Latest / Black Holes and Bubblegum / Why English Kings Had to Kneel to France
Transcript
- 0:00Close your eyes for a moment, Claudio and Santi, and imagine you're a king.
- 0:05You have a crown, a castle, and nobody in your kingdom can tell you what to do.
- 0:11Then a messenger arrives with a letter.
- 0:13It says you must sail across the sea, kneel in front of a different king,
- 0:18put your hands between his hands, and promise to obey him.
- 0:21Not for your own kingdom.
- 0:23Just for a piece of land you own over there.
- 0:27For hundreds of years, this really happened to English kings.
- 0:30And it's the secret key to our big mystery today.
- 0:34How did two neighbours, England and France, become enemies,
- 0:38marry into each other's families, fight for centuries, and finally become allies?
- 0:44Wait, wait, wait.
- 0:45A king who has to kneel?
- 0:46Kings don't kneel!
- 0:47Kings are the ones that everybody else kneels to!
- 0:50That's the whole point of being a king, isn't it?
- 0:53That is exactly the puzzle, Santi.
- 0:56Let's go back to the year 1066.
- 0:58A man called William was the Duke of Normandy, which is a region in northern France.
- 1:04He sailed across the Channel, won the Battle of Hastings, and became King of
- 1:09England.
- 1:10As King of England, he answered to nobody.
- 1:13But he was still the Duke of Normandy, and a duke in France was a vassal of the King
- 1:18of France.
- 1:19A vassal is someone who receives land and promises loyalty in return.
- 1:24The ceremony is called homage.
- 1:27The vassal kneels, puts his hands between the overlord's hands,
- 1:30and swears to be faithful.
- 1:33So William was the boss of England, but kind of like an employee in France?
- 1:37Like he had two jobs at the same time, and one job was being the top boss and the
- 1:42other job was kneeling to somebody else.
- 1:44That sounds really awkward.
- 1:46It was awkward, Claudio, and that's a great way to put it.
- 1:49Imagine being anointed king in a church, and then having to kneel to another king
- 1:55for a piece of land.
- 1:56And there was a real risk.
- 1:59If a French king felt a vassal wasn't being loyal, he had the right to confiscate
- 2:04the fief, which means take the land back.
- 2:07That threat came up again and again.
- 2:09But if they were kings, couldn't they just say no?
- 2:12Like, forget it, I'm not kneeling?
- 2:14They could, but then the French king could say, fine, then the land isn't yours
- 2:19anymore.
- 2:19And these lands were valuable.
- 2:22They weren't just dots on a map.
- 2:24They had farms and vineyards and towns full of people.
- 2:28So English kings usually decided that kneeling was the price of keeping them.
- 2:33Okay, and here's something I'm wondering.
- 2:35If the king came from Normandy, what language did everybody speak?
- 2:39Did they speak English or French or both?
- 2:42Because that seems like it would get confusing really fast.
- 2:45Great question.
- 2:46For about 300 years, the language of the English royal court,
- 2:50the nobles, and the law was a kind of Norman French.
- 2:53The ordinary farmers still spoke English, but the people at the top spoke French.
- 2:58Historians often point to food words as a clue.
- 3:02The animal in the field kept its English name, cow, pig, sheep.
- 3:07But when it arrived on the lord's dinner table, it got a French style name: beef,
- 3:12pork, mutton.
- 3:14Hundreds of French words are still sitting in English today.
- 3:17That's so cool!
- 3:18So English has French hiding inside it!
- 3:20So were the kings basically French?
- 3:22Not exactly, but their families had roots on both sides of the Channel.
- 3:27They thought of their French lands as their patrimony, which means something you
- 3:32inherit from your ancestors, like a family treasure.
- 3:35And that's why this is more like a family feud than a fight between strangers.
- 3:41A dynasty is a family that passes the crown down through the generations,
- 3:45and these royal families were tangled up together from the very start.
- 3:50Here's the first thing for you both to think about.
- 3:53If you were an English king, would you kneel to the French king just to keep your
- 3:57family's French orchards and vineyards?
- 3:59Or would you give them up to keep your pride?
- 4:02Take a few seconds and think it over.
- 4:04Hmm.
- 4:05I think I would kneel but maybe cross my fingers behind my back.
- 4:09Is that cheating?
- 4:10I think I'd keep the orchards, because if you give them up,
- 4:13then somebody else has your orchards.
- 4:15But I'd probably complain the whole time.
- 4:17Those are very much the choices kings made, and complaining happened a lot.
- 4:22So here's our first quick check.
- 4:24At this moment, are England and France enemies, allies, or family members who aren't
- 4:29sure who's in charge?
- 4:31Family members who aren't sure who's in charge.
- 4:33Definitely.
- 4:34Now let's bring in the weddings, because in royal families,
- 4:37a marriage was never only about love.
- 4:39It could carry land, treaties, and sometimes trouble.
- 4:43And our first bride might be the most powerful woman in Europe in her day: Eleanor
- 4:48of Aquitaine.
- 4:50Aquitaine was a huge, rich region in the southwest of France.
- 4:55When her father died in 1137, Eleanor inherited it.
- 4:59Historians don't know her exact birth year, but she was around thirteen.
- 5:04Thirteen and she owned a whole region?
- 5:07What did she do, build a castle?
- 5:09Her problem was different, Santi.
- 5:11An unmarried heiress with that much land was in danger.
- 5:15In those days, someone could kidnap an heiress and force her to marry,
- 5:20and then claim her lands.
- 5:21So her father arranged for the King of France to look after her.
- 5:25That same year, in July 1137, she married the king's son, Louis.
- 5:30Within days, the old king died, and Eleanor was suddenly Queen of France.
- 5:35Wow.
- 5:35So in one summer she got married and became a queen and her father in law died.
- 5:40That's a lot of stuff for one summer.
- 5:41It really was.
- 5:43Eleanor and Louis the Seventh were married for about fifteen years.
- 5:47They had two daughters but no son, and a king wanted a son to inherit.
- 5:52In March 1152, the marriage was annulled, which means officially declared over.
- 5:58And here comes the part that changed history.
- 6:02Just eight weeks later, on 18 May 1152, Eleanor married Henry,
- 6:09the Duke of Normandy and Count of Anjou.
- 6:12There's a story that she sent a message telling him to marry her,
- 6:16and the sources aren't sure it's true.
- 6:18We do know that another man, Geoffrey of Anjou, tried to kidnap her around that
- 6:24time, and she escaped.
- 6:26Hold on.
- 6:27She married the French king, and then eight weeks later she married a guy who was
- 6:31about to be the English king?
- 6:33That's wild!
- 6:34What did the French king think?
- 6:36He wasn't happy, as you can imagine.
- 6:38In 1154 Henry became King Henry the Second of England.
- 6:43Think about what that adds up to.
- 6:46Henry already ruled Normandy and Anjou.
- 6:50Now, through Eleanor, he controlled Aquitaine too.
- 6:53For a time, the King of England held more land in France than the King of France
- 6:58did.
- 6:59Historians call this huge collection of lands the Angevin Empire.
- 7:04So did the wedding bring peace?
- 7:06I'm gonna guess no, because if I lost my whole southwest to my ex wife's new
- 7:10husband, I'd be pretty mad, and I'd probably go to war about it.
- 7:14You guessed right, Claudio.
- 7:15It fed fighting between Henry and Louis.
- 7:18And the trouble moved inside the family too.
- 7:21In 1173, three of Henry and Eleanor's sons plotted against their father.
- 7:26Eleanor supported them, though historians aren't sure of her exact reasons.
- 7:31The revolt failed.
- 7:32Henry imprisoned Eleanor for almost sixteen years, though records suggest she was
- 7:37kept in some comfort.
- 7:38When her son Richard became king in 1189, he released her, and she helped rule
- 7:44England while he was away.
- 7:45She lived to about eighty.
- 7:47So she was in prison for sixteen years and then she went back to ruling stuff?
- 7:51She's like a boss.
- 7:52One caution, Santi.
- 7:54We know surprisingly little about Eleanor.
- 7:57Most of what we have was written by monks and clerks who often disliked powerful
- 8:01women, and later writers invented legends in both directions,
- 8:05some making her a villain and some a perfect hero.
- 8:09Careful historians say we should be skeptical of both.
- 8:13Here's your second question.
- 8:15Imagine you're Eleanor, still a teenager, and you've just inherited a huge amount of
- 8:20land.
- 8:21People are scheming to marry you or kidnap you.
- 8:24How would you protect your independence?
- 8:26Okay, I would get lots of loyal knights, and I'd probably pick a husband super
- 8:30carefully.
- 8:31Or maybe I'd make a rule that nobody gets to marry me unless they let me keep
- 8:35running my own land.
- 8:37I'd have a secret escape tunnel!
- 8:39And then a really fast horse.
- 8:41Eleanor sort of did the horse thing, right?
- 8:43She escaped the kidnappers.
- 8:45She did escape.
- 8:46Now let's meet another queen with a different kind of problem.
- 8:50Isabella of France was the daughter of King Philip the Fourth,
- 8:53and in 1308 she married Edward the Second of England.
- 8:57That marriage followed a war over Gascony, and a peace deal in 1303 helped set it
- 9:03up.
- 9:03But Isabella is famous for what happened next.
- 9:06Her three brothers, Louis the Tenth, Philip the Fifth and Charles the Fourth,
- 9:10each became king of France in turn.
- 9:13None of them left a son who could inherit.
- 9:15When Charles died in 1328, the crown had nowhere obvious to go.
- 9:19So the next in line was Isabella's son, right?
- 9:21Because he was the king of England and he was also Charles's nephew.
- 9:25That's what Edward the Third said, Claudio.
- 9:27He was the nearest male relative, and his claim came through his mother.
- 9:31But French nobles didn't want a foreign king.
- 9:33They also had a recent rule that a woman couldn't inherit the crown,
- 9:37and they decided that meant a man couldn't inherit through a woman either.
- 9:41They chose Charles's cousin, Philip of Valois, as Philip the Sixth.
- 9:46Later, French writers claimed this was an ancient law called Salic law,
- 9:50a very old Frankish code.
- 9:52But historians have found no reliable evidence that Salic law was used in 1328.
- 9:58The link to it only shows up in the fifteenth century.
- 10:02The nobles made a political choice, and the law story came afterwards.
- 10:07That's kind of sneaky.
- 10:08They made up the rule after they already picked the guy?
- 10:11Historians say the explanation came later, yes.
- 10:15And Edward the Third waited.
- 10:17In 1340, in the city of Ghent, he publicly announced that he was the true King of
- 10:22France, and he added the French royal lilies, called fleurs de lys,
- 10:28onto the English royal coat of arms.
- 10:30So here's a recap.
- 10:32Marriages here didn't make peace.
- 10:34They created cousins with competing claims to the same throne.
- 10:38At this moment, are England and France enemies, allies or fighting family members?
- 10:44Fighting family members!
- 10:45They're basically two cousins arguing about who gets Grandpa's whole house.
- 10:49And that argument over grandpa's house turned into the Hundred Years' War,
- 10:53which ran from 1337 to 1453.
- 10:57Santi, can you do the math on that?
- 10:59Okay, 1453 minus 1337...
- 11:03that's 116 years!
- 11:05That's more than a hundred!
- 11:06Why's it called the Hundred Years' War then?
- 11:09That's like a pizza that says it's got eight slices and it's got nine!
- 11:13Ha, exactly.
- 11:14Historians gave it that name much later as a handy label.
- 11:18It wasn't one non stop battle.
- 11:20There were different campaigns, with truces and quiet years in between,
- 11:25and the fighting stretched across five generations.
- 11:29Think of the people living in northern France.
- 11:32Armies crossed their fields, they paid taxes for wars, and sometimes whole towns
- 11:37were under siege.
- 11:38For ordinary people, it wasn't a story.
- 11:41It was a long, hard time to live through.
- 11:44And the English had those archers with the huge bows, right?
- 11:48The longbows.
- 11:49I read that they were super strong.
- 11:51They did.
- 11:52Edward the Third won major victories with longbows, like at Crécy in 1346.
- 11:59Archers were often ordinary men, not nobles, and a lot of them practised for years.
- 12:05Later, Edward's great grandson, Henry the Fifth, won a famous victory at Agincourt
- 12:11in 1415.
- 12:12After that, France was in trouble.
- 12:14In 1420, the Treaty of Troyes said that the French king, Charles the Sixth,
- 12:19would let Henry rule as his regent and his heir, and the French king's own son,
- 12:25the Dauphin, would be left out.
- 12:27Wait, the king's own son got kicked out of being the next king?
- 12:30And how did Henry get the French king to agree to that?
- 12:33France was divided, and the king's side was weak at that moment.
- 12:38And here's where a marriage comes in again.
- 12:40As part of the deal, Henry married Catherine of Valois, the French king's daughter.
- 12:46The idea was that their son would one day rule both countries.
- 12:50In 1422, both Henry the Fifth and Charles the Sixth died within weeks of each other.
- 12:56Their baby, Henry the Sixth, was crowned king of England and France,
- 13:01something called a dual monarchy.
- 13:03But most of France never accepted him.
- 13:06He was recognised mainly in the north.
- 13:08A baby king of two countries.
- 13:10That's wild.
- 13:10He probably didn't even know what was going on.
- 13:13And then what happened?
- 13:14Is this where Joan of Arc comes in?
- 13:16I know a little about her.
- 13:18It is, Claudio.
- 13:19Joan was a teenager from a farming family, and she said she heard the voices of
- 13:24saints telling her to help the French cause.
- 13:27We know she said that from trial records, but what really lay behind it is something
- 13:32historians can't be sure about.
- 13:34What we do know is that she joined the French army, and in 1429,
- 13:38the siege of Orléans was lifted.
- 13:41Soon after, Charles the Seventh, the Dauphin, was crowned king at Reims.
- 13:46Joan was captured by the French king's enemies and died in 1431,
- 13:50but her story became one of the most famous in France.
- 13:53So she was like a teenage hero?
- 13:55That's amazing.
- 13:56But how did the English lose after that?
- 13:58Did she make them all run away?
- 14:00Not by herself, Santi.
- 14:01Another big shift came in 1435, when Burgundy, a powerful region that had been
- 14:07helping England, changed sides and backed France.
- 14:10Without that help, the dual monarchy crumbled.
- 14:13By 1453, at the Battle of Castillon, the English were pushed out of France.
- 14:18They kept just one port, Calais, until 1558.
- 14:21So that's it?
- 14:22The English gave up on France?
- 14:24Here's a surprising fact.
- 14:25English kings kept calling themselves King of France for centuries afterwards.
- 14:29The title lasted all the way until 1801.
- 14:33We'll come back to why it stopped.
- 14:35For now, let's hop forward to 1625, because there's one more royal wedding.
- 14:40Charles the First of England married Henrietta Maria, the youngest daughter of Henry
- 14:45the Fourth of France.
- 14:46She was a Catholic princess from the French royal family, the Bourbons.
- 14:50Hmm, but I thought England had its own church by then.
- 14:54Was that a problem?
- 14:56Great memory, Santi.
- 14:58England had the Church of England, and many people in England were deeply suspicious
- 15:03of Catholics.
- 15:04Because Henrietta Maria was Catholic, she couldn't be crowned in a Church of England
- 15:08service in Westminster Abbey, so she never had a coronation at all.
- 15:13Her religion made many English people uneasy, and that unease added to the tensions
- 15:18that led to the English Civil War.
- 15:20And the marriage did not stop England and France from fighting.
- 15:23In 1627, English forces fought French forces near the port of La Rochelle.
- 15:28So even when they married each other, they still fought each other.
- 15:32Marriages didn't actually fix anything.
- 15:34They just made everybody more related.
- 15:36That's a sharp summary, Claudio.
- 15:38Let's do a mini recap.
- 15:40After the Hundred Years' War and these weddings, are England and France enemies,
- 15:44allies, or fighting family members?
- 15:46Enemies, mostly!
- 15:48But also still family.
- 15:50Ugh, it's confusing!
- 15:52I think...
- 15:53fighting family members who are also enemies who also share words.
- 15:57That might be the most accurate answer so far.
- 16:00Now we need to clear up a naming problem we've been dodging.
- 16:02Up to now, we've been saying England.
- 16:05But that changed.
- 16:06In 1707, the Acts of Union joined England and Scotland into one kingdom,
- 16:12called Great Britain.
- 16:14Then, in 1801, Great Britain and Ireland joined together as the United Kingdom of
- 16:19Great Britain and Ireland.
- 16:21So England is one part of Britain, and Britain is a part of the United Kingdom,
- 16:25and from 1707 on, the state fighting France was really Britain.
- 16:30So England is like one Lego piece, and Britain is a bigger Lego build,
- 16:35and the United Kingdom is an even bigger Lego build?
- 16:38That works nicely, Santi.
- 16:40And it ties into the title question.
- 16:43In 1801, King George the Third finally gave up the claim to the French throne and
- 16:48dropped the French fleurs de lys from the royal arms.
- 16:51This happened after the new French Republic objected during peace negotiations.
- 16:56So for about 460 years, from Edward the Third in 1340, English and British monarchs
- 17:02had been calling themselves kings of France.
- 17:06That's so long!
- 17:07Four hundred and sixty years of saying you're king of somewhere you don't even rule.
- 17:11That's like me saying I'm the champion of a tournament I didn't even play in.
- 17:16Ha, that's a good comparison.
- 17:18By then, the argument between the two countries wasn't mainly about crowns anymore.
- 17:23It was about trade, ships and colonies, which are lands far away that a country
- 17:29controls.
- 17:30In the Seven Years' War, from 1756 to 1763, Britain and France fought on
- 17:37several continents.
- 17:38Britain won New France, which means much of what we now call Canada.
- 17:43Hang on, so France lost Canada?
- 17:46And did France just say okay, fine?
- 17:48France looked for a chance to strike back, and it came in the American Revolutionary
- 17:52War, from 1778 to 1783.
- 17:57The thirteen American colonies were fighting Britain for independence,
- 18:01and France sent money, soldiers and ships.
- 18:04A French general named Rochambeau brought troops.
- 18:08The young Marquis de Lafayette fought beside the Americans.
- 18:11And a French admiral, de Grasse, brought a fleet.
- 18:15The Americans won.
- 18:16But the war was extremely expensive, and it helped bankrupt the French crown.
- 18:22That money trouble was one of the things that led to the French Revolution in 1789.
- 18:28Whoa, so France helped America win, but then it ran out of money,
- 18:32and that caused its own big revolution?
- 18:34That's like helping a friend win a game by giving away all your own Pokémon cards,
- 18:39and then you have nothing left.
- 18:41A very fair comparison, Claudio, although in real life it was far more serious.
- 18:46Here's your third question.
- 18:47Imagine you're the French king.
- 18:50You'd love to get back at Britain for losing Canada, but helping the Americans will
- 18:54cost a huge amount of money.
- 18:56Would you do it, or would you save your treasure?
- 18:59Think for a few seconds.
- 19:01I'd help!
- 19:02But then I'd try to be really careful with the money.
- 19:05Maybe I'd have a budget!
- 19:06Is that a thing kings had?
- 19:08I think I'd say no, because if there's a chance it makes my own country go broke,
- 19:12that's too risky.
- 19:13I'd just stay out of it.
- 19:15Both choices make sense, and that's exactly why it was such a hard decision.
- 19:21The long story ends with Napoleon, the French emperor who conquered much of Europe.
- 19:26In 1805, the British navy, under Admiral Nelson, won the Battle of Trafalgar at sea.
- 19:32And in 1815, at Waterloo, Napoleon was defeated for good by a British led alliance.
- 19:39Ordinary sailors on both sides spent years at sea, and many families waited at home
- 19:44through years of war.
- 19:46After Waterloo, the fighting between the two countries cooled down,
- 19:50and the long list of wars was mostly over.
- 19:52So how do we get from Waterloo to friends?
- 19:56Let's jump to 1898.
- 19:58Britain and France nearly went to war at a fort called Fashoda in Sudan,
- 20:04where both countries wanted control of the upper Nile.
- 20:07France backed down, partly because it was worried about Germany.
- 20:12And over the next few years, both countries began to feel that Germany was a bigger
- 20:16concern than each other.
- 20:18So they found a new thing to worry about, so they stopped worrying about each other?
- 20:22Partly, yes.
- 20:23And one person, King Edward the Seventh, played a famous role.
- 20:28In 1903, he made a visit to Paris.
- 20:31French crowds were cold to him at first.
- 20:34Some even shouted about Fashoda.
- 20:36At the theatre, according to newspaper reports, he met an actress named Jeanne
- 20:40Granier and told her he remembered applauding her in London,
- 20:44where she represented all the grace and wit of France.
- 20:48The next day, Paris papers printed it, and crowds began cheering him.
- 20:52One historian, Stephen Clarke, argues that this weekend of charm helped open the way
- 20:56to the agreement.
- 20:57That's his interpretation, though, and other historians weigh Edward's part
- 21:01differently.
- 21:02So a compliment to an actress helped end hundreds of years of fighting?
- 21:05That feels almost too simple.
- 21:07It was one piece of a bigger puzzle, Claudio.
- 21:10On 8 April 1904, the British foreign secretary, Lord Lansdowne,
- 21:15and the French ambassador, Paul Cambon, signed the Entente Cordiale,
- 21:19which means cordial understanding.
- 21:22It wasn't a formal alliance.
- 21:24It was a set of agreements settling colonial disputes.
- 21:26Britain accepted France's role in Morocco, France accepted Britain's role in Egypt,
- 21:31and they sorted out fishing rights around Newfoundland.
- 21:34The phrase itself came from a letter written in 1843.
- 21:38It seems small, but it taught the two countries to trust each other.
- 21:41Okay, but what's the difference between an entente and an alliance?
- 21:44Isn't it the same thing?
- 21:46An alliance is a team agreement to face a challenge together,
- 21:49with promises.
- 21:51An entente is more like a friendly understanding, a shared way of thinking.
- 21:55When the First World War began in 1914, Britain and France became full military
- 22:01allies.
- 22:02They fought side by side on the Western Front, and in 1918,
- 22:06their armies finally came under one commander, a French Marshal,
- 22:10Ferdinand Foch.
- 22:11And then there was the Second World War.
- 22:13That's the one where it got really complicated, right?
- 22:16I've heard about Dunkirk.
- 22:17Yes, so let me explain it carefully.
- 22:20In May and June 1940, Germany invaded and defeated France in just weeks.
- 22:26During the Dunkirk evacuation, ships large and small carried more than 330,000
- 22:32Allied soldiers across the Channel to safety.
- 22:36After France fell, Marshal Philippe Pétain led a new French government based in the
- 22:41town of Vichy, which worked with Germany.
- 22:44But many French people did not accept that.
- 22:47On 18 June 1940, General Charles de Gaulle spoke on the BBC from London and called
- 22:54on the French to keep fighting.
- 22:56That became the Free French movement.
- 22:59And on 6 June 1944, D-Day, Allied forces landed in Normandy to begin freeing
- 23:05France.
- 23:06So Normandy, where William the Conqueror started, was where they came back to free
- 23:12France?
- 23:13That's like a circle!
- 23:14That is a lovely connection, Santi.
- 23:16Let's do a recap.
- 23:18By the end of the Second World War, are England and France enemies,
- 23:22allies, or fighting family members?
- 23:24Allies!
- 23:25Definitely allies.
- 23:26But still, like, family members who sometimes argue.
- 23:29Now, today.
- 23:31In 2010, the two countries signed the Lancaster House treaties on defence.
- 23:36They set up a combined force of up to 10,000 people and agreed to work together on
- 23:42military equipment and nuclear research.
- 23:44The United Kingdom and France are the only two nuclear powers in Europe,
- 23:49and both are permanent members of the United Nations Security Council.
- 23:54The Channel Tunnel, which opened in 1994, links them for 31.4 miles.
- 24:00On 8 April 2024, for the 120th anniversary of the Entente Cordiale,
- 24:07French Republican Guard soldiers took part in the Changing of the Guard at
- 24:12Buckingham Palace, the first time non Commonwealth soldiers ever did.
- 24:17At the same time, British Coldstream Guards stood sentry at the Élysée Palace in
- 24:23Paris.
- 24:24That's awesome!
- 24:25They swapped places!
- 24:26So they trust each other with their palaces!
- 24:29They do, though they still argue.
- 24:31Since Brexit, border checks have been a topic of tension.
- 24:35Small boats carrying migrants across the Channel have led to disagreements and joint
- 24:39meetings about funding and enforcement.
- 24:42In 2021, there was a fishing licence dispute linked to the island of Jersey.
- 24:47And in sports, there's friendly rivalry.
- 24:50In rugby, France against England in the Six Nations is known as Le Crunch.
- 24:55In the 2022 World Cup quarterfinal, France beat England 2 to 1.
- 25:01At a recent UK France summit press conference, the British prime minister joked
- 25:06about it.
- 25:06So they work together on important things, but they still argue about fish and
- 25:11sports.
- 25:11That's kind of like how I play tennis with my friends and we're friends but we still
- 25:16argue about whether the ball was in or out.
- 25:18Exactly that, Claudio.
- 25:20Close partners can still disagree, as long as they have ways to talk,
- 25:25and the habit of working together.
- 25:28One last small fact.
- 25:30When the Eurostar train from Paris first ran to London Waterloo,
- 25:35some French politicians complained about the station's name,
- 25:38which comes from the 1815 battle.
- 25:41In 2007, the London end moved to St Pancras.
- 25:46Ha!
- 25:47They moved the station because of an old battle?
- 25:49That's hilarious!
- 25:51So let's answer our big question.
- 25:53Were England and France really enemies for a thousand years,
- 25:57or is the true story much more interesting?
- 26:00Historians describe almost a thousand years of intermittent conflict,
- 26:05and the key word is intermittent.
- 26:07It was less a story of ancient blood enemies and more a tangled family feud.
- 26:12Their crowns, lands and languages were so mixed up that wars often began over legal
- 26:18technicalities and inheritance.
- 26:20And over time, those two stubborn cousins became partners in a modern alliance.
- 26:25If you'd like to read more, the episode notes list the sources we used,
- 26:29including English Heritage, the House of Commons Library, the French embassy's
- 26:34account of the 2024 guard swap, and the Wikipedia articles on the Entente Cordiale,
- 26:40Eleanor of Aquitaine and the English claims to the French throne,
- 26:44along with Stephen Clarke's essay.
- 26:47So the answer is, it's way more interesting.
- 26:50They were enemies sometimes, family sometimes, and friends now.
- 26:53And they still argue about fish and soccer!
- 26:56Which makes them the best neighbours ever, kind of!