Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / eBay: Deep Value Fortress or the Ultimate Value Trap
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep dive. Today our mission is to really
- 0:04tackle a company that's, well, it's a huge contradiction in the
- 0:08e-commerce space. We're talking about eBay Inc,
- 0:10ticker eBay. Yeah, it's a fascinating one
- 0:13because you look at the numbers, the quantitative stuff, and it
- 0:15looks like this rock solid fortress, you know, potentially
- 0:18a massive deep value play. Exactly.
- 0:20But then you look at the the qualitative side, the actual
- 0:24business, and you see this, this sort of fundamental erosion
- 0:28happening, it's struggling. So that's the core conflict,
- 0:31right? We're looking squarely at this
- 0:32battle between, let's call it financial engineering, mainly
- 0:35these huge share buybacks and the the core health of the
- 0:39marketplace itself. Can they keep driving earnings
- 0:42with buybacks while the actual user base is shrinking?
- 0:44That's really the key question you need answered today.
- 0:46Is it a textbook value stock or is it maybe something more
- 0:50dangerous? You know, a classic value trap.
- 0:52We've dug into about a decade of metrics.
- 0:54The latest? Q 3/20/25 results and maybe most
- 0:58revealingly, the insider trading data.
- 1:00I think we give you the context you need here.
- 1:02OK. But before we dive in, we
- 1:04absolutely have to make this clear.
- 1:06All the analysis we're presenting is based on publicly
- 1:09available sources. It could be subject to
- 1:11revisions, different interpretations.
- 1:13Right. And importantly, this is purely
- 1:15for educational purposes. It is definitely not investment
- 1:18advice. Please do your own homework,
- 1:20your own due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 1:24That's crucial. And hey, if you're interested in
- 1:26tracking the overall market mood, you might want to check
- 1:29out the iOS App Buffett Indicator.
- 1:31Just search for it on the Apple App Store and download it.
- 1:34Also, if you want the the really deep version of this analysis,
- 1:38the full story, you can join our Deep Value Club membership.
- 1:41Or just subscribe to our channel Deep Value investing on Apple or
- 1:44Spotify podcasts. OK, let's get started.
- 1:49All right, let's kick off with the bull case because honestly,
- 1:52looking at the numbers, it is genuinely a jaw-dropping.
- 1:56It really is if you were just sketching out the ideal
- 1:58financial profile for a mature tech platform. eBay ticks so
- 2:03many boxes. It's durable, margins are high,
- 2:05very capital light. And the cash generation, wow,
- 2:09that's the star, wouldn't you say?
- 2:11Oh, absolutely undisputed. This business has just been a
- 2:14reliable cash machine for well over a decade now.
- 2:18We're talking consistently strong free cash flow, right?
- 2:22What are the numbers? Like, yeah, FCF averages over
- 2:25$2.1 billion a year. Consistently positive.
- 2:29Consistently strong. That's just a phenomenal amount
- 2:32of cash spinning off. Yeah, and the efficiency.
- 2:34That's impressive to the FCF margin regularly above 18%.
- 2:38It's just excellent. And even before FCF, the basic
- 2:40margins are staggering gross margin.
- 2:42Consistently over 70% Seventy. I mean, that's world class for
- 2:45almost any business. It tells you the core platform,
- 2:48once built, costs very little to maintain relative to revenue.
- 2:52Exactly. And that flows down the income
- 2:54statement. Operating profit is super
- 2:56stable, usually between say 1.7 and $2.9 billion.
- 3:00The operating margin averages over 20%, again very strong.
- 3:04So, you know, if you're running a sort of deep value checklist,
- 3:07this business just sails through gross margin over 70%, check.
- 3:11Return on invested capital. ROIC consistently above 12%?
- 3:15Check. Balance sheet solid interest
- 3:18coverage is like 7.4 times check.
- 3:21Financially, it looks like a quality compounder.
- 3:24It looks like the perfect money printer, doesn't it?
- 3:26But here's the nagging question If it's so robust, why isn't it
- 3:31funding massive organic growth? Right.
- 3:33Why is management using all this cash primarily to, well, play
- 3:38the stock market? Which brings us to the financial
- 3:40engineering engine. This is key to understanding the
- 3:43stocks performance. They funnel almost all that cash
- 3:46into one thing, share repurchases.
- 3:49An incredibly aggressive program.
- 3:51And we really need to stress how aggressive they aren't just
- 3:53trimming around the edges. This is fundamentally reshaped
- 3:56the company's share structure. Over the past decade or so,
- 3:59they've cut the diluted weighted average shares outstanding by
- 4:02nearly 58%. 58 yeah, think about that.
- 4:05It went from about 1.19 billion shares in 2015 down to just over
- 4:10half a billion .501 billion in 2024.
- 4:13It basically shrunk the ownership pie by more than half.
- 4:16And that's critical for the bull case because it mechanically
- 4:19juices the earnings per share, the EPS, right?
- 4:22Even if total profit, the net income is flat if you slash the
- 4:27number of shares that profit is divided by.
- 4:29Your EPS goes up, it creates the appearance of growth even
- 4:32without underlying business expansion, and it helps support
- 4:35the stock price. And they are sticking with it.
- 4:38The latest Q32025 update, another $625 million spent just
- 4:43on buybacks in that quarter alone.
- 4:45It's clearly the central pillar of their strategy for returning
- 4:48value to shareholders right now. OK, Now we have to pivot because
- 4:52against those, you know, beautiful financial metrics,
- 4:55there's a starkly different reality when you look at the
- 4:58actual marketplace. Yeah, this is the part that
- 5:01frankly keeps me up at night regarding eBay.
- 5:03The core problem? The active buyer count.
- 5:07It's the lifeblood of the platform and it's been eroding
- 5:09persistently. We're talking 13 consecutive
- 5:12quarters of decline from the peak back in 2018. 13 that's
- 5:15that's not just a blip, that's a clear secular trend downwards.
- 5:18And the implication is simple, but really serious if you're
- 5:20constantly losing buyers and seemingly not attracting enough
- 5:24new younger ones to replace them.
- 5:26You risk undermining the whole point of the platform, right?
- 5:30The network effect. Exactly, the network effect is
- 5:33eBay score competitive advantage.
- 5:35More buyers attract more sellers, more sellers attract
- 5:38more buyers. It's self reinforcing.
- 5:40But if the buyer side consistently shrinks, the value
- 5:44proposition for sellers weakens and the whole thing could start
- 5:47to unravel almost exponentially. The moot starts to drain, right?
- 5:51So here's the puzzle. Then Q32025 results, they
- 5:55reported $2.8 billion in revenue that was up 9% year over year.
- 6:00How can revenue be up if buyers are down?
- 6:03That's the tricky part, isn't? It it is.
- 6:05And the answer seems to be it's not coming from more people
- 6:08buying more things, it's coming from increased monetization, a
- 6:11higher take rate. So they're basically getting
- 6:14better at extracting more money from each transaction from the
- 6:17sellers and buyers who are still there, like squeezing A
- 6:20shrinking sponge harder. That's a decent analogy, and the
- 6:23key driver here isn't the core gross merchant volume or GMV,
- 6:27it's advertising revenue. Ah.
- 6:29So sellers are paying more to get their listing seen by the
- 6:32fewer buyers. Seems like it.
- 6:34Ad revenue surged 25% year over year.
- 6:36It hit $525 million just in Q3. So yes, they can monetize the
- 6:42existing ecosystem more effectively, but it doesn't fix
- 6:45the leaky bucket of users. And trying to stay relevant,
- 6:49trying to maybe attract higher value users.
- 6:51That costs money too, right? They're pushing these focus
- 6:54categories, collectibles, luxury goods.
- 6:56Yeah. And those categories did grow
- 6:57well over 15%, but supporting them, building trust there, that
- 7:02requires investment. Things like authentication
- 7:04services for sneakers or handbags that can't be cheap.
- 7:06Exactly. We call it the cost of defense
- 7:08they have to spend on AI platform trust, maybe
- 7:12subsidizing shipping, sometimes those authentication services,
- 7:16all just to stay in the game in those valuable niches.
- 7:19And you see the impact on profitability, don't.
- 7:21You, you do. Despite the revenue jump in Q3,
- 7:23the Jap operating margin actually fell.
- 7:25It went down to 20.4% from 23.1% the year before.
- 7:28So the cost of staying relevant, the cost of defense is eating
- 7:32into their margins. They're spending more just to
- 7:34kind of tread water competitively.
- 7:35And the competition is fierce. They lost the new stuff market
- 7:39to Amazon and its logistics years ago.
- 7:43Now the used stuff or non new market is getting squeezed by.
- 7:47Those low cost international players like Timu Shane.
- 7:51Precisely. They're masters of cheap
- 7:53logistics and operate very differently, so eBay is fighting
- 7:56battles on multiple fronts. OK, so we've got this picture,
- 8:01an impressive financial engine built on this foundation that
- 8:05seems to be slowly cracking roading.
- 8:09But here's maybe the most critical piece of the puzzle,
- 8:11the thing that really elevates this from just a business
- 8:14analysis to a potential value trap warning.
- 8:16It's the conflict at the executive level.
- 8:18You mean the disconnect between what the company says and what
- 8:21the insiders do? Exactly.
- 8:22It's probably the most unsettling finding from our deep
- 8:24dive because it really hits at trust and alignment.
- 8:27So the company message authorized by the board is
- 8:30basically our stock is cheap. We believe in it.
- 8:33Right. So much so we're spending
- 8:35billions of your money, shareholder money to buy back
- 8:38shares. That's the signal from the
- 8:39buybacks. OK, that's the corporate action.
- 8:42Now, what about the personal actions?
- 8:44The top executives? The CEO?
- 8:45The CFO. This is where it gets stuck.
- 8:48We looked at the insider trading data over a recent six month
- 8:52period stretching through August 2025 and the top brass CEO,
- 8:57former CFO included. How many shares did they buy?
- 9:00Zero. None.
- 9:01Not a single purchase recorded for these key insiders.
- 9:04Zero buys, OK. And how many sales?
- 9:0728 28 separate instances of selling eBay stock during that
- 9:12same period. Wow.
- 9:14OK, let that sink in for a moment.
- 9:15You listening? 0 Buys 28 sales from the people
- 9:20who know the company best. It's a profound contradiction,
- 9:23isn't it? The company screams by with
- 9:25shareholder money while the insiders whisper sell with their
- 9:28own money. What does that imply really?
- 9:30Well, it strongly suggests that management might be using that
- 9:33big buyback program, funded by the company's cash flow to prop
- 9:37up the stock price. While they systematically reduce
- 9:39their own personal holdings at that supported price.
- 9:41If they genuinely believed the stock is deeply undervalued,
- 9:45wouldn't you expect to see some insider buying, especially with
- 9:48their knowledge? Instead, they seem to be
- 9:50consistently heading for the exits.
- 9:52That lack of alignment, it's a massive red flag.
- 9:55It makes you question if the buyback is truly about intrinsic
- 9:58value or more about maybe managing EPS expectations.
- 10:02Yeah, it casts a shadow. And you know, just as a side
- 10:05note on management credibility, there was that incident in
- 10:08October 2025. The Fox Business interview.
- 10:12Right, The CEO incorrectly stated the GMV guidance on live
- 10:16TV. They had to rush out an 8K
- 10:18filing to correct almost immediately.
- 10:20Not a huge deal fundamentally maybe, but it felt like an
- 10:23unforced error. Doesn't exactly screen
- 10:25preparedness or transparency. It just adds another small
- 10:28question mark, perhaps around management's handling of
- 10:30communication. So.
- 10:32Given all this this complexity, this contradiction, trying to
- 10:36value eBay using simple traditional metrics gets really
- 10:40tricky. Doesn't it?
- 10:41Oh, absolutely. Those aggressive buybacks we
- 10:43talked about, they really mess with the standard ratios you
- 10:45might look at like. Price to book?
- 10:47Yeah. PB.
- 10:48Yeah, exactly. PB looks really high.
- 10:50Something like 7.8 times a quick glance might make you think wow
- 10:54that's way too expensive. But it looks high because of the
- 10:56buybacks, right? Explain that for.
- 10:58US right. When the company spends billions
- 11:00buying back stock, that money comes out of shareholders
- 11:04equity, which is the book value in the PB ratio.
- 11:07So the shrinks massively. Exactly.
- 11:10The buybacks hollow out the book value, so even if the stock
- 11:14price itself hasn't gone up proportionally, the ratio price
- 11:17divided by a smaller book value inflates.
- 11:20It looks artificially expensive. And price to earnings PE also
- 11:25problematic. Also tricky, net income for eBay
- 11:28has been quite volatile because of gains or losses on
- 11:31investments. They hold things that aren't
- 11:32core operations, so the E in PE jumps around too much to be a
- 11:36reliable guide. OK, so simple metrics are out,
- 11:39or at least need huge caveats. Where do we anchor the valuation
- 11:42then? We have to go back to what is
- 11:44relatively stable and reliable, that free cash flow we discussed
- 11:48earlier. So a discounted cash flow ADCF
- 11:50model? Exactly.
- 11:51We ran ADCF, but crucially, we based it on the stable
- 11:55historical FCF generation, not on, you know, speculative hopes
- 11:59of a big turn around. What kind of growth did you
- 12:01assume? Just a very modest 2.0% annual
- 12:04growth in FCF going forward. Basically just keeping pace with
- 12:08long term inflation. Nominal case, nothing heroic.
- 12:11OK. Makes sense.
- 12:12So based on that historical cash flow profile and minimal growth,
- 12:17what did the DCF spit out as an intrinsic value?
- 12:19The calculation came out to $62.91 per share. 6291 and where
- 12:25was the stock actually trading around say November 2025 when we
- 12:29looked? It was trading around $81.00
- 12:31euro one cents. $81.00, so quite a bit higher than the value
- 12:34suggested by its historical cash flows with just nominal growth.
- 12:38Significantly higher. And that for us ties the story
- 12:41together. The current market price seems
- 12:43to be baking in expectations of a significant growth recovery or
- 12:47some kind of turn around. Of a recovery that just isn't
- 12:49supported by the actual data, like that persistent decline in
- 12:52active buyers we keep talking about.
- 12:53Right, so the valuation analysis really seems to corroborate that
- 12:58value trap thesis. The price seems to be reflecting
- 13:01hope more than the established reality of its cash generation
- 13:05potential, assuming things just continue as they are.
- 13:08Hashtag tag Tag outro. So wrapping this all up, what's
- 13:12the final take away for you investing in eBay today?
- 13:16Well, it's not a straightforward decision.
- 13:18It's really a complex bet. Yeah, you're essentially betting
- 13:21that the financial engineering, these continued massive share
- 13:24buybacks can keep propping up the stock price and the EPS.
- 13:28Long enough or effectively enough to mask that underlying
- 13:32fundamental erosion we see in the shrinking user base of the
- 13:35core marketplace. And you have.
- 13:37To weigh that undeniably durable high margin capital light
- 13:40business structure against what looks like a pretty profound
- 13:43lack of alignment. That disconnect between the
- 13:45company buying shares hand over fist and the insiders
- 13:48consistently selling their personal shares.
- 13:50It's a critical point to consider.
- 13:51OK. Let's leave you with a final
- 13:53thought to chew on, something to Mull over as you do your own
- 13:56research. Think about this, if ebay's main
- 13:58competitive advantage, it's Moat, truly rests on that
- 14:02network effect and the unique data that comes from it.
- 14:04Right. The value of having all those
- 14:06buyers and sellers interacting. And we know the active buyer
- 14:09count is consistently shrinking. At what point does the value of
- 14:13that network, the value of that proprietary data, start to decay
- 14:17exponentially, regardless of how many billions they spend buying
- 14:22back stock? When does the core asset itself
- 14:25begin to seriously degrade? That's a heavy question,
- 14:29something to definitely consider.
- 14:30OK, one last time. Remember all this content was
- 14:33based on public sources. It's purely for educational
- 14:35purposes. Definitely not investment
- 14:37advice. Please, please do your own due
- 14:39diligence before making any decisions.
- 14:40And if you found this deep dive valuable, consider joining our
- 14:43Deep Value Club membership for more.
- 14:45Or subscribe to the channel Deep Value Investing.
- 14:47You can find us on Apple Podcast, Podcasts and Spotify.
- 14:50Thanks for tuning in.