Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Set Their First Shareholder Letter
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Rivian's stock has dropped about seven percent over the past week, and that got me thinking about the first shareholder letter they wrote after their IPO. Because that letter set a tone, and it's still shaping how investors read the company today. Luna: That's a good angle. First shareholder letters are such a weird hybrid—part annual report, part manifesto. I feel like most investors skim them, but they're actually one of the most deliberate pieces of writing a company ever puts out. Lucas: Exactly. And look, we're not going to dissect Rivian's entire letter, but there's a specific pattern that a lot of tech IPOs follow, and it's worth unpacking. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that's the link—buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Every little bit keeps this show ad-free and going. Luna: Yeah, and we genuinely appreciate that. It's a small way to support what we do here, and it goes a long way. Lucas: So back to the letters. The thing is, a first shareholder letter has to do three jobs at once. It has to thank early believers, it has to set expectations for the next few quarters, and it has to lay out a vision that justifies the IPO price. That's a lot of weight for a few pages. Luna: And most companies get the balance wrong. They either lean too hard into the hype or they get so cautious that they sound like a legal disclaimer. Lucas: Right. Let's talk about Roblox, because their IPO was in early 2021, and their first shareholder letter was almost entirely about the metaverse—before that term became a punchline. They talked about 'human co-experience' and the idea that the platform was a new kind of social space. It was bold, and it worked for a while. But then the market turned, and they had to walk some of that back. Luna: So the letter can actually create a liability if the vision doesn't pan out? That's interesting. I remember reading that their stock got hammered when they missed on user metrics, partly because the narrative had been so focused on growth at all costs. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the tension. You want to inspire, but you also don't want to paint yourself into a corner. Contrast that with a company like Airbnb, which went public a few months before Roblox. Their first letter was more grounded—they talked about the travel industry's recovery, the resilience of their hosts, and a clear path to profitability. They didn't promise the moon, and that's part of why their stock has held up relatively well. Luna: But Airbnb had the advantage of already being profitable, right? I mean, they had a strong brand and a clear business model. A company like Rivian is still in the heavy investment phase, so their letter has to acknowledge that they're burning cash while still convincing investors it's worth it. Lucas: Right. And Rivian's letter did that really well, actually. They were upfront about the challenges of scaling production, but they framed it as a marathon, not a sprint. They even used the phrase 'the long road to a sustainable future'—which is both a nod to their trucks and a signal that they're not just chasing quarterly numbers. Luna: So it's about managing expectations without dampening enthusiasm. How do you actually craft that? I've seen some founders say they write multiple drafts and get input from everyone from lawyers to PR folks. Lucas: Yeah, and that process matters. But there's a formula underneath it. One, you lead with your mission—why you exist. Two, you acknowledge the market reality—what's happened since the S-1. Three, you outline your strategy for the next few years. And four, you close with a forward-looking statement that leaves investors wanting more. Luna: And the order changes depending on the company. If you're a unicorn that's gone through a down round, you might lead with the market reality to reset expectations. If you're a high-growth company, you might lead with the mission to build excitement. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a real skill to matching the tone to the circumstances. Take a company like Palantir—they didn't even do a traditional IPO, they went with a direct listing. Their first shareholder letter was famously long, almost like a philosophical essay, and it doubled down on their contrarian identity. That worked because their investors were already bought into that story. Luna: So the letter is really a reflection of the company's culture. I think that's why so many of them feel samey—because a lot of tech founders read the same playbooks and use the same buzzwords. Lucas: There's some truth to that. But the best ones find a way to be specific. Instead of saying 'we're building a platform for the future,' they talk about a specific customer problem they solved last quarter. That's what makes a letter memorable and credible. Luna: And what about the numbers? How much financial detail should a first letter include? Because you'd think the 10-K has all that, but some letters go into surprising depth. Lucas: That's a great question. The letter is not the place to rehash the numbers—that's what the financial statements are for. But you do want to highlight a few key metrics that support your narrative. For example, if you're a SaaS company, you might talk about your net revenue retention rate, because that speaks to the quality of your customer base. You don't need to list every number, but you should pick the ones that tell your story. Luna: So it's about curation, not completeness. And I guess that's why some letters fail—they try to be all things to all people, and they end up being nothing to anyone. Lucas: Exactly. And there's another layer: the letter is also a signal to employees. A good letter can reinforce the company culture and remind everyone why they're working so hard. Some CEOs even include a section specifically addressing employees, telling them they're the reason for the success. Luna: That's true. I've seen letters that read more like a company-wide email than a shareholder update. But I suppose that's intentional—you want to motivate your team, and you want investors to see that you have a motivated team. Lucas: Right. And that's part of the genius of a well-written letter—it serves multiple audiences at once. The investors are reading for strategy, the employees are reading for validation, and the media is reading for a hook. If you can satisfy all three, you've done something pretty remarkable. Luna: So what are some common mistakes you see in first letters? Besides being too generic, I mean. Lucas: One is being too defensive. If your stock has dropped since the IPO, you might be tempted to address the decline head-on. But a letter that spends too much time justifying short-term performance can erode confidence. Better to acknowledge the volatility briefly and then pivot to the long-term plan. Luna: And another mistake is overpromising timetables. Some letters say things like 'we'll be profitable by 2024' or 'we'll launch in 20 countries by next year.' And then when they miss those targets, the market punishes them. Lucas: Right. One of the most famous examples is Tesla's early letters. They had a tendency to set ambitious timelines for Model 3 production, and they consistently missed them. But because Musk had built such a strong narrative, investors gave him slack. Most CEOs don't have that luxury. Luna: So the letter has to match the CEO's credibility. If you're a first-time founder, you might want to be more conservative. If you have a track record like Musk, you can afford to be bolder. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why it's so important for the letter to be authentic to the founders' personality. If the letter sounds like it was written by a PR firm, investors can tell. They want to hear from the person who's actually leading the company. Luna: So how do you think the role of the first shareholder letter is changing? With social media and quarterly earnings calls, is it still as important as it used to be? Lucas: I think it's more important, actually. Because there's so much noise out there, a well-crafted letter can cut through and set the record straight. It's a chance to tell your story on your terms, without the filter of analysts or reporters. And it's also a document that gets referenced for years—people will quote it in future coverage. Luna: That's a good point. I've seen analysts pull lines from a company's IPO letter in their reports years later, just to check if the company delivered on what it promised. Lucas: Exactly. So the first letter is almost like a founding document. It sets the terms of the relationship between the company and its public shareholders. And if you get it right, it can build a foundation of trust that lasts for decades. If you get it wrong, you're playing catch-up from day one. Luna: So for a founder listening right now who's preparing for their own IPO, what's the one thing you'd tell them to focus on? Lucas: Be honest about your business, but also be honest about your ambitions. Don't hide the challenges, but don't undersell what you're trying to build. And remember that your letter is not just for the investors—it's for your future self, as a record of why you started this company in the first place. Luna: That's a nice way to think about it. And I guess it's a reminder that the letter is a reflection of the company's values, not just a financial document. Lucas: Right. And that's what makes the best letters stand out—they're not just about the money, they're about the mission. And if you can capture that in a few pages, you've done something genuinely valuable for your company.