Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Who Created Wolverine with Roy Thomas
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome Back Everybody time for word Balloon, the Conversation show John Santras here today
- 0:06an editorial addressing the current controversy over the creation of Wolverine. Roy Thomas has
- 0:14made a claim as a co creator of Wolverine. It was long established fact
- 0:21that Len Wain and Herb Trimpy were a long time listed as the writer and
- 0:26artists who created Wolverine for an Incredible hellk Isssue from the seventies, and then,
- 0:31of course Lenn went on to write the initial New X Men stories that
- 0:35started with Giant X Men Number one. Well, we all heard the news
- 0:39this week that Disney and Marvel have decided that Roy Thomas should be listed as
- 0:46a co creator Wolverine. Len's widow has been made public of the fact,
- 0:53and apparently it's going to be in the screen credits. And not only that,
- 0:55but there likely will be compensation for Roy for creating co creating Wolverine?
- 1:03Is it just? I will let you decide. You will hear my editorial
- 1:07in a moment, and then you will hear a conversation with doctor Susannah Flores,
- 1:12Roy Thomas, and myself. After Len's death in twenty eighteen, when
- 1:17doctor Flores wrote a book called The Psychology of Wolverine, and you will hear
- 1:21Roy give his reasons of or his you know, and again just in conversation
- 1:26of why he feels he's a co creator of Wolverine as well. It was
- 1:32the first I had ever heard of it. But like I said, I
- 1:34know, this is kind of a big story right now, and I think
- 1:38it is in either a very binary either you agree with Roy or you don't.
- 1:44I think there are a lot of shades of gray. I explain more
- 1:46in my editorial, but that's the subject for today's episode of word Balloon,
- 1:53and I hope you'll enjoy it. Word Balloon is brought to you by Alex
- 1:56Rosshart dot com. Alex is a good friend of the show, and I
- 2:00am honored that he aligns himself with word Balloon and good lord. We all
- 2:05love his iconic art, whether it's for DC Marvel, things like Bonnie Python,
- 2:10the Monkeys, David Bowie, so many other great license things the Beatles.
- 2:15If you go to Alex Rossart dot com, you will find great value
- 2:21for your dollar, whether you can spring for something like original cover art or
- 2:28pages to lithos and posters. Every price point you can imagine you will find
- 2:35something at a beautiful image from Alex Rossart dot Com. Coming to Kickstarter from
- 2:39the mind of Franco the man behind Teen Titans, Go to the Library,
- 2:44Fay and the Moon and All Yah Comics comes the new LXT the Adversarial Fighting
- 2:50card game, live now on Kickstarter. LXT Lux Versus Tenebris Imagine a loved
- 2:57one has been spirited away to align of terror and torture. Would you be
- 3:01willing to go after them and fight through a horde of acolytes of the Dark
- 3:06One just to get them back? Developed as a role playing card game that
- 3:09could be played multiple ways. The cards will have full color illustrations on the
- 3:14front and chock full of steps and moves on the back. You can also
- 3:17get the LEXT Who's Who book with origin stories and information about all the characters
- 3:24still on more. Also available is the LXT Dark Atlas Book, filled with
- 3:30pro stories about all the batties and illustrations from a wine selection of comic artists.
- 3:36There are plenty of add ons you could purchase separately, like comic books,
- 3:38stickers, original art from the game, and more. It's going to
- 3:42be a howling good time. LXT live now on Kickstarter. Word Balloon brought
- 3:47to you by my League of word Balloon Listeners. That's right, my financial
- 3:52backers of what I'm trying to do here, it's pretty simple. Everybody.
- 3:57Word Balloon is free, It'll always be free, but I sure use your
- 4:00financial help. If you've ever thought about subscribing to word Balloon, I certainly
- 4:04would appreciate it. Now. Is word Balloon worth the price of a comic
- 4:09book a month? Is it even worth a dollar a month? If you
- 4:11think so, if you can swing it, I sure would appreciate your support.
- 4:15All I try to do is bring you fantastic content talking to some of
- 4:18the greats of pop culture. Consider subscribing to word Balloon by going to my
- 4:24Patreon Patreon dot com slash word balloon. Thank you very much for your support.
- 4:30League of word Balloon Listeners. Hi, everybody, welcome back. It's
- 4:33word Balloon the Comic Book Conversation Show. John Centris here presenting a conversation that
- 4:41happened at Terrifica back in twenty eighteen. The reason why I'm representing it is
- 4:46certainly in the last week we all found out if you pay attention to comic
- 4:51book sites like Bleeding Cool and others that it has come out that Disney and
- 4:59Marvel are going to now list Roy Thomas as a co creator of the character
- 5:04Wolverine. Now, this is a complicated issue. We all know that len
- 5:11Ween wrote the whole issue that Wolverine first appeared in herb Trimpy drew that issue.
- 5:17We also learned, because people were honest, that John remit A Senior
- 5:24designed the original Wolverine costume. And through the years, I think slowly Roy
- 5:30Thomas has been demonstrative about asserting that he is a co creator of Wolverine.
- 5:36He has said in the past for years now that the concept started with him.
- 5:44He presented the problem to Lenuen and said, I want to introduce a
- 5:47Canadian character. I want him to be animal based. I think Wolverine is
- 5:54a fierce creature to base him on, go write the script. But Roy
- 5:59has always been very earnest in the past about that lenn really did the heavy
- 6:02lifting when it came to the writing of Wolverine's character certainly further developed in X
- 6:09Men Giant Size X Men Number one as Wolverine joined the team, and you
- 6:14know, we learn more and more about Logan in the ensuing years. I
- 6:18say this as a complicated question because I have certainly read and heard and seen
- 6:25whether it's a podcast or a video cast, and some articles that people are
- 6:29obviously a little upset for the memory of Len Wain, for his widow.
- 6:34God, I remember that wonderful moment at the red carpet of Logan where Hugh
- 6:40Jackman, the star of the Wolverine films of the twenty century Fox movies including
- 6:45Logan, had Len stand up and said, I would not be here today
- 6:48if were not for this man. Len Waen and Lenn got a well deserved
- 6:53round of applause. Everyone has always acknowledged that Len is the written creator of
- 7:00Wolverine, and again kind of a little Herb trip, you know, Herb
- 7:03Trippy again drew that first appearance in Hulk and remit A Senior got his credit
- 7:10for a while. He designed the character, he designed all that they made.
- 7:14His clause adamantium. And you can say that Roy created and the idea
- 7:18of the metal adamantium. But I don't know. I really, I honestly
- 7:24don't know. I wasn't there, And sadly Len is not here to not
- 7:28only defend himself but perhaps share the credit with Roy and say, well,
- 7:32yeah, that's true, you know, right, Rye. It did kind
- 7:34of give me the initial guidelines of what he was looking for. But I
- 7:39really think if there's a pecking order, and I think most comic book fans
- 7:42who know comic book history would agree that, I would say Len is first,
- 7:48then Herb Trippy, then John remita senior, and finally Roy Thomas.
- 7:53So if you want to list co creators, sadly these other three people aren't
- 7:57with us anymore. You know, John just died a last year, and
- 8:01Herb died a few years ago, and poor Lenn died a few years ago.
- 8:03Lenn was in tough health, and I'm really glad that Marvel did right
- 8:09by Lenn and gave him a nice fat paycheck near the end of his life
- 8:15as a thank you. This current controversy reminds me of it wasn't a controversy,
- 8:22but it's kind of murky if you go back to the Silver Age and
- 8:26you say, well, who created the Barry Allen version of The Flash?
- 8:31Julie S. Schwartz, the editor of Showcase, said I want a new
- 8:37version of the Flash and updated version. John Broom wrote the story Carmei and
- 8:41Fantino drew the story, and again is Julie's involvement in the creating Barry Allen
- 8:48along the same lines as Roy Thomas when it comes to Wolverine. I don't
- 8:52know. I really don't know. I wasn't there. We weren't there in
- 8:56the seventies for the creation of Wolverine when they were making that whole issue.
- 9:01And sadly Roy is the only man living that can give his side of the
- 9:05story. But again we don't get Lens side. So I don't doubt that
- 9:09Roy had a hand in creating Wolverine, but it does kind of bother me
- 9:16that he has gone to the length of claiming full co credit rights. Apparently,
- 9:24according to Disney and Marvel, Roy will be listed as a co creator
- 9:28on the credits of the upcoming Deadpool Wolverine movie. He will get some sort
- 9:35of compensation. I don't know what the amount was. It could be a
- 9:39six figure sum. Possibly it could be a four figure sum. I remember
- 9:43at Brewbaker only getting five thousand dollars for creating the concept of the Winter Soldier
- 9:50in Captain America Winter Soldier, but in the comics first Winter Soldier arguably is
- 9:54the best I think solo Marvel movie of the and Marvel era, and it's
- 10:01certainly my favorite. And I know it's a lot of other peoples and we
- 10:03all feel like it got jipped. I also know that the laundry list of
- 10:09Roy Thomas characters is certainly impressive of the various people, and you can look
- 10:16up online the other great characters. In fact, in the conversation with Roy
- 10:20and his co panelist Susanna Flores that I'm going to present later, I list
- 10:24a bunch of other creations by Roy, by the way, including ultron Age
- 10:28of ultron Well, you know, I bet Roy got a check for that.
- 10:33But I wonder if, like a lot of other Silver Agent Bronze Age
- 10:39creators who have had to remind the parent companies, by the way, I
- 10:43did create this and deserve some sort of compensation. It might be small,
- 10:48like I said, it might only be four figures. I really don't know.
- 10:52I know of creators from DC and Marvel that when these characters have been
- 10:58exploited in television the checks aren't huge, but in some cases recurring. I
- 11:03know in the Supergirl TV series, a guy like Jerry Ordway got you know,
- 11:09a decent check some sort of residual. It wasn't life changing, but
- 11:15it certainly was helpful added income. And again these are my words, not
- 11:18Jerry's, but based on my conversations with Jerry, both on and off the
- 11:22air, I can say that I again, I'm shaking my head right now,
- 11:28and I'm really speaking steporaneously. I don't know. And it does kind
- 11:33of bother me that len Ween's widow has to share money with Roy. But
- 11:43then again, maybe Disney saw this as like, all right, let's catch
- 11:46up with our money that we probably owe Roy for the many characters that he
- 11:52created from the Marvel Universe that have been and likely in the future will be
- 11:56exploited in Disney TV shows and movies. Maybe there's some of that in this
- 12:01agreement. What also really bothers me is I know that a man that represents
- 12:07Roy these days and has been for many years, almost ten years. As
- 12:11far as I know, I'm not gonna name him. You can find out
- 12:18if you really want to hunt around and read some of the articles, you'll
- 12:20get his name. Not a fan of this guy, and frankly, I
- 12:24think is an opportunist that is likely getting a slice of whatever Roy is gonna
- 12:30get again. I don't mean to mitigate Roy's amazing contributions to Marvel, amazing
- 12:35contributions to DC as well. Roy's a great writer on his own and a
- 12:41guy just like all these other silver and Bronze age guys that are still around.
- 12:46Hey, if you're gonna exploit their stuff in films or in TV,
- 12:50they deserve a check, and they deserve a healthy check. And I mean
- 12:54again, think of the multi millions that DC has made from the creation of
- 13:01Jerry Siegel and Joe Schuster. When it comes to Superman. Think of all
- 13:05the money that came from And you got to give Bob Kane a little credit,
- 13:09but you better throw in Jerry Robinson and Bill Finger two when it comes
- 13:11to Batman and Robin and the Joker and all the Batman mythos that Bill Finger
- 13:16and Jerry Robinson majorly contributed to alongside Bob Kane's initial idea. You know,
- 13:24these guys deserve and their estates deserve to be paid. I think we all
- 13:28agree on that. Again, I'm so conflicted about this. It's one of
- 13:33the reasons why I wanted to present this episode, which not only has this
- 13:41conversation between myself doctor Susanna Flores, who wrote a book called The Psychology of
- 13:46Wolverine, and Roy himself, because you'll get Roy's side of the story in
- 13:52his own words back in twenty eighteen, six years ago. I wish Lenn
- 14:01were around to kind of raise his end and say, well, yes,
- 14:03Bud or no, I think Roy. You know again, the originalized DA
- 14:07started with Roy and I executed it. But no, I would consider Roy
- 14:13a co creator as well. Man Lenn was such a gracious guy, you
- 14:18know. I don't know, but regardless, I know Roy's representation is rather
- 14:24forceful, and I think he kind of laid the carpet for this a couple
- 14:28of years ago, and it's likely been hounding Marvel and Disney about this fact,
- 14:33especially knowing after Logan that they were going to come back with at least
- 14:37one more Wolverine movie. The likelihood is as Marvel and Disney move forward,
- 14:43Wolverine will be recast as the X Men enter the Marvel Cinematic universe, and
- 14:48we'll get another Wolverine. Roy's in his eighties. I don't know this gravy
- 14:54train, won't you know. I don't know. I don't know how it
- 14:56was set up. I don't know if Roy's wife or if Roy has children,
- 15:01if there will be an a state and they will continue to get compensated
- 15:05for Wolverine in the same way that Jack Kirby's grandchildren got a nice settlement.
- 15:11I don't know if they get ongoing payment for the use of Kirby characters in
- 15:15Marvel movies and TV. I do remember reading years ago, and I'm sure
- 15:20you could find online how stan Lee was compensated beyond his death, and his
- 15:26wife Joan made money for a long time. His daughter also made money for
- 15:31a reasonable amount of time. Again, I don't want to see these Bronze
- 15:35Age and Silver age creators screwed the way that Siegel and Schuster were. I
- 15:43don't know. I really don't know. So to get more into this,
- 15:48I'm going to present now this great conversation between Roy Thomas, Susanna Flores,
- 15:54and myself. It happened at terrific On back in twenty eighteen. Judge for
- 16:00yourself, and again, I can appreciate the binary society we live in that
- 16:04everything is black and white. I think there are a lot of shades of
- 16:07gray when it comes to the creation of Wolverine. And again I can see
- 16:14an argument where Roy might deserve some credit, but I still at the end
- 16:18of the day think Lenn and Herb Trimpy deserve a hell of a lot.
- 16:22More So, again, my pecking order would be Len Ween, Herb Trimpy.
- 16:27John Remade a senior than Roy Thomas. You know that role of an
- 16:32editor. What does it mean? How involved was Roy beyond what we've heard
- 16:38as far as these are the cues and then go make it. There are
- 16:41quotes that are all over the place from both Lenwin and Roy Thomas in the
- 16:45past, some in a very humble way in Roy's part to say that len
- 16:51did the heavy lifting. I don't know. I really really don't know.
- 16:56So as further and ammunition to judge for yourself, I wish I had a
- 17:00conversation with myself and Lynn. I only had a very brief convention floor conversation
- 17:07with Lynn about fifteen years ago, and frankly, I was really focused on
- 17:11what he was doing currently, which was DC Animation, and he did a
- 17:17Batman Superman annual where it was a news story with that crazy villain, the
- 17:22composite Superman that was on one side of his body Superman on the other side
- 17:27of his body Batman, one of my favorite Goofy's Silver Age origins. But
- 17:33that's what Lenna and I talked about on the record. I had several encounters
- 17:37with Lenn, including at his last San Diego, and man, that poor
- 17:41guy. I was so glad he was in a wheelchair. He just he
- 17:45looked like he was dying. I don't mean to be rude, but it
- 17:48was wonderful. And I shook his hand, said and I knew how much
- 17:53events like Comic Con meant to Len, and it had to be just a
- 17:57positive tonic of ex experience for Len to be at that last comic Con.
- 18:03And I'm like, Glenn, we're all so glad you're here. And he
- 18:06smiled and shook my hand, and yeah, it was tough, it was.
- 18:08It really was bittersweet. So I'm glad I got to say goodbye to
- 18:12Lenn without actually saying it. But you know, sadly, we all kind
- 18:15of knew the end was near. Anyway, This is Easter Sunday when I'm
- 18:21recording this intro, and I don't know, I really don't know. I
- 18:26don't know if fan backlash will cause Disney to make any subtle changes to the
- 18:32agreement again, given Roy's body of work and contributions to Marvel that were extensive
- 18:38and should not be denied. If it's like a kind of culmination of payback
- 18:44of yeah, you know, kind of like Kirby and the Kirby grandchildren.
- 18:48You know, maybe we own we owe this creator more than whatever we initially
- 18:52paid him for the times that the Vision and Ultron have been used in Avenger
- 18:59movies. I really don't know, so a little more Chris for the mill.
- 19:03From the Word Balloon perspective. In this conversation with doctor Susanna Flores and
- 19:11Roy Thomas, sadly not Lennwen, I wonder what Lenn was thinking from heaven
- 19:15as he was watching this conversation. Was he shaking his fist, was he
- 19:18nodding along? None of us will know, But here's that conversation from terrificon
- 19:23back in twenty eighteen. Now on Word Balloon. My name is John Santris.
- 19:33I host a podcast called word Balloon, and one of our panels has
- 19:36actually been on the podcast. But I'm very excited to be here today for
- 19:41the psychology of Wolverine. And this is going to be great because let's get
- 19:47really into the psychology the psychoses of Logan, a very complicated character that started
- 19:55with this gentleman. Roy Thomas a legendary comic book writer and editor who was
- 20:00Family's first successor as editor in chief of Marvel Comics. He's known for co
- 20:03creating some of the comics greatest characters, such as Wolverine, Carol Danvers,
- 20:08Morbius, Division I Am Fist, and Ultram. He introduced the pulp magazine
- 20:12heroes Conan and Red Sonia, along with the sci fi fantasy Star Wars to
- 20:17Marvel Comics. How About That. Also, Roy has had lengthy writing states
- 20:22on Marvel's X Men and Avengers, and in DC Comics, The All Star
- 20:26Squadron and Infinity Incorporated, among many other titles, books, and a couple
- 20:30of movies like Fire Knight's Big Fan. Yeah Right, You're the guy in
- 20:34Solid Artside got on my DVD? Come On Man. Yeah. In twenty
- 20:40eleven, he was inducted into the Will Eisner Comic Book Hall of Fame and
- 20:42currently edits the Comic History magazine that I Get every time there's a new issue
- 20:48Alter Ego, and also works with Stanley on the Spider Man newspaper strip.
- 20:52Mister Roy Thomas ladies and gentleman and also joining us forgive me psychiatrists or psychologists,
- 21:02psychologists, psychologists, thank you. I know there's a distinction. Yeah,
- 21:04I prescribe medications. It'd be way more popular. We'll have to talk
- 21:07about it, all right, that's good enough. Who wrote the psychology of
- 21:11Wolverraine? Doctor Susannah flores So, doctor, So this is man. I
- 21:21think you picked a pretty complex person character to write a book about, Susanne.
- 21:26So Susanna, So tell me, yeah, tell me about what intrigue
- 21:30about writing a book about Wolverine. Well, to me, very forthcoming.
- 21:33Now, I was not racing. I recently became one, and now that
- 21:38I'm in cool And it heard a few years ago to during a time when
- 21:45I was actually assaulted. And I'm putting it out there because it's an important
- 21:51topic to talk about. And you know, a lot of people assume that
- 21:55psychologists said, you know, we only experience the same level of trauma as
- 21:59other people, just because as we understand the game of behavior. And I'm
- 22:02here as witness to tell you that it's absolutely not the case. During that
- 22:07time was very difficult for summer reason. It's not just the trauma, but
- 22:11also the judgment from society and an experience firsthand how people loved to win the
- 22:15victim, and I just felt the numb I think that was the worst part,
- 22:21is the numbing, because before and then I was like South Side of
- 22:23Chicago girl, I was to opinionated in your Facebook. I the enemy and
- 22:29I lost myself completely. And then I ran across the panel of long bull
- 22:34ring from the Dark Penis side out word the hell Fire Club, and he's
- 22:38in the gutter and he's covered in dungu and he beaten in battle, and
- 22:45still he had his You know, I had imagined Claus out right, and
- 22:48then it was a sneer, right, the sneer I'm going to get them
- 22:55back, right, like you've taken your best shot outs soccers and now it's
- 22:59my turn. Something just kept bringing me back to that panel, like I
- 23:03can put it away your things, saw it to come at a star like
- 23:04I just saw it and then come back and said, Okay, there's something
- 23:08here, like some mythological pool or something. Because obviously, and I don't
- 23:12believe we go into this in terms of inspiration. So I looked at like,
- 23:18ok, who's to this guy? And of course we like we know
- 23:19somethings we love movies or so, but I didn't. I wasn't a bad
- 23:22funnel year with the character. And then the more I researched, the more
- 23:26I realized, Wow, like okay, that panel of him in the gutter,
- 23:32that was me. I was there and sorry, sometimes it's just so
- 23:40hits. Trauma has a way of sneaking upon you. Sometimes it just you
- 23:47know, when people say, like, when are you completely ild? I'm
- 23:48like anything, know, but you know, so he was raw and he
- 23:57was damaged, and so was I. And from then on when I researched
- 24:03him, I realized that he and people would think that he's a very simple
- 24:07character, he actually is very complex because he mirrors our realities in so many
- 24:12different ways. And in this case, for me, he represented the need
- 24:19that I had to get any grade like not just a little angry, pissed
- 24:25off like mutes piss yeah, okay, And I went off on whoever I
- 24:33needed to go off on. And it was a matter of me for playing
- 24:37my truth and I needed to fight back and I was not going to win
- 24:41a legal battle, and I didn't care. It was a matter of I
- 24:45am going to make this as painful as I can or for longer because I
- 24:49am proclaiming my truth and win I lose. That's ould Raine talky is that
- 24:55sometimes the clients things are not okay, and we had to listen to are
- 25:00young or to remind us of you know, who we are and what we
- 25:03stand for and that's not to be compromised, and learning to live with as
- 25:11you managed to strust myself the start of myself while creating patients and just realizing
- 25:17that Jen like Wolverine, we're all perfectly imperfect, we're all damaged in some
- 25:22way, and so that was the being Wow. Now, Roy, when
- 25:27you had all of that, how do I want to take it back to
- 25:33the beginning, Because now Len Len Wayne and her Trippy did the first story
- 25:37in art, but I know that the concept of Wolverine began with you,
- 25:42and I want to hear that story. But when you hear that, because
- 25:47so much has been built from the foundation of where the character started. Were
- 25:51you thinking about a psychologically damaged character when you were conceiving Wolverine? No,
- 25:57No, I mean I'll take whatever credit I feel. You know I'm deserved
- 26:02and I don't want you know, and I owed him more all ahead of
- 26:06you, lifting on the character, you know, after its basic content was
- 26:10done first bying genre Meter designing Hostle okay, sure earlier. Lynn is the
- 26:18writer that I asked to do it because he had to help roaming around.
- 26:21I thought he would be easy for him to get up to Canada and to
- 26:25do a story there, which he did very quickly. And of course then
- 26:29her Trippy is the artist who actually had to take that one drawing or so
- 26:32of Wolverine and make it just later on other people added Dave Cockrand brought in
- 26:37like a face because you know, Ghenre Metera didn't design a face on him,
- 26:40and Cochran used the face of another character who I guess had been called
- 26:45the Wolverine that he had showed me before. Had no connection with the thing
- 26:48I did. It was sub character geting made up for DC for the leach
- 26:51of the superhero. So it meant nothing to me because you know, I
- 26:55mean I knew what a Wolverine was since I was like five, you know,
- 26:57I was always interested in a was and and also I thought about it.
- 27:03Well, we'll tell you what happened. Happened is that we were doing
- 27:07all these books. This is I guess seventy four that's too long before I
- 27:11quit his editor. Gee. It suddenly heard me one day that we had
- 27:14we had I don't know, five percent, ten percent whatever of our readers,
- 27:18you know, certainly several percent where I'm in Canada. You know they
- 27:22read English. They you know, they were their clothes, they got some
- 27:26of our cominges. And you know, we should have a Canadian character.
- 27:29I had already made up for expin with infnition, with artists of course,
- 27:33the Bansheet and Sunfire, you know, with Irish and Japanese backgrounds. But
- 27:37I thought, you know, we should have a Canadian character. So I
- 27:40called lenin and I see, you know, if Len hadn't been available,
- 27:44or you know something or somebody else would writing in the hall, he would
- 27:47have been the person or whatever. But Lenn was like, you know,
- 27:49one of the couple of very best you know writers economy. So we worked
- 27:52out very well way and I called it up and I brought him and said
- 27:56that just four things is James Woolvery? And I thought, am I calling
- 28:00him badger? You know? I wanted an animal that lives up in off
- 28:03the partner. But what am I to call him? You know? The
- 28:07moose? You know, to say that it was awful, But what find
- 28:12aside was not. I didn't remember the name of you know, the character
- 28:17that they've had. But the thing is that or else I wouldn't have thought
- 28:22of the badger. But the thing is that a badger, you know,
- 28:26as a verb, it just sounds like somebody's annoying or you're badgering somebody.
- 28:29He doesn't have that right sound. Even though the badger is a very fairst
- 28:32feature and Wolverine, nobody knew what that was either. John Bravida said that
- 28:37when he's when he saw the name, he thought it was a female wolf,
- 28:40that he had to look it up. The picture of the side repeta
- 28:41but uh uh. But I liked it because it sounded like wolf. You
- 28:45know, anything that sounds like wolf the good word for a character. So
- 28:48Wolverine was good. So I just said I wanted to call the wolverine.
- 28:53You know. They dropped the later, but that was the original thing.
- 28:56And he was Canadian. And Lennon done brother Voodoo another character concept of mine,
- 29:03a little not quite as memorable as Wolvery, and I liked the way
- 29:08he had done the accent for that character Haitian character. Of course, he
- 29:12gave a Jamaican accent, but it's still his accent. So I said,
- 29:15you can do a Canadian accent. You know, it's so weird that which
- 29:18I guess been putting the word a in the end, and the other two
- 29:22things, which is when he'd kind of forgotten and he sort of rediscovered the
- 29:26wheel by lead himself. But I told him, I said, he's got
- 29:27to be short because I want to, you know, wolverine is a small
- 29:30animal, which I like because all the heroes are all six foot something tall,
- 29:34and I wanted a hero that was shorter, saying hot as knee say
- 29:38or something. You know, there weren't that many of those. So and
- 29:41the other one was that he would be very fierce, because the wolverine was
- 29:45noted for attacking the animals several times in size. And with that I set
- 29:48it off the lead and everything else was either done by Lend with the artists
- 29:52or else a little later, after just a couple of stories by lead by
- 29:56Chris Clarmont, who really developed the character of the most I forget, you
- 30:00know myself, whether it's len or what some of them gave him Adam,
- 30:04I didn't tell him give him clause specifically or let them let him own adam
- 30:08Antium clause. I'm happy it is since I had also created Adam ACiE,
- 30:12so it was nice. But that was strictly either lenn Or or Chris,
- 30:18and it was probably Chris in conjunction with Dave Cockran originally and later John Burne,
- 30:22but especially with the early days of COCCR that developed that character. After
- 30:26what he really became the breakaway star of the Accident and one of Marvel's you
- 30:32know, I'm happy to say, even though I don't own the piece of
- 30:34him or anything, one of Marvel's you know, handful of most popular characters.
- 30:38But you know, as I said, it was other people that did
- 30:41at all. I just sort of my job was to kind of get things
- 30:42going. It wasn't even to create characters. But once in a while when
- 30:45I had an idea, I would either do it myself or get somebody else
- 30:49to do it. And that was basically but I was afraid that you know,
- 30:52it would unfortunately, you know, Len and her alonger with this,
- 30:56but you know, they were the ones that you know, really got it,
- 31:00got it, Billy. It is interesting that, as you say,
- 31:03it started from a Dave Cochrane, drawing for the leeching of Superhero, said,
- 31:07there is timber Wolf, who's very similar to Wolf Ringe. Yeah,
- 31:10but that's the thing I don't I don't think it started from that drawing at
- 31:12all. Oh but I just think he did it first, I said,
- 31:15And I saw it, but I saw about ten characters. And as I
- 31:18said, when I started for the day, I started to think of just
- 31:22animals, and I thought of Wolverine and Badger and Moose and maybe a couple
- 31:25other animals. But what Dave did that later was when Wolverine takes off his
- 31:30mask sort of, he gave him the head I think that he had had
- 31:33for the civilian version of Jewelry. But of course that had nothing to do
- 31:37with his creation, because you know he didn't have that. But that's the
- 31:41thing, you know, you start creating things too. Some characters have one
- 31:45creator. Bill Erett created the Submarer, nobody else, probably Carl Berger has
- 31:48created human Torch. I started to say, Bob Kana Batman. We know
- 31:52that isn't true. But anyway, our Doctor Bolton and Wonder Room, and
- 31:56that's not true. But you know a few things have one creator, but
- 32:01mostly they often they have two or or in the case of some four or
- 32:06five or six, and with Wolverine you'd have to have at least three or
- 32:08four before you could even I got annoyed when they I think they left her
- 32:12Trippy's name off of the Logan movie they had. Don't get it. I
- 32:16mean I was really annoyed, absolutely because the guy who did. And yet
- 32:20when they've got Luke Cage on Netflix, they give George Tuska the credit and
- 32:23his role in Louke Cage with a bit exactly what hers was. Sure the
- 32:28characters had one drawing, and you know, and then do that story from
- 32:31a plot, you know, so you know, they do the best they
- 32:35can with these credits. You know, it's hard to and you know it's
- 32:37hard to figure out who did it because if you ask, you know,
- 32:39everybody did it, you know well, and it was a group effort.
- 32:43And in fact, because of that, there was always this mystery about Wolverine,
- 32:46and for decades that was part of the intrigue of Wolverine was he didn't
- 32:51know his background and we didn't know his background. And Susanna, I want
- 32:54to know from you as well, because I love the book. I read
- 32:59the book and It's fantastic because it really is a hand in hand examination of
- 33:04Wolverine's personal psychoses but reflected through the comics and in the films. And you
- 33:09know, Paul Jenkins was given the assignment back in the early two thousands to
- 33:15do the origin story and that was very controversial, and I remember the controversy,
- 33:20and I've even interviewed Paul about said controversy as well. So you know,
- 33:27well both of you, and Susanna will start with you first. Was
- 33:30it helpful that there was a clear origin because again, for us, a
- 33:35lot of times as defense, the mystery was always part of the entry.
- 33:38So I'm very able that the origin story was written. Because as a psychologist,
- 33:43we always go back to the child party. Where did it stem?
- 33:47Are in this phase the absence the emotionally absent monitor, which led to what
- 33:55we call pound class trauma where you were review the either adored or neglected by
- 34:02a primary parent, and your self esteem is of course affected, your sense
- 34:08of trust, your your fear of vulnerability. This is probably something very familiar
- 34:14great the needs to distance yourself from people when you when you get too close.
- 34:19Best complex trauma and the associated the memory loves we call that associative amnesia.
- 34:25So we had a name for all of these days. But everything began
- 34:30to make sense. And so Paul Jenkins was one of the first peek who
- 34:32was the first person that I interviewed. I got connected with him through a
- 34:37friend of elliots around a came a piece of Chicago, and so Kin and
- 34:43I started talking about why we were both drawn to both great and the answer
- 34:46was simply pain. We both experienced, you know, pain in some way
- 34:51the hand and who hasn't And it's actually wanted to share that interesting part because
- 34:57he was very kind and very supported that. He said, so you're sharing
- 35:00your story and I was like, like, so called theist are not supposed
- 35:06to do that, and he said, it humanizes you and it's it's literature
- 35:12and reality in the sense that Wolverine is afraid of vulnerability and right now you
- 35:16need to conquer yours. And I said, okay, I will if you
- 35:20will, and he had his own story and he's like, oh, you
- 35:22know, so we kind of agree to share our stories there. So yeah,
- 35:27I'm very grateful of the origin of the story It's sister, because it
- 35:30added to the explanation of why Olga is the way that he is, you
- 35:34know, and also why perhaps he's attracted the red heads, right, rosal
- 35:38Era, right, and why he becot after win and he goes after perhaps
- 35:49the unattainable. It's safer, right, so we can get to the women.
- 35:52Yeah, absolutely, yeah, why each of them represents so when?
- 36:00And again also as an editor, and these pieces of Wolverine's history were added
- 36:06to you know, the story and everything. Was you know, was it
- 36:09great that he was a man of mystry? Was it great when they finally
- 36:13decided to well he had to remember by the time the Wolverine comedy came out
- 36:17and then six months a year later the giant size X Men, which was
- 36:22like his next So right, I had left being editor in chief, and
- 36:29although I almost came back, I ended up not so basically that was really
- 36:31you know, out of my hands paid for you know, I only I
- 36:37read a bunch of X Men back in about nineteen eighty three years or so,
- 36:42when my then writing partner in movies, Jerry Conway, and I were
- 36:45writing an X Men movie script for Ryan that never got made, and the
- 36:51people that were doing it, they they wanted to change it in ways that
- 36:53you know, I didn't think were right, but they did. They were
- 36:55smarted enough to keep Wolverine anyway, so that at that time I went back
- 37:00and was reading the material by that had been drawn by Cocherman there ay Byrne,
- 37:02and I read that and so forth, and you know, I found
- 37:06they'd probably done some nice things with that, with that character. And it's
- 37:09interesting to see, of course that I would sporadically I would see that somebody
- 37:14was doing something weird, like you know, like Frank Miller with his taken
- 37:19him to Japan and all that came to the base of what the second of
- 37:22the Wolverine movies and so forth. But it was interesting that you know,
- 37:25you know, you've got a good character, I guess, so that we
- 37:28all made up together out of pieces when it's open to that kind of interpretation.
- 37:32Because all these characters, I think, I guess Batman maybe the supreme
- 37:37example, they all became. They're all like rorshach tests or blots, you
- 37:42know. They you know, eventually you've got you got enough writers and enough
- 37:45artists, and everybody wants to have his own interpretation, and if the editors
- 37:50allow that, encourage it, when the audience encouraged it, as they have
- 37:52in recent years, You're gonna sometime it gets a little weird, Like I
- 37:57think it's like they're at least fifteen or twenty Batman now, it would not
- 38:00even recognize each other in the same room. I sometimes think Wolverine, I
- 38:04think is and this is an approach I prefer. I think is always Wolverine,
- 38:07and there's a bit of respect for what the character was, and it's
- 38:10built up, but it's but thank Heaven, they haven't yet yielded as far
- 38:14as I know, to the temptation. The usual temptation is for the egotistic
- 38:19creator to come in and say everything you know about character X is wrong,
- 38:22but I'm here to tell you what it really is like. You know,
- 38:25why do you do that? You know you're in that in the presence of
- 38:29an egotistical idiot who will not be telling you the defendant of anything, but
- 38:31he may still do some good word I love also, and we will get
- 38:37into the women. But as far as the howlt family, uh, Sabretooth's
- 38:40role in Wolverine's formation of his character and the mind tricks that Sabertooth over the
- 38:49years has been playing with Wolverine. I'm your father, I'm your brother,
- 38:53very very and now I'm blanking Chinatown if I just saw the movies, all
- 39:00that heard come from, I think in terms of that formation a lot of
- 39:05it. How to deal with Paul Jenkins and his brother and interesting, yeah,
- 39:08yeah, that's a little stream, you right. And so we started
- 39:13talking about the nature versus nurture argument, you know, how good two brothers
- 39:17that grew up in the relatively you know, this similar household end up so
- 39:22different. And again I don't want to divorce too much, but he just
- 39:28remembered that his family struggled financially and they were always at the bottom of the
- 39:30hill, you know, And so he swayed certain genders like his you know,
- 39:35the grandfather, the surly grandfather is actually his grandmother, and you know
- 39:39other things. But had talked about, you know, feeling like an outcast
- 39:43and feeling like a reject and feeling that you have to prove yourself and the
- 39:46psychological lived told into two brothers and how they ended up in different places,
- 39:52and I used so that's when I told him you have to let the share
- 39:54this you must let be shared too. And I'm glad you that sucks.
- 40:00This can be a group therapy session. So if if you would like to
- 40:05chime in with questions as we're discussing, I'm happy to open it to the
- 40:08floor as well, or or the three of us can talk, so seriously
- 40:12consider that as we as we move on. But also all right, so
- 40:16we we mentioned briefly Logan's women. Yes, the women that fascinate Logan,
- 40:22the women, both the attainable and the unattainable. Yes, and that again
- 40:27great, great part of your book as you kind of go down from Rose
- 40:30to Gene and Eureko as I always get her name wrong, Americo. Is
- 40:36I keep confusing her with the other Japanese character your, yeah, Urico and
- 40:42everything. But yeah, so yeah, talk about talk about the loves of
- 40:45Logan. Okay, so many many many loves of Logan. So I talk
- 40:49about triangulated love and to be confused with love triangle. So he talks about
- 40:57like how you need you know, like love, you know, try and
- 41:00commitment and uh and sis of course right and and so you know I had
- 41:05to do an analysis of why each character men. And he was going down
- 41:07at a dangerous road, right because you know, I was like, okay,
- 41:12taking who is the love of his life? Is a Gene or is
- 41:14it Marico, and I made an argument that you know, in many ways,
- 41:17Gene represents his strength. She's a fellow mutant, the most arguably,
- 41:22you know, one of the most powerful of mutants. And so I think
- 41:25he represents his strength and his mutation. But I think manuco represents his vulnerability
- 41:32and his willingness to do it's experience that in order to better himself. She
- 41:43makes him want to be a better man. And so there's a difference between
- 41:46the factelory of love, right. I'm I don't say that he doesn't love
- 41:50her. He loves her. He loves Gene, yes, but it's an
- 41:52infatuation. It's it's a love that has not come to fruition. And do
- 41:57you do wonder like if these two actually did about right when they last?
- 42:01And I think Gene is a very rational, reasonable person. That's why she
- 42:07chooses Scott because it is not a safe bet, you know, like you
- 42:12know, he's either gonna or you you know, or he's gonna STABU the
- 42:15better mesidently you know, and so you know, he's a little bit of
- 42:22a liability, sure, and she understand it. Throway spot, that's fine,
- 42:25Yeah, yeah, that's fine. You know, it's a you know,
- 42:29short term thing, no problem, right, And I think there's always
- 42:31been a chemistry between them, like there's always been that connection. But I
- 42:36think she makes a decision based on her head instead of her heart. And
- 42:42you know, so yeah, she's very near and dear. And in terms
- 42:44of the movies, you could see that he was just never the same after
- 42:49you know that Gene character died and so but I think that he finds new
- 42:52life through Manico. Really, you know, I'm glad she mentioned the movies
- 42:57because, as you say, when when the character originally created, he was
- 43:01meant to be this small, little, unattractive guy, and he didn't.
- 43:06He didn't an attractive He just had mean all right, small mean guy there,
- 43:09ye go. Yeah, but more of a more and I know you're
- 43:13a pulp guy, more of a Monk Mayfair than a Doc seven and I
- 43:15think a little of the head in mind. A favorite character. He was
- 43:20a minor character in DC, but a character I always loved as a kid,
- 43:23probably because I was small, the atom sure of the Justice Society who
- 43:28later did become atomic power. And he was always a tough and he was
- 43:31always a tough, mean kind of guy. He wore this kind of leather
- 43:35these leather pants, you know, brown leather pants. It was like a
- 43:38girdle almost, and you know, he didn't have any power, but he
- 43:40was a mean little guy that was trained by a boxing trainer and everything there
- 43:45was and so forth. And of course I didn't really know that when I
- 43:46was growing up. I was just he just appealed because he was small and
- 43:50strong, you know, and everything and and and the other favorite character of
- 43:52mine, another one that I used to play it being when I was like
- 43:57it was doll Man, sure who. He was like eight inches tall,
- 44:00you know, his giant compared at the later at it of the Freedoms and
- 44:04the doll main character and things like this. But so I didn't really you
- 44:07know. But obviously Hugh Jackman is not alarmingly sharp. Yeah, let's talk
- 44:12about that, because then we get Matt and a idol Hugh Jackman. Hey,
- 44:15great logan, don't get me wrong, right right, I just couldn't
- 44:19be forgot the whole short They wasn't that important. He's still smaller than a
- 44:22lot of the other X Men, even Colosses and these, you know,
- 44:25some of these other characters are still not huge. And the size about it.
- 44:30Yeah, actually I think he's kind of the leading mountain six foot tall.
- 44:32Yeah, I mean, I've never met him. I don't know,
- 44:36it's still as important thing that wasn't what you usually thought about. It was
- 44:39the size of shir Pierson's really that. You know, you think of the
- 44:43size, and cause there was some characters like Thor, but sizes is what
- 44:46you think of when you think of Wolverine, even if he's played by a
- 44:49six foot guy size. I don't know. Have you Have you enjoyed the
- 44:57X Men movies? Right? Yeah? Mostly? You know, Apotops to
- 45:00me was like too much like a cartoon villain of a Saturday morning cartill disappointed.
- 45:05But I do generally like the movies that they're so complex. Sometimes you
- 45:09know, not if you're not a regular reader of the books, it's a
- 45:12little hard to follow. And then of course it's going to beer off in
- 45:14its own direction. But you know, I'm not gonna equival with what was
- 45:17the real first Marvel superhero, you know, success and so forth, and
- 45:22the fact they've made a number of the movies or with what you know,
- 45:25Len Chris and the other guys did with in the comics and so forth.
- 45:29You know, it's it's an amazing accomplishment, and even after what the larger
- 45:31part of two decades, Yeah, it's still a going, going concern and
- 45:37now leading to you know, to more things in the future. So I
- 45:40think it's it's great. I'm disappointed that we won't see Hugh Jackman spoke and
- 45:45interact with the Marvel Cinematic universe, because that's a great opportunity. I can
- 45:50appreciate him feeling like, all right, it's time to go. Yeah,
- 45:53but you know, Susanna, what do you what do you think of?
- 45:55Because again I'm glad that you explore both the comics and the films well.
- 46:00As I got into this world and it started, you know, the research,
- 46:04and then the first time that it hurted me was like I have forty
- 46:07years of research and I like what I do, and of course getting I
- 46:15knew the movies first, but I experienced what a lot of X Men fans
- 46:21experienced when they first see the movies. I like, wait, that's not
- 46:23right, and that's certainly not right, you know, you know. My
- 46:25Husban's like, it's tough, it's not right, it's a correct So I
- 46:31enjoyed him too. I think huge Aha definitely brought Wolverte. You know,
- 46:37the aspect I think he brought him best was the vulnerability, like he made
- 46:43a move. Wolver very liable and you you you cared about him, you
- 46:47fell the passion and empathy for him and you he he really exemplified the suffering.
- 46:53You know, look at how he is a tortured soul in any ways,
- 46:58So no, I definitely enjoyed them. How you write about the populist,
- 47:01but I do. You're okay? The next there was canceled for a
- 47:04few years there or else you'd had any word? Yeah, you're right,
- 47:07the very Luckily I had a lot of help. Any questions from the audience
- 47:14or we didn't serve? How did you feel about Logan as a as a
- 47:16book end of that portrayal of the character, Yeah, I'd like to hear
- 47:21the situation of that the common name of anyone can really gets close to my
- 47:24Emily Loves come to a bad end. I thought that movie was superherb.
- 47:30I love the ending I write like of aving because in order to write this
- 47:36book, I had to really imagine that this person was real, so he
- 47:40wasn't real to me in order to write it and to have that excruciating,
- 47:46very painful ending was hard for many of us. I love that his the
- 47:53struggle continued, the inner conflict continued, and you know, absolutely it was
- 47:59still right in the regards the impression is stimiliar and mutans are never seen as
- 48:07equals and they're still hiding or such. But you know those that are the
- 48:12newer generation. But I think that my favorite part was handing where everyone's seen
- 48:19it right and that's gonna behave okay, you know where he had to let
- 48:28that vulnerability go, like he had to work through. That is the whole.
- 48:32That's what he means to me is that it is resurrection if you will
- 48:37through through suffering. It is healing through suffering. And at that moment he
- 48:43saw Laura and he left her that legacy of don't become what they made you.
- 48:51And also he dies supplies back forward the glow of the cart standing,
- 48:54which is very close to Yeah. Yeah, it was Ortellian right, like
- 49:00you know, there's a lot everywhere you would have your heart in your hand.
- 49:02It was very beautiful. And I think the part that got gave more
- 49:06than the death itself was when Laura grabbed the cross and she did you chuck
- 49:12down now, she she turned it over to an x you know, because
- 49:15he was the last X Men at that point in fear Went. But it
- 49:23was true he was, and that was more appropriate for him. I think
- 49:30the movie did it justice. I think that it this this long row that
- 49:36you Jack had it. He ended it beautifully, very beautifully. What you
- 49:40think of the X Men or the Wolverine movies, right, I liked all
- 49:45the movies that the last one was definitely the probably the high point. I
- 49:50probably quite remember it as well, you know, maybe because as I saw
- 49:52it just as another movie. I enjoyed it. I was seeing my popcorn
- 49:57sitting there. Whoa, you know, I always go to the theaters like
- 50:00I go in something like a Monday afternoon I might be only it's almost like
- 50:04a private screen. And usually even a popular movie. I enjoyed it tremendously.
- 50:08I thought it was real. It was the first what R rated,
- 50:12Yeah, well, Dark Night of the Marvel movie of the Marble Artist death.
- 50:15Ye know, well yeah, you're right, technically dead Pool, but
- 50:19yeah, you know Fox exactly exactly. But yeah, and you know I
- 50:22thought that I like that. I guess the Fox, right, I probably
- 50:27you know, just didn't you know, I don't remember it quite as well.
- 50:30I saw it, I said, the movies since but I intend to,
- 50:35you know, watch it again one of these days. I just haven't
- 50:37got around to it. But it was an excellent movie. Stan always said
- 50:39that, you know, stan Lee always leaned on the fact that, you
- 50:43know, mutants were substitutions for minorities and some of the problems and stuff.
- 50:49Was that evident in the sixties and seventies. Yeah, honestly way, And
- 50:52I appreciate you saying that because, truthfully, I mean, I'm glad that
- 50:55it grew up to that. I'll tell you the thing, you too.
- 50:58I think it was there from the beginning. But I doubt if you know,
- 51:01San and Jack, because they both worked on the plots, I I
- 51:06doubt if they really ever consciously thought except of course, she wants the human
- 51:09condition, so you're naturally, you know, when you start building a character
- 51:13and you're trying to get human emotions, it's going to come out. And
- 51:15whether they actually physically thought they did sort of think about the outsider, I
- 51:20don't think. I don't think that they would necessarily think of, you know,
- 51:22like that civil rights connections per se or something were close. But again,
- 51:27you know, it was still things were in the air. If they
- 51:30had created it two or three years later, probably they would have been more
- 51:32so, but you know, it's still something that they were aware of,
- 51:37and the whole idea of the Outsider has been in debt to a lot of
- 51:38superheroes, from sub Maritor and from Batman on, and so they just took
- 51:45it and he did it. I don't think that that was Stan's main motivation,
- 51:49but once he did his version of it, and then once Jack started
- 51:52drawing and adding to the plot and they all put it together, it was
- 51:54it was there from the start, and it had to be there and the
- 51:58start, because already just about what three or four years in, when Stan
- 52:01has finished the run, they did that they had had they had had become
- 52:06conscious enough that they did the Sentinels storyline, which, as far as I'm
- 52:08concerned, is almost the only really really good X Men stuff. I mean,
- 52:16I like the whole series, but the only thing that really to me
- 52:20stands out is really exceptional storyline in the entire series. Is you know that
- 52:25that Stan and Jack did before they turned it over to Lesser lightside me and
- 52:30believe me, I did kind of plunge before I've deserved it because you know,
- 52:34we didn't have the initial inspiration was the Sentinel storyline, because by that
- 52:37time he had realized that it was about uh, you know, bigotry and
- 52:43things for it, and it was you know, tell it. It was
- 52:45you know, made very very clear in that story, and which means that
- 52:50it was kind of partly there. And on the one hand, they kind
- 52:52of by then they'd sort of consciously recognized it and decided to really play with
- 52:55it, and and they really you know, did it with a bang.
- 53:00That's cool, Susannah, what did did you? And And not to put
- 53:01you on spot given that he's right next to you, but have you read
- 53:05Royce run on x Men Roy and Neil Roy and Neil Adams where Thomas and
- 53:10Neil Adams stated, we do not have Okay. Well, when I started
- 53:17out, it was just kind of imitating Stan and Jack, except without Jack,
- 53:22and that makes the difference, you know, sure, but it was
- 53:25still okay. But I don't think I was inspiring over a couple of people
- 53:29who did it after me. The lucky thing that happened was that Stan asked
- 53:32me that the sales were, you know, they were kind of soft,
- 53:36and so he eventually have me to come back. I guess they had been
- 53:37a little better under me. And uh, just one issue after I brought
- 53:42it back, Neil Adams walked in the door and said he'd like to do
- 53:45something you know awful, you know, some book that wasn't selling. And
- 53:47so I said, well, we got ex man and Neil and I had
- 53:54He doesn't remember we had met you a couple of times previously, but what
- 53:58at least was but you know, I was, you know, I'd seen
- 54:00his work, really liked it. We got on like a house fire and
- 54:04things, and you know, I would sort of just give him little direction
- 54:07and you know, let him do whatever he wanted to do. I had
- 54:09some ideas, you know, he had more, and he would just do
- 54:12whatever he wanted to do and we'd sort of tie it together, go out
- 54:15to lunch. By the end of the lunch we had some kind of story,
- 54:17you know, you know. And I think those issues, those those
- 54:21issue I'm not how to apologize to those Those were a good issue, yeah,
- 54:23and for both for both of them truly, and I think they were
- 54:27rather influential on what happened later Chris and the other people were doing and so
- 54:32forth in that sense. But you know, if we'd done Woe worry and
- 54:37maybe we'd have done okay by it, we'd never had a shot at it.
- 54:39But I want to get back to Logan and also more of your questions.
- 54:43There are there other questions about in the front, kind of a twofold
- 54:46question. I'm not sure how we sent in your researching for the book you
- 54:52went, but there's the old Man logan and what going on, and of
- 54:55course the return of Wolverine where he magic we escaped that adamantium. Did you
- 55:04go into the that at all when you research? What are your thoughts on
- 55:09the old Man logan, the storyline and now apparently he's going back and they're
- 55:16gonna geal up with that and that sort of thing. Well a funny thing
- 55:20about this sort of trauma feeling. Yeah, yeah, we heard here's a
- 55:24funny story about we'll very coming back. So the moot was complete and one
- 55:29of my friends called me and said you have to read and I was like
- 55:34what He's like, don't turn it until you read it. So I was
- 55:37like, okay, So then you know, Mary, I'm going to answer.
- 55:38And I was like all right, because I had and get you another
- 55:45section to it because sir, enough had you know, the first time that
- 55:49I hurt me, I was like, you can't toy with my emotions like
- 55:52this, you know, like we have completion. I had more, you
- 55:54know, I went through the grease stages and now you're doing this to be
- 56:00you know, and then a boy's back acceptance acceptance, yeah expected, and
- 56:05then you know, and then you know, my world gets started up.
- 56:07I know, I didn't address the old Man Logan, which was of course
- 56:12the inspiration for the Logan movie in yourself right, it gets like a Western
- 56:16field of readiness, and here's someone who has you know, I am never
- 56:22willing to unchieve my clause again because you know of the damage that he did,
- 56:29which was different than the Logan movie. Absolutely yeah, I'll be care
- 56:32and around us to say, I think that the day you're being responsible for
- 56:37the massacre makes more sense to me. I understand the power to do that.
- 56:42Like the other expend we're pretty powerful too. I don't know if they
- 56:45could you know, if we'll work can wipe them all out, you know.
- 56:50But you know, just that notion of Guild ten shame, you know,
- 56:54that lives with in this character. And you know, I remember obviously
- 57:00from John Vita Junior where he talked about, you know, his reach,
- 57:04and it occurred after nine o one, and he said that at that moment
- 57:07he wanted to be judge, jury and executioner and one and whatever was responsible.
- 57:13You know, He's like, love New York and no one's going to
- 57:15do this to New York. And you know, but he said, you
- 57:16have to tumber that, you know, with with with balance and grace,
- 57:22because you can't. And then he's like, but however Wolverine is, he
- 57:25is judge, jury and executioner, and as by far he wanted for one
- 57:30person to carry and that of coarsely screens to the old Man logan you begin
- 57:35where he's done. He doesn't want to do this anymore. I also like
- 57:38how beyond the Mark Miller's mini series, what they've done with old Man Logan
- 57:45in the more recent years, and that they are wrapping that up to allow
- 57:50modern day Wolfverine to come back and everything. But I really enjoyed his role
- 57:53in the six one, six and and and again, like you said,
- 57:57carrying that guilt and seeing an alternate universe where the damage hasn't happened yet,
- 58:04but it's almost like knowing that it could happen and that kind of responsibility,
- 58:08And I really I understand why it's necessary to go back to modern Wolverine,
- 58:13and I'm all for it. But I have to say I really did enjoy
- 58:16exploring old Man Logan beyond Millers. So you think they'll leave them in the
- 58:20comics, then you think Marbles, no, I think you're no. I
- 58:22think I think I think it's I think low old Man Logan will will yeah
- 58:27wrap up there, So they're not They're not gonna let Wolverine go the way
- 58:30of Hugh Jackman. Probably well they might as far as how however they get
- 58:36rid of them. I I don't know. I'm I know what I'm in
- 58:38is, but what I'm in is maybe no more be in the young cope
- 58:42a certain way that maybe they will be another Wolverine movies. But I think
- 58:45Marble will kind of hang on to him, you know that, come on,
- 58:47right? They can't get rid of the original. But isn't it it
- 58:54is? It is fun because there is that wish fulfillment and you have a
- 58:59character like that and where it's like, well it did Grace with me,
- 59:00Batman and stuff, and they've done it for for a moment, and Asrael
- 59:05certainly, and Danny O'Neill can speak to that obviously. Daniell be here by
- 59:07the way, Sunday if you guys are here all weekend, so Ben Danny
- 59:10O'Neill's here and find out about all that. But yeah, I mean,
- 59:14I mean, and that's why, as with Infinity War and everyone, it's
- 59:17great to see as I'm sure we all feel that way when we see,
- 59:22forgive the term mainstream audiences go, but Spider Man's done, what's gonna happen
- 59:29now? And it's like, and I love all the nerd blogs, here's
- 59:32how they can bring them back? And it's like, really, come on,
- 59:36man, there's like dozens of hundreds of writers and artists that have been
- 59:39doing it a lot better than Jimmy's blog telling you how Black Panther could come
- 59:44back. The same people that believe Superman was gonna die exactly, remember how
- 59:50I out of desperation absolutely the Superman, which they had done a couple of
- 59:53times before, and they but only in imaginary story as yeah, but they
- 59:58spoke. Yeah, you can tell the difference. But they do it on
- 1:00:02a slow news day, you know, when there's they couldn't do it now
- 1:00:06there's too much news. But back then, I guess twenty years ago they
- 1:00:08could the slow news days. All these reporters. Hey, the DC copies
- 1:00:13is killing all Superman and there's there'll be no more Superman, and they put
- 1:00:16it out and these idiots, you don't go out and buy all these comics
- 1:00:21and then you know, and then and then of course they're shot. They
- 1:00:22think they're going to put their children through school by buying one hundred copies of
- 1:00:25the Death the Superman. It is great, and just realize that death doesn't
- 1:00:30stick. Right. There's a lot of brainwashing. They getting a lot of
- 1:00:35brainwashing. They getting brainwashing, right, especially when people go down the aisle
- 1:00:39over apparently or something you know, and something you explore, and sir,
- 1:00:45I will get to your question. You explore uh. You know certainly his
- 1:00:49time at uh and now I'm blanking with Striker and Weapon X, you know
- 1:00:53the Weapon X period, the World War two period as well as is certainly
- 1:00:58mentioned in there in your very Winster Smith was hard. That was so difficult,
- 1:01:02and because because the only way I send I had around like, okay,
- 1:01:07how do I write this in sychological terms? And so I said,
- 1:01:10okays, the psychology of torture, and they had to do research of you
- 1:01:15know, what is real and what actually happens, and so very evening,
- 1:01:19like I either needed a scotchar this a film. Afterwards, you know,
- 1:01:22I was just like this is this is not okay, and you know,
- 1:01:24I am going to be taken to a very very very dark place because there's
- 1:01:30a lot of atrocities then to book her and I do in my book that
- 1:01:34Webin X and the X Men chatterber would be controversial and I can I can
- 1:01:38talk about the act can they do with Clara in a second, But yeah,
- 1:01:43webin X I that is probably my favorite series because he goes into like
- 1:01:47this this subconscious mind, you know, and you know even in his you
- 1:01:52know, uh the state of him being you know, assaulted and victimized and
- 1:01:57being an experiment and he's wanted to destroy them. You know, you see
- 1:02:00that rage there and is battlin and I heard and I oh sorry that the
- 1:02:07imnas from I probably led to him to his great humanity because he was fighting
- 1:02:14against being controlled, like he was fighting for his humanity. So I believe
- 1:02:19that, you know, like he that led to the ultimate delist of nature
- 1:02:22of the character. Very cool sir, you had a question. Excellent.
- 1:02:27I guess that's kind of you can change by the question a little, because
- 1:02:30I I was curious about you made of that period and they so they can
- 1:02:35help me in your life. It's detailed from like I think it's actor he
- 1:02:38lost his atomy at him when he is in this sort of that's field stage
- 1:02:45and it's uh a latro that sort of helps a great out his humanity.
- 1:02:51And that was something I was always curious about him, was that he's always
- 1:02:54found this appealed with uh Japan and with very structured orders of either ni jitsu
- 1:03:01or the samurai. And he is sort of interesting in that he is like
- 1:03:07if you look at like Plato's tritopic tripartite soul, he's mostly appetiting and sphirit.
- 1:03:14There's not a lot of reason. And I guess what is his appeal
- 1:03:20is the structure of those kind of codes of Japan. What is the appeal
- 1:03:25there for? You know, yeah, like they're both oftor. I think
- 1:03:36it's good the honor that he strives for. It's the code of honor and
- 1:03:40loyalty and discipline. And I know we also talking about his enemies, and
- 1:03:45I listen to Psyclops as one of them only be does. Yeah, it's
- 1:03:51interesting, Ry, but and listen to his one, because I think that
- 1:03:53he is envious of the discipline that the Cyclops has and that he perhaps may
- 1:03:59never acquire on some level. And so perhaps you know, maybe the Buddhist
- 1:04:05nature of you know, like allance or peace or so so that that's what
- 1:04:09I think when you need what she said, well, you know, I
- 1:04:15think there is something to the structure well, being able to channel the rage
- 1:04:19and the way that that a great samurai warrior can go bzooker when he needs
- 1:04:25to, but also you know, keep it tight when he needs to as
- 1:04:28well. I wondered also both of you, And I don't know Roy if
- 1:04:30you've read Greg rutkas Wolverine Run and Susanna, I don't know if you've read
- 1:04:35his run either, Okay, because yeah, I thought I thought he had
- 1:04:40a more introspective logan, which kind of turned off some fans, but I
- 1:04:45found interesting and stuff. Give me the time, called our pat My glasses
- 1:04:47were not ten minutes, so you know, honestly, that's like right at
- 1:04:51six, and we want to give it people a chance to come in and
- 1:04:54see the fonds. So I'm going to say five minutes actually, if that's
- 1:04:57okay, because you want to get people at Jeff the cove in the fond.
- 1:05:02Yeah, I mean, yeah, exactly. We're the opening act for
- 1:05:04Henry Winkler and everything. So well that's and also the romance thing kind of
- 1:05:08ran over because we went right till right till five. But anyway, please
- 1:05:14another question. Yes, I have a question. This book sounds very interesting.
- 1:05:18Where would I go to buy it? Oh? Yeah, well,
- 1:05:21thank you. It's us title exactly change. We're gonna filo a normal whole
- 1:05:31right the exactly and it is found at Amazon or Arginable or an English star
- 1:05:39danser right. I had a fighting for this title. Were having this conversation
- 1:05:43because you can answer this question better. But my understanding is that there's an
- 1:05:48arrivative of the reading language that you know, it means like adamantiam and is
- 1:05:53you know so Instagram and adamantium right, is montange or say my strength or
- 1:06:00unchanged, And so I explained that wow, it'd be just like you know,
- 1:06:03we are unbreakable. The thing is the well I said for it,
- 1:06:09I'll just mentioned where the name came from, since I had imagine it was
- 1:06:12such an important part of Woolver. And you're probably because you've asked you about
- 1:06:15it. But if the saying is that back what I was doing Avengers with
- 1:06:19Barry Smith was drawing in these a couple of issues that I doing. It
- 1:06:24was the second Ultrot storyline, Ultron six and into number collect the ball,
- 1:06:28and he and I wanted to get a medal. It would be the the
- 1:06:31moostal that the hardest metal you could possibly ever have. Anything else could only
- 1:06:36be, you know, breaking up against it. And I need the name,
- 1:06:40and I, you know, couldn't think that I'm not that good at
- 1:06:43the names. I never liked the names I made up. You know,
- 1:06:45I could choose a good one like Wolvery. But I must say I could
- 1:06:46have been betting the names, and Sana Jacket and some other people are.
- 1:06:49But I remembered that I had been in back of the early sixties, and
- 1:06:54I have it on my shop at home. I had a particular English language
- 1:06:59translation of the School This is Green Tragedy Prometheus bound and on the very like
- 1:07:04the first page or so, there's also a couple of charas in cradleson be
- 1:07:08a Force and might I made them Curtis the Aven years later too, and
- 1:07:11and there's a line in there that Prometheus is brought up to be, you
- 1:07:15know, so he can be chained up here and his gizzard will be out
- 1:07:17eaten. Every day they'll grow back and then they'll get it the next day.
- 1:07:21And and there's talk and there's a talk about that he's bound in Adamantine
- 1:07:26chains. Now I heard you an adamant but Adamantine. I hadn't seen that
- 1:07:29word before before sixty two zero or whatever I saw it, so suddenly it
- 1:07:33just came to me at Adamantine and from that it just became Adamantium. And
- 1:07:39you know, my greatest sorrow now is that they can't they can't use that
- 1:07:42in the Marvel Studios movies because it's kind of control, you know, it
- 1:07:45stuck in the XBN universe, because it's all funny, because this is a
- 1:07:49one number of call. I did better than Stanley Jack. I think adam
- 1:07:53Antium was a better metal name than Vibrating, But you know, they're they're
- 1:07:57both okay. I don't know, I'm pretty boded by the press. But
- 1:08:01adam I accidentally stumbling something kind of nice. Well, in case the merchant,
- 1:08:05it doesn't go through it. I imagine eventually we will be using Adamant.
- 1:08:10Yeah, they don't have a you know, by bye Brad Matthew versus
- 1:08:14mean, well you have to hear that. Well, you've got to test
- 1:08:15the metal against metal. Absolutely came on foregron conclusion. Absolutely. Other questions
- 1:08:20we've got about two minutes left, sir. Unrelated questions and psychology. Since
- 1:08:25you did so much research in the Little break, do you like any of
- 1:08:29the other characters involved with him? What's your next day of stay tuned?
- 1:08:38That's awesome, excellent, good, I'm glad you're going to be an artists
- 1:08:45aud that's cool. No, that's great. Yes, please your favorite part
- 1:08:53psychology me and the writers and the illustrators and the creators. Nice because you
- 1:09:00know what I was saying, saying it's very briefly about the accident, like
- 1:09:03where it had to be in my organs is something. Here's what I would
- 1:09:06say to that is that the mining is very complex and the subconscious mind is
- 1:09:12also very complex. So even if it wasn't conscious, it might have even
- 1:09:15been subconscious. And I think that you know, writers and illustrators employed in
- 1:09:19their stuff, they protect conto their character, their characters. Of course,
- 1:09:24it's inevitable, and so it was meeting them and meeting their stories and also
- 1:09:29just it's a different you know, culture and being embraced in this journey.
- 1:09:33This has been the best part by far. Well, remember this, this
- 1:09:35is a Those are two characters that were totally created by a Jewish writer editor
- 1:09:43and a Jewish cole plotter artist, characters with secret identities. These waterfloone was
- 1:09:51using the name they were born. Yeah, I mean, you know,
- 1:09:54there's there's got a lot of stuff in there. So the matter of fact
- 1:09:57that they whether they whether as I said, they recognized we're constantly trying to
- 1:10:00do it. But as somebody said, you know, and many people said,
- 1:10:02you can't write writing if you got to write something, and so so
- 1:10:06you dig into whatever you had and I'm sure that that some part of the
- 1:10:12Jewish experience problem. That's one of the reasons why it worked so well,
- 1:10:14maybe with some of the holot cost stuff with ni Agneto and Professor Accent Bafuly,
- 1:10:21because you know that came again out of the experience of the two people
- 1:10:26who really created the X Men. Between Absolutely, that's great. You know,
- 1:10:30I'm going to wrap up because we want to again give people a chance
- 1:10:32to get to the next bound. The title of the book again untamed the
- 1:10:35Psychology of Wolverine, and they're both in artists. All check them out right.
- 1:10:43Thank you very much, And if you enjoyed this level of conversation I
- 1:10:45was become to woodbling got found in. Please list some of these please.
- 1:10:49Do want to thank you personally for creating Wolverine and for inspiring millions around the
- 1:10:55world, and for in my personal case health. You know, there is
- 1:10:58surprising way create a character that change. Welcome idea. All right, classes
- 1:11:11out great discussion Susanna Flores and Roy Thomas on the psychology of Wolverine. Well,
- 1:11:21there you go, folks. I do suggest you check out Bleeding Cool.
- 1:11:27I thought they did a fantastic article about it. There are other websites
- 1:11:31as well that are addressing this air quotes controversy. I still don't know.
- 1:11:38I really don't know. We weren't there. And also the uber fans like
- 1:11:44us, we're all outraged and a little disappointed. Uh. The average convention
- 1:11:50goer, they're not gonna know, they're not gonna care. The average moviegoer,
- 1:11:54they're not gonna know. They're not going to care, but it does
- 1:11:57bother me. And I just feel like Roy and his more so his representation.
- 1:12:03Instead of reminding us how great Roy's contributions to comics have been, there's
- 1:12:10been an overstep and an overreach, and unfortunately, that and other controversies that
- 1:12:16I think were unfair, Like when Roy made a point of talking about Iron
- 1:12:21Fist and referred to him as a character that was influenced by oriental you know,
- 1:12:32factors, and he said, oh, you know, I guess oriental
- 1:12:35isn't a good word anymore. Well, you know, it isn't. But
- 1:12:41Roy's you know, Roy's in his eighties, and I don't think he meant
- 1:12:45it with any malice. But that was a little knock on Roy recently.
- 1:12:49And now this thing and this overreach of creation, when Roy him literally has
- 1:12:56dozens of other characters that are significant and he deserves the absolute credit for as
- 1:13:01the writer. It's almost like if Stan were still around and said, well,
- 1:13:06you know, I was enterator in chief, so I should get credit
- 1:13:10for Ultront and it's like, yeah, no, you know, but again
- 1:13:15we weren't there. And I pointed to the Barry Ellen an example that I
- 1:13:17did in my opening editorial to say that's a great example as well. We
- 1:13:23weren't there. I don't know. I wish Lenn was still around to really,
- 1:13:30you know, give us a clearer definition of what the marching orders from
- 1:13:35where I were and how much he feels or felt that Roy contributed to the
- 1:13:42creation of Wolverine. We're not gonna know. We're really not gonna know.
- 1:13:46We can only go back to previous quotes from all involved, including Roy,
- 1:13:51including Herb Trimpy, including of course Lenn Wayne. But it just bugs me,
- 1:13:59and it's so unnecessary because nobody has to plead the case for Roy Thomas's
- 1:14:06contributions to the Marvel universe or the DC universe for that matter. I don't
- 1:14:13know, I really don't know. Someone reminded me that when the hot of
- 1:14:15the Black Adam movie came out, Adam Smasher was a co creation of Jerry
- 1:14:21Ordway and Roy Thomas in Infinity, Inc. And yeah, they got checks,
- 1:14:28you know, not huge checks, but they got something. You know,
- 1:14:31Adam Smasher could have been, it could have been another character in that
- 1:14:35Black Adam movie, but they did use him. But yeah, and again,
- 1:14:40I am so for these guys getting properly compensated. I don't know.
- 1:14:45I'm shaking my head. Maybe you are as well. I hope at least
- 1:14:49you were found the conversation I had with doctor Flores and mister Thomas interesting and
- 1:14:58you can decide for yourselves. I hope you enjoyed today's episode of Word Balloon.
- 1:15:01We got great stuff coming up in April as we begin April, and
- 1:15:05this is no April full program as you heard, but lots of other great
- 1:15:10stuff. And I can tell you in the weeks ahead, we're gonna have
- 1:15:14new conversations with Brian Hitch and Sandford Green, among others, and it's gonna
- 1:15:19be great. Of course, Discovery is coming back Star Trek, and we'll
- 1:15:24talk about the first couple episodes of that next week, probably next Monday,
- 1:15:28because I want Mitch, Wayne and Franco all involved and give them a chance
- 1:15:31to watch the shows. I mean, Mitch is gonna be busy with a
- 1:15:35gamer convention that he's doing that weekend. So until then, thanks for listening.
- 1:15:45Until next time. Word Balloon is copyright Feature of Shaky Productions, copyright
- 1:15:49twenty twenty four. Stay safe, Stay happy, Stay healthy,