
- 29:16These more extreme views make people set in their ways, and and because they're more set in
- 29:24their ways, they're less likely to budge from their position because they got it all figured
- 29:29out.
- 29:30But as I talked about multiple times before and and other writings that I have not just on this
- 29:36podcast, especially the especially big issue when it comes to polarization is effective
- 29:44polarization with an a that refers to our thoughts and feelings on each other.
- 29:49We don't want to work together with people we strongly dislike or even hate because it's just
- 29:56it just makes us feel disgusted to do that.
- 30:00So we don't want to work with other people.
- 30:03So we tend to find people that we already agree with.
- 30:06And so we don't listen to those people.
- 30:10We don't bring them into anything.
- 30:11We don't have compromise with them.
- 30:14And then lastly, is simply a failure to listen or to try to understand the other side.
- 30:20When people feel like they're not being listened to, they're not going to budge.
- 30:24They don't want to budge like, well, if I'm not even going to be listened to, I'm not going to
- 30:29even try to listen to you either.
- 30:35And if you're you can't actually have compromise if you're not at least listening to
- 30:40other people, because you're not getting any other information other than what you already
- 30:45agree with.
- 30:47But that's more of the doom and gloom part.
- 30:50Let's talk about where we do see compromise more often because compromise does happen.
- 30:57A lot of times, what gets highlighted is the dissension because that's what generates clicks
- 31:03and views and listens.
- 31:05But there is plenty of working together that we see not just within the parties, but across
- 31:11party lines.
- 31:13So where do we see political compromise more often?
- 31:17In the legislative process, this happens a lot, especially in budget negotiations where there's
- 31:22a lot of give and take behind the scenes of, okay, we'll do this project, but you also have
- 31:27to include my project on here, and then we'll include so and so's project.
- 31:32And there's a lot of specific projects that the specific government officials want.
- 31:36So there's it gets very complex and complicated of what projects get involved on there.
- 31:44Not everybody can get all their projects on there.
- 31:48And there's actually quite a few issues, even in federal government where there is a
- 31:52bipartisan consensus and the compromise is actually fairly or relatively easy to get to.
- 31:59But those don't grab headlines like controversy does.
- 32:03So they just don't get as much coverage.
- 32:07International relations and diplomacy.
- 32:10A lot of countries that have a lot of diverse interests and especially when you consider the
- 32:18capability of war, even nuclear warfare, you do have to sometimes consider compromises.
- 32:29And not only that, but trade policy also has a lot of compromise to it as well.
- 32:36And one way you see that in is is an economic term that's called comparative advantage.
- 32:42So country a so there's absolute advantage, and there's comparative advantage.
- 32:48Absolute advantage means you are more efficient at creating one good over another country.
- 32:55Comparative advantage means you have less of an opportunity cost.
- 32:59So how if you're gonna create good a, how much does that cost where you could devote some of
- 33:08those time that time and those resources to making good b?
- 33:12So country a might be able to make good a and good b with an absolute advantage compared to
- 33:19country b, but it might behoove them to focus more on good a to send a country b and then
- 33:25country b focuses on focuses on making good b because there's less of an opportunity cost.
- 33:31Country A can't spend all its resources to effectively do good A and good B.
- 33:37So you might have some compromises there where one country decides to send one type of good to
- 33:43another country and that other country sends a different type of good to country a.
- 33:49That's just one example.
- 33:51Trade policies have different all sorts of compromises all the time.
- 33:56Another where another area we see compromise is between chambers of congress and 49 of the 50
- 34:03state legislatures.
- 34:04I say 49 because Nebraska is a unicameral legislature.
- 34:08While 49 states and congress are bicameral, bicameralism inherently, regardless of whether
- 34:15they're both controlled by the same party or one's controlled by Republicans and one's
- 34:20controlled by Democrats, it inherently leads to some level of compromise because both the house
- 34:25and the senate need to agree on the exact same wording in a bill.
- 34:30Even if they both have the same general philosophy on guns or abortion or health care,
- 34:39They need to agree on the exact same stipulations, which they might not necessarily
- 34:43agree on.
- 34:44So if you have both a state and a house that are Republican, so they're probably be more
- 34:51likely to be against gun control.
- 34:54And maybe both chambers generally agree on that.
- 34:58But maybe the Senate says, you know what though?
- 35:01We need to ban bump stocks.
- 35:02And then the house is not about banning bump stocks, but maybe they want to raise the age
- 35:08limit for buying guns from 18 to 21.
- 35:11So the house and senate might need to work those differences out in some way.
- 35:17So even if it's just one party that controls both chambers, there's still some level of
- 35:22compromise that needs to be achieved.
- 35:24And then the last situation that we'll look at where we see compromise more often, though not
- 35:29by any means, the only other one that we see it is at the local level of government.
- 35:35Although there is a trend of nationalization of local politics, so local politics are being
- 35:42increasingly through viewed through the lens of national politics, especially in the really big
- 35:48cities.
- 35:49And consequently, there's more polarization.
- 35:53Local government is still much more amenable to compromise.
- 35:57Why is that?
- 35:57Well, more of the issues for local government are less partisan or ideological compared to
- 36:04federal and state level.
- 36:06So things like fixing roads.
- 36:11Republicans, Democrats, and independents all want good roads.
- 36:14How do we achieve that?
- 36:18After school programs, if if the county has a certain policy on that, that's not inherently
- 36:26partisan or ideological either.
- 36:28There's a lot of different things that are really fundamental everyday responsibilities of
- 36:36a local government that do not have a partisan or ideological bet.
- 36:40Now there may be some people who try to make those partisan or ideological issues, but
- 36:44generally speaking, those are not issues that lean one way or another.
- 36:50Another reason that local government is much more amenable to compromise is they simply have
- 36:57a much closer proximity to voters.
- 36:59So voters and local officials interact much more.
- 37:03And this interaction leads to decreased polarization, more humanization, and more
- 37:08willingness to compromise because you are seeing what actual people think and feel.
- 37:14When you can actually put a name and face to certain views, it becomes a lot easier to
- 37:20empathize with them.
- 37:21At the national level, it's a lot more dehumanization and saying, well, these people
- 37:25are stupid and evil.
- 37:26The this conglomerate of people, they are all this amorphous blob of terrible people, and you
- 37:35base you just it's much easier to make people sound like the enemy.
- 37:39If you're at the local level, you're a much closer proximity.
- 37:42You're much more likely to actually encounter them.
- 37:45And so it's a lot harder to do that.
- 37:47It's a lot easier to be a keyboard warrior and talk all this.
- 37:54You know what I'm you know what word I wanna say, but to talk all this, you know what.
- 38:00But when you actually encounter people, a lot of those same people aren't so tough like they
- 38:05are behind a computer screen.
- 38:07Funny that.
- 38:09Another reason that local government tends to be more amenable to compromise is that a lot
- 38:15more local races are nonpartisan elections while a large majority of federal and state
- 38:21races are partisan elections.
- 38:23So most school boards, nonpartisan.
- 38:26A lot of city council city councilors, nonpartisan.
- 38:32Some county commissions are nonpartisan too.
- 38:34Not always, but a lot of them are.
- 38:37A lot of these local area officials are nonpartisan races, and so there's no partisan
- 38:45queues, which means it's a lot less likely for people to try to rally a partisan base for
- 38:54themselves and try to pit the parties against each other.
- 38:59And all these factors are especially noticeable when you get to really small local governments.
- 39:06So you're talking peep ones where they serve a thousand to 10,000 to 25,000 people.
- 39:15The smaller they get, they tend to be less polarized and more beholding to compromise
- 39:20because of those factors just talked about that proximity, that humanization becomes much more
- 39:26amplified because they're a lot closer to each other because there's a lot fewer of those
- 39:32people within that local electorate, within that local government.
- 39:37So local government is a really good place to look to if you are disenchanted with the idea
- 39:47that government can reach compromise and consensus because it does happen a lot more at
- 39:54the local level.
- 39:54Now sometimes, again, local government, local politics is becoming increasingly nationalized,
- 40:02and so it's a lot easier to focus on the times where local government is not being so
- 40:11compromising and not willing to work together, but it does happen a lot more often than you
- 40:17might think.
- 40:18So, how do we reorient ourselves toward a more compromising mindset?
- 40:26Not every compromise works out and not every one of them is good.
- 40:30We've seen, as we talked about some of the historical examples, some of them were good,
- 40:37some of them not so good, some of them maybe or maybe not were the best that could be done at
- 40:44the time.
- 40:45I mean, again, that's for you to decide, but the at least willingness to compromise needs to
- 40:52be there.
- 40:52But first, we need to effectively demonstrate why we should see compromise.
- 40:59Because progress is most often built on compromise.
- 41:02A lot of people don't think that because a lot of people think their idea of compromise is it
- 41:06has to be my way or nobody's way.
- 41:11So you really need to hone in and show that progress is much more built on compromise.
- 41:17A lot of times we treat that as a self evident truth, but for a lot of people, that's not
- 41:22necessarily the case.
- 41:23Some people think it has to be their way.
- 41:26And this all or nothing mentality often leads to full losses instead of small gains.
- 41:31You go back to that those moralized attitudes where they'd rather stand on principle and lose
- 41:36than than give up any sort of ground to get a small win.
- 41:43Even though those small wins now can build into bigger wins in the future.
- 41:48Like a lot of times for advocates when they're going to a state government or a local
- 41:54government fighting for something.
- 41:57They may be only to get they might only be able to get a small win, only partially get what
- 42:03they were seeking, but that might be a good stepping stone to the year after.
- 42:08And the next legislative session, if we're talking about the state government, they might
- 42:12be able to get another win there and keep building towards their actual ultimate goal.
- 42:18But when you focus on you need to only stand your ground completely.
- 42:25And then when when it's us running the show that we're going to ram through everything we
- 42:30wanna do, that partisan pendulum is inevitably gonna swing back and forth between the parties
- 42:37because at some point, Republicans are gonna give it up to Democrats.
- 42:42Democrats at some point are gonna give it up to Republicans.
- 42:46What one party does in one term will often just be reversed by the other party when majority
- 42:52control changes.
- 42:53And this ultimately leads to no progress.
- 42:56We just get back to square one, and it just results in more hostility because, oh, you're
- 43:01just reversing everything we wanna do.
- 43:02No.
- 43:03You're just reversing everything we wanna do.
- 43:04And so we just we just don't get anywhere.
- 43:10It's also this unwillingness to compromise and the subsequent hostility and anger, it's
- 43:18unhealthy.
- 43:19It's it's not just bad for our mental health, but it's also unhealthy for political discourse
- 43:25to for us to try to stonewall each other.
- 43:29And we need to recognize that we don't have all the answers.
- 43:34Even when we don't realize it, we have a tendency to think that we've figured out
- 43:39everything that we've figured out much more than we actually have, that we have more of the
- 43:43answers that we actually do.
- 43:45We think we're completely right.
- 43:46So why should we have to budge?
- 43:48It sees other people that are stupid and evil and obnoxious and whatever negative other term
- 43:56you want to come up with for them.
- 43:58I why should I have to give it up?
- 44:00They need to figure things out.
- 44:03But funny enough, when people of different views start thinking that way, just keep
- 44:11butting heads and don't get anywhere.
- 44:13It's funny how we all think we have more figured out than we actually do, and then
- 44:22complain that other people feel that way that they think they know more than they actually
- 44:28do.
- 44:29Could use a little bit more self awareness in that regard.
- 44:32But at the very least, we need to be open to discussion and hear each other out.
- 44:38Even if we don't ultimately compromise a whole lot where one side does get much more of what
- 44:44they want than the other side does, there's a the the lack of willingness to even be open to
- 44:53discussion, that's what really kills our political discourse.
- 44:58Because if people at least feel heard, most of them will feel better regardless of the
- 45:03results.
- 45:04And I wanna point to a couple of things from my interview with doctor Guy and Heidi Burgess of
- 45:10the conflict information consortium that they talked about on the podcast.
- 45:15When people at least feel heard, they can at least feel better about the situation.
- 45:20You can really tamp down hostility.
- 45:22You need to at least the losers of an election need to at least feel like they got something
- 45:29out of it, or the losers of a policy battle need to feel like they got something out of it,
- 45:36especially because if they get into power next and you were completely hostile to them,
- 45:47they're gonna be hostile to you.
- 45:49And then so we're just gonna keep having this vicious cycle of polarization.
- 45:53And then also the two fundamental words for political discourse that could really transform
- 46:01how we deal with each other is listen and respect.
- 46:08Not just listening to people, not just letting them talk, but actually respecting, okay.
- 46:14I see where you're coming from.
- 46:15Doesn't mean you have to agree with them, and it doesn't mean you have to incorporate
- 46:18everything that they want, but you do at least need to give them some voice in the process.
- 46:26I know there's some people that think, well, I don't owe them anything.
- 46:29No, you do owe them something because this is this country is not just for you.
- 46:34This system of government is not just for you.
- 46:37It's for all of us here.
- 46:39And we can discuss and debate about what exactly that looks like, but you cannot just
- 46:47shut out other people.
- 46:48You never come to the best solution by doing that.
- 46:55So do we need to reframe compromise?
- 46:58Because we talked about some of those contradictory views that people have about
- 47:02compromise.
- 47:03Because when we hear the word compromise, we often think too much about what we lose instead
- 47:09of what we gain.
- 47:11Oh, but I'm conceding such and such.
- 47:14Yes.
- 47:14But you also could be gaining at least a small win on what you want.
- 47:21You at least feel better about yourself.
- 47:23You don't hate other people that don't think like you.
- 47:27We have better discourse.
- 47:29We all come to a more enlightened understanding of things.
- 47:34Those are all the things that we gain from compromise.
- 47:38So maybe there's a different word that we need to use that's not compromise.
- 47:44And especially when you say, oh, somebody's been compromised.
- 47:46That's a negative connotation because it means, oh, somebody got to them that has a different
- 47:52set of values, different worldview.
- 47:55So maybe not just about reframing compromise, but choosing a different word for it.
- 48:02I'm not saying that that is the case, but may that might be something we need to think about.
- 48:08And even if we ostensibly want compromise, we oftentimes, or at least sometimes punish
- 48:14officials for being compromising and reward those who eschew it.
- 48:20And we sometimes don't even realize it.
- 48:22We don't have to be polarized along partisan or ideological or issue lines to do that.
- 48:29Anybody can be against compromise, especially if they're effectively polarized because some
- 48:38all of us have things that we just don't wanna budge on.
- 48:41And again, there is some truth to the fact that you need to stand for what you believe in and
- 48:49where that dividing line is between standing for what you believe in and willing to give up
- 48:54something.
- 48:57That that's not an easy thing to figure out, but it is something that we really do need to
- 49:01work toward.
- 49:02Unfortunately, there are organizations that are working towards that.
- 49:06You have the bipartisan policy center, which is made up of an assortment of people that have
- 49:13worked in governments, that have been government officials, that have been involved
- 49:17in policy from both the Democratic and Republican sides and some independents as well.
- 49:23You have braver angels, which really works to bridge political divides and and focus on the
- 49:29values that we all share, the fundamental values that we all share, like freedom, wanting
- 49:36someplace safe for our families and our friends, wanting good schools, wanting to be
- 49:45able to put food on the table, wanting to be able to have good jobs.
- 49:51We all want those things.
- 49:52We all have different ideas of how to get there, but we all want those things.
- 49:56But groups like braver angels, builders movements, various civics organizations all
- 50:04have a lot of focus or some focus on that.
- 50:09And and a lot of those places are out there.
- 50:12Just need to find them, and I try to highlight their work as much as possible.
- 50:16And then, obviously, I try to do my part in trying to bring more compromise or at least
- 50:26making people more amenable to compromise as well.
- 50:29Because when you start to hear more people and more views and try to understand more of where
- 50:34they're coming from, you tend to see, okay, maybe they have a point or at the at the very
- 50:39least you see, okay, I see why they think that.
- 50:41Oh, this is something I hadn't considered.
- 50:44You'll become much more amenable to compromise that way.
- 50:47So there are people that are working towards that, and those ideals are not dead and we can
- 50:55work towards them and we can work towards at least more open dialogue, but we all have to be
- 51:01a bit more cognizant of how we view compromise and our sometimes contradictory opinions on
- 51:09compromise.
- 51:10But that is gonna do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 51:13As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 51:15My links in the show notes, my Facebook, Paul Raider, author and speaker, my LinkedIn, my
- 51:21five day educational email course about how not specifically about compromise, but about the
- 51:28very closely related polarization, why we sometimes actually unintentionally make
- 51:36polarization worse even when we're trying to make it better.
- 51:40Why we make those mistakes and how we can be better and fix those mistakes.
- 51:45My book, why independence rarely win elections and how they could become competitive.
- 51:50Not arguing that we should or shouldn't have more independence, but just talking about some
- 51:54of the issues they face and how some of those issues could be at least mitigated.
- 52:01And my matchmaker FM profile, if you want to get on if you wanna be a guest on this podcast
- 52:07or have me as a guest on your podcast, mywritingsonmedium.com, and my website,
- 52:14paulraider.org.
- 52:16And with that, we're gonna wrap things up.
- 52:18So as always, thank you so much for listening and tuning in.
- 52:22Please like, share, subscribe this this podcast, and show it to all your friends.
- 52:29And until next time, take care.