Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / AI Revolution in Engineering: A Deep Dive into ACEC's Groundbreaking Study
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to Engineering Influence, the podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:09Companies coming to you from the 2025 Annual Convention and Legislative Summit.
- 0:14And today, during our general session, we had a fantastic presentation on a
- 0:18new research study that is being produced by the ACEC Research Institute in
- 0:24conjunction with BST Global on everyone's favorite topic these days, AI,
- 0:29and exactly what it means for the industry, what it means for the practice of
- 0:33engineering and how our firms operate.
- 0:34And to talk about that study, I'm very pleased to be joined by Joe Bates,
- 0:38senior researcher with the Institute. Joe, how are you?
- 0:41I'm doing great, Jeff. Thank you. I always enjoy having the opportunity to speak
- 0:45with you. So thanks for having me today.
- 0:47I'm glad that you're in person. We've done like the past five of these things
- 0:50remotely. So I'm glad that you're actually here.
- 0:53So it's nice to be face to face. Yes, right.
- 0:56Instead of digital, which is kind of what we're talking about today. Actually, it's AI.
- 1:00You can't go a day without hearing about AI, right? Yeah. Every single day,
- 1:04it seems like there's another breakthrough.
- 1:06It seems like the researchers are going at a breakneck pace,
- 1:10and no question is changing the industry.
- 1:13This study, though, is really the first of us to kind of take a look at AI,
- 1:18its impact, and really what the future holds.
- 1:21So kind of tell us a little bit about the study and the general approach that you took. Sure.
- 1:26So this is the first study in our Firm of the Future series.
- 1:30And there's a reason it's the first one.
- 1:32It's the most important development in the world, really, in many ways,
- 1:37and certainly in our industry as well.
- 1:39So the idea was we need to make sure we bring a level playing field for all ACEC member firms.
- 1:47And you don't even have to be a member to be able to access this study.
- 1:51So I pitched it as the AI 101 for engineering because there's 40% of firms who
- 1:58actually have not even started looking into AI.
- 2:02There might be people in their firm, you know, using it here or there,
- 2:05but as firm leaders, they're not. Where?
- 2:08And so we wanted to do a historical background. We wanted to conduct interviews
- 2:14with people who are in the field right now who are using it,
- 2:20who are trying to advance their organization.
- 2:22So we talked to 20 individuals from firms that were very large,
- 2:28multinational to, you know, smaller regional firms, all different sectors,
- 2:33and even firms that were just starting out using AI and firms who are very,
- 2:39very advanced in what they're doing.
- 2:41And we also asked them about the future.
- 2:44What does the future hold in terms of what they see?
- 2:47Yeah. So those are sort of the three components that we addressed in the report.
- 2:51Overall, the findings aren't negative, right? It's, you know,
- 2:55you kind of hold your breath and you hope that it's not going to be,
- 2:58well, this is going to be a disruptor.
- 2:59It's going to actually negatively impact the industry.
- 3:01But really what you found is that it's going to not replace but enhance the
- 3:05talent that's already in place at firms.
- 3:07Absolutely. We have roughly 27% of our firm employees who are going to retire
- 3:15in the next five to 10 years.
- 3:16That's a lot of people when you're talking about one and a half million employed
- 3:21directly by our industry.
- 3:24So 25% of that, it's a lot, right? It's 300,000 people.
- 3:27We don't have enough young people to replace them.
- 3:32Part of it is there's fewer individuals going into engineering.
- 3:36Part of it is that half of those who graduate with an engineering degree are
- 3:41in the U.S. on an F-1 student visa. And there are not enough jobs in terms of
- 3:47H-1B applications to go around.
- 3:50So we have a huge challenge from a workforce perspective.
- 3:56And AI is going to help us. We're going to need it.
- 3:59In fact, it's coming at the right time. And it's going to make engineers and
- 4:03others in the office more productive.
- 4:06It's the production and efficiency side. I mean, AI is a fantastic tool at aggregating
- 4:13and analyzing aggregate data.
- 4:16And firms have a lot of that, right? So, one of the things I found was interesting
- 4:21is that AI as a virtual employee kind of – actually,
- 4:26you know, there are a couple of podcasts I've been listening to where the findings
- 4:30of the study were kind of echoed.
- 4:32It was the idea of you have the costs associated with onboarding new employees.
- 4:36You have the sourcing of talent for new employees, and AI can serve kind of as a research assistant.
- 4:44To existing engineers to take care of things that are more mundane,
- 4:49aggregating code, instead of having to pour through code, having AI kind of
- 4:56identify things very quickly.
- 4:58So it takes that time out so you can focus in on the actual engineering work. Right.
- 5:03Yeah. There's absolutely limitations right now and things that people want to
- 5:07do, but, you know, they just, they're not there yet and they're planning on
- 5:10it, they're working on it.
- 5:11But the potential is really amazing when you start to talk to these firms that
- 5:17are actually using AI in amazing ways.
- 5:20So there was this one firm leader that I talked with, and he said,
- 5:25you know, we needed to conduct an inspection for repairs of a commuter training platform.
- 5:33And it was concrete overhead. And when they arrived on the site,
- 5:36you know, they looked up and there was a lot of cracks, right?
- 5:42And some bigger than others. And it would have taken, you know,
- 5:46people laying on their back, literally mapping, hand drawing where they needed to make fixes.
- 5:53Well, what they did was they brought in a drone with very high resolution imagery
- 5:58and they then use software to map all that together.
- 6:02And they created this immensely highly detailed image of the structure. Yeah.
- 6:11AI then went in and said, boop, boop, boop, boop, boop. Yeah.
- 6:15Here we go. Yeah, exactly. Now we know what we need to do.
- 6:18It would have taken months, months of an individual or more individuals laying
- 6:25on their back and mapping that out.
- 6:26And they did that in a matter of a week or so.
- 6:29Exactly. And then they were able, the client said, we've never had this level
- 6:35of detail to actually then cost the project.
- 6:39And they were like, we had the closest, you know, discrepancies and costs from
- 6:45all these different contractors that we've ever seen.
- 6:48And the contractors were like, this is amazing. And they got it done very easily
- 6:54and efficiently and quickly.
- 6:55And that's going to be replicated across the industry. I mean,
- 6:58people are going to find new use cases.
- 7:00I mean, I was talking to a member firm principal earlier today on an EA winner, TSX Broadway.
- 7:07And we got talking to a couple of other projects that he worked on,
- 7:11St. Patrick's Cathedral being one of them.
- 7:13And it was right in, you know, Langan Engineering was the firm,
- 7:16and they did geotech work.
- 7:18And when they were doing the rehabilitation of St. Patrick's Cathedral in New
- 7:22York, what they realized is that they could use laser scanning and LIDAR,
- 7:25LIDAR2, to actually create a model. And at the time, that wasn't done.
- 7:32And he kind of explained about being on the leading edge of that technology
- 7:35and how much of a revelation it was to the people who were doing the restoration work.
- 7:40And, you know, I think it's going to be a really important tool,
- 7:44AI, for creative people within firms to leverage technology in ways where they otherwise couldn't.
- 7:50It's going to be a big business differentiator for firms. I absolutely agree.
- 7:55And I think it's going to allow, based on our research and based on what I've
- 7:59learned from doing this research,
- 8:01we are going to be able to do things that we haven't done before because we
- 8:05have the time to spend and the time to focus on the creativity,
- 8:09which we haven't really had before.
- 8:13So, and I think younger people today, I think you're going to be able to harness
- 8:17different skill sets that they have as well. They're going to be trained as engineers.
- 8:22There's a lot of people who have a lot of creative outlets, right?
- 8:26They might play guitar. They might draw.
- 8:29Well, we need creativity from all different workers to approach problems in a different way.
- 8:37And so I think we're going to have a lot more time to do that.
- 8:39You know, the younger generation is always, you know, every generation is less
- 8:44put off or concerned by technology that's being used by the generation currently in the office, right?
- 8:50So, you're going to have these next generations that are going to be,
- 8:53you know, AI is going to be a tool. It's not going to have an area of concern.
- 8:58That's the future. Currently, what are you seeing? I mean, we talked about the positives.
- 9:02But so, what are the barriers that are right now present? Yeah.
- 9:07Right now, you know, from the numbers side, Ray, we've got 40% of firms who
- 9:12just haven't even started really, right?
- 9:14And but yet the sentiment is very positive, you know, and it's growing.
- 9:18It's positively growing. So we asked the question two different times in the last year and a half.
- 9:23And even more firm leaders are positive about the impact AI will have on their firm.
- 9:29So lots of positivity out there. But what we're hearing and the interviews really
- 9:34brought this out as well, that there's sort of half of the people and in general,
- 9:40right, there's a half that they're really excited.
- 9:42They want to know more about it and they're trying to figure out where do I start?
- 9:46Yeah. So that that right there is like, OK, well, we need a roadmap to help
- 9:50these individuals know where to start, how to go through this. Yeah.
- 9:53So that's one challenge. But then the other half are, you know, I don't know about this.
- 9:59You know, we've been doing things the way we've been doing them,
- 10:01and I'm worried that we're going to sacrifice quality or something,
- 10:06right, if we don't do it the way we've always done it.
- 10:09And sure, I understand that. You should be cautious with the new technology.
- 10:14But it really is this sort of institutional hesitancy trying something different
- 10:20and trying something new. And this is somewhat human nature as well.
- 10:24Yeah, absolutely. bit more maybe in engineering because we're a risk adverse,
- 10:28adverse, adverse industry.
- 10:30But, but I do think it's just the resistance to change. I honestly think what
- 10:34I'm hearing, what people are telling me that they're facing,
- 10:37that's the biggest challenge is just resistance to change. And that's, that's,
- 10:42the tale as old as time when it comes to new technologies coming out, right?
- 10:46Getting quick adoption is always a challenge. Something as pervasive as AI and
- 10:51seeing how it's used outside of engineering and the general population,
- 10:55you know, is enough to make people pause.
- 10:58But I mean, a lot of it comes down to education and the fact that AI is not a monolith, right?
- 11:03It's a technology that can be applied uniquely to your needs as at a firm,
- 11:09which is something different than the internet, let's say, which is like a utility.
- 11:15Right, right. Yeah. You put in a query in the internet and it brings you back information.
- 11:18And you put in something in AI and it gives you information or it produces something,
- 11:23but it's not right all the time.
- 11:26And so that's why we are always going to need the human element.
- 11:30So there's a challenge there in that AI is not perfect. It's going to learn
- 11:34over time, But there's always going to be the need for humans to do that quality
- 11:40control check, at least for the foreseeable future. Yes. Right.
- 11:43Maybe another couple generations will be different. But for the emerging workforce
- 11:49coming now and for the next 20 years, it's it's really OK, let's train it to do what we need it to do.
- 11:56And that's another challenge. Yes. Because it only can use what you're telling it and feeding it.
- 12:01Yeah. And then how do we manage it and help it to grow over time?
- 12:05Like, it's in its infancy, truly. Exactly.
- 12:09And then again, it opens the door to the firm of the future.
- 12:13What is the firm of the future going to look like, right? Because someone who's
- 12:17writing an AI agent doesn't need to be a licensed engineer, right?
- 12:22Somebody who is training that agent is more of a data scientist. So kind of...
- 12:28And extrapolating off of the study and the work that the firm of the future
- 12:31is already doing, you know, how do you think AI is going to really just influence
- 12:35that changing dynamic of what an engineering firm is?
- 12:39So this is something we asked, you know, 20 different individuals.
- 12:44And what we heard the most often is that AI is going to augment the staff.
- 12:54It's going to make us more efficient. But you have to have people who can learn
- 12:59how to understand and utilize and map out AI. And what are the workflows?
- 13:05What are the new workflows? What are the new business models?
- 13:07And so you're going to have to retrain and retool the existing workforce that's
- 13:12not going to retire in the next five or 10 years.
- 13:15And the younger people are going to honestly be the ones, I think, to carry this forward.
- 13:20Just as I was, you know, 30 years ago when I was working at a political polling
- 13:25firm and they're like, hey, we're doing surveys, you know, but we're still hand
- 13:30punching things into the computer or tabulating them by hand.
- 13:34And then I was like, you've got a computer here. Let me show you how to use it.
- 13:38So I think you're going to have a lot of that. And what we also heard was.
- 13:43Some of those other challenges, but connecting with that workforce is we're
- 13:48seeing the most successful firms have engineers who are super interested in
- 13:56AI because you do need to understand engineering. Absolutely.
- 14:00That's the best case scenario. You have your engineering people who then start
- 14:04to understand AI, who can then start to program the AI and teach the AI.
- 14:10It's going to be a little slower and a little
- 14:12less perfect if you have the engineers trying
- 14:15to tell the people creating ai how to
- 14:18you know here's what we need how to you know so it's kind of interesting but
- 14:23yeah i do think that we're going to see an ai enabled workforce in the next
- 14:29five to ten and that's i think that's the biggest again with the the the is
- 14:34an ai enabled workforce done an AI replaced workforce.
- 14:37That's what we're hearing. That is, yeah. And that's what we're seeing so far even.
- 14:42Yeah. You know, there was one interviewee and he talked about,
- 14:45because he's been in a lot of different industries, but he's an engineer by training.
- 14:49And he talked about in computer coding, you would have what's called a 10X employee.
- 14:56I'd never heard this before, but he was like, yeah, it's pretty common.
- 14:59You call them a 10X because they just get it. They can sit down and they can
- 15:02crank out that code 10 times faster. They're worth 10 employees.
- 15:06And he said, AI is going to let every engineer become 10x. Yes.
- 15:13And that was when I was like, now I get it. Yeah. Yeah. It's a force multiplier for the industry.
- 15:19The study is great. I think that everybody out there should access it because it's a good primer.
- 15:25You go through the kinds of AI because there's not one kind. Yeah.
- 15:29Generative AI or what have you, you know, all the different kinds.
- 15:32And then you get into the nitty gritty about use cases and what people are seeing.
- 15:37So, Joe, we're going to be putting that out on the Research Institute website.
- 15:42And again, you don't have to be a member to access that research.
- 15:45What comes next after this? So we're already working on our next project.
- 15:50It is workforce. And I don't quite have a working title yet for it.
- 15:55But what we are trying to do is to quantify those workforce challenges that
- 16:02we're sort of anecdotally talking about.
- 16:05You know, we've got a little data here, a little data there.
- 16:07And we're finding a lot of conflicting data. So, I want to get some reliable data.
- 16:13Here's the number of students who graduated. Here's the demographic pipeline.
- 16:17You know, so start from the big funnel, go down to the small funnel,
- 16:20and really quantify what the current situation is with the current workforce.
- 16:26And on the other end, how many are going to retire in the next 10 years?
- 16:30Okay, so that's one piece. And that way we'll have the numbers that we can use to talk about.
- 16:34The second piece is going to be all about skills and expectations,
- 16:38because if you are looking to be that firm of the future, how are you going
- 16:45to attract the talent that's actually interested in working?
- 16:48OK, so we're going to understand what the young workers are looking for in firms,
- 16:54what skill sets they think they need and what skill sets they're interested in developing.
- 16:59And we're going to compare that to what the firm leaders are saying they think
- 17:03they need and are looking to see what they see how they line up. There's the gap.
- 17:07Yeah. And that gap is where we then can start to address the challenges.
- 17:11Yeah. Other challenges that are maybe preventing us from developing the workforce
- 17:15that we need. That's fantastic.
- 17:16I think every additional release of institute research is just another move
- 17:24down the line of really just informing our members and also the public about engineering.
- 17:29I mean, you started off with the economic stuff, actually sizing and scoping the size of the impact.
- 17:36Now we're going into workforce, going into technology and forming the future.
- 17:39So it is just great stuff that keeps on coming out. So, you know, keep it up.
- 17:44Keep it up. Thank you, Jeff. I have a lot of fun doing this.
- 17:47And so we thank the supporters, the donors of the ACEC Research Institute.
- 17:54We need more so we can expand the work even further and continue to do the great
- 17:58work that we're doing now.
- 18:00Well, fantastic. Joe, thanks again for being part of the program.
- 18:02Look forward to continuing to have you on to talk about the new research coming out.
- 18:07We'll have, we'll just do Q2, we'll do Q3 on the sentiment study.
- 18:11So all this stuff is going to be continuing on. So, again, this has been Engineering
- 18:17Influence, a podcast for the American Council of Engineering Companies,
- 18:20and we will see you next time.
- 18:22Music.