Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / AI in Your Practice: A Trial Attorney's Guide to Tools, Ethics, and Efficiency
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to AI in Your Practice, a trial attorney's
- 0:06guide to tools, ethics, and efficiency. I'm Mark
- 0:10Hoag, chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:14AI in the Law section, along with my co -chair
- 0:16Amanda Harris. And I'm the founder of hoaglaw
- 0:20.ai, an AI first law practice where I serve as
- 0:23fractional GC to tech companies while spending
- 0:27nights and weekends vibe coding apps. because,
- 0:30of course, I do. I'm delighted to introduce today
- 0:32our speaker, Kenny Ramirez. So Kenny is the founder
- 0:35and principal attorney of the law office of Kenny
- 0:38S. Ramirez, based in the Inland Empire, where
- 0:41he represents plaintiffs in personal injury,
- 0:44catastrophic injury, wrongful death, and related
- 0:47matters throughout California. He's tried cases
- 0:50as lead counsel in both state and federal courts,
- 0:54and has successfully mediated and arbitrated
- 0:57matters across a wide range of case types. And
- 1:02with that, let's get started. Kenny, please take
- 1:04it away. Thank you very much, Mark. And it's
- 1:08a pleasure to be here with everybody. I have
- 1:10a lot of material, so I'll sort of get going
- 1:14here. But if you have any questions, please feel
- 1:16free to ask. If I can answer them the questions
- 1:19as we get as we're going, I'll try to do that.
- 1:22If not, I'll save it till the end. Again, I have
- 1:26a practice out of the Inland Empire. I have a
- 1:29small growing firm, and it's one of the situations
- 1:31where tech, our legal tech stack and AI has been
- 1:35something that has helped us grow and also to
- 1:40be able to, you know, compete and operate as
- 1:46a much larger firm than otherwise, right? So
- 1:52our bandwidth is a lot greater and at the same
- 1:55time, the quality of our legal services and the
- 1:58work that we provide for our clients, which is
- 1:59number one, more than anything, hasn't been sacrificed
- 2:03and instead is being augmented by the use and
- 2:07the assistance of tech and AI. So that's sort
- 2:10of the stuff that I wanted to share with everybody
- 2:11today. Again, based out of the Inland Empire,
- 2:16my office is in San Bernardino, practiced for
- 2:19many years in Los Angeles, and I'm an IE kid
- 2:22and was able to move back and open up my practice.
- 2:26So when thinking about tech and AI, I like to
- 2:29give this analogy of building a house. My dad
- 2:33was a contractor. I grew up on construction sites
- 2:35as a kid. So a lot of my analogies sometimes
- 2:39revert back to construction. And so when I think
- 2:42about AI, I think about building a house. And
- 2:46generally speaking, there are three phases, very
- 2:48generally speaking, three phases when building
- 2:50a house. One, the first stage is getting a permit,
- 2:54right? Making sure you're in compliance with
- 2:56city ordinances and codes and that you have the
- 2:58city's permission to build a house. And then
- 3:02after that, the second phase is laying the foundation,
- 3:06right? Making sure that you have a strong foundation
- 3:09on which to build and then you start the framing,
- 3:12building the structure around that's gonna house.
- 3:15the house pardon the redundancy there and then
- 3:19the third phase is the finish it's the actual
- 3:24like that the fancy finishing that everybody
- 3:27sees the paint the molding the tile the crown
- 3:31molding the base molding all the beautiful stuff
- 3:33the light the fixtures that everybody sees and
- 3:36that everybody's enthralled with is that third
- 3:39phase and so when I think about tech and AI,
- 3:44think about it in a very similar way as building
- 3:46a house. The first phase is permits, making sure
- 3:50that you're in compliance with the appropriate
- 3:54laws, particularly as attorneys. There's attorney
- 3:58-client privilege. There's HIPAA. There's a lot
- 4:00of things that we're concerned with that we have
- 4:01to be in compliance with. There's security and
- 4:03ethical guardrails. And that's all part of that
- 4:06first phase when we're making sure that we have
- 4:08the permission, the permits to be able to use
- 4:11that. AI in that tech and implement it into our
- 4:15practice. That second phase is about the foundation
- 4:19and framing. It's making sure that you have the
- 4:20right case management software, the client relationship
- 4:24management software, CRMs, all part of that second
- 4:28phase which forms the foundation and the framing
- 4:32around which your firm is going to be housed
- 4:36and then lastly is that finished all the fancy
- 4:39ai tools that that's the stuff that everybody's
- 4:41talking about right it's the generative ai assistance
- 4:44it's document review chronology is demand letters
- 4:47and tools that you can implement at across all
- 4:51and any phases of litigation whether it's discovery
- 4:54deposition trial intake even um and so That's
- 4:58sort of what I think about when I think about
- 5:02whether I'm going to use, when I'm considering
- 5:04whether I'm going to use a particular tool or
- 5:07AI product. And so I want to start with permits
- 5:11first and foremost, because I think that's the
- 5:13thing that as attorneys we're most concerned
- 5:15with. We have concerns about the ethical, the
- 5:21ethics of using AI. And our concerns are around
- 5:25attorney -client privilege, making sure that
- 5:26we don't violate that first first and foremost,
- 5:29confidentiality around sensitive client data,
- 5:31cybersecurity and data breaches, accuracy and
- 5:34reliability of the outputs of the information
- 5:37that we input and get back from AI. You know,
- 5:42is it making things up? And of course, whether
- 5:46client data is used to train models, because
- 5:48if client data as we're going to talk about client
- 5:50data is used to train models, that is a violation
- 5:53of something as basic as attorney -client privilege.
- 5:56So we have a lot of concerns and because of those
- 5:58concerns, I think a lot of attorneys are not
- 6:00using AI categorically and then using it very
- 6:07sparingly and maybe not using it in the best
- 6:12way that they can or in other applications in
- 6:15other ways throughout their practice. So to start
- 6:17off, I do want to discuss just what an LLM is,
- 6:21and that's really what we've all, our first exposure
- 6:24to AI has been to chat GPT for the most part,
- 6:29right? There's been other applications prior,
- 6:31but that's really where it all blew up. You know,
- 6:34started recently in the past couple of years
- 6:36has been through chat GPT, Claude, Gemini, and
- 6:39these are all large language models. And the
- 6:41question is, what is an LLM? In basic terms,
- 6:46it's an AI system that's been trained to recognize
- 6:51patterns in text data to understand it and then
- 6:57generate human language. It's that sort of ability
- 7:02that allows this AI, these LLMs to review documents,
- 7:08to create summaries, and to assist us with any
- 7:12tasks that we might set this AI on. And so again,
- 7:18it's trained on these large text data. And the
- 7:21big thing from these LLMs is that it pulls from
- 7:24all of the known universe, right? The entire
- 7:27Internet. That's why we hear these stories about,
- 7:30you know, cases being made up because it's pulling
- 7:35from some random subreddit thread because, really,
- 7:39these LLMs are pulling from anywhere in the known
- 7:42universe. Now, I'm gonna talk a little bit about
- 7:47some of the strengths of the different public
- 7:50or general purpose AI models like ChatGBT, Gemini,
- 7:54and Claude a little bit later. But this particular
- 7:57slide that I have up right now is not necessarily
- 7:59intended as a comparison between ChatGBT and
- 8:02co -counsel, though it functions as that as well.
- 8:05But the idea is to sort of give you an example
- 8:07of the difference between what is a public model
- 8:10or a An all purpose sort of general purpose model
- 8:13in chat GPT Gemini Claude versus something that
- 8:18is legal specific like co council or Lexis AI.
- 8:24And the big difference is that we see. from a
- 8:28security standpoint, which is sort of this first
- 8:30phase that we're on with permits, is that the
- 8:33public or general purpose models are not specifically
- 8:36designed for legal work. And that's important
- 8:38because it hasn't been trained necessarily to
- 8:41help with legal work, though it definitely can.
- 8:43And it is helpful in certain applications. And
- 8:46when it's set to do certain things, but it wasn't
- 8:48designed to do that. Whereas something like co
- 8:50-counsel or Lexis AI, for example, they have
- 8:53legal applications and were designed specifically
- 8:56to be optimized. by and for attorneys the the
- 9:00other point here is the source and training right
- 9:04with chat GPT if we just talk about sort of the
- 9:07environment and the source it's pulling from
- 9:09all of the known universe all and anything that's
- 9:12available on the internet so it could be information
- 9:15that's accurate it could be information that's
- 9:17very inaccurate and I think more information
- 9:20more that type of information is available on
- 9:22the internet right whereas something like co
- 9:24-counsel they operate on what is a closed universe
- 9:27meaning that it is only going to pull from the
- 9:32information contained within that environment
- 9:34so with co -counsel for example they are owned
- 9:36by Westlaw it only operates within the Westlaw
- 9:41universe within the cases that we've we all know
- 9:44and that are either checked or shepard eyes whatever
- 9:48through Westlaw Right? So it's a much more stable
- 9:53environment and one that we can trust more simply
- 9:56because it's closed and it's not pulling from
- 9:57anything else. So closed environment versus an
- 10:00open environment, closed universe versus an open
- 10:03universe, that really matters for us as attorneys,
- 10:06particularly when it comes down to something
- 10:08like research. The other point is with security
- 10:13and attorney -client privilege and HIPAA, with
- 10:16general purpose models, public models, The model
- 10:20will train on your data. So under no circumstance
- 10:27should you be uploading medical records or any
- 10:30client documents data into these public models
- 10:34because a public model is Training on that data
- 10:38and by doing that attorney -client privilege
- 10:40has been violated if it's medical records or
- 10:43a violation of HIPAA. There's a lot of issues
- 10:47with doing that as opposed to something like
- 10:49co -counselor Alexis AI where they have specific
- 10:52guardrails to protect against that and I'll get
- 10:54into a little bit later. I will note and it's
- 10:59important to know I have it at the. at your bottom,
- 11:01I guess left here, that certain enterprise models
- 11:05or versions of these general purpose models,
- 11:08so enterprise or business version of ChatGPT,
- 11:10enterprise version of Gemini, of Claude, do allow
- 11:15for closed environments. And that's something
- 11:17that has been developed, developing over the
- 11:21last year in particular. So it does allow for
- 11:23closed environments. So you can toggle that off.
- 11:26so that it doesn't go beyond your workspace or
- 11:29the information that you've inputted, uploaded.
- 11:33It's not pulling from some random subreddit thread.
- 11:38And it's going to keep the model from trading
- 11:41on that uploaded data. And most of these enterprise
- 11:45models are also up to date with safety measures.
- 11:48And I'll mention some of these safety measures
- 11:50in a bit. And so that's good because that wasn't
- 11:53something that these general purpose models were
- 11:56necessarily concerned with some of the things
- 11:59that they've now noticed that attorneys and other
- 12:02professionals, other individuals are concerned
- 12:03with. So there are better security measures.
- 12:07The big caveat here, though, is still with these
- 12:09general purpose models. like Chad GBT, Gemini,
- 12:13and Claude, is that they don't necessarily equate
- 12:16to HIPAA compliance or legal grade privacy, medical
- 12:20protections even. And so that's really important
- 12:25because they don't make themselves or market
- 12:28themselves out to be something that attorneys
- 12:32can use and that it protects against things like
- 12:37violation of attorney -client privilege or violations
- 12:39of HIPAA. Whereas something like these legal
- 12:42specific models like or platforms like co counsel
- 12:45and Lexus AI, they specifically address those
- 12:48concerns because hey, if they're providing the
- 12:52service to attorneys, they know that's paramount
- 12:55for attorneys. So, enterprise versions of ChatGBT
- 12:59have gotten better with respect to what information
- 13:02they're pulling from. They can become closed
- 13:04universe and that they're up to date with a lot
- 13:07of safety measures, but they're not marketed
- 13:09that way. That doesn't mean that it's not helpful,
- 13:13that these general purpose models, public models
- 13:16are not helpful. It's more about alignment and
- 13:19the correct approach, right? What I have here
- 13:23on the screen here is really a solid approach
- 13:25is to reserve your public AI, these all purpose
- 13:30models, general purpose models for non -confidential
- 13:32tasks. Something like creating correspondence
- 13:36or something that you want to send that isn't
- 13:40necessarily, that isn't concerned with communications
- 13:43that should be privileged and then rely on closed
- 13:46environment. Legal specific platforms when you're
- 13:49handling client data privileged materials and
- 13:51substantive legal work So go ahead and use a
- 13:55chat GPT if you want to refine some correspondence
- 13:57and email or Whatever other tasks you may need
- 14:00but if it comes when it comes to client data
- 14:03privileged materials That's when you want to
- 14:05make sure that you're using the closed environment
- 14:08and legal specific platforms as well So again,
- 14:11there's a use for both of them. You just have
- 14:14to make sure that you're employing them in the
- 14:18correct manner. And I also have here in the materials,
- 14:20and you all have access to the materials. You
- 14:22can download that. But just a little bit of a
- 14:25Vendect diagram here of the different types of
- 14:28LLMs that are available. The public model is
- 14:31ChatGPT, Claw, Gemini. That can be upgraded to
- 14:34Enterprise, of course. And then there's also
- 14:36the very specific legal grade, reliable, closed
- 14:41case universe models that are co -counsel and
- 14:44Lexus AI. And then also there's these other platforms
- 14:49and companies really that have been created specifically
- 14:52for attorneys that I call sort of you do it all
- 14:55options like Harvey, like Eve, Everlaw, Anytime
- 14:58AI. Talk a little bit about some of these in
- 15:02a moment, but they are also very, very similar
- 15:06to co -counsel and Lexis AI, but they try to
- 15:11do a lot more in terms of their services. So,
- 15:14you know, I do think that they are great. And
- 15:17if you don't have co -counsel, you don't have
- 15:19Lexus AI, you don't have any other type of AI
- 15:22or LLM that you're using, any of these, Harvey,
- 15:26Eve, Everloh, any time AI, it would be worth
- 15:27the look. Take a demo. And that's something that
- 15:32I, myself, I practice with my sister. My sister
- 15:35practices with me and we're building our business
- 15:38is we always take meetings. because i want to
- 15:41see what is available and many times there are
- 15:45demos you know or a trial maybe like a week where
- 15:48you just kind of get to go in and see what is
- 15:50being offered is that something that makes sense
- 15:52for your practice is that something that makes
- 15:53sense for your firm maybe not at the moment and
- 15:57we've had those situations where we go okay you
- 15:59know what maybe We don't need that yet, but I
- 16:02know this is available and I might need it in
- 16:04a year, right? And start implementing it from
- 16:06wide. And so take those demos and check them
- 16:10out is really the biggest thing. All right, so
- 16:14when it comes down to security standards, a few
- 16:18things, and this is a good list of like four
- 16:20or five different things that you can use when
- 16:24you're evaluating whether you're going to use
- 16:28a certain AI tool or platform. It's your way
- 16:34of sort of this little bullet list and just have
- 16:36it ready and make sure that it checks off each
- 16:39one of these. And if it does, it is something
- 16:41that you could use with your practice because
- 16:44it meets the security concerns and gets you past
- 16:47that. So first and foremost, is the platform
- 16:50SOC 2 Type 2 compliant? We don't necessarily
- 16:52need to get into the technical explanation of
- 16:56what SOC 2 Type 2 is, but essentially what it
- 16:59is, it's just this audit that makes sure that
- 17:03there are security controls in place that exist
- 17:09not only at one point in time, but that are sustained
- 17:15over an in a longer period of time, meaning that
- 17:18it's not just when the audit was done on X day
- 17:22that things were secured. No, it's something
- 17:24that is secured and can be trusted to be secured
- 17:27when it is used. And so you want SOC 2 type 2
- 17:31compliance. You can find whether or not a tool
- 17:36or a platform uses SOC 2 type 2 just by going
- 17:39onto their website because they have to have
- 17:41that up there and if it doesn't they don't. You
- 17:42can also ask for their reports and certificates.
- 17:44These companies will share that with you particularly
- 17:47if they have it right because they want to make
- 17:49sure they want you to know that they are SOC
- 17:522 type 2 compliant. So it's about the security.
- 17:56that is extended over a period of time, not just
- 18:00randomly. And then the other one, the other question
- 18:03is, is data encrypted at rest and in transit?
- 18:05Meaning, is it encrypted, is it protected, not
- 18:08just when it's in your system, but also when
- 18:10it's being transmitted between systems. And so
- 18:13even if, God forbid, there's an authorized access,
- 18:17the data is still encrypted and it's not compromised.
- 18:22So you want it to be encrypted at rest and in
- 18:25transit. The other thing to note here or to make
- 18:31sure that your tool or platform that you're evaluating,
- 18:34make sure that it has, is whether it's a closed
- 18:37environment. So we discussed that a little bit.
- 18:39Making sure that it is an environment that is
- 18:42not going to pull from something that it shouldn't
- 18:44pull and it's not shared with or exposed to any
- 18:46external systems or trained by public models.
- 18:53That's what this next security concern is as
- 18:55well, is the information used to train the model.
- 18:58Again, if the information that you upload is
- 19:01being used to train that model, there is a violation
- 19:06of attorney client privilege happening immediately.
- 19:09Right. And so you want to make sure that your
- 19:12information is not retained, reused or incorporated
- 19:14into any of their future future models. So again,
- 19:18make sure that it's a closed environment and
- 19:20it's not being used. Your information is not
- 19:22being used to train their model and help them
- 19:24get better. That's why something like going back
- 19:25to that, like co -counsel and Lexis AI and their
- 19:28versions that they offer are great because they've
- 19:31already been trained for specific legal tasks.
- 19:34You know, it's not a public model that's being
- 19:35used that's learning necessarily how to do that.
- 19:38It's already been trained to do that, and that
- 19:41helps. And lastly, is the AI company familiar
- 19:45with legal ethics and compliance? And without
- 19:48any, if you don't have answers to these questions,
- 19:52if they can't provide you with the certificates
- 19:54and reports, then you might not have the permits
- 19:56to build on top of this model. So it might not
- 19:59be something, a tool or a model or a platform
- 20:02that you want to implement into your firm, at
- 20:04least not at that time. I also have up here just
- 20:10some rules and recommendations by the State Bar.
- 20:18We don't necessarily need to go through them
- 20:20here. It's more just as a reminder. And of course,
- 20:23the State Bar, this is something that they've
- 20:25looked into, already looking into, because it
- 20:27is something that is prevalent throughout our
- 20:30industry. Here, due to confidentiality, a lawyer
- 20:35can't input any confidential information into
- 20:37any AI tools. And so that's everything we've
- 20:41discussed. This is what that addresses. I want
- 20:43to make sure that you avoid entering details
- 20:45that can be used to identify the client. What
- 20:49I will say is sometimes... let's say if you I
- 20:51know attorneys have uploaded medical records
- 20:55that when they do that and if it's something
- 20:57that they're not sure whether it has whether
- 21:00it has the correct privacy or security that they
- 21:03redact names they'd redact identifying information
- 21:06they redact a lot of that and I think that's
- 21:09a way of getting around that and making sure
- 21:11that you're not disclosing anything necessarily
- 21:13from your client the client is still you know
- 21:16questionable whether you should or shouldn't
- 21:17do that. The reality of doing that though at
- 21:20the end of the day is that that still takes a
- 21:23lot of time, right? If you're looking you're
- 21:25working with a set of you know, something that's
- 21:27quite common, right? It could be a thousand pages
- 21:29of medical records what you're gonna go through
- 21:31all of that and redact every single page every
- 21:34single client identifying piece of information
- 21:36that takes more time, right and so That's why
- 21:41it's more helpful to use legal grade and medical
- 21:44grade specific platforms We also have a duty
- 21:49of competence and diligence making sure that
- 21:52the AI outputs don't include false and inaccurate
- 21:55information. We have the responsibility of making
- 22:00sure that we use the technology competently and
- 22:04that it's not inconsistent with the act of practice
- 22:06of law. So we've all heard those stories of attorneys
- 22:09submitting, you know, law and motion information
- 22:13with cases that have been entirely hallucinated
- 22:16by AI. That's why it's important for us to review
- 22:20that. And I will also say that a lot of my approach
- 22:25with tech and AI, throughout as a through line,
- 22:29is that I look at AI as the best first year associate
- 22:34that I could hire. The first year associate is
- 22:39great. I send them out on tasks, they'll give
- 22:43them to me, but I'm still going to review it,
- 22:45right? I'm not just gonna blindly turn something
- 22:47in that a first -year associate gives to me and
- 22:49neither of us would and that's exactly what AI
- 22:53is, right? It's a greatest... assistance in our
- 22:57in our practice it helps us you know fifty sixty
- 23:00percent get fifty sixty percent of the way there
- 23:02sometimes more but it's still information that
- 23:05we have to review it's still information that
- 23:07it's our responsibility to make sure that what
- 23:09we're turning in is is true and accurate Next
- 23:15is regarding communication regarding generative
- 23:18AI. If it's going to be used, it's a good idea
- 23:22to put it in your retainer agreements and your
- 23:25attorney -client retention agreements to have
- 23:29that in there and just let them know, right?
- 23:30It's not a big deal. I think now folks anticipate
- 23:34and expect that to happen, but it's important
- 23:35to have that communicated to your client. And
- 23:38also, there's this rule about charging for work
- 23:42produced by gen .ai. the costs associated with
- 23:45generative AI can be charged to clients in compliance
- 23:48with applicable laws. So make sure that the fee
- 23:50agreement spells out the costs and fees associated
- 23:54with that, and then you're in the clear. And
- 24:00again, another rule about reviewing generative
- 24:03AI outputs before you submit it to the court.
- 24:06Okay, so moving right along now. The second phase,
- 24:10so that was the first phase, making sure that
- 24:12we have the right permits. We're addressing compliance,
- 24:16security concerns, and now we're moving on to
- 24:19the second phase. This is the foundation and
- 24:23the framing right of the house. And when it comes
- 24:25to law, this is really about law practice management
- 24:30tech tools, case management software or CMS,
- 24:34or sometimes known as CMPs. case management platforms
- 24:37or CRMs, client relationship management programs
- 24:41or software. And I won't for our purposes necessarily
- 24:47go down a detailed look into each one and all
- 24:51the different options that are available. I'll
- 24:52just discuss one briefly. It's the one that I
- 24:55use. It's not necessarily I'm saying that everybody
- 24:59has to use it. It's the best thing. It works
- 25:01for our practice. I very much like it. But it's
- 25:05more an example of something that's available
- 25:08and that everybody uses the case management platform,
- 25:11case management software. And it definitely is
- 25:12something that I think is a value add to everybody's
- 25:16practice. So what is a CMS? It's a cloud -based
- 25:20platform to help firms better organize their
- 25:22cases. It provides various tools, document storage,
- 25:26task tracking, and allows everyone to have access
- 25:29to essential client information and streamline
- 25:30communication within the team. I remember when
- 25:32I first started practicing law, I started practicing
- 25:35in 2015, and if you wanted to do work outside
- 25:39of the office, you needed to have a VPN, you
- 25:43needed to be given a specific computer, and only
- 25:45certain attorneys, right, as first year, didn't
- 25:48have access to that, so I needed to be in the
- 25:50office, and that's why you're in the office 24
- 25:52-7. basically, right? Because you didn't have
- 25:54access to any information or documents outside
- 25:58of the office. Nowadays, it's all cloud -based,
- 26:02right? And so I can be on vacation working on
- 26:05my cases. It doesn't matter where I'm at. I have
- 26:08everything available to me on this system. It
- 26:12acts as an all -in -one solution as well for
- 26:15streamlining communication with our team, with
- 26:16our clients. moving along, just sort of examples
- 26:22of what it can do, can manage client data, deadlines,
- 26:27tasks, documents, storage, records, communications,
- 26:30workflow automation. And that's a big one. I'll
- 26:33discuss that in a moment and provide reporting
- 26:36and analytics as well, which is super helpful
- 26:38when you're looking at the business of law as
- 26:42opposed to just the practice of it. And important
- 26:47for everyone to know here and to sort of Take
- 26:50with respect to their approach to tech and AI
- 26:53is that AI isn't a substitute for case management
- 26:55it's just an enhancement that sits on top of
- 26:57it and again with all tech and AI It's not supposed
- 27:03to substitute people necessarily. It's supposed
- 27:05to assist and enhance our practice It makes us
- 27:09it can help make us better But not it it shouldn't
- 27:12be used to do necessarily the work for us or
- 27:14think in place of us, right? All right, so some
- 27:18examples of case management systems are something
- 27:21like Filevine, Clio, Smart Advocate, Litify,
- 27:25My Case, some of you might use one, have experience
- 27:27with another, have experience with several of
- 27:30them, have your favorites. There are others,
- 27:33but this is not an exhaustive list, but if you're
- 27:35interested in looking at a case management system,
- 27:39here are some options that I would encourage
- 27:43you to take a look at and see which one best
- 27:45fits your practice. And so, as I mentioned, I
- 27:49use Filevine. Filevine does a lot of great stuff.
- 27:53From the very beginning, when I started using
- 27:56it, I immediately saw the benefits of having
- 28:01a case management system, being able to assign
- 28:04stuff like tasks, for example. I think that was
- 28:06the very first thing that I started using when
- 28:07we got Filevine. It goes beyond document storage,
- 28:11right? Because you can have Dropbox, which is
- 28:13what I had when I first opened up my practice
- 28:15as a solo practitioner. You have Dropbox and
- 28:17you have everything stored there. Hey, it's cloud
- 28:18-based. I could access it anywhere. But that's
- 28:21just document storage. And there's really nothing
- 28:23beyond that. File buying goes... way beyond that.
- 28:28So it's not just document storage. It's not just
- 28:29a repository for your records and your files,
- 28:32but it's also a way to assign tasks. I said that
- 28:35was one of the first things that I started using,
- 28:37right? Being able to assign tasks to my team
- 28:39members specifically to do certain things. And
- 28:42it's tracked and I can keep track of the tasks
- 28:44that I assign instead of, for example, when in
- 28:48the firm where I worked with and I worked at
- 28:51for many years, I created my own Excel sheet
- 28:55where I had my tasks. and sort of was tracking
- 28:57all that, marking it off, like, did I do this?
- 29:00Did I do that? Now it's all just available within
- 29:04this case management system. And also, I remember
- 29:07my boss from a previous firm, once he saw that
- 29:11I did that, would ask for that Excel sheet so
- 29:14he could also see, like, hey, what is Kenny working
- 29:16on, right? What else can I assign him? And moving
- 29:22ahead, with Filevine now, even myself as the
- 29:25person who's assigning tasks, I can keep track
- 29:27of all of that and see all the tasks that I've
- 29:29assigned and whether they've been completed or
- 29:30not. But you can also calendar and deadlines
- 29:34and automating task flows is huge. Being able
- 29:37to create a task flow, for example, with something,
- 29:40I'll just give a very simple example. I'm a trial
- 29:44attorney and we have cases of litigation. We
- 29:47try cases. We also have a pre -litigation department.
- 29:52Pre litigation sometimes a little bit more cookie
- 29:54cutter in terms of things that need to be done
- 29:56at the beginning of the case, right? And so now
- 29:59these things are automated and the tasks are
- 30:02assigned immediately. It takes a lot of the thinking.
- 30:06out of certain tasks that should be automated,
- 30:09right? Like assigning who should send the initial
- 30:13client letter, the email, the letters of representation
- 30:16to insurance adjusters. It doesn't do that, but
- 30:19assigns a task immediately and the documents
- 30:22could also be automated by the staff to create
- 30:26those record, those correspondences and send
- 30:29those out. So it works in a way that helps simplify
- 30:33everything and you're not necessarily thinking
- 30:35about what is next in line because that's already
- 30:39been predetermined about what's next in line.
- 30:41So workflows, task flows, unlimited cloud storage,
- 30:45which is huge. There's an AI suite. I'll mention
- 30:48that. I'll talk about that. And several integrations
- 30:52with a lot of your attorney services and vendors
- 30:56so that you don't have to leave the platform
- 30:59to do things like order medical records. You
- 31:02can stay on that same page. Do it you don't have
- 31:05to go anywhere else it all gets done from without
- 31:08leaving that page I have examples here. I don't
- 31:12necessarily skip through some ways. I already
- 31:15talked about tasks Calendaring I love their calendaring.
- 31:19It's two -way so it gets shared with your outlook
- 31:23calendar for example because I use outlook calendar
- 31:25But I can see everything that is calendared individual
- 31:30individual cases so every single case has their
- 31:32own individual calendar and you can see everything
- 31:35that's coming up in each each individual case
- 31:37but then separate from that there's a master
- 31:38calendar that includes everything and then it's
- 31:41two -way synced with your outlook so that anything
- 31:44that you've personally put into your calendar
- 31:47also gets included and so it's great because
- 31:50you have this very comprehensive calendar where
- 31:53it's Very difficult to miss anything Deadline
- 31:57chains are automatically generated. These are
- 32:00great, you know Again before if we have a trial
- 32:05date, for example, we have to set all the important
- 32:08pre -trial dates or the trials schedule and law
- 32:13and motion schedule a lot of times that was manually
- 32:16done or we create Excel sheets and try to you
- 32:19know uh get the correct dates but then you have
- 32:22to calendar that separately you have to get on
- 32:24calendar make sure your calendar that's that's
- 32:26gone now uh you have we have it for example trial
- 32:28deadline chain all i have to do is put the trial
- 32:31date and it immediately will generate all the
- 32:35dates that are important leading up to trial
- 32:37and not just give me those dates put them in
- 32:40put them on my calendar immediately If any changes
- 32:44need to be made because a judge gives this specific
- 32:46order, they change the FSC, TS, whatever it is,
- 32:52we just manually go in there and change that
- 32:54specific date. So again, very helpful. Particularly,
- 32:59let's say when I started as a solo and then as
- 33:01a small firm, because that's something that can
- 33:05be done immediately. It doesn't even need to
- 33:07necessarily be assigned out. Dock generation,
- 33:12I think a lot of people are accustomed to something
- 33:15like this, but you can create correspondences,
- 33:17pleadings, and motions with a click of a button
- 33:19now. We've had macros before on Microsoft Word,
- 33:23but this is, I think, a lot more detailed and
- 33:28flexible. Limited cloud storage. AI Suite, we'll
- 33:34talk about that in a little bit. Timekeeping,
- 33:36billing, expense tracking as well for folks that
- 33:39do billing, that's available. And custom reports,
- 33:44I love these reports. We have reports that are
- 33:47generated weekly about any deadlines that are
- 33:50coming up. It could be financial report as well,
- 33:55list of tasks. payments, whatever it is, there's
- 34:00different reports that are generated and goes
- 34:01to their particular department. Very helpful,
- 34:05again, because it's just something that's done
- 34:07with a click of a button. And what I love as
- 34:10well is that they're all hyperlinked reports,
- 34:12right? So I get a list of, let's say, upcoming
- 34:15deadlines. And it's not just the name of the
- 34:18case, but it's hyperlinked. So I can click onto
- 34:20it and it'll take me directly to... What is it
- 34:22telling me that's due? When is it due? Are there
- 34:25any additional information, hearings, et cetera,
- 34:29that have been attached to it? So it's very comprehensive
- 34:32and detailed. And as I mentioned, there's a lot
- 34:35of integrations. You can use different types
- 34:38of programs, vendors, and they're integrated
- 34:41into, in this case, Filevine, but it could be
- 34:43any other case management system. It's very holistic.
- 34:49And it goes beyond, again, just document storage.
- 34:53And they also, in Paul Vines' case, and in any
- 34:55other case management system, they're all growing.
- 34:58I mean, the cool thing about this particular
- 35:00sort of time that we're in is that all of these
- 35:02companies are also competing with each other.
- 35:04right? They're trying to be better than the CMS
- 35:09that's next to them, right? So they're growing,
- 35:12they're innovating at all times. And, you know,
- 35:15Filevine, for example, they have these three
- 35:17newer products and additions into their system.
- 35:22Depot Copilot, for example, is something that
- 35:25just wowed, it sort of, you know, tacked on to,
- 35:29let's say like a Zoom meeting, when most folks
- 35:31are many depositions are being done through Zoom
- 35:34now. It could also be done live, but if it's
- 35:36through Zoom, and it'll make suggestions about
- 35:41questions that should be asked, because what
- 35:44you do initially even before the depo, you set
- 35:46out sort of, this is what I wanna do, these are
- 35:48the certain things that I wanna get from the
- 35:50witness, and it'll keep track of all those things
- 35:53and make suggestions. So act sort of as a second
- 35:56chair during your depo. Again. they're not doing
- 36:00the work for you, but something like that can
- 36:02augment your practice, right? Because you're
- 36:05doing, you're taking a depot just like you've
- 36:06always done, you prepare for it just like you
- 36:08always have, but now you have this sort of second
- 36:11chair that is adding some additional information
- 36:13that you might not have considered or had time
- 36:15to consider as you're going live. Client portal
- 36:20is a way to... communicate directly with your
- 36:23client, let them know when it's the next phase
- 36:25in litigation, they get communication, you can
- 36:28automate that stuff. It's really great. And a
- 36:32lot of other companies have individual sort of
- 36:36client portals that they provide as integrations,
- 36:39but something like Filevine, they're putting
- 36:41that natively into their system, so you don't
- 36:43have to go anywhere or even integrate. Lois is
- 36:47also something that's really cool. another article
- 36:52that's coming out on the Kala Magazine in a couple
- 36:56of months on this particular new tool within
- 37:01Filevine. I encourage you to just check it out.
- 37:04But it really represents sort of the second phase
- 37:06of AI, where it's not just a tool, but it's trying
- 37:11to create an operating system. So it's an AI
- 37:15agent, essentially, that is overseeing, that
- 37:18is implemented into Filevine, and it operates
- 37:24within each individual case. So for example,
- 37:28I have a case in random. I'm just going to make
- 37:31something up, right? Herrera v. Johnson. And
- 37:37I can use Lois to ask any questions about the
- 37:42case, and it'll pull from all the information
- 37:45within that case. So I can ask about the liability
- 37:47picture. I had that recently in a case where
- 37:49we got pulled in for trial. There are a lot of
- 37:52depositions that have already been taken. The
- 37:55liability question was not quite clear. And I
- 38:00uploaded and put everything into my case file.
- 38:03Again, I didn't upload it into any other system
- 38:06or LLM or into my case management system where
- 38:09my entire case file is housed. And you know i
- 38:13said hey like give me a summary of the liability
- 38:16picture what are the strengths weaknesses with
- 38:18best case scenario which case scenario what are.
- 38:21What still needs to be done just as a way to
- 38:24get some baseline information on this case right
- 38:26and what it. Look through absolutely everything
- 38:29through notes through memos to transcripts through
- 38:32lawn motion everything that was there and it
- 38:35provided a really good summary as a sort of jumping
- 38:38off point. to where the liability issue was.
- 38:42I've also used it a lot, for example, on calls
- 38:43with clients. The client will call and want to
- 38:45get a status update, and you can very quickly
- 38:48ask it, and it'll provide you the answer, let's
- 38:53say, on the status of the case. But as with everything,
- 38:56everything is linked as well, hyperlinked. So
- 38:58it's not just making things up. I can verify
- 39:00that what they're saying is true, right? And
- 39:02so it'll link to a note that myself wrote. team
- 39:06member may have put into that case file to an
- 39:10email, to a document, to correspond, whatever
- 39:12it is. So it's something that's really cool.
- 39:15And it's also then, in many instances, suggesting
- 39:18next steps. It recognizes what phase a case is
- 39:22in and suggests next up, whether it's ready for
- 39:24demand, for example, whether there's something
- 39:26that still needs to be obtained in the liability
- 39:29picture. It's not doing the work for you, but
- 39:31it's making suggestions that go beyond just,
- 39:33hey, I'm going to upload information. Because
- 39:36with a lot of, let's say, public models, whether
- 39:40you're using Dropbox or something like a case
- 39:42management system, you have all of your file
- 39:45in one place. And if you're going to use an LLM,
- 39:50you're going to download certain documents and
- 39:52upload them into that LLM. The issue with that
- 39:56is that it's still operating off a very basic
- 39:59or limited set of information because you're
- 40:02still missing a lot of documents information
- 40:05context that's contained within your case file.
- 40:08Something like Lois now doesn't run into that
- 40:11issue. It's pulling from your entire case context
- 40:14and file. So that's really great. I would encourage
- 40:18folks, and again, I'm talking about Filevine
- 40:21because it's something I use, but I'm not saying
- 40:24necessarily you have to stick with Filevine.
- 40:27It could be your case management system already,
- 40:29or there's another one that you like better,
- 40:30and I imagine, and many of these rather, are
- 40:33implementing and attempting to implement very
- 40:35similar tools. All right, I'm gonna keep going
- 40:38because I'm... Notice that we've got like 20
- 40:41minutes and there's a lot. So I'm going to go
- 40:43quickly now through this last phase, which is
- 40:48the finish. This is the fancy stuff that everybody
- 40:52likes, right? Like I said, it's the tile, it's
- 40:56the painting, it's the light fixtures, it's the
- 40:57chandelier, it's the base molding, the crown
- 41:00molding of a house that everybody actually sees.
- 41:04And in the legal sphere, it's the tools that
- 41:07we hear that are doing all these cool and great
- 41:08things. So that's what I want to talk about right
- 41:11now. Generative AI assistance, document review
- 41:13chronologies, demand letters. tools that can
- 41:16be used in the different phases of litigation.
- 41:21So we talked a bit already about LLMs. And again,
- 41:27the same sort of slide where our LLMs is just
- 41:30an AI system that's been trained to understand
- 41:32patterns in human language and be able to generate
- 41:36human language. With, I'm gonna give you some
- 41:43strengths and weaknesses, or really strengths
- 41:45of Chad GPT, Claude, and Gemini. Each one of
- 41:49them, they're also competing with each other,
- 41:51but each one of them has a different strength
- 41:53compared to the other. With Chad GPT, they're
- 41:57very versatile with a creative writing style.
- 42:02I think they are probably... And they definitely
- 42:05are the one that's used the most by folks. Many
- 42:08people, this was sort of their first introduction
- 42:11to what we now know as AI. But chat GPT continues
- 42:18to be very versatile and consistent for general
- 42:21legal writing tasks. So correspondences, emails,
- 42:24small memos. It's very good with that non -case
- 42:27specific correspondence. And if you're going
- 42:31to just have or pay for one, this might be one
- 42:34that, hey, you feel comfortable with because
- 42:36it's very versatile in general. Laud they have
- 42:41a large context window a strong legal and it's
- 42:44a very excellent legal writer what I mean by
- 42:47large context window is that it can handle a
- 42:50lot and long documents We're not going to get
- 42:55into the discussion of like tokens and get a
- 42:57little bit more specific, but essentially There
- 43:01there is for example, which has GPT which has
- 43:03less of a context window there there's a limit
- 43:08to how long the document that you're uploading
- 43:10can be. Because it's not going to be able to
- 43:13read all of that or handle all of it. Whereas
- 43:15Clot can handle these long documents. And it's
- 43:19also a very strong legal writer compared to ChadGBT
- 43:23and Gemini. So if you're looking for something
- 43:26to help you with legal writing itself, this might
- 43:29be something that you maybe gravitate more towards.
- 43:34And Gemini, Versatile, again, oops, no, that's
- 43:38the wrong title in there, but it has a deep integration
- 43:41with Google services, and it's great for understanding
- 43:43audio and video content. So ignore that title
- 43:46about versatile with creative writing style.
- 43:48But the good thing about Gemini is that it's
- 43:51something that if you're using Google, for example,
- 43:55or you have that, that how, you know, Gmail,
- 43:57you're... Google business that might be something
- 44:00that you're very interested in using because
- 44:01it integrates really well with all that and it
- 44:04works really well with audio and video Content
- 44:05if you've tried to use audio video content with
- 44:07like chat GBT, for example, you're gonna run
- 44:10into some issues You try to upload an audio file.
- 44:12For example, it might not be able to transcribe
- 44:15or understand it Whereas something like Gemini
- 44:18will work very well with that So depending on
- 44:22what you're using it for, depending on your need,
- 44:26you know, whether it could be ChatGBT, Gemini,
- 44:29or Claude, you have an option there. You have
- 44:33options. So with chat GPT, this is more for you
- 44:37to have just in your material. These are prompt
- 44:39suggestions. Definitely encourage folks when
- 44:43you're writing in prompts to tell the LLM, tell
- 44:48the AI who and what they are, right? Hey. Act
- 44:51as my opposing counsel or you are an attorney
- 44:54for X right and Let it take on that role in order
- 44:59to provide a better response for you Provide
- 45:01as much context context as possible Because the
- 45:06more context provided the better their outputs
- 45:08are going to be You can always iterate and follow
- 45:11up with questions, ask for sources as well so
- 45:15that you can sort of prevent it from hallucination,
- 45:18but you're always gonna have to double check
- 45:19because again, the issue with an open universe
- 45:23tool is that it is going to pull from the known
- 45:27universe. All right. This was a previous slide.
- 45:39Let's keep it moving for now. With co -counsel,
- 45:42talked a little about it before, but it's a generative
- 45:45AI system for lawyers. I started using it co
- 45:51-counsel before it was acquired by Westlaw, Thomson
- 45:53Reuters, and I liked it before and it's getting
- 45:57better now. I'm a fan of it. And what I will
- 46:02say is that it's been trained for the law. Again,
- 46:05it's private, it's secure, it's in a closed environment.
- 46:08And I think that for me from the very beginning,
- 46:11when I started using was something that was really
- 46:13important. That it was selected by OpenAI to
- 46:17be tailored for the legal world was also something
- 46:19that was important for me then, and it continues
- 46:21to be now. One note here is that they Co -counsel
- 46:28also says that it is a multi -model system, which
- 46:36basically means that initially it only used chat
- 46:39GPT for everything. Now as a multi -model, it
- 46:43uses the functionality of Gemini and Claude and
- 46:47chat GPT and sort of uses it for different tasks
- 46:53and employs the different ones for different
- 46:55tasks depending on what it's best for. So that's
- 46:58something that's helpful to know because you're
- 47:00not just limited to one particular type of output
- 47:03or system. All right, what can I do? Review documents,
- 47:09helps prepare for depositions. I've used that
- 47:13tool because it's like, hey, if I have it, why
- 47:15not, right? Like I'm gonna prep for my deposition
- 47:17as I typically do, but also, Hey, what are some
- 47:22recommendations that you have? What are some
- 47:23things that I might be missing? And I've definitely
- 47:26used some of the questions or areas that co -counsel
- 47:31has used, has prompted to me in the past. Again,
- 47:35it's not a substitute because I used to have
- 47:37to know your case file, right? And this is just
- 47:39something that augments your practice, not a
- 47:41substitute for it. You can create timelines,
- 47:44search databases, summarize documents, draft
- 47:47correspondence. Oops, it does all of that. I
- 47:50have prompt suggestions here as well, similar
- 47:53to what I discussed with ChatGPT. Assign a role,
- 47:57provide context, do all of that. But again, here,
- 48:00we have less of an issue of it pulling any random
- 48:04information because it's closed environment.
- 48:08Because of time, I'm going to go quickly here,
- 48:10but these are just slides showing you what that
- 48:12sort of looks like on the dashboard when you
- 48:16use CodeCounsel. Keep going. I mentioned that
- 48:28co -counsel is getting better, and it is. I think
- 48:30there were, in my practice, in the way that I
- 48:33employed co -counsel, I've always I've always
- 48:36liked it. I think there were some folks that
- 48:38thought that it could be better and sometimes
- 48:40it was using some of the older models and that
- 48:43it wasn't sort of as cutting edge as the others.
- 48:46This new co -counsel legal that Thomson Broderidge
- 48:49is doing is new and it's an upgraded version.
- 48:52I've had demos of it and it's again a multi -model
- 48:55structure architecture and it has something called
- 48:59a Gentic AI workflows that many of the other
- 49:02companies like EVE, Everlaw, Anytime AI, Harvey
- 49:09have popularized. And so what is a GenTech AI
- 49:13workflows? It's essentially you being able to
- 49:15create a workflow that fits your practice or
- 49:19specific tasks. So something as simple as creating
- 49:22a demand letter. I know that's really popular
- 49:24to discuss, but something like creating a demand
- 49:26letter, you can create a workflow and save that
- 49:31workflow so that you're not prompting things
- 49:35every single time you want a demand letter or
- 49:37section to be created but rather you can create
- 49:39that workflow and just initiate it and get that
- 49:43going which is again very helpful very something
- 49:47that can be modified for for depending on your
- 49:51practice depending on your firm and Even some
- 49:55of the folks that I have had sort of criticized
- 49:57or maybe thought that co -counseling could be
- 49:59better in the past. I've also tried some of this
- 50:01newest stuff and kind of gone down. It is getting
- 50:03better. Like this is pretty good now. I like
- 50:04it a lot. So again. I'm getting paid by them,
- 50:09but it is something that you might want to check
- 50:10out. Lexus AI is also very similar in that sphere.
- 50:13I don't use Lexus AI, so that's why I talk about
- 50:15co -counsel. I talk about the stuff that I use,
- 50:17but I also mention the alternatives or other
- 50:19options because they exist and they might work
- 50:22better for you. If you already have, for me,
- 50:24I use co -counsel. I stayed with co -counsel
- 50:27once Thomson and Reuters bought it because it
- 50:29made sense, right? I already have Westlaw. I
- 50:31don't use Lexus. I have Westlaw and it just made
- 50:33sense. continue to go with them, in addition
- 50:36to the fact that I like them. Lexis, you might
- 50:37have Lexis AI. It might make sense to just go
- 50:39with Lexis. Rather, you might have Lexis, and
- 50:41it might just make sense to continue with Lexis
- 50:44AI. I also have an example of one of those do
- 50:49-it -all options that I mentioned. Eve is something
- 50:52that I've also looked at. I thought it was great.
- 50:56I have other, you know... Colleagues who use
- 50:59it who are getting it? It's a do -it -all option
- 51:03that With their true what they try to do is kind
- 51:05of hit every single area of a particular practice
- 51:08whether it's intake and evaluation medical reviews
- 51:12demand letters drafting propounding discovery
- 51:16responding to discovery They want to be sort
- 51:19of your go -to place for a I tools and anything
- 51:23that you might need So for example with case
- 51:28intake and evaluation identifying cases with
- 51:31highest potential summarizing key facts quantifying
- 51:34damages Keep going medical overviews and can
- 51:40create comprehensive medical chronologies rather
- 51:42than necessarily having to you know pay someone
- 51:46to do that on a case -per -case basis, now you
- 51:49have this built into the system that you have.
- 51:53Demand letters, drafting legal documents, unlimited
- 51:56iterations, propounding discovery, and creating
- 51:59workflows as well. You might have a template
- 52:01for the types of questions that you... types
- 52:04of interrogatories that you might want or requests
- 52:07for production or now requests for admissions
- 52:11for a slip -and -fall case for You know a crash
- 52:15case for a TBI For whatever it might be and you
- 52:19can create those workflows and save those and
- 52:21use those now a lot of us already have templates
- 52:23you might have that safe like on your desktop
- 52:25or somewhere and Just like use those but then
- 52:27these can be created in a manner that also eliminates
- 52:30additional sort of input when it comes to templates,
- 52:34right? Something can just be created and you
- 52:36eliminate time. And that's where I think AI does
- 52:39some of its best work, right? It eliminates some
- 52:41of the time that can be better spent on strategy
- 52:47and thinking about your case and moving your
- 52:48case along rather than some of the more mundane
- 52:51tasks, whether it's you or whether it's your
- 52:54staff as well. There might be more important
- 52:56things for them to do than just be working on
- 52:58updating a template. or turning a template, making
- 53:02a case specific. And again, this Venn diagram
- 53:06just as a reminder between the general purpose
- 53:10public LLMs, the legal specific closed universe,
- 53:14and some of your do it all options. If you just
- 53:16want to go ahead and check them out and take
- 53:18some of those demos, I encourage you to do that.
- 53:20That's, I think, where so much of what So much
- 53:24is learned and you decide what you use and what
- 53:28you want to use for your practice. Transcript
- 53:31Genius, Steno is a core reporting company and
- 53:36they have Transcript Genius and have had it for
- 53:39a while, so it's not really introducing anymore.
- 53:42But what Transcript Genius does is basically
- 53:45if you use Steno once, Right for as your core
- 53:50reporting agency you have immediate access to
- 53:52this platform that they have where you can upload
- 53:56your transcripts and it doesn't have to be transcripts
- 54:00that were obtained from within through them.
- 54:03You can upload any other transcripts in any other
- 54:05cases. And you can chat with your transcripts,
- 54:09have an interactive conversation, ask for facts,
- 54:14summaries, legal insights, analyze and synthesize
- 54:18information across multiple transcripts as well.
- 54:23to find any contradictions, inconsistencies,
- 54:27where those occur, and it'll locate those. Customized
- 54:31transcript summaries are also really great. Refining
- 54:34responses, asking for follow -up questions, and
- 54:38just finding transcripts faster. And so I think
- 54:41this is such a great platform. If you're still
- 54:46sort of wondering whether AI is something that
- 54:48you should dip your toes into, I would urge you
- 54:53Try standing out first because again just use
- 54:56them on a depot and you have access to them and
- 54:58to this platform and Then just try it out. I
- 55:03think this is something that's a very helpful
- 55:05particularly that being able to Interrogate across
- 55:09multiple transcripts is very helpful when you're
- 55:11trying to find information One of the other things
- 55:16about this as I sort of just go through this
- 55:18is that it can also search It does hyperlink
- 55:21citations, of course, the biggest thing for me
- 55:23at all times, but it could also search based
- 55:26on concepts. So, you know, if you, you know,
- 55:31you know, someone talked about being sad, but
- 55:34you forgot where it was. Right. And they actually
- 55:37might not have said the word sad. Maybe they
- 55:39said depressed and you say, Hey, like, You can
- 55:42input, when did this person talk about being
- 55:43sad? It won't just look for this word sad, it'll
- 55:46look for those concepts. So it'll locate the
- 55:49area where depression was discussed. And so that's
- 55:53helpful as well because it's not just searching
- 55:55for a word, it's searching on concepts and ideas,
- 55:58and it will locate those for you. Demand letters,
- 56:04I won't go through these necessarily because
- 56:05they're very, I think... can be plaintiff specific,
- 56:08but there are many tools that allow for demand
- 56:12letters to be created. I use those tools as well,
- 56:16but what I will say is that those are always
- 56:19used sort of as like a baseline. At no point
- 56:23are those ever taken, generated, and sent immediately
- 56:26over as a demand, because again, these are just
- 56:31tools that help you. uh, not substitute the work
- 56:34for you. Um, so, uh, even up as a company that
- 56:39does that as well. Um, the one thing I will mention
- 56:42about even up, uh, well, okay, right here is
- 56:45that what I really like from them is their med,
- 56:46MedCrons. Um, I think they do medical chronology
- 56:49is different from other ones that I've seen.
- 56:51Um, there was a case where it came in on as a
- 56:54TBI case. Okay. We got brought in for trial and,
- 56:58um, you know, large file. it was over the course
- 57:02of four years before it had come to me. So there
- 57:06was a large medical file. And just for me to
- 57:08get a basic understanding of where things were,
- 57:10I use their medical chronology tool. And I love
- 57:14that it is very visual. Here's some examples,
- 57:17right? It's very color coded. There's timelines.
- 57:22And it very much helps prepare for trial. immediately.
- 57:28So I saw and see the benefit of that and it's
- 57:31all against citations. You can click and it'll
- 57:33take you to the exact place that it's pulling
- 57:35the information from. It's just a wonderful way
- 57:39to visually to see and interact with medical
- 57:42chronologies. Parrot is also a tool that, see
- 57:49we have it here, where you can get medical chronologies.
- 57:53Just as another option won't necessarily go through
- 57:56it right now See I have just a minute left. So
- 58:01I'm just trying to go quickly here Document organization
- 58:04and retrieval you can charge squad is used to
- 58:07get medical records. They're very great company
- 58:10I use them all the time and the one thing really
- 58:13cool thing about them is that there's no contracts.
- 58:15It's a flat fee It's you know per order So many
- 58:20companies nowadays are you know, everybody wants
- 58:22an annual contract Everybody wants, you know
- 58:24credits that you need to purchase and buy and
- 58:26one thing I like about you know charge squad
- 58:27is that they don't do that and you just take
- 58:29it and use them as you need them. They also have
- 58:32a lot of AI tools now that they're implementing
- 58:35as services for their attorneys, firms that are
- 58:38using them, and so that's available there. And
- 58:40they also just acquired Parrot that I just discussed
- 58:42for medical chronologies. Foundation AI if you
- 58:47have this this is just a way of organizing collecting
- 58:50information So like any emails I get sent to
- 58:53you if they immediately file it into your system
- 58:56Anything that scan they file it into your system
- 58:59rather than having an individual do it I've heard
- 59:01about this helping firms, you know take their
- 59:04team like scanning team or sort of staff down
- 59:08From you know 20 down to five or whatever. Um,
- 59:12but this is again an option that's available.
- 59:17I will go through these briefly. I'll go over
- 59:21just a little bit here, but with case intake
- 59:23client communication tools, I really like the
- 59:25Smith AI we use for as like sort of a virtual
- 59:29receptionist, not AI speaking to people, but
- 59:33it does virtual reception service, but we use
- 59:38the actual. people. So they also do that as well.
- 59:42And they use AI chatbots features to log and
- 59:45route calls efficiently. For us, it's been great
- 59:48because we use them a lot during like off hours,
- 59:50right? And they are able to take all the calls,
- 59:53able to pass the information on to us. And let's
- 59:58say Speed AI, we use Speed AI with our intake
- 1:00:01system. It doesn't replace your CRM or your intake
- 1:00:04system. It's sort of like an add -on on top of
- 1:00:06that. And it works with your AI system. I really
- 1:00:09liked it because it was a way to sort of power
- 1:00:13up your intake platform. It analyzes all the
- 1:00:18calls that had come in and analyzes them for
- 1:00:22any missed opportunities and scores case quality.
- 1:00:24So the people doing intake, it'll provide a score
- 1:00:26for them as well. And provide coaching opportunities
- 1:00:29like, hey, maybe you weren't necessarily empathetic
- 1:00:31when the potential client was discussing this.
- 1:00:37And it's just a great way for people to receive
- 1:00:39immediate feedback because sometimes that feedback
- 1:00:42might be lacking. But it's a great way to sort
- 1:00:45of provide a safeguard for making sure that you
- 1:00:49don't miss opportunities in the future and for
- 1:00:51also helping and training your team. Whippy,
- 1:00:56I really like Whippy. We use that. would be the
- 1:01:01way that we've used it. They have a lot. They
- 1:01:03have AI web chat, they have a mobile app, sequences,
- 1:01:07integrations. The way that I use it most is that
- 1:01:11it allowed me to turn my office phone number,
- 1:01:16and I'll pull back a little bit here. What something
- 1:01:19like Filevine allows you to have is a specific
- 1:01:22case, sort of text number for every single case.
- 1:01:25So every single one of my clients had a specific
- 1:01:27text number they could always text. And that
- 1:01:29was great because all they had to do is text
- 1:01:31that number, it would be uploaded directly into
- 1:01:33their case file. Again, another great thing of
- 1:01:35case management systems. The one thing though
- 1:01:38is that what I started realizing is that when
- 1:01:40we send that welcome letter to our client, they
- 1:01:43initially call my office number. I provide my
- 1:01:47clients with my cell phone as well. I then also
- 1:01:52gave them this case specific text number in our
- 1:01:56email. There were that was just a lot of numbers
- 1:02:00for folks So like where are they actually sending
- 1:02:01the information to if they need to call me? They
- 1:02:03need to send a text like where should they send
- 1:02:05it to and so what would be allowed us to do is
- 1:02:09to take our main office line our number and T
- 1:02:13and to turn that so that people can text that
- 1:02:16number Every single one of our clients every
- 1:02:19single potential client could text that number
- 1:02:23For the entirety of from when they called us
- 1:02:27for an intake to when the case resolves. And
- 1:02:30the way that it looks like on our end is that
- 1:02:33it's just a platform. It's also on my phone,
- 1:02:35it's an app. And let's say once a client, the
- 1:02:38first time a client communicates with our office,
- 1:02:40it'll be the intake team talking to them. When
- 1:02:43we sign the case up, that... client's number
- 1:02:47gets assigned to a specific attorney in the office,
- 1:02:50and now they're the ones that are speaking with
- 1:02:52the client, but always through that same door.
- 1:02:54As far as the client knows, they don't know any
- 1:02:56better. They're always speaking and texting with
- 1:02:58that office number. Internally, it's assigned
- 1:03:03to the attorney that's handling the case. It
- 1:03:07just helped with client communication, helped
- 1:03:12facilitate and make a conversation a lot easier
- 1:03:15and smoother. And also, from one of the other
- 1:03:19things that we do is that any text conversations
- 1:03:21that we have with clients gets forwarded immediately
- 1:03:22to the case file at the end of the day. And so,
- 1:03:26again, Any information, no matter where it's
- 1:03:30communication it's had with client gets sent
- 1:03:32into the case file at the end of the day. There's
- 1:03:36another slide there on that. I won't discuss
- 1:03:39discovery tools, but there are discovery tools
- 1:03:42available like Esquire Tech and BriefPoint. It's
- 1:03:46in the materials. The very last thing I'll say
- 1:03:50is just with content creation, there's also these
- 1:03:53tools that are available for you. Creating content
- 1:03:59is not necessarily something that people should
- 1:04:03shy away from. I think it's something that us
- 1:04:06as attorneys can lean into. I'm a very private
- 1:04:08person. I never posted things on my social media
- 1:04:11prior to opening up my own practice. But when
- 1:04:13you open up your own practice, you go, hey, I
- 1:04:15need to sign cases up. So I need to be a little
- 1:04:17bit more visible. But you could do it in a way
- 1:04:19that where you're comfortable and that you feel
- 1:04:20comfortable. And you don't feel that you're being
- 1:04:22gimmicky. You don't feel that you're doing something
- 1:04:24out of your comfort zone or where you're not
- 1:04:26being genuine. You could do it in your own way.
- 1:04:27But most of the time, we're busy as attorneys.
- 1:04:30We don't have time to do any of this editing
- 1:04:32or do this additional stuff. Here are some tools
- 1:04:34that can help you quickly take any video or photos
- 1:04:37that you've taken and turn that into something
- 1:04:41that you can post online, right? Something like
- 1:04:44CapCut, for example, is a great tool, an app
- 1:04:46that you can have on your phone. It'll take videos
- 1:04:49and photos that you have and make something really
- 1:04:51cool and like... You just post it. And now you're
- 1:04:54visible for clients, for referring attorneys.
- 1:04:58That's something that is important to you. And
- 1:05:03so those are just tools using AI as well that
- 1:05:06can help you. Just closing thoughts. Take time
- 1:05:10to test products. So that was saying take the
- 1:05:12demos, take the meetings, and embrace the ever
- 1:05:15-evolving nature of technology. Be exposed to
- 1:05:18it. Learn. test it, just to discover and rediscover.
- 1:05:24That is my time for today. Thank you all so much
- 1:05:27for having me, and if you guys have any questions,
- 1:05:29that's my contact information. Feel free to...
- 1:05:32to email me, reach out to me as well. Those are
- 1:05:35social media as well. We also have a podcast.
- 1:05:38It's called Art of Purpose. It's not even like
- 1:05:40legal. It's just where we talk about how individuals
- 1:05:43discover purpose, obviously because of our industry.
- 1:05:46We have a lot of attorneys and judges as well
- 1:05:48in a lot of folks that you might know. So check
- 1:05:52us out and thank you for your time. It was a
- 1:05:54pleasure.