Latest / Booked For Questioning / Are Thrillers Too Predictable Or Are We Getting Harder To Impress
Transcript
- Jo: Welcome to Book for Questioning, where today we're investigating ourselves as readers. Mm. Kaci: Because when you first start reading thrillers, everything is shocking. The husband did it. The narrator was lying? No way. There's a secret twin? Jo: Yeah. Marilena: But then you've read, Kaci: Everything shocks you. Marilena: but then you've read 50 thrillers, then a hundred, then two hundred, Jo: Right. Mm-hmm. Marilena: and sudden suddenly 37 pages in, it looks like it's the neighbor. Kaci: Yeah. Jo: And then you're mad because it was actually the freaking neighbor. Kaci: Yeah. So today we're talking about whether books really are becoming more predictable or whether we've just read so many that we know all the tricks. Jo: Mm. It is, it it is. Marilena: I mean it's tough. It's tough. As an author, like Kaci: Uh-huh. Marilena: what else can you do? You know? Kaci: Yeah. Yeah. Marilena: But there are authors that are still amazing that are doing that that I've read. Kaci: yes, for sure. Every day. Jo: Right. So let's get into our first case file. Okay. Have we just read too many books? the that's just the obvious question, right? Do we genuinely think that it's harder to impress us because we have read so much and we first started off reading heavily. You know? I've read a hundred and sixty five books this year. Marilena: I mean, here's the thing. Anything that you do in excess of, it's gonna get mundane, right? you can't it ed anything's gonna Kaci: Mm-hmm. Jo: Mm. Marilena: get not boring because I still love reading it, but on that note, do you think that thriller genre is worse than it's harder to impress us on in the thriller genre than it is anything else? Kaci: Yeah, I think it's predictable. I think it's more predictable because there are only so many possibilities because it's finite, it's reality. You know, whereas if fantasy or I mean romance can get predictable too, but like if it's fantasy, Jo: Yeah. Kaci: there's a whole infinite amount of possibilities. But with a thriller, there's really not as many, you know. And I do think Jo: Right. Kaci: that if you if you look at yourself now versus before, you can get away with a lot less or you could catch a lot more. quicker because you've had practice, basically, you know? Jo: Practice makes perfect. I think it just depends on the genre or the subtrope that you're reading. Kaci: Mm-hmm. Jo: I that's why I think I like to mix mine up and not read multiple domestic ones back to back. I I try to do a rotation, maybe I'll read a cult one and then maybe I'll read, a serial killer, and then I'll read a psychological and then maybe because, sometimes they can seem similar. Kaci: Mm-hmm. So have we trained have Jo: You know, maybe not exact, but similar. Kaci: we trained ourselves though to ruin thrillers? have we trained ourselves to look for the clues all the time and if you don't find the clues, you don't like See, not me. Jo: I'm gonna look for clues. I'm gonna look for them. Kaci: I don't. Yeah. Marilena: But I look for clues, but I don't. I read I just if I feel like somebody's shady in my head, but I'm not trying to find out. Because I still Kaci: Yeah, me either. Marilena: want the element of surprise. I still want to enjoy the book. And if I'm not enjoying it, I DNF it, you know? But I feel like the authors, Kaci: Yeah, I'm exactly the same. Marilena: yeah, and I feel like they do such a good job, especially the ones that I've read this this year, especially. They're they're so I've had so many that have left me with my jaw, like, what? You know? Jo: I mean, this year for me, I think has been a lot, hasn't been so much similar because I think I know I'm gonna get smoked for this and I don't care. I've read more indie than traditionally published. So I think that the creativity is a little bit different. and they're not so similar. I don't like using copycat because I don't think anybody is copying anything, but it's just so difficult to read. one author and then there's another book that's similar to that book. It might have a different plot twist, it might have a different element, it might be a slower burn or where one is more fast paced than the other one. But I I have to be entertained. So as long as I'm entertained and you keep my attention captivated, whether it's predictable or not, I'm still gonna read it. But for the most part, because I've I've read so much, most of the time I can predict. Marilena: But I don't think that has anything to do with indie or traditional. I I think that we've read so many good indie books this year that I don't I don't think a traditional published author would be better. You know what I mean? I don't Jo: I'm not saying that would be better. What I'm saying is that the creativity is different. they're not I don't know how to explain it where it's just very different from what I read. I could read a book about a cruise ship, right? And then there's then I can read like four more that are traditionally published that seem similar. Where I could read one from an indie that might be about a cruise ship but it's completely different. It goes completely in a different direction. Marilena: Which is a good thing. Yeah. Jo: Right. That's that's what I'm trying to say, yeah. Kaci: think it's all about the twist. All about the twist. Marilena: I agree. So who Jo: So I Marilena: at this little circle here, do you think is the hardest to impress? Jo: You No, I think Marlena Kaci: I think Jo. No, I think Jo. Jo: I think Marlena. Marilena: Why? Jo: Because you're so you only read thrillers. So you don't expand yourself outside of that genre. you enjoy them but that's mainly what you read. So I think that you would be the best to say, it's predictable because that's all you read. Where I where we read Kaci: literally have heard her say one book that she doesn't particularly enjoy. That's it. And we talk about books constantly. that's true. That's true. That's true. Jo: No, she's she's DNF. She's DNF'd quite a bit. She's DNF'd quite Marilena: A few not quite a bit. Jo: a bit. Marilena: I've I've DNF'd a few that I don't like. Jo: Yeah. Marilena: But I will say this. I will be out of I'm not out of. I will never be out of the thrillers. But I started reading that dark romance. So Kaci: yeah. Jo: But it still has a thriller element though. Yes, it's still thriller. It still has a thriller element. Kaci: But that's as close to thriller as you can get though. Marilena: I love me my thrillers. I can't get away from I will get sick of it someday. Someday I'm gonna be like, okay, I've read it all. I can't do it anymore. I will be this one. Yeah. Jo: surprised she doesn't get into a reading slump because that's all she reads. Kaci: Yeah, I am too. I am quite surprised. Marilena: I love it. Well, I read a little palette palette cleanser, the one that you read too, Case. the little love story. The one yeah. Yeah. Kaci: yeah, you she read Defany Perry's picture something about a picture or something. She did and it was good. Jo: She read Daphne. Where did I miss this Marilena: I did. It was like eighty nine pages. Jo: in the chat? I must have missed this in the chat because I don't recall this conversation. Marilena: You did. Kaci: Y Yeah, and she liked it. Marilena: And I really liked it. It was cute. Mm-hmm. Jo: What? I'm I'm Kaci: Come for me. Yeah. Jo: glad I'm glad this is recorded as evidence. We have this in the evidence locker that she read something outside of a thriller. Kaci: gosh. Marilena: Yeah. I read Rebecca Yarros too one day. that was last year though, but yeah. I Jo: One day. Marilena: read her book. That was a sad one. Kaci: You must have read the last letter. Jo: Yes, she tends to be a tear jerker. Yes, yes. The things we leave unfinished, yeah. But it just depends. do we do we f do you find, that you're finding yourself reading differently now? I think I do. Kaci: a lot different, I do. I would have never been a person to Marilena: I wonder if I Kaci: let it happen, like Marlena was saying. I would have never been that person before until now where I'm like, just enjoy it. I you know what I even stopped doing? I stopped counting how many books I've read this year because I don't care. Because I decided that like I was so involved of how many books I had read that I just stopped because now I'm like I'm not reading what I don't want to read. And I'm going to take my time and read these books because I just felt like I was flying through them Jo: Mm. Kaci: So I I would have never been that person before. I would have always been like, Let's go, let's go, let's go. But Marilena: My problem is is I get book FOMO. Cause if I if Jo: Mm. Marilena: I'm reading something, then I'm like, my gosh, I gotta read this and I gotta read this and I gotta I do though. No, no, no, it's not from social media though. I I literally will Kaci: Sometimes that's book that's social media's problem though, is that they're like, Jo: Mm. Yeah. Marilena: s I'll scroll on Kindle or Amazon and I'll that's how I Kaci: huh. Marilena: find my books. And then I'll literally s read every the synopsis and I'm like, my god, I gotta read this. I gotta read this. Or I'm in NetGalley, one of the you know what mean? So Kaci: I know, I want to read it, I want to read it, I know. Me too. Net Gally, I'm bad at doing too. Yeah. Jo: Yeah. Kaci: Okay, so let's talk about the twist though. is it because at some Jo: Mm. Kaci: point you're gonna recognize a formula. Is there a formula? I know you know some authors out there have a formula. We won't name names Jo: Yeah. Kaci: because they're doing their thing, but you know, it's the suspicious husband. We always joke about that. The missing woman, the unreliable narrator. does it just become so predictable? You know? Marilena: It does, but it doesn't. Cause think about Jo: Right. Marilena: think about this. Carter Wilson, you guys, I don't know if you guys have read his new one yet, When They Find Me, and Megan Jo: Mm. Marilena: Dwyer, the one that we just read with hers until Your Father Comes Home. I I liked the stories. Don't get me wrong. I'm the I they both rated five stars, okay? But the twist got me and I was like this is a solid five star on both of those books because of the twist. And I didn't see it. And that's what I love. I but Megan had said it when we talked to her, it's not forced. It's not forced via she dropped a bunch of clues along the way. We just didn't pick them Kaci: Mm-hmm. Jo: W Marilena: up. Jo: I mean I Kaci: Yeah. Jo: picked I picked a lot of her clues up. So for me, I mean you rated it five star. I didn't rate it five star. I think I rated it four star for me because I picked up and again it's because of my background with mental health and how I was trained and I look for those little things. where I think you're more relaxed in a book where I'm like, I gotta know. I have to investigate, I'm looking at Kaci: What Jo: different angles for me. Kaci: I think what you just said though, that brings up a good point, Jo What you just said. You said you didn't rate it a five star because you figured out the twist. So Marilena: Right. Kaci: what point do you for me, I'm yeah, how Marilena: Is that fair to the author? Kaci: fair is that? 'Cause Jo: I mean it's to me it's fair. I mean to me I I don't see anything wrong with me figuring out the twist. Some people will and some people don't. Marilena: But you said you Kaci: But you said you knocked it down a whole rating for it. Jo: No, I imagine that a whole reading because I wanted a little bit more back more towards the end. I would need it a little bit more. Marilena: I feel that but I feel like this is a a good conversational piece because you are harder to impress, you are harder to because Jo: Mm-hmm. Marilena: of your background and because you've read so many thrillers, but why should I thought it was a phenomenal book. You know what I mean? Jo: Right. Marilena: Like Jo: I didn't say it was bad. I just for me the ending, I just need a little bit more on the like the dynamic of how the brothers, right? One married the girl and then at the end he ends up marrying the girl. I just need a little bit more of that dynamic and the point of view of the wife. I needed more on that. how does she really feel about that? It w it was it was sparsely. You you got the pr point of view of him, how he felt about her and how his brother why the brother married her and the reason with the dad and all that, but you really didn't get the point of view from her fully why she agreed to do that and how sh if she battled with her feelings this the whole time was she feeling the brother and it I Marilena: She did. Jo: just want a little bit more. I just want a little bit more. Kaci: I know think what we're saying too is that a twist can be predictable, but it can be done really well. That's what I think. Jo: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Kaci: need if I figure I don't care if I figure out the twist on the first page, as long as the journey is good, then I don't care because there are formulas. Yeah. Jo: Right. Right. I just need a little bit more. Yeah, I just need Marilena: Yeah. Yeah. Jo: a little bit more. Marilena: I mean, and that's again to each their own, right? It's all Kaci: Mm-hmm. Marilena: subjective. But, Jo: Right. Marilena: you know, 'cause I I rate something five stars, you might rate it two. I mean, not that you ever would, but you know, no. But I'm just saying Kaci: Yeah. absolutely. That's everyone for sure. But Jo: I would never read anything too. Ooh God. Kaci: is that we and I feel like sometimes, and this is because we have a lot of author friends between all of us. And I don't know if it's just personally you wanting to take up for them or whatever, but I do feel like the way the thriller world is now, and I'm a writer, right? So I look at some of these things and I'm thriller author has so much more pressure because we're expecting that we could read three thrillers a week. And we're expecting that each of those thrillers has these twists, keeps us all these things. I mean, we're putting so much pressure on a thriller author for these twists. Marilena: I know poor things. Kaci: And I'm like, I kind of feel bad for them, you know, 'cause I'm like, Marilena: I do too actually. Kaci: you know. Marilena: But Jo: I mean, it is a hard job. It is a hard job. But I think Kaci: Mm-hmm. It is very hard. Jo: everyone has a different perspective. And I think your backgrounds and I think how you Kaci: Yeah. Jo: process thing and information and how you v your your worldview and your moral compass and all that plays a role in how you view what you're reading as well. Marilena: But I I'm gonna say this and I I've said this before, but I will die on this hill for it, right? Steve Cavanagh is one that you know his books are about, right? His Eddie Flynn books. And you you feel like, it's gonna be this. Because in each each book that he has for the Eddie Flynns, there's always a crazy twist. And you're every book that I go into, I'm like, I I'm gonna figure this one out. his Jo I'm absolutely trying to figure it out because it's courtroom, it's law, right? Jo: Right. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: That guy gets me every dang time. every Kaci: Mm-hmm. Marilena: time. So I don't know how he does it, but he gets me every time. So if I could give Kaci: So it Marilena: it to one author for sure, it'd be him. Kaci: If you could say that there w what's one twist that got you before that won't get you now? is there a big one that just comes to mind? Marilena: I would think unreliable narrator, but that Kaci: Okay. Marilena: that one gets me every time. Jo: I wanna see how, you know, we we're getting ready to get an arc. We're getting ready to get Nigel Carlisle's arc for his second book of confession. Cause Marilena: Yeah. I can't wait. Yeah. Jo: that book that Kaci: Yeah. Jo: now that's one book that had me on edge, gaslit anxiety. I had to know, like, I had to figure right, I was, cause Kaci: It didn't have me on edge, but I don't know. Marilena: I was questioning my r own reality. I was like what Jo: I'm like, is this Kaci: That's true. Jo: person alive? Is this who is this? Like, is is the is she writing a story and making us believe that this has actually happened, but it's actually her writing the story. Is it a her? Is it a him? It was so much. So for me, that one, it took me a minute to figure out. I couldn't Marilena: Well Jo: put it down. Kaci: I know in the words of the famous, the iconic Annie Wilkes, I judge books the Marilena: Not fair. Kaci: same way she does. Is it fair? I hate, you girls know this. I hate a name change twist. And and then I'm not gonna call an author out on this one, but you guys will probably know a book that I'm talking about. But I also hate when authors use complexity as a plot twist. They make it so confusing. that you couldn't even figure it out. in the end it doesn't make sense. I hate name changes and complexity. Those will never get me again. Marilena: Can you give me an example of a complexity one or not? Kaci: my gosh. I will, but and not and I'm again I'm not saying it's a bad book, but I think when you hinge on complexity, it's not a good it it just makes it for me a little bit kind of ugh. It was My Husband's Wife by Alice Feney. Marilena: I guess I just I'm trying to figure out the yeah. Jo: Why didn't I like that book? Kaci: And I love Alice Feeney. I'm a diehard Alice Feeney, but when you I just felt like Jo: And I like her, but I didn't like that book. Kaci: it got so complex that it just lost it. Marilena: I felt that I felt that way about the anatomy of an alibi. I was so confused. I was like, what? Yeah. Kaci: Yeah, I mean I could kind of see that. I so it just it just so Jo: Yeah. It made a good wait, let me let's correct. Kaci: you're using complexity. Jo: It made a great movie adaptation. For me. For me. For me. Yeah, the atmospheric Kaci: maybe it might the atmosphere was great. I love the atmosphere of that book. Jo: was great. But I just think when I was reading, I was just like, what? Kaci: So comp there's just so much that you're just okay, Marilena: Yeah. Kaci: we gotta start somewhere, we gotta put a a a steady somewhere. Jo: But I think the tension maybe was the the complexity was like to build tension and build the suspense. Kaci: Yeah, I'm sure. Jo: that's my opinion. I mean, it wasn't a bad book, but it did get muddied a little bit towards the middle end, and I was just okay. And then yeah. So Kaci: Yeah, what's going on. Yeah. Jo: I could see, I could see that. I could see that. Kaci: Yeah. Jo: I don't mind a name change. If it's done great. I don't mind it. I don't mind Well, maybe they use the middle name and they use it they didn't use the first name. Kaci: No. You ain't getting me with that bullshit. God, when they changed the name and the at the end, that's not my name. My name was this in the beginning. Mm. Mm-mm. No, no, no, girl. Marilena: No, I don't like it. I don't like it. Yeah. I I just I just finished an arc with a name change. But I did like the book because it w it had a really great twist at the end, but I there was a name Jo: Right, that's what I'm saying. Marilena: change and I was like, Yeah, I don't like it. I didn't I didn't I didn't I didn't Kaci: yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I will. 100% Jo: So do you knock it because of the name change? Just like you just asked me? Kaci: I will. And I will call her. I call her out because I told I just read an arc where I thought it was gonna be a name change. I said, don't do this to me. Cause I was Marilena: No. Kaci: like, I'm gonna call her. I'm gonna tell her it better be fair, but it it wasn't. It was just a false alarm. It was a false alarm. Jo: I know who you're talking about. Kaci: And I was like, girl, you almost got me. Anyway, yeah, Marilena: DLs. Kaci: yeah. All right, here we go. So let's talk about. Book talk, but we'll say slash social media, because we don't want to blame it all on book talk. Because technically, someone Jo: No, no. Kaci: can tell you absolutely nothing about a book and still completely spoil the experience. I am ready to talk about this. We talk about this a lot. you know, what what hints or things are you like off? No way. Jo: Mmm I don't know, Marilena: So well I feel like you have we've talked about this, Kaci where you f say wait until chapter twenty-three. That's Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: is that a spoiler for you? Kaci: sometimes, yeah. I think Jo had a good point the other day where she was like, if she's telling you to hang in there, then that's different than being Marilena: Yeah. Kaci: no, something's gonna happen in twenty three or don't trust anyone. Marilena: I agree. Jo: It's situational. Kaci: The ending destroyed me. Yeah. don't be telling me, you know, the ending destroyed you because you didn't see it kinda Marilena: guys must hate my book reviews 'cause I say that sometimes. Kaci: I'll scroll if I do, but Jo: Don't hate your beauty. I you know what? That's what makes me read a book. If you tell me that it destroyed you, it made you cry, it hurt your feelings, it confused you. Kaci: Yeah. Jo: Because I'm not gonna I have to have a little bit of the atmospheric feel or the Marilena: Yeah. Jo: tension. Because if I just watch your review and you're like, it was a good book, you should read it. I'm gonna I'm not interested. But if you're telling me, if you're telling me there's lies, there's lies, this is what it's about. Marilena: Yeah, I'm not interested. And I don't wanna know the synopsis all over again. Yeah. Yeah. Kaci: Yeah. I don't either. I don't wanna know the synopsis. Jo: See, I don't agree with that. I you how you cannot go into the synopsis if you go to the bookstore, you read the back of the book to choose a book. See, I no, Kaci: I don't though. I don't. Marilena: I don't. I go in pretty blind. Jo: no, I don't like going in blind because my money Kaci: Mm-hmm. Jo: and my time is valuable to me. So I'm not doing that. Kaci: I don't I don't like I don't even want to trope list. I don't wanna know that it's I I an enemies to lovers is one thing, but I don't wanna know that it's an unreliable narrator. Don't tell me that. I wanna just figure it out. Or like, you know, don't tell me it's Jo: Yeah, no. That don't bother me. That don't bother me because I have to have some element that draws me to it. Kaci: No. Jo: So I need to know is it dual P O V? you know, Kaci: That's funny though. Jo: I yeah. I'll be Marilena: I'm gonna tell you guys this real quick. Jo: mm. Marilena: The book that you both need to read, September 22nd, it comes out, is Maybe You Lied by Jennifer Sadera This book, you guys have to read it. I'm not gonna tell you why, because Kaci: Ha ha ha. Marilena: it'll be a spoiler. No. There's because there's so many twists. Jo: Then I'm not gonna read it. I need to know why. I need to read the synopsis. I need to know what is the d what is the general Marilena: The synopsis, I just Go watch my latest TikTok video. I just did a video yesterday. But there's so many twists. But this woman, she did such an amazing job because you think you know where everything's going and you're like, okay, this, and you're trying to figure it out. And then all of a sudden she slides something else in there. And it's throughout the whole book. And I'm always like, if there's too many twists, it's like shock factor, right? this isn't good anymore. Not with hers. I was. Kaci: Mm-hmm. What's it called? Maybe you lied. Marilena: Maybe You Lied by Jennifer Sidera. Comes out the twenty second of September. So I I read it in March and I still think about that book. It's so Jo: Gotcha. Kaci: Yeah, have you guys ever figured Jo: But yeah, I just Kaci: out a book because somebody's told you what it's about? Or Marilena: No. Jo: No. Kaci: been like, this is a boyfriend's best friend killed her trope. w and then what do you do? Well shit, now I don't even need to read the book. Yeah. Marilena: Then they don't read it. Yeah. Jo: still gonna read it because you're not you just give you just gave me that but I need to I Kaci: See, not me, I don't wanna know. Jo: need I need to know the details. how did he kill her? Marilena: Same. This is Jo: why did he kill her? How did he kill her? Where did Kaci: No. Jo: he kill her? that's just me. Marilena: is why I don't watch a a movie if I read the book or I don't read the book if I watched because I don't I already know. Kaci: Yeah, me either. Me too. Jo: But then that makes no sense because when you watch a preview, it's giving you a preview of what the movie's about. So how do you go that Marilena: Yeah, but I don't know how it ends. I do know how a book ends if I read it. Kaci: Or know the trope. Marilena: Yeah, I don't want to watch it again. Jo: I mean, I don't know. I don't agree with you guys on that one. I don't. I don't. I don't. Kaci: Ha ha ha. Marilena: Yeah, I don't know. Kaci: So does hype make it harder for the books to impress you guys? all the hype, like say say with my husband's wife or something, does it Jo: It can, it Marilena: Yes. Jo: it can, it can. Marilena: Absolutely. Because then I have huge expectations. And Kaci: Yeah, me too. Me too. Marilena: and then if it if I'm like, well, that was just all right, you know, then Kaci: Yeah, I agree. Marilena: I'm like, I might rate it lower because I had so much hype. Hmm. Kaci: I do the same. Jo: Like the Whisper Man? Marilena: No, like atmosphere. Kaci: But you're the only one Jo: I'm just gonna take a sip. Kaci: I haven't literally a couple people have said that, but that but but that's another one. You're so ADD. Okay, but Dom doesn't make the rules either. Dom doesn't make the rules. Jo: No, Dom even said he agreed with me. No, he don't, but it's Marilena: I've heard so many people. Jo: a lot of people who agree that that that was not it. Kaci: There's a lot of people that disagree too. Jo: It said it was horror and it was there was no element of horror whatsoever. At all. At all. At the movie, the Kaci: To you, to you, but I again you're someone that needs con no, you need something constant, not me. movie was good too. Jo: adaptation. And I rated it a little bit higher Kaci: The movie was good too. Jo: because of the movie, not because of the book. Sorry. Kaci: Well, you don't get to make all the rules. Marilena: Yeah, I Jo: Well Marilena: mean we c to each their own, right? We're gonna stop there with that one. You guys are getting all heated. So would you rather have a thriller that has an amazing twist or and it's it was an okay story, right? Or it's an amazing story but no twist at the end. Jo: Mm. I'd rather have a okay story with Kaci: that's hard. Jo: a good twist. Kaci: Yeah, probably. Jo: 'Cause the twist would make it worth reading it, worth sticking through it, versus Kaci: Yeah. Jo: I stick through it and then it's like won won. Kaci: Yeah, I'm on the fence about that Marilena: Yeah, agree. Kaci: one, but yeah, probably. Marilena: Agree. I Jo: I mean Marilena: want here's what I want. And since we're talking about how it's harder to impress us, I want a book that even if I can figure it out, even if I'm like, the Jo: Right. Marilena: wife did it or whatever, right? Or I kind of know where it's gonna go. If it's a good story and you still have a good twist, even if I figured it out, if you delivered it to me well, I'm gonna rate it high. Jo: Yeah, I agree with Kaci: Yeah. Jo: that. I agree with that. Marilena: If it's not a rushed ending and you know, it's not forced, Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: I'm gonna rate you high. If I if I could not stop reading it, I'm gonna Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: rate it high. Jo: Yeah, I agree Kaci: Yeah. Jo: with that. Kaci: Mm hmm. Marilena: Right. Kaci: For sure. Jo: I agree with that. I completely agree with that. But I don't wanna I don't want it to be five, six hundred pages before I have to get to that. I don't Marilena: god, me neither. I will not read it because I tell Kaci: Amen. Amen. Yes. Marilena: three hundred three hundred and eighty-nine's max. that's that's right where I'm good. 389. Mm-hmm. Jo: I mean, and that's even pushing it for a thriller. Like, give me some short chapters. Kaci: Yeah. for a thriller that is. Jo: Yeah. Marilena: But I will say if you guys read the 4MK series, they are long, but they are so worth it. They are so worth it. Girl, Jo: might have to do that on audiobook. Marilena: I Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: I don't care how you guys do it, but I'm getting you guys are reading them. That's all I gotta say. I gotta I gotta talk. Kaci: I'm j I just yeah. I just read the Jo: Are we forcing us? Kaci: king of short chapters is James Patterson and I just read the Jo: Yes, I like. Kaci: most dangerous games with him and Mr. Beast. They wrote a thriller and it's pretty good, but it's short chapters, get through it like I liked it. It was good. Marilena: I don't think I've ever read a James Patterson book. I don't think. Jo: like James Patterson, but sometimes he can do overdo the filler, like over and over. he didn't judge stone. I Yeah. Kaci: got so many books out there, Jo: But he's a good writer. Like I love I love James Patterson. Kaci: Yeah, me too. Jo: Don't get me wrong. But if you gotta get through the fluff in some of the books to get to Marilena: She I can't, I'm gonna, I'm not gonna say it. I was gonna really make Kaci mad if I said it. I don't wanna make her mad. I tried to read Jo: No, make her mad because she tried to come for me. No, get that hefa. Kaci: Happen for you? Which one? Marilena: a Stephen King book and I just was like, my god. Kaci: yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You have to Stephen King is just a journey. Yeah, you cannot expect it and for me, I and again, I enjoy that, but I do know that when I start a Stephen King book, it's not like you're gonna read this book quickly. Misery is short, short, and some of his stuff is short, but yeah, you have to yeah, those are not thrillers for sure. Jo: Nah, some things are far fetched. Marilena: I just don't have I don't have yeah. Kaci: Absolutely. Marilena: a hundred Jo: it is not it for me. Marilena: The far fetched ones? Jo: Like it, the book It Yeah. Yeah, like it was not is Kaci: No, no, no. He's got a lot more far fetched ones. Marilena: his. Okay. I thought she meant Firefetch. Jo: one book that I just yeah. Kaci: I wouldn't even consider them thrillers. They're paranormal horror. They're not thrillers. Jo: Yeah, paranormal. Like some of that is just yeah, I Marilena: Yeah. Jo: don't know. Marilena: some to sum it up, right? So what kind of a thriller are you looking for? what how are you impressed by the thrillers? Kaci: Atmosphere. If you've got a f good Jo: Missia. Kaci: atmosphere, man, I'm in it with you. you know, and and that's hard to do. It's hard to do. Yeah, tension is a good one. Jo: And the tension and the suspense and the suspense and the I I can't go to sleep and I gotta work tomorrow. But I gotta know. I got to know how this ends. Marilena: You gotta know. Kaci: A hundred percent island. Marilena: So can a s can a slow burn have the tension and suspense that you want? Jo: It can, Kaci: Yes, but not 500 pages, I don't care. Not not a thriller. I'll hang on with Jo: it can. Right, but not five hundred pages. Absolutely not, no. Marilena: Agree, yeah. Agree. Kaci: you a little bit longer, but there's a little bit. Marilena: But you better impress me and scare me a little bit in there too. Jo: Yeah, it I need to I need to have some action. It better be some atmospheric stuff. It I Marilena: Yeah. Jo: better be gaslit. I better be whatever. But it Kaci: Museum. Jo: needs to be something that's gonna keep me zoned in. Kaci: For sure. Marilena: So I I think we're all in agree in agreement with that, what we're looking for. So I don't think we're hard to impress. I don't think we're high maintenance. I think we're real. Jo: No, no. I mean, it is what it is. And we're not even gonna get into what tropes would we rather, because we've already discussed our tropes. And so we're just gonna move on to case file four, right? Are the authors running out of twists? And this is what we kind of touched a little bit base up a little bit on, where a lot of we we see certain authors or certain not even authors, but certain books that kind of seem similar, but the twists or the endings are different. But most some of the book or maybe a part of the book, a third of the book may seem similar to another book we've read and we're kind of just like, okay, I think we're nowhere where this is going but it's still good or maybe it isn't and we're actually seeing it as the same because Kaci: Well, I think Jo: it reminds of us another book. How do you how do you Kaci: Well, and that goes back to our how how many ways like can you do one thing? And thriller readers are a specific a very specific niche because we can Jo: Mm. Kaci: again get through a 300 page book. You can do three or four of those really rapidly. So it's like we read a hundreds hundreds of books a year. So it's like, you know, can you really surprise somebody that's doing that? Marilena: And at the end of the day, if if that's how you feel, not you, but I'm saying the person that's reading these, if Kaci: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Jo: Right, right. W in general. Marilena: that's how you feel, switch your genre. Because there's gonna be somebody new that's coming Kaci: Yeah, agreed. Marilena: to read them and they don't need to be as impressed as you do, right? So that's not the author's fault. The author is doing what they need to do at their time, this time. As long as they're not writing the same thing over and over in their books, right? They're Jo: Yeah. Marilena: they're changing their books up, then that they're doing their job. Jo: Yeah, for sure. Marilena: You know, we gotta change our genre if we if we need to. Yeah. Jo: That's why I do a palette cleanser. That's why I alternate between genres so that I have a clear perspective when I go back to a thriller. my mind is I just read a fantasy, I just read a romance, I just read a horror, and now I'm going back into my thriller and I have a different perspective right now. Kaci: All over Marilena: Yeah. Kaci: these tick these streets here. Jo: Right. Marilena: Yeah. That's how it should be. Are you guys ready for a rapid fire? Jo: Let's let's do it. Kaci: Are Marilena: I don't like answering. All right. All right. Predictable but well written or shocking but messy. Jo: All of I think all of Kaci: kinda want messy. Yeah. Yeah. Marilena: Slow burn or non-stop action. Jo: Both Kaci: I prefer nonstop, but yeah, they're both okay. Marilena: Unreliable narrator or multiple POVs? Jo: I like multiple POVs, but I do like unreliable narrator for certain books. Kaci: Well, if it's an unreliable narrator, it's basically like having multiple POVs. Yeah, Marilena: Yep. Yep, I see. Jo: Yeah, but it depends, but it depends. Kaci: I agree. Marilena: Figure out the twist early or have the ending make absolutely zero sense to you. Kaci: I'd rather figure it out than it make no sense. Jo: I'd rather figure it out. It needs to make sense. Marilena: Huge twist or Kaci: Miss Annie. Marilena: incredible characters. Jo: Huge twist for me. Yeah. Kaci: Big big twist, yeah. Marilena: I already know. I'm not even gonna ask this one. Short chapters or long. I know, we all know. Jo: You didn't even ask that one. Short, short. Kaci: Short, short. Marilena: Domestic thriller or serial killer? Jo: Serial. Kaci: Ooh. Ooh, that's hard, but I'm gonna go with serial killer. Marilena: Same. One massive twist or five smaller twists? Jo: that's hard because Kaci: Smaller. Mm-hmm. Jo: depends on the author. Kaci: I'm just gonna go with a bunch of small ones 'cause keep me whiplash. Jo: Yeah, I would go with small one, yeah. Marilena: Yeah. Know the trope or going completely blind. Kaci: Blind. Jo: I got another trope. Marilena: I go blind. a book everyone loves or a hidden gem nobody's talking about? Kaci: Hidden Jim. Jo: I like hidden gems. Marilena: Same. Open ending or everything completely wrapped up. Explained. Kaci: Explain it to me before unless it's a continued Jo: Who unless a series, yeah. Unless it's a series, I prefer explained. Kaci: But close some of it, don't leave it all open. Marilena: Yeah. Jo: Yeah. Yeah. Marilena: One POV or dual timeline? Jo: I like dual. Kaci: Dual timelines, me too. Marilena: Plot twist at fifty percent or save everything for the end. Kaci: Let's do it halfway through and then keep going. Jo: Halfway through and then keep going, yep. Marilena: Ooh, I get bored. No, I like it at the end. For sure. Not that you guys asked me, but read the Jo: He Marilena: most read the most hyped thriller on Book Talk or choose one you've never heard anyone talk about. Jo: She was one I never heard anyone talk about. Kaci: Same. Marilena: Perfect ending or perfect beginning? Kaci: Ooh. Jo: Mm, some books start at the ending and go to the beginning and they it end out good too. So I don't I would I'm neutral on that. Kaci: Me too. That's a that's an interesting one. But it also if I'm gonna stick with you the whole time, the ending better be real good if the beginning's not. So Marilena: Okay, so you choose this isn't bad. I didn't make these ones up, so you can erase one thriller from your memory and Jo: Mm. Marilena: experience it all over again. Which one you choosing? Just one. Misery, are you gonna Jo: I don't know. Marilena: say? Kaci: No, because that's more I don't I consider that horror more Marilena: Okay. Kaci: or less razor blade tears, maybe? to experience it all over again. Razor blade tears. Jo: experience it over. Marilena: I'm gonna say A Killer's Mind by Mike Omer. That book had me Jo: Mm. Marilena: Yeah. Jo: That's hard for me. That's really hard. Kaci: Razor Blade Tears is the only one I've ever cried in, so I wanna experience it with new eyes. Jo: If I had to pick one recently that I would really wanna read again, the price of a rose. Kaci: yeah, that's a good one. That's a good one. Jo: By London Marilena: Okay, yeah. Jo: Valen. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: For sure. Well, we've talked about it all. We've talked about books getting more predictable or are we just getting harder to impress? Jo: We've reviewed the evidence, y'all. And it and it don't look good for some people. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: Ha ha ha. Jo: So now we have some official verdicts coming down. So who's the hardest person to impress? Kaci: Jo Jo: Really? I think Marlena. No, you are you're Marilena: Yeah. No. I'm the easiest one. Well, not the easiest, but Jo: not easy to impress Most likely to guess the twist. Kaci: Jo. Marilena: I'd say me. Me or you. Kaci: Really. Jo: Yeah. Marilena: Yeah. Jo: Most likely to give five stars. Marlena. I'm stingy with my five Marilena: Me. I do. I give five I don't I don't give you know what though, I don't give a Kaci: I would agree, she has. Jo: stars. Kaci: We do, we do. Marilena: Are you? How many five stars you've given this year? Jo: Out of a hundred and sixty five books that I've read, I have only given thirty-five stars. Marilena: I've given less than thirty five. Jo: But how many books have you read? Kaci: Y'all I can count probably on one hand. Marilena: A hundred and twenty seven. Shund Jo: A hundred and what? Yeah, see I've read a hundred I've read it h Marilena: and twenty seven. So she's the stingy one. Jo: over a hundred I've read more, yeah. Kaci: I've maybe only Marilena: Yes. Kaci: given like I could count on one hand and I I don't know how many books I've read 'cause I've quit counting, but I'm close to Jo. Marilena: I think this is another episode for us. The next Jo: Yeah. Marilena: one needs to be what is your five stars? What how do you come up with five stars? This is a good subject because I didn't know a lot of people asked. Kaci: Yeah, no kidding. Jo: So yeah, so who's a most likely to lower a rating because they guess the twist? Marilena: You, Jo. Kaci: Yeah. Jo: I don't know. It depends on the book. It depends. It depends. It depends. Okay. Most likely Marilena: Well, you yeah. Jo: to ignore the hype and love the book anyway. Marilena: Mi Kaci: Me or Marlena, I think. Jo: You and Marlena. Yeah, yeah. Most likely to say I knew it a hundred pages before the reveal. Kaci: I don't know, Joe's pretty Jo, whether she likes it or doesn't like it, I could see her liking it no matter what anybody says. Marilena: Yeah, she'll be stingy with her five stars though. Jo: Yeah, I don't I don't give a dang. I don't give a dang. I might not give you five stars, but you know. Most likely to say I knew it a hundred pages before Marilena: Jo Jo: the reveal. Kaci: Mm-hmm. Jo: Don't shade me, okay? All right. Most likely to forgive a bad twist because the rest of the book was good. Kaci. Marilena: Kaci C Kaci: Yeah. Jo: For sure. Kaci: Okay. Okay. After everything Jo: Yeah. Kaci: we've talked about, we need to answer the actual question. Are books getting more Jo: Mm. Kaci: predictable or are we getting harder to impress? Jo: We're getting harder to impress. Yeah. So we're guilty. We are guilty. Kaci: Me too. Agreed. Wow. We actually agree on something. Marilena: We are guilty. Kaci: Yeah. Marilena: Now we want to know what you think. Are thrillers becoming predictable, or have we all just read enough books that we learned the tricks? Let us know. Jo: Mm, and to right. And tell us what your last book that you genuinely felt shocked that just shook you. I need to know. Marilena: don't forget to find Book for Questioning wherever you listen to your podcasts and never miss an episode. Kaci: And until next time. Jo: You already know you've been booked for questioning. Bye. Marilena: Bye.