Latest / The Women's Soccer Podcast / Liga MX Femenil’s CONCACAF Breakthrough: How Mexico Is Shifting the Balance of Women’s Club Soccer
Transcript
- 0:09This tournament was not just a blip or a bad
- 0:12week for the NWSL. It exposed that Liga Amequis
- 0:17Feminiles top clubs are operating at a level
- 0:21where they can realistically challenge and overwhelm
- 0:24even the most elite of NWSL sides. The gap we
- 0:29once spoke of has dramatically shrunk between
- 0:32these two leagues on the assumptions around the
- 0:35women's soccer hierarchy in North America. may
- 0:38now be outdated and need to be rewritten. Hello
- 0:42and welcome back to the Women's Soccer Podcast.
- 0:44I'm your host, Liam Greco, and you know me better
- 0:46as LGG. I've always been one to take a very level
- 0:49-headed approach when analyzing results and games.
- 0:53And I think for me, a lot of the surprise around
- 0:56this match felt very, well, surprising as someone
- 0:59who's covered Liga Mejia in a lot of detail on
- 1:02the show, though not as much as I'd like to.
- 1:05have done. And we're going to do more of it in
- 1:07the future. We have some great interviews coming
- 1:08up. I actually got the chance to work with Club
- 1:11America Feminil earlier on in their Clasforo
- 1:14campaign this season and Karina Rodriguez. And
- 1:17I think that when I got to that project, I watched
- 1:21a lot of matches and I very much immersed myself
- 1:23in Mexican women's football culture in a way
- 1:26that I don't think I would have done without
- 1:28that project, which is why I'm eternally grateful
- 1:30for not only the project itself, but its experience.
- 1:34This allowed me to understand a more nuanced
- 1:38perspective about the league and about the dynamics
- 1:41and relationship between Mexico and the U .S.
- 1:45in that regard. There were some results that
- 1:48were very surprising. I didn't expect Pachuca
- 1:50to beat Gotham, let alone in the manner that
- 1:52they did. It was one of the first few moments,
- 1:56I would argue, in the broader women's soccer
- 1:58landscape that People are realizing that Liga
- 2:02Mejia's top clubs are no longer just chasing
- 2:05NWSL teams. They're at that level. We just saw
- 2:09Pachuca beat a pretty much full -strength Gotham
- 2:12team. And so I think it's vital to understand
- 2:15not only the actual matches and the tactical
- 2:18reasons behind the results that were yielded
- 2:21from them, but the structural differences between
- 2:23the two leagues, the business and cultural implications
- 2:26that play a large role on their expansion. And
- 2:29whether this weekend signals a real power shift
- 2:32or how much weight should we put on these results?
- 2:36And honestly, why these results might ultimately
- 2:39be great for all of North American women's soccer.
- 2:43I want to start by just speaking about the results
- 2:45in case you happen to miss them. In the semifinals,
- 2:48Club America beat Gotham 4 -1. Then they scored
- 2:51five goals against the Washington Spirit in a
- 2:54continental final. They put nine past two sides
- 2:57that met in the NWSL final last fall. Play a
- 3:00lot of three -match weeks that NWSL teams don't
- 3:03play. As I mentioned at the top of this episode,
- 3:06Pachuca then, after already being crushed Gotham
- 3:09by Club America, beat Gotham 3 -0. NWSL teams
- 3:14in their three matchups versus Liga Mejia teams,
- 3:18besides the one where... Pachuco lost 1 -0 to
- 3:21Washington, conceded 12 goals in three knockout
- 3:28games against Liga Mejia Femenil opposition.
- 3:30Gotham conceded eight goals in the stretch. The
- 3:33last time they did so was 2022. For years, the
- 3:39assumption in women's soccer was simple. The
- 3:41NWSL was clearly the dominant women's league
- 3:44in the region, and Liga Mejia, having founded
- 3:46a few years after the NWSL, was just trailing
- 3:49behind. It was never a competition. And I feel
- 3:53like that assumption from the last few years
- 3:56of the trajectory of the two years has been starting
- 3:59to feel shaky and inconsistent. Jessica Berman
- 4:03has spoken at length about why the NWSL is the
- 4:07best league in the world. For her to say that
- 4:10not only unfolded very poorly after the 2020
- 4:13Women's World Cup, but to lose the title of being
- 4:17the best club. in your own region, it's an embarrassing
- 4:21blow that she will feel far more than either
- 4:25the Spirit or Gotham. I don't think that Gotham
- 4:28and the Spirit are going to be dwelling on these
- 4:29games. I don't think for them, they were particularly
- 4:31excited about them being on their calendar. It's
- 4:34not an excuse. They played very poorly. They
- 4:36were outclassed in a lot of ways. I want to take
- 4:38a very balanced approach to this. I think it's
- 4:40important to say too, Club America just won their
- 4:43league last Sunday. I was watching. And less
- 4:46than a week later, They had thrashed both Gotham
- 4:50and the Spirit. It's embarrassing. I think that
- 4:53while the teams themselves should be focused
- 4:55on the next match, I think it's important to
- 4:58unpack a few questions that I kind of wanted
- 5:00to write out during the game. I guess the idea
- 5:02of these results, how much emphasis should we
- 5:05put on them, and why I think this result is actually
- 5:09the best thing for both NWSL and Liga Meji. I
- 5:14think that Liga Meji's caught up. Much faster
- 5:16than NWSL than people have realized. This is
- 5:18not a fluke nor a severe turning point. But I
- 5:22do think that the NWSL's tactics were exposed
- 5:26on a wider level. Parity is not going to hurt
- 5:29continental dominance except for the NWSL and
- 5:33for the league that paints itself as being this
- 5:36premier untouchable enterprise to get dismantled
- 5:42in this way. But for a Gotham team that has lost
- 5:45twice in this calendar year to teams that they
- 5:48would have thought they would have beaten, I
- 5:49think the narrative for January was that they
- 5:51were going to be playing Arsenal in the final
- 5:53of the first ever club competition globally.
- 5:57And so I think the overarching idea of this is
- 6:00what this means for the future of women's soccer.
- 6:03Gotham entered this competition as the defending
- 6:06NWSL champions. The Spirit were the runner -ups.
- 6:09For reference, last year in the first ever CONCACAF
- 6:12Champions Cup, in this four -match format, NWSL
- 6:16teams took three of four. This year, Liga Mahit
- 6:19flipped that result completely on NWSL's head
- 6:23and won three of four. We expected them to dominate
- 6:25these NWSL clubs, and that was not the case.
- 6:28I was missing the first half. I checked my phone,
- 6:31and I not only saw the fact that Gotham was down
- 6:351 -0. I later learned that their goalkeeper and
- 6:39Katrin Berger suffered a debilitating injury.
- 6:42And as much as I want to send my best regards
- 6:44to her and very much honor the fact that that
- 6:49injury was horrible, I think it's also important
- 6:52to say, to avoid my bias as being a New Yorker,
- 6:55as being a former golf and season ticket holder,
- 6:57is that... The result of the game would have
- 6:59been three points for Club America regardless.
- 7:01Scarlett Cambrera's absolutely dominated Gotham
- 7:04backline that looked incredibly overwhelmed with
- 7:06a hat trick. Jays had three assists. And even
- 7:10though Gotham had entered on a five -game unbeaten
- 7:13run against NWSL opposition, they flopped in
- 7:17comparison to the players that they had once
- 7:20dominated while in their league. This style of
- 7:24vertical attacking, aggressive wide play. And
- 7:27transition -focused, fearless pressing that,
- 7:30in a lot of ways, very much looked similar to
- 7:34the style of play that NWSL teams had used in
- 7:37the past to outlast their European competition.
- 7:41So even the narrative for all NWSL clubs has
- 7:44been, how do we keep up with Europe? How do we
- 7:47keep up with Europe? They're next -door neighbors.
- 7:49And Liga Meji just completely threw a wrench
- 7:52into that idea of Gotham in this first fixture.
- 7:55was exposed defensively repeatedly, a side that
- 7:58has, even through all of their ups and downs,
- 8:00had a strong defense as a hallmark value, looked
- 8:04completely outclassed, not only technically,
- 8:06but physically and athletically. They looked
- 8:09lethargic. They struggled in their recovery shape
- 8:12and defenders were isolated in space. And even
- 8:15when they were in 1v1 moments, they lost pretty
- 8:18much every single time. This wasn't an upset
- 8:21where... Club America sat back and got a goal
- 8:25on the counterattack or just smashed and grabbed
- 8:28the team until they just outlasted them physically.
- 8:31America, we're the better team. The better team
- 8:34won the match. Every single fixture of this competition.
- 8:37I mentioned earlier the 2023 Women's World Cup.
- 8:39It's a wake -up call for the U .S. And I know
- 8:41that they didn't lose to this team specifically.
- 8:43But during that competition, Catalina Guzmán,
- 8:47who's actually played in Liga Mejia before, had
- 8:50said a quote. I don't remember the exact wording,
- 8:52so I'm going to paraphrase. But she kind of spoke
- 8:54about how it was like 11 -on -11 soccer and how
- 8:57any team can win after they beat Germany. And
- 9:00she spoke about how she wasn't really surprised
- 9:02about it because I think that the talent on her
- 9:04team was so good and it was just a matter of
- 9:06a lack of talent being recognized. And I think
- 9:09that that idea of just a lack of talent being
- 9:12recognized in Liga Meji, despite the fact that
- 9:15Jackie Ovalle was... a world record transfer
- 9:17coming into the NWSL. As much as I'm very excited
- 9:20to get into the overarching topics and questions,
- 9:22I do want to do some game analysis. The program
- 9:25injury didn't matter. Right, we know that. I
- 9:27think it very much impaired the team in the second
- 9:29match, but Gotham was already structurally vulnerable.
- 9:33They didn't necessarily lose the flow of the
- 9:36game from that injury. They were losing it from
- 9:39the second they stepped on the pitch. And now
- 9:41the final. One of the wildest matches, yes, in
- 9:44CONCACAF women's club history, granted, albeit
- 9:46a very short one. I just feel like this was CONCACAF
- 9:50chaos personified. America led 2 -0. The spirit
- 9:54came back. It was tied 3 -3. Then America scored
- 9:57the winner and then it was sealed in stoppage
- 9:59time by a Scarlett Camberos goal off a very selfless
- 10:03pass from Jays. We saw Jays get two goals. Camberos
- 10:06get two goal contributions. Arringuero getting
- 10:10the winning goal to score 4 -3 off that beautiful
- 10:13cross. The Spirit, while losing, played much
- 10:17more dangerously and energetically than Gotham
- 10:19did. They scored two goals via Rosamund Kwasi
- 10:22and the attack as a whole was very dangerous
- 10:25throughout. But I think like every time Washington
- 10:28or Gotham punched back at Club America, Club
- 10:33America emotionally, physically, and tactically
- 10:36outlasted them by responding better. I think
- 10:40the composure, the confidence, the emotional
- 10:43sharpness and game management that they exhibited
- 10:46very clearly frustrated Gotham and Washington
- 10:50in those two fixtures. Pachuca's defeat of Gotham
- 10:54is very much underscored and has the asterisk
- 10:57of being a third place match that no one really
- 10:59wanted to play. Truly. But I think it is important
- 11:04to mention it because it's not just one Liga
- 11:06Mejia team beating NWSL teams, it's multiple.
- 11:08Because it prevents the idea of the semifinal
- 11:11being a fluke. It prevents this idea of it being
- 11:14an anomaly, that Club America just happened to
- 11:16beat Gotham. The reigning NWSL champions were
- 11:19not only beaten, but thrashed twice, losing 8
- 11:23-1 in two matches versus Liga Mejia opposition.
- 11:27At a certain point, this trend stops becoming
- 11:31randomness of fixtures and starts being solidified
- 11:34as a pattern within the women's game. So let's
- 11:38think about the why, because I think that coming
- 11:41out of this fixture, not just the final, but
- 11:45the whole competition as a whole, it's clear
- 11:48the Liga Mejia side's won, not just on the pitch,
- 11:52but off of it, commercially, economically. This
- 11:56is a league that has very much positioned itself
- 11:58to compete and beat NWSL on all of the same paradigms
- 12:04that Jessica Berman and the league office right
- 12:08down the street from where I'm recording this
- 12:10in New York City are using as proof of the pudding
- 12:13of NWSL. But when that same proof that they have
- 12:17reiterated time and time again is the same thing
- 12:22that's making them lose, the tangible investment
- 12:25we're seeing from Liga Mejia Scuads that is real
- 12:28now. It launched in 2017. And the early perceptions
- 12:32around the league was that it was very much developmental.
- 12:34A lot of the best Mexican players still played
- 12:37in Europe or in the end of Bucel even. And lacking
- 12:41in multiple areas, the infrastructure was poor,
- 12:44training facilities and stadiums were not the
- 12:47same as they were today. They weren't playing
- 12:49in the traditional quote unquote men's stadiums
- 12:52that were traditionally only occupied by male
- 12:54teams. And I think the tactics were very poor.
- 12:58It wasn't necessarily seen in a very competitive
- 13:01landscape. And regardless of all the top Liga
- 13:05Mejia sides were below every NWSL team that was
- 13:08exhibited by the Summer Cup. Every single time
- 13:11there was a fixture play, even if it was a worse
- 13:13team than NWSL, like Seattle did a preseason
- 13:15game at Starfire. That was their entire reserves
- 13:19and they still crushed Club America. And now
- 13:22that same Club America team is beating the...
- 13:26cream of the crop of the nwsl and that trend
- 13:30happened overnight and that perhaps in america
- 13:33we didn't see it coming but it came not just
- 13:36from coincidence it came from the elite facilities
- 13:38the international talent the growing salaries
- 13:40and the strong attendance from the league that
- 13:43also overarchingly above all of those the actors
- 13:47was from a giant wealthy club backing it. At
- 13:50some point, you do start to question whether
- 13:53or not the salary cap model is going to work
- 13:55for the NWSL. If they truly want to stitch themselves
- 13:59into best league in the world territory, Copa
- 14:02America is one of the biggest football brands
- 14:04in the Americas. And I had to explain that to
- 14:07people when I was interviewing a player with
- 14:08them, because even though it's not necessarily
- 14:10the biggest brand in America, when it comes to
- 14:14non -Liga Meji viewers within the Mexican diaspora.
- 14:20It is such a known quantity that regardless of
- 14:23whether it's a male or a female wearing the crest,
- 14:25it's treated with the utmost respect. Tigres,
- 14:29Monterey, and Bachuca also have institutional
- 14:31backing from their male sides, massive support
- 14:34from the crossover, from the men's fan base,
- 14:36with also new fans coming in, and serious investment
- 14:39backing up this messaging of wanting the women's
- 14:42teams to have the same level of respect to their
- 14:45name on and off the pitch. as the men's teams
- 14:47have garnered from their success. The top end
- 14:50of Liga Mejia Feminil is elite now. And that's
- 14:54pretty much been the case for a while. I think
- 14:56it's fair to say. There's a lot of talent. There's
- 14:59a lot of players who have gone on to do great
- 15:01things. But I think the difference in the league
- 15:03now is that we're not seeing the players come
- 15:06to the NWSL or USL. for that top competition
- 15:10because they don't have to. Look at Brazil's
- 15:12national team. They just called up Isa Haas from
- 15:15Club America and numerous other Mexican -based
- 15:18players to their national team. It's not necessarily
- 15:21just a breeding ground for top talent anymore.
- 15:24It is the home for top talent in women's football.
- 15:28There's so much talent on this team in Club America,
- 15:32but that's always been the case. Now we're seeing
- 15:36that talent expand throughout the league. And
- 15:38I think the environments off the pitch maximize
- 15:41that professionalism. I was asked the other day
- 15:43by someone as to why this tournament is always
- 15:46held in Mexico. And while I do think that in
- 15:48the future, the new format will change this,
- 15:50it's simply a money thing. It's the most American
- 15:52concept ever to hold it where you can sell tens
- 15:55of thousands of tickets, where if those matches
- 15:58got over 32 ,000. In the U .S., at Gotham Stadium,
- 16:01it would probably be more close to $3 ,200 than
- 16:04$32 ,000. And that's just a sad reality. There's
- 16:06more cultural embeddedness of these clubs. The
- 16:10fixtures and the environments feel much more
- 16:12hyper -focused, emotionally intense, and intimidating
- 16:15for players to play. And then when we sell matches,
- 16:17it's not even close. Mexico is a football -first
- 16:20culture. There's a multi -generational club identity.
- 16:22And there's this connection between the men's
- 16:25and women's brands that is undeniable. And I
- 16:28don't want to disregard the NWSL because on average,
- 16:31the NWSL teams have attendances across the league
- 16:34that are six times greater than league -admitted
- 16:37fan bases for regular season games. The Thorns,
- 16:41the Current, the Pride, even Angel City, the
- 16:45Spirit definitely, are just a few of the environments
- 16:48that come to mind that I think could very much
- 16:50be qualified as elite sporting environments for
- 16:53women's football worldwide. But I think there's
- 16:56a difference between a top environment, a top
- 16:58attendance, a top business sector, and a footballing
- 17:02atmosphere that's to die for. And when you watch
- 17:05these Liga de Mejia matches, top Liga de Mejia
- 17:08familial atmospheres are rivaling any other women's
- 17:12football league in the world. You cannot convince
- 17:14me otherwise of that notion. And I think that
- 17:18in large part, the fan base and their chants
- 17:23and their... energy and their passion that derives
- 17:27from the sport that makes it impossible not to
- 17:29cheer for the club and to just envy the culture
- 17:34that American soccer, as much as it wish it could,
- 17:37cannot manufacture. I think a big point of contention
- 17:43that I did want to discuss while also not making
- 17:46it seem like an excuse is the altitude, is the
- 17:50travel and the conditions. Pachuca, the host
- 17:54site for all four matches of this competition,
- 17:56has almost an 8 ,000 -foot elevation, which can
- 18:00increase fatigue, make pressing more difficult,
- 18:03and increase recovery times while also the travel
- 18:06element complicating it due to the fact that
- 18:10it is a much harder environment than, say, playing
- 18:13in many NWSL environments. For example, Utah
- 18:16is an environment in NWSL that has one of the
- 18:19higher elevations. I just looked this up right
- 18:21now. It's about like 6 ,000 feet. Denver is about,
- 18:26yeah, 5 ,280. Even the top teams in NWSL where
- 18:29they speak about the altitude being unbearable,
- 18:32Kachuka far exceeds the altitude. However, I
- 18:36don't think we can use the altitude for an excuse
- 18:39for the defensive collapses, transition problems.
- 18:42and conceding of 10 goals in the NWSL. I don't
- 18:46think the altitude wasn't a factor. I think it
- 18:50was. I think that these NWSL teams didn't deal
- 18:55with it well, point blank. But I also don't think
- 18:59the altitude makes defenders lose their marks.
- 19:02makes teams pass the ball as poorly as both Gotham
- 19:06and the Spirit did throughout the series. And
- 19:08granted, I think the Spirit were much better
- 19:09than Gotham, and I can say that as a Gotham fan
- 19:11myself. It was horrible from the Gotham perspective.
- 19:15And so I think that altitude, atmosphere, travel,
- 19:18all still should be part of the equation. And
- 19:21I'm sure we're going to hear a lot about that
- 19:23from Juan and Adrián this next week. Luka and
- 19:26Mahi sides deserve full credit for these victories,
- 19:29and they should not be discounted. Regardless
- 19:31of the fact that, yes, I don't think this competition
- 19:34holds nearly as much weight as the Champions
- 19:37League in Europe. Yes, I don't think that these
- 19:40NWSL clubs were especially ecstatic to go to
- 19:43Mexico. But at the end of the game, you're professionals.
- 19:46I don't really care about the circumstances and
- 19:48the scoreboard tally isn't in your favor. And
- 19:51I think that they all should be part of the conversation.
- 19:54But at the end of the day, NWSL teams were outclassed
- 19:58for the tactics. And I want to dive into that
- 20:02specifically to you and give these clubs the
- 20:05credence they deserve, not only off the pitch,
- 20:07but also on it. Because I think the NWSL and
- 20:09American soccer specifically has been known for
- 20:12its physicality. In 2023, we saw that narrative
- 20:15of it being the best start to unravel as more
- 20:19tactical approaches to the game started beating
- 20:22the U .S. But in 2024 at the Olympics, we saw
- 20:25how the physicality and pace of the team still
- 20:27outmatched. most top European sides. Mexico's
- 20:31women's national team, for comparison, has not
- 20:34qualified for either the 2019 or 2023 Women's
- 20:38World Cups as the league was still growing. And
- 20:40that was one of the main reasons why Liga Mejia
- 20:42was founded on the women's side was to improve
- 20:45the performance of the raw talent, yet poor execution
- 20:50from the Mexico side internationally. I think
- 20:53there was... a lot of elements of the physicality
- 20:57of the dynamism that we expect in the NFL paired
- 20:59with the tactical ability. They were very much
- 21:02good at vertical play and playing over the top.
- 21:06The goal that Charlene Corral scored against
- 21:08Gotham, I think is example number one of just
- 21:12capitalizing off a turnover and playing that
- 21:15pass confidently and quickly. They were very
- 21:17aggressive in transition. They never held back
- 21:19Pachuca and Club America in these fixtures, but...
- 21:23That's also a theme. We've seen throughout this
- 21:25competition, beyond those two clubs in Closura
- 21:28and Apodura, the technical freedom and the confidence
- 21:32within the chaos, though, were two points that
- 21:35I think really pose this league to succeed in
- 21:39so many different areas. Whereas at the Excel
- 21:42sides had a lot of weaknesses exposed. There
- 21:44was a vulnerable defense and rest positions.
- 21:46And even when there were the numbers back that
- 21:49should have been tracking sides, I think the
- 21:51Aline Gomez goal on Gotham was an example of
- 21:55not only the vulnerable defense factor, but the
- 21:58exposure in transition. Even when center backs
- 22:00were isolated in 1v1 positions where you should
- 22:03just be able to hold the forward off, they failed.
- 22:05They collapsed. There was a lot of emotional
- 22:07swings. It felt like the lack of stability was
- 22:11apparent, but debilitating at the same time.
- 22:15And I think that this idea of comfortability
- 22:18and chaos was very much a point won by... Mexican
- 22:23clubs in these fixtures because their ability
- 22:26to not only stick with their game plan, but adapt
- 22:29to whatever the tactics of their opposition were,
- 22:33regardless of the solutions that were thrown
- 22:36on the chalkboard by Juan Carlos Samaras and
- 22:38Adrian Gonzalez, it felt like they were very
- 22:42much defeated. And so this next question I think
- 22:45is pretty easy. Did the NWSL underestimate Liga
- 22:49Mejia Feminil? And of course, that's a very broad
- 22:50question. Who are we talking about? Journalists,
- 22:53the players, the teams, the fans even. I think
- 22:56the overwhelming answer for a lot of those parties
- 22:59is yes. A lot of English language coverage surrenders
- 23:03around NWSL, Europe, and of course, the UEFA
- 23:06Champions League was also yesterday, that final.
- 23:09That caught a lot more coverage in the US. And
- 23:12I think a lot of... fans and media rarely watch
- 23:15Liga Mejia, or if they do, I'd assume the talent
- 23:18gap is larger than what it is in reality because
- 23:21of the fact that, as I mentioned earlier, a lot
- 23:24of players who've come into the NWSL from that
- 23:25league have really not performed the best. And
- 23:30so I think that impression is still true. And
- 23:31I still very much agree with that idea that there
- 23:34has been this translation struggle. Should NWSL
- 23:37clubs be afraid of that given the past precedents
- 23:40or? Are these recent results proof in the pudding
- 23:43of them being able to beat NWSL quality talent?
- 23:48I don't know. It's interesting. I think it's
- 23:50an important idea to contemplate. But one that
- 23:53I can answer is that I think the shock from fans
- 23:56around these results almost revealed a little
- 23:59bit more about the perception of the league than
- 24:03its actual quality in regards to Liga Mejia from
- 24:06NWSL fans. Now, I do want to also talk about...
- 24:10the counter argument to this claim, because I
- 24:13don't think that we should allow this one tournament
- 24:14to distort our entire perception. Gotham won
- 24:17the previous edition of this competition last
- 24:19year. They swept the floor with all the Gamahi
- 24:22sides in their path. And Nibisel has been historically
- 24:25much more dominant. And maybe this wasn't a matter
- 24:30of arrogance, or maybe it was just the fact that
- 24:33the gap between the two was closed and that on
- 24:36any given day. these sides could beat each other.
- 24:39Well, under the new format, it's not going to
- 24:41be all in Mexico, which I'm very excited to see.
- 24:43If Mexican sides come into the NFL in the U .S.
- 24:46and they beat them, then those points are null
- 24:49and void. And so I think that it's important
- 24:53to, as a journalist at least, I've done a lot
- 24:55of reflecting about this idea of coverage and
- 24:59women's football. And even though we have this
- 25:01overarching problem of lack of coverage in the
- 25:03U .S. of women's sports and specifically women's
- 25:05soccer in the larger... slice of the pie for
- 25:08American media, when you center it around women's
- 25:11soccer, what's covered in the US with leagues
- 25:14all around the world, the discourse from fans
- 25:17is shaped by what leagues get covered in a language
- 25:21that is most accessible to a lot of the skeptics
- 25:24of Liga Mejia, which is English. And so I think
- 25:27for me, the fact that I did an interview with
- 25:29Karina Rodriguez in English, which I know a lot
- 25:31of people from Liga Mejia weren't happy about,
- 25:34like... if you're a superstar fan of the league.
- 25:38But I think it's good to have this, you know,
- 25:40interchange between the two. We have a lot more
- 25:42projects to look forward to with some other top
- 25:45clubs and perhaps another one of Club America,
- 25:47where we'll talk all about these matches and
- 25:49hear directly from the players. And I hope that
- 25:52not just changes from the Monday clickbait episode
- 25:55that you'll all receive in your podcast feeds
- 25:57about did Liga Mejia surpass and maybe sell,
- 26:00but it's a sustained effort that goes beyond.
- 26:03Just moments where we're overwhelmed and amazed
- 26:07by Mexican quality, talent, and talent that it's
- 26:10not only in the context of American defeat. Like
- 26:13I think both things can be true. And so with
- 26:15that, I want to end by answering the question
- 26:17that I had mentioned earlier in the episode.
- 26:20Does parody in the women's sporting landscape,
- 26:22specifically in North America, hurt the NWSL's
- 26:25phase and I guess face of just the brand internationally?
- 26:30I think yes, in that. The NWSL's structure is
- 26:35built for this idea of parity and it's built
- 26:37around salary caps, competitive balance, which
- 26:40in Jessica Berman's eyes has worked great domestically
- 26:44because we're seeing different victors of the
- 26:46title. But I think we're starting to see where
- 26:49the salary cap can fail on the other end of the
- 26:51coin because contentual competitions are rewarding
- 26:54the super teams, the continuity and the concentrated
- 26:57talent that a salary cap basically just will
- 27:00not allow because... better talent on lower down
- 27:04a roster of a top team just didn't get swooped
- 27:06up for twice the price to a better team. I think
- 27:09that a good example of this in Europe was the
- 27:12Leons, the Barcelonas, and the Chelsea's the
- 27:15world who've optimized their systems for dynasties
- 27:19and were allowed to buy Europe, invest without
- 27:22any severe caps, whereas in NBCL, it's very much
- 27:26optimized for the most fairness. And I think
- 27:28that We're starting to really question what is
- 27:31fair. I think the biggest point of contention,
- 27:33though, is where the salary cap is at. I don't
- 27:35think the conversation would be the same if the
- 27:37salary cap was, instead of being $4 .7 million,
- 27:40if you include the HIP money, if you doubled
- 27:42that and made it $9 .4 million, I don't think
- 27:48that the same problems would occur. And I think
- 27:50that's where it should be at. I know Tottenham
- 27:52was just above the end to be sold salary cap
- 27:55significantly. They published their... financial
- 27:57report and that's not even the best teams in
- 28:00Europe so I think just thinking about where the
- 28:02NWSL is spending and why the league has so much
- 28:06more turnover why there are fewer stacked rosters
- 28:08and the stars are much more spread out across
- 28:10the competition whereas in Liga Meji the top
- 28:13clubs have consolidated power increasingly parity
- 28:19is a strength it does improve the weekly competition
- 28:21it does allow players to develop and prevent
- 28:23stagnation. Two truths can be true with this
- 28:27situation in that Liga Meki is getting much better
- 28:30and it would also be vastly irresponsible for
- 28:33me to be a self -proclaimed journalist and to
- 28:35overreact to one tournament and suddenly declare
- 28:37the other side of the coin parody or imbalance
- 28:43a failure structurally. Maybe the ideal system
- 28:46is somewhere in between the extreme parody and
- 28:49unrestricted superclubs. But I just think the
- 28:52league at this point, like Jessica Berman was
- 28:54in the crowd. She was on the podium watching
- 28:57as her biggest competitors in North America lifted
- 29:01a trophy over her crown jewel that plays 10 miles
- 29:04away from her league office. I do have to wonder
- 29:06what are the thoughts in her head? We all wonder
- 29:08that all the time. But like, do you think she's
- 29:11questioning this idea of parody when it comes
- 29:14to the cost of dominance? Because we know how
- 29:16much. The league values its image. We know how
- 29:18much it values the idea of being the best. But
- 29:20is it really the best if you can't even beat
- 29:23a team in your own confederation? It's not the
- 29:26best in the world. Yeah. I think this idea of
- 29:30like the league being surpassed by Liga de Meji,
- 29:33I don't think that's the case. Y 'all can come
- 29:35for me. But I think that while the gap has dramatically
- 29:39shrunken over the last few years and is smaller
- 29:42than a lot of people would have anticipated,
- 29:43I think NBCL is still much... more talented as
- 29:48league as a whole. The global reputation is there
- 29:49for a reason. There's a much more consistency
- 29:52and the quality across rosters. And also like
- 29:56in the middle of the table, the quality is much
- 29:59higher. The infrastructure league -wide is better.
- 30:02But I think there's also other areas where Ligue
- 30:051, the Menil exceeds NWCL when it comes to the
- 30:08top end club atmosphere for the biggest matches,
- 30:11the emotional intensity and momentum of the league.
- 30:14And then... Thinking about this idea of being
- 30:16connected to male clubs, the ceiling of these
- 30:19elite clubs and the giant club culture and the
- 30:22impact that that has on these top teams. The
- 30:25NWSL right now does have the stronger ecosystem,
- 30:27but Club America, Tigres and Monterey have equally
- 30:31high ceilings that should not be disregarded.
- 30:34If you're a future star in 2024, you're choosing
- 30:37the NWSL. But if you're a star, let's thinking
- 30:41now like 10 years down the line in... 2030, what
- 30:44league would you choose? I think the NBSL will
- 30:47still have stronger weekly competition, the visibility
- 30:49that comes with the league and the talent depth.
- 30:51But Liga Meji has these giant brands, huge fan
- 30:55bases, and an atmosphere of increasing salaries
- 30:57that are already continuing to grow. Women's
- 31:01soccer is exiting this idea of one league dominating
- 31:04and entering, to use a chemistry term, a multipolar
- 31:09era of different sides continuing to thrive and
- 31:13thrive. This idea of the country you play your
- 31:16football in not dictating how good your league
- 31:20is. This rivalry is good for the sport. Women's
- 31:23soccer needs continental tension and the emotional
- 31:27stakes and rivalry and clubs pushing each other
- 31:30to a point of uncertainty. We don't want a league
- 31:32just sitting at the top coasting and not necessarily
- 31:35being challenged for the best league being in
- 31:37the world. Looking at Europe. Women's soccer
- 31:41there exploded because Lyon was dominant, Barcelona
- 31:43rose, and Chelsea invested. Arsenal had a resurgence
- 31:47that allowed them to lift their second Champions
- 31:50League trophy. It wasn't because the league was
- 31:52even, it was the opposite. And now CONCACAF may
- 31:56finally have Gotham, The Spirit, Orlando, Club
- 32:00America, Tigres, and Pachuca creating real club
- 32:03rivalry that shouldn't be discounted. But now,
- 32:06after this tournament, Club America will move
- 32:09into FIFA's women's club structure and compete
- 32:11in the first ever FIFA Club World Cup alongside
- 32:14last year's champions of the CONCACAF Cup, Gotham
- 32:18FC. Let's think about how these competitions
- 32:21are not going to matter because unlike the kind
- 32:23of wishy -wash makeshift tournament this past
- 32:26January, these tournaments matter much more because
- 32:29they're connecting directly not only to the women's
- 32:31game, but to where the league is continuing to
- 32:34go in regards to sponsorships, player recruitment,
- 32:37money and prestige, and the global legitimacy
- 32:39of a brand that matters when you're pitching
- 32:42your product to top athletes in the world. This
- 32:45tournament doesn't erase everything that NWSL
- 32:48has built, nor is it complete proof of the Liga
- 32:51de Magi. Both leagues have so much farther to
- 32:53go. But I think it's ended the assumption that
- 32:56the hierarchy in this region is settled and untouchable.
- 33:00Leagues like Liga de Magi. and their rise are
- 33:03real. Mexican clubs are legitimate powers that,
- 33:06not just on their best day, but on any day, can
- 33:09challenge their NWSL counterparts, which makes
- 33:12CONCACAF Champions Cup dramatically more interesting.
- 33:16Women's soccer benefits from the real competition
- 33:18because now we won't have finals of cup competitions
- 33:21like that very boring one between Kansas City
- 33:24and Gotham for NWSL, the Gamahi Summer Cup, because
- 33:28both leagues and clubs within it. we'll have
- 33:31much better competitions. I think we can end
- 33:34this episode with the stakes of that. The pathway
- 33:37to the FIFA Women's Club World Cup, the idea
- 33:41of the first ever Mexican club winning the CONCACAF
- 33:44W Champions Cup matter a lot. And I think that
- 33:48Club America should be relishing in all of their
- 33:51confetti from winning two trophies in the last
- 33:54week. None of that should be discounted. And
- 33:57I also think on a more... large scale, both these
- 34:01leagues are going to have a lot of questions
- 34:03to ask themselves as to how they will continue
- 34:06to grow, because you're not just running a race
- 34:09against yourself and trying to beat your own
- 34:11time from prior seasons. This is now a marathon
- 34:14where you look to your left and to your right,
- 34:17and there's runners going right against you,
- 34:19an ecosystem that thrives upon the competition.
- 34:23Gotham just took a bunch of top players from
- 34:27Europe. and so have other NWCEL teams. European
- 34:30clubs will continue to swipe from NWCEL and Liga
- 34:34Meji is now this third party in the equation.
- 34:37And I think a big question that we cannot answer
- 34:39today is whether or not in our minds it'll be
- 34:42North America versus Europe or Liga Meji versus
- 34:46NWCEL versus UEFA. For the purpose of CONCACAF,
- 34:51I hope that Liga Meji and NWCEL can repair any
- 34:54relationships that were refracted from that.
- 34:57Very poor initial Liga de Mejia and Nibizal Summer
- 35:00Cup and banned together because both leagues
- 35:03have things that the other needs. And I think
- 35:06that in order to continue competing with the
- 35:08top clubs in Europe, as we watch FC Barcelona
- 35:12lift yet another Champions League trophy, everyone
- 35:16in CONCACAF needs to work together. The Northern
- 35:18Super League needs to grow. The Caribbean League
- 35:20needs to grow. The conversation won't just be
- 35:24about... NWSL versus NWSL, we're sick of it being
- 35:27NWSL versus Liga Mejia. Northern Super League
- 35:30will need to step up. Every single party in this
- 35:32region needs to be meeting together, needs to
- 35:34be working together to make the CONCACAF Champions
- 35:36Cup as attractive as a competition as possible.
- 35:39Because the reality is, is European players will
- 35:43look at this result and it'll make, will be beneficial
- 35:45for both NWSL and Mexico because it will make
- 35:49both leagues attractive to those athletes. That's
- 35:52all for me today for a little... Sunday special.
- 35:55Thank you so much for tuning in. I hope you guys
- 35:57have a great holiday weekend. If you're listening
- 36:00from the US, enjoy that day off from work. And
- 36:04if you're listening from Mexico or around the
- 36:06world, or if you're listening from the Clue America
- 36:08side, congratulations on true trophies that were
- 36:11very much well -deserved. And I can't wait to
- 36:13come back on the show and talk about some more
- 36:15different trophies and more storylines and narratives.
- 36:19But for now... As much as I'd love to keep chatting
- 36:22with you all about the million other crazy things
- 36:24that happened this weekend, that's all from your
- 36:26host, LDG. Peace out and see you next time. Bye.