Latest / Raising Men / Why Boys Are Falling Behind (and What We Can Do About It) with Steve Biddulph
Transcript
- 0:00I would get stopped in the street and I still
- 0:02I still get stopped in the street by guys
- 0:04these big guys come over to me and say you're
- 0:06you're Steve Biddulph aren't you
- 0:08and I I said yeah
- 0:09what what you gonna do to me
- 0:10you know you gonna break my head off
- 0:12ha ha ha ha ha
- 0:14and and I said
- 0:15that book that that
- 0:16that effing book of yours
- 0:17that that's the story of my life mate and
- 0:20and it it really helped me
- 0:21and I just wanna let you know I
- 0:23you know sometimes
- 0:23you know
- 0:24like I wouldn't be alive if it wasn't for that
- 0:34welcome back to Raising Men
- 0:35one of the founding hypotheses of this whole project
- 0:41is that there is a quiet crisis happening with boys
- 0:46today across classrooms
- 0:49playgrounds and homes boys are falling behind in school
- 0:53they're struggling with identity
- 0:56and they're being forced
- 0:58to grow up in a world that's not quite sure
- 1:01what to do with masculinity anymore
- 1:04and my guest today Steve Biddulph
- 1:07has been one of the world's leading voices on this
- 1:10for over three decades he's a psychologist
- 1:14an educator and an author of two books
- 1:17Raising Boys and The New Manhood
- 1:21and those books have shaped how millions of parents
- 1:24and teachers understand
- 1:26male development his message is simple
- 1:29but I think profound if we want strong men
- 1:33we need to raise emotionally healthy young boys
- 1:36Steve welcome to raising men
- 1:39hi Shawn
- 1:40and hello to everyone that's watching
- 1:41or listening to this great to have some time with you
- 1:46well thanks so much
- 1:47and now how did you come to focus
- 1:49on boys and men and fatherhood
- 1:52and parenting and education for your career
- 1:55okay well
- 1:57long people who are watching this can see
- 2:00I've got grey hair and I'm seriously elderly and um
- 2:05geriatric now and so
- 2:07but in the 1970s I was a young um
- 2:11keen young guy um this
- 2:14this just graduated as a psychologist
- 2:16and I got recruited to a
- 2:18a new clinic that was being set up in a
- 2:21an industrial kind of town in Tasmania
- 2:24Australia
- 2:26and this clinic was doing something pretty radical
- 2:28it was seeing the whole family
- 2:30it was a family therapy clinic
- 2:32which in those days was a new idea
- 2:34and so we uh
- 2:36someone had a a kid with all
- 2:38with some kind of problems uh
- 2:40with the law or with with behaviour or something
- 2:44my boss said the whole family's gotta come
- 2:47we're not seeing kids on their own
- 2:49which is pretty sensible thing when you think about it
- 2:53um let's yeah
- 2:54I'm astonished that that was revolutionary
- 2:57but it absolutely is
- 2:58that seems like an obvious thing to do
- 3:01yeah cause in those days
- 3:02it was like you getting your car serviced
- 3:04you know you would
- 3:05you drop your kid at the psychologist to get them fixed
- 3:09and that that never worked but
- 3:11but anyhow we
- 3:12we got to see hundreds and hundreds of families
- 3:15and these were what we call
- 3:17I think you call it in the States as well
- 3:18blue collar families that's right
- 3:20um
- 3:22families
- 3:23parents who worked at the mill or worked on a farm
- 3:25or worked in the forest and um
- 3:28and what we found was that the mums were great
- 3:33the mums pretty much knew what they were doing
- 3:37um but the dads really struggled
- 3:40and and in
- 3:42in in the families that came to see us
- 3:44you could tell that dads they love their kids
- 3:46and they work their guts out
- 3:48all their life to provide for their kids and um
- 3:52but the when it came to actually relating to their kids
- 3:56they were kind of distant and stiff and awkward
- 4:01um and
- 4:04and so I'm so began to think well
- 4:07someone's gotta help the dads and um
- 4:10and then something happened Sean
- 4:12which was more personal that I was a
- 4:15a young I
- 4:17I was married with Sharon
- 4:18I had a farm and we had a
- 4:23um
- 4:24had um
- 4:25a little boy and we are ready to have another child and
- 4:29um and the
- 4:31the pregnancy of our much hoped for second child um
- 4:34miscarried and um
- 4:38and that's the thing that happens
- 4:40very common thing
- 4:41happens to millions of people every week
- 4:44um but it really knocked me around
- 4:47I don't I didn't understand it
- 4:49but it put my wife Sharon and I
- 4:51we kind of we had a
- 4:51kind of
- 4:52a grief reaction that was on a different timetable
- 4:56her grief was different to mine
- 4:58and she didn't want to talk to me
- 4:59and I I didn't know
- 5:00what was happening and I just got very
- 5:02very sort of depressed and
- 5:05and really affected by that
- 5:07and when I tried to talk to my friends
- 5:11they didn't they just didn't come through for me Shawn
- 5:14they just didn't know what to say
- 5:16and I began to realize well
- 5:18have I even got friends you know
- 5:20I thought these were my friends um
- 5:23us guys don't um
- 5:26we don't support each other properly and um
- 5:29and this began a lot
- 5:30a journey right into the whole thing
- 5:33Robert Bly had just written Iron John
- 5:35his book about men um
- 5:37the idea of father hunger and the father wound
- 5:40and so
- 5:41manhood was the book I wrote out of that experience and
- 5:46and so I it was it was personal
- 5:49but it was also something professional
- 5:51I saw the need for
- 5:52and manhood started 500 men's groups around Australia
- 5:57and I would get stopped
- 5:59I would get stopped in the street and I still
- 6:01I still get stopped in the street by guys
- 6:03these big guys come over to me and say
- 6:05you're you're Steve Biddulph
- 6:06aren't you and I
- 6:07I said yeah
- 6:08what what you gonna do to me
- 6:09you know you gonna break my head off hahaha
- 6:13and and I said that book that
- 6:15that that effing book of yours that
- 6:17that's the story of my life mate and
- 6:19and it
- 6:19it really helped me and I just wanna let you know I
- 6:22you know sometimes
- 6:23you know like
- 6:23I wouldn't be alive if it wasn't for that book
- 6:26and that was just you know
- 6:29I'm a quiet sort of guy
- 6:30and I'm very unsure of anything that I do
- 6:34but this was very affirming message
- 6:37that we were onto something here
- 6:39and we had to we had to help the guys
- 6:41and the guys would respond to that
- 6:43and they would turn around
- 6:45you get you give a man the right help
- 6:47he will turn around you know and
- 6:49and um
- 6:51it's just that no one ever did that
- 6:53and so that was this that's enough of
- 6:55of the origin sort of I'd story but
- 6:58but that's that's where it began
- 7:00that is such a powerful story I
- 7:03I love it and I love that legacy that
- 7:05that you have
- 7:06I love the fact that you get recognized on the street
- 7:09that is that's
- 7:10that's fantastic hmm
- 7:13now you have argued that uh
- 7:17and I agree with this argument
- 7:18that boys might benefit from starting school later
- 7:23um but that
- 7:24you know that's a big kind of systematic change
- 7:27and I don't think we should be holding our breath
- 7:30waiting for the culture to catch up to this
- 7:34so since
- 7:36traditional school environments can disadvantage boys
- 7:39in in areas like
- 7:41like reading or behavioral expectations
- 7:44emotional development that sort of thing
- 7:45what do we
- 7:46what can we do to support our son's education when
- 7:51you know within the current system
- 7:53that funnels them into a situation that's
- 7:55frankly suboptimal yeah okay
- 7:58well we gonna take a while to unpack that one
- 8:01um sure
- 8:02because okay well
- 8:03we got a while first of all to understand um
- 8:08what's going on is that when
- 8:10when a little baby is still in the womb
- 8:12you know it was still inside his mum um
- 8:16if it's a boy baby in his
- 8:18his
- 8:20there's a point about third trim
- 8:22third sort of month of pregnancy
- 8:23the little testicles start to pop out and start to grow
- 8:29and straight away they make testosterone
- 8:31that's their job and they start making testosterone
- 8:33and they start shaping this little fetus into a boy
- 8:36baby
- 8:38and one of the main effects they have is that they
- 8:42they put the brakes on the testosterone
- 8:45slows down the development of a boy
- 8:48and whereas a little baby girl in the womb is kind of
- 8:52kind of surging on little baby boys grow more slowly
- 8:56and we have no idea why that is
- 8:59but at the moment of birth they're
- 9:02they're probably three
- 9:04three or four weeks less developed than baby girls
- 9:09wow that that's counter intuitive yeah
- 9:12yeah and um
- 9:15and maybe it's got something to do with that
- 9:16they've got extra things they need to
- 9:18to develop but we
- 9:20we don't know but the
- 9:22the result is that with a little baby boy
- 9:24he's a little bit harder to switch on in
- 9:27it's sort of like you know
- 9:28when you hold when mum's holding him and talking
- 9:31to him and you know
- 9:32how you going little fella
- 9:33you know you
- 9:34and tickling him and and smiling at him
- 9:37you have to work a little harder to get him
- 9:39on the outside and uh
- 9:42Richard Reeves who's written about the science of this
- 9:44it's it's
- 9:45you know that they're um
- 9:46they're even more likely to
- 9:48you know to die in
- 9:49in in early childhood um
- 9:54it's a vulnerability in boy babies
- 9:57and and so
- 9:59and by the time they are starting school
- 10:03it would coming to your question
- 10:05um so age 5 or so
- 10:084 or 5 the difference
- 10:10between the boys and girls is from 6 to 12 months
- 10:14difference Sean
- 10:15so it's a you know enormous
- 10:18the gap gets bigger
- 10:20yeah at that age
- 10:21it gets bigger and and
- 10:23and then they slowly start to catch up
- 10:25but they don't catch up till they're about 22
- 10:28and so so it's a lifelong thing
- 10:31and so girls for instance
- 10:32have puberty um
- 10:34a year and a half to two years sooner than boys do
- 10:37um and
- 10:40but if we stay with our school be
- 10:41school starting what this means is that little boys are
- 10:45can be a year behind the girl that's sitting beside
- 10:48in the desk yeah
- 10:50and and that's not good and and
- 10:54and a year behind what that
- 10:55what they're behind in is two things um
- 10:58talking
- 11:00you know be able to put a sentence together
- 11:02and express themselves and
- 11:05and getting finger control
- 11:07you know
- 11:07picking up a pen and being able to do nice work
- 11:11in which
- 11:12and schools have traditionally been very big on
- 11:14you know neat work
- 11:15you know and answering the questions and and
- 11:19and so if you're a little boy
- 11:21and you just get this pretty immediate
- 11:23you know they're not silly
- 11:24they're not stupid
- 11:25they can see that those girls are so good at it
- 11:27you know um
- 11:29what can I do um
- 11:31and so very likely to get restless
- 11:34discouraged not be able to follow the teacher
- 11:37and the whole trajectory which of course
- 11:39ends up in not very good places sometimes
- 11:43and so I began when I wrote Raising Boys
- 11:46which was 1996 um
- 11:51I said don't send them
- 11:53if you if you got any doubts
- 11:55just hold your kid back um
- 11:57send them the following year
- 11:59and so many parents as I said
- 12:02Raising Boys
- 12:03is the top selling parenting book in the world
- 12:05so far this century and
- 12:08and it was massive particularly in Europe and
- 12:12and Asia and
- 12:14and so I
- 12:15I met someone who was a Scottish education bureaucrat
- 12:20he said your book gave us so much trouble
- 12:23he said we had
- 12:24like 10,000 families held their kids back
- 12:28the year your book came out
- 12:30we had to we had empty classrooms
- 12:33we had to build other classrooms in other places
- 12:35because they this great wave came through the next year
- 12:38yeah the year that gets implemented
- 12:40you don't have any boys in school no
- 12:42that's right that's extreme
- 12:44but yeah but but
- 12:45but I get you know
- 12:47I get stopped by mums and dads
- 12:51especially when I used to do my speaking tours
- 12:54and they say we did that
- 12:55we kept our son back and and he did great
- 12:59you know he
- 13:00he was a year more mature
- 13:02he could hold his own and um
- 13:04I'd never met
- 13:05in out of thousands of people who told me that
- 13:08I never met anyone who regretted doing that
- 13:11you know cause it paid off in high school as well
- 13:14and it does does that make sense Shawn
- 13:15just as a as a dad to you
- 13:17so yeah
- 13:18I mean what your
- 13:19your description of that problem is
- 13:22I mean it's like you're talking you're
- 13:24you're telling my story of my childhood
- 13:25I I have this distinct memory when I was quite young
- 13:31maybe kindergarten aged and I went
- 13:34my parents brought me over to a friend's house
- 13:37and they had a daughter my same age
- 13:38and we were sitting down
- 13:40and the parents were socializing
- 13:42and me and the daughter were hanging out
- 13:45and she had a bunch of coloring books
- 13:47and I was coloring with her
- 13:50and she colored beautifully
- 13:53she outlined the area that she wanted to color in
- 13:56the color that she wanted to use
- 13:58and then she was just filling it in
- 14:00and it was her pictures were gorgeous
- 14:03and I desperately wanted to be able to do
- 14:06that and she was getting on me like why
- 14:08you know stop coloring outside the lines
- 14:10stop coloring outside the lines
- 14:12and I couldn't physically do it
- 14:14I I
- 14:14I I
- 14:15I was so frustrated
- 14:16because I actually couldn't physically keep
- 14:19the crayon from going outside the lines
- 14:22and it it ended up I ended up in in school
- 14:27I I have a September birthday and in September
- 14:30you can kind of fall on that edge
- 14:33where you can be in the earlier school year
- 14:36or in the later school year
- 14:37and my parents put me in school early and and then
- 14:42and to make matters worse
- 14:44I was big for my age and I started skipping grades
- 14:49and I prided myself on that
- 14:50I was so smart that I'm skipping grades
- 14:51but my emotional development
- 14:53and my intellectual development
- 14:56diverged and I was and frankly
- 15:01the best thing that ever happened to me is
- 15:05after 8th grade my parents decided to put me in a
- 15:09I was in a public school for 8th grade
- 15:11and they decided to put me in a private school
- 15:14and the private school said
- 15:17we don't want him to go into 9th grade
- 15:19we want him to repeat 8th grade
- 15:21wow and that was actually a blow to me
- 15:23because it was such a an area of pride
- 15:26that I'd skipped all these grades when I was younger
- 15:27and did all that stuff and they said listen
- 15:31like he's just he's gonna fit in better if
- 15:34he repeats 8th grade and cause
- 15:36he's not gonna be the youngest kid in class anymore
- 15:39and um
- 15:42and I I
- 15:43they could very well have cited your book
- 15:45it would not have surprised me
- 15:47and that's what they did
- 15:50and it was the best thing that ever happened to me
- 15:53it wow
- 15:54it just I
- 15:55I wasn't playing ketchup anymore and I didn't feel
- 15:59I felt so much I didn't even understand
- 16:01how much anxiety and stress I had
- 16:03associated with this having to perform at this level
- 16:07that I just wasn't ready for
- 16:09and it took that all off the table for me
- 16:13and now I look at my son who has my same makeup
- 16:18he's he's only 6
- 16:20unfortunately he's a January baby
- 16:22so he's like
- 16:23fully smack dab in the middle of the school year
- 16:27um but
- 16:29and and
- 16:29but he's very big he looks
- 16:31he's 6 but he looks like he's 9 or 10
- 16:34and so people have expectations of him
- 16:36that he has maturity that he doesn't
- 16:39he can't access
- 16:40and I can see that same frustration in him and
- 16:44and it is I'm
- 16:46I'm just like
- 16:47I really struggle with knowing what to do about that
- 16:51and we've had conversations where I
- 16:52where I've sat him down and said listen
- 16:55this is what happened and it can't happen that way
- 17:00people it's not fair
- 17:02but people have expectations of you
- 17:04that are well beyond your age
- 17:08and that's not fair sometimes life isn't
- 17:10fair and this is one of those times
- 17:13we're gonna have to figure out how to
- 17:15how to do the right thing here
- 17:16and it's it's been a real tough thing for us
- 17:19hmm and he's only 6 still and and
- 17:22and yeah
- 17:23yeah and
- 17:24and and so yeah
- 17:25so we need to we need to do both we
- 17:28we we gotta
- 17:28as an individual mum and dad
- 17:30we have to do what we can to slow this down
- 17:35and and the school systems need to change um and
- 17:39and give people a option and
- 17:41you know in the school of the future Sean
- 17:43the average boy will be a year older than the girl
- 17:45he sits beside yeah
- 17:48and and
- 17:48and that'll and because it
- 17:51for people listening it's you
- 17:53what happens is the way girls bodies develop is they
- 17:58they get their fine motor skills at about 4
- 18:04you know they pick up their
- 18:05those crayons and pencils you were talking about
- 18:08and they're good at it straight away
- 18:09their fingers work properly
- 18:11but boys develop and so what if you've got a daughter
- 18:14anyone listening who's got a daughter
- 18:16what you've got to do with girls is you build that
- 18:17you have to build their core strength
- 18:19you know so you get girls on trampolines
- 18:21you know and
- 18:22and throwing um
- 18:23throwing big netballs and baseballs sorry
- 18:27um basketballs to them
- 18:29because girls need strength in the core
- 18:31but boys develop core outwards
- 18:35and so so first
- 18:36of all they develop the trunk muscles and
- 18:39and then they develop their arms and legs
- 18:41and also the nerves running to those
- 18:43you know the nerves that control those arms and legs
- 18:46and then when they've got that
- 18:47finally it's the fingers that come last
- 18:51and so what a boy's body tells him to do is move me
- 18:56you know a little boy sitting in the classroom
- 18:58and his body is saying you know
- 19:00move me ha ha
- 19:02run around yeah
- 19:04yeah noise yeah and
- 19:06and he's he knows
- 19:07he knows you know
- 19:08a good kid is a still kid
- 19:10you know in a elementary school classroom
- 19:13you're supposed to be still
- 19:14but his body's screaming and
- 19:17and guys that are listening to this
- 19:19if you think back you'll remember this feeling
- 19:22it sitting at a desk
- 19:24it hurts it actually physically hurts
- 19:26it was yesterday
- 19:27I remember that feeling like it was yesterday yeah
- 19:30yeah
- 19:31and so I work a lot with elementary school teachers
- 19:34and I and I help them to
- 19:36to realize you know
- 19:38that little guy get them moving
- 19:40you know and so a lot of our schools now they
- 19:43they have exercise at the start of the day they
- 19:46they do a lot of moving around that you you
- 19:49you can get up from your chair and
- 19:51and you know
- 19:52stretch yourself and stand up and
- 19:53and you won't get sent to the principal
- 19:56um so you
- 19:58you've got to find a boy find
- 19:59a boy friendly school and and
- 20:02and the teachers are are attuned to this Boyd needs um
- 20:07then it's it's my
- 20:08it's a whole lot better but but
- 20:10but the main one of course was
- 20:12you know that
- 20:12I mean I think that probably changed your life
- 20:15Shawn changed the trajectory of your life
- 20:16it really did it there's no question
- 20:18it changed the trajectory of my life
- 20:20no question at all and if it had happened earlier
- 20:23it would have changed it even more
- 20:25even better I
- 20:26I would have gotten involved in sports
- 20:28in a different way and
- 20:29or much earlier
- 20:30which has been a wonderful part of my life
- 20:32but you know I it
- 20:33you know it would have been it
- 20:35it really would have changed things for me
- 20:38let's shift gears a little bit
- 20:39I wanna talk about you know
- 20:42it's increasingly the case that households
- 20:45are becoming separate
- 20:47moms aren't living with dads as much and
- 20:49and there's a bunch of research
- 20:51that links the absence of a father
- 20:53in the home to higher risks of
- 20:56bad outcomes delinquency
- 20:58poor academic performance
- 21:00and you know one
- 21:01and at least here in the US
- 21:03more than 1 in 4 children are living without a
- 21:07a male in the home
- 21:09and for a lot of parents it's just simply
- 21:13that's just the reality mom and dad don't live together
- 21:15so what what do you think we can do to mitigate
- 21:19the issues there I
- 21:21I
- 21:22if you're staring down that reality
- 21:24what do you do about it
- 21:26okay so again
- 21:28this is this is huge um
- 21:30and it's it's lucky this is not new
- 21:33this has been the case for
- 21:35for the whole 30 years that I've been writing about it
- 21:38that that um
- 21:40a lot of kids are in single parent homes
- 21:43um and it's always really important to say to to
- 21:48to single mums that are listening to
- 21:50to the podcast um
- 21:52that women have raised boys on their own
- 21:55for thousands of years um
- 21:58and and done just fine
- 22:01had them turn out really well and
- 22:04and what I it just means you gotta understand the
- 22:09the landscape and
- 22:11and because when I came I came back to live in
- 22:15the town I live in is called Launceston and
- 22:17and I I came back here um
- 22:20after a 20 year absence
- 22:21I lived in the UK and I lived in
- 22:23in up in the rainforest of New South Wales and
- 22:26and I but I came back to Launceston and
- 22:29and when I go to the supermarket
- 22:31I'd sometimes bump into people who'd been
- 22:34clients of mine back in the seventies
- 22:37and and
- 22:38and it's kind of like the elephant in the room
- 22:41it's it's like um
- 22:43I'd have to ask them they say
- 22:45oh Steve
- 22:46it's us you know
- 22:46we saw you when we came with our little boy
- 22:48you know and and
- 22:50and it was a single and the elephant in the room
- 22:54was well
- 22:55was it any help you know
- 22:57I was a young yeah
- 22:58how'd it turn out
- 23:00yeah how'd it go and
- 23:01and but more well
- 23:02and that they say well
- 23:03you know um
- 23:05yeah look
- 23:06it was it helped and um
- 23:08and I'd say well
- 23:09what would you
- 23:11what would you pass on to a young single mum today
- 23:15what as
- 23:15as you've raised a son I've met him he's doing great
- 23:20what would you pass on and they'd say
- 23:23it was always the same thing Sean
- 23:25they'd say
- 23:25I made sure he knew what a good man looked like
- 23:31because you can't turn into one
- 23:34if you've never seen one
- 23:36and so those mums they
- 23:38they recognise OK
- 23:40I can do I can get him 90% there
- 23:42you know if I'm loving and if I
- 23:45if I'm understanding of his boy energies
- 23:47and I don't get into negative
- 23:49um you know
- 23:51put downs and fights with him um
- 23:55then I can get 90% there
- 23:58but he's got to see some good men
- 24:00and so that's right you know
- 24:01so we we say don't send him to Kev's College of karate
- 24:06um unless you like the look of Kev
- 24:09ha ha
- 24:10you know if
- 24:11there you go you know yeah
- 24:13whether it's a sport or a musical instrument
- 24:16or whatever it is um
- 24:19role models are the real thing
- 24:21and in a second
- 24:22we can talk a bit about that if you've got time Shawn
- 24:24cause it's a big theme of mine
- 24:26but but those mums they
- 24:28you know they kind of recruited
- 24:31you know they said OK
- 24:33he hasn't got a dad um
- 24:35but he's got an uncle who's really nice guy
- 24:40you know so uncle
- 24:42can you take him fishing every
- 24:43you know couple of times a month
- 24:45and um
- 24:46Grandpa you know
- 24:48can you take an interest
- 24:49he's having a bit of a struggle
- 24:50can you take a bit of an interest in him
- 24:53um you know
- 24:54it doesn't matter who it's what
- 24:55you know the
- 24:56the guys who the two guys who live next door
- 24:58you know if if um
- 25:00he can he gets this kind of
- 25:02palette of a lot of different styles of masculinity um
- 25:07then he can begin to
- 25:08to have a bit of that and a bit of this and and
- 25:12you know learn what kindness looks like in a male and
- 25:15and um
- 25:17and that it's a combination of of
- 25:22kind of taken in the the
- 25:23this this
- 25:24the way of being male
- 25:25but it's also feeling validated as a male
- 25:29you know Grandpa and I hang out
- 25:32Grandpa thinks I'm alright
- 25:33even though I'm struggling at school
- 25:35Grandpa says I'm a great kid and I'm good company
- 25:38and I'm good with a fishing line and
- 25:41and so um
- 25:43and that that's what those mums did
- 25:45they made sure that the
- 25:45the boy didn't go up in a kind of hostile
- 25:50a world hostile to males um
- 25:53yeah does that
- 25:55make sense Shawn
- 25:56it does well
- 25:57and I think that there's
- 26:00you know the
- 26:00the thing that we talked about in the very beginning
- 26:02where men aren't supportive of each other
- 26:05in the way that women are right
- 26:06my wife has eight friends
- 26:08that she tells every detail of her life to
- 26:09and I
- 26:10I really struggle to open up to even my closest friends
- 26:16and in that same way
- 26:19we're not we don't seek out
- 26:22you know young men to to to mentor necessarily
- 26:26or we're not necessarily going to seek out mentors
- 26:29if we're a high school age boy
- 26:30or something like that and it's so critical
- 26:34and the cultural institutions that used to exist
- 26:39to make that happen your church or
- 26:41you know local programs and those sorts of things
- 26:43those are all gone now
- 26:45and so it's not gonna happen by default
- 26:46and that
- 26:47that means you have to take responsibility of it
- 26:50you have to design it yourself
- 26:51you have to be intentional about it
- 26:52now that also means that you can customize it
- 26:55you don't just have to go to the Catholic Church
- 26:57on the corner where there might be some problems
- 26:59you can customize it for your own needs
- 27:02but you have to do it
- 27:04yeah
- 27:06and and um
- 27:09knowing that
- 27:10I think people can get very intentional about it and
- 27:13and and
- 27:14and and
- 27:14and and it's not it's not rocket science
- 27:16it's not that hard the guys that are in the
- 27:20the terrific thing about the psychology of us as men is
- 27:25if someone points us to a job
- 27:27we'll do it yeah
- 27:28um and and and
- 27:29and we we have a
- 27:32a really great quality which is a
- 27:34we like to do heroic things and
- 27:38and if someone says my kid's in trouble
- 27:40you know can
- 27:41can you know it's
- 27:42I think it's it's
- 27:43you know it's gonna be a year or two
- 27:45where he needs just someone a bit that
- 27:47that's a bit involved in his life um
- 27:50so you know
- 27:51we think OK
- 27:51well if that's what you like
- 27:53yeah I'll
- 27:53I'll give it a go and
- 27:55but we would have been there is a man on the planet
- 27:58I don't think that there is a man on the planet
- 28:00a decent man on the planet
- 28:01that being asked that question
- 28:02wouldn't love the opportunity to do that for somebody I
- 28:08I think I I just
- 28:10if I just can't imagine anybody I know
- 28:13any decent man I know when come
- 28:15when having that question posed to them
- 28:17every single one of them would jump at the opportunity
- 28:19to do that is yeah
- 28:21yeah it's a hopeful message
- 28:24and Sean
- 28:25can I talk about a little part of this that will make
- 28:28it make sense to people more and
- 28:31and because it's um
- 28:33it's to do with um
- 28:36there are qualities that you would wanna have
- 28:39you know when we talk about um
- 28:41a good man or a life affirming masculinity um
- 28:45that that um
- 28:48it opens up into some things and and for instance
- 28:53you know you would be patient
- 28:55you know he's always gonna grow up
- 28:57he's probably gonna be a dad
- 28:58and be a husband or a partner um
- 29:01so you want him to be patient
- 29:02you want him to be kind
- 29:04you want him to have stickability and endurance
- 29:07and want him to be a man of his word
- 29:09and those kinds of
- 29:11whole bunch of things now
- 29:14if we take take patience for example
- 29:18that's
- 29:18it's actually quite a complicated thing to be patient
- 29:22yeah um yeah
- 29:23it's not you can't sort of say to a kid be patient and
- 29:27and I'll have it in a Powerpoint presentation and
- 29:31and because what it is
- 29:33it's actually it's a way of breathing
- 29:37you know when you when you're patient
- 29:38you kind of change how you breathe
- 29:40and you change how you stand
- 29:42and yeah there's a physiological component to patience
- 29:45yeah yeah
- 29:47there's and there's a whole um
- 29:49you you drop you drop your agenda that
- 29:52you know and you say okay
- 29:53this is gonna take a bit
- 29:54I'm gonna listen to this kid while he
- 29:57unpause something out
- 29:58or I have to wait'cause he's really slow with this
- 30:01and so so patience is a very complex
- 30:04nonverbal multifaceted skill now
- 30:09the only way to learn that is it's a right brain thing
- 30:13you have to see it going on and you take and
- 30:17human beings it's called mirror
- 30:19mirror learning and and we
- 30:21our nervous system I
- 30:23you know I watch you and I
- 30:25and I take in your movements and your breathing rhythms
- 30:28and your the
- 30:29the way that your face moves and your eyes move
- 30:32and I've got a
- 30:33kind of a Shawn sense that I can take on board
- 30:37if I if I spend it
- 30:38you know a couple of days with you
- 30:39I could do Shawn
- 30:41and qualities that you have that I don't have
- 30:45and I can put those into my masculinity for future
- 30:49you know use
- 30:50and so so the
- 30:53the the role modeling is made up of
- 30:56you know
- 30:58the a boy
- 30:58we drink in what we are
- 31:00is
- 31:00we're a bundle of all the good people we've ever met
- 31:05male or female and so if your
- 31:07if your son has seen patience
- 31:10and he's seen forbearance
- 31:11and he's seen stickability and
- 31:14and vulnerability and and all those qualities
- 31:17then it's it's
- 31:18it's it's programmed into him and he can do it uh
- 31:22and and so we
- 31:23so they they need thousands of hours of male company
- 31:29um school teachers and coaches and guys on TV and and
- 31:35and um
- 31:37and in the old days that was there you would yeah
- 31:40it happened by default all the yeah hmm
- 31:45yeah I wanna touch on one more really
- 31:50really big subject and I know this is something
- 31:52we could probably go hours on but
- 31:54but I really wanna get your opinion about it
- 31:57and that is navigating the digital wild west
- 32:01I'm talking about like
- 32:02stuff like screen time and pornography
- 32:05and gaming
- 32:06and gambling in our pocket and all of those things
- 32:08I'm terrified about these things
- 32:10this is in fact
- 32:11one of the reasons that I started this whole project
- 32:14is because I realized that the world that my boy
- 32:17is gonna graduate into is so completely
- 32:21it's a foreign territory for me
- 32:22it might as well be a different planet
- 32:24from the one that I grew up in
- 32:26and and because of these things
- 32:29how what is your advice to parents
- 32:33to navigate these boundaryless
- 32:35digital realities rather
- 32:37I mean
- 32:38I think a lot of us just stick our head in the sand
- 32:40and pretend it doesn't exist
- 32:41or pretend it's you know
- 32:43a matter of force of will or something like that
- 32:45but they rewire your brain
- 32:47what do we do what what what is your advice about that
- 32:50very important question
- 32:52Sean and it's a it's a combination of two things um
- 32:56one is just restricting the the whole phenomenon
- 33:01you know putting the brakes on um
- 33:04and the other is giving them some
- 33:06giving them some guidance and
- 33:08and tools to use when they do encounter it um
- 33:12and I can spell those out a tiny bit now in
- 33:15in my country Australia
- 33:16I don't know if you know this but about I do I love it
- 33:20go go ahead and tell everybody four weeks ago
- 33:24the government passed a law
- 33:25legislation
- 33:27that social media companies are not allowed to
- 33:30subscribe under sixteens
- 33:33and so under sixteens and are not are not able to go on
- 33:38not able to have a um
- 33:39a Facebook account an Instagram account
- 33:42a whole bunch of the of TikTok
- 33:43all of those
- 33:45they can still do YouTube's
- 33:47but they can't have an account
- 33:49so that they can't be algorithmed
- 33:51and because it's the it's when you have an account
- 33:53the algorithm steers you into
- 33:55you know the matter sphere and the
- 33:56and the toxic stuff
- 33:58and so already parents are incredibly um
- 34:03relieved and and it meant that
- 34:06you know if
- 34:07I mean if you had a involved mum or dad
- 34:10they were already putting those brakes on
- 34:12but if you had a a kind of deadbeat parent who didn't
- 34:17just was too exhausted or didn't care or whatever
- 34:22it meant you didn't miss
- 34:23you didn't have a horrible childhood
- 34:25because the government had solved that problem for you
- 34:28yeah um
- 34:30and this is sweeping the world now
- 34:33there are countries in Europe are just following
- 34:35quickly they're watching our
- 34:36you know the experiment here
- 34:37and they're pretty much bringing it on board
- 34:39but meantime yeah
- 34:41I mean and it's just
- 34:42it's the kind of thing
- 34:43the government has to step in and do
- 34:44because I mean you could say oh well
- 34:47you know just
- 34:47don't let your kid use social media until they're 16
- 34:49alright good luck
- 34:51that's somebody who doesn't have kids
- 34:52that's somebody who isn't getting pestered day by
- 34:54when can I get a smartphone
- 34:55when can my kid my six year old boy is asking me
- 34:58when he can have an iPhone already
- 35:00he's already pushing me on it
- 35:02and yeah I mean
- 35:04I don't it's tough
- 35:06yeah and so
- 35:08so it's like um
- 35:10we're a herd animal and and
- 35:13and it's very hard to stand against the herd
- 35:16and so um
- 35:17so it helps um
- 35:19you know there's
- 35:21it's called in Australia
- 35:21there's a thing called the Heads Up Alliance
- 35:24and it's kind of heads up from your phone
- 35:26from your device yeah
- 35:27and it's a school communities
- 35:29it tends to happen school by school
- 35:31um that the school will say look
- 35:34can every let's all get on board
- 35:36let's
- 35:36none of us give kids smartphones till they're fourteen
- 35:39um and and
- 35:42and and our whole
- 35:43let's all do this
- 35:44so it makes it easier on the individual
- 35:47um and I know we're running out of time Shawn
- 35:49and so I'll come around
- 35:50to the other part really quickly for you
- 35:52um yeah
- 35:53that um
- 35:55the
- 35:55the other part is that particularly with pornography um
- 35:59kids they will see it um
- 36:02and there'll be some kid in the in
- 36:05you know usually by the age of 10
- 36:07some kid in the school will have shown them some
- 36:09horrible thing on their phone or
- 36:11or in a photograph and so we
- 36:14have to let them know you say look
- 36:16there's this thing around it's called pornography and
- 36:19and it's people doing things with each other's bodies
- 36:22and
- 36:24um and you'll be if you see you'll be kind of
- 36:26you know like wow
- 36:27what's that you know
- 36:28you you wanna have a look
- 36:29cause you're curious and that's alright
- 36:31and if it's a you know picture of a
- 36:33you know girl with no clothes on
- 36:35of course we're attracted to girls and they're
- 36:38they're beautiful and um
- 36:40but there's some problems with this stuff
- 36:42and it's in particular the
- 36:47what happens in pornography is different to real life
- 36:51and um
- 36:52and in in our books we have we list the differences um
- 36:56that you can teach your kids for instance
- 36:58people are not up for sex
- 36:59the minute they first meet each other um
- 37:02and um that um and the most specific one is that um
- 37:10real girls don't like being strangled
- 37:13they don't like being slapped
- 37:14and they don't like being um
- 37:16put down you know
- 37:17with put downs and and verbal abuse
- 37:20because I think it's
- 37:2170% of pornography depicts those things
- 37:25wow
- 37:25and and and the actresses are are are paid you know
- 37:29they and you explain to your kids
- 37:30the actresses are often really poor
- 37:32and they have a lot of trouble
- 37:34you know paying their
- 37:34for their food and their kids and their apartment
- 37:38and so sometimes they make this
- 37:40these movies to make some money and
- 37:42it's really sad that they have to do that
- 37:44and they have to pretend to like it
- 37:47uh and so
- 37:48trust me girls don't like that stuff and
- 37:51and if you do that stuff to girls
- 37:53they won't like you and
- 37:55and so you know
- 37:57so pornography is is mis
- 38:00miseducates you and
- 38:01and so
- 38:02this is the sort of thing you talk to kids about
- 38:04when they're about 12
- 38:06Shawn um
- 38:07when their age you just
- 38:08look what a powerful way to
- 38:10to communicate that and I
- 38:12I love that trigger of when they see it
- 38:14they're gonna come to you
- 38:16I mean you've got to have that kind of relationship too
- 38:18and then you have
- 38:19you get prepared for that conversation
- 38:21hmm yeah
- 38:23and and so
- 38:24and because the effects of all of these things are
- 38:27are to do with exposure with
- 38:29it's a dose related thing
- 38:31the more you see the worse you are was is
- 38:34is you don't have devices in bedrooms and um
- 38:38and and
- 38:38and only in in the public parts of your
- 38:42of your house that
- 38:43where everyone sees what each other's doing
- 38:45um yeah and
- 38:47and very you know
- 38:50very important
- 38:52because the kids get so messed up with this
- 38:54and there's huge companies
- 38:56making a lot of money from messing your kids up
- 38:58and so you have to fight back
- 38:59yeah
- 39:01wow that's
- 39:02that is tremendous advice
- 39:04I appreciate it now
- 39:05I always love I like to finish off every single
- 39:08one of these discussions
- 39:09by asking the same question of everybody
- 39:12you know I'm gonna put you on the spot here
- 39:14feel free to take as much time as you want to
- 39:16think about it but um
- 39:18give me one principle that you think is important
- 39:22for raising strong powerful
- 39:25uh excellent men
- 39:30okay look
- 39:31I think it's a paradoxical thing Shawn
- 39:35that tenderness is um
- 39:39is the secret of
- 39:40of strength and that what happens if we
- 39:45if we tender and gentle with our little guys um
- 39:49including when we wrestling with them
- 39:51and fighting with them and things like that
- 39:53where we where we never ever hurt them yeah
- 39:57and and they know that they can um
- 40:00that they're deeply loved um
- 40:03then their natural empathy will stay and so
- 40:06so when they see someone hurting
- 40:10they'll wanna help them
- 40:12and they'll never be the cause of hurt
- 40:14to somebody else
- 40:15and so it's the stuff you do in the first two years
- 40:18you know where
- 40:19where you're gentle with them and
- 40:20and patient and and um
- 40:23and even when they're just impossible
- 40:26you know and you gotta kind of
- 40:28you know hold them
- 40:31you know carry them back to the car in a screaming heap
- 40:34um um
- 40:36don't get angry don't hurt them because when you
- 40:40when you put hurt into a kid
- 40:41the hurt will come out on someone else down the track
- 40:45you know kids
- 40:46kids who are hit will hit when they grow up
- 40:49kids who see their dad hit their mum
- 40:51will hit their wife as well
- 40:53and you know
- 40:54if if you hit your kid and you hit your wife
- 40:58it's almost a guarantee your son will end up in jail
- 41:02guarantee and so um
- 41:05so that that
- 41:06those are things if if you're a dad
- 41:07you know and this is not just a minority
- 41:10it's all of us all of us dads
- 41:12me too we had to learn how to be safe and
- 41:16and how to
- 41:17to manage our strong feelings to walk away when we're
- 41:20when we just don't know what we're gonna do
- 41:23and so that so that a kid can say
- 41:25I always feel safe with my dad um
- 41:28he's he's my safety go to guy
- 41:31that's the foundation of everything yeah
- 41:34yeah that's what I mean
- 41:36half of masculinity is being a protector right
- 41:38you're being a you're a protector and you're a provider
- 41:40yeah and you're not a protector
- 41:42if your kid can't say that about you right
- 41:45you know he's not protected
- 41:46he's protected from you that's right yeah
- 41:49yeah
- 41:51I love that that is a fantastic principle
- 41:53thank you for adding that to my list
- 41:55I I
- 41:56that is that is tremendous
- 41:57the books are raising boys and the new manhood
- 42:02check them out this
- 42:03you can learn more about Steve's work at Steve
- 42:07bedoff.com the link is in the show notes
- 42:10if this episode moved you
- 42:12please share it with another dad or
- 42:15a mentor a teacher or
- 42:17or another parent
- 42:18who's in the fight for the soul of our boy
- 42:21Steve thank you so much for joining me today
- 42:25great interview Sean
- 42:26thanks very much and
- 42:27and love to everyone who is watching or listening
- 42:30see you later bye bye
- 42:39raising men is produced by Phil Hernandez
- 42:43this episode was edited by Ralph Tolentino