Latest / Bloomberg Law / The Legal Fight Over the Abortion Pill
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio Today.
- 0:09Speaker 2: South Carolina Supreme Court reversed a decision made in January
- 0:14Speaker 2: and allowed the state's six week abortion ban to take effect.
- 0:18Speaker 2: Why the reversal, The only female justice who wrote the
- 0:22Speaker 2: January opinion retired, leaving an all male bench. As state
- 0:27Speaker 2: abortion bans multiply, the legal battle over the abortion drug
- 0:31Speaker 2: MIFA pristone becomes more important for access to abortion, and
- 0:35Speaker 2: the conservative Fifth Circuit has turned back the clock and
- 0:39Speaker 2: rolled back FDA regulations which made the drug more widely available.
- 0:44Speaker 2: The fight over the abortion pill will end at the
- 0:46Speaker 2: Supreme Court, and April order from the court effectively keeps
- 0:50Speaker 2: the existing MIFA pristone regulations in place until the High
- 0:54Speaker 2: Court rules again on the matter or refuses to hear.
- 0:57Speaker 1: The case on appeal.
- 0:59Speaker 2: White House Press Secretary Carene Jean Pierre says, the Biden
- 1:02Speaker 2: administration is prepared to fight to keep myth A pristone
- 1:06Speaker 2: readily available.
- 1:08Speaker 3: What we're saying is we're prepared for a long legal fight,
- 1:13Speaker 3: and that's the promise that we can make to millions
- 1:15Speaker 3: of women across the country. Right now.
- 1:17Speaker 2: My guest is Mary Ziegler, a professor at the UC
- 1:19Speaker 2: Davis School of Law. This was a divided ruling explain
- 1:23Speaker 2: what the Fifth Circuit did, So this is.
- 1:26Speaker 3: Obviously in the middle of litigation. So one thing to
- 1:28Speaker 3: be clear about at the outset is that the Fifth
- 1:31Speaker 3: Circuit did not actually change the situation on the ground.
- 1:33Speaker 3: So the US Supreme Court is issue to stay in
- 1:36Speaker 3: this case that happened last spring. That date basically freezes
- 1:39Speaker 3: the status quo with respect him if for pristone, as
- 1:42Speaker 3: the litigation probably continues on the merits to the Supreme Court.
- 1:45Speaker 3: But the Fifth Circuit was weighing in this time not
- 1:47Speaker 3: on whether to grant to stay, but on whether the
- 1:50Speaker 3: outcome should be similar when the case is resolved on
- 1:53Speaker 3: the merits. So the majority held that on the merits,
- 1:58Speaker 3: the FDA lacked the authority to change the rules on
- 2:01Speaker 3: methachristone in both twenty sixteen and twenty twenty one, so
- 2:05Speaker 3: they would have essentially turned the clock back to before
- 2:07Speaker 3: twenty sixteen and reimposed a lot of restrictions on methachristone.
- 2:12Speaker 3: We also had an opinion by Judge Hoe, concurring and
- 2:15Speaker 3: dissenting in part that would have gone even further in
- 2:18Speaker 3: a few different ways.
- 2:19Speaker 2: Yeah. So this was a very conservative panel of two
- 2:22Speaker 2: Trump appointees, one George W. Bush appointee and Judge Ho
- 2:27Speaker 2: if he wanted to invalidate the whole thing, the FDA approval, correct.
- 2:32Speaker 3: Yeah, I'm not sure any of the judges really thought
- 2:34Speaker 3: the FDA had the approval authority in two thousand. But
- 2:38Speaker 3: the majority simply thought that the plantiffs had brought the
- 2:40Speaker 3: case too late, that they didn't have any justification for
- 2:44Speaker 3: waiting as long as they did to challenge an approval
- 2:46Speaker 3: that came almost, you know, twenty five years ago. At
- 2:49Speaker 3: this point, Judge Hoe disagreed on that point and said
- 2:51Speaker 3: the FDA had never had the authority to approve mithopristone
- 2:54Speaker 3: in the first place. He also added a lot of
- 2:57Speaker 3: thoughts on the Federal Comstock Act, which the majority declined
- 3:00Speaker 3: really to discuss at any kind of length.
- 3:03Speaker 2: So, the FDA is the agency that approves drugs. Why
- 3:06Speaker 2: do they think that the FDA doesn't have authority to
- 3:09Speaker 2: approve MIFA pristone.
- 3:10Speaker 3: So the argument is that the FDA proceeded under Subpart H,
- 3:15Speaker 3: which is a regulation that allows for somewhat expedited approval
- 3:18Speaker 3: of drugs and the plaintiffs in this case, and ultimately
- 3:22Speaker 3: Judge Hoe believed that the subpart each authority wasn't appropriate because,
- 3:26Speaker 3: as they argued, pregnancy isn't a disease. Judge ho said,
- 3:30Speaker 3: it isn't a condition in the sense that Subpart EH means,
- 3:33Speaker 3: it's sort of a normal right of passage. And he
- 3:36Speaker 3: also added that as the plaintiffs did, that MYTHI pristone,
- 3:40Speaker 3: in their view, is not safer than the alternative methods
- 3:44Speaker 3: of abortions. So for both of those reasons, they argued,
- 3:47Speaker 3: Judge Hoke ultimately concluded that the FDA didn't have the
- 3:50Speaker 3: authority to approve MIA pristone in two thousand.
- 3:53Speaker 2: Did they have any scientific backing for saying that MiFi
- 3:57Speaker 2: pristone isn't safer than let's say, it's surgical abortion.
- 4:01Speaker 3: Not much, right, I mean, this is a case where
- 4:04Speaker 3: the majority's criticisms of the FDA were essentially that they
- 4:07Speaker 3: weren't thorough enough, not that they were wrong necessarily, but
- 4:10Speaker 3: that they could have gathered more evidence, or they should
- 4:12Speaker 3: have relied on different studies, or they didn't have essentially
- 4:16Speaker 3: holding the FDA to a higher standard than usually would
- 4:19Speaker 3: apply to drug approvals or lifting of restrictions. I think
- 4:22Speaker 3: Judge host concerns were more almost sort of linguistic, right
- 4:26Speaker 3: that if you don't think pregnancy is a disease, the
- 4:29Speaker 3: safety profile mythriystone becomes less important, right, because that's one
- 4:33Speaker 3: of the concerns that Judge Hoe really prioritized in his opinion.
- 4:37Speaker 3: I think this is an example where you know, the
- 4:39Speaker 3: science is getting either contested or ignored.
- 4:42Speaker 2: And just for those who are not familiar, tell us
- 4:46Speaker 2: about you know, the importance of mythi priss stone to
- 4:49Speaker 2: those seeking an abortion.
- 4:51Speaker 3: And methipriston is important in more than one way. It's
- 4:54Speaker 3: one of the drugs that's used in a majority of
- 4:56Speaker 3: abortions in the United States. Pill based abortions are also
- 4:59Speaker 3: in important from the standpoint of access in states where
- 5:02Speaker 3: abortion is criminal, because there are nonprofit organizations that are
- 5:06Speaker 3: willing to send abortion pills into states even if doing
- 5:09Speaker 3: so is criminal. Obviously, if those pills are not available,
- 5:12Speaker 3: it becomes much harder for nonprofits to circumvent those laws.
- 5:16Speaker 3: We've seen proposals for an alternative where myth of pristone
- 5:20Speaker 3: to become one available. The other drug in that protocol
- 5:23Speaker 3: is called misiprostal. So some providers are already preparing for
- 5:28Speaker 3: misiprostal only abortions, which are possible. They're not as effective.
- 5:33Speaker 3: They're safe, but they have more complications and they're less
- 5:36Speaker 3: effective than the current standard protocol. So that's the possibility
- 5:40Speaker 3: should things come out a certain way. When all is
- 5:43Speaker 3: said and done.
- 5:44Speaker 2: Let's just say, at the end of the road, this
- 5:47Speaker 2: goes against the FDA, Could the FDA just start another
- 5:52Speaker 2: process and improvem if a priystone, you know, through a
- 5:55Speaker 2: full process.
- 5:56Speaker 3: Yeah. Absolutely, that would be very time consuming. Even on
- 6:00Speaker 3: the fifth Circuit, if the majority's decision were to hold
- 6:03Speaker 3: that is the same myth of pristone didn't have to
- 6:05Speaker 3: be withdrawn and could be taken under the pre twenty
- 6:07Speaker 3: sixteen protocol. Even that would cause a lot of chaos
- 6:10Speaker 3: because it's not clear if all the existing MITHI pristone
- 6:13Speaker 3: would need to be relabeled, and also, you know, people
- 6:15Speaker 3: would have to make multiple in person visits to a physician.
- 6:19Speaker 3: The FDA couldn't theory reapprove MITHRA pristone. It's just that
- 6:22Speaker 3: that process, especially if it's not the accelerated process, would
- 6:26Speaker 3: be time consuming and also would be politically uncertain of course,
- 6:29Speaker 3: because we've seen you know, Republican presidential candidates signaling disapproval
- 6:33Speaker 3: of MITHI pristone. Then they might have an interest in
- 6:35Speaker 3: reshaping FDA to make that kind of approval process either
- 6:38Speaker 3: slower or impossible.
- 6:40Speaker 2: When the District judges ruling came out, you know, many
- 6:43Speaker 2: legal experts thought it wasn't in line with precedent. It
- 6:47Speaker 2: was sort of in left field. Maybe I shouldn't say
- 6:50Speaker 2: right field, because the judge is known for being anti
- 6:53Speaker 2: abortion and anti LGBTQ. It reminds me of the Obamacare decision,
- 6:58Speaker 2: where there was an outlier judge who made this ruling
- 7:01Speaker 2: and everyone thought that, okay, the Fifth Circuit will knock
- 7:04Speaker 2: it down, and then we ended up with years of
- 7:06Speaker 2: litigation over that judge's ruling.
- 7:10Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, I think what we are seeing both
- 7:12Speaker 3: in Judge Matthew tasmerick u is the District judge ruling,
- 7:14Speaker 3: and honestly in Judge Hose ruling, which has struck others
- 7:17Speaker 3: as very extreme. It's kind of a shifting of the
- 7:19Speaker 3: Overton windows. So once a conservative judge steaks out a
- 7:22Speaker 3: position that in right field, as you said, instead of
- 7:25Speaker 3: other conservative judges saying that's a bridge too far, We're
- 7:28Speaker 3: not going to do that. Instead, we've seen them come
- 7:30Speaker 3: back with decisions that are also really sweeping and unusual,
- 7:34Speaker 3: but less so than the original right or less so
- 7:36Speaker 3: like contrast to Judge Hose ruling. And I think that
- 7:39Speaker 3: creates a new normal for the judiciary where conservative courts
- 7:42Speaker 3: are going to go further whether it comes to things
- 7:44Speaker 3: like standing or merits or abortion access, but they're going
- 7:47Speaker 3: to frame it as if they're not right because they're
- 7:50Speaker 3: not going as far as some of their colleagues.
- 7:52Speaker 2: And just to be clear, they're making these decisions when
- 7:56Speaker 2: the merits of the case haven't even been.
- 7:58Speaker 3: Litigated yet, right, I mean, especially on the original opinion
- 8:02Speaker 3: by Judge kas Merrick was just a stay ruling. So
- 8:06Speaker 3: there's a lot that can happen in these kinds of
- 8:08Speaker 3: situations where we don't have yet merits rulings. Then we
- 8:11Speaker 3: don't have The only guidance we have from the US
- 8:14Speaker 3: Supreme Court is that there's been a stay issue, right,
- 8:17Speaker 3: So the signs are not full steam ahead even from
- 8:20Speaker 3: the US Supreme Court, and yet this is still the
- 8:22Speaker 3: kind of outcome we'rece theme.
- 8:23Speaker 2: I was wondering that and I was wondering whether I
- 8:25Speaker 2: was reading too much into the Supreme Courts deciding to
- 8:30Speaker 2: keep mifor pristone fully available as the litigation plays out,
- 8:34Speaker 2: because it seemed like the Justices might be sending a message.
- 8:37Speaker 1: To the Fifth Circuit not to go out on a limb.
- 8:39Speaker 3: Again, Yeah, I mean, we don't know entirely, right, because
- 8:43Speaker 3: when the Supreme Court issues a stay like that, they
- 8:45Speaker 3: don't explain why. We don't know who voted, how beyond
- 8:49Speaker 3: the fact that some of the justices recorded the sense,
- 8:52Speaker 3: so they're just Justice Alito and Justice Thomas. Other than that,
- 8:56Speaker 3: we can just read between the lines. The one thing
- 8:58Speaker 3: we do know is that one of the factors in
- 9:00Speaker 3: granting estay is who's likely to prevail on the merits.
- 9:03Speaker 3: So the Supreme Court is thinking about that right, They
- 9:06Speaker 3: have to think about that in granting estay, and so
- 9:08Speaker 3: we can infer that at least as of last spring,
- 9:11Speaker 3: there were a majority of the justices who thought the
- 9:13Speaker 3: plaintiffs were ultimately going to loose this case.
- 9:16Speaker 2: This ruling would interfere with states where abortion is legal,
- 9:21Speaker 2: and Justice Brett Kavanaugh said the court had to be
- 9:24Speaker 2: scrupulously neutral since he's a pivotal vote on abortion.
- 9:29Speaker 1: How much depends on him sticking to that.
- 9:32Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, I think that's part of what's going on.
- 9:34Speaker 3: I mean, I think honestly most of what will happen
- 9:36Speaker 3: in this case will depend on if the plaintiffs has standing,
- 9:39Speaker 3: because this is a case that, regardless of what you
- 9:41Speaker 3: think about the merits, just has very very weak procedurally.
- 9:45Speaker 3: So I think it's fairly easy for someone like Kavanaugh
- 9:48Speaker 3: who would be torn. I think, on the one hand,
- 9:50Speaker 3: between the fact that he probably is sympathetic to the
- 9:52Speaker 3: plaintiff's arguments and the fact that he said he was
- 9:55Speaker 3: going to remain neutral as the Constitution is in his
- 9:59Speaker 3: view on a version, he may not even need to
- 10:01Speaker 3: go there with this case because it is so procedurally defective,
- 10:04Speaker 3: it will be easy to just say, you know, sorry,
- 10:06Speaker 3: I can't really get into it because you people don't
- 10:09Speaker 3: have standing, and leave.
- 10:10Speaker 2: It at best, explain the standing issue as far as
- 10:13Speaker 2: the plaintiffs here.
- 10:14Speaker 3: Sure. So, the plaintiffs here are a group of anti
- 10:17Speaker 3: abortion doctors. They are in a group called the Alliance
- 10:20Speaker 3: for Hippocratic Medicine, and standing, as most people remember, sort
- 10:24Speaker 3: of has to do with whether you were actually injured
- 10:26Speaker 3: by a law, whether you have enough skin in the
- 10:28Speaker 3: game to be in court challenging it. And the problem
- 10:31Speaker 3: for these doctors essentially is that they're speculating that they're
- 10:34Speaker 3: going to have an injury in the future, and that
- 10:36Speaker 3: was ultimately the conclusion drawn by the Fifth Circuits. So essentially,
- 10:39Speaker 3: with the Circuits said, well, mith a pristone is a drug,
- 10:41Speaker 3: It's complication rate isn't zero. So some percentage of people
- 10:44Speaker 3: who take mitha pristone are going to have complications. Some
- 10:47Speaker 3: percentage of those people are going to go not to
- 10:50Speaker 3: their original provider but to the emergency room, and some
- 10:53Speaker 3: percentage of those people are going to end up in
- 10:55Speaker 3: front of these specific doctors as opposed to other doctors
- 10:58Speaker 3: who don't have objections to ortion in the same emergency room,
- 11:02Speaker 3: and assuming these places are even going to be in
- 11:03Speaker 3: the emergency room. So it's sort of in prints upon
- 11:06Speaker 3: inference upon infernce, a lot of which aren't really very convincing.
- 11:09Speaker 3: So ordinarily, especially conservative judges are much more demanding than
- 11:13Speaker 3: that when finding standing. So most people are speculating that
- 11:17Speaker 3: there reason the Supreme Court granted this stay was just
- 11:20Speaker 3: because that case for standing is really hard to make
- 11:23Speaker 3: with this straight face, and.
- 11:24Speaker 2: I assume the pharmaceutical industry would be up in arms
- 11:27Speaker 2: because the court would be interfering with the FDA approval
- 11:31Speaker 2: of a drug.
- 11:32Speaker 3: Yeah, and also opening the door, by the way, to
- 11:35Speaker 3: a lot of lawsuits about drug approval because the argument
- 11:38Speaker 3: that I just made about standing, you know, mythipristone doesn't
- 11:42Speaker 3: have a very high complication rate. The New York Times
- 11:44Speaker 3: reviewed I think over one hundred studies on the drug
- 11:47Speaker 3: and found the complication rate was aboutzero point three percent.
- 11:50Speaker 3: So if the standard is any drug with a complication
- 11:53Speaker 3: rate you know, around what mythipristones is or higher, it's
- 11:57Speaker 3: hard to see how you couldn't have acted. This group's
- 12:00Speaker 3: challenging the approval of any drug.
- 12:03Speaker 2: How would they enforce a ban on MIFA pristone being
- 12:07Speaker 2: sent through the mail If organizations in blue states where
- 12:11Speaker 2: abortion is legal decide to, you know, send out MIFA pristone.
- 12:16Speaker 3: Well, we're the court to ultimately conclude that the FDA
- 12:21Speaker 3: didn't have the authority to approve myth a pristone, or alternatively,
- 12:25Speaker 3: that it violates the Federal Comstock Act for the FDA
- 12:28Speaker 3: to mail myth apristone, then it would really come down
- 12:31Speaker 3: to federal law enforcement enforcing it. So the FDA itself
- 12:34Speaker 3: has enforcement authority and could theoretically prosecute people in blue
- 12:38Speaker 3: states for continuing to mail a drug that was unapproved.
- 12:42Speaker 3: Were the Comstock Act argument to be vindicated and you
- 12:45Speaker 3: had a Republican in the White House, the DOJ could
- 12:48Speaker 3: do the same. So I think the common denominator there
- 12:51Speaker 3: you're seeing is a lot depends on who's in the
- 12:53Speaker 3: White House. And that's one of, you know, my great
- 12:55Speaker 3: frustrations as a watcher of all of this is that
- 12:58Speaker 3: we're not hearing republic candidates asked about that. We're not
- 13:02Speaker 3: hearing them asked about Comstock or FDA or the things
- 13:05Speaker 3: that interior Republican president could actually do. We're hearing hypotheticals
- 13:09Speaker 3: about bans at ten weeks, six weeks, you know, twelve weeks,
- 13:12Speaker 3: none of which are going to pass. But I think
- 13:14Speaker 3: we're seeing in this litigation and possibilities that really could
- 13:17Speaker 3: be transformative. We're a Republican to be in office.
- 13:19Speaker 1: Let's start to the states for a moment.
- 13:21Speaker 2: These fights over abortion are going on in both state
- 13:25Speaker 2: and federal courts. What's the difference for those bringing these lawsuits.
- 13:30Speaker 3: I think we've seen a deliberate attempt on the part
- 13:32Speaker 3: of abortion rights supporters to focus on state court and
- 13:35Speaker 3: challenging state bans, in part because state constitutional traditions could
- 13:40Speaker 3: be more expansive than the federal law, and because you know,
- 13:43Speaker 3: the conservative Supreme Court is unlikely to be sympathetic to
- 13:46Speaker 3: arguments that abortion bans are unconstitutional. Conversely, we've seen other
- 13:51Speaker 3: efforts by conservative lawyers to bring things into federal court
- 13:54Speaker 3: on the Comstock Act, which is a part of the
- 13:55Speaker 3: Smith of Pristone case, is also part of a whole
- 13:58Speaker 3: bunch of other cases actually coming from blue states, where
- 14:01Speaker 3: we've seen conservative lawyers fighting for local laws banning abortion
- 14:06Speaker 3: and saying that the state, the blue state, has to
- 14:09Speaker 3: comply with federal law, namely the Comstock Act. So we're
- 14:12Speaker 3: seeing I think, a kind of chess match in terms
- 14:14Speaker 3: of which court, which movement wants to.
- 14:16Speaker 1: Be in wichapel at. State courts have ruled on abortion.
- 14:22Speaker 3: So we've heard from the Idaho Supreme Court to South
- 14:24Speaker 3: Carolina Supreme Court, the Oklahoma Supreme Court. There's litigation pending
- 14:30Speaker 3: in other state supreme courts. We've also heard from state
- 14:33Speaker 3: supreme courts that haven't changed their minds, like the Montana
- 14:36Speaker 3: Supreme Court, and we have litigation pending in any number
- 14:39Speaker 3: of places as well, Utah, Iowa. So this is a
- 14:43Speaker 3: very active issue in state supreme courts, and we've seen,
- 14:47Speaker 3: you know, mixed results, but I would say surprisingly good
- 14:50Speaker 3: results for abortion rights supporters, given that almost all of
- 14:54Speaker 3: the courts where this litigation is happening are quite conservative.
- 14:57Speaker 2: Even in states like Kansas and Kentucky where there was
- 15:00Speaker 2: a lot of hoop law because the voters defeated ballot
- 15:04Speaker 2: questions that would have found no right to abortion in
- 15:07Speaker 2: the state constitution. But even in those states, the bands
- 15:11Speaker 2: on abortion are still in place, right, Yeah, Well, and.
- 15:14Speaker 3: So there's been I think in those ballot initiative states
- 15:18Speaker 3: there's often been. So Kansas doesn't have a ban. Kentucky's
- 15:21Speaker 3: vote was a little bit different because Kentucky was voting
- 15:24Speaker 3: not to declare that the state constitution had no abortion rights. Essentially,
- 15:28Speaker 3: Kentucky voters were saying, we're going to leave it up
- 15:30Speaker 3: to our Supreme Court to figure out, we're not going
- 15:32Speaker 3: to pre judge, so that state's abortion ban remains in place.
- 15:35Speaker 3: Other states like Michigan had abortion bans and voted for
- 15:39Speaker 3: ballot initiatives that wipe them away. So I think we're
- 15:41Speaker 3: seeing that it's not just whether or not you have
- 15:44Speaker 3: a ballot initiative, it's what ballot initiative you have. So,
- 15:49Speaker 3: for example, in Ohio, coming this November, voters are looking
- 15:53Speaker 3: at a substantive measure that would actually create abortion rights
- 15:56Speaker 3: and also likely not wipe.
- 15:58Speaker 4: The law off the books, but to its removal.
- 16:01Speaker 3: Likely by a court that strikes it down down the road.
- 16:04Speaker 2: I mean, this is why the legal landscape as far
- 16:07Speaker 2: as abortion is concerned, is so confusing to people. It's
- 16:11Speaker 2: just it's hard to keep up with it, even if
- 16:14Speaker 2: you're trying.
- 16:15Speaker 3: It is I mean, it's constantly changing, and I mean
- 16:17Speaker 3: I think that that's probably the most important thing people
- 16:20Speaker 3: can do when trying to keep up with this is
- 16:23Speaker 3: to realize that whatever snapshot you have is just that
- 16:26Speaker 3: it's not a forever thing. That the law can and
- 16:29Speaker 3: will change. And I think that makes it important for
- 16:34Speaker 3: people who really care about this issue to continue to,
- 16:36Speaker 3: you know, think about it when they're going to the polls,
- 16:38Speaker 3: in particular, because this is not a situation where something
- 16:41Speaker 3: will be resolved and you can simply put it on
- 16:43Speaker 3: the back burner and ignore it in pavor of other issues.
- 16:46Speaker 3: It's going to continue coming up.
- 16:47Speaker 2: Well, you certainly have an encyclopedic knowledge about abortion law,
- 16:52Speaker 2: and as always I appreciate your sharing it with us.
- 16:55Speaker 1: That's Professor Mary Ziegler of the UC Davis Law School.
- 17:00Speaker 3: Well, mister Reid, do we have an agreement on custody
- 17:04Speaker 3: or not?
- 17:05Speaker 2: No, I see.
- 17:09Speaker 3: In that case, there will be a custody hearing on
- 17:12Speaker 3: the nineteenth at nine am.
- 17:14Speaker 4: Court is adjourn.
- 17:17Speaker 2: Whether it's the comedy Liar Liar or the drama marriage Story,
- 17:22Speaker 2: movies about divorce have a lot of common themes, but
- 17:25Speaker 2: one theme that none of them have is a couple
- 17:29Speaker 2: not being able to get a divorce because of a
- 17:31Speaker 2: shortage of judges. But that's exactly the situation in New
- 17:35Speaker 2: Jersey where there's a backlog of nearly four thousand divorce cases,
- 17:40Speaker 2: delays of many years, and blocks on any divorce trials
- 17:44Speaker 2: in several counties, all because there aren't enough judges. Joining
- 17:49Speaker 2: me is Alex Ebert Bloomberg Laws senior correspondent who's investigated
- 17:53Speaker 2: this tell us generally about the backlog of divorce and
- 17:59Speaker 2: family law cases in New Jersey.
- 18:02Speaker 4: So The backlog of cases in New Jersey ebbs and
- 18:04Speaker 4: flows over the years because of its unique political process,
- 18:08Speaker 4: But right now there's a serious crunch throughout the state
- 18:11Speaker 4: in both divorce and family law cases. There are a
- 18:15Speaker 4: backlog of more than four seven hundred family law cases
- 18:20Speaker 4: in an additional four thousand divorce and separation proceedings that
- 18:25Speaker 4: are really really posing problems to family attorneys.
- 18:29Speaker 2: The state's chief Justice has stopped civil and matrimonial trials
- 18:34Speaker 2: in several counties, but are they moving ahead in other
- 18:38Speaker 2: counties or has it all come to a complete stop
- 18:41Speaker 2: barely so.
- 18:42Speaker 4: I've spoken with many attorneys in the state but are
- 18:45Speaker 4: just woefully sad about the situation. It's come to the
- 18:49Speaker 4: point where it's difficult to get any trial at all
- 18:52Speaker 4: moving forward in a contested divorce case. And it's because
- 18:56Speaker 4: there's so few judges to handle these matters that the
- 19:00Speaker 4: judges on the bench, no matter which count you're in,
- 19:04Speaker 4: have to prioritize the emergencies that come before them in
- 19:07Speaker 4: family law cases over these divorced and separation proceedings. And
- 19:11Speaker 4: so if it's someone an abusive relationship, or if it's
- 19:16Speaker 4: an emergency over something that might cause harm to a child,
- 19:19Speaker 4: then you're going to have that pop up and sort
- 19:21Speaker 4: of interfere with the ability to run a trial. Then
- 19:24Speaker 4: if you take that compounding issue over years of people
- 19:28Speaker 4: not being appointed to these judge ships, you just get
- 19:30Speaker 4: a backlog of so many cases it's impossible to get
- 19:34Speaker 4: anything done.
- 19:35Speaker 2: One lawyer told you it's like families are stuck in limbo.
- 19:39Speaker 2: Another that children are living in toxic environments.
- 19:43Speaker 3: Yeah, these are.
- 19:44Speaker 4: Really sad stories, June, and it can be anything from
- 19:48Speaker 4: you know, families where mom and dad are fighting, to
- 19:51Speaker 4: situations where a parent can't move their kid into a
- 19:55Speaker 4: school district because they can't get an order from a court.
- 19:58Speaker 4: Sometimes these issues written to the family structure completely. There's
- 20:03Speaker 4: a couple instances where folks are scared that one a
- 20:07Speaker 4: strange partner is going to take the passport of a
- 20:10Speaker 4: child and actually kidnap them out of the country, which
- 20:13Speaker 4: would make it very difficult to get the child back.
- 20:16Speaker 4: And since publishing this piece, I've actually had people reach
- 20:19Speaker 4: out to me with similar stories and it can be
- 20:22Speaker 4: really heartbreaking to hear what these families are going through.
- 20:25Speaker 2: So let's talk about the big question, why are there
- 20:28Speaker 2: so many judicial vacancies in New Jersey.
- 20:32Speaker 4: So there are a few factors, and I'll lay them
- 20:35Speaker 4: out for you, but the largest one is this unique
- 20:38Speaker 4: political process New Jersey has called senatorial currency. So we
- 20:42Speaker 4: know about the blue slip system in the federal court, right,
- 20:46Speaker 4: so home senators can refuse to allow the appointment of
- 20:50Speaker 4: a judge in their home state. The same thing applies
- 20:54Speaker 4: in New Jersey, but for the counties. But the strange,
- 20:58Speaker 4: unique thing about New Jersey is that there are often
- 21:02Speaker 4: more than one state senator that lives in a particular county,
- 21:06Speaker 4: and so these state senators can use this ability to
- 21:09Speaker 4: block a nomination to get something else out of the
- 21:12Speaker 4: governor's team or other senators.
- 21:16Speaker 1: So is this courtesy?
- 21:19Speaker 2: Is it part of any law? Is it part of
- 21:21Speaker 2: a regulation? Is it just a practice that people honor.
- 21:26Speaker 4: It is so fascinating when you raise that question with
- 21:29Speaker 4: people in the know. It's a mix of these things.
- 21:32Speaker 3: Right.
- 21:32Speaker 4: There's no law that it points to, so it's sort
- 21:35Speaker 4: of an unspoken agreement among the Senate and it's recognized
- 21:40Speaker 4: and respected by the rest of the state government. And
- 21:43Speaker 4: back in the nineties, there was a legal challenge that
- 21:46Speaker 4: was actually foisted forward by the Whitman administration the governor
- 21:50Speaker 4: at the time seeking to undo senatorial courtesy, and the
- 21:55Speaker 4: Supreme Court in New Jersey actually said it's fine. You know,
- 21:59Speaker 4: they approved of the process. And so it's gone from
- 22:03Speaker 4: this handshake agreement among the political system to now being
- 22:08Speaker 4: adopted and accepted throughout the state and is considered to
- 22:12Speaker 4: be part of the state's constitutional fabric and framework. And
- 22:15Speaker 4: it's fascinating because when you talk with people, they will
- 22:18Speaker 4: say that it's sort of like a force of nature.
- 22:21Speaker 4: There's not really anything you can do to get rid
- 22:23Speaker 4: of it, and so it's just working through it as
- 22:25Speaker 4: best as you can to get more judges on the bench.
- 22:28Speaker 2: If this dates back decades, why is it causing more
- 22:32Speaker 2: problems now? Why is it holding up more judicial appointments now?
- 22:37Speaker 4: That's a great question. So there's a couple facets to this.
- 22:41Speaker 4: The biggest and most important one is that the state
- 22:44Speaker 4: has a larger crunch on the dockets right now because
- 22:47Speaker 4: of the pandemic. You know, like every state, it took
- 22:50Speaker 4: New Jersey a while to get used to remote proceedings.
- 22:53Speaker 4: It's had to deal with all of the legal issues
- 22:55Speaker 4: around remote proceedings, and it's still getting.
- 22:58Speaker 3: Used to it.
- 22:59Speaker 4: You know we are in state litigation, but because of that,
- 23:03Speaker 4: there were more early retirements from judges as they were
- 23:07Speaker 4: slammed with more and more work. And these early retirements
- 23:11Speaker 4: build up because the state can't replace these judges fast
- 23:14Speaker 4: enough to deal with these burden backets, and so we've
- 23:18Speaker 4: seen more early retirements now, people taking retirement before the
- 23:23Speaker 4: state's mandatory retirement age of seventy because they're just overwhelmed
- 23:27Speaker 4: and overworked.
- 23:28Speaker 2: We live in a very partisan time in this country.
- 23:31Speaker 2: Is that also at play here?
- 23:34Speaker 4: Yes, there is an aspect of it that is partisans
- 23:37Speaker 4: in that there isn't so much that the governor's office
- 23:41Speaker 4: can do in order to put pressure on these senators.
- 23:44Speaker 4: There's just less accountability for the Senate than there used
- 23:47Speaker 4: to be. According to a Rutgers law professor, John Farmer,
- 23:51Speaker 4: who was actually in the Witman administration and was helping
- 23:55Speaker 4: with these nominations, he said that they would apply pressure
- 23:59Speaker 4: to a senator to the press, and hopefully the negative
- 24:03Speaker 4: attention on whatever that senator wanted the whold up the
- 24:06Speaker 4: nomination would eventually grind on that senator and the senator
- 24:10Speaker 4: would have to give in and allow the nomination to
- 24:13Speaker 4: go forward. Now, that's not the case. We're getting hold
- 24:16Speaker 4: ups from both Democrats and from Republicans because Farmer says
- 24:20Speaker 4: we're just less accountable now as a political system to
- 24:24Speaker 4: the people due to partisanship.
- 24:26Speaker 2: You spoke to a former family court judge tell us
- 24:29Speaker 2: about how she described her workload.
- 24:32Speaker 4: Judge Lisa Cristo, you know what a fascinating interview. She
- 24:35Speaker 4: described her workload as something that would terrify me. Constant
- 24:40Speaker 4: interruptions all the time, and an incredible workload where you
- 24:45Speaker 4: have to stay on point to get things done throughout
- 24:48Speaker 4: your day. She said that in the morning she would
- 24:50Speaker 4: handle about eight different family law cases, and then after
- 24:54Speaker 4: lunch she'd handle another eight family law cases. So we're
- 24:57Speaker 4: talking rapid succession here. You never know how alone they're
- 25:00Speaker 4: going to take. And in between she was constantly being
- 25:03Speaker 4: interrupted by emergencies on her docket from people that needed
- 25:07Speaker 4: to get out of a dangerous situation in their home
- 25:10Speaker 4: or needed to protect the child. Then on top of that,
- 25:13Speaker 4: every single night she was bringing home paperwork to prefare
- 25:16Speaker 4: for the next day. You know, she said that after
- 25:18Speaker 4: twenty years of doing it, she just couldn't believe that
- 25:21Speaker 4: she was able to get it done.
- 25:23Speaker 2: Let's talk about the spillover effect with other civil cases
- 25:27Speaker 2: where you have elderly people and others not able to
- 25:32Speaker 2: move forward with their cases because of the backlog.
- 25:37Speaker 4: Yeah, this is such a strange spillover problem. But a
- 25:44Speaker 4: lot of folks they might not realize that that trial
- 25:47Speaker 4: date is essential to building leverage to settle. So if
- 25:52Speaker 4: an attorney doesn't have a trial date and they're trying
- 25:54Speaker 4: to get an insurance company to pay up for a
- 25:57Speaker 4: claim for an injured person, they're not going to be
- 26:00Speaker 4: able to do it because the insurance company has the
- 26:03Speaker 4: incentive of just kicking the can down the road. And
- 26:06Speaker 4: that's not a bad thing. It's the insurance company is
- 26:08Speaker 4: looking out for its bottom line and if there's no
- 26:10Speaker 4: need to pay money now, why pay it. But that
- 26:13Speaker 4: means that injured folks are in such a poor situation
- 26:16Speaker 4: because they're not able to work anymore, or because they
- 26:19Speaker 4: really need the money that they're now taking out what
- 26:22Speaker 4: someone considered predatory loans amounts with interest in excess of
- 26:27Speaker 4: thirty percent that are taken out on their future earnings
- 26:31Speaker 4: from the settlement, and so over time, if these trial
- 26:35Speaker 4: courts cannot set dates for these cases, that interest builds
- 26:40Speaker 4: up and builds up, and it eats into their settlements
- 26:42Speaker 4: until they just disappear.
- 26:44Speaker 2: So a Rutgers law professor, John Farmer told you that
- 26:48Speaker 2: this courtesy appointment system, it has the potential to really
- 26:52Speaker 2: undermine the public's confidence in the judiciary. What do they
- 26:56Speaker 2: say on the other side of the issue, You know,
- 26:59Speaker 2: what's a reason for keeping this in place.
- 27:02Speaker 4: The reason for keeping this in place is to create
- 27:06Speaker 4: a bargaining and leveraging system for the Senate. For decades,
- 27:11Speaker 4: it has been a way to get other nominations through,
- 27:14Speaker 4: and so you will see a boatload of nominations go
- 27:18Speaker 4: through at the same time that one of these judicial
- 27:20Speaker 4: nominations go through. And it's because the Senators use this
- 27:24Speaker 4: as a prerogative to basically move the gears of state government.
- 27:29Speaker 4: Without this system, you would have a much more powerful
- 27:33Speaker 4: governor than you currently do. Right now, the Senate holds
- 27:37Speaker 4: the cards and because of that, both Republicans and Democrats
- 27:40Speaker 4: that have courtesy power, they can use that to leverage
- 27:44Speaker 4: different policies that they want need, and they can also
- 27:47Speaker 4: use it to improve the quality of the judiciary. You'll
- 27:51Speaker 4: hear Senator John Bramnick, who's the top Republican on the
- 27:56Speaker 4: Senate Judiciary as well as other senators, say that this
- 28:00Speaker 4: process where you get so much scrutiny from senators, improves
- 28:04Speaker 4: the judiciary New Jersey, and I think that the state
- 28:08Speaker 4: bar leaders would agree that. I didn't speak with a
- 28:10Speaker 4: single attorney who said that the process led for worst judges.
- 28:14Speaker 4: They all say the judges are pretty great. It's just
- 28:16Speaker 4: there aren't that.
- 28:17Speaker 2: Many of them, and it could take as many as
- 28:20Speaker 2: five senators to agree on a judge before an appointment
- 28:23Speaker 2: goes forward.
- 28:25Speaker 4: It can yes, and so the process can be arduous,
- 28:29Speaker 4: it can be long, and it can be a single
- 28:31Speaker 4: senator that holds it up. You could have four senators
- 28:35Speaker 4: that all sign off, and then one person, because of
- 28:38Speaker 4: a policy, because of a personal beef, decides this person can't.
- 28:42Speaker 1: Sit on the bench.
- 28:44Speaker 2: In light of this shortage of judges, why are the
- 28:47Speaker 2: governor and the state Senate leader touting the number of
- 28:52Speaker 2: judges they've appointed?
- 28:54Speaker 4: So the political system responded to our request for comment,
- 28:58Speaker 4: both the governor and Senate leadership by pointing to the
- 29:01Speaker 4: results they've gotten in the past. They say correctly that
- 29:05Speaker 4: last year the numbers were higher and the amount of
- 29:08Speaker 4: vacancies was greater, and they've done yeomen's work to appoint
- 29:13Speaker 4: judges and get the benches filled, but it's just not
- 29:17Speaker 4: keeping up with the state's needs. So Governor Murphy and
- 29:21Speaker 4: sent a president to Kari. They're in this pest situation
- 29:24Speaker 4: where the legislature isn't present in Trenton right now. They're
- 29:28Speaker 4: out campaigning and it's a part time legislature anyway, so
- 29:31Speaker 4: getting folks into the room to hammer out these deals
- 29:35Speaker 4: and get pass any blockages and the courtesy process is difficult.
- 29:39Speaker 4: So they point to their success in getting people on
- 29:41Speaker 4: the bench, whereas state bar leaders and attorneys that are
- 29:45Speaker 4: in the trenches say that it's just not enough.
- 29:48Speaker 1: So what's the solution. Is there a solution?
- 29:51Speaker 4: Throughout our conversations with the attorneys and law professors and
- 29:56Speaker 4: the administration, what always puzzled me was how is this
- 30:00Speaker 4: going to get fixed? And I didn't hear a single
- 30:05Speaker 4: thought from anyone that it could. It was really a
- 30:08Speaker 4: matter of getting more judges through this arcane process than
- 30:12Speaker 4: it was fixing the process. It's been a fight in
- 30:15Speaker 4: the state for decades, and it seems like everyone is
- 30:17Speaker 4: resigned to the unique nature of the political to and
- 30:21Speaker 4: fro of New Jersey, even if it means the fewer
- 30:24Speaker 4: judges around the bench.
- 30:26Speaker 1: A lot of investigation went into your story.
- 30:28Speaker 2: It's really interesting. Thanks so much, Alex. That's Alex Ebert,
- 30:32Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Senior Correspondent, and that's it for this edition
- 30:36Speaker 2: of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get
- 30:38Speaker 2: the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You
- 30:41Speaker 2: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www
- 30:46Speaker 2: dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, And remember
- 30:50Speaker 2: to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at
- 30:53Speaker 2: ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 30:57Speaker 2: listening to Bloomberg