Latest / Newcomer Pod / Emperor Zuck (w/Deepa Seetharaman)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Hey, it's our newcomer here with
- 0:15dead cat. Katie's laughing at me.
- 0:17She's here Tom's here. We have our friend Deepa
- 0:21longtime friend from The Wall Street Journal, who's been
- 0:24involved in the Facebook files. Reporting is covered Facebook
- 0:29forever. Iran has been listening to this
- 0:32podcast. I think with some irritation and
- 0:36the goal of this podcast, in my mind is to solve the Facebook
- 0:41issue. I mean, I I sort of I didn't
- 0:43want to do it. I thought it to be like, sorry
- 0:44for issue with us. This is like a Marc Maron
- 0:47podcast because I thought it, I thought it was more of a therapy
- 0:50session my cell. We good.
- 0:52Are we good deeper? Are we good?
- 0:54I mean, I think there's been so much Facebook coverage that.
- 0:57Yeah, it's a fast. Lady media story also which is
- 1:01why we've talked about it and there's a certain like oh my
- 1:05God, is this story? Just going to go on forever when
- 1:08at the same time it feels like nothing's changed.
- 1:10So I want to try and structure this a little because it does
- 1:14feel like a lot and deeper. You're the expert here, I guess
- 1:19it's to help organize it I think a good starting point would just
- 1:22be like in your mind if you had to give us two or three of the
- 1:26core like Facebook, open threads.
- 1:28Like if we have all this report, Eating obviously, you had a
- 1:31bunch of different topics in the Facebook files.
- 1:33If you're like, oh, the real story lines about Facebook if
- 1:37you had to narrow down just so we can focus around something.
- 1:41Start off with. What would you say are like the
- 1:43key open threads? I mean, okay.
- 1:46They're all going to be kind of obvious, because this cover this
- 1:48company's been covered so aggressively and for so many
- 1:52years. But like I think if I'm thinking
- 1:55about different storylines for Facebook, that I find the most
- 1:59interesting. Most important one.
- 2:01It's like the consolidation of Power by Mark.
- 2:03This is a company that is always had Mark Zuckerberg at its
- 2:06center, right? I mean like like shareholder,
- 2:09he's all the voting power, use a chairman, he's a CEO.
- 2:11He's, the founder is because those cultural cachet and said
- 2:14the company, but lately, like, if you look at all these
- 2:17different external bodies that are supposed to check the
- 2:20company if they don't really do much of what the oversight board
- 2:24was likely lied to right in the process of its creation.
- 2:30I haven't done anything. Have they publicly rebuked?
- 2:32Mark. I don't know.
- 2:33No, write the actual board was at one point.
- 2:37It included people who disagreed with Mark and wanted to push
- 2:40back against him and then they got replaced last year, right?
- 2:43And, and, you know, there's nothing that shareholders can
- 2:47really do if you look at all shareholders, not named Mark
- 2:50Zuckerberg, most of them are unhappy with the current
- 2:54governance structure, but it doesn't matter because they're
- 2:57not named Mark Zuckerberg, right?
- 2:58And so I think there's That is a threat.
- 3:01I think a lot about. I think about the fact that like
- 3:03so much power is concentrated in this one person and that's not
- 3:07something you see in government, like necessarily, you don't
- 3:12necessarily you don't really see that.
- 3:14In other companies, I've covered where it's like, literally one
- 3:18person is making all these calls and the name of this podcast,
- 3:22obviously isn't right? Very episode of him.
- 3:27Consolidating control. Would you relate the rise?
- 3:29Of zuckuss emperor of Facebook to that moment that has become,
- 3:34you know, eponymous with our show that he was able to create
- 3:37this dual class structure that allowed him to.
- 3:40Even if he was selling off his shares, maintain absolute voting
- 3:44control over things. I mean, was that like the
- 3:46villainous turn in his leadership that brought him to
- 3:49where things are today? I think it's one of the moments,
- 3:51right? I think there's a lot of
- 3:52different periods in time where Mark, like collects more power.
- 3:56I mean, like think like, I personally as a reporter when I
- 3:59think, Worth going back to the early days where this share
- 4:03structure was even decided, right?
- 4:05Like this is like, you know, Sean Parker like trying to
- 4:09convince Mark that this is that he needed to make sure he
- 4:12retained as much power as possible.
- 4:14Like I want, I think more. I'd love to know a little bit
- 4:17more about those conversations and I'd love to know a little
- 4:20bit more about like because that to me, is starting moment where
- 4:24he just starts to wield incredible.
- 4:27Like he always had technical power like you always Has had
- 4:30the control of Youth of the company but then like what you
- 4:35seen in the last couple of years is a willingness to exercise
- 4:39that power. So before the 2016 election know
- 4:42Mark was the majority voting shareholder, right?
- 4:45But it was the Sheryl Sandberg as his partner in crime and
- 4:49right and she handled all the government Affairs and all the
- 4:52politics and she and he, where is he, like really focused on
- 4:55the technology and then that content that's completely
- 4:57changed in the last few years, right?
- 4:59And each Each one of these is a little Sway and that
- 5:02conversation the dead pack. Conversation is one of them
- 5:05because, you know, he's convincing me.
- 5:07Marc Andreessen is so in his Corner, he's texting him in the
- 5:11middle of a supposedly independent board meeting about
- 5:16like a committee meeting about like the share structure, right?
- 5:20I mean, like, it's right, it's in, it's just incredible.
- 5:24Yeah, and it's the infrastructure that was put in
- 5:27place to keep at least mark. Brick specifically in throned
- 5:33has been set and they're sort of nothing we can do about it, we
- 5:38can dig into all these and obviously we love the Mark
- 5:41Zuckerberg control one because it's personality and fun.
- 5:44Yeah. Like and it's sort of, you know,
- 5:47value neutral. So reporters can like really
- 5:49wade into that because it's just sort of like anyway.
- 5:52But I want to go through your sort of big, faceless narrative.
- 5:55So, what's number two? So that's one.
- 5:57And then the second is, I mean, one another is Facebook and the
- 6:01continuing kind of erosion of democratic Norms, right?
- 6:05And look, what is the role? That one's a little, that one's
- 6:08a little murkier. There's a lot of complex reasons
- 6:10why Democratic Norms around the world have changed and I mean
- 6:15and casebook is a potentially contributing factor in a lot of
- 6:19those cases. It's it's like what do you say I
- 6:22mean what do we say at this point, right?
- 6:23So much has been written about that but does the flood of
- 6:28disinformation misinformation. Nation, you know what is the
- 6:32effect that it has on society? What does it have on democracy?
- 6:36And the way that people like facts that they believe in and
- 6:40what they believe is real and how they vote?
- 6:42I mean, I actually think there's that moment.
- 6:44I was in the room for that economy conference in 2016 and
- 6:48Tory has one, you know? Or yes, me too.
- 6:51Hello wow. Royalty.
- 7:00I was I felt flattered and I you know, I was I was, you know, you
- 7:08know, see you were there when he was.
- 7:09Like yeah, it's pretty crazy to think about.
- 7:11Well, I have no idea what you guys are talking about.
- 7:13I don't even, this isn't even a. So I write basically the day
- 7:17after the election, there was a conference and Zuck was
- 7:19scheduled to speak. So, of course, the first
- 7:21question Zach is asked, is, do you think that Facebook played
- 7:25any role in Donald Trump's election in his victory and
- 7:29Zuckerberg I said, Depot, what was do you remember exactly what
- 7:31he said? Well, I remember to the words he
- 7:33says, I think of yes, pretty crazy.
- 7:35Pretty crazy to think that Facebook affected the election.
- 7:39Yes. I mean, you know, I don't
- 7:41remember in the room, I remember the room being kind of like
- 7:43silent and like there wasn't like some Big Lagoon, Collective
- 7:47gasp or anything, but like externally on social media like,
- 7:50yeah. It was like a like a bomb.
- 7:53It was the day after the election.
- 7:54Everyone was pretty numb for the most people are in the room.
- 7:57Nobody had any emotional reaction to Thing and that only
- 8:01now I remember to in terms of picking up pieces of words that
- 8:05he said during that, I think he said that people make their
- 8:07election voting decisions based on lived experiences rather
- 8:12than, you know, the information that they consume online.
- 8:15I think what was the point is, right?
- 8:17It would take him like it would take him what seven years later
- 8:20to acknowledge that. Facebook is a lived experience.
- 8:23When he renamed his company, medical things at all anymore.
- 8:27Like, that's a good boy. Yeah, yeah.
- 8:30And I mean, I actually, in some ways, I think there is a
- 8:33continues to be like a debate about the extent to which
- 8:36Facebook's responsible for, for that 100%.
- 8:40I don't think it's worth saying that he, that was that insane of
- 8:43a statement to make. I mean, like we can laugh about
- 8:45it. Now as we can, I don't wanna
- 8:47interrupt you. But yeah, I don't I don't want
- 8:49to say okay I don't want to posit that as like a completely
- 8:51crazy thing that he said, I think this many years later if
- 8:55there's reasonable debate to be had.
- 8:56Yeah, on whether or not that was right now.
- 8:59The discussion with Alex and we'll come back to that.
- 9:02Yeah, yeah. I remember the discussion with
- 9:04Alex. Well, then I and then, you know,
- 9:07I think there's also another thread, it's just Facebook and
- 9:11like, like harms to like mental health, like, the way that it
- 9:19sort of, I mean, like the Teen Health story, which I know we're
- 9:23going to talk about, there's also the problematic use slash
- 9:26Tech addiction storyline, right? Like, we're people are
- 9:29compulsive. Only using Facebook and they to
- 9:33the point where they don't spend time with their kids, there's a
- 9:36subset of that. There's some sort of those
- 9:38users. That's something that came out
- 9:39of the Facebook files documents. And so, there's just a lot of
- 9:43how does Facebook personally harm to get the Tom's Point?
- 9:46Like how does it personally harm the individual?
- 9:48There you? Yeah, you.
- 9:50Yeah. And so I think there's there's
- 9:52that there's that, there's so many others names, but those are
- 9:55the ones, those are the ones. I'm and some, my, some I argue
- 9:59that theme. Yeah.
- 10:01Two and three are related as well.
- 10:04Yes they were all right. Now we have a even go.
- 10:07Like this is helpful. This is a well organized as
- 10:11review of Facebook. Yeah, it's almost so deep as
- 10:14been thinking about for a long time, a long time, I mean, there
- 10:19is a lot by the way, there's a lot of Prior just like three.
- 10:22Can I ask you on these on these points as you are thinking about
- 10:26them and doing your reporting How Deeply do?
- 10:29Do a lot of your sources at Facebook, contemplate.
- 10:32These things. There's such a broad range
- 10:34right. There are definitely people who
- 10:36think that this is all bullshit, but okay, yeah, maybe Facebook
- 10:40had a role in Myanmar, okay, fine.
- 10:42Yeah. Maybe, you know, disinformation
- 10:44is bad, but we don't necessarily know how this information like
- 10:50affects votes. I mean, okay, January 6, you
- 10:54know, like there's definitely people who are a little bit in
- 10:55denial and that's like kind of the mental, what their thinking,
- 10:58their train of thought. And then there's Definitely
- 11:00people who it's hard for them to engage in this conversation
- 11:03because they feel like the media is out to get them.
- 11:05All right? There's a whole media versus
- 11:07Facebook theme to, which is, I don't think particularly
- 11:10helpful, but it is something that a lot of people think
- 11:13they're at, you know, there's a feeling of like, oh well the
- 11:15media's. I've actually had Facebook
- 11:17people argue to me before like the media is jealous of of us
- 11:24because we make so much money and we're taking all their
- 11:27influence and, you know, that's We got to the truth to it, but
- 11:33it's very complicated. I don't want.
- 11:35Yeah. I mean reporter is by their very
- 11:37profession Believe In Like A reported intentional way of
- 11:41knowing things about the world, they believe in like truth.
- 11:45They believe in like fact checking and they believe that
- 11:48people who do those things in our virtuous and that way should
- 11:52get rewarded in some sense for it and Facebook loves reward
- 11:56people. I mean Ryan Broderick at garbage
- 11:59day was just I dream about, you know, these viral like the cat
- 12:02breastfeeding episode, you know, like social media, whether it's
- 12:05Tick-Tock or Facebook sort of thrive on pumping out things
- 12:08that are like obviously Falls. And I think any of us is
- 12:11reporters, it can drive us crazy because we believe in like truth
- 12:17and we think it's bad that these platforms just in and of itself,
- 12:20feed people stuff, that's obviously not true.
- 12:23Just to make them angry for a second to get engagement.
- 12:26And so, is that bias? I don't know.
- 12:29We all share. That's literally never been a
- 12:32motivating factor. Anything I've thought about
- 12:34recording, we share like a worldview about like you don't
- 12:37agree with that. No, I don't like I don't, I
- 12:41don't think that's like something that motivates me to
- 12:42report at all. 100% know the couple times I've written about
- 12:46Facebook that was literally not something.
- 12:48I thought about what did I think about.
- 12:50Here's a list of people. I need to call.
- 12:52Here's a list of things. I need to know.
- 12:54I have X amount of hours to get the information, and I'm going
- 12:58to get it. And I'm going to Roger this file
- 13:01and someone else is going to clean it up and I hit publish.
- 13:04That's what I thought was very, it wasn't.
- 13:06It wasn't known as easier for like the Mark Zuckerberg sort of
- 13:09style bucket one but like, bucket, two and three have a lot
- 13:13of like, what are your values, your values play into it or
- 13:17Depot. I mean, if you want them to, I
- 13:20mean, but like deeper, when you let's go like drill and
- 13:22specifically on the year, a member of the media and you're
- 13:25only writing critically about us because you're jealous of our ad
- 13:29money or Something. I mean and if you've actually
- 13:31had these conversations because I never have a, you see it play
- 13:34out on Twitter which is the world's worst medium to have a
- 13:37meaningful and nuanced conversation with someone.
- 13:39But yeah, as you are engaging with, you know, in a background
- 13:43setting, so you can speak sort of freely with someone and they
- 13:45and they put to you this like, you know, Canard about what the
- 13:50media is, are you able to have like a reasonable conversation
- 13:53with them about it and, you know, and maybe your mind is
- 13:56changed slightly by them and vice versa.
- 13:59It's like kind of gets down to the function of news though.
- 14:02Like if your I had a I went to journalism school and I had this
- 14:05professor in college, he talked about how during the Vietnam
- 14:08war, he felt like it was newspapers responsibility to
- 14:11consistently shove in people's faces.
- 14:14The pictures will coffins coming home, you know like repeatedly
- 14:17show it to them. Like he I think he used the word
- 14:19force, it down their throats and not because they like it like
- 14:22like news is one of those weird Industries or it's not just you
- 14:26don't give people what they want or what they say.
- 14:28They want you give people What? The, you know, you as an
- 14:31institution, think they need, and if we as an institution,
- 14:34thank you. Hey, you need to understand, and
- 14:37highlight the harms of Technology.
- 14:40Then I mean, that's yeah, I guess that's an editorial
- 14:44choice. But like, you know, that's the
- 14:46purpose of news and to highlight issues so that people can kind
- 14:50of make their choices and understand, because they're
- 14:53going to get PR from everywhere, right?
- 14:55There's advertising that like, you know, if you, if you're a
- 14:59think of Like a Facebook user, you will get a lot of
- 15:02information about Facebook from the news.
- 15:03But Facebook has all these other routes right there is actual
- 15:06Facebook, right product that is used by millions of people.
- 15:10Lots of men. I know they pump out whenever
- 15:12Sheryl, Sandberg has some live stream.
- 15:15I get some notification in there.
- 15:16I am suddenly listening to her directly, it's extreme.
- 15:20It's a huge microphone. That's my favorite show every
- 15:22time and you know, so that they have their own platform, they
- 15:26have advertising, they have, you know, there's still a lot of
- 15:29places. At will, like, do interviews
- 15:31with them that are crossed off Bali.
- 15:32Like, I don't, you know, I don't know if it's that's not my job.
- 15:35My job isn't to be PR. It's not your job to be like,
- 15:38this is the number one movie in America, you know what I mean?
- 15:40So, mainstream media, Where The Red Pill.
- 15:46All right. So so the sort of Alex Stamos,
- 15:49sort of democracy fight. I mean this fits into sort of
- 15:52the media has an agenda because I think a key framing there for
- 15:57him was this idea? Year, that Facebook was guilty
- 16:03in that, they, you know, let the Russians like by, you know, get
- 16:09some ads that sort of manipulated people, but that
- 16:12campaign was much smaller than the effect of the actual hack,
- 16:17which was sort of laundered through the media and that the
- 16:20media was far more complicit and that the media has an interest
- 16:24in blowing one of those two scandals out of proportion.
- 16:29And And that's, that's sort of where we are.
- 16:31Do you disagree with, with that argument?
- 16:34It's like two different sets of media, though, right?
- 16:36Like, I mean, Tech reporters who are the media is not like a blob
- 16:40in that, like a blob, is really moves in unison, right?
- 16:45And it's not even though we're not like look, we're not
- 16:48organized enough to be like a conspiracy, like we don't have
- 16:53like enough look, I don't know what my colleague who sits next
- 16:57to me is doing. I got any at Maybe like more
- 17:01than half the time, right more than half the time.
- 17:03And like, not that I have any colleagues who sit next to me
- 17:06anymore, but you know what I mean?
- 17:07Like, I don't give your kids right now and I also don't know
- 17:09what my kids are doing. I relate.
- 17:12And so, I just think that, you know, I, I detect reporters were
- 17:17focusing on, on Facebook and sort of the impact of the Russia
- 17:23campaign, and there isn't necessarily A like, what's the
- 17:28like those same I'm reporters weren't involved in a lot of the
- 17:32Hillary Clinton, like, kind of the week coverage that Alex is
- 17:36talking about, right? Like this is like where I am way
- 17:38out of my depth like it but it's not the same individual
- 17:42reporters. So who should who should answer
- 17:45that? Question is so hard for me to
- 17:47answer it but also the other thing that Alex sort of he this
- 17:51the store if you end the story at the 2016 election, I think
- 17:55his point is very strong but what he then goes on to say and
- 17:58he does not link these Points is that disinformation
- 18:01misinformation bad information, democracy.
- 18:04Eroding information is now spread by everyday Americans.
- 18:07We actually don't need Russia to hack.
- 18:10Tom podesta's, email, and grab it and give it to reporters now,
- 18:16everyday Americans are taking care of that, but the tool they
- 18:19are using, is still Facebook. And so I under, like I said, if
- 18:24you stop his narrative at 2016, I think it is very strong, but
- 18:28what we do, he Aunt, do is extend the timeline to show that
- 18:32you no longer need Russians to hack anyone because Americans
- 18:35are taking care of it themselves, but the tool that
- 18:37they need in order to spread that information is Facebook.
- 18:41You know, if I can just say one thing that is probably like just
- 18:46sort of a side point. Alex has broader point about the
- 18:48media introspection and like how reporters need to really think
- 18:53about the editorial choices they made.
- 18:55I don't, it's like, to me, it's separate from Facebook's
- 18:58responsibility, but it's also Men like true, but I agree like
- 19:01reporters need to be constantly thinking about it, but when it
- 19:04comes to issues and I don't think we as an industry, do
- 19:08enough to interrogate ourselves and look at our choices.
- 19:12Specially our editorial choices, right.
- 19:14A lot of the criticism is the Masthead level rather than beat
- 19:17reporter level. Yeah and we're talking to the
- 19:19beat reporter obvious, right. But I also kind of think those
- 19:22are separate questions from the impact of technology and
- 19:27whenever I talk to somebody who's very defensive about Out
- 19:29technology. They're always try to like, kind
- 19:31of throw it to this other argument, which is the media.
- 19:33And I'm like this is like these aren't the same topic well, but
- 19:37do they agree with that because the media has made it.
- 19:39I mean, like, you know, this is the argument that tech people
- 19:42will always make is like, you can pull the audience, but the
- 19:45audience is just a reflection of the media that they consume
- 19:47which we've now. Agreed is the case, one way or
- 19:50the other, then you know they can definitely say an agenda is
- 19:53responsible for that sentiment. Well, I mean, if it is I don't
- 19:57know. If you look at just what could
- 19:58like, just look at consumers. Southeast will use Facebook
- 20:01constantly. Look, I've been writing about
- 20:02this company for almost seven years.
- 20:03I use Facebook. I sold my couch recently on
- 20:06Facebook Marketplace. I do best program.
- 20:11I'm not anti Facebook, right? Like if these things aren't this
- 20:15is its these it's not it mutually exclusive to use
- 20:20Facebook products but also be critical of the company's harms.
- 20:23It's like, I don't know. We all vote.
- 20:25We live in a democracy but we can still challenge our
- 20:27Democratic leaders. The Fect of all this reporting
- 20:31on Facebook, is that there's like a there are people are,
- 20:34like, shut Facebook down or it does, it does feel like, you
- 20:37know, some of it can feel like it's so relentless, because the
- 20:41goal is to get rid of Mark Zuckerberg or because it's like,
- 20:45well, he's responsible. There's been no change.
- 20:47How can you believe, you know that?
- 20:50The company really means to change when the guy in charge.
- 20:53Yeah, and I know, you can't say one way or the other whether you
- 20:56think Mark Zuckerberg should be replaced.
- 20:59Yes, but I don't know. What can you say about the
- 21:02relationship between the fact that it's one guy and sort of
- 21:06the relentlessness? I mean, I think that this, I
- 21:12just think he's a crude, a lot of power and I think he's
- 21:16probably more. He appears to be, at least from
- 21:19the outside, right? There's a lot, we don't
- 21:21necessarily know, but he appears from the outside to be like, you
- 21:26know, as powerful a situation as a 10.
- 21:29Anytime before right guy, I don't see him stepping.
- 21:33Yeah, he literally floats above water right.
- 21:38He's he has godley's a crude. Godlike abilities.
- 21:42That's a, he's using a hydrofoil hydrofoil New York Times.
- 21:46It was not. It was not a windsurf, it was it
- 21:49was a hydrofoil, right? What are the worst Corrections?
- 21:53I've seen in the times history and so there's there's a real
- 21:58question of Okay. So what's been the impact of all
- 22:03this reporting this fairly good, investigative reporting on
- 22:09Facebook. And I think there's a lot of
- 22:11people within one thing that I find really interesting.
- 22:14So you guys remember Cambridge analytic about the under that
- 22:17that all that episode unfortunately.
- 22:19Yes and so camera J. Let It Go.
- 22:22Was it was interesting for a lot of reasons like it.
- 22:25I don't there is that narrative that, you know, the data Was
- 22:29taken by. Let me see if I can remember it.
- 22:32I haven't thought about this in a long time like Hogan and then
- 22:38Alexander Cogan, right? That's his name, I think.
- 22:40And then, it was given to Cambridge analytical and then
- 22:43Cambridge analytic gotta supposedly fed that into their,
- 22:48like, kind of their machine learning software, whatever, and
- 22:52then were able to Target would be Trump voters or like voters
- 22:57in general, didn't Action and flip their votes, either got
- 23:01them to vote for Trump or got them right to not vote for
- 23:04Hillary. And I think that feels super
- 23:07hard to prove. Like, I don't, it's a fake
- 23:09scandal-ridden into your times, the nobody believes anymore,
- 23:13that they've never really apologized for.
- 23:15I mean, that's also the guardian.
- 23:17Eric, there are absolutely right.
- 23:19And then when they there was a Pulitzer campaign, there was a
- 23:22lot of drama around, which side should get credit there, but I
- 23:26do like the the times is the only publication.
- 23:29Remember For writing that story. I mean, that's what I read.
- 23:33I mean, it's very influential no.
- 23:34But that, that is a good point. That is a good point.
- 23:36I mean, no Angry. Like, why is the times the only
- 23:39publication remembered for writing that story?
- 23:41Because it wasn't just the time special, it was the guardian.
- 23:43It was the guardian for I believe won awards for it.
- 23:46They broke the story, right? And like every other publication
- 23:51matched is so why is the times, the only what time is it?
- 23:53The Forefront would know. First of all, they did have, you
- 23:55know an ultra Ultra long story? No, we had to, we had to team up
- 23:58with the guard. DS.
- 24:00Yeah, it's see that. You'll see that care her by
- 24:03lines on all of the stories. I mean this is sort of similar
- 24:07wiser - coverage of Facebook. It's like because New York Times
- 24:10is the most powerful you know, like news Alan people hold it in
- 24:13highest. I'm not, I'm not saying I'm not,
- 24:16I'm not saying you shouldn't criticize.
- 24:17I'm just wondering like, why you only want the times to
- 24:20apologize, I trust the times 10x to the guardian so I don't care.
- 24:24Really. If the guardian even though
- 24:26Carol called baller is now credited with actually breaking
- 24:29the story. Archie has a very strong.
- 24:31She's a very opinionated report anyway, totally different.
- 24:34Yeah, we're but we also trusted Journal equally to the time I
- 24:37do. Trust the journal.
- 24:40Yeah. Well what I was going to say
- 24:41that so that part was like kind of hard to prove but what if
- 24:44absolutely demonstrated was that there was a time when you could
- 24:47just like kind of suck up user data from Facebook and then the
- 24:51company infinite absolutely no idea where it went right?
- 24:54And the end and that is a legitimate issue and I think
- 24:56they were kind of and then they Addressed it.
- 25:00And, you know it was like Mark, Zuckerberg took five days to
- 25:03sort of sit down and like, understand what was going on.
- 25:05Come up with a bunch of scenes and are fixes or whatever and
- 25:09then, finally spoke up criticized for waiting that
- 25:11long. I mean, there's certain certain
- 25:13things in hindsight that are I mean like this like the five-day
- 25:17wait how big of a scandal is it? I mean it's it's a little in the
- 25:22like kind of as we go further pass it.
- 25:26I don't run running was the biggest scan true skin on.
- 25:29That whole thing, that was, what morning?
- 25:31Remember the Facebook comms front ran the actual issue
- 25:38because that it made them look guilty and then everybody was
- 25:40like oh fuck Facebook was nothing reporters, hate more
- 25:43than front running. Like yeah that what's the five
- 25:47days they took a while to actually like figure it out and
- 25:49come up with this substantive response to the like the kind of
- 25:52contract. Because I remember I actually
- 25:54remember this very well because I was in the process of planning
- 25:56my wedding, during the Cambridge analytic has gone away.
- 25:59It was a beautiful wedding, thank you.
- 26:01It was also really hard to plan at a certain point.
- 26:05I just sort of like stepped. I was like, okay I'm I can't
- 26:07plan what you did to religions multiple days at a retreat.
- 26:12It was wow, that's nice. Eric was actually there.
- 26:15While I was getting ready when the published time, that is your
- 26:25fault. And I'm so anyway, we so we just
- 26:29Just we, you know, the actual thing that I think is really
- 26:33important is that is the leak of data.
- 26:36And so anyway, if you remember the Facebook response to that
- 26:39was, okay, we're really sorry. We this is what all the things
- 26:42we're doing around privacy, these are all the different
- 26:45steps were going to take etcetera, etc.
- 26:47Etc. You haven't seen that this time,
- 26:50right? With the, with the documents
- 26:52that right? That were published in the
- 26:55journal and then later by a lot of other outlets, like what the
- 26:57Whistleblower got. Like, you just You haven't seen
- 27:00that level of apology in fact, what you see his Defiance.
- 27:03And I think that's a reflection of can Mark gaining more power,
- 27:09just feeling more confident, and sort of asserting what he thinks
- 27:12is, right? And like our understanding is,
- 27:14it is and it's been reported elsewhere.
- 27:16Is that a lot of that is being driven through, Mark, with sort
- 27:19of saying, I don't want apologies.
- 27:21I want us to be tough and they happen to us when they get into
- 27:25arguments, like I feel like they're doing our hair.
- 27:27Like I do think there's six. Feeding is it Facebook files,
- 27:31like, champagne. They're only Facebook files.
- 27:34If it's published in the Wall Street Journal and anywhere
- 27:36else. It's sparkling sparkling wine.
- 27:40Yeah, right, this is what we called our series.
- 27:42And then, like guess one, the Consortium got it.
- 27:45They were like, we don't want to go on to Facebook files, but it
- 27:48isn't it? I forget, which reporter said
- 27:50that you don't want to call it. I forget, what do they call it?
- 27:52They called it like the Facebook because Casey, the left over,
- 27:54right? So they want to bring like the
- 27:57Facebook papers. So like, Yeah, you know, some
- 28:00people say Facebook papers Facebook, but this is evidence
- 28:03here that media does not glued very well.
- 28:05You know, Eddie like, yeah, so you're you know, the Facebook
- 28:10file story, The tell us about your Instagram story.
- 28:13We've talked about on the podcast, somewhat, maybe in ways
- 28:17you disagree with so I don't care.
- 28:19We've always been incredibly positive about all the journals
- 28:23Facebook stores. I mean and a lot of like all
- 28:25credit kind of goes to my colleague.
- 28:27Jeff for basically convincing Francis, how good.
- 28:29Come forward and provide all these documents and it's been
- 28:32awesome to work with him. And he actually is funny.
- 28:34I I was on maternity leave earlier this year and he's like,
- 28:40hey, I can, I come over? I just want to talk to you about
- 28:42this like project were working on and I had three month old
- 28:47daughter at the time and like, listen, three months, you know,
- 28:49Tom knows its base, they're like they're a lot and and so he's
- 28:54sitting in like he's sitting there.
- 28:55It's like post vaccine times. He's like a cliff that I really
- 28:58want your help on this project. I'm like okay fine yeah what is
- 29:02it is like we have a bunch of internal documents and they're
- 29:04really revelatory and I was like okay I don't look at wasn't
- 29:08processing at all and then my daughter vomited on me and then
- 29:12like all these things happened and then you know key it wasn't
- 29:16that like the moment where things click tree, like wait a
- 29:18second. There's something that is putrid
- 29:20and gross that lives inside an organism that when it gets out
- 29:23says something about the world and what it means to me, if I
- 29:27had the mental capacity to think like that, Maybe but I've had
- 29:30nothing. I was so fried and I you know, I
- 29:32just I didn't really appreciate what he was talking about until
- 29:36like I came back like a few weeks later and started going
- 29:41through the documents and I was like, this is amazing.
- 29:43Like it was just fascinating, right?
- 29:45And in part because you know, you asked this question that I
- 29:47didn't really fully answer earlier about, like, what's the
- 29:49conversation internally at the company?
- 29:52Like, all right, and they're definitely people who are
- 29:53defensive and feel like the media is out to get them.
- 29:56There's also so many people there, That are really
- 30:00thoughtful conscientious, and like trying the furnace, right?
- 30:05There's a lot of earnestness in there, where they believe that
- 30:09they can effect change which, you know, we can debate whether
- 30:13that's ever possible at a company like that, but they
- 30:15believe that they have a duty to do that.
- 30:18And you see that in a lot of these.
- 30:20You see that on a lot of these comments and you see this in
- 30:22what, you know, she captured. And I think that's that thing,
- 30:26that's meaningful. You know, it's not a monolith,
- 30:28it to Riley. The media is not a block.
- 30:30Facebook's not a block either, there's a lot of, right?
- 30:32I mean there's an argument that this sort of way you're saying
- 30:34that part of what the Facebook files are our employees inside
- 30:38the company, sort of doing research aligned with the
- 30:42reporters outside the company. I mean, I laugh sometimes when
- 30:45we talk about company companies like you, we talk.
- 30:49We talk about Facebook a lot and you write about Facebook but
- 30:52like, who is Facebook? Because sometimes Facebook is
- 30:56like calms people write like a lot of times that's Of the
- 30:59ultimate because we sometimes talk about Facebook is being
- 31:02sort of separate from Mark Zuckerberg even though he's
- 31:05like, very in control and then, there are obviously people who
- 31:09are doing the research that you're sort of writing about
- 31:12positively and they're saying, that's not Facebook, so it can
- 31:16be very confusing. Yeah.
- 31:18Been talking about a company to, to say that Facebook's like
- 31:21getting one point when it's yeah, yeah, I mean, like that's
- 31:26what we that's true and we should just be a little bit
- 31:28more. Located about what we're talking
- 31:30about when we say Facebook right?
- 31:32Like is that leadership, is it Zuckerberg Cheryl?
- 31:35You know, all these different Executives that are up stopping
- 31:37company? Are you talking about, is this
- 31:39like a message coming from the Integrity folks, which is where
- 31:42a lot of This research, is being conducted?
- 31:44Is it? You got to think through the
- 31:45differences of Instagram and WhatsApp and Facebook.
- 31:49They all have different and discreet cultures.
- 31:50I mean, there's a it's obviously I mean like this is this is very
- 31:54obvious, I think but it is not a yeah it's all a single Be like
- 31:59blah bright. Like the way all companies and
- 32:01the way the media is it's just it's a really complex place and
- 32:05I think one thing I've enjoyed about and I've been proud about
- 32:08with our coverage is the fact that I think we've highlighted
- 32:11that because we're talking about these sort of Divisions within
- 32:14the company and in terms of how to approach certain issues and
- 32:20how the Integrity teams that were built and tasked with,
- 32:24protecting the company, and protecting users are often side.
- 32:29I'd lined. You know, so I you know, has the
- 32:31chi like in terms of impact, I'm not sure if you like the company
- 32:35is restricting access to that kind of research now, they are
- 32:39really cutting down on leaks. Someone was telling me that now
- 32:43data scientists are a lot more careful about how they were
- 32:46their conclusions. Like, they don't want to,
- 32:48because, like, they have to think, okay, this is going to be
- 32:50leaked. So, how do I say it?
- 32:53And I mean, we haven't heard them pulling research, right?
- 32:57Like felt like they're disbanding.
- 32:59Any That study is addiction or whatever, but we don't know
- 33:01what, what else might be going. I mean, is this central question
- 33:05of the Facebook files? You know, is Facebook just like
- 33:09a tobacco company? Or like, are we going to look at
- 33:12that? I mean, do you think the Tobacco
- 33:14Company metaphor? Because it's like very oriented
- 33:17around, what your internal research says?
- 33:20Yeah and how that can come back to bite you sort of as negative
- 33:25opinion sort of evolved over time I think it's not Okay, so I
- 33:29don't I think like the similar coverage strategy, right?
- 33:34Like, where are you? And in part, because strategy is
- 33:37almost too fancy of award. We don't we didn't know that
- 33:40this data This research existed before it was like, like we had
- 33:44all heard of a lot of This research, but like, we've nobody
- 33:48had seen it, right? And so that parallel is
- 33:53unplanned, I guess, but so yeah, we're looking at what the
- 33:57company's own assessment of itself.
- 33:59You saw this with like that like Exxon coverage.
- 34:02I think a few years ago and how they are, scientists knew that I
- 34:07liked about the company's effect on climate change and, you know,
- 34:09like there's a lot of this framework and this about the
- 34:13strategy of coverage is common in a lot of Industries.
- 34:17Write the stories were good because it was about what
- 34:20Facebook knew about their own behavior.
- 34:23Not just what's happening? Yeah, and also what they, you
- 34:27know, like that's one thing with the teen.
- 34:29Health, and mental health stuff. You know, there is an argument
- 34:31out there that this stuff, this research, you do these five
- 34:34research reports, some of which included, surveys of, tens of
- 34:37thousands of people that they weren't conclusive and fine
- 34:40fair. But then, you know, the company
- 34:43then then you look at what the choices the leadership made
- 34:46like, did they then go do the more intense research did they
- 34:49then go like, partner with any of these academics that have
- 34:54been studying this stuff and try to get their opinions?
- 34:56All right, we're taught we're talking around the Instagram
- 34:58story. This point frame.
- 34:59Yeah, and like let's let's get into the meat of the.
- 35:01Alright. So that was the story.
- 35:03I was involved in the initial run.
- 35:05You know we've done a lot of stories since then but an
- 35:07initial run, the Instagram team helped Stories the way that the
- 35:11general conceit of the story is that Facebook had internal
- 35:16research that Instagram had undermined the mental health of
- 35:22a subset of teams, right? So you had not all gains but
- 35:26like a lot of teams you had If you were experiencing body image
- 35:32issues for one in three teens Instagram, made it worse, for if
- 35:36you were experiencing kind of suicidal ideation, if you were,
- 35:41if you were in that mindset for a small percentage of those
- 35:45teens and the UK and in the u.s. Instagram, made it worse, right?
- 35:50And and so you look at the study and they're like, there's a,
- 35:54there's a sizable percentage of teams that are not just, it's
- 35:58not neutral. It's like Actually harmed by
- 36:00what they see in our platform and through the actual feed
- 36:05through and through the explore page.
- 36:07And you know, the story then also goes into what leadership
- 36:13actually did about it. You know, and they, there was a
- 36:19one particular feature that they decided to launch.
- 36:22It was like, an opt-in feature to remove likes, right?
- 36:27From your, from your From your feed.
- 36:30And, you know, a lot of the researcher said, well, that
- 36:34isn't really going to solve the problem and Instagram went
- 36:37forward with it anyway, because and this is also from their
- 36:39internal documents. I thought it would be a PR with,
- 36:42so, it raises some questions. Sorry, what would be rolling
- 36:45out? Like a optional feature to
- 36:47remove your like, counts likely using a removing the likes.
- 36:51Sorry. It hurt people.
- 36:53No, so one of excel, I'm not being clear.
- 36:56I think one research just said that removing the likes would
- 36:58not. Do anything.
- 37:00And so why bother and Facebook said, well the reason to bother
- 37:02us because would be a PR one and like the idea being that, you
- 37:06know, the hypothesis was like, if you remove likes and you
- 37:09remove that social comparison issue, right?
- 37:11Where you're like, comparing yourself against like somebody
- 37:14else in your class and then if they get more likes that might
- 37:17make you feel bad. And you know, so maybe one
- 37:20solution was removed the likes but they found that that doesn't
- 37:22really help if it's especially if it's optional, right?
- 37:25But Facebook, went ahead with it anyway because I thought it
- 37:28would look good. And so there's there's there's a
- 37:31lot of in there about not just like the problem itself.
- 37:36But then the way the company went about, like, quote-unquote,
- 37:42solving it. And like the way they just sort
- 37:44of like they sort of sidestep the issue and try to put
- 37:47Band-Aids on on some of these on some of these problems and I
- 37:51think I'm actually so now I'm curious like what did you guys
- 37:55think? Like, that's so that's the story
- 37:57that's actually generated a lot of heat.
- 37:59Well And just yeah, I mean like the critics they all say the
- 38:02critics point to the fact that the research wasn't as dire as
- 38:06the headlines might have made it seem and the sales throughout
- 38:09the entire story. And I think that what has been
- 38:12lost for in you let me know, you let us know why you think has
- 38:15happened. What has been lost in the
- 38:18reading of these stories? Is this focus on what the
- 38:22company does with information rather than whether or not.
- 38:24The information is objectively, good or bad, whether it's
- 38:26objectively as harmful as it could be.
- 38:29You're not quite fitting into that.
- 38:31I think we've said on and maybe Katie said, I forget, who but
- 38:35does Facebook need to be clearly worse than Vogue for this story
- 38:39to have impact. And I do think how the headlines
- 38:42framed, it's like, oh some percentage of women feel bad
- 38:45when they see Instagram or teenage girls, excuse me, you
- 38:48know, is that true of Vogue? And if it's not worse than
- 38:52Vogue, like why is that the headline or not?
- 38:55Even just worse than Vogue but if the metaphor is going to hold
- 38:59it, Being a tobacco company in which there is clear and
- 39:02unarguable, medical evidence, that smoking dramatically
- 39:06increases your likelihood of getting lung cancer, other kind
- 39:08of negative health effects. That's not the same thing as
- 39:11like, a subset of, you know, people, it's all smokers have a
- 39:14higher percentage, likelihood of getting cancer and so does that
- 39:18kind of hurt you think the the the strength of the metaphor and
- 39:22you know, contribute to an idea of overhyping the actual
- 39:26findings of this report? Yeah, I do.
- 39:29Don't, you know, it's interesting.
- 39:31I just pulled up the story because I wanted to make sure I
- 39:34was remembering this, right? And like I've gone back and
- 39:37reread the story because I feel like when it's been quoted back
- 39:40to me, sometimes I don't recognize the story at all.
- 39:43And so the story says, you know, 32 percent of teen girl, this is
- 39:47actually quoting from the slide, right?
- 39:4932 percent of teen girls said that when they felt bad about
- 39:52their bodies, Instagram made them feel worse.
- 39:55This has been quoted back to me as 13 teen girls Being destroyed
- 40:00by Instagram, right? And that's not the same thing,
- 40:03and I don't, you know, unlike I sort of have to step in and sort
- 40:07of, you know, I do what I can, you know, I'm like, oh, well
- 40:10actually that that had to do with body image issues.
- 40:12And I think we were very responsible and careful and how
- 40:15we trained it. We drew it directly from their
- 40:18side presentations. What do you think about the
- 40:20accusation that you guys selectively pulled information
- 40:24that prove that point. But slides, that actually showed
- 40:26there were beneficial aspects of Instagram People to feeling
- 40:29better. That was something Alex.
- 40:30I think brought up on it and I know others have as well.
- 40:33I mean what's your response to that?
- 40:34I think everything we want to be like little careful about how I
- 40:40say this because I want the story to stand for itself and I
- 40:43think we did a good job of expressing the individual data
- 40:47points. But there is a distinction
- 40:48between what we wrote in our story and then how it gets
- 40:50interpreted by other news, outlets commentators Advocates
- 40:55activists like that kind of thing.
- 40:57And so there are people that I have taken that stat, the 32%
- 41:01Scott, and, you know, they don't couch it or or, you know,
- 41:05describe it the way it's written in both our story and the slides
- 41:09right eye. So it's a little hard for me,
- 41:11too. I don't know.
- 41:13You guys have been in the situation.
- 41:15I'm sure a number of times, like, what happens when someone
- 41:18is saying? Hey, this version of the story
- 41:21that's been circulating is wrong, okay?
- 41:25I really exciting. We've all experienced as
- 41:27reporters is some subject hates the story and they're like, this
- 41:30is false and you're like, well, I've been through it with
- 41:33columns every line of it is factually, true.
- 41:36Like, you guys aren't contesting on anything any individual
- 41:40person, calms or a lawyer would think is false.
- 41:44You know, like isn't that the definition of what truth and
- 41:46falsity is the like all the claims are true and then the
- 41:51subjects and the public are like, well, it reads false to me
- 41:56and I do think we sometimes, you know, for a lot of my Career.
- 41:59I would get lost in the journalistic side of it, but I
- 42:02do think there's there's there's a valid point that if, like,
- 42:05people feel like your article is leading them somewhere, right?
- 42:09Given other facts. They wouldn't believe then
- 42:12there's like a falsity even if obviously all the moves are fair
- 42:17and I as a reporter, obviously I'm sympathetic it's terrible to
- 42:19say some things like false when the lot when it's truly
- 42:22constructed and fair and the journal in particular is very
- 42:25judicious in a way that other outlets aren't.
- 42:28I mean you You read back the Thera, no story, which we've
- 42:30been talking about. Obviously, it really speaks, you
- 42:33know, at the time I'm sure I would have criticized it for
- 42:36pulling its punches. A hated win when Bloomberg would
- 42:39do this, but there is something to be said for the restraint in
- 42:43positioning stuff and then which may be played into, you know,
- 42:46Francis has reason to lie, specifically to the journal.
- 42:48I think she's mentioned that, that she thought that Jeff was a
- 42:51pretty even-handed operator, but I want to go back for a second
- 42:54on the Facebook front because I think what a lot of the wife as
- 42:58we get such an interesting Company on this topic is that
- 43:01there is so much that people personally feel about the
- 43:04company at this point that it almost doesn't matter how nuance
- 43:07and even-handed your story is because once certain conclusions
- 43:10that are in there, get interpreted by the people and
- 43:13get mixed in with their preconceived, notions about
- 43:16things. It's just, it's out of our
- 43:18control as the media and and it really struck me when I was,
- 43:21when I was prepping for the episode with Alex and I went
- 43:24back and I read all the stories about Russia gate that you were
- 43:27by lined on many of And I found the stories to be very
- 43:31even-handed and and not alarmist and just sort of laying out what
- 43:34was in Facebook's report that they were going to be
- 43:37demonstrating to to Congress. And that's the same of the New
- 43:40York Times and the journal and the garden, all these places.
- 43:44But then we see an article by a very smart journalists columnist
- 43:49Margaret Sullivan, who completely Miss interprets, the
- 43:52conclusion of that report who we love.
- 43:54I feel like we've had to criticize her but most of her
- 43:56work, well, we think Great. I said she's smart.
- 44:00Like I think she's great, but she misinterpreted the report
- 44:03and said, we need to come to the realization that had Facebook
- 44:06not have allowed you know, whatever mishegoss on the part
- 44:10of the, you know, Russians to post like you know, spend eighty
- 44:14thousand dollars promoting fault.
- 44:16Fake articles that Donald Trump would not be president, which is
- 44:18not something that Facebook's report ever said, there's no
- 44:20backing of that. And I think what happened here,
- 44:23and what probably happened so often with Facebook, is that a
- 44:26well-reasoned and nuanced story? Gets out there and gets, you
- 44:32know, mixed up in all of the personal issues that people have
- 44:35with the government, with Facebook, with Mark Zuckerberg,
- 44:38with whatever. And and I think it's and I think
- 44:41this is what people don't recognize about the media.
- 44:43When I say people, I mean, like Tech critics is that there's
- 44:45only so much that we can do, because once the sort of stories
- 44:48out there, it's out of our control, it was always amazing
- 44:50to me, you know, I covered a lot of uber, I wrote a lot of the
- 44:54negative stories about Uber, and then I come across people that
- 44:57had such Such a Negative view of Hubert, I didn't share, you know
- 45:03what I mean? Like it is just amazing with
- 45:06like, you're not. I mean, obviously there are
- 45:08other things and people have different sort of moral calculus
- 45:12as but it is interesting that like people can read your body
- 45:15of work and then come to just a much more like yeah, like a
- 45:20finite and a vehement sort of just an activist crowd, has a
- 45:26different sentiment than like reporters do.
- 45:29Do and read this stuff was such like a lens.
- 45:33I think what Tom said, it's sort of speaks to two things.
- 45:36One, the idea of the media, the problem with the media and the
- 45:39reason I hate the moniker, the media is that it clumps
- 45:44reporters and columnists into one group.
- 45:47When reporters and columnists are almost always working at
- 45:49Cross purposes, right? Call us.
- 45:51Call columnists, like, I had this debate with a friend of
- 45:54mine, who's a, he's a columnist, and a thought leader here in
- 45:57Washington DC. And he has like very little
- 46:00regard for reporting. He thinks it's dumb.
- 46:02He thinks that he's the person who controls the conversation,
- 46:04which is fine, because actually I kind of agree with this
- 46:06assessment. But the thing is, is he wouldn't
- 46:09be able to control a conversation.
- 46:10If reporters were not mining facts and bringing them to him.
- 46:13To converse about that said, his job is something that hurts and
- 46:22I would say hurts his job. What it will do is, we'll take
- 46:25attention away from the facts on the ground because he is running
- 46:28it through his Worldview machine.
- 46:30So the idea that the media is this monolith includes both
- 46:35commentary and Reporting. I think it's horrifying, but
- 46:38there seems to be, like, no way to change it like we can like
- 46:41what do we do to undo this knot in the age of Twitter too?
- 46:44Yeah, right. It's like we're all the media.
- 46:46It's like that Gary stronger book, super sad.
- 46:48True love, story, are you Media or you credit?
- 46:51Like, it's like this horrifying World anyway.
- 46:54And then, the other thing is gas.
- 46:56So you have this like view of the media.
- 46:58And then, I think the His view on Facebook, running it through
- 47:01that machine. One of the reasons why we then
- 47:03start depending on these very lazy comparisons.
- 47:06Like the tobacco industry comparison is because it's like
- 47:09one that everyone in the media seems to be able to be
- 47:13comfortable with because there might be some reporting to Bear
- 47:16it out and it's like, easy for Abed writers to kind of use
- 47:20because it's so visceral when they're writing a column, when
- 47:23the tobacco, when those sorts of comparisons are like incredibly
- 47:27lazy and make zero sense, Like at all, you know, tobacco
- 47:30company made cigarettes and push them to people Facebook, created
- 47:34some technology. But the product is made by Deepa
- 47:37and me and Tom and Eric, we're the ones pushing toxic shit to
- 47:42one another. So the only way to you can stop
- 47:45to back the tobacco industry, by shutting down their factories.
- 47:47The only way to stop Facebook is to get all of us off the
- 47:50platform. That's totally different.
- 47:52Well, I don't know about that. Yeah.
- 47:55Right algorithm I think, is, is a complex a fire there?
- 47:58I mean, like, yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
- 48:00The algorithm has a lot of control, but at the end of the
- 48:02day that people creating the real excitement.
- 48:04I actually think, I mean, deep is reacting to this, but Katie's
- 48:06position is very far from. I think deeply you're just say,
- 48:11simply that it's not. I think that might be giving
- 48:15Facebook too much credit. I mean there is this really
- 48:19fascinating story that was in the original series.
- 48:22I wasn't involved in my colleague Keech road and it was
- 48:25a, there's this Eastern European political party that after face,
- 48:29Book changed. Like it's news feed algorithm.
- 48:31They complain to the company and said listen, like before it was
- 48:34like 5050 - positive but ever since you've changed the
- 48:37algorithm like we can't, we like the positive stuff isn't
- 48:40reaching. So we've now shifted to, I think
- 48:4280/20 and like that's an example of like that's not coming,
- 48:47that's a party responding to the to, you know, whatever the
- 48:52record books, whatever the news feed algorithm is promoting,
- 48:55right? You look at these top Facebook
- 48:57content, producers. I mean, they're all spam.
- 48:59It's right. It's clear that if you want to
- 49:01get engagement on Facebook, I mean, buzz buzz.
- 49:04Feeds whole Insight was like chasing the algorithm.
- 49:08You know what? Like I mean obviously there.
- 49:10Oh yeah, I'm not, I'm not I guess what I meant by.
- 49:12That was just that by having that kind of lazy comparison,
- 49:15what it does is it distracts us from any kind of real solution
- 49:19because the comparison implies a solution that does not apply to
- 49:22this industry. Well I don't think the
- 49:25comparison is the solution for tobacco was like well just shut
- 49:28down. In the factories and don't make
- 49:30the cigarettes anymore. So if you're if you're going
- 49:33down that road, well that's not the sky, that solution was that
- 49:37we make the tobacco companies, try to wean people off their
- 49:40product and there is a similarity know that the
- 49:42solution was actually making the product too expensive.
- 49:45The solution was making the product very, very expensive.
- 49:47That was the solution was a market solution.
- 49:49Well, making the product make it less addictive, which Facebook
- 49:51could do. There are a lot of thing.
- 49:53I like, but I like them, but they don't, they never made
- 49:55tobacco's. They never made tobacco.
- 49:57Less addictive, trust me. Will you?
- 49:59Is regulated, right? Well, the amount of nicotine was
- 50:04was brought down but the never made it less addictive.
- 50:07That is a ridiculous thing to say.
- 50:09But the idea that using the metaphor will get you to
- 50:12Solution on social media, I think is just wrong.
- 50:16It's wrong. And yeah, you know, this story
- 50:19and particular, I think really sparked those comparisons, but I
- 50:24just think it's an opening. Look, we want to know more,
- 50:27right? Like I could you guys introduce
- 50:29This that metaphor, is that in the?
- 50:31I do not think we did introduce that metaphor.
- 50:35It was an enterprising. Op-ed columnist, who read the
- 50:38story? Yeah.
- 50:39If you did, we can take it out. But, you know, it's so
- 50:42Blumenthal set it in his, in a comment to us.
- 50:47Marc benioff, said it before you guys even realize, remember, oh,
- 50:50that's pretty awesome. I mean, I don't know if it was
- 50:52the first one but his was after Trump's election.
- 50:55He because, you know, there was this period where all these Tech
- 50:57leaders that were not social. A company's per say we're trying
- 51:00to differentiate themselves from me.
- 51:02Tim Cook, most memorably but benioff also which we I think
- 51:06under plays the fact that you know, Salesforce is my Twitter.
- 51:10Yeah. What else was he just a super
- 51:12addictive product. I mean, I love myself can't get
- 51:15enough of my sales for us but um, but yeah, I know, right?
- 51:20They were gonna be in that game. He was gonna buy the worst one
- 51:22of them all there. We get a by like the absolute
- 51:24like pure distilled Cesspool of the internet, which is I'm gonna
- 51:29ask her cascoon doing question. I feel like we reporters You
- 51:34know, I don't know. There's a strong, especially if
- 51:37you work for a big Outlet to not want to say like that.
- 51:40The story is fully like are tight like you wouldn't change
- 51:43anything. Like there are a lot of
- 51:45institutional. I do think of failure of media
- 51:47is, there's a lot of institutional pressure to say,
- 51:49like stand by every word of the story.
- 51:52We don't change, you know? But is there anything in the
- 51:54Instagram story that you would do differently?
- 51:57Now, sort of just watching all play out knowing that you
- 52:00probably can't say yes but I mean I do think it's an issue
- 52:04with Media that we will never say yes.
- 52:07I don't, you know, I wish I was, I wish had come across more.
- 52:11That I can, I can I look, I wish it and come across at this was
- 52:14based on, not just like one or two internal studies, but
- 52:18several, I wish it went to come across more, was that?
- 52:22Yeah. There's a range of studies.
- 52:23Some of them were small, some of them bow included, tens of
- 52:26thousands of people. I wish that it really is somehow
- 52:30like the idea that we wasn't our our findings, right?
- 52:35Like we aren't quoting ourselves and we're not put, we're using
- 52:40the researchers descriptions. This is what they think it is.
- 52:45I wish that I could write it sort of a hard response.
- 52:47Facebook's is sort of like, it's our research and it's bad,
- 52:51right? That sort of their defense,
- 52:52right? And it's like, then why in
- 52:54should you be headlining research that they think is,
- 52:57like, pretty weak, but do they think it's weak?
- 53:00And I guess the thing is, is that we're looking at five
- 53:03different studies, and I think it's also that point in this One
- 53:06Direction that's where I and I thought this is my thing.
- 53:12I that I really wish to come across.
- 53:14It's just like it. Like even if the Steve's, even
- 53:16if all these studies are really inconclusive.
- 53:18What's really important is what how does the company respond?
- 53:21How does the company like push get decide to to address these
- 53:27issues, maybe they do a big deep study and they find it's a
- 53:30really small number of people, but you remember that even in
- 53:33their Public statements afterwards or like you know even
- 53:36one person who feels that this all started on on Instagram is
- 53:40too many right. So like there's their standard
- 53:43is quite high right? They're not.
- 53:46You know it's not and how they're responding is shutting
- 53:49down all the teams right or just for our reader.
- 53:51Well they outdid the controls right.
- 53:53I mean that happened a couple weeks ago but that's something
- 53:55they could have done years ago. Yeah yeah so they do control
- 53:59type. If a pause they put a pause on
- 54:02Instagram kids although they haven't committed to a We
- 54:05killing it, right? So they're still thinking of
- 54:06going forward with that, but they're going to go slow and you
- 54:12know, Adam Masseria was in front of Congress and there's there's
- 54:14something there have been some changes, they've been some
- 54:17discussions, you're seeing the story, the critical part of how
- 54:20they responded just to spell that out.
- 54:23The part that we've outlined in our story is when presented with
- 54:27different options. They picked an option that
- 54:28didn't necessarily have the biggest mental health impact,
- 54:32but did have a PR impact. Hi.
- 54:34Ding likes, right? But there's a way to frame that
- 54:37as sort of they're doing with the media in Katie's version
- 54:41where it's like this chattering class.
- 54:43That's not very informed, not like necessary with the beat
- 54:45reporters would say they should do what.
- 54:50So right. I mean in some ways like the
- 54:52public and the media chattering class would have thought,
- 54:55removing likes was the best idea and in some ways the media
- 54:59pushes them to to what seems intuitively useful rather.
- 55:04What scientists researchers or smartphone?
- 55:07Right? Think is useful and I mean,
- 55:09that's like all the points I said that, just now that I
- 55:12wanted that, I wish you'd come across more work in the story
- 55:15but there and there's a lot of nuance in the store and there's
- 55:17a I was also surprised by the internal research that showed
- 55:20that removing likes had. No real wasn't really gonna make
- 55:24an impact of that was counterintuitive to me.
- 55:26Yeah. But it means that's the
- 55:29conclusion and you know, I just wish that I do wish as even
- 55:33though it's part of our story. Tori.
- 55:34It's like the part that didn't like a lot of people focus on
- 55:36other aspects of it. I think those are really
- 55:38important and I don't want them to get lost.
- 55:40Right? And, you know, I mean, to finish
- 55:42up on the tobacco thing too. I think there's, there's
- 55:44actually nuance and bringing it up not again because Facebook
- 55:48causes cancer. But again, because this was
- 55:50internal research, that the company ended up sort of
- 55:53ignoring because it was inconvenient to their, to their
- 55:56bottom line, or it'll to them. And again, I think that that's
- 56:00one of those things where it actually is a good metaphor in
- 56:02that sense. But it's not.
- 56:03It's not that The accepted interpretation of it which
- 56:06almost makes you think. It's maybe not a great metaphor
- 56:09but I do want to make sure that we get to one quick thing here
- 56:11because it's super relevant the Deepa.
- 56:13So what's your thoughts on Francis Haugen and and her
- 56:17becoming of a media, a figure because you guys had her
- 56:20Anonymous or the research was given to you by an anonymous
- 56:23person and she is the engine behind all the reporting behind
- 56:27it. And then on the last day she
- 56:29sort of like steps forward and it's going to be testifying for
- 56:31Congress and now you know is on the The, I don't know if the
- 56:34cover but had, you know, photo shoot for Vogue and she's got a
- 56:37rival book with the Wall Street Journal now, they're
- 56:39competitors. I don't think that's not.
- 56:45Yeah, because the Journal of the journal won't Explore her like
- 56:48beliefs and crypto. For example, were you surprised
- 56:52that she decided to come forward in the way that she decided to
- 56:55come forward? And how do you think her
- 56:57becoming a figure impacted the the interpretation of the
- 57:01studies that she made? Yeah, I was, I surprised by the
- 57:08way, she came forward. I mean, I, I, it's what is the
- 57:12playbook for coming forward after you, you know?
- 57:16Like, is there a parallel? Like, I guess I didn't, I didn't
- 57:19know what to expect. Yeah, okay.
- 57:20I mean, I didn't really know what to expect.
- 57:22I didn't really know that like Chelsea Manning also.
- 57:25What, what it would look like for somebody who had what kind
- 57:31of copied all these different documents, and And like how she
- 57:36would? Yeah, I got it.
- 57:37I didn't really know how she would come forward and think
- 57:40about, and present herself. So I didn't it's hard to say
- 57:44whether or not anything surprised me because I like I
- 57:45would just truly just had no expectations.
- 57:47I don't, I don't, you know, think I am your second question.
- 57:52I'm just thinking, like, how does it change the effect of the
- 57:56actual? And I've talked to, I've been
- 57:59talking to a lot of people, what kind of activists who are on the
- 58:03left and people who are on the right, and a lot of people who
- 58:09believe that Facebook needs to be broken up.
- 58:11And one thing that's been very interesting is, like, at least
- 58:14when they're talking to me, what, there's a distinction
- 58:16being drawn between her the figure and the documents you.
- 58:21Right? Like there are she doesn't think
- 58:23that Facebook needs to be broken up.
- 58:25That's not, you know, she actually thinks that would be
- 58:27bad for society, etc, etc. She should make sure like a
- 58:31complicated figure for a lot of the maximalist.
- 58:33Exactly. And, you know, antitrust
- 58:36legislation is like one of those things that there's by part.
- 58:40There are plenty of, by people in both the right and the left
- 58:44who think that Facebook should be broken up, should be reined
- 58:47in all these different ways. And, and You know, she doesn't
- 58:51comport with those beliefs and I think that there is a like so I
- 58:56think that that that is that makes it really complicated but
- 58:59like the actual documents themselves and that's what
- 59:02distinguishes her I think from basically everybody else has
- 59:04come, there been a lot of Facebook dissenters she's come
- 59:06out with with her own opinions and a description of her
- 59:11experiences which I think are really interesting but the but
- 59:14she's got documents. There are a lot of hard evidence
- 59:18of what company internal companies.
- 59:20And so like around these issues and I think plenty of people
- 59:23just separate that they're like, you know what, she's that's
- 59:26great. Thank you so much for the
- 59:27documents. Did she betray The Wall Street
- 59:29Journal? I think that Francis had always
- 59:31wanted these documents to go out there and to be kind of read and
- 59:39interpreted and understood by as many people as possible.
- 59:43I'm pretty grateful. She gave it to us first and let
- 59:47us run with it for as long as we did.
- 59:51I mean it's a fun conversation but like you know, think deeply
- 59:55about some of these Facebook issues on just pure personality
- 59:58level. Just like some fun Facebook.
- 1:00:01Like I know, obviously if you had the full picture, there
- 1:00:05would be a profile of this, maybe you have to hold back some
- 1:00:07but like your general sense of the Mark and Cheryl relationship
- 1:00:12and then Marc Andreessen, and Peter teal to the extent, you
- 1:00:16can you have any observations about the role they play on the
- 1:00:19board just like the Fascinating People and what you're sort of
- 1:00:22gut sense of how, how involved they are right now, what you're,
- 1:00:26what you would tell us. Yeah, I mean I've been reporting
- 1:00:30on both of those topics and it does seem like and the times has
- 1:00:35done some good reporting on the to.
- 1:00:36It's sort of the Mark and Cheryl partnership was always like the
- 1:00:42co-ceo thing. And then it feels like after the
- 1:00:452016 election. There was just a loss of a loss
- 1:00:48of trust or something. There is a fee.
- 1:00:50Feeling of, oh well politics is supposed to be Cheryl's job,
- 1:00:54right? And she maybe dropped the ball,
- 1:00:56but is that a reasonable expectation and picked the wrong
- 1:00:59team and was going to leave for the Hillary Clinton rice?
- 1:01:04And this was, this is like the Dark Universe for her.
- 1:01:07Like you're not supposed to happen this The Darkest Timeline
- 1:01:11and obviously I celebrate her for picking the wrong team, you
- 1:01:14know? I mean but as a pure sort of
- 1:01:18cynical sort of calculating move it.
- 1:01:20Was a loser and but there is a real question to be asked, like
- 1:01:24why was that her job? Why was it all left up to her
- 1:01:27anyway, right? Like that, that isn't really a
- 1:01:29realistic way of structuring a company.
- 1:01:31And so what I think you've seen is rather than like a co-ceo
- 1:01:34thing. She's just become one of the
- 1:01:36Lieutenant's. One of the the one of the things
- 1:01:39that we got through the documentation is, Like or charts
- 1:01:47right? Like see ability to see.
- 1:01:49So one of the so we did this graphic in October that showed
- 1:01:54that over time Cheryl's, share of the company has actually
- 1:01:58shrunk right. She's got cheese to have like a
- 1:02:00lot of people, I don't remember the numbers anymore, but like
- 1:02:03she's to have a big chunk of the company and like, over the last
- 1:02:06five years it's gotten smaller. And like what does that tell you
- 1:02:09about their Partnerships and right?
- 1:02:10And so that I think that that era of the market Cheryl is sort
- 1:02:16of over and it's now just its Mark right there moments.
- 1:02:20During the Cambridge analytic, that's saying we're Cheryl would
- 1:02:22tell her friends. We reported this, I think other
- 1:02:24people reported this. She thought she was thing get
- 1:02:26fired because Mark was really angry about the way in, which
- 1:02:32the company was being portrayed in in media and press whatever.
- 1:02:38And I think that's the cell is just like interesting to me
- 1:02:42because like there's a lot of things that Facebook app.
- 1:02:45Currently thinks her like a lot of Facebook executive thing for
- 1:02:47like, comms problems. And like, hey, if you'd only
- 1:02:50just like explain this properly, then the Press would get it, and
- 1:02:55then they would get off her back, but Some of these issues
- 1:02:59are not comms problems. A lot of these issues our
- 1:03:01product issues, right? And like there's nothing I don't
- 1:03:04know what a common person can really do to like to solve for
- 1:03:08product issue and I think there's like that continuing
- 1:03:11tension continued that is there but you know and I don't know.
- 1:03:17It just does feel like Cheryl has just defeated a lot like
- 1:03:21she's really receded. She's in the back, she's not his
- 1:03:23coat like partnership anymore. At some point during the last
- 1:03:26few years, she's just say something.
- 1:03:28Started to say something, or at least people started to tell me.
- 1:03:30She was saying things like, I serve at the pleasure of Mark
- 1:03:37sad. That's always a good.
- 1:03:38Like he's yeah. I mean that's basically what
- 1:03:41advisors say which right that's her role.
- 1:03:43Now is incredibly diminished from the lean in days.
- 1:03:48Do you have a Peter teal Marc Andreessen take?
- 1:03:51Oh yeah. They teal in particular, I don't
- 1:03:54have like the strongest read on on Entry sins, roll.
- 1:03:58It does feel like he's I mean just from the title of your
- 1:04:01podcast, you know. He's a Mark Zuckerberg booster
- 1:04:04right now while they're well. They're deep in web three
- 1:04:07though. At like Chris Dixon is on
- 1:04:08Twitter shitting on web to while Marc Andreessen is on the board
- 1:04:13of Facebook, they don't name Facebook, but to me, there is a
- 1:04:16sort of, I mean, that's the magic of Andresen that somehow
- 1:04:20don't know. Now, we're seeing Jack Dorsey
- 1:04:21and people sort of fight back against it but that they could
- 1:04:24simultaneously have been responsible or heavily involved.
- 1:04:27And in web to while arguing, that web 3 is an indictment of
- 1:04:32web to is mystified using Facebook, also trying to
- 1:04:36graduate like, isn't aren't there, right?
- 1:04:38Like I don't know, but it may not be a lot and it's, that's
- 1:04:42the kind of thing that I think Marc Andreessen has been has
- 1:04:45also just kind of gotten away. Not, you know, he said a lot of
- 1:04:49things that do remember the whole India thing.
- 1:04:50Yeah. Oh yeah.
- 1:04:52Now where he's like a something about well, like like think it's
- 1:04:55a, oh, how did Independence workout for your economy India?
- 1:04:59Like, when, when Facebook's internet.org got cut, like,
- 1:05:03kicked off the kicked out of the country and ain't there, he had
- 1:05:07to like deleted asshole Twitter and then more storms are ecology
- 1:05:11Market to make an apology. And you don't know core things
- 1:05:13like did Marc Andreessen support Donald Trump?
- 1:05:16Like, I feel like we don't have, there isn't a definitive answer?
- 1:05:20Like, what? I don't know that isn't he is
- 1:05:21avoided Idea to an extent that we don't have clear answers
- 1:05:25about huge, huge things about what about teal though?
- 1:05:30What do you have on him? I think Tails interesting.
- 1:05:32Yeah but he'll we do at morita-ya to is definitely
- 1:05:35interesting teals one of these like there's always like rumor
- 1:05:39as kind of circulating the teal wants to leave the board.
- 1:05:42You know that eels like a disillusion but he stays on the
- 1:05:46board and he is and he is like as far as our reporting goes,
- 1:05:54he's been influential, right? I mean, he is incorrect.
- 1:05:58There was a point when Mark had our Facebook had a couple of
- 1:06:04board members who wanted to create like an independent
- 1:06:06committee that would report to the board.
- 1:06:09And I kind of think through all the different, like, risks and
- 1:06:11issues and whatever that Facebook was going to, that
- 1:06:15might impair or Facebook. And, you know, because the board
- 1:06:19said, no, right? Because this wouldn't report to
- 1:06:21mark, it would report to this. Pennant committee would be
- 1:06:23outside of his control deal. You know, are reporting in our
- 1:06:27understanding is a big reason why Mark has been a big
- 1:06:30encourager of Mark, maintaining that kind of control and making
- 1:06:34sure that he's sort of at the center of everything right?
- 1:06:38He doesn't. And I think there's that's very
- 1:06:41powerful, interesting somewhat mystifying relationship it
- 1:06:44because I'd love to know more. So it's interesting too because
- 1:06:47I've heard the, you know, teal is going to be moving here to
- 1:06:49Washington, and he does still have A lot of influence that he
- 1:06:53managed to grow during the Trump era here with a lot of people
- 1:06:58who will be making decisions about what to do around social
- 1:07:02media companies. And I wonder if that will change
- 1:07:04his relationship with Mark improve his relationship with
- 1:07:09Mark, make them closer. If he continues to try to become
- 1:07:12a Washington player that was Max Shopkin who we've also had on
- 1:07:15this podcast his argument was yeah that Peter Thiel is only
- 1:07:19going to become more politically influential that this is The
- 1:07:22beginning. I'm not sure I'm convinced of
- 1:07:26that yet but it's a provocative thesis.
- 1:07:29Well if you're a Mark Zuckerberg, why not just keep
- 1:07:32him close because that's that could be a very valuable
- 1:07:34relationship for you. And you know Peter also remember
- 1:07:37Peter was there at the beginning a like he knew Mark way back
- 1:07:40when right? He's the first investor one of
- 1:07:42the First Investors in Facebook and big believer and legitimize.
- 1:07:46Ur of the the company and Mark is loyal.
- 1:07:49Like I think he he appreciates and I I think values loyalty and
- 1:07:54I think that factors into their relationship as well.
- 1:07:57Again, these are sources, who described him.
- 1:08:00Directly, I am not talk to Mark directly about this relationship
- 1:08:04so and 20, let's actually end on that note.
- 1:08:06So when's the last time you talked to Mark, what's what was
- 1:08:10your sense of sense of the man? And the way he views things,
- 1:08:14it's been a really long time, you know, I think when he talks
- 1:08:21to, I didn't see you in the Any of the Instagram videos.
- 1:08:24So you have been invited to go. Water are skiing with them, I'm
- 1:08:28sure just got lost. What do I think of him?
- 1:08:31I mean, I think he's, I don't know.
- 1:08:33He's not like, I never. So I know that there's this,
- 1:08:36this reputation for him, like, as a robotic and stuff, but I
- 1:08:41actually never, I don't know if I experienced that.
- 1:08:44Thanks so much for coming on, much like Cheryl scenario.
- 1:08:47We serve at your pleasure as our friend, so thank you.
- 1:08:52For thank you for doing this a loyal listener.
- 1:08:56They yeah, love listening. I actually really do love
- 1:08:59listening to this podcast and I don't say that about a lot of
- 1:09:01podcasts which is interesting, given the fact they've had
- 1:09:04multiple of gas and we ourselves have dissected so many of the
- 1:09:07articles that you have done. And so I appreciate that you've
- 1:09:11continued to listen. Yeah.
- 1:09:13Now no. Now she gets the opportunity,
- 1:09:15you know, when you're like reading a story and you're like
- 1:09:17shouting into nothing about like your response to it.
- 1:09:20Now she is actually like I mean, they're definitely have been a
- 1:09:24couple of moments where it like there is a like, you know, we're
- 1:09:27someone was saying like well did the Instagram thing is based on
- 1:09:30only like a couple of studies or small.
- 1:09:32I wanted to be like, no, it was like five or six studies, one of
- 1:09:37them, tens of thousands of people, but whatever.
- 1:09:40So that's me shouting in fear now.
- 1:09:42Thank you so much stupa. Thank you.
- 1:09:44Yeah. Thanks for having me guys.
- 1:09:58Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:10:00Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:09:58Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:10:00Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.