Latest / The Vegan Report / The Halal Argument for Veganism | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, this is Sueda and Gülbike, the co -founders
- 0:03of Animetrix for The Vegan Report. So today we
- 0:07are introducing Animetrix to you and we will
- 0:09be talking about why culturally grounded and
- 0:12evidence -based advocacy matters and we will
- 0:15also be sharing the key insights about our brand
- 0:18new study which is on Muslim consumers and how
- 0:22they view animal welfare in halal food production.
- 0:26Please connect with us. on our email and social
- 0:30links, which are available in the episode notes.
- 0:33And you can find new episodes every Wednesday
- 0:35on this podcast. Please share this episode with
- 0:38your community as well. And yeah, I would like
- 0:41to start by saying that it is such a pleasure
- 0:43to be here. Thank you so much for the intro,
- 0:46Sueda. So yeah, I'm Gürbike. We are super excited
- 0:50to share a bit about who we are and some of our
- 0:52recent research. Just to start, so my background
- 0:57is in economics. I did my PhD about how behaviors
- 1:00separate between people, like how social influence
- 1:03works, and economics of crime. I also work part
- 1:07-time as an assessor for software projects, and
- 1:10I also give lectures on animal rights, welfare,
- 1:13and environmental issues. I do this with Middle
- 1:17East Vegan Society and... In two and a half years
- 1:21I have given more than 25 workshops across many
- 1:24countries like Egypt, Turkey, Rwanda, Uganda,
- 1:29Mozambique, Sri Lanka, Philippines and El Salvador.
- 1:33And as for me... I'm a behavioural and experimental
- 1:36economist and currently I am a post -doctoral
- 1:39researcher at the Berlin Social Science Centre
- 1:42where my work is focusing on finding tools to
- 1:46promote pro -social behaviour across the society,
- 1:50behaviour such as volunteering, donating, sustainable
- 1:53actions, pro -environmental actions and so on.
- 1:57And my previous work has been about studying
- 1:59discrimination and biases and how they basically
- 2:02shape people's decision making. And through Animatrix,
- 2:06I am connecting these perspectives with animal
- 2:10advocacy. Yeah, so Animatrix was born two years
- 2:14ago. The idea actually started when we were housemates
- 2:17in Netherlands during our PhD years. It was out
- 2:21of long conversations about how we could contribute
- 2:23to the movements in a more meaningful way. But
- 2:27for that, we were like keeping asking to each
- 2:30other and circling back to one question. So how
- 2:33can we use our skills as economists and academics
- 2:36to make the advocacy more effective? Yeah, exactly.
- 2:40So we were looking at the animal advocacy movement
- 2:44with our, you know, researcher glasses on, and
- 2:47we noticed that something was missing. So first
- 2:49of all, we know and appreciate that there's a
- 2:53lot of great research out there. But much of
- 2:56this is coming from or focusing on the global
- 2:59north, even though 85 % of farmed animals live
- 3:03in the global south or global majority. So that's
- 3:06billions of lives. And the second thing we realize
- 3:09is that in animal advocacy, there are almost
- 3:13no people with advanced training in economics.
- 3:17And this is super important. Because the animal
- 3:21advocacy movement, it relies on understanding
- 3:23the behavior of people or the industry and the
- 3:26demand and the supply and how they operate and
- 3:28so on. And to be able to make things better for
- 3:34the animals, what we need essentially is behavior
- 3:36change. And economics is the study of exactly
- 3:39that. So we look into how people make decisions,
- 3:42how organizations make decisions, and what sorts
- 3:45of interventions, programs can effectively change
- 3:50those decisions. Yeah, right. So there's, apart
- 3:55from that, another gap that we saw. So even though
- 3:58these good research exists, it doesn't always
- 4:01reach the advocates. Or it doesn't directly answer
- 4:06the most pressing questions. So yeah, even when
- 4:09the data exists, it should be in a format that's
- 4:13more usable for the advocates. So we want to
- 4:16fill this gap. So we created Animetrix out of
- 4:19this and to work in three areas. So, well, first
- 4:24of all, it should be obvious by now we conduct
- 4:26research, right? We use economics and behavioral
- 4:29science to answer the most pressing, moment relevant
- 4:34questions. And yeah, so we look at how, you know,
- 4:39how to shift food choices or how to design effective
- 4:42campaigns and so on. And second, we provide implementation
- 4:47support. So what does that mean? This means that
- 4:49we not only publish our findings and tell the
- 4:53advocates in the movement, say, here's our findings,
- 4:55do what you've got to do with them, but we try
- 4:58to turn them, as Gerbike said, into useful formats,
- 5:01like toolkits, visuals, like short little summaries,
- 5:04so that advocates can actually put them into
- 5:07practice. And this is one of the things that
- 5:11makes us quite unique. So we co -design projects
- 5:14with the advocates from the start. So it's not
- 5:17just our academic curiosity or our own little
- 5:20perspective, but we go to the advocates working
- 5:22in the fields and ask them what they need, what
- 5:25is the most pressing need right at that moment.
- 5:27And we focus on that particular question and
- 5:31produce our studies based on these insights.
- 5:36Yeah, and apart from this, our third program
- 5:39is that we do capacity building. So what does
- 5:42it look like? We train advocates in research
- 5:46design, survey methods, impact evaluation and
- 5:49so on in the things that they need help. So our
- 5:53aim is that with this capacity, they can run
- 5:57their own studies or they can use evidence more
- 6:00strategically. So since we launched, we have
- 6:02supported over dozens of organizations internationally,
- 6:07from Uganda to Philippines to Kenya, and we have
- 6:10delivered more than 300 free trainings. And in
- 6:16our work, we mostly focus on the global majority
- 6:20or the global south and also the Muslim majority
- 6:24regions. So these areas are critical for animals,
- 6:28but research in these areas and also advocacy
- 6:30in general in these areas are deeply underfunded.
- 6:34And of course, we're doing this and we are telling
- 6:37that as Animatrix, this is our current focus.
- 6:40And we often get this question like, okay, but
- 6:42why do you focus on Muslim communities in particular
- 6:47and what is peculiar about it? Yeah, that's a
- 6:51really good question. And that is partly related
- 6:53to our personal background because we both come
- 6:56from Turkey, from Muslim backgrounds. And we
- 6:59have long been aware of how questions of food,
- 7:02faith, or ethics are like integrated in our communities.
- 7:08But when we look at the broader advocacy and
- 7:11my advocacy space, we noticed that Muslim perspectives
- 7:14were almost entirely absence. And of course this
- 7:19gap matters because Muslim consumers make up
- 7:23nearly a quarter of world's population. We're
- 7:26talking about around two billion people here.
- 7:29And halal food systems, they shape a massive
- 7:32share of the global meat and dairy production.
- 7:36So halal consumption is also growing faster than
- 7:41almost any other part of the global food system.
- 7:44So all of this means that if you want to make
- 7:47real global progress for animals, we cannot ignore
- 7:51these particular segments and their specific
- 7:54behaviors and perspectives and so on. Yeah, exactly.
- 8:01So the halal market is really important and it's
- 8:04projected to keep expanding across Asia, Africa
- 8:07and even Europe. But the conversations about
- 8:11animal welfare within the system is just beginning.
- 8:15And apart from this, most of the animal advocacy
- 8:18research and messaging is designed for Western
- 8:20audiences. So it doesn't always fit local realities
- 8:24or religious frameworks. So we saw a huge challenge
- 8:28and a huge opportunity, we could say, in terms
- 8:31of supporting more faith -sensitive and culturally
- 8:34grounded advocacy. And from this, one example
- 8:39that really shows our approach is our new study
- 8:42we run in Turkey on perspectives on halal food
- 8:45production and animal welfare. So the idea for
- 8:48this project came from a very personal place
- 8:50again, because we grew up in Muslim communities
- 8:54and we often heard people say things like, okay,
- 8:58I eat halal and halal food means that animals
- 9:01were treated well. But that belief, I mean the
- 9:05gap between perception and practice, made us
- 9:09a bit curious to understand more deeply how people
- 9:13think about ethics and what is the relation of
- 9:17animal welfare to halal. Yeah, we basically think
- 9:22that there's a very strong and comforting belief
- 9:25that halal automatically guarantees animal welfare,
- 9:29right, in these halal food production facilities.
- 9:32But in practice, when we started looking into
- 9:34it, we realized that halal certification focuses
- 9:37primarily on the slaughter. methods and processing
- 9:42rules, and it's not necessarily about how animals
- 9:46are raised or treated throughout their life.
- 9:51Yeah, and we weren't the only ones noticing this.
- 9:54Advocates working in Muslim majority regions
- 9:56often told us like, yeah, we wish we had data
- 10:00to back up conversations about this misconception
- 10:02as well. Yeah, exactly. So we said, okay, you
- 10:07know, we have this little instinct and advocates
- 10:10agree with this. So let's go and start designing
- 10:15a study and test this systematically to really
- 10:18understand if there is this gap, how big is this
- 10:20gap, and so on. So we conducted a survey that
- 10:25included around 800 Muslim adults in Turkey,
- 10:29which is a country where halal food is the default
- 10:32for food production. And we were basically after
- 10:36answering two main questions. So question number
- 10:39one is, how much do consumers know about whether
- 10:43certain common and harmful industrial farming
- 10:48practices are allowed under allowed food production?
- 10:52Do they know whether or not they're permitted
- 10:54or not? What's their take? And then we also wanted
- 10:59to understand In case they don't know, if you
- 11:01tell them the truth, the correct information,
- 11:04would this affect their willingness to buy these
- 11:06products or consider switching to plant -based
- 11:10alternatives? Yes, so we wanted to understand
- 11:14how consumer knowledge on the some common industrial
- 11:18farming practices, which is currently allowed
- 11:20in halal food production. So we selected six
- 11:24practices, which are the most one of the most
- 11:27used ones. So these include tickling, like killing
- 11:31of male chicks, the beaking of chicken, separating
- 11:36cow and calf, lack of long -term care for injured
- 11:40animals or inadequate space for chickens to move
- 11:44naturally. And for each practice we basically
- 11:50gave the participants a definition of the practice
- 11:53and then we asked them Yeah, this practice is
- 11:57allowed in halal food production, true or false.
- 12:00You know, we ask them true false questions. And
- 12:03then if someone answered the question incorrectly,
- 12:06so basically they're all permitted, right? So
- 12:09we wanted to understand if they know this or
- 12:10not. And then if someone said like, oh, I don't
- 12:13know, or they say that, oh, this is not legal
- 12:16in halal food production, we tell them, hey,
- 12:18you know, this is actually legal in halal production.
- 12:22And then we asked them, you know, knowing this
- 12:24information, would this affect your willingness
- 12:26to buy products who involved this specific practice?
- 12:31And yeah, would this affect your intention to
- 12:36switch to plant -based options, basically? And
- 12:40what we saw, the results were really shocking
- 12:43because all of the six practices we tested, more
- 12:48than half of the participants either didn't know
- 12:50whether those practices were permitted under
- 12:53these halal rules or they incorrect the belief
- 12:56they were forbidden I mean even though in reality
- 12:59they are permitted in the halal systems so in
- 13:03every case at least one in four people held incorrect
- 13:06beliefs about what halal production actually
- 13:09allows yeah so like to give a little bit more
- 13:15um yeah insight with numbers in it so nearly
- 13:19half of the respondents, about 47%, believe that
- 13:23in halal facilities, halal certified facilities,
- 13:27it is legally required to provide long -term
- 13:30or medical treatment to animals who are injured
- 13:33or who are no longer, quote -unquote, productive.
- 13:37And this is simply not true, right? There is
- 13:40no such legal requirement currently in Turkey's
- 13:43halal food production system. And similarly,
- 13:47almost the same share, so again, around half
- 13:50of the respondents thought that Halal standards
- 13:53guarantee enough space for chicken to express
- 13:56their natural behaviors, right? You know, like
- 13:59opening their wings, for example. And this is
- 14:02a huge misconception. Yeah, and what participants
- 14:07were presented with accurate information, their
- 14:11reactions were really important for us because
- 14:14Many said that they would be less likely to buy
- 14:17products from these systems using these practices
- 14:20and a significant number said that they would
- 14:22consider plant -based alternatives instead. So
- 14:28what's especially interesting is that these reactions
- 14:31weren't also uniform. So not everybody reacted
- 14:33in the same way, right? There were certain groups
- 14:36of people. For example, women were way more responsive.
- 14:40Interestingly, older adults were also more responsive
- 14:43to information in terms of like changing their
- 14:45behavior and being more pro -animal, making more
- 14:49pro -animal welfare choices, let's say. And also
- 14:53the people who said that animal welfare is a
- 14:55central part of halal, like as part of the belief,
- 15:00they were also more responsive to new information.
- 15:04So we also found that the type of the knowledge
- 15:07gap method, so we basically compared people who
- 15:11didn't know but who are not a certain practice
- 15:13was not allowed to people who had incorrect beliefs,
- 15:16so the people who thought that they were forbidden.
- 15:18And the participants who taught a practice was
- 15:21forbidden when it wasn't showed a stronger reaction
- 15:25in response. So it seems that for these groups,
- 15:30learning the truth actually created a sort of
- 15:34moral tension. Yeah, exactly. So another thing
- 15:40what we found fascinating is that Around 70 %
- 15:45of our participants said that animal welfare
- 15:47is essential to what halal means to them. So
- 15:50that tells us that for many Muslims, halal isn't
- 15:54just about technical compliance, but it's broader
- 15:57than that. It's not only about the technical
- 16:00side of it. It's a moral framework, so about
- 16:03compassion, stewardship, and avoiding unnecessary
- 16:07harm. Yeah, so basically when we show up the
- 16:12participants that some practices are technically
- 16:14allowed You know they not always aligned with
- 16:18with the halal values in terms of like the faith
- 16:21and and the guidelines and What we think is that
- 16:25so this is our interpretation of the findings
- 16:28is that the participants actually experienced?
- 16:31What psychologists call the cognitive dissonance
- 16:33right that uncomfortable feeling when your values
- 16:36and the facts do not match one another And that
- 16:40discomfort can actually be a bridge for change,
- 16:43right? So sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't,
- 16:46but it is definitely worth exploring in this
- 16:49particular case. Especially when the participants
- 16:52said that their intentions would change in reaction
- 16:55to corrected information. So what does this mean
- 17:00for advocacy? One takeaway is that value -based
- 17:04framing matters. because it suggests that if
- 17:08we want to promote plant -forward diet in Muslim
- 17:11communities, it might not be enough only talking
- 17:14about climate or health, because we also have
- 17:19to connect to religious and ethical values that
- 17:22already motivate people. And of course, this
- 17:25is not just about Turkey, although we conducted
- 17:29this study there. We believe that similar dynamics
- 17:32likely to exist in in other Muslim majority regions
- 17:37and within diaspora communities. So this is why
- 17:40we are currently expanding our work to study
- 17:43how beliefs and Islamic faith and faith -based
- 17:48perspectives shape behaviour within Muslim communities
- 17:53across various regions. Yeah, definitely. So
- 17:57it's our long -term vision. We want to help build
- 18:00the evidence base for advocates, certifiers,
- 18:04and policymakers. Yeah, we basically believe
- 18:07that advocacy becomes much more effective when
- 18:10it's... builds on what people are already caring
- 18:13about. So understanding the cultural and moral
- 18:16dimension, we believe that it's not just something
- 18:19extra, you know, we bring to the table, but it
- 18:21is actually central to designing effective strategies
- 18:25that connect with people and create shifts in
- 18:29the behavior. I mean, yeah, definitely. And evidence
- 18:33can guide us. But more importantly, local evidence
- 18:38is our superpower. I mean, because, for example,
- 18:42what works in the US or Europe might backfire
- 18:45in the Middle East or Africa or Asia. So important
- 18:49strategies often miss the mark. And it's very
- 18:53important to create it together with the advocates
- 18:56who are locally relevant, like present there,
- 19:00to have more impact in the region. I mean we
- 19:04all have the same goals but we live in different
- 19:06worlds. That's why we have to try keep one foot
- 19:11in each world with more like a better research
- 19:15but also culturally grounded activism. And a
- 19:19big part of our mission is also to make sure
- 19:22that our findings, our reports, they just like
- 19:25don't... collect dust on shelves, but they actually
- 19:28reach the people who can act on them, who can
- 19:31change their strategies, their campaigns based
- 19:33on this. And this is what our implementation
- 19:36support is about. So we basically help advocates
- 19:39translate research into strategies through workshops
- 19:45that are specifically designed for them or through
- 19:49outputs like infographics and so on that we specifically
- 19:53create for them to understand and interpret the
- 19:57findings and use them in their daily work. Yeah,
- 20:03so if you would like to learn more about our
- 20:05work or read our Halal Welfare Study or if you're
- 20:09an advocate and think that this work can benefit
- 20:13your work in wherever you are Please visit us
- 20:17at animatrix .org. We are always open to collaborations,
- 20:21questions or just any conversations about evidence
- 20:24and activism. And thank you so much for listening
- 20:28and thank you to everyone out there who is trying
- 20:33to make this world a better place for all non
- 20:38-humans, more than humans. Hopefully we can make
- 20:44sure that every insight, every campaign and every
- 20:47action brings us closer to a world with less
- 20:51suffering for all beings.