Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Accelerated Christian Education Exposed (with Jenna Scaramanga)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. I was in
- 0:57third grade at Carl Sandberg Elementary School. It's a public school, and I
- 1:03remember going home and telling my mother about all the wonderful things I had learned
- 1:08in home room about Neanderthal Man. Now, remember I came out of an
- 1:14evangelical Bible literalist environment, and you know what's not in the Bible is Neanderthal
- 1:23Man. Well, my mother was horrified, and she determined right then that
- 1:27all of her children, all three of us still in the house, had
- 1:32to be plucked out of this satanic secular environment and placed in religious education.
- 1:38First top fourth grade was Temple Christian school, tiny little school with just a
- 1:44handful. I think we had a few dozen students, and it employed the
- 1:49ACE program, the Accelerated Christian Education Program, which is very, very very
- 1:57culty and it continues to influence today. Well, I followed the work of
- 2:01someone who has done years of investigative reporting on ACE, really exposing the damage
- 2:08done. I actually joined a Facebook page called Accelerated Christian Education Exposed, and
- 2:15I wanted to speak to someone heavily involved in that whole endeavor in exposing ACEE
- 2:21Jennie Scaramanga. Thank you so much for coming, Thanks for having me.
- 2:24It's good to be here. Did you found that page? Are you the
- 2:28one who started the Facebook page? I am yeah. I started that when
- 2:31I was blogging really heavily about ACE. I guess like coming up with ten
- 2:36years ago. Now, can you tell me about where the genesis of your
- 2:39interest in ACE came from? Were you indoctrinated? I absolutely was. I
- 2:45think indoctrination is entirely the right word to use. I went to kindergarten in
- 2:50an Accelerated Christian Education school. You don't call it kindergarten in the UK,
- 2:53but that's what the program is. And then I went to a normal primary
- 2:59school. Over the next kind of six years, I had a pretty standard
- 3:02education for this country. And then when I was eleven, my parents took
- 3:07the decision to put me back into this hyper evangelical environment and I was there
- 3:13for like another until I was fifteen, until I was just turning fifteen,
- 3:15so it was only a bit over three years that I was there as like
- 3:20a secondary school age kid. But it had a big, big impact on
- 3:23my life. And when I started to train to teach myself, I was
- 3:28training to teach music. Everything I learned about what good education is was just
- 3:31the opposite of what had happened to me in that school. And I couldn't
- 3:35stop thinking about that. And I wrote a letter to a government agency about
- 3:39their endorsement of this curriculum, and I copied that letter to the Times Education
- 3:45Supplement, which is a newspaper for teachers in the UK, and I said,
- 3:49this curriculum taught me that the lockness monster exists, and that that is
- 3:53a reason to disbelieve evolution. I don't think that anybody should be endorsing this
- 3:58curriculum for any purpose, accept possibly as an exemplar of what not to do.
- 4:02And then yeah, that interest in really phase. So in twenty thirteen
- 4:06I started a PhD on the experiences of students that have been to Accelerated Christian
- 4:12Education schools in England and that I finished in twenty seventeen, and during that
- 4:17time I was doing a lot of activism type work as well. So it's
- 4:21been investigative as well because I've spoken to lots of other people about their experiences,
- 4:25but it was primarily a personal interest. It's interesting it shows my ignorance
- 4:30because I thought this was primarily an American phenomena. But they are in countries
- 4:34all over the world. Yeah, they claim to be in one hundred and
- 4:38forty something countries. It's exported itself extremely well because, like a lot of
- 4:44cults, AC had its charismatic leader, a guy called Donald Howard who enthusiastically
- 4:49went to countries and campaigned extensively for his curriculum to be taken up. Which
- 4:55other fundamentalist home school and curricula like a Becker Book and BJU Press that some
- 5:00of your listeners who are homeschooled will be familiar with that are doctrinally really similar
- 5:05to AC, but they don't have really much of a presence outside of North
- 5:09America as far as I'm ware, whereas ACE has aggressively marketed itself in other
- 5:14countries. And the thing that ACE has going for it from that point of
- 5:18view is that it is designed to be teacherss. The curriculum is a series
- 5:26of self instructional work books, and the children are meant to work through them
- 5:30individually and in silence in cubicles with vertical screens separating them from other kids if
- 5:34they're in a school or otherwise just at home. And all of the information
- 5:40that you need is contained within texts within the workbooks, and then you do
- 5:43fill in the blank exercises almost exclusively in every subject, and then you go
- 5:48and mark your own work from a score key check if you've got the answers
- 5:53right, and you repeat that process until all the answers are right. And
- 5:56that is the entire system. The idea is that it's supplemented with some other
- 5:59things, but the curriculum itself, that's it. That's the whole thing.
- 6:03So you don't need qualified teachers for that, and you can have kids of
- 6:06all ages and different academic levels studying together in the same room. Like AC's
- 6:13whole thing was that you've for just a couple of thousand dollars. You can
- 6:15start a school even if you have no experience, even if you don't know
- 6:18anything about education, and that has allowed AC to spread into dozens and dozens
- 6:24of countries. I remember our monitor, I don't know if we called her
- 6:28a teacher, was the principal's wife, and she did not have a college
- 6:31education. She had no educational background whatsoever. She just sort of walked around,
- 6:35she kind of trolled. You mentioned the partitions. Let me describe that
- 6:40for everybody. Ours were wooden and they had a tiny little hole on the
- 6:44top where you would place an American flag. So if I'm in my pace
- 6:48workbook and there's something that has vexed me, I take my flag and I
- 6:54stick it up in the little hole and it's up hanging above my partition,
- 6:59and that would cause the monitor to show up and quote unquote answer my question.
- 7:04Was that an experience that you can relate to? Yeah, that is
- 7:09that's universal. This is one of the things you'll find this with being in
- 7:13ACE Exposed, the Facebook group, is that regardless of where in the world
- 7:17you were schooled and when where we have people that did this in the seventies
- 7:21and we have people that have finished within the last five years, and everybody
- 7:27has the same experience because ACE schools sign a contract with ACE to run their
- 7:32school according to these procedures as laid down by ACE. So the guy that
- 7:39founded it bragged about having designed this learning center as he called it, and
- 7:43it replicating itself around the world, and that's absolutely true. As a campaigner,
- 7:46that's been frustrating trying to expose this because ACE contractually doesn't allow these schools
- 7:51to use the words Accelerated Christian Education in the name of the schools. They're
- 7:57not allowed to call themselves Accelerated Christian Educations. They're only allowed to say they
- 8:01are schools that use the Accelerated Education curriculum. So when something horrific happens at
- 8:07an Accelerated Christian Education school like conversion therapy or a child being beaten to death,
- 8:13which happened a few years ago in New York State, or sexual assault,
- 8:16the news reports won't mention Accelerated Christian Education, usually because because why would
- 8:22they like, As far as the news reporters know, this is just the
- 8:24textbook publisher that the school uses, and you wouldn't if you're writing a new
- 8:26story about a normal school. Bother to say which textbook publisher the school used,
- 8:31But there's much more than a textbook publisher. They really are. It's
- 8:35a regime. It sounds very much like IBLP right the Institute for Basic Life
- 8:39Principles, where a good parent has to beat the kid, and if you
- 8:43don't beat the child, then you are, I don't know, you're setting
- 8:46the child up for failure. It's a loving act. You say there was
- 8:50a child beaten to death. I can't let that go. Give me some
- 8:54specifics about that case. Yeah, absolutely so. I talked about this in
- 8:58my PhD thesis. I mean only based on news reports. I didn't do
- 9:01any firsthand research on this. It didn't happen in the school. It happened
- 9:07in the church. But the point of ACU schools is that the church and
- 9:09the school, that the line between them is blurry or almost non existent.
- 9:13Really, they call them like church schools with a hyphen. And the idea
- 9:16is that the kid is in one completely consistent environment all the time, so
- 9:24that the same ideology as always being reinforced everywhere. They never are subject to
- 9:28any ideas that would kind of challenge their beliefs or contradict this belief system.
- 9:33And so yeah, there was a church school setup that used accelerated Christian education
- 9:39in its schooling, but it was on a Sunday that the beating took place,
- 9:41as I understand it. Yeah, I might need to look this up
- 9:46and fact check myself, because I don't want to give any incorrect information,
- 9:48but I know that there were electrical cords were used. There was a group
- 9:52of adults. There were two brothers involved. One of them died, one
- 9:56of them was hospitalized with injuries, and at the time of the reports was
- 10:00expected to recover. And I never sweaty follow up reporting after that. And
- 10:05yeah, it was just USTERI a tragedy. And the schooling system has always
- 10:09endorsed corporal punishment, but obviously it's always claimed to have a line between abuse
- 10:15and godly discipline, and in this case that line was completely obliterated. And
- 10:22it's a fact that the research shows that in the home, particularly use of
- 10:26mild corporal punishment is a predictor of use of more extreme corporal punishment in the
- 10:31future. Because the gentler in inverted commas, the gentler corporal punishment stops working,
- 10:37kids stop being afraid of it, it stops being a deterrent and it's
- 10:41just not a very effective system of discipline, and so it can spin out
- 10:43of control like this. Yeah, it's just an extremely tragic case. I
- 10:48want to get into some of the specific and very tragic. I don't know,
- 10:54I was going to say lessons or you know, whatever they're selling is
- 10:58fact. The stuff they're teaching two children as fact. I want to get
- 11:01into that. You are familiar with the origins of ace doctor Donald Howard and
- 11:07his wife. I mean, can you give us a premer on that?
- 11:09Just in a nutshell, where did this come from? So like pretty much
- 11:13all of the major fundamentalist home school in curricula, it has roots of Bob
- 11:18Jones University, which is like the bastion of Christian fundamentalism really in the world,
- 11:28and it was mostly notable to mainstream observers for the Supreme Court case in
- 11:35the nineteen seventies where they sued because they refused to integrate after it became illegal
- 11:41to segregate by race in universities and they lost. The upshot of that Supreme
- 11:48Court case was that they lost their tax exemption, but they chose to keep
- 11:52on segregating. In the nineteen sixties, Bob Jones Senior, the founder of
- 11:54the university, said that the civil rights movement was not of God, it
- 11:58was of the So this is the home of Christian white nationalism, and that's
- 12:05what ACE grew out of. Donald Howard got his doctorate from there. I
- 12:09have never seen his doctoral thesis. Actually, that's a thing I'd be amused
- 12:13to read. In nineteen seventy he founded a school which he just had this
- 12:18idea for self and instructural curriculum, and initially he photocopied some mainstream textbooks,
- 12:24like a chapter at a time, and created exercises and that was the first
- 12:30kind of the beta testing phase. Second edition, by his own account,
- 12:33was riddled with errors. And then by the late seventies they were introducing the
- 12:39third edition of those pages, which was the addition that like most people that
- 12:43have been through ACE that are listening to this will have done, because they
- 12:46started introducing them in the late seventies, and they started replacing them in like
- 12:52the two thousands. Like, it was a long long time that that audition
- 12:54was in force for and the fourth edition that's out now is materially pretty much
- 12:58unchained. I published an academic paper about this earlier this year where we compared
- 13:03a load of them, and yeah, there's very strong similarities, especially in
- 13:07the lower grades. There were like entire pages that were not a single word
- 13:11had been changed from the previous edition. So yeah, that's the roots of
- 13:16it, like white nationalism and a weird belief in individualized education, which kind
- 13:22of goes with like a real belief in American individualism in general. I have
- 13:26this book that he wrote here. I thought you'd be interested to see this.
- 13:28I'll take a photo of this as well so you can put it on
- 13:31your website. But this is a diagram from inside his first book. It
- 13:35says Christian Americanism, and then there's two stylized stone tablets that clearly represent the
- 13:41Ten Commandments, and that says source, means and end around them, which
- 13:46isn't really explained, and then below that says law, freedom and limited government.
- 13:52So that's what Donald Howard believed. He was like a free market fundamentalist
- 13:56as well as a Christian fundamentalist. Really believed that the principles that we now
- 14:01know as kind of the right wing economics of the Republican Party were as much
- 14:07Christian values as any other belief that he held. And he thought that an
- 14:11education system needed to inculcate this. Absolutely. This was Acrosse the nineteen seventies.
- 14:16It was the height of the Red Scare as well, and so anti
- 14:20communism was just through all of those workbooks. There was a real paranoia about
- 14:26the USSR and about the threat of communism in the United States, and this
- 14:31was a curriculum that was designed to stamp that out. We would be taught
- 14:35that free enterprise and low taxation were God's will, and that the more that
- 14:39you move away from that, the more anti God you were leading right into
- 14:45sort of the greedy eighties, you know, the las a fair capitalism and
- 14:48the rugged individualist sort of. I don't know the propaganda of the Reagan era.
- 14:54Find that interesting. Back to racism. I had cut and pasted this
- 15:00which was part of an ACE workbook, and it was talking about Nelson Mandela.
- 15:05You can correct me or speak to this. It said, although apartheid
- 15:09appears to allow the unfair treatment of blacks, the system has worked well in
- 15:13South Africa. Although white businessmen and developers are guilty of some unfair treatment of
- 15:20blacks, they turned South Africa into a modern, industrialized nation which the poor,
- 15:26uneducated blacks couldn't have accomplished in several more decades. If more blacks were
- 15:31suddenly given control of the nation its economy in business, as Mandela wished,
- 15:37they could have destroyed what they had waited and worked so hard for. Does
- 15:41that ring true for you, Jenna, Yeah, absolutely So that quote there,
- 15:45I think is from a nineteen ninety three New York Times article where a
- 15:48black student in an AC school had actually brought this to the attention of the
- 15:52media. I have never seen that workbook firsthand, but I did another one
- 15:58that was very, very similar in nineteen ninety seven, Like the wording was
- 16:03almost the same, and there was another one besides that, so that AC
- 16:07have published at least three that I know about work. I mean, we're
- 16:10hearing this in Florida in the USA, if you'll forgive the interjection, they're
- 16:14saying, well, you know, slavery wasn't optimal, But I mean,
- 16:18think of the people who benefited in the life skills they learned under their masters.
- 16:22That rings familiar right absolutely, And I mean in fundamentalist education more widely,
- 16:29like famously, there's an a Backer book textbook which says that the trail
- 16:33of tears allowed many Native America people to get to know Jesus. So that's
- 16:37all good then, And yeah, very much like Ace's system is pro colonialism
- 16:44and pro imperialism, and they teach you absolutely explicitly that the reason the British
- 16:48Empire got so big was because Britain was a Christian country and God was on
- 16:52their side. And the reason for like international US military supremacy as well is
- 16:57because God is on that side. And when you do their geography course,
- 17:03it correlates, and they're quite open about this, it correlates the prosperity of
- 17:07nations with how Christian those nations are or is you have to be quite selective
- 17:11with the facts for that you kind of gloss over Saudi Arabia and Ethiopia.
- 17:14But that is the position that if you are good, God will bless you.
- 17:18And also they work from the off because the Christian day school private day
- 17:23school movement really exploded after schools were integrated in the US, Like there's a
- 17:29very very clear historical correlation that one of the major drivers was white flight.
- 17:33When black kids started going to the local schools, the white parents started taking
- 17:37their kids out of them, and the people that were promoting these curriculums knew
- 17:41of this reputation and they were aware that it was like bad publicity for them,
- 17:45so they were trying to deny it. And the denials that appear in
- 17:49So I've got two books here of this one is by Donald Howard, who
- 17:52started the curriculum, and this one is why his vice president of AC Ronald
- 17:56Johnson, and they both contained denials of like the claim that AC is racist.
- 18:00And Donald Howard says, some ACU schools are segregated and some of them
- 18:04are integrated and that's all good. Like he's really like it's a choice for
- 18:08the schools whether to integrate or not, like a kind of a state's rights
- 18:11argument for schools is the way I think of that. And then Ronald Johnson's
- 18:15is just wild because he has an entire chapter which is called Christian Education is
- 18:19for whites only? Or is it? And then the whole chapter is just
- 18:23slavery apologism. It's like it has nothing to it's a non sequitur, Like
- 18:27the question is is Christian education for whites only? And his response is slavery
- 18:33wasn't so bad, and he's like it starts going on about you know,
- 18:37East African Muslims have been enslaving black natives for hundreds of years before Columbus discovered
- 18:41America. It was not unusual for whites, browns, and yellows. Excellent
- 18:45language to use there if you want to prove to people you're not racist.
- 18:48Not unusual for whites, browns, and yellows to be sold to pay debts
- 18:51or to settle political disputes. Like His argument is that without Jesus' slavery is
- 18:57just one of those things that happens because humanity is inherently corrupt. But there
- 19:02was nothing especially bad about slavery in the United States or about European colonialism.
- 19:11Okay, still to come. We got to talk about the dress code for
- 19:15ACE schools and what their quote unquote science curriculum has to say about dun dunt
- 19:22dan evolution. We'll talk about it next. I've got doctor Jenna Scaramanga,
- 19:37former ACE student who escaped and has now been sounding the alarms about accelerated Christian
- 19:45education programs all around the world. I'm going to use four words here.
- 19:51I'm sure it relates to you. The big bad world. Everybody's out there.
- 19:56It's the scientists are all in league with each other want to kill God,
- 20:00and the Communists are coming and the foreigners are coming. And by the
- 20:04time I got out of there, I mean I wanted to just crawl under
- 20:07a rock. And that was your experience. No, yes, absolutely,
- 20:11I mean the curriculum even, I mean what the entire idea of the system
- 20:17is, if you send your kids to a mainstream school, they will be
- 20:19corrupted. The thing that I always think of in relation to that is that
- 20:23we were discouraged from having friends that weren't Christians. Like both by the whole
- 20:27point of sending us to this school that was a little bubble was that there
- 20:30wouldn't be non Christians there to influence us to sin. But also like in
- 20:37the paces, there were explicit messages of just like, you shouldn't hang out
- 20:41with non Christians apart from when you're doing evangelism. And then as you say,
- 20:45conspiracy theories the law. There's even ace offered a college level which is
- 20:51a joke, but of course that was supposedly college level or like advanced placement
- 20:55on collectivism, and it has stuff about the Illuminati in it, like it's
- 20:59proper like that level of conspiracy because it's inherently a conspiracist mindset. Donald Howard
- 21:06in his book views humanism as the big source of the conspiracy, and when
- 21:10he talks about humanism, he's kind of talking about humanism in the way that
- 21:15probably quite a lot of listeners to this podcast identify as humanist or at least
- 21:18sympathetics to humanism, and he's kind of talking about that, like he does
- 21:22refer to the American Humanist Association or like the Second Humanist Manifesto and things like
- 21:26that, but it also is just a devil term for anything that he doesn't
- 21:29like, in the way that now you would hear people talking about postmodernist Marxism
- 21:33or like cultural Marxism, or like it's one of those terms you can just
- 21:36use to like slap a label and anything you don't like, you'll call it
- 21:40humanist. But the humanists were out to create world government, and this world
- 21:44government was going to destroy the family and end religion and destroy Christianity, and
- 21:48yeah, just everything in the world was scary and wrong and bad, and
- 21:55we had to be kept pure and clean and away from it. All Right,
- 21:57I'm going to describe my uniform, and I want you to describe yours.
- 22:03Was it red, white, and blue? Were you dressed in the
- 22:07color. I'm trying to think in the UK what your colors might have been,
- 22:10because we look like little patriotic paper dolls. They had flags on my
- 22:15tie. I mean, describe your uniform amazing. So I've never seen those
- 22:19US uniforms. I think you're talking about the ones that ACE did actually like
- 22:23sell like. It wasn't compulsory for school to offer those, but there was
- 22:26a red white blue uniform. We had to either buy them or make them
- 22:33red white or blue. But the design of them I think came from ACE
- 22:37Central. So we didn't have those, but they were thinking about it.
- 22:40Predominantly red white and blue. Yes, we had because the Union flag is
- 22:45also red, white and blue, so those are still patriotic colors. Here,
- 22:48the kids that were aged eleven and younger had red v neck sweaters that
- 22:55they had to wear with a white collar shirt and a tie. For girls
- 23:00it was an ankle length kilt with a tartan design on it and tights and
- 23:03flat shoes, and for boys it was gray trousers or actually for the kids
- 23:10under eleven, it was shorts all year round, like some weird Dickenzian old
- 23:15public school fantasy bizarre a Pink Floyd video right where bizarre. Yeah, just
- 23:23for me, it was whiplash when my mum sent me to that school because
- 23:26she used to talk about how that used to be a thing in British public
- 23:30schools. A public school, by the way, in the UK, really
- 23:33confusingly means extra posh private school, and what you think of as public school
- 23:38is called a state school. So but like the elite schools in the UK
- 23:42used to make the boys wear shorts all year round because it was seen as
- 23:45like a character building, will toughen you up, like matcho masculinity thing,
- 23:51And my mum used to talk about how cruel she thought that was, and
- 23:53then she sent me to the school that did that, and it was likely
- 23:56she had to backpedal really hard. I was out in the parking lot.
- 24:00We had a basketball goal in the parking lot. We didn't have like a
- 24:03and we were really on a shoe string, hardly any funding whatsoever, so
- 24:07it was kind of a small cheap church building. It was actually at a
- 24:11church. And then we had a basketball goal in the parking lot and I
- 24:14was out there in like a dress shirt and slacks and shiny black dress shoes
- 24:22with all the other kids, and that's how we played at recess. We
- 24:25played basketball and tag and everything else dressed for Sunday church. Did you have
- 24:30that? Yeah, it was a similar thing. So you were actually at
- 24:33break times allowed to put on like joggers if it was really cold. But
- 24:40yeah, well that's progressive, right, as were really really edgy, right,
- 24:45Praise the Lord absolutely, that thing of it being on a shoe string.
- 24:49One hundred percent. There were in twenty I think twenty seventeen. There
- 24:55are a bunch of snap inspections of religious schools because actually in the wake of
- 25:00the Trojan Horse affair, which some of you will have heard the excellent New
- 25:03York Times podcast series on, but following that, there was a crackdown on
- 25:07religious institutions and a bunch of ACU schools were found to be in violation of
- 25:14code in a whole bunch of ways, including a few of them that didn't
- 25:18have an adequate supply of hot and cold running water. And that's not a
- 25:21religious thing, that is just these schools have no money. They are tiny
- 25:26cults that are run on a shoe string. As you say, many of
- 25:29my audience are going to be wildly curious about just how bad the quote unquote
- 25:33education was. So let's start with the evolutionists. I'm reminded actually of our
- 25:41new Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, who is aligned with the Creation
- 25:44Museum Young Earth creationism. They talk a lot about evolutionists, those evil scientists.
- 25:51Talk to me about creation evolution from your history in Ace, would you?
- 25:57AC was always like the most extream end of the Young Earth creationism because
- 26:03it was founded in Lewisville, which is just outside Dallas, and not far
- 26:07from there is the Piluxi River in Texas, where creationists used to claim that
- 26:11there were footprints, like fossilized footprints of human footprints and dinosaur tracks alongside each
- 26:18other in the same rock, which they said blue evolution out of the water,
- 26:21and certainly would be an interesting finding if they could have turned up the
- 26:26evidence. And Carl Bohr was a creationist from that neck of the woods who
- 26:32really persisted with the Perluxi tracks thing long after places like you know, people
- 26:37like ken Ham and Answers in Genesis had gone, oh, actually, we're
- 26:41kind of embarrassing ourselves by continuing to claim this is true because we haven't been
- 26:44able to substantiate it. But AC was still fully fucking going for it.
- 26:48In fact, I have the latest revision of their curriculum here, and this
- 26:56is from this is a relatively new publication, which by theirs, they never
- 27:02have revised anything, so that's really new. And in this they are like,
- 27:07they kind of admit that the Perluxi tracks thing doesn't quite hold up.
- 27:12What do they say? Some creation scientists now advise against using the print still
- 27:18remaining in the Peleuxi River valley as evidence concerning mankind and dinosaurs like, But
- 27:23I think reading the whole text, what I would conclude if I read this
- 27:29as a student, is that there were dinosaur tracks and human tracks fossilid is
- 27:34in the same rock. But those tracks now have been destroyed and some of
- 27:40them turned out to be fakes, possibly of like false flag operation, like
- 27:45the bad evolutions have covered this up, so we can't prove this anymore,
- 27:48but we used to be able to prove to this. I think that would
- 27:51be my kind of takeaway on that. As I mentioned at the top of
- 27:55the program, they taught me that the Lotnest monster existed and that was the
- 27:57reason to doubt the theory of evolution. They, like Cardboard, had a
- 28:02bunch of theories that were just like I just think stuff that he made up.
- 28:06Like he claimed that there was this vapor canopy around the Earth prior to
- 28:10the flood, which he wasn't alone in doing, and that's where the floodwaters
- 28:12came from. So there used to be like a super greenhouse effect on the
- 28:15planet. So everywhere would have been a tropical environment because there was all this
- 28:19water vapor just floating around above the earth somehow contained and that all fellers rain
- 28:26during the flood and that's why it's not there anymore. But he said that
- 28:29this made the sky pink, and that it meant that there'll be some kind
- 28:34of magic filter that would allow you to hear the stars singing in the morning,
- 28:37because there's a Bible verse that refers to that, and it's like that
- 28:40was literally true. You could actually used to be able to hear like music
- 28:44coming from the heavens before the flood, and like the pink sky thing that
- 28:48was in a pace like within the last ten years. So some of the
- 28:52stuff I was able to kind of get them to quite negative publicity about,
- 28:56and some of those things have been removed from the new additions, but fund
- 29:00mentally, like it's still at that extreme end of like we think the Earth
- 29:03is six thousand years old, We're not even going to talk about microevolution.
- 29:07It's the most extreme form of Young Earth creations into conspiracy. It's a conspiracy,
- 29:11but that's got to relate to the firmament. Right, the waters of
- 29:15Earth separated from the waters of heaven. I've heard that above and blow.
- 29:19Yeah. They used in the curriculum the old seven forty seven in a junk
- 29:25yard quote unquote refutation for evolution. Right, if a tornado went through a
- 29:29junk yard and assembled as seven forty seven or you got it, yeah,
- 29:34seven seven, because you'll do that. This is eighth grade. This is
- 29:38this is their eighth grade science curriculum. I'm struck by how the indoctrination spilled
- 29:44into every subject. I didn't just learn English. They would teach us phrasing
- 29:48of sentences like you know, here's subject and predicate and adtatives and adverts.
- 29:52But it was always framed around religious messages. When God created the trees,
- 30:00he did so because he wanted us to love the color green. That kind
- 30:03of thing. I mean, if you noticed there's no escape, no,
- 30:07and some of it's quite dark. Like there's like a sixth grade English book
- 30:11where one of the sentences that you have to like underline the verb in is
- 30:14in hell, the fires won't ever be put out, and like it comes
- 30:18up like three times within the same book. Like that's strong stuff. Even
- 30:22in mathematics. I'm saying mathematics because saying math sounds weird to me, and
- 30:26saying maths will sound weird to your listeners. But even in maths, you
- 30:30have to do Bible verses. I have to memorize a Bible verse and that
- 30:33will come up on the test and that will affect your grade so potentially,
- 30:37And this is one of the criticisms that I made of ac my first paper
- 30:41that I published, Like, if you are like a college admissions tutor and
- 30:45you're looking at a graduating certificate from an ACU student, like you don't know
- 30:48if third GPA is a bit subpar? Is it? Like, actually,
- 30:52they were a fairly decent student, and they were crap at memorizing Bible verses,
- 30:55which is not relevant to the academic study at hand. You could grade
- 31:00in maths because you fail to memorize Bible verses, and I just don't think
- 31:03that's fair. I was looking at some of this. This is social studies
- 31:11in regard to family review the visualized instructions in sequence and to describe daddy,
- 31:18they had protector, provider, leader, hero, discuss mama's roles such as
- 31:23helper, cook, clean's house, washes and irons, clothes, a very
- 31:29primitive view of the nuclear family that's in the kindergarten curriculum, like it is
- 31:36there from absolutely day one. And the other thing that's in the kindergarten curriculum,
- 31:38which I think about all the time. I'm trans and I came out
- 31:42only a couple of years ago, so the majority of my activism was done
- 31:45before I came out, And I think back to that kindergarten because there was
- 31:51a dressing up box in my ac preschool and it was me and two girls.
- 31:56That was the whole class, and we always would if we had free
- 32:00time to play, they would be like, we're playing mummies and daddies.
- 32:04You have to be the daddy. I always hated it, but it says
- 32:07in the instructions to the supervisors in those kindergarten classes, make sure that the
- 32:14kids only wear gender appropriate clothing, like make sure boys are not allowed to
- 32:17wear skirts and dresses and girls are not allowed to wear boys clothes. Like
- 32:22it was very very explicitly, like inbolded text, there as an instruction to
- 32:27the supervisors. And I don't have a clear memory of what happened at that
- 32:30time in my life, but I just like, huh, did I express
- 32:35any interest in girls stuff then and have it slapped out of me? Because
- 32:38they would have come down that on that extremely hard. I'll never know how
- 32:42much of an influence that was, but it was like, that's what it's
- 32:45designed to do, you know. One of the real as you were talking
- 32:46about the big bad world earlier, like one of the big things is if
- 32:50you send your kids to a mainstream school, they're going to turn out queer.
- 32:52But if you send it to our godly Christian school, that won't happen.
- 32:55And people like mere evidence that that doesn't work. But it does leave
- 32:59people, I me, the pibit of package. A lot of people who
- 33:04have escaped FUNDI cultures still struggle with a whole bunch of damage done. So
- 33:08what happens next and where might they go? I'm going to talk to doctor
- 33:12Jennis Scaramanga about this next. Talking here with doctor Jenna Scaramanga, all right.
- 33:22I get email messages all the time from people who said I got out,
- 33:28I graduated, I entered the world. I was a minno, I
- 33:30had no idea what was going on. I went to college. What is
- 33:35this foreign planet? I was wrestling with the fact that I was the square
- 33:39peg who didn't fit into the round world, the real world. Real damage
- 33:45being done. We've got inhibited kids far behind the curve. They're not even
- 33:50playing ketchup. They're still back here in an embryonic state and they are thrown
- 33:54out into the world and trying to navigate. You want to speak to that.
- 33:59Were you that person? Yeah? I was. Luckily I got out
- 34:01when I was fifteen, so I did the last like I moved midway through
- 34:07I guess the equivalent of ninth grade for you guys, And in the UK
- 34:10you start preparing in that year for compulsory national exams that are called GCSS.
- 34:15So I was able to get recognised qualifications on leaving school, and that I
- 34:22wasn't in the situation that most UKAC grads are in, which is that they
- 34:27have a certificate for going through the ACEE system that doesn't legally carry any weight
- 34:32in the UK system, and which no one at university admissions office has ever
- 34:37heard of. So yeah, it could have been a lot worse for me.
- 34:39It was a difficult transition and I was behind in many ways, but
- 34:45I'm glad I did it then and not when I was older. But in
- 34:47your research, I know, I know you've heard the stories. You've crossed
- 34:52paths who've interviewed people who just got fucked up by ACEE. Right, Oh,
- 34:59absolutely, yeah. I think about my participants a lot. I had
- 35:02two participants that had spent time in psychiatric institutions, and I had others that
- 35:09had dropped out of university because they didn't feel able to cope when they were
- 35:13there, or had struggled through university. I think the trauma of it as
- 35:17well as a thing that stays with you for a long line time after it
- 35:21I had. I can think about this a lot lately. But I had
- 35:24a participant who was by and she said that she'd had an opportunity to have
- 35:30a girlfriend, and she'd really like that person and really wanted to start that
- 35:34relationship, but she hadn't felt able to because there was a voice in her
- 35:37head that told her that this was unnatural and that she'd go to hell.
- 35:39If she did, and like that's she knew that wasn't rational, but she
- 35:45still couldn't stop herself from acting on it. And that kind of trauma response
- 35:51that takes a lot of work to get out of. And even when you
- 35:53even when you've learned rationally speaking that that's wrong, it stays with you.
- 35:58It's like these really formative experiences that they're hard to overcome. Is there a
- 36:01resource you direct people too? For those who are filled, scarred or maybe
- 36:07have open wounds, you know, and we talk about religious recovery religious trauma.
- 36:12Some people don't think that religious trauma is a thing, and I'm like,
- 36:15you have no idea, right, I mean, the people are off
- 36:17in trauma. It's a thing, right, you'd agree with me? Back
- 36:21me up here, Janet, one hundred percent. That's a thing. Yeah.
- 36:22Absolutely. I wish I'd use trauma more in my doctorate as a framework
- 36:27for understanding these things, because now I think that is the most useful way
- 36:30to understand it. And resource though, I mean, is there a place
- 36:32that you direct people? Maybe even your own page on Facebook a buddies?
- 36:37Absolutely no. So yeah, so ACE Exposed can be quite a validating place,
- 36:42and we welcome new members, and there's a private group which I've vet
- 36:45people a bit more carefully, so there's a bit more of a safe space
- 36:49which also exists, which having joined the main group, if you message me,
- 36:52then you can join that one too, potentially. And I guess that
- 36:57book Leaving the Fold, who is the the therapist who developed this term religious
- 37:02trauma syndrome. She has done the most work because she that work came out
- 37:07of fundamentalist Christianity. Marlene went out, that is a useful resource. I'm
- 37:13glad you asked me this question. I want to do more. For a
- 37:15long time, my activism was focused on I'm going to take ACU down,
- 37:19and I realized what a giant task that was after I've been trying to do
- 37:22it for like five years and getting nowhere, And I realized now that the
- 37:27best thing that we can do is support each other. And what I really
- 37:30want to do is to support the other survivors. Speaking of which, if
- 37:34I may give a shout out to some other people whose work I think is
- 37:37really important, there's a podcast called Legacy of Abuse and they're as a group
- 37:43of former AC schoolers in Saskatchewan, Canada who are suing their former school for
- 37:49neglect and for sexual abuse. And there are also legal cases ongoing, and
- 37:53they have new people joining their lawsuit all the time, and they're also chronicling
- 37:58this in legacy of abuse. Be a difficult listen because it's a lot of
- 38:01people recounting their trauma. But as a you know, if you want to
- 38:05feel heard, if you want to feel not alone, and if you want
- 38:07to know what these people have been through, then that's a great podcast listen
- 38:10to. That's something I might be interested in having a conversation with those hosts,
- 38:15maybe here, or they were very interested. I might like to throw
- 38:16a feeler out and see where they're at. I'm a fantasy. I don't
- 38:21think this is petty. I think it's more of a liberation exercise. But
- 38:25I fantasize that, you know, Temple Christian School, which I think is
- 38:30now defunct, but they have a reunion and I get to go back.
- 38:36I would love to have a conversation. I would love to say, all
- 38:38right, look here's who I am, here's where I am, and you
- 38:45know you didn't win. I don't know if that's is that petty Jenna to
- 38:49think along those lines. I mean, no, I think that yeah,
- 38:53certainly I've fantasized about encounters with my old teachers Many's high and I had so
- 39:00many nightmares for so many years, mostly about confronting them and then finding that
- 39:06I couldn't speak, or that my mouth was sealed shut, or that my
- 39:08jaw was so tight that I could barely speak, or my voice would come
- 39:12out as a whisper, just like really not at all subtle. I felt
- 39:16like I had no voice, dreams like barely even metaphors, and like,
- 39:22since doing some activism on it, I don't have those nightmares anymore, but
- 39:25certainly the idea of confronting them out I'd still have a lot to say to
- 39:29them now I did. I I was, my family were quite close friends
- 39:35with the people that ran my school, and I wrote them a letter and
- 39:37I was like, what the fuck? And I got quite a gas lightly
- 39:43response. But I've still got it. Yeah, oh it's your fault,
- 39:45you've straight from the path kind of a thing, or I mean, don't
- 39:49let me pry. But lots of like I brought up some very specific instances
- 39:54of things that I thought were unacceptable what happened while I was at the school,
- 39:58and there was lots of like go oh, I'm not sure if we
- 40:01can ever agree on that based on different recollections of past events and stuff like
- 40:06this is interesting. They didn't deny it. They didn't actually quite go as
- 40:08far as saying that I was lying or making it up, but they wouldn't
- 40:13say they would admit that they've done it either. Beyond all of the exposing
- 40:15of the bad ideas, I really do appreciate the human aspect of what you
- 40:21do, creating a support and encouragement network for those who've been harmed. Thank
- 40:28you so much. If I can make a possibly cheeky request, I don't
- 40:30think anyone's going to take me up on this. But so I blogged on
- 40:35Patheos for years, and as you possibly may have heard, the evangelical company
- 40:39belief Net that owns the Pathos blogging network, when all the atheist bloggers left
- 40:45a few years ago, they were not as cooperative as they could have been
- 40:49about giving everyone their old blog archives. And in fact I was not active
- 40:52at the time and mine just got deleted. So loads of my articles just
- 40:55don't exist anymore. They've just been wipe from the net. But they are
- 40:59in the wayback machine, They're in the web archive, so if anyone wanted
- 41:04to do me an enormous solid if you could help me archive my old blog
- 41:08and restore it to the internet, that would be amazing because there's probably hundreds
- 41:12of articles that I wrote about a see that are not destroyed, but you
- 41:15can't find them on Google anymore. I read about that himmet Mean and a
- 41:19few other people were blogging on Patheos, and then this religious organization came in
- 41:23and just decided we're going to do nothing controversial, and they're obviously going to
- 41:29lean less secular and less religious criticism. They just dumped everything that you had
- 41:34been doing. They just deleted it out right. Yeah. So what happened
- 41:37was that I hadn't blogged for a couple of years, so I wasn't when
- 41:42all of those bloggers went off and formed only Sky together. I wasn't really
- 41:45party to that because I wasn't doing anything. And then I contacted Pathos after
- 41:49that happened and said, can I have my blog archive flease? And they
- 41:51were like, no, we've deleted it. Right, So if people are
- 41:54finding the articles, let's say I've got some people who can go in and
- 41:58spider where about send those How would they contact you? What's the best method
- 42:01for that. Oh yeah, that's a good point. I'm not super active
- 42:07on social media right now. I guess I'm gonna just give out my email
- 42:10address and if I start getting shit on that office different you want to set
- 42:15you up for that, I mean, let's do this. I'll put it
- 42:17in the description box if we decide at the end, or I'll put a
- 42:22link to maybe one of your pages and that way out. I guess my
- 42:24Instagram message me on Instagram. That'd be cool. I'm not Instagram isn't like
- 42:28super active, but I do check it regularly. Okay, I'll link that
- 42:31as well in the description box. By the way, I love the word
- 42:35cheeky. Like in the UK, you have such great sayings. I learned
- 42:38one. This is total digression. I was watching a show the other day
- 42:44and somebody something bad had happened, and she said, well, that's a
- 42:46bag of pants. I had no idea what they were talking about, so
- 42:51I had to go look up. Apparently, pants in the UK is when
- 42:53something is shit or it's bad, like it's pants. Is that do you
- 42:58say pants? I haven't said pans for a while, but it's definitely a
- 43:00thing that I have said in my life than that people do say because obviously
- 43:04pans to us are underpants. If we say pants, we yeah, we're
- 43:07talking about underwear. Hey, sa way, pants are underpants? Than what
- 43:09are pants? Pants? What are your over the larger pants? They're trousers?
- 43:15Okay, all right, Well for the record, Acee is a big
- 43:19bag of pants that I just want that on the record. Jenna Scarrimonga all
- 43:22the links in the description box. Thanks again, great talking to you and
- 43:27ye, thank you so much. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 43:31for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 43:36featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 43:42on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist
- 43:46dot com.